1 00:00:01,440 --> 00:00:12,321 Welcome to Top Traders Unplugged. In markets success doesn’t 2 00:00:12,321 --> 00:00:24,411 come from predicting what happens next, it comes from being 3 00:00:24,411 --> 00:00:31,665 prepared for what you can’t predict. In each episode we go deep 4 00:00:04,620 --> 00:00:10,450 with some of the world’s most thoughtful minds in investing, economics, 5 00:00:10,450 --> 00:00:16,280 and beyond to understand how they think, how they prepare, and 6 00:00:16,280 --> 00:00:21,580 how they decide, and the experiences that shaped how they 7 00:00:21,580 --> 00:00:26,880 see the world. No noise, no short-cuts, just real conversations 8 00:00:26,880 --> 00:00:31,650 to help you think better and invest with confidence. 9 00:00:35,900 --> 00:00:40,641 Welcome and welcome back to this week's edition of the Systematic 10 00:00:40,641 --> 00:00:44,520 Investor series with Alan Dunne and I, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, 11 00:00:44,520 --> 00:00:49,692 where each week we take the pulse of the global market through 12 00:00:49,692 --> 00:00:52,278 the lens of a rules-based investor. Alan, it is wonderful to 13 00:00:40,000 --> 00:00:49,840 be back with this with you this week. Hope you're doing well. 14 00:00:49,840 --> 00:00:52,300 How was summer? 15 00:00:52,860 --> 00:00:56,388 Summer was good. Yeah, we had a great summer in Ireland. Definitely 16 00:00:56,388 --> 00:01:00,210 had a long spell of good sunshine which is now coming to an 17 00:01:00,210 --> 00:01:04,326 end here. It's dark and dreary and it's wet and rainy. So, it definitely 18 00:01:04,326 --> 00:01:08,148 feels like the summer has come to an abrupt close in Dublin. But 19 00:01:08,148 --> 00:01:10,500 no, we definitely had a really good summer. 20 00:01:10,520 --> 00:01:14,864 I think a lot of places actually right now in Europe would 21 00:01:14,864 --> 00:01:18,846 say, oh, rain, that sounds great because even here in Switzerland 22 00:01:18,846 --> 00:01:23,190 we had, how should I say, information in our mailbox that you're 23 00:01:23,190 --> 00:01:27,896 not allowed to use any kind of watering of your gardens or anything 24 00:01:27,896 --> 00:01:32,240 like that. There really is a very, very severe drought even where 25 00:01:32,240 --> 00:01:36,946 I am. So anyways, we've got a pretty good lineup of topics. Thanks 26 00:01:36,946 --> 00:01:41,290 very much for putting that together. We’ve got a couple of questions 27 00:01:41,290 --> 00:01:45,996 that came in and so, very excited to dive into all of that. 28 00:01:45,996 --> 00:01:51,064 But of course, before we do any of that, as usual, love to hear 29 00:01:51,064 --> 00:01:55,046 what's been on your radar the last two or three weeks. 30 00:01:55,880 --> 00:02:13,076 Yeah, well, it's probably going back at the end of July. It's 31 00:02:13,076 --> 00:02:30,272 been a couple of months since I was on, but definitely thought 32 00:02:30,272 --> 00:02:47,468 it was worth commenting on the US intervention in the yen because 33 00:02:47,468 --> 00:03:01,798 it still remains quite topical. All of, you know, everything 34 00:03:01,798 --> 00:03:18,994 that happened around that. So, I mean, for context (I don't know 35 00:03:18,994 --> 00:03:37,623 if people don't follow the FX market so closely.) It is very rare 36 00:03:37,623 --> 00:03:51,953 for the US to intervene in currency markets. They intervened, 37 00:03:51,953 --> 00:04:10,582 I think, in 2011, but the last time they bought the Japanese yen 38 00:04:10,582 --> 00:04:16,314 was back in 1998. So, we're talking about very rare occurrences 39 00:02:06,226 --> 00:02:22,484 which kind of begs the question what's going on? And it 40 00:02:22,484 --> 00:02:40,220 was very interesting this time around - a couple of aspects. One, 41 00:02:40,220 --> 00:02:57,956 they sold the euro and bought the yen, which was an interesting 42 00:02:57,956 --> 00:03:15,692 twist in it. And then the second thing was they announced that 43 00:03:15,692 --> 00:03:33,428 kind of going forward, that if Japan would continue to buy yen, 44 00:03:33,428 --> 00:03:49,686 they could tap this FEMA facility at the Fed, which would 45 00:03:49,686 --> 00:04:04,466 effectively allow them to borrow dollars, to sell dollars if 46 00:04:04,466 --> 00:04:16,290 they felt further intervention was needed going forward. So, I think 47 00:01:59,855 --> 00:02:15,755 that aspect really points to the sensitivity the US has big bondholder 48 00:02:15,755 --> 00:02:30,330 selling bonds at the moment, and the sensitivity they have to 49 00:02:30,330 --> 00:02:46,230 rising yields. And obviously we saw more on that with Scott Bessent's 50 00:02:46,230 --> 00:03:00,805 announcement the week before last. So, I think it's very much 51 00:03:00,805 --> 00:03:14,055 consistent with the idea that we're in unprecedented maybe, or 52 00:03:14,055 --> 00:03:25,980 certainly very rare occurrences, and there is this very 53 00:03:25,980 --> 00:03:40,555 heightened concern about the US bond market, is the sense you 54 00:03:40,555 --> 00:03:56,455 get. And also, interestingly, the FT had an article that the US 55 00:03:56,455 --> 00:04:12,355 didn't inform Europe, the ECB, in advance of the euro sales, which 56 00:04:12,355 --> 00:04:16,330 was quite unusual. Now, you might say that's a bit surprising, 57 00:02:15,592 --> 00:02:40,232 but obviously there's been a lot of surprising developments in 58 00:02:40,232 --> 00:03:02,408 how the current administration has dealt with its international 59 00:03:02,408 --> 00:03:34,440 partners. But again, it was another angle on it and kind of a 60 00:03:34,440 --> 00:04:06,472 twist of the US very much acting in its own interests and not 61 00:04:06,472 --> 00:04:16,328 necessarily coordinating with Europeans. So, I think, yeah, I mean, 62 00:02:19,964 --> 00:03:08,132 that the thing I took away from it was this real sensitivity 63 00:03:08,132 --> 00:04:00,314 about rising yields and a real reluctance to allow a big asset holder 64 00:04:00,314 --> 00:04:16,370 to sell their treasuries. 65 00:04:16,540 --> 00:04:21,688 Yeah, I completely agree, of course, but I think there's more 66 00:04:21,688 --> 00:04:26,368 to the story, actually. And later today, I'm actually recording 67 00:04:26,368 --> 00:04:32,452 an episode that comes out a few days after this one with Cem 68 00:04:32,452 --> 00:04:38,068 and Marvin Barth on Global Macro. And I think we're going to 69 00:04:38,068 --> 00:04:43,684 probably touch on this as well. But I get the feeling that 70 00:04:43,684 --> 00:04:48,364 it's not necessarily just about the level of the currency. 71 00:04:48,364 --> 00:04:53,512 There's so much more into it, including sort of interest concerning 72 00:04:53,512 --> 00:04:57,724 industrial production because Japan has actually turned out to 73 00:04:57,724 --> 00:05:04,276 become, really, the only place the US can go to get some of their 74 00:05:04,276 --> 00:05:10,828 military stuff built in time for it to be used and to a standard 75 00:05:10,828 --> 00:05:13,168 that is up to scratch. 76 00:05:13,180 --> 00:05:25,296 Yeah, I think there are many dimensions to it. I mean, I think 77 00:05:25,296 --> 00:05:37,412 it was positioned as the US helping out a friend in Japan. But 78 00:05:37,412 --> 00:05:49,528 I mean, I think that's a very superficial reading of it. I think 79 00:05:49,528 --> 00:06:01,644 the other thing to keep in mind is, I think, with FX markets, 80 00:06:01,644 --> 00:06:09,100 a case of careful what you wish for. I mean, I started off in 81 00:05:16,318 --> 00:05:22,594 FX, so I remember very clearly the 1998 episode, and actually it 82 00:05:22,594 --> 00:05:27,301 was seemingly successful, initially, in the sense that the 83 00:05:27,301 --> 00:05:33,054 yen stopped selling off and then it stabilized, but then the 84 00:05:33,054 --> 00:05:39,330 Fed cut rates and dollar/yen had a huge collapse in about four 85 00:05:39,330 --> 00:05:46,129 days. So, I mean, you don't want to have that kind of instability 86 00:05:46,129 --> 00:05:52,928 of a massive carry unwind. Not suggesting we will, but it just shows 87 00:05:52,928 --> 00:05:58,681 you that you start pushing currencies one way and then back 88 00:05:58,681 --> 00:06:05,480 to another way, you just don't know what kind of second order effects 89 00:06:05,480 --> 00:06:09,141 it can have. But yeah, it's definitely… 90 00:06:09,150 --> 00:06:10,350 It’s worth keeping an eye on. 91 00:06:10,590 --> 00:06:11,390 Yes, for sure. 92 00:06:11,550 --> 00:06:29,238 Yeah. And actually yeah, the price had initially a decent move, 93 00:06:29,238 --> 00:06:48,534 but some of it has obviously disappeared again, so to speak. The 94 00:06:48,534 --> 00:07:04,614 effect has disappeared. So, it will be interesting to see. So, on 95 00:06:12,946 --> 00:06:22,020 my radar this week I’ve only got one thing, but it involves you, 96 00:06:22,020 --> 00:06:30,396 Alan, because I got inspired by a Danish podcast that I sometimes 97 00:06:30,396 --> 00:06:39,470 listen to where the two hosts have to guess what a certain number 98 00:06:39,470 --> 00:06:48,544 that has been in the news refers to. So, I thought I'm going 99 00:06:48,544 --> 00:06:57,618 to try it out with you, Alan. Obviously not rehearsed in any shape 100 00:06:57,618 --> 00:07:04,598 or form. So, the number for you is US$16.68 billion. What do 101 00:06:26,718 --> 00:07:04,638 you think that number represents? 102 00:07:05,600 --> 00:07:10,132 Wow, US$16.68 billion... I don't know. It's got to be something 103 00:07:10,132 --> 00:07:14,664 related… I was going to say related to, obviously, the US$30 104 00:07:14,664 --> 00:07:20,432 trillion that has been in the news on the debt side, so I thought 105 00:07:20,432 --> 00:07:24,552 maybe, but then US$16.68 seems low… yeah… relative to that. 106 00:07:24,660 --> 00:08:19,508 I’ll take you off the hook. Yeah, absolutely. It is, as far as 107 00:07:28,630 --> 00:07:37,364 I understand, the proposed, or part of the proposed settlement between 108 00:07:37,364 --> 00:07:44,510 29 States, Mark Zuckerberg's meta organization, which also includes 109 00:07:44,510 --> 00:07:52,450 some significant changes in terms of how Instagram and Facebook 110 00:07:52,450 --> 00:08:01,184 interact with children and teens, which I'm sure you, with a 111 00:08:01,184 --> 00:08:10,712 young daughter will welcome - that maybe they won't be able to 112 00:08:10,712 --> 00:08:19,446 interact with young children the way they have been so far. But 113 00:07:25,906 --> 00:07:42,104 of course, US$16.68 billion is not a lot of money compared to the 114 00:07:42,104 --> 00:07:54,564 US$60 billion Mr. Zuckerberg spent on his Metaverse, which seems 115 00:07:54,564 --> 00:08:09,516 to have been completely a waste of time and money… well, we'll 116 00:08:09,516 --> 00:08:19,484 see. I'm sure they've learned something. But anyways. 