1 00:00:01,040 --> 00:00:05,484 You're about to join Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on a raw and honest 2 00:00:05,484 --> 00:00:09,524 journey into the world of systematic investing and learn about 3 00:00:09,524 --> 00:00:13,160 the most dependable and consistent yet often overlooked investment 4 00:00:13,160 --> 00:00:15,988 strategy. Welcome to the Systematic Investor series. 5 00:00:26,890 --> 00:00:29,948 Welcome and welcome back to this week's edition of the Systematic 6 00:00:29,948 --> 00:00:32,728 Investor series with Andrew Beer, and Tom Wrobel, and myself, 7 00:00:32,728 --> 00:00:35,786 Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, where each week we take the pulse of the 8 00:00:35,786 --> 00:00:38,566 global markets through the lens of a rules-based investor. Andrew 9 00:00:38,566 --> 00:00:42,180 and Tom, it's great to have you both here. It's been a while, 10 00:00:42,180 --> 00:00:46,072 but how are you doing? Tom, I'll start with you. I know you were 11 00:00:46,072 --> 00:00:47,740 traveling last night, so you must… 12 00:00:49,050 --> 00:00:53,432 Yeah, very well, thanks Niels. Very well. I was in, I was in Sweden 13 00:00:53,432 --> 00:00:57,188 and it was interesting to see how attitudes to hedge funds seem 14 00:00:57,188 --> 00:00:59,066 to be slowly shifting, maybe, there. 15 00:00:59,650 --> 00:01:02,926 I'm sure we'll talk about that. Andyourself, Andrew, how are 16 00:01:01,990 --> 00:01:02,926 you doing? 17 00:01:03,250 --> 00:01:07,267 Things are good. Things are good. We had a great year end, you 18 00:01:07,267 --> 00:01:10,666 know, multi person session and it'll be very interesting to talk 19 00:01:10,666 --> 00:01:14,065 about things that have happened in just the past six weeks, 20 00:01:14,065 --> 00:01:17,155 which seems like it's been about six months of activity. 21 00:01:17,490 --> 00:01:21,162 I know, I know, it's crazy. Anyway, we've got, actually, a pretty 22 00:01:21,162 --> 00:01:24,528 strong lineup of various topics as you said. Some of that 23 00:01:24,528 --> 00:01:28,200 will be inspired from what we talked about in the group conversations 24 00:01:28,200 --> 00:01:32,178 and maybe also some new stuff that we normally don't talk so much 25 00:01:32,178 --> 00:01:36,156 about in this specific series. But of course, as we always do, I'm 26 00:01:36,156 --> 00:01:39,828 always curious to know kind of what's been on your radar, what's 27 00:01:39,828 --> 00:01:43,806 caught your attention the last few weeks. I'm going to kick it off 28 00:01:43,806 --> 00:01:46,866 with you, Andrew. Anything in particular that you’ve been noticing? 29 00:01:47,710 --> 00:02:00,970 Well, I mean, I think, look, it's not an original topic at all. 30 00:02:00,970 --> 00:02:13,210 I'm totally fascinated with AI and how the narrative around it is 31 00:02:13,210 --> 00:02:25,450 shifting. I mean, some recent things and just in terms of both 32 00:02:25,450 --> 00:02:38,710 the power of it, but also the pace at which things are changing. 33 00:02:38,710 --> 00:02:52,990 I'm not an expert at all and I'm sort of realizing that, you know, 34 00:02:52,990 --> 00:03:05,230 part of what I need to be thinking about more actively, in 35 00:03:05,230 --> 00:03:16,450 terms of myself and our strategy as a business, is really 36 00:03:16,450 --> 00:03:25,630 where AI fits into it as it's evolving now. Fortunately,I have 37 00:01:50,158 --> 00:01:59,134 a couple of partners who are extraordinarily capable at it. So, 38 00:01:59,134 --> 00:02:08,926 it's not that we're not focused on it but, but there was 39 00:02:08,926 --> 00:02:16,270 something interesting that happened recently where our PR firm 40 00:02:16,270 --> 00:02:26,878 … Usually I I'm very, very involved in anything that we do that 41 00:02:26,878 --> 00:02:36,670 goes out into the public domain. And while I was very distracted 42 00:02:36,670 --> 00:02:45,646 on other things, in December, they basically took podcasts of mine, 43 00:02:45,646 --> 00:02:56,254 as well as material that we had done, and did a killer two-minute 44 00:02:56,254 --> 00:03:06,862 video that I'll release in the next day or two that basically… But 45 00:03:06,862 --> 00:03:17,470 it's my voice, but it's my AI generated voice. The content is incredible 46 00:03:17,470 --> 00:03:25,630 by people who really are not experts in this field. So,for me, 47 00:01:52,159 --> 00:02:06,989 it sort of encapsulated that there's something very, very profound 48 00:02:06,989 --> 00:02:23,302 in this. And so, you know, watching what's happening in the 49 00:02:23,302 --> 00:02:41,098 markets and how people are trying to figure this out, I think 50 00:02:41,098 --> 00:02:58,894 it's going to be disruption galore and I believe that that is 51 00:02:58,894 --> 00:03:13,724 actually going to be very, very positive for trend following. 52 00:03:13,724 --> 00:03:25,588 We need real economic change to make money. 53 00:03:25,730 --> 00:03:29,344 As long as you promise there's always going to be the real Andrew 54 00:03:29,344 --> 00:03:32,124 that shows up on the podcast and not AI Andrew. 55 00:03:32,210 --> 00:03:35,807 So, my theory is that people who actually have human connections 56 00:03:35,807 --> 00:03:39,404 to other people in this, like the asset management business is 57 00:03:39,404 --> 00:03:42,674 a people business. I don't think asset allocators are going 58 00:03:42,674 --> 00:03:46,925 to say, you know what, let's have AI pick the next hedge fund 59 00:03:46,925 --> 00:03:51,503 for me. I think it's too risky and it honestly takes all the fun 60 00:03:51,503 --> 00:03:55,427 out of the business. But I think understanding the ways in which 61 00:03:55,427 --> 00:03:59,351 it can be leveraged and I think this is what everyone's going 62 00:03:59,351 --> 00:04:03,602 to be thinking about for the next 20 years, and seeing it happen 63 00:04:03,602 --> 00:04:06,545 in real time, it's just, you know, endlessly fascinating. 64 00:04:06,990 --> 00:04:17,370 It's interesting. Just before we hit record, I asked Tom if he 65 00:04:17,370 --> 00:04:27,750 was going to the iConnections conference in Miami in a couple of 66 00:04:27,750 --> 00:04:39,860 weeks. And both Tom and I will be there. So of course, if anybody's 67 00:04:39,860 --> 00:04:50,240 listening and they have a lot of money to allocate, they should 68 00:04:50,240 --> 00:04:57,160 definitely reach out to us in the app. But,but having said that, 69 00:04:09,380 --> 00:04:15,594 it kind of is interesting with what you say because here you have 70 00:04:15,594 --> 00:04:19,418 probably the largest conference where you put together 71 00:04:19,418 --> 00:04:24,676 5,000 people or whatever the number is in one convention center 72 00:04:24,676 --> 00:04:31,846 for two or three days. So, you can either say AI is going to either 73 00:04:31,846 --> 00:04:37,104 completely change that and nobody really needs to go to these 74 00:04:37,104 --> 00:04:42,840 events, or it's going to strengthen it and say no, as you 75 00:04:42,840 --> 00:04:48,098 say, Andrew, we do need the personal connections. We do need 76 00:04:48,098 --> 00:04:54,312 to sit down physically and talk, and so on, and so forth. Very 77 00:04:54,312 --> 00:04:57,180 hard to tell at this stage. 78 00:04:59,200 --> 00:05:06,999 Yeah, look, one of my favorite investors sent me something they'd 79 00:05:06,999 --> 00:05:16,216 done last night where they basically used AI to do a whole asset 80 00:05:16,216 --> 00:05:24,015 allocation analysis. And he said it took him about 15 minutes, 81 00:05:24,015 --> 00:05:31,814 and the results are pretty astonishing. And one thing that was 82 00:05:31,814 --> 00:05:39,613 actually kind of encouraging about it is that it actually did 83 00:05:39,613 --> 00:05:47,412 say, all right, if you want to achieve these investment objectives, 84 00:05:47,412 --> 00:05:55,920 it brought managed futures is one of the core elements of doing 85 00:05:55,920 --> 00:05:56,629 that. So,you know, there's a way in which the promulgation of 86 00:05:06,218 --> 00:05:13,236 this kind of technology and knowledge will also, you know, help 87 00:05:13,236 --> 00:05:19,616 the average allocator to be more sophisticated about the space, 88 00:05:19,616 --> 00:05:28,548 to cut through a lot of the noise in the space, which is what, 89 00:05:28,548 --> 00:05:36,842 you know, I think you and your guests do incredibly well. And so, 90 00:05:36,842 --> 00:05:44,498 I mean, look, everything's going to be… You know, the only constant 91 00:05:44,498 --> 00:05:52,792 is change. And seeing how it plays out in all the various manifestations, 92 00:05:52,792 --> 00:05:56,620 I think it's just incredibly interesting. 93 00:05:56,670 --> 00:06:02,676 I don't think it's the same investor, but I have a client as 94 00:06:02,676 --> 00:06:08,682 well who's AI savvy and he sent me something a couple of months 95 00:06:08,682 --> 00:06:14,226 ago where he had given two or three different AI platforms kind 96 00:06:14,226 --> 00:06:19,308 of a question about asset allocation for the next five, seven 97 00:06:19,308 --> 00:06:25,314 years, based on the fact that he was based in Switzerland and this 98 00:06:25,314 --> 00:06:31,320 is what he was looking for. And as you say, not necessarily specifically 99 00:06:31,320 --> 00:06:35,016 mentioning any strategies as far as I remember. Andthat also 100 00:06:00,507 --> 00:06:14,576 came back with a fairly large allocation to trend following. So, 101 00:06:14,576 --> 00:06:29,924 the information must be out there since they are picking up on 102 00:06:29,924 --> 00:06:35,040 it. So, that's interesting. 103 00:06:35,940 --> 00:06:39,040 My one-line response, after reading his analysis, was super intelligence 104 00:06:39,040 --> 00:06:41,210 this year because I like the conclusion. 105 00:06:43,310 --> 00:06:46,610 Anyways, Tom, I mentioned that you'd been traveling. Not sure that's 106 00:06:46,610 --> 00:06:50,210 what's really been on your radar, but what has been on your 107 00:06:50,210 --> 00:06:51,710 radar the last few weeks? 108 00:06:52,510 --> 00:07:13,630 Yeah, it's really been many discussions with investors and managers 109 00:07:13,630 --> 00:07:43,198 around the shift away from the US dollar and from the US in general, 110 00:07:43,198 --> 00:08:08,542 I think. Global markets really did change in 2025, and the perception 111 00:08:08,542 --> 00:08:31,774 as investors is that the period of US exceptionalism is maybe 112 00:08:31,774 --> 00:08:33,930 over. Imean,in April, Liberation Day really hit markets. 113 00:07:05,182 --> 00:07:24,894 We did end up with a fantastic recovery in 2025. The S&P ended up 114 00:07:24,894 --> 00:07:41,790 16%. But was the conclusion that the US has won at capitalism? 115 00:07:41,790 --> 00:08:00,094 I think, for a US investor, based in US dollars, that's a fair 116 00:08:00,094 --> 00:08:18,398 enough conclusion. But for the rest of the world, you can't go back 117 00:08:18,398 --> 00:08:33,886 to the same state where American assets are all that matters. 118 00:06:52,510 --> 00:08:33,930 Ithinkthe risk in the US is perceived as potentially higher than 119 00:07:11,893 --> 00:07:29,785 it was previously, and the rest of the world is now clearly 120 00:07:29,785 --> 00:07:43,204 looking at the country's markets through an entirely different 121 00:07:43,204 --> 00:07:56,623 lens. Normally you have non-American investors can rely on 122 00:07:56,623 --> 00:08:18,988 the US dollar to rise in times of stress, and the US dollar is enjoyed 123 00:08:18,988 --> 00:08:33,898 the status of being a safe haven currency for assets. Butfor 124 00:06:55,014 --> 00:07:07,534 non-domestic investors in 2025, the weakening of the US dollar 125 00:07:07,534 --> 00:07:22,558 meant that actually a Euro investor with the same S&P 500 investment 126 00:07:22,558 --> 00:07:35,078 was up just 2.50% last year and, actually, potentially negative 127 00:07:35,078 --> 00:07:48,850 for other indices. So, I don't think investors are necessarily looking 128 00:07:48,850 --> 00:08:01,370 to sell American investments or avoid them entirely. It's just 129 00:08:01,370 --> 00:08:15,142 a rethinking of what assets investors are holding and a real 130 00:08:15,142 --> 00:08:31,418 kind of analysis of US risk and how they choose to engage with 131 00:08:31,418 --> 00:08:33,922 that risk. 132 00:08:35,290 --> 00:08:38,170 As a completely selfish observation, here in Switzerland, 133 00:08:38,170 --> 00:08:41,770 the Swiss National Bank distributes some of its profits every 134 00:08:41,770 --> 00:08:46,450 year, I think to all the cantons. And, of course, it is well 135 00:08:46,450 --> 00:08:50,050 known for having huge investments in the US tech stocks, 136 00:08:50,050 --> 00:08:55,090 and so on, and so forth. So, I hope someone is listening and maybe 137 00:08:55,090 --> 00:08:57,610 reconsidering that strategy if you're right, Tom. 138 00:08:58,620 --> 00:09:03,300 Well, there's two things to think about. I think there's a very 139 00:09:03,300 --> 00:09:07,200 valid argument that global equity markets don't have the capacity 140 00:09:07,200 --> 00:09:11,490 for a wholesale shift in investor assets away from the US. 141 00:09:11,490 --> 00:09:15,390 But there's definitely a thought about, outside of tech, what 142 00:09:15,390 --> 00:09:20,460 is the asset that we're accessing in the US and can we get 143 00:09:20,460 --> 00:09:21,240 it elsewhere? 