Speaker:

The school of podcasting uses chapters in their episodes. So if

Speaker:

I'm talking about a topic and there are many in this episode, feel free to

Speaker:

skip to the next one. Today I kind of want to do a

Speaker:

year wrap up of podcasting, the Good, the Bad

Speaker:

and the Ugly. And of course, that means we're going to start off with.

Speaker:

And now it's time for a power rant. Actually, let's not do

Speaker:

a power rant. What I'd like to do, because it's

Speaker:

Christmas time. Let's start off with a fun Christmas story.

Speaker:

This is called the Cridland Boys Choir.

Speaker:

Mildred Broombaugh had finally become the

Speaker:

superintendent of all the schools in Cridland.

Speaker:

And she had one mission. You see, when she was just a little

Speaker:

girl, she had seen the Vienna Boys Choir and

Speaker:

she wanted to create one in Cridland. So she reached out to

Speaker:

all the teachers in Cridlin and said, I want to put on a

Speaker:

Christmas concert. Everyone who meets this criteria

Speaker:

will be in the Cridland Boys Choir. They will be between the

Speaker:

ages of 9 and 14, have a red sweater,

Speaker:

black pants, and be able to sing. So

Speaker:

the teachers went through all the classes and there were 27

Speaker:

boys who met the criteria, but that was a long

Speaker:

way from 100. So Ms.

Speaker:

Broombaugh, she changed the criteria. She said, well, you

Speaker:

can wear any color of pants as long as you have a red

Speaker:

sweater and a boy who could sing between the

Speaker:

ages of 9 and 14. And this got her closer to her

Speaker:

goal as there were 34 boys who met that

Speaker:

criteria. But she was still a long way off of her

Speaker:

goal of 100 people. So she

Speaker:

changed the criteria again. And she said, okay, I'm going

Speaker:

to change the ages from 9 to

Speaker:

27. And the teachers went out again.

Speaker:

And it turned out there weren't that many older people in the

Speaker:

elementary schools. And so it only got her up

Speaker:

to 50. Fine. She said,

Speaker:

I need this choir to be 100 people. I've got it.

Speaker:

This will work. Find dogs that can howl.

Speaker:

They don't even need sweaters. And so some of the children

Speaker:

brought their dogs to practice and the howling was awful. But at this point,

Speaker:

she was up to 82 people, or 82 participants,

Speaker:

and still a fair amount to go to reach her goal of 100.

Speaker:

Now she was beyond frustrated. And she was walking down the

Speaker:

halls one day of Cochrane elementary with when she saw a

Speaker:

cleanliness engineer mopping the floor. That's it. She

Speaker:

said, prop all the mops up and put a red sweater on them.

Speaker:

And someone said, Ms. Broombaugh. Mops don't make any

Speaker:

noise. They can't sing. And she quipped back, but it

Speaker:

will have a red sweater. And that's close enough.

Speaker:

So the night came and the choir assembled with a bunch of creepy dudes

Speaker:

with mops standing in the back row, dogs howling over a

Speaker:

few talented boys who you really couldn't even here

Speaker:

over all the ruckus. But Ms. Broombaugh had achieved her

Speaker:

boys choir. And then the concert

Speaker:

was over. And it turns out the entire audience had left because,

Speaker:

well, they expected to hear a boys choir

Speaker:

and, well, it was awful.

Speaker:

The end. Now, what does that have to do with

Speaker:

podcasting? I'll explain in just a second.

Speaker:

Hit it, ladies. The school of podcasting

Speaker:

with Dave Jackson.

Speaker:

Podcasting since 2005. I am

Speaker:

your award winning hall of fame podcast coach, Dave

Speaker:

Jackson. Thanking you so much for tuning in. If you are new to

Speaker:

the show, I am so glad you're here. You are in the right

Speaker:

spot. This is where I help you plan, I help you launch, I help you

Speaker:

grow, I help you monetize. If you want to your podcast,

Speaker:

my website is schoolofpodcasting.com you can

Speaker:

use the coupon code listener when you sign up for either a monthly,

Speaker:

quarterly, or yearly subscription. So,

Speaker:

Dave, what the heck was that? Well, this is in

Speaker:

remarks, and I need to say this up front.

Speaker:

I'm not picking on Steve Goldstein. I like

Speaker:

Steve Goldstein as a person. I've met him. Really nice guy. I remember one of

Speaker:

the first calls we had was probably back in 2000, 2006. And so

Speaker:

he's been around a long time. And I'm just letting you

Speaker:

know you're allowed to disagree with people even

Speaker:

if you're friends. And I cannot disagree more

Speaker:

with Steve Goldstein and some of his

Speaker:

statements. And this goes back to two years

Speaker:

ago when he announced that if you weren't on

Speaker:

YouTube, well, you were going to miss the boat, in fact, in his presentation.

Speaker:

And YouTube has moved rapidly. We've seen studies

Speaker:

over the past couple of years as it's growing and growing, and now it

Speaker:

is dominant, but it is different.

Speaker:

It is a bit vexing for most podcasters because it does involve

Speaker:

video. There's no RSS feed. There will be. And

Speaker:

yet this was two years ago. There's still no RSS feed out. You

Speaker:

have to watch YouTube. On YouTube, it's a closed system.

Speaker:

It's video based, and 3.7 million people

Speaker:

are uploading content. Videos are uploaded every day,

Speaker:

500 hours, every minute. I mean, it's just incredible how

Speaker:

big it is. And I've never argued that YouTube is not huge.

Speaker:

It has a huge number of people that are watching it. More people are

Speaker:

watching now on their television set. But they came out with

Speaker:

this. The new rules of podcasting on YouTube. And it was Steve

Speaker:

Goldstein and Jay Naturalist. And here's what they said

Speaker:

about the whole podcasting. And in

Speaker:

this case, they were talking about defining it. Big headline from this

Speaker:

study today. The definition of a podcast is changing.

