If meditation and breathing exercises make you more anxious, you're not broken.
Speaker:Your nervous system is potentially telling you something important.
Speaker:In this episode, we're brakeing down why certain safety practices backfire for
Speaker:freeze dominance people in particular, and what actually works instead.
Speaker:Plus, um, what that postan anxiety spike really means about your recovery.
Speaker:Hi, I am Justin Sunseri, and this is Stuck Not Broken.
Speaker:I'm a therapist coach and a member of the Polyvagal Institute Editorial Board.
Speaker:That means I'm one of a few people who review articles and board games
Speaker:or apps for Polyvagal Theory accuracy when they are submitted for review.
Speaker:So I'm responding to an email I got from someone I will call, uh, Jeri
Speaker:with an i. Jeri with an I says,
Speaker:Hi Justin.
Speaker:I have your Stuck Not Broken: Book 2 book and am working through it.
Speaker:It's really clicking with me and I feel so grateful to have found your work.
Speaker:Where can I buy Stuck Not Broken: book 3 to work through once I've
Speaker:built enough safety through Book 2?
Speaker:I can't see it for sale anywhere.
Speaker:So book three is nearly done.
Speaker:Um, the release date should be by mid 2026, which is way overdue, but
Speaker:this one's been quite a challenge.
Speaker:Um, so Jeri goes on to say, I believe I am mainly stuck in
Speaker:freeze and other times flight.
Speaker:In doing some of the safety anchors, I often then experience a huge
Speaker:amount of anxiety for a while.
Speaker:It's improved when moving away from stationary safety practices like
Speaker:breathing or meditation and doing things like mindful walking and or movement.
Speaker:I will experience deep relaxation and then a while later, a huge physical anxiety.
Speaker:I believe this is a good sign, a sign of the body moving up the polyvagal ladder.
Speaker:I just wanted to check that I can expect this to reduce as time goes on.
Speaker:I'm in my second week of daily practice.
Speaker:I've also reduced the length of time I spend in safety anchoring.
Speaker:I was doing a lot, maybe 30, 45 minutes a day.
Speaker:Thank you for the email, Jeri and, um, not only for buying book two, not only
Speaker:for reading book two, but implementing the book two ideas and practices as well.
Speaker:If you're not familiar with my books, dear Listener, um, Book One teaches the
Speaker:polyvagal theory and helps you to write a new, simple shame-free life narrative.
Speaker:And Book Two helps you learn deeply about, uh, Polyvagal safety, how
Speaker:to access it, and how to build it.
Speaker:So there's a lot to get into with this question.
Speaker:We will start with, um, a potentially unhelpful assumption that you may have.
Speaker:And this is for everyone, not just, uh, Jeri, of course.
Speaker:First off, safety refers to biology.
Speaker:In the Polyvagal Theory, it refers to biology.
Speaker:There are specific biological pathways responsible for our
Speaker:capacity to think critically.
Speaker:To socially engage, to play, to create, and to even sit quietly in meditation.
Speaker:Safety does not necessarily look like calm, still meditative and quiet.
Speaker:It depends on what safety is mixing with- that, that biological pathway.
Speaker:So if you have safety plus mobility of flight, fight, this combination of
Speaker:safety results in play and productivity, creativity and motivation, when safety
Speaker:combines with the, uh, immobility of shutdown, that results in stillness.
Speaker:Freeze is a little different.
Speaker:Freeze, by the way, is the combination of flight, fight, mobility, the sympathetic
Speaker:mobility plus shutdown immobility.
Speaker:It's mobile and immobile at the same time, like having one foot
Speaker:on the gas and one on the brake.
Speaker:Um, this can be true for people who get triggered into a freeze, like a panic
Speaker:attack, but it can also be true for those who live in a chronic freeze where
Speaker:their underlying state is, is freeze.
Speaker:This person is a, is always in an underlying overwhelm or panic or rage.
Speaker:So when those who are more flight fight or freeze dominated, try to sit still
Speaker:and meditate, it doesn't go very well.
Speaker:Because immobilizing for these individuals is kind of not safe.
Speaker:Literally in the environment, sure it, it might be safe, but as far
Speaker:as the body is concerned in the polyvagal and nervous system world, no.
