The difference between a 3% rate and a 7% rate is hundreds of dollars.
Seth:The real estate industry has been kind of holding out, waiting to
Seth:see whether the Federal Reserve is going to be lowering rates.
Seth:And that is going to create more demand in the marketplace.
Jenn:We should title this episode the "Seth's Nerd Brain"
Seth:episode.
Seth:Seth's Nerdbrain.
Jenn:You lock yourself into your house because of your rate.
Seth:That has kept a lot of people from selling their home.
Seth:As rates go down, these two things are going to collide.
Seth:There is a chance that this whole market could get blown open again.
Seth:We've now in the real estate industry been like through this massive
Seth:roller coaster And we are hopeful that things are on its way down.
Seth:I Welcome back to Millennia Up.
Jenn:Welcome back.
Seth:uh, you mentioned a quote the other day.
Seth:Why don't you tell us what it was?
Jenn:for every 1 percent rates drop, 5 million buyers re enter the market.
Jenn:I personally love.
Jenn:I think she is a wonderful human being.
Jenn:I would love to see her.
Jenn:Ooh, here's a new 2024 goal.
Jenn:Hey, Barbara Corcoran, come on to our podcast.
Jenn:We would love to have you.
Jenn:Yeah,
Seth:We were not able to find the, like, the statistical data
Seth:for it, but the principle's right.
Seth:that the lower the interest rates are, The, easier it is for people find
Seth:the will to, transact in real estate.
Jenn:It's also just common sense, to be honest.
Seth:Well, it just makes cheaper.
Seth:The lower the interest rates, the cheaper real estate is, and
Seth:it's basically just discount.
Seth:So, you know, a lot of people talk about, you know, COVID and how, how
Seth:people were rushing to get homes.
Seth:There were a lot of people doing that because of COVID, but there were a lot
Seth:of people, you know, and the lifestyle and work from home and they needed
Seth:a new home or they needed to move.
Seth:But a lot of it had to do with the fact that interest
Seth:rates were really, really low.
Seth:They were at the 3 percent and
Seth:I even have a client who locked in 1.
Seth:625 percent
Jenn:Okay, that one I haven't heard
Seth:on, on a 15 year on a huge, like huge house.
Seth:And, it was like a jumbo loan.
Jenn:no matter what happens in the market, don't expect them to resell.
Jenn:Yeah.
Seth:That's not going to come up, but I want like a standard 30 year fixed.
Seth:conventional loan, which is what you would get, if you buy
Seth:a house, in the United States.
Seth:you were probably at about 2.
Seth:75 to 3.
Seth:25 there for about two and a half years.
Jenn:and then it made people think it was normal, you know, 'cause like
Jenn:us millennials, that was when we were getting to the point of, I had already
Jenn:had my house by then, but still it was in, within that timeframe of where.
Jenn:Our average millennials starts to like buy the first house and whatnot, so they're
Jenn:kinda like, we're going into the home buying life with rates at like two, 3%.
Jenn:People thinking it's normal.
Jenn:It's like, oh.
Jenn:then it's all like a mindset thing of, you know, the psychology of, you
Jenn:see rates at 3%, you see them go up to 5% and you're like, oh no, not that.
Jenn:And then you see them go up to 7% and then they're really like, oh God, really?
Jenn:No, not that.
Jenn:Yeah.
Jenn:But as soon as you go from 7 back down to 5, the psychology behind it is
Seth:Yeah, the relativity, the relativity
Jenn:shopping on Black Friday and seeing like, Oh my god, it's on sale!
Jenn:It's literally like, just like marked up and the price is down.
Seth:literally the same price.
Seth:the opposite has now taken place where the rates have gone up.
Seth:Relativity is terrible.
Seth:prices of homes have gone up in general, just because time has gone
Seth:March forward, but also interest
Jenn:gone up because, they are an asset and because they, they do, they
Seth:And it's, and there's, and there's demand for them.
Seth:Like I always say, like if we're selling yachts, like that's a totally
Seth:different thing, but people need houses.
Seth:So there's always going to be value for them.
Seth:It's just a matter of.
Seth:timing and the interest rates in the market timing of year, which is
Seth:what I mean, but now what happened in 2022 the rate started creeping
Seth:up and they went up faster than any other time in United States history.
Seth:So.
Seth:They went down to these historic lows in COVID because they wanted to
Seth:make it very cheap to borrow money.
Seth:They wanted it to be very cheap to keep the economic engine going because
Seth:we had been, I mean, COVID was an unprecedented event of shutdown.
Seth:They gave away a ton of money.
