1 00:00:43,820 --> 00:00:46,820 All right, folks, this is Steve with Macro and Cheese. Today's 2 00:00:46,820 --> 00:00:52,660 guest is Ian Angus and I want to express how interesting this guest 3 00:00:52,660 --> 00:00:56,780 is. The book that he is going to be discussing today is called 4 00:00:57,100 --> 00:01:02,180 Metabolic Capitalism's Assault on the Earth System. So Ian Angus 5 00:01:02,180 --> 00:01:06,850 is, is the author of Facing the Anthropocene, A Monthly Review 6 00:01:06,850 --> 00:01:11,970 Press, 2016, and he's the editor of the online ecosocialist 7 00:01:11,970 --> 00:01:16,210 journal Climate and Capitalism and a founding member of the Global 8 00:01:16,370 --> 00:01:21,450 Ecosocialist Network. And so with that, Ian, welcome to the show, 9 00:01:21,450 --> 00:01:21,890 sir. 10 00:01:22,210 --> 00:01:23,730 Thank you very much for having me. 11 00:01:24,130 --> 00:01:27,010 Absolutely. This book is really interesting. It plays off 12 00:01:27,010 --> 00:01:30,370 of some stuff that we've covered recently with guys like Errol 13 00:01:30,370 --> 00:01:34,760 Colassi, who wrote the Physics of Capitalism. And we've talked to 14 00:01:34,760 --> 00:01:38,880 a lot of other folks too about the interrelatedness of all things. 15 00:01:39,040 --> 00:01:42,760 And, you know, it's really important to understand the domino 16 00:01:42,760 --> 00:01:48,000 effects of way a decision made over here impacts so many things, 17 00:01:48,000 --> 00:01:52,080 so many unseen things, things that we don't necessarily relate 18 00:01:52,080 --> 00:01:56,080 to one another, but they are tied together through a complex web 19 00:01:56,080 --> 00:02:00,600 of systems that keep us alive, quite frankly. And I think your book 20 00:02:01,000 --> 00:02:04,960 is really excellent in terms of tying all that together. Can you 21 00:02:04,960 --> 00:02:10,120 give us just an overview of your book and kind of explain where 22 00:02:10,120 --> 00:02:12,600 the genesis of writing this came from? 23 00:02:13,239 --> 00:02:17,480 Well, the concept of metabolic rifts sort of emerged as an important 24 00:02:17,640 --> 00:02:22,440 subject within Marxism and ecology over the past 20 years and 25 00:02:22,440 --> 00:02:26,530 really over the past five or six that it's gotten a fair bit of 26 00:02:26,530 --> 00:02:30,410 exposure. It goes back to Marx. You know, I can say at the 27 00:02:30,410 --> 00:02:34,050 beginning, if you went around 20 years ago and asked even most 28 00:02:34,050 --> 00:02:38,170 Marxists, what did Karl Marx have to say about ecology? The typical 29 00:02:38,170 --> 00:02:40,610 answer would have been, well, he didn't really have anything to 30 00:02:40,610 --> 00:02:45,010 say about that. Nature wasn't big on his agenda. He was just interested 31 00:02:45,010 --> 00:02:49,250 in factories and so on, well, it's literally not true. The only 32 00:02:49,250 --> 00:02:51,810 way you could say that is if you haven't actually read what Marx 33 00:02:51,810 --> 00:02:55,890 wrote. Now, he didn't have our contemporary vocabulary. The word 34 00:02:55,890 --> 00:02:59,530 ecology hadn't been invented when he wrote on this subject. And 35 00:02:59,530 --> 00:03:02,730 even the word metabolism, which I'm going to use here, didn't 36 00:03:02,730 --> 00:03:05,490 exist in English. When he was writing, there was a German word 37 00:03:05,490 --> 00:03:10,050 for it, stockfishel, but he was writing in German. But one result 38 00:03:10,050 --> 00:03:14,010 of that is even the first translations of Marx's work didn't 39 00:03:14,010 --> 00:03:17,370 include what he had to say about this or used other words. And 40 00:03:17,370 --> 00:03:20,010 so when you go back and look at it, it's hard to say, oh, that 41 00:03:20,010 --> 00:03:23,490 he's talking about a modern ecological subject. But in fact, 42 00:03:23,490 --> 00:03:27,690 he was. And what he talks about, beginning with some of his 43 00:03:27,690 --> 00:03:32,250 earliest writings, is the fundamental connection between human 44 00:03:32,250 --> 00:03:35,850 existence and the natural world around us. He says somewhere 45 00:03:35,850 --> 00:03:39,010 that we have to remain in constant dialogue with nature if 46 00:03:39,010 --> 00:03:43,170 we are not to die. It's a constant exchange. And this occurs 47 00:03:43,170 --> 00:03:46,570 on. You can think of this in many, many ways, but possibly the 48 00:03:46,570 --> 00:03:50,740 one that almost anybody is familiar with is the fact that animals 49 00:03:50,740 --> 00:03:55,180 inhale oxygen and exhale carbon dioxide, and plants inhale 50 00:03:55,180 --> 00:03:58,660 carbon dioxide and exile oxygen. So you have a cycle that 51 00:03:58,660 --> 00:04:02,940 goes on there and keeps the overall content of our atmosphere 52 00:04:02,940 --> 00:04:06,820 roughly even over time, so that we can, both plants and animals 53 00:04:06,820 --> 00:04:11,780 can live in it. The concept of a metabolic rift then emerges in 54 00:04:11,780 --> 00:04:15,380 Marx's writings a little later, where he points out that the 55 00:04:15,380 --> 00:04:18,380 way capitalism works is it tends to take things from nature 56 00:04:18,380 --> 00:04:22,180 and not put things back. And he would be talking mainly about 57 00:04:22,180 --> 00:04:26,980 agriculture, where farmers take plants out of the earth or take 58 00:04:26,980 --> 00:04:30,020 all the things they grow. Historically, they would have been 59 00:04:30,020 --> 00:04:32,900 feeding themselves and their neighbors, but with the coming of 60 00:04:32,900 --> 00:04:37,260 capitalism, they were shipping that food off to markets to be eaten 61 00:04:37,260 --> 00:04:41,180 elsewhere. And the nutrients that were in that food ended up being 62 00:04:41,180 --> 00:04:44,420 discarded, going into sewers and rivers and not going back into 63 00:04:44,420 --> 00:04:48,410 the Earth. So gradually you saw this, and it happens, particularly 64 00:04:48,410 --> 00:04:53,530 in England in the 1840s and 1850s, that the productivity of the 65 00:04:53,530 --> 00:04:57,730 soil declined because of this removal of nutrients, because of 66 00:04:57,730 --> 00:05:02,530 this rift in the nutrient cycle in which typically we take 67 00:05:02,530 --> 00:05:05,570 nutrients from the soil and we return them both in terms of our 68 00:05:05,570 --> 00:05:09,570 excrement and in terms of when our bodies die. Everything goes back 69 00:05:09,570 --> 00:05:13,420 to the Earth, ultimately. And that then forced the development 70 00:05:13,420 --> 00:05:18,100 of artificial fertilizers on a large scale because the natural cycle 71 00:05:18,100 --> 00:05:21,900 was interrupted. That's a beginning of a discussion of what 72 00:05:21,900 --> 00:05:25,220 turns out, as scientists have learned over the past century and 73 00:05:25,220 --> 00:05:30,060 a half, that the entire Earth system functions on this basis of 74 00:05:30,060 --> 00:05:33,540 biogeochemical cycles, things that are constantly being cycled 75 00:05:33,540 --> 00:05:37,460 and reused and reused. Nature is the ultimate recycler, and it 76 00:05:37,460 --> 00:05:41,500 comes in conflict with a system that works in a linear way. 77 00:05:41,500 --> 00:05:45,020 It takes things from nature and then just discards the waste 78 00:05:45,020 --> 00:05:48,420 Product rather than reusing it, rather than returning it to the 79 00:05:48,420 --> 00:05:50,060 soil or the air or the water. 80 00:05:50,860 --> 00:05:54,620 Very powerful. And I think that kind of continuity, that cyclical 81 00:05:54,620 --> 00:05:59,740 nature of matter is an important point in Marxism in general, 82 00:05:59,820 --> 00:06:03,700 you know, especially for those of us who've recently just sort of 83 00:06:03,700 --> 00:06:06,780 bumped our heads into historical and dialectical materialism, 84 00:06:07,510 --> 00:06:11,350 understanding kind of that approach to the connectivity and 85 00:06:11,350 --> 00:06:16,350 the way things come to be. And it was very illuminating to kind 86 00:06:16,350 --> 00:06:19,470 of think differently. I mean, it's a totally different way of thinking 87 00:06:19,470 --> 00:06:23,510 than I think most people have been trained to believe and think 88 00:06:23,910 --> 00:06:27,430 as well. One of the things I wanted to bring out from your book, 89 00:06:27,430 --> 00:06:30,870 and I think it was really powerful, was you mentioned how Marx 90 00:06:31,430 --> 00:06:34,890 discussed this stuff, and people didn't really, you know, believe 91 00:06:34,890 --> 00:06:37,970 that Marx discussed this stuff, but it wasn't just him, it 92 00:06:37,970 --> 00:06:41,370 kept going. And you detail this. Well, you talked about August 93 00:06:41,370 --> 00:06:44,890 Bevel, you talk about Karl Kotsky, and you talked about Nikolai 94 00:06:44,890 --> 00:06:48,570 Bukharin. Can you talk about the lineage of people within the 95 00:06:48,570 --> 00:06:52,730 Marxist segment that actually discussed this? Because I think it's 96 00:06:52,730 --> 00:06:55,970 really important to know that it wasn't some isolated thing that 97 00:06:56,130 --> 00:06:59,250 thus saith the Marx, it kept going. It was bigger than that. 98 00:06:59,820 --> 00:07:03,380 That's very true. You know, and in fact, when John Bellamy Foster, 99 00:07:03,380 --> 00:07:06,300 who was really the first person to write in modern times about 100 00:07:06,300 --> 00:07:10,340 the metabolic rift, a very common criticism was, oh, well, that's 101 00:07:10,340 --> 00:07:13,420 just a few passages in Marx, and then there was nothing else. 102 00:07:13,420 --> 00:07:16,620 So it wasn't very important. Well, you have to go back and see 103 00:07:16,620 --> 00:07:20,020 what actual socialists of Marx's time were talking about, what 104 00:07:20,020 --> 00:07:22,540 they were saying. Well, first of all, Marx talked about it a fair 105 00:07:22,540 --> 00:07:26,210 bit, especially in Capital, which was his major work. His major 106 00:07:26,450 --> 00:07:30,490 comrade and coworker Engels talks about this whole problem of 107 00:07:30,490 --> 00:07:34,050 cycles and metabolic rifts and a number of his important works. 108 00:07:34,530 --> 00:07:38,770 But then, and this is things I'm talking about in my book that 109 00:07:38,770 --> 00:07:42,530 I haven't seen elsewhere, somebody like August Bebel, who was. 110 00:07:42,930 --> 00:07:46,250 He's not well remembered today, but in his time he was the 111 00:07:46,250 --> 00:07:49,730 principal leader of the German socialist movement, which was really 112 00:07:49,730 --> 00:07:54,060 the largest socialist party in the world in Marx's time. And he 113 00:07:54,060 --> 00:07:58,100 wrote a book called Socialism and Women, which was probably the 114 00:07:58,100 --> 00:08:02,660 most widely read popularization of socialist ideas 115 00:08:02,980 --> 00:08:07,060 in the late 1800s. And it's got an extensive discussion of these 116 00:08:07,060 --> 00:08:11,340 issues of the cyclical nature, in particular of agriculture and 117 00:08:11,340 --> 00:08:16,660 the need to return nutrients to the soil and so on. And then Karl 118 00:08:16,660 --> 00:08:21,420 Kautsky, who was the principal theoretician of German Marxism, he 119 00:08:21,420 --> 00:08:26,110 was the capitalist Press used to refer to him as the Pope of Marxism. 