117 00:08:19,510 --> 00:08:22,282 There was a story that he's bought a castle here in Ireland, 118 00:08:22,282 --> 00:08:24,823 in Waterford. So, that would have been another good question to 119 00:08:24,823 --> 00:08:28,288 have had for me, but I don't know how much he paid for that. Probably 120 00:08:28,288 --> 00:08:29,905 not US$16 billion, anyway… a little less. 121 00:08:31,270 --> 00:09:13,954 Well, there we are. Anyways, I'm pretty sure I'm not going to 122 00:09:13,954 --> 00:09:49,524 repeat this experiment with a number for the co-host, although 123 00:09:49,524 --> 00:10:32,208 sometimes is quite funny what they come up with, these two guys. 124 00:08:31,270 --> 00:09:00,838 Anyways, another number that is somewhat lower, it's 43. I'm sure 125 00:09:00,838 --> 00:09:30,406 you can guess, that is actually the trend barometer as of 126 00:09:30,406 --> 00:09:54,598 yesterday. So, it's pretty neutral. We are recording Thursday, 127 00:09:54,598 --> 00:10:32,230 so we have about two and a half trading days left of the month. 128 00:08:31,270 --> 00:08:44,578 So far August looks pretty decent when I look at the numbers 129 00:08:44,578 --> 00:08:54,559 which we'll go through shortly. But August, actually, hasn't 130 00:08:54,559 --> 00:09:08,976 necessarily been an easy month when you look at kind of the “two 131 00:09:08,976 --> 00:09:18,957 types”. I know maybe the official yen intervention happened 132 00:09:18,957 --> 00:09:33,374 in late July, but we've had kind of these two types of interventions. 133 00:09:33,374 --> 00:09:47,791 One was the yen first and then “intervention in the US bond market”, 134 00:09:47,791 --> 00:09:59,990 both of which actually went against the bigger trend. So, that 135 00:09:59,990 --> 00:10:09,971 would have hurt performance. So, all-in-all I think, actually, 136 00:10:09,971 --> 00:10:22,170 it's a pretty respectable month so far. But of course, lots 137 00:10:22,170 --> 00:10:32,151 of things can happen in the last few days. In addition to the 138 00:08:36,362 --> 00:08:51,638 “manipulated moves” in the yen and the bonds, we've also seen a 139 00:08:51,638 --> 00:09:04,368 big move in bitcoin. I wouldn't necessarily call it manipulated, 140 00:09:04,368 --> 00:09:19,644 but of course it's completely tied to some policies that the White 141 00:09:19,644 --> 00:09:33,647 House is trying to get through, as far as I understand, 142 00:09:33,647 --> 00:09:50,196 and I don't know, I mean we don't trade bitcoin on our side. 143 00:09:50,196 --> 00:10:09,291 So, I have no idea whether this has been a good move or a bad 144 00:10:09,291 --> 00:10:24,567 move for trend followers, but it certainly moved 25%, 30% or so 145 00:10:24,567 --> 00:10:32,205 in the last couple of weeks. So, yeah. Any thoughts on your side? 146 00:09:08,083 --> 00:10:16,450 I mean now that you have your own fund, you're tracking these managers 147 00:10:16,450 --> 00:10:32,227 closely, I'm sure. 148 00:10:32,800 --> 00:10:41,989 Absolutely, yeah, it's interesting. I mean August is interesting, 149 00:10:41,989 --> 00:10:55,262 as you say. You might have said, okay, it feels like the trend 150 00:10:55,262 --> 00:11:07,514 has been rising yields, but actually kind of US bond yields have 151 00:11:07,514 --> 00:11:20,787 been kind of flat to slightly lower over the course of this month. 152 00:11:20,787 --> 00:11:32,018 Yields outside the US have risen a bit. But actually, across 153 00:11:32,018 --> 00:11:41,207 the managers that we're allocating to, notably seeing good 154 00:11:41,207 --> 00:11:53,459 gains on the commodity side in August, which is obviously a really 155 00:11:53,459 --> 00:12:03,669 positive aspect of allocating to trend. We're talking about markets 156 00:12:03,669 --> 00:12:15,921 like zinc, and wheat, and lean hogs. Copper has been rising again. 157 00:10:32,800 --> 00:10:47,727 So, as you mentioned, we've had kind of choppy conditions in 158 00:10:47,727 --> 00:11:04,011 currencies, not just in the yen. Obviously, the euro had a big… 159 00:11:04,011 --> 00:11:21,652 the dollar sold off on the kind of on the Bessent bond intervention 160 00:11:21,652 --> 00:11:40,650 and as did the gold. So, they were both kind of a weaker dollar 161 00:11:40,650 --> 00:11:54,220 trade which would have been negative for trend followers. But 162 00:11:54,220 --> 00:12:06,433 it’s certainly encouraging to see those strong, strongish gains 163 00:12:06,433 --> 00:12:15,932 I would say on the commodity side. And yeah, I mean, in July it 164 00:10:47,836 --> 00:11:09,316 was a decent amount of dispersion again there. Some managers 165 00:11:09,316 --> 00:11:24,352 with some idiosyncrasies were outperforming and underperforming. 166 00:11:24,352 --> 00:11:50,128 You see some people trading in credit, for example, and that was 167 00:11:50,128 --> 00:12:13,756 a negative. Others, with kind of non-trend signals, doing a bit 168 00:12:13,756 --> 00:12:15,904 better. So, I think yeah, we're definitely seeing a decent 169 00:10:52,132 --> 00:11:17,908 amount of dispersion, but I would say, kind of from the perspective 170 00:11:17,908 --> 00:11:43,684 of the role of trend in a portfolio and getting it diversification, 171 00:11:43,684 --> 00:12:07,312 it's always a very encouraging sign when you see stronger trends 172 00:12:07,312 --> 00:12:15,904 in the commodity markets. 173 00:12:17,341 --> 00:12:21,791 And since you mentioned the word dispersion which we normally 174 00:12:21,791 --> 00:12:26,241 associate as you say with the difference in performance between 175 00:12:26,241 --> 00:12:29,801 managers, CTAs, trend followers, whatever, however we define 176 00:12:29,801 --> 00:12:35,586 it, I will say I've also noticed there's been a lot of dispersion 177 00:12:35,586 --> 00:12:41,816 in returns among “CTA ETFs”. And I know that the ETFs can be very, 178 00:12:41,816 --> 00:12:47,156 very different, I mean, they can really be different. So, I do 179 00:12:47,156 --> 00:12:52,941 understand that, but I will say some of the moves have been surprisingly 180 00:12:52,941 --> 00:12:58,726 large. Also, I guess my worry a little bit is that most people 181 00:12:58,726 --> 00:13:03,621 who buy them probably don't really know what's behind it. So, 182 00:13:03,621 --> 00:13:08,961 they have probably less of a chance (my words of course), less 183 00:13:08,961 --> 00:13:13,856 of a chance of getting a feel for what to expect. 184 00:13:14,921 --> 00:13:18,419 Yeah, I think, as you say, there are quite notable differences 185 00:13:18,419 --> 00:13:22,553 in the US ETF market with some managers not trading the full set 186 00:13:22,553 --> 00:13:26,051 of asset classes, others trading a very narrow set. So, I 187 00:13:26,051 --> 00:13:28,913 think that definitely drives a good chunk of it. 188 00:13:29,001 --> 00:16:09,960 Yeah, for sure. Anyways, let's reveal the numbers. As of Tuesday, 189 00:13:43,145 --> 00:14:06,129 25th August, we see the BTOP 50 up 2.14% in August, up 10.26% 190 00:14:06,129 --> 00:14:29,113 so far this year, so, very strong. SocGen CTA up 1.34% in August, 191 00:14:29,113 --> 00:14:48,561 up 9.55% so far this year, also very respectable. SocGen Trend 192 00:14:48,561 --> 00:15:13,313 up 1.19%, up 9.19% so far this year, also pretty good. And the Short-Term 193 00:15:13,313 --> 00:15:36,297 Traders index a pretty good month, I will say, up 1.69% [so far 194 00:15:36,297 --> 00:15:57,513 this month], and up 4.93% [so far this year], so, definitely coming 195 00:15:57,513 --> 00:16:09,889 back a little bit on that front. In the traditional world MSCI 196 00:13:46,121 --> 00:14:30,633 World (and these numbers are as of last night) up 2.68% so far 197 00:14:30,633 --> 00:15:15,145 this month, up 13.49 so far this year. Taking out the US and 198 00:15:15,145 --> 00:15:56,233 Canada. So, the MSCI World EAFE index up 2.54%, and up 14.85% 199 00:15:56,233 --> 00:16:09,929 so far this year. The US Aggregate Bond index up 78 basis 200 00:13:54,249 --> 00:14:35,277 points for the month, up 45 basis points for the year. So, not 201 00:14:35,277 --> 00:15:19,461 a lot of real returns so far this year. And the S&P 500 Total 202 00:15:19,461 --> 00:16:03,645 Return up to 2.58% in August and up 12.97% this year, so, a very 203 00:16:03,645 --> 00:16:09,957 respectable return. Now, I mentioned we had two questions that 204 00:13:47,937 --> 00:14:18,708 came in, so the first question must have come in just after you 205 00:14:18,708 --> 00:14:51,846 were on last time because I made a note in my little sheet here 206 00:14:51,846 --> 00:15:24,984 saying that it came in on the 17th of July. So, we apologize but 207 00:15:24,984 --> 00:15:55,755 Alan didn't come back on the show until now, so we've kept it 208 00:15:55,755 --> 00:16:09,957 for you. And it's from Jason. And Jason writes, Kevin Warsh made 209 00:13:36,429 --> 00:13:53,761 it known that he's not a big fan of the Fed's balance sheet. His 210 00:13:53,761 --> 00:14:06,141 thinking is that lingering balance sheet risk acting too much 211 00:14:06,141 --> 00:14:19,759 like fiscal policy rather than classic front end only monetary policy 212 00:14:19,759 --> 00:14:30,901 like the Fed has traditionally performed before Bernanke. Ideally, 213 00:14:30,901 --> 00:14:43,281 we need free markets to be determining price discovery beyond 214 00:14:43,281 --> 00:14:56,899 the overnight rate. His thinking is that the Fed should act 215 00:14:56,899 --> 00:15:09,279 responsibly, instead of kicking the can down the road similar 216 00:15:09,279 --> 00:15:22,897 to what the US government has done with its unsustainable spending. 217 00:15:22,897 --> 00:15:37,753 If what was once used as a temporary emergency measure QT needs 218 00:15:37,753 --> 00:15:53,847 to be paid back, how does he plan to lowering mortgage rates if 219 00:15:53,847 --> 00:16:08,703 he saturates the market with new heavy supply of the Fed's balance 220 00:16:08,703 --> 00:16:09,959 sheet? Well, that's an easy question, right, Alan? 221 00:16:10,281 --> 00:16:28,836 Exactly. I mean, it does cut to a lot of the points that are very 222 00:16:28,836 --> 00:16:39,969 relevant in the whole discussion around not just Bessent's 223 00:16:39,969 --> 00:16:53,576 actions but Warsh's comments at the last press conference as well. 224 00:16:53,576 --> 00:17:09,657 And I think the reality is we don't really know what Kevin Warsh's 225 00:17:09,657 --> 00:17:25,738 plans are. He did come into the role talking a lot about, as 226 00:17:25,738 --> 00:17:38,108 the listener pointed out, the excessive balance sheet. And basically, 227 00:17:38,108 --> 00:17:51,715 his suggestion was that the Fed was complicit in the Treasury's 228 00:17:51,715 --> 00:18:01,611 ballooning deficit and debt by engaging in QE. But at the same time, 229 00:16:14,466 --> 00:16:23,673 we haven't heard of a framework yet as to what's going 230 00:16:23,673 --> 00:16:34,554 to be done. Now obviously, he has his various task forces, so my 231 00:16:34,554 --> 00:16:45,435 sense is he's not going to make any decisions till he gets the 232 00:16:45,435 --> 00:16:53,805 reports from the various task forces. And then, obviously, there 233 00:16:53,805 --> 00:17:05,523 is this question is he really going to go down this route of normalizing 234 00:17:05,523 --> 00:17:13,893 the balance sheet which would obviously increase the supply of 235 00:17:13,893 --> 00:17:25,611 bonds in the market at a time when the treasury is trying to increase 236 00:17:25,611 --> 00:17:35,655 its demand and reduce its supply of bonds and shift its issuance 237 00:17:35,655 --> 00:17:46,536 to T bills, that doesn't seem unlikely for a Fed chair who's having 238 00:17:46,536 --> 00:17:55,743 regular phone calls with the President as well, as another kind 239 00:17:55,743 --> 00:18:01,602 of element to go into the mix. So, I mean, I think the problem is 240 00:16:23,577 --> 00:16:41,859 we don't know what Kevin Warsh's latest thinking on any of 241 00:16:41,859 --> 00:17:01,803 these things are since he became Fed chair. So, I'm kind of 242 00:17:01,803 --> 00:17:25,071 a bit skeptical that we're going to see much in the way of balance 243 00:17:25,071 --> 00:17:40,029 sheet reduction in the short-term and certainly not until 244 00:17:40,029 --> 00:17:59,973 we hear what are the various views from all the different task 245 00:17:59,973 --> 00:18:01,635 forces. 