1 00:00:01,040 --> 00:00:05,484 You're about to join Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on a raw and honest 2 00:00:05,484 --> 00:00:09,524 journey into the world of systematic investing and learn about 3 00:00:09,524 --> 00:00:13,160 the most dependable and consistent yet often overlooked investment 4 00:00:13,160 --> 00:00:15,988 strategy. Welcome to the Systematic Investor Series. 5 00:00:23,280 --> 00:00:43,685 Welcome and welcome back to this week's edition of the Systematic 6 00:00:43,685 --> 00:01:00,380 Investor series with Katy Kaminski, Cem Karsan, Rob Carver, 7 00:01:00,380 --> 00:01:15,220 Mark Rzepczynski, Rich Brennan, Alan Dunne, Nick Baltas, 8 00:01:15,220 --> 00:01:35,625 Andrew Beer, Yoav Git, and I, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen. As you can 9 00:01:35,625 --> 00:01:52,320 tell from this introduction, today's and last week's episodes 10 00:01:52,320 --> 00:02:16,435 were very special because it's the time of the year where all ten 11 00:02:16,435 --> 00:02:34,985 of us get together for one big conversation and debate. Sofirstly, 12 00:00:26,792 --> 00:00:51,376 let me start by thanking all of you for making the time for this 13 00:00:51,376 --> 00:01:07,180 extended recording today, which I really have been looking 14 00:01:07,180 --> 00:01:30,008 forward to and, of course, for all the time and energy you have 15 00:01:30,008 --> 00:01:49,324 put into making all the amazing weekly episodes that we have 16 00:01:49,324 --> 00:02:13,908 published this year. It means a lot to me and based on the feedback 17 00:02:13,908 --> 00:02:34,980 that we get, I know it means a lot to our community. We'verecorded 18 00:00:25,812 --> 00:00:38,472 our conversation on December 17th, and last week we published 19 00:00:38,472 --> 00:00:53,664 part one of the conversation and today you'll be joining us for 20 00:00:53,664 --> 00:01:10,122 part two. We got a great lineup of topics across the two episodes. 21 00:01:10,122 --> 00:01:26,580 And just to mention some of the themes that we will be covering 22 00:01:26,580 --> 00:01:39,240 in this group conversation. These are things like the impact 23 00:01:39,240 --> 00:01:51,900 of market selection on trend following, the massive bull cycle 24 00:01:51,900 --> 00:02:04,560 in non-correlated investments and how three years in it's still 25 00:02:04,560 --> 00:02:19,752 in its infancy. We're going to be talking about the period 2023 26 00:02:19,752 --> 00:02:31,146 to 2025 which has been characterized by large dispersion 27 00:02:31,146 --> 00:02:34,944 between trend managers. We'realso going to be debating whether 28 00:00:37,917 --> 00:00:58,827 model design decisions are ever obvious. We're going to look 29 00:00:58,827 --> 00:01:23,919 at the trend and performance and how much data you really need 30 00:01:23,919 --> 00:01:44,829 in order to make any inference about manager performance. We're 31 00:01:44,829 --> 00:02:07,830 going to be debating process stability in a changing market landscape 32 00:02:07,830 --> 00:02:35,013 and also if we should have more high vol versions of CTA products. 33 00:00:23,280 --> 00:00:53,464 Andfinally, we have a topic about drawdowns, whether long drawdowns 34 00:00:53,464 --> 00:01:29,136 or deep drawdowns are to be desired or which is worse. So, really, 35 00:01:29,136 --> 00:02:04,808 it has been a packed agenda across the two episodes and I really 36 00:02:04,808 --> 00:02:34,992 hope you enjoy it. So, with that, let's rejoin the conversation. 37 00:02:36,150 --> 00:03:13,538 Well, there are two questions that I have that I'd like to ask 38 00:03:13,538 --> 00:03:50,926 the rest of the panelists. One is about the AI revolution and modeling. 39 00:02:36,150 --> 00:02:57,094 So,I know that we see that everybody is getting on the AI bandwagon, 40 00:02:57,094 --> 00:03:16,542 and I was doing some work with the Harvard Business school and we 41 00:03:16,542 --> 00:03:28,510 were assessing new entrepreneurs. And it doesn't matter 42 00:03:28,510 --> 00:03:47,958 what the problem is, they know that they have to have AI involved 43 00:03:47,958 --> 00:03:50,950 in it. So,I want to ask everyone else, how are you using 44 00:03:07,786 --> 00:03:39,422 AI to improve your models or to improve your research process? 45 00:03:39,422 --> 00:03:50,926 So, that's one question. Andthe other question has to do 46 00:02:42,457 --> 00:02:51,467 with this total portfolio approach, and Alan and I touched 47 00:02:51,467 --> 00:03:03,180 on this a little bit in our last podcast. But there's now strategic 48 00:03:03,180 --> 00:03:13,091 asset allocation versus TPA, and what does that mean for trend 49 00:03:13,091 --> 00:03:23,903 following? Is a TPA approach good or bad for trend following versus 50 00:03:23,903 --> 00:03:33,814 strategic asset allocation? So, is this going to help CTAs and 51 00:03:33,814 --> 00:03:42,824 trend following if there's a new portfolio approach? So those 52 00:03:42,824 --> 00:03:50,933 are my two questions that I am focusing on. 53 00:03:50,950 --> 00:04:14,324 The TPA is probably an easiest question to answer in a sense that, 54 00:04:14,324 --> 00:04:35,900 in principle, this should be really good for CTAs. Okay, so in 55 00:04:35,900 --> 00:04:53,880 terms of, I think Cem talked about uncorrelated strategies, and 56 00:04:53,880 --> 00:05:13,658 if you start looking at CTAs within a normal allocation process 57 00:05:13,658 --> 00:05:29,840 (which just looks at total portfolio allocation), you should 58 00:05:29,840 --> 00:05:53,214 allocate an insane amount of risk to CTAs. Okay? And like… I don't 59 00:05:53,214 --> 00:06:14,790 mean insane… Like, even if you expect your Sharpe ratio of your 60 00:06:14,790 --> 00:06:38,164 other portfolio to be 1.50 and you think that CTAs are 0.5 Sharpe, 61 00:06:38,164 --> 00:06:59,740 then in order to maximize your Sharpe, you need to essentially have 62 00:06:59,740 --> 00:07:12,326 a 1 to 3 allocation to CTAs. So,I'm looking really forward to 63 00:04:20,422 --> 00:05:14,454 the CTA industry running 25% of all assets under management, which 64 00:05:14,454 --> 00:06:13,398 will bring us to a mere sort of US$30 trillion, actually. So, 65 00:06:13,398 --> 00:07:07,430 I’m really looking forward to that happening. In reality, I suspect 66 00:07:07,430 --> 00:07:12,350 not. Ithinkit's a good thing that allocators are actually beginning 67 00:04:17,636 --> 00:04:46,748 to think about the portfolio as a whole, rather than, oh, here 68 00:04:46,748 --> 00:05:15,860 is the hedge fund bucket. This has got 20% allocation. Within this, 69 00:05:15,860 --> 00:05:49,824 we have to have macro, we have to have long/short, we have to have 70 00:05:49,824 --> 00:06:18,936 real estate, we have to have private credit or whatever. And then 71 00:06:18,936 --> 00:06:50,474 CTAs get like 2% where they make a zero difference to the overall 72 00:06:50,474 --> 00:07:12,308 portfolio in terms of convexity, in terms of diversification. 73 00:03:50,950 --> 00:04:25,400 So,I think it's a good thing for you to think holistically about 74 00:04:25,400 --> 00:04:54,550 CTAs. And I've long argued that really you should think about 75 00:04:54,550 --> 00:05:23,700 CTAs in the context of the asset classes that you're holding 76 00:05:23,700 --> 00:05:55,500 in your own portfolio. So, if you're a fixed income manager, you 77 00:05:55,500 --> 00:06:24,650 should think about fixed income CTAs. If you have fixed income 78 00:06:24,650 --> 00:06:53,800 exposure if you're an equity manager, so, a very different story. 79 00:06:53,800 --> 00:07:12,350 But I don't expect that to happen. Ithinkthat the TPA is a 80 00:04:06,609 --> 00:04:26,742 buzzword. I think it's a management consultant speak. It's 81 00:04:26,742 --> 00:04:46,875 some governance and discussion. And I don't really see 82 00:04:46,875 --> 00:05:09,245 huge flows flowing into CTAs. In practice, flow follows performance 83 00:05:09,245 --> 00:05:33,852 and that will be the most determining factor of flows into 84 00:05:33,852 --> 00:06:02,933 the CTA universe. And I can't blame people because at the end of 85 00:06:02,933 --> 00:06:29,777 the day that's exactly what we are trading. We are trading performance, 86 00:06:29,777 --> 00:06:45,436 like, flows follow performance, and that's absolutely 87 00:06:45,436 --> 00:07:12,280 fine. So, I don't imagine a huge change in behavior from TPAs. 88 00:03:50,950 --> 00:04:10,190 Ifyou want me to, I can comment about AI, but generally the 89 00:04:10,190 --> 00:04:26,470 approach has been very cautious on our side. It is able 90 00:04:26,470 --> 00:04:47,190 to help us in coding. It has helped us to in terms of summary 91 00:04:47,190 --> 00:05:03,470 of client discussion. It's helpful in terms of summary of lots 92 00:05:03,470 --> 00:05:21,230 of the way that we think. It's actually useful for testing. You 93 00:05:21,230 --> 00:05:38,990 know, I can feed my presentation to an AI, and it comes 94 00:05:38,990 --> 00:05:58,230 back, and it's, oh my God, I didn't actually mean to say that. 95 00:05:58,230 --> 00:06:17,470 So, the fact that the AI has not understood what I said, that's 96 00:06:17,470 --> 00:06:36,710 been very useful for me to rethink the message and what is the 97 00:06:36,710 --> 00:06:51,510 absolute message. But I suspect other people have used AI 98 00:06:51,510 --> 00:07:10,750 in a more creative fashion so I will let them comment about it 99 00:07:10,750 --> 00:07:12,230 themselves. 100 00:07:13,290 --> 00:07:14,330 Alan, over to you. 101 00:07:14,570 --> 00:08:07,392 Yeah, I think TPA is interesting, and we did chat about 102 00:08:07,392 --> 00:09:09,818 it, Mark. I think there are a few different lenses you have to 103 00:09:09,818 --> 00:09:29,026 think about this from. AndI think if you take from the pure return 104 00:07:25,240 --> 00:07:36,977 lens, what Yoav said is correct. GIC and J.P. Morgan Asset 105 00:07:36,977 --> 00:07:49,781 Management had a paper out last year, I think it was, looking 106 00:07:49,781 --> 00:08:02,585 at if you construct a hedge fund portfolio and optimize it on 107 00:08:02,585 --> 00:08:14,322 a standalone basis versus if you optimize the hedge fund portfolio 108 00:08:14,322 --> 00:08:24,992 in the context of an overall portfolio alongside traditional assets, 109 00:08:24,992 --> 00:08:35,662 you get a different allocation. You get much more allocation 110 00:08:35,662 --> 00:08:47,399 to CTA, to macro commodities when you optimize in the context 111 00:08:47,399 --> 00:08:58,069 of the overall portfolio because you're going to have less 112 00:08:58,069 --> 00:09:06,605 allocations to long/short equity and credit and strategies 113 00:09:06,605 --> 00:09:18,342 like that which pick up factors which you already have in 114 00:09:18,342 --> 00:09:29,012 your portfolio. So, I think that that's a valid perspective. 