1 00:00:00,049 --> 00:00:06,320 Despite what you may have heard recently, no, the polyvagal theory is not dead. 2 00:00:06,560 --> 00:00:07,800 Hi, I am Justin Sunseri. 3 00:00:08,810 --> 00:00:12,620 I'm a therapist and a member of the Polyvagal Institute's editorial board. 4 00:00:13,504 --> 00:00:14,254 What does that mean? 5 00:00:14,254 --> 00:00:17,915 That means I'm one of a handful of individuals who review other 6 00:00:17,915 --> 00:00:22,355 people's work for Polyvagal Theory accuracy, and it's been a huge part 7 00:00:22,355 --> 00:00:24,064 of this podcast here for years now. 8 00:00:24,754 --> 00:00:30,155 I've gotten a few questions recently from listeners about a new- question mark- 9 00:00:30,215 --> 00:00:33,095 debatably new polyvagal theory criticism. 10 00:00:33,455 --> 00:00:38,494 I dismissed these because they were linking me to third and fourth hand 11 00:00:38,494 --> 00:00:43,265 sources, uh, on Instagram, and I don't take them seriously in all honesty. 12 00:00:44,015 --> 00:00:48,844 But today, one of my, or yesterday as recording this, one of my Untucking 13 00:00:48,844 --> 00:00:53,705 Academy students messaged me with a link to a very popular YouTube 14 00:00:53,825 --> 00:00:59,165 psychology channel that gave us the bad news- the polyvagal theory is dead. 15 00:00:59,894 --> 00:01:00,674 Am I biased? 16 00:01:00,914 --> 00:01:01,994 Yeah, I am. 17 00:01:01,994 --> 00:01:03,074 You can probably hear it in my voice. 18 00:01:03,074 --> 00:01:08,534 I'm a little annoyed by this stuff, but I am much more interested in what's true. 19 00:01:08,714 --> 00:01:12,014 So yeah, I'm biased, but I want truth, or at least as close 20 00:01:12,014 --> 00:01:13,694 to the truth as we can get. 21 00:01:14,714 --> 00:01:15,944 Things need to make sense to me. 22 00:01:16,694 --> 00:01:20,054 None of what I discuss here has anything to do with bias. 23 00:01:20,954 --> 00:01:23,864 Hear out my arguments and decide for yourself. 24 00:01:25,184 --> 00:01:29,114 The writer of the article is Paul Grossman, and the article is called 25 00:01:29,354 --> 00:01:32,174 Why the Polyvagal Theory is Untenable. 26 00:01:32,174 --> 00:01:35,324 I'll put links in the description to that and to other things as well. 27 00:01:36,194 --> 00:01:41,384 Grossman has been a polyvagal theory critic for a very, very long time. 28 00:01:42,014 --> 00:01:45,854 Stephen Porges, the creator of the political theory, has replied to 29 00:01:45,854 --> 00:01:48,974 these criticisms numerous times. 30 00:01:49,379 --> 00:01:54,569 Over the many, many years, he, uh, port has even chatted with me on 31 00:01:54,569 --> 00:01:56,519 my podcast about these criticisms. 32 00:01:57,209 --> 00:02:00,999 I don't mind criticizing people's science, but I don't like to 33 00:02:00,999 --> 00:02:06,699 go on a, a offense where saying people are, are blatantly wrong. 34 00:02:07,009 --> 00:02:11,249 But it's really quite remarkable for over about a 20 year period. 35 00:02:11,769 --> 00:02:16,229 A couple of people were repeatedly misrepresenting the theory and publishing 36 00:02:16,229 --> 00:02:21,209 statements that were creating what is classically called a strawman argument. 37 00:02:21,259 --> 00:02:22,729 He's not shying away from them. 38 00:02:23,359 --> 00:02:26,509 I'm a therapist and even though my knowledge on the topic is 39 00:02:26,509 --> 00:02:28,519 deep, I'm gonna stay in my lane. 40 00:02:29,029 --> 00:02:33,529 I won't address, uh, either of who these two I think is right. 41 00:02:33,619 --> 00:02:38,809 Uh, but I will use critical thinking and simply check Porges' work and that's gonna 42 00:02:38,809 --> 00:02:40,609 tell us a lot and check both their work. 43 00:02:41,419 --> 00:02:44,779 You and I don't need to be experts in the polyvagal theory, actually. 44 00:02:44,929 --> 00:02:48,979 All we need to do is look at the new paper's claims about the polyvagal 45 00:02:48,979 --> 00:02:54,019 theory, and check whether Grossman accurately understands the theory. 