144 00:09:21,650 --> 00:09:24,900 Yeah, well, we're going to talk a little bit about that. I know 145 00:09:24,900 --> 00:09:28,150 Andrew has some topics on that. But on my radar, a few things 146 00:09:28,150 --> 00:09:31,150 that caught my attention. But the first thing is more a question 147 00:09:31,150 --> 00:09:34,650 for you, and that is, of course, we are in the middle of the 148 00:09:34,650 --> 00:09:37,400 Winter Olympics. So, I'm curious to know if you have like 149 00:09:37,400 --> 00:09:40,650 a favorite sport that you are watching or that you want to make 150 00:09:40,650 --> 00:09:43,650 sure you are going to watch in the next couple of weeks? 151 00:09:44,930 --> 00:09:59,386 So, I've gotten very down on the Olympics in that, you know, one 152 00:09:59,386 --> 00:10:13,842 is I don't think you should have 37 events per sport. I sort 153 00:10:13,842 --> 00:10:28,298 of grew up in an era when the Olympics was special because you 154 00:10:28,298 --> 00:10:42,754 had people who were, you know, toiling as waiters in at ski lodges 155 00:10:42,754 --> 00:10:59,434 and that yet were finding six hours a day to ski and to kind of 156 00:10:59,434 --> 00:11:04,994 compete at the international level. Therewas something very… 157 00:09:51,742 --> 00:10:12,178 This was their moment. Right? Every four years you had this opportunity 158 00:10:12,178 --> 00:10:34,317 to become a Mark Spitz or a Bruce Jenner or somebody who goes 159 00:10:34,317 --> 00:10:51,347 from total obscurity to becoming kind of a national hero, 160 00:10:51,347 --> 00:11:04,971 you know, the American hockey team in 1980. Andit's a little bit 161 00:09:49,280 --> 00:09:58,850 like in US sports where they've added more and more playoffs 162 00:09:58,850 --> 00:10:07,550 because they're very, very high generative. And here, I was 163 00:10:07,550 --> 00:10:16,250 at the gym this morning and watching some snowboarding competition. 164 00:10:16,250 --> 00:10:26,690 But it could be snowboarding, you know slash V1, you know, whatever, 165 00:10:26,690 --> 00:10:36,260 whatever, like some subset, and then also with the barrage of 166 00:10:36,260 --> 00:10:44,090 promotion around individual athletes and the elevation of them, 167 00:10:44,090 --> 00:10:57,140 to me it's just lost a lot of the special quality to it. But that's 168 00:10:57,140 --> 00:11:04,970 going to make me sound incredibly old and cranky. 169 00:11:05,330 --> 00:11:06,290 What about you, Tom? 170 00:11:06,610 --> 00:11:11,074 In the UK we don't have many snowy mountains or frozen lakes. 171 00:11:11,074 --> 00:11:15,910 So, for us it still has that special element, I think. I'm definitely 172 00:11:15,910 --> 00:11:19,258 following the curling. The curling is quite interesting. All 173 00:11:19,258 --> 00:11:23,722 the curling stones are still made in Scotland, so it's very exciting. 174 00:11:23,722 --> 00:11:29,302 And we seem to be very good at the luge and the sliding events so 175 00:11:29,302 --> 00:11:32,650 we're definitely following that. But you're right Andrew, there's 176 00:11:32,650 --> 00:11:37,486 never been a time for interest in niche sports as around the Olympics. 177 00:11:37,980 --> 00:11:59,190 I hate to break it to you but, actually, one of the things that 178 00:11:59,190 --> 00:12:15,855 caught my attention, that I'm really looking forward to, is actually 179 00:12:15,855 --> 00:12:35,550 one of the new sports at the Winter Olympics. They call it ski 180 00:12:35,550 --> 00:12:50,700 mo, but it's actually ski mountaineering where they first have 181 00:12:50,700 --> 00:13:08,880 to climb the mountain before they ski down. I'm very excited to 182 00:13:08,880 --> 00:13:30,090 see what that is going to be like. That seems like a fun thing 183 00:13:30,090 --> 00:13:51,300 to do. But, in general, I kind of know what you're getting at Andrew, 184 00:13:51,300 --> 00:14:04,935 in terms of too many things doing the same. Anyways,more interesting, 185 00:11:43,560 --> 00:12:04,020 from a financial point of view, something that caught my attention. 186 00:12:04,020 --> 00:12:28,200 I don't know if you saw this, but Google has issued 100-year bonds 187 00:12:28,200 --> 00:12:50,520 I think this week. I thought that's kind of interesting. I mean 188 00:12:50,520 --> 00:13:12,840 I don't know what that tells us about their expectation of interest 189 00:13:12,840 --> 00:13:31,440 rates if they're issuing 100-year bonds at these levels. But 190 00:13:31,440 --> 00:13:48,180 that apparently has not happened since 1997 where Motorola 191 00:13:48,180 --> 00:14:04,920 issued a 100-year bond. So, that is pretty rare. Andthen the 192 00:11:45,093 --> 00:12:11,174 other thing that caught my attention, I kind of quickly shared 193 00:12:11,174 --> 00:12:44,368 it with you. It was a little bit unfair because it was with short 194 00:12:44,368 --> 00:13:12,820 notice. But it's just this email that I received from Dan Rasmussen 195 00:13:12,820 --> 00:13:46,014 over at Verdad. And I don't know Dan at all, but I know he's 196 00:13:46,014 --> 00:14:04,982 involved in kind of the private equity world. Buthe was 197 00:11:47,778 --> 00:12:23,704 writing an email about some of the differences between hedge funds 198 00:12:23,704 --> 00:13:02,896 and private equity, and the heading was Why Hedge Funds Got Better 199 00:13:02,896 --> 00:13:42,088 While Private Equity Just Got Bigger. And I think there is some 200 00:13:42,088 --> 00:14:04,950 interesting aspects to that observation for sure. Mykey takeaway, 201 00:11:42,024 --> 00:11:59,548 and feel free to weigh in here, but my key takeaway was, if 202 00:11:59,548 --> 00:12:13,028 I remember correctly, that hedge funds, in his view, simply 203 00:12:13,028 --> 00:12:27,856 had to improve because of the competition and the attention that 204 00:12:27,856 --> 00:12:45,380 private equity was given by investors for so long, and to a large 205 00:12:45,380 --> 00:12:58,860 extent maybe, operating in liquid markets with mark to market. 206 00:12:58,860 --> 00:13:17,732 And all of those things that we do in the liquid alt space, for 207 00:13:17,732 --> 00:13:29,864 sure, basically meant that they became better managers, better 208 00:13:29,864 --> 00:13:43,344 structures, better processes, etc., etc. And I think that's kind 209 00:13:43,344 --> 00:13:59,520 of an interesting observation. I don't know if you agree with it 210 00:13:59,520 --> 00:14:04,912 or have another take. 211 00:14:08,200 --> 00:14:29,910 I think from our side, I think we see renewed interest in hedge 212 00:14:29,910 --> 00:14:51,620 funds kind of across the board. And part of it is people got 213 00:14:51,620 --> 00:15:11,660 out over their skis, to use an Olympic analogy, in their exposure 214 00:15:11,660 --> 00:15:33,370 to private equity. And the way people often would do it was that 215 00:15:33,370 --> 00:15:53,410 they would over commit to it with the expectation that they would 216 00:15:53,410 --> 00:16:08,440 get money back in a certain period of time. Andso, the fact 217 00:14:19,652 --> 00:14:51,145 that kind of the money coming back didn't really materialize while 218 00:14:51,145 --> 00:15:22,638 they still had the commitment outstanding meant a lot of allocators 219 00:15:22,638 --> 00:15:56,994 simply had too much exposure to it. And that's also driven kind 220 00:15:56,994 --> 00:16:08,446 of the secondaries market. Youknow, I think when you're in 221 00:14:15,578 --> 00:14:27,172 a persistently long bull market… And look, Dan has done great 222 00:14:27,172 --> 00:14:36,658 research on the return characters of private equity essentially 223 00:14:36,658 --> 00:14:47,198 being some version of leverage equity with the wonderful feature 224 00:14:47,198 --> 00:14:59,846 that you could pretend that there's… you don't have to mark things 225 00:14:59,846 --> 00:15:12,494 to market. I think now, when people are thinking about, all right, 226 00:15:12,494 --> 00:15:23,034 where equity market valuations are and what the expected returns 227 00:15:23,034 --> 00:15:37,790 are over the next 10 years, and leverage on top of it, and being 228 00:15:37,790 --> 00:15:50,438 up to their gills in things like software stocks that could be 229 00:15:50,438 --> 00:15:58,870 disrupted, maybe having long-term leverage, long equity exposure 230 00:15:58,870 --> 00:16:08,356 is not as attractive as it used to be. Andin a world where 231 00:14:16,110 --> 00:14:31,930 the macro environment is shifting, back to Tom's point about 232 00:14:31,930 --> 00:14:49,332 this migration, I wouldn't say it's a wholesale migration out of 233 00:14:49,332 --> 00:15:09,898 US assets. I would say that the attitude used to be FOMO about 234 00:15:09,898 --> 00:15:28,882 the US markets, and now has come to people saying, well, wait 235 00:15:28,882 --> 00:15:51,030 a second, this used to be the global bastion of rule of law around 236 00:15:51,030 --> 00:16:05,268 business activity, in terms of predictability, and clearly things 237 00:16:05,268 --> 00:16:08,432 have changed. Andso, you know, I think in the context of that, 238 00:14:27,648 --> 00:14:50,632 you think who has the ability to make money on a going forward 239 00:14:50,632 --> 00:15:11,848 basis? And then you point to the hedge fund industry, which has 240 00:15:11,848 --> 00:15:29,528 done… I mean, certain hedge funds have done astonishingly well 241 00:15:29,528 --> 00:15:47,208 in this environment. And so, that's drawing attention back to 242 00:15:47,208 --> 00:16:08,424 it, which ultimately, I think, will be good for all of us. 243 00:16:08,540 --> 00:16:11,020 Yeah. Do you come across private equity a lot, Tom? 244 00:16:11,980 --> 00:16:23,750 It's something we come across as discussions with investors because 245 00:16:23,750 --> 00:16:33,166 it's part of their alternatives portfolio, it's part 246 00:16:33,166 --> 00:16:46,113 of the portfolio allocation. And I think you're right, it's become 247 00:16:46,113 --> 00:17:01,414 a big part of what investors do. But we've been in an unbelievable 248 00:17:01,414 --> 00:17:15,538 environment for 15 years, more than 15 years. And is that environment 249 00:17:15,538 --> 00:17:24,954 going to persist for equities? We don't know. ButI think when I 250 00:16:17,510 --> 00:16:30,782 was last on the podcast, we were talking about the macro environment 251 00:16:30,782 --> 00:16:44,054 for, let's just sort of call it, global macro hedge funds. So, 252 00:16:44,054 --> 00:16:58,432 a hedge fund that can go into any asset class, deploy assets long/short, 253 00:16:58,432 --> 00:17:10,598 in a relative value kind of perspective, and take advantage of 254 00:17:10,598 --> 00:17:22,764 any kind of inefficiency. That environment for hedge funds has only 255 00:17:22,764 --> 00:17:24,976 gotten better. We'vegot stubborn inflation, we've got geopolitical 256 00:16:19,274 --> 00:16:27,610 dislocations and tensions, we've got commodities bursting back 257 00:16:27,610 --> 00:16:38,030 onto the asset class, which has been underappreciated, with compressed 258 00:16:38,030 --> 00:16:49,492 volatility for a long, long time. And we've got interest rates 259 00:16:49,492 --> 00:17:00,954 still relatively low, but higher than they've been for a long 260 00:17:00,954 --> 00:17:13,458 period. And it just looks like a very interesting time for tactical 261 00:17:13,458 --> 00:17:22,836 trading strategies that can deploy assets across markets long 262 00:17:22,836 --> 00:17:24,920 and short. 263 00:17:25,859 --> 00:17:51,898 Yeah, we'll dig into that some more. Let me just quickly run through 264 00:17:51,898 --> 00:18:15,934 where we are on the scoreboard, so to speak. My own trend 265 00:18:15,934 --> 00:18:35,964 barometer finished yesterday at 50, and that's still a pretty 266 00:18:35,964 --> 00:18:53,991 productive environment for trend following. And it has, more 267 00:18:53,991 --> 00:19:12,018 importantly, been very consistent the last few weeks as 268 00:19:12,018 --> 00:19:22,033 data also will be supporting. Thesenumbers are as of Tuesday of 269 00:17:36,849 --> 00:17:58,829 this week. And the TOP 50 is up 1.48 in February, up 6.58 for 270 00:17:58,829 --> 00:18:20,809 the year. The SocGen CTA index up 1.25 for the month, and up 6% 271 00:18:20,809 --> 00:18:41,219 or so for the year. SOcGen Trend Index up 1.65% for the month, 272 00:18:41,219 --> 00:19:00,059 up 6.43% for the year. And the SocGen Short-Term Traders Index up 273 00:19:00,059 --> 00:19:22,039 about half a percent so far in February, up 2.78% so far this year. 274 00:17:25,859 --> 00:17:52,667 Andin the traditional world, MSCI World up 94 basis points in 275 00:17:52,667 --> 00:18:21,709 February, up 3.22% so far. The S&P US Aggregate Bond Index up 41 276 00:18:21,709 --> 00:18:50,751 basis points in Feb and up 60 basis points in 2026. And finally, 277 00:18:50,751 --> 00:19:22,027 S&P 500 is pretty flat for February, up 1 1/2% so far this year. 278 00:17:25,859 --> 00:19:22,040 Iwaswondering before we go and step back a little bit, I mean 279 00:17:41,805 --> 00:17:55,473 maybe we talk a little bit about your own review, Tom, that 280 00:17:55,473 --> 00:18:10,280 you put out in the last day or two, this more comprehensive look 281 00:18:10,280 --> 00:18:27,365 at 2025. But I wanted to also ask you a little bit (and of course, 282 00:18:27,365 --> 00:18:41,033 Andrew, you can jump in as well) about the first six, seven 283 00:18:41,033 --> 00:18:52,423 weeks so far this year have obviously been very constructive, 284 00:18:52,423 --> 00:19:04,952 clearly continuing where we left off in 2025. Is there something 285 00:19:04,952 --> 00:19:18,620 about the new year that you're noticing, Tom, that you find particularly 286 00:19:18,620 --> 00:19:22,037 interesting or anything? 