I'm Paul Comfort, and this is the eighth anniversary
Paul Comfort:of our Transit Unplugged podcast.
Paul Comfort:Welcome to the world's leading podcast that is focused on top
Paul Comfort:public transportation executives.
Paul Comfort:Great to have you with us.
Paul Comfort:You know, it all started for me.
Paul Comfort:Over 30 years ago, when I first began my career, I'd always been
Paul Comfort:interested in communications.
Paul Comfort:As a matter of fact, when I was in college, I worked at the
Paul Comfort:campus radio station and was the news director, and a DJ.
Paul Comfort:During that time, I also had a part time job at a local radio
Paul Comfort:station near where I lived.
Paul Comfort:And I ended up working there for 16 years.
Paul Comfort:I was a weekend DJ, sometimes at nights as well.
Paul Comfort:We played, uh, middle of the road music, and then I started a show called Comfort's
Paul Comfort:Corner, which was like a local talk show.
Paul Comfort:Sometimes it was done online where I would record an interview, but most of
Paul Comfort:the time it was recorded at a local gas and appliance store in the downtown,
Paul Comfort:County seat of the county where I lived, right in the front window, where I would
Paul Comfort:invite people, whether they were a county commissioner or the adjutant general of
Paul Comfort:the Maryland National Guard, and all kinds of officials, gubernatorial candidates
Paul Comfort:and congressmen, and, it was fun.
Paul Comfort:I loved it.
Paul Comfort:I did that.
Paul Comfort:I also worked early on in communications.
Paul Comfort:for local newspapers where I was a columnist and also,
Paul Comfort:wrote articles for them.
Paul Comfort:Basically, I'd always try to integrate my love of communications
Paul Comfort:into what I was doing day to day.
Paul Comfort:So I was doing this part time while I was working as the transportation coordinator
Paul Comfort:for Queen Anne's County and then on to my next jobs in the private sector.
Paul Comfort:So much so that when I became a county administrator for two counties in
Paul Comfort:Maryland, in both counties, I used the Cable Access Fund to Open up cable access
Paul Comfort:channels, government channels, where you could watch public access shows.
Paul Comfort:When I was at the MTA as CEO, we opened up America's first and only FM radio
Paul Comfort:station operated by a transit system.
Paul Comfort:It was, and is, WTTZ FM 93.
Paul Comfort:5 with smooth jazz all day long.
Paul Comfort:And then five times an hour transit and traffic updates.
Paul Comfort:There was a guy named Mark on our staff that had a much better late
Paul Comfort:night FM DJ voice than I did.
Paul Comfort:he was brilliant, man.
Paul Comfort:And then when I got here to Trapeze and now Vontas and they asked me that I want
Paul Comfort:to start a podcast, I was like, sure.
Paul Comfort:And they said, what do you want it to be?
Paul Comfort:I said, I know exactly what I want it to be.
Paul Comfort:I just left being CEO of the MTA in Baltimore, the 11th largest
Paul Comfort:transit system in America.
Paul Comfort:And I wanted to interview CEOs.
Paul Comfort:I wanted to give them a chance in their own voice to talk about
Paul Comfort:what they wanted to talk about.
Paul Comfort:You see, cause I knew from experience that most of the time when CEOs
Paul Comfort:get an opportunity to speak publicly or in the media, they're
Paul Comfort:going to It's very prescribed.
Paul Comfort:They can only say certain things because usually they're responding to
Paul Comfort:a crisis, whether it's a bus crash or a derailment or some other type of incident.
Paul Comfort:And they've got their, you know, PR person right there with them and
Paul Comfort:they have to stay right on script.
Paul Comfort:I wanted to give them a chance to talk about the things they were excited about,
Paul Comfort:open up about, you know, their lives and careers so that other people could learn.
Paul Comfort:possible career paths or talk about the current challenges.
Paul Comfort:Maybe, you know, whether it's zero mission buses or autonomous vehicles
Paul Comfort:or cybersecurity, whatever the current challenges they were doing, their big
Paul Comfort:projects, give them a chance just to talk.
Paul Comfort:And so that's what we did.
Paul Comfort:And here we are now, eight years later, well into our run now with,
Paul Comfort:You know, lots of, lots of programs under our belt currently, as we have
Paul Comfort:been for the last eight years, pretty much put out a show every week.
Paul Comfort:It's now on Wednesdays it comes out.
Paul Comfort:We've had, over 320 published episodes with hundreds and
Paul Comfort:hundreds of thousands of downloads.
Paul Comfort:We're heard in a hundred countries with, the majority of our audience
Paul Comfort:in North America, but strong listenership in Canada, the
Paul Comfort:United Kingdom, and in Australia.
Paul Comfort:where I'm headed shortly, to, for a two week trip to visit with our
Paul Comfort:Australian partners over there and record podcasts and shows there.
Paul Comfort:Our podcast has been recognized as a top 60 government podcast and
Paul Comfort:was winner of the American Public Transportation Association's AdWheel
Paul Comfort:Award for best educational effort.
Paul Comfort:APTA's AdWheel.
Paul Comfort:We were very proud of that a few years ago.
Paul Comfort:And we've aired compelling interviews with, you know, nearly 400 transit
Paul Comfort:industry executives, and we continue to do it, and of course the show has expanded.
Paul Comfort:It first started by doing live events, live CEO roundtables at my own company's
Paul Comfort:conferences, and then at the booths of our companies and other companies, At
Paul Comfort:trade shows like the one we just did in APTA that you're going to hear today.
Paul Comfort:we've also moved into television.
Paul Comfort:after the pandemic, I felt like, you know, we wanted to travel.
Paul Comfort:People wanted to see what was going on in the world.
Paul Comfort:So we started our own travel show, food, fun, and culture at cities
Paul Comfort:around the world, from Barcelona to Sacramento and, every city in between,
Paul Comfort:we show you the food, fun, and culture, and we show you behind the scenes of
Paul Comfort:their public transportation system, like you won't see anywhere else.
Paul Comfort:And.
Paul Comfort:We show you how to use that transit system to get around the city, to get to all
Paul Comfort:those fun places I just told you about.
Paul Comfort:And that show is going gangbusters, man.
Paul Comfort:We've won several awards this year.
Paul Comfort:We're now at over 2 million views on YouTube with our shows.