46 00:02:54,889 --> 00:02:59,419 If he does not accurately understand the theory, then his counterarguments 47 00:02:59,419 --> 00:03:01,039 are kind of moot, right? 48 00:03:02,419 --> 00:03:06,139 At that point, he's arguing against his own interpretation 49 00:03:06,949 --> 00:03:08,599 and not the theory itself. 50 00:03:08,599 --> 00:03:10,069 This is extremely important. 51 00:03:10,220 --> 00:03:12,800 So they make the false statement, they say, this isn't true. 52 00:03:12,940 --> 00:03:15,320 Well, the theory never said that, and I would agree with them. 53 00:03:15,600 --> 00:03:19,840 That that's not true either, but then they would go on and on with these things. 54 00:03:19,860 --> 00:03:24,270 So let's start from the very beginning of the polyvagal of it all. 55 00:03:24,330 --> 00:03:25,110 The polyvagal theory. 56 00:03:25,560 --> 00:03:27,420 That is the vagal paradox. 57 00:03:28,260 --> 00:03:32,370 This question is what drove the creation of the poly vagal theory. 58 00:03:33,360 --> 00:03:37,860 Understanding the vagal paradox is obviously very important, right? 59 00:03:38,940 --> 00:03:40,710 Or at least for their purposes it is. 60 00:03:41,820 --> 00:03:46,710 Grossman says the vagal paradox often mentioned by Porges- this is a quote- 61 00:03:46,800 --> 00:03:51,030 often mentioned by Porges to indicate that RSA, which is respiratory sinus 62 00:03:51,030 --> 00:03:55,290 arrhythmia, sometimes correlates with changes in cardiac vagal tone 63 00:03:55,290 --> 00:04:00,090 and other times fails to, is not paradoxical at all when RSA is no 64 00:04:00,090 --> 00:04:02,430 longer equated with cardiac vagal tone. 65 00:04:03,090 --> 00:04:08,160 But when RSA is realistically considered as a vulnerable and approximate index 66 00:04:08,220 --> 00:04:13,470 of cardiac vagal tone constrained in its accuracy by many factors. 67 00:04:15,990 --> 00:04:16,740 That sounds good, right? 68 00:04:16,740 --> 00:04:18,960 It's kind of intimidating, lots of fancy words and whatnot. 69 00:04:18,960 --> 00:04:24,300 The only problem is that's not what the vagal paradox is, I'm not gonna 70 00:04:24,300 --> 00:04:25,950 speak for cor uh, Porges, of course. 71 00:04:26,490 --> 00:04:30,810 I'm, I'm simply gonna quote him from his paper called The Vagal Paradox. 72 00:04:31,200 --> 00:04:37,785 He says, how could the vagus be both protective when it was expressed as 73 00:04:37,785 --> 00:04:43,725 RSA and life-threatening when it was expressed as bradycardia and apnea? 74 00:04:44,835 --> 00:04:46,635 Okay, so what's the problem here? 75 00:04:48,075 --> 00:04:54,315 Grossman is fundamentally misidentifying what the vagal paradox actually is. 76 00:04:55,665 --> 00:04:59,955 Grossman reframes the vagal paradox as a measurement problem. 77 00:05:01,575 --> 00:05:05,895 He is essentially arguing that it's just a methodological limitation of 78 00:05:05,895 --> 00:05:10,095 RSA as an index of cardiac vagal tone. 79 00:05:11,265 --> 00:05:16,875 In his framing, there's no real paradox, just, um, an imprecise uh, measuring tool. 80 00:05:17,265 --> 00:05:18,525 The RSA is a measuring tool. 81 00:05:19,695 --> 00:05:23,145 But that's not the paradox that Porges identified. 82 00:05:23,985 --> 00:05:28,755 The actual vagal paradox, as Porges articulated it is a 83 00:05:28,755 --> 00:05:30,675 question about neurobiology. 84 00:05:30,675 --> 00:05:37,905 How the same nerve, the vagus, how it can be both life sustaining when expressed 85 00:05:37,905 --> 00:05:43,395 as RSA, which indicates healthy, uh, vagal tone and resilience, how it can 86 00:05:43,395 --> 00:05:48,315 be life sustaining and life threatening when it's expressed as bradycardia and 87 00:05:48,315 --> 00:05:51,255 apnea, which can kill a preterm infant. 88 00:05:52,395 --> 00:05:55,215 These are two completely different questions. 89 00:05:55,215 --> 00:05:57,825 I'll try to reword it one more time. 90 00:05:58,575 --> 00:06:03,945 Grossman's version is- is RSA good enough ruler for measuring vagal tone? 91 00:06:05,385 --> 00:06:10,335 Porges' actual version is, Why does the same nerve produce 92 00:06:10,395 --> 00:06:11,835 opposite survival outcomes? 