287 00:19:23,050 --> 00:19:38,395 Well, I think understanding 2025 performance, and the second 288 00:19:38,395 --> 00:19:55,445 half of the year in particular, does help us understand 289 00:19:55,445 --> 00:20:15,905 what the beginning of 2026 looks like. Because one of the conclusions 290 00:20:15,905 --> 00:20:34,660 we came to when we were writing and analyzing what happened 291 00:20:34,660 --> 00:20:51,710 last year was that performance and opportunities for trend following 292 00:20:51,710 --> 00:21:12,170 came from a really kind of diverse number of markets. We obviously 293 00:21:12,170 --> 00:21:27,515 saw standout performance from metals. And precious metals, again, 294 00:21:27,515 --> 00:21:47,975 this year they have been a key performance driver, but it wasn't 295 00:21:47,975 --> 00:21:51,385 just metals. Andit's interesting hearing about your trend 296 00:19:38,317 --> 00:20:00,127 barometer because we run a similar exercise where we calculate 297 00:20:00,127 --> 00:20:24,118 breakout models over almost, I think, 200 or 500 different parameters 298 00:20:24,118 --> 00:20:45,928 from very short-term to super long-term, across all different markets 299 00:20:45,928 --> 00:21:09,919 that are sort of potentially tradeable by CTAs. And, on average 300 00:21:09,919 --> 00:21:33,910 last year the Z scores, the opportunity sets, similar to your 301 00:21:33,910 --> 00:21:51,358 kind of barometer, I think was pretty poor. So,last year your selection 302 00:19:32,320 --> 00:19:54,568 of asset classes and the way you allocated risk and managed risk 303 00:19:54,568 --> 00:20:09,400 was really, really important because there weren't opportunities 304 00:20:09,400 --> 00:20:27,940 broadly across all equity markets and all currencies and all 305 00:20:27,940 --> 00:20:50,188 bonds. In fact bonds was really poor last year. So, what we've 306 00:20:50,188 --> 00:21:12,436 seen I think this year is a continuation of that theme where 307 00:21:12,436 --> 00:21:32,830 we've got really important market trends and if you're not trading 308 00:21:32,830 --> 00:21:51,370 those markets, you're going to be missing out on something. So,I 309 00:19:26,758 --> 00:19:47,152 think last year, for the second year in a row, commodities 310 00:19:47,152 --> 00:20:09,400 was one of the key performance drivers, and 2024 was very similar 311 00:20:09,400 --> 00:20:33,502 but it wasn't coming from the same place. In 2024 we saw trends 312 00:20:33,502 --> 00:20:53,896 in the softs commodities, so, cocoa, coffee as well as precious 313 00:20:53,896 --> 00:21:14,290 metals. In 2025 it's really been the precious metals that have 314 00:21:14,290 --> 00:21:32,830 been the key performance drivers. And if you weren't trading 315 00:21:32,830 --> 00:21:51,370 them, as I said, then that wasn't available to you. Butalso, 316 00:19:27,684 --> 00:19:53,171 there were some really, really strong trends in other markets and 317 00:19:53,171 --> 00:20:20,975 that's again continued this year. So, for this year, in our trend 318 00:20:20,975 --> 00:20:44,145 indicator, we're seeing really good trending markets in KOSPI, NIKKEI, 319 00:20:44,145 --> 00:21:14,266 the Swedish OMX and IBEX 35. So, these are sort of lesser, smaller 320 00:21:14,266 --> 00:21:35,119 European equity indices often that aren't necessarily the go-to 321 00:21:35,119 --> 00:21:51,338 financial markets that people are looking at. 322 00:21:52,791 --> 00:21:58,263 It's funny you say this thing about yeah, if you weren't trading 323 00:21:58,263 --> 00:22:03,735 all these markets like the softs and some of the other metals 324 00:22:03,735 --> 00:22:09,663 you would be missing out. But not if your name is Andrew because 325 00:22:09,663 --> 00:22:16,047 he does not trade them. But he did not miss out last year, that's 326 00:22:16,047 --> 00:22:17,871 all I can say. Butlet's, let's stay with this year and then 327 00:22:00,072 --> 00:22:09,780 we'll maybe dive a little bit deeper into your report, Tom, but 328 00:22:09,780 --> 00:22:17,870 anything, any thoughts from your side, Andrew, for this year? 329 00:22:18,511 --> 00:22:39,013 CTAs generate alpha when they're early contrarian and right. 330 00:22:39,013 --> 00:23:06,349 The second half of last year they were dialing up equity risk 331 00:23:06,349 --> 00:23:26,851 after Liberation Day, they were holding their gold position. 332 00:23:26,851 --> 00:23:49,631 So, basically, from our perspective, you look at last year, 333 00:23:49,631 --> 00:24:10,133 it's gold and equities, and predominantly non-US equities, and 334 00:24:10,133 --> 00:24:30,635 it was either maintaining that exposure after Liberation Day. Now,human 335 00:22:23,903 --> 00:22:48,167 strategists, after Liberation Day, were really rattled and really 336 00:22:48,167 --> 00:23:20,519 wrong in that, you know, the inflation was suppose to come soaring 337 00:23:20,519 --> 00:23:58,263 back, we were going to go into a deep recession. I think the Bill 338 00:23:58,263 --> 00:24:17,135 Ackman used the term self-inflicted, nuclear, economic 339 00:24:17,135 --> 00:24:30,641 annihilation or something like that. Imeanpeople really thought… 340 00:22:29,901 --> 00:22:54,959 And this is, again, the enormous advantage of CTAs is they 341 00:22:54,959 --> 00:23:24,573 don't care, as long as they see it bouncing off the lows and 342 00:23:24,573 --> 00:23:54,187 however they end up measuring it or continuing a trend. And I think 343 00:23:54,187 --> 00:24:16,967 that's continued into this year. I think there's an arbitrary 344 00:24:16,967 --> 00:24:30,635 end date as of December 31st. Butlook, we started talking about 345 00:22:31,723 --> 00:22:55,945 a rotation to non-US equities. People have been talking about a 346 00:22:55,945 --> 00:23:15,763 fundamentally driven rotation into non-US equities for 15 years 347 00:23:15,763 --> 00:23:35,581 and it hasn't worked. It's consistently underperformed US equities. 348 00:23:35,581 --> 00:24:04,207 But it's been happening for the past couple of years, and I think 349 00:24:04,207 --> 00:24:30,631 it goes back to the risk premium issue that we talked about. 350 00:22:18,511 --> 00:22:36,196 Andon gold… Gold was a failed trade for a decade and a half. You 351 00:22:36,196 --> 00:22:52,702 know, it worked really well for a period of time. You had a lot 352 00:22:52,702 --> 00:23:05,671 of very, very smart people in 2010 expecting this profligate monetary 353 00:23:05,671 --> 00:23:20,998 policy to drive up gold. It didn't for a very, very long time. 354 00:23:20,998 --> 00:23:31,609 And, while most people had essentially abandoned the trade, 355 00:23:31,609 --> 00:23:48,115 look, in 2022 gold didn't go up, right? I mean, that was the moment 356 00:23:48,115 --> 00:24:01,084 everyone was waiting for in gold. Inflation's going to come back, 357 00:24:01,084 --> 00:24:18,769 and gold is going to pay off, and gold didn't go up in 2022. And 358 00:24:18,769 --> 00:24:30,559 then it starts soaring in 2024 for very different reasons. So,I 359 00:22:27,035 --> 00:23:13,917 don't think it's complicated. I think it's non-US equities, I think 360 00:23:13,917 --> 00:24:00,799 it's an emerging markets versus US equities, and I think it's 361 00:24:00,799 --> 00:24:30,633 gold which encapsulates the whole metals complex. 362 00:24:31,041 --> 00:24:54,321 Yeah, I mean it's been interesting for me to see, for example, 363 00:24:54,321 --> 00:25:19,541 and I know this is early days, right, but clearly the momentum in 364 00:25:19,541 --> 00:25:44,761 some of the key markets from 2025 spilled over to 2026. So, in 365 00:25:44,761 --> 00:26:06,101 January20, definitely the same themes in terms of leaders and of 366 00:26:06,101 --> 00:26:23,561 course precious medals, despite a massive sell-off, the last 367 00:26:23,561 --> 00:26:46,841 day of the month, still came out ahead for most managers, I'm 368 00:26:46,841 --> 00:26:48,781 sure. Butthe leadership has changed a little bit in February. 369 00:24:50,441 --> 00:25:13,721 It's not so much metals anymore. We seem to be shifting more 370 00:25:13,721 --> 00:25:35,061 towards equities in certain parts of the world, as you rightly 371 00:25:35,061 --> 00:25:58,341 pointed out. Nat gas has been more productive for sure. And even 372 00:25:58,341 --> 00:26:19,681 some of the currencies are starting to support, which it doesn't 373 00:26:19,681 --> 00:26:41,021 happen that often, but yeah. So, that's been kind of interesting 374 00:26:41,021 --> 00:26:48,781 for me to see. Now,Tom, I wanted to give you the chance to, 375 00:24:45,101 --> 00:24:59,161 if there were more, because it's a pretty comprehensive paper 376 00:24:59,161 --> 00:25:18,845 you just published. So, if you want to dig out some more of those 377 00:25:18,845 --> 00:25:34,311 things that you felt were really important. I know we will 378 00:25:34,311 --> 00:25:52,589 talk about some of the topics as well because we will dive into, 379 00:25:52,589 --> 00:26:08,055 I think, Andrew had sort of specifically gold, silver, you know, 380 00:26:08,055 --> 00:26:23,521 and some specific markets to talk about. But is there anything 381 00:26:23,521 --> 00:26:40,393 that stood out, when you wrote the report, you thought, wow, that 382 00:26:40,393 --> 00:26:48,829 actually did surprise me a bit. Andletme frame that, if you 383 00:24:44,250 --> 00:25:05,007 missed the last couple of episodes of this podcast, Tom. What 384 00:25:05,007 --> 00:25:29,538 I've said to people, when I've been speaking with them in the first 385 00:25:29,538 --> 00:25:54,069 few weeks of this year, was that in many respects, I think we 386 00:25:54,069 --> 00:26:18,600 can all agree, that last year was very unusual. We can say that 387 00:26:18,600 --> 00:26:37,470 about almost every year. But last year was another unexpected 388 00:26:37,470 --> 00:26:48,792 set of events that we saw. Yetfrom a trend following perspective, 389 00:24:41,121 --> 00:25:02,961 it was a very familiar year. Few markets did all the heavy lifting. 390 00:25:02,961 --> 00:25:26,481 Then you had a few markets that lost a little bit of money and 391 00:25:26,481 --> 00:25:48,321 you had a lot that didn't move much either/or. So, from a trend 392 00:25:48,321 --> 00:26:06,801 following perspective, I mean if you didn't know what took place 393 00:26:06,801 --> 00:26:25,281 during the year, you would just say, yeah, just another trend 394 00:26:25,281 --> 00:26:47,121 following year. Maybe a little bit on the low side. Okay, fair but 395 00:26:47,121 --> 00:26:48,801 yeah… 396 00:26:48,831 --> 00:27:07,011 I completely agree and I think that's why the conclusion that we 397 00:27:07,011 --> 00:27:23,676 came to, of the allocation of risk, was so important. Normally, 398 00:27:23,676 --> 00:27:41,856 we see some sort of speed factor, and I think Katy Kaminski's 399 00:27:41,856 --> 00:27:58,521 done some really interesting analysis on the speed factor in previous 400 00:27:58,521 --> 00:28:15,186 years, and we'd normally see a much stronger preference for longer-term 401 00:28:15,186 --> 00:28:28,821 models outperforming. But it's the classic sort of contradiction 402 00:28:28,821 --> 00:28:43,971 about how you marry your investors who maybe can't always 403 00:28:43,971 --> 00:29:00,636 look at the performance with such a long-term lens versus the 404 00:29:00,636 --> 00:29:17,301 performance of models there where you can sort of show, systematically, 405 00:29:17,301 --> 00:29:30,936 that being longer-term and into longer-term trends does pay 406 00:29:30,936 --> 00:29:32,451 off. So,it's really the allocation of risk, last year, that 407 00:27:09,031 --> 00:27:37,311 was the key thing and how you managed that risk. And we were monitoring 408 00:27:37,311 --> 00:27:59,531 performance this year as those trends continued. I think the trend 409 00:27:59,531 --> 00:28:23,771 index peaked at 7% as you correctly said, it's now at 6.5%. 