Paul Comfort:I mean, people are watching them.
Paul Comfort:They love this stuff.
Paul Comfort:They love seeing the fun side of public transportation.
Paul Comfort:We love bringing it to them.
Paul Comfort:And for those of you who really want to dig in more, we've also opened up a new
Paul Comfort:show, just a couple months ago, called, Transit Unplugged Behind the Scenes,
Paul Comfort:Transit Unplugged TV Behind the Scenes, where you get the full interviews, you get
Paul Comfort:to see them, which airs the week after.
Paul Comfort:The main show drops on the second Thursday of each month.
Paul Comfort:We've also started a News Minute, which is very popular now.
Paul Comfort:It's, every Monday, you can get dropped in your email box or in your LinkedIn.
Paul Comfort:A great News Minute by one of America's former top FM DJs herself,
Paul Comfort:Julie Gates, who's on our team.
Paul Comfort:And she brings you kind of the fun side of transit and big news that it's happening.
Paul Comfort:That show has been picked up now by the Transportation
Paul Comfort:Channel, as has our TV show.
Paul Comfort:And also, even by places like MSN, we're becoming recognized as a
Paul Comfort:authority, a source for news information regarding the transit industry.
Paul Comfort:Our editor, Tris Hussey, also puts out a weekly newsletter, which you should get.
Paul Comfort:If you don't get it, I encourage you to subscribe to it.
Paul Comfort:It's free and it tells you everything going on in Transit Unplugged world.
Paul Comfort:And of course, I've been writing books now for seven years, a book
Paul Comfort:a year, and I'm working on the next one, with my book agent, for
Paul Comfort:coming out next year on leadership.
Paul Comfort:Yep.
Paul Comfort:Even beyond the transit industry, but these books also include many of
Paul Comfort:the guests we've had on these shows.
Paul Comfort:That's what Transit Unplugged has become.
Paul Comfort:It's become a whole franchise and there's lots more new things to come.
Paul Comfort:as you may be aware, we are, we're doing, a whole new look for the show, rebranding
Paul Comfort:for the show and for eight season because eight is the number of new beginnings.
Paul Comfort:On to this week's episode, it is our Live CEO Roundtable recorded and
Paul Comfort:brought to you today here on Transit Unplugged, it's our 8th anniversary show.
Paul Comfort:It includes Andy Lord, who is the CEO of the world's
Paul Comfort:largest transportation network.
Paul Comfort:He is the Commissioner for Transport for London.
Paul Comfort:Dottie Watkins, who is the CEO of CapMetro in Austin, who has the nation's
Paul Comfort:largest capital program going on with a 7 billion program approved by the voters.
Paul Comfort:Dwight Farrell, who heads up.
Paul Comfort:Detroit's transit system, the Suburban Mobility Authority for regional
Paul Comfort:transportation in the suburbs there, Sean Donahue, my friend from North
Paul Comfort:County Transit District in San Diego, and Adam Leishman, a newer friend who's
Paul Comfort:from Hong Kong, who talks about what it's like to run transit in probably
Paul Comfort:the world's most transit friendly city, where over 90 percent of the people ride.
Paul Comfort:Today, you'll also learn about the success of London's Elizabeth Line,
Paul Comfort:their upcoming Piccadilly Line with Andy Lord You'll get Information on
Paul Comfort:Austin's Project Connect and their unique microtransit services, Detroit Smarter
Paul Comfort:Mobility Initiative, and the role of leadership, mentorship, and authentic
Paul Comfort:decision making from all of our guests, from AI technology to the transformative
Paul Comfort:impact of public transport on our cities.
Paul Comfort:This podcast is a perfect summary of what we bring you
Paul Comfort:every week on Transit Unplugged.
Paul Comfort:If you don't follow us, Subscribe.
Paul Comfort:I encourage you to do so.
Paul Comfort:You will be, hopefully, like my friend Schneider St.
Paul Comfort:Preux who was one of the top 40 under 40 public transit leaders in America
Paul Comfort:this year, who was just on the show a couple episodes ago, who told me
Paul Comfort:a year ago, and also repeated it on our podcast, Paul, I've listened to
Paul Comfort:every one of your podcast episodes.
Paul Comfort:Wow, huh?
Paul Comfort:What a compliment.
Paul Comfort:And he said, This show I credit largely with the advancement of my career.
Paul Comfort:I went from a bus driver up the ranks to now general superintendent of the
Paul Comfort:entire bus service for Miami Dade Transit and he said he credits what he learned
Paul Comfort:from the guests on the show largely for his advancement in his career.
Paul Comfort:This show is powerful.
Paul Comfort:This show today is likewise.
Paul Comfort:Enjoy.
Paul Comfort:Welcome everyone to the Transit Unplugged Live CEO Roundtable here at
Paul Comfort:the Vontas booth at APTA Transform.
Paul Comfort:Great to have you here.
Paul Comfort:Come on over.
Paul Comfort:We're going to spend a few minutes talking to some of the world's
Paul Comfort:leading public transit CEOs.
Paul Comfort:here at the Vontas booth.
Paul Comfort:Thank you for sponsoring us, Vontas.
Paul Comfort:Let's kick it off with Andy Lord, the Commissioner of Transport for London.
Paul Comfort:Andy, thank you for coming.
Paul Comfort:You made it all the way across the pond.
Paul Comfort:Andy has got so much going on.
Paul Comfort:If you haven't listened to his podcast episode, Transit Unplugged, we kind of
Paul Comfort:break it all down over half an hour.
Paul Comfort:But tell us about one or two of the big things you've got going on there at TFL.
Andy Lord:Yeah, thanks, Paul.
Andy Lord:So, obviously we're now, three years after the Elizabeth Line, opened.
Andy Lord:fastest growing railway in Europe.
Andy Lord:Huge success.
Andy Lord:So now we're working on, upgrading some of the other tube lines, so the
Andy Lord:big project we're doing on the tube is the upgrade of the Piccadilly line,
Andy Lord:which is the primary east west, link from Heathrow through the centre of
Andy Lord:the city and out to, the north east.
Andy Lord:new fleet of rolling stock, built by Siemens, first train arriving
Andy Lord:in London imminently for testing.
Andy Lord:It's a three, just under a three billion pound programme of work that'll increase
Andy Lord:capacity on the line by about 12 to 15%.
