1 00:00:00,080 --> 00:00:03,200 Hey there and welcome to Cut and Tell. I'm Liz Malphrus. I'm a 2 00:00:03,200 --> 00:00:06,160 newly minted plastic surgeon in Philadelphia. And this season 3 00:00:06,240 --> 00:00:09,240 is all about arming you with the health policy knowledge that 4 00:00:09,240 --> 00:00:12,440 you need to be an advocate for your patients and just as importantly, 5 00:00:12,440 --> 00:00:21,640 for yourself in this crazy healthcare system. Okay, y', all, 6 00:00:21,640 --> 00:00:23,800 it's time to get down to business with this learning health 7 00:00:23,800 --> 00:00:26,960 policy thing that we're going to do together. Okay? And this first 8 00:00:26,960 --> 00:00:30,200 episode is actually, it's one of my. One of my least favorite things, 9 00:00:30,200 --> 00:00:32,860 honestly, is history. But I got to tell you, you. The history 10 00:00:32,860 --> 00:00:36,780 that I'm going to share with you in this episode, I once I learned 11 00:00:36,780 --> 00:00:39,220 about it, I think about it all the time. Like, I think about this 12 00:00:39,220 --> 00:00:43,500 stuff at least once a week because I truly believe that the 13 00:00:43,500 --> 00:00:47,060 history that we're going to talk about today, this is the root 14 00:00:47,060 --> 00:00:50,020 of the problem. Like, this is where it all began. These are like 15 00:00:50,020 --> 00:00:53,820 the core issues that we, I think, as a profession have never 16 00:00:53,820 --> 00:00:57,820 really dealt with. It's like our, it's our professional deep seated 17 00:00:57,900 --> 00:01:02,140 trauma that we've forgotten about that we are never going to 18 00:01:02,380 --> 00:01:07,240 move past unless we talk about it. Okay? And so despite this, I'm 19 00:01:07,240 --> 00:01:10,200 not a dates person, not a places person. Could not tell you 20 00:01:10,360 --> 00:01:13,480 dates of world wars. Like, I literally, this is just stuff that 21 00:01:13,480 --> 00:01:17,000 doesn't go in my brain. But this stuff, I promise you it's gonna 22 00:01:17,000 --> 00:01:19,200 be interesting, it's gonna be important and it's gonna shed some 23 00:01:19,200 --> 00:01:23,000 major light on why our system is so broken, how we got here. The 24 00:01:23,000 --> 00:01:25,640 big thing that I mean when I talk about the history being so important 25 00:01:25,720 --> 00:01:29,800 is that this history is how the culture of our profession was 26 00:01:29,800 --> 00:01:34,840 established. And it goes way back. And while culture in this way, 27 00:01:34,840 --> 00:01:38,580 it's harder and to measure than so much of what we do in healthcare 28 00:01:38,580 --> 00:01:41,620 and think about in healthcare today. But I really think that it's 29 00:01:41,620 --> 00:01:44,820 the most powerful force in this story and something we need 30 00:01:44,820 --> 00:01:48,300 to pay more attention to. A lot of what I'm going to talk about 31 00:01:48,300 --> 00:01:51,819 today comes from one book that I really think is so important. I've 32 00:01:51,819 --> 00:01:54,540 recommended it before. It's the Social Transformation of American 33 00:01:54,540 --> 00:01:57,740 Medicine by Paul Starr. I would encourage everyone to read 34 00:01:57,740 --> 00:02:01,500 it. And I think this episode today will give you an idea of like, 35 00:02:01,500 --> 00:02:03,940 sort of why I think this book is powerful. And it's really about 36 00:02:04,100 --> 00:02:07,610 connecting the culture of medicine today with what happened 37 00:02:07,610 --> 00:02:12,970 in the past. So let's start with a question. What is doctoring 38 00:02:12,970 --> 00:02:18,850 anyway? Is it a calling? Is it a trade? Is it a job? Is it a public 39 00:02:18,850 --> 00:02:22,770 service? This is kind of a silly question, but when you go back 40 00:02:22,770 --> 00:02:25,810 and look at the origins of our profession, these are the questions 41 00:02:25,810 --> 00:02:28,890 that they were dealing with, trying to sort out. And the reality 42 00:02:28,890 --> 00:02:32,340 is medicine is kind of its own thing. Like, it's kind of a little 43 00:02:32,340 --> 00:02:34,940 bit of all of those things. And that is a lot of where the tension, 44 00:02:34,940 --> 00:02:37,900 I think, in terms of how medicine works in our society comes 45 00:02:37,900 --> 00:02:41,860 from. So if we go back to 19th century American medicine, this is 46 00:02:41,860 --> 00:02:46,900 like very early roots, not an organized system yet at all. And 47 00:02:46,900 --> 00:02:49,700 there also really wasn't much like real medicine to be had. You 48 00:02:49,700 --> 00:02:52,380 know, like, we're talking about leeches and bloodletting and 49 00:02:52,380 --> 00:02:55,900 like, you know, like poultices. This is not. This is definitely 50 00:02:55,900 --> 00:02:59,820 before we had any defensible ground to stand on, that we were 51 00:02:59,820 --> 00:03:03,120 actually helping people in a meaningful way, but we were trying. 52 00:03:03,120 --> 00:03:06,760 In 19th century American medicine, there were no fixed prices. 