410 00:28:23,771 --> 00:28:43,971 But the range of the individual manager returns is still 411 00:28:43,971 --> 00:29:10,231 pretty the same. So, I think the best trend followers are up about 412 00:29:10,231 --> 00:29:32,511 nearly 15% and still there are some up nearly that amount. Ithinkthat's 413 00:26:53,946 --> 00:27:09,291 on a slightly higher volatility target than many, but 414 00:27:09,291 --> 00:27:33,161 we still have many managers in that 10% to 15% range and many just 415 00:27:33,161 --> 00:27:58,736 hovering just below the 10% in sort of 8% or 9%. So, CTAs have definitely 416 00:27:58,736 --> 00:28:19,196 allocated risk and managed risk very well. If you want to see 417 00:28:19,196 --> 00:28:36,246 what un-risk managed approach to trend following looks like, please 418 00:28:36,246 --> 00:29:00,116 ask us for the data on the SG Trend Indicator which is our hypothetical 419 00:29:00,116 --> 00:29:13,756 model-based portfolio, with very limited risk management. And 420 00:29:13,756 --> 00:29:29,101 you'll see some very interesting swings in the precious 421 00:29:29,101 --> 00:29:32,511 metals markets. ButI think, in general, a couple of weeks ago 422 00:27:08,081 --> 00:27:33,106 many CTAs were down a small amounts, but they had a laser focus 423 00:27:33,106 --> 00:27:54,281 on risk. So, not only allocation of risk but managing of 424 00:27:54,281 --> 00:28:17,381 positions. Silver has caught a lot of headlines but it's not as 425 00:28:17,381 --> 00:28:44,331 big a market as gold and so, maybe the allocation of risk to that 426 00:28:44,331 --> 00:29:07,431 market wasn't as big as many people might assume. And there was 427 00:29:07,431 --> 00:29:30,531 definitely a close monitoring of what the risk looks like in that 428 00:29:30,531 --> 00:29:32,456 market. So,we've had CTAs kind of building proprietary models 429 00:27:22,311 --> 00:28:06,951 over the years to help them work out when trends are overextended, 430 00:28:06,951 --> 00:28:51,591 when trends are reversing. And I really think there was a looking 431 00:28:51,591 --> 00:29:32,511 at trend strength and looking at, are these breakouts really supportable? 432 00:26:48,831 --> 00:27:46,330 AndI don't think CTAs have had as much risk to precious metals 433 00:27:46,330 --> 00:28:48,252 as you might think. I looked at a CTA report today and there was 434 00:28:48,252 --> 00:29:32,482 a much bigger allocation of VAR to equities and FX. 435 00:29:33,231 --> 00:29:37,791 Yeah, I mean we can dive into that. I know there was one of Andrew's 436 00:29:37,791 --> 00:29:41,743 topics actually. We can jump around a little bit if you want to 437 00:29:41,743 --> 00:29:45,999 stay on sort of the theme of gold and silver and how these were 438 00:29:45,999 --> 00:29:49,039 traded. I know you had some questions about this Andrew. 439 00:29:49,961 --> 00:29:54,173 Yeah, I mean, I mean every time I think somebody answered the 440 00:29:54,173 --> 00:29:59,087 point about… So look, I mean you look at 2025, and gold is up 441 00:29:59,087 --> 00:30:03,650 60%. I mean this should have been a banner year for the space, 442 00:30:03,650 --> 00:30:08,213 right? Equities were up a lot. So, you had very, very, very distinct 443 00:30:08,213 --> 00:30:12,074 trends and it's continued into this year, obviously. And yet the 444 00:30:12,074 --> 00:30:13,127 space was flat. 445 00:30:14,191 --> 00:30:21,495 And in Tom's analysis, which mirrors what Nick Baltas was talking 446 00:30:21,495 --> 00:30:28,799 about at year end, and Katy has talked similarly, was short-term 447 00:30:28,799 --> 00:30:34,775 models really detracted from performance last year. And Tom's 448 00:30:34,775 --> 00:30:41,415 report, which everyone should read, has a great analysis basically 449 00:30:41,415 --> 00:30:49,383 on a factor by factor and using his trend indicator. But you're 450 00:30:49,383 --> 00:30:56,023 up 20% or something in long-term trend according to that 451 00:30:56,023 --> 00:31:03,327 and you're down12%, 13%, 14%, 15% in short-term trend. You know 452 00:31:03,327 --> 00:31:11,959 again, as we've looked at the space, and we've looked at the shorter-term 453 00:31:11,959 --> 00:31:18,599 models, we just don't see really positive Sharpe ratios in 454 00:31:18,599 --> 00:31:27,231 it. They sound great, right? But our view is they’re a risk management 455 00:31:27,231 --> 00:31:33,207 tool and they're often a costly risk management tool. Ifyou're 456 00:30:15,577 --> 00:30:23,200 going to allocate a meaningful amount of money to something that 457 00:30:23,200 --> 00:30:31,516 has a zero Sharpe ratio over time, that drives up your trading 458 00:30:31,516 --> 00:30:40,525 cost and creates all sorts of sorts of other issues. So, I think 459 00:30:40,525 --> 00:30:48,148 that's sort of the hard narrative part about the space right 460 00:30:48,148 --> 00:30:57,157 now is it feels like things are trending like crazy. So why isn't 461 00:30:57,157 --> 00:31:05,473 the space doing better? This year they are, but last year, you 462 00:31:05,473 --> 00:31:14,482 know, it was making money in our side, it was making money in 463 00:31:14,482 --> 00:31:21,412 gold and non-US equities, was about half the performance each. 464 00:31:21,412 --> 00:31:30,421 And then you got whipsawed and hope you didn't lose too much money 465 00:31:30,421 --> 00:31:33,193 in rates and currencies. 466 00:31:33,961 --> 00:32:24,151 I mean, I think last year, if we just stick with that for a little 467 00:32:24,151 --> 00:33:00,957 bit, you're absolutely right. When people look at the year they 468 00:33:00,957 --> 00:33:44,455 will say, well hang on, equities were up a lot, so why didn't 469 00:33:44,455 --> 00:34:21,261 trend followers make more money in equities? It was very select 470 00:34:21,261 --> 00:35:01,413 equities that we could make money in because it really was all 471 00:35:01,413 --> 00:35:28,181 about the April deleveraging thanks to Liberation Day. So,obviously, 472 00:31:38,943 --> 00:32:11,326 you execute once a week, so you have a different way of interpreting 473 00:32:11,326 --> 00:32:36,236 what happened. Managers who are much more frequent, of course, 474 00:32:36,236 --> 00:33:06,128 we have a different way of interpreting. So, I do think, for 475 00:33:06,128 --> 00:33:38,511 sure, the fact that we had to delever the equity long side for 476 00:33:38,511 --> 00:34:10,894 a while, and I think maybe some managers even got short at that 477 00:34:10,894 --> 00:34:38,295 stage, that obviously would have cost some. So, I agree with 478 00:34:38,295 --> 00:35:05,696 that. But people obviously need to understand the way we got 479 00:35:05,696 --> 00:35:28,115 to the strong equity wasn't in a straight line. Whereit was in 480 00:31:42,037 --> 00:32:06,265 a straight line, as you rightly said, is in the metals. And 481 00:32:06,265 --> 00:32:32,512 I think most people made all or most of their profits in metals 482 00:32:32,512 --> 00:32:56,740 or some select equities. A couple of them also in the, say, 483 00:32:56,740 --> 00:33:25,006 short JGBs, and so on, and so forth. What is most puzzling to me, 484 00:33:25,006 --> 00:33:49,234 and this may not be very popular with some of my friends, 485 00:33:49,234 --> 00:34:11,443 but I'll venture into it anyways. In a sense, you're kind 486 00:34:11,443 --> 00:34:33,652 of right because we have the discussion about being a classic 487 00:34:33,652 --> 00:34:53,842 trend follower where you don't adjust your positions, and being 488 00:34:53,842 --> 00:35:18,070 kind of maybe a more modern trend follower where we do adjust 489 00:35:18,070 --> 00:35:28,165 our positions all the time. Andso, last year, which may come 490 00:31:54,198 --> 00:32:34,672 as a surprise to people, even though we made most money in in precious 491 00:32:34,672 --> 00:33:00,691 metals, we were selling precious metals all year, right? 492 00:33:00,691 --> 00:33:35,383 So, our largest exposure was a long time ago in precious metals. 493 00:33:35,383 --> 00:34:12,966 And then you could say, well, that's not great when the trend is 494 00:34:12,966 --> 00:34:47,658 so strong, you should just have stayed with it. You would have 495 00:34:47,658 --> 00:35:25,241 made a killing. And there were one or two that probably did exactly 496 00:35:25,241 --> 00:35:28,132 that. Butof course, we also know they kind of had a huge surprise 497 00:32:00,663 --> 00:32:27,365 on the last day of January and had that day, for example, continued 498 00:32:27,365 --> 00:32:52,013 on the Monday with the same velocity instead of a rebound, some 499 00:32:52,013 --> 00:33:16,661 of those managers could have been in real trouble, in my estimation 500 00:33:16,661 --> 00:33:41,309 of how it took place. Because some managers will, when you get 501 00:33:41,309 --> 00:34:08,011 a big drawdown, like in silver and gold prices on Friday, the 29th 502 00:34:08,011 --> 00:34:32,659 to 30th, whenever it was, you may trigger your signal. You may 503 00:34:32,659 --> 00:34:57,307 trigger your stop. But you may not execute that trade until the 504 00:34:57,307 --> 00:35:21,955 next day. Had the next day been down another 20%, things would 505 00:35:21,955 --> 00:35:28,117 have been different. Butfor the larger managers who don't have 506 00:31:49,841 --> 00:32:09,691 static position size, you know, we were just basically reducing 507 00:32:09,691 --> 00:32:31,526 our risk along with volatility expanding. So, yes, you could say 508 00:32:31,526 --> 00:32:59,316 it's a little bit of a shame when you have two or three markets 509 00:32:59,316 --> 00:33:23,136 that really move strongly that we didn't make more money. But on 510 00:33:23,136 --> 00:33:50,926 the other hand, from what I can tell, and this is by no means 511 00:33:50,926 --> 00:34:14,746 any criticism, it's just an observation, but I do see many managers… 512 00:34:14,746 --> 00:34:40,551 or not many… but there is a handful of managers who talk about 513 00:34:40,551 --> 00:35:02,386 this, oh, you should never touch your position size. You should 514 00:35:02,386 --> 00:35:26,206 just stick with it. And that's how you really capture these big 515 00:35:26,206 --> 00:35:28,191 outliers. Butthe problem is their performance was not in any 516 00:32:04,371 --> 00:32:43,904 way, shape, or form, better last year. And why is that? And I 517 00:32:43,904 --> 00:33:26,478 think it has to do with the fact that they often trade 300, 400, 518 00:33:26,478 --> 00:34:02,970 500 markets, and therefore any one market, even if you don't touch 519 00:34:02,970 --> 00:34:36,421 your position size, becomes a very small risk allocation in reality. 520 00:34:36,421 --> 00:35:15,954 And that's always been my view, that it's not a wrong or right, 521 00:35:15,954 --> 00:35:28,118 it's just a difference. Butif you really want to have punchy returns 522 00:32:15,289 --> 00:33:05,801 and make those 50%, 60%, 80% returns, yeah, then you actually 523 00:33:05,801 --> 00:34:10,089 have to have a fairly small set of markets but then be very gutsy 524 00:34:10,089 --> 00:35:05,193 about your risk allocation and stick with it. But that opens up 525 00:35:05,193 --> 00:35:28,153 another set of risk issues. 526 00:35:28,911 --> 00:35:32,827 Yeah, there's a London CTA manager who is very committed to 527 00:35:32,827 --> 00:35:35,675 trend following, very committed to commodities, and trading 528 00:35:35,675 --> 00:35:40,303 a small number of markets, and letting risk run. I think we all 529 00:35:40,303 --> 00:35:44,575 know who it is, but is the end product something that's palatable 530 00:35:44,575 --> 00:35:48,847 to investors when they have these pressures on them from an investment 531 00:35:48,847 --> 00:35:51,695 committee and they have strategic asset allocations that 532 00:35:51,695 --> 00:35:55,967 they have to follow. I think you end up creating something which 533 00:35:55,967 --> 00:35:59,527 is difficult to sell to investors when you have something 534 00:35:59,527 --> 00:36:00,239 like that. 535 00:36:00,441 --> 00:36:03,873 Yeah, I mean, you don't need many investors. I mean, frankly. 536 00:36:03,873 --> 00:36:08,241 And I think that's what I like about the space is, in the sense, 537 00:36:08,241 --> 00:36:12,297 if you have a certain profile you want to express then you can 538 00:36:12,297 --> 00:36:16,041 probably find enough investors who will want to join you. It's just 539 00:36:16,041 --> 00:36:20,097 a different set of investors. But I agree with you on that topic. 540 00:36:21,181 --> 00:36:26,030 It's something that comes up, and it came up this week, about the 541 00:36:26,030 --> 00:36:30,879 role that your hedge fund or your CTA is playing in the portfolio. 542 00:36:30,879 --> 00:36:35,355 And it's something that we've heard about this. We have as our 543 00:36:35,355 --> 00:36:39,458 core risk, asset equity risk, and we're trying to diversify that. 544 00:36:39,458 --> 00:36:43,188 These large asymmetric returns are really good, and trend following 545 00:36:43,188 --> 00:36:47,291 is really good at diversifying that. And so, the investor's sort 546 00:36:47,291 --> 00:36:50,648 of continued fascination with multi strat isn't necessarily meeting 547 00:36:50,648 --> 00:36:54,378 the requirements or the objective that CTA maybe does when 548 00:36:54,378 --> 00:36:58,854 you get these large moves and you want to have these asymmetric 549 00:36:58,854 --> 00:36:59,600 portfolio diversification. 