Speaker:

Welcome to The Get, the podcast about recruiting and

Speaker:

leadership in B2B SaaS marketing.

Speaker:

I'm your host, Erica Seidel.

Speaker:

This season we're looking at how SaaS marketing organizations are changing

Speaker:

in both seismic and subtle ways.

Speaker:

My guest today is someone you will learn a ton from.

Speaker:

I'm speaking with Matt Selheimer from Forrester.

Speaker:

He's VP and Research Director for B2B marketing executives.

Speaker:

So he gets both a broad and a deep look into the trends in B2B SaaS marketing.

Speaker:

Through all of his research and all of his advising, he's talking to dozens,

Speaker:

if not hundreds or thousands, Matt can fill in the blanks on marketing leaders

Speaker:

and gets all of these data points.

Speaker:

I always have a soft spot in my heart for Forrester because I am

Speaker:

a former Forester person, as well.

Speaker:

So I'm excited to have him join.

Speaker:

He has had CMO and VP marketing roles at companies like Alert Logic

Speaker:

and BMC software, and ITinvolve.

Speaker:

And he has a background previously spanning consulting, sales, and product

Speaker:

marketing just as well as marketing leadership before he came to Forrester.

Speaker:

Today we're gonna talk about some themes that have come up so far on

Speaker:

The Get podcast, and I'd love to get Matt's take on them as well as what

Speaker:

he's seeing in general in his research.

Speaker:

So this is gonna be fun.

Speaker:

Matt, welcome to the show.

Speaker:

Thanks, Erica.

Speaker:

I'm glad to be here.

Speaker:

Great.

Speaker:

Again, I love talking to Forrester people because a soft spot in my heart.

Speaker:

So I am thrilled to hear you riff on some of the things

Speaker:

that we've been seeing so far.

Speaker:

I'm just gonna recap some of the very high level themes from the podcast episodes

Speaker:

that I've done so far this season.

Speaker:

Then would love to get your reactions to them, as well as diving into some

Speaker:

of the research that you've been doing.

Speaker:

One theme is that AI is now part of the buying committee.

Speaker:

I've talked to people who have said, oh, I'm ready for situations where

Speaker:

ChatGPT told me I should talk to you.

Speaker:

And somebody who said, oh, ChatGPT, or actually AI chatbots

Speaker:

in general are part of my personas.

Speaker:

I'm not just marketing to individuals, I'm marketing to chatbots, and I'm

Speaker:

thinking about them as personas.

Speaker:

So that's one theme.

Speaker:

I'm gonna go through a couple others, and then you can react.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

Another one is this focus on disciplined experimentation over scattershot testing.

Speaker:

So this idea of not being a mile wide and an inch deep with testing, but

Speaker:

having a rapid prototyping approach with micro experts, hiring micro

Speaker:

experts to focus on specific channels, and maybe micro influencers to really

Speaker:

get into specific audiences that are going to respond to marketing messages.

Speaker:

So this idea of microsegmentation has come up, this idea of pairing strategic intent

Speaker:

with hyper experimentation has come up.

Speaker:

I think part of this is the do more with less domain.

Speaker:

As part of that, there's this renewed focus on discoverability.

Speaker:

I think we might see a resurgence of brand and PR roles with shifts towards citations

Speaker:

and building context for buyers through what has been traditionally PR motions.

Speaker:

So those are just three things, probably poorly articulated, but I would love

Speaker:

to hear you give a little intro on you and a fun fact and then react a little

Speaker:

bit to some of those things that I've thrown out there and see does this jive,

Speaker:

does this gel, and can you add on it?

Speaker:

But why don't you say a little bit more about you?

Speaker:

So there's a book that I read a couple years ago, Erica, called Range.

Speaker:

It's a counterpoint to Gladwell's Outliers.

Speaker:

I don't know if you've read it, but one of the things that the author

Speaker:

talks about is that having a range of experiences can actually be more

Speaker:

beneficial than just having one, highly specialized area of expertise.

Speaker:

In addition to being a twenty, twenty-five-year-plus marketing leader

Speaker:

and having to spend some time in sales and business development roles

Speaker:

and things like that, I started my career actually as a systems engineer.

Speaker:

So I have a technical background, which served me really well as a product

Speaker:

marketer and as a CMO because I could talk the same language with the product team.

Speaker:

I could resonate with the buyer and the messaging that we were trying to

Speaker:

produce for more technical buyers.

Speaker:

In addition to having been an engineer, I'm an archeologist.

Speaker:

I have a PhD in Roman archeology, and I work as a professional

Speaker:

archeologist, publish research as a professional archeologist in my spare

Speaker:

time when I'm not doing marketing.

Speaker:

And people always seem really interested in the archeology side of me when I say,

Speaker:

oh, I'm a cybersecurity CMO, or I advise CMOs, but I'm also an archeologist.

Speaker:

They always wanna talk about the archeology side 'cause it's fun.