Speaker:

Says who? Coleman Insights. Because you interviewed a

Speaker:

thousand people, there are hundreds of thousands of podcasters.

Speaker:

That's not a great sample size. I mean, look, I love

Speaker:

Mariah Carey. She's majorly talented. But I did not get

Speaker:

my ballot when it came to voting her Queen of Christmas, because

Speaker:

I've had enough of that song. And I did not get my ballot when they

Speaker:

said, hey, we're going to change the definition of podcasting. Because

Speaker:

I would have said, you're wrong. You know, we hear all the time everybody's got

Speaker:

their opinions of what a podcast is, particularly in the podcast

Speaker:

industry. Now, why is that? Because there is a

Speaker:

definition of what a podcast is. It's audio, video, or

Speaker:

PDF delivered via rss. And we all agreed on that

Speaker:

because, well, you know, it's a fact. But we thought it was

Speaker:

really important in the study to take it outside of the industry

Speaker:

and figure out, you know, what are podcast consumers

Speaker:

saying? And I guess my question is why?

Speaker:

Why do we care what the consumer says? Because we are also

Speaker:

the first to say the consumer doesn't

Speaker:

care how we define it. But the thing that drives

Speaker:

me nuts is a. There was a study called

Speaker:

the New Rules of podcasting on YouTube. And right

Speaker:

there, we should have said, hey, guys, I

Speaker:

appreciate the work you put into that, but I don't know if you know this

Speaker:

or not, but podcasts aren't on YouTube. We did

Speaker:

not push back. And everyone

Speaker:

believed this whole thing about YouTube. There's been some major

Speaker:

shifts, and as a podcaster, this really impacts your

Speaker:

marketing plan and how you get your podcast out there.

Speaker:

It's a YouTube world. We're just living in it. Ugh. No. And

Speaker:

why were there major shifts? And by saying there are major shifts, you're kind of

Speaker:

going, hey, look, our report was important because nobody

Speaker:

pushed back to say, hey, I don't know if you realize this or not, but

Speaker:

YouTube's not a podcast. All right? And I'm going to point out

Speaker:

just one thing, and this sounds kind of mean, and I don't mean

Speaker:

it to be mean, but we're taking podcast advice from guys

Speaker:

that sound like that? Because I know you're thinking it, and

Speaker:

I just said it. These guys are telling me how to grow my audience on

Speaker:

YouTube. I would tell them, figure out how to work a microphone. They got

Speaker:

a background in radio in some cases. That's some horrible audio.

Speaker:

Sorry, just saying it. So the reason people aren't

Speaker:

pushing back is because of the massive

Speaker:

megaphone that is YouTube and Spotify. So with YouTube,

Speaker:

the advertising market, they were losing a

Speaker:

small percentage, but nonetheless a percentage from TikTok.

Speaker:

And they're like, we gotta get people talking about YouTube again. And so

Speaker:

they said, oh, I know. We'll just say that YouTube is

Speaker:

now a podcast. Now, why would they say that? Because every report.

Speaker:

In fact, there was one that came out today that said how YouTube

Speaker:

advertising on YouTube is not as good as

Speaker:

advertising on a real podcast. And that's the part

Speaker:

that kind of makes my blood boil, is the fact they're hijacking

Speaker:

our reputation. All right? And for those of you

Speaker:

that are like, oh, who poked the bear? There is new information

Speaker:

that I'm just like, oh, are you kidding me? Because if you look at,

Speaker:

like, a clock, 12 o', clock, that was normal. That was where

Speaker:

things made sense. 10 o' clock was when we said, sure,

Speaker:

YouTube's a podcast, and nobody pushed back. And now

Speaker:

we're going even further away from common sense.

Speaker:

YouTube is a wolf in

Speaker:

podcast clothing that drives me nuts. And

Speaker:

now it's filtered over. TikTok now is

Speaker:

calling itself a podcast. Why not? If YouTube can do it and

Speaker:

nobody's gonna push back, we're a podcast, too. In

Speaker:

fact, this kitchen timer sitting right here on my desk is. It's

Speaker:

a podcast. I'll tell you more about that in a second, because

Speaker:

now there's this show on TikTok featuring Demi

Speaker:

Lovato, who I love, and they're calling it a

Speaker:

podcast. There's no RSS feed, but it's a podcast. And James

Speaker:

Kridlin from podnews.net made a great point.

Speaker:

So figure this. You're a marketing person.

Speaker:

You want to spend your marketing dollars the best. Here's another report that

Speaker:

shows how podcasting outperforms everything.

Speaker:

And you're like, I gotta spend some money on this podcasting stuff.

Speaker:

TikTok comes along and says, hey, we're a podcast. Now,

Speaker:

here's the thing. When that comes down

Speaker:

to reporting, is that gonna be classified as

Speaker:

money spent on a podcast or money spent on

Speaker:

social media? And I can't answer that question. Only the

Speaker:

marketing director that's sponsoring that show can do

Speaker:

that. But I just know that people in the podcast industry

Speaker:

are jonesing so hard to get over the $2 billion

Speaker:

mark that they will call anything a podcast. So

Speaker:

that marketers will spend money on podcasting so they can say,

Speaker:

look at us, we're growing. And they don't care

Speaker:

if their actions actually are a detriment to the

Speaker:

whole podcasting space. They're going to get their money, so they

Speaker:

don't care. But that report about podcasts on

Speaker:

YouTube, we should have pushed back on that. I don't understand why we didn't.

Speaker:

I don't know if Steve and the guy from Coleman

Speaker:

Insights have friends at YouTube because this

Speaker:

video is such an advertisement for YouTube.

Speaker:

And so the new thing that came out. And this is such

Speaker:

bs, this is from Amplify

Speaker:

Media, and it's Steve Goldstein. And again, I don't

Speaker:

dislike Steve. I just really disagree with his opinion.

