1 00:00:00,560 --> 00:00:04,240 Election season and every party is fighting for your vote. 2 00:00:04,320 --> 00:00:07,520 And no surprise, the main way they're trying to do it is through 3 00:00:07,520 --> 00:00:12,440 your wallet. So many of us do not feel financially secure, let 4 00:00:12,440 --> 00:00:15,959 alone comfortable. So the parties are lining up to convince 5 00:00:15,959 --> 00:00:20,080 you they've got the fix. Top of the list is your Kiwisaver, which 6 00:00:20,080 --> 00:00:22,880 everyone seems to have thoughts about, and a wish list to 7 00:00:22,880 --> 00:00:27,910 change. But there's also the cost of living, your food, your job. 8 00:00:28,390 --> 00:00:32,510 Paying attention to all of this, Bernard Hickey. These days 9 00:00:32,510 --> 00:00:36,430 he's a journalist with his own independent outlet, the Kaka. But 10 00:00:36,430 --> 00:00:40,110 he's been following these issues for literally decades, and 11 00:00:40,110 --> 00:00:42,470 it's pretty hard to pull the wool over his eyes. 12 00:00:42,470 --> 00:00:45,670 Well, of course Kiwisavers should be compulsory. And of course 13 00:00:45,670 --> 00:00:48,990 we should put more into it. Really? Are you going to starve the 14 00:00:48,990 --> 00:00:51,980 economy of all the cash that currently goes into it, buy food 15 00:00:51,980 --> 00:00:52,700 and other things? 16 00:00:53,180 --> 00:00:56,860 Because pretty words from politicians are one thing, but will 17 00:00:56,860 --> 00:01:00,140 any of this actually help those of us in the real world? 18 00:01:00,460 --> 00:01:04,460 So it's tough to trust either of the major parties here. New Zealand 19 00:01:04,460 --> 00:01:07,900 can feed 40 million people, but we have a million people having 20 00:01:07,900 --> 00:01:10,140 to go to food banks. Something's wrong. 21 00:01:10,140 --> 00:01:13,660 And if we actually plan ahead for the future, what's the big change 22 00:01:13,980 --> 00:01:15,780 that could really move the needle? 23 00:01:15,780 --> 00:01:19,480 Kiwisavers should not be allowed to invest overseas. We're 24 00:01:19,480 --> 00:01:22,760 not going to get rich unless we invest in Aotearoa. 25 00:01:22,760 --> 00:01:27,000 And when so many of these issues are driven by big global international 26 00:01:27,240 --> 00:01:31,000 events, is there anything we can even do from here in little old 27 00:01:31,000 --> 00:01:31,640 New Zealand? 28 00:01:31,960 --> 00:01:35,560 This is something that people don't talk about in public because 29 00:01:35,560 --> 00:01:36,840 it's quite frightening. 30 00:01:36,920 --> 00:01:39,720 So welcome to Making Sense. It's the podcast for people who want 31 00:01:39,720 --> 00:01:43,040 financial freedom without giving up their coffee. I'm Frances 32 00:01:43,040 --> 00:01:46,480 Cook, financial journalist and fellow financial freedom seeker who 33 00:01:46,480 --> 00:01:50,160 makes money simple for you today, whether this election will 34 00:01:50,160 --> 00:01:53,760 change your Kiwisaver and your money. This episode of Making Sense 35 00:01:53,760 --> 00:01:57,360 is supported by Odoo, the All in one solution to make running your 36 00:01:57,360 --> 00:02:01,480 business smoother and more affordable. Go to odoo.com that's 37 00:02:01,480 --> 00:02:06,960 odd.com for more. I want to help as many people as possible build 38 00:02:06,960 --> 00:02:10,520 a better life for themselves by understanding and taking control 39 00:02:10,520 --> 00:02:13,840 of their money. You can be part of how that happens. First, 40 00:02:14,000 --> 00:02:16,880 make sure you're subscribed, wherever you like to listen, whether 41 00:02:16,880 --> 00:02:21,680 it's YouTube, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. And then send your favorite 42 00:02:21,680 --> 00:02:24,560 episode to a mate. Then we can all level up with money together. 43 00:02:24,560 --> 00:02:28,280 The show grows and I can keep bringing you the Money info that 44 00:02:28,280 --> 00:02:32,280 actually moves the dial. Welcome Bernard. Thank you so much 45 00:02:32,280 --> 00:02:37,520 for coming in. Look, politics season and the election is looming 46 00:02:38,000 --> 00:02:42,540 and cost of living money kiwisavers, certainly all of these 47 00:02:42,540 --> 00:02:46,700 things seem to be really looming large this election season. 48 00:02:47,180 --> 00:02:50,260 What's standing out for you as you're looking at the landscape and 49 00:02:50,260 --> 00:02:51,180 what's being chatted about? 50 00:02:51,420 --> 00:02:54,660 It's amazing really. I mean I've spent the last 30, 40 years 51 00:02:54,660 --> 00:02:58,700 of my life being a finance and economics nerd, but this election 52 00:02:58,940 --> 00:03:02,900 is going to be about two or three key things. Firstly, cost of 53 00:03:02,900 --> 00:03:06,840 living, that's a very broad topic, but it all about what the 54 00:03:06,840 --> 00:03:10,480 Reserve bank is doing with the official cash rate and mortgages 55 00:03:11,200 --> 00:03:14,600 or on the other side of the equation, term deposits. It's going 56 00:03:14,600 --> 00:03:17,480 to be all about what's happening with fuel prices. So that's 57 00:03:17,480 --> 00:03:22,120 a story about geopolitics. It's going to be all about the groceries 58 00:03:22,120 --> 00:03:26,320 market and the electricity market. Market design, structural 59 00:03:26,320 --> 00:03:32,370 separation, nationalization, all sorts of sort of amazing things 60 00:03:32,450 --> 00:03:37,650 that, you know, us, you know, competition economist, geeky people 61 00:03:37,650 --> 00:03:41,730 would go, whoa. And now we have all major parties coming up 62 00:03:41,730 --> 00:03:48,050 with substantial policies and a lot of conflict, a lot of debate 63 00:03:48,050 --> 00:03:52,450 about, you know, are you a communist or are you a capitalist? 