246 00:18:01,981 --> 00:18:13,537 Yeah, I think that is very diplomatic and correct to say at 247 00:18:13,537 --> 00:18:26,056 this stage. And of course, I think we're going to dive into this 248 00:18:26,056 --> 00:18:35,686 a little bit later in our conversation today because there 249 00:18:35,686 --> 00:18:48,205 is a lot of stuff going on around the policy makers and some 250 00:18:48,205 --> 00:18:56,872 of their proteges or vice versa, I should say. Anyways, we 251 00:18:03,697 --> 00:18:15,709 also had a question in from Ben Dasian. He came in with a question 252 00:18:15,709 --> 00:18:24,289 for you, Alan. If short term trend has structurally degraded, 253 00:18:24,289 --> 00:18:33,727 does that actually make medium slow trend more crowded and potentially 254 00:18:33,727 --> 00:18:40,591 create larger synchronized exits when those signals eventually 255 00:18:40,591 --> 00:18:50,029 flip? What markets today have the biggest gap between the macro 256 00:18:50,029 --> 00:18:56,893 narrative and what systematic positioning is actually saying? 257 00:18:58,041 --> 00:19:13,133 Yeah, well I think there's two distinct questions there. I mean, 258 00:19:13,133 --> 00:19:30,969 yes, obviously the last time I was on we talked about the paper 259 00:19:30,969 --> 00:19:46,061 from the researchers at CFM, or associated with CFM, about the 260 00:19:46,061 --> 00:19:57,037 degradation in short-term trend following, in some contracts 261 00:19:57,037 --> 00:20:14,873 but not all. And I mean, I think this is something that's been 262 00:20:14,873 --> 00:20:31,337 known for quite a while that the short-term trend has got more 263 00:20:31,337 --> 00:20:32,709 challenging. I mean some people, some managers still like 264 00:19:09,881 --> 00:19:26,161 it in terms of having that fast reactivity, having that convexity 265 00:19:26,161 --> 00:19:45,401 that you get particularly in kind of as you go into risk-off periods. 266 00:19:45,401 --> 00:20:04,641 So, I mean, I don't think we're going to see or we've recently 267 00:20:04,641 --> 00:20:22,401 seen a big shift into medium and long-term trend. I think that's 268 00:20:22,401 --> 00:20:32,761 been the pattern for a while now. And I think what the research, 269 00:19:06,921 --> 00:19:23,201 actually, from that paper, also showed was that we're not seeing 270 00:19:23,201 --> 00:19:38,001 that the size of the asset increase, that those explanations 271 00:19:38,001 --> 00:19:49,841 for the degradation and performance across trend strategies 272 00:19:49,841 --> 00:20:09,081 didn't stack up. So, the size of the CTA industry relative to the 273 00:20:09,081 --> 00:20:25,361 liquidity of the futures market is not so large that there 274 00:20:25,361 --> 00:20:32,761 is a concern around that. So, I think, yeah, short-term trend is 275 00:19:13,826 --> 00:19:31,866 probably something that managers have in their portfolio 276 00:19:31,866 --> 00:20:01,181 to varying degrees. Some keep it in for that convexity, but I don't 277 00:20:01,181 --> 00:20:25,986 think that it's pointing to a generalized overcrowding in the medium 278 00:20:25,986 --> 00:20:32,751 and long-term space. 279 00:20:33,011 --> 00:20:53,590 Yeah, I have two thoughts on that. One is, I actually think that 280 00:20:53,590 --> 00:21:12,586 short-term… and by the way, I don't really know that there's something 281 00:21:12,586 --> 00:21:25,250 called short-term trend following because frankly all the 282 00:21:25,250 --> 00:21:41,080 managers I know in the short-term space, they're not really 283 00:21:41,080 --> 00:21:55,327 trend followers, they're like vol expansion type strategies or 284 00:21:55,327 --> 00:22:07,991 whatever. But let's just call a short-term trend. I'm not so sure 285 00:20:36,967 --> 00:20:49,824 that AUM didn't play a role here because I've seen a couple of 286 00:20:49,824 --> 00:21:01,692 examples where people did well and had a very good narrative, very 287 00:21:01,692 --> 00:21:13,560 strong narrative, and you saw lots of money flowing in their direction 288 00:21:13,560 --> 00:21:24,439 and after that return stopped really to be materialized. So, I've 289 00:21:24,439 --> 00:21:37,296 always felt, and I'm sure I've said it many times on the podcast, 290 00:21:37,296 --> 00:21:48,175 when I see short-term managers managing even US$2, US$3, US$4 plus 291 00:21:48,175 --> 00:21:59,054 billion dollars, I'm really curious, how do they do that successfully 292 00:21:59,054 --> 00:22:07,955 without it becoming just way too expensive to execute? So, I do 293 00:20:38,099 --> 00:20:55,059 think, I mean, of course you're completely right in saying 294 00:20:55,059 --> 00:21:13,715 that the overall industry hasn't really grown a lot. So, I'm 295 00:21:13,715 --> 00:21:32,371 not concerned about liquidity and cost of execution when it comes 296 00:21:32,371 --> 00:21:51,027 to long-term or medium-term trend. That's not the issue for sure. 297 00:21:51,027 --> 00:22:07,987 But when it comes to short-term, without knowing the details… 298 00:22:08,001 --> 00:22:08,841 I think that's a different question. 299 00:22:08,841 --> 00:22:09,441 Yeah, exactly. 300 00:22:09,441 --> 00:22:10,601 But yeah, I don't disagree. 301 00:22:10,601 --> 00:22:12,081 Yeah, absolutely. 302 00:22:12,081 --> 00:22:16,833 And the second part of that question, which markets is the macro 303 00:22:16,833 --> 00:22:17,229 narrative? 304 00:22:17,241 --> 00:22:17,561 Right? 305 00:22:18,171 --> 00:22:23,651 Yeah, I mean that's an interesting question. Hard to… I 306 00:22:23,651 --> 00:22:31,323 mean, I was racking my brains a little bit. I mean maybe the US 307 00:22:31,323 --> 00:22:36,803 dollar, I mean the macro narrative is probably more pessimistic 308 00:22:36,803 --> 00:22:43,927 on the dollar arguably, but I mean you could debate that. But at 309 00:22:43,927 --> 00:22:50,503 the same time, I think CTAs are still generally okay. They may 310 00:22:50,503 --> 00:22:56,531 have pared back recently, with net long dollar exposure. So, that's 311 00:22:56,531 --> 00:22:58,723 one I would say. I think on fixed income trend positioning is 312 00:22:29,371 --> 00:22:44,771 probably in line with the macro narrative. The trend is for 313 00:22:44,771 --> 00:22:58,771 higher yields for all the reasons people are worried about. 314 00:22:58,781 --> 00:23:09,701 But this is the other thing, because I see now, I mean, in the 315 00:23:09,701 --> 00:23:18,281 last, what, let's say five years, it's become very normal to 316 00:23:18,281 --> 00:23:26,081 receive these emails from the big investment houses saying, oh, 317 00:23:26,081 --> 00:23:35,441 CTAs are getting ready to buy US$70 billion worth of equities if 318 00:23:35,441 --> 00:23:46,361 the S&P closes above this level for two days in a row, or whatever. 319 00:23:46,361 --> 00:23:55,721 I mean, it's completely crazy to pay any attention to these things, 320 00:23:55,721 --> 00:24:05,081 in my opinion, because there's so much more that goes into that. 321 00:24:05,081 --> 00:24:15,221 And to this question, I would say, yeah, we could talk about positioning 322 00:24:15,221 --> 00:24:24,581 and being close to narrative, but what people often forget is that, 323 00:24:24,581 --> 00:24:33,161 at certain times, even though you're a “longer term manager”, we 324 00:24:33,161 --> 00:24:37,061 can change positioning pretty quickly. I mean, for example, with 325 00:23:03,596 --> 00:23:15,152 the yen, I'm sure lots of people pared down their yen exposure 326 00:23:15,152 --> 00:23:26,708 very quickly because it was such a big move after the intervention, 327 00:23:26,708 --> 00:23:40,190 and so on, and so forth. So, again, I think yes, we’d love to 328 00:23:40,190 --> 00:23:50,783 have a narrative for what trend followers are doing, but in 329 00:23:50,783 --> 00:24:03,302 the reality the best thing is probably not to spend too much time 330 00:24:03,302 --> 00:24:19,673 on that and just let us do what we do and that is to, in a completely 331 00:24:19,673 --> 00:24:31,229 unbiased way, just follow the price and keep our heads down, so 332 00:24:31,229 --> 00:24:37,007 to speak. But there we are. Anyways, let's move on because we 333 00:23:17,213 --> 00:23:47,933 move straight into your current macro view and that obviously 334 00:23:47,933 --> 00:24:27,869 opens up a lot of avenues that we touched on already. But let's 335 00:24:27,869 --> 00:24:37,085 dive into it. 336 00:24:38,081 --> 00:24:42,641 Yeah, well, again, following up on what we spoke about the last 337 00:24:42,641 --> 00:24:46,821 time, the last day we did speak about communication at the 338 00:24:46,821 --> 00:24:51,761 Fed. And that was, I guess was the middle of July or something. 339 00:24:51,761 --> 00:24:55,561 It was obviously before the second FOMC press conference because 340 00:24:55,561 --> 00:24:59,361 after that this whole topic really escalated as something that 341 00:24:59,361 --> 00:25:00,121 has been… 342 00:25:00,121 --> 00:25:03,745 And sorry to interrupt you here, but maybe just for people to 343 00:25:03,745 --> 00:25:07,067 realize, I mentioned we are recording on Thursday, but in terms 344 00:25:07,067 --> 00:25:09,785 of communication, I mean, we're heading straight into Jackson 345 00:25:09,785 --> 00:25:10,389 Hole, so… 346 00:25:10,401 --> 00:25:11,001 Yes, exactly. 347 00:25:11,001 --> 00:25:13,281 So, it is relevant to talk about communication. 