115 00:07:14,570 --> 00:09:29,040 Ithinkanother perspective is that if you think about what a trend 116 00:07:43,703 --> 00:08:10,595 following program or a CTA does, it does TPA already. It evaluates 117 00:08:10,595 --> 00:08:35,246 the market and assesses where are the best risk adjusted returns, 118 00:08:35,246 --> 00:08:57,656 where are the best opportunities in real time. So, it's 119 00:08:57,656 --> 00:09:22,307 evaluating coffee, and sugar, and cocoa, and all of these markets 120 00:09:22,307 --> 00:09:29,030 and allocating risk. Andthat's the idea of TPA. You don't 121 00:07:36,522 --> 00:08:01,218 have static allocations to different markets that you dynamically 122 00:08:01,218 --> 00:08:28,658 allocate risk to where the opportunities are greatest. So, in 123 00:08:28,658 --> 00:09:01,586 that sense, adding a trend following program or a CTA on top 124 00:09:01,586 --> 00:09:29,026 of 60/40, you're already building a more TPA like approach. 125 00:07:14,570 --> 00:09:29,040 Acomplicatingfactor though, then, is, I mean, the whole point 126 00:07:48,967 --> 00:08:26,491 of TPA seems to be to empower these investment teams. So rather 127 00:08:26,491 --> 00:08:51,507 than just sticking with strategic asset allocation, they 128 00:08:51,507 --> 00:09:29,031 can decide, okay, we want to have more risk in these areas. So,how 129 00:07:18,016 --> 00:07:38,692 do they account for the fact that if you're allocating the hedge 130 00:07:38,692 --> 00:07:55,922 funds which are already making tactical bets in certain sectors, 131 00:07:55,922 --> 00:08:20,044 do they look through that or do they have to adjust for that in 132 00:08:20,044 --> 00:08:42,443 terms of their own views as well? So, I think that's where it 133 00:08:42,443 --> 00:09:04,842 remains to be seen how it plays out. But I think in theory, 134 00:09:04,842 --> 00:09:27,241 there are a couple of reasons why it should be very positive for 135 00:09:27,241 --> 00:09:28,964 CTAs. 136 00:09:30,660 --> 00:09:48,060 I completely agree with Yoav on this in that people are going 137 00:09:48,060 --> 00:10:06,910 to come up with an allocation that they like, that they think makes 138 00:10:06,910 --> 00:10:22,860 them look good and smart, that their investing committees will like, 139 00:10:22,860 --> 00:10:40,260 that their clients will like, that they can explain in good times 140 00:10:40,260 --> 00:10:54,760 and bad. I mean, in a strategic asset allocation, manage 141 00:10:54,760 --> 00:11:12,160 futures is a 25% allocation, right? It's just, it's sort of mathematically 142 00:11:12,160 --> 00:11:28,110 obvious. There aren't many things you have out there that have 143 00:11:28,110 --> 00:11:46,960 zero correlation to stocks and bonds and do well when you need it 144 00:11:46,960 --> 00:12:04,360 the most, that you can scale and do it in liquid fashion. Youknow, 145 00:09:35,390 --> 00:10:01,405 back to the paper that Alan mentioned, it was true, actually, 146 00:10:01,405 --> 00:10:25,055 CTAs were basically on almost every statistical measure in terms 147 00:10:25,055 --> 00:10:39,245 of alpha generation, correlation characteristics, and 148 00:10:39,245 --> 00:11:05,260 performance, when you need it the most. There just wasn't much 149 00:11:05,260 --> 00:11:33,640 else there. The pod shops come pretty close. But where TPA could 150 00:11:33,640 --> 00:11:59,655 be very useful is it could break the anchoring around indices 151 00:11:59,655 --> 00:12:04,385 and allocations. So,a typical institutional allocator in the US 152 00:09:57,996 --> 00:10:39,000 has about a 6% allocation to hedge funds today, of which managed 153 00:10:39,000 --> 00:11:13,170 futures, according to kind of the broad classification of hedge 154 00:11:13,170 --> 00:11:57,591 funds, is sub 10%. And so, you're looking at about a 50 basis 155 00:11:57,591 --> 00:12:04,425 point allocation. Itis extremely difficult for the guys 156 00:09:54,579 --> 00:10:32,166 who are in charge of running those hedge fund portfolios, when 157 00:10:32,166 --> 00:11:13,170 they are benchmarked to these hedge fund indices, to take it from 158 00:11:13,170 --> 00:12:01,008 a 6% or 7% allocation to a 30% allocation, which is where it should 159 00:12:01,008 --> 00:12:04,425 be. Evenif they believe that the Sharpe ratio of equity long/short, 160 00:10:03,187 --> 00:10:26,843 or the diversification benefits of equity long/shorts, would 161 00:10:26,843 --> 00:11:05,284 be a pale shadow of what you would get from this strategy, it 162 00:11:05,284 --> 00:11:37,811 is still very, very difficult, from a career perspective, to break 163 00:11:37,811 --> 00:12:04,424 away from how they are anchored these benchmark-like measures. 164 00:09:30,660 --> 00:09:45,192 Andso, I think a glimmer of hope and… I think that most people 165 00:09:45,192 --> 00:09:57,648 still view it as a largely unlikable strategy, for some of the 166 00:09:57,648 --> 00:10:06,990 reasons we've described, because it doesn't have the kind 167 00:10:06,990 --> 00:10:22,560 of warm and fuzzy of, you know, I get to talk to some guy about 168 00:10:22,560 --> 00:10:37,092 whether he thinks we're going to be in recession in a year. I do 169 00:10:37,092 --> 00:10:46,434 think that breaking that anchoring mechanism and having people 170 00:10:46,434 --> 00:10:59,928 kind of start with a blank sheet of paper and then come back 171 00:10:59,928 --> 00:11:11,346 to the table thinking about things in statistical terms is going 172 00:11:11,346 --> 00:11:25,878 to be positive for the space. But my caveat is that (I think maybe 173 00:11:25,878 --> 00:11:41,448 Alan may have just said it in the space) a lot of it is theater 174 00:11:41,448 --> 00:11:52,866 around people trying to come up with, basically get a broader 175 00:11:52,866 --> 00:12:04,284 mandate. It sounds cool, etc., etc. but, you know, cautiously optimistic. 176 00:12:05,310 --> 00:12:11,407 Well, before we move on to the next topic that Rich will bring, 177 00:12:11,407 --> 00:12:17,973 I certainly need to hear from Cem because I think we left out one 178 00:12:17,973 --> 00:12:22,194 strategy that is also mentioned, often in this context, 179 00:12:22,194 --> 00:12:25,008 and that is of course volatility. AndI know that you, 180 00:12:10,235 --> 00:12:20,085 Cem, have had some great conversation with David Dredge recently, 181 00:12:20,085 --> 00:12:25,010 very much on this topic. 182 00:12:25,010 --> 00:13:04,538 Yeah, look, to take a step back from this conversation, I think, 183 00:13:04,538 --> 00:13:44,066 we get really deep on trend allocation and that's part of why 184 00:13:44,066 --> 00:14:23,594 people listen to us. But I also think it's important to step 185 00:14:23,594 --> 00:15:03,122 back and look at the big picture. 95% of the world invests 186 00:15:03,122 --> 00:15:42,650 in the most simplistic basic way, which is they go shopping for 187 00:15:42,650 --> 00:16:12,296 stuff. And most of those things, they think diversification 188 00:16:12,296 --> 00:16:51,824 is probably buying more things in different ways, which we all know 189 00:16:51,824 --> 00:17:28,058 are highly correlated on the tail and even much more correlated 190 00:17:28,058 --> 00:17:37,940 than people realize. Thismove to diversification non-correlation 191 00:12:44,330 --> 00:13:26,834 is practiced by a relatively small portion of the investing world. 192 00:13:26,834 --> 00:14:28,658 We can get into the details of how and why, but I talk to RIAs all 193 00:14:28,658 --> 00:15:26,618 the time and one of the first questions I ask, when I talk to RIAs, 194 00:15:26,618 --> 00:16:20,714 is what do you think the Sharpe ratio is of the S&P over the 195 00:16:20,714 --> 00:17:14,810 last 125 years? What do you think the Sharpe ratio is of a 60/40 196 00:17:14,810 --> 00:17:37,994 portfolio over the last 125 years? Doyou know how many of the 197 00:12:59,786 --> 00:14:04,370 hundreds I talk to know or even have a guess on that answer? 198 00:14:04,370 --> 00:15:08,954 Answer is zero, zero. And, by the way, does anybody here have a 199 00:15:08,954 --> 00:16:18,506 sense of what that is, by the way? 0.35. Both of them, zero correlation, 200 00:16:18,506 --> 00:17:03,218 zero diversification benefit of bonds versus stocks, zero. Yet 201 00:17:03,218 --> 00:17:37,994 that's what 95% of the world does. So,this idea that we need 202 00:12:43,418 --> 00:13:11,030 to be talking about these little details of diversification, 203 00:13:11,030 --> 00:13:50,914 how it fits, let's get the big picture. And there are several things: 204 00:13:50,914 --> 00:14:09,322 there's diversification broadly meaning true diversification, 205 00:14:09,322 --> 00:14:40,002 things that are not assets (let's start there), trend following 206 00:14:40,002 --> 00:15:13,750 (one of those many things because the second you have assets 207 00:15:13,750 --> 00:15:44,430 they are going to be correlated, by definition, in certain 208 00:15:44,430 --> 00:16:21,246 ways). But too, Niels, the one thing that tons of academic research 209 00:16:21,246 --> 00:16:58,062 points to is the one thing that is a true consistent diversifier, 210 00:16:58,062 --> 00:17:34,878 and the most important thing in portfolio which is a long volatility 211 00:17:34,878 --> 00:17:37,946 hedge. Toour conversation with David Dredge, which was my favorite 212 00:12:51,990 --> 00:13:24,366 of the year, we have so many. He gives this incredible metaphor 213 00:13:24,366 --> 00:14:04,836 which is the more you dig into it, the better it is. So many people 214 00:14:04,836 --> 00:14:37,212 go look at long volatility, much like a lot of other strategies, 215 00:14:37,212 --> 00:15:01,494 but particularly long volatility. And they say, oh, this 216 00:15:01,494 --> 00:15:28,474 returns zero over the long-term. You know, this thing makes 217 00:15:28,474 --> 00:15:58,152 me go slower. Why would I allocate to something that makes 218 00:15:58,152 --> 00:16:35,924 me go slower? That sounds like an awful idea to 99% of people, but 219 00:16:35,924 --> 00:17:08,300 that's like looking at your brakes on a race car. These brakes 220 00:17:08,300 --> 00:17:37,978 make me go slow. You gotta get rid of these brakes. Thereality 221 00:12:32,550 --> 00:13:14,020 is long volatility (and this applies to other things in different 222 00:13:14,020 --> 00:14:03,030 ways) are brakes on your race car. And the net result of removing 223 00:14:03,030 --> 00:14:44,500 the brakes from the car means everybody goes slower because you're 224 00:14:44,500 --> 00:15:29,740 going to have turns and you can't go around those turns without 225 00:15:29,740 --> 00:16:14,980 brakes at full speed. So, what stocks and bonds actually is, is 226 00:16:14,980 --> 00:16:45,140 going slower. There's no diversification benefit. You just 227 00:16:45,140 --> 00:17:26,610 go slower. And people do that because they're worried about flying 228 00:17:26,610 --> 00:17:37,920 off the tracks. Brakes,importantly, don't just make 229 00:13:08,480 --> 00:14:52,808 sure you don't go off the tracks. And this is the critical 230 00:14:52,808 --> 00:16:28,442 part. Everybody thinks, oh, long vol, that'll make sure you stay 231 00:16:28,442 --> 00:17:37,994 in the tracks and you don't fly off. Themore important part 232 00:13:13,162 --> 00:15:37,618 of that metaphor is the brakes give you control. The brakes allow 233 00:15:37,618 --> 00:17:37,998 you to slow down into the turn and accelerate out. Youwin races, 234 00:12:34,037 --> 00:13:16,163 you go faster by having vol in the portfolio. What do you do with 235 00:13:16,163 --> 00:13:55,280 brakes? You don't sit on brakes and sit on gas all day. Yeah, 236 00:13:55,280 --> 00:14:37,406 that will make you go slower. What you do is you have brakes on 237 00:14:37,406 --> 00:15:13,514 the car. You hit the brakes, when you're coming around a turn 238 00:15:13,514 --> 00:15:55,640 and there's risk or up it a little bit. You always have a little 239 00:15:55,640 --> 00:16:28,739 bit in the portfolio. And guess what? When that, when those 240 00:16:28,739 --> 00:17:04,847 brakes pay off and give you control, that gives you the ability 241 00:17:04,847 --> 00:17:37,946 to monetize, push on the gas, go faster down the straightaway. 