1 00:00:02,519 --> 00:00:08,101 He was often described as enigmatic, smooth, and effortlessly confident. 2 00:00:08,101 --> 00:00:09,972 His colleagues called him Mr. 3 00:00:09,972 --> 00:00:22,627 Bond, not as a joke, but as a recognition of how he moved through the world, unbothered by rules, unconstrained by embarrassment, certain that doors would open because they always 4 00:00:22,627 --> 00:00:23,487 had. 5 00:00:23,767 --> 00:00:28,489 He once claimed he studied psychology at University College London. 6 00:00:28,489 --> 00:00:30,378 When journalists later checked, 7 00:00:30,378 --> 00:00:33,580 UCL confirmed that he had never been enrolled. 8 00:00:33,841 --> 00:00:35,782 The lie barely mattered. 9 00:00:36,003 --> 00:00:41,047 Prestige, in his world, was a costume you could simply put on. 10 00:00:41,388 --> 00:00:53,118 In his youth, he attended Eaton College, the largest private boarding school in England, a place for the wealthiest and most prestigious families, many of them aristocratic. 11 00:00:53,624 --> 00:01:03,401 Born into an establishment military family, he socialized early among people from whom proximity to power felt natural, royalty included. 12 00:01:03,962 --> 00:01:08,424 He carried himself like someone who assumed history would bend around him. 13 00:01:08,645 --> 00:01:20,113 In the late 80s, he dated Lady Helen Taylor, a member of the British royal family, and he made headlines when he was caught sneaking into her Grace and Favor apartment. 14 00:01:20,173 --> 00:01:21,260 After breaking up, 15 00:01:21,260 --> 00:01:29,855 He reportedly crashed her 21st birthday party at a royal residence, Windsor Castle, only to be ejected by staff. 16 00:01:29,915 --> 00:01:33,797 These were incidents said to have dismayed the Queen herself. 17 00:01:33,938 --> 00:01:36,780 For most people, that would be the end of the road. 18 00:01:36,780 --> 00:01:39,861 For him, it was just proof of access. 19 00:01:40,202 --> 00:01:42,363 His name is Nigel Oakes. 20 00:01:43,003 --> 00:01:47,512 In the United States, he's virtually unknown, but behind the scenes, 21 00:01:47,512 --> 00:01:57,987 The 007 of data helped shape one of the most destabilizing forces of the modern era, the industrialization of psychological influence. 22 00:01:58,328 --> 00:02:11,415 Oakes entered advertising in the late 1980s, joining Satchi & Satchi, one of Britain's most powerful agencies, famous for its political campaigns as much as its commercial work. 23 00:02:11,495 --> 00:02:16,818 There, he became obsessed with a problem advertising rarely emitted out loud. 24 00:02:17,144 --> 00:02:21,386 Persuasion worked, but no one could precisely measure how. 25 00:02:23,778 --> 00:02:32,060 He conveyed that sentiment in this interview on the Daily Maverick with influence directors Richard Publick and Diane Neal. 26 00:02:32,060 --> 00:02:46,004 Advertising agencies were quite good at informing you of stuff or making you think or even potentially changing your attitudes to stuff, but were particularly bad at changing your 27 00:02:46,004 --> 00:02:47,244 behavior. 28 00:02:48,045 --> 00:02:52,386 And changing your behavior is really where it counts. 29 00:02:52,430 --> 00:03:04,490 In 1989, he formed the Behavioral Dynamics Working Group, part think tank, part intellectual experiment, bringing together academics and strategists interested in 30 00:03:04,490 --> 00:03:08,310 psychology, motivation, and behavioral modeling. 31 00:03:11,224 --> 00:03:19,898 The group later formalized as Behavioral Dynamics Institute, or BDI, where their premise was simple and unsettling. 32 00:03:19,898 --> 00:03:24,079 If group behavior could be mapped, it could be engineered. 33 00:03:24,380 --> 00:03:37,856 The company's About Us section reads, where a problem of group behavior can be identified, the BDI works to determine its primary causes and precisely what, if any kind of 34 00:03:37,856 --> 00:03:38,786 intervention, 35 00:03:38,786 --> 00:03:45,171 would be most effective in bringing about sustainable and desirable behavior change outcomes. 36 00:03:45,372 --> 00:03:47,133 Oakes pushed further. 37 00:03:47,253 --> 00:03:59,444 In the early 1990s, he experimented with sensory manipulation, launching a company called Marketing Aromatics Limited to influence consumer behavior through scent. 38 00:03:59,604 --> 00:04:03,067 The business failed, but the lesson stuck. 39 00:04:03,187 --> 00:04:06,760 Subtle stimuli could bypass conscious reasoning. 40 00:04:06,958 --> 00:04:15,338 In a 1992 trade interview, Oakes was blunt, quote, we use the same techniques as Aristotle and Hitler. 41 00:04:15,398 --> 00:04:22,058 We appeal to people on an emotional level to get them to agree on a functional level, end quote. 42 00:04:22,298 --> 00:04:35,518 By 1993, Oakes formalized the approach into strategic communication laboratories or SCL, adapting military psychological warfare techniques for civilian, political, and commercial 43 00:04:35,518 --> 00:04:36,398 use. 44 00:04:36,846 --> 00:04:49,777 The firm built massive psychographic super samples, sometimes surveying tens of thousands of people at once to identify local grievances, housing shortages, job insecurity, 45 00:04:49,777 --> 00:04:54,961 migration anxiety, and then weaponized them with tailored messaging. 46 00:04:55,062 --> 00:05:00,766 SCL Group bragged of working on over 200 campaigns across 50 countries. 47 00:05:00,927 --> 00:05:05,198 Early applications included an election project in Indonesia, 48 00:05:05,198 --> 00:05:13,298 surveying for the US military in Iran and Yemen, and an advisory role in post-apartheid South Africa. 49 00:05:13,418 --> 00:05:16,398 After 9-11, the business scaled. 50 00:05:16,818 --> 00:05:28,978 SCL secured contracts tied to hearts and minds campaigns in Afghanistan and Iraq, supporting US and British military efforts to manage perception in unstable regions. 51 00:05:29,198 --> 00:05:30,718 The logic was clear. 52 00:05:30,718 --> 00:05:34,158 If you could shape belief, you could shape behavior. 53 00:05:34,158 --> 00:05:36,218 without firing a shot. 54 00:05:36,558 --> 00:05:45,898 By 2005, Oakes reorganized everything into SCL Group, a holding company for influence subsidiaries operating globally. 55 00:05:46,118 --> 00:05:47,938 But tensions emerged. 56 00:05:48,198 --> 00:05:52,938 Some partners wanted to focus on the research, while Oakes wanted results. 57 00:05:53,038 --> 00:05:57,038 To him, measurement wasn't enough when change was the product. 58 00:05:57,338 --> 00:05:59,038 Then came 2008. 59 00:05:59,038 --> 00:06:02,726 The global financial system collapsed under its own weight. 60 00:06:02,934 --> 00:06:14,900 As banks failed and governments intervened, intense public pressures pushed regulators to reassert control, tightening oversight of finance, data, labor, and markets. 61 00:06:15,100 --> 00:06:19,182 In Europe especially, regulation became the tool of choice. 62 00:06:19,442 --> 00:06:28,887 The European Union positioned itself as the world's leading regulator on privacy, competition, environmental standards, and digital power. 63 00:06:28,887 --> 00:06:31,449 To supporters, this was accountability. 64 00:06:31,449 --> 00:06:32,556 To critics, 65 00:06:32,556 --> 00:06:33,933 it was constraint. 66 00:06:34,019 --> 00:06:35,869 And that tension wasn't new. 67 00:06:39,146 --> 00:06:53,551 if in two weeks' time at the Intergovernmental Conference all 11 of our European partners say they can accept his hard-eque proposal on the provision that he will accept that that 68 00:06:53,551 --> 00:06:59,854 could be used as a transition mechanism towards a single currency, perhaps by the end of the decade. 69 00:06:59,854 --> 00:07:01,014 Will he agree? 70 00:07:01,760 --> 00:07:06,372 I'm grateful to the right honourable gentleman for his generous welcome, which I very much appreciate. 71 00:07:06,372 --> 00:07:10,414 I think in the intergovernmental conference there be a wide range of matters to be discussed. 72 00:07:10,414 --> 00:07:13,885 I think we need to discuss those with very great care before we proceed. 73 00:07:13,885 --> 00:07:18,067 The government's position about the imposition of a single currency is quite clear. 74 00:07:18,067 --> 00:07:19,618 It is not acceptable. 75 00:07:19,638 --> 00:07:23,300 Britain's relationship with Europe had always been uneasy. 76 00:07:23,300 --> 00:07:29,022 It joined late, resisted often, and negotiated exceptions like a reflex. 77 00:07:29,272 --> 00:07:36,564 From the beginning, the UK hovered between integration and distance, inside the system but never fully of it. 78 00:07:36,564 --> 00:07:41,145 By the 2010s, the ambivalence hardened into something sharper. 79 00:07:41,145 --> 00:07:44,446 Financial elites detested EU rules. 80 00:07:44,526 --> 00:07:55,609 Sovereignty became shorthand, not for democracy, but for flexibility, for deregulation, for the freedom to move capital faster than laws could follow. 81 00:07:55,609 --> 00:07:58,630 The UK independence party surged and sub... 82 00:07:58,630 --> 00:08:05,575 by framing Brussels, the de facto capital of the European Union, as an unelected enemy. 83 00:08:05,575 --> 00:08:12,980 They were early advocates of a referendum, or public vote, on whether the UK should leave the EU or not. 84 00:08:12,980 --> 00:08:14,722 This was the opening. 85 00:08:14,722 --> 00:08:19,565 British Conservative Party members followed with their own calls for a referendum. 86 00:08:19,565 --> 00:08:26,862 And after previously saying it would not be the best thing for the country, David Cameron, Prime Minister of the UK from 87 00:08:26,862 --> 00:08:32,325 2010 to 2016 conceded behind an internal party revolt. 88 00:08:32,325 --> 00:08:41,571 Three years ago I committed to the British people that I would renegotiate our position in the European Union and hold an in-out referendum. 89 00:08:41,851 --> 00:08:44,392 Now I am delivering on that commitment. 90 00:08:44,833 --> 00:08:51,137 You will decide and whatever your decision I will do my best to deliver it. 91 00:08:52,018 --> 00:08:53,034 On Monday 92 00:08:53,034 --> 00:09:04,027 I will commence the process set out under our Referendum Act and I will go to Parliament and propose that the British people decide our future in Europe through an in-out 93 00:09:04,027 --> 00:09:07,658 referendum on Thursday 23 June. 94 00:09:08,198 --> 00:09:13,940 The choice is in your hands but my recommendation is clear. 95 00:09:14,260 --> 00:09:22,412 I believe that Britain will be safer, stronger and better off in a reformed European Union. 96 00:09:22,840 --> 00:09:24,141 Thank you very much. 97 00:09:24,141 --> 00:09:28,775 citizens, migration anxiety collided with austerity fatigue. 98 00:09:28,775 --> 00:09:37,061 And beneath it all, wealthy donors began funding movements that promised control, freedom and taking back power. 99 00:09:37,302 --> 00:09:46,990 In fact, five of the UK's richest businessmen supplied 4.9 million of 24.4 million euros that were donated. 100 00:09:46,990 --> 00:09:52,034 The bulk of the funding for Leave.EU, the political campaign group 101 00:09:52,034 --> 00:09:55,136 that supported the UK's withdrawal from the EU. 102 00:09:55,136 --> 00:09:58,078 This moment was the stage for SCL. 103 00:09:58,078 --> 00:10:09,624 One of its subsidiaries, founded in 2013 with funding from billionaire hedge fund manager Robert Mercer and his daughter Rebecca, was called Cambridge Analytica. 104 00:10:09,624 --> 00:10:12,266 Its pitch was simple and terrifying. 105 00:10:12,266 --> 00:10:20,370 Use behavioral science, big data, and psychological profiling to predict and shape how people vote. 106 00:10:20,674 --> 00:10:29,922 The firm built models using personality traits and darker psychological indicators layered atop consumer data and voter files. 107 00:10:29,922 --> 00:10:42,692 For the Brexit referendum, as it became known, Cambridge Analytica advised Leave.eu, identifying immigration as the emotional lever most likely to fracture consensus. 108 00:10:42,692 --> 00:10:50,158 Parallel firms handled Facebook ad delivery, saturating targeted geographies with tailored fear narratives 109 00:10:50,158 --> 00:10:52,158 which I'll discuss in a second. 110 00:10:52,158 --> 00:10:58,822 On June 23rd, 2016, 71.8 % of eligible voters turned out. 111 00:11:01,102 --> 00:11:15,522 Well, at 20 minutes to five, we can now say the decision taken in 1975 by this country to join the common market has been reversed by this referendum to leave the EU. 112 00:11:15,702 --> 00:11:20,602 We are absolutely clear now that there is no way that the remain side can win. 113 00:11:20,602 --> 00:11:29,158 It looks as though the gap's going to be something like 52 to 48, so a four-point lead for leaving the EU. 114 00:11:29,174 --> 00:11:37,999 And that's the result of this referendum, which has been preceded by weeks and months of argument and dispute and all the rest of it. 115 00:11:37,999 --> 00:11:41,541 The British people have spoken and the answer is we're out. 116 00:11:41,621 --> 00:11:45,324 The vote to leave passed by less than 4%. 