Speaker:

And this is what he says. He says podcasting is no longer

Speaker:

a one size fits all medium. And I would say

Speaker:

it never has been. It's always been from day one,

Speaker:

audio, video, and PDF. The video thing is

Speaker:

not new. He says it's become an ecosystem. A

Speaker:

podcast can be a YouTube show. No,

Speaker:

it can't. Not without an RSS feed.

Speaker:

He says it can be vertical clips,

Speaker:

newsletters. And that's the one I went,

Speaker:

that's it. We got to talk about this. A

Speaker:

newsletter is not a podcast. And you might say, but, Dave, some blogs

Speaker:

can be delivered via rss. And I would agree,

Speaker:

and I would say that's why it has a different word. It's not a

Speaker:

newsletter, it's a blog. When you have a different

Speaker:

definition, you have a different word.

Speaker:

Live streams or even a live event. So let's read that again.

Speaker:

Podcasting is no longer a one size fits all medium. It has

Speaker:

become an ecosystem. A podcast can be a YouTube show, vertical

Speaker:

clips, newsletters, short episodes, live streams, or even a live event.

Speaker:

You can. There's one thing he forgot to put, and I would have been perfectly

Speaker:

fine if he said, when it's delivered via RSS

Speaker:

in honor of my grandma Irene, I have one thing to say.

Speaker:

Poppycock. Yeah. I don't understand

Speaker:

why people didn't push back. When Jay and Steve are like, hey,

Speaker:

guess what? YouTube's a podcast. We should have said, no, it's not.

Speaker:

And that's kind of like, now people think that

Speaker:

YouTube is a podcast. It's still not.

Speaker:

And yet now that causes people. And then they say things like, it's

Speaker:

weird. We don't have as many new Podcasters as we used to. Yeah,

Speaker:

because you've convinced everyone they have to be on video and people don't want to

Speaker:

be on video. Way to go. Congratulations. Here's a question.

Speaker:

Are podcast reports from the major companies that do

Speaker:

podcast reports, are they better or worse?

Speaker:

Are they helpful or less helpful than when

Speaker:

people came down from the mountain with their tablets saying, YouTube is a

Speaker:

podcast? In my opinion, they are less helpful because

Speaker:

they say things like, yeah, well, video podcasts,

Speaker:

better known as YouTubers, are exploding on YouTube. Yeah,

Speaker:

no kidding. Wow. Then they say other brilliant things like, well,

Speaker:

if you. If you're just an audio podcast and

Speaker:

you're not using YouTube, you're limiting your audience.

Speaker:

Wow, Sherlock. How did you come up with that? Wait a minute.

Speaker:

Audio podcasting is a stage. Video on

Speaker:

YouTube is a stage. You mean if I got on another stage, I might grow

Speaker:

my audience, but a different audience? Yeah.

Speaker:

Never would have figured that one out. Adam Curry, co creator of

Speaker:

podcasting, said it best. Every book doesn't need to be

Speaker:

a movie. And I have people that come to me all the time, and they're

Speaker:

thinking of starting a podcast, but they don't want to be on video. As

Speaker:

always, if I said this from day one, if you want to be on YouTube,

Speaker:

I am on YouTube because I want to be.

Speaker:

But you don't have to be. If you don't want to be on video,

Speaker:

you don't have to. There are plenty of people who

Speaker:

achieve success without doing video.

Speaker:

And one more thing I want to point out, because Jay said this, but.

Speaker:

We thought it was really important in this study to take it outside of

Speaker:

the industry. And I kind of go, why did you

Speaker:

go outside the industry? I guess if you're trying to do a study

Speaker:

on what makes a good teacher, you would ask the students,

Speaker:

but you weren't asking what makes a good podcast. You were asking,

Speaker:

what makes a teacher? And

Speaker:

then people said, well, I sometimes learn

Speaker:

when I stub my toe on a chair. So a chair is a

Speaker:

teacher. And while that is a lesson,

Speaker:

it's not an actual teacher standing up in a classroom.

Speaker:

And so do we have the courage

Speaker:

to stand up and go, hey, people that do these,

Speaker:

you know, surveys, because they have been doing them for decades,

Speaker:

maybe they're not asking the right questions. How long have we

Speaker:

heard that the average podcast listener listens to

Speaker:

X amount of podcasts? And we still kind of have

Speaker:

to go, is that episodes or shows? Maybe

Speaker:

they're not asking the right questions. It's just a

Speaker:

thought. And I know you probably fast forward to

Speaker:

this point, and you're asking yourself, dave, why do you care? And I totally

Speaker:

get that. Because you know what? The audience doesn't care. They don't

Speaker:

care how the sausage is made. They just want the sausage. I

Speaker:

get that. Totally get that. And it comes down to rss, and it comes down

Speaker:

to control. If you get kicked off of YouTube, you're kind of

Speaker:

screwed. But if you're doing a podcast on

Speaker:

RSS and somebody kicks you off, Spotify, you have a whole bunch of

Speaker:

other apps that you. You can still listen to me on. In

Speaker:

fact, if I get kicked out of all the apps and I still have an

Speaker:

RSS feed, my audience can still consume my

Speaker:

data. It's a little more challenging, but I'm not dead in the

Speaker:

water. And when the bigger these companies get

Speaker:

and the more they dig their trenches in, what they're really doing

Speaker:

is they're going for control. They're going for

Speaker:

control. They want it to be. They're already putting things in place.

Speaker:

Spotify is to where you have to use their ads, and they

Speaker:

don't pay much, and they're going through all these different things. It's all

Speaker:

about control. And I'm just here to say, the more we

Speaker:

water down the definition of a podcast, now it's a

Speaker:

newsletter. That is such crap. That is such

Speaker:

absolute nonsense. It's idiotic.