120 00:08:26,430 --> 00:08:29,990 He edited all the major journals. And he was, as I say, the 121 00:08:29,990 --> 00:08:33,110 principal theoretician in European socialism right up until 122 00:08:33,110 --> 00:08:36,870 World War I. And he wrote a book called the Agrarian Question 123 00:08:36,870 --> 00:08:39,790 and what Was Going on in Farming. And once again, he went 124 00:08:39,790 --> 00:08:43,950 into those ideas in great detail. And both Webel and Kautsky 125 00:08:43,950 --> 00:08:47,470 knew Marx and Engels personally. And they, in addition 126 00:08:47,470 --> 00:08:50,590 to having read their work, they would have discussed these questions. 127 00:08:51,010 --> 00:08:54,010 These were things that were just on the agenda for socialists 128 00:08:54,010 --> 00:08:57,810 at the time. And the third person you mentioned, Nikolai Bukharin, 129 00:08:57,810 --> 00:09:00,730 well, he's the next generation. He's one of the leaders 130 00:09:00,730 --> 00:09:05,050 of the Bolshevik party, part of Lenin's Central Committee, the 131 00:09:05,050 --> 00:09:08,530 people who made the Russian Revolution. And he was at the time 132 00:09:08,610 --> 00:09:12,330 widely regarded as, next to Lenin, the most important of the 133 00:09:12,330 --> 00:09:16,890 theoreticians in the party. And he again, he wrote about the 134 00:09:16,890 --> 00:09:20,890 importance of metabolism in a textbook that he wrote about 1921 135 00:09:20,890 --> 00:09:24,850 at the. The Russian Communists published as a textbook to train 136 00:09:24,850 --> 00:09:29,690 their members in the ideas of Marxism. And then, and this was an 137 00:09:29,690 --> 00:09:33,890 important discovery for me, Bukharin was one of the victims of 138 00:09:33,890 --> 00:09:37,890 the Stalinist repression that occurred in the Soviet Union beginning 139 00:09:37,890 --> 00:09:42,850 in the late 1920s and ended up being arrested and ultimately being 140 00:09:43,090 --> 00:09:48,100 executed in Stalin's prison in the mid-1930s. Well, while he was 141 00:09:48,100 --> 00:09:52,340 in prison, he wrote several books, and one of them is called 142 00:09:52,340 --> 00:09:56,580 Philosophical Arabesques or other obscure title. But again, it's 143 00:09:56,580 --> 00:10:00,500 a book about Marxist theory and it deals at considerable length 144 00:10:00,500 --> 00:10:04,220 with this question of metabolism in nature and the need 145 00:10:04,460 --> 00:10:09,220 for a new society that builds itself around this constant recycling 146 00:10:09,220 --> 00:10:12,620 rather than in simply churning out waste. 147 00:10:14,040 --> 00:10:17,040 Sure. You know, I, I appreciate the feedback there, because 148 00:10:17,040 --> 00:10:21,600 when I think about the various voices of the time, I don't want 149 00:10:21,600 --> 00:10:26,600 to relitigate Stalin, Trotsky, all that stuff. I mean that, my goodness, 150 00:10:26,680 --> 00:10:30,880 there's probably a billion hours of back and forth that people 151 00:10:30,880 --> 00:10:36,000 go through, breaking down that long, you know, entire discussion. 152 00:10:36,000 --> 00:10:39,640 And we're not any different. I think we've done it a number of times 153 00:10:39,640 --> 00:10:43,290 too, here. But I think it's important to kind of realize for 154 00:10:43,290 --> 00:10:46,930 those that are, you know, because in my circles today, there 155 00:10:46,930 --> 00:10:52,690 is a distaste for various people to say, well, I'm an eco socialist. 156 00:10:52,690 --> 00:10:55,090 It's like, well, why aren't you just a socialist? Marx was a. 157 00:10:55,090 --> 00:10:58,130 So. I mean, he said these things, so why do you have to differentiate 158 00:10:58,130 --> 00:11:01,410 that you're an ecosocialist. What, why does that matter? Why do 159 00:11:01,410 --> 00:11:04,050 you need that differentiator I mean, bottom line is, we're fighting 160 00:11:04,050 --> 00:11:07,370 capitalism. You're still dealing with the same things. I don't 161 00:11:07,370 --> 00:11:11,090 understand the distinction. But on the flip to that, I oftentimes 162 00:11:11,090 --> 00:11:15,170 hear the flip side with people like within the ecosocialist degrowth 163 00:11:15,170 --> 00:11:19,530 movement who kind of focus on the concept of, hey, I gotta shock 164 00:11:19,530 --> 00:11:23,130 you into waking up. Let me at least throw a piece of dynamite into 165 00:11:23,130 --> 00:11:26,170 the lake to bring the fish up to the surface so you'll at least 166 00:11:26,170 --> 00:11:30,290 pay attention to it. Guys like Jason Hickel, who we've talked to 167 00:11:30,290 --> 00:11:34,050 a bunch of times, spoke to the fact that it may not be the greatest 168 00:11:34,050 --> 00:11:37,570 name, but it gets people talking. And I think that's key here 169 00:11:37,570 --> 00:11:41,810 because none of us really have power right now. So the idea here 170 00:11:41,810 --> 00:11:46,010 is socializing these ideas. Can you explain to me how we take 171 00:11:46,010 --> 00:11:50,770 a move from theory into kind of like the physical reality? I think 172 00:11:50,770 --> 00:11:55,770 a lot of people read these theoretical pieces and they see words 173 00:11:55,770 --> 00:11:59,530 that are not really common vernacular of their time. They're 174 00:11:59,530 --> 00:12:04,600 just strange words that are of yesteryear. What does this translate 175 00:12:04,600 --> 00:12:07,440 to in reality, what we're talking about here? All the theory 176 00:12:07,520 --> 00:12:12,280 aside, what is the physical outcomes of all this? What are we 177 00:12:12,280 --> 00:12:13,360 talking about, Ian? 178 00:12:14,240 --> 00:12:19,080 Well, on the issue of sort of that term ecosocialism, I was among 179 00:12:19,080 --> 00:12:22,080 the people who adopted that term early, and I certainly went 180 00:12:22,080 --> 00:12:26,040 through many discussions, including with many Marxists who 181 00:12:26,040 --> 00:12:28,960 would say, well, why do you have to say ecosocialism? Surely 182 00:12:29,360 --> 00:12:32,800 we will get socialism, and that will solve all of these problems, 183 00:12:33,220 --> 00:12:36,180 so we don't need to talk about it as anything particularly special. 184 00:12:36,820 --> 00:12:41,780 And my response then and my response now is, well, capitalism, 185 00:12:41,780 --> 00:12:44,340 the system we're trying to get rid of, one of the principal things 186 00:12:44,340 --> 00:12:48,500 it is doing is destroying our planet. Destroying in particular 187 00:12:49,140 --> 00:12:53,340 the. The Earth system, the conditions on Earth that have made 188 00:12:53,340 --> 00:12:57,820 human life and human civilization possible. And focusing 189 00:12:57,820 --> 00:13:02,320 on solving those is going to be a huge part of, not only of building 190 00:13:02,320 --> 00:13:05,400 a socialist movement today and the things that we fight for and 191 00:13:05,400 --> 00:13:09,280 the changes that we try to make, but in a socialist society, 192 00:13:09,360 --> 00:13:13,280 these problems aren't going to go away immediately. It's not like, 193 00:13:13,520 --> 00:13:17,240 you know, when the revolution will come, suddenly everything will 194 00:13:17,240 --> 00:13:20,480 be green and solved. If we haven't actually thought these things 195 00:13:20,480 --> 00:13:26,160 through, you know, we will inherit the incredible damage that 196 00:13:26,160 --> 00:13:30,150 capitalism has done and continues to do. I mean, at a very 197 00:13:30,150 --> 00:13:34,390 simple level, imagine that, okay, tomorrow we have socialist 198 00:13:34,390 --> 00:13:36,550 governments everywhere. Well, you know, one thing that's going 199 00:13:36,550 --> 00:13:40,510 to happen is that the ice caps and all the glaciers are not going 200 00:13:40,510 --> 00:13:43,430 to stop melting because of the increase in temperature that's already 201 00:13:43,430 --> 00:13:46,950 happened. So the oceans are going to be rising for centuries. 202 00:13:47,590 --> 00:13:50,030 Well, that means that the new society is going to have to deal 203 00:13:50,030 --> 00:13:53,390 with. How do we deal with coasts? How do we deal with this 204 00:13:53,390 --> 00:13:57,060 enormous number of cities that are built right on coastlines? How 205 00:13:57,060 --> 00:14:01,500 are we going to solve many of the problems of areas of agriculture 206 00:14:01,820 --> 00:14:06,300 where the rising sea level will put salt into the groundwater? 207 00:14:06,780 --> 00:14:10,540 And that's not something that can just be magically wished away. 208 00:14:11,180 --> 00:14:15,340 It means that socialists need to pay careful attention to these 209 00:14:15,340 --> 00:14:18,860 subjects. As I've said on a couple of occasions, there's sort 210 00:14:18,860 --> 00:14:22,140 of a tendency, or there was. It's tended to go away. But among 211 00:14:22,140 --> 00:14:25,230 socialists and socialist groups, sort of, you know, ecology 212 00:14:25,230 --> 00:14:28,710 and environmental problems are sort of. Let's add them to the list 213 00:14:28,710 --> 00:14:32,950 of things that we don't like. You know, it's like it's just another 214 00:14:32,950 --> 00:14:36,910 stick to beat capitalism with. Well, it isn't just another stick. 215 00:14:36,910 --> 00:14:41,630 It's one of the fundamental questions of the continuation of 216 00:14:41,630 --> 00:14:45,350 civilization and ultimately the survival of our species that 217 00:14:45,350 --> 00:14:48,950 we have to make central to our activity has to be part of our program 218 00:14:49,110 --> 00:14:53,410 at a very. A big part of our program, a big part of the activity 219 00:14:53,410 --> 00:14:57,370 that we engage in has to be building movements around this and 220 00:14:57,370 --> 00:15:01,450 explaining to people how capitalism is responsible. Many people 221 00:15:01,450 --> 00:15:04,650 are certainly aware of the environmental destruction that goes 222 00:15:04,650 --> 00:15:09,650 on, but there's often a tendency to say, oh, well, sooner 223 00:15:09,650 --> 00:15:13,490 or later the government will wise up. Well, the market analysis 224 00:15:13,490 --> 00:15:18,450 says they haven't wised up for many decades and they're not going 225 00:15:18,450 --> 00:15:22,160 to. And there's a reason for that, and that's that ecological 226 00:15:22,160 --> 00:15:26,440 destruction is actually built into capitalism's DNA. If we don't 227 00:15:26,440 --> 00:15:29,960 understand that and we don't stress that, we are not going to 228 00:15:29,960 --> 00:15:30,520 solve it. 229 00:15:31,240 --> 00:15:34,120 Ben, I couldn't agree with you more. I am not one of those people 230 00:15:34,120 --> 00:15:39,240 that feels like, I think, sometimes just hand waving. And again, 231 00:15:39,240 --> 00:15:44,160 we have completely divorced ourself of class consciousness in 232 00:15:44,160 --> 00:15:46,960 this country. I don't know that we ever really had it because 233 00:15:46,960 --> 00:15:49,400 we didn't go through some of the development that the rest of 234 00:15:49,400 --> 00:15:53,520 the world did. United States is kind of a unique empirical project, 235 00:15:53,600 --> 00:15:58,920 if you will, genocidal project at that. But when I think about the 236 00:15:58,920 --> 00:16:04,440 idea of specifying the tools of the trade, if you will, capitalism, 237 00:16:04,440 --> 00:16:08,960 sure, it's a big word. It kind of carries a lot of meanings. But 238 00:16:08,960 --> 00:16:12,760 there's phases of capitalism, the tools of capitalism, the morphing, 239 00:16:12,760 --> 00:16:16,220 the virus of capitalism continues to shift. And we've been 240 00:16:16,220 --> 00:16:20,340 through this neoliberal phase of capitalism. It's still just capitalism, 241 00:16:20,500 --> 00:16:24,220 but it's a very specific set of tools that they've pushed forward. 