93 00:06:13,770 --> 00:06:17,820 The vagal paradox drove porges to investigate the brainstem and to 94 00:06:17,820 --> 00:06:22,140 ultimately discover that there are two anatomically distinct vagal 95 00:06:22,140 --> 00:06:27,510 pathways originating from different brainstem nuclei with fundamentally 96 00:06:27,510 --> 00:06:32,310 different functions, uh, but both of which utilize the vagus nerve. 97 00:06:34,170 --> 00:06:40,290 A personal thought- and I find it very, very odd that Grossman did not include 98 00:06:40,290 --> 00:06:47,520 a direct quote from Porges in this critique paper about the vagal paradox. 99 00:06:48,360 --> 00:06:49,590 It took me 30 seconds. 100 00:06:49,860 --> 00:06:51,030 It's really not hard. 101 00:06:51,810 --> 00:06:54,990 Porges has a paper called The Vagal Paradox. 102 00:06:56,640 --> 00:07:00,630 I imagine if Grossman had maybe reread that paper, he would've 103 00:07:00,630 --> 00:07:02,160 realized that he misunderstood. 104 00:07:02,160 --> 00:07:03,510 I I, I would hope. 105 00:07:04,575 --> 00:07:09,855 I also find it odd that Grossman dismisses Porges' question about RSA 106 00:07:09,855 --> 00:07:13,095 and bradycardia in the vagal paradox. 107 00:07:14,025 --> 00:07:20,265 The polyvagal theory hypothesizes that the vagus nerve serves as the 108 00:07:20,265 --> 00:07:27,045 highway four, two heart rate- heart rate influences- ventral and dorsal. 109 00:07:28,365 --> 00:07:31,185 That's the theory derived from the vagal paradox. 110 00:07:32,445 --> 00:07:36,795 Why does Grossman ignore the bradycardia piece of this in his 111 00:07:36,795 --> 00:07:39,315 definition of the vagal paradox? 112 00:07:39,315 --> 00:07:40,365 He didn't mention it at all. 113 00:07:41,295 --> 00:07:44,325 Either he doesn't get it or he's ignoring it. 114 00:07:45,795 --> 00:07:51,615 Remember, Grossman is responding to Porges' vagal paradox question. 115 00:07:52,725 --> 00:07:56,865 Grossman does not have his own vagal paradox as, as best I can tell. 116 00:07:58,065 --> 00:08:05,055 So to respond to Porges' vagal paradox question, Grossman needs 117 00:08:05,055 --> 00:08:07,305 to accurately understand it, right? 118 00:08:08,805 --> 00:08:12,315 So why doesn't he accurately express Porges vagal paradox 119 00:08:12,315 --> 00:08:13,485 to set up his rebuttal? 120 00:08:14,835 --> 00:08:17,565 Either again, either he doesn't get it or he is ignoring it. 121 00:08:18,495 --> 00:08:23,895 And another reminder, Porges has responded to this guy numerous times. 122 00:08:24,435 --> 00:08:26,985 There is no excuse for this misunderstanding. 123 00:08:28,080 --> 00:08:31,350 I actually did a super easy, and this is something I knew just because I'm 124 00:08:31,350 --> 00:08:34,650 familiar with both of them, but I took it to another level and I did a really 125 00:08:34,650 --> 00:08:36,360 easy experiment that you can do yourself. 126 00:08:36,570 --> 00:08:40,260 So go to Grossman's paper, download it, and then go to 127 00:08:40,490 --> 00:08:41,910 Porges' paper and download it. 128 00:08:42,030 --> 00:08:44,190 I'll put a link in the description for both of them. 129 00:08:45,060 --> 00:08:48,450 Then upload them to a non-biased ai. 130 00:08:48,450 --> 00:08:53,310 I used Google Notebook, lm, which is amazing at using sources and has a 131 00:08:53,310 --> 00:08:55,770 huge context for exactly this purpose. 132 00:08:57,195 --> 00:09:00,505 And then I asked it to give me the definitions from Grossman and Porges. 133 00:09:01,125 --> 00:09:01,785 And guess what? 134 00:09:02,565 --> 00:09:07,335 It define- the AI- defines Porges definition as protection versus 135 00:09:07,335 --> 00:09:12,135 threat, and Grossman's definition as a measurement misunderstanding. 136 00:09:13,440 --> 00:09:16,380 You could do this little experiment yourself with any questions you 137 00:09:16,380 --> 00:09:21,570 have about their work, how it is misaligned, just trying to understand 138 00:09:21,570 --> 00:09:23,700 it better, who misunderstands what? 139 00:09:23,790 --> 00:09:25,260 Don't taint the ai. 140 00:09:25,260 --> 00:09:28,890 Just ask it objective questions and it'll tell you to give, ask it to give 141 00:09:28,890 --> 00:09:30,360 it to you at like a fifth grade level. 