Speaker:

A podcast is not a newsletter, and

Speaker:

we need to start pushing back, because the more blurry it

Speaker:

gets, the more we're wasting our time to talking about what a

Speaker:

podcast is when we could be

Speaker:

informing advertisers what a great deal it

Speaker:

is to advertise in a podcast.

Speaker:

And then we would have reports where people didn't have

Speaker:

to go, I think this means this, because I don't know if they're doing this.

Speaker:

No, the reports would be crystal clear, and we would know

Speaker:

exactly what to do to enhance

Speaker:

podcasting to make it better and what was working and what

Speaker:

doesn't. And when everything's a podcast, you're like, well,

Speaker:

wait a minute. This box of Kleenex is a podcast. All right, I'll

Speaker:

shut up. All right. And to finally wrap this up, we're going to play a

Speaker:

fun game called Is this a Country Song

Speaker:

or a Pop Song? Ready?

Speaker:

This could easily be Def Leppard. I was running on

Speaker:

the dad. Right? That's

Speaker:

off the. And yes, I know I'm breaking the rules here, but

Speaker:

that's the number 19 hit from

Speaker:

Spotify's Country Hits 2025. The song is called

Speaker:

Things We Learn in a Bar where I was expecting it to

Speaker:

sound like this.

Speaker:

Right. Little lap steel, you know, this is

Speaker:

Work for the Wind by Aliyah Langley. And

Speaker:

that, to me, sounds like a country song. And so

Speaker:

if everybody sounds like Cody Koz,

Speaker:

then all the pop guys, all the rock people are like,

Speaker:

wow, they're playing rock on this station. Notes. New country.

Speaker:

You change the definition, and all of a sudden, what do you know?

Speaker:

It's the most popular genre now. Why?

Speaker:

Because you changed the definition of the genre and it

Speaker:

doesn't sound like country anymore. Yeah, yeah, yeah,

Speaker:

yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay, next subject. Netflix. People are

Speaker:

all excited that some shows that are really, really popular

Speaker:

are getting on Netflix, but Netflix is

Speaker:

dictating how you can consume

Speaker:

that subject. And to that I go,

Speaker:

no, no, thank you. I mean, we learned that all from

Speaker:

Spotify. I mean, they had the Joe Rogan experience call

Speaker:

her Daddy, Armchair Expert, Anything Goes with Emma Chamberlain,

Speaker:

and various Spotify owned shows from

Speaker:

Gimlet. Remember Gimlet? Yeah. And

Speaker:

what's interesting about that is, aside

Speaker:

from, well, there's Joe Rogan, but Joe now has his

Speaker:

stuff beyond Spotify. You can find

Speaker:

him on YouTube and Apple. Same thing with Alex Cooper

Speaker:

and Caller Daddy. And they're all, if you notice, they're not

Speaker:

exclusive anymore. They're Spotify

Speaker:

originals. And so this is where, being

Speaker:

an old curmudgeon who has seen things over 20 years, I'm like,

Speaker:

yeah, you don't want to do that. They separate you from your audience,

Speaker:

and then they get mad because your marketing efforts don't

Speaker:

work. Why? Because the audience that's going to follow you

Speaker:

follows you, and the rest don't. And big,

Speaker:

large companies don't care when big money gets involved.

Speaker:

They don't care about you. I'll give you a quick example. I live in

Speaker:

Cleveland, Ohio. The Cleveland Browns are our American

Speaker:

football team. And the previous owner, in the middle

Speaker:

of the night, picked up the team and moved them to Baltimore. Years

Speaker:

later, we got a new. We got our team kind of back.

Speaker:

We've gone through a few owners in the latest one is horrendous.

Speaker:

But the good news is Cleveland, which at one point in the 70s was a

Speaker:

horrendous town, has really turned itself around. We have

Speaker:

a stadium for our football team. We have an arena for our basketball

Speaker:

team. We have a, you know, a diamond or whatever for our

Speaker:

baseball team. And the city

Speaker:

of Cleveland made a law that said you can't move the football team without

Speaker:

our acknowledgment and approval.

Speaker:

And the current owner wants to

Speaker:

move about 20 minutes from where he is. Which would cost the

Speaker:

city millions in taxes and local

Speaker:

businesses because it drives a lot of traffic

Speaker:

downtown. But here's the thing. You got the you can't move the team

Speaker:

law, called the Modell law because the old owner was Modell. And

Speaker:

then where they want to build the land, coincidentally, the land is

Speaker:

now owned by the billionaire owner. They said you can't put a stadium

Speaker:

there because it's right next to an international airport. And

Speaker:

you're like, well, between the you can't move the team law

Speaker:

and you know, you can't change the flight path at

Speaker:

a international airport. Well, this guy,

Speaker:

there's no way he's going to get to move. Did I mention he's a billionaire?

Speaker:

And, yeah, they're moving the team. So when big

Speaker:

people get involved, they don't care many times

Speaker:

about the audience. They don't care about really. It

Speaker:

appears to be anything but making more millions.

Speaker:

And so my favorite Spotify story

Speaker:

was, I think it was 2025, when they brought in

Speaker:

audiobooks into Spotify,

Speaker:

even though there's no bookmarking tool, because, you know, why make it a good

Speaker:

app, but you can listen to audiobooks. And when

Speaker:

they brought those in, I'm not sure authors were really thrilled because

Speaker:

we know how well Spotify pays the

Speaker:

musicians. But once they brought them in,

Speaker:

they then came up with a plan that

Speaker:

allows you to bundle music and audiobooks.