53 00:03:07,160 --> 00:03:10,960 The way that any kind of compensation tended to work for health 54 00:03:10,960 --> 00:03:14,960 care would basically be bartering. So, like, you know, you 55 00:03:14,960 --> 00:03:17,840 go help the farmer and they give you some eggs, or like, you 56 00:03:17,840 --> 00:03:20,080 know, you go help the lawyer and they like, you know, get you 57 00:03:20,080 --> 00:03:22,960 out of your ticket for parking your carriage in the wrong place 58 00:03:22,960 --> 00:03:26,040 or something. I don't know. It also tended to be based on this idea 59 00:03:26,040 --> 00:03:30,000 of ability to pay. So if you're someone with resources, you 60 00:03:30,000 --> 00:03:33,330 were kind of expected to be, to be able to pay more. You probably 61 00:03:33,330 --> 00:03:35,850 got a higher level of service. Like, you know, you think back to 62 00:03:36,010 --> 00:03:40,250 the doctors you see in period pieces of pop culture, like say Downton 63 00:03:40,250 --> 00:03:43,810 Abbey or like Deadwood or something. That guy coming over to 64 00:03:43,810 --> 00:03:45,730 see you, like, you know, you know, they're, they're tossing him 65 00:03:45,730 --> 00:03:48,690 a tip of some kind. Most healthcare at that point was not 66 00:03:48,690 --> 00:03:51,690 happening in clinics or hospitals like we think of it today. 67 00:03:52,170 --> 00:03:54,770 Healthcare was happening in people's homes, at least if you were 68 00:03:54,770 --> 00:03:58,170 a person of means. The only people who were getting healthcare 69 00:03:58,170 --> 00:04:01,690 in those early days in any kind of institution were people who 70 00:04:01,690 --> 00:04:04,710 had no other options. We're talking people with like, like truly 71 00:04:04,790 --> 00:04:08,190 the very bottom of our society. People who just had nothing 72 00:04:08,190 --> 00:04:11,190 else, nowhere else to go, no, no one else to care for them, no 73 00:04:11,190 --> 00:04:15,430 family, no money. Like that is who was getting care in any kind 74 00:04:15,430 --> 00:04:19,389 of facility. And often that was under the auspices of a church 75 00:04:19,389 --> 00:04:21,870 or a charity. Some of this persists today. Like, we certainly 76 00:04:21,870 --> 00:04:24,910 do have some, you know, hospital systems that are associated 77 00:04:24,910 --> 00:04:27,510 with the Catholic Church or with other religious institutions, 78 00:04:28,150 --> 00:04:31,190 but doctoring in those institutions was very much about 79 00:04:31,190 --> 00:04:34,110 an act of service. So if doctors were working in institutions 80 00:04:34,110 --> 00:04:38,130 in those time period, it was much more about an act of service. 81 00:04:38,210 --> 00:04:40,810 Like, you were doing it because you felt called to help these 82 00:04:40,810 --> 00:04:45,090 people and you were not expecting much in return. In fairness, 83 00:04:45,090 --> 00:04:49,330 though, medicine really did not have much to offer people in 84 00:04:49,330 --> 00:04:52,010 those days. Like, again, if we call back, like, think about whatever 85 00:04:52,010 --> 00:04:55,410 period drama you've watched from this time period, like, like, 86 00:04:55,410 --> 00:04:59,210 this is how it goes. The, the poor woman in the corset, she passes 87 00:04:59,210 --> 00:05:02,650 out, she takes to her bed, and then they call the doctor and like, 88 00:05:02,650 --> 00:05:06,370 she almost always dies, okay? And like, that is probably pretty 89 00:05:06,370 --> 00:05:10,110 acc. Calling a doctor in that time was sort of like calling a priest. 90 00:05:10,110 --> 00:05:12,830 Like, you probably called a priest around the same time, because 91 00:05:12,830 --> 00:05:15,670 you weren't really getting doctors involved until things were 92 00:05:15,670 --> 00:05:19,310 really dire. And once you had them involved, like, the odds of 93 00:05:19,310 --> 00:05:22,830 anything, anyone getting better were very low. And like, people 94 00:05:22,830 --> 00:05:26,750 kind of knew that that just was how society worked. And it's 95 00:05:26,750 --> 00:05:28,950 not like the person, the doctor who would come to your house 96 00:05:28,950 --> 00:05:32,310 was like a learned professional necessarily. A lot of 97 00:05:32,310 --> 00:05:35,270 times these people had had some kind of apprenticeship. Like, 98 00:05:35,270 --> 00:05:38,310 maybe they're a botanist. Like, this is like, not in no way 99 00:05:38,310 --> 00:05:40,630 a standardized profession. You did not know what you were going 100 00:05:40,630 --> 00:05:43,950 to get. Basically, you got a person who would come to your house 101 00:05:44,110 --> 00:05:46,830 who said that they might be able to help, and you tried. You. 102 00:05:46,830 --> 00:05:48,790 You gave them the chance to help, and that's really about it. 103 00:05:48,790 --> 00:05:51,710 And while I think through a lot of American history, we think 104 00:05:51,710 --> 00:05:55,310 of doctors having been like a trusted part of society in these 105 00:05:55,310 --> 00:06:00,470 early days, doctors were not necessarily a trusted group. Honestly, 106 00:06:00,470 --> 00:06:03,310 a lot of grifters in the mix. They also, they just did not have 107 00:06:03,310 --> 00:06:06,310 much esteem in our society. So, like, if you look at wages at 108 00:06:06,310 --> 00:06:09,150 the time, like in the early 1800s, doctors at that time were 109 00:06:09,690 --> 00:06:12,930 earning like, a little bit more than an unskilled laborer. Like, 110 00:06:12,930 --> 00:06:16,050 this was definitely not a prestige profession. And the kind 111 00:06:16,050 --> 00:06:19,610 of respect that society had for doctors, though, it's sort of 112 00:06:19,610 --> 00:06:23,210 reflects that. When we're talking about prestige, it's always 113 00:06:23,210 --> 00:06:25,930 worth looking at what the Ivy Leagues were up to, because Ivy Leagues 114 00:06:25,930 --> 00:06:29,010 were around at this time. So if you look at Ivy League graduates 115 00:06:29,010 --> 00:06:33,610 From this early 1800s period, only