117 00:11:45,324 --> 00:11:50,036 Across the Atlantic, the same playbook was unfolding simultaneously. 118 00:12:39,726 --> 00:12:48,026 This populist language is that of Steve Bannon, a key strategist for Donald Trump's 2016 presidential campaign. 119 00:12:48,046 --> 00:12:53,326 Later, the White House chief strategist for the first seven months of Trump's administration. 120 00:12:53,486 --> 00:12:57,906 Oh, and by the way, vice president of Cambridge Analytica. 121 00:12:57,926 --> 00:13:06,206 What you have to understand is that government, however flawed, is one of the few institutions capable of restraining corporate power. 122 00:13:06,206 --> 00:13:09,738 From the 1930s through the 1960s, 123 00:13:09,738 --> 00:13:11,799 It did exactly that. 124 00:13:11,939 --> 00:13:17,722 Setting rules, enforcing standards, and absorbing risk markets wouldn't. 125 00:13:17,722 --> 00:13:19,643 That made it an obstacle. 126 00:13:19,643 --> 00:13:29,707 So for decades, corporate interests invested in priming the public to despise government enough to slowly dismantle it piece by piece. 127 00:13:29,808 --> 00:13:34,780 The administrative state, the deep state, bureaucracy as villain. 128 00:13:58,798 --> 00:14:05,323 But for corporations, the deep state translates to standards, rules, and regulations. 129 00:14:05,323 --> 00:14:08,346 Regulations intended to protect the public. 130 00:14:08,346 --> 00:14:12,529 Anti-government rhetoric is in line with corporate interests. 131 00:14:12,529 --> 00:14:19,655 So wealthy elites and corporations gladly empower right-wing populist rhetoric as a means to an end. 132 00:14:19,655 --> 00:14:28,552 Less regulation, less rules, less standards, and a shift from competing with government to being contracted by the government. 133 00:14:28,748 --> 00:14:36,900 Behind the rhetoric sat lots of money, and behind the money sat tools to pull off a favorable electoral win. 134 00:14:37,120 --> 00:14:38,781 And this is how. 135 00:14:39,001 --> 00:14:46,283 Around the same time, a researcher named Alexander Kogan partnered with Facebook on academic studies. 136 00:14:46,283 --> 00:14:55,425 As part of the partnership, Facebook provided Kogan data on 57 billion friendships across the world aggregated by country. 137 00:14:55,425 --> 00:14:58,486 In collaboration with Cambridge Analytica, 138 00:14:58,510 --> 00:15:06,532 Kogan developed a personality quiz app called This Is Your Digital Life, where users consented to share their data. 139 00:15:06,532 --> 00:15:11,575 What they didn't realize was that the app also harvested data from their friends. 140 00:15:11,595 --> 00:15:14,897 Tens of millions of profiles were collected. 141 00:15:14,897 --> 00:15:21,620 With that data, Cambridge Analytica claimed it could build up to 5,000 data points per person. 142 00:15:21,620 --> 00:15:27,732 Psychological fingerprints used to micro-target fear, anger, and identity. 143 00:15:27,874 --> 00:15:38,920 During the 2016 US presidential election, Cambridge Analytica first supported Ted Cruz's Republican primary bid, testing similar psychographic tools. 144 00:15:38,920 --> 00:15:47,225 After his withdrawal, the firm shifted to the Trump campaign, securing a $5 million contract for digital operations. 145 00:15:47,225 --> 00:15:56,300 The operation targeted swing voters in battleground states with Facebook ads amplifying concerns over immigration and national security. 146 00:15:56,300 --> 00:16:03,213 such as portraying Muslims as threats, aiming to mobilize low propensity and disaffected demographics. 147 00:16:03,213 --> 00:16:14,048 Though he maintained no operational role in Cambridge Analytica itself, Oakes later attributed this strategy's success to straightforward, emotion-driven narratives that 148 00:16:14,048 --> 00:16:19,540 bypassed rational debate and echoed historical mass influence tactics. 149 00:16:20,081 --> 00:16:23,374 Having been involved in political campaigns all my life is the 150 00:16:23,374 --> 00:16:29,174 pretty much always you're going to upset 50 % of the people who go, well, you shouldn't be using that. 151 00:16:29,174 --> 00:16:35,734 And then the 50 % that's on your side go, well, I think it's okay to use that as long as it's on our side. 152 00:16:36,254 --> 00:16:40,874 And everybody thinks that their own morality is the right thing. 153 00:16:40,874 --> 00:16:50,514 But I maintain a very simple position on this is that I'm not smart enough or bright enough to make moral judgments myself. 154 00:16:50,534 --> 00:16:53,058 I famously have said I have no 155 00:16:53,058 --> 00:16:59,778 moral compass because a lot of what I designed is used for good. 156 00:16:59,778 --> 00:17:02,666 A lot of what I've designed has been used for bad. 157 00:17:02,666 --> 00:17:07,269 And often stuff that was used for good has now turned out to be bad. 158 00:17:07,429 --> 00:17:19,128 In this undercover investigation by Channel 4 News, a British public broadcast service, Alexander Nix, the CEO and more prominent name behind Cambridge Analytica, 159 00:17:19,128 --> 00:17:28,622 boasts on hidden camera about additional methods of their influence campaigns, including bribery, entrapment, and information warfare. 160 00:17:29,763 --> 00:17:32,244 We do a lot more than that. 161 00:17:32,324 --> 00:17:37,818 I mean, deep digging is interesting, oh you know, we're effective. 162 00:17:37,818 --> 00:17:46,170 It can be just to go and speak to the incumbents and to oh offer them. 163 00:17:46,670 --> 00:17:50,990 deal that's too good to be true and make sure that that's video recorded. 164 00:17:51,230 --> 00:17:53,830 You know, source of tactics are very effective. 165 00:17:54,370 --> 00:17:57,470 Instantly having video evidence of corruption. 166 00:17:57,470 --> 00:17:57,810 Right. 167 00:17:57,810 --> 00:17:59,290 When you get on the internet. 168 00:17:59,970 --> 00:18:02,610 And the operative you will use for this is home. 169 00:18:02,670 --> 00:18:04,230 Well, someone known to us. 170 00:18:04,230 --> 00:18:05,190 OK, so it is somebody. 171 00:18:05,190 --> 00:18:06,810 You won't use a Sri Lankan person, no? 172 00:18:06,810 --> 00:18:08,050 then there's issue. 173 00:18:08,050 --> 00:18:11,010 We'll have a wealthy developer come in. 174 00:18:11,010 --> 00:18:12,950 Somebody posing as a wealthy developer. 175 00:18:12,950 --> 00:18:14,390 I'm a master of disguise. 176 00:18:14,390 --> 00:18:15,250 Yes. 177 00:18:15,250 --> 00:18:23,590 They will offer a large amount of money to the candidate to finance this campaign in exchange for land, for instance. 178 00:18:23,810 --> 00:18:30,030 We'll have a whole bunch of people with cameras, flank out face of our guy, we'll have posts on Instagram. 179 00:18:30,150 --> 00:18:33,124 So it'll be Facebook or YouTube or something like this. 180 00:18:37,836 --> 00:18:41,096 We have lots of history of things. 181 00:18:41,416 --> 00:18:50,536 For example, you're saying when you're using the girls to introduce to the local fellow and you're using the girls for this seduction, they're not local girls, not Sri Lankan 182 00:18:50,536 --> 00:18:50,776 girls. 183 00:18:50,776 --> 00:18:52,136 I wouldn't have thought so. 184 00:18:53,116 --> 00:18:54,976 That was just an idea. 185 00:18:55,296 --> 00:18:58,656 Bring some Ukrainians in on holiday with us. 186 00:19:00,814 --> 00:19:02,656 They very beautiful Ukrainian girls. 187 00:19:02,656 --> 00:19:04,437 They are very beautiful. 188 00:19:04,437 --> 00:19:04,618 Yes. 189 00:19:04,618 --> 00:19:07,700 I find that's very well. 190 00:19:07,701 --> 00:19:17,020 Please don't pay too much attention to what I'm saying because I'm just giving you examples of what can be done and what has been done. 191 00:19:17,020 --> 00:19:17,770 Yes. 192 00:19:20,142 --> 00:19:29,790 When you can deploy tactics like these, map people's fears, nudge their choices, and predict their behavior at scale, you don't just win elections. 193 00:19:29,790 --> 00:19:34,854 You position yourself to write the rules and policies for your own interests. 194 00:19:35,155 --> 00:19:41,359 And while deregulation can create opportunities for innovation, it does the same for abuse. 195 00:19:41,500 --> 00:19:46,884 In unregulated systems, bad actors don't just survive, they scale. 196 00:19:46,965 --> 00:19:49,076 Because if you can shape belief, 197 00:19:49,260 --> 00:19:51,111 You don't need consensus. 198 00:19:51,111 --> 00:19:54,731 If you can fragment truth, you don't need trust. 199 00:19:54,812 --> 00:20:01,893 And without trust, power concentrates quietly, efficiently, and potentially permanently. 200 00:20:01,933 --> 00:20:05,654 Brexit didn't deliver sweeping deregulation overnight. 201 00:20:05,694 --> 00:20:08,935 Trump didn't dismantle the state in four years. 202 00:20:08,935 --> 00:20:13,056 But the influence and destabilization were the opening. 203 00:20:13,096 --> 00:20:14,517 That was the win. 204 00:20:14,517 --> 00:20:16,297 Institutions weakened. 205 00:20:16,297 --> 00:20:17,838 Trust eroded. 206 00:20:17,838 --> 00:20:19,398 Norms dissolved. 207 00:20:19,574 --> 00:20:26,799 And that destabilization would soon echo into housing, land, data, and daily life itself. 208 00:20:26,860 --> 00:20:30,592 I'm Demetrius Lynch, and this is Built to Divide. 209 00:20:35,928 --> 00:20:39,449 I don't want to blame the real estate markets because I always made a lot of money in bad markets. 210 00:20:39,449 --> 00:20:40,370 I love bad markets. 211 00:20:40,370 --> 00:20:42,600 You can do very well in a bad market. 212 00:20:43,060 --> 00:20:50,443 And when his father told you not to rent apartments to people of color, what was Donald's response? 213 00:20:50,818 --> 00:20:52,383 And he shook his head. 214 00:20:53,324 --> 00:20:56,585 And that's the way it's supposed to be. 215 00:20:57,725 --> 00:20:59,706 Agreeing with his father. 216 00:21:13,088 --> 00:21:26,535 In the last episode, we examined a housing industry under pressure, NIMBYism, CEQA, why new construction skews luxury, influences of the creative class, the cause and impact of 217 00:21:26,535 --> 00:21:30,147 gentrification, and global investment into housing. 218 00:21:30,147 --> 00:21:37,191 If you haven't listened to that episode, I encourage you to go back and listen to all of the episodes of this series in order. 219 00:21:37,251 --> 00:21:42,824 In this episode, we'll trace how crisis, chaos, and division reshape ownership. 220 00:21:42,830 --> 00:21:55,059 From the pandemic's economic shock to wildfires that erased entire neighborhoods, we'll follow how moments of collective vulnerability became moments of private accumulation. 221 00:21:55,059 --> 00:22:07,048 We examine how housing instability deepened during COVID, how disaster accelerated displacement, and how policies, markets, and money moved faster than people could recover. 222 00:22:07,048 --> 00:22:09,970 And we'll get into all of that after this break. 223 00:22:21,878 --> 00:22:24,777 Episode 10, Divide and Conquer. 224 00:22:26,766 --> 00:22:31,329 For much of American history, a home was more than a place to live. 225 00:22:31,429 --> 00:22:36,652 It was how families saved, built stability, and passed something forward. 226 00:22:36,753 --> 00:22:38,634 A house wasn't just shelter. 227 00:22:38,634 --> 00:22:46,860 It was a store of value, a hedge against inflation, a quiet promise that tomorrow might be easier than today. 228 00:22:46,860 --> 00:22:50,423 Home ownership became the backbone of middle-class growth. 229 00:22:50,423 --> 00:22:55,786 After World War II, government policy and cheap suburban land opened that door. 230 00:22:56,002 --> 00:22:58,504 Millions of households bought homes. 231 00:22:58,504 --> 00:23:01,846 What followed wasn't just comfort, it was equity. 232 00:23:01,846 --> 00:23:04,548 Down payments turned into leverage. 233 00:23:04,568 --> 00:23:09,371 Mortgages turned into college tuition, small businesses, retirements. 234 00:23:09,472 --> 00:23:15,496 A wealth machine ran quietly in the background of everyday life, but the gate narrowed. 235 00:23:15,696 --> 00:23:19,179 Land prices and job-rich cities soared. 236 00:23:19,179 --> 00:23:21,300 Construction costs rose. 237 00:23:21,420 --> 00:23:24,222 Zoning locked neighborhoods into low density. 238 00:23:24,416 --> 00:23:26,747 Supply lagged behind demand. 