242 00:16:24,220 --> 00:16:28,900 We're at a different phase of its life cycle, if you will. And 243 00:16:28,900 --> 00:16:32,580 I think ecosocialists is a great term. I think it's important 244 00:16:32,660 --> 00:16:37,980 to center what's going to kill us first. So I'm in a complete agreement 245 00:16:37,980 --> 00:16:41,060 on that. I do want to bring up from your book one of the things 246 00:16:41,060 --> 00:16:44,510 I really found fascinating. And I want to keep with specifics 247 00:16:44,510 --> 00:16:48,670 here because I really want people to be able to come back, look 248 00:16:48,670 --> 00:16:51,710 at this podcast and go do research on their own. Don't just 249 00:16:51,710 --> 00:16:54,230 take our word for it. Look these things up. Read your book, 250 00:16:54,390 --> 00:16:59,270 look them up. But you talked about various scientists, like justice 251 00:16:59,270 --> 00:17:01,990 von Liebig, I believe, is the way you pronounce it. 252 00:17:01,990 --> 00:17:02,510 That's right. 253 00:17:02,510 --> 00:17:08,630 Or Liebig, Vladimir Vernadsky and Barry Commoner, for example. 254 00:17:08,950 --> 00:17:12,550 I'm curious, can you talk a little bit about the work, the natural 255 00:17:12,550 --> 00:17:17,559 history these folks did that help build this knowledge and help 256 00:17:17,559 --> 00:17:18,639 build your thesis? 257 00:17:19,119 --> 00:17:22,399 Well, what I tried to do in the book was sort of tell two parallel 258 00:17:22,399 --> 00:17:25,399 stories. One of them I've already been talking about, and that 259 00:17:25,399 --> 00:17:29,999 is how these ideas of the metabolism of nature, Marx calls 260 00:17:29,999 --> 00:17:33,879 it the universal metabolism of nature. One story is the story about 261 00:17:33,879 --> 00:17:36,319 how that went through the socialist movement, how socialists 262 00:17:36,319 --> 00:17:40,519 carried those ideas into the 20th century. And then the parallel 263 00:17:40,519 --> 00:17:45,290 story, which was never totally never separated from Marxism, but 264 00:17:45,290 --> 00:17:49,370 which was done by different people, was the evolution of a group 265 00:17:49,370 --> 00:17:54,210 of scientists who made the underlying discoveries in natural 266 00:17:54,210 --> 00:17:58,650 science that fed and reinforced the whole theory of metabolic 267 00:17:58,650 --> 00:18:04,050 rift. Justus von Liebig is one. Again, in his time, he was basically, 268 00:18:04,450 --> 00:18:11,530 think in terms of 1825 to about 1860, one of the most respected 269 00:18:11,850 --> 00:18:15,890 of all chemists in the world. He invented all kinds of essential 270 00:18:15,890 --> 00:18:19,890 methods and in particular of studying soil chemistry. He developed 271 00:18:19,890 --> 00:18:24,490 the technologies. He published hundreds of papers personally. And 272 00:18:24,490 --> 00:18:31,690 he, in roughly 19, excuse me, 1840, was hired by British experts 273 00:18:31,690 --> 00:18:35,170 to evaluate this problem of the declining fertility of the soil 274 00:18:35,170 --> 00:18:38,780 that I just talked about. And it was he that came up with the whole 275 00:18:38,860 --> 00:18:42,820 analysis that said, basically the nutrients are being taken out 276 00:18:42,820 --> 00:18:47,780 of the soil and, well, basically in England, shipped off 277 00:18:47,780 --> 00:18:50,580 to London, which was now a city of a million people who weren't 278 00:18:50,580 --> 00:18:54,140 growing their own food and their waste, both the food waste 279 00:18:54,140 --> 00:18:56,700 and the restraint and everything pretty much ended up in 280 00:18:56,700 --> 00:18:59,900 the Thames. That was the period of what's historically called 281 00:18:59,900 --> 00:19:05,180 the Great stink, where around 1857, there was so Much. And if I 282 00:19:05,180 --> 00:19:08,940 can use the word shit in the Thames, that Parliament, if you ever 283 00:19:08,940 --> 00:19:11,420 go to England, you'll see the Houses of Parliament are right on 284 00:19:11,420 --> 00:19:15,380 the shores of the Thames. And it smelled so bad in the summer of 285 00:19:15,380 --> 00:19:20,700 1857 that they actually had to shut Parliament down. And that triggered 286 00:19:21,020 --> 00:19:24,260 a whole lot of interest in how you can deal with this. And it in 287 00:19:24,260 --> 00:19:27,420 fact resulted in the development of the whole London sewer 288 00:19:27,420 --> 00:19:32,280 system, which up until then, they simply hadn't had sewers. And 289 00:19:32,280 --> 00:19:36,720 Marx was a great follower of Liebig. He's probably the most influential 290 00:19:36,720 --> 00:19:41,000 scientist in terms of Marx's view of metabolic rift. Marx says 291 00:19:41,320 --> 00:19:44,600 somewhere he wrote a letter to Engels. Well, Marx was writing Capital, 292 00:19:44,600 --> 00:19:48,080 which was of course, his life work. And he said he'd been reading 293 00:19:48,080 --> 00:19:51,040 the German chemists and had learned more from them than all the 294 00:19:51,040 --> 00:19:55,680 economists combined. And so Levig's work was very important to 295 00:19:55,680 --> 00:19:58,160 this. Now, he didn't understand it all. Many of the things 296 00:19:58,160 --> 00:20:02,310 that we now take for granted were not yet known. The role of cells, 297 00:20:02,390 --> 00:20:05,750 the role of living creatures, you know, at the cellular level, 298 00:20:05,910 --> 00:20:10,030 that were actually causing much of the stink, if you will, he 299 00:20:10,030 --> 00:20:13,710 didn't know about. And that took other scientists, Pasteur, for 300 00:20:13,710 --> 00:20:18,630 example. So he's one. I talk about another one. A man who's again, 301 00:20:18,870 --> 00:20:23,270 not well known in the west, was Vernadsky, who was basically 302 00:20:23,830 --> 00:20:29,230 roughly a Russian chemist and geologists from about to, say, the 303 00:20:29,230 --> 00:20:32,510 beginning of the 20th century or from about 1900 until his death 304 00:20:32,510 --> 00:20:38,710 in 1945. And he came up with a number of concepts that we now take 305 00:20:38,710 --> 00:20:43,270 for granted, in particular the concept of the biosphere. He borrowed 306 00:20:43,270 --> 00:20:46,350 the word from someone else, but he gave it meaning. And he was 307 00:20:46,350 --> 00:20:49,310 the one that basically did the studies that showed that the Earth 308 00:20:49,310 --> 00:20:52,550 wasn't a whole lot of little separate pieces that didn't interact, 309 00:20:52,850 --> 00:20:57,370 but rather was a complete system of interchanges of what he 310 00:20:57,370 --> 00:21:01,010 called biogeochemical cycles. And again, that's a word he invented. 311 00:21:01,410 --> 00:21:06,370 And he did much of the research that basically underlies 312 00:21:06,770 --> 00:21:10,770 modern theories of how the Earth system works. Now, he's an 313 00:21:10,770 --> 00:21:13,650 interesting guy in his own right. He was active in Russian politics. 314 00:21:13,650 --> 00:21:17,730 He was a liberal. He was a member of the Russian Duma, the parliament. 315 00:21:17,890 --> 00:21:21,690 He opposed the Russian Revolution, but also opposed the 316 00:21:21,690 --> 00:21:24,600 efforts of the Western countries and of the White Russians 317 00:21:24,830 --> 00:21:28,910 to overthrow the government. And after the Russian Civil War, 318 00:21:29,230 --> 00:21:33,870 Lenin specifically invited Vernadsky to return to Russia. He'd 319 00:21:33,870 --> 00:21:37,750 gone into exile and set up his own research lab, which he did in 320 00:21:37,750 --> 00:21:41,190 St. Petersburg or Petrograd and he spent the rest of his life 321 00:21:41,190 --> 00:21:44,830 working in Russia. He was not himself a Marxist, but he was a Russian 322 00:21:44,830 --> 00:21:49,150 patriot. And he produced an enormous amount of research, most 323 00:21:49,150 --> 00:21:51,750 of which didn't get known in the west because he was writing in 324 00:21:51,750 --> 00:21:54,630 Russia. And then of course, the Cold War was on all the prejudices 325 00:21:54,630 --> 00:21:58,350 there. But his work has largely been rediscovered really 326 00:21:58,510 --> 00:22:03,230 since the 1950s, and it's had a big influence on thinking about 327 00:22:03,230 --> 00:22:07,510 how the world works. And the third one you mentioned was Barry 328 00:22:07,510 --> 00:22:11,910 Commoner, an interesting guy in his own right. Barry is. He taught 329 00:22:11,910 --> 00:22:17,550 at University in St. Louis beginning in the 1940s or late 1940s, 330 00:22:17,870 --> 00:22:22,720 and he was a biology teacher and chemistry teacher. And he initiated 331 00:22:22,720 --> 00:22:25,840 a lot of interesting things, including one of his studies was 332 00:22:25,840 --> 00:22:29,120 the issue of radioactive fallout. Because when the nuclear 333 00:22:29,120 --> 00:22:33,320 bomb tests were going off in the early 1950s, the official line 334 00:22:33,400 --> 00:22:38,240 of the atomic energy people, the nuclear bomb people, was that 335 00:22:38,240 --> 00:22:41,640 the radiation from the bomb simply fell to the ground and didn't 336 00:22:41,640 --> 00:22:45,800 affect anybody very much. Well, what he demonstrated was interesting. 337 00:22:45,800 --> 00:22:49,350 He did this campaign where he had mothers all over North America 338 00:22:49,350 --> 00:22:53,230 send in their children's baby teeth. And literally hundreds of 339 00:22:53,230 --> 00:22:56,670 thousands of people sent in the baby teeth from their kids. And 340 00:22:56,670 --> 00:23:00,550 then they analyzed them and discovered how much the fallout from 341 00:23:00,550 --> 00:23:04,749 nuclear explosions was traveling, how it was all over the 342 00:23:04,749 --> 00:23:08,030 place, and it was in the kids teeth. And in particular strontium 343 00:23:08,030 --> 00:23:12,430 90, which is the. One of the radioactive elements that was produced 344 00:23:12,430 --> 00:23:16,570 only in atomic explosions. So I mean, he's getting at this subject 345 00:23:16,570 --> 00:23:20,010 of everything links together. This is not. You can't simply set 346 00:23:20,010 --> 00:23:24,090 off a atomic bomb in Nevada and expect that it's going to have 347 00:23:24,090 --> 00:23:27,770 no effect in England. But it did because the atmosphere carries 348 00:23:27,770 --> 00:23:32,690 those things around. He also then went on to become a major figure 349 00:23:32,690 --> 00:23:36,210 in the environmental movement. And he wrote a book on the Broken 350 00:23:36,210 --> 00:23:40,850 Circle, which came out in 1970 and was actually a bestseller, although 351 00:23:40,850 --> 00:23:44,500 he's not as well known today. Time magazine actually put him on 352 00:23:44,500 --> 00:23:47,980 the COVID as the main figure in the environmental movement at 353 00:23:47,980 --> 00:23:51,980 that time. And his book, which is now back in print, really deserves 354 00:23:51,980 --> 00:23:56,540 to be widely read. Terms we use now, he doesn't use ecology scarcely 355 00:23:56,540 --> 00:24:00,060 appears in his book, and Metabolic Rift doesn't appear in 356 00:24:00,060 --> 00:24:03,780 his book, but the ideas certainly do. What he described is 357 00:24:03,780 --> 00:24:06,260 very much the kind of thing I'm talking about in my book. 358 00:24:07,070 --> 00:24:11,670 I just want to bring us back to capitalism, right? And I want 359 00:24:11,670 --> 00:24:15,870 to make a editorial statement here. I think a lot of people debate 360 00:24:15,870 --> 00:24:19,470 the. Even the existence of capitalism, which I find humorous. 