Andy Lord:new walk through, first ever air conditioned trains on the
Andy Lord:Deep Tube, in London, going to service towards the end of, 2025.
Andy Lord:So that's the, the major project on the Tube.
Andy Lord:we also have the Docklands Light Railway, our driverless, light rail
Andy Lord:system in the east of the city.
Andy Lord:we have the new rolling stock for that, also under test, built by CAF in Spain.
Andy Lord:Again, transformative from the customer.
Andy Lord:experience perspective, but also from a capacity perspective.
Andy Lord:So, two really major programs on the rail side that we're focusing on.
Andy Lord:and then the other big thing that's occupying my mind, is how we
Andy Lord:convince our new government in the UK, to give us some more money, so
Andy Lord:that we can continue to invest and maintain the services that we do.
Andy Lord:So, get a long term, sustainable capital funding deal for London.
Paul Comfort:Tell us real quickly about the model there, of how you're structured.
Paul Comfort:You're actually a department of the city government.
Paul Comfort:You report to the mayor of London?
Andy Lord:That's correct.
Andy Lord:We're a public sector organisation, wholly owned subsidiary of
Andy Lord:the Greater London Assembly.
Andy Lord:we have a independent board appointed by the Mayor.
Andy Lord:I'm accountable to the board and the Mayor who's chair of the board.
Andy Lord:the Mayor has complete control over TFL, in terms of decision making.
Andy Lord:and he actually, by legislation has the ability to set the fares himself.
Andy Lord:so, so I run a nine and a half billion pound cost based, I do what I can to
Andy Lord:influence his decision making on the fares, but ultimately the mayor is the
Andy Lord:one who sets the fares, so we're very proud of having an affordable system.
Andy Lord:we have the lowest bus fares in the UK, and, we generate the operating surplus
Andy Lord:so we invest in it going forward.
Andy Lord:All our meetings are fully scrutinized, held in public.
Andy Lord:and, I have the pleasure of attending various public committee
Andy Lord:meetings to, explain what we're doing and why we're doing it.
Paul Comfort:I'm sure all the time.
Paul Comfort:When we come, we're going to go down the line, but, when we come back, I'm going to
Paul Comfort:ask, Andy Lord, how in the world do they get everybody to ride transit in London?
Paul Comfort:Because everybody rides, and we need that here in America.
Paul Comfort:You know, less than, on average, across America, only 5 percent of the people
Paul Comfort:ride public transit on a regular basis.
Paul Comfort:What's your number there?
Paul Comfort:Do you know?
Andy Lord:Well, we're 90 percent ridership compared to pre pandemic levels.
Andy Lord:11 million passengers a day.
Andy Lord:London has a 9 million population.
Andy Lord:Not everybody is coming into the office every day.
Andy Lord:So I want more people to ride.
Andy Lord:But the biggest thing we did is we refused to cut services during the pandemic.
Andy Lord:Which enabled us to have high frequency turn up and go services.
Andy Lord:And what we have is a tube system that is designed to connect people
Andy Lord:from the mainline stations and bring them to the place of work.
Andy Lord:We have a bus system that is designed to operate in the outer reaches of the city.
Andy Lord:it's the most affordable element, particularly for, people of low
Andy Lord:income, and it's the primary means of traveling, and, and we have an ambitious
Andy Lord:target of 80 percent of everybody in London, either walking, cycling,
Andy Lord:or using public transport by 2041.
Paul Comfort:80%.
Paul Comfort:Wow.
Paul Comfort:That's amazing.
Paul Comfort:All right, Dottie.
Paul Comfort:So, Dottie started her career as a bus operator.
Paul Comfort:As a matter of fact, when I was down there with her, we were riding a bus, and we
Paul Comfort:went out to Barton Springs, and when we got off the bus, she said, oh by the way,
Paul Comfort:I started driving with him when I started.
Paul Comfort:Quite a story, Dottie.
Paul Comfort:All
Dottie Watkins:right, good afternoon.
Dottie Watkins:I'm Dottie Watkins, President and CEO at CapMetro in Austin, Texas, and as
Dottie Watkins:Paul mentioned, we've got a lot of fun things going on down in Austin.
Dottie Watkins:Most exciting is Project Connect, which is our vision for transit expansion
Dottie Watkins:over the next decade or so, but next spring we'll be launching two new BRT
Dottie Watkins:lines as a first step in that expansion.
Dottie Watkins:We've been very blessed to get Small Starts grants for two new
Dottie Watkins:lines to go through the eastern portion of our service area.
Dottie Watkins:Um, and we're really excited to start that.
Dottie Watkins:Along with that, we're starting a new microtransit zone.
Dottie Watkins:Our microtransit service that we call PICKUP, um, has been very powerful, um,
Dottie Watkins:tool in helping us serve neighborhoods and communities that are otherwise really kind
Dottie Watkins:of hard to get transit connections to.
Dottie Watkins:So we're really excited about that.
Paul Comfort:Let me ask you a follow up to that.
Paul Comfort:So in Austin, when Randy was there, you all passed the 7 billion referendum.
Paul Comfort:Has politics changed?
Paul Comfort:Are things changing?
Paul Comfort:Are you still on course?
Paul Comfort:What's happening?
Dottie Watkins:We're still on course.
Dottie Watkins:I wouldn't say politics have changed.
Dottie Watkins:We are still in the state of Texas, which is one of Austin's unique, challenges
Dottie Watkins:and opportunities because, our, we tend to be a much more progressive city
Dottie Watkins:than the rest of the state around us, although all of the cities in Texas
Dottie Watkins:are getting more and more progressive.
Dottie Watkins:Texas is an enormous place.
Dottie Watkins:we are on course.
Dottie Watkins:We're actually looking in the next couple of months with our partners to
Dottie Watkins:be looking at a draft environmental impact statement for our light rail
Dottie Watkins:line, which is the biggest chunk of money in that 7 billion investment.
Dottie Watkins:but things are moving forward.
Dottie Watkins:We're really excited about how that's going.
Dottie Watkins:We still have tons of local support, which is great.
Dottie Watkins:I think the pandemic was the We made the difficult decision to go
Dottie Watkins:for the vote during the pandemic.