64 00:03:52,770 --> 00:03:57,090 What does it mean to be a socialist? Why is it that New Zealand's 65 00:03:57,860 --> 00:04:01,460 spends more on food as a share of income than just about any other 66 00:04:01,460 --> 00:04:06,500 country in the world? What went wrong over the years with how 67 00:04:06,500 --> 00:04:12,100 our supermarkets have gone or our banks or our insurers or our 68 00:04:12,100 --> 00:04:16,180 electricity markets? We've just gone through a brutal winter 69 00:04:16,180 --> 00:04:23,300 of discontent when electricity prices went up 9% three times faster 70 00:04:24,070 --> 00:04:27,830 than the top of the Reserve Bank's inflation target zone. Why? 71 00:04:28,230 --> 00:04:31,070 Well, nothing to do with fuel prices because we didn't actually 72 00:04:31,070 --> 00:04:37,350 burn much gas or diesel through the year. This was actually 73 00:04:37,590 --> 00:04:41,870 because interest rates went up and the Commerce Commission forced 74 00:04:41,870 --> 00:04:46,310 through higher prices for electricity distributors and the 75 00:04:46,310 --> 00:04:49,910 government owned, mostly government owned electricity industry 76 00:04:50,640 --> 00:04:54,600 loves lots of dividends. So you know, we're going to have an 77 00:04:54,600 --> 00:04:58,880 election where these quite high minded, I think important issues 78 00:04:59,040 --> 00:05:06,679 around how we save, how our markets are run, what is a properly 79 00:05:06,679 --> 00:05:10,920 competitive market, what's happening with the Iranian Revolutionary 80 00:05:10,920 --> 00:05:14,040 Guard Corps. All of these things which normally wouldn't be 81 00:05:14,040 --> 00:05:16,850 part of election campaign are right at the heart of it and there 82 00:05:16,850 --> 00:05:19,730 is a real contest of ideas and solutions. 83 00:05:20,770 --> 00:05:23,970 Yeah, and I'm finding it fascinating that all of these things 84 00:05:23,970 --> 00:05:26,690 are actually, as you say, being picked up by multiple parties. 85 00:05:26,850 --> 00:05:31,930 These are the hot button issues and it's fascinating, as you 86 00:05:31,930 --> 00:05:35,370 say, I Want to jump into Kiwisaver soon, but you started mentioning 87 00:05:35,370 --> 00:05:37,890 about the supermarkets, so we're just going to dig on that too 88 00:05:38,050 --> 00:05:42,530 because as you say, we are paying a lot for our food. And I'm 89 00:05:42,530 --> 00:05:44,210 getting a lot of people messaging me, a lot of people in 90 00:05:44,210 --> 00:05:48,400 my DMs, a lot of people in my inbox saying food is insane and I 91 00:05:48,400 --> 00:05:51,800 can't stop feeding my kids, but I don't know how I can keep paying 92 00:05:51,800 --> 00:05:57,120 for this. And yet we are a huge food producing nation. What's 93 00:05:57,120 --> 00:05:58,560 going on? What do you think is going on? 94 00:05:58,720 --> 00:06:03,200 Well, we've bought into this idea that New Zealand is a truly 95 00:06:04,480 --> 00:06:09,240 flexible, transparent part of the global economy. We don't have 96 00:06:09,240 --> 00:06:14,000 controls on exports or imports, we don't have tariffs. We 97 00:06:14,000 --> 00:06:16,920 bet on our future, on the idea that we can grow food and export 98 00:06:16,920 --> 00:06:22,920 it for high prices. And when you have a problem like New Zealand 99 00:06:22,920 --> 00:06:26,360 can feed 40 million people, but we have a million people having 100 00:06:26,360 --> 00:06:30,440 to go to food banks, something's wrong. And what's wrong 101 00:06:30,440 --> 00:06:36,840 is that we thought that a globalized economy with apparently 102 00:06:36,840 --> 00:06:41,270 free and transparent pricing based off supply and demand would 103 00:06:41,270 --> 00:06:48,230 work to feed everyone. And in theory it should. But when you have 104 00:06:48,470 --> 00:06:55,390 extraordinary climate issues plus geopolitical issues, and they're 105 00:06:55,390 --> 00:07:00,710 often quite connected, that is pushing up the price of hard things, 106 00:07:00,710 --> 00:07:07,960 real things, commodities. Copper, oil, cobalt, fertilizer, 107 00:07:08,200 --> 00:07:12,680 beef. You know my favorite joke at the moment, and I should 108 00:07:12,680 --> 00:07:17,080 stick to not being a comedian, is that mince is the new cheese. 109 00:07:17,080 --> 00:07:21,600 You know, it's incredibly expensive. Why? Because of climate 110 00:07:21,600 --> 00:07:26,200 change in the United States, which has reduced the size of America's 111 00:07:26,440 --> 00:07:30,160 beef herd. A whole bunch of the Midwest hasn't had a lot of water 112 00:07:30,160 --> 00:07:34,900 lately, so those cows aren't there. And all of those burger chains 113 00:07:34,900 --> 00:07:38,580 in America want ground mince. Where do they get it from? Well, 114 00:07:39,060 --> 00:07:43,220 America has stopped importing it from Brazil and a bunch of other 115 00:07:43,220 --> 00:07:46,380 places. They're still importing from New Zealand. And we're 116 00:07:46,380 --> 00:07:51,260 able to charge a high price because we are selling protein and 117 00:07:51,260 --> 00:07:54,820 beef is at the top of the protein chain. When you have immense 118 00:07:54,820 --> 00:07:58,340 pressures on food costs because of climate change and rising 119 00:07:58,340 --> 00:08:02,790 energy costs, you know that flows through. Now to change that, 120 00:08:02,950 --> 00:08:07,070 we would have to intervene in our economy to make sure that some 121 00:08:07,070 --> 00:08:11,670 farms only produce food for New Zealanders. And then we'd have 122 00:08:11,670 --> 00:08:15,509 to somehow subsidize those farms so that they weren't worse 123 00:08:15,509 --> 00:08:17,670 off because they weren't selling to the rest of the world. 