142 00:09:31,350 --> 00:09:33,690 Um, RSA is not essential to the polyvagal theory. 143 00:09:33,690 --> 00:09:35,340 That's what we're moving on to next. 144 00:09:36,690 --> 00:09:39,480 Grossman spends a lot of time on RSA. 145 00:09:39,480 --> 00:09:40,170 In this paper. 146 00:09:40,560 --> 00:09:44,460 He treats RSA as a foundational construct of the polyvagal theory. 147 00:09:45,540 --> 00:09:49,950 Basically, if he can break down the RSA argument, then the theory crumbles, 148 00:09:49,950 --> 00:09:51,210 I think is what he is getting at. 149 00:09:52,710 --> 00:10:00,060 However, Porges said in his 22, 20 23 paper that quote, RSA is a portal 150 00:10:00,300 --> 00:10:05,250 to the function of the ventral vagus enabling the testing of polyvagal 151 00:10:05,250 --> 00:10:10,950 informed hypotheses, but is not a foundational construct of the theory. 152 00:10:12,010 --> 00:10:17,640 Porges uses RSA as a potential measurement of something very specific. 153 00:10:18,030 --> 00:10:18,960 Very specific. 154 00:10:19,320 --> 00:10:21,870 If that does, that measurement doesn't work out, it doesn't. 155 00:10:22,110 --> 00:10:24,990 It doesn't mean that the entire theory is untenable. 156 00:10:25,710 --> 00:10:26,460 Think of it this way. 157 00:10:26,460 --> 00:10:31,350 Let's say you hypothesized that the temperature of someone's forehead 158 00:10:31,680 --> 00:10:33,040 correlates with how sick they are. 159 00:10:34,095 --> 00:10:37,185 You use a thermometer as your measurement tool. 160 00:10:38,445 --> 00:10:45,225 Now, somebody comes along and says that thermometer is not perfectly accurate. 161 00:10:45,795 --> 00:10:50,475 It gives inconsistent readings depending on ambient temperature 162 00:10:50,475 --> 00:10:52,035 and sweat and skin tone. 163 00:10:52,485 --> 00:10:56,535 Therefore, the concept of illness is untenable. 164 00:10:57,795 --> 00:10:59,115 That sounds absurd, right? 165 00:11:00,105 --> 00:11:06,420 The thermometer is just one portal- potential- into detecting something real. 166 00:11:07,380 --> 00:11:11,670 Attacking the instrument doesn't dissolve the underlying phenomenon. 167 00:11:13,710 --> 00:11:16,210 That's exactly what Grossman is doing with RSA. 168 00:11:16,410 --> 00:11:23,340 RSA is Porges' thermometer- a portal has his own word into 169 00:11:23,340 --> 00:11:25,500 detecting ventral vagal activity. 170 00:11:26,370 --> 00:11:32,250 It is a useful, testable, measurable, repeatable window into something 171 00:11:32,250 --> 00:11:34,140 that the theory proposes is real. 172 00:11:34,290 --> 00:11:38,550 But Polyvagal Theory does not stand or fall on whether RSA is a 173 00:11:38,730 --> 00:11:41,130 perfect index of cardiac vagal tone. 174 00:11:41,340 --> 00:11:46,515 The theories, foundational constructs are neuro anatomical and evolutionary. 175 00:11:47,310 --> 00:11:53,220 Existence of two distinct vagal pathways, the evolutionary hierarchy 176 00:11:53,250 --> 00:11:58,320 of the autonomic nervous system, and the adaptive functions of each circuit. 177 00:11:59,400 --> 00:12:05,910 Those claims live in the brainstem, not in a heart rate variability graph. 178 00:12:07,110 --> 00:12:12,180 So when Grossman dedicates really substantial effort to dismantling 179 00:12:12,180 --> 00:12:14,010 RSA as a reliable measure. 180 00:12:14,850 --> 00:12:18,840 He's essentially arguing that the thermometer is flawed and 181 00:12:18,840 --> 00:12:21,870 concluding that fever does not exist. 182 00:12:23,190 --> 00:12:28,410 Again, I don't understand why Grossman would go to such effort 183 00:12:28,530 --> 00:12:34,530 to dismantle RSA when Porges said that it's not central to his theory. 