Speaker:

And when that happened, it enabled Spotify,

Speaker:

who's not paying the musicians very much, to

Speaker:

pay them even less. So I say this

Speaker:

to say I am weary of when

Speaker:

companies with billions of dollars and millions of dollars because

Speaker:

they don't give a crap about you, they care about

Speaker:

making money for stock owners. And I know that

Speaker:

because I worked for a company that was,

Speaker:

you know, open or whatever you call it, It's a public company,

Speaker:

and there were times when many bad decisions were made

Speaker:

because they are not serving you

Speaker:

the customer, they're serving their stock owners.

Speaker:

So I say this about Netflix. If you are

Speaker:

like, hey, I gotta get on Netflix, that would be cool.

Speaker:

A exclusive. Deals are crap. Unless, I guess,

Speaker:

you're getting paid millions of dollars and you save and invest.

Speaker:

Well, okay, but here's the thing that James

Speaker:

Kridlin said that I was like, oh, we got to bring this up. James Kridlin

Speaker:

again. Podnews.net if you're not subscribed to that newsletter,

Speaker:

and then I'm not supposed to give you

Speaker:

my favorite show, that's next week's episode. But there's a

Speaker:

really good chance that podcast Weekly Review is going to be my favorite

Speaker:

show for I think the second year in a row. But here is James

Speaker:

talking about Netflix.

Speaker:

Netflix and iHeartMedia have announced an exclusive video partnership

Speaker:

for top iHeart podcasts. IHeart continues to retain

Speaker:

audio only rights and distribution, but the 14 announced

Speaker:

shows will be removed from YouTube. And for me,

Speaker:

that's a bad idea. I don't want to be exclusive on anybody,

Speaker:

but we know we always hear about video shows and things like

Speaker:

that. James also mentioned this. One of iHeart's biggest shows

Speaker:

is also obviously missing stuff you should know doesn't

Speaker:

currently make video versions of its podcast. So for all those

Speaker:

people going, can you even be successful without having video? Yeah,

Speaker:

apparently you can. But check this out. How big is Netflix?

Speaker:

Well, in 2023, Pod News built a tool using Netflix's

Speaker:

own data to help compare the size of Netflix shows to

Speaker:

podcasts. Our own Pod News Weekly Review is bigger than

Speaker:

1 in 5 of all the shows on Netflix, despite

Speaker:

only getting 26,500 downloads a month.

Speaker:

And I'll be at PodFest in January cheering

Speaker:

James on as he is inducted into the

Speaker:

Podcaster hall of Fame. And congratulations on

Speaker:

that. Well deserved. Some more things that may

Speaker:

be hurting the podcasting space right after this.

Speaker:

The school of podcasting. Yeah, yeah,

Speaker:

yeah. One of my favorite interviews this year was from Pod

Speaker:

News Weekly Review, where my buddy again, James

Speaker:

Kridlin, he interviewed the woman

Speaker:

Janine Wright, behind Inception Point. And if you're like, what's

Speaker:

Inception Point? It's a company that uses

Speaker:

AI to source and then voice

Speaker:

thousands, thousands of

Speaker:

episodes per week. And I

Speaker:

know a lot of people complain about how it's hard to discover podcasts

Speaker:

in different directories and stuff. They

Speaker:

are flooding, they are adding litter. Just think of that.

Speaker:

If podcasting is a street, they're coming by with

Speaker:

thousands of bags of garbage and throwing it all

Speaker:

over your neighborhood. So why is

Speaker:

this bad? The one thing that podcasters

Speaker:

need every year since I have started podcasting, you know what it is?

Speaker:

More listeners. And now when we finally

Speaker:

get Uncle Merv to try a

Speaker:

podcast at Thanksgiving, the chances of him

Speaker:

finding absolute garbage

Speaker:

worthless, zero value content is

Speaker:

a lot greater than it was a year ago.

Speaker:

That's bad. When you look at the technology

Speaker:

that powers the actual podcast industry,

Speaker:

things like Apple Podcasts and

Speaker:

the podcast index, this is more data

Speaker:

that they have to store about shows that are

Speaker:

absolutely worthless. There's one

Speaker:

that is supposed to be about Sydney, Australia, and it

Speaker:

is for about 50% of the episode. And then from what

Speaker:

I'm Told it, then switches and starts talking about

Speaker:

Sydney Sweeney. Why? Because there's only about eight people

Speaker:

at Inception Point AI and they admit, yeah, we don't

Speaker:

listen to this stuff, or at least most of the stuff before we put

Speaker:

it out. So they're littering, they're

Speaker:

cluttering up the podcasting space. Now the other thing that's bad about

Speaker:

this is I've said, and reports have come out over

Speaker:

and over and over, true podcasting, because of

Speaker:

the relationship we build with our audience, it

Speaker:

outperforms everything. Say it with me,

Speaker:

everything. And the one thing

Speaker:

that will drive the price of ads down if we don't

Speaker:

hold tight is when you get that idiot that will take the

Speaker:

low paying ads. Well, that idiot is called Inception

Speaker:

AI. It's basically spam in

Speaker:

the podcasting space. How do we fix this? Adam Curry, co

Speaker:

inventor of podcasting and co host of the no Agenda show,

Speaker:

said this. "Instead of this being a problem, why don't we just block as

Speaker:

much as we can and every single app that uses the index

Speaker:

should market itself as slop free. If you want to listen to

Speaker:

AI Slop, go use Spotify." And then the other thing that could

Speaker:

be potentially bad, Look, I know I talk about advertisers,

Speaker:

but look, there are times when advertisers, when they're treated

Speaker:

like partners, it's a win, win, win for everyone. It's a win for

Speaker:

the podcaster, it's a win for the audience and it's a win for the advertiser.