361 00:24:19,870 --> 00:24:25,550 But in reality, the concept of capitalism is oftentimes thrown up 362 00:24:26,110 --> 00:24:30,110 like a talk to the hand, not to the face kind of movement, where 363 00:24:30,750 --> 00:24:33,530 that's the beyond. The conversation ended. You. You said 364 00:24:33,530 --> 00:24:37,610 capitalism, okay? Capitalism's the cause. We understand, most of 365 00:24:37,610 --> 00:24:43,050 us understand that capitalism has had a horrible effect on our 366 00:24:43,050 --> 00:24:47,650 lives in general. It is alienated us from our work. It has 367 00:24:47,730 --> 00:24:52,690 created systems that predate upon people and subjugate people 368 00:24:52,690 --> 00:24:58,250 and really enslave people. At some level, the idea that capitalism 369 00:24:58,250 --> 00:25:02,250 is this benign thing that, you know, we just need a few reforms 370 00:25:02,250 --> 00:25:06,250 and it'll be okay. And it feels folly. But the problem is, 371 00:25:06,250 --> 00:25:10,290 is that a lot of times people stop at just saying capitalism, capitalism's 372 00:25:10,290 --> 00:25:15,370 the problem. Can you explain the mechanisms of capitalism that 373 00:25:15,370 --> 00:25:18,970 fuel this biohazard that we're living through? 374 00:25:19,290 --> 00:25:22,410 Right. Well, you know, Mark, somewhere one of my very favorite 375 00:25:22,410 --> 00:25:26,790 passages in Karl Marx is an article he wrote about 1853 or about 376 00:25:27,110 --> 00:25:33,110 as he describes capitalism. He says he compares it to the pagan 377 00:25:33,190 --> 00:25:38,630 idol that will only grant your wishes in exchange for human sacrifices. 378 00:25:39,350 --> 00:25:44,510 It will only drink the nectar from the skulls of the slain. And 379 00:25:44,510 --> 00:25:47,910 that's an important way of thinking about capitalism because 380 00:25:48,150 --> 00:25:51,230 what he's saying is capitalism does good things, but the only way 381 00:25:51,230 --> 00:25:54,880 it does them is in destructive ways. And that's consistent in the 382 00:25:54,880 --> 00:25:59,400 history of capitalism. Now, the problem here is people will fake 383 00:25:59,400 --> 00:26:04,160 capitalism, and they. Unless you have a fairly clear idea of what 384 00:26:04,160 --> 00:26:09,479 capitalism is, you know, it is not just I can set up a store if 385 00:26:09,479 --> 00:26:14,120 I want to. It is not just I get to own my house. In fact, neither 386 00:26:14,120 --> 00:26:17,400 of those things are particularly characteristic of capitalism. 387 00:26:17,640 --> 00:26:20,400 They have existed in previous societies, and they'll probably exist 388 00:26:20,400 --> 00:26:23,430 in future ones. What we're talking about in capitalism is a 389 00:26:23,430 --> 00:26:26,870 system that has certain fundamental characteristics. The 390 00:26:26,870 --> 00:26:32,350 first one is basically that the means of production, the means 391 00:26:32,350 --> 00:26:36,790 of making all of the things we need, all of the, you know, you name 392 00:26:36,790 --> 00:26:40,670 it, the billions of things that are made, the ways of making 393 00:26:40,670 --> 00:26:44,350 those are privately owned. They're in the hands of people who 394 00:26:44,430 --> 00:26:47,670 own them and use them for their own purposes and their own 395 00:26:47,670 --> 00:26:52,350 enrichment. That's fundamental to the system is that private ownership. 396 00:26:52,830 --> 00:26:57,470 Second to it is the need for profit. And that's again, absolutely 397 00:26:57,470 --> 00:27:01,670 critical. Mark uses the formula mcm. He says what a capitalist 398 00:27:01,670 --> 00:27:06,030 does, he takes m, which is money. He uses it to buy commodities, 399 00:27:06,030 --> 00:27:09,470 which would be the things he needs to make things. And it means 400 00:27:09,790 --> 00:27:13,070 the ability to labor of the working people who work for him or 401 00:27:13,070 --> 00:27:19,430 who he hires. He buys those commodities and uses them and then 402 00:27:20,150 --> 00:27:24,150 uses what they make. To sell and get more money. And it's constantly 403 00:27:24,150 --> 00:27:28,270 this money to commodities, to money. And if the second amount of 404 00:27:28,270 --> 00:27:31,830 money isn't bigger than the first one, that is, if he's not actually 405 00:27:32,710 --> 00:27:37,030 selling the goods for more than they cost, the whole thing is 406 00:27:37,030 --> 00:27:41,750 pointless and nobody would do it. And as that need to constantly 407 00:27:41,750 --> 00:27:46,960 grow, to constantly accumulate more and more wealth is just built 408 00:27:46,960 --> 00:27:50,600 into the system, there really isn't a way around it. When you have 409 00:27:50,600 --> 00:27:54,040 a system that's based on making profit, well, when you think 410 00:27:54,040 --> 00:27:57,520 about what that means for the environment, I would just think in 411 00:27:57,680 --> 00:28:01,440 very simple terms, very obvious terms that we all know about. 412 00:28:01,760 --> 00:28:04,520 Taking oil out of the ground, petroleum out of the ground, and 413 00:28:04,520 --> 00:28:08,440 turning it into oil and gasoline and selling that is one 414 00:28:08,440 --> 00:28:12,660 of the biggest businesses there is. Well, the process of doing 415 00:28:12,660 --> 00:28:16,460 that also generates a whole lot of stuff that the capitalist 416 00:28:16,460 --> 00:28:20,780 can't sell, that there's no money in it, and that's carbon dioxide, 417 00:28:20,780 --> 00:28:25,860 among many other things. So instead of preserving that, what 418 00:28:25,860 --> 00:28:30,340 the oil company does is simply release it into the atmosphere. And 419 00:28:30,340 --> 00:28:34,260 as a result, we end up with steadily increasing carbon dioxide 420 00:28:34,260 --> 00:28:37,840 in the atmosphere over the past half century to the point where 421 00:28:37,920 --> 00:28:41,440 there's now actually more CO2 in the atmosphere than there has 422 00:28:41,440 --> 00:28:45,280 been for several million years. And that's what's causing 423 00:28:45,280 --> 00:28:50,160 global warming. That happens right across the board. Isvan Musarus 424 00:28:50,560 --> 00:28:54,920 was a Hungarian philosopher who says the measure of capitalist 425 00:28:54,920 --> 00:29:00,080 growth is the measure of waste. How much waste and pollution 426 00:29:00,080 --> 00:29:04,440 do they create? That's how you tell how rich a country under capitalism 427 00:29:04,440 --> 00:29:04,800 is. 428 00:29:05,650 --> 00:29:09,650 You are listening to Macro and Cheese. A podcast by Real Progressives. 429 00:29:09,970 --> 00:29:15,130 We are a 501c3 non profit organization. All donations are tax 430 00:29:15,130 --> 00:29:19,250 deductible. Please consider becoming a monthly donor on Patreon 431 00:29:19,570 --> 00:29:24,690 substack or our website, realprogressives.org now back to 432 00:29:24,690 --> 00:29:25,490 the podcast. 433 00:29:28,130 --> 00:29:32,020 Well said. I think one of the other. You know, I've got a bunch 434 00:29:32,020 --> 00:29:34,820 of them, by the way, but one of the things that jumped out at 435 00:29:34,820 --> 00:29:39,420 me a lot was the idea of private ownership, which you said. 436 00:29:39,420 --> 00:29:43,020 And I want to, I'm doing this as much as a document of record here 437 00:29:43,020 --> 00:29:46,380 to make sure we have a trail, you know, a chain of custody, from 438 00:29:46,380 --> 00:29:50,420 the thought to the final product here. And what you said, 439 00:29:50,420 --> 00:29:53,780 what you laid clear, and I think Marxism as a whole in general 440 00:29:53,860 --> 00:29:58,400 lays clear, is that private owners, not democratic politics, 441 00:29:58,400 --> 00:30:02,280 not democratic publics, not the public sector, not the working 442 00:30:02,280 --> 00:30:07,160 class, makes these decisions. And so in the absence of workplace 443 00:30:07,160 --> 00:30:11,560 and community democracy, how does this enable metabolic rifts 444 00:30:11,560 --> 00:30:15,880 to grow and what are the consequences of that? I mean, obviously 445 00:30:16,200 --> 00:30:19,680 we've laid out quite a few of them here. I mean, it just. The biosphere 446 00:30:19,680 --> 00:30:22,520 is going to continue to warm up. Even if we stopped everything 447 00:30:22,520 --> 00:30:26,710 now, we've already warmed up so much to your point, centuries 448 00:30:26,710 --> 00:30:30,630 from now it'll still be melting ice and so forth. Help me 449 00:30:30,630 --> 00:30:35,190 understand what that private ownership does and the lack of democratic 450 00:30:35,190 --> 00:30:37,710 control over the means of production. 451 00:30:38,110 --> 00:30:42,030 Well, I guess the simplest way to think about it is if I were the 452 00:30:42,030 --> 00:30:45,350 president of, I don't know, pick your company. If I were the 453 00:30:45,350 --> 00:30:49,390 president of Toyota or General Motors or some oil company or other, 454 00:30:49,470 --> 00:30:53,700 me as a socialist might not just plunked into the, into the executive 455 00:30:53,860 --> 00:30:59,380 office. I'm now the CEO of a great big company. I'm still an ecosocialist. 456 00:30:59,380 --> 00:31:02,860 I still have the desire to produce a really nice world. So I 457 00:31:02,860 --> 00:31:06,060 start issuing all kinds of instructions because I'm now the 458 00:31:06,060 --> 00:31:09,340 president. And I tell everybody, okay, from now on, we 459 00:31:09,340 --> 00:31:12,980 are not going to pump out any emissions into the atmosphere. We're 460 00:31:12,980 --> 00:31:15,860 going to cut those off immediately. We're going to install 461 00:31:15,860 --> 00:31:20,550 what it takes to stop them. We are going to stop forcing our employees 462 00:31:20,550 --> 00:31:24,750 to work long hours and at low pay. We are going to pay better than 463 00:31:24,750 --> 00:31:28,110 living wage to everybody who works here. We're going to do all 464 00:31:28,110 --> 00:31:31,590 of these things. Basically, we are going to become a company that 465 00:31:31,590 --> 00:31:36,070 works to save the planet, that really does everything that the scientists 466 00:31:36,070 --> 00:31:39,070 say is necessary. Well, you know, the first thing that's going 467 00:31:39,070 --> 00:31:43,110 to happen, the profits of the company are going to plunge because 468 00:31:43,110 --> 00:31:46,950 we're spending enormous amounts of our income on of our money 469 00:31:47,270 --> 00:31:53,150 on things that don't produce revenue. So we are not reducing costs, 470 00:31:53,150 --> 00:31:56,230 which is what's fundamental to maintaining a profit level. We're 471 00:31:56,230 --> 00:31:59,990 increasing them substantially in areas where there is no prospect 472 00:31:59,990 --> 00:32:03,670 of a profit. So what I'm going to tell you is that I would not last 473 00:32:03,670 --> 00:32:09,670 long in that CEO's job. Right on the board of directors or the 474 00:32:10,470 --> 00:32:14,270 big shareholders. The banks who own very large percentages of 475 00:32:14,270 --> 00:32:18,130 these companies are basically going to get me kicked out. And they're 476 00:32:18,130 --> 00:32:22,090 going to put somebody in who's going to do it their way. And the 477 00:32:22,090 --> 00:32:26,650 fact is that if I want to keep my job, I would have to change my 478 00:32:26,650 --> 00:32:31,170 views. And the job, in fact, tends to. There tends to be a filter 479 00:32:31,249 --> 00:32:34,530 in every corporation. There is a filter in every corporation which 480 00:32:34,530 --> 00:32:37,810 keeps people like me out of the, out of the corporate suite. 