Speaker:

But I specifically study Roman cities.

Speaker:

And if you think a little bit about like how we work as humans, we

Speaker:

build on top of what's come before.

Speaker:

That's the way cities in many cases are.

Speaker:

Even if you build a brand new city, green field, over time it becomes organic.

Speaker:

New layers get built on top of it.

Speaker:

So my systems engineering background that resonates with, but also my marketing

Speaker:

background and experience because marketing operates much the same way.

Speaker:

We build on what's come before, the systems, the processes, the perceptions

Speaker:

of what marketing does, marketing's value, all of these things are cultural

Speaker:

aspects, if you will, and related aspects.

Speaker:

So I find that the archeology side of my brain and the marketing

Speaker:

side of my brain are not all that different from one another.

Speaker:

So that's a little fun fact about me.

Speaker:

That's great.

Speaker:

I love that.

Speaker:

And it's also, companies are built, you know, layer on top of layer.

Speaker:

Exactly.

Speaker:

And not just teams and not just marketing strategies.

Speaker:

It's so funny to think that sometimes the thing that you did that was your

Speaker:

first job is actually very telling.

Speaker:

I had a career coach who said, okay, Erica, let me get to know you.

Speaker:

What was your first job?

Speaker:

And I said, I was scooping ice cream and working in a store.

Speaker:

And she was like, well, what would you have done differently

Speaker:

if you were the manager?

Speaker:

And I talked about interfacing with customers in a different

Speaker:

way and the product setup.

Speaker:

And she was like, yes, you're marketing oriented because that's what you're

Speaker:

saying, you're not talking about the operations of it all, for instance.

Speaker:

It's very interesting for people who are in career transition or in

Speaker:

a kind of career reflection moments.

Speaker:

Sometimes it helps to look back and to say, what are those

Speaker:

themes, like you've articulated so well with the archeology stuff.

Speaker:

If you can remember the themes that I threw out there, any reactions?

Speaker:

Make sense, not make sense?

Speaker:

What are your thoughts?

Speaker:

So the three things you've laid out are big, meaty topics.

Speaker:

We could probably do a whole podcast on each one of those,

Speaker:

so I'll try to be brief.

Speaker:

AI is absolutely transforming the nature of buying, and we may be not at the

Speaker:

world yet where it's let my bot talk to your bot, but there's definitely

Speaker:

a trajectory in that direction.

Speaker:

Every year, Forrester does what we call our B2B Buyer's Journey Survey,

Speaker:

typically has 15, 16,000 respondents to it across industries, across

Speaker:

company sizes, across geographies.

Speaker:

We believe it's the most robust B2B buying survey that's conducted annually.

Speaker:

In the most recent survey data, we're absolutely seeing that AI use in

Speaker:

the buyer's journey is ubiquitous.

Speaker:

90% plus of people are using AI as part of buying now.

Speaker:

So it's gonna go probably close to a hundred percent,

Speaker:

and it's already above, 90%.

Speaker:

But what was most interesting to us when we were looking at the data was the range

Speaker:

of usage of AI across the buying journey.

Speaker:

One hypothesis we had was, it's probably gonna be more

Speaker:

common in the discovery phase.

Speaker:

People are trying to find potential vendors to work with, but what we

Speaker:

found was that it was the number one self-service information source in

Speaker:

the discover phase, in the evaluate phase, and in the commit phase.

Speaker:

So it's completely pervasive now across the buying process.

Speaker:

We're in prediction season now at Forrester, so we haven't quite

Speaker:

published our predictions yet.

Speaker:

But one of the sort of draft predictions I put forward, which didn't end

Speaker:

up making the cut, 'cause there's always that debate, but one of the

Speaker:

draft predictions that I put forward was, are we gonna see next year that

Speaker:

marketing operations needs to step in to organize the AI inputs into purchasing?

Speaker:

Because if one buyer persona is off there using an AI tool for information and

Speaker:

another is using another and so on and so forth, what rationalization of these

Speaker:

different AI inputs needs to happen?

Speaker:

Do we trust Co-pilot more than we trust Gemini, for example?

Speaker:

Or do we trust ChatGPT more than we trust Grok or Meta AI or whatever AI LLM

Speaker:

might be being used by particular buyers?

Speaker:

There's bias in responses.

Speaker:

Studies have shown that there can be gender biases in the way AI talks to

Speaker:

people, as well as other kinds of factors.

Speaker:

So I think there is potentially, well, this is what my AI said.

Speaker:

Well, this is what my AI said.

Speaker:

Somebody's gonna have to rationalize that.

Speaker:

That's a second order challenge that maybe we're not quite seeing yet, but maybe we

Speaker:

will see as we look ahead to next year.

Speaker:

But there's no doubt that the nature of B2B buying is changing.

Speaker:

It's not just AI, though.

Speaker:

It's also there's a generational shift happening in B2B buying.