Speaker:

But in this case, when an audience finds a horrible

Speaker:

podcast and they get greeted with two to

Speaker:

who knows how many ads before the show even starts,

Speaker:

who's losing there? The advertiser. And

Speaker:

so now they're like, well, we advertised on this show and they said they were

Speaker:

great because they, the woman used to work at Wondery, she must know what she's

Speaker:

doing. No, they're putting out spam, they're putting out horrible

Speaker:

content and your ads are not going to perform well there because the

Speaker:

minute the podcast listener figures

Speaker:

out this is AI Slop, if it's me, I can

Speaker:

only talk about me, I'm tuning out. So it's

Speaker:

going to hurt discoverability, it's going to hurt the

Speaker:

directories, it's going to hurt the technology and it's going to hurt the

Speaker:

advertiser. We need to, to push back.

Speaker:

If podcasting is a pool and we're all swimming in

Speaker:

it, companies like this using this strategy

Speaker:

of just dump out all this AI into the space,

Speaker:

that space is us, that's our living room. That's our swimming pool, and

Speaker:

we're in it, and the water's turning bright yellow and starting to stink. And

Speaker:

everybody's going, hey, anybody else notice it's getting kind of warm in here.

Speaker:

We need to kick them out of the pool. And I

Speaker:

know you're like, but, Dave, that's censorship. Yeah, but here's the

Speaker:

thing. We all need an audience.

Speaker:

And when they come in and chase our audience away,

Speaker:

we gotta do something or we all go away.

Speaker:

So, again, I don't have all the answers. I just know

Speaker:

we need to push back. Yeah,

Speaker:

yeah, yeah. And just to clarify, I'm not anti

Speaker:

AI. Chris Stone from castahead.net

Speaker:

was showing off some really cool stuff at a group coaching call

Speaker:

we did at the school of podcasting. I've done some interesting things

Speaker:

with SEO where you can have chat GPT

Speaker:

find the right kind of post you have on

Speaker:

your website to link to your main. I mean, there's just a lot of stuff

Speaker:

that AI can do. The one thing I wouldn't use it for is

Speaker:

generating content unless it was an image. But actually

Speaker:

having it write something first, I prefer. So this is one of

Speaker:

those, hey, it's Dave's opinion. I like to write it and have

Speaker:

AI kind of basically polish it

Speaker:

a bit and keep my voice for me.

Speaker:

If you think about it, AI is trained on the best stuff, that's a 10,

Speaker:

and the worst stuff that's a 1. And then if it gives you the average

Speaker:

of that, that's a five. And so I'm not a big fan of having it

Speaker:

generate stuff, but that all depends on who's gonna be reading it. But

Speaker:

if it's your audience, I would start with you

Speaker:

and then let ChatGPT keep your voice

Speaker:

and buff it up. But there's some really cool things you can do with

Speaker:

AI. I just know I was approached by a company and their

Speaker:

whole thing was, you don't even have to talk. You can just

Speaker:

basically type in an idea. You know, type in two sentences.

Speaker:

It'll write a script. AI will read it, it will publish. It's your media

Speaker:

host. And I'm just like, I don't want any part of that. Yeah,

Speaker:

yeah, yeah. Another thing that is hurting the podcasting space,

Speaker:

and this is just a case of you don't know what you don't know, or

Speaker:

in some cases, you're asking the wrong person. You're asking your web

Speaker:

hosting person a podcasting question. And in the same way

Speaker:

you wouldn't ask me a JavaScript question, I don't work in

Speaker:

that. I'm a podcast guy, so. And that is

Speaker:

people are submitting their shows

Speaker:

multiple times to Apple Podcasts and all the other

Speaker:

apps. So again, this creates a discovery problem. It

Speaker:

also makes it harder for you to rank in the charts because

Speaker:

Instead of having one listing, that is 500

Speaker:

subscribers, you've got two listings, and both of them have 250.

Speaker:

And that can affect your ranking in the charts,

Speaker:

because now we're talking followers. And why is this? This is

Speaker:

because people don't understand how podcasting

Speaker:

works. And I might actually do a webinar on this in January.

Speaker:

But in a nutshell, when you move from one host to

Speaker:

another. So let's say you're just tired of your media host

Speaker:

and they aren't putting out any new features, and

Speaker:

you want to move to Captivate or Transistor or Buzzsprout or whoever,

Speaker:

anybody but Spotify. And you

Speaker:

take your feed, you import it into the new host, we'll just

Speaker:

say it's Captivate. What you want to do is

Speaker:

redirect your old feed to point at your new one. It's kind of a change

Speaker:

of address. You know, you drive by a small business and it

Speaker:

says, hey, we've moved. We're now on South Howard street at 4:56.

Speaker:

Stop by and say, hi. It's a change of address. And that's

Speaker:

fine. And when you do that, one of the things that sees that change of

Speaker:

address is Apple Podcast. And they update your listing

Speaker:

to keep looking at the new source of your content.

Speaker:

But people don't realize that. And what they do is they go, oh, well, at

Speaker:

the old company, I went in, I clicked a couple boxes and it submitted to

Speaker:

Apple and Spotify for me. So on the new company, I click a couple

Speaker:

boxes and it submits to Apple and Spotify for you. And. And

Speaker:

from Dave Jones, who runs podcast index.org

Speaker:

he said there are times when there will be a show with

Speaker:

seven different listings. And this is just. You

Speaker:

don't know what you don't know. So I have a blog post

Speaker:

I put on my website on how to move from one host to the next.

Speaker:

But that, again, is costing you money in many

Speaker:

cases. It's hurting your discovery,

Speaker:

it's hurting your rankings. And it's not that you

Speaker:

are stupid, you're uneducated. And there is a difference

Speaker:

there, by the way. And it's also then

Speaker:

hurting these directories that they have to host

Speaker:

multiple versions of your show. And it just is confusing.