481 00:32:38,610 --> 00:32:42,130 The people that get put into that position are the people who 482 00:32:42,130 --> 00:32:46,370 can live with, or perhaps never Even gave any thought to the 483 00:32:46,370 --> 00:32:50,650 moral damage they are doing to the world. The fact that if you are 484 00:32:50,650 --> 00:32:55,410 an oil company today, your current activities, the things you 485 00:32:55,410 --> 00:32:59,610 do every day, all the time, are dooming our children and our 486 00:32:59,610 --> 00:33:04,730 grandchildren to live in an absolutely devastated world. And 487 00:33:04,730 --> 00:33:08,050 I'm sure that many of those executives would say, if you ask 488 00:33:08,050 --> 00:33:10,570 them in private, oh, yeah, I want my children to live in a nice 489 00:33:10,570 --> 00:33:15,640 world, and so on. But they, in order to be president, Marx refers 490 00:33:15,640 --> 00:33:19,320 to the capitalists. He says, in their jobs, they are the personifications 491 00:33:19,320 --> 00:33:25,600 of capital. They actually act as capital in human form, and capital 492 00:33:25,840 --> 00:33:31,080 has to grow. We have to go back to that MCM formula where the 493 00:33:31,080 --> 00:33:34,720 second M always has to be bigger than the first one. The money 494 00:33:34,880 --> 00:33:38,550 that you take in always has to be bigger than the money you spent. 495 00:33:38,550 --> 00:33:40,610 And. And if it isn't, you go out of business. 496 00:33:41,170 --> 00:33:45,810 You know, I want to say that for a long time we were champions 497 00:33:45,970 --> 00:33:50,650 of like a Green New Deal. And I got to tell you, part of what radicalized 498 00:33:50,650 --> 00:33:56,210 this organization was the insanely obvious lack of democracy. 499 00:33:56,370 --> 00:34:01,010 And then we started putting theory to what our eyes were seeing 500 00:34:01,730 --> 00:34:04,850 and things like, we speak frequently about Gramsci because 501 00:34:04,850 --> 00:34:08,730 Gramsci's cultural hegemony really, really helped open our eyes 502 00:34:08,730 --> 00:34:14,740 to how the bourgeois society and the system itself kind of manufactures 503 00:34:14,740 --> 00:34:19,700 consent, and that the institutions tend to be direct, you 504 00:34:19,700 --> 00:34:23,700 know, food chain, if you will, thought chain from the oligarchy, 505 00:34:23,700 --> 00:34:27,340 if you are the powers that be. And really, at the end of the day, 506 00:34:27,340 --> 00:34:30,860 what you just said adds to that with, it's really not whether 507 00:34:30,860 --> 00:34:34,460 or not they're a good person, it's the system demands it in order 508 00:34:34,460 --> 00:34:38,360 to. You know, part of that cultural hegemon is, hey, you got 509 00:34:38,360 --> 00:34:41,000 to work hard and do great things and you can move right on 510 00:34:41,000 --> 00:34:45,160 up the food chain, move up the ladder, become a CEO someday, become 511 00:34:45,160 --> 00:34:48,920 a this, become a that. And then when you realize that part of 512 00:34:48,920 --> 00:34:53,880 that is that now all of a sudden you've got to become capitalism 513 00:34:54,200 --> 00:34:58,320 personified. It kind of goes back to what Rosa Luxemburg said 514 00:34:58,320 --> 00:35:02,930 about a socialist entering into government doesn't change the 515 00:35:02,930 --> 00:35:06,850 government to a socialist government, but instead that socialist 516 00:35:06,850 --> 00:35:09,210 becomes an administrator of capital. 517 00:35:09,450 --> 00:35:10,090 That's right. 518 00:35:10,170 --> 00:35:14,570 And at the end of the day, I don't think people realize how deep 519 00:35:14,730 --> 00:35:18,129 that contradiction is. They think, hey, we'll just vote a few 520 00:35:18,129 --> 00:35:20,930 more progressives and everything's going to be okay. But 521 00:35:20,930 --> 00:35:26,330 in reality, Gillens and Page 2014 Princeton study demonstrates 522 00:35:26,330 --> 00:35:31,140 in spades that not only do we not live in a democracy, but the 523 00:35:31,140 --> 00:35:36,740 idea that capitalism itself can produce these outcomes, especially 524 00:35:37,060 --> 00:35:41,780 based on the eloquent way you laid out what feeds capitalism, how 525 00:35:41,780 --> 00:35:46,020 capitalism has to survive, survives by profit, not by being 526 00:35:46,020 --> 00:35:50,940 a good citizen, not by ratcheting up expenses so that it 527 00:35:50,940 --> 00:35:54,580 can be a responsible corporation, because capitalism is 528 00:35:54,580 --> 00:35:59,550 highly dependent on increasing shareholder value and so forth. But 529 00:35:59,550 --> 00:36:03,750 within that, you know, obviously I spoke with an anarchist 530 00:36:03,750 --> 00:36:08,390 long time ago, Michael Albert, and Michael was talking about the 531 00:36:08,870 --> 00:36:11,790 environment as well. And he said, you know something, I'm an 532 00:36:11,790 --> 00:36:17,910 anarchist, but there's precisely 0.0% way that my anarchist 533 00:36:18,230 --> 00:36:23,310 ideas right now would make sense. We need a strong authority 534 00:36:23,310 --> 00:36:27,240 to be able to force the kind of changes that we need to make because 535 00:36:27,240 --> 00:36:31,360 we're no longer dealing with some far off distant disaster, we're 536 00:36:31,360 --> 00:36:35,000 dealing with a near and present danger. I'm curious, when 537 00:36:35,000 --> 00:36:38,640 you think of democracy and you think of capitalism and the rift 538 00:36:38,640 --> 00:36:42,600 there and the quote that I gave you from Rosa and throwing some 539 00:36:42,600 --> 00:36:45,720 of the Gramsci stuff, you know, on and on, help me understand 540 00:36:45,720 --> 00:36:49,960 because it seems like people keep going to the well put NAI voted 541 00:36:49,960 --> 00:36:52,800 sticker on their forehead, hoping for the best and we get the 542 00:36:52,800 --> 00:36:57,410 worst. What are your thoughts on democracy and capitalism and their 543 00:36:57,410 --> 00:37:00,530 relationship in terms of being able to make change? 544 00:37:01,650 --> 00:37:05,450 You can simply argue that the term capitalist democracy is a contradiction 545 00:37:05,450 --> 00:37:11,290 in terms. We live in a society where democracy is defined as once 546 00:37:11,290 --> 00:37:14,650 every four or five years, depending on which particular system 547 00:37:14,650 --> 00:37:20,560 you're under. You get to put a mark on a piece of paper that decides 548 00:37:20,560 --> 00:37:24,240 who makes the decisions, but then they don't even make the decisions. 549 00:37:24,400 --> 00:37:27,320 As you say, the studies that show that the decisions that are 550 00:37:27,320 --> 00:37:30,880 made in the US Congress have almost nothing to do with what the 551 00:37:30,880 --> 00:37:34,520 citizens of the United States actually want to do, the changes 552 00:37:34,520 --> 00:37:38,840 they actually want. And the range of democracy in our lives and 553 00:37:38,840 --> 00:37:42,600 our society is extraordinarily restricted. Now that doesn't mean 554 00:37:42,600 --> 00:37:46,150 we shouldn't take advantage of all the opportunities that do exist. 555 00:37:46,230 --> 00:37:49,630 If there are opportunities to actually make even some short term 556 00:37:49,630 --> 00:37:52,590 changes, I'm certainly not going to oppose them and I would 557 00:37:52,590 --> 00:37:55,910 support them. I think I live in a small town where not long ago 558 00:37:55,910 --> 00:37:59,870 there was a plan to put a pipeline through our town and we 559 00:37:59,870 --> 00:38:03,150 all organized and had big meetings and protests and we were 560 00:38:03,150 --> 00:38:06,590 able to stop it. Well, we didn't stop capitalism, but we did 561 00:38:06,590 --> 00:38:10,430 stop some damage being done that would have lasted a long time. 562 00:38:10,430 --> 00:38:13,350 So I think those are important things to do. We should not say, 563 00:38:14,080 --> 00:38:18,120 you know, it's the revolution or nothing. But I think we also have 564 00:38:18,120 --> 00:38:22,400 to recognize, I Mean, let me put it another way, a big part of 565 00:38:22,400 --> 00:38:25,680 winning the revolution is going to be building up to it. As 566 00:38:26,000 --> 00:38:28,960 another thing I've said from time to time is if we can't stop 567 00:38:28,960 --> 00:38:33,200 a pipeline or win higher wages, what on earth makes us think 568 00:38:33,200 --> 00:38:37,400 we can take over the society and change it completely? The movement 569 00:38:37,400 --> 00:38:40,880 that needs to be made is going to have to be built by everyday people 570 00:38:41,410 --> 00:38:45,170 and we are going to have to learn how to fight. There are historical 571 00:38:45,410 --> 00:38:49,570 examples in the United States, in Canada, where I live and so on, 572 00:38:49,730 --> 00:38:53,570 of people building such movements. So far we have not been 573 00:38:53,570 --> 00:38:57,049 successful. But the other thing from Gramsci is the famous 574 00:38:57,049 --> 00:39:01,010 line about, you know, pessimism of the intellect, optimism 575 00:39:01,010 --> 00:39:05,130 of the will. We know how hard it is and we know the chances that 576 00:39:05,130 --> 00:39:08,380 we will not win. But on the other hand, if we don't fight at 577 00:39:08,380 --> 00:39:10,220 all, we know for sure we're going to lose. 578 00:39:10,540 --> 00:39:13,300 You brought up something that I want to hit on really hard. You 579 00:39:13,300 --> 00:39:16,580 didn't sit there and say we stood in line at the ballot box for 580 00:39:16,580 --> 00:39:21,020 12 hours to vote. You said you got together and organized. You said 581 00:39:21,020 --> 00:39:24,860 that you protest. You did things that made it uncomfortable 582 00:39:24,860 --> 00:39:29,260 for them not to pay attention to you. I want to be clear that what 583 00:39:29,260 --> 00:39:32,100 you did and didn't say there. Can you elaborate on that? Because 584 00:39:32,100 --> 00:39:37,100 I don't think people realize that to claim any form of democracy 585 00:39:37,180 --> 00:39:40,820 is. It's not a spectator sport, but it's also not just an 586 00:39:40,820 --> 00:39:44,980 act of hitting the I voted sticker. There's a whole chasm of 587 00:39:44,980 --> 00:39:48,340 things. There's a difference, right? I mean, there's so much more 588 00:39:48,340 --> 00:39:49,340 to that conversation. 