239 00:23:26,747 --> 00:23:30,188 Entry costs climbed and millions were priced out. 240 00:23:30,188 --> 00:23:32,529 And when you can't buy, you rent. 241 00:23:32,669 --> 00:23:37,251 When you rent, you miss the house as investment channel entirely. 242 00:23:37,251 --> 00:23:39,752 The wealth ladder tilts away from you. 243 00:23:39,752 --> 00:23:43,734 Those who bought earlier captured compounding gains. 244 00:23:43,734 --> 00:23:47,355 Appreciation, tax advantages, equity extraction. 245 00:23:47,355 --> 00:23:48,956 They passed down help. 246 00:23:48,956 --> 00:23:51,857 Down payments, credit, even homes. 247 00:23:51,857 --> 00:23:54,078 Wealth reproduced itself. 248 00:23:54,326 --> 00:23:57,247 Renters, meanwhile, paid to stand still. 249 00:23:57,247 --> 00:24:01,309 Rent consumed income that could have gone to savings or investment. 250 00:24:01,309 --> 00:24:04,450 Without equity, a rung on the ladder disappeared. 251 00:24:04,450 --> 00:24:07,350 And over generations, the gap widened. 252 00:24:07,411 --> 00:24:13,033 Families whose parents never owned started adulthood without assets to lean on. 253 00:24:13,033 --> 00:24:15,454 That divide was not accidental. 254 00:24:15,454 --> 00:24:16,634 In the 20th century, 255 00:24:17,196 --> 00:24:24,731 Redlining and mortgage discrimination systematically blocked black families from buying homes in appreciating neighborhoods. 256 00:24:24,752 --> 00:24:29,435 The most powerful wealth engine in America was selectively walled off. 257 00:24:29,435 --> 00:24:32,256 The consequences compound to this day. 258 00:24:32,277 --> 00:24:35,299 Housing wealth is historically engineered. 259 00:24:35,299 --> 00:24:39,222 Ownership built wealth, exclusion built stagnation. 260 00:24:39,382 --> 00:24:45,166 And once you see that wealth also moves through belief as much as balance sheets, 261 00:24:45,230 --> 00:24:54,728 Housing stops looking like shelter alone and starts looking like a story people are taught to accept, defend, or never be allowed to enter. 262 00:24:57,282 --> 00:25:01,324 Well, the new book is entitled Surviving at the Top. 263 00:25:01,325 --> 00:25:05,387 There are many people who would say failing at the top. 264 00:25:06,249 --> 00:25:17,356 Well, I think what the press has done is taken a situation where they see something and blown it to kingdom come. 265 00:25:17,356 --> 00:25:22,120 I've never seen anything like it, whether it's a marriage, by the way, or whether it's financial. 266 00:25:22,120 --> 00:25:25,396 I've never seen press reporting. 267 00:25:25,396 --> 00:25:27,446 as I have with regard to me. 268 00:25:27,446 --> 00:25:32,208 And I hope the general public understands how inherently dishonest the press in this country is. 269 00:25:32,528 --> 00:25:36,869 As a member of the press, let me try to clear up some of the things which you say are untrue. 270 00:25:36,870 --> 00:25:43,991 You write in your book, my bankers and I worked out a terrific deal that allows me to come out stronger than ever. 271 00:25:44,112 --> 00:25:48,993 I see the deal as a great victory and eventually the rest of the world will too. 272 00:25:49,833 --> 00:25:51,822 Being on the verge of bankruptcy. 273 00:25:51,822 --> 00:26:00,602 being bailed out by the banks, skating on thin ice and almost drowning, that's a businessman to be admired. 274 00:26:00,902 --> 00:26:05,942 You say on the verge of bankruptcy, and you talk on the verge and you listen to what people are saying. 275 00:26:05,942 --> 00:26:07,082 to your bankers. 276 00:26:07,082 --> 00:26:07,702 Well, that's fine. 277 00:26:07,702 --> 00:26:08,502 And what do they say? 278 00:26:08,502 --> 00:26:11,502 mean, you know, depending on which banker you're talking to, what do they say? 279 00:26:11,542 --> 00:26:17,582 This is Donald Trump in 1990 speaking with Barbara Walters on ABC's 2020. 280 00:26:18,522 --> 00:26:20,122 In this worldview, 281 00:26:20,270 --> 00:26:24,673 Truth is not something discovered, it's something asserted. 282 00:26:24,833 --> 00:26:27,635 Whatever is said last becomes reality. 283 00:26:27,675 --> 00:26:31,678 Consistency is irrelevant, evidence is optional. 284 00:26:31,678 --> 00:26:35,260 The logic isn't persuasion, it's domination. 285 00:26:35,261 --> 00:26:42,285 Reality bends, not because it's weak, but because repetition and confidence can overpower doubt. 286 00:26:42,285 --> 00:26:44,927 But false narratives create tension. 287 00:26:45,067 --> 00:26:49,230 The facts don't line up and that friction generates resistance. 288 00:26:49,420 --> 00:26:57,212 What turns distortion into danger isn't just the lie itself, it's the people who decide to benefit from it anyway. 289 00:26:57,212 --> 00:27:04,014 Some align themselves with the narrative not because they believe it, but because they hope to profit from what follows. 290 00:27:04,034 --> 00:27:06,675 That complicity produces chaos. 291 00:27:06,675 --> 00:27:11,596 And chaos is not a flaw in the system, it's the growth medium. 292 00:27:11,596 --> 00:27:15,757 It's inside that disorder that this personality scales. 293 00:27:15,957 --> 00:27:19,098 Authority hardens as confusion spreads. 294 00:27:19,382 --> 00:27:24,488 Attacking institutions becomes easier when trust is already fractured. 295 00:27:26,264 --> 00:27:34,277 Veterans CBS journalist Leslie Stahl later described an exchange with Trump that exposed this strategy plainly. 296 00:27:34,398 --> 00:27:45,313 At one point he started to attack the press and it's just me and my boss and him and he has a huge office and he's attacking the press and there were no cameras there was nothing 297 00:27:45,313 --> 00:27:53,132 going on and I said you know that is getting tired why are you doing this you're doing it over and over and it's boring and it's 298 00:27:53,132 --> 00:27:55,044 It's time to end that. 299 00:27:55,044 --> 00:27:56,575 You've won the nomination. 300 00:27:56,575 --> 00:28:01,270 And uh why do you keep hammering at this? 301 00:28:01,270 --> 00:28:03,491 And he said, you know why I do it? 302 00:28:03,672 --> 00:28:10,548 I do it to discredit you all and demean you all so when you write negative stories about me, no one will believe you. 303 00:28:12,088 --> 00:28:23,391 This is a glimpse into the ethos of financialization, a world where belief is not incidental, but instrumental, where outcomes matter more than consequences and success is 304 00:28:23,391 --> 00:28:25,502 measured only by extraction. 305 00:28:25,502 --> 00:28:29,963 It is a system obsessed with results and indifferent to fallout. 306 00:28:29,963 --> 00:28:39,966 That ethos gained more momentum with the rise of social media in the early 2000s, where narratives could be tested, amplified, and normalized at scale. 307 00:28:40,088 --> 00:28:47,720 By around 2015, it reached maturity, armed with influence techniques refined by firms like SCL. 308 00:28:47,720 --> 00:28:55,482 Behavioral science, psychological targeting, and emotional manipulation turned belief itself into infrastructure. 309 00:28:55,482 --> 00:29:02,544 And as crisis multiplied, those who controlled the narrative learned to convert disruption into advantage. 310 00:29:02,604 --> 00:29:04,785 Wealth didn't retreat from chaos. 311 00:29:04,785 --> 00:29:06,886 It learned to feed on it. 312 00:29:06,966 --> 00:29:08,152 In 2020, 313 00:29:08,152 --> 00:29:12,723 built wealth and built stagnation widened again, fast. 314 00:29:12,723 --> 00:29:16,204 Because in tragedy and chaos, opportunists follow. 315 00:29:16,204 --> 00:29:25,607 And in a media environment already primed for manipulation, crisis becomes fuel for fear, for division, and for control of the narrative. 316 00:29:26,847 --> 00:29:37,310 In December 2019 in Wuhan, an unfamiliar city name soon became globally known in connection with a respiratory disease, COVID-19. 317 00:29:37,632 --> 00:29:43,145 a contagious disease caused by the coronavirus, SARS-CoV-2. 318 00:29:43,485 --> 00:29:52,911 At first, it's distant, a headline you scroll past, a clip of masked commuters, a chart with a curve that looks like someone else's problem. 319 00:29:52,911 --> 00:29:54,972 Then it starts hopping borders. 320 00:29:54,972 --> 00:29:57,093 It starts leaving fingerprints. 321 00:29:57,293 --> 00:30:00,755 And in January, warnings enter the US system. 322 00:30:00,755 --> 00:30:05,778 Embassy alerts, early airport screenings, the first confirmed case. 323 00:30:05,890 --> 00:30:10,134 But the country still thinks the outbreak is an issue overseas. 324 00:30:10,134 --> 00:30:15,258 Inside the White House, the first instinct isn't triage, it's optics. 325 00:30:16,866 --> 00:30:24,934 The CDC has identified a case of coronavirus in Washington state, the Wuhan strain of this. 326 00:30:25,276 --> 00:30:30,521 If you remember SARS, that affected GDP, travel related effects. 327 00:30:30,521 --> 00:30:34,025 Have you been briefed by the CDC? 328 00:30:34,025 --> 00:30:36,498 Are there words about a pandemic at this point? 329 00:30:36,498 --> 00:30:37,749 No, not at all. 330 00:30:38,414 --> 00:30:40,334 We have it totally under control. 331 00:30:40,334 --> 00:30:45,234 It's one person coming in from China and we have it under control. 332 00:30:45,294 --> 00:30:47,094 It's going to be just fine. 333 00:30:47,094 --> 00:30:53,314 That was on January 22nd, but behind the curtain, the tone and knowledge is different. 334 00:30:54,054 --> 00:30:57,054 As early as January 3rd, U.S. 335 00:30:57,054 --> 00:31:07,000 officials were alerted on the severity of the outbreak, conveyed by Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar, who informed his chief of staff, 336 00:31:07,000 --> 00:31:14,656 to make sure that the National Security Council was aware that, quote, this is a very big deal, end quote. 337 00:31:15,057 --> 00:31:21,402 In fact, on January 18th, Azar called President Trump to warn him about the virus. 338 00:31:21,562 --> 00:31:33,672 The National Security Advisor, Robert O'Brien, also told Trump that COVID-19 would be the, quote, largest national security crisis of your presidency, end quote. 339 00:31:33,772 --> 00:31:35,950 On February 7th, Trump 340 00:31:35,950 --> 00:31:39,303 privately told journalist Bob Woodward what he knew. 341 00:31:40,948 --> 00:31:42,359 It goes through air, Bob. 342 00:31:42,359 --> 00:31:43,999 That's always tougher than the touch. 343 00:31:43,999 --> 00:31:46,030 You know, the touch, don't have to touch things, right? 344 00:31:46,030 --> 00:31:48,131 But the air, you just breathe the air. 345 00:31:48,131 --> 00:31:50,482 That's how it's passed. 346 00:31:50,882 --> 00:31:52,503 And so that's a very tricky one. 347 00:31:52,503 --> 00:31:54,303 That's a very delicate one. 348 00:31:54,564 --> 00:32:00,146 It's also more deadly than your, you know, your even your strenuous flus. 349 00:32:00,146 --> 00:32:01,166 This is more deadly. 350 00:32:01,166 --> 00:32:07,629 This is five per, you know, this is five percent versus one percent and less than one percent. 351 00:32:07,629 --> 00:32:10,242 You know, so this is deadly stuff. 352 00:32:10,242 --> 00:32:11,703 This wasn't confusion. 353 00:32:11,703 --> 00:32:13,864 It was a glimpse behind the messaging. 354 00:32:13,864 --> 00:32:18,826 Because in a crisis, what leaders choose to say isn't just information. 355 00:32:18,826 --> 00:32:20,326 It's instruction. 356 00:32:20,326 --> 00:32:25,948 Later on March 19th, Trump explains the difference in his messaging to Woodward. 357 00:32:26,349 --> 00:32:34,262 Well, I think Bob, really, to be honest with you, I wanted to, uh I wanted to always play it down. 358 00:32:34,262 --> 00:32:38,934 I still like playing it down because I don't want to create a panic. 359 00:32:40,300 --> 00:32:45,313 In public, the administration sells calm, bordering insignificance. 360 00:32:45,313 --> 00:32:55,138 Not because calm is always a virtue, but because calm protects markets, and markets, especially in an election year, protect incumbents. 361 00:32:55,159 --> 00:33:00,742 The virus becomes a communications problem before it becomes a national mobilization. 362 00:33:00,742 --> 00:33:06,945 And that delay is critical, compounding the problem and the extent of the damage. 363 00:33:07,026 --> 00:33:07,864 In public, 364 00:33:07,864 --> 00:33:11,678 February is filled with reassurance and minimization. 365 00:33:11,678 --> 00:33:13,439 It'll go away with the heat. 366 00:33:13,439 --> 00:33:14,901 The numbers are small. 367 00:33:14,901 --> 00:33:16,692 The press is hysterical. 368 00:33:18,614 --> 00:33:24,599 Now the Democrats are politicizing the coronavirus. 369 00:33:24,599 --> 00:33:27,081 You know that, Coronavirus. 370 00:33:28,122 --> 00:33:29,964 They're politicizing it. 371 00:33:29,964 --> 00:33:31,625 We did one of the great jobs. 372 00:33:31,625 --> 00:33:34,607 You say, how's President Trump doing? 