242 00:12:25,010 --> 00:13:12,827 We'retrying to build race cars, trying to build control and 243 00:13:12,827 --> 00:13:51,950 risk management in the portfolio. But risk management doesn't 244 00:13:51,950 --> 00:14:48,461 mean we go slower. You can't eat Sharpe sortino, but if you get 245 00:14:48,461 --> 00:15:36,278 a balanced Sharpe sortino, if you get control of the portfolio, 246 00:15:36,278 --> 00:16:41,483 guess what? You can go a heck of a lot faster. And I think that's 247 00:16:41,483 --> 00:17:33,647 what we all need to be thinking about. And that's the big 248 00:17:33,647 --> 00:17:37,994 picture. Andagain, I think this broad communication will make 249 00:13:05,834 --> 00:13:51,194 an incredibly greater impact to the majority of allocators than 250 00:13:51,194 --> 00:14:32,018 the little details, given how overwhelmingly the whole investment 251 00:14:32,018 --> 00:15:17,378 world, the majority of the investment world is completely doing 252 00:15:17,378 --> 00:16:07,274 things that, again, didn't exist until 1985 and doing it simply 253 00:16:07,274 --> 00:17:01,706 because of recency bias and a lack of needing to really manage 254 00:17:01,706 --> 00:17:37,994 risk and understand risk in a meaningful way. 255 00:17:41,451 --> 00:17:46,515 All right, Rich, all the way from Australia, what do you want 256 00:17:46,515 --> 00:17:47,359 to discuss? 257 00:17:48,651 --> 00:18:08,077 Well, I thought I'd bring up this idea about process stability 258 00:18:08,077 --> 00:18:25,737 in a changing market landscape. So, we all accept the 259 00:18:25,737 --> 00:18:46,929 fact that markets change all the time, but to me that doesn't 260 00:18:46,929 --> 00:19:02,823 necessarily mean your process should change all the time. So,I 261 00:17:50,427 --> 00:18:04,155 think one of the biggest mistakes that investors make is changing 262 00:18:04,155 --> 00:18:17,883 their rules in response to recent outcomes. But a stable process 263 00:18:17,883 --> 00:18:31,611 does not eliminate drawdowns. In fact, you must embrace your drawdowns. 264 00:18:31,611 --> 00:18:46,587 That's part of the process. But what a stable process does do, 265 00:18:46,587 --> 00:18:59,067 it doesn't eliminate the drawdowns, but it does prevent panic 266 00:18:59,067 --> 00:19:02,811 and behavioral drift. So,what allocators really need is not a promise, 267 00:17:56,922 --> 00:18:08,910 they say, of smooth returns, but clarity on how the strategy behaves 268 00:18:08,910 --> 00:18:15,903 when conditions are uncomfortable. And this stability 269 00:18:15,903 --> 00:18:25,893 builds this trust, especially when these markets are so noisy, 270 00:18:25,893 --> 00:18:39,879 as we all know they are. So, I suppose the question I've got to 271 00:18:39,879 --> 00:18:50,868 ask people is how much change of our trend following strategies 272 00:18:50,868 --> 00:19:01,857 is evolution versus how much is really just reacting to recent 273 00:19:01,857 --> 00:19:02,856 pain? 274 00:19:03,941 --> 00:19:20,755 I'll take a first stab at that even though I'm not the trend follower 275 00:19:20,755 --> 00:19:37,569 in here, I think I do have an important thought here. I think trend, 276 00:19:37,569 --> 00:19:50,780 almost by definition, at least started out as really thinking about 277 00:19:50,780 --> 00:20:05,192 things and up down, and catching the up down. And the reality 278 00:20:05,192 --> 00:20:18,403 is, here in vol world, we think about distributions of outcomes 279 00:20:18,403 --> 00:20:30,413 and really taking this framework of how is the distribution 280 00:20:30,413 --> 00:20:43,624 different in this environment, and why is it different? We have 281 00:20:43,624 --> 00:20:54,433 actually a pretty good ability to predict distribution. Predicting 282 00:20:54,433 --> 00:20:58,036 direction is hard. Butif you can broadly predict broad distribution 283 00:19:27,965 --> 00:20:00,998 of regime, and that does change, then you can really more 284 00:20:00,998 --> 00:20:37,034 accurately have a sense of what type of trend model is going 285 00:20:37,034 --> 00:20:58,055 to work better in a different environment. AndI think taking that 286 00:19:10,141 --> 00:19:25,021 broad approach and that mental kind of model, as opposed to just 287 00:19:25,021 --> 00:19:38,661 back testing and seeing how it performed and what performs better 288 00:19:38,661 --> 00:19:54,781 and optimizing to that, is going to get you to a much better 289 00:19:54,781 --> 00:20:09,661 place, I think, from a forward process. And volatility plays a huge 290 00:20:09,661 --> 00:20:27,021 role in that. If we can think about, you know, what the width of 291 00:20:27,021 --> 00:20:40,661 the distribution and how fat the tails are in different environments, 292 00:20:40,661 --> 00:20:54,301 that input, which again is broadly easier to predict, can play 293 00:20:54,301 --> 00:20:58,021 an incredible role. So,I agree, historically, that we've been 294 00:19:14,448 --> 00:19:33,961 taking the wrong process and there has been just a lot of curve 295 00:19:33,961 --> 00:19:51,973 fitting and naturally kind of, you know, getting to the last best 296 00:19:51,973 --> 00:20:09,985 outcome. But I do think, you know, this ability to think forward 297 00:20:09,985 --> 00:20:24,995 on distribution, based on supply and demand and factors that 298 00:20:24,995 --> 00:20:43,007 are changing in the market, can really pay dividends and do the 299 00:20:43,007 --> 00:20:58,017 opposite. I think there's more of that happening than ever. 300 00:21:00,151 --> 00:21:01,911 Great, Andrew. 301 00:21:01,911 --> 00:21:33,495 So, Rich, it's interesting you say that because I have very funny 302 00:21:33,495 --> 00:21:57,183 conversations with people. So, we've been replicating the space 303 00:21:57,183 --> 00:22:31,399 for about 10 years, and I get the questions from people. They say, 304 00:22:31,399 --> 00:23:05,615 tell us all the changes you've made in your model, and the answer 305 00:23:05,615 --> 00:23:39,831 is none. Zero. Not a line of code, not an instrument. And that 306 00:23:39,831 --> 00:23:58,255 is not what they want to hear. Theywant to hear that, you know, 307 00:21:24,773 --> 00:22:07,231 five years ago we decided that there was an 11th factor that we 308 00:22:07,231 --> 00:22:49,689 should throw into it, that we decided to switch up our window links 309 00:22:49,689 --> 00:23:28,881 because we had some sense that, you know, I don't know, Trump's 310 00:23:28,881 --> 00:23:58,275 election was going to change window lengths or something. And,what 311 00:21:05,335 --> 00:21:27,591 I've said to people, I said, look, we have an extremely high bar 312 00:21:27,591 --> 00:21:49,847 that we look at. And it's very, very hard not to change what 313 00:21:49,847 --> 00:22:10,391 you do because, back to your point about response to pain, of 314 00:22:10,391 --> 00:22:27,511 course, there are always periods you're going to go through, 315 00:22:27,511 --> 00:22:44,631 and you're looking at it, constantly thinking about, God darn 316 00:22:44,631 --> 00:23:06,887 it, why didn't we make that change six months ago or wish we'd 317 00:23:06,887 --> 00:23:27,431 done some other things. The problem goes back to the point that 318 00:23:27,431 --> 00:23:47,975 I raised before, that it's not obvious whether those will have an 319 00:23:47,975 --> 00:23:58,247 impact on a going forward basis. Andwhat I've often said to 320 00:21:13,935 --> 00:21:31,971 allocators, and this actually dovetails to something that Alan 321 00:21:31,971 --> 00:21:58,023 asked a little while ago, is I said the very, very best outcome 322 00:21:58,023 --> 00:22:24,075 for you… So, the easiest thing for you, from a fund manager selection 323 00:22:24,075 --> 00:22:48,123 process, should be you can look at our entire track record and 324 00:22:48,123 --> 00:23:06,159 know it's completely consistent. You don't have to think 325 00:23:06,159 --> 00:23:30,207 about, you know, whether these changes were good or bad that we 326 00:23:30,207 --> 00:23:56,259 made and whether they had an impact and what it would have been 327 00:23:56,259 --> 00:23:58,311 like. Isaidthe second thing is the very best outcome for you, 328 00:21:32,151 --> 00:22:07,431 on a going forward basis if you invest with us, is 10 years from 329 00:22:07,431 --> 00:22:40,191 now you ask us the same question, and we said we still haven't 330 00:22:40,191 --> 00:23:07,911 had to change anything. I'm slowly winning hearts and minds with 331 00:23:07,911 --> 00:23:40,671 that. But it is a very, very, very contrarian view because it feels 332 00:23:40,671 --> 00:23:58,311 like a loss of power and control. Butwhat it does is it comes 333 00:21:13,342 --> 00:21:32,938 back to, you know, what I've said about, there's an owning the 334 00:21:32,938 --> 00:21:49,268 investment process and the investment decisions, in a very real 335 00:21:49,268 --> 00:22:07,231 way, that I think people outside of this space… Cliff Asness, 336 00:22:07,231 --> 00:22:26,827 I think, is a great example of somebody who runs a quantitatively 337 00:22:26,827 --> 00:22:44,790 based business but is very good at owning their decisions and 338 00:22:44,790 --> 00:23:06,019 is very good about saying, you know, we picked this factor in the 339 00:23:06,019 --> 00:23:25,615 following time and it was a terrible decision on our part to 340 00:23:25,615 --> 00:23:46,844 do it, or things are working in our favor and boy we're flipping 341 00:23:46,844 --> 00:23:58,275 heads, and flipping heads, and flipping heads. AndI think what 342 00:21:09,495 --> 00:21:32,247 Alan said about the difficulty of an allocator in this space is 343 00:21:32,247 --> 00:21:56,895 this idea that when things go badly it just feels like bad luck 344 00:21:56,895 --> 00:22:19,647 and you don't really have a narrative necessarily as to why it's 345 00:22:19,647 --> 00:22:44,295 going to recover. And so, I think this idea of that there's a 346 00:22:44,295 --> 00:22:57,567 difference between those individual decisions that people 347 00:22:57,567 --> 00:23:18,423 make, and the broader asset allocation thesis that one is trying 348 00:23:18,423 --> 00:23:41,175 to make, and the source of alpha and excess returns. And those 349 00:23:41,175 --> 00:23:58,239 are really the challenges on a going forward basis. 