Dottie Watkins:We had actually been preparing for a November 2020 election long before we
Dottie Watkins:thought we knew that we were going to have a global pandemic, but we knew that the
Dottie Watkins:problems of our community weren't going to go away just because we were all sitting
Dottie Watkins:at home for some unknown amount of time.
Dottie Watkins:And so we went ahead and went for it, and that was great.
Dottie Watkins:it would have been great if we'd managed to not have inflation
Dottie Watkins:coming out of it and all the other problems that all of us are facing,
Dottie Watkins:post pandemic, but, we're on track.
Dottie Watkins:No pun intended.
Dottie Watkins:That's awesome.
Paul Comfort:On track, yeah.
Paul Comfort:I was just in Austin last week.
Paul Comfort:I'm one of your tracks.
Paul Comfort:You guys still have a great service there.
Paul Comfort:It's just, and it's growing.
Paul Comfort:It's just gonna be phenomenal.
Paul Comfort:It's really one of the most exciting agencies in the country
Paul Comfort:for what's happening there.
Paul Comfort:So, Dwight, tell us about when some big projects going on there in Detroit
Paul Comfort:and how you're recovering the city.
Dwight Ferrell:The biggest project that we have that's
Dwight Ferrell:going on is Smarter Mobility.
Dwight Ferrell:travel patterns were already changing, even before the pandemic.
Dwight Ferrell:The pandemic just took it to a whole different level.
Dwight Ferrell:one of the things that we're addressing in Metro Detroit
Dwight Ferrell:is, is a lot of you know it's a manufacturing city, or at least it was.
Dwight Ferrell:And so now trying to make that adjustment to serve manufacturing shifts to now more
Dwight Ferrell:service jobs coming into the organization like Amazon and other places like that.
Dwight Ferrell:Then we have to be able to provide more frequent service.
Dwight Ferrell:The other thing is that we are also taking into consideration the silver tsunami
Dwight Ferrell:that's coming as it relates to more and more baby boomers who are retiring.
Dwight Ferrell:And you've ever had the misfortune to ever have to take your parents
Dwight Ferrell:keys like I have, It's awful because that loss of independence.
Dwight Ferrell:And so we're looking at smarter mobility as a way to be able to provide that kind
Dwight Ferrell:of service across the region that allows people to maintain their independence.
Dwight Ferrell:And quite frankly, we have a number of people who are in
Dwight Ferrell:the millennial and Generation Z generation who don't want a car.
Dwight Ferrell:And so being able to provide that service to give them those options.
Dwight Ferrell:we've done some research in that space, and it's not that people couldn't
Dwight Ferrell:afford a car, they'd just rather do something else with the money for a car.
Dwight Ferrell:So there's a lady that works, works at, in, in, at SMART with us.
Dwight Ferrell:She and her husband could afford two cars, but she says she doesn't want
Dwight Ferrell:to give up her golf club membership.
Dwight Ferrell:Okay.
Dwight Ferrell:All right.
Dwight Ferrell:Well, I can see that.
Dwight Ferrell:And so that's what we are looking at in terms of the smarter
Dwight Ferrell:mobility, how we can do it cheaper.
Dwight Ferrell:How we can have the service actually fit the need, as opposed to, well, why do
Dwight Ferrell:you have all these empty buses out here?
Dwight Ferrell:And the other thing we're looking at, too, is moving away
Dwight Ferrell:from what I call the Southwest Airlines model to the Delta model.
Dwight Ferrell:And by that I mean Southwest Airlines has one plane, 737.
Dwight Ferrell:They may be different lengths, but there's just one plane.
Dwight Ferrell:Delta has planes of different sizes, so they can go to different places.
Dwight Ferrell:And so that's the other part about our, we're going to be diversifying our
Dwight Ferrell:fleet as well as, you know, making the transition to low emission, zero emission,
Dwight Ferrell:but also making sure that we have a fleet that better reflects the ridership.
Dwight Ferrell:So that's gonna, that's something else that we're doing.
Dwight Ferrell:And so that's it for right now.
Dwight Ferrell:It's more than enough to say grace over.
Paul Comfort:There you go.
Paul Comfort:You probably can tell Dwight, has a lot of experience.
Paul Comfort:He and I have worked together in this business for over 35 years.
Paul Comfort:Transcribed Together in various places and, uh, uh, Detroit is well
Paul Comfort:served by having someone, a seasoned leader like, like him at the helm.
Paul Comfort:All right, Sean, what do you got going on there?
Paul Comfort:What's the biggest thing happening?
Shawn Donaghy:Yeah, first of all, I want to say how amazing it is to have
Shawn Donaghy:multi generational, leadership here.
Shawn Donaghy:I'm also third generation public transit.
Shawn Donaghy:I'm contractually obligated to give a shout out to my grandfather, who's
Shawn Donaghy:in the APTA Hall of Fame, and my dad, who just retired as a transit
Shawn Donaghy:CEO about three years ago, in Ohio.
Shawn Donaghy:So, love being up here with, you know, the multi generational aspect of transit.
Shawn Donaghy:I think it speaks volumes of the industry.
Shawn Donaghy:You know, we got a lot of unique things going on, and I'm, I'm
Shawn Donaghy:gonna, I'm gonna state the obvious.
Shawn Donaghy:We've got a lot of capital projects happening in our world.
Shawn Donaghy:But something that we're also dealing with is workforce development.
Shawn Donaghy:One of the things that's really an impact, especially in Southern
Shawn Donaghy:California, is the cost of living.
Shawn Donaghy:And so when we have conversations with our frontline employees, or even up
Shawn Donaghy:to the director, manager, director level, we, we really have to be
Shawn Donaghy:thoughtful about where people live.
Shawn Donaghy:We have a great deal of our workforce that's an hour from our facilities, an
Shawn Donaghy:hour and a half from our facilities.
Shawn Donaghy:and that's just for them to be able to have that livability factor, so how are
Shawn Donaghy:we as an agency really trying to transform our employee experience, what we want
Shawn Donaghy:that to look like, making sure that our operators have the right shifts so they
Shawn Donaghy:can take care of their families, not working six, six and a half days a week.
Shawn Donaghy:and then on the Capital Project side, I mean, we're, we're a huge county.
Shawn Donaghy:Like, San Diego County, just in terms of square miles, is big enough to be
Shawn Donaghy:like the 48th largest state in the U.