124 00:08:17,910 --> 00:08:21,910 Now these are these seems like completely wild communistic things 125 00:08:21,910 --> 00:08:26,200 to think, but up until 1984, that's how new Zealand did it. You 126 00:08:26,200 --> 00:08:29,480 know, we subsidized dairy farmers and sheep farmers and beef 127 00:08:29,480 --> 00:08:34,120 farmers to ensure partly at least, that New Zealanders could 128 00:08:34,360 --> 00:08:39,800 buy food at a reasonable price and that those farmers could cope 129 00:08:39,800 --> 00:08:42,800 through the ups and downs of commodity prices. Now, at the moment, 130 00:08:42,800 --> 00:08:46,400 commodity prices are going ever higher, and that's great for 131 00:08:46,400 --> 00:08:50,600 farmers, or at least for the banks who are receiving repayments 132 00:08:50,600 --> 00:08:54,930 of debt, which those farmers have got, but for consumers it's 133 00:08:54,930 --> 00:09:00,490 not. And that's one layer of extra cost on top of the highest 134 00:09:00,810 --> 00:09:04,290 profit margins in supermarkets in the developed world. And this 135 00:09:04,290 --> 00:09:08,010 has crept up on us over the years in part because of mergers 136 00:09:08,010 --> 00:09:10,290 and takeovers that were blocked when perhaps they should 137 00:09:10,290 --> 00:09:16,010 have been. The one we think of Countdown, which became Woolworth's 138 00:09:16,010 --> 00:09:21,480 buying a thing called foodtown back in 2006. Six, seven. That takeover 139 00:09:22,280 --> 00:09:24,760 is one of many that have happened over the last 20 years, 140 00:09:24,760 --> 00:09:28,640 which, bit like the boiling frog we've suddenly discovered, actually 141 00:09:28,640 --> 00:09:32,400 gave market dominance to one or two players. And we're now in 142 00:09:32,400 --> 00:09:37,560 a position where consumers are paying more, workers are getting 143 00:09:37,560 --> 00:09:41,520 less, and the owners of capital and the profit share is getting 144 00:09:41,520 --> 00:09:47,080 higher. So all of those things combined has essentially made consumers, 145 00:09:47,080 --> 00:09:52,270 particularly workers who do pay tax. And it's really all come 146 00:09:52,270 --> 00:09:57,270 to a head at once, and people are rightly asking the question, 147 00:09:57,990 --> 00:10:01,470 all those usual assumptions and rules, and this is the way it 148 00:10:01,470 --> 00:10:04,710 should happen, and this is the way it's normal we're going. Well, 149 00:10:04,710 --> 00:10:06,710 actually, it doesn't seem to have worked for a lot of people, 150 00:10:06,790 --> 00:10:09,590 so maybe we should do it differently. And that's part of what 151 00:10:09,590 --> 00:10:10,950 the selection campaign's about. 152 00:10:11,190 --> 00:10:16,240 A lot of the talk has been about do we need to split up the 153 00:10:16,240 --> 00:10:19,680 supermarkets? And you mentioned there that the mergers 154 00:10:20,160 --> 00:10:23,960 are a huge part of the initial problem. So is splitting them up 155 00:10:23,960 --> 00:10:24,560 the right call? 156 00:10:24,560 --> 00:10:28,120 Then how you split them up is almost important as the question 157 00:10:28,120 --> 00:10:32,720 of do you split them or not? And it's worth looking back to one 158 00:10:32,720 --> 00:10:36,720 example that actually worked in terms of intervening in a market 159 00:10:36,720 --> 00:10:41,930 to split up a dominant player or duopoly, and creating the conditions 160 00:10:41,930 --> 00:10:46,570 for a third player, which then led to significant more competition 161 00:10:46,570 --> 00:10:50,570 and better results for consumers. Lower prices, better services, 162 00:10:50,970 --> 00:10:55,450 better quality. And that's telecommunications. In 2005, the 163 00:10:55,450 --> 00:10:59,930 then labor government forced the breakup of telecom into Chorus 164 00:10:59,930 --> 00:11:04,290 and Sparc, and then making sure that a third player in mobile, 165 00:11:04,290 --> 00:11:09,390 which became 2 degrees, got access to some mobile spectrum at 166 00:11:09,390 --> 00:11:12,550 a reasonable price. We then had real competition between three 167 00:11:12,550 --> 00:11:17,230 players. The addition of government intervention with the 168 00:11:17,470 --> 00:11:22,150 Ultra fast broadband network has helped as well to create some 169 00:11:22,150 --> 00:11:26,990 of the best, lowest priced, best quality broadband in the world. 170 00:11:27,310 --> 00:11:31,270 Again with mobile, New Zealand is in a pretty good place compared 171 00:11:31,270 --> 00:11:34,810 to the rest of the world. Whereas in 2005, 6 it wasn't. So 172 00:11:34,810 --> 00:11:39,050 that's the model. You break up a dominant player into at least two 173 00:11:39,050 --> 00:11:42,570 parts and you encourage a third competitor to come in to really 174 00:11:42,570 --> 00:11:46,290 keep the bastards honest if you like. And in New Zealand we have 175 00:11:46,290 --> 00:11:51,890 the duopoly of bootstuffs and Woolworths. The idea that you could 176 00:11:51,890 --> 00:11:57,290 just break up that duopoly and this is the national proposal Woolworths 177 00:11:57,290 --> 00:12:01,540 left on its own and that somehow you could break up the ownership 178 00:12:01,540 --> 00:12:04,980 and the cooperative buying arrangements that currently tie together 179 00:12:05,300 --> 00:12:10,420 Pack and Save, New World and Foursquare and that would be enough 180 00:12:10,660 --> 00:12:16,819 to create