373 00:33:34,607 --> 00:33:36,749 They go, not good, not good. 374 00:33:37,170 --> 00:33:38,110 They have no clue. 375 00:33:38,110 --> 00:33:39,011 They don't have any clue. 376 00:33:39,011 --> 00:33:41,213 They can't even count their votes in Iowa. 377 00:33:41,213 --> 00:33:42,714 They can't even count. 378 00:33:46,924 --> 00:33:48,981 They can't count their votes! 379 00:33:52,605 --> 00:33:55,255 One of my people came up to me and said, Mr. 380 00:33:55,255 --> 00:33:59,646 President, they tried to beat you on Russia, Russia, Russia. 381 00:33:59,646 --> 00:34:01,486 That didn't work out too well. 382 00:34:02,407 --> 00:34:03,807 They couldn't do it. 383 00:34:03,807 --> 00:34:06,167 They tried the impeachment hoax. 384 00:34:06,827 --> 00:34:09,328 That was on a perfect conversation. 385 00:34:10,488 --> 00:34:11,708 They tried anything. 386 00:34:11,708 --> 00:34:13,138 They tried it over and over. 387 00:34:13,138 --> 00:34:15,549 They've been doing it since you got in. 388 00:34:15,569 --> 00:34:16,649 It's all turning. 389 00:34:16,649 --> 00:34:17,339 They lost. 390 00:34:17,339 --> 00:34:18,309 It's all turning. 391 00:34:18,309 --> 00:34:19,310 Think of it. 392 00:34:19,310 --> 00:34:20,310 Think of it. 393 00:34:20,310 --> 00:34:22,130 And this is their new hoax. 394 00:34:22,534 --> 00:34:25,265 But you know, we did something that's been pretty amazing. 395 00:34:25,265 --> 00:34:28,117 We're 15 people in this massive country. 396 00:34:28,117 --> 00:34:34,139 And because of the fact that we went early, we went early, we could have had a lot more than that. 397 00:34:34,139 --> 00:34:35,070 We're doing great. 398 00:34:35,070 --> 00:34:36,940 Our country is doing so great. 399 00:34:36,940 --> 00:34:38,001 We are so unified. 400 00:34:38,001 --> 00:34:40,582 We are so unified. 401 00:34:44,736 --> 00:34:49,728 Another hoax, another plot, another reason to distrust institutions. 402 00:34:50,128 --> 00:34:51,669 And this wasn't new. 403 00:34:51,689 --> 00:35:04,754 By 2020, we'd already watched influence become a monetized professional industry, an assembly line that turns psychology into turnout, outrage into clicks, and uncertainty 404 00:35:04,754 --> 00:35:06,315 into obedience. 405 00:35:06,855 --> 00:35:10,197 Different crises, same operating system. 406 00:35:10,197 --> 00:35:14,248 Control the frame, control the public, protect the machine. 407 00:35:14,274 --> 00:35:20,879 Because when people are arguing about whether the fire is real, they aren't watching the back door for intruders. 408 00:35:21,000 --> 00:35:25,424 By March 11th, the World Health Organization declares a pandemic. 409 00:35:25,424 --> 00:35:29,567 Two days later, the US declares a national emergency. 410 00:35:29,567 --> 00:35:32,589 And by then, the country is already behind. 411 00:35:32,610 --> 00:35:42,668 Testing limited, mixed messaging doing their work, the public unsure whether to stock up on canned beans, get tissue, or keep shaking hands. 412 00:35:43,032 --> 00:35:50,327 Then to prevent the spread of COVID-19, stay-at-home orders and restrictions on social interactions followed. 413 00:35:50,367 --> 00:35:54,249 But in that isolation, another disease flourished. 414 00:35:54,250 --> 00:36:00,414 The algorithm continued to do its work, spreading extremism like a digital virus. 415 00:36:00,514 --> 00:36:10,221 With the background of social unrest and rising messages of hate, it became impossible to see what was happening and who was behind the curtain. 416 00:36:10,581 --> 00:36:12,184 Even before COVID, 417 00:36:12,184 --> 00:36:14,876 Housing was a slow motion emergency. 418 00:36:14,876 --> 00:36:20,679 Wages flattened, supply lagged, rent climbed, ownership drifted out of reach. 419 00:36:20,679 --> 00:36:23,280 The floorboards were already rotting. 420 00:36:23,280 --> 00:36:25,841 COVID just jumped up and down on them. 421 00:36:25,841 --> 00:36:30,544 And when shutdowns hit, it wasn't an abstract economic contraction. 422 00:36:30,544 --> 00:36:32,285 It was a hard stop. 423 00:36:32,305 --> 00:36:37,988 Restaurants went dark, hotels emptied, flights vanished from departure boards. 424 00:36:37,988 --> 00:36:42,130 Millions of workers were told to stay home and figure it out. 425 00:36:42,348 --> 00:36:48,321 others, the essential workforce, were told to keep showing up and absorb the risk. 426 00:36:48,321 --> 00:37:00,088 In April 2020, payroll employment collapses by roughly 20.5 million jobs and unemployment spikes to around 14.7 to 14.8%. 427 00:37:00,088 --> 00:37:05,331 In one month, America experiences a crash that usually takes years. 428 00:37:05,331 --> 00:37:10,614 By early summer, families are falling behind on rent, skipping utilities, 429 00:37:10,614 --> 00:37:18,577 stretching groceries and wondering whether an eviction moratorium means anything when the tally keeps a croon. 430 00:37:18,618 --> 00:37:25,380 This is where built wealth and built stagnation widen the gap because crisis doesn't hit evenly. 431 00:37:25,380 --> 00:37:26,721 It never has. 432 00:37:27,681 --> 00:37:31,223 don't want to blame the real estate markets because I always made a lot of money in bad markets. 433 00:37:31,223 --> 00:37:32,153 I love bad markets. 434 00:37:32,153 --> 00:37:34,404 You can do very well in a bad market. 435 00:37:34,664 --> 00:37:38,774 In a leadership role, the tone you set changes what people do. 436 00:37:38,774 --> 00:37:42,315 Narratives don't just calm people, they shape timing. 437 00:37:42,315 --> 00:37:45,717 And timing in markets is everything. 438 00:37:45,777 --> 00:37:51,859 The federal response to the economic crisis hit the housing market like a match in dry grass. 439 00:37:51,919 --> 00:37:57,441 In March 2020, the Federal Reserve drops interest rates to nearly zero. 440 00:37:59,614 --> 00:38:07,496 The Federal Reserve announced a number of other actions today to support the flow of credit to households and businesses, thereby promoting our maximum unemployment and price 441 00:38:07,496 --> 00:38:08,526 stability goals. 442 00:38:08,526 --> 00:38:10,626 Of these, I will highlight two. 443 00:38:10,806 --> 00:38:18,366 First, we reduced the interest rate on discount window loans by one and a half percentage points, bringing that rate to a quarter of a percent. 444 00:38:18,866 --> 00:38:27,526 The discount window plays an important role in supporting liquidity and stability in the banking system, and we encourage banks to turn to the discount window to help meet demands 445 00:38:27,526 --> 00:38:29,746 for credit from households and businesses. 446 00:38:30,646 --> 00:38:36,706 To make the discount window more effective, we will also offer discount window loans for periods up to 90 days. 447 00:38:36,984 --> 00:38:38,735 We've seen this story before. 448 00:38:38,735 --> 00:38:43,977 When money got cheap, the winners were the ones already positioned to harvest the upside. 449 00:38:44,037 --> 00:38:47,218 At first, housing stalls under uncertainty. 450 00:38:47,218 --> 00:38:48,839 Then it surges. 451 00:38:50,120 --> 00:38:56,662 For homeowners, remote work turned spare bedrooms or any available nook into an office. 452 00:38:56,662 --> 00:38:59,123 Quarantine made space essential. 453 00:38:59,123 --> 00:39:05,632 So families with equity and means started hunting for yards, garages, extra rooms. 454 00:39:05,632 --> 00:39:09,784 anything that feels like control in a world that suddenly has none. 455 00:39:09,784 --> 00:39:17,967 Work from home policies allow movement to larger homes and even relocation from cities to rural properties in other states. 456 00:39:17,967 --> 00:39:20,828 Low rates supercharge buying power. 457 00:39:20,828 --> 00:39:22,809 Scarcity does the rest. 458 00:39:22,829 --> 00:39:27,251 Prices skyrocket, inflating even low-cost markets. 459 00:39:27,251 --> 00:39:29,932 Houses go under contract in hours. 460 00:39:29,932 --> 00:39:33,834 Buyers wave inspections like they're waving their right to reality. 461 00:39:33,834 --> 00:39:35,454 Cash offers win. 462 00:39:37,182 --> 00:39:43,122 And the line between shelter and asset gets erased in real time. 463 00:39:43,142 --> 00:39:55,862 By 2023, the median existing home price is dramatically higher than it was at the start of the pandemic, often cited around $406,700 at peak points. 464 00:39:56,102 --> 00:40:03,802 The exact month-to-month number matters less than the shape of the story, a surge that turns stability into a bidding war. 465 00:40:03,882 --> 00:40:05,346 Investors notice that 466 00:40:05,346 --> 00:40:07,948 They don't need a home, they need a yield. 467 00:40:07,948 --> 00:40:11,251 They don't need a neighborhood, they need a portfolio. 468 00:40:11,251 --> 00:40:13,072 They don't need stability. 469 00:40:13,072 --> 00:40:14,674 They need you to pay. 470 00:40:14,674 --> 00:40:15,635 Every month. 471 00:40:15,635 --> 00:40:16,755 Forever. 472 00:40:16,936 --> 00:40:20,298 Meanwhile, renters live inside the contradiction. 473 00:40:20,298 --> 00:40:28,585 You're told to stay home to keep society safe, but the bill for staying home is the very thing pushing you towards instability. 474 00:40:28,585 --> 00:40:32,788 Then, predictably, inflation follows cheap money. 475 00:40:32,789 --> 00:40:34,766 Supply chains seize 476 00:40:34,766 --> 00:40:36,226 prices climb. 477 00:40:36,246 --> 00:40:45,506 The cost of daily life balloons and the same Fed that flooded the system with cheap money starts pulling the brake and rates rise. 478 00:40:45,586 --> 00:40:49,866 Mortgages get heavier, deals die, buyers disappear. 479 00:40:50,126 --> 00:41:02,846 But here's the trap, higher rates make homes harder to buy, especially when the price is already inflated and people who locked in low mortgages in 2020 and 2021 don't want to 480 00:41:02,846 --> 00:41:03,360 move. 481 00:41:03,360 --> 00:41:07,211 inventory tightens and the market freezes in place. 482 00:41:07,371 --> 00:41:13,273 So by the time the country is recovering, it's in a housing market worse than the one we entered with. 483 00:41:13,273 --> 00:41:18,354 Prices elevated, mortgage rates punishing, inventory scarce. 484 00:41:18,354 --> 00:41:20,995 First time buyers boxed out again. 485 00:41:21,075 --> 00:41:23,636 COVID didn't invent the housing crisis. 486 00:41:23,636 --> 00:41:26,436 It put the crisis on steroids. 487 00:41:26,537 --> 00:41:30,338 And in America, crisis is not just a disaster. 488 00:41:30,338 --> 00:41:32,148 It's a sorting mechanism. 489 00:41:32,270 --> 00:41:39,210 Some people lived through the pandemic and came out with more equity, more stock gains, more leverage, and more options. 490 00:41:39,510 --> 00:41:43,070 They worked on laptops and their money worked while they slept. 491 00:41:43,330 --> 00:41:55,530 Since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, the wealth of the wealthiest Americans has surged significantly, with the top 1 % saying their wealth increased by approximately $4 492 00:41:55,530 --> 00:42:01,730 trillion, reaching a record $52 trillion by mid-2025. 493 00:42:01,824 --> 00:42:02,824 Overall, U.S. 494 00:42:02,824 --> 00:42:14,034 billionaires' assets have nearly doubled, with their combined wealth growing from $4 trillion in early 2020 to about $8.1 trillion by the end of 2025. 495 00:42:14,080 --> 00:42:25,325 Other people lived through the pandemic and came out with debt, anxiety, lost savings, lost time, and the kind of instability that doesn't show up on a chart until it becomes 496 00:42:25,325 --> 00:42:27,628 eviction, homelessness, 497 00:42:27,628 --> 00:42:33,100 or moving your kids again because your neighborhood got too expensive while you were trying to survive. 498 00:42:33,100 --> 00:42:36,080 That is the financialization of survival. 499 00:42:36,080 --> 00:42:40,762 The conversion of a public health emergency into a private wealth event. 500 00:42:40,762 --> 00:42:46,884 And the people who minimize the danger to protect the economy weren't just protecting GDP. 501 00:42:46,884 --> 00:42:53,465 They were protecting the machine that decides who gets to own the future and who just keeps paying for it. 502 00:42:53,766 --> 00:42:55,970 By now, the playbook is familiar. 503 00:42:55,970 --> 00:43:00,393 manage attention during the crisis, manage assets after it. 504 00:43:00,593 --> 00:43:06,157 You see the pattern of equity following catastrophe in neighborhoods all across America. 505 00:43:06,157 --> 00:43:10,840 And one particularly tragic occurrence was in Altadena, California. 506 00:43:11,020 --> 00:43:21,998 Altadena is a foothill community where porches matter, where neighbors know your and your dog's names, where you can smell citrus when the wind comes down from the San Gabriel 507 00:43:21,998 --> 00:43:22,968 Mountains. 