about 8% of people chose to 116 00:06:33,610 --> 00:06:38,090 go into medicine. That's relative to 25% going into law and 117 00:06:38,170 --> 00:06:42,440 25% going into clergy. And so if you think about it this, you know, 118 00:06:42,440 --> 00:06:45,480 I think nowadays we think of medicine and law as being on, like, 119 00:06:45,480 --> 00:06:48,560 sort of closer to equal footing in terms of societal, like, 120 00:06:48,560 --> 00:06:51,320 esteem or like, how these professions are perceived. That was 121 00:06:51,320 --> 00:06:54,840 not the case back then. So how do we pull ourselves out of that? 122 00:06:54,840 --> 00:06:57,800 Like, how did we go from being this, like, kind of lowly profession 123 00:06:57,800 --> 00:07:00,760 with not a lot to offer to this period of time where doctors 124 00:07:00,760 --> 00:07:05,040 really became leaders in society. So imagine you're one of 125 00:07:05,040 --> 00:07:07,680 these early, like, quote, unquote, doctors of the time, and 126 00:07:08,000 --> 00:07:10,840 you, you think you deserve more. Okay, you look around, say 127 00:07:10,840 --> 00:07:14,060 you look at the lawyers, look at the clergy. Both of these groups 128 00:07:14,060 --> 00:07:17,140 are achieving a better position in society, but through 129 00:07:17,140 --> 00:07:20,340 very different means. So think about clergy. They got like, you 130 00:07:20,340 --> 00:07:23,460 know, garments. They have this like, authority from on high. They 131 00:07:23,460 --> 00:07:26,100 don't necessarily get paid that much, but people do respect 132 00:07:26,100 --> 00:07:28,299 them and they're con. They're really a part of people's lives. 133 00:07:28,700 --> 00:07:31,580 Law, on the other hand, this was a totally different thing. Law, 134 00:07:31,740 --> 00:07:35,860 very much that profession approached this as like, we are tradesmen. 135 00:07:35,860 --> 00:07:40,060 Like, we lawyers, we provide a service. We are paid for that service, 136 00:07:40,060 --> 00:07:43,260 and we do it very well, you know, and these were two really very 137 00:07:43,260 --> 00:07:47,120 different kind of examples that were existing in the time that 138 00:07:47,120 --> 00:07:49,880 doctors could potentially follow. And I would argue this is 139 00:07:49,880 --> 00:07:53,480 one of the main, like, forks in the road that has led to a lot 140 00:07:53,480 --> 00:07:56,440 of the kind of downstream effects that we even see today. Because 141 00:07:56,440 --> 00:07:59,480 doctors, they chose that clergy route. They didn't follow 142 00:07:59,480 --> 00:08:05,280 the lawyers. Think about it. We got, we got robes, we got a noble 143 00:08:05,280 --> 00:08:08,720 calling, we got laying on of hands. We have a lot, honestly of 144 00:08:08,720 --> 00:08:12,200 the same features of clergy. And maybe this is like a little bit 145 00:08:12,200 --> 00:08:16,680 dark, but kind of like clergy medicine didn't have a predictable 146 00:08:16,680 --> 00:08:20,160 thing that it could offer you at that time, and the outcomes were 147 00:08:20,160 --> 00:08:24,080 much less predictable, you know, and that's a little bit similar 148 00:08:24,320 --> 00:08:28,880 to clergy in that, you know, they provide these intangible benefits 149 00:08:28,880 --> 00:08:31,159 primarily. I don't want to make this about religion, but just, 150 00:08:31,159 --> 00:08:34,000 you understand me, right? Like, there's a little bit of a magicalness 151 00:08:34,000 --> 00:08:37,800 to both of these in those early days. So I would argue, and 152 00:08:37,800 --> 00:08:41,960 I, I think I see this argument and Starr's book as well, that this 153 00:08:41,960 --> 00:08:45,760 early move towards becoming a noble profession, kind of like clergy, 154 00:08:45,760 --> 00:08:49,860 was really a coping mechanism for a profession that wanted to gain 155 00:08:49,860 --> 00:08:53,620 social status but really didn't have that much of a leg to 156 00:08:53,620 --> 00:08:56,700 stand on. It was kind of a big old fake it till you make it scheme. 157 00:08:56,700 --> 00:08:58,980 And while I think I'm certainly a big fan of the fake it 158 00:08:58,980 --> 00:09:01,780 till you make it strategy, but it really has a different flavor 159 00:09:01,780 --> 00:09:04,380 when you look back on it in this context. Because if you thought 160 00:09:04,380 --> 00:09:07,540 that Doctors were like, out there early. Doctors were like healing 161 00:09:07,540 --> 00:09:11,780 people and like doing science and like, that's why people respected 162 00:09:11,780 --> 00:09:15,610 them because of their results. That is very much not true. If you 163 00:09:15,610 --> 00:09:18,810 look at the timeline, a lot of that kind of respect and like moral 164 00:09:18,810 --> 00:09:23,610 authority preceded any kind of actual tangible societal benefit 165 00:09:23,610 --> 00:09:27,170 that they were offering. So I just want to pause for a second here 166 00:09:27,170 --> 00:09:29,569 because this is something that I, I've even like mentioned this 167 00:09:29,569 --> 00:09:31,530 before, I think, on the podcast. Like, let's just do, as 168 00:09:31,530 --> 00:09:35,370 a thought experiment, what if doctors had tried to model themselves 169 00:09:35,370 --> 00:09:40,620 at this point after lawyers instead of after clergy? Lawyers 170 00:09:40,620 --> 00:09:43,660 at the time had a very clear scheme with a lot of transparency. 