Speaker:There may not be safety internally.
Speaker:So anyways, immobilizing for someone in freeze is not felt as safe in the body.
Speaker:"Why would this be Justin?" Well, freeze is immobilization plus mobilization
Speaker:feet on the gas and the brake, remember?
Speaker:More immobilization like meditation and breath work can
Speaker:feel like being trapped again.
Speaker:The internal flight fight can't tolerate the immobility.
Speaker:And the immobility of freeze can't tolerate the internal
Speaker:unrest of flight, fight.
Speaker:Freeze types often need to mobilize to cue safety.
Speaker:In fact, I think they're drawn to it.
Speaker:I've worked with freeze clients who feel a pull toward hyper productivity,
Speaker:hyper exercising, hyper everything.
Speaker:So their body knows something that their conscious sprain doesn't.
Speaker:That movement is good, but it's out of control.
Speaker:Dysregulated.
Speaker:But as their safety state strengthens over time, the dysregulated
Speaker:mobility decreases in intensity.
Speaker:So needing movement is not a flaw.
Speaker:It's it's okay to need movement and to not feel okay with stillness practices.
Speaker:So if you've ever felt like meditation makes you more anxious, or breathing
Speaker:exercises make you feel more trapped, or you need to move to feel better, yeah.
Speaker:And that's okay.
Speaker:Your body's probably telling you something.
Speaker:So instead of immobility, you might need movement.
Speaker:What kind of movement?
Speaker:I can't answer that for you in particular.
Speaker:I don't think that's, um, the way that this works.
Speaker:Some practical examples of potential movements include walking, fidgeting,
Speaker:swaying, or even working out.
Speaker:But no matter what movement you decide to try out, do it mindfully.
Speaker:Actually pay attention to the sensory input around you on a walk.
Speaker:Actually pay attention to your muscles contracting and
Speaker:stretching when you work out.
Speaker:As you bring a bit more mindfulness, also be a bit more aware of your breath.
Speaker:And as you do these, not controlling your breath, but just being aware of it.
Speaker:And as you do these, you'll probably slow down a little, and connection
Speaker:with the present moment might increase.
Speaker:And if you can do that, you'll be better able to connect with what's
Speaker:happening internally and for autonomic shifts to spontaneously happen.
Speaker:So now let's talk about the anxiety spike.
Speaker:There are three potentials here I can think of.
Speaker:When you anchor into safety through the ideas and the skills in book two,
Speaker:there's a potential for defensive activation to surface during
Speaker:your practice or even later on.
Speaker:This is a very normal and expected outcome of practicing safety.
Speaker:And I discuss this briefly on page 18 in the book, if you, if you
Speaker:own the book, it's on page 18.
Speaker:One possibility is that the body attempts to self-regulate while
Speaker:you do your safety practice.
Speaker:And when it does, the feelings of that state will surface.
Speaker:For example, when someone in shutdown mindfully connects with
Speaker:their passive safety environment, they're likely to feel sadness.
Speaker:The sadness is already there, but now the individual is practicing present moment
Speaker:mindfulness, so they're more aware of it.
Speaker:But the body is also now accessing safety and naturally attempts to self-regulate,
Speaker:which is good, but it may be unexpected.
Speaker:The second possibility that I can think of is that these are sort
Speaker:of this, the anxiety is like an after effect of safety practices.
Speaker:During stage two, the focus is on building safety- uh, the book too, the
Speaker:focus is on building safety and capacity, but it's not all hunky dory, exactly.
Speaker:The body is undergoing autonomic shifts, so it needs to integrate and to adjust.
Speaker:That's the kind of the best way I can put it.
Speaker:Basically, we may notice emotional shifts later on.
Speaker:I recommend to my clients that they don't push it and do very minimum self-care
Speaker:stuff for like the rest of the day, like, get enough water, rest, connection
Speaker:with other people or maybe their pet.
Speaker:Uh, basically give the body a chance to recover.
Speaker:These are autonomic shifts that are, uh, that we're undergoing.
Speaker:And the third potential is that the immobilization piece of the freeze is
Speaker:releasing, opening the, the mobility's potential for mobilizing- for movement.
Speaker:But the system lacks a sufficient vagal brake, which is the influence
Speaker:of the safety state on the heart.