Shawn Donaghy:S.
Shawn Donaghy:And that's a big deal, because MTS does an absolutely phenomenal job
Shawn Donaghy:of, of, the city of San Diego itself, and really a lot of East County.
Shawn Donaghy:I know, I thought I saw Brian Riley over here, he's our Chief Operating Officer.
Shawn Donaghy:amazing.
Shawn Donaghy:but we sort of handle the rest, all of North County, you know, 73, 76, 78, I 5
Shawn Donaghy:Corridor, we've, you know, our commuter rail service took a little bit of a hit
Shawn Donaghy:during the pandemic because we didn't see that commuter service, down into
Shawn Donaghy:San Diego, but we saw, what we saw was a, almost a doubling of ridership on
Shawn Donaghy:the week, and so we really moved a lot of our service area, our service around
Shawn Donaghy:to sort of manage, midday, later in the evening, weekend service, we sort of,
Shawn Donaghy:much to what everybody else said, we sort of layered on top of that, really our
Shawn Donaghy:NCTD Plus service, which is our, sort of microtransit, and it sort of overlays over
Shawn Donaghy:our fixed route, and some of the other spaces, and I think the idea behind that
Shawn Donaghy:for us was, are there opportunities, like Dwight said, to change the condition of
Shawn Donaghy:the type of bus that's in that, In that scenario, and that's a big deal for us.
Shawn Donaghy:We're providing the same level of service, possibly even a little better.
Shawn Donaghy:our planning team is absolutely phenomenal.
Shawn Donaghy:They do a great job of, really sort of imagining what North County
Shawn Donaghy:could be and what it looks like.
Shawn Donaghy:So just, real happy with their work and we got a lot of great stuff going on.
Paul Comfort:That's great.
Paul Comfort:Adam, tell us in Hong Kong, one of the interesting things you may
Paul Comfort:not be aware of, but in Hong Kong, there's no real public subsidy.
Paul Comfort:For the bus or the rail, they make their own money.
Paul Comfort:How do you do that, man?
Adam Leishman:You have a lot of people catching buses.
Paul Comfort:A dollar ahead, come on!
Adam Leishman:I mean, we don't have, we didn't have a
Adam Leishman:subsidy for buses in Hong Kong.
Adam Leishman:Traditionally, we never have.
Adam Leishman:and, and 90 percent of the public use public transport for their trips.
Adam Leishman:So 90 percent
Paul Comfort:of trips.
Adam Leishman:90%!
Adam Leishman:Which is, I think it ranks number one in the world.
Adam Leishman:It's quite amazing, but I think that's only possible when you
Adam Leishman:have a holistic view on how to build and develop your city.
Adam Leishman:And, as an Australian, I think a lot of the cities that, we have very similar to
Adam Leishman:the US, where we have a thing called urban sprawl, and it makes it very difficult
Adam Leishman:to run commercial, transport operations.
Adam Leishman:Then I had the privilege of living in London for a few years, and it reset my
Adam Leishman:thinking, and I decided not to have a car.
Adam Leishman:I'm one of those people, actually, do I?
Adam Leishman:I, I enjoy living in a city where I don't need to have a car, and I've
Adam Leishman:done that in London and Hong Kong.
Adam Leishman:I haven't had a car for, for eight years.
Adam Leishman:But I think we need to rethink how we do cities.
Adam Leishman:I think urban sprawl is our enemy.
Adam Leishman:Cars and roads are our enemy, in a sense, if you want to use colourful language.
Adam Leishman:And we need to get urban planning departments working
Adam Leishman:alongside transport departments.
Adam Leishman:And the transport infrastructure needs to be the backbone of the community.
Adam Leishman:And then we need to build density around those stations, and that's the only way
Adam Leishman:you can make public transport commercial.
Adam Leishman:And I look at a model like in King's Cross, if anyone's been there in
Adam Leishman:London, and, and Dwight, you were talking about, reinvigorating a city.
Adam Leishman:make public transport the backbone of that.
Adam Leishman:And, and you look at King's Cross in London, it was like the worst
Adam Leishman:area you could go in London.
Adam Leishman:If you wanted to buy drugs, you went to King's Cross.
Adam Leishman:They put major stations in that go to France, Go all across the UK, and the
Adam Leishman:bus stops there, you can get anywhere in London, and now it's like the
Adam Leishman:hottest place to live in, in, in London.
Adam Leishman:It's a fantastic case study, and I think we need to be thinking more than
Adam Leishman:just you know, buses or trains, we need to think about how we make them the
Adam Leishman:backbone of the community and change the perception of what public transport is.
Adam Leishman:What we bring to a city is very unique.
Adam Leishman:If you list me all the problems cities face in the world, where 55
Adam Leishman:percent of the world's population live, public transport helps with
Adam Leishman:just about every single one of those.
Adam Leishman:That's right.
Adam Leishman:So I think we need to get better at being advocates for taking money out
Adam Leishman:let's say roads and putting it into public transport, transitioning people
Adam Leishman:into public transport because actually people will choose to live that way
Adam Leishman:if we give them the right opportunity.
Paul Comfort:Way to go.
Paul Comfort:That's great Adam.
Paul Comfort:Alright Andy, what do you want to talk about next?
Paul Comfort:Tell us something cool going on in London, man.
Andy Lord:I'll pick up on Adam's point.
Andy Lord:there's been a big debate in the UK.
Andy Lord:You'll be aware of, some of you will be aware of a program called HS2,
Andy Lord:which is the next high speed rail link, and the previous government
Andy Lord:decided to chop off the northern section, and also say it wasn't going
Andy Lord:to come into Euston in, in London.
Andy Lord:And the, the problem is that everybody focused on the journey time benefit of
Andy Lord:building this super fast railway and how it was going to reduce the journey
Andy Lord:time between London and Birmingham.
Andy Lord:Birmingham is the second largest city in the UK, you know, hugely
Andy Lord:important, but it was all about how it was going to improve the journey
Andy Lord:time for people from Birmingham to London, not the other way around.
Andy Lord:And it wasn't talking about, most importantly, about the economic growth
Andy Lord:and the wider benefits of how it would free up capacity on the existing rail
Andy Lord:line, benefit towns and cities and areas there, whilst also creating
Andy Lord:economic growth and regeneration.