350 00:24:08,313 --> 00:25:50,283 Having consistency and staying true to trend is a really important 351 00:25:50,283 --> 00:27:32,253 decision. But I think there are two aspects which are important 352 00:27:32,253 --> 00:28:37,143 in making any changes to your strategy. Thefirst one is truly 353 00:24:30,351 --> 00:25:20,975 actually understanding the causes for performance or underperformance. 354 00:25:20,975 --> 00:26:24,255 That is actually measuring things properly. And the second thing 355 00:26:24,255 --> 00:27:33,863 is actually understanding your thesis and staying true to your thesis. 356 00:27:33,863 --> 00:28:37,143 Okay, And I'm going to give two examples on that. So,the first 357 00:24:08,095 --> 00:24:42,503 one is about benchmarking. So, we've seen performance the last three 358 00:24:42,503 --> 00:25:16,911 years has been difficult. And you ask yourself what has possibly 359 00:25:16,911 --> 00:25:57,575 caused this? And then you need to break your process. It says, the 360 00:25:57,575 --> 00:26:35,111 reason why I've not been able to perform well is because maybe 361 00:26:35,111 --> 00:27:18,903 the asset itself has had a Sharpe 1. But in the past, I've been 362 00:27:18,903 --> 00:28:05,823 able to extract maybe a Sharpe 0.4 out of a market which had a Sharpe 363 00:28:05,823 --> 00:28:37,103 1. But now suddenly I'm only able to extract 0.3. Okay,that's 364 00:24:05,341 --> 00:24:45,121 cause for concerns. For some reason my model is broken down. But 365 00:24:45,121 --> 00:25:28,216 doing that, you actually need to be able to measure the data. You 366 00:25:28,216 --> 00:26:01,366 actually have to say, well, actually, if we see, historically, 367 00:26:01,366 --> 00:26:41,146 we've seen assets that have trended a Sharpe 1 (like the underlying 368 00:26:41,146 --> 00:27:24,241 asset has trended Sharpe 1), what do we see in the last three 369 00:27:24,241 --> 00:28:10,651 years versus what we've seen in the past? And by the way, I think 370 00:28:10,651 --> 00:28:37,171 for most CTAs, this has stayed roughly constant. BecauseI think 371 00:24:17,275 --> 00:25:25,343 the reason why we have seen the underperformance in the last 372 00:25:25,343 --> 00:26:33,411 few years is not because the model doesn't work, it’s because 373 00:26:33,411 --> 00:27:29,103 we've seen this vol compression that we're talking about. 374 00:27:29,103 --> 00:28:30,983 We have seen just less outliers, we've seen less outside 375 00:28:30,983 --> 00:28:37,171 trend. So,the first thing that gives you comfort is actually 376 00:25:00,591 --> 00:26:14,847 just being able to measure which parts of your model are actually 377 00:26:14,847 --> 00:27:29,103 not performing. So being able to break it down, before we even 378 00:27:29,103 --> 00:28:24,795 start a discussion, you actually have to understand what's 379 00:28:24,795 --> 00:28:37,171 going on. Andthen it comes to the question of what is your thesis? 380 00:24:31,471 --> 00:25:06,961 And we talked a little about the design choices that we make in 381 00:25:06,961 --> 00:25:39,721 the CTAs. What is obvious, what is not obvious, like, if what 382 00:25:39,721 --> 00:26:09,751 you are selling to the investor is risk factors which are 383 00:26:09,751 --> 00:26:31,591 not financialized, or risk factors which are financialized, 384 00:26:31,591 --> 00:27:07,081 or a certain speed. So suppose, if you are a very fast trend 385 00:27:07,081 --> 00:27:42,571 follower and you say, well, I'm not able to make money, I'm going 386 00:27:42,571 --> 00:28:15,331 to drift away from that space, that's actually going to be very 387 00:28:15,331 --> 00:28:37,171 bad. You're just going to lose your investors. Inour case, if we 388 00:24:15,686 --> 00:24:59,821 say we want to concentrate in markets with very low beta to the 389 00:24:59,821 --> 00:25:30,376 financialized universe, then things that you can actually measure 390 00:25:30,376 --> 00:26:07,721 is the physical properties of those markets and how they've become 391 00:26:07,721 --> 00:26:48,461 more financialized. So, one of the things that we monitor on an 392 00:26:48,461 --> 00:27:29,201 ongoing basis, for example, if we're looking at iron ore. I was 393 00:27:29,201 --> 00:28:09,941 with traders in Singapore in iron ore. So, in the past nobody 394 00:28:09,941 --> 00:28:37,101 was trading it. No CTA was trading it. Thesedays I was talking 395 00:24:19,806 --> 00:25:14,653 to the guy, to the traders from one of the big broker houses 396 00:25:14,653 --> 00:26:09,500 and he said, well, about 70% of the volume in the front month 397 00:26:09,500 --> 00:27:04,347 contract are CTAs. Okay, to me that's a warning sign. I just don't 398 00:27:04,347 --> 00:27:59,194 want to trade this market, I don't want to trade the front month 399 00:27:59,194 --> 00:28:37,165 in iron ore anymore because it is completely financialized. Andthe 400 00:24:07,839 --> 00:24:48,915 market, the underlying properties of the market have changed. 401 00:24:48,915 --> 00:25:43,683 And it doesn't mean it doesn't trend well. But the program, the 402 00:25:43,683 --> 00:26:47,579 thesis of what we are giving you as an investor is all about we 403 00:26:47,579 --> 00:27:37,783 are giving you stuff that other people are not trading. Well, 404 00:27:37,783 --> 00:28:32,551 that market is no longer in that category. So sometimes it really 405 00:28:32,551 --> 00:28:37,171 depends… Imeanit's great. If you're saying I'm going to give you 406 00:25:20,203 --> 00:26:34,904 the most financialized and I'm going to give you replication of 407 00:26:34,904 --> 00:27:42,814 the SocGen index, then actually you don't really need to 408 00:27:42,814 --> 00:28:37,142 do much. You just follow a mathematical exercise. Butactually, 409 00:24:06,553 --> 00:24:41,842 I think understanding the markets that you're trading, understanding 410 00:24:41,842 --> 00:25:24,973 what is the thesis that you're providing the investors and staying 411 00:25:24,973 --> 00:26:15,946 true to that, it means that you may be throwing out markets which 412 00:26:15,946 --> 00:27:02,998 trend very well. You might not have a gold exposure because gold 413 00:27:02,998 --> 00:27:42,208 is very highly financialized and you don't mind, actually, not 414 00:27:42,208 --> 00:28:33,181 having it. You just have to be true to what you've promised the 415 00:28:33,181 --> 00:28:37,102 investors. AndI think changes in the portfolio which reflect that, 416 00:25:56,521 --> 00:28:05,041 I think are changes which are about following process in a very 417 00:28:05,041 --> 00:28:37,171 fast changing world. 418 00:28:42,371 --> 00:28:46,063 All right, we're going to move over to Nick and then we're going 419 00:28:46,063 --> 00:28:49,755 to head over to Rob and hear his secret topic because we're not 420 00:28:49,755 --> 00:28:50,607 aware of that. 421 00:28:50,851 --> 00:29:33,295 Look, I'm going to be brief because it's a super nice question 422 00:29:33,295 --> 00:30:19,276 by the way, Rich. I mean, is the pain an invitation to change 423 00:30:19,276 --> 00:31:08,794 your model? I would say no. Is the pain an invitation to think about 424 00:31:08,794 --> 00:31:22,942 changing the model? Maybe. Andlet me explain that. So, I'm 425 00:29:00,616 --> 00:29:15,961 going to maybe use the same thing that we started discussing 426 00:29:15,961 --> 00:29:32,701 about those V shapes. If it happens once, you're fine, you kind 427 00:29:32,701 --> 00:29:49,441 of understand what's going on, you go back to your investors, you 428 00:29:49,441 --> 00:30:03,391 have an explanation, everything is what it says on the 429 00:30:03,391 --> 00:30:18,736 tin. If it happens again, if the dollar/yen happens again, or 430 00:30:18,736 --> 00:30:35,476 the Liberation Day, that kind of makes an invitation for you to 431 00:30:35,476 --> 00:30:52,216 kind of look through. Is there any blind spot? Is there something 432 00:30:52,216 --> 00:31:08,956 that the market is kind of telling us? Should we somehow change 433 00:31:08,956 --> 00:31:22,971 the model? Is it the right time to do so? Ithinkthe bar, as 434 00:29:05,201 --> 00:29:33,901 I said earlier on, is extremely high. I think underperformance 435 00:29:33,901 --> 00:30:14,081 and pain is an invitation to reflect upon. But we try to be extremely, 436 00:30:14,081 --> 00:30:45,651 extremely averse to just changing the model just as a response 437 00:30:45,651 --> 00:31:05,741 of underperformance, specifically when it's fully explainable. 438 00:31:05,741 --> 00:31:22,961 And that's back to your point. Maybea soft comment on what Andrew 439 00:29:13,993 --> 00:29:47,053 said, I think there's a subtle difference between an underlying 440 00:29:47,053 --> 00:30:26,725 model and a replication model. So, as long as the underlying managers 441 00:30:26,725 --> 00:30:59,785 change, or not, their model, it doesn't necessarily make their 442 00:30:59,785 --> 00:31:22,971 application of the aggregation better or worse. Ithinkto the extent 443 00:29:03,116 --> 00:29:35,005 (and you tell me if you know if I'm getting that incorrect), to 444 00:29:35,005 --> 00:30:04,441 the extent that those managers do not become super quick in the 445 00:30:04,441 --> 00:30:28,971 way that they behave, and therefore a replication model lags 446 00:30:28,971 --> 00:30:58,407 too far behind, I think it will remain to be successful. Obviously, 447 00:30:58,407 --> 00:31:22,937 you kind of played out the benefits of the averaging. AndI 448 00:28:57,059 --> 00:29:31,203 guess a good question is, is the objective to minimize tracking 449 00:29:31,203 --> 00:29:59,139 error? Probably not, because obviously the outperformance is important. 450 00:29:59,139 --> 00:30:36,387 Actually, I'm sure this year you're happy to have this kind of 451 00:30:36,387 --> 00:31:10,531 high tracking error. Now, is that indication that the model does 452 00:31:10,531 --> 00:31:22,971 work, yes or no? Iguesswe don't really have a straight answer, 453 00:29:08,626 --> 00:29:34,301 but I think to my point, kind of summarizing on this one, their 454 00:29:34,301 --> 00:29:54,051 application model almost has an assumption on how the average 455 00:29:54,051 --> 00:30:13,801 underneath behaves. And as long as that remains through time, 456 00:30:13,801 --> 00:30:35,526 you don't really have to change your recipe, right? Even if 457 00:30:35,526 --> 00:30:57,251 the underlying managers change their models, if the sum of those 458 00:30:57,251 --> 00:31:20,951 changes kind of sum up to zero, you're already done with your 459 00:31:20,951 --> 00:31:22,971 application. Idon'tknow. I don't want to speak on your behalf, 460 00:29:43,134 --> 00:30:40,170 but I think that's how my thought process kind of went through 461 00:30:40,170 --> 00:31:22,947 as you were speaking. But thanks Rich, good question. 