Speaker:You would increase vagal brake strength through exercising the safety pathways.
Speaker:When sufficiently strengthened, the safety state's vagal brake
Speaker:will calm, uh, the heart.
Speaker:And if the heart rate calms, then flight fight calms along with it.
Speaker:So, although safety is very possible, even for those living in chronic freeze,
Speaker:it's also likely that whatever's frozen might mobilize, uh, potentially even
Speaker:to the point of dysregulation if the safety state's not strong enough.
Speaker:Someone who's starting to regulate out of a frozen fight will experience
Speaker:increased agitation and potentially rage depending on vagal brake strength.
Speaker:Frozen flights might show up as anxiety, but also as panic.
Speaker:Again, depending on the vagal brake strength.
Speaker:If this is you or it has been you, there's a good chance you've given up
Speaker:and, and lost hope, um, or you were terrified of what you assumed you would
Speaker:find, uh, within or what would happen.
Speaker:And these are valid concerns.
Speaker:You may think, "This practice is making me worse," but the reality might be "My
Speaker:system's finally safe enough to start processing or to start self-regulating."
Speaker:You can reframe this as the beginning of untucking and yeah, it's not easy.
Speaker:I'm not saying that.
Speaker:Think of it, um, like you started a, a new workout routine.
Speaker:You might have moments when you feel incredible and motivated.
Speaker:So you put in the reps at the gym and you are, you get your heart
Speaker:rate up and you sweat buckets.
Speaker:You feel proud, accomplished.
Speaker:And that's great, good for you.
Speaker:But, um, it's not all feeling empowered and motivated, right?
Speaker:Over the next day or two, your body will recover, but you may
Speaker:feel incredibly sore and achy.
Speaker:It might even hurt to move.
Speaker:So it's not exactly the same, but there is some parallel to the
Speaker:unstucking work that we're doing here.
Speaker:With with that scenario, if you go too hard, your body will pay the price
Speaker:and the recovery will be a struggle no matter what stuck state that you're in.
Speaker:So I recommend working within your capacity.
Speaker:I recommend this for you if you are working through book two.
Speaker:Um, and for those in the Unstucking Academy and those who are
Speaker:doing the safety simplified or self-regulation simplified cohorts.
Speaker:Work within your capacity.
Speaker:This is something I've really been harping on recently.
Speaker:Work within your capacity.
Speaker:Working within your capacity means practicing the unstucking skills at a
Speaker:doable but challenging pace and depth.
Speaker:So person A might practice 30 seconds of simple mindfulness daily, and
Speaker:that's the best that they can do.
Speaker:Uh, person B might do a five minute guided meditation a few times a week as
Speaker:we do inside of the Untucking Academy.
Speaker:And person C might practice meditation, self-guided for 20 minutes a week
Speaker:and every other day they are doing simple sensory mindfulness practices.
Speaker:There's no right answer.
Speaker:You need to listen to your capacity.
Speaker:Once one gets to the edge of what they can tolerate of their capacity.
Speaker:Once you get to that edge, it's probably time to compassionately greet
Speaker:that edge and then stop the practice.
Speaker:You'll know the edge of your capacity because uninvited and uncomfortable
Speaker:emotions and thoughts will show up like fear or a painful memory.
Speaker:Those are clear signs that we're at the edge of our capacity.
Speaker:We don't want to avoid these things.
Speaker:That's not the point.
Speaker:Um, we want to invite them from a regulated state.
Speaker:When regulated, you'll actually invite un uncomfy emotions and memories
Speaker:and thoughts from compassion and curiosity, but you gotta be regulated.
Speaker:So yeah, the anxiety spike for someone coming out of a flight flavored
Speaker:freeze is pretty darn normal and to be expected, or at least a potential.
Speaker:Those will come and go, and over time the intensity, frequency
Speaker:and duration will decrease as as you strengthen your safety state.
Speaker:In the meantime, listen to your capacity.
Speaker:If the anxiety's not improving, you're likely doing too
Speaker:much and need to scale back.
Speaker:Shorten your practice and simplify them as much as possible.
Speaker:Uh, the email writer is a couple of weeks into their practices.