508 00:43:23,069 --> 00:43:25,170 A place built in layers. 509 00:43:25,302 --> 00:43:27,583 Early settlers chasing water. 510 00:43:27,583 --> 00:43:32,704 Ranchers and growers proving the land could produce at higher elevations. 511 00:43:32,704 --> 00:43:36,765 Midwestern transplants chasing health and sunlight. 512 00:43:36,765 --> 00:43:43,267 And eventually, black families chasing something even rarer in mid-century California. 513 00:43:43,267 --> 00:43:45,348 A fair shot at ownership. 514 00:43:45,348 --> 00:43:53,960 In 1960, it was still overwhelmingly white, but the 1960s and 70s hit Southern California like an earthquake. 515 00:43:54,112 --> 00:44:06,300 School integration fights, redevelopment battles in Pasadena, freeways carving up neighborhoods, smog thickening against the mountains, and the larger national convulsions 516 00:44:06,300 --> 00:44:11,133 of civil rights, riots, war, and assassinations. 517 00:44:11,334 --> 00:44:22,781 White flight followed, and in the vacuum, minorities moved in, many of them Black families who had been shut out of mortgages and neighborhoods across the region by discrimination 518 00:44:22,781 --> 00:44:23,942 and red lines. 519 00:44:24,374 --> 00:44:29,136 Altadena became for many families what the American dream was supposed to be. 520 00:44:29,136 --> 00:44:33,958 A house that could become stability, then security, then inheritance. 521 00:44:34,159 --> 00:44:38,701 That history matters because catastrophe doesn't just burn structures. 522 00:44:38,701 --> 00:44:41,792 It burns leverage and upward mobility. 523 00:44:45,838 --> 00:44:51,138 In January 2025, a powerful Santa Ana wind event took shape. 524 00:44:51,398 --> 00:45:00,818 Dry forceful winds accelerated through passes and canyons with forecasts warning of dangerous gusts and extreme fire conditions. 525 00:45:01,358 --> 00:45:04,278 The region had endured months of dry weather. 526 00:45:04,418 --> 00:45:08,758 By the time the catastrophe arrived, the landscape was primed. 527 00:45:08,758 --> 00:45:15,590 Dry grasses and shrubs, low humidity, and wind that doesn't just push fire, it throws it. 528 00:45:20,290 --> 00:45:22,491 businesses and other structures were destroyed. 529 00:45:22,491 --> 00:45:26,484 CBS News correspondent Carter Evans joins us now from Pacific Palisades, California. 530 00:45:26,484 --> 00:45:29,930 So Carter, what new information did this report reveal? 531 00:45:29,930 --> 00:45:32,357 there have been lot of reporting all night long. 532 00:45:32,357 --> 00:45:35,549 This fire, the Eaton fire has chewed through homes. 533 00:45:35,549 --> 00:45:39,670 This is one of them that we're able to get close to ah at this hour. 534 00:45:39,670 --> 00:45:41,494 What we're seeing is. 535 00:45:41,494 --> 00:45:43,976 Honestly, pure pandemonium and chaos. 536 00:45:43,976 --> 00:45:48,679 huge plume of smoke is blowing all across Al-Fadina and Al-Fadina, right? 537 00:45:48,679 --> 00:45:52,792 We just have one house after another that is completely on fire. 538 00:45:52,792 --> 00:45:58,046 Only way to describe the destruction of what we're seeing out here, it looks like a war zone. 539 00:46:00,096 --> 00:46:05,068 On the evening of January 7th, the fire ignited near Eden Canyon. 540 00:46:05,268 --> 00:46:10,671 Within minutes, it was moving with the kind of speed that makes a neighborhood feel like paper. 541 00:46:10,771 --> 00:46:14,812 Embers jumped, spot fires formed at distance. 542 00:46:15,233 --> 00:46:25,417 Air tankers were forced to pull back from violent air, and the fire grew into a structure-eating event that outpaced the normal rhythm of response. 543 00:46:25,998 --> 00:46:27,010 By the end, 544 00:46:27,010 --> 00:46:35,876 The Eden Fire killed 19 people and destroyed more than 9,000 buildings, becoming one of the most destructive fires in California history. 545 00:46:35,896 --> 00:46:47,804 The cause, as later determined, pointed to high-tension power lines operated by Southern California Edison, the primary electric utility company for much of Southern California. 546 00:46:47,804 --> 00:46:57,030 A private utility and serving 15 million people across approximately 50,000 square miles, a regulated monopoly. 547 00:46:57,408 --> 00:47:05,982 It is a corporation entrusted with infrastructure so essential that failure doesn't just inconvenience people, it can kill them. 548 00:47:05,982 --> 00:47:17,607 That detail matters because if you want to understand why privatization paired with corporate personhood is dangerous, California has already run the experiment. 549 00:47:17,808 --> 00:47:21,769 Look north to Butte County, Paradise, California. 550 00:47:21,770 --> 00:47:23,298 In 2018, 551 00:47:23,298 --> 00:47:28,180 The Camp Fire became the deadliest wildfire in California history at that point. 552 00:47:28,180 --> 00:47:40,705 This was in the territory of Pacific Gas and Electric Company, or PG &E, an investor-owned utility that covers the northern two-thirds of California, providing natural gas and 553 00:47:40,705 --> 00:47:44,067 electricity to 5.2 million households. 554 00:47:44,067 --> 00:47:51,894 The cause of the Camp Fire was PG &E's Caribou Palermo transmission line, built in 1921. 555 00:47:51,916 --> 00:47:54,787 nearly a century old when it failed. 556 00:47:54,848 --> 00:48:05,793 Investigators found the company knew the risk, knew the infrastructure was aging, knew the danger, and still failed to act because of high costs for repairs and upgrades. 557 00:48:05,894 --> 00:48:12,777 PG &E pleaded guilty to 84 felony counts of involuntary manslaughter for the campfire. 558 00:48:12,857 --> 00:48:14,298 Eighty-four. 559 00:48:14,338 --> 00:48:16,519 One for each life loss. 560 00:48:16,920 --> 00:48:22,002 It also pleaded guilty to a felony count tied to its own criminal negligence. 561 00:48:22,303 --> 00:48:24,904 And PG &E wasn't new to this. 562 00:48:25,004 --> 00:48:34,551 At the time, the company was already on probation for federal felonies related to the 2010 San Bruno gas explosion that killed eight people. 563 00:48:34,611 --> 00:48:38,714 Another case rooted in poor safety practice and management failure. 564 00:48:38,714 --> 00:48:44,998 The consequences, like so many corporate consequences, were structured to preserve continuity. 565 00:48:44,998 --> 00:48:50,614 Fines, settlements, bankruptcy reorganization, policy changes, 566 00:48:50,614 --> 00:49:02,762 and an uncomfortable political fact that even after becoming a convicted felon, PG &E continued to lobby and politicians continue to accept its donations. 567 00:49:02,963 --> 00:49:06,365 This is the problem with treating corporations like people. 568 00:49:06,365 --> 00:49:10,327 When a person commits manslaughter, we ask, who did it? 569 00:49:10,348 --> 00:49:17,773 When a corporation commits manslaughter, the answer dissolves into org charts, committees, and quarterly reports. 570 00:49:17,873 --> 00:49:19,724 The company pays a fine 571 00:49:19,724 --> 00:49:22,677 writes a press release, and keeps operating. 572 00:49:22,677 --> 00:49:35,147 PG &E has since faced additional scrutiny, including investigations tied to later fires like the Zogg fire in 2020, raising similar questions about inspection, maintenance, and 573 00:49:35,147 --> 00:49:36,588 risk management. 574 00:49:36,648 --> 00:49:42,934 To be clear, Southern California Edison is not PG &E, but the structure rhymes. 575 00:49:42,934 --> 00:49:48,494 Privatized utilities, shareholder pressures, aging infrastructure, 576 00:49:48,494 --> 00:49:58,977 climate accelerated risk, political insulation, and regulatory systems that punish after the fact rather than preventing catastrophe before it happens. 577 00:49:59,237 --> 00:50:03,398 And here's where the Eden Fire folds back into Altadena's story. 578 00:50:03,398 --> 00:50:08,480 Because the fire didn't just destroy homes, it destroyed generational wealth. 579 00:50:08,480 --> 00:50:13,661 In the wake of the Eden Fire, signs sprouted up in ash-laden yards. 580 00:50:13,781 --> 00:50:16,732 Quote, Altadena not for sale. 581 00:50:17,208 --> 00:50:24,341 But families who might have rebuilt over five or 10 years suddenly face decisions measured in weeks. 582 00:50:24,421 --> 00:50:31,804 Stay displaced, drain savings, fight insurers, or sell and try to move forward. 583 00:50:31,804 --> 00:50:33,925 Developers don't feel that pressure. 584 00:50:33,925 --> 00:50:37,566 They arrive with cash, patients, and attorneys. 585 00:50:37,667 --> 00:50:40,748 This is how disaster becomes acquisition. 586 00:50:40,948 --> 00:50:44,149 Burned lots are a particular kind of opportunity. 587 00:50:44,149 --> 00:50:46,260 To investors, they look clean. 588 00:50:46,262 --> 00:50:51,105 No old structure, no renovation surprises, just location. 589 00:50:51,106 --> 00:51:01,114 Schools, foothill charm, proximity to Pasadena and job centers, and the brutal fact that many families cannot afford years of rebuilding. 590 00:51:01,254 --> 00:51:04,457 If you can't carry the cost of waiting, you sell. 591 00:51:04,457 --> 00:51:10,321 If you sell under pressure, someone with cash has the leverage in negotiations. 592 00:51:10,362 --> 00:51:16,276 If enough lots change hands, the neighborhood's future gets written by whoever can afford the pen. 593 00:51:16,632 --> 00:51:20,003 That's the fear in Altadena, a reversal current. 594 00:51:20,003 --> 00:51:27,025 The first wave of white flight created conditions for black home ownership at scale in a region that often denied it. 595 00:51:27,025 --> 00:51:30,686 Families built wealth in a place where they could finally buy. 596 00:51:30,686 --> 00:51:32,506 They passed keys down. 597 00:51:32,507 --> 00:51:35,767 Now the fire knocked those keys out of people's hands. 598 00:51:35,767 --> 00:51:39,188 And the market doesn't ask what a neighborhood means. 599 00:51:39,349 --> 00:51:42,789 It asks what it can become and for how much. 600 00:51:43,270 --> 00:51:44,824 When the ash settles, 601 00:51:44,824 --> 00:51:48,296 The question isn't whether Altadena will be rebuilt. 602 00:51:48,296 --> 00:51:49,317 It will. 603 00:51:49,477 --> 00:51:58,063 The question is whether the people who made it, the families who turned the refuge into community, will still be there when the new paint dries. 604 00:51:58,063 --> 00:52:05,948 Because if catastrophe becomes a pipeline for acquisition, then the fire doesn't end when the containment hits 100%. 605 00:52:05,948 --> 00:52:08,530 It ends when the deed changes hands. 606 00:52:08,950 --> 00:52:14,954 And if new owners turn around and rent these homes, as trends suggest is likely, 607 00:52:15,000 --> 00:52:23,332 Tenants will have to contend with technology that is now playing an outsized role in housing insecurity for millions of renters. 608 00:52:23,653 --> 00:52:30,014 A widely cited rule of thumb says housing should consume no more than 30 % of income. 609 00:52:30,014 --> 00:52:33,375 Go much beyond that and shelter becomes a burden. 610 00:52:33,495 --> 00:52:38,757 Millions of renters now spend 50 % or more on rent and utilities. 611 00:52:38,757 --> 00:52:43,200 When half your paycheck goes to your landlord, what's left for healthcare? 612 00:52:43,200 --> 00:52:46,352 education, emergencies, savings. 613 00:52:46,473 --> 00:52:50,636 Rent burden becomes a trap rather than merely a cost. 614 00:52:50,857 --> 00:53:04,028 In October 2022, ProPublica published an investigation into RealPage, a Texas-based company whose rent-setting software provided price recommendations to property managers. 615 00:53:04,088 --> 00:53:06,811 The reporting raised a cold question. 616 00:53:06,811 --> 00:53:11,094 What happens when many of the largest landlords in a city 617 00:53:11,124 --> 00:53:18,940 used the same pricing tool informed by shared market data and rent increases began to move in parallel. 618 00:53:22,466 --> 00:53:33,554 take Atlanta, which is a down market right now and has suffered significant job loss and really an erosion of rental rates unlike we've seen in a long time. 619 00:53:33,554 --> 00:53:43,840 And what we found was, what we thought intuitively that in order to maintain the occupancy levels that we decided were important as the market went down was we felt that we were 620 00:53:43,840 --> 00:53:52,526 giving under the old system, just giving away too much to get to that point to be able to retain and maintain the occupancy levels that we had targeted for the properties. 621 00:53:52,598 --> 00:54:01,691 And as we began the switch over to YieldStar, we started to look to see what impact that would have on how we retained and how we brought new residents in. 622 00:54:01,691 --> 00:54:11,983 What we found was that under YieldStar, we didn't have to give away as much as the market was uh providing for in order to retain our occupancies. 