462 00:31:23,531 --> 00:32:15,261 So, look, Nick, I mean, you know what we do very well and those 463 00:32:15,261 --> 00:32:59,601 are all the key questions. If everybody goes to a 15-day model, 464 00:32:59,601 --> 00:33:43,941 it's not going to be a surprise. It would be foolish. We'll 465 00:33:43,941 --> 00:34:02,416 be talking about it, right? Everybody'sabandoned long-term trend, 466 00:31:32,875 --> 00:31:58,571 medium-term trend, everybody's doing 15 or 20 day models and everyone's 467 00:31:58,571 --> 00:32:26,603 become Grable or something. And so, no, of course you have to 468 00:32:26,603 --> 00:32:52,299 look, and reflect, and try to be intelligent about the underlying 469 00:32:52,299 --> 00:33:17,995 thing. But unless it indicates that there is something, and, you 470 00:33:17,995 --> 00:33:46,027 know, you try to understand what it is, and what's causing the 471 00:33:46,027 --> 00:34:02,379 deviation, and whether that's consistent with it, WhatI would 472 00:31:30,059 --> 00:31:53,995 say, and again, because I think there were so many fascinating 473 00:31:53,995 --> 00:32:15,755 parts of this overall conversation, and just to bring a 474 00:32:15,755 --> 00:32:39,691 couple of different things together, one of the things is this 475 00:32:39,691 --> 00:32:59,275 whole idea of… You presented incredibly interesting data that, 476 00:32:59,275 --> 00:33:23,211 over the past three years, slower and simpler has worked better. 477 00:33:23,211 --> 00:33:42,795 Which obviously has benefited us, presumably, and certain people, 478 00:33:42,795 --> 00:34:02,379 the ETFs, more broadly, things that have been simpler. Butwhat 479 00:31:28,575 --> 00:32:01,361 I think is missing from this space is, because in the US mutual 480 00:32:01,361 --> 00:32:34,147 fund market, for instance, a lot of firms have been going in the 481 00:32:34,147 --> 00:32:59,367 opposite direction up until the past three years. Their claim 482 00:32:59,367 --> 00:33:32,153 to fame was moving into, and outside of the hedge funds as well, 483 00:33:32,153 --> 00:33:59,895 moving outside of the simpler strategies and adding more and more 484 00:33:59,895 --> 00:34:02,417 things. Soas an allocator, when I look at it, and again, maybe 485 00:31:43,391 --> 00:32:04,906 people say this, but again, I think this is where sort of like 486 00:32:04,906 --> 00:32:23,111 somebody is saying, like, yeah, I made a really big mistake 487 00:32:23,111 --> 00:32:44,626 over the past three years. I gave up this much return by adding 488 00:32:44,626 --> 00:33:02,831 these things that haven't worked well in this regime. I didn't 489 00:33:02,831 --> 00:33:21,036 see this regime coming. I'm still trying to understand what it 490 00:33:21,036 --> 00:33:44,206 was because I didn't have to do this, but I did. And it's cost 491 00:33:44,206 --> 00:34:02,411 me 1,100 basis points of returns relative if I've done nothing. 492 00:31:23,531 --> 00:31:58,199 Thatkind of ownership of the design decisions, I think if you 493 00:31:58,199 --> 00:32:29,978 do that with dispersion, it makes it easier for allocators to 494 00:32:29,978 --> 00:33:01,757 locate the managers. It's that you have all these decisions that 495 00:33:01,757 --> 00:33:36,425 are made and then kind of raising the hands and saying, well, 496 00:33:36,425 --> 00:34:02,426 it didn't work because the markets just are weird. Andso, I 497 00:31:31,346 --> 00:32:02,606 think Yoav makes this point, Rich has made this point, etc., is 498 00:32:02,606 --> 00:32:31,261 that there is something about owning the decisions and why they're 499 00:32:31,261 --> 00:33:05,126 being made and staying true to it in some fashion. That's what also 500 00:33:05,126 --> 00:33:36,386 helps allocators to figure out how to put together this mosaic of 501 00:33:36,386 --> 00:34:02,436 exposures to a space that's really complicated for most people. 502 00:34:03,081 --> 00:34:06,513 All right, let's jump over… Well, actually, we're going to jump 503 00:34:06,513 --> 00:34:09,945 down all the way down to Israel now. Because that's where 504 00:34:09,945 --> 00:34:12,441 you are today, Yoav. What's on your mind? 505 00:34:12,441 --> 00:34:52,341 Right, so, with your permission, I'm going to steal your 506 00:34:52,341 --> 00:35:36,231 very own question because I think that's the way the discussion 507 00:35:36,231 --> 00:36:20,121 has been going here. And it's about risk management, it's about 508 00:36:20,121 --> 00:37:04,011 drawdown, it's about staying true to your hypothesis. And I think 509 00:37:04,011 --> 00:37:51,891 it's also about the discussion that Cem was talking about, the volatility 510 00:37:51,891 --> 00:38:39,771 and the having the brakes and the outsized gains when things are 511 00:38:39,771 --> 00:38:47,751 going well. AndI'm going to talk about drawdowns. So, you asked 512 00:34:59,911 --> 00:35:47,381 questions, what's worse, having a long drawdown or a deep 513 00:35:47,381 --> 00:36:49,092 drawdown? And I think what is very interesting to me is that when 514 00:36:49,092 --> 00:37:31,815 we have discussions with allocators, I'm trying to explain 515 00:37:31,815 --> 00:38:24,032 to them that CTA drawdowns are actually very distinct to drawdowns 516 00:38:24,032 --> 00:38:47,767 in other hedge fund managers. Andwhat I mean by that is that normally, 517 00:34:34,968 --> 00:35:02,501 for most positions and most hedge funds, big drawdowns or very 518 00:35:02,501 --> 00:35:32,537 sharp drawdowns are to do with like poor risk management and just 519 00:35:32,537 --> 00:36:00,070 events playing against the big positions. So, they will be losing 520 00:36:00,070 --> 00:36:27,603 money because things happen. So, you know, you happen to… the 521 00:36:27,603 --> 00:37:00,142 big shorts, imagine you have the big, big shorts. You put a position 522 00:37:00,142 --> 00:37:27,675 on the housing market, and the housing market tanks, and suddenly 523 00:37:27,675 --> 00:38:00,214 you have a big drawdown, and you have to explain to the investor 524 00:38:00,214 --> 00:38:32,753 and actually you can tell a story (which I think that's the discussion 525 00:38:32,753 --> 00:38:47,771 that Andrew was talking about earlier). WithCTAs, it's almost 526 00:34:20,845 --> 00:34:46,057 the other way around. The reason why CTAs tend to lose money 527 00:34:46,057 --> 00:35:04,966 is mostly because nothing happens. So obviously, when there 528 00:35:04,966 --> 00:35:36,481 is a position on, and there is an event on, like if there is Liberation 529 00:35:36,481 --> 00:35:57,491 Day, then you suffer. But the consistent drawdown really comes 530 00:35:57,491 --> 00:36:20,602 from recognizing that CTAs are a little bit like buying straddles, 531 00:36:20,602 --> 00:36:43,713 in the same way that the volatility insurance is about buying 532 00:36:43,713 --> 00:37:08,925 straddles at various times. And that means that we pay for them 533 00:37:08,925 --> 00:37:34,137 through trading cost, maybe not in the case of Andrew, but in 534 00:37:34,137 --> 00:38:01,450 the case of most of the assets that we trade, we essentially replicate 535 00:38:01,450 --> 00:38:24,561 an option. We replicate a trading profile which is a straddle 536 00:38:24,561 --> 00:38:47,672 and we will lose money if nothing happens on this market. Andin 537 00:34:18,843 --> 00:34:57,255 fact, in a normal CTA, most years, most of your markets, you 538 00:34:57,255 --> 00:35:35,667 will lose money. And I think investors kind of puzzle about it. 539 00:35:35,667 --> 00:36:17,280 They go, what's going on here? And the truth is because you will 540 00:36:17,280 --> 00:36:58,893 make outsized returns when there is a trend in one of your markets 541 00:36:58,893 --> 00:37:27,702 that will more than compensate. So, you don't actually 542 00:37:27,702 --> 00:38:09,315 need 50% of your markets to be winners, you just need maybe 40% 543 00:38:09,315 --> 00:38:47,727 of your markets to be winners to have a good positive year. Andthe 544 00:34:21,321 --> 00:35:14,601 reason why you might have a situation where you're in a drawdown 545 00:35:14,601 --> 00:36:03,441 is not because you haven't been able to capitalize on trends. 546 00:36:03,441 --> 00:36:56,721 It's not necessarily because there was a big event and you badly 547 00:36:56,721 --> 00:37:50,001 risk managed yourself. It's to do with the fact that instead of 548 00:37:50,001 --> 00:38:38,841 having 40% winners, suddenly you only had 35% winners or maybe 549 00:38:38,841 --> 00:38:47,721 30% winners. Andthat's a very different drawdown profile, which 550 00:34:39,969 --> 00:35:14,379 is actually very difficult for investors to accept because what 551 00:35:14,379 --> 00:36:05,994 you find is that the allocator would like to go to the IC and say, 552 00:36:05,994 --> 00:36:54,168 yeah, he got this call wrong. He didn't know he made a bet about 553 00:36:54,168 --> 00:37:35,460 who's going to be the Fed chairman, and that bet went sour. 554 00:37:35,460 --> 00:38:20,193 But like we really trust this guy. He's come from a great pedigree. 555 00:38:20,193 --> 00:38:47,721 So, we're going to stick with this guy. Withthe CTA, drawdowns 556 00:34:29,921 --> 00:35:09,251 are much more difficult because there isn't necessarily one 557 00:35:09,251 --> 00:35:57,321 event that will explain the drawdown. It's just a very consistent 558 00:35:57,321 --> 00:36:45,391 event where we've seen a vol compression and the percentage of 559 00:36:45,391 --> 00:37:29,091 winners has just shrunk below the break-even point. And that's 560 00:37:29,091 --> 00:38:25,901 something that we have seen in the last three years, which has been 561 00:38:25,901 --> 00:38:47,751 very difficult for the industry. So,I think in CTAs, you 562 00:34:44,205 --> 00:35:42,439 don't necessarily see a very deep drawdown, but you might have 563 00:35:42,439 --> 00:36:51,261 a go through a situation where for a long period the events, like 564 00:36:51,261 --> 00:37:33,613 vol compression, have basically made outsize trend very 565 00:37:33,613 --> 00:38:37,141 difficult to harvest. And I would like to hear the panel's view 566 00:38:37,141 --> 00:38:47,729 about that. 567 00:38:49,461 --> 00:38:50,501 Katy, over to you. 568 00:38:50,501 --> 00:41:14,209 I love this Yoav. Weactually wrote an interesting paper this year 569 00:39:00,237 --> 00:39:11,190 about managed futures drawdowns and sort of studied them 570 00:39:11,190 --> 00:39:23,360 and looked at sort of the historical largest drawdowns for 571 00:39:23,360 --> 00:39:35,530 managed futures. And we have this really interesting bubble chart 572 00:39:35,530 --> 00:39:52,568 in there where we look at sort of the time of the drawdown, the 573 00:39:52,568 --> 00:40:07,172 depth of the drawdown, and then we also look at the recovery 574 00:40:07,172 --> 00:40:22,993 period for drawdowns. And what we find is, if you look at what's 575 00:40:22,993 --> 00:40:35,163 happening during a lot of our very challenging environments, they 576 00:40:35,163 --> 00:40:47,333 tend to be pretty good environments for equities. So, when 577 00:40:47,333 --> 00:41:01,937 things are stable we didn't look at vol, but you can imagine 578 00:41:01,937 --> 00:41:14,107 when equities are doing well, vol is also often lower. Andthen 579 00:38:54,233 --> 00:39:16,625 the recovery for the strategy, since it tends to be very cyclical, 580 00:39:16,625 --> 00:39:39,017 was much faster when you have sort of a challenging equity environment 581 00:39:39,017 --> 00:40:01,409 or things are changing. And what