589 00:39:49,980 --> 00:39:54,380 Yes, well, you're right, of course. Again, back to my previous 590 00:39:54,380 --> 00:39:57,580 comment. If democracy is something you do once every four 591 00:39:57,580 --> 00:40:01,190 or five years, then it's not democracy at all. Our day to day 592 00:40:01,190 --> 00:40:05,990 existence is dominated by forces that we typically have no 593 00:40:05,990 --> 00:40:10,510 control over. You have zero control over most of the things that 594 00:40:10,510 --> 00:40:15,190 affect you. We tend to simply accept those. But the way we are 595 00:40:15,190 --> 00:40:19,070 going to change this world is I say by organizing and going back 596 00:40:19,070 --> 00:40:21,350 to what I was talking about with the pipeline in my town, the 597 00:40:21,350 --> 00:40:24,070 town I'm living in, is very conservative. I don't think it's 598 00:40:24,070 --> 00:40:28,160 even ever voted liberal. But the fact is that when people realized 599 00:40:28,160 --> 00:40:31,400 what was happening to their environment, we started getting meetings 600 00:40:31,400 --> 00:40:36,080 of 3 and 4 and 500 people and petitions and so on that ultimately 601 00:40:36,160 --> 00:40:41,800 won. And maintaining that kind of organization is a big part of 602 00:40:41,800 --> 00:40:45,360 our fight for a better world is building movements. They will 603 00:40:45,360 --> 00:40:49,480 rise and fall. But if we don't spend our time building people, giving 604 00:40:49,480 --> 00:40:53,880 people the confidence and the ability to fight, because we're basically 605 00:40:53,880 --> 00:40:57,270 told there's nothing you can do. You know, there is no alternative. 606 00:40:57,590 --> 00:41:00,510 It's the expression. It's easier to think of the end of the 607 00:41:00,510 --> 00:41:04,230 world than to imagine the end of capitalism for many people because 608 00:41:04,230 --> 00:41:08,710 we are completely dominated by this system. And the way we get around 609 00:41:08,710 --> 00:41:12,670 that is by changing people's actions, allowing people and engaging 610 00:41:12,670 --> 00:41:15,110 people in the actual fight for a better world. 611 00:41:15,510 --> 00:41:18,390 You know, one of the things that I want to bring up here, because 612 00:41:18,390 --> 00:41:23,510 I think this is key, right? We live in a society and we just covered 613 00:41:23,510 --> 00:41:27,230 this recently with some Project Censored friends that is 614 00:41:27,310 --> 00:41:31,870 heavily influenced by the tiniest of all tiny groups of people, 615 00:41:32,190 --> 00:41:38,350 the owners of media. The media voices are controlled. They have 616 00:41:38,510 --> 00:41:43,070 an agenda. And when you look at reality and you map it against 617 00:41:43,070 --> 00:41:49,610 what they say, it typically doesn't add up. And so the art of 618 00:41:49,610 --> 00:41:54,810 educating a public that has a vested interest, a personal vested 619 00:41:54,810 --> 00:42:00,050 interest in maintaining their own stability, their own personal, 620 00:42:01,010 --> 00:42:04,050 you know, the synapses that fire in their own brain and their 621 00:42:04,050 --> 00:42:10,010 ability to be okay in society is dramatically impacted by the way 622 00:42:10,010 --> 00:42:12,810 people view the world and the way they view themselves within that 623 00:42:12,810 --> 00:42:17,910 world. And when you alter the connecting points in that, it fundamentally 624 00:42:17,910 --> 00:42:22,350 destabilizes a person. And I think there's a tendency to fall 625 00:42:22,350 --> 00:42:26,910 backwards and to go into that. Either there is nothing we can do, 626 00:42:26,990 --> 00:42:30,830 or I'm just going to vote and go about my business because there's 627 00:42:30,830 --> 00:42:35,310 nothing I can do. Like it ends up being a form of nihilism. And 628 00:42:35,310 --> 00:42:40,070 I consider the acts between voting. I'm not a huge electoral 629 00:42:40,070 --> 00:42:43,750 guy. In fact, I don't believe that this system will allow us to 630 00:42:43,750 --> 00:42:47,840 make the kind of change that we need to do. But that said, I do 631 00:42:47,840 --> 00:42:51,920 believe in educating. I do believe in motivating and mobilizing 632 00:42:51,920 --> 00:42:56,920 and organizing. But I think that there becomes a question of 633 00:42:57,400 --> 00:43:01,720 am I organizing to do this thing and then I'm done, Or am I 634 00:43:01,720 --> 00:43:06,240 organizing for socialism? Do I want socialism? Am I going to bring 635 00:43:06,240 --> 00:43:11,720 about socialism? And some of the questions that you bring up in 636 00:43:11,720 --> 00:43:16,640 this, in the facts that you paint for us, the two are incompatible. 637 00:43:16,640 --> 00:43:22,720 Capitalism and a survivable planet are at odds with one another. 638 00:43:23,120 --> 00:43:26,520 So how do you do that within? You know, I'm a project manager by 639 00:43:26,520 --> 00:43:29,680 trade, so let me just throw that out there. So I live in timeline 640 00:43:29,680 --> 00:43:33,640 land. And so when I think about crashes on my schedule, I think 641 00:43:33,640 --> 00:43:37,720 about deadlines and stuff like that. I'm managing risk. I'm looking 642 00:43:37,720 --> 00:43:41,360 at what has to happen to make this thing happen within the timeframe 643 00:43:41,360 --> 00:43:45,250 we need it to happen in. And we're living with a ticking time 644 00:43:45,250 --> 00:43:50,490 bomb. So how do we balance that? I mean, the education, obviously 645 00:43:50,890 --> 00:43:54,490 organizing. You know, I'm a little bit of a vanguardist. I'm 646 00:43:54,490 --> 00:43:58,729 not gonna lie. I definitely find myself a Lenin supporter. How 647 00:43:58,729 --> 00:44:03,730 would you tell people? Because what I'm watching from, quote unquote, 648 00:44:03,730 --> 00:44:07,930 the official acceptable political parties is a bunch of hogwash. 649 00:44:07,930 --> 00:44:10,730 There's nothing about what we're talking about, not, not one 650 00:44:10,730 --> 00:44:13,850 bit of it is coming out through those official channels. 651 00:44:14,570 --> 00:44:19,170 So how do we educate? And obviously I'm not asking you to solve 652 00:44:19,170 --> 00:44:23,210 world hunger here, but I am asking you to make the case that, 653 00:44:23,210 --> 00:44:26,090 you know, people don't know they've been lied to, they've been 654 00:44:26,090 --> 00:44:30,170 propagandized, they've been, oh, it's just a scam. This greening 655 00:44:30,170 --> 00:44:34,490 thing is just another scam. Blah, blah, blah. How do we educate 656 00:44:34,490 --> 00:44:38,410 people and at the same time deal with the ticking time bomb that 657 00:44:38,410 --> 00:44:41,450 doesn't matter whether we agree with the facts or not, it's 658 00:44:41,450 --> 00:44:41,970 going to happen. 659 00:44:42,690 --> 00:44:47,930 Well, you know, I've been involved in socialist and activist 660 00:44:47,930 --> 00:44:53,690 politics for my entire life, you know, say 50, 60 years of this 661 00:44:53,690 --> 00:44:57,970 kind of thing. And if I had a magic answer for how we could break 662 00:44:57,970 --> 00:45:01,570 through, I would have dealt with it already. You know, I don't 663 00:45:01,570 --> 00:45:05,690 think anybody has a magic answer. The thing we have most going 664 00:45:05,690 --> 00:45:09,330 for us, and this will seem odd, but the thing that is mostly 665 00:45:09,330 --> 00:45:13,610 on our side ultimately is capitalism. The fact that the system 666 00:45:13,610 --> 00:45:19,610 that we are in is crisis prone, constantly recreates catastrophe, 667 00:45:20,010 --> 00:45:24,250 constantly generates opposition of all different kinds, 668 00:45:24,650 --> 00:45:30,730 again and again causes people to fight back, whether it's at a 669 00:45:30,730 --> 00:45:33,490 local level or national level. I mean, I'm currently watching in 670 00:45:33,490 --> 00:45:38,170 Bolivia where people are now basically blocking the streets, on 671 00:45:38,170 --> 00:45:41,290 strike en masse right now, fighting against the government. 672 00:45:41,850 --> 00:45:47,930 Those things do recur and the opportunities recur. And it's those 673 00:45:47,930 --> 00:45:51,610 kinds of things that I think will ultimately bring the system 674 00:45:51,690 --> 00:45:55,930 down, that the system itself will become unbearable. Now, within 675 00:45:55,930 --> 00:46:00,480 that context, however, it isn't just going to happen automatically. 676 00:46:00,950 --> 00:46:03,790 You know, the system gets awful and everybody rises up and 677 00:46:03,790 --> 00:46:06,750 says, yep, it's gone, or everybody votes for it or something 678 00:46:06,750 --> 00:46:11,750 like that. Within that context, as people become aware of 679 00:46:11,750 --> 00:46:15,510 how bad it is and you know, it's not surprising that most people 680 00:46:15,590 --> 00:46:19,830 don't right away and don't over time because people have to 681 00:46:19,830 --> 00:46:22,550 live their lives, people have to work, people have to raise their 682 00:46:22,550 --> 00:46:25,630 children, people have to eat. They have all those things, all those 683 00:46:25,630 --> 00:46:28,650 responsibilities, all those things you have to live with. And 684 00:46:28,650 --> 00:46:32,570 it is hard to be an active opponent of the system. It's hard 685 00:46:32,570 --> 00:46:36,690 work. So you don't tend to get large numbers in the short term. 686 00:46:36,850 --> 00:46:40,330 What we are doing, I think in this phase of the development of 687 00:46:40,330 --> 00:46:44,930 movements is basically bit by bit acquiring people like me, like 688 00:46:44,930 --> 00:46:48,410 you, like others who are starting to see what's going on and 689 00:46:48,410 --> 00:46:51,850 start organizing, start, first of all, trying to understand what's 690 00:46:51,850 --> 00:46:55,460 going on, sort of figuring out which subject, which particular struggles 691 00:46:55,460 --> 00:46:58,940 are right now going to lead us in positive directions and help people 692 00:46:58,940 --> 00:47:02,380 to understand what's going on, which struggles we can actually win 693 00:47:02,380 --> 00:47:06,420 right now, in which people will gain confidence that they don't 694 00:47:06,420 --> 00:47:09,780 have to accept the way things are. All of those things are part 695 00:47:09,780 --> 00:47:14,460 of it. But how it's going to ultimately lead to the complete transformation. 696 00:47:14,460 --> 00:47:17,940 I think all we can do is prepare to be ready for when the 697 00:47:17,940 --> 00:47:21,920 crisis occurs. Because the crises do occur, we know they occur 698 00:47:22,480 --> 00:47:26,520 again and again and again, and the power of capitalism makes it 699 00:47:26,520 --> 00:47:29,040 hard to fight, but it is defeatable. 700 00:47:29,520 --> 00:47:32,120 You know, it's funny you say that, I agree with you, by the way, 701 00:47:32,120 --> 00:47:35,520 but it's funny you say that because I oftentimes will say to 702 00:47:35,520 --> 00:47:38,800 people, we've got to do something other than what you think 703 00:47:38,800 --> 00:47:42,680 you're doing. If it's the acceptable pathway, if the capitalists 704 00:47:42,680 --> 00:47:46,800 have given you a microphone to scream in, you better check to see 705 00:47:46,800 --> 00:47:50,180 if it's plugged in. Really, at the end of the day, if you're going 706 00:47:50,180 --> 00:47:53,620 through the system that they've given you, the customer service 707 00:47:53,620 --> 00:47:56,860 line, so to speak, you're going to be waiting on hold for an 708 00:47:56,860 --> 00:48:02,580 awful long time. Okay? And what I think is important is that 709 00:48:02,900 --> 00:48:07,540 I don't need to have the answer necessarily to how we do everything. 710 00:48:07,540 --> 00:48:11,220 What I need to do is demonstrate to you this problem. 