Seth:You know, there's a whole political side to all this, whether they should
Seth:have done it, shouldn't have done it.
Seth:There's a lot of Monday morning quarterbacking about like, Hey,
Seth:should have they done this?
Seth:Should they done that?
Seth:I honestly think that what they did in the beginning was good.
Seth:They just did it for too long.
Seth:They kept the rates way too low for way too long, which created a huge
Seth:rush into real estate, which then created really a supply and demand,
Seth:you basically have a bunch of people hunkering in their homes and then you
Seth:make it really attractive to buy houses.
Seth:Of course, it's going to create a mismatch.
Seth:There's not going to be enough houses.
Seth:Prices go up.
Seth:Then we're running into problems with the amount of money flowing around, which
Seth:is just a fancy way of saying inflation,
Jenn:and
Seth:had to raise rates.
Seth:And now there has been an announcement that rates are capped and now they
Seth:are going to be coming back down.
Seth:So we are on the downward slope, seemingly, unless something else happens
Seth:in the market of this roller coaster.
Seth:And that's what Barbara is talking
Jenn:would never
Seth:That would never happen.
Seth:but Barbara is absolutely right.
Seth:If the right now is rates go down.
Seth:More people are going to enter the market in 2022 and 2023.
Seth:We saw a lot of people pull back and not want to buy anything because either a
Seth:they like really just couldn't afford it
Jenn:They saw what they could have gotten before, and
Seth:well, they they could have.
Seth:But there's like the interest rates going up definitely caused people to
Seth:just flat out not be able to afford the house that they were looking at before.
Seth:And then the other one was it became too hard to afford it.
Seth:the ability to borrow money became more expensive.
Seth:so a 2, 000 a month payment is now like a 3, 400 payment just because of the
Seth:interest rate and like 1, 400 is that's a that's a hefty sum for a lot of people.
Seth:I mean, I have people who are looking at in this market, they're looking at 10,
Seth:000, 11, 000 mortgage payments and they're like, yeah, we can, we can swing it.
Seth:But what?
Jenn:do they do for a living?
Seth:he works in securities and, and she's a HR director for some
Seth:pharmaceutical company somewhere.
Seth:So, but no, but I also work with like people who are, you know, 97%,
Seth:you know, conventional and FHA.
Seth:And yeah, I mean, the, the difference between a 3 rate and
Seth:a 7 rate is hundreds of dollars.
Seth:And for them, that's a big, jump.
Seth:So the real estate industry has been kind of holding out, waiting to see.
Seth:Whether the The Federal Reserve is going to be lowering rates, it
Seth:appears that they are topped out and they are going to be lowering rates.
Seth:And that is going to create more demand in the marketplace.
Seth:have I talked to you about the rate lock effect?
Jenn:we should title this episode the Seth's Nerd Brain
Seth:episode.
Seth:Seth's Nerdbrain.
Seth:no, the rate log effect.
Seth:other thing that happened when you lower rates to 3%, all the existing home
Seth:buyers before 2020, before COVID, all these people had their, these mortgages.
Seth:And so what they did when they saw rates were 3%, they did
Seth:what's called a refinance.
Seth:They refinanced so they took their four or five or six percent rate that they got
Seth:anywhere between 2013 and 2019 and they refinanced it and got that lower rate.
Seth:So now what you have is, I think it's like over 65 percent of
Seth:Americans have a mortgage of three and a half percent or less.
Jenn:So in short, to cover rate lock effect, it's pretty much exactly what
Jenn:it sounds like, is you lock yourself into your house because of your rate.
Seth:Your rate.
Seth:And so, so the idea is, yeah, psychologically and, and financially,
Seth:I mean, if you have a 3% rate in the house that you're living in and you
Seth:want to move, but then you have to go, spend, money at a 7% rate, just
Seth:doesn't make sense for someone to move.
Seth:And so that has kept a lot of people from selling their home.
Seth:And there's been a lot of buyers waiting for interest rates to
Seth:come down and Corcoran is talking about as rates go down, these
Seth:two things are going to collide.
Seth:These rates are going to become more attractive for the three
Seth:percenter holders to sell
Jenn:it's going to be less to like walk away from and like give
Seth:but also as money gets cheaper, i.
Seth:e., you know, interest rates coming down.
Seth:There is a chance that this whole market could get blown open again,
Seth:and that's why she was saying that right now it's not a bad time to buy,
Seth:because if you wait for rates to come down, you're gonna be competing against
Jenn:the law.
Jenn:Well, we talked about that A couple weeks ago too.
Jenn:so I was looking up a bunch of, I, again, me going down a rabbit hole as I'm doing
Jenn:my prep work for these episodes, went down a big Barbara Corcoran rabbit hole again.