competition. I'd challenge that because they are still 181 00:12:17,540 --> 00:12:22,620 acting together in a buying cooperative which is using its market 182 00:12:22,620 --> 00:12:28,260 power to push down the returns for supplies. Also that doesn't remove 183 00:12:28,260 --> 00:12:32,540 the regional and local monopolies that for example Pack 184 00:12:32,540 --> 00:12:38,900 Save and New World have and doesn't ensure that the Foursquare 185 00:12:39,140 --> 00:12:43,860 and New World stores compete against Pack Save when for decades 186 00:12:43,860 --> 00:12:47,900 they've been working as a team. And you really only get proper 187 00:12:47,900 --> 00:12:53,710 competition when you get someone new of scale come in to compete 188 00:12:53,710 --> 00:13:01,070 away those monopoly profits. Now the labor proposal is for a telecom 189 00:13:01,070 --> 00:13:04,790 style structural separation, creating a wholesale group that is 190 00:13:04,790 --> 00:13:08,150 different from the retail group at the moment. There's a real 191 00:13:08,150 --> 00:13:10,990 intertwining of those ownership and those connections. 192 00:13:12,030 --> 00:13:17,600 Pack and Save store operators often buy off their own bet because 193 00:13:17,600 --> 00:13:20,880 they're big enough to do it. An individual store they might do 194 00:13:20,880 --> 00:13:25,360 some stuff with the buying cooperative of foodstuffs. Sometimes 195 00:13:25,360 --> 00:13:29,920 they might not. It's hard. And you know there's been lots of attempts 196 00:13:29,920 --> 00:13:32,800 to wag fingers at the industry. That hasn't worked. And 197 00:13:32,800 --> 00:13:38,720 also there's the Green proposal which is to literally nationalize 198 00:13:38,720 --> 00:13:42,960 or buy 120 stores and distribution centers off the two 199 00:13:42,960 --> 00:13:47,920 chains and create Kiwi Mart a new state owned competitor. So all 200 00:13:47,920 --> 00:13:51,400 three of those options, in old times that would have been all seen 201 00:13:51,400 --> 00:13:54,720 as radical, you know, that it would all be called communists. But 202 00:13:54,720 --> 00:13:59,879 now nationals decision to go hard or at least say they're going 203 00:13:59,879 --> 00:14:03,680 to go hard because remember they won't do anything until the 204 00:14:03,680 --> 00:14:07,360 Kunis Commission has done a formal review and then it goes through 205 00:14:07,360 --> 00:14:11,600 parliament and actors said they'll block it. And then labor 206 00:14:11,600 --> 00:14:15,640 also has, remember being here before, they were on the verge of 207 00:14:15,720 --> 00:14:21,920 some sort of Split up in 2022, 3, but got spooked when the supermarket 208 00:14:21,920 --> 00:14:24,840 said, ah, if there's another Covid outbreak, you know who's going 209 00:14:24,840 --> 00:14:28,120 to save you then? So it's tough to trust either of the major 210 00:14:28,120 --> 00:14:31,320 parties here. And you're absolutely right. It's at the heart 211 00:14:31,320 --> 00:14:37,760 of everything. Everyone needs to eat and sometimes we can't afford 212 00:14:37,760 --> 00:14:38,080 it. 213 00:14:38,400 --> 00:14:41,320 Yeah, well, I look at these issues and I'm like, people are feeling 214 00:14:41,320 --> 00:14:44,400 the crunch now. They're certainly also feeling the crunch 215 00:14:44,400 --> 00:14:48,800 in terms of being able to make any sort of future planning as well, 216 00:14:49,120 --> 00:14:53,840 which is people just seem to be squeezed on all fronts on these 217 00:14:53,840 --> 00:14:58,080 very core issues. I want to run through some of the Kiwisaver 218 00:14:58,080 --> 00:15:02,480 policies as well, because now this is going to be not all of the 219 00:15:02,480 --> 00:15:04,840 things they've talked about, but a quick run through. So labor 220 00:15:04,840 --> 00:15:08,130 saying changes including compulsory employer contributions 221 00:15:08,130 --> 00:15:11,890 at 6% and banning total remuneration. Meanwhile, national 222 00:15:12,450 --> 00:15:15,890 saying they would want changes including making Kiwisaver compulsory, 223 00:15:16,130 --> 00:15:19,450 automatically enroll every baby born in New Zealand, as well 224 00:15:19,450 --> 00:15:22,410 as a little baby boost payment, fifteen hundred dollars 225 00:15:22,410 --> 00:15:25,410 on that and making contribution into Parents Kiwisaver 226 00:15:25,410 --> 00:15:28,450 when they're on paid parental leave. New Zealand first was actually 227 00:15:28,450 --> 00:15:31,170 the first off the blocks on the KiwiSaver election promises, 228 00:15:31,830 --> 00:15:35,390 saying they wanted to increase employee and employer contributions 229 00:15:35,390 --> 00:15:39,070 to 10%, make KiwiSaver compulsory and a similar baby bonus 230 00:15:39,070 --> 00:15:43,110 policy, but of $1,000 instead. If anyone can follow all of those 231 00:15:43,110 --> 00:15:45,990 and keep them in their heads, well done to them, but just sort 232 00:15:45,990 --> 00:15:49,390 of giving an idea of where we're at with the areas being discussed 233 00:15:49,390 --> 00:15:53,150 here. I find it fascinating that everyone is getting into this 234 00:15:53,150 --> 00:15:56,550 as well. Do you think they're the right areas to be debating? 235 00:15:57,360 --> 00:16:02,920 It's certainly worth using Kiwisaver as one of the tools to 236 00:16:02,920 --> 00:16:08,960 solve our problems, but I think it's worth pulling apart, unfortunately, 237 00:16:08,960 --> 00:16:12,640 the complicated strands of this debate and looking at each one 238 00:16:12,640 --> 00:16:15,160 of them. Before you do that, though, I think it's worth sort of 239 00:16:15,160 --> 00:16:18,400 pulling back and understanding the context of Kiwisaver and the 240 00:16:18,400 --> 00:16:22,320 debates we're having right now. And whenever we do this, the 241 00:16:22,960 --> 00:16:26,720 elephant in the room is the Australian superannuation system. 