348 00:25:13,441 --> 00:26:01,477 So, this is the next episode is coming imminently. Warsh is scheduled 349 00:26:01,477 --> 00:26:45,510 to speak tomorrow. But we've had two press conferences, and after 350 00:26:45,510 --> 00:27:29,543 his first one, he said, we're committed to price stability and 351 00:27:29,543 --> 00:28:09,573 he kind of hinted at less communication basically and given 352 00:28:09,573 --> 00:28:53,606 less guidance. And then he carried that through into the second 353 00:28:53,606 --> 00:29:33,636 press conference where his performance was very kind of debated. 354 00:29:33,636 --> 00:30:17,669 Generally, I think he had a poor score for that performance. 355 00:25:13,441 --> 00:26:19,067 But it's interesting how the market then split into two camps 356 00:26:19,067 --> 00:27:36,625 of people. Some people say, no, this is okay, we've had too long 357 00:27:36,625 --> 00:28:48,217 for the Fed spoon-feeding the market, and this is a good thing, 358 00:28:48,217 --> 00:29:53,843 free markets. And then the other camp saying, no, no, that's 359 00:29:53,843 --> 00:30:17,707 not how it works. So, I would be in his camp of saying, no, it 360 00:26:04,151 --> 00:27:04,081 doesn't work like that. And I think the thing is that it's not 361 00:27:04,081 --> 00:27:50,181 that people want forward guidance. That's not the issue. I 362 00:27:50,181 --> 00:28:31,671 think Warsh is correct. The forward guidance wasn't necessarily 363 00:28:31,671 --> 00:29:31,601 a good thing. But the market doesn't have a sense on the Fed's 364 00:29:31,601 --> 00:30:08,481 what's called reaction function, so, how they're seeing 365 00:30:08,481 --> 00:30:17,701 the economy. At the moment, we've got this AI boom. It's inflationary 366 00:25:43,271 --> 00:26:16,084 in the short-term, it may be disinflationary down the line. What's 367 00:26:16,084 --> 00:26:48,897 the appropriate policy for that? Warsh has kind of thrown that 368 00:26:48,897 --> 00:27:27,676 question out there but hasn't given any kind of sense on how they're 369 00:27:27,676 --> 00:28:00,489 thinking about that. How did they think about the supply side 370 00:28:00,489 --> 00:28:36,285 issues related to Iran? And I think his comment that the market 371 00:28:36,285 --> 00:29:12,081 needs to play the ball, not the referee, I think it appealed 372 00:29:12,081 --> 00:29:41,911 to certain people, but it doesn't really make sense because 373 00:29:41,911 --> 00:30:17,707 Wall Street has always tried to infer what the Fed was doing. 374 00:25:13,441 --> 00:26:06,560 Even before the 1990s when they didn't even make an announcement, 375 00:26:06,560 --> 00:27:04,508 all the banks would have had Fed watchers trying to infer what 376 00:27:04,508 --> 00:27:57,627 the Fed is doing from their open market operations. Why? Well, 377 00:27:57,627 --> 00:28:41,088 obviously what's happened to liquidity is an important factor 378 00:28:41,088 --> 00:29:39,036 for the economy and for asset markets. So, to suggest don't ignore 379 00:29:39,036 --> 00:30:17,668 the Fed, it doesn't really make any sense. And then he pointed 380 00:25:31,605 --> 00:26:30,638 to the rise in bond yields in the period since the previous meeting, 381 00:26:30,638 --> 00:27:20,589 saying this is the market doing the Fed's job. But obviously 382 00:27:20,589 --> 00:28:15,081 some of that rise in yields reflected the fact that the market 383 00:28:15,081 --> 00:29:00,491 interpreted his last press conference as being a bit hawkish. 384 00:29:00,491 --> 00:29:54,983 And the market understands, or at least the thought of it, that 385 00:29:54,983 --> 00:30:17,688 it’s the Fed's reaction function. So, I think it's been frustrating 386 00:25:32,455 --> 00:26:10,483 for people. You might say, does it matter? Well, I think it 387 00:26:10,483 --> 00:26:48,511 matters in a few ways because obviously the Fed's trying to reestablished 388 00:26:48,511 --> 00:27:20,201 credibility. It's missed the inflation target for five years now, 389 00:27:20,201 --> 00:28:04,567 and he's come in saying he's going to do a lot, but actually he 390 00:28:04,567 --> 00:28:39,426 hasn't backed it up with action. And if you're not backing 391 00:28:39,426 --> 00:29:17,454 it up with action, if you don't have a good explanation as 392 00:29:17,454 --> 00:29:58,651 to why, well, then that's when the market starts to wonder, is there 393 00:29:58,651 --> 00:30:17,665 really that resolve to tackle it? I think that's what we saw after 394 00:25:28,540 --> 00:25:47,953 the July FOMC meeting, immediately during and after the 395 00:25:47,953 --> 00:26:05,209 conference and the press conference, the curve steepened, 396 00:26:05,209 --> 00:26:28,936 the dollar sold off, gold rose, all of these classic signs 397 00:26:28,936 --> 00:26:52,663 of reduced credibility. So, I think what it means for investors 398 00:26:52,663 --> 00:27:20,704 going forward is a lot of focus is now on Warsh tomorrow. If 399 00:27:20,704 --> 00:27:48,745 he continues to go down this vein, I think the focus may shift 400 00:27:48,745 --> 00:28:14,629 to other avenues, such as the minutes as being the more important 401 00:28:14,629 --> 00:28:42,670 area to get an assessment of where the Fed is. And the suspicion 402 00:28:42,670 --> 00:29:08,554 is, maybe that before he joined, the question is, is he a 403 00:29:08,554 --> 00:29:38,752 dove, is he a hawk? My own view is that I'm shifting to the 404 00:29:38,752 --> 00:30:06,793 view, yeah, maybe he is more dovish than he's letting on and he 405 00:30:06,793 --> 00:30:17,578 doesn't want to raise rates. But I think what it means is that 406 00:25:51,473 --> 00:26:43,767 some of the other members, like Waller and Williams, that their 407 00:26:43,767 --> 00:27:45,569 influence is going to be even greater now, given that we know there 408 00:27:45,569 --> 00:28:52,125 are kind of three in the camp of raising rates. So, I think where 409 00:28:52,125 --> 00:29:49,173 it sets us towards is possible fracture within the Fed, that you 410 00:29:49,173 --> 00:30:17,697 could get kind of distinct factions. Obviously, you have Trump 411 00:25:33,725 --> 00:26:34,577 trying to stack the Fed with his own appointees and you've got 412 00:26:34,577 --> 00:27:30,358 Lisa Cook coming under renewed pressure again. So, it does have 413 00:27:30,358 --> 00:28:26,139 that sense of the ongoing politicization of the Fed. And we 414 00:28:26,139 --> 00:29:32,062 still don't know whether Warsh is kind of immune from that or not. 415 00:29:32,062 --> 00:30:17,701 So, I think that's a big credibility question mark. Yes, it'd 416 00:25:25,859 --> 00:26:46,576 be great for him if he came out tomorrow and gave clarity and 417 00:26:46,576 --> 00:28:13,502 all of that. I doubt he will, but I think it is important that 418 00:28:13,502 --> 00:29:34,219 he does so or else we're going to see this credibility issue hanging 419 00:29:34,219 --> 00:30:17,682 over the Fed for a lot longer. 420 00:30:17,711 --> 00:30:28,799 Yeah, I mean, there's an additional twist to this story, and 421 00:30:28,799 --> 00:30:41,903 that is of course, that on one hand you have Scott Bessent, and 422 00:30:41,903 --> 00:30:53,999 then in the ring you have Kevin Warsh. These two guys, they 423 00:30:53,999 --> 00:31:06,095 used to work together and they happen to work together with Stanley 424 00:31:06,095 --> 00:31:14,159 Druckenmiller. And Stanley Druckenmiller, of course, came out 425 00:31:14,159 --> 00:31:28,271 (and I say of course, but it's not, of course), he came out with 426 00:31:28,271 --> 00:31:41,375 an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal only a few days ago, admittedly 427 00:31:41,375 --> 00:31:54,479 helped by AI but leave that aside. He has a different view, let's 428 00:31:54,479 --> 00:32:05,567 call it that, where he essentially, as far as I understand, 429 00:32:05,567 --> 00:32:16,655 basically wants the market to decide where rates should be and 430 00:32:16,655 --> 00:32:21,695 he doesn't like this intervention. Now, what makes the 431 00:30:23,763 --> 00:30:41,919 kind of the story even more interesting is of course that Scott 432 00:30:41,919 --> 00:30:57,049 Bessent worked for George Soros when they went against the 433 00:30:57,049 --> 00:31:13,692 central bank and broke the British pound. So now he suddenly 434 00:31:13,692 --> 00:31:31,848 feels, oh hang on you guys, you shouldn't go against us because 435 00:31:31,848 --> 00:31:50,004 we are the good guys here. But he's getting some pushbacks from 436 00:31:50,004 --> 00:32:06,647 his former mentor and former… I don't know about exactly where 437 00:32:06,647 --> 00:32:21,777 Warsh's stance on this, but it's a very interesting twist. And 438 00:30:19,680 --> 00:30:41,339 then on top of that, I, in preparation for our conversation, 439 00:30:41,339 --> 00:31:06,936 I saw a piece by one of our other guests, Pippa Malmgren, who 440 00:31:06,936 --> 00:31:30,564 was on recently, and from the conversation we had with her and 441 00:31:30,564 --> 00:31:54,192 I think in her latest writing she talks basically about that Washington 442 00:31:54,192 --> 00:32:13,882 is deliberately changing the regime, so we're facing a different 443 00:32:13,882 --> 00:32:21,758 way of doing things. And then I noticed a little piece I got this 444 00:30:44,681 --> 00:31:11,651 morning from one of your previous guests, Ed Yardeni, who 445 00:31:11,651 --> 00:31:41,318 basically I think says, well, maybe the bond market isn't warning 446 00:31:41,318 --> 00:32:10,985 us at all. It's just putting yields roughly where economic fundamentals 447 00:32:10,985 --> 00:32:21,773 says they should be. 448 00:32:23,291 --> 00:32:32,982 I think that's right. And I mean, that was Druckenmiller's point 449 00:32:32,982 --> 00:32:43,554 as well. I mean, he's pointing out that growth is strong, strongish, 450 00:32:43,554 --> 00:32:54,126 not mega strong, and inflation has been above target for quite a 451 00:32:54,126 --> 00:33:05,579 while. So yeah, 10-year yields that are just heading up to 5% is 452 00:33:05,579 --> 00:33:17,032 maybe not that unusual. And actually, if you look at it, if you 453 00:33:17,032 --> 00:33:26,723 look where yields are, we're just normalizing back to where they 454 00:33:26,723 --> 00:33:38,176 were in the 1990s and the 2000s, and the 2010s was the aberration. 455 00:33:38,176 --> 00:33:48,748 So, in an economy like this that is growing as strongly. Yeah, 456 00:33:48,748 --> 00:33:52,272 it's probably not unusual. The big problem, obviously, is that the 457 00:32:31,278 --> 00:32:44,970 size of the debt is much greater now. So, the debt service 458 00:32:44,970 --> 00:32:58,662 cost is greater obviously. And as time goes by that increases because 459 00:32:58,662 --> 00:33:12,354 some of the debt that was issued at lower yields will roll 460 00:33:12,354 --> 00:33:26,046 off. And now that's providing the impetus to issue more at the 461 00:33:26,046 --> 00:33:39,738 short end, which again puts more pressure on Warsh not to be 462 00:33:39,738 --> 00:33:52,289 raising rates because it will feed directly into the higher costs. 