184 00:12:35,640 --> 00:12:38,670 Either he doesn't get it or is ignoring it. 185 00:12:39,390 --> 00:12:42,570 He read the same 2023 paper that I did. 186 00:12:43,260 --> 00:12:43,890 He cites it. 187 00:12:44,280 --> 00:12:47,190 In his article, there's no reason for this. 188 00:12:49,320 --> 00:12:51,450 Let's talk about, uh, freeze and shutdown. 189 00:12:51,990 --> 00:12:54,870 This is the third, um, issue I'll tackle. 190 00:12:57,060 --> 00:13:01,410 Listeners of this podcast will know very well the difference between 191 00:13:01,410 --> 00:13:06,390 freeze and shutdown, but for those who might be new to this channel, freeze 192 00:13:06,390 --> 00:13:08,640 and shutdown are not the same thing. 193 00:13:09,585 --> 00:13:12,615 They both involve, uh, immobility, yes. 194 00:13:12,615 --> 00:13:14,775 And are, you know, autonomically driven. 195 00:13:14,775 --> 00:13:20,385 But shutdown is a limp collapse and freeze is a tense paralysis. 196 00:13:21,645 --> 00:13:25,695 Shutdown would be like playing dead and falling to the floor. 197 00:13:27,015 --> 00:13:28,605 Freeze is like a panic attack. 198 00:13:29,835 --> 00:13:30,555 It's tense. 199 00:13:31,905 --> 00:13:35,650 In the polyvagal theory, shutdown is a dorsal vagal response. 200 00:13:36,960 --> 00:13:41,520 Freeze is a dorsal vagal response, plus sympathetic flight fight. 201 00:13:42,660 --> 00:13:47,760 Grossman confuses the two, and actually, I, I don't even blame him, uh, entirely 202 00:13:47,760 --> 00:13:51,750 for this because Porges' language on the subject was, was very confusing, 203 00:13:52,410 --> 00:13:54,360 um, in his like primary documents. 204 00:13:54,360 --> 00:13:55,080 His, uh, writings. 205 00:13:55,410 --> 00:13:58,245 I asked him about this during my first interview with him way, way, 206 00:13:58,245 --> 00:14:03,090 way back in episode 15, and he, he did clarify the distinction. 207 00:14:03,113 --> 00:14:09,563 So there, there's this whole ambiguity because people use the word freeze 208 00:14:09,563 --> 00:14:11,423 when they really mean shutting down. 209 00:14:11,428 --> 00:14:11,638 Okay? 210 00:14:11,843 --> 00:14:16,913 So the mouse in the jaws of a cat is not frozen, it's just, it just limp. 211 00:14:17,513 --> 00:14:23,243 And that is clearly the limp loss of muscle tone is a dorsal vagal response. 212 00:14:23,603 --> 00:14:28,558 The rigidity is much more- let's say, okay mixed or complex. 213 00:14:28,558 --> 00:14:32,168 Porges says that bradycardia reflects dorsal vagal 214 00:14:32,168 --> 00:14:33,638 influence, uh, as a measurement. 215 00:14:34,778 --> 00:14:38,198 Bradycardia is a significantly slower heartbeat, which 216 00:14:38,198 --> 00:14:40,088 is, uh, potentially fatal. 217 00:14:41,078 --> 00:14:48,428 In shut down, a dorsal vagal response, we would expect to see bradycardia. 218 00:14:49,988 --> 00:14:52,908 We would expect to see a massive drop in heart rate, just like Porges 219 00:14:52,928 --> 00:14:58,283 saw in the preterm neonatal unit that prompted the vagal paradox. 220 00:14:58,328 --> 00:14:59,287 But what about freeze? 221 00:14:59,617 --> 00:15:03,157 Would we expect to see a massive drop in heart rate during a freeze? 222 00:15:03,157 --> 00:15:07,507 Again, freeze is the combination of immobility and mobility. 223 00:15:08,197 --> 00:15:10,747 Shut down, plus flight fight. 224 00:15:11,527 --> 00:15:14,902 Dorsal plus sympathetic, both pathways are active. 225 00:15:14,902 --> 00:15:15,652 At the same time. 226 00:15:16,102 --> 00:15:20,842 Freeze can look like a panic attack or scared stiff or tonic immobility. 227 00:15:21,442 --> 00:15:25,042 So outwardly it's immobile, but internally there's a high level of 228 00:15:25,042 --> 00:15:27,202 activation including a higher heart rate. 229 00:15:27,772 --> 00:15:32,152 So, no, I don't- we would not expect to see bradycardia and freeze, I don't think. 230 00:15:33,052 --> 00:15:35,662 Grossman does not understand this and argues that there 231 00:15:35,662 --> 00:15:38,632 is no bradycardia in freeze. 232 00:15:39,862 --> 00:15:43,582 I assume Porges' response would be, "Yeah. No kidding." 233 00:15:43,668 --> 00:15:44,328 Next topic. 