Andy Lord:So we have spent a huge amount of time in TfL over the last year, 18 months.
Andy Lord:Talking to the government, talking to the supply chain, talking to
Andy Lord:business stakeholders, exactly Adam's point around transport infrastructure
Andy Lord:is the driver of economic growth.
Andy Lord:It's the driver of jobs, it's the driver of skills and development, and
Andy Lord:it's a driver for how you certainly, grow the country, economy more widely.
Andy Lord:And we've been really successful at that.
Andy Lord:So, for example, we had no idea before the pandemic how many
Andy Lord:jobs were directly, accountable, attributable to TfL outside of London?
Andy Lord:So we did, independent review.
Andy Lord:We are directly responsible for over a hundred thousand jobs outside
Andy Lord:London and the southeast of England.
Andy Lord:So that's jobs in the north of England, in the north and east,
Andy Lord:the midlands, the southwest.
Andy Lord:That drives economic benefit to those areas.
Andy Lord:The second thing that we focused on is we are the second
Andy Lord:largest landowner in London.
Andy Lord:don't After the Crown Estate, which is the Royal Family.
Andy Lord:so how do we maximize that?
Andy Lord:We have a lot of very old infrastructure, a lot of operational infrastructure
Andy Lord:that we'd like to upgrade and replace, a lot of very old train sheds, that we
Andy Lord:can rationalize and then we can reduce the land footprint and then build on it.
Andy Lord:So we now have our own property company called Places for London.
Andy Lord:We will be building by the end of this, decade, 20, 000 new homes on our land.
Andy Lord:half of which will be affordable.
Paul Comfort:All right, one more round of questions down the line here.
Paul Comfort:Many of you may not know, but Andy got his start in aviation
Paul Comfort:and was at British Airways for 20 years before he came into transit.
Paul Comfort:Talk to us about that transition, Andy, and what did you bring from your aviation
Paul Comfort:experience into public transport?
Andy Lord:Well, you better ask my team that, I guess.
Andy Lord:Look, there's many similarities.
Andy Lord:Safety is hugely safety critical.
Andy Lord:Safety is first priority for all of us.
Andy Lord:huge people leadership, massive, complexity from an engineering
Andy Lord:and technical perspective, and of course, customer service.
Andy Lord:they're, they're the key elements.
Andy Lord:from a BA perspective, I was running their global operation.
Andy Lord:TfL is now a London operation.
Andy Lord:So, the geography is different, but the decision making is similar.
Andy Lord:The time frames are different.
Andy Lord:but I think the two big things I would say that, that one I've brought in and
Andy Lord:one that we need to learn from aviation.
Andy Lord:One is We, we have got to be far more customer centric
Andy Lord:in terms of how we operate.
Andy Lord:We've got to think much more proactively around how we give customers choice,
Andy Lord:particularly when there's disruption.
Andy Lord:we've got to be able to communicate more proactively to our customers.
Andy Lord:we kind of, have a disruption and forget about them.
Andy Lord:Because they can, you know, unlike aviation, they can, they can find
Andy Lord:their own way home, generally.
Andy Lord:so we need to be much more putting the customer at the heart of our
Andy Lord:decision making, which is something we're really focused on in, in TFL.
Andy Lord:The second thing that I'm pushing really hard for is,
Andy Lord:we should learn from aviation.
Andy Lord:They are, you know, they, they learn from, you know, tragic events, but
Andy Lord:they are incredibly proactive in terms of how they develop new technology,
Andy Lord:and they are far quicker at putting it into practice and then, consistently
Andy Lord:adopting it across the globe.
Andy Lord:so if you look at safety in aviation, it is phenomenal.
Andy Lord:and we need to be much more proactive as an industry, working
Andy Lord:together, which is one of the reasons why I'm here, to see how we can
Andy Lord:share and learn from each other.
Andy Lord:But we all do everything slightly differently, and it adds cost,
Andy Lord:it adds complexity, and it adds a hell of a lot of time and money,
Andy Lord:to us actually making a difference.
Andy Lord:And we need to learn from aviation and how they can do that, and
Andy Lord:how we can learn from them.
Paul Comfort:That's excellent.
Paul Comfort:Dottie, talk to us about what new technologies you see coming in future
Paul Comfort:and how are you going to utilize them?
Paul Comfort:Maybe AI?
Dottie Watkins:Yeah, some of the stuff that, we are kind of nibbling around the
Dottie Watkins:edges at right now, really just trying to identify the use case and looking
Dottie Watkins:for some grants, if anybody from the USDOT is listening, to help us do that.
Dottie Watkins:one of them is using AI and just advanced camera analytics.
Dottie Watkins:We have a significant number of cameras in our system.
Dottie Watkins:We have cameras at many of our BRT stations.
Dottie Watkins:We have cameras all over all of our buses.
Dottie Watkins:we partner with this, with our local city to be able to view the
Dottie Watkins:traffic cameras that we see there.
Dottie Watkins:one of the use cases that, that we think would actually be very
Dottie Watkins:beneficial to us, a big piece of what we operate is a commuter rail line.
Dottie Watkins:so we operate commuter rail on freight rail tracks.
Dottie Watkins:We actually also operate the freight rail.
Dottie Watkins:but there are portions of that commuter rail line that go through ranchland.
Dottie Watkins:I mean, they go from suburban communities through ranchland to the
Dottie Watkins:next suburban community, then into town.
Dottie Watkins:For And, in Austin, we have issues with people who are experiencing homelessness
Dottie Watkins:making encampments along the right of way.
Dottie Watkins:and an encampment along the right of way is dangerous for a lot of reasons.
Dottie Watkins:the pedestrians on the right of way is the biggest one, but also, we continue to
Dottie Watkins:have significant drought and fire risk, so when you're camping, that's also an issue.
Dottie Watkins:And so, we're hoping to be able to use the cameras that are already on
Dottie Watkins:our vehicles, We that are going up and down that line all day, every day, to
Dottie Watkins:look at what was there the last time a vehicle came through, 30 minutes
Dottie Watkins:later, what's there, 30 minutes later, what's there, and tell us when we see
Dottie Watkins:the evidence of human activity and we have an encampment that we need to go
Dottie Watkins:talk to the folks and help them find a different place to build their encampment.
Dottie Watkins:Currently, we do that with a very labor intensive process.