Speaker:

I'm Gen X, but Millennials and Gen Zs are now the majority

Speaker:

of buying personas in B2B.

Speaker:

They may not be the number one economic buyer yet but they are the

Speaker:

largest population within the buying group and most B2B buying scenarios.

Speaker:

They work differently.

Speaker:

They think differently.

Speaker:

I was at an event with some client folks last week and one of the

Speaker:

things that we talked about was the notion of Facebook is for old people.

Speaker:

You don't really see Millennials and Gen Z on Facebook.

Speaker:

The watering holes for Millennials and Gen Z are different.

Speaker:

They're maybe more likely to go to Reddit to ask for input in

Speaker:

their buying purchase, than to, say, go to LinkedIn as an example.

Speaker:

So how are you thinking about your content?

Speaker:

How are you thinking about your brand, your messaging, your channels,

Speaker:

as it relates to this generational shift that's happening in B2B buying?

Speaker:

So that's topic one.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Or at least a quick riff on topic number one.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Topic number two, you talked about testing.

Speaker:

As a practitioner CMO, I always used to try and achieve

Speaker:

what I call the 85/15 rule.

Speaker:

I could hit the goals that I needed to hit with 85% of my resources, and I would

Speaker:

reserve the 15% as my flex budget, my flex resources, and those 15% ensured that

Speaker:

I would have room for experimentation.

Speaker:

And if nothing came out of that experimentation, I could still

Speaker:

hit my targets with the other 85%.

Speaker:

Now, did I always get to 85/15?

Speaker:

Maybe not.

Speaker:

Maybe it was 90/10, or 95/5 if I was coming in as a new CMO.

Speaker:

But you always need to have some portion of your resources allocated

Speaker:

to testing and experimentation.

Speaker:

But more than that, in the world that we're operating in now and the volatility

Speaker:

that we're operating in right now, we firmly believe and we're telling this

Speaker:

to our clients on a regular basis, that your understanding of your buyers, your

Speaker:

customers, the markets you're operating in is your competitive differentiator.

Speaker:

I know that sounds kind of obvious, maybe, and I can bring in the archeology

Speaker:

side of my brain here as well.

Speaker:

The group that you study, the audience you're marketing to, you need to know them

Speaker:

better than your competitors know them.

Speaker:

That's gonna help ensure that you're producing the right resonating

Speaker:

content that's going to engage them.

Speaker:

People are going to conversational AI tools and they're putting all

Speaker:

kinds of information into them as part of those conversations.

Speaker:

They're putting demographic information, firmographic information, psychographic

Speaker:

information, and then, the LLM is trying to figure out, okay, based on

Speaker:

these inputs in this conversation, what do I suggest and recommend?

Speaker:

Well, if you don't have content that is indexable and ingestible by the

Speaker:

LLMs around those different parameters, then it's not gonna recommend you.

Speaker:

If somebody's in a healthcare organization that's a billion dollar

Speaker:

company that operates only in the United States, do you have content that maps

Speaker:

to those parameters, as an example?

Speaker:

If not, why would you expect the LLM to recommend your organization or

Speaker:

suggest your organization as someone that that individual should talk to?

Speaker:

So we're gonna see an explosion in content.

Speaker:

We need to see an explosion in content in order to be able to deal with

Speaker:

this sort of zero click change in the B2B buying "search" landscape.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And that means you gotta test.

Speaker:

That means you gotta experiment.

Speaker:

Back to that point, we don't know what we don't know.

Speaker:

The only way to know is to do, and to learn.

Speaker:

The CMOs who can create a continuous learning organization are the ones

Speaker:

that are gonna be more successful.

Speaker:

In fact, I was talking with a

Speaker:

brand and communications leader

Speaker:

two weeks ago who had a research team underneath her, and I was told

Speaker:

that she had to fire that entire research team, that there wasn't

Speaker:

budget any longer for research.

Speaker:

What a big mistake, what a massive mistake.

Speaker:

That research team is more important now than ever before.

Speaker:

So now she's trying to figure out, okay, I don't have these resources any longer.

Speaker:

How do I stay in touch with the market and understand what's going

Speaker:

on in the market now that I no longer have this research team?

Speaker:

Of course, AI can be of help there, but are you gonna trust

Speaker:

your entire research to what comes out of a conversational AI tool?

Speaker:

That sounds like a risky strategy to me as a CMO.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

That's debatable.

Speaker:

And then the third one brand, we are seeing a resurgence in brand interest.

Speaker:

It's interesting how brand goes in cycles.

Speaker:

Right now, there's this weird dichotomy going on that we're seeing as we're

Speaker:

looking at data and talking to clients and non-clients alike, there's a

Speaker:

recognition that more brand awareness is needed, but there is a reluctance to

Speaker:

commit to long-term brand investment.