234 00:15:44,328 --> 00:15:48,198 Non mammals and myelinated nerves that affect heart rate. 235 00:15:48,828 --> 00:15:54,828 Grossman points to extensive research showing that non mammal mammalian 236 00:15:54,828 --> 00:15:59,988 species such as sharks and fish and reptiles also possessed- possess fast 237 00:15:59,988 --> 00:16:05,028 acting myelinated nerves and can use them to instantly change their heart 238 00:16:05,028 --> 00:16:07,788 rate in response to their environment. 239 00:16:08,898 --> 00:16:14,028 From Grossman's perspective, because this hardware exists throughout the 240 00:16:14,028 --> 00:16:21,018 vertebrate vertebrate family tree, it cannot be a special mammalian innovation 241 00:16:21,078 --> 00:16:24,468 for social engagement, as Porges suggests. 242 00:16:25,818 --> 00:16:29,358 But this is not a Polyvagal Theory proposition. 243 00:16:30,168 --> 00:16:33,768 Porges has already clarified that polyvagal theory does not rely 244 00:16:33,768 --> 00:16:39,363 on mammals being the only ones with fast acting nerves uh, that, 245 00:16:39,753 --> 00:16:40,923 you know, slow down heart rate. 246 00:16:40,983 --> 00:16:43,623 It doesn't matter if non mammals can slow their heart with 247 00:16:43,623 --> 00:16:45,933 fast acting myelinated nerves. 248 00:16:46,623 --> 00:16:47,133 It doesn't matter. 249 00:16:48,033 --> 00:16:51,543 In- instead- instead, polyvagal theory focuses on the brainstem 250 00:16:51,543 --> 00:16:53,613 regions where those nerves originate. 251 00:16:54,903 --> 00:16:59,523 Porges argues that in mammals, these nerves underwent an evolutionary, 252 00:17:00,213 --> 00:17:05,913 uh, ventral migration to the front of the brainstem, moving from the dorsal 253 00:17:05,943 --> 00:17:09,018 motor nucleus to the nucleus ambiguous. 254 00:17:09,618 --> 00:17:13,908 This shift is critical because it places the heart's, uh, braking system 255 00:17:14,628 --> 00:17:20,898 right next to the nerves that control the face, voice, and listening. 256 00:17:23,148 --> 00:17:30,408 So this brings us to the next issue, which is Grossman's, um, 257 00:17:30,438 --> 00:17:32,868 misunderstanding about social behavior. 258 00:17:32,868 --> 00:17:38,688 He says, or he points out that modern reptiles are far from asocial creatures. 259 00:17:39,678 --> 00:17:45,768 They exhibit complex behaviors such as long-term pair bonding, communal 260 00:17:46,308 --> 00:17:49,968 parenting, and social learning, which actually was really interesting. 261 00:17:49,968 --> 00:17:51,648 I didn't- I'm not aware of these things. 262 00:17:52,188 --> 00:17:55,698 But in response, poor just says that's, that's cool about the 263 00:17:55,698 --> 00:18:00,843 reptiles, but it's also entirely irrelevant to the polyvagal theory, 264 00:18:01,353 --> 00:18:04,023 which he describes as mammal centric. 265 00:18:05,133 --> 00:18:10,383 He clarifies that polyvagal theory is interested in the specific evolutionary 266 00:18:10,473 --> 00:18:17,373 transition from ancient, extinct common ancestors to mammals, not the 267 00:18:17,463 --> 00:18:20,823 separate path that modern reptiles took. 268 00:18:21,993 --> 00:18:26,508 The sociality of modern reptiles is irrelevant. 269 00:18:27,648 --> 00:18:32,238 Mammals have a unique social engagement system according to the polyvagal theory. 270 00:18:33,348 --> 00:18:39,048 This system integrates heart regulation with, uh, facial expressions and voice 271 00:18:39,078 --> 00:18:44,808 giving mammals the ability to use social cues like a, a warm voice, gentle eye 272 00:18:44,808 --> 00:18:52,483 contact, eye crinkles, or smiling to help calm each other and to indicate safety. 273 00:18:53,623 --> 00:18:55,483 This is called co-regulation. 274 00:18:57,343 --> 00:19:01,903 Porges' Social engagement system- co-regulation- is not the same, 275 00:19:02,143 --> 00:19:05,923 I don't think as Grossman's social behaviors in reptiles. 276 00:19:06,943 --> 00:19:08,623 I mean, just think about it for a second. 