550 00:37:00,971 --> 00:37:02,891 Yeah. Any thoughts, Andrew? 551 00:37:03,771 --> 00:37:52,996 Again, I think about the space very differently than most people 552 00:37:52,996 --> 00:38:51,171 in that I view it as an allocator. And originally we got 553 00:38:51,171 --> 00:39:44,871 into space as an allocator trying to figure out… We love the 554 00:39:44,871 --> 00:40:47,521 signal of the space, but how do we access that in the most efficient, 555 00:40:47,521 --> 00:41:14,391 straightforward, liquid way that we can? Imean,to me, the alpha 556 00:37:28,419 --> 00:38:17,715 in the space… I remember the moment, in September of 2020, when 557 00:38:17,715 --> 00:38:50,579 we started shorting treasuries. I remember the moment 558 00:38:50,579 --> 00:39:35,767 when we were starting buying gold. And, you know, we're buying 559 00:39:35,767 --> 00:40:20,955 gold well below US$3,000, when we started shorting the yen around 560 00:40:20,955 --> 00:41:02,035 US$105, US$106 or something like that. Those were really contrarian, 561 00:41:02,035 --> 00:41:14,359 really early calls. Andbecause, again, I sort of straddle 562 00:37:17,162 --> 00:37:42,031 this world and the world of people who are trying to make these 563 00:37:42,031 --> 00:38:04,987 judgments on a regular basis. I also started a commodity firm called 564 00:38:04,987 --> 00:38:27,943 Pinnacle Asset Management back in the 2000s. And it was a fundamentally 565 00:38:27,943 --> 00:38:48,986 driven commodity firm where you had guys who knew more about 566 00:38:48,986 --> 00:39:08,116 the… Somebody, like John Arnold, knew more about the fixed 567 00:39:08,116 --> 00:39:29,159 price natural gas swap market than anybody ever in the history 568 00:39:29,159 --> 00:39:54,028 of planet Earth, then or now. And the way that they viewed CTAs 569 00:39:54,028 --> 00:40:16,984 was they waited for the day when some signal went off somewhere, 570 00:40:16,984 --> 00:40:36,114 and CTAs were selling, because they were, in effect, straddling 571 00:40:36,114 --> 00:40:57,157 between being market makers and trying to think about, you know, 572 00:40:57,157 --> 00:41:10,548 sort of the fundamental supply/demand characteristics of 573 00:41:10,548 --> 00:41:14,374 the markets. Andso, to me, when I think about alpha, in the 574 00:38:01,202 --> 00:39:09,075 CTA space, as an allocator what I care about is when they pick 575 00:39:09,075 --> 00:40:01,285 up something whether, as I said, early contrarian and right. 576 00:40:01,285 --> 00:41:14,379 And it's big, and you can make money in it. How does that happen? 577 00:37:03,771 --> 00:37:56,523 So,you've got an asset that's worth around US$10, let's say just, 578 00:37:56,523 --> 00:38:53,671 just assume it's sort of a basic model. There's a lot of noise 579 00:38:53,671 --> 00:39:37,631 around it, right? So just based upon sentiment or whatever, 580 00:39:37,631 --> 00:40:39,175 whatever, it'll go up to US$11 and then back down to US$9, and then 581 00:40:39,175 --> 00:41:14,343 back up to US$11, back down to US$9. Andso, the basic model is, 582 00:37:25,563 --> 00:38:05,515 when you have people with local knowledge of that market who 583 00:38:05,515 --> 00:38:41,835 are maybe sitting on trading desks or high frequency traders, 584 00:38:41,835 --> 00:39:25,419 whatever you want to want to call them, you know, generally the 585 00:39:25,419 --> 00:40:05,371 smart money is selling at US$11, buying at US$9, selling at 586 00:40:05,371 --> 00:40:45,323 US$11, buying at US$9. And this sentiment is driving these prices 587 00:40:45,323 --> 00:41:14,379 around, but with no change in fundamental value. Thevaluable trends 588 00:37:14,070 --> 00:37:48,400 for CTAs are, when it's something's at US$10, fair market 589 00:37:48,400 --> 00:38:22,730 value is US$10. And then the information changes, something in 590 00:38:22,730 --> 00:39:03,926 the world changes and fair market goes to US$11. And the people 591 00:39:03,926 --> 00:39:45,122 with local knowledge like it more at US$11 than they liked it 592 00:39:45,122 --> 00:40:29,751 at US$10. And then it goes from US$11 to US$12 and the smart 593 00:40:29,751 --> 00:41:14,380 money likes it more at US$12 than they liked it more at US$11. 594 00:37:03,771 --> 00:37:19,336 Thatmeans the world is changing and that they know something 595 00:37:19,336 --> 00:37:34,901 about it. They have some special insight that the world is 596 00:37:34,901 --> 00:37:47,636 slowly adapting to this information, and they think it's 597 00:37:47,636 --> 00:38:04,616 going to play out. And so, when I think about what happened 598 00:38:04,616 --> 00:38:21,596 in 2024, ’25, and this year, and I think about longer-term versus 599 00:38:21,596 --> 00:38:34,331 shorter-term models, in a sense, the shorter-term models are 600 00:38:34,331 --> 00:38:51,311 the ones that are going to get whipsawed violently when you have 601 00:38:51,311 --> 00:39:06,876 these changes in sentiment like we had last year. But there's 602 00:39:06,876 --> 00:39:23,856 no real change in the state of the world. Whereas the longer-term 603 00:39:23,856 --> 00:39:42,251 models are the ones that say, you know what, this shift… I know, 604 00:39:42,251 --> 00:39:56,401 I get it, everybody with their investing committees basically has 605 00:39:56,401 --> 00:40:16,211 been talking about a shift out of US assets and out of US equities 606 00:40:16,211 --> 00:40:37,436 for a long time. But we can see it in the prices. And we can 607 00:40:37,436 --> 00:40:54,416 see people moving their money at the margin. And so, we're going 608 00:40:54,416 --> 00:41:11,396 to get behind it regardless of what we thought about things six 609 00:41:11,396 --> 00:41:14,226 months ago. So,by that definition of alpha short-term models 610 00:37:40,899 --> 00:38:31,950 detract value. It's not the exposure that I would want. And, 611 00:38:31,950 --> 00:39:23,001 I think people have conflated risk management with, if you're going 612 00:39:23,001 --> 00:40:09,411 to introduce something into your portfolio and allocate a lot 613 00:40:09,411 --> 00:41:05,103 of risk to something with a zero Sharpe ratio, no thanks. Not 614 00:41:05,103 --> 00:41:14,385 for me. 615 00:41:15,031 --> 00:41:19,354 I don't know if you remember, Andrew, because obviously you do 616 00:41:19,354 --> 00:41:22,891 things completely differently to an underlying manager, did you 617 00:41:22,891 --> 00:41:27,214 manage to keep a fairly static allocation to gold last year? 618 00:41:28,201 --> 00:41:55,405 No, it bounced around. You know, when we think about the variation 619 00:41:55,405 --> 00:42:22,609 between us and the hedge funds, you know, there are kind of 620 00:42:22,609 --> 00:42:52,080 four drivers of variation, and we tended to get all of them right 621 00:42:52,080 --> 00:43:21,551 last year. You know, in 2023 they all went against us, and we 622 00:43:21,551 --> 00:43:46,488 underperformed by 500 basis points. It can happen but it's the 623 00:43:46,488 --> 00:44:18,226 only time it has ever happened to us. We outperformed a lot in 2024 624 00:44:18,226 --> 00:44:22,760 and 2025. Slownesshelped us last year. And if you look at our 625 00:41:59,683 --> 00:42:25,441 performance… So, one is our performance, around Liberation Day, 626 00:42:25,441 --> 00:43:02,647 was much better than the index and it was better for two things, 627 00:43:02,647 --> 00:43:39,853 one, I think your position 297 when your vol is spiking and you're 628 00:43:39,853 --> 00:44:08,473 de-risking after Liberation Day, I think you are making somebody's 629 00:44:08,473 --> 00:44:22,831 P&L in that local market. Ithinkyou are the amateur outsiders 630 00:41:45,414 --> 00:42:14,922 who somebody has pressed a button to sell it, and you're not 631 00:42:14,922 --> 00:42:41,971 executing at… The liquidity dries up in that market because they 632 00:42:41,971 --> 00:43:13,938 can see you coming. That's why you have all these things on zero 633 00:43:13,938 --> 00:43:40,987 hedge about what CTAs are doing. Now translate that into a 634 00:43:40,987 --> 00:44:10,495 market where you've built your career for the past 25 years trading 635 00:44:10,495 --> 00:44:22,790 that market every single day. CharlieMcGarraugh actually, who 636 00:41:41,133 --> 00:42:19,929 runs Altis, which is the sub advisor to Simplified CTA hedge fund, 637 00:42:19,929 --> 00:43:05,191 used to run the metals desk at Goldman. And he's talked a lot about 638 00:43:05,191 --> 00:43:43,987 this, that when you have that kind of local knowledge, and you 639 00:43:43,987 --> 00:44:16,317 have systematic traders coming into the market, that's your P&L 640 00:44:16,317 --> 00:44:22,783 right there. So,I think this diversification into a lot of excess 641 00:41:55,911 --> 00:42:18,079 positions, increasingly non-core positions, I think it hurt 642 00:42:18,079 --> 00:42:45,789 people after Liberation Day. It exacerbated the drawdowns. I think 643 00:42:45,789 --> 00:43:10,728 that's a market structure problem. That, when you're building 644 00:43:10,728 --> 00:43:38,438 these models, you have to make certain assumptions about implementation 645 00:43:38,438 --> 00:44:11,690 costs, and I don't think most people factor in getting taken advantage 646 00:44:11,690 --> 00:44:22,774 of by local traders. Andthen the second was, we still had some 647 00:41:52,006 --> 00:42:23,746 risk on, we were slow to de-risk and bounced when Trump changed 648 00:42:23,746 --> 00:42:58,131 his mind. So, that kind of blows up the idea…I mean, in Tom's 649 00:42:58,131 --> 00:43:19,291 data, interestingly, really short-term models were fine during 650 00:43:19,291 --> 00:43:43,096 that. They preserved capital much better than longer-term guys 651 00:43:43,096 --> 00:44:12,191 during that initial period. It was actually later when they started 652 00:44:12,191 --> 00:44:22,771 to get chopped up. Butagain, so look, I think, as an allocator, 653 00:41:55,291 --> 00:42:40,441 and I think, back to the point that you and Tom have made that investor 654 00:42:40,441 --> 00:43:16,561 preferences are often to live in paralyzing fear about what a bad 655 00:43:16,561 --> 00:43:52,681 whipsaw looks like. And, as you say, whether a bad Friday turns 656 00:43:52,681 --> 00:44:22,781 into a horrible Monday, which is what happened with SVB. Andso, 657 00:41:34,327 --> 00:42:14,146 it can happen. I just don't think you're paid for… As an allocator, 658 00:42:14,146 --> 00:42:50,902 you lose too much. It's like saying, well, let's do a long-term 659 00:42:50,902 --> 00:43:30,721 trend model and then buy out of the money puts on equities because 660 00:43:30,721 --> 00:44:07,477 that's what we're afraid of. Fine, you're just not going to have 661 00:44:07,477 --> 00:44:22,792 a business after five years. 662 00:44:23,791 --> 00:44:26,741 We’ve got a few different topics, mainly from you, Andrew. 663 00:44:26,741 --> 00:44:31,166 So, I'm going to kind of defer to you which one you'd like to bring 664 00:44:31,166 --> 00:44:35,296 up. We talked about the gold and the silver. We tried to get into 665 00:44:35,296 --> 00:44:39,131 kind of a little bit more of the nitty gritty about how managers 666 00:44:39,131 --> 00:44:42,081 probably were different and how they handled this. Where would 667 00:44:42,081 --> 00:44:43,556 you like to go next? 668 00:44:44,251 --> 00:45:56,862 Well, since I'm on a rant about product design, let's talk 669 00:45:56,862 --> 00:47:02,872 about the liquid alternative space. So, the broader liquid alternative 670 00:47:02,872 --> 00:48:08,882 space, which means hedge fund strategy, and we're talking about 671 00:48:08,882 --> 00:48:22,084 Dan's article. So,hedge fund strategies in mutual funds and UCITS 672 00:45:25,966 --> 00:46:12,316 funds, and increasingly in ETFs, has been an astonishingly bad 673 00:46:12,316 --> 00:46:54,031 category. Like, the ratio between intelligent people and serious 674 00:46:54,031 --> 00:47:40,381 firms who've launched products relative to the total utter lack 675 00:47:40,381 --> 00:48:22,096 of success, from an investment perspective, is pretty astonishing. 676 00:44:44,251 --> 00:45:43,121 You'retalking about hundreds of products that have been launched. 