Speaker:Absolutely amazing.
Speaker:Keep going.
Speaker:The safety state can strengthen over weeks, but I would
Speaker:expect more like months.
Speaker:How many months?
Speaker:I can't say for certain.
Speaker:There are a ton of variables that come into play.
Speaker:I recently returned to focusing on my own safety practices, and I noticed
Speaker:that my, because I was tracking it through my co- AI coaching app- um,
Speaker:I noticed that my safety baseline had increased over the past few months.
Speaker:So I'll switch gears completely now and get to the overall picture.
Speaker:Yes, you want to get unstuck from freeze.
Speaker:You want more freedom, more calm, and more connection.
Speaker:Of course.
Speaker:Absolutely.
Speaker:And it's possible to get there.
Speaker:But I want you to keep in mind that when working with any stuck defensive
Speaker:state, including freeze, the goal of practice is to build capacity.
Speaker:There is no fix, no hack or short shortcut.
Speaker:I, I know you know that, but we need to keep that at the forefront of our mind.
Speaker:So when you practice, think of it like putting in the reps as if you're
Speaker:going to a gym to build strength.
Speaker:Or think of it like practicing drawing a face over and over to
Speaker:get better at drawing portraits.
Speaker:As you put in reps in the gym, you gradually get stronger over time.
Speaker:As you practice drawing faces, your skill increases and you
Speaker:can draw better portraits.
Speaker:It is not easy and it takes time.
Speaker:It takes patience, which somebody in freeze typically may have very little of.
Speaker:But as you practice safety, patience will probably grow along with it.
Speaker:Freeze can thaw quickly, so it's important to listen to the body's
Speaker:signals and adjust your practices.
Speaker:Ideally, freeze thaws slowly.
Speaker:As it thaws, we gently connect with the flight, fight underneath it, and then
Speaker:channel it through mindful movement.
Speaker:And then we repeat, slowly and gently releasing the frozen
Speaker:mobility a little bit at a time.
Speaker:I love this process because it puts you into the position
Speaker:of being your own expert.
Speaker:Yeah, you're listening to me right now and I appreciate that.
Speaker:But I want you to eventually build your own self-regulation.
Speaker:I want you to be able to recognize what's too much or too little, and to
Speaker:make small adjustments here and there.
Speaker:Just experiment and see what works best for you.
Speaker:Yeah, listen to me and, and others along the way.
Speaker:I'm honored.
Speaker:Seriously.
Speaker:Um, you could even join me in the next free, live, Mindful Moment and practice
Speaker:super simple mindfulness, uh, no matter where you are or what you're doing.
Speaker:I'm happy to be an aid as you connect with the present moment and with yourself.
Speaker:I will include a link to find out more about, uh, Mindful Moments and
Speaker:my other offerings in the description.
Speaker:It is stucknotbroken.com/start.
Speaker:stucknotbroken.com/start.
Speaker:So I will wrap things up, uh, with a handful of key points to
Speaker:remember, this is kind of a lot.
Speaker:If meditation makes you more anxious, that's not a flaw in you.
Speaker:That's your nervous system asking for something different.
Speaker:Listen to it, trust it, and keep going.
Speaker:Meditation is maybe most challenging for somebody and freeze, so come back to it
Speaker:maybe another day when you're ready to.
Speaker:Safety looks different for different nervous systems.
Speaker:The right practice is the one your body tells you works.
Speaker:You gotta listen.
Speaker:Post anchor anxiety, movement based anchoring, shorter
Speaker:sessions, self-correction.
Speaker:All of this is progress.
Speaker:If you're in freeze or flight, experiment with, uh, movement based
Speaker:anchoring, safety cueing, I mean.
Speaker:Notice what happens and, and trust that.
Speaker:I appreciate you so much for spending some time with me here on Stuck Not Broken.
Speaker:Bye.
Speaker:This, another content I create is not therapy, not intended to be therapy
Speaker:or be a replacement for therapy.
Speaker:Nothing in this creates or indicates a therapeutic relationship.
Speaker:Please consult with your therapist or speak for one in your area if you're
Speaker:experiencing mental health symptoms.
Speaker:Nothing should be construed to be specific life advice.
Speaker:It is for educational and entertainment purposes only.