Speaker:

So here's how you can test to See, have I done that? Go to

Speaker:

Apple Podcasts and search for your show and see if it shows up more

Speaker:

than once. If it does, figure out which one has the most

Speaker:

reviews and then hide the other one. Yeah, yeah,

Speaker:

yeah. And this one, I don't know if it's hurting the podcasting space,

Speaker:

but it does hurt you, and that is you came up with a show for

Speaker:

your name and didn't take time to see. Hey, is anybody else using

Speaker:

this? My favorite is the title Thinking Outside the box,

Speaker:

which over 20 shows have the title Thinking Outside

Speaker:

the Box, which shows that they were not. Mm, Thinking Outside

Speaker:

the Box. So you want to go to Google, you want to go

Speaker:

to Apple, you want to go to Spotify and search for your show, and

Speaker:

if the name has already existed, check to see are they currently making

Speaker:

episodes. And if they're not, you might want to try to contact them and say,

Speaker:

hey, would you like to sell me your domain and your name? And you

Speaker:

take it over. So you're not really even starting from zero, but that is

Speaker:

something that, again, is. It's just causing hassles and

Speaker:

confusion in the podcasting space. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker:

The school of podcasting. Well, what do I

Speaker:

predict for 2026? I think we're gonna

Speaker:

see more podcasters who are tired

Speaker:

of taking this $3 per

Speaker:

1,000 downloads, better known as CPM. I think they're gonna get

Speaker:

tired of that and just switch to premium

Speaker:

podcasts. That we've had this forever. There's Patreon.

Speaker:

I like Supercast. And the reason I say this

Speaker:

is if you gave me $5,

Speaker:

and right now, $5 won't even buy you a Happy Meal.

Speaker:

Five is like the new $1 bill. And if you gave

Speaker:

me $5, that would be the same if I was really, really

Speaker:

good of getting a thousand downloads.

Speaker:

So the question is, what's easier, getting a thousand

Speaker:

downloads or getting one person to give you $5

Speaker:

a month? It's been kind of fun because Sam and

Speaker:

James over at Pod News Weekly Review, they use

Speaker:

Buzzsprout. This is also available from Captivate.

Speaker:

You know, again, you could use super cash. You don't have to use this from

Speaker:

your media host, but they just threw it out

Speaker:

there, like, hey, if you'd like to support us, you know, buy us a

Speaker:

beer, whatever you want to call it. And I think the last time they talked

Speaker:

about it, they're up to close to 25 people. 25

Speaker:

people. And I think they're giving them. You can give them 3, 5, 7.

Speaker:

I think you can even name your own price. But just because

Speaker:

I hear so many people saying, I wish I could just cover the cost

Speaker:

of hosting. Well, I think if you put it

Speaker:

out there and you ask,

Speaker:

but that requires confidence that you're delivering value.

Speaker:

But to me, I think we're going to see people

Speaker:

do that where they're like, hey, if you'd like to support the show and

Speaker:

they're not going to get a ton, you might get 1%.

Speaker:

In my book, I talk about how the people that were really crushing it were

Speaker:

getting 3%. But I can see people saying, look,

Speaker:

this advertising where I'm making $1.17

Speaker:

isn't cutting it. Let's see if we can get one person

Speaker:

to give us five, let's see if we can get one Person to give us

Speaker:

10 or whatever it is. I think that's going to be a monetization

Speaker:

strategy that I think more people are going to try.

Speaker:

I think another thing, and I've kind of explained why,

Speaker:

but I think we're going to see AI slop. Not AI,

Speaker:

AI slop as in horrible, worthless content

Speaker:

I pray is going to get pushed back. I think we should all

Speaker:

just boycott it. Just get it out of here. And I know

Speaker:

somebody's going to say, but this is great for someone who

Speaker:

was hurt in a motorcycle accident. They had half their jaw ripped out

Speaker:

of their head and they can't talk anymore. Now this person. That's not what I'm

Speaker:

talking about. I'm not talking about the person that can't talk and is

Speaker:

using, you know, 11 labs to. No, that's not what I'm talking about.

Speaker:

Just crappy content created only for monetization

Speaker:

and no real value to the audience. I'm hoping,

Speaker:

I have faith in the podcasting space

Speaker:

that that will cause enough problems for

Speaker:

everybody that we all collectively just, just flush it down

Speaker:

the drain. I think we're gonna see some

Speaker:

podcast related companies merge.

Speaker:

There's just some weird stuff going on.

Speaker:

Companies doing things that really make zero sense.

Speaker:

And there's just a part of me that goes, I think they're trying to

Speaker:

thin themselves down to make them look more

Speaker:

attractive for a potential purchase. So

Speaker:

I, I'm watching a couple companies and I just think we're going

Speaker:

to see that happen. I think we're going to see

Speaker:

20% of people that try YouTube

Speaker:

decide this isn't for me. And I think that's

Speaker:

because people expect

Speaker:

faster growth. I think they expect it just to be.

Speaker:

We're all looking for that 10,000 download kind of

Speaker:

switch and I think they will realize that

Speaker:

audio is easier. Audio has a much better completion

Speaker:

percentage. So for me, YouTube is kind

Speaker:

of mile wide and an inch deep when it comes to actual

Speaker:

people consuming your content. And call me weird. I'm kind of

Speaker:

offended that my content may not even be

Speaker:

clicked unless I have some sort of clickbaity title. And

Speaker:

me looking surprised. It almost doesn't matter if your content is good now.

Speaker:

It does, because you have to hook them in the first 30 seconds. But

Speaker:

I think we're going to see a number of podcasters

Speaker:

say, yeah, this isn't for me. I tried it and they're going to come back

Speaker:

now. I also think probably 20% of those podcasters, another

Speaker:

20 will try it and actually

Speaker:

have some success because they'll study the algorithm and they'll

Speaker:

study the thumbnails and they'll do all the extra steps it

Speaker:

takes to make it on YouTube. But I think

Speaker:

we are going to see some say, yeah, this isn't for me.