677 00:45:43,121 --> 00:46:41,991 Each one, when they get launched, is somebody sitting there 678 00:46:41,991 --> 00:47:46,748 saying, we've got some great way of doing equity long/short, or 679 00:47:46,748 --> 00:48:22,070 market neutral, or this, or that. Thereturns over 15 years, 680 00:44:59,811 --> 00:45:37,155 according to Wilshire's data, is between 2% and 3%. And the fee 681 00:45:37,155 --> 00:46:11,387 structures, on average, is about 200 basis points in a period 682 00:46:11,387 --> 00:46:51,843 of time when equity markets have gone up 14% a year over that 683 00:46:51,843 --> 00:47:29,187 period of time. So, this is worse than throwing darts. If this 684 00:47:29,187 --> 00:48:09,643 was a sports team, you would be asking, are you throwing the game 685 00:48:09,643 --> 00:48:22,091 on purpose? It's horrendous. AndI had this sort of epiphany last 686 00:45:05,243 --> 00:45:39,355 year as I was thinking about it, because we've only done a very, 687 00:45:39,355 --> 00:46:08,219 very small number of products over time because we've always had 688 00:46:08,219 --> 00:46:42,331 a view that for us if we launch a bad product, something that 689 00:46:42,331 --> 00:47:05,947 doesn't work, it's our reputation, it's a huge percentage 690 00:47:05,947 --> 00:47:40,059 of our time gets allocated to it. In fact, we ended up shutting 691 00:47:40,059 --> 00:48:08,923 products that we didn't think were scalable even though they did 692 00:48:08,923 --> 00:48:22,043 fine from a performance perspective. Buta typical firm has 693 00:45:02,106 --> 00:45:30,674 a huge distribution infrastructure to support, and they 694 00:45:30,674 --> 00:46:17,097 have no view on which is the best product that they're going to 695 00:46:17,097 --> 00:46:52,807 launch. There's no one who approaches this from an investment 696 00:46:52,807 --> 00:47:35,659 perspective. What would I want to own over the next five years? 697 00:47:35,659 --> 00:48:22,082 And how am I going to get that in the most efficient way? Withactually 698 00:44:48,361 --> 00:45:13,021 one exception, which SEI hired us 10 years ago with that mandate, 699 00:45:13,021 --> 00:45:37,681 to help them build a UCITS fund where they basically said, can 700 00:45:37,681 --> 00:46:04,396 you find a way to construct an absolute return product with a beta 701 00:46:04,396 --> 00:46:33,166 of 0.2 cash plus 5 gross and all in expense ratio less than 100 702 00:46:33,166 --> 00:46:53,716 basis points and no asset liability mismatch, and you figure 703 00:46:53,716 --> 00:47:24,541 out how to kind of build it. But I think the problem, on the product 704 00:47:24,541 --> 00:47:47,146 development side, is that most products that are developed in the 705 00:47:47,146 --> 00:48:07,696 space are developed by salespeople who think they can sell 706 00:48:07,696 --> 00:48:22,081 it over the next year or two. It'sa hot area. And they're going 707 00:45:10,543 --> 00:45:48,103 to launch something where they think there might be incremental 708 00:45:48,103 --> 00:46:33,175 demand. And I compare that to the hedge fund industry (going back 709 00:46:33,175 --> 00:47:10,735 to Dan's article), generally when hedge funds launch new products 710 00:47:10,735 --> 00:47:44,539 is because there's a great investment opportunity. They're going 711 00:47:44,539 --> 00:48:18,343 to buy real estate in Greenland, denominated in Bitcoin 712 00:48:18,343 --> 00:48:22,101 (laughter). Imean,you know, but they think there's something 713 00:45:09,379 --> 00:45:42,883 real there and they're going to put their own money behind it 714 00:45:42,883 --> 00:46:16,387 and they want to do it. It's completely backwards in the liquid 715 00:46:16,387 --> 00:46:49,891 alts world in that the guys who are building the products are 716 00:46:49,891 --> 00:47:20,603 the equivalent of the salesman on the showroom floor designing a 717 00:47:20,603 --> 00:47:59,691 car for you because he thinks you'll buy it. And if it's a lousy 718 00:47:59,691 --> 00:48:22,027 car in three years, it's not his issue. Andso it kind of dovetails 719 00:45:07,177 --> 00:45:49,208 with this thing about, should CTA managers be making changes to 720 00:45:49,208 --> 00:46:23,597 their portfolio models to maximize their risk adjusted returns 721 00:46:23,597 --> 00:47:05,628 over the next five years (things that they have high conviction 722 00:47:05,628 --> 00:47:47,659 in), or should they be responding to fears of clients about 723 00:47:47,659 --> 00:48:22,048 that once a year whipsaw that everyone runs into. 724 00:48:22,741 --> 00:48:27,767 I mean, I have some thoughts, but I want to hear Tom first. But 725 00:48:27,767 --> 00:48:32,793 by the way, I will, I will say I have noticed, on your LinkedIn 726 00:48:32,793 --> 00:48:36,383 post, Andrew, that you're certainly not shy of calling out 727 00:48:36,383 --> 00:48:39,614 some of your competitors, let's put it that way. 728 00:48:39,621 --> 00:48:42,099 Someone has to, for God's sake. 729 00:48:42,101 --> 00:48:44,257 I'm going to defer to Tom first. 730 00:48:44,951 --> 00:49:19,180 Well, we live in a world where Simpsons episodes seem to have predicted 731 00:49:19,180 --> 00:49:50,776 most of modern life. And Andrew, I think there is a Simpsons 732 00:49:50,776 --> 00:50:19,739 episode where Homer designs a car from the showroom which then 733 00:50:19,739 --> 00:50:48,702 bankrupts the company. So, I think your analogy is quite interesting 734 00:50:48,702 --> 00:51:15,032 and quite correct. There definitely seems to be some sort 735 00:51:15,032 --> 00:51:20,298 of disconnect. Myworry, in the liquid alts data (and it was 736 00:49:01,471 --> 00:49:19,643 something that I came across yesterday in a discussion) was the 737 00:49:19,643 --> 00:49:37,815 classification is the key thing. And are we talking about real 738 00:49:37,815 --> 00:49:57,639 hedge funds in that data or are we talking about quasi alternatives 739 00:49:57,639 --> 00:50:14,159 that live in this semi alternative world where it's kind 740 00:50:14,159 --> 00:50:32,331 of multi asset but being described, because it's a bit of 741 00:50:32,331 --> 00:50:53,807 a hot topic or sexy, as multi stress or macro when actually it's 742 00:50:53,807 --> 00:51:13,631 just a kind of a GTAA kind of tactical asset allocation across 743 00:51:13,631 --> 00:51:20,239 multiple different asset classes? Theconversation I had yesterday 744 00:48:57,086 --> 00:49:23,783 was with someone who was interested in quant multi strap UCITS 745 00:49:23,783 --> 00:49:55,334 funds and was telling me that there was a universe of a hundred 746 00:49:55,334 --> 00:50:24,458 of these funds, and I struggled to name even two. So, I 747 00:50:24,458 --> 00:50:48,728 think there's a disconnect in what liquid alternatives are, and 748 00:50:48,728 --> 00:51:12,998 what may be represented there isn't necessarily hedge fund strategies 749 00:51:12,998 --> 00:51:20,279 all the time. ButI think you're definitely right. There's 750 00:49:07,603 --> 00:49:39,963 definitely a mismatch or a misalignment between what hedge funds 751 00:49:39,963 --> 00:50:15,559 are creating as product and what an investor can satisfy their 752 00:50:15,559 --> 00:50:51,155 investment committee with. It goes back to what we were talking 753 00:50:51,155 --> 00:51:20,279 about earlier about has the hedge fund industry improved? You'realways 754 00:48:48,291 --> 00:49:06,661 going to get these different areas within the hedge fund industry 755 00:49:06,661 --> 00:49:23,361 where you've got strategies that become scalable that form part 756 00:49:23,361 --> 00:49:38,391 of a larger, longer-term tactical asset allocation that you 757 00:49:38,391 --> 00:50:00,101 want to have as a core holding, like a CTA. And then pure 758 00:50:00,101 --> 00:50:20,141 alpha where you are going to have strategies that come in and 759 00:50:20,141 --> 00:50:41,851 out of vogue. Maybe it's multi strat at the moment, there’s a huge 760 00:50:41,851 --> 00:50:58,551 amount of interest in commodity hedge funds at the moment. 761 00:50:58,551 --> 00:51:16,921 Commodities were nowhere five to ten years ago, but now, suddenly, 762 00:51:16,921 --> 00:51:20,261 they’re interesting. Sothat seems to be this kind of split in 763 00:49:05,661 --> 00:49:30,513 two, within the hedge fund industry, of, as I sort of said, 764 00:49:30,513 --> 00:49:55,365 this niche alphas and things that form part of a larger tactical 765 00:49:55,365 --> 00:50:14,004 asset allocation which, obviously, are going to then have 766 00:50:14,004 --> 00:50:40,927 costs come down and there are going to be periods when they underperform. 767 00:50:40,927 --> 00:51:01,637 But you've got to remember we're living through an unbelievable 768 00:51:01,637 --> 00:51:20,276 equity bull cycle which shows no sign of abating. 769 00:51:22,171 --> 00:51:42,149 I mean, to address your point. So, on the data side, you can look 770 00:51:42,149 --> 00:52:00,700 at the data in a lot of different ways. It sucks, okay? I 771 00:52:00,700 --> 00:52:16,397 mean the performance across the board is terrible. And this is 772 00:52:16,397 --> 00:52:34,948 one of those areas where they ended up alienating a lot of people 773 00:52:34,948 --> 00:52:52,072 because people make money on products that scale up to a couple 774 00:52:52,072 --> 00:53:07,769 billion dollars. They've got five products, one of them has a 775 00:53:07,769 --> 00:53:24,893 couple of good years of returns, you send an army of salespeople 776 00:53:24,893 --> 00:53:46,298 out to sell it, it scales up to 3 billion and then it just kind 777 00:53:46,298 --> 00:54:03,422 of whittles down over time, and clients end up often not making 778 00:54:03,422 --> 00:54:04,849 money. So,I mean look, you can look at the multi strats, the 779 00:51:48,907 --> 00:52:13,415 multi manager, mutual funded ETF, so, mutual fund and UCITS category. 780 00:52:13,415 --> 00:52:37,923 Even Blackstone gave up on that. You know, I mean Neuberger 781 00:52:37,923 --> 00:53:04,659 Berman shut down their alt. It was a failed business model. Now 782 00:53:04,659 --> 00:53:29,167 there are some funds in it, like Blackstone's BIMBX, which has 783 00:53:29,167 --> 00:54:00,359 done a bit better, but again that's more of kind of a quant multi 784 00:54:00,359 --> 00:54:04,881 strat product. Imeanit was interesting. I went to speak at EQ 785 00:51:41,839 --> 00:52:03,295 Derivatives a couple of weeks ago. It's the whole QIS versus premia 786 00:52:03,295 --> 00:52:22,963 space. And one of the observations that I had about it 787 00:52:22,963 --> 00:52:42,631 is that people really don't talk much about returns. They talk 788 00:52:42,631 --> 00:53:00,511 about modeling, and research, and data, and innovations, and all 789 00:53:00,511 --> 00:53:20,179 these other things. And I kept asking these questions, like, what's 790 00:53:20,179 --> 00:53:39,847 the realized Sharpe ratio of the strategy over what period of 791 00:53:39,847 --> 00:54:01,303 time? And what do you think it's going to be, going forward, 792 00:54:01,303 --> 00:54:04,879 and why? Butgoing back to the point about, that is a different 793 00:51:38,440 --> 00:51:51,751 example on the product development side where products are 794 00:51:51,751 --> 00:52:08,020 created there because there's an audience that wants to hear, you 795 00:52:08,020 --> 00:52:25,768 know, wants a pitch around engineering. A guy who I know, who 796 00:52:25,768 --> 00:52:46,474 is quite a serious allocator, he said, look, if I had to rank the 797 00:52:46,474 --> 00:53:01,264 single most successful allocator to the CTA space over the 798 00:53:01,264 --> 00:53:20,491 past 10 years, it's you, it's DBI, and not by investing in funds, 799 00:53:20,491 --> 00:53:36,760 and not by picking managers, but by saying, what's the signal 800 00:53:36,760 --> 00:53:58,945 here? What is it we're really trying to get? And how do we do that 801 00:53:58,945 --> 00:54:04,861 as efficiently as possible? Andso, I think the challenge is, 802 00:51:31,817 --> 00:51:51,109 or the test for people on the allocation side is to get very, very 803 00:51:51,109 --> 00:52:06,267 clear about what you're expecting a product to do and how 804 00:52:06,267 --> 00:52:20,047 you're attempting to achieve it, and understand how to evaluate 805 00:52:20,047 --> 00:52:36,583 that, and how realistic it is for them to achieve those goals. 806 00:52:36,583 --> 00:52:55,875 And so, back to Niels's point, I often call out people where I think 807 00:52:55,875 --> 00:53:15,167 they don't have a strong view as to whether this is a good idea 808 00:53:15,167 --> 00:53:34,459 or not, but they sure have a good idea that it's good for them 809 00:53:34,459 --> 00:53:52,373 to launch a new product. And I just think it's bad for investors. 810 00:53:52,373 --> 00:54:04,775 You know, obviously a thing I feel strongly about. 811 00:54:05,841 --> 00:54:25,469 I mean, this is a great thing about this, we can have these pretty 812 00:54:25,469 --> 00:54:40,891 frank discussions. I mean, I think we could probably say, with 813 00:54:40,891 --> 00:54:57,715 most firms, when you launch a product, you know, a certain narrative 814 00:54:57,715 --> 00:55:10,333 goes with it. I certainly remember your narrative, Andrew, 815 00:55:10,333 --> 00:55:25,755 when you launched your product. Focused on kind of the cost 816 00:55:25,755 --> 00:55:38,373 savings in order to get exposure to CTA returns. Butwhen 817 00:54:07,897 --> 00:54:23,317 I look at it, if I'm being very frank about it, I look at your 818 00:54:23,317 --> 00:54:37,709 product… Actually, the more I look at it, the more I look at it 819 00:54:37,709 --> 00:54:46,961 differently. That it's actually not about the cost savings, 820 00:54:46,961 --> 00:55:00,325 because I feel, at least, that the tracking error to the index that 821 00:55:00,325 --> 00:55:14,717 it's trying to mirror is too large for that. So, I see it more 822 00:55:14,717 --> 00:55:26,025 as an alternative data strategy where you just use a different 823 00:55:26,025 --> 00:55:38,361 data set input. And it has worked really well, in that sense. 