Speaker:

Because it's hard to prove the ROI and in the current volatile

Speaker:

environment, it's like, gimme pipeline, gimme pipeline, gimme pipeline.

Speaker:

It's harder to show the path from brand investment to pipeline.

Speaker:

But what we're seeing, back to buying behavior shifting, is we're

Speaker:

seeing more decisive buyers now.

Speaker:

We haven't quite published this statistic yet, so I'm giving a little

Speaker:

bit of a forward-looking view here to something Forrester hasn't released yet.

Speaker:

But we are crunching our recent buyer journey data around what do buyers have

Speaker:

in mind when they're starting their purchasing process, in terms of vendors?

Speaker:

And we see that most buyers have a preferred vendor in mind.

Speaker:

They may have one vendor and that's their preferred vendor, or they

Speaker:

may have multiple vendors they're considering and they've got one that's

Speaker:

preferred, but most buyers have a preferred vendor, and what we're seeing

Speaker:

in the data is that more than 50% of the time that preferred vendor wins.

Speaker:

That's huge.

Speaker:

That's a huge shift in how marketers need to think about marketing and the role of

Speaker:

brand because if you're sitting around waiting for in-market intent signals,

Speaker:

which is what we've been trying to do.

Speaker:

We've been polishing the pebbles on in-market intent signals and using tools

Speaker:

around that for the last five or so years.

Speaker:

And it's helped us, but there's the 95/5 rule.

Speaker:

There's other ways this gets expressed, but ultimately, most

Speaker:

buyers are not actively in market.

Speaker:

So if they have a preferred vendor when they start their purchasing

Speaker:

process and you wait for them to show large amounts of intent signals,

Speaker:

you're probably getting in too late.

Speaker:

You're more likely gonna end up being used as negotiating leverage

Speaker:

against the preferred vendor, which is not a good place to be.

Speaker:

That's an expensive business model.

Speaker:

That means poor conversion rates, low win rates, high cost of acquisition.

Speaker:

So what we're telling our clients is they

Speaker:

actually need to bond brand and demand.

Speaker:

They need

Speaker:

to stop thinking about brand investment separately, and demand investment

Speaker:

separately, and think about how the two are synergistic to one another.

Speaker:

And they also need to stop thinking about brand awareness as the only thing that

Speaker:

is measurable from a brand standpoint.

Speaker:

There's perception, how accurate do people understand what you do as a business?

Speaker:

If you're a new business, they may not have heard of you, or they may have, but

Speaker:

they may not know really what you do.

Speaker:

There was the funny thing that happened with the Coldplay concert.

Speaker:

I don't know if you saw the viral little video that they put out with Gwyneth

Speaker:

Paltrow after, um, an astronomer put out.

Speaker:

Yeah, exactly.

Speaker:

What a great opportunity.

Speaker:

You got all this inbound traffic, use that to clarify what you do.

Speaker:

Improve brand perception, not just awareness.

Speaker:

Then after perception comes sentiment.

Speaker:

How do people feel about your brand?

Speaker:

That allows you to, then, build and show preference, and then

Speaker:

ultimately build loyalty and advocacy.

Speaker:

What we are really seeing and what we're challenging our clients to think about

Speaker:

is how do brand and demand, like I say, work together more synergistically?

Speaker:

If you just put your dollars into demand, you are not realizing the

Speaker:

impact of more decisive buyers and how brand investments can give you lift.

Speaker:

Not just lift in your demand programs, but lift for sales,

Speaker:

lift for partners, investors, recruiting and retaining employees.

Speaker:

There's all these other ways that brand drives value in

Speaker:

addition to attracting new logos.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Great.

Speaker:

This is a great overview.

Speaker:

I wanna skip to talking about advice to CEOs who have failed at hiring CMOs

Speaker:

because we've talked around this a little bit that often the impact of

Speaker:

marketing has felt in the short term and in the long term, but a lot of CEOs and

Speaker:

investors, they want the pipeline, the leads, and there can be this focus on

Speaker:

short-term to the expense of long term.

Speaker:

I think that's why some CMO, CEO matches don't work so much, and the alignment

Speaker:

is, I guess, the number one word before you make one of these matches.

Speaker:

I think another thing is this expectation of doing more with less.

Speaker:

One of my podcast guests said, I will not do more with less.

Speaker:

I will just prioritize differently.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Those are some ways to think about CEO and CMO partnerships

Speaker:

flourishing rather than failing.

Speaker:

But what's your advice?

Speaker:

If you could pick one thing about advice to a CEO who has had a mis-hire in a CMO?

Speaker:

I'm gonna answer that question, but I'm gonna first give the CMO's perspective.

Speaker:

I was talking with a CMO client just a couple days ago and I asked

Speaker:

her, what's top of mind right now?

Speaker:

What's keeping you up at night?

Speaker:

And she said, I'm trying to survive the second budget cycle.

Speaker:

And I said, tell me what does that mean?