happens there is you just have 582 00:40:01,409 --> 00:40:23,801 a higher hit ratio of trending things which kind of mirrors what 583 00:40:23,801 --> 00:40:44,327 you were saying. So, I think, at least qualitatively, this study 584 00:40:44,327 --> 00:41:04,853 for managed features drawdowns was kind of explaining some of the 585 00:41:04,853 --> 00:41:14,183 things you just talked about. Butit also focused on, and I think 586 00:39:08,749 --> 00:39:36,121 this is important for why I care a lot about dispersion driving 587 00:39:36,121 --> 00:40:03,493 behavioral effects, if you look at most of the fund of funds 588 00:40:03,493 --> 00:40:30,865 who have studied our space, it's very difficult to pick a winning 589 00:40:30,865 --> 00:40:58,237 manager in any one year. And if you look at drawdown periods, 590 00:40:58,237 --> 00:41:14,204 the strategies, on average, tend to recover. So,if you look 591 00:38:56,025 --> 00:39:11,216 over at when there's been a very challenging period of performance, 592 00:39:11,216 --> 00:39:23,645 usually that's followed historically by one or two years 593 00:39:23,645 --> 00:39:38,836 of very positive performance. So, I think that is something that, 594 00:39:38,836 --> 00:39:56,789 you know, although we can have skewness in the short term or we 595 00:39:56,789 --> 00:40:13,361 can have persistence in the short term, we tend to have mean 596 00:40:13,361 --> 00:40:25,790 reversion over longer time horizon. So, I think understanding 597 00:40:25,790 --> 00:40:40,981 that for investors is important because if you try to sort 598 00:40:40,981 --> 00:40:53,410 of pick tops and bottoms, you're basically trend following 599 00:40:53,410 --> 00:41:05,839 trend following, which I wouldn't suggest… or trend falling 600 00:41:05,839 --> 00:41:14,125 squared, which is an interesting strategy. Butyeah, so, 601 00:39:09,245 --> 00:40:30,469 interesting. I don't know if you saw the paper, but I think this 602 00:40:30,469 --> 00:41:14,205 paper does give some insights on that. 603 00:41:14,771 --> 00:41:38,883 So fascinating point is, I think, the perception of risk in 604 00:41:38,883 --> 00:42:07,379 the space is far greater than it is. And again, this goes sort 605 00:42:07,379 --> 00:42:31,491 of with the narrative that disconnect spaces have like a 15%, 606 00:42:31,491 --> 00:42:53,411 16% drawdown over 25 years. Like, it’s child's play compared 607 00:42:53,411 --> 00:43:19,715 to equities. And now, for a while, you could say again, bonds 608 00:43:19,715 --> 00:43:43,827 didn't have a drawdown for 20 years, basically, and now you've 609 00:43:43,827 --> 00:43:54,787 had a 15%, 16% drawdown. ButI think also, going back to the point 610 00:41:28,100 --> 00:41:41,429 about sort of how to communicate the alpha generation 611 00:41:41,429 --> 00:41:57,720 of the space back to investors. I think where, at least, 612 00:41:57,720 --> 00:42:16,973 we've seen it is that you're going to go through… The space is 613 00:42:16,973 --> 00:42:37,707 going to make money, a lot of money when the world changes a lot; 614 00:42:37,707 --> 00:42:55,479 when there's a big change in information. And there was no inflation 615 00:42:55,479 --> 00:43:14,732 and then there was a lot of inflation. And no one thought inflation 616 00:43:14,732 --> 00:43:31,023 was going to come back, and then everyone was totally confident 617 00:43:31,023 --> 00:43:50,276 inflation was going to 10%. So, you get this kind of big shift 618 00:43:50,276 --> 00:43:54,811 over 24 months. Ithinkwhat you can do is you can take that idea 619 00:41:30,383 --> 00:41:44,694 and explain to the total portfolio people and the asset allocators 620 00:41:44,694 --> 00:42:00,306 that this is what you do badly. Your whole business is designed 621 00:42:00,306 --> 00:42:12,015 to build these long-term capital markets assumptions and not 622 00:42:12,015 --> 00:42:28,928 change what you do. And so, when you have a noisy market like 623 00:42:28,928 --> 00:42:44,540 this year or last year, where the world really doesn't change very 624 00:42:44,540 --> 00:42:56,249 much. We haven't had that catastrophic return of inflation 625 00:42:56,249 --> 00:43:09,259 or deeper tariff induced recession, we haven't had some crazy 626 00:43:09,259 --> 00:43:22,269 contagious bond market tantrum. So, when there's a lot of 627 00:43:22,269 --> 00:43:37,881 noise, but the world doesn't change very much, of course the strategy 628 00:43:37,881 --> 00:43:50,891 is going to struggle. You're getting whipsawed and knocked around 629 00:43:50,891 --> 00:43:54,794 all day long. Butmy God, if a year from now equities are down 50%, 630 00:42:02,783 --> 00:42:54,796 what are you going to do with your portfolio where you're all in 631 00:42:54,796 --> 00:43:34,806 on the AI trade across equities, rates, and pretty much 632 00:43:34,806 --> 00:43:54,811 everywhere else you have it? So,I think again, what's so fascinating 633 00:41:30,773 --> 00:41:58,205 about the drawdowns in the space is that they're just not that 634 00:41:58,205 --> 00:42:27,923 big of a deal in the context of any asset. Somehow it's difficult 635 00:42:27,923 --> 00:42:55,355 to explain to people because then you say, oh no, what's really 636 00:42:55,355 --> 00:43:25,073 good about the space is that they cut losses as they start losing 637 00:43:25,073 --> 00:43:52,505 money on things. They don't hold onto things with a white knuckle 638 00:43:52,505 --> 00:43:54,791 grip. Buta lot of allocators want to hear that you have like an 639 00:41:50,638 --> 00:42:23,746 iron spine. You know, you were still buying Bitcoin at $20,000 because 640 00:42:23,746 --> 00:42:59,613 you knew it was going to recover. And I think that's the sort 641 00:42:59,613 --> 00:43:24,444 of need for some sort of anthropomorphism and storytelling 642 00:43:24,444 --> 00:43:54,793 to get it passed through the gates for the average allocator. 643 00:43:57,002 --> 00:44:08,426 This was a great question, by the way, Yoav, I have to say, but 644 00:44:08,426 --> 00:44:19,034 I have a little bit of a follow up question mainly to Andrew, 645 00:44:19,034 --> 00:44:29,642 because I learn a lot every time I speak to Andrew. And today 646 00:44:29,642 --> 00:44:38,618 I've just learned that, actually, we don't even have to have 647 00:44:38,618 --> 00:44:47,594 a research department and investors will be just fine if we 648 00:44:47,594 --> 00:44:57,386 say that. But the other thing that is very interesting, I'd love 649 00:44:57,386 --> 00:45:02,282 to hear your thoughts about this. So,in the ETF world, my perception 650 00:44:01,440 --> 00:44:09,682 is that I think people think this much more along the lines of, 651 00:44:09,682 --> 00:44:16,022 it's another stock, it's another ticker. So, I actually wonder 652 00:44:16,022 --> 00:44:22,362 whether drawdowns are even really being considered in the same 653 00:44:22,362 --> 00:44:29,970 way? When people look at the performance of your ticker, do they 654 00:44:29,970 --> 00:44:37,578 even talk about the word drawdown or is it just like with 655 00:44:37,578 --> 00:44:45,820 an equity, oh, yeah, it's maybe not in a new high. But the 656 00:44:45,820 --> 00:44:52,160 word drawdown, when I think about equity investors, they never 657 00:44:52,160 --> 00:45:01,036 use that word. Does that come up in your world or you're part of 658 00:45:01,036 --> 00:45:02,304 the world? 659 00:45:03,072 --> 00:45:41,286 Oh, yeah, no, people don't like drawdowns. They don't like it 660 00:45:41,286 --> 00:46:26,448 because you can see it every day. You can see it every minute. 661 00:46:26,448 --> 00:47:15,084 And so, Alan made a point about how do you talk to people about 662 00:47:15,084 --> 00:48:03,720 the space, or at least how do I talk to people about the space? 663 00:45:03,072 --> 00:48:03,762 Ithinkthe problem is when you have a space with wide dispersion, 664 00:45:46,570 --> 00:46:16,684 the allocator's natural response (and it's a very rational 665 00:46:16,684 --> 00:46:50,144 response from a career perspective) is you pick the guy 666 00:46:50,144 --> 00:47:33,642 who's been doing well, who has a good brand name. That's a rational, 667 00:47:33,642 --> 00:48:00,410 fund selector, investment decision that's persisted for 50 668 00:48:00,410 --> 00:48:03,756 years. Thechallenge, the way it sort of flows through (to use 669 00:45:23,554 --> 00:45:45,898 a term from Cem’s discussion), in terms of like a negative feedback 670 00:45:45,898 --> 00:46:08,242 loop or something like that, is that what happens is a typical 671 00:46:08,242 --> 00:46:30,586 allocator, who is not as well versed in statistics of no persistence 672 00:46:30,586 --> 00:46:49,206 of alpha and a wide dispersion, will tend to oversell 673 00:46:49,206 --> 00:47:07,826 a given individual manner of outperformance relative to the space 674 00:47:07,826 --> 00:47:28,308 because they want to get it into the portfolio. There's something 675 00:47:28,308 --> 00:47:46,928 in their incentive structure where they've been asked, you know, 676 00:47:46,928 --> 00:48:03,686 go find us the best person in this space. Andso, if they go back 677 00:45:14,244 --> 00:45:36,588 and say, hey, I don't really know, but this guy's done better, 678 00:45:36,588 --> 00:45:57,070 this woman's done better over this past period of time. That's 679 00:45:57,070 --> 00:46:21,276 not really what the person on the other side wants to hear. So, 680 00:46:21,276 --> 00:46:45,482 they tend to get more and more confident and it happens with every 681 00:46:45,482 --> 00:47:07,826 hedge fund strategy. It starts out with like, I really don't know 682 00:47:07,826 --> 00:47:28,308 who's the best equity long/short guy, and by the time you're 683 00:47:28,308 --> 00:47:46,928 sitting in front of the investing committee, we found the 684 00:47:46,928 --> 00:48:03,686 very best, the guy who could do no wrong. So,what happens is 685 00:45:25,656 --> 00:46:16,470 though, that people get worried about elevating the manager 686 00:46:16,470 --> 00:47:24,222 and, then when it goes badly, they don't have a narrative around 687 00:47:24,222 --> 00:48:03,744 that you have in other asset classes. Butto your point about 688 00:45:14,087 --> 00:45:38,320 it, because when people have been trained that when equities go 689 00:45:38,320 --> 00:46:06,959 down, if anything it's a buy; if anything, buy the dip. And so, 690 00:46:06,959 --> 00:46:35,598 what they're looking for in this space is some sort of a story 691 00:46:35,598 --> 00:47:04,237 that explains the rebound. And people in this space tend to be very 692 00:47:04,237 --> 00:47:26,267 financially sophisticated, which kind of leads to a sort of 693 00:47:26,267 --> 00:47:54,906 a level of honesty about it. We don't really know that it's going 694 00:47:54,906 --> 00:48:03,718 to rebound, we don't. We'veactually have gotten out of 695 00:45:28,284 --> 00:46:18,708 the positions that we lost money on, but we think we're going 696 00:46:18,708 --> 00:47:00,728 to find new trends and opportunities on a going forward 697 00:47:00,728 --> 00:47:38,546 basis. And that honesty and equivocation actually plays against 698 