Jenn:Love you.
Jenn:Come on.
Seth:like I
Jenn:people have asked her, her take on.
Jenn:Is right now a good time to buy and there's some people saying that she's
Jenn:crazy for saying yes, this is a great time to buy But she is right because
Jenn:it depends on what you want and what's important to you Like do you not want
Jenn:competition because I've heard people say like but I don't want to do a bidding
Jenn:wars Which that's a totally different topic entirely but if that's the case
Jenn:then get out there right now, but something I want to kind of get back to
Jenn:what you said is You know sellers haven't sold because of the rate lock effect.
Jenn:what the Fed is doing, is that going to help support the inventory
Jenn:problem that we've been having?
Seth:okay, imagine the federal lowers the rate and, and they go to 3 percent again.
Seth:The rate log effect would be completely irrelevant because no, I'm not saying
Seth:that's going to happen, but to give it an extreme example, if somebody is
Seth:sitting on a 3 percent rate and the rates go to 3%, then all of a sudden
Seth:that whole idea of like, I don't want to give up my rate, that all goes away.
Seth:But the theory is, is that if it goes from 7 to 5, then it's like, okay, well,
Seth:if I've got a 3 percent rate and I'm, yeah, 5 percent rate, I know I'm not, I'm
Seth:going to give up this great rate, but.
Seth:And this is stuff we always talk about.
Seth:What are the other pain points?
Seth:Like, does the person need more space?
Seth:are they getting divorced?
Seth:want to change school districts or whatever?
Seth:Those considerations then become kind of more in play.
Seth:But right now, the difference between three and a 7 percent rate, like
Seth:that's just too much for most people.
Seth:So as those rates come down, it's going to become more appetizing for people to sell.
Seth:And that's going to be great for the economy and great for buyers because
Seth:they are going to have more options.
Jenn:And that's going to put even more buyers out into the market too, though.
Jenn:So think that the people, so like, obviously there have still
Jenn:been buyers, since this has happened, since the rates went up.
Jenn:just a lot of them, probably I would say, I don't have a statistic for it,
Jenn:but, Common sense would tell me that the majority of them are likely first time
Jenn:homebuyers or downsizers, whatever it may be, where you're paying cash, etc.
Jenn:that took up the buyer's share, but now if we have sellers selling, that's just
Jenn:adding even more buyers into the pool.
Seth:Well, it is, but it's also every, every listing that
Seth:comes up, pulls a bar out.
Seth:as sellers come on the market, it will start satisfying that demand and getting
Seth:people off the buyers out of the market.
Seth:And it's really just a, very rarely is the market really ever balanced.
Seth:That's usually you're in a buyer's market or a seller's market.
Seth:We were really in a pretty balanced market in like 2017, 18, beginning of
Seth:19, 19, before COVID everything started.
Seth:Kind of getting tilted the wrong way and a lot of that had to do
Seth:with a lot of millennial homebuyers coming online meaning they started
Seth:to become of age where they had the financial ability to buy
Jenn:And then COVID just came in and just fucked shit up.
Seth:yeah, and just just messed everything up.
Seth:we've now in the real estate industry been like through this massive roller
Seth:coaster And we are hopeful that things are on its way down I know this was like
Seth:kind of super technical what we talked about I try to distill it down into
Seth:terms that most people can understand if you own a home you definitely Get
Seth:what we're talking about because you were definitely paying attention to
Seth:rates You always pay attention to your rate when you buy a house, but if you
Seth:don't own a home And this is a little technical you have any questions.
Seth:We're always around to Answer them, I'm excited.
Seth:I think it's going to be ultimately good for the economy
Seth:for these rates to come down
Jenn:I mean they're starting to come down slavishly, something that people aren't
Seth:this point of recording they've come from eight to seven and I believe
Seth:that has been over the last about 40 days
Jenn:we're not saying that's a bad time to buy, it might not be the best time to
Jenn:sell, depending on your situation, but for somebody who's looking to buy, even
Jenn:at 7%, like, you're still winning out, because you can still refinance when those
Seth:rates go
Seth:down.
Seth:When those rates all, go down.
Jenn:All right.
Jenn:So we hope it was beneficial hope that sets nerd brain, taught you something.
Jenn:I was here to look pretty, and show off my favorite gift that I've ever been given.
Jenn:And it's really funny.
Seth:guys have any questions about, any of this?
Seth:you can find us at, millennia podcast on Instagram.
Seth:we are on there more than we probably should be.
Seth:We're a little distractible,
Jenn:Alright, see ya, bye!