171 00:09:44,140 --> 00:09:48,020 You, you pay them for their time and their attention and they 172 00:09:48,020 --> 00:09:51,220 defend you in a court of law. And it was much more cut and dry 173 00:09:51,220 --> 00:09:54,020 than what doctors were doing. I don't think anybody questions today 174 00:09:54,020 --> 00:09:58,100 in society that a lawyer's time has a dollar value. In fact, 175 00:09:58,100 --> 00:10:01,460 if you talk to lawyers today, this is only intensified, like every 176 00:10:01,460 --> 00:10:05,380 single minute, or at least every 15 minute increment of a lawyer's 177 00:10:05,380 --> 00:10:10,860 time is tracked. And it has a certain price to it. I definitely, 178 00:10:10,860 --> 00:10:13,500 I, this is a little bit my personal, my personal feeling about 179 00:10:13,500 --> 00:10:16,220 it, but I, I would say that lawyers are still a respected part 180 00:10:16,220 --> 00:10:19,860 of our society. Maybe you would say a little bit less so than 181 00:10:19,860 --> 00:10:22,940 doctors, but again, I think that's kind of a judgment call. But 182 00:10:22,940 --> 00:10:26,980 I will say that the benefit of this, the fact that lawyers position 183 00:10:27,060 --> 00:10:30,460 themselves as providing a service in an economy, as being part 184 00:10:30,460 --> 00:10:33,780 of an economy, it has led to them being much more successful in 185 00:10:33,780 --> 00:10:36,960 protecting their profession. And I'm going to come back to this 186 00:10:36,960 --> 00:10:39,720 topic several times. I think the lawyer comparison is very informative 187 00:10:39,800 --> 00:10:43,480 and sort of highlights how some of these very early moves in 188 00:10:43,480 --> 00:10:46,560 terms of how medicine developed as a kind of institution 189 00:10:46,560 --> 00:10:49,680 and a culture, really have all these ramifications that we still 190 00:10:49,680 --> 00:10:53,640 see today. Okay, so to kind of like sum up where we are right now, 191 00:10:53,640 --> 00:10:58,400 if you read Starr's book, one of his major arguments is that medicine 192 00:10:58,400 --> 00:11:02,080 as a profession built its authority, which he calls professional 193 00:11:02,080 --> 00:11:06,330 sovereignty. They did that by building themselves as something 194 00:11:06,330 --> 00:11:10,810 distinct from commerce. Medicine is a calling. Medicine is 195 00:11:10,810 --> 00:11:14,810 an act of service. Medicine from this lens from these early days 196 00:11:14,810 --> 00:11:17,930 was very much not a business. In fact, it was kind of positioning 197 00:11:17,930 --> 00:11:21,850 itself as anti business. It's about taking care of people. Like 198 00:11:21,850 --> 00:11:24,530 the clergy is taking care of your soul. You're taking care of 199 00:11:24,530 --> 00:11:27,570 the body. That was the sort of like initial way that we approached 200 00:11:27,570 --> 00:11:31,650 this. And doctors used in those early days that professional 201 00:11:31,650 --> 00:11:36,650 Sovereignty, to have respect and authority in society. And that 202 00:11:36,650 --> 00:11:39,610 is where the power comes from, not from the money. So for me, I 203 00:11:39,610 --> 00:11:43,130 really think that Star is onto something and that this is where. 204 00:11:43,130 --> 00:11:45,530 This is me, like, taking a leap kind of beyond what he said. 205 00:11:45,530 --> 00:11:48,730 But stick with me. This, I think, is where the seeds were laid 206 00:11:48,730 --> 00:11:52,890 for a lot of our problems that we have today. There's this uneasy 207 00:11:52,970 --> 00:11:57,210 kind of, like, root of all of this that boils down to that. We 208 00:11:57,450 --> 00:12:01,450 as a society, I think, on both sides, both in medicine and just 209 00:12:01,450 --> 00:12:05,660 from a patient perspective, we're not comfortable with the concept 210 00:12:05,900 --> 00:12:10,180 of paying for healthcare. Doctors don't want to have to charge 211 00:12:10,180 --> 00:12:12,660 people because, again, we're in this profession of, like, you 212 00:12:12,660 --> 00:12:14,420 know, we're here to, like, help you. We're here to, like, make 213 00:12:14,420 --> 00:12:17,940 you whole. And who could. How could you put a price on that? And 214 00:12:17,940 --> 00:12:21,420 they also don't want to be like, especially early doctors, it's 215 00:12:21,420 --> 00:12:23,340 hard to say that you're doing something out of the goodness of 216 00:12:23,340 --> 00:12:26,300 your heart and then also track somebody down if they don't pay you. 217 00:12:26,300 --> 00:12:29,340 You just kind of can't have it both ways. Patience on the other 218 00:12:29,340 --> 00:12:33,100 side, I think if you're offering them something akin to salvation, 219 00:12:33,100 --> 00:12:36,500 if you're saying, I can make you whole again, I don't think most 220 00:12:36,500 --> 00:12:39,420 people feel like they should have to pay for that. Like, if you 221 00:12:39,420 --> 00:12:43,460 can save their life, how dare you not? You know? So I think there's 222 00:12:43,460 --> 00:12:47,020 this really deep discomfort on both sides with this being an economic 223 00:12:47,260 --> 00:12:50,100 transaction. Like, think about it. Like, there's an interesting 224 00:12:50,100 --> 00:12:52,140 history here, too, that I'm not going to dive into. But, like, 225 00:12:52,140 --> 00:12:54,620 imagine like, a fire truck comes to your house because your 226 00:12:54,620 --> 00:12:57,510 house is on fire, and they stop and they're like, hey, lady, 227 00:12:57,510 --> 00:13:00,670 like, until you pay us, we're gonna just let it burn like that. 228 00:13:00,670 --> 00:13:02,910 That's not gonna work in our