242 00:16:27,600 --> 00:16:32,440 And the way I look at this is in the early 1990s, New Zealand had 243 00:16:32,440 --> 00:16:36,880 a sliding door moment. We could have gone down one route or 244 00:16:36,880 --> 00:16:42,240 another route. We went down the route of not subsidizing pensions 245 00:16:42,640 --> 00:16:45,920 and the view was we were going to have a very simple tax system 246 00:16:46,640 --> 00:16:50,470 and we'd of course tax capital gains to make it properly comprehensive. 247 00:16:50,470 --> 00:16:53,870 We never got round to the capital gains thing and we left off 248 00:16:53,950 --> 00:16:59,230 the incentives for people to save into a pension scheme. Australia, 249 00:17:00,270 --> 00:17:04,430 through some interesting accidents of political history, decided 250 00:17:04,430 --> 00:17:09,230 in the early 1990s under a labor government that to solve a 251 00:17:09,230 --> 00:17:12,070 particular problem they had right then, which was they were worried 252 00:17:12,070 --> 00:17:17,129 about rising wages, causing inflation and causing interest rates 253 00:17:17,129 --> 00:17:22,929 to go up. And so a deal was done between Paul Keating and the 254 00:17:22,929 --> 00:17:25,969 labor movement in Australia, which is much stronger and more aggressive, 255 00:17:25,969 --> 00:17:30,689 in which Keating said, I'll get you a pay increase, but it's 256 00:17:30,689 --> 00:17:33,009 not going to be a normal sort of pay increase. It's actually going 257 00:17:33,009 --> 00:17:38,369 to be money put into a compulsory pension system and we'll 258 00:17:38,369 --> 00:17:43,400 over time increase that share of your income and the share of your 259 00:17:43,400 --> 00:17:49,000 income being contributed by your employers up to more than 10%. 260 00:17:49,880 --> 00:17:53,520 And the workers who are on the verge of having strikes and going 261 00:17:53,520 --> 00:17:56,800 for big pay increases in the early 90s, said, okay, that's fair 262 00:17:56,800 --> 00:18:01,000 enough. That avoided an inflationary spiral in Australia 263 00:18:01,000 --> 00:18:04,920 and now Australia has the third largest pool of pension savings 264 00:18:04,920 --> 00:18:10,700 in the world. And it helped fund their investment and development 265 00:18:11,020 --> 00:18:16,220 over the last 20 years and for most of that period essentially powered 266 00:18:16,620 --> 00:18:20,180 Australia's productivity growth and therefore its real wages 267 00:18:20,180 --> 00:18:23,260 growth, which has now led to a situation where New Zealand, which 268 00:18:23,260 --> 00:18:28,140 didn't have that pension scheme, has wages 30% below Australian 269 00:18:28,300 --> 00:18:33,260 wages and is driving this constant leakage we have of people 270 00:18:33,760 --> 00:18:37,520 across the Tasman. So that's the, I think, the background before 271 00:18:37,520 --> 00:18:40,080 we even think about this. Essentially New Zealand's going, 272 00:18:40,080 --> 00:18:42,880 oh no, we should have got ourselves an Australian style scheme. 273 00:18:42,880 --> 00:18:46,280 How can we turn Kiwisaver into an Australian style scheme? Worth 274 00:18:46,280 --> 00:18:49,320 remembering that there's no way the Australians could have gotten 275 00:18:49,320 --> 00:18:53,120 that scheme across the line in the early 90s unless that offered 276 00:18:53,200 --> 00:18:58,480 an incentive for people to save. In Australia you contribute 277 00:18:58,480 --> 00:19:01,080 money to your compulsory pension scheme and you don't pay 278 00:19:01,080 --> 00:19:05,310 tax on it. Kiwisaver, you pay the tax first and then you put whatever's 279 00:19:05,310 --> 00:19:09,630 left over into the scheme. There's no incentive. So national 280 00:19:09,790 --> 00:19:14,510 and labor are both now talking about compulsion without compensation. 281 00:19:14,990 --> 00:19:20,710 It's a tax and it's a tax into a savings scheme, most of which will 282 00:19:20,710 --> 00:19:26,150 be invested overseas. More than 60% of KiwiSaver funds are overseas. 283 00:19:26,150 --> 00:19:33,500 If we go to 12% and 12% of New Zealand's after tax income is put 284 00:19:33,500 --> 00:19:38,820 into a scheme which is not spent on stuff and services in New 285 00:19:38,820 --> 00:19:42,900 Zealand, which is not circulating in the economy, 40% of 286 00:19:42,900 --> 00:19:48,380 it might go into New Zealand investments, but most of it will 287 00:19:48,380 --> 00:19:54,840 go into data centers in America. Bomb manufacturers in Europe 288 00:19:54,840 --> 00:20:00,320 and America will go into government bonds in America, helping 289 00:20:00,320 --> 00:20:06,320 Donald Trump to fund his wars and tax cuts. And that's a whole 290 00:20:06,320 --> 00:20:08,360 bunch of money that's not going to be invested in New Zealand. 