623 00:54:11,983 --> 00:54:19,115 And we also found, from a renewal's perspective, that we didn't have to meet the market every day in order to keep our residents. 624 00:54:19,115 --> 00:54:21,806 And so what we found was that while 625 00:54:22,112 --> 00:54:24,053 rents inherently in Atlanta are going down. 626 00:54:24,053 --> 00:54:29,914 There's nothing that anybody either using Yieldstar or any other revenue management system can change that. 627 00:54:29,914 --> 00:54:34,385 What we found was though relative to our competitive set, we were outperforming. 628 00:54:34,385 --> 00:54:43,168 So we were maintaining our occupancies and at the same time, not having to give away the amount of revenue or the amount of rents, both for new leases and for renewals that our 629 00:54:43,168 --> 00:54:44,188 competitors were doing. 630 00:54:44,188 --> 00:54:47,829 And so for us and our partners, we viewed that to be very positive. 631 00:54:48,009 --> 00:54:51,586 If rent isn't only rising because of supply and demand, 632 00:54:51,586 --> 00:54:59,889 but because a system is guiding the market toward the highest tolerable price, then competition starts behaving differently. 633 00:54:59,969 --> 00:55:11,594 The Department of Justice and lawmakers began examining whether algorithmic pricing could facilitate coordination that old antitrust frameworks weren't built to anticipate. 634 00:55:12,755 --> 00:55:16,916 Now imagine, each lease renewal brings a higher number. 635 00:55:16,916 --> 00:55:19,997 Your friends across towns see the same. 636 00:55:19,998 --> 00:55:21,758 It feels like the market 637 00:55:21,878 --> 00:55:27,440 It feels inevitable, but zoom out and you see the possibility of something else. 638 00:55:27,500 --> 00:55:38,485 A market nudged by code, where comps are generated by the same system that recommends the next increase, where maximum tolerable rents become the target. 639 00:55:38,565 --> 00:55:46,668 Kind of sounds like collusion, but renters, because housing is an essential need, do whatever they can to stay. 640 00:55:46,988 --> 00:55:51,540 Good for business, bad for a society already under strain. 641 00:55:51,874 --> 00:56:02,937 And when your income is low and your rent is high, even a modest shock, a mischief, a medical bill, a car breakdown can tip you over. 642 00:56:03,157 --> 00:56:09,959 Eviction becomes less a story of personal failure and more a story of structural vulnerability. 643 00:56:09,959 --> 00:56:17,641 Eviction is not just losing a roof, it's losing stability, schooling, job access, support networks. 644 00:56:17,661 --> 00:56:20,702 It can propel households into homelessness. 645 00:56:20,748 --> 00:56:26,079 And once you've been evicted, your chances of rehousing decline sharply. 646 00:56:26,360 --> 00:56:32,681 In cities where wages haven't kept pace with housing costs, rent burden feeds homelessness. 647 00:56:32,681 --> 00:56:37,263 And homelessness rarely appears overnight like a lightning strike. 648 00:56:37,263 --> 00:56:40,983 It is often the final stage of a longer sequence. 649 00:56:41,064 --> 00:56:50,066 Low wages, constrained supply, rising rents, lack of savings, shocks, eviction, then no fallback. 650 00:56:50,358 --> 00:57:00,706 In Matthew Desmond's book, Evicted, he documents the lifestyle and conditions for low-income families in Milwaukee, sharing a blunt insight. 651 00:57:00,967 --> 00:57:04,250 Evictions aren't simply a result of poverty. 652 00:57:04,250 --> 00:57:06,771 They can deepen and reproduce it. 653 00:57:06,792 --> 00:57:12,536 Displacement unravels job stability, school continuity, social ties. 654 00:57:12,657 --> 00:57:14,638 Poverty compounds. 655 00:58:34,808 --> 00:58:36,098 So what do we do? 656 00:58:36,419 --> 00:58:48,385 Well, there are tools and policies like Housing First, Eviction Moratoria, Right to Counsel in Housing Court, Rental Assistance, and Strong Tenant Protections. 657 00:58:48,686 --> 00:58:59,752 These are often framed as radical solutions, but in reality, they're baseline interventions, attempts to stabilize people before the ground disappears beneath them. 658 00:59:00,773 --> 00:59:02,894 During the Obama administration, 659 00:59:02,894 --> 00:59:08,037 Housing First moved from localized models into broader federal policy. 660 00:59:08,117 --> 00:59:10,598 The premise was disarmingly simple. 661 00:59:10,598 --> 00:59:18,402 If you want someone to address addiction, mental illness, unemployment, or trauma, they need a door that locks first. 662 00:59:18,503 --> 00:59:30,509 Housing First prioritizes permanent housing as quickly as possible with voluntary supportive services layered afterward without requiring sobriety, treatment, or readiness 663 00:59:30,509 --> 00:59:32,010 as a precondition. 664 00:59:32,270 --> 00:59:35,970 This wasn't just philosophy, it was evidence driven. 665 00:59:36,190 --> 00:59:47,850 Studies show that approximately 85 % of individuals in Housing First programs remain housed for years, indicating a significant improvement over traditional models. 666 00:59:47,890 --> 00:59:57,430 There's also evidence of improvements in health and wellbeing among participants, although results can vary widely based on program implementation. 667 00:59:57,770 --> 01:00:01,400 Program evaluations repeatedly found that Housing First 668 01:00:01,400 --> 01:00:10,599 could reduce chronic homelessness and lower public costs by reducing reliance on emergency rooms, shelters, and the criminal legal system. 669 01:00:10,660 --> 01:00:13,422 But there are critics to this approach. 670 01:00:15,234 --> 01:00:22,036 The Housing First model tells us that people are homeless because they're down on their luck and all they need is a leg up. 671 01:00:22,036 --> 01:00:24,497 They need a house to stay in and they're gonna be fine. 672 01:00:24,497 --> 01:00:25,837 But that's not the case. 673 01:00:25,837 --> 01:00:35,090 Any of you who've dealt with addiction in your lives, in your family's lives, and I know that every single one of you has been touched by addiction by somebody, knows that you 674 01:00:35,090 --> 01:00:41,271 can't just give them some money or give them an apartment or give them a college degree and they're gonna be fine. 675 01:00:41,271 --> 01:00:43,232 No, they've gotta deal with the demon. 676 01:00:43,232 --> 01:00:46,364 of drug and alcohol abuse in their lives. 677 01:00:46,364 --> 01:00:52,527 The criticism typically comes from two places and they often get blurred together on purpose. 678 01:00:52,527 --> 01:01:04,073 There are good faith critiques, concerns that voluntary services may not be enough for people with severe needs, that supportive housing is expensive and slow to build, that a 679 01:01:04,073 --> 01:01:11,738 shift in funds from programs that require treatment to providing units can multiply tents faster than units. 680 01:01:11,738 --> 01:01:12,898 These are real. 681 01:01:12,898 --> 01:01:17,140 They're problems of scale, supply, and clinical capacity. 682 01:01:17,140 --> 01:01:23,022 We've spent $10 billion in the past few years on the Housing First model. 683 01:01:23,623 --> 01:01:28,665 That has resulted in 35 % more housing units, which is great. 684 01:01:28,665 --> 01:01:32,546 But it's also resulted in 48 % more people on the streets. 685 01:01:32,586 --> 01:01:42,130 But the loudest backlash often comes from somewhere else, an ideology that treats homelessness as moral failure instead of market outcome. 686 01:01:42,188 --> 01:01:46,123 In that worldview, housing without punishment feels like cheating. 687 01:01:46,123 --> 01:01:49,587 Stability without compliance feels undeserved. 688 01:01:49,587 --> 01:01:59,468 That's where the conversation gets messy, especially in California, where homelessness is both enormous in scale and constantly politicized. 689 01:02:01,112 --> 01:02:15,972 California has spent extraordinary sums in recent years, often cited around $24 billion since 2019, across dozens of programs, housing conversions, supportive services, grants to 690 01:02:15,972 --> 01:02:21,356 local governments, encampment response, and behavioral health investments. 691 01:02:21,416 --> 01:02:30,446 In March 2024, voters narrowly approved Proposition 1, authorizing billions in bonds for behavioral health facilities 692 01:02:30,446 --> 01:02:34,606 in housing for veterans and people experiencing homelessness. 693 01:02:34,766 --> 01:02:43,606 The state also created encampment resolution funding to help jurisdictions move people off the street and into housing. 694 01:02:43,626 --> 01:02:45,206 Then came the audit. 695 01:02:45,486 --> 01:02:57,016 Later in 2024, the California State Auditor reported that the state had not consistently tracked whether large portions of its homelessness spending actually improved outcomes. 696 01:02:57,016 --> 01:03:02,508 The review found that only some programs could be assessed as likely cost effective. 697 01:03:02,508 --> 01:03:06,350 Others could not be evaluated because of insufficient data. 698 01:03:06,350 --> 01:03:11,552 A state senator who requested the audit described the landscape as a data desert. 699 01:03:11,552 --> 01:03:14,053 That's not proof that programs can't work. 700 01:03:14,053 --> 01:03:18,095 It's proof that accountability systems didn't keep pace with spending. 701 01:03:18,095 --> 01:03:24,337 And in any data desert, uncertainty follows and corruption can grow like weeds. 702 01:03:24,398 --> 01:03:25,794 In 2025, 703 01:03:25,794 --> 01:03:38,107 Federal prosecutors brought real cases alleging fraud tied to homelessness funding, fake financial documents, suspicious property flips, secrecy clauses, and public money buying 704 01:03:38,107 --> 01:03:39,398 private margin. 705 01:03:39,398 --> 01:03:42,579 If proven, those cases demand accountability. 706 01:03:42,579 --> 01:03:44,979 But they also serve another function. 707 01:03:44,979 --> 01:03:51,821 They fuel political narratives designed to discredit political parties and Housing Firsts by association. 708 01:03:51,821 --> 01:03:54,338 Not because Housing Firsts is corrupt, 709 01:03:54,338 --> 01:04:07,758 But because it competes, like public housing before it, housing first removes people from profit-generating pipelines, emergency rooms, jails, treatment churn, eviction cycles, and 710 01:04:07,758 --> 01:04:13,613 most critically, it reframes housing as infrastructure, not commodity. 711 01:04:13,613 --> 01:04:21,318 Studies have shown that it stabilizes lives in ways that reduce recurring revenue for systems built on crisis. 712 01:04:21,396 --> 01:04:30,829 And it's important to caution that abandoning an evidence-based model because oversight failed repeats a familiar American move. 713 01:04:30,829 --> 01:04:34,409 Sabotage the system, then declare it broken. 714 01:04:34,630 --> 01:04:41,351 Housing First gets blamed not for what it is, but for what the surrounding system refuses to become. 715 01:04:41,351 --> 01:04:45,553 So the choice isn't between Housing First and accountability. 716 01:04:45,553 --> 01:04:50,454 It's between abandoning what works or fixing the system around it. 717 01:04:50,454 --> 01:04:51,244 That means 718 01:04:51,244 --> 01:05:03,714 Tracking outcomes and enforcing audits, closing loopholes that let public dollars leak into private extraction, scaling housing supply so vouchers have somewhere to land, and 719 01:05:03,714 --> 01:05:07,868 pairing emergency response with structural reform. 720 01:05:07,868 --> 01:05:13,212 But even a strong model hits a hard ceiling in an unaffordable market. 721 01:05:13,212 --> 01:05:20,950 If rents are detached from wages, if supply is constrained, if land is treated as speculative asset, 722 01:05:20,950 --> 01:05:26,091 instead of shelter, then Housing First is still triage instead of cure. 723 01:05:26,091 --> 01:05:32,613 You can help someone into a unit, but you can't solve a structural shortage one voucher at a time. 724 01:05:32,613 --> 01:05:34,634 Messaging matters here too. 725 01:05:34,654 --> 01:05:44,057 Based on a 2019 point in time count, approximately one third of homeless individuals have a mental health or substance abuse issue. 726 01:05:44,057 --> 01:05:49,486 So most people become homeless because they couldn't find a job that paid a sustainable wage, 727 01:05:49,486 --> 01:05:56,191 housing is unaffordable, or they encounter family issues including death, divorce, or abuse. 728 01:05:56,191 --> 01:06:08,230 But public perception of homelessness is constantly shaped through images of encampments, selective stories of disorder, moral narratives that shift from lack of shelter to 729 01:06:08,230 --> 01:06:10,181 choosing to be unhoused. 