society. And I think in general, 229 00:13:02,990 --> 00:13:05,590 our society views doctors kind of like that. Like, we're more like 230 00:13:05,590 --> 00:13:09,550 the firemen. We're not the lawyers. The problem is that today 231 00:13:10,270 --> 00:13:14,910 medicine is big business, y'. All. Medicine is a fifth of our gdp. 232 00:13:15,070 --> 00:13:20,190 It is. It's a huge. It's so much money. And this core problem 233 00:13:20,190 --> 00:13:23,030 we have never dealt with. We're uncomfortable exchanging money 234 00:13:23,030 --> 00:13:25,750 for healthcare. And a lot of the complexity. We're gonna talk 235 00:13:25,750 --> 00:13:27,900 about a lot of all these things, systems that we've put in 236 00:13:27,900 --> 00:13:31,780 place around healthcare that, like, make it, honestly, so challenging 237 00:13:31,780 --> 00:13:35,940 and difficult and onerous. It's all a route, I think, about 238 00:13:35,940 --> 00:13:39,180 hiding the fact that doctors are getting paid to treat patients, 239 00:13:40,300 --> 00:13:43,060 because that's an idea that makes both sides uncomfortable. To 240 00:13:43,060 --> 00:13:46,100 try to allow doctors and patients to both live in this kind 241 00:13:46,100 --> 00:13:51,420 of fantasy world that they're not in an economy. So I think a lot 242 00:13:51,420 --> 00:13:55,620 of this complexity comes down more or less to this. This discomfort 243 00:13:55,620 --> 00:13:58,780 we have with this paradox at the center of the healthcare system 244 00:13:59,100 --> 00:14:02,900 where everybody is uncomfortable with the idea that 245 00:14:02,900 --> 00:14:05,220 they're going to pay for healthcare and doctors are uncomfortable 246 00:14:05,220 --> 00:14:09,700 as well getting paid for healthcare. But as we'll see in future 247 00:14:09,700 --> 00:14:13,900 episodes, this just makes us very vulnerable to anyone who wants 248 00:14:13,900 --> 00:14:17,620 to come in and try to make that money that nobody else feels 249 00:14:17,620 --> 00:14:21,460 comfortable taking off the table. But okay, I also want to talk 250 00:14:21,460 --> 00:14:23,900 a little bit about, like, obviously we have these roots where 251 00:14:24,470 --> 00:14:27,350 medicine was not respected, but we had a long period in American 252 00:14:27,350 --> 00:14:30,110 history where doctors absolutely were respected. Doctors 253 00:14:30,110 --> 00:14:33,270 were members of Congress. They were like major players in our society, 254 00:14:33,270 --> 00:14:37,510 very well respected and often very wealthy. So like, how did we 255 00:14:37,750 --> 00:14:41,230 do this thing where for a while, I think early doctors found 256 00:14:41,230 --> 00:14:45,550 a way to have their cake and eat it too on this question. They 257 00:14:45,550 --> 00:14:48,630 got to be revered for their selflessness and their acts of courage 258 00:14:48,630 --> 00:14:52,150 and acts of service, but also got to be paid kind of like the cultural 259 00:14:52,150 --> 00:14:55,370 elites that they basically lift as. One of the earliest, biggest, 260 00:14:55,370 --> 00:14:58,690 like concrete successes in this space was credentialing. And 261 00:14:58,690 --> 00:15:02,770 credentialing use now just, I just like to remind everybody, credentialing 262 00:15:02,770 --> 00:15:05,730 is essentially just another term for gatekeeping. That's what 263 00:15:05,730 --> 00:15:09,570 this is about. Our first attempt as a nation at setting up 264 00:15:09,570 --> 00:15:13,370 a system for credentialing failed miserably. So very early on, 265 00:15:13,370 --> 00:15:17,610 like 18, early 1800s, 18, 10, 80, 20, we had gotten some momentum 266 00:15:17,610 --> 00:15:20,490 for this early kind of rudimentary credentialing system 267 00:15:20,570 --> 00:15:24,050 for doctors to set some kind of standards for what a doctor actually 268 00:15:24,050 --> 00:15:27,930 was. That ended up falling apart in the 30s and 40s. And basically 269 00:15:27,930 --> 00:15:31,130 that was like political context at the time was Jacksonian 270 00:15:31,130 --> 00:15:34,290 anti elitist sentiment. So doctors had kind of started to gather 271 00:15:34,290 --> 00:15:38,530 a little bit of this elite like reputation. And this was just 272 00:15:38,530 --> 00:15:42,330 a moment in our society where that was not cool anymore. And there 273 00:15:42,330 --> 00:15:45,730 are also were these really successful alternative medicine groups. 274 00:15:45,730 --> 00:15:48,210 So at some point we're going to do like a side history on alternative 275 00:15:48,210 --> 00:15:51,360 medicine because it's fascinating. But that was kind of 276 00:15:51,360 --> 00:15:54,080 just like we have that today that was going on back then too. 277 00:15:54,320 --> 00:15:58,080 And those groups are pretty successful at kind of challenging 278 00:15:58,080 --> 00:16:03,800 this idea that doctors got to own medicine and healthcare. So there's 279 00:16:03,800 --> 00:16:07,160 this point like in the 1840s or so where like, only about four 280 00:16:07,160 --> 00:16:10,160 or five states even had anything pretending to be credentialing. 