Dottie Watkins:We send a group of community intervention specialists, we have social workers
Dottie Watkins:on staff that we will send out.
Dottie Watkins:once a month on the weekend, and they'll ride the line in a high rail
Dottie Watkins:with one of our rail staff, and they'll go see what they can see, right?
Dottie Watkins:and that works, but it's a very labor intensive process, and we
Dottie Watkins:don't always, can't always see the things, because we don't know, oh
Dottie Watkins:wait, that this has been disturbed, there's actually people over here.
Dottie Watkins:And so, we're hoping to be able to do more and more things, with
Dottie Watkins:the many cameras that we have.
Dottie Watkins:I think there's a lot, a lot that can be done to just be more efficient
Dottie Watkins:and effective at what we do.
Paul Comfort:That's awesome.
Paul Comfort:Thank you.
Paul Comfort:Dwight, I want to ask you a little different question to close up.
Paul Comfort:You've been in executive management in many different jobs in many different
Paul Comfort:cities, and I'd like you, in our podcast, you shared some interesting thoughts for
Paul Comfort:mid level managers who want to move up.
Paul Comfort:Lessons from your career.
Paul Comfort:Give us one or two of the lessons for people who work in public
Paul Comfort:transportation today to help them.
Dwight Ferrell:find a good mentor.
Dwight Ferrell:that can help you and be honest with you.
Dwight Ferrell:And don't be afraid to fail.
Dwight Ferrell:If you're afraid to fail, you're already screwed.
Paul Comfort:You're not going to make a difference if
Paul Comfort:you're afraid to fail, right?
Paul Comfort:Correct.
Paul Comfort:You'll be a cheerleader, not a change agent.
Dwight Ferrell:My first promotion, I went from bus operator to assistant manager.
Dwight Ferrell:That hasn't been done before or since then, because I was
Dwight Ferrell:willing to take the risk.
Dwight Ferrell:And so you've got to be willing to get and be willing to take a risk.
Dwight Ferrell:I mean, at the end of the day, that's what it is.
Dwight Ferrell:And so anytime, if you ask any of these people here, the gentleman from London,
Dwight Ferrell:he went from aviation to transit.
Dwight Ferrell:That's a risk.
Dwight Ferrell:So, yeah, so I think, I think,
Paul Comfort:biggest transit system in the world.
Dwight Ferrell:Yeah, no, no risk in that at all.
Dwight Ferrell:But I think that those are the two things, you know, and the mentor
Dwight Ferrell:who will tell you the truth.
Dwight Ferrell:And I do have one more thing to add.
Dwight Ferrell:Introspection.
Dwight Ferrell:The one person that we lie to the most of is ourselves.
Dwight Ferrell:So you really have to be honest about you with yourself.
Dwight Ferrell:Because when you look at the failures that you've had in your lifetime,
Dwight Ferrell:what's the one common denominator?
Dwight Ferrell:You.
Dwight Ferrell:Failures and you learn from them.
Dwight Ferrell:Be honest about yourself.
Dwight Ferrell:You know, this is my role in this.
Dwight Ferrell:It's easy to point the finger and blame your boss for whatever, but what did you
Dwight Ferrell:do to cause your boss to take the action?
Paul Comfort:That's good.
Paul Comfort:Sean, I'm gonna ask you to keep that going for just a minute if you don't mind.
Paul Comfort:I think, what a lot of folks don't realize that when you move into the
Paul Comfort:senior chair, all the easy decisions have already been made before they get to you.
Paul Comfort:The decisions that have a template for them.
Paul Comfort:A plus B equals C.
Paul Comfort:The ones that come to the CEO job are the ones without a
Paul Comfort:template that require judgment.
Paul Comfort:Judgment that's been forged in the fires of a thousand decisions
Paul Comfort:that you've made along the way.
Paul Comfort:And like Dwight just said, you've integrated the lessons from them.
Paul Comfort:Oh, that didn't work.
Paul Comfort:I better do something different next time.
Paul Comfort:Give us your thoughts on that, and as a leader, how do you handle that?
Shawn Donaghy:Yeah, I would say first, like Andy, I came from
Shawn Donaghy:aviation also, right after 9 11.
Shawn Donaghy:and I was in a position where I was starting to see a lot of information
Shawn Donaghy:that came post 9 11, and I said, man, I, I gotta get out of this.
Shawn Donaghy:Like, this is too much, and sort of worked my way into public transit at
Shawn Donaghy:that point, but I think, I think the one thing that we talk about a little bit
Shawn Donaghy:as CEOs, we talk a lot about the CEO's Council as sort of, it's one of the
Shawn Donaghy:most amazing jobs you could ever have.
Shawn Donaghy:It is also one of the loneliest jobs you can ever have.
Shawn Donaghy:Because it is your responsibility to make sure that every single person
Shawn Donaghy:under your care knows that you got it.
Shawn Donaghy:Doesn't mean you're always right.
Shawn Donaghy:It just means they gotta know that you got it.
Shawn Donaghy:And, and sometimes, that's really taxing.
Shawn Donaghy:Things are gonna come your way.
Shawn Donaghy:Like, when the pandemic hit for us, I, I was with our board, our deputy CEO,
Shawn Donaghy:and another individual in Washington, D.
Shawn Donaghy:C., the day they enacted the Stafford Act and closed the doors to the Capitol.
Shawn Donaghy:And so we're trying to get our board out of D.
Shawn Donaghy:C., and I remember the three of us were kind of sitting around
Shawn Donaghy:at Baltimore Airport, the only place we could get a flight.
Shawn Donaghy:And we're kind of like, what the heck are we going to do?
Shawn Donaghy:And I just remember, at that point in time, it was like, it was up to sort
Shawn Donaghy:of the three of us to build a plan.
Shawn Donaghy:And I remember my deputy CEO saying, hey, I really want to help you,
Shawn Donaghy:but, you know, this is your call, boss, you've got to figure this out.
Shawn Donaghy:And, and I remember kind of never feeling more lonely in my life than
Shawn Donaghy:thinking I'm about to make a thousand wrong decisions over the next 30 days,
Shawn Donaghy:because, right, I thought 30, 60 days, hey, yeah, I was wrong right there.
Shawn Donaghy:But I think you got to own it.
Shawn Donaghy:You got to be authentic about what you're doing.