711 00:48:11,780 --> 00:48:16,810 We need to center and situate the problem so that people can really 712 00:48:16,810 --> 00:48:20,090 see it for what it is and understand the inputs, outputs, tools 713 00:48:20,090 --> 00:48:24,850 and techniques that are tied directly to the system so that they 714 00:48:24,850 --> 00:48:27,770 can begin to understand. Because right now you're right, you 715 00:48:27,770 --> 00:48:31,330 know, the end of history, right? Capitalism, this is what folks 716 00:48:31,890 --> 00:48:35,050 have come to believe in. You know, they've been brainwashed with 717 00:48:35,050 --> 00:48:39,130 a million forms of self hate, you know, for why they haven't succeeded, 718 00:48:39,130 --> 00:48:42,410 why they aren't the boss of all, why they haven't risen up and 719 00:48:42,410 --> 00:48:46,090 owned the mansion, all the other lies that capitalism has to 720 00:48:46,090 --> 00:48:50,130 feed us to keep us behaving like temporarily embarrassed millionaires 721 00:48:50,130 --> 00:48:53,810 right? Like this whole idea that we are going to suddenly become 722 00:48:54,210 --> 00:48:58,370 the Ayn Rand maker as opposed to the taker or whatever nonsense 723 00:48:58,370 --> 00:49:02,690 fills up what we call common sense. I think it's really important 724 00:49:02,690 --> 00:49:06,090 to understand that we have to wake these folks up. I mean, it is 725 00:49:06,090 --> 00:49:09,610 a part of a process that we have to do. It's not necessarily 726 00:49:09,610 --> 00:49:13,440 that we have all the answers, really. It pains me. Well, what's 727 00:49:13,440 --> 00:49:17,400 your solution, Steve? You know, what's your solution? And it's 728 00:49:17,400 --> 00:49:20,840 like, I get it, you think you got me there, right? It's like an 729 00:49:20,840 --> 00:49:24,200 alcoholic can't get sober until they agree that they have a 730 00:49:24,200 --> 00:49:27,640 problem and then they can work on a program of recovery. But you 731 00:49:27,640 --> 00:49:30,520 got to at least admit you got a problem. If you're not going to 732 00:49:30,520 --> 00:49:32,480 admit you got a problem, you're not going to solve the problem. 733 00:49:32,480 --> 00:49:35,680 You're not even going to try. And I guess this brings me to the 734 00:49:35,680 --> 00:49:39,160 end of your book. And I want to, you know, put a little bit of 735 00:49:39,160 --> 00:49:42,280 a positive framing on this. Even though I feel like we're in 736 00:49:42,280 --> 00:49:46,720 a really big doom spiral, given that I don't feel like we have 737 00:49:46,720 --> 00:49:49,920 the democratic controls that would allow us to do what we want 738 00:49:50,160 --> 00:49:54,200 short of revolution. I'm all about exercising muscles because 739 00:49:54,200 --> 00:49:57,680 we've lost them, we don't have them. And so we need to develop some 740 00:49:57,680 --> 00:50:01,720 muscles somewhere so that we get the strength to fight back. But 741 00:50:01,720 --> 00:50:05,930 you talk about what an eco socialist society would kind of look 742 00:50:05,930 --> 00:50:08,770 at and you know, I'm interested. I've always wondered 743 00:50:08,770 --> 00:50:11,930 this, because what I don't want to do is be the good liberal 744 00:50:11,930 --> 00:50:15,370 where I, like, take my recycling down the end of the street 745 00:50:15,370 --> 00:50:17,610 and feel like I've done a great thing or what. I don't want 746 00:50:17,610 --> 00:50:20,850 it to end there, you know, I mean, I don't. Well, I'm not shopping 747 00:50:20,850 --> 00:50:23,970 at Amazon, so I'm doing good things for the environment. I think 748 00:50:23,970 --> 00:50:28,650 that it's much deeper than that. Can you sketch out what democratic 749 00:50:28,650 --> 00:50:33,230 metabolism restoration would look like? It really kind of, you 750 00:50:33,230 --> 00:50:36,830 know, I am a central planning kind of guy for so many reasons, 751 00:50:36,830 --> 00:50:40,710 but I'm here to learn, so I'm not here to dictate. But I am curious, 752 00:50:40,790 --> 00:50:44,310 how do you make that happen? How do you create the decision making 753 00:50:44,310 --> 00:50:47,790 process? And what does that system look like in your democratic 754 00:50:47,790 --> 00:50:49,590 eco socialist society? 755 00:50:50,230 --> 00:50:53,110 Well, again, you know, Marx once said that he didn't want to 756 00:50:53,110 --> 00:50:58,410 write cookbooks for the chefs of the future. And one of the problems, 757 00:50:58,410 --> 00:51:01,930 of course, is of discussing this at all, is that we don't know 758 00:51:01,930 --> 00:51:04,970 what the conditions are going to be like, at the point of which 759 00:51:04,970 --> 00:51:08,810 we are in a position to do anything about it, to make the radical 760 00:51:08,810 --> 00:51:12,650 changes that need to be made. How much worse will global warming 761 00:51:12,650 --> 00:51:17,850 be before capitalism finally bites the bullet? How much will the 762 00:51:17,850 --> 00:51:22,210 oceans have risen? How badly polluted will the air be? How much 763 00:51:22,210 --> 00:51:26,010 of our resources and time is going to have to be devoted to. To 764 00:51:26,490 --> 00:51:31,370 restoring humane conditions or to curing diseases, or all of the 765 00:51:31,450 --> 00:51:35,290 dealing with all of the things that this system has left us. In 766 00:51:35,530 --> 00:51:39,570 the last chapter of my book, I talk about some of the measures that 767 00:51:39,570 --> 00:51:43,970 I think need to be taken by such a government. But, you know, 768 00:51:43,970 --> 00:51:47,210 assuming we can get a government either directly through 769 00:51:47,210 --> 00:51:51,250 elections or through a mass uprising that occurs and the justice 770 00:51:51,250 --> 00:51:55,120 had occurred in, you know, 1776, if people decide, no, we're 771 00:51:55,120 --> 00:51:57,480 going to be governed differently from now on. We are not 772 00:51:57,480 --> 00:52:00,480 going to be governed by King George. We are not going to be governed 773 00:52:00,480 --> 00:52:04,320 by the current crowd in Washington. We are going to be governing 774 00:52:04,320 --> 00:52:08,720 ourselves. And the book has a number of lists of possibilities 775 00:52:08,880 --> 00:52:11,640 that would be in there. I would think, for example, one of 776 00:52:11,640 --> 00:52:15,560 the very first things would be to decommodify the essentials of 777 00:52:15,560 --> 00:52:19,560 life. That is simply to establish as quickly as we can and 778 00:52:19,560 --> 00:52:22,740 that there will be issues around this, that things like food, 779 00:52:22,740 --> 00:52:26,900 clean water, sanitation, health care, housing, education, 780 00:52:27,060 --> 00:52:32,140 and so on are every human being by right. Those are not things 781 00:52:32,140 --> 00:52:34,820 that depend on your income. Those are not things that depend 782 00:52:34,820 --> 00:52:37,940 on your ability to pay for them. This society should simply 783 00:52:37,940 --> 00:52:43,180 provide those routinely that workplaces, our factories, our offices, 784 00:52:43,180 --> 00:52:46,340 wherever else should be controlled by the people who work 785 00:52:46,340 --> 00:52:49,100 in them. That people should be able to make decisions about how 786 00:52:49,100 --> 00:52:53,020 their lives are organized. For most of us, the time we spend in 787 00:52:53,020 --> 00:52:55,980 the factory or in the office is the biggest single part of our 788 00:52:55,980 --> 00:52:59,580 lives. But it's the time when in the current system, we are totally 789 00:52:59,580 --> 00:53:04,180 subject to a dictatorship in which we have absolutely zero input 790 00:53:04,420 --> 00:53:08,180 into what we do, how we do it, how we relate to the other workers 791 00:53:08,340 --> 00:53:11,060 and the other activities that are going on in the organization, 792 00:53:11,460 --> 00:53:14,660 the democratizing that structure is going to be utterly 793 00:53:14,660 --> 00:53:18,900 critical. Changing agriculture so that it focuses more on maintaining 794 00:53:18,900 --> 00:53:22,970 the soil, or we stop spending so much time in our farming systems 795 00:53:23,050 --> 00:53:26,650 producing things that aren't even human food. The single largest 796 00:53:26,650 --> 00:53:30,930 crop in the United States is corn, almost all of which goes either 797 00:53:30,930 --> 00:53:35,609 to feed livestock or to make ethanol. Very little of it ends up 798 00:53:35,609 --> 00:53:39,490 on human tables as food. Changing the structure of the food 799 00:53:39,490 --> 00:53:42,610 system is going to be a very big part of it. But all of those 800 00:53:42,610 --> 00:53:46,730 things are going to require taking profit out of the picture, 801 00:53:47,350 --> 00:53:50,310 establishing that the goal of the economy should be to meet human 802 00:53:50,310 --> 00:53:56,390 needs, not to maximize profit. In fact, profit should not be a significant 803 00:53:56,630 --> 00:54:00,710 factor at all. Obviously, we have to have control, but we can't 804 00:54:00,790 --> 00:54:04,510 simply leave it to the wishes of the people who make income from 805 00:54:04,510 --> 00:54:04,790 it. 806 00:54:05,270 --> 00:54:08,710 I want to take a moment to plug the kind of stuff that we talk 807 00:54:08,710 --> 00:54:12,350 about here as well. One of the things that stressed me out when 808 00:54:12,350 --> 00:54:18,050 I began my journey in Marx was that I come from a modern monetary 809 00:54:18,050 --> 00:54:21,610 theory background and understanding that the state is the 810 00:54:21,610 --> 00:54:27,730 creature that creates the currency. And being able to do these 811 00:54:27,730 --> 00:54:31,410 things, I started off very naively going, well, you know, we'll 812 00:54:31,410 --> 00:54:33,450 just vote for a few more progress and we'll have a Green New 813 00:54:33,450 --> 00:54:36,610 Deal. It'd be great, everything be kosher. But the fact 814 00:54:36,690 --> 00:54:41,370 is that the state itself can decommodify our existence. It can 815 00:54:41,370 --> 00:54:45,990 provide universal basic services. It can provide a job guarantee 816 00:54:45,990 --> 00:54:49,870 for everyone, and it can provide a job that is directly in 817 00:54:49,870 --> 00:54:54,790 service of the environment in terms of the community. It can provide 818 00:54:54,870 --> 00:54:59,230 jobs that people themselves create, that serve needs that are 819 00:54:59,230 --> 00:55:01,950 not considered profitable. Like what you were saying, hey, I'd 820 00:55:01,950 --> 00:55:05,190 be a terrible CEO because, you know, I'd want to do these great 821 00:55:05,190 --> 00:55:08,230 things. Well, you can do that with a job guarantee. So these were 822 00:55:08,230 --> 00:55:11,860 things that I really. That we positioned, we cared about, we put 823 00:55:11,860 --> 00:55:15,420 forward, and they're all still valuable. I still believe that you 824 00:55:15,420 --> 00:55:19,260 could provide universal basic services. You just can't get there 825 00:55:19,260 --> 00:55:23,180 because it flies in the face of what capitalism is and the system 826 00:55:23,180 --> 00:55:26,500 itself. And all you have to do is look at the revolving door, the 827 00:55:26,500 --> 00:55:30,820 enclosure, the capture that the capitalists have done to whatever 828 00:55:30,820 --> 00:55:32,980 government. And I don't believe it's something that just 829 00:55:32,980 --> 00:55:35,420 happened. I believe this is something that was baked in from 830 00:55:35,420 --> 00:55:39,520 the start that we're just maybe getting hip to, or maybe we 831 00:55:39,520 --> 00:55:43,240 had forgotten and now it's coming back in vogue. But the reality 832 00:55:43,240 --> 00:55:47,720 is, is that our government right now, today could, if it was 833 00:55:47,720 --> 00:55:51,640 not a capitalist government running