Speaker:

She goes, well, a new CMO can typically survive the first

Speaker:

budget cycle because they're new.

Speaker:

But the second budget cycle is the one that really is the make or

Speaker:

break moment for a new CMO because you've been there long enough.

Speaker:

You're expected to be able to put forward a solid well thought through

Speaker:

plan and then deliver against it.

Speaker:

A big problem that we see is mis-set expectations between the CEO and the

Speaker:

CMO as part of the hiring process.

Speaker:

I think a lot of this comes back to CEOs don't really know what they're hiring for.

Speaker:

Yes, they put a job description together and they put all the things in the

Speaker:

job description, but what they don't really put in the job description

Speaker:

is, how do I expect marketing to contribute as part of the C-suite?

Speaker:

Do I expect marketing to be a coequal partner with sales

Speaker:

and product driving growth?

Speaker:

Marketing is shaping growth strategy and segmentation strategy

Speaker:

as much as sales leader is.

Speaker:

Marketing is providing insights to guide product roadmap and

Speaker:

driving the brand message back to deliverables on the roadmap that

Speaker:

fulfill the promise of the brand.

Speaker:

Is marketing in that partnering mode or is marketing a support function?

Speaker:

Is marketing the butler to sales?

Speaker:

Like, hey, gimme more events, gimme more webinars, gimme more leads.

Speaker:

Or is marketing the butler to product, like, hey, you got a new release?

Speaker:

Okay, we'll do a launch plan.

Speaker:

In our research, we classify four purposes for marketing.

Speaker:

There's marketing as a support function.

Speaker:

There's marketing as a partnering function, as I mentioned.

Speaker:

There's also marketing as a promoting function, and

Speaker:

marketing as a driving function.

Speaker:

When you're in the support zone or you're in the promoting zone,

Speaker:

you are thinking activities first.

Speaker:

You're thinking, how do I drive short-term productivity?

Speaker:

If you're in the support zone, short-term productivity for sales,

Speaker:

as an example, and if you're in the promoting zone, it's short-term revenue.

Speaker:

The challenge of being in the support zone is that's not a very nice place to be if

Speaker:

you really wanna be a business leader.

Speaker:

If you're content with being an operator and either reporting up

Speaker:

to sales or being subordinate to sales from a political standpoint,

Speaker:

then fine, the supporting zone.

Speaker:

But most marketers I talk to don't really wanna be in the support zone.

Speaker:

The promoting zone sounds attractive, but the challenge of being in the

Speaker:

promoting zone is that you're only as good as the last promotions you've done.

Speaker:

I call that the hamster wheel or the treadmill.

Speaker:

It's just constant.

Speaker:

You just have to promote, promote, promote, promote.

Speaker:

The partnering zone is a better place typically for a CMO because

Speaker:

they're acting as a business leader.

Speaker:

They're working on growth strategy jointly with the sales leader and

Speaker:

the product leader and the CEO.

Speaker:

They're also probably working with the customer success leader, and

Speaker:

they have a hand in driving the segmentation and the targeting.

Speaker:

They're not just accepting the segmentation handed to them from

Speaker:

the sales leader and the CEO.

Speaker:

The driving zone, everybody likes to think of that as the best place to be

Speaker:

or like the ideal state, but it's not always necessarily the ideal state.

Speaker:

If marketing is in the driving zone, that means marketing's calling the shots.

Speaker:

That may make sense in certain scenarios, in certain segments.

Speaker:

You may have a certain segment where self-service buying, digital

Speaker:

commerce is how they wanna buy.

Speaker:

So marketing might need to own that and drive that.

Speaker:

Whether that's on your own website, where you're standing up, an

Speaker:

e-commerce or marketplace site, or whether that's through third party,

Speaker:

marketplaces with distributor partners or with the hyperscalers, et cetera.

Speaker:

But marketing is driving that motion.

Speaker:

Or marketing is feeding product requirements back and saying,

Speaker:

product, you need to go build this.

Speaker:

That can sometimes be a difficult place to position yourself in because

Speaker:

products might be very resistant to that.

Speaker:

Sales might be very resistant to that.

Speaker:

You're also putting yourself out there on a plank.

Speaker:

You're saying I'm gonna be the growth driver for the company, so the

Speaker:

accountability is on you, you, and you.

Speaker:

So we generally suggest that if you're sitting in the support

Speaker:

zone, that moving to the partnering zone is the next best place to be.

Speaker:

Yes, you can move to the promoting zone, but like I said, the challenge

Speaker:

there is it's just that constant hamster wheel or treadmill.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Let me go back to your question now that I set that context.

Speaker:

The mismatch is often when the CMO comes in thinking that they're gonna

Speaker:

be a driver or they're gonna be a partner only to find out that the

Speaker:

reality is they're a support function.

Speaker:

The CEO may have told him a great story, but the culture in the organization

Speaker:

is marketing is a support function.