Shawn Donaghy:You got to let the workforce know that who you are is who
Shawn Donaghy:you're going to be as a leader.
Shawn Donaghy:When you need to be strong, you got to be strong.
Shawn Donaghy:When you need to make the call, you got to make the call.
Shawn Donaghy:Managing board relationships is interesting, too, because you got to make
Shawn Donaghy:sure that even if you don't agree with what they want, you have to find a way
Shawn Donaghy:to keep them involved to make sure that their thoughts and opinions are heard,
Shawn Donaghy:and that's sort of an interesting space that employees don't necessarily see or
Shawn Donaghy:have to deal with, and then communicate those expectations to your employees.
Shawn Donaghy:I love being a leader.
Shawn Donaghy:It's one of my favorite things in the world.
Shawn Donaghy:but one of these days I'm going back to operations just so I can get back
Shawn Donaghy:on the street, but, yeah, I love it.
Shawn Donaghy:But, you know, you got to make sure you got the people around
Shawn Donaghy:you that give you good counsel.
Shawn Donaghy:I've been super fortunate in my career to have some of the best, senior
Shawn Donaghy:staff and director level employees to walk next to me anytime I needed
Shawn Donaghy:somebody to walk next to me, and I've always been thankful for that.
Shawn Donaghy:and I wouldn't be here today if it wasn't for those individuals, and like Dwight
Shawn Donaghy:said, for some of the mentors I had.
Shawn Donaghy:there's one right over there, Bill Sprawl.
Shawn Donaghy:you know, like, I could walk through this hall right now and talk to a hundred
Shawn Donaghy:people that impacted my career, if not more, and I'm so thankful for that.
Shawn Donaghy:and I know each one of us could do the same thing.
Shawn Donaghy:Yeah,
Paul Comfort:And Shawn has just been named head of APTA's mid size bus
Paul Comfort:council, so congratulations on that.
Paul Comfort:Adam, you've operated public transportation, I think, on
Paul Comfort:four continents, and, you've operated five continents.
Paul Comfort:Give us some final thoughts and lessons learned along the way.
Adam Leishman:I think what was just said previously is really wonderful
Adam Leishman:and it does get lonely as a CEO.
Adam Leishman:and you do have to take a lot of risks and your job is literally
Adam Leishman:solving problems non stop.
Adam Leishman:and in an industry that's quite thankless in many ways, it's like
Adam Leishman:the blood system in the body.
Adam Leishman:You know, like, everyone expects it to work.
Adam Leishman:No one really thanks your blood system for working, but when it stops working,
Adam Leishman:when there's a clot or a problem, You know, there's a major problem.
Adam Leishman:And so often you're dealing with crisis management issues.
Adam Leishman:you know, I guess I've been really blessed in many ways, but also inspired
Adam Leishman:having experienced London, Singapore, Hong Kong, like you said before,
Adam Leishman:three of arguably the top cities in the world when it comes to buses.
Adam Leishman:And seeing how a public transport system can transform a city.
Adam Leishman:And, you know, that really inspired me.
Adam Leishman:When I said before I went to London and then the Singapore experience,
Adam Leishman:it really inspired me to dedicate my life to this industry because
Adam Leishman:we can make such a difference.
Adam Leishman:And, all of you here are, I assume, in this industry.
Adam Leishman:Thank you.
Adam Leishman:Thank you for being in this industry.
Adam Leishman:It is one of the most important industries in existence.
Adam Leishman:The impact we can have in cities, the impact we can have In transforming
Adam Leishman:lives, improving a lot of the problems we collectively face as a society.
Adam Leishman:I, I don't think we say that enough.
Adam Leishman:And I think we need to congratulate the people that
Adam Leishman:are doing well in the industry.
Adam Leishman:These guys here doing all a fantastic job and all of you.
Adam Leishman:And, and I think we need to, to bring that spirit of encouragement and working
Adam Leishman:together to really make a transformation.
Adam Leishman:I get really sad when I hear about, you know, A major project that's collapsed
Adam Leishman:like what Andy was talking about before.
Adam Leishman:So much time, energy, resource gone into it.
Adam Leishman:Transformational for the country.
Adam Leishman:You know, and, and often we've had so many hurdles to get over and
Adam Leishman:we make it so hard for ourself.
Adam Leishman:We need to make it easy and a priority to invest in public transport.
Adam Leishman:So that's the message I leave for you.
Adam Leishman:And thank, thank you for everyone that contributes to our industry.
Paul Comfort:Thank you.
Paul Comfort:Let's give our panelists a round of applause.
Paul Comfort:And remember, at the heart of what we do is compassion for our passengers.
Paul Comfort:As all of them have said, we make a difference in their lives.
Paul Comfort:When we do it right, we Things go smooth.
Paul Comfort:We don't often get thanked.
Paul Comfort:When we do it wrong, we can ruin their day or even their life.
Paul Comfort:So let's go out there and give it our A game every day.
Paul Comfort:Thank you, Modaxo and Vontas for sponsoring.
Paul Comfort:Thank you, our panelists.
Tris Hussey:Thank you for listening to this week's episode of transit.
Tris Hussey:Unplugged.
Tris Hussey:Hi, I'm Tris Hussey editor of the podcast.
Tris Hussey:And I'd like to thank our guests, Andy Lord.
Tris Hussey:Adam Leishman Dottie Watkins.
Tris Hussey:Dwight Ferrell.
Tris Hussey:And Shawn Donaghy for their time to participate on this
Tris Hussey:CEO panel at APTA transform.
Tris Hussey:And coming up next week, we have something really cool and
Tris Hussey:interesting to share with you.
Tris Hussey:Stephen Tu of LA Metro is responsible for Station Experience.
Tris Hussey:And you'll learn how Stephen has been able to enhance the safety
Tris Hussey:and cleanliness of the stations.
Tris Hussey:And the perception of safety.
Tris Hussey:So it increases.
Tris Hussey:Creases ridership.
Tris Hussey:It gets more people enjoying LA Metro.
Tris Hussey:Transit unplugged is brought to you by Modaxo.
Tris Hussey:At Modaxo we're passionate about moving the world's people and at
Tris Hussey:Transit Unplugged, we're passionate we're about telling those stories.
Tris Hussey:So until next week ride safe and ride happy.