291 00:20:08,360 --> 00:20:12,320 Now, some would say, okay, we just need to build up the pile of 292 00:20:12,320 --> 00:20:15,520 money to a high enough level and then eventually we'll get invested 293 00:20:15,520 --> 00:20:20,040 in New Zealand. But ultimately that'll never be more than 10, 20% 294 00:20:20,040 --> 00:20:24,340 of it. And essentially it's taking choices away from New Zealanders 295 00:20:24,660 --> 00:20:29,380 to put money into their own businesses. And this is an interesting 296 00:20:29,380 --> 00:20:33,700 problem which no one's really challenged the main parties on. Hang 297 00:20:33,700 --> 00:20:36,779 on a minute, you're making this compulsory. What's in it for 298 00:20:36,779 --> 00:20:40,060 us? Why are we being forced to do this? There is no incentive. We 299 00:20:40,060 --> 00:20:43,260 are paying tax before it goes in. While it's in there, it's paying 300 00:20:43,260 --> 00:20:48,110 tax, and it's only when it comes out that it's not taxed. Whereas 301 00:20:48,110 --> 00:20:52,190 in other countries, often there's no tax paid on the income 302 00:20:52,190 --> 00:20:56,030 before it goes in. Sometimes there are funds where there's no 303 00:20:56,030 --> 00:20:59,470 tax paid while it's in. And one of the most interesting sort 304 00:20:59,470 --> 00:21:04,230 of accidents of our savings history of the last 20 years is that 305 00:21:04,230 --> 00:21:07,070 one of the biggest sources of taxation revenue for the government 306 00:21:07,070 --> 00:21:13,330 now is tax from the New Zealand Super Fund and from Kiwisaver. 307 00:21:13,480 --> 00:21:17,640 In fact, for most of the last couple of years, New Zealand super 308 00:21:18,040 --> 00:21:21,720 pays tax to the government, which is greater than the contributions 309 00:21:21,720 --> 00:21:26,040 the government's making to the Super Fund. So, you know, if you're 310 00:21:26,040 --> 00:21:29,599 really serious about building up those investment funds and, you 311 00:21:29,599 --> 00:21:33,120 know, encouraging people to save, you would give that thing a 312 00:21:33,120 --> 00:21:37,480 tax break. Particularly when you're not, you're still giving a 313 00:21:37,480 --> 00:21:40,770 big tax break for people to put money into leveraged residential 314 00:21:40,770 --> 00:21:44,490 property. And that's the other thing about Kiwisaver that I challenge. 315 00:21:45,210 --> 00:21:48,210 We built this thing up and it's presented as this, you know, 316 00:21:48,210 --> 00:21:51,650 amazing investment scheme that puts money into real assets and, 317 00:21:51,650 --> 00:21:55,090 you know, and. And luckily for New Zealanders, there hasn't been 318 00:21:55,090 --> 00:21:57,610 a complete wipeout. So there's a generation of New Zealanders who 319 00:21:57,610 --> 00:22:00,170 love Kiwisaver. They look at their accounts every day and go, 320 00:22:00,170 --> 00:22:03,410 oh, I'm rich, I'm richer and richer. The other thing they're doing, 321 00:22:03,410 --> 00:22:06,910 though, is looking at that Kiwisaver encounters and going, oh, 322 00:22:06,910 --> 00:22:10,430 my first home deposit just got bigger. One of the drawbacks of Kiwisa 323 00:22:10,430 --> 00:22:13,790 that I think, is that it's one of the tools that is pumping up house 324 00:22:13,790 --> 00:22:18,990 prices. It's a drug in a way, that we need to kick at least partially 325 00:22:19,790 --> 00:22:24,950 and we need to challenge the assumption that of course it should 326 00:22:24,950 --> 00:22:28,230 be compulsory just like the Australians. Well the Australians 327 00:22:28,230 --> 00:22:30,350 don't mind paying into that thing because they get a tax break 328 00:22:30,350 --> 00:22:34,310 to go into it and they do have a capital gains tax now and it's 329 00:22:34,310 --> 00:22:37,830 a proper one on their rental property. Investors too national 330 00:22:37,830 --> 00:22:42,630 is not planning a capital gains tax, labor is. And I think 331 00:22:42,790 --> 00:22:49,270 that this debate on Kiwisaver needs to be a lot more robust and 332 00:22:49,270 --> 00:22:52,430 challenging of the underlying assumptions we have about. Well of 333 00:22:52,430 --> 00:22:55,550 course Kiwisaver should be compulsory and of course we should 334 00:22:55,550 --> 00:22:59,070 put more into it really. Are you going to starve the economy of 335 00:22:59,070 --> 00:23:01,950 all the cash that currently goes into it to buy food and other 336 00:23:01,950 --> 00:23:07,110 things? Are you going to pump it up so that people can leverage 337 00:23:07,110 --> 00:23:10,590 yet more money into the residential property market? Are 338 00:23:10,590 --> 00:23:14,790 you going to leave in place the current wild advantage for residential 339 00:23:14,790 --> 00:23:20,710 property versus investment in funds? And in a world where just 340 00:23:20,710 --> 00:23:24,380 everyone puts everything into an exchange traded fund and you know, 341 00:23:24,380 --> 00:23:30,500 simply because it costs point, not one basis points to manage, why 342 00:23:30,500 --> 00:23:34,820 on earth would anyone put money into a proper New Zealand investment, 343 00:23:34,980 --> 00:23:39,140 a listed equity or even a private equity? We're talking cost 344 00:23:39,140 --> 00:23:43,060 management funds management costs of you know, 100, 200, 300 345 00:23:43,060 --> 00:23:50,510 basis points. You know, eventually pension funds where consumers 346 00:23:50,510 --> 00:23:53,670 are in charge. In fact even the professionals when, even when 347 00:23:53,670 --> 00:23:57,470 they're in charge they just go, I just dump it in the s and P500, 348 00:23:58,590 --> 00:24:02,470 that's three basis points brilliant and I can see why. But 349 00:24:02,470 --> 00:24:07,070 that's not a way to any sort of national glory or development 350 00:24:07,070 --> 00:24:13,390 of our economy because that's not how the globalized free movements 351 00:24:13,390 --> 00:24:18,280 of capital people, trade services works. And that's the debate 352 00:24:18,280 --> 00:24:20,840 everyone's having at the moment is should we allow that to 353 00:24:20,840 --> 00:24:22,800 continue because it hasn't really worked for most people. 