00:47:38,546 --> 00:48:03,758 the broader adoption of the space. But,I think, back to the 699 00:45:13,296 --> 00:45:37,152 point about if you can get people to focus on this as a strategic 700 00:45:37,152 --> 00:45:52,488 long-term allocation and basically get them focused on day 701 00:45:52,488 --> 00:46:18,048 one, not on the gears and how they work, but as much in terms of 702 00:46:18,048 --> 00:46:36,792 the broader benefit and why it makes the overall portfolio better, 703 00:46:36,792 --> 00:47:00,648 that's my thesis as to how I can get this to become a standard 704 00:47:00,648 --> 00:47:22,800 allocation for people who are not going to want to engage in debates 705 00:47:22,800 --> 00:47:44,952 as to model lengths or number of positions. But when we do this 706 00:47:44,952 --> 00:48:03,696 in five years, you'll know if I was right or not. 707 00:48:05,752 --> 00:48:10,552 Okay, cool. All right. Now, before we get to our outrageous predictions 708 00:48:10,552 --> 00:48:16,152 for 2026, we need to hear from Rob. And he's been keeping us in 709 00:48:16,152 --> 00:48:19,352 suspense as to what he might bring up. 710 00:48:19,432 --> 00:49:16,665 Yeah, and it's definitely not because I hadn't thought of anything 711 00:49:16,665 --> 00:50:13,898 until I went to get coffee. That's definitely not the reason, 712 00:50:13,898 --> 00:50:19,101 honestly. Yeah,so, as we're getting towards the outrageous section, 713 00:48:39,016 --> 00:49:02,952 I thought I'd be a bit outrageous because, you know, you 714 00:49:02,952 --> 00:49:26,888 guys are all very serious and intelligent, and clever, and it's 715 00:49:26,888 --> 00:49:50,824 all very worthy and stuff. But, you know, people have probably 716 00:49:50,824 --> 00:50:16,936 fallen asleep listening to all that. So, let's stir things up a 717 00:50:16,936 --> 00:50:19,112 bit. So,one thing that occurred to me is we were kind of 718 00:48:55,336 --> 00:49:25,256 worried about selling our sort of product to mainly institutional 719 00:49:25,256 --> 00:49:49,192 investors or, you know, serious people. There's actually 720 00:49:49,192 --> 00:50:19,112 a big untapped market out there we haven't thought of. So,it 721 00:48:23,292 --> 00:48:50,312 occurs to me that, if you say, we've got a Sharpe 1 strategy, you 722 00:48:50,312 --> 00:49:13,472 know, maybe slightly lower, then even if we run that at sort 723 00:49:13,472 --> 00:49:36,632 of half Kelly, we could be running at sort of annualized risk 724 00:49:36,632 --> 00:50:01,722 of sort of 40%, 50%. And if you think we've got positive skew, 725 00:50:01,722 --> 00:50:19,092 you could probably push it a little bit higher. Andactually, 726 00:48:22,386 --> 00:48:43,064 if you look at the kind of retail market over the last few years, 727 00:48:43,064 --> 00:48:57,834 people want vol, they want massive returns, they want massive 728 00:48:57,834 --> 00:49:15,558 outliers, they want things that are going to go up and down 729 00:49:15,558 --> 00:49:31,805 a lot. They're not that interested in kind of worthy things 730 00:49:31,805 --> 00:49:52,483 that are trying to track the SG CTA index with its sort of single 731 00:49:52,483 --> 00:50:04,299 digit standard deviation. They're interested in weird crypto 732 00:50:04,299 --> 00:50:19,069 coins and meme stocks and all this kind of stuff. So,actually, 733 00:48:23,230 --> 00:48:47,917 I think we should be going for that market basically. So, I think 734 00:48:47,917 --> 00:49:10,705 everyone should go to their sales team now and say, right, we 735 00:49:10,705 --> 00:49:35,392 want a high vol ETF product, off you go. Because it's high vol, 736 00:49:35,392 --> 00:50:00,079 you can put the fees up a little bit higher as well because 737 00:50:00,079 --> 00:50:19,069 fees should be in there as a proportion of vol. Andlet the money 738 00:48:30,564 --> 00:49:03,960 come in. And this time next year everyone's going to be living 739 00:49:03,960 --> 00:49:37,356 in much nicer houses, and our backgrounds on this video are going 740 00:49:37,356 --> 00:50:07,969 to look very, very nice indeed. So, I welcome your feedback 741 00:50:07,969 --> 00:50:19,101 on my excellent suggestion. 742 00:50:21,192 --> 00:50:25,001 Well, you mentioned the word ETF, so I have to ask Andrew, high 743 00:50:25,001 --> 00:50:27,345 vol CTA, in the ETF land, does that…? 744 00:50:27,752 --> 00:51:00,296 There are a million different kinds of ETF investors. A lot of 745 00:51:00,296 --> 00:51:38,264 people have come to us and said, can you do 2x versions of what 746 00:51:38,264 --> 00:52:05,384 you do? And I was actually on a TTU one. So,there's a guy named 747 00:50:35,502 --> 00:50:54,102 Corey Hoffstein, in the US, who has pioneered the use of basically 748 00:50:54,102 --> 00:51:06,502 bolting managed features on… He's basically recreated portable 749 00:51:06,502 --> 00:51:23,552 alpha, calling it return stacking, and put it into ETFs. And 750 00:51:23,552 --> 00:51:43,702 I was with Niels once, and Niels, I think, asked me, why don't 751 00:51:43,702 --> 00:52:05,402 you do that? And my response was, well, I think it's a niche market. 752 00:50:27,752 --> 00:50:43,548 Andthen I got chased around by angry villagers with pitchforks 753 00:50:43,548 --> 00:51:00,780 on Twitter for about two weeks for having what they perceived as 754 00:51:00,780 --> 00:51:18,012 having insulted Corey, which it wasn't that at all. I said Innovator 755 00:51:18,012 --> 00:51:35,244 was just sold at 2 billion. It's a niche product. The buffered, 756 00:51:35,244 --> 00:51:53,912 or the covered call ETFs, are niche markets. You can have a multi 757 00:51:53,912 --> 00:52:05,400 deca billion-dollar niche market in the ETF world. So,I think 758 00:50:33,077 --> 00:50:56,152 there's a market for all of this stuff. If you'd asked me whether 759 00:50:56,152 --> 00:51:19,227 there's a market for 2x Tesla ETFs, again, where I think the big 760 00:51:19,227 --> 00:51:42,302 money is are the people who are risk averse and who spend 80% 761 00:51:42,302 --> 00:52:01,827 of their mental energy on how to avoid being embarrassed. That's 762 00:52:01,827 --> 00:52:05,377 my debt. So,I think that there is an enormous amount of opportunity 763 00:50:41,876 --> 00:50:57,284 to create products that can be huge in individual markets. I just 764 00:50:57,284 --> 00:51:16,544 think you have to try it and go out and talk to people who would 765 00:51:16,544 --> 00:51:34,520 be users of it and try to figure out a way to monetize. And 766 00:51:34,520 --> 00:51:48,644 I think, more leveraged products is the flip side of the 767 00:51:48,644 --> 00:52:05,336 portable alpha coin; you know, how do I do things with less capital? 768 00:52:05,722 --> 00:52:28,810 I'll add one thing to that. I wouldn't say leverage as much as 769 00:52:28,810 --> 00:52:46,570 capital efficiency. The return stacking idea, you know, we've talked 770 00:52:46,570 --> 00:53:04,330 about yield stacking, a similar thing, for five years, before 771 00:53:04,330 --> 00:53:11,434 these ETFs were launched. There’sa reason that options were 772 00:52:14,686 --> 00:52:28,132 introduced. The options exchanges started in 1971. If interest 773 00:52:28,132 --> 00:52:44,566 rates go higher, it is the simplest, most important thing in 774 00:52:44,566 --> 00:52:59,506 the world to be capital efficient. Nobody's cared about that 775 00:52:59,506 --> 00:53:11,458 for 20 years because interest rates were zero. Thattrend towards 776 00:52:07,654 --> 00:52:13,450 capital efficiency, which again, in general people call leverage, 777 00:52:13,450 --> 00:52:22,466 is what I think is critical. And so, the 2x, 3x, the growth in 778 00:52:22,466 --> 00:52:30,194 those, I don't think will be because people want more risk per 779 00:52:30,194 --> 00:52:38,566 se. It's just they want to be more capital efficient. And I think 780 00:52:38,566 --> 00:52:45,650 there's an ability to lump things in together. If you separate 781 00:52:45,650 --> 00:52:52,734 them, they're less capital efficient. But a lot of these strategies, 782 00:52:52,734 --> 00:52:58,530 when lumped together, can be dramatically more capital efficient. 783 00:52:58,530 --> 00:53:06,258 So, I do see that trend continuing, but less because of a 784 00:53:06,258 --> 00:53:11,410 need for leverage and more for that reason. 785 00:53:12,661 --> 00:53:23,749 I love this question, Rob. It's really fun. The reason it's 786 00:53:23,749 --> 00:53:37,861 fun to hear is that, you know, when we think about the old school 787 00:53:37,861 --> 00:53:50,965 CTAs, like back in the day, they were sort of, I guess, gun-slinging 788 00:53:50,965 --> 00:54:03,061 high vol. But what was missing in that world was monthly prints. 789 00:54:03,061 --> 00:54:14,149 So, basically you didn't have a Liberation Day, you didn't have 790 00:54:14,149 --> 00:54:27,253 a ticker where you could kind of publish it. And then that was 791 00:54:27,253 --> 00:54:39,349 more retail, actually in some ways, especially in the US. And then 792 00:54:39,349 --> 00:54:46,405 what happened was institutions got into CTAs. AndNiels is one to 793 00:53:18,306 --> 00:53:31,854 talk about this because he knows all the old school CTAs. Institutions 794 00:53:31,854 --> 00:53:44,273 got into it, assets got bigger, vols got down. You know, 795 00:53:44,273 --> 00:53:57,821 it was much more about managing the size. But I do agree 796 00:53:57,821 --> 00:54:12,498 that there is a segment of the market that wants higher risk, wants 797 00:54:12,498 --> 00:54:23,788 something a little different that goes back to the dispersion 798 00:54:23,788 --> 00:54:38,465 of products. But I guess one thing that's going to be hard to 799 00:54:38,465 --> 00:54:46,368 see is like that daily print, right? So,you know, you kind of 800 00:53:19,201 --> 00:53:32,281 wish that you could do some things that they do with private 801 00:53:32,281 --> 00:53:43,181 equity like smoothing or sort of monthly or quarterly reporting 802 00:53:43,181 --> 00:53:56,261 which, unfortunately, most of us we're daily liquid. So, I do think 803 00:53:56,261 --> 00:54:10,431 that it's going to be great when it goes up just like bitcoin, 804 00:54:10,431 --> 00:54:24,601 and it's going to be terrible when it goes down. So, you know, 805 00:54:24,601 --> 00:54:37,681 you could lose, have people rush in only to like be disappointed 806 00:54:37,681 --> 00:54:46,401 once it doesn't go the direction they wanted. 