281 00:16:10,400 --> 00:16:13,960 So during that time, you could just say you were a doctor, like, 282 00:16:13,960 --> 00:16:17,320 there was no one would stop you. And really anyone could just 283 00:16:17,320 --> 00:16:20,680 have whatever training or no training at all. So like an Ivy League 284 00:16:20,680 --> 00:16:24,560 trained, you know, doctor of the time could just had no additional 285 00:16:24,560 --> 00:16:27,720 standing, no further, like, kind of signals that they were a 286 00:16:27,720 --> 00:16:32,360 legitimate doctor than, like just a guy on the street. And mostly 287 00:16:32,360 --> 00:16:35,960 this worked because there were no consequences. Like, if there's 288 00:16:35,960 --> 00:16:39,200 no credentialing, if there's no enforcement mechanism, like if 289 00:16:39,200 --> 00:16:41,680 there's no rules, there's also no consequences. So people were really 290 00:16:41,680 --> 00:16:45,880 getting away with it. And as you can imagine, that led to some 291 00:16:45,880 --> 00:16:49,880 significant erosion at the time in that early trust that people 292 00:16:49,880 --> 00:16:52,200 had started to establish between doctors and patients. Because 293 00:16:52,200 --> 00:16:55,300 suddenly what the doctor and how are you as a patient to know 294 00:16:55,540 --> 00:17:00,580 who to trust? So this situation, this, like, kind of dissolution 295 00:17:00,580 --> 00:17:03,820 of our first attempt at credentialing set up a good argument 296 00:17:03,820 --> 00:17:07,420 for doctors at the time to seize on, actually make a really 297 00:17:07,420 --> 00:17:10,580 big move. So that set up this argument that we needed credentialing, 298 00:17:10,580 --> 00:17:13,820 we needed some kind of gatekeeping mechanism in order to 299 00:17:13,820 --> 00:17:18,340 protect people's safety. So this is the big move here. The American 300 00:17:18,340 --> 00:17:21,170 Medical association, an organization you're probably familiar 301 00:17:21,170 --> 00:17:24,570 with that I would argue operates very differently today than 302 00:17:24,570 --> 00:17:27,810 it did in the past. The AMA was actually a huge player in a lot 303 00:17:27,810 --> 00:17:30,850 of early moves around this, our profession, and kind of how it 304 00:17:30,850 --> 00:17:34,010 got established and I think is much less significant, much less 305 00:17:34,010 --> 00:17:38,170 powerful today. But back then, the AMA got to that, got together 306 00:17:38,170 --> 00:17:44,410 in 1847 and adopted a code of ethics. Note that this was the first 307 00:17:44,410 --> 00:17:48,330 code of ethics of any profession in American society ever. 308 00:17:48,330 --> 00:17:51,370 Like, if you look back, the. Like the American Board association, 309 00:17:51,370 --> 00:17:54,250 like the lawyers equivalent of the ama, they didn't get a code of 310 00:17:54,250 --> 00:17:59,090 ethics till, like, the 1880s. So, like, 40 years later, then when 311 00:17:59,090 --> 00:18:01,650 I say code of ethics, let me guess, you're probably thinking like, 312 00:18:01,650 --> 00:18:04,730 yeah, the Hippocratic oath, like all of those principles that 313 00:18:04,730 --> 00:18:08,170 we are all familiar with from med school, kind of. So like that, 314 00:18:08,170 --> 00:18:12,130 yes, that was part of it. But if you go back and look and I've 315 00:18:12,130 --> 00:18:13,930 gone and seen it, it's like, kind of interesting to read. This 316 00:18:13,930 --> 00:18:19,250 first 1847 code of ethics for doctors was much closer to a man 317 00:18:19,630 --> 00:18:22,950 guide, I would say, for how physicians should conduct themselves 318 00:18:22,950 --> 00:18:26,390 in our society. And to a lesser extent, was it about, like, 319 00:18:26,390 --> 00:18:28,990 how you should conduct yourself in the treatment of patients. 320 00:18:29,630 --> 00:18:33,030 So a lot of what was in there was actually more about how doctors 321 00:18:33,030 --> 00:18:36,870 should interact with other doctors. Because while, you know, 322 00:18:36,870 --> 00:18:39,270 safety is, I think the argument they used and kind of the 323 00:18:39,270 --> 00:18:42,630 justification for this at a societal level, the reality is that 324 00:18:42,630 --> 00:18:46,340 a lot of the motivation for these individuals was this really 325 00:18:46,340 --> 00:18:50,740 intense infighting among doctors over, like, who gets which 326 00:18:50,740 --> 00:18:53,340 patient. So think about this at the. At the time we're talking, 327 00:18:53,340 --> 00:18:56,580 like, this is a time of, like, country doctor. You got, like some 328 00:18:56,580 --> 00:19:00,060 little town. They got one doctor. Imagine that a second doctor 329 00:19:00,060 --> 00:19:03,900 moves into town, or worse yet, some guy who says he's a doctor, 330 00:19:03,900 --> 00:19:07,380 and you went to, like, you know, Columbia, and they went nowhere. 331 00:19:07,540 --> 00:19:10,780 Like, this is a problem. You can imagine how that could. That 332 00:19:10,780 --> 00:19:14,140 situation could quickly become a big problem, especially for the 333 00:19:14,140 --> 00:19:17,920 people in that group who viewed themselves as like, the right 334 00:19:17,920 --> 00:19:21,120 ones, as the. The doctor, like the real doctors, you know. So a 335 00:19:21,120 --> 00:19:24,440 lot of it like this, this early one included a prohibition 336 00:19:24,440 --> 00:19:28,560 on advertising that actually held basically until, like, the 1980s. 337 00:19:28,960 --> 00:19:32,120 And that was, again, that was that, like, country doctor who had 338 00:19:32,120 --> 00:19:34,760 someone moving in on their turf and taking all their patients 339 00:19:34,760 --> 00:19:37,680 away. It even included rules about, like, physicians having to, 340 00:19:37,680 --> 00:19:40,920 like, take care of each other and each other's families as, like, 341 00:19:40,920 --> 00:19:45,490 an ethical obligation. It also was, and this is, I mean, this is 342 00:19:45,490 --> 00:19:48,410 partly just the times, but very paternalistic. A lot of the 343 00:19:48,410 --> 00:19:51,770 ideas in this document as well are very much focused on, like, this 344 00:19:51,770 --> 00:19:55,090 doctor knows best idea. Like, this whole, like, movement that we've 345 00:19:55,090 --> 00:19:59,090 had now today towards, like, patient centered care, towards patients 346 00:19:59,090 --> 00:20:02,410 having rights. Like, they did not have that in the early days. 347 00:20:02,730 --> 00:20:06,250 What this, what the early code of ethics actually said is that patients 348 00:20:06,250 --> 00:20:11,570 have an obligation to obey their physicians. So if you take 349 00:20:11,570 --> 00:20:14,650 a step back and think about this, like, why. Why a code of ethics. 