277 00:19:08,623 --> 00:19:13,363 When was the last time you saw iguana smiling with each other or heard a snake 278 00:19:13,423 --> 00:19:15,028 Singing to their young to calm them? 279 00:19:16,118 --> 00:19:19,968 How about two frogs embracing closely in the moonlight? 280 00:19:20,958 --> 00:19:25,548 Grossman does not accurately reflect Porges social engagement system. 281 00:19:25,548 --> 00:19:26,748 These are not the same thing. 282 00:19:27,198 --> 00:19:30,798 The sociality he's discussing is obviously different. 283 00:19:32,178 --> 00:19:35,178 I don't know why he bothers making the distinction and 284 00:19:35,178 --> 00:19:36,258 it's, it's not the same thing. 285 00:19:37,638 --> 00:19:40,818 So I'll wrap it up, um, here-ish. 286 00:19:41,208 --> 00:19:44,598 Um, gross men and friends have more to say. 287 00:19:45,318 --> 00:19:49,368 I assume Porges is gonna respond yet again, but honestly, if 288 00:19:49,368 --> 00:19:50,538 he doesn't, I don't blame him. 289 00:19:50,652 --> 00:19:51,612 Hey, this is editing Justin. 290 00:19:51,612 --> 00:19:57,282 I was looking into more of, uh, what Grossman was saying, and, um, I found 291 00:19:57,282 --> 00:20:02,532 that, uh, Porges has already released a rebuttal to, so I wasn't even aware of it. 292 00:20:02,532 --> 00:20:03,282 I'll have to read through that. 293 00:20:03,282 --> 00:20:04,377 So everything that I've talked about. 294 00:20:05,337 --> 00:20:09,267 And everything that I have on the YouTube video, the citations that 295 00:20:09,267 --> 00:20:13,647 are, the quotes that I've put up on the screen, there may be even better 296 00:20:13,647 --> 00:20:15,657 arguments that I haven't got into yet. 297 00:20:15,687 --> 00:20:16,917 So I can't wait to read that. 298 00:20:17,047 --> 00:20:17,857 Back to the podcast. 299 00:20:18,017 --> 00:20:25,187 Grossman is recycling the same talking points he has harped on for years on 300 00:20:25,247 --> 00:20:29,027 ResearchGate to the general public, begging for others to interact with 301 00:20:29,027 --> 00:20:31,877 him, to respond to him, to debate him. 302 00:20:32,567 --> 00:20:34,427 No, I am not exaggerating. 303 00:20:34,427 --> 00:20:36,047 Read it for yourself. 304 00:20:36,662 --> 00:20:39,962 I will of course, give you a link in the description to, 305 00:20:40,232 --> 00:20:42,272 uh, Grossman's Research Gate. 306 00:20:43,322 --> 00:20:46,712 Did Grossman collect a few dozen others to edit and sign this paper? 307 00:20:46,712 --> 00:20:47,042 Yeah. 308 00:20:47,192 --> 00:20:47,912 And that's something. 309 00:20:48,992 --> 00:20:54,512 But the paper largely doesn't address what the polyvagal theory actually says. 310 00:20:55,052 --> 00:20:58,172 So I, I don't know what that's worth. 311 00:20:58,438 --> 00:20:59,548 Scientists get things wrong. 312 00:21:00,028 --> 00:21:03,658 It has happened throughout history, especially when new ideas that 313 00:21:03,958 --> 00:21:09,208 contradict traditional, uh, understandings and status quo surface 314 00:21:10,078 --> 00:21:11,878 and scientific debate is totally fine. 315 00:21:12,778 --> 00:21:16,948 But one thing really sticks out to me about this specific 316 00:21:16,948 --> 00:21:18,868 paper from Grossman and Friends. 317 00:21:19,798 --> 00:21:22,558 It seems to be written with a psychological bent. 318 00:21:23,218 --> 00:21:26,338 It doesn't seem to be written for the science crowd, exactly. 319 00:21:26,638 --> 00:21:30,298 I mean, it is kind of because it uses all the science terminology, 320 00:21:30,808 --> 00:21:35,638 but it also singles out people like me who use the theory to better 321 00:21:35,638 --> 00:21:37,138 understand and help my clients. 322 00:21:38,008 --> 00:21:42,568 The paper starts off addressing people like me in the abstract 323 00:21:42,568 --> 00:21:44,398 and in the introduction as well. 324 00:21:45,508 --> 00:21:49,378 It seems pretty clear to me that this is who it's written for. 325 00:21:49,620 --> 00:21:51,960 It doesn't seem to be written for Dr. Porges. 326 00:21:52,470 --> 00:21:55,590 There are no new arguments there for him to rebut. 327 00:21:56,385 --> 00:21:58,335 It seems like the same stuff over and over again. 