463 00:32:23,291 --> 00:32:42,497 But yeah, I mean from that perspective, it's not like inflation 464 00:32:42,497 --> 00:32:59,957 expectations have skyrocketed. They're kind of still kind of 2.25% 465 00:32:59,957 --> 00:33:19,163 or so. What's pushing up yields is real yields, which reflects 466 00:33:19,163 --> 00:33:31,385 greater competition for capital because governments have 467 00:33:31,385 --> 00:33:50,591 greater deficits and we've got this huge CapEx spend related to 468 00:33:50,591 --> 00:33:52,337 AI. 469 00:33:53,001 --> 00:33:57,005 Yeah, yeah, for sure, absolutely. Now, we can stay on this 470 00:33:57,005 --> 00:34:02,465 topic a little longer if you want, but I know we have a lot of 471 00:34:02,465 --> 00:34:06,833 other sort of headlines, at least, that we wanted to touch on. 472 00:34:06,833 --> 00:34:11,565 And they're somewhat related in any way. And so, as I said, I'm 473 00:34:11,565 --> 00:34:17,025 going to hand it back to you, but one of the things you also wanted 474 00:34:17,025 --> 00:34:21,393 to bring up was these three fractures in the macro regime. So, 475 00:34:21,393 --> 00:34:23,941 maybe that's a natural point to go. 476 00:34:24,401 --> 00:35:41,321 Yeah, I mean, I think we've been talking about the change regime 477 00:35:41,321 --> 00:37:11,061 for a long time now. And we wrote a paper last year, The Regime 478 00:37:11,061 --> 00:38:27,981 Adaptive Portfolio. And as part of that, looked at how the economic 479 00:38:27,981 --> 00:39:38,491 regime has changed from the last decade, really from the last 480 00:39:38,491 --> 00:40:16,951 four decades to the current period. And at a high level we've 481 00:35:05,081 --> 00:36:06,101 gone from an environment, a disinflationary to great moderation, 482 00:36:06,101 --> 00:37:13,901 the great disinflation period of low interest rates, low inflation, 483 00:37:13,901 --> 00:38:28,481 and very little volatility in rates and inflation. And that's linked 484 00:38:28,481 --> 00:39:36,281 to the globalized world, neoliberalism, all of that. And now 485 00:39:36,281 --> 00:40:16,961 we've changed into this new regime. And I guess, in the paper 486 00:34:43,631 --> 00:35:18,886 we highlighted kind of three key fractures in the regime that 487 00:35:18,886 --> 00:35:57,346 are kind of leading to this evolution in the economy and the 488 00:35:57,346 --> 00:36:39,011 markets. And the first one is, I think it's the one that probably 489 00:36:39,011 --> 00:37:11,061 gets talked about the most, inflation being higher and stickier, 490 00:37:11,061 --> 00:37:46,316 which we've seen. And obviously the upshot of that is basically 491 00:37:46,316 --> 00:38:18,366 bonds and equities become more correlated, which is something that 492 00:38:18,366 --> 00:38:44,006 we've seen. And that's something that everybody, probably 493 00:38:44,006 --> 00:39:22,466 most guests that we've had on the podcast have alluded to. Certainly, 494 00:39:22,466 --> 00:39:57,721 on the Allocator series side, that's been a very pronounced and 495 00:39:57,721 --> 00:40:16,951 notable change this decade versus last. But the other fractures 496 00:34:37,457 --> 00:35:16,625 that I think that we talked about in the paper, we're starting 497 00:35:16,625 --> 00:35:59,057 to see more of those coming through now, is what I wanted to 498 00:35:59,057 --> 00:36:28,433 talk about. The second one being, obviously, debt sustainability 499 00:36:28,433 --> 00:37:01,073 and the coincidence of high debt and high equity valuations. 500 00:37:01,073 --> 00:37:43,505 And obviously, we've seen this come to the market and go away. Obviously, 501 00:37:43,505 --> 00:38:25,937 we saw it in 2023 when there's concerns about US debt issuance and 502 00:38:25,937 --> 00:38:55,313 then they changed the quarterly refunding with Janet Yellen 503 00:38:55,313 --> 00:39:27,953 at the time, which was controversial. But again, we're seeing 504 00:39:27,953 --> 00:40:00,593 it with Bessent now they're tinkering with the markets because 505 00:40:00,593 --> 00:40:16,913 of concerns about debt sustainability. But not just that. 506 00:34:36,053 --> 00:35:08,096 And obviously, this happens at a time when you've got unusually 507 00:35:08,096 --> 00:35:31,400 high equity valuations or relatively high equity valuations. 508 00:35:31,400 --> 00:36:12,182 And I think the concern here is that if you had an equity market 509 00:36:12,182 --> 00:36:50,051 decline, the US economy is so levered in the US equity market at 510 00:36:50,051 --> 00:37:22,094 the moment, that would have a meaningful impact on debt. Again, 511 00:37:22,094 --> 00:37:57,050 because what you've seen is, if you look at the trajectory of 512 00:37:57,050 --> 00:38:32,006 the debt over the last 20 years, basically every time you have 513 00:38:32,006 --> 00:39:09,875 a recession you get a jump up in debt because your revenues go 514 00:39:09,875 --> 00:39:41,918 down, there's generally some kind of fiscal support, so you get 515 00:39:41,918 --> 00:40:16,874 a new deficit, and that kind of pushes it up even higher. So, 516 00:34:28,979 --> 00:35:33,071 the concern now is if we got that again, given that debt GDP levels 517 00:35:33,071 --> 00:36:28,007 are already above 100%, that could be the tipping point of fiscal 518 00:36:28,007 --> 00:37:13,787 dominance. And that's really where we're getting to now. We're 519 00:37:13,787 --> 00:37:59,567 edging towards that. And the related concern is financial repression 520 00:37:59,567 --> 00:38:45,347 and that's basically holding down interest rates below where they 521 00:38:45,347 --> 00:39:40,283 should be to try and manage debt service levels. And that's effectively 522 00:39:40,283 --> 00:40:16,907 what you're seeing from Bessent at the moment. And the third 523 00:34:34,667 --> 00:35:19,153 fracture, that we talked about in the paper, is the kind of the 524 00:35:19,153 --> 00:35:46,529 fraying institutional order, the erosion of institutional norms. 525 00:35:46,529 --> 00:36:31,015 And again, we're seeing this, we have been seeing this on an ongoing 526 00:36:31,015 --> 00:37:12,079 basis with the pressure on the Fed. Obviously we're seeing it with 527 00:37:12,079 --> 00:37:53,143 this more kind of active tinkering in the bond market in terms 528 00:37:53,143 --> 00:38:27,363 of issuance. We've seen the threat to central bank independence; 529 00:38:27,363 --> 00:39:05,005 and not just the kind of institution order, I suppose, the 530 00:39:05,005 --> 00:39:39,225 erosion of any kind of conservative fiscal policies as well. 531 00:39:39,225 --> 00:40:16,867 So, there's no appetite to deal with the fiscal debt problem. 532 00:34:24,401 --> 00:35:26,869 So, the point is that I think we've been very focused on the first 533 00:35:26,869 --> 00:36:07,027 fracture that changed at the higher inflation, stickier inflation, 534 00:36:07,027 --> 00:36:56,109 and what that means. That means obviously the bonds won't be 535 00:36:56,109 --> 00:37:40,729 as good a diversifier for equities. But actually, what we're 536 00:37:40,729 --> 00:38:29,811 seeing with these other changes as well, I think has pretty 537 00:38:29,811 --> 00:39:09,969 significant implications for asset allocation as well. And obviously 538 00:39:09,969 --> 00:39:59,051 the debt concerns also mean that bonds would be less reliable 539 00:39:59,051 --> 00:40:16,899 diversifiers for equities too. But equally, if you've got that combination 540 00:35:09,271 --> 00:36:06,961 of concerns about debt sustainability and the erosion of 541 00:36:06,961 --> 00:37:17,471 the kind of institutional norms, it does mean that more unorthodox 542 00:37:17,471 --> 00:38:21,571 policies like these active bond buybacks and whatever else may 543 00:38:21,571 --> 00:39:38,491 come, may become more of a feature of the markets. And that's 544 00:39:38,491 --> 00:40:16,951 the whole area of financial repression. And again, it's about 545 00:34:45,449 --> 00:35:48,593 what kind of real return will you get from holding fixed income 546 00:35:48,593 --> 00:36:35,951 markets? And then it's obviously positive for things like 547 00:36:35,951 --> 00:37:33,833 gold and bitcoin, as you alluded to earlier. Because as soon 548 00:37:33,833 --> 00:38:47,501 as you get a sense that the US is heading towards these kind of 549 00:38:47,501 --> 00:40:01,169 policies, you see it in the dollar, you see it in gold, you see 550 00:40:01,169 --> 00:40:16,955 it in bitcoin. So, I think it's interesting. I think definitely 551 00:35:19,697 --> 00:36:42,641 what we've seen in the last couple of weeks is definitely one 552 00:36:42,641 --> 00:37:37,937 step closer to fiscal dominance. It's something that's 553 00:37:37,937 --> 00:39:07,793 been talked about for a while, but I think we are actually getting 554 00:39:07,793 --> 00:40:16,913 much closer to the point of that being a reality. 555 00:40:17,601 --> 00:40:21,096 Yes. So, it's kind of make me think that if only you had a Regime 556 00:40:21,096 --> 00:40:23,426 Adaptive Portfolio, things life would be so much easier, right, 557 00:40:23,426 --> 00:40:23,659 Alan? 558 00:40:23,841 --> 00:40:24,561 Exactly. 559 00:40:24,561 --> 00:40:40,045 But the other thing is of course that we also live in a world 560 00:40:40,045 --> 00:40:52,211 that is deglobalizing, meaning that all the central banks, all the 561 00:40:52,211 --> 00:41:04,377 governments are more in it for themselves than necessarily the way 562 00:41:04,377 --> 00:41:19,861 it was in the past. And I think that kind of touches on the 563 00:41:19,861 --> 00:41:34,239 next topic that you wanted to talk about and that is what about 564 00:41:34,239 --> 00:41:43,087 trend following performance in a shifting macro regime? Because, 565 00:40:25,205 --> 00:40:33,577 to some extent, I would say that part of the challenge that trend 566 00:40:33,577 --> 00:40:41,305 followers were facing, in the 2010s, was a high degree of coordinated 567 00:40:41,305 --> 00:40:47,745 and successful policies by central banks and whoever is involved 568 00:40:47,745 --> 00:40:55,473 obviously leading to very low interest rates and very low and stable 569 00:40:55,473 --> 00:41:03,845 (and I think the ‘and stable’ is the key here) inflation. All of 570 00:41:03,845 --> 00:41:12,217 that seems to have changed. And I think that makes a change to 571 00:41:12,217 --> 00:41:18,657 trend following performance even though we and know well not 572 00:41:18,657 --> 00:41:27,029 to forecast (well, at least not until we get to the next topic 573 00:41:27,029 --> 00:41:34,757 of today). But we know well not to forecast our own performance. 574 00:41:34,757 --> 00:41:41,841 But what are your thoughts about trend performance in the shifting 575 00:41:41,841 --> 00:41:43,129 macro regime? 576 00:41:43,541 --> 00:43:25,006 Yeah, well, I wanted to just go back and look at how performance 577 00:43:25,006 --> 00:44:35,251 has evolved this decade because, obviously, we've been in 578 00:44:35,251 --> 00:46:01,106 a changed macro environment, as we've been saying, and now we're 579 00:46:01,106 --> 00:47:50,376 2/3 of the way, more or less, through a decade, I think. So, it's 580 00:47:50,376 --> 00:49:24,036 kind of interesting time to look back and say, well, what can 581 00:49:24,036 --> 00:49:55,256 we say about it? There are a couple of interesting observations. 