Speaker:

You hear these kind of pejorative expressions.

Speaker:

One of our clients that we interviewed for some research recently told

Speaker:

us that she found out that when she wasn't in the room, she was

Speaker:

referred to as "The PR Lady."

Speaker:

Ooh.

Speaker:

So she quit.

Speaker:

She was like, this is a culture that I'm just not gonna be able to be successful

Speaker:

in, because it's gonna be too difficult for me to convince all of my peers to see

Speaker:

me differently than the way they see me.

Speaker:

So she literally opted out of the organization and left the organization.

Speaker:

She didn't try to - she did not to

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

- evolve the-

Speaker:

She decided I don't wanna deal with this.

Speaker:

I don't want the headache of it, and I'm gonna go find another job, and

Speaker:

so I'm just gonna twiddle my thumbs.

Speaker:

That's a bit harsh, but obviously she was still trying to advance the

Speaker:

business, but she's like, I am not going to try and change the culture of how

Speaker:

marketing is viewed in this organization.

Speaker:

I'm gonna go work somewhere else.

Speaker:

So that's one thing we definitely see CMOs do is they opt out.

Speaker:

That's one of the reasons why the tenure is also short.

Speaker:

The tenure isn't short just because CMOs are getting laid off.

Speaker:

The tenure is also short 'cause CMOs are saying, this is an organization

Speaker:

that's not compatible with how I see marketing and how I want to run marketing.

Speaker:

So what I tell our clients is, obviously we're talking to people

Speaker:

who are already in the CMO role, but sometimes they're in a transition, too.

Speaker:

I tell them, look, make sure there's a really good fit here

Speaker:

for the purpose of marketing.

Speaker:

That what you see as the purpose of marketing and your CEO and the board sees

Speaker:

as the purpose of marketing is aligned.

Speaker:

If you need to do education, that's the time to do the education.

Speaker:

Educating the CEO on this is how you should be thinking about marketing,

Speaker:

and don't think that marketing's just about new logo acquisition.

Speaker:

Marketing can play a role also in expansion, but also in retention

Speaker:

and renewal, and expand the aperture of how they think about

Speaker:

marketing and the role of marketing.

Speaker:

If you don't get the CEO resonating with that, then that may not be the place

Speaker:

that you want to go join, as an example.

Speaker:

But if you are already in a function, already in a company as a

Speaker:

CMO, what we're telling all of our clients is, now's a great time to

Speaker:

recalibrate the purpose of marketing.

Speaker:

We have all these advancements in technology that are happening.

Speaker:

We have all of this more empowerment around buyers that's happening.

Speaker:

We have some pretty gnarly dynamics going on in the C-suite right now.

Speaker:

Let's be honest, sales is kinda struggling a bit to figure out what its existence

Speaker:

is gonna look like in this new world too.

Speaker:

And product is trying to deal with the rapid pace of evolution as well.

Speaker:

Use these what might look like pressures to your advantage.

Speaker:

Go have the conversation with your CEO.

Speaker:

Because of more empowered audiences, this is how we need to think

Speaker:

about the purpose of marketing.

Speaker:

Because of the advancements in technology, this is how we need to

Speaker:

think about the purpose of marketing, and really use this 2026 planning

Speaker:

cycle to recalibrate the purpose of marketing, the scope of marketing.

Speaker:

And then that drives a different conversation around resources.

Speaker:

It breaks the cycle of we're gonna look at last year's budget and do a little

Speaker:

incremental up, little incremental down because it recalibrates the conversation

Speaker:

to what do we want marketing to do here-

Speaker:

Yeah, yeah.

Speaker:

-Before we get into the budget discussion.

Speaker:

Agree or disagree, it's easier to calibrate ahead of joining

Speaker:

a company versus once you're in there with perceptions set?

Speaker:

I think it's easier when you're joining a company during the hiring process.

Speaker:

When I think back about the times I've shifted marketing or worked

Speaker:

to shift marketing, if I didn't have the understanding from the

Speaker:

CEO and I going into me joining the company, it was much harder to shift.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

I love those perspectives on the different framings of what kind of

Speaker:

marketing leader a company is looking for.

Speaker:

And often the company's looking for somebody that, they've bumped

Speaker:

down marketing, oh, it used to be a CMO and now it's a VP.

Speaker:

But they still want the person to be able to be the partner.

Speaker:

Exactly.

Speaker:

So that's where most CEOs fail.

Speaker:

The pithy soundbite comment is the CEO fails when they hire a driver

Speaker:

marketer or a partner marketer and they put them into a support role.

Speaker:

Yeah, it's like having a Ferrari, but using it to go to the grocery store.

Speaker:

But only driving it in your neighborhood.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And never taking it out on the Audubon.

Speaker:

Exactly.

Speaker:

Cool.

Speaker:

That's awesome.

Speaker:

Now let's talk about marketing org design.