328 00:21:58,635 --> 00:22:01,455 It's written for mental health service providers, which 329 00:22:01,455 --> 00:22:02,505 I find really interesting. 330 00:22:02,805 --> 00:22:05,715 The last three of the 12 conclusions are about psychology 331 00:22:05,715 --> 00:22:10,275 and treatment, and encourage people like me to look elsewhere; to 332 00:22:10,305 --> 00:22:12,255 disregard the polyvagal theory. 333 00:22:13,755 --> 00:22:16,215 What's sad is that it seems to have worked. 334 00:22:17,325 --> 00:22:22,965 Therapists and psychologists and the like seem to be responding, abandoning 335 00:22:22,965 --> 00:22:26,535 the theory except for the stuff that they like, like the states and and 336 00:22:26,535 --> 00:22:30,525 co-regulation, because Grossman's paper seems scary and like he gets 337 00:22:30,525 --> 00:22:33,855 the theory and has counterarguments and a few dozen people who agree. 338 00:22:35,145 --> 00:22:39,435 Therapists, even popular YouTube therapists and Instagram 339 00:22:39,435 --> 00:22:44,445 therapy influencers are not spending the time to examine it. 340 00:22:46,005 --> 00:22:47,295 And I don't blame them either. 341 00:22:47,955 --> 00:22:48,915 It's, it's really difficult. 342 00:22:48,915 --> 00:22:49,725 It's very dense. 343 00:22:49,905 --> 00:22:52,815 And to read to people who disagree, it's not easy. 344 00:22:53,145 --> 00:22:55,635 So I don't, I don't blame them, but you know, mostly I don't blame them. 345 00:22:56,415 --> 00:22:58,965 A lot of what I pointed out here just requires a smidge of 346 00:22:58,965 --> 00:23:00,255 research and critical thinking. 347 00:23:00,795 --> 00:23:01,725 It's really not that hard. 348 00:23:02,475 --> 00:23:08,385 You don't have to be an expert in neuroanatomy to say, this dude does not 349 00:23:08,385 --> 00:23:10,335 understand what this other dude is saying. 350 00:23:11,985 --> 00:23:15,735 And you really don't need to be an expert in 2026 to upload two 351 00:23:15,735 --> 00:23:19,965 scientific papers into an unbiased AI and then to ask your own questions. 352 00:23:20,055 --> 00:23:21,405 I think it's actually a really good idea. 353 00:23:22,785 --> 00:23:26,745 Now, does any of this mean that I know for certain, um, that 354 00:23:26,745 --> 00:23:28,545 what Dr. Porges says is true? 355 00:23:28,725 --> 00:23:29,055 No. 356 00:23:29,625 --> 00:23:30,285 No, it doesn't. 357 00:23:31,215 --> 00:23:35,835 But what he, and I'm, I'm, I'm a lay person- but what he writes about makes 358 00:23:35,835 --> 00:23:40,530 sense to me and it's made more sense in the psychology realm than anything 359 00:23:40,530 --> 00:23:42,060 else I've learned about, honestly. 360 00:23:42,390 --> 00:23:44,790 And it's not a modality, it's the science that kind of contributes 361 00:23:44,790 --> 00:23:45,870 to the way we think about things. 362 00:23:47,340 --> 00:23:50,730 The serious criticism of the polyvagal theory, which really 363 00:23:50,730 --> 00:23:55,560 all come from Grossman, who cites someone named Taylor all the time- 364 00:23:56,610 --> 00:23:57,930 it, it really doesn't measure up. 365 00:23:59,550 --> 00:24:04,440 And so I hope you can see, um, that from just this one video, I don't 366 00:24:04,440 --> 00:24:06,360 think I'll continue commenting on this. 367 00:24:06,390 --> 00:24:06,660 Um. 368 00:24:07,500 --> 00:24:09,330 I don't really have much more to say about it. 369 00:24:09,330 --> 00:24:13,500 So if people are gonna have follow up questions, I would recommend you 370 00:24:13,500 --> 00:24:19,290 read Dr. Porges' direct response to Gro- responses, plural to Grossman. 371 00:24:19,800 --> 00:24:21,870 Um, that would be the best place to go. 372 00:24:23,280 --> 00:24:25,980 Anyhow, I appreciate you watching all the way to the end. 373 00:24:25,980 --> 00:24:29,850 You obviously take this stuff seriously and I'm glad to be in your company. 374 00:24:30,570 --> 00:24:35,940 I think the Polyvagal Theory bandwagon is disappearing, and I love it. 375 00:24:37,050 --> 00:24:37,290 Bye.