582 00:42:19,773 --> 00:43:11,533 Obviously, it has been a better decade, obviously, for trend 583 00:43:11,533 --> 00:44:03,293 relative to the previous period. Last SocGen Trend has annualized 584 00:44:03,293 --> 00:45:05,405 nearly 7.5% this decade to date, where it was just under 2% 585 00:45:05,405 --> 00:46:02,341 in the previous decade. And obviously, the big change has been 586 00:46:02,341 --> 00:46:59,277 bonds. US bonds were annualized about 7% in the last decade. 587 00:46:59,277 --> 00:47:51,037 And it's been negative this period, obviously, because the starting 588 00:47:51,037 --> 00:48:58,325 point was yields of 50 basis points and yields have risen to close 589 00:48:58,325 --> 00:49:55,261 to 5%. So, that's a big headwind, obviously, for bond markets. 590 00:41:43,541 --> 00:42:56,381 The curious thing was, you would have said the last decade was 591 00:42:56,381 --> 00:43:57,081 good for equity markets, and equities annualized at 13.5%, but 592 00:43:57,081 --> 00:45:09,921 this decade has been even better at over 15%. So, that's the 593 00:45:09,921 --> 00:46:04,551 kind of context. And obviously, we have mentioned the 594 00:46:04,551 --> 00:46:53,111 kind of the shifting correlations and that's definitely 595 00:46:53,111 --> 00:48:05,951 borne out by the data. If you look at the bond/equity correlation 596 00:48:05,951 --> 00:49:12,721 now, it's positive 0.3 this decade versus last decade it was 597 00:49:12,721 --> 00:49:55,211 negative 0.5. So that's quite a shift. But then from a trend following 598 00:42:36,221 --> 00:43:46,461 perspective, what's really notable is that equity correlation 599 00:43:46,461 --> 00:45:31,821 with trend was about 0.2 last decade. This decade it's been negative 600 00:45:31,821 --> 00:47:17,181 0.16. And then on the bond side, bonds and trend were positively 601 00:47:17,181 --> 00:48:44,981 correlated last decade 0.33. Whereas this decade bonds and trend 602 00:48:44,981 --> 00:49:55,221 are negatively correlated negative 0.37, which is interesting. 603 00:41:43,541 --> 00:42:53,787 And actually, if you look at the performance, obviously 2022 was 604 00:42:53,787 --> 00:43:51,261 the big blowout year, obviously for some managers very 605 00:43:51,261 --> 00:45:20,665 good in 2021. But 2022, at the index level, was the year where we've 606 00:45:20,665 --> 00:46:30,911 seen the bulk of the gains this period. And obviously, that 607 00:46:30,911 --> 00:47:41,157 very strong performance that we've seen from trend has even included 608 00:47:41,157 --> 00:48:57,789 a period where a lot of managers got close to their largest 609 00:48:57,789 --> 00:49:55,263 drawdown. So, we've had ups and downs in it. But actually, when 610 00:42:08,975 --> 00:43:59,189 you look at the shape of performance, I went back and I kind 611 00:43:59,189 --> 00:45:40,925 of split up the periods from 2020 to today. And actually, some 612 00:45:40,925 --> 00:47:14,183 of the best periods of performance for trend have been when 613 00:47:14,183 --> 00:48:38,963 we've seen these fractures that I'm talking about when we've 614 00:48:38,963 --> 00:49:55,265 seen them really start to bite in the market. So, if you think about 615 00:42:08,886 --> 00:42:59,576 when would have been the strong periods of performance, 2021 616 00:42:59,576 --> 00:43:55,335 was when we first started to see the inflation episode starting 617 00:43:55,335 --> 00:45:01,232 to pick up. Then this next one was 2022, which was obviously the 618 00:45:01,232 --> 00:45:51,922 sticky inflation and bonds and equities selling off together. But 619 00:45:51,922 --> 00:46:57,819 also, we had a second big bond sell-off in 2023 which people nearly 620 00:46:57,819 --> 00:47:58,647 forget about a bit. And that was another strong period of performance 621 00:47:58,647 --> 00:48:54,406 for trend. Between April and October of that year, bonds were 622 00:48:54,406 --> 00:49:55,234 down 20% and trend was up 9%. Equities were only up 3%. And that 623 00:41:59,151 --> 00:43:32,811 was the period where there was all the concerns about debt sustainability 624 00:43:32,811 --> 00:44:58,666 which ultimately started to weigh on the equity market. And then, 625 00:44:58,666 --> 00:46:16,716 obviously, what shifted that was in the quarterly refunding announcement 626 00:46:16,716 --> 00:47:42,571 that year, Yellen kind of hinted at shifting away from issuing 627 00:47:42,571 --> 00:49:31,841 so much on the long-term bond. So that was the next kind of strong 628 00:49:31,841 --> 00:49:55,256 period of performance. And then the other strong period of performance 629 00:42:38,173 --> 00:44:20,608 has been kind of the last 12, 15 months or so when we have seen 630 00:44:20,608 --> 00:45:56,214 what have been the big themes. For part of that it was the debasement 631 00:45:56,214 --> 00:47:11,333 trade, it was the concerns, the rise in precious metals. Obviously, 632 00:47:11,333 --> 00:49:00,597 AI has been a huge theme too, but it has been the big run up in 633 00:49:00,597 --> 00:49:55,229 metals was certainly a part of it too. So, it is interesting that 634 00:42:38,176 --> 00:44:16,519 when these… In aggregate, we've had positive performance, but 635 00:44:16,519 --> 00:46:16,716 a lot of the performance has been, I suppose, concentrated in 636 00:46:16,716 --> 00:47:55,059 those periods when these stress factors are becoming more 637 00:47:55,059 --> 00:49:55,256 of a market theme. So, I think that's an important point. I think 638 00:41:54,115 --> 00:42:57,559 another point is that what we've seen from trend in this decade 639 00:42:57,559 --> 00:44:01,003 has been it's done well in periods when bonds have done badly. 640 00:44:01,003 --> 00:44:59,160 And people say, oh, it's a better diversifier than bonds. Yes, 641 00:44:59,160 --> 00:46:02,604 in a way. I mean, the reality is equity holders haven't needed 642 00:46:02,604 --> 00:46:50,187 diversification. But what we've seen from trend following is 643 00:46:50,187 --> 00:47:48,344 its more adaptive nature, its ability to capitalize on new themes 644 00:47:48,344 --> 00:48:35,927 emerging in markets. Debt sustainability wasn't a theme in 645 00:48:35,927 --> 00:49:39,371 markets in the last decade, it is now, and trend followers have 646 00:49:39,371 --> 00:49:55,232 been capturing that. But in a sense, it almost feels like the performance 647 00:43:02,851 --> 00:44:22,161 of trend has maybe not garnered as much attention because 648 00:44:22,161 --> 00:45:49,402 it hasn't… Obviously 2022 was a period when equities did badly, 649 00:45:49,402 --> 00:47:16,643 but outside of that it's generally been in periods when bonds 650 00:47:16,643 --> 00:48:51,815 have been doing badly and not when equities have been doing badly. 651 00:48:51,815 --> 00:49:55,263 So, I think that's an interesting feature too. And the 652 00:41:56,313 --> 00:43:06,559 other point is that even though, in aggregate, we've had this 653 00:43:06,559 --> 00:44:10,419 kind of theme of sticky inflation, it has been interspersed 654 00:44:10,419 --> 00:45:20,665 with kind of periods that looked more like the old regime. 655 00:45:20,665 --> 00:46:24,525 Remember after the Fed tightened you had that, what was 656 00:46:24,525 --> 00:47:09,227 called the immaculate disinflation, where inflation seemed 657 00:47:09,227 --> 00:48:19,473 to come down and everybody was saying, okay, inflation's no longer 658 00:48:19,473 --> 00:49:48,877 a problem. But then it did stall-out and found a base at a higher 659 00:49:48,877 --> 00:49:55,263 level. And obviously we've had the AI boom as well, which has led 660 00:43:01,181 --> 00:44:12,351 to hopes that we're going to see a disinflationary impact from 661 00:44:12,351 --> 00:45:42,931 AI as well. So, it hasn't been that this kind of theme of supply 662 00:45:42,931 --> 00:46:47,631 shocks, etc., that hasn't been a constant. It's been interspersed 663 00:46:47,631 --> 00:48:05,271 with, I suppose, signs at times that we might be going back 664 00:48:05,271 --> 00:48:50,561 to that kind of disinflationary environment. But 665 00:48:50,561 --> 00:49:35,851 ultimately, obviously inflation has stayed above target 666 00:49:35,851 --> 00:49:55,261 for five years. So, I think what stands out for me is really 667 00:43:46,471 --> 00:45:37,108 that link, that negative correlation between bonds and trend. 668 00:45:37,108 --> 00:47:52,331 And obviously the question I think that people are focused on 669 00:47:52,331 --> 00:49:55,261 now is like, what if US yields went above 5%? Obviously, that seems 670 00:41:57,863 --> 00:42:55,151 to be what Bessent is worried about. Obviously, when we got up 671 00:42:55,151 --> 00:43:52,439 close to the highs, they came out with the announcement and we've 672 00:43:52,439 --> 00:44:54,501 seen that kind of playbook, to an extent in that October 2023 scenario, 673 00:44:54,501 --> 00:45:51,789 that was a very good period for trend. But the question mark 674 00:45:51,789 --> 00:47:03,399 is, at some point, if you did see that yield break and we see a 675 00:47:03,399 --> 00:47:55,913 ratcheting higher in yields, would that be the straw that breaks 676 00:47:55,913 --> 00:48:48,427 the camel's back for the equity market? And that could be 677 00:48:48,427 --> 00:49:40,941 the environment where you really see the benefit of trend from 678 00:49:40,941 --> 00:49:55,263 a portfolio perspective. So yeah, I think it's interesting, as 679 00:42:39,968 --> 00:44:08,639 I say in aggregate, a strong period, but interesting how it's 680 00:44:08,639 --> 00:45:53,432 come at the expense of bonds and trends in those markets as opposed 681 00:45:53,432 --> 00:47:38,225 to it being largely driven by kind of not like the 2000s where 682 00:47:38,225 --> 00:49:06,896 we had two big equity market sell-offs, and that would provide 683 00:49:06,896 --> 00:49:55,262 the environment for trend following performance. 