824 00:54:05,841 --> 00:54:15,695 Butof course, you know, even five or ten years worth of data, 825 00:54:15,695 --> 00:54:27,065 we don't know what the next 10 or 20 years is going to be like. 826 00:54:27,065 --> 00:54:36,919 And I completely agree with you, by the way, that there is a 827 00:54:36,919 --> 00:54:45,257 lot of products that really shouldn't be launched and it's not 828 00:54:45,257 --> 00:54:55,111 good for investors to come out there. But I also, you know, from 829 00:54:55,111 --> 00:55:04,207 having seen this space from the inside for quite a few decades, 830 00:55:04,207 --> 00:55:14,819 some of these things will just go in and out of favor. And even 831 00:55:14,819 --> 00:55:22,399 if you have five years of underperformance, it doesn't mean 832 00:55:22,399 --> 00:55:32,253 the next five years, the next 10 years that you're going to be 833 00:55:32,253 --> 00:55:38,317 the highest performer. It's really hard to tell. 834 00:55:38,391 --> 00:55:48,651 Things that I try to highlight are when it's predictable on the 835 00:55:48,651 --> 00:55:58,056 front end. Right. So, Standard Life GARS. Okay. I learned about 836 00:55:58,056 --> 00:56:09,171 Standard Life GARS in 2015 for the first time. They were out telling 837 00:56:09,171 --> 00:56:16,866 everybody that a largely long-only but also with derivatives 838 00:56:16,866 --> 00:56:26,271 built into it, multi asset portfolio could deliver a beta of 839 00:56:26,271 --> 00:56:37,386 0.2 to equities and cash plus 5. Okay. That's a top quartile, maybe 840 00:56:37,386 --> 00:56:46,791 a top decile hedge fund portfolio over time. It's not realistic. 841 00:56:46,791 --> 00:56:57,051 It was never realistic. It was, we happen to have done that 842 00:56:57,051 --> 00:57:06,456 because we flipped heads. And again, it went to US$90 billion, 843 00:57:06,456 --> 00:57:15,006 this thing. It was bigger than Bridgewater at its peak. Andso, 844 00:55:40,969 --> 00:55:57,726 I talked about it at the time and I said you're kidding yourself 845 00:55:57,726 --> 00:56:14,483 if you're going to do a beta… Like, once you start talking about 846 00:56:14,483 --> 00:56:29,951 a beta 0.2 unless you start bringing in things that are quite 847 00:56:29,951 --> 00:56:42,841 interesting like CTAs, and CTAs before fees, or before reducing 848 00:56:42,841 --> 00:56:57,020 your trading costs, unless you can bring in something like that, 849 00:56:57,020 --> 00:57:13,777 the reduction to beta of 0.2 is also going to kill your return 850 00:57:13,777 --> 00:57:15,066 profile. Thesame thing with the multi manager funds. I wrote 851 00:55:50,781 --> 00:56:05,649 a paper in 2013 basically saying a mutual fund that tries to 852 00:56:05,649 --> 00:56:19,278 pick six underlying hedge fund managers and hires them in managed 853 00:56:19,278 --> 00:56:31,668 accounts is not going to achieve the return objectives that 854 00:56:31,668 --> 00:56:47,775 people are talking about at the time. You know, I said the same 855 00:56:47,775 --> 00:57:01,404 thing about risk premia in 2014. G10 currency carry does not 856 00:57:01,404 --> 00:57:15,033 have a long-term Sharpe ratio 1.2. I'm sorry that's a backtest. 857 00:57:16,031 --> 00:57:27,647 And now I think people have realized the drop-off between the 858 00:57:27,647 --> 00:57:38,207 backtested numbers and the live numbers is something like 75%, 859 00:57:38,207 --> 00:57:49,823 or something. You know, I mean, equity long/short as a category, 860 00:57:49,823 --> 00:58:05,663 if you have a beta of 0.5 or 0.4 to equities, the amount of stock 861 00:58:05,663 --> 00:58:18,335 selection alpha and other things you need to do to be able 862 00:58:18,335 --> 00:58:32,063 to overcome even the cost of a mutual fund doing it, you're likely 863 00:58:32,063 --> 00:58:43,679 not to generate much alpha. So, I think the allocator community 864 00:58:43,679 --> 00:58:56,351 is getting smarter every year about a lot of these points. But 865 00:58:56,351 --> 00:59:06,911 I think there are things that work better on it. Andthe structural 866 00:57:22,307 --> 00:57:43,227 problem that you have is that most liquid alternative products 867 00:57:43,227 --> 00:58:10,423 are sold and not bought. The capital tends to go to the largest 868 00:58:10,423 --> 00:58:29,251 firms with the largest salespeople who already have people 869 00:58:29,251 --> 00:58:50,171 who are invested in multiple products under the same umbrella. 870 00:58:50,171 --> 00:59:06,907 And it's an incremental addition to their portfolio. Andthe 871 00:57:19,665 --> 00:57:39,652 typical allocator does not… Again, going back to this being a 872 00:57:39,652 --> 00:57:57,822 human exercise, [the typical allocator] doesn't want to ask the 873 00:57:57,822 --> 00:58:21,443 kinds of questions that I'm known for asking. I just did a post 874 00:58:21,443 --> 00:58:45,064 on somebody who launched a CTA product with a team of people who, 875 00:58:45,064 --> 00:59:06,868 as far as I can tell, have never run a CTA program. Okay,so 876 00:57:19,339 --> 00:57:35,879 that is taking a flyer. Basically US$300 million of their 877 00:57:35,879 --> 00:57:57,381 client capital going into it. Now, if it works, if they get lucky, 878 00:57:57,381 --> 00:58:15,575 it's great. They have a $300 million product that's done really, 879 00:58:15,575 --> 00:58:35,423 really well. If it goes badly, it's their client issue and they 880 00:58:35,423 --> 00:58:55,271 won't talk about it. And in three years from now maybe they'll 881 00:58:55,271 --> 00:59:06,849 shut it down, or something like that. Solook, I mean, I'm going 882 00:57:34,007 --> 00:58:09,959 to keep calling out things in this industry where I think that 883 00:58:09,959 --> 00:58:45,911 people who are standing there waving a fiduciary flag are not acting 884 00:58:45,911 --> 00:59:06,883 in the best interest of their clients. 885 00:59:07,631 --> 00:59:10,920 It's interesting. You say, do you think these products are sold 886 00:59:10,920 --> 00:59:14,807 and not bought? I was just looking at my screen trying to see 887 00:59:14,807 --> 00:59:18,096 if I can get the flow information on DBMF, because I'd 888 00:59:18,096 --> 00:59:21,684 be interested to know, do you have clients actively coming in and 889 00:59:21,684 --> 00:59:25,870 out of your funds or is it more of a very long term allocation 890 00:59:25,870 --> 00:59:27,066 part of the portfolio? 891 00:59:27,231 --> 00:59:55,996 I can't really talk about DBMF for compliance reasons, but I'll 892 00:59:55,996 --> 01:00:19,531 give you sort of generalizations. So, I wrote the 893 01:00:19,531 --> 01:00:53,526 business plan for DBMF in 2016, and what it was based on were 894 01:00:53,526 --> 01:01:19,676 conversations with allocators who were looking for ways to get 895 01:01:19,676 --> 01:01:51,056 exposure to this space but had three issues that they were dealing 896 01:01:51,056 --> 01:01:53,671 with. Onewas a line-item constraint. So, if I talk to Cambridge 897 00:59:46,635 --> 01:00:02,511 Associates or Mercer or somebody else, they can populate 898 01:00:02,511 --> 01:00:20,151 an institutional portfolio with four funds and get some measure 899 01:00:20,151 --> 01:00:39,555 of diversification. The reason AQR went to 14 billion in assets 900 01:00:39,555 --> 01:00:58,959 in their mutual fund was because a lot of allocators were 901 01:00:58,959 --> 01:01:21,891 basically saying, A, it's AQR, what can go wrong? And, B, I want 902 01:01:21,891 --> 01:01:46,587 to do a 5% allocation space, I guess the easiest thing is just to 903 01:01:46,587 --> 01:01:53,643 give it to AQR. Okay,that was a catastrophically bad decision… 904 00:59:35,428 --> 00:59:47,138 I mean, AQR is an absolutely, staggeringly, incredible firm, but 905 00:59:47,138 --> 00:59:56,506 they were taking idiosyncratic manager risk without understanding 906 00:59:56,506 --> 01:00:11,729 it. So, what I thought was that there would be demand for something 907 01:00:11,729 --> 01:00:24,610 that would allow a model allocator, who's not the fund selector, 908 01:00:24,610 --> 01:00:37,491 who wants to be in the business of deciding whether it's 909 01:00:37,491 --> 01:00:50,372 Niel's or somebody else and how to assemble that portfolio, but 910 01:00:50,372 --> 01:00:59,740 rather for somebody overlooking the whole portfolio saying, 911 01:00:59,740 --> 01:01:11,450 give me as consistent and straightforward exposure as you can 912 01:01:11,450 --> 01:01:26,673 to this area in a reasonably priced way. So, 85 basis points for 913 01:01:26,673 --> 01:01:41,896 ETFs was about half of what the mutual funds were at the time. 914 01:01:41,896 --> 01:01:53,606 And ETFs were a growing vehicle in terms of popularity. Soagain, 915 00:59:30,103 --> 00:59:48,771 we built it on the basis of feedback from people who were the 916 00:59:48,771 --> 01:00:07,439 decision makers to how to make it better. So back to your point. 917 01:00:07,439 --> 01:00:21,799 The vast majority of the capital are model allocators. There 918 01:00:21,799 --> 01:00:37,595 is somebody there who has a series of models for high-net-worth 919 01:00:37,595 --> 01:00:53,391 clients or mass affluent clients who is trying to… It's usually 920 01:00:53,391 --> 01:01:09,187 not a single allocation, but usually it's a core allocation or 921 01:01:09,187 --> 01:01:23,547 within that bucket. So, it's not actively… Very few allocators 922 01:01:23,547 --> 01:01:37,907 actively trade, which they shouldn’t. I tell them, if you're 923 01:01:37,907 --> 01:01:53,703 going to actively trade, you should find something else to trade. 924 01:01:54,511 --> 01:02:01,735 SG has a very active and a very diverse and comprehensive QIS 925 01:02:01,735 --> 01:02:09,561 business. And I feel that the way those products are used and the 926 01:02:09,561 --> 01:02:14,979 way those products are approached by clients is probably 927 01:02:14,979 --> 01:02:21,601 more in line with how you describe your client journey, but 928 01:02:21,601 --> 01:02:28,825 it's a client engaging in trying to get exposure to a specific 929 01:02:28,825 --> 01:02:36,651 asset class, or strategy, or theme. So, there seems to be a very 930 01:02:36,651 --> 01:02:40,865 sort of thematic use of these QIS. AndI was actually really surprised 931 01:01:59,965 --> 01:02:10,873 to hear that often we have global macro hedge funds who want 932 01:02:10,873 --> 01:02:21,781 to access some sort of curve steepener or some sort of thematic 933 01:02:21,781 --> 01:02:35,416 play for a finite period of time who will use the QIS as a much 934 01:02:35,416 --> 01:02:40,870 simpler implementation of a macro theme. 935 01:02:42,491 --> 01:03:03,477 No, I'm a huge fan of QIS when you know what you're doing. When 936 01:03:03,477 --> 01:03:21,465 you are trying to articulate a bet, and you are outsourcing execution 937 01:03:21,465 --> 01:03:37,954 and financing and everything else to somebody who, in most cases, 938 01:03:37,954 --> 01:03:58,940 is better situated to do it, if you're not Two Sigma, or GE, or 939 01:03:58,940 --> 01:04:09,433 something, who can do it themselves, presumably. No,I mean, 940 01:02:44,645 --> 01:02:54,697 what I was referring to is back in 2013 was that the space was 941 01:02:54,697 --> 01:03:01,877 being marketed as having these liquid strategies… as having strategies 942 01:03:01,877 --> 01:03:09,775 with Sharpe ratios that were unrealistic. And I think, even in 943 01:03:09,775 --> 01:03:18,391 the US, the use of indices within ETFs and structure, and mutual 944 01:03:18,391 --> 01:03:27,725 funds and UCITS funds, this is going to be a hotbed of innovation, 945 01:03:27,725 --> 01:03:34,187 not just for capital efficiency, not just for trading 946 01:03:34,187 --> 01:03:41,367 efficiency, but also because it opens a different category of 947 01:03:41,367 --> 01:03:51,419 investors who is not going to buy a 150 or 160 basis point single 948 01:03:51,419 --> 01:04:00,035 manager mutual fund in what they do because they have low cost 949 01:04:00,035 --> 01:04:07,215 ETF model portfolios that require things that look and feel 950 01:04:07,215 --> 01:04:09,369 more beta like. So,I mean, you know, the product innovation 951 01:03:01,811 --> 01:03:35,621 is there. My criticism is that there are a lot of landmines in the 952 01:03:35,621 --> 01:03:57,356 space that have been predictable and I've been talking 953 01:03:57,356 --> 01:04:09,431 about it for 15 years. 954 01:04:11,281 --> 01:04:15,727 And so, I am hoping that, again, you know, in terms of the 955 01:04:15,727 --> 01:04:19,489 investors that I talk to, they're really smart. I'll tell you, 956 01:04:19,489 --> 01:04:23,593 I started talking about an AI story about an allocator who really 957 01:04:23,593 --> 01:04:28,039 knows what he's doing, and his clients are much better off for it. 958 01:04:28,039 --> 01:04:31,459 And the allocator base will continue to get more sophisticated 959 01:04:31,459 --> 01:04:35,221 in the same way that QIS allocators are much more sophisticated 960 01:04:35,221 --> 01:04:40,351 than they were 12 or 13 years ago when I first talked to them about 961 01:04:40,351 --> 01:04:41,035 this space. 