Speaker:

I was talking to Wanda Cadigan who runs marketing for Cloudinary, and

Speaker:

she had this great concept about in a team you're gonna have Swiss Army

Speaker:

knives and you're gonna have scalpels.

Speaker:

There are the generalists and the specialists, and then you're

Speaker:

gonna have enhancements or AI team members, however you think of that.

Speaker:

Your thoughts?

Speaker:

I like that analogy of Swiss Army knives and scalpels.

Speaker:

That resonates with me.

Speaker:

One challenge we have in marketing is that we've developed so much specialization

Speaker:

in marketing over the last twenty years that we've siloed ourselves.

Speaker:

A good example of this is how program budgets get allocated.

Speaker:

Here at Forrester, we track budget benchmarks for B2B, and we look at how

Speaker:

do people organize their program's budget by function or what we call by family?

Speaker:

And we still see it's about 90% by function, 85, 90%

Speaker:

depending upon the survey.

Speaker:

And so it's basically the CMO divvies out the program dollars to

Speaker:

each one of their direct reports.

Speaker:

That reinforces siloed behavior just from the start.

Speaker:

I've got my budget to spend.

Speaker:

Instead, what we say is programs should be organized based on integrated campaigns.

Speaker:

And yes, there's probably some outta campaign stuff you need to do too,

Speaker:

so put some money aside for that.

Speaker:

But in terms of the bulk of the program dollars, that should be campaigns.

Speaker:

It should be aligned to audiences and themes, and each campaign should

Speaker:

have a component of reputation programs, brand programs, demand

Speaker:

programs, customer engagement programs, and enablement programs.

Speaker:

So as you bring a group of marketers together to say, okay, we have X amount of

Speaker:

dollars to go spend around this audience.

Speaker:

Lemme give you two quick examples.

Speaker:

We're going into a new market.

Speaker:

That's a part of our growth strategy.

Speaker:

We're not gonna be very well known.

Speaker:

It's a new market.

Speaker:

So we gotta lead with brand and reputation.

Speaker:

We don't wanna put too much demand investment in there 'cause it's gonna

Speaker:

be inefficient for us to do that.

Speaker:

So we wanna start with more brand investment and then ratchet up the

Speaker:

demand and investment over time.

Speaker:

We probably don't need to do very much investment around customer engagement.

Speaker:

It's a new market.

Speaker:

But for those initial lighthouse customers, we sure wanna do

Speaker:

customer engagement 'cause we want to turn those into advocates.

Speaker:

And it's a new market, so we gotta invest in enablement programs for our marketers

Speaker:

and our sellers and our partners.

Speaker:

Compare that to a cash cow business, you probably don't need to do as much

Speaker:

brand programs, reputation programs 'cause you're hopefully well known.

Speaker:

But maybe you do need to invest because people have

Speaker:

poor perceptions of your brand.

Speaker:

Maybe they think of you as what you used to be, or they have

Speaker:

bad sentiment around your brand.

Speaker:

So you gotta calibrate that.

Speaker:

But you need to do a lot more demand 'cause it's a cash cow business.

Speaker:

So the way you grow market share is by stealing customers from your

Speaker:

competitors, but then that also means you need to invest more in customer

Speaker:

engagement 'cause you gotta keep your customers retained and happy.

Speaker:

Otherwise your competitors are gonna steal them.

Speaker:

But you don't need to do a lot from a enablement standpoint

Speaker:

'cause it's a core business, and your team probably understands

Speaker:

how to sell 'em to those markets.

Speaker:

While that's not org design, per se, to your question, how we think about

Speaker:

our campaigns and how we work together and how we divvy out budget absolutely

Speaker:

crosses over into organizational design.

Speaker:

So what we'd like to see and what we advocate to our clients is moving more

Speaker:

towards a pod model or what we call a crew model, where you're bringing the

Speaker:

right resources, the right specialists, the right scalpels together, using that

Speaker:

analogy, along with some Swiss army knives as appropriate, but you're organizing

Speaker:

them in a crew that has a target audience, that has objectives, that has a budget

Speaker:

that's shared, that can be allocated across those different program families.

Speaker:

But using the crew analogy, you have a coxswain at the front of the boat.

Speaker:

And that coxswain is calling the pace and keeping everybody in line and

Speaker:

making sure we're all rowing together.

Speaker:

It's not just an unfettered pod where it's left to its own devices.

Speaker:

The coxswain is making sure that we're moving towards

Speaker:

those particular objectives.

Speaker:

What I love about that model is it doesn't require a reorg.

Speaker:

We hear from clients quite regularly that they're under reorg fatigue.

Speaker:

I can think of a few companies that I know of that they seem to reorg about

Speaker:

every twelve to eighteen months in marketing, and I wonder how can they

Speaker:

get anything done reorging that often?

Speaker:

If you've got reorg fatigue in your organization, then the pod or crew

Speaker:

model can be an effective way to be more audience centric and be more

Speaker:

strategic while not having to go through a big HR reorganizational approach.