Speaker:

And this one isn't really a prediction. It's more of something I want to

Speaker:

see. And that is, I want to see a

Speaker:

resurgence in creativity. I want to see people

Speaker:

getting outside of their comfort zones. I want to see people break the

Speaker:

format a bit. And it's not just a chat show. It's not just a

Speaker:

interview show. It's not just this just it's everybody's kind of doing the

Speaker:

same thing. I miss the days when people are being really wacky

Speaker:

on their show, and I kind of hope that we

Speaker:

break the cycle with True

Speaker:

Crime. That was the last genre to really take off, and

Speaker:

it's really kind of held the crown. And I'd like to see

Speaker:

something else step up and be way different. I

Speaker:

would love to see something way different

Speaker:

without being stupid. I listened to a show the other

Speaker:

day that is apparently very popular, and

Speaker:

I'm here to tell you, the first two minutes, I had no idea what they

Speaker:

were talking about. It was just endless chatter and laughing and

Speaker:

inside jokes. I'm tired of that. I want to

Speaker:

see somebody be professional, but also be super creative.

Speaker:

The only thing I saw creative that I was like, huh?

Speaker:

Was Amy Poehler's show where she

Speaker:

calls the friend of one of the interviewees

Speaker:

and asks them, what should I ask the interviewee?

Speaker:

And I know, I think she's up for a Golden Globe

Speaker:

and that whole nine yards now, to me

Speaker:

especially, her first episodes were not great, which I was kind of surprised

Speaker:

because she's been podcasting not in this format, but in a while,

Speaker:

and her first episodes really reeked of. Ooh,

Speaker:

I should have probably practiced more. I should have done my homework if I realized

Speaker:

people were actually going to listen to me. But then again,

Speaker:

everybody hates their first episode. So that show is called Good Hang with

Speaker:

Amy Poehler. And that was one of the few things that I was like, oh,

Speaker:

I've never heard somebody do that before. And it really wasn't that

Speaker:

crazy. So I'm hoping to see some people do.

Speaker:

You know, again, going back to that phrase, thinking outside

Speaker:

the box. Because the beautiful thing of podcasting is you

Speaker:

can do whatever you want. If you want to do a three minute opening

Speaker:

about a weird superintendent who keeps trying to

Speaker:

ruin Christmas with a yeah, you can do that.

Speaker:

It's yours. Some of it's good, Some of

Speaker:

it maybe not so good. But if you need help with your

Speaker:

podcast and you're like, dave, I don't have a podcast, well, then you need to

Speaker:

launch, I can help you with that. Like, Dave, I've, I've, I've got an idea.

Speaker:

Okay, well, I can help you plan that. Great. Okay, well, I've

Speaker:

got mine planned. Okay, I can help you launch it. Launching is so

Speaker:

easy. People really overthink that one and then you need to grow

Speaker:

it. Well, let's go back to the, the launch. Let's take a listen to

Speaker:

that. Because your content's what's going to help you grow. But we got other things

Speaker:

we can look into and we got members of the school of podcasting that have

Speaker:

tried a lot of things and you can learn from their mistakes and you

Speaker:

can learn and watch their success. It's all there

Speaker:

out@schoolofpodcasting.com use the coupon code

Speaker:

listener when you sign up. And that could be for a monthly, could

Speaker:

be for quarterly. A lot of the people doing the quarterly thing, I like that,

Speaker:

that's cool because you do save over the monthly and if

Speaker:

you got the budget, do the yearly thing and then you save a ton. And

Speaker:

that comes with a 30 day money back guarantee.

Speaker:

I'm Dave Jackson. I've been podcasting for 20 years. I

Speaker:

love to help podcasters. It's really what I do. And I can't wait to

Speaker:

see what we do together. And until next

Speaker:

week, where we will be talking about your favorite podcast

Speaker:

and why, if you haven't answered it yet,

Speaker:

schoolofpodcasting.com? i need it by the

Speaker:

26th of December and we will be learning together

Speaker:

what makes a good podcast because we're going to really be digging into

Speaker:

the why. And of course we'll be

Speaker:

Putting the links to your website on my website.

Speaker:

Thank you so much for listening. Have a Merry Christmas. Happy

Speaker:

Kwanzaa, Massica. Whatever you're celebrating, I'm hoping you're taking time

Speaker:

to hang out with your family, your friends, and make those

Speaker:

memories that are absolutely tattooed to your forehead

Speaker:

that you will remember from years to come. Take care.

Speaker:

God bless. Class is dismissed.

Speaker:

Hey, no real bloopers today, but just a little behind the

Speaker:

scenes. If you thought this episode sounded a little

Speaker:

with some weird edits or you thought maybe my voice sounded a little

Speaker:

weird, that's because I started recording this

Speaker:

about one o', clock, had to run and do some stuff, had to go and

Speaker:

sing tonight at a concert, and

Speaker:

I ended up recording this. I think. I think I'm on four,

Speaker:

maybe definitely three. And some of it was good, some

Speaker:

of it wasn't good. And so if you're like, man, he just rambled on. But

Speaker:

I did. I poked. This sounds weird. I poked my own bear.

Speaker:

Usually when people say, you poked the bear, it's like, no, no. I guess

Speaker:

in this case, that article poked the bear. And the first

Speaker:

crack at that, I went on for like 45 minutes. I

Speaker:

was like, I'm not even to the other subjects yet. So I was like, we

Speaker:

got to do that again. Get some bullet points. What am I really trying to

Speaker:

say? And so I did cut that down. But if you

Speaker:

heard some edits, like, what's going on with Dave's voice? That was what was going

Speaker:

on with Dave's voice. And it's pretty raspy right now. I gave it all I

Speaker:

had in the choir tonight. And again, I wish you a merry Christmas.

Speaker:

And if you're looking for something else to listen to, check out the

Speaker:

website, powerofpodcasting.com.

Speaker:

Yeah.