354 00:24:22,800 --> 00:24:26,240 Well, yeah, it's an interesting time because I feel like 355 00:24:26,240 --> 00:24:30,200 there is a real movement building for making some sort of 356 00:24:30,200 --> 00:24:33,600 change to Kiwisaver. Right. We're coming up on 20 years of having 357 00:24:33,600 --> 00:24:37,520 it. We've got a new retirement commissioner, we've got an election 358 00:24:37,840 --> 00:24:41,160 coming. The previous retirement commissioner on her way 359 00:24:41,160 --> 00:24:46,340 out the door said I don't think that Kiwisaver is very equitable 360 00:24:46,340 --> 00:24:49,740 right now, but also we need to be careful about making too many 361 00:24:49,740 --> 00:24:53,100 changes to it because people lose confidence in what it can be. 362 00:24:53,340 --> 00:24:58,299 Some very good salient points there. So what do you think when 363 00:24:58,299 --> 00:25:01,180 you look at this debate that we're having now? Obviously you're 364 00:25:01,180 --> 00:25:04,660 not loving the direction of the debate currently, but if you 365 00:25:04,660 --> 00:25:08,900 were put in charge Just for a day. And you could make one big change 366 00:25:08,900 --> 00:25:12,180 to KiwiSaver. What do you think would move the dial the most 367 00:25:12,180 --> 00:25:14,020 to make this scheme better? 368 00:25:16,020 --> 00:25:21,940 Stop it from being a slush fund for first Home deposits. Ooh. 369 00:25:22,020 --> 00:25:24,700 First home buyers are going to get their backs up. Yeah. 370 00:25:24,700 --> 00:25:28,100 But house prices would fall, which would make housing more affordable. 371 00:25:29,540 --> 00:25:34,270 Secondly, it would allow those funds to build up faster and bigger 372 00:25:34,430 --> 00:25:37,510 because at the moment a lot of people are taking that money out 373 00:25:37,510 --> 00:25:42,070 in their early to mid-30s and that money, if it was left in, would 374 00:25:42,070 --> 00:25:47,350 be worth an enormous amount more by the time we get to 65. I 375 00:25:47,350 --> 00:25:52,350 would also look to provide some sort of tax incentive for people 376 00:25:52,350 --> 00:25:56,230 to put more money into KiwiSaver. And if you are going to 377 00:25:56,230 --> 00:26:01,240 make it compulsory. Yes. Make sure that you, you don't have these 378 00:26:01,560 --> 00:26:06,200 horrible total remuneration deals that happen at the moment and 379 00:26:06,360 --> 00:26:13,680 that employers should make compulsory contributions. And one 380 00:26:13,680 --> 00:26:19,120 way to make it more fiscally acceptable for the government is 381 00:26:19,120 --> 00:26:23,640 to ensure that there's at least some sort of subsidy, particularly 382 00:26:23,640 --> 00:26:27,320 for the consumer and for self employed people, to put money into 383 00:26:27,400 --> 00:26:34,920 KiwiSaver. I also think that Kiwisavers should not be allowed 384 00:26:34,920 --> 00:26:35,960 to invest overseas. 385 00:26:36,520 --> 00:26:37,560 Not be allowed at all. 386 00:26:37,640 --> 00:26:42,840 No, go on. Because that money should go into New Zealand investments, 387 00:26:43,320 --> 00:26:48,440 infrastructure, people skills, technology, businesses to grow our 388 00:26:48,440 --> 00:26:52,510 wealth here and our skills and our productivity. At the moment we're 389 00:26:52,510 --> 00:26:56,150 investing in other people's economies to make them more productive 390 00:26:56,230 --> 00:26:59,750 and wealthier and have higher wages. We're not investing in our 391 00:26:59,750 --> 00:27:03,350 own. And it's a lot of money. You know, we're up to whatever it 392 00:27:03,350 --> 00:27:10,430 is. $140 billion or so for KiwiSaver now and 80 billion of that 393 00:27:10,430 --> 00:27:13,470 went overseas. Ultimately we're not going to get rich unless 394 00:27:13,470 --> 00:27:18,400 we invest in Aotearoa. It means it's people, it's infrastructure, 395 00:27:18,400 --> 00:27:21,680 it's technology, it's businesses. And I think if you're 396 00:27:21,680 --> 00:27:27,280 going to reform KiwiSaver or make it compulsory, provide incentives 397 00:27:27,280 --> 00:27:30,640 for it, you need to do it as part of a wider tax reform, which 398 00:27:30,640 --> 00:27:34,200 means that we have a much more level playing field for investments. 399 00:27:34,200 --> 00:27:37,840 At the moment. There's a big thumb on the scales in favor of residential 400 00:27:37,840 --> 00:27:41,280 property investment. That's always the way because you can leverage 401 00:27:41,280 --> 00:27:46,100 it and because it's still tax free, particularly on the family 402 00:27:46,100 --> 00:27:52,420 home. My view is that the rise in the value of land for the family 403 00:27:52,420 --> 00:27:56,580 home should be taxed. Neither of the main parties are saying that 404 00:27:56,580 --> 00:27:58,460 the family home should be taxed. 405 00:27:58,620 --> 00:28:02,660 They're terrified of it. It's Basically referred to as the third 406 00:28:02,660 --> 00:28:03,740 rail of politics. Right? 