807 00:54:47,532 --> 00:54:52,407 I'll turn to you, Alan, now. But I just want to interject one 808 00:54:52,407 --> 00:54:57,282 thing before and that is, as Katy referred to, back in the day, 809 00:54:57,282 --> 00:55:01,782 in the ‘80s and early ‘90s, the Barclay CTA Index were running 810 00:55:01,782 --> 00:55:06,282 at an annualized volatility of between 20% and 25%. And since then 811 00:55:06,282 --> 00:55:11,157 it's gone down and, actually, in the last few years we are now 812 00:55:11,157 --> 00:55:12,657 below 5%, just FYI. 813 00:55:12,712 --> 00:55:24,614 Yeah, I mean I agree with everything that's been said. There's 814 00:55:24,614 --> 00:55:36,516 been that institutional trend for lower vol but there has been 815 00:55:36,516 --> 00:55:50,582 a little bit of a swing back. We have seen some managers launching 816 00:55:50,582 --> 00:56:03,566 high vol trend again, in the last while. And we obviously have 817 00:56:03,566 --> 00:56:15,468 some data points of high vol managers, very successful, long standing: 818 00:56:15,468 --> 00:56:25,206 Paul Mulvaney… So, we know how that plays out. Theygo through exceptional 819 00:55:15,256 --> 00:55:22,252 periods, raise some assets, they have a drawdown, lose a lot 820 00:55:22,252 --> 00:55:29,248 of assets, it repeats. So, presumably that would be the same 821 00:55:29,248 --> 00:55:38,152 if we were seeing high vol trend in the ETF space. But at the 822 00:55:38,152 --> 00:55:46,420 same time, I do think there is that trend in increase of knowledge 823 00:55:46,420 --> 00:55:53,416 of capital efficiency. So, maybe it is more, not just trend 824 00:55:53,416 --> 00:56:00,412 at high vol but more balanced products at reasonable vol. Because 825 00:56:00,412 --> 00:56:06,772 the challenge in the market in most wealth management portfolios 826 00:56:06,772 --> 00:56:13,768 is, you want more risk, we'll give you more equities. Whereas, 827 00:56:13,768 --> 00:56:20,764 in fact, you should have a balanced portfolio and then decide 828 00:56:20,764 --> 00:56:25,216 how much leverage to apply to it. AndI think we are seeing a bit 829 00:55:29,288 --> 00:55:52,080 more of that now with return stacking and with portable alpha 830 00:55:52,080 --> 00:56:12,800 products. So yeah, it's not just… It's balance plus leverage 831 00:56:12,800 --> 00:56:25,232 and high vol, I would say. 832 00:56:31,392 --> 00:56:37,904 We'll start with you, Andrew. What is your 2026 outrageous prediction? 833 00:56:37,912 --> 00:56:41,602 I think institutions start buying ETFs in the manage future 834 00:56:41,602 --> 00:56:46,030 space. I think the probability is that it’s quite low because I 835 00:56:46,030 --> 00:56:49,351 think most allocators at institutions have a business card 836 00:56:49,351 --> 00:56:53,779 that says Hedge Fund Analyst, and they have a hammer, they're going 837 00:56:53,779 --> 00:56:58,945 to look for hedge funds. I think they like it. But I think it 838 00:56:58,945 --> 00:57:03,004 would be very, very significant, but I think if you see 839 00:57:03,004 --> 00:57:07,432 institutions starting to look at ETFs as a plausible way to get 840 00:57:07,432 --> 00:57:11,491 exposure to the managed future space, that would be very outrageous 841 00:57:11,491 --> 00:57:12,229 and significant. 842 00:57:13,732 --> 00:57:17,332 Katy, I'm excited to hear your outrageous prediction. 843 00:57:17,732 --> 00:57:22,652 I think for me the biggest thing we've been talking about is 844 00:57:22,652 --> 00:57:27,162 like how there seems to be something brewing, whether or not 845 00:57:27,162 --> 00:57:33,312 it's good or bad, so, the boom and bust cycle. To me, I think next 846 00:57:33,312 --> 00:57:37,822 year could be a roller coaster. That we could have sort 847 00:57:37,822 --> 00:57:41,512 of rates go lower, overstimulation of the US Economy, 848 00:57:41,512 --> 00:57:46,022 and things could look awesome, and then suddenly things could fall 849 00:57:46,022 --> 00:57:52,172 apart. And so, I think for me, I think 2026 could be a pivotal year 850 00:57:52,172 --> 00:57:56,682 to see that macroeconomic change of what happened in the news 851 00:57:56,682 --> 00:57:57,502 this year. So,I think that's my prediction is that we will be 852 00:57:43,472 --> 00:57:57,512 on a roller coaster next year. 853 00:57:58,552 --> 00:58:01,032 Rob, what about you? 854 00:58:01,032 --> 00:58:04,032 As I’m being the funny guy today, my prediction, outrageous 855 00:58:04,032 --> 00:58:07,332 prediction, is that the next Fed chair will be Jared Kushner. 856 00:58:08,952 --> 00:58:13,747 Fair enough. Rich, an outrageous prediction from down under? 857 00:58:13,752 --> 00:58:19,641 I think, in 2025, I said that in 2025, in the prediction segment 858 00:58:19,641 --> 00:58:24,624 of this show, we'd have the low orbit commercial space station. 859 00:58:24,624 --> 00:58:26,889 I'm doing that for 2026. 860 00:58:27,612 --> 00:58:31,532 Fair enough. You're entitled to. . Alan,what's your outrageous 861 00:58:30,748 --> 00:58:31,532 prediction? 862 00:58:31,932 --> 00:58:35,820 I'm revisiting one from, not last year but the year before. So, 863 00:58:35,820 --> 00:58:40,356 I think next year will be the year of the bond breakout. So, US 864 00:58:40,356 --> 00:58:43,596 10-year yields up to 6% and then down to 3.50%. 865 00:58:44,822 --> 00:58:47,618 Very good, very good. Nick, what are your thoughts for next year? 866 00:58:48,262 --> 00:58:50,022 That finally we'll see rates trend. 867 00:58:50,662 --> 00:59:00,896 Okay, yeah, that would be nice, good. Cem,I think you may 868 00:58:52,627 --> 00:58:57,736 have won last year. So at least that was a pretty good call. 869 00:58:57,736 --> 00:59:00,880 So, what are your thoughts for next year? 870 00:59:01,302 --> 00:59:15,022 That 2026 will, in a lot of ways, look like 2022. The pain trade 871 00:59:15,022 --> 00:59:26,782 will be market down, vol down, and interest rates up. Nobody wants 872 00:59:26,782 --> 00:59:36,582 to sell stocks, take their winners. Everybody's putting a band 873 00:59:36,582 --> 00:59:42,482 aid in terms of long vol. Idothink long vol could be, again, 874 00:59:08,022 --> 00:59:17,262 implemented the right way to make money. I'm talking more like 875 00:59:17,262 --> 00:59:26,502 VIX and implied vol broadly. And then I think, again, interest 876 00:59:26,502 --> 00:59:37,422 rates going higher could be a pain point for some that are still 877 00:59:37,422 --> 00:59:42,462 in the bond space for diversification. 878 00:59:44,242 --> 00:59:47,182 I think we're all going to root for you to be the winner for 879 00:59:47,182 --> 00:59:47,602 next year. 880 00:59:47,602 --> 00:59:50,482 I think trend has a year anyways as part of that again. 881 00:59:52,482 --> 00:59:56,162 All right, Yoav, what's your prediction for 2026? 882 00:59:57,202 --> 01:00:02,805 Equity is up 25%. That will make me happy, but I'm afraid I'm 883 01:00:02,805 --> 01:00:07,977 kind of in the camp of a 6% 10-year rate most likely. 884 01:00:09,832 --> 01:00:13,032 Fair enough. AndMark, what is yours? 885 01:00:13,112 --> 01:00:37,248 So, last year, 2025 I thought was the year of the optimist. I think 886 01:00:37,248 --> 01:01:01,384 that a lot of people came in, they were very negative of what we 887 01:01:01,384 --> 01:01:15,176 would see for 2025. I was an optimist. 2026,I'm now going to 888 01:00:20,007 --> 01:00:35,176 be a pessimist. You’re going to see higher inflation which means 889 01:00:35,176 --> 01:00:50,345 higher yields on treasuries. We're going to see some credit crises. 890 01:00:50,345 --> 01:01:08,272 We've seen some start in 2025. We're going to see that it’s going 891 01:01:08,272 --> 01:01:15,167 to carry over to 2026. We'regoing to see stable to down 892 01:00:17,683 --> 01:00:25,519 equity markets. Not because the Russell 2000 is going to do poorly, 893 01:00:25,519 --> 01:00:35,314 but we're going to see some of a bubble burst for our Mag 7 which 894 01:00:35,314 --> 01:00:45,109 is such a high weight in the S&P 500. That's going to put a pale 895 01:00:45,109 --> 01:00:52,945 on all equities. The positive side is we'll see a resurgent Europe. 896 01:00:52,945 --> 01:01:01,434 So, we're starting to see it this year. I think that they're going 897 01:01:01,434 --> 01:01:10,576 to start to get their house in order. So, if I was an optimist, 898 01:01:10,576 --> 01:01:15,147 it would be an optimist in Europe. 899 01:01:16,222 --> 01:02:10,532 Fantastic. I think that was everyone, except for myself, and 900 01:02:10,532 --> 01:02:43,118 I'll keep mine very short, actually. Myprediction is that, 901 01:01:24,122 --> 01:01:45,847 despite all the pressures on the Fed, and despite Trump electing 902 01:01:45,847 --> 01:02:09,547 the next Fed chair very shortly, the Fed will end up having 903 01:02:09,547 --> 01:02:35,222 to hike rates next year at least once. So, that's going to be 904 01:02:35,222 --> 01:02:43,122 my prediction for 2026. Onthat note, let's wrap up part 905 01:01:23,208 --> 01:01:34,186 2 of our year end group conversation. We hope that you've 906 01:01:34,186 --> 01:01:49,156 enjoyed it as much as we did making it for you. And if you want 907 01:01:49,156 --> 01:02:01,132 to show your appreciation for all the work that the amazing co-hosts 908 01:02:01,132 --> 01:02:13,108 put into making these episodes each and every week, I would encourage 909 01:02:13,108 --> 01:02:24,086 you to head over to Apple podcast, or Spotify, or wherever 910 01:02:24,086 --> 01:02:37,060 you listen to your podcast and leave a nice rating and review. We 911 01:02:37,060 --> 01:02:43,048 really do appreciate all of them. Nextweek I'll be back with 912 01:01:25,876 --> 01:01:48,402 Rich to kick off the new year in style. So, this is your chance 913 01:01:48,402 --> 01:02:07,710 to have him tackle some of your questions. And also, feel free 914 01:02:07,710 --> 01:02:27,018 to suggest some topics you think would be relevant for us to 915 01:02:27,018 --> 01:02:43,108 discuss. And of course, you can email them to info@toptradersunplugged.com. 916 01:01:16,222 --> 01:01:45,188 Fromall of us at Top Traders Unplugged thank you so much for listening. 917 01:01:45,188 --> 01:02:12,085 We look forward to being back with you next week. And until next 918 01:02:12,085 --> 01:02:38,982 time, Happy New Year, and take care of yourself and take care of 919 01:02:38,982 --> 01:02:43,120 each other. 920 01:02:44,162 --> 01:02:54,602 Thanks for listening to the Systematic Investor Podcast series. 921 01:02:54,602 --> 01:03:10,842 If you enjoy this series, go on over to iTunes and leave an honest 922 01:03:10,842 --> 01:03:25,922 rating and review. And be sure to listen to all the other episodes 923 01:03:25,922 --> 01:03:30,562 from Top Traders Unplugged. Ifyou have questions about systematic 924 01:02:53,444 --> 01:03:12,008 investing, send us an email with the word question in the subject 925 01:03:12,008 --> 01:03:18,196 line to info@toptradersunplugged.com and 926 01:03:18,196 --> 01:03:30,572 we'll try to get it on the show. Andremember, all the discussion 927 01:02:46,857 --> 01:02:52,786 that we have about investment performance is about the past, and 928 01:02:52,786 --> 01:02:57,637 past performance does not guarantee or even infer anything 929 01:02:57,637 --> 01:03:02,488 about future performance. Also, understand that there's a significant 930 01:03:02,488 --> 01:03:07,878 risk of financial loss with all investment strategies, and you 931 01:03:07,878 --> 01:03:13,807 need to request and understand the specific risks from the investment 932 01:03:13,807 --> 01:03:18,658 manager about their products before you make investment decisions. 933 01:03:18,658 --> 01:03:25,126 Thanks for spending some of your valuable time with us and we'll 934 01:03:25,126 --> 01:03:30,516 see you on the next episode of the Systematic Investor.