capitalist affairs, could 834 00:55:51,640 --> 00:55:56,600 in fact make the decision to provide all those things to us as 835 00:55:56,600 --> 00:56:00,560 a public commons, as a good, as a right, as you called it. And 836 00:56:00,560 --> 00:56:04,850 I think for me, the real thing that radicalized me was realizing 837 00:56:04,850 --> 00:56:08,450 that it could do that, but it won't do that, and it isn't doing 838 00:56:08,450 --> 00:56:12,770 that. And people are afraid to ask for better because there's no 839 00:56:13,090 --> 00:56:20,050 pathway to getting what we ask for, to get into legislative reality 840 00:56:20,530 --> 00:56:23,810 through the systems that the capitalists have kind of paved out 841 00:56:23,810 --> 00:56:27,090 for us. I mean, I think it was Elizabeth Warren that came out and 842 00:56:27,090 --> 00:56:30,920 said I'm a capitalist to my bones. And of course we have Nancy 843 00:56:30,920 --> 00:56:34,600 Pelosi, the billionaire who sits there and, you know, trades 844 00:56:34,600 --> 00:56:38,400 and so forth. We are not represented in any way, shape or 845 00:56:38,400 --> 00:56:42,520 form by people that look for what the working class wants. They 846 00:56:42,520 --> 00:56:48,680 serve bourgeois society, they serve capital. And every single decision 847 00:56:49,000 --> 00:56:54,080 made, if there's any kind of crumbs that they throw our way, we 848 00:56:54,080 --> 00:56:57,200 celebrate like we won the Super Bowl. And the reality is, is 849 00:56:57,200 --> 00:57:01,520 that it's all within their power. He literally choose not to 850 00:57:01,520 --> 00:57:04,640 do it. And the worst part, and I think this is the part that really 851 00:57:04,640 --> 00:57:08,960 radicalized me the most, was I had always believed it was my quote 852 00:57:08,960 --> 00:57:12,160 unquote, hard earned tax dollars that were doing this stuff. 853 00:57:12,160 --> 00:57:16,560 When in reality they spend money into existence. So they not 854 00:57:16,560 --> 00:57:19,760 only give us the double whammy of making us feel guilty that we 855 00:57:19,760 --> 00:57:22,360 didn't vote hard enough, we didn't do whatever hard enough, we 856 00:57:22,360 --> 00:57:25,620 didn't phone bank hard enough, we didn't whatever, but then they 857 00:57:25,620 --> 00:57:28,940 turn around and they fund wars directly, not with our tax. They 858 00:57:28,940 --> 00:57:31,180 never, they don't even increase tax. They don't even pretend 859 00:57:31,180 --> 00:57:34,700 anymore we got to raise a war tax to pay for this war. No, they 860 00:57:34,700 --> 00:57:38,300 just do it. But then the minute you say, hey, what about Medicare 861 00:57:38,300 --> 00:57:41,300 for or what about, you know, a universal health care? What about, 862 00:57:41,540 --> 00:57:45,300 you know, child this or that, they're like, oh, we just, we don't 863 00:57:45,300 --> 00:57:47,620 have the money, we're broke. Where are we going to find the money 864 00:57:47,620 --> 00:57:51,680 for that? How are you going to pay for that, Steve? So this kind 865 00:57:51,680 --> 00:57:55,920 of dance that we do, this fake dance where we pretend like the nation's 866 00:57:55,920 --> 00:57:59,880 drowning in debt, right? I mean, it's like it's a ruse. That 867 00:57:59,960 --> 00:58:04,400 part of the hegemonic nature, the austerity narrative folks like 868 00:58:04,400 --> 00:58:08,680 Clara Matei talk to very eloquently. I think it's really important 869 00:58:08,760 --> 00:58:12,520 to understand that it is possible, but it's not in their class 870 00:58:12,520 --> 00:58:16,360 interest to do this. Your final thoughts take us out. 871 00:58:17,260 --> 00:58:20,500 Right. Well, back on your discussion. When you say our government 872 00:58:20,500 --> 00:58:23,420 could do things, I think the problem is that it's not our government, 873 00:58:23,500 --> 00:58:28,140 it's their government. And that's an utterly critical part of 874 00:58:28,140 --> 00:58:33,060 this. It is not us that decides to have a war budget of a 875 00:58:33,060 --> 00:58:36,540 trillion dollars a year. I mean an insane amount that it's spent 876 00:58:36,700 --> 00:58:41,740 on bombing people on the other side of the world into the stone 877 00:58:41,740 --> 00:58:46,580 age. The wealth of this society is extraordinarily large 878 00:58:46,900 --> 00:58:51,100 and we certainly could restore the earth. And in fact, I start and 879 00:58:51,100 --> 00:58:55,460 end the book with a poem by James Connolly, a great Irish socialist 880 00:58:55,700 --> 00:59:00,260 who says he wrote this back about 1900 or thereabouts. And let 881 00:59:00,260 --> 00:59:04,420 me just finish by reading this very short poem that he wrote. He 882 00:59:04,420 --> 00:59:09,060 said, some men faint hearted ever seek, are programmed to retouch 883 00:59:09,900 --> 00:59:15,500 and will insist whenever they speak that we demand too much. Tis 884 00:59:15,500 --> 00:59:21,020 passing strange, yet I declare such statements give me mirth for 885 00:59:21,020 --> 00:59:26,980 our demands most moderate are we only want the earth. And that 886 00:59:26,980 --> 00:59:27,820 is what we want. 887 00:59:28,620 --> 00:59:33,860 Wow, that is powerful, man. I really appreciate that. Hey, Ian, 888 00:59:33,860 --> 00:59:37,450 I want to thank you so much for. For joining me today. This was 889 00:59:37,450 --> 00:59:41,290 a pleasure. I mean, it was kind of a random selection out there 890 00:59:41,290 --> 00:59:44,130 on Substack. I want to be honest. I mean, I feel bad that I 891 00:59:44,130 --> 00:59:46,850 had not heard of you, but I'm glad that I have heard of you and 892 00:59:46,850 --> 00:59:50,410 I'm glad I reached out and I'm glad you said yes and I'm glad I 893 00:59:50,410 --> 00:59:53,650 got your book. It's really good. It's powerful. It fits into 894 00:59:53,650 --> 00:59:57,370 the work that we're trying to do here. Where can we find more of 895 00:59:57,370 --> 00:59:59,810 your work? Obviously on Substack, but where else? 896 01:00:00,450 --> 01:00:04,210 Well, I maintain the Climate and Capitalism, which is climate 897 01:00:04,210 --> 01:00:09,330 and capitalism.com just the words. I have been writing there 898 01:00:09,330 --> 01:00:13,570 and publishing other people's material there for 20 years. So I 899 01:00:13,570 --> 01:00:17,690 would you certainly refer you to that. I've also written about 900 01:00:17,690 --> 01:00:22,210 half a dozen books on subjects related to this. My latest one, as 901 01:00:22,210 --> 01:00:25,330 you've said, is called Metabolic Rifts. I had one come out 902 01:00:25,330 --> 01:00:28,690 two years ago called the War against the Commons, which is about 903 01:00:28,690 --> 01:00:32,650 capitalism's taking away of land from the people who produce. 904 01:00:33,320 --> 01:00:37,160 And possibly the book that has had the most circulation is my book 905 01:00:37,160 --> 01:00:39,400 Facing the Anthropocene and that you talked at the beginning. 906 01:00:39,400 --> 01:00:42,480 So certainly if people want to find what my views on things, those 907 01:00:42,480 --> 01:00:46,160 books are readily available from any. Any bookstore can order 908 01:00:46,160 --> 01:00:48,360 them for you if they don't have them in stock and they're available 909 01:00:48,440 --> 01:00:51,440 from most of the online bookstores or you can go directly 910 01:00:51,440 --> 01:00:54,480 to my publisher, Monthly Review Press, their website, that 911 01:00:54,480 --> 01:00:58,440 you can buy the books there. But I would say my substack, certainly. 912 01:00:58,440 --> 01:01:01,440 But I would say climateandcapitalism.com is the main 913 01:01:01,440 --> 01:01:03,310 place that people can learn about. 914 01:01:03,310 --> 01:01:07,110 What I have to think that's fantastic. And I just want to say 915 01:01:07,110 --> 01:01:10,430 you are very accessible, you are very flexible and I appreciate 916 01:01:10,750 --> 01:01:14,190 you just doing this. So with that, I hope we can have you back 917 01:01:14,190 --> 01:01:18,510 again sometime soon. Just so you know, every Tuesday night We 918 01:01:18,510 --> 01:01:23,390 do a webinar for that week's podcast and we sit down, we break 919 01:01:23,390 --> 01:01:27,110 it down into 15 minute increments and we have a little mini 920 01:01:27,110 --> 01:01:30,630 video that shows the words that go across and they've got caricatures 921 01:01:30,630 --> 01:01:35,390 of myself and the speaker and we put some funny little emojis and 922 01:01:35,390 --> 01:01:39,030 things in there, GIFs and things to help keep people's interest 923 01:01:39,110 --> 01:01:42,670 alive. But we break it down to 15 minute increments and we talk 924 01:01:42,670 --> 01:01:45,830 about it, we discuss it. And when this comes out, it would be 925 01:01:45,830 --> 01:01:49,710 an honor to have you. If your schedule allows you to join us, it's 926 01:01:49,710 --> 01:01:53,870 8pm Eastern Standard Time on Tuesday nights. And again, this will 927 01:01:53,870 --> 01:01:57,150 probably come out in a couple weeks, so I can let you know offline 928 01:01:57,150 --> 01:01:58,550 when it occasionally is if you're available. 929 01:01:59,460 --> 01:02:01,060 Thanks very much. I will do my best. 930 01:02:01,620 --> 01:02:03,940 Absolutely. All right, well, I'm going to go ahead and take us 931 01:02:03,940 --> 01:02:07,340 out. First of all, let me thank my guest, Ian Angus, who we've 932 01:02:07,340 --> 01:02:12,700 just been talking about his book which is called Metabolic Capitalism's 933 01:02:12,700 --> 01:02:17,300 Assault on the Earth System. And you know, folks, this is Real 934 01:02:17,300 --> 01:02:21,460 Progressives. This is podcast Macro and Cheese is a part of Real 935 01:02:21,460 --> 01:02:26,990 progressives, which is a 501C3. We live and die on your contributions. 936 01:02:27,150 --> 01:02:31,110 There is absolutely no billionaire sitting there throwing 937 01:02:31,110 --> 01:02:35,470 money at us. We are scratching and clawing. So if you consider what 938 01:02:35,470 --> 01:02:39,110 we're doing worthwhile, please consider becoming a monthly donor. 939 01:02:39,110 --> 01:02:43,670 You can go to patreon.com RealProgressives Become a monthly 940 01:02:43,670 --> 01:02:47,470 donor there. You can go to our substack Real Progressives and become 941 01:02:47,470 --> 01:02:51,550 a monthly donor. Or you can go to our website realprogressives.org 942 01:02:52,190 --> 01:02:55,950 and become a monthly donor or a one time donor there. All donations 943 01:02:56,030 --> 01:03:00,870 are helpful and if you have the bug, we are also a volunteer 944 01:03:00,870 --> 01:03:04,990 driven organization so we could always use help with producing 945 01:03:04,990 --> 01:03:09,150 the work that we do here. And so with that, on behalf of my guests, 946 01:03:09,150 --> 01:03:13,390 Ian Angus, myself, Steve Grumbine for the podcast Macro and 947 01:03:13,390 --> 01:03:16,110 Cheese, we are outta here. 948 01:03:24,760 --> 01:03:28,320 Production transcripts, graphics, sound engineering, extras 949 01:03:28,320 --> 01:03:31,600 and show notes for macroencies are done by our volunteer team at 950 01:03:31,600 --> 01:03:35,120 Real Progressives, serving. In solidarity with the working class 951 01:03:35,120 --> 01:03:41,320 since 2015. To become a donor, please go to patreon.com realprogressives 952 01:03:41,720 --> 01:03:46,020 realprogressives substack.com or realprogressives.org.