730 01:06:10,181 --> 01:06:13,784 That framing invites punishment instead of solutions. 731 01:06:13,784 --> 01:06:17,286 It makes enforcement easier to sell than investment. 732 01:06:17,292 --> 01:06:25,134 You can see the outer edge of that dehumanization and cruel rhetoric from public figures like Brian Kilmeade on Fox News. 733 01:06:27,298 --> 01:06:36,383 Billions of dollars to mental health and the homeless population a lot of them don't want to take the programs a lot of them don't want to get the help that is necessary you can't 734 01:06:36,383 --> 01:06:45,648 give them a choice either you take the resources that we're going to give you and or you decide that you're to be locked up in jail that's the way it has to be now or uh 735 01:06:45,648 --> 01:06:47,850 Involuntary lethal injection or something. 736 01:06:47,850 --> 01:06:48,900 I just kill him Brian. 737 01:06:48,900 --> 01:06:50,611 Why did it have to get to this point? 738 01:06:50,611 --> 01:06:54,093 I would say this we're not voting for the right people in North Carolina wake up. 739 01:06:54,093 --> 01:06:55,934 It's the same old play 740 01:06:55,980 --> 01:07:00,473 strip people of humanity and the public becomes numb to their suffering. 741 01:07:01,335 --> 01:07:05,398 After the Obama administration, government posture changed. 742 01:07:05,398 --> 01:07:12,923 Housing and civil rights were no longer framed as protections to be enforced, but as constraints to be rolled back. 743 01:07:12,965 --> 01:07:15,887 Donald Trump didn't arrive at this moment neutral. 744 01:07:15,887 --> 01:07:22,250 His worldview was shaped by ownership, not shelter, and by a career as a landlord. 745 01:07:22,250 --> 01:07:23,938 In 1973, 746 01:07:23,938 --> 01:07:32,201 the Justice Department sued Trump and his father for refusing to rent apartments in predominantly white buildings to black tenants. 747 01:07:32,201 --> 01:07:37,183 Applications from black renters were allegedly marked with a C for colored. 748 01:07:37,183 --> 01:07:46,367 The case ended without an admission of guilt, but the government stated the Trumps had failed and neglected to comply with the Fair Housing Act. 749 01:07:46,367 --> 01:07:52,210 As part of the consent decree, the Trumps promised to basically desegregate their properties. 750 01:07:52,210 --> 01:07:53,698 But three years later, 751 01:07:53,698 --> 01:07:59,102 the Justice Department returned to court alleging non-compliance again. 752 01:07:59,142 --> 01:08:11,151 Then in 1982, Trump management faced another class action discrimination suit, settling by again agreeing to rent a share of vacant units to black tenants. 753 01:08:11,952 --> 01:08:19,997 Stanley Leibowitz, a rental agent for the Trumps at the time, later described his experience to NBC News. 754 01:08:20,522 --> 01:08:29,846 A black lady completed an application for an apartment in the building, a one-bedroom apartment as I recall. 755 01:08:30,867 --> 01:08:34,878 And it was a very professionally cleared application. 756 01:08:34,878 --> 01:08:37,569 It was checked and verified. 757 01:08:37,569 --> 01:08:40,911 There were no liens, no judgments against her. 758 01:08:42,351 --> 01:08:48,724 And she was calling me on a daily basis wanting to know the status of her application. 759 01:08:48,974 --> 01:08:51,174 And one day Mr. 760 01:08:51,174 --> 01:09:04,334 Trump and his son Donald came into the office and I asked this Fred Trump what I should do with this application because she's calling me constantly. 761 01:09:04,974 --> 01:09:11,594 And his response to me was, you know, I don't rent to the N word. 762 01:09:12,314 --> 01:09:15,878 Put the application in the desk and forget about it. 763 01:09:17,710 --> 01:09:22,270 So, Fred Trump is the N-word, told you, you don't credit to people? 764 01:09:22,270 --> 01:09:24,270 That is correct, yes. 765 01:09:24,670 --> 01:09:27,250 What was your response? 766 01:09:27,950 --> 01:09:30,850 Well, I was employed by them. 767 01:09:30,850 --> 01:09:33,430 I did what he said. 768 01:09:33,490 --> 01:09:38,130 The reporter followed up to find out Donald Trump's actions at the time. 769 01:09:38,130 --> 01:09:45,390 And when his father told you not to rent apartments to people of color, what was Donald's response? 770 01:09:45,850 --> 01:09:47,370 And he shook his head. 771 01:09:48,318 --> 01:09:50,956 And that's the way it's supposed to be. 772 01:09:50,956 --> 01:09:54,676 Degreeing with his father. 773 01:09:57,260 --> 01:10:03,095 Later as president, Donald Trump's administration went on to weaken fair housing enforcement. 774 01:10:03,095 --> 01:10:06,057 Whatever the politics, the pattern holds. 775 01:10:06,058 --> 01:10:08,420 Ownership remains protected. 776 01:10:08,420 --> 01:10:10,882 Exclusion remains active. 777 01:10:10,882 --> 01:10:20,470 When you trace ownership, exclusion, and disinvestment, homeownership on one side, homelessness on the other, you don't see two separate stories. 778 01:10:20,470 --> 01:10:23,853 You see two endpoints of the same pipeline. 779 01:10:23,853 --> 01:10:26,156 And this isn't only American. 780 01:10:26,156 --> 01:10:29,349 Around the world, housing shortages are acute. 781 01:10:29,349 --> 01:10:38,536 Population growth, urban migration, limited usable land, climate stress, and the financialization of real estate converge. 782 01:10:38,596 --> 01:10:45,502 Institutional investors, private equity, and REITs compete for housing as an asset class. 783 01:10:45,502 --> 01:10:48,785 Affordability and sustainability collide. 784 01:10:48,785 --> 01:10:55,000 The rising costs of labor and materials, lengthening construction timelines, and income 785 01:10:55,000 --> 01:11:01,955 These regulations have pushed architects, developers, and policy makers to rethink how we build. 786 01:11:01,955 --> 01:11:08,499 I've had ongoing conversations with professionals attempting to tackle these problems through design. 787 01:11:08,499 --> 01:11:10,661 Two key themes emerge. 788 01:11:10,661 --> 01:11:13,142 Build faster and build smarter. 789 01:11:13,142 --> 01:11:19,187 In dense urban markets, there have been explorations into micro housing and co-living. 790 01:11:19,187 --> 01:11:24,640 Smaller units with shared kitchens, lounges, co-living models emerged. 791 01:11:24,654 --> 01:11:32,333 Think Tokyo's capsule apartments as a way to reduce per-tenant costs while staying in city cores. 792 01:11:34,542 --> 01:11:41,745 Steve Schapilski, CEO and co-founder of Stay Open, shared his insight on pod hotels. 793 01:11:42,025 --> 01:11:44,196 And I said, what are the pain points of a hostel? 794 01:11:44,196 --> 01:11:51,355 And one of those pain points was you don't get any privacy and the bunk beds are like you're sleeping like in a prison cell, right? 795 01:11:51,355 --> 01:11:56,131 And like the mattresses are razor thin and you have no physical barriers. 796 01:11:56,131 --> 01:11:58,592 You have no privacy with lighting. 797 01:11:58,592 --> 01:12:04,494 So we started to explore different concepts in Australia, New Zealand, actually, and in Asia. 798 01:12:04,702 --> 01:12:14,576 And we're like, okay, there's people that are using pods, some which, you know, looked like porta-potties, like plastic-y, space-ag, and we didn't like those, and some that were 799 01:12:14,576 --> 01:12:16,257 very cool and designed. 800 01:12:16,257 --> 01:12:18,988 And we're like, okay, those are, there's a little bit more along the lines. 801 01:12:18,988 --> 01:12:28,322 And we designed ours in-house on our own and built them in Southern California with the vendor, actually, the company that did our cabinets for our hotel. 802 01:12:28,322 --> 01:12:31,053 We're like, can you kind of build a big cabinet with a mattress in it? 803 01:12:31,053 --> 01:12:33,518 And we did lighting and we did. 804 01:12:33,518 --> 01:12:38,558 some like sound insulation and ventilation and a bunch of charging ports. 805 01:12:38,558 --> 01:12:40,078 We tested them. 806 01:12:40,078 --> 01:12:45,598 So we said, know, a pod is finds this great middle ground where we can have a room with eight people. 807 01:12:45,598 --> 01:12:51,318 But when you close up your pod, you may, don't know if there's one other person or if there's seven other people in there. 808 01:12:51,318 --> 01:12:59,758 And when someone comes in and flips on the lights to the room, it's not going to bother you because your lights insulated, you can flip on a light, you can charge your devices. 809 01:12:59,758 --> 01:13:02,104 You know, it doesn't take up that much more real estate, but we 810 01:13:02,104 --> 01:13:06,737 but like the bang for the buck in terms of user experience made a whole lot of sense. 811 01:13:07,498 --> 01:13:13,702 There are approaches like Passive House, Net Zero Housing, and even Net Zero Communities. 812 01:13:13,702 --> 01:13:26,691 These are buildings designed to use minimal energy, tight thermal envelopes, solar panels, efficient HVAC, reducing long-term costs, and helping tenants avoid runaway utility bills. 813 01:13:26,692 --> 01:13:30,454 I had an inspiring conversation with Matthew Grokoff. 814 01:13:30,456 --> 01:13:43,256 founder of Thrive Collaborative about Viridian at County Farm, a beautiful 13 and a half acre community in Ann Arbor, Michigan that is one of the US's first mixed income net zero 815 01:13:43,256 --> 01:13:44,937 energy communities. 816 01:13:45,759 --> 01:13:53,825 And so I said, if we do our job right and we start the design from the bottom up, meaning what is this land? 817 01:13:53,825 --> 01:13:55,727 Where does the water want to go? 818 01:13:55,727 --> 01:14:00,290 What was this land like pre-human development? 819 01:14:00,768 --> 01:14:08,321 And then all and so we began not by placing buildings on a square box, which is what all the other proposals did. 820 01:14:09,342 --> 01:14:17,305 We began by looking at the complexity of the soils and the water flow and the park were surrounded by 130 acre park. 821 01:14:17,305 --> 01:14:19,896 ah Where's that water coming from? 822 01:14:19,896 --> 01:14:23,588 Because the water in the park is part of the water that's on our site. 823 01:14:23,588 --> 01:14:28,150 They're not two separate things just because some lawyer drew a boundary around it. 824 01:14:28,886 --> 01:14:42,917 Lawyers love boundaries and water doesn't give a So we showed that pattern first and then what emerged was a street pattern, a path pattern that is almost identical. 825 01:14:42,917 --> 01:14:54,826 So on that first day in 2006 that we all got together in that room for eight hours, what emerged in that conversation is almost exactly what we ended up with here five years later 826 01:14:54,907 --> 01:14:59,050 and what we'll be building because the soil and the water 827 01:14:59,062 --> 01:15:03,544 and the ecology of that property is what guided the design. 828 01:15:03,844 --> 01:15:13,688 Modular construction, offsite building components, 3D printing for concrete shelves, all aiming to cut construction time and costs. 829 01:15:13,868 --> 01:15:24,772 One fascinating product I've come across is HyperFrame, a snap together metal framing system enhanced by software and mixed reality technology. 830 01:15:24,853 --> 01:15:28,524 Founder and CEO Ken Sobel discussed the product 831 01:15:28,524 --> 01:15:31,696 and how the system can lead to lower labor costs. 832 01:15:32,758 --> 01:15:42,396 Basically, the way that our application will work is that you pick up a piece off the ground, you glance at a QR code on that piece, you get some arrows, some holographic 833 01:15:42,396 --> 01:15:45,989 arrows that show you which way you should move your body or pivot your head. 834 01:15:45,989 --> 01:15:53,575 uh And then you see a hologram of the part you're holding in the physical location where you need to snap it in place. 835 01:15:53,575 --> 01:15:54,996 And so it's very visceral. 836 01:15:54,996 --> 01:15:57,334 um It's very 837 01:15:57,334 --> 01:16:00,585 It's like you don't even need to be trained on how to use it. 838 01:16:00,585 --> 01:16:04,457 It's just, it's like in the same way that you need to be trained how to use a video game. 839 01:16:04,457 --> 01:16:07,658 You just kind of like do what it tells you. 840 01:16:08,319 --> 01:16:18,803 The Yenby movement and advocacy for upzoning and high density housing near transit and jobs as one lever to increase supply and affordability. 841 01:16:18,803 --> 01:16:25,558 Chris Adams, president and founder of Balancing Act, highlighted that most people are aware of 842 01:16:25,558 --> 01:16:28,039 and went to solve the housing crisis. 