350 00:20:15,130 --> 00:20:18,130 Code of ethics weren't a thing then. Okay? Y', all, like, they invented 351 00:20:18,130 --> 00:20:21,370 this new concept out of nothing. They could just as easily 352 00:20:21,530 --> 00:20:24,290 have had a code of science of some kind. Like, to say that you 353 00:20:24,290 --> 00:20:27,770 needed to be following, like, whatever science of the day. That's 354 00:20:27,770 --> 00:20:31,370 not what this was. This also was not about setting standards for 355 00:20:31,370 --> 00:20:33,690 training or for the kind of knowledge. It's not some, like, test 356 00:20:33,690 --> 00:20:36,690 you gotta take. Like, you can imagine them. That could have been 357 00:20:36,690 --> 00:20:39,170 a strategy as well. If what you're concerned about is safety, 358 00:20:39,880 --> 00:20:43,320 it also is not in any way about penalties or any legal means 359 00:20:43,320 --> 00:20:47,160 for enforcing anything. Okay? This is very much. This is like a 360 00:20:47,160 --> 00:20:50,800 gentleman's agreement. And the main focus of it, in reality, was 361 00:20:50,800 --> 00:20:53,280 about physicians and how physicians should conduct themselves 362 00:20:53,280 --> 00:20:56,880 with other physicians. And it called for etiquette and courtesy 363 00:20:56,880 --> 00:21:00,920 and restraint. So this, this, like this early code of ethics, this 364 00:21:00,920 --> 00:21:03,800 founding of the American Medical association, this is a big 365 00:21:03,800 --> 00:21:07,000 part of how medicine became a legitimate profession in society. 366 00:21:07,830 --> 00:21:10,550 So not through showing that what they do works, not through, 367 00:21:10,550 --> 00:21:13,630 like, laws that punish people who are doing bad things. It was 368 00:21:13,630 --> 00:21:17,430 really this self policing of behaviors and norms and through basically 369 00:21:17,430 --> 00:21:21,590 this complete abandonment of any economic considerations in this 370 00:21:21,590 --> 00:21:26,110 community's work. So the profession, the doctors, this group, 371 00:21:26,110 --> 00:21:28,910 the American Medical association, they're the ones who 372 00:21:28,910 --> 00:21:33,920 get to define what medicine is. Not the market, not the state, 373 00:21:34,560 --> 00:21:38,440 and not the patient. And the reason that we are deciding to trust 374 00:21:38,440 --> 00:21:42,080 doctors to do this is because they lack economic entanglements. 375 00:21:42,080 --> 00:21:44,880 So part of what Starr says, or part of what he argues in his book, 376 00:21:44,960 --> 00:21:48,200 is the early success of, like, how these people kind of saved our 377 00:21:48,200 --> 00:21:51,960 profession from being just totally dissolved into, like, random, 378 00:21:51,960 --> 00:21:55,200 you know, like snake oil salesmen. Basically, it was through 379 00:21:55,440 --> 00:22:00,290 deciding to police themselves and at the same time rejecting the 380 00:22:00,290 --> 00:22:03,890 idea that this was a commercial enterprise. And it worked, 381 00:22:03,890 --> 00:22:06,450 y'. All. Like, it worked. It worked for a really long time. Like 382 00:22:06,450 --> 00:22:09,530 these early. It's. It's amazing to me to look back on, because 383 00:22:09,530 --> 00:22:13,410 I think that a lot of us think of our profession as being founded 384 00:22:13,410 --> 00:22:17,570 on science. That's not really what it's. I think that medicine 385 00:22:17,570 --> 00:22:21,370 was founded on anymore. It was founded on this idea of becoming 386 00:22:21,370 --> 00:22:24,250 this profession with a certain set of standards for how they behave. 387 00:22:24,890 --> 00:22:30,090 And then fortunately, over time, we gained this real authority, 388 00:22:30,090 --> 00:22:33,530 or what I would call a more real authority, based on the science 389 00:22:33,530 --> 00:22:37,850 that we use to support how we. How we. What we do for patients and 390 00:22:38,250 --> 00:22:40,690 how we kind of present ourselves to society. But that was 391 00:22:40,690 --> 00:22:44,810 not there at the start. And if you think about it, this. I think 392 00:22:44,810 --> 00:22:47,290 this is the key problem is, like, that's all well and good. Like, 393 00:22:47,290 --> 00:22:51,290 sure, it worked. We made medicine into a profession that was 394 00:22:51,290 --> 00:22:56,240 respected, but you still. We still need money to survive. Especially 395 00:22:56,240 --> 00:22:59,000 if you want this to be an elite profession, then you need an 396 00:22:59,000 --> 00:23:01,880 elite level of money to make this work and to make this actually 397 00:23:01,880 --> 00:23:05,640 thrive. Because if you want. If you want those graduates who are 398 00:23:05,640 --> 00:23:08,480 looking at clergy and looking at law, you want them to choose medicine, 399 00:23:08,960 --> 00:23:11,520 you need to be able to offer them a life that's going to match 400 00:23:11,520 --> 00:23:15,440 those in a lot of ways. And if we as a society, like, especially 401 00:23:15,440 --> 00:23:18,440 as science became more of something real that actually was 402 00:23:18,440 --> 00:23:21,630 prolonging people's lives, if we want our best and brightest to 403 00:23:21,630 --> 00:23:24,670 go into that, you got to make it worth doing. And it can't all 404 00:23:24,670 --> 00:23:27,390 be intangibles. I think back then, a lot of it was intangibles. 