684 00:49:56,982 --> 00:50:15,637 Yeah, I mean a strong period for trend in a period where equity 685 00:50:15,637 --> 00:50:29,987 returns have been strong. That's part of the attraction that 686 00:50:29,987 --> 00:50:50,077 we don't need a crisis to make money. But I think the other point 687 00:50:50,077 --> 00:51:11,602 I just want to stress also is that this decade, yes, we had a big 688 00:51:11,602 --> 00:51:30,257 help from fixed income markets in 2022 on the short side, but it 689 00:51:30,257 --> 00:51:50,347 has also been a decade where a lot of the markets that people find 690 00:51:50,347 --> 00:52:04,697 very difficult if not impossible to get exposure to themselves, 691 00:52:04,697 --> 00:52:17,612 at least successfully, namely the commodities, have done really 692 00:52:17,612 --> 00:52:31,962 well and at different times, which has been very useful. And I 693 00:50:00,466 --> 00:50:26,596 don't know this for a fact, so bear with me here. But when I look 694 00:50:26,596 --> 00:50:47,500 at the way the portfolios that I follow move around, there seems 695 00:50:47,500 --> 00:51:04,920 to be somewhat more dispersion between markets. They're kind of 696 00:51:04,920 --> 00:51:22,340 doing more their own thing. The correlation between markets are 697 00:51:22,340 --> 00:51:46,728 not as high as it used to be within the sectors and that's generally 698 00:51:46,728 --> 00:52:09,374 good for trend. And I think that is partly because of also the 699 00:52:09,374 --> 00:52:26,794 deglobalization and the change in policy from the US administration 700 00:52:26,794 --> 00:52:32,020 towards foreign countries. I mean, just look what's going on between 701 00:50:10,766 --> 00:50:27,996 the US and Canada. Lake America, I understand Lake Ontario 702 00:50:27,996 --> 00:50:50,395 is likely to be called soon. So yeah, not a good situation. But 703 00:50:50,395 --> 00:51:09,348 if we just look at it objectively, it does provide some 704 00:51:09,348 --> 00:51:19,686 interesting opportunities potentially for these strategies. 705 00:51:19,686 --> 00:51:42,085 And of course, we always try to promote the point. It should at 706 00:51:42,085 --> 00:51:59,315 least raise more questions in the investment committees to say, 707 00:51:59,315 --> 00:52:19,991 hmm, maybe we need something else in our portfolio that we haven't 708 00:52:19,991 --> 00:52:32,052 had before to compensate for this change. Anyways, enough about 709 00:50:01,776 --> 00:50:24,148 that. We still have a little bit of time left and I know that 710 00:50:24,148 --> 00:50:43,324 there were a couple of papers that you've come across. I'm not 711 00:50:43,324 --> 00:51:05,696 an expert in these things, but I know you are. And so, I'm going 712 00:51:05,696 --> 00:51:29,666 to kind of hand it over to you with, I think the first paper you 713 00:51:29,666 --> 00:51:50,440 wanted to pick up on is very much related to what we're talking 714 00:51:50,440 --> 00:52:09,616 about, meaning what does the future hold, so to speak. And it's 715 00:52:09,616 --> 00:52:31,988 a paper from our friends over at AQR. So yeah, tell us about that. 716 00:52:32,052 --> 00:53:37,128 I mean, it's two sets of forecasts, really. So, I mean it's 717 00:53:37,128 --> 00:54:25,935 their latest capital markets assumptions. And this is something 718 00:54:25,935 --> 00:55:31,011 that you see from lots of asset managers and banks that they 719 00:55:31,011 --> 00:56:14,395 periodically produce their capital market assumptions. And I 720 00:56:14,395 --> 00:57:08,625 mean, you might say, well, what's the relevance, what's the 721 00:57:08,625 --> 00:58:08,278 importance of this? But this is basically the kind of exercise 722 00:58:08,278 --> 00:59:18,777 that a lot of pension funds go through to try and determine their 723 00:59:18,777 --> 00:59:35,046 strategic asset allocation. Now, I know we're talking about TPA 724 00:52:52,611 --> 00:53:27,855 a lot more, but basically having an estimate of where you think 725 00:53:27,855 --> 00:54:00,162 asset classes, what kind of level of return they will deliver 726 00:54:00,162 --> 00:54:38,343 over the next number of years is kind of the starting point for 727 00:54:38,343 --> 00:55:04,776 most kind of strategic asset allocation perspectives. And there's 728 00:55:04,776 --> 00:55:45,894 basically kind of two ways you can do this. One is you can look 729 00:55:45,894 --> 00:56:21,138 at the past and say, well, what have equities done over the 730 00:56:21,138 --> 00:56:59,319 long term? Or else you can build in some kind of yield version. 731 00:56:59,319 --> 00:57:34,563 So, you could say, well, at the moment, based on the earnings 732 00:57:34,563 --> 00:58:12,744 yield in the US, which is the inverse of the price earnings ratio, 733 00:58:12,744 --> 00:58:39,177 and based on a certain assumption about earnings growth 734 00:58:39,177 --> 00:59:14,421 and inflation, etc., you can come up with an expectation of what 735 00:59:14,421 --> 00:59:34,980 asset class returns should be going forward. And in some asset 736 00:52:59,340 --> 00:54:21,204 classes it's easier in some sense than in others. So, in bonds, 737 00:54:21,204 --> 00:55:56,712 if the 10 year yield is 5%, then that's a pretty good proxy for 738 00:55:56,712 --> 00:57:32,220 what you can expect to receive if you bought a bond and held it 739 00:57:32,220 --> 00:58:47,262 for maturity over the next 10 years. But obviously in equities 740 00:58:47,262 --> 00:59:35,016 you have a lot of moving parts. And I think the reason I highlighted 741 00:53:25,882 --> 00:54:42,782 the two different approaches is just from the radically different 742 00:54:42,782 --> 00:56:07,372 answers that you can get doing this exercise, depending on your 743 00:56:07,372 --> 00:57:08,892 perspective. In AQR's analysis, US equities are priced 744 00:57:08,892 --> 00:58:56,552 to deliver about 3.9% real over the next 5 to 10 years and that's 745 00:58:56,552 --> 00:59:35,002 a nominal return of 6.3%. So, I mean, that seems like a sensible 746 00:53:05,892 --> 00:53:56,652 kind of number. Obviously, it would be less than what we've seen 747 00:53:56,652 --> 00:54:43,182 like the numbers I mentioned earlier. It was double digit returns 748 00:54:43,182 --> 00:55:38,172 we've seen in equities this decade to date and in the last decade. 749 00:55:38,172 --> 00:56:33,162 So, you have to assume we can't go on forever. But then if 750 00:56:33,162 --> 00:57:32,382 you look at the GMO forecast, and GMO split it out between a normal 751 00:57:32,382 --> 00:58:10,452 interest rate environment and a low interest rate environment. 752 00:58:10,452 --> 00:58:48,522 But in a normal interest rate environment, they're forecasting 753 00:58:48,522 --> 00:59:35,052 a negative real return of 7.2%, negative 7.2% for US large. 754 00:52:32,052 --> 00:53:37,968 So, you might query, well, how can you get such radically different 755 00:53:37,968 --> 00:54:38,391 results from the same exercise? And the reason is it all 756 00:54:38,391 --> 00:55:27,828 comes down to different assumptions. So, mean reversion is 757 00:55:27,828 --> 00:56:33,744 a big feature of GMO and how they approach investing. So, they're 758 00:56:33,744 --> 00:57:28,674 assuming not just valuations mean revert, but profit margins would 759 00:57:28,674 --> 00:58:23,604 also mean revert. Whereas AQR are assuming that basically valuations 760 00:58:23,604 --> 00:59:18,534 stay unchanged and they're just backing out the return forecast 761 00:59:18,534 --> 00:59:35,013 based on that. On the fixed income side also, I think GMO were 762 00:53:47,582 --> 00:55:33,324 a little bit lower, but they had cash at, well real cash at 1.4%, 763 00:55:33,324 --> 00:57:11,513 whereas what did AQR have for that? They also had the same. So 764 00:57:11,513 --> 00:58:57,255 yeah, both are kind of saying 1.4%, which is about 3.5% to 4% nominal 765 00:58:57,255 --> 00:59:35,020 rates over the next decade. So, I mean, I think it does highlight 766 00:53:17,172 --> 00:54:19,212 that something that's supposed to be kind of nearly scientific in 767 00:54:19,212 --> 00:55:04,332 approach can yield such massively different outcomes. Obviously 768 00:55:04,332 --> 00:56:12,012 if you take the GMO analysis at face value, you would obviously 769 00:56:12,012 --> 00:57:08,412 be totally exiting US equities and even international large cap 770 00:57:08,412 --> 00:58:04,812 are negative too. Japan small cap are positive, International deep 771 00:58:04,812 --> 00:59:01,212 value are positive, but generally it's a very bleak picture 772 00:59:01,212 --> 00:59:35,052 for equities according to GMO's forecasts. The other thing 773 00:52:46,980 --> 00:53:41,716 that was interesting is then, AQR also looked at commodities and 774 00:53:41,716 --> 00:54:21,524 active strategies. And with commodities, again, obviously as 775 00:54:21,524 --> 00:55:21,236 I say, you can't do the yield analysis because there's no effective 776 00:55:21,236 --> 00:56:20,948 yield. But they basically take the long run average return of an 777 00:56:20,948 --> 00:57:00,756 equally weighted basket of commodity futures. And according 778 00:57:00,756 --> 00:57:50,516 to their analysis that generates a 3% geometric return over 779 00:57:50,516 --> 00:58:45,252 cash over long term. So, again, that's also, that would be 780 00:58:45,252 --> 00:59:35,012 kind of 6.8% nominal. So that would be attractive too. I mean, 781 00:52:44,870 --> 00:53:48,960 the interesting thing then, from the perspective of active strategies, 782 00:53:48,960 --> 00:55:05,868 obviously AQR runs a lot of active strategies, so we have to 783 00:55:05,868 --> 00:56:22,776 keep that in mind when we're reading their analysis. But I mean, 784 00:56:22,776 --> 00:57:33,275 if you think about it, they were forecasting, what's a reasonable 785 00:57:33,275 --> 00:58:43,774 kind of baseline assumption for a net Sharpe for active strategies, 786 00:58:43,774 --> 00:59:35,046 they were saying maybe 0.7, which seems high. But even if you're 787 00:52:43,036 --> 00:53:07,750 really pessimistic on say trend following and you're going 788 00:53:07,750 --> 00:53:48,940 to say it's going to be a 0.1 Sharpe at 12 vol, I mean, that's 789 00:53:48,940 --> 00:54:27,384 still a 5% return. If it's a 0.3 Sharpe, you would be over 7% 790 00:54:27,384 --> 00:54:57,590 in terms of expected return. So again, it highlights the fact 791 00:54:57,590 --> 00:55:25,050 that these active strategies, like trend following, given the assumption 792 00:55:25,050 --> 00:55:55,256 around where cash rates are, I think that's the important point. 793 00:55:55,256 --> 00:56:33,700 If cash rates are going to be 3.5%, 4% over the next decade, that's 794 00:56:33,700 --> 00:56:58,414 obviously radically different from the last decade. It doesn't 795 00:56:58,414 --> 00:57:31,366 take much in terms of Sharpe ratio for these strategies to be 796 00:57:31,366 --> 00:57:53,334 relatively competitive versus traditional asset classes in terms 797 00:57:53,334 --> 00:58:18,048 of expected returns. And obviously the expectation is they 798 00:58:18,048 --> 00:58:45,508 will deliver those returns with a very low correlation based 799 00:58:45,508 --> 00:59:12,968 on the analysis that we've talked about - negative correlation 800 00:59:12,968 --> 00:59:34,936 to bond, negative correlation to equities as well. So, from a portfolio 801 00:52:52,436 --> 00:53:53,588 context, again, it begs the question, why don't we see much higher 802 00:53:53,588 --> 00:54:59,836 allocation? So, I mean, it seems to me that on the one hand 803 00:54:59,836 --> 00:55:45,700 people do these long-term forecasts and say, okay, equities 804 00:55:45,700 --> 00:56:41,756 are going to deliver 7%, but really they believe that equities 805 00:56:41,756 --> 00:57:48,004 are going to deliver 12% to 15% because that's the way it's been 806 00:57:48,004 --> 00:58:54,252 for the last while. So, I don't know, I mean, that's the only 807 00:58:54,252 --> 00:59:35,020 way you can kind of square the circle. 