843 01:16:28,080 --> 01:16:38,796 His innovative simulation tool changes the conversation with NIMBYs, helping local governments engage with constituents to collaboratively address complex housing 844 01:16:38,796 --> 01:16:39,966 challenges. 845 01:16:41,367 --> 01:16:50,913 And so what our tool does is instead of just saying, hey, we're thinking about rezoning this area three blocks or six blocks from your house, it says, this is what we need to do 846 01:16:50,913 --> 01:16:51,853 as a community. 847 01:16:51,853 --> 01:16:53,630 And then it provides 848 01:16:53,630 --> 01:17:00,915 options, places that could be changed, could be rezoned, could be accommodated in planning process for more housing. 849 01:17:00,915 --> 01:17:02,746 But then it also gives a goal. 850 01:17:02,746 --> 01:17:11,262 And that's really the key part is it gives the goal of the jurisdiction of the community and then asks people to show how they would meet that goal. 851 01:17:11,262 --> 01:17:19,108 And so it's perfectly fine for people to go in and participate using our simulation product and be against something, but they can't just be against it. 852 01:17:19,108 --> 01:17:22,730 They also have to say what they would do in order to meet the goal. 853 01:17:24,022 --> 01:17:31,886 And there are innovative materials that are renewable and cost effective like hemp that can revolutionize construction. 854 01:17:31,886 --> 01:17:40,271 Jacob Waddell from the Hemp Building Institute highlighted the capabilities of hemp and sustainable building practices. 855 01:17:40,711 --> 01:17:44,643 Hemp alone, you can do insulation in multiple ways. 856 01:17:44,643 --> 01:17:47,695 You can have hempcrete, you can have hemp bat insulation. 857 01:17:47,695 --> 01:17:52,418 There's boards that are like trying to replace like foam boards that are created. 858 01:17:52,418 --> 01:17:53,548 You have 859 01:17:54,006 --> 01:17:58,427 Hempwood that's used on flooring, cabinetry, desks. 860 01:17:58,507 --> 01:18:04,649 They're doing research right now to get it into uh being able to carry a structural load. 861 01:18:04,749 --> 01:18:08,600 You have pottery and interior design. 862 01:18:08,600 --> 01:18:11,031 can have fabrics. 863 01:18:11,031 --> 01:18:12,611 It's a little bit less construction. 864 01:18:12,611 --> 01:18:14,382 But then you have things like bamboo. 865 01:18:14,382 --> 01:18:18,573 And bamboo is amazingly amazing for structural components. 866 01:18:18,713 --> 01:18:23,424 So there's a wide range of things that can be used. 867 01:18:23,470 --> 01:18:26,352 for all aspects of a building. 868 01:18:26,352 --> 01:18:34,677 And it's really cool because you're seeing more and more companies come out with different products that kind of fill different gaps. 869 01:18:34,858 --> 01:18:42,263 the design and construction side, the industry has been busy solving for speed, efficiency, carbon, and costs. 870 01:18:42,263 --> 01:18:44,524 We have a surplus of tools. 871 01:18:44,565 --> 01:18:47,046 What we don't have is alignment. 872 01:18:47,046 --> 01:18:52,878 Because every one of these innovations runs headlong into two forces design alone, 873 01:18:52,878 --> 01:18:54,418 cannot defeat. 874 01:18:55,058 --> 01:18:57,898 Policy resistance and financialization. 875 01:18:58,358 --> 01:19:00,058 Start with resistance. 876 01:19:00,318 --> 01:19:04,078 Not the loud kind, the quiet institutional kind. 877 01:19:04,118 --> 01:19:11,038 The kind that doesn't chant at city hall, but files comments, drafts amendments, and writes checks. 878 01:19:11,418 --> 01:19:19,222 The National Association of Realtors is a useful case study with roughly 1.5 million members 879 01:19:19,222 --> 01:19:26,827 and one of the most powerful lobbying operations in Washington, NAR is a heavyweight in housing policy. 880 01:19:26,827 --> 01:19:33,450 Publicly, it talks about access and opportunity, but its incentives are complicated. 881 01:19:33,451 --> 01:19:41,275 Scarcity supports home and property values, and 6 % of that higher price is quite attractive to members. 882 01:19:41,495 --> 01:19:45,912 Appreciation supports wealth, and through local affiliates, 883 01:19:45,912 --> 01:19:51,045 Political campaigns often defend the zoning status quo that constrains supply. 884 01:19:51,045 --> 01:20:01,311 NOR has opposed or resisted some statewide up-zoning efforts that would legalize more small multifamily housing in single-family zones. 885 01:20:01,332 --> 01:20:09,237 It has lobbied for tax policies like restoring the full state and local tax, or SALT, deduction cap. 886 01:20:09,237 --> 01:20:12,010 Framed as protecting home values, 887 01:20:12,010 --> 01:20:17,791 even as benefits skew toward higher income homeowners in high cost markets. 888 01:20:18,072 --> 01:20:29,835 And while it has apologized for a segregationist past, the local politics of neighborhood preservation often continue to carry exclusionary outcomes. 889 01:20:29,915 --> 01:20:32,135 The contradiction is structural. 890 01:20:32,135 --> 01:20:41,778 The association that represents people who sell homes also lives inside a system where rising prices reward existing owners. 891 01:20:41,918 --> 01:20:43,239 and themselves. 892 01:20:43,439 --> 01:20:48,362 And then there's the force no amount of better design can solve on its own. 893 01:20:48,443 --> 01:20:50,184 Financialization. 894 01:20:50,244 --> 01:21:02,533 When housing is treated primarily as an asset, bundled into portfolios, traded by algorithms, warehoused by institutional investors, innovation becomes cosmetic. 895 01:21:02,613 --> 01:21:05,776 A net zero building can still be unaffordable. 896 01:21:05,776 --> 01:21:09,198 A modular unit can still be bid up by cash. 897 01:21:09,536 --> 01:21:18,390 A beautifully efficient apartment can still sit empty if it performs better as a balance sheet placeholder than as a place to live. 898 01:21:18,390 --> 01:21:21,611 When you map the system, the pattern is clear. 899 01:21:21,691 --> 01:21:27,774 Ownership for some, rent burden for many, homelessness for the most exposed. 900 01:21:27,934 --> 01:21:37,678 Consider that, a society where a majority are burdened and vulnerable, what type of leverage and control does that afford those with the most? 901 01:21:38,070 --> 01:21:46,835 Innovation runs into resistance, supply strains under demand, and all of it operates inside rules written by power. 902 01:21:46,835 --> 01:21:53,978 Rules that quietly decide who gets to stay, who gets priced out, and who never gets in at all. 903 01:21:53,998 --> 01:21:56,300 This isn't just a housing problem. 904 01:21:56,300 --> 01:21:58,981 It's a political economy problem. 905 01:21:58,981 --> 01:22:03,564 One that design can reveal, but only policy can undo. 906 01:22:03,684 --> 01:22:07,808 Division isn't simply gated communities versus public housing. 907 01:22:07,808 --> 01:22:13,703 It's embedded in tax codes, zoning maps, financing pipelines, and labor markets. 908 01:22:13,703 --> 01:22:18,587 It's who gets to own, who must rent, and who is pushed out entirely. 909 01:22:18,587 --> 01:22:26,194 When half your income goes to rent while someone across town builds equity, division is built into the bricks. 910 01:22:26,194 --> 01:22:33,499 When a rent hike leads to eviction while housing is converted into yield, division is built into the floors. 911 01:22:33,540 --> 01:22:36,876 When density is blocked in the name of character, 912 01:22:36,876 --> 01:22:39,688 division is built into the lot lines. 913 01:22:39,789 --> 01:22:43,171 And the divide isn't just in land and structures. 914 01:22:43,171 --> 01:22:56,693 It receives its power in the division of us as a society through the mapping of fear, shaping belief, nudging behavior, and steering outcomes at scale until disorientation 915 01:22:56,693 --> 01:23:00,886 becomes policy and displacement becomes predictable. 916 01:23:01,046 --> 01:23:02,488 We can build differently. 917 01:23:02,488 --> 01:23:05,804 We can protect renters, make ownership reachable, 918 01:23:05,804 --> 01:23:09,696 and restore a pathway from shelter to stability to equity. 919 01:23:09,696 --> 01:23:17,399 But first, we must ask, are the rules built for yesterday's winners or for tomorrow's neighbors? 920 01:23:17,839 --> 01:23:19,620 History gives us the warning. 921 01:23:19,620 --> 01:23:23,241 Power has always protected itself the same way. 922 01:23:23,521 --> 01:23:28,503 Name and other, stoke fear, destabilize, then acquire. 923 01:23:28,543 --> 01:23:35,316 From red scares to moral panic, fear has always mapped neatly onto land and profit. 924 01:23:35,500 --> 01:23:41,573 And now the pattern repeats at borders, in war zones, and in American cities. 925 01:23:41,573 --> 01:23:43,954 People are branded as threats. 926 01:23:44,115 --> 01:23:46,356 Neighborhoods are destabilized. 927 01:23:46,356 --> 01:23:48,037 Capital moves in. 928 01:23:48,097 --> 01:23:50,218 Division becomes policy. 929 01:23:50,218 --> 01:23:52,599 Property becomes the prize. 930 01:23:52,880 --> 01:24:04,578 We'll follow that map into the worlds of theocracy, technocracy, and oligarchy to identify where this all goes and expose who profits 931 01:24:04,578 --> 01:24:07,888 when fear redraws the lines of ownership. 932 01:24:08,112 --> 01:24:10,408 Next time on Built to Divide. 933 01:24:14,732 --> 01:24:16,143 in Gaza's waterfront property. 934 01:24:16,143 --> 01:24:21,978 could be very valuable to, ah if people would focus on kind of building up, know, livelihoods. 935 01:24:21,978 --> 01:24:25,191 You think about all the money that's gone into this tunnel network and into all the munitions. 936 01:24:25,191 --> 01:24:29,235 If that would have gone into education or innovation, what could have been done? 937 01:24:29,235 --> 01:24:37,412 And so I think that ah it's a little bit of an unfortunate situation there, but I think from Israel's perspective, I would do my best to move the people out and then clean it up. 938 01:24:37,412 --> 01:24:42,306 But I don't think that Israel has stated that they don't want the people to move back there afterwards. 939 01:24:55,854 --> 01:24:57,254 Thanks for listening. 940 01:24:57,435 --> 01:25:02,777 Built to Divide is presented by Lines, my architecture and creative studio. 941 01:25:03,138 --> 01:25:07,240 This podcast is produced in collaboration with Gable Media. 942 01:25:07,380 --> 01:25:13,724 If you enjoyed the show, please tell a friend and rate and review it on Apple podcasts and Spotify. 943 01:25:13,724 --> 01:25:15,684 It really helps others find it. 944 01:25:15,745 --> 01:25:23,589 And if you're looking for similar content, Built to Divide is part of the Gable Media network where you can find even more like this. 945 01:25:23,769 --> 01:25:25,848 Visit gablemedia.com. 946 01:25:25,848 --> 01:25:29,863 That's G-A-B-L media.com. 947 01:25:29,904 --> 01:25:40,939 And before I go, if you want to see additional photos, video clips, and content that went into this episode, you can visit me at lines.studio slash podcasts. 948 01:25:41,601 --> 01:25:42,612 Talk soon. 949 01:25:52,908 --> 01:25:56,949 When we came, these were the only two antique pieces of furniture in the room. 950 01:25:56,949 --> 01:25:58,980 This pair of card tables. 951 01:25:59,120 --> 01:26:04,641 As we hate to change, we decided that we would let them dictate the style of the room. 952 01:26:04,761 --> 01:26:16,304 But the funny thing about them is, know, Henry DuPont, who's the chairman of my committee in an established winter tour, he noticed them right away and said, these are the only 953 01:26:16,304 --> 01:26:17,295 good things in the room. 954 01:26:17,295 --> 01:26:18,865 I wonder who gave them. 955 01:26:18,865 --> 01:26:20,496 Turned out it was his sister, Mrs. 956 01:26:20,496 --> 01:26:21,886 Crown and Shield. 957 01:26:22,434 --> 01:26:26,075 What other objects of special interest are there in the room now? 958 01:26:26,176 --> 01:26:34,519 Well, there's this sofa, which belonged to Daniel Webster, and is really one of the finest pieces here in this room. 959 01:26:34,539 --> 01:26:37,360 And then there's this mirror. 960 01:26:37,940 --> 01:26:43,022 It was George Washington's, and he had it in the executive mansion in Philadelphia. 961 01:26:43,162 --> 01:26:48,434 Then he gave it to a friend, and it was bought for Mount Vernon in 1891. 962 01:26:48,574 --> 01:26:52,416 And it was there until Mount Vernon lent it to us this fall. 963 01:26:52,566 --> 01:26:56,706 And I must say, I appreciate that more than I can say. 964 01:26:56,706 --> 01:27:06,348 It's when Matt Vernon, which is probably the most revered house in this country, lends something to the White House, you know they have confidence that it will stay here and be 965 01:27:06,348 --> 01:27:07,710 taken care of.