405 00:23:27,390 --> 00:23:31,830 But over time, you need to also give them money. And I feel 406 00:23:31,830 --> 00:23:36,670 that this contradiction, this paradox of how to get paid for something 407 00:23:36,830 --> 00:23:41,470 that is a mission, that is a calling, I think that we've never 408 00:23:41,470 --> 00:23:45,070 really gotten past this. And I think it's why, in a lot of ways, 409 00:23:45,070 --> 00:23:48,630 we have the complicated mess we have today and why I think a lot 410 00:23:48,630 --> 00:23:51,780 of doctors are made uncomfortable to even, like, think 411 00:23:52,010 --> 00:23:55,850 about it or talk about it. But we need to talk about it, y', all, 412 00:23:55,850 --> 00:23:59,130 because this is. This is. This is where the. This is where kind 413 00:23:59,130 --> 00:24:02,210 of the whole problem starts. And so as we go, the next episodes 414 00:24:02,210 --> 00:24:04,890 are going to be much more tangible, much more about, like, 415 00:24:04,890 --> 00:24:07,330 learning about specific concepts and specific ideas and, 416 00:24:07,330 --> 00:24:10,370 like, kind of how the system works today. But I want you to keep 417 00:24:10,370 --> 00:24:15,450 in mind these roots, because this is the foundation. This is where 418 00:24:15,450 --> 00:24:18,990 it all came from. And I think in a lot of ways, it's rotted, or 419 00:24:18,990 --> 00:24:21,830 at the very least, it's eroded away enough that it doesn't serve 420 00:24:21,830 --> 00:24:25,630 us as it did in the past. So part of what I want to do through 421 00:24:25,630 --> 00:24:29,870 this series is express to you why I think this is a crisis by showing 422 00:24:29,870 --> 00:24:33,510 you evidence of what I think is going on here and by helping you 423 00:24:33,990 --> 00:24:37,310 have a clearer picture of, like, this machine that's operating 424 00:24:37,310 --> 00:24:40,230 around you all the time. Because I think until we are willing 425 00:24:40,230 --> 00:24:43,270 as a profession to open our eyes and look at this stuff and recognize 426 00:24:43,270 --> 00:24:46,660 that it matters and that we need to engage with it, I think we're 427 00:24:46,660 --> 00:24:49,500 going to continue to lose in our society. So, whatever. If you're 428 00:24:49,500 --> 00:24:51,660 in clinical medicine, I just want you to think about this concept 429 00:24:51,660 --> 00:24:57,060 today. Do you think that you individually are uncomfortable with 430 00:24:57,060 --> 00:25:03,460 the concept that you're getting paid to help people? And 431 00:25:03,460 --> 00:25:07,100 do you see systems around you that you think might be designed 432 00:25:07,500 --> 00:25:11,140 to hide the fact from you and from your patient that this is an 433 00:25:11,140 --> 00:25:15,250 economic interaction? Because whatever else you're doing with that 434 00:25:15,250 --> 00:25:19,450 patient in that room, money is exchanging hands. It's not exchanging 435 00:25:19,450 --> 00:25:23,170 it directly, but it's exchanging hands. And that is affecting 436 00:25:23,170 --> 00:25:26,410 how your patient feels about you. And that even if. Even if you 437 00:25:26,410 --> 00:25:28,890 know that that money isn't going directly into your hand, it's 438 00:25:28,890 --> 00:25:32,170 passing through a lot of other people's pockets. First, just remember 439 00:25:32,170 --> 00:25:34,610 that the patient doesn't know that, like, the patient is paying 440 00:25:34,610 --> 00:25:39,460 a lot of money, and you're the only person they see. And I feel 441 00:25:39,460 --> 00:25:42,020 strongly that if we're ever going to move forward in this system. 442 00:25:42,020 --> 00:25:45,620 If we're ever going to regain all that autonomy that we've lost, 443 00:25:46,020 --> 00:25:49,420 we need to grapple with the fact that we are in an economy. We 444 00:25:49,420 --> 00:25:53,300 are huge. We are a huge part of an economic engine. And if we're 445 00:25:53,300 --> 00:25:57,500 not willing to kind of accept this fact that we get paid to provide 446 00:25:57,500 --> 00:26:01,860 healthcare, other people will continue to make money off of us 447 00:26:02,500 --> 00:26:07,950 and off of our patients, and in so doing, continue to erode the 448 00:26:07,950 --> 00:26:11,430 trusting relationship that underlies American healthcare in 449 00:26:11,430 --> 00:26:15,470 the first place. Thank you for listening to Cut and Tell. If you 450 00:26:15,470 --> 00:26:18,110 enjoyed this episode, and especially if you know anybody else 451 00:26:18,110 --> 00:26:21,430 who needs like a little health policy, health, economics, medicine, 452 00:26:21,750 --> 00:26:24,310 please send this episode to them. Rate and review us. I love 453 00:26:24,310 --> 00:26:27,070 to read the reviews and then check out all of our other amazing 454 00:26:27,070 --> 00:26:30,070 shows and content at hippocratic-collective.com.