962 01:04:43,181 --> 01:05:23,705 I don't know if this is completely hitting this mark, but 963 01:05:23,705 --> 01:06:04,229 I'll venture it anyways. Of course we're going to have product 964 01:06:04,229 --> 01:06:41,069 innovation. I mean you, Andrew, have been definitely a part 965 01:06:41,069 --> 01:07:06,857 of that revolution and disrupting the space. Myconcerns 966 01:04:47,815 --> 01:05:17,936 with things like QIS is that yeah, we know it's there, we know 967 01:05:17,936 --> 01:05:43,423 it's huge. We have no transparency, we have no idea what 968 01:05:43,423 --> 01:06:06,593 the returns actually are, compared to “if they're trying to 969 01:06:06,593 --> 01:06:29,763 replicate trend following” or replicate CTAs or whatever, but we 970 01:06:29,763 --> 01:06:52,933 don't really know how they're doing because they don't publish 971 01:06:52,933 --> 01:07:06,872 their returns or anything like that. Iguessmy concern, and I do 972 01:04:55,011 --> 01:05:15,291 know this sounds really old fashioned when I say it. It's great 973 01:05:15,291 --> 01:05:33,881 with innovation. But I am still concerned that when you come 974 01:05:33,881 --> 01:05:55,851 at something and say, yeah, we can give you that, right, we can 975 01:05:55,851 --> 01:06:16,131 give you the CTA returns, or we can give you trend following, 976 01:06:16,131 --> 01:06:33,031 low cost, and we'll do it completely differently. But often, 977 01:06:33,031 --> 01:06:51,621 over time, when you do things really differently, why would you 978 01:06:51,621 --> 01:07:06,831 expect to be able to deliver the same outcome? Andmaybe we have 979 01:04:47,009 --> 01:04:59,450 not seen it yet, right? Maybe the way markets have behaved. I noticed 980 01:04:59,450 --> 01:05:09,977 both Katy and Nick had some analysis where the environment for 981 01:05:09,977 --> 01:05:23,375 managers had been in a certain way the last 10 years, but it was 982 01:05:23,375 --> 01:05:33,902 completely opposite almost in the first 10 years of this millennium. 983 01:05:33,902 --> 01:05:46,343 And so, all I'm just saying, I'm open to surprise both ways in 984 01:05:46,343 --> 01:05:57,827 a sense that yes, there's going to be periods where these innovative 985 01:05:57,827 --> 01:06:08,354 structures outperform and do really well. And it kind of looks 986 01:06:08,354 --> 01:06:19,838 like, oh, we've solved it. There's another easy way to do trend 987 01:06:19,838 --> 01:06:30,365 following without you having to do all the nitty gritty stuff 988 01:06:30,365 --> 01:06:44,720 that we do and have done in the last 50 years. But hey, at some 989 01:06:44,720 --> 01:06:56,204 point maybe we realize that okay, it works, but it doesn't work 990 01:06:56,204 --> 01:07:06,731 all the time. And that's just my expectation to this space. ButI 991 01:04:51,391 --> 01:05:40,651 do agree that firms should not knowingly move into this space without 992 01:05:40,651 --> 01:06:21,701 the right experience. And just, if they can, put investors 993 01:06:21,701 --> 01:07:06,856 into products that are not, you know, built as they should. 994 01:07:07,192 --> 01:07:09,752 Can I…? So, when 995 01:07:12,272 --> 01:07:41,532 I first looked at trend following models, and these are the 996 01:07:41,532 --> 01:08:10,792 bank trend following models. It is easier to get the information 997 01:08:10,792 --> 01:08:50,692 now than it used to be. When I first looked at the space, I was 998 01:08:50,692 --> 01:09:14,632 asking questions that other people weren't asking, which was 999 01:09:14,632 --> 01:09:43,892 okay, when did you actually launch this index? If you launched 1000 01:09:43,892 --> 01:10:13,152 the index three weeks ago, then have you launched other indices 1001 01:10:13,152 --> 01:10:34,432 that look like this? How did those do? So,these are normal due 1002 01:07:26,712 --> 01:07:55,592 diligence questions. I mean, the fascinating thing about it was 1003 01:07:55,592 --> 01:08:27,360 that I think a lot of allocators just sort of suspended 1004 01:08:27,360 --> 01:08:59,128 belief and decided not to ask those questions because they were 1005 01:08:59,128 --> 01:09:30,896 under so much pressure to find liquid investable ways of getting 1006 01:09:30,896 --> 01:09:56,888 things that had low correlation to equities. But that's 1007 01:09:56,888 --> 01:10:31,544 a different story. My issue, also, was calling it a risk premia, 1008 01:10:31,544 --> 01:10:34,432 right? So,labeling trend a risk premia… Like, as Tom knows, 1009 01:07:39,592 --> 01:08:09,644 their trend indicator can look very different than the SocGen CTA 1010 01:08:09,644 --> 01:08:42,428 index, can look very different than the SocGen CTA Trend index can. 1011 01:08:42,428 --> 01:09:17,944 And so, risk premia implies that if the three of us design it, 1012 01:09:17,944 --> 01:09:53,460 it's going to look the same. Like, maybe it's not the S&P 500, 1013 01:09:53,460 --> 01:10:28,976 but it's going to be within kind of… And I think that's been 1014 01:10:28,976 --> 01:10:34,492 a narrative. Imean,you know, the narrative history behind that 1015 01:07:45,356 --> 01:08:29,468 was after the quants almost blew up in 2007, and before that 1016 01:08:29,468 --> 01:09:02,552 they were saying, you know, basically we're quantitative long/short 1017 01:09:02,552 --> 01:09:39,312 order-based lock boxes and we're going to generate alpha from 1018 01:09:39,312 --> 01:10:23,424 scratch. And it was like, oh my God, this is almost long-term 1019 01:10:23,424 --> 01:10:34,452 capital second time. Andso, starting with AQR and others, the 1020 01:07:31,760 --> 01:08:00,992 narrative on the space shifted to no, no, no, we're just harvesting 1021 01:08:00,992 --> 01:08:30,224 risk premia that has been around for 70 years. And these are 1022 01:08:30,224 --> 01:08:54,584 permanent features of the market. And so, BlackRock, and AQR, 1023 01:08:54,584 --> 01:09:21,380 and others, who jumped into this space, talked about this as, 1024 01:09:21,380 --> 01:09:48,176 it's not risky, these are just permanent features of the market 1025 01:09:48,176 --> 01:10:19,844 and we're just going to help you to access it in an efficient 1026 01:10:19,844 --> 01:10:34,460 way. That I think was wrong. So,when I wrote about the trend 1027 01:07:28,925 --> 01:07:59,852 and I wrote a paper on the trend products, we know that manager 1028 01:07:59,852 --> 01:08:30,779 risk, as we talk about, is very, very high in this space. The 1029 01:08:30,779 --> 01:09:01,706 three of us design a model, a long-term trend model, we may have 1030 01:09:01,706 --> 01:09:35,012 a correlation of 0.8. We can still be 20 points apart at the end 1031 01:09:35,012 --> 01:10:05,939 of the year. But it was the characterization of it as risk premia 1032 01:10:05,939 --> 01:10:32,108 implied that XYZ Bank's solution would be the easy one stop 1033 01:10:32,108 --> 01:10:34,487 solution. Now,the way sophisticated allocators have adapted 1034 01:07:26,860 --> 01:07:53,952 to this is not only by going underneath the hood on all these 1035 01:07:53,952 --> 01:08:16,876 products, to a great degree, but also thinking about, okay, so 1036 01:08:16,876 --> 01:08:41,884 this is your flavor, this is another bank's flavor and this is 1037 01:08:41,884 --> 01:09:04,808 another bank's flavor. How as an investor, how is an allocator 1038 01:09:04,808 --> 01:09:29,816 do I want to put these together into a package thereby becoming 1039 01:09:29,816 --> 01:09:50,656 almost like an outsourced portfolio manager? And again, I think 1040 01:09:50,656 --> 01:10:15,664 that's an enormous improvement relative to where we were 12 or 15 1041 01:10:15,664 --> 01:10:34,420 years ago. But then people, they can make calls. Anddo we think 1042 01:07:30,244 --> 01:08:19,667 the team here, who has 37 other quant projects that they're 1043 01:08:19,667 --> 01:09:18,076 working on, do we think these are the people that we really want 1044 01:09:18,076 --> 01:10:11,992 to invest in to be able to build this particular product or 1045 01:10:11,992 --> 01:10:34,457 do we want specialized expertise? 1046 01:10:34,652 --> 01:10:38,744 Yeah, I mean with all models, whether it's CTA models, replication 1047 01:10:38,744 --> 01:10:42,836 models, or whatever, I mean there is a model risk somewhere, 1048 01:10:42,836 --> 01:10:46,928 or an execution risk, or whatever that might be. But yeah, 1049 01:10:46,928 --> 01:10:51,020 this was great. We certainly got around today. Tom, Andrew, any 1050 01:10:51,020 --> 01:10:53,252 final thoughts before we wrap up? 1051 01:10:53,772 --> 01:10:55,932 I hope this is the trendiest year we've ever seen. 1052 01:10:56,832 --> 01:10:59,548 So, do I. What about you, Tom? 1053 01:11:00,512 --> 01:11:03,900 Well, yeah, it's something that seems to happen here. We touched 1054 01:11:03,900 --> 01:11:07,288 on the global kind of conferences and every year the first 1055 01:11:07,288 --> 01:11:11,908 half of the year seems to go off with a bang. And I agree with 1056 01:11:11,908 --> 01:11:15,912 Andrew, we want those trends to persist and we want to have good 1057 01:11:15,912 --> 01:11:17,452 volatility but not bad volatility. 1058 01:11:17,792 --> 01:11:29,791 Yeah, I mean, I think we didn't even touch that much on it, 1059 01:11:29,791 --> 01:11:42,713 but we had written it down that we would talk a little bit more 1060 01:11:42,713 --> 01:11:54,712 about global macro and all that stuff. But I think we can all 1061 01:11:54,712 --> 01:12:07,634 agree that there are a lot of things going on in the world right 1062 01:12:07,634 --> 01:12:16,864 now. So, if you are engaged with strategies that essentially 1063 01:12:16,864 --> 01:12:28,863 not trying to predict too much about where things going to go, but 1064 01:12:28,863 --> 01:12:39,939 do enjoy change as a return driver, then yeah, maybe this could 1065 01:12:39,939 --> 01:12:45,477 be a good year for us. Anyways,Tom, I look forward to seeing 1066 01:11:38,960 --> 01:12:18,272 you in Miami in a couple of weeks. Andrew, I look forward to 1067 01:12:18,272 --> 01:12:45,488 seeing you in a few weeks, back virtually here. Nowfor those 1068 01:11:21,839 --> 01:11:38,027 listening, if you want to show your appreciation for Tom and Andrew 1069 01:11:38,027 --> 01:11:55,564 for all the work they put in in these conversations, go to your 1070 01:11:55,564 --> 01:12:10,403 favorite podcast platform and leave a rating and review. It does 1071 01:12:10,403 --> 01:12:26,591 really help us and it's nice to show, you know, some appreciation 1072 01:12:26,591 --> 01:12:44,128 for all the co-hosts who put a lot of time into producing these 1073 01:12:44,128 --> 01:12:45,477 episodes. Nextweek, Alan will take over hosting for a couple of 1074 01:11:35,986 --> 01:11:57,488 weeks while I travel. He's going to be joined by Mark, one week, 1075 01:11:57,488 --> 01:12:18,990 he's going to be joined by Cem another week. So, please make sure 1076 01:12:18,990 --> 01:12:30,568 to send your questions to info@toptradersunplugged.com and 1077 01:12:30,568 --> 01:12:45,454 I'll make sure that Alan gets ahold of them. FromAndrew, Tom, 1078 01:11:24,902 --> 01:11:53,342 and me, thanks ever so much for listening. We look forward to 1079 01:11:53,342 --> 01:12:24,152 being back with you next week and in the meantime, as always, take 1080 01:12:24,152 --> 01:12:45,482 care of yourself. And take care of each other. 1081 01:12:46,052 --> 01:12:56,492 Thanks for listening to the Systematic Investor Podcast series. 1082 01:12:56,492 --> 01:13:12,732 If you enjoy this series, go on over to iTunes and leave an honest 1083 01:13:12,732 --> 01:13:27,812 rating and review. And be sure to listen to all the other episodes 1084 01:13:27,812 --> 01:13:32,452 from Top Traders Unplugged. Ifyou have questions about systematic 1085 01:12:55,334 --> 01:13:13,898 investing, send us an email with the word question in the subject 1086 01:13:13,898 --> 01:13:20,086 line to info@toptradersunplugged.com and 1087 01:13:20,086 --> 01:13:32,462 we'll try to get it on the show. Andremember, all the discussion 1088 01:12:48,747 --> 01:12:54,676 that we have about investment performance is about the past, and 1089 01:12:54,676 --> 01:12:59,527 past performance does not guarantee or even infer anything 1090 01:12:59,527 --> 01:13:04,378 about future performance. Also, understand that there's a significant 1091 01:13:04,378 --> 01:13:09,768 risk of financial loss with all investment strategies, and you 1092 01:13:09,768 --> 01:13:15,697 need to request and understand the specific risks from the investment 1093 01:13:15,697 --> 01:13:20,548 manager about their products before you make investment decisions. 1094 01:13:20,548 --> 01:13:27,016 Thanks for spending some of your valuable time with us and we'll 1095 01:13:27,016 --> 01:13:32,406 see you on the next episode of the Systematic Investor.