Speaker:

It's interesting what you were initially saying about how marketing leaders have

Speaker:

traditionally said, oh, you're this person, you get this much budget, you're

Speaker:

this person, you get this much budget.

Speaker:

Hey, I've done it.

Speaker:

Yeah, and I think it's probably because, oh, we wanna get you to be like a P&L, a

Speaker:

mini P&L leader, build GM type of skills.

Speaker:

But I see your point, how that could

Speaker:

- It's, it's easier.

Speaker:

It's easier.

Speaker:

And budget cycles are, there's always pressures to plan.

Speaker:

There's never enough time to plan properly.

Speaker:

We're humans, and sometimes we just take the easy way out, okay, you get this much,

Speaker:

you get this much, you get this much.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Now I wanna go back to you, you used a car analogy about a Ferrari earlier.

Speaker:

So, I use the car analogy when it comes to org design.

Speaker:

One of the questions we get asked a lot is can you send me some sample org charts?

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

I try to politely tell clients, no, I'm not gonna send you sample org

Speaker:

charts because it's like asking me what kind of car should they buy?

Speaker:

I could tell you should buy Ferrari.

Speaker:

You should buy minivan.

Speaker:

Both of those could be completely wrong.

Speaker:

So what we tell our clients is, let's start with your business objectives.

Speaker:

What are you trying to achieve as a company?

Speaker:

And then what are the marketing objectives associated with those business objectives?

Speaker:

Which by the way, gets back into the purpose conversation

Speaker:

we were just talking about.

Speaker:

Once you've defined your marketing objectives, what

Speaker:

resources do you have available?

Speaker:

Can you realistically achieve those objectives with the

Speaker:

resources that you have available?

Speaker:

It's only then that you can really start to build the org chart.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Looking at sample org charts before you've thought through company objectives,

Speaker:

marketing objectives, resources, you could design the perfect org chart, but

Speaker:

it's not relevant to what your business is actually trying to achieve and the

Speaker:

resources that you have available.

Speaker:

So we always like to guide clients through that process.

Speaker:

The other thing we find with a lot of our clients is, and this is a

Speaker:

habit of executives generally, it's not just limited to marketers, is

Speaker:

we spend so much time thinking about the reorganization that when it comes

Speaker:

time to announce it, we are fatigued already about it as the leader.

Speaker:

Because we've been planning this for maybe a few months before the announcement,

Speaker:

and so we finally announce it and we're like, [deep sigh] catch our breath.

Speaker:

We finally got this organizational announcement out.

Speaker:

Guess what?

Speaker:

That's when the communications need to actually ramp up because now you've gotta

Speaker:

manage that change in the communication.

Speaker:

So one of the things we really try to guide our clients on is the reorganization

Speaker:

doesn't stop at the announcement.

Speaker:

The reorganization continues for a period of time afterwards.

Speaker:

And the success of the reorganization is more dependent on that than it is on

Speaker:

the quality of what you've announced.

Speaker:

It's like a product launch.

Speaker:

We have so much more we could talk about, but I am excited for people to

Speaker:

check out the research that you've been doing and to chat with you further.

Speaker:

And thank you again for joining me, Matt.

Speaker:

Yeah, I would suggest to people find me on LinkedIn.

Speaker:

I post Forrester research fairly regularly.

Speaker:

It may be a blog or a short snippet 'cause our full reports are only accessible to

Speaker:

clients, but we do try to make at least some key aspects of our research available

Speaker:

outside of the paywall, so to speak.

Speaker:

And all of us at Forrester have bios, as well, on our Forrester websites.

Speaker:

So you can see our blogs from those bios, and you can see our

Speaker:

research we're writing as well.

Speaker:

Great.

Speaker:

All right.

Speaker:

Thank you so much, Matt.

Speaker:

You're welcome.

Speaker:

Pleasure being here.

Speaker:

That was Matt Selheimer, VP and Research Director for B2B

Speaker:

marketing executives at Forrester.

Speaker:

Thanks for listening to The Get.

Speaker:

I'm your host, Erica Seidel.

Speaker:

The Get is here to drive smart decisions around recruiting and

Speaker:

leadership in B2B SaaS marketing.

Speaker:

We explore the trends, tribulations, and triumphs of today's top

Speaker:

marketing leaders in B2B SaaS.

Speaker:

If you liked this episode, please share it with your friends, or rank

Speaker:

it on your podcast platform of choice.

Speaker:

For more about The Get, visit TheGetPodcast.com.

Speaker:

To learn more about my executive search practice, which focuses on recruiting the

Speaker:

make-money marketing leaders, rather than the make-it-pretty ones, follow me on

Speaker:

LinkedIn or visit TheConnectiveGood.com.

Speaker:

The Get is produced by Evo Terra and the team at Simpler Media Productions.