808 00:59:35,132 --> 00:59:40,605 Yeah, I mean, first, firstly, let me just say that I hope there's 809 00:59:40,605 --> 00:59:46,499 not a lot of people listening to us who are negative on trend following 810 00:59:46,499 --> 00:59:51,551 because then it's the wrong podcast, of course. But on the other 811 00:59:51,551 --> 00:59:56,603 hand, the interesting thing about it, and I don't know if that 812 00:59:56,603 --> 01:00:02,497 was made clear, but of course when you invest in a fund, like a 813 01:00:02,497 --> 01:00:07,128 trend following fund, the good thing is that actually the higher 814 01:00:07,128 --> 01:00:11,759 the interest rates go, the more you benefit as well, because 815 01:00:11,759 --> 01:00:17,232 we simply don't use that much of the cash. So, there should be 816 01:00:17,232 --> 01:00:22,284 also a payment there into the fund, meaning that it doesn't cost 817 01:00:22,284 --> 01:00:27,757 a lot. You're not giving up a lot of your fixed income allocation 818 01:00:27,757 --> 01:00:32,809 or interest income by choosing to replace some of the bond portfolio 819 01:00:32,809 --> 01:00:36,598 with trend following. Obviously, you're taking on a different 820 01:00:36,598 --> 01:00:42,071 active risk. But in terms of the interest income, a lot of that 821 01:00:42,071 --> 01:00:47,123 goes back to the investor when you buy that. So. Yeah, interesting. 822 00:59:35,132 --> 01:00:08,555 I mean also I thought the… I mean we've talked about this many 823 01:00:08,555 --> 01:00:44,549 times but of course in the GMO paper they also have the lost decades 824 01:00:44,549 --> 01:00:47,120 chart. 825 01:00:47,462 --> 01:00:47,942 Yes. 826 01:00:48,102 --> 01:00:52,482 And that they are actually more common than you think. I think 827 01:00:52,482 --> 01:00:57,227 they count something like 11. Oh no, so the average of 11 years. 828 01:00:57,312 --> 01:00:59,472 Yeah. Seven distinct periods. 829 01:00:59,472 --> 01:01:04,867 Yes. Yeah, exactly. So that's a long time not to get any return. 830 01:01:04,867 --> 01:01:09,847 I know we've been close probably as an industry, but I would 831 01:01:09,847 --> 01:01:14,827 say most managers who've been around for a long time, they probably 832 01:01:14,827 --> 01:01:20,222 have never really had a 10 year period with no return in their 833 01:01:20,222 --> 01:01:24,787 strategy. Could have been a close call but. Well, at least… 834 01:01:24,802 --> 01:01:29,183 And they do point out in the paper that those periods of negative 835 01:01:29,183 --> 01:01:33,227 to flat to negative for the 60/40 have all come after periods 836 01:01:33,227 --> 01:01:35,923 of exceptionally strong returns obviously, which we have 837 01:01:35,923 --> 01:01:39,630 seen obviously last decade was very strong for 60/40, less strong 838 01:01:39,630 --> 01:01:43,674 just a decade because of the bond side but still, in aggregate, 839 01:01:43,674 --> 01:01:47,381 it's been very strong kind of 17 year period. So yeah. 840 01:01:47,422 --> 01:01:52,163 Yeah, absolutely. So, we managed to get around quite a few 841 01:01:52,163 --> 01:01:57,335 topics today. A lot of things for people to consider and think 842 01:01:57,335 --> 01:02:03,369 about. Anything in all of this that kind of stands out to you? Anything 843 01:02:03,369 --> 01:02:08,541 you thought, well this is the most important thing we should be 844 01:02:08,541 --> 01:02:10,696 watching out for going forward? 845 01:02:10,702 --> 01:02:15,286 Well, I think the theme has been this evolution of the macro 846 01:02:15,286 --> 01:02:19,488 regime, that we're seeing, that we've talked about it for a 847 01:02:19,488 --> 01:02:24,072 long time but we've seen it coming in different ways. It was 848 01:02:24,072 --> 01:02:27,892 on the inflation side first. Now we're seeing debt sustainability 849 01:02:27,892 --> 01:02:32,858 becoming a new theme, and then at some point does it infect the 850 01:02:32,858 --> 01:02:37,442 equity market? Is that the next part? I don't know. You can 851 01:02:37,442 --> 01:02:42,026 make arguments on both sides. But I think it's something that to 852 01:02:42,026 --> 01:02:46,610 track and I think it is something to keep front and center 853 01:02:46,610 --> 01:02:47,374 going forward. 854 01:02:47,662 --> 01:03:14,572 Yeah. And I don't know if we can stretch our imagination far enough 855 01:03:14,572 --> 01:03:41,482 to say that a lot of these analyses, a lot of these papers, 856 01:03:41,482 --> 01:04:06,322 they kind of talk about what people should be investing in, so 857 01:04:06,322 --> 01:04:29,092 to speak, in terms of their expectations. But the great thing 858 01:04:29,092 --> 01:04:56,002 that trend does is actually in a sense it helps with the timing 859 01:04:56,002 --> 01:05:14,632 of it, when should we invest in these things? Because we're simply 860 01:02:52,159 --> 01:03:08,648 not going to buy anything that's going down, for example. So, 861 01:03:08,648 --> 01:03:26,636 we kind of avoid that being early type, because some of these 862 01:03:26,636 --> 01:03:44,624 may be completely right. But if you're wrong with the timing by 863 01:03:44,624 --> 01:04:01,113 a few years, you probably lose the confidence of the investors. 864 01:04:01,113 --> 01:04:17,602 Now, it doesn't mean that trend following is flawless and we're 865 01:04:17,602 --> 01:04:37,089 going to have our drawdowns and all that, but at least if people 866 01:04:37,089 --> 01:04:59,574 spend a bit of time studying it, that is just part of how it works. 867 01:04:59,574 --> 01:05:14,564 So anyway, let's leave it for today on that note. Of course, as 868 01:02:51,217 --> 01:03:04,252 always, I would encourage people to go and leave a positive 869 01:03:04,252 --> 01:03:20,842 rating and review as a thank you note to Alan and all the other 870 01:03:20,842 --> 01:03:32,692 co-hosts coming on every week prepared with topics and interesting 871 01:03:32,692 --> 01:03:48,097 talking points. It actually is a lot of effort on their part. So, 872 01:03:48,097 --> 01:04:02,317 I really do appreciate if you would show your appreciation on that. 873 01:04:02,317 --> 01:04:17,722 That and you might still be in the running for the competition we 874 01:04:17,722 --> 01:04:33,127 have running until the 1st of September where you can win the actual, 875 01:04:33,127 --> 01:04:48,532 not the actual vest that Alan is wearing today, but a similar very 876 01:04:48,532 --> 01:05:00,382 sleek Top Traders Unplugged vest. So anyways, there's still a 877 01:05:00,382 --> 01:05:14,602 few more days, but you need to leave a rating and review. You need 878 01:02:54,832 --> 01:03:30,682 to email the usual email the usual address at info@toptradersunplugged.com 879 01:03:30,682 --> 01:04:20,872 and tell me who you are, what you wrote, and where we can find 880 01:04:20,872 --> 01:05:07,477 it, because we do want to verify, of course, that it was an 881 01:05:07,477 --> 01:05:14,647 actual review. Anyways, next week I'm joined by Yoav. I know he's 882 01:03:14,882 --> 01:03:50,268 already put out to me some notes about what he's going to cover 883 01:03:50,268 --> 01:04:17,488 and I thought that looked very, very interesting indeed. If 884 01:04:17,488 --> 01:04:41,986 you have a question for Yoav at info@toptradersunplugged.com is 885 01:04:41,986 --> 01:05:14,650 the email and I'll do my very best to bring them up. That's it 886 01:02:55,010 --> 01:03:39,098 for today from Alan and me. Thanks ever so much for listening. 887 01:03:39,098 --> 01:04:30,534 We look forward to being back with you next week. And in the meantime, 888 01:04:30,534 --> 01:05:14,622 as usual, take care of yourself and take care of each other. 889 01:05:17,132 --> 01:06:50,169 Thanks for listening to Top Traders Unplugged. If you feel you 890 01:05:22,448 --> 01:05:35,738 learned something of value from today's episode, the best way 891 01:05:35,738 --> 01:05:53,015 to stay updated is to go on over to your favorite podcast platform 892 01:05:53,015 --> 01:06:11,621 and follow the show so that you'll be sure to get all the new 893 01:06:11,621 --> 01:06:24,911 episodes as they're released. We have some amazing guests lined 894 01:06:24,911 --> 01:06:42,188 up for you and to ensure our show continues to grow, please leave 895 01:06:42,188 --> 01:06:50,162 us an honest rating and review. It only takes a minute and 896 01:05:38,600 --> 01:06:28,692 it's the best way to show us you love the podcast. We'll see you 897 01:06:28,692 --> 01:06:50,160 next time on Top Traders Unplugged. This podcast expresses 898 01:05:23,069 --> 01:05:48,796 the views of its hosts and the guests appearing on the podcast as 899 01:05:48,796 --> 01:06:14,523 of the date of its recording, and such views are subject to change 900 01:06:14,523 --> 01:06:36,292 without notice. Top Traders Unplugged do not have any duty or 901 01:06:36,292 --> 01:06:50,145 obligation to update the information contained herein. Furthermore, 902 01:05:19,401 --> 01:05:42,091 Top Traders Unplugged make no representation to its accuracy and 903 01:05:42,091 --> 01:06:07,050 it shall not be assumed that past investment performance is an 904 01:06:07,050 --> 01:06:29,740 indication of future results. Moreover, wherever there is a potential 905 01:06:29,740 --> 01:06:50,161 for profit, there is also the possibility of loss. This content 906 01:05:27,468 --> 01:06:13,980 is made available for educational purposes only and should 907 01:06:13,980 --> 01:06:50,156 not be used for any other purpose. The information contained 908 01:05:24,884 --> 01:05:53,308 in this podcast does not constitute and should not be construed 909 01:05:53,308 --> 01:06:24,316 as investment advice or an offer to sell or a solicitation to 910 01:06:24,316 --> 01:06:50,156 buy any securities or related financial instruments in any jurisdiction. 911 01:05:17,132 --> 01:05:34,730 Certain information contained herein concerning economic trends 912 01:05:34,730 --> 01:05:59,870 and performance is based on or derived from information provided 913 01:05:59,870 --> 01:06:19,982 by independent third-party sources. Top Traders Unplugged may 914 01:06:19,982 --> 01:06:45,122 believe that the sources from which such information are obtained 915 01:06:45,122 --> 01:06:50,150 are reliable. However, Top Traders Unplugged cannot guarantee 916 01:05:25,850 --> 01:05:38,927 the accuracy of such information and has not independently 917 01:05:38,927 --> 01:05:50,551 verified the accuracy or completeness of such information 918 01:05:50,551 --> 01:06:06,534 or the assumptions on which such information is based. This podcast, 919 01:06:06,534 --> 01:06:19,611 including the information contained herein, may not be reproduced, 920 01:06:19,611 --> 01:06:37,047 copied, republished or posted in whole or in part in any form, 921 01:06:37,047 --> 01:06:50,124 without the prior written consent of Top Traders Unplugged.