407 00:28:03,740 --> 00:28:07,580 Yeah. Because so many New Zealanders have bet their financial 408 00:28:07,660 --> 00:28:10,820 lives and the financial lives of their families on it and they 409 00:28:10,820 --> 00:28:16,250 think the age of 55, 60, 65, I don't have time to go back and do 410 00:28:16,250 --> 00:28:20,690 it the other way because I'm not old enough and I'm probably going 411 00:28:20,690 --> 00:28:24,650 to stop working at some point or can't work at some point. So if 412 00:28:24,650 --> 00:28:27,369 you're going to do that, you have to think about how to either 413 00:28:27,369 --> 00:28:31,170 compensate in my view. I don't think those people require compensation 414 00:28:31,330 --> 00:28:35,050 because they made out like bandits for 30 years. Many of those 415 00:28:35,050 --> 00:28:40,940 people have made leveraged tax free returns of 300, 400% on the 416 00:28:40,940 --> 00:28:43,900 money they've invested in their family home and other homes 417 00:28:44,700 --> 00:28:49,140 and they're perfectly fine. The real problem is for people who 418 00:28:49,140 --> 00:28:53,340 don't own a home when they retire or don't own a home full stop 419 00:28:53,500 --> 00:28:57,100 throughout their working lives, they're paying tax, income 420 00:28:57,100 --> 00:29:02,980 tax, gst. People who've put all their money into leveraged residential 421 00:29:02,980 --> 00:29:06,960 land are not paying taxes tax and they've had that benefit for 422 00:29:06,960 --> 00:29:11,000 30 or 40 years. Okay, sure, the value of their land might fall 423 00:29:11,000 --> 00:29:16,200 if there is some sort of tax on it and that expectation of future 424 00:29:16,600 --> 00:29:19,640 leveraged spectacular gains may be gone and they may have to 425 00:29:19,640 --> 00:29:23,000 think about something different. But unless we change the 426 00:29:23,160 --> 00:29:28,320 fundamental incentives in our economy around investing and focus 427 00:29:28,320 --> 00:29:32,450 a lot more on on investing in great infrastructure, companies, 428 00:29:32,690 --> 00:29:38,370 people, technology, businesses, science, research, we're 429 00:29:38,370 --> 00:29:41,010 not going to get rich and we're going to stay poor and we're 430 00:29:41,010 --> 00:29:45,649 going to keep exporting our kids and our grandkids and having 431 00:29:45,649 --> 00:29:51,850 to import lots of brand new people who we work for barely minimum 432 00:29:51,850 --> 00:29:55,450 wage and or exploit and then kick out after three years. That's 433 00:29:55,450 --> 00:29:58,180 not a way to run an economy or a society. 434 00:29:59,300 --> 00:30:03,020 This episode of Making Sense is supported by Odoo because they're 435 00:30:03,020 --> 00:30:06,460 all about making business smarter, easier to manage and more 436 00:30:06,460 --> 00:30:10,180 affordable. Odoo is a software platform that gives you access to 437 00:30:10,180 --> 00:30:14,420 over 70 apps to help you manage your website, accounting, 438 00:30:14,420 --> 00:30:19,100 invoicing, sales, inventory and way more. But instead of Death 439 00:30:19,100 --> 00:30:22,890 by a thousand Cuts where you pay for all of those apps individually, 440 00:30:23,130 --> 00:30:28,170 it's just one affordable subscription which starts from $34.40 441 00:30:28,170 --> 00:30:32,890 Aussie dollars per user per month. It's not just about the cost 442 00:30:32,970 --> 00:30:37,130 either. It's having all of those apps in one integrated dashboard 443 00:30:37,130 --> 00:30:41,010 to make your business or side hustle possible. Let your software 444 00:30:41,010 --> 00:30:45,570 work for you so you can handle the important stuff. Try Odoo for 445 00:30:45,570 --> 00:30:50,820 free for 15 days, no card details required. That's o-o.com 446 00:30:50,900 --> 00:30:54,500 for more. If this episode is your kind of thing, you'll want to 447 00:30:54,500 --> 00:30:57,940 check out the Market Memo too. It's my weekly newsletter where I 448 00:30:57,940 --> 00:31:01,980 break down how to actually invest. All plain English chat about 449 00:31:01,980 --> 00:31:05,460 how the share market really works and how you can get it working 450 00:31:05,700 --> 00:31:09,180 for you. It's everything I wish I'd had when I was starting 451 00:31:09,180 --> 00:31:15,110 out. Head to franciscook Co nz slash Invest. Also pop that link 452 00:31:15,110 --> 00:31:19,550 into the show notes for you. Right back to it. So if we were going 453 00:31:19,550 --> 00:31:24,430 to, I mean, ideally, I guess, in your plan using kiwisaver funds, 454 00:31:24,430 --> 00:31:28,190 but you know, look at this investment into New Zealand in general. 455 00:31:28,670 --> 00:31:32,390 Try and get incomes up, try and boost our economy. What would 456 00:31:32,390 --> 00:31:34,830 be the big areas that you think, you know? Are there certain 457 00:31:34,910 --> 00:31:38,510 parts of New Zealand that are ripe for investment that we really 458 00:31:38,510 --> 00:31:40,860 good, good at? What could be those hot areas? 459 00:31:41,420 --> 00:31:47,540 We need to build lots of affordable, warm, dry homes that 460 00:31:47,540 --> 00:31:51,020 work with cheap public transport. And we essentially need 461 00:31:51,020 --> 00:31:57,020 to build lots of really fantastic cities full of buses and 462 00:31:57,020 --> 00:32:03,140 trains and bikeways and apartments and townhouses where maybe 463 00:32:03,140 --> 00:32:06,300 we don't have such big houses, maybe we don't have garages, maybe 464 00:32:06,300 --> 00:32:09,180 we only have a couple of bedrooms, but at least it's insulated 465 00:32:09,180 --> 00:32:12,940 and it's warm and dry and it's a short walk to our work or our school 466 00:32:12,940 --> 00:32:16,940 or our university. It's going to be much cheaper to live in those 467 00:32:16,940 --> 00:32:22,100 homes and get around our cities and they're much healthier, 468 00:32:22,500 --> 00:32:26,460 more productive places. We know that intense, closely developed 469 00:32:26,460 --> 00:32:30,220 cities are the way to grow productivity. In an economy there 470 00:32:30,220 --> 00:32:33,790 is an agglomeration effect, we know that. Yet New Zealand has sort 471 00:32:33,790 --> 00:32:39,590 of built itself in this suburban, provincial image that this 472 00:32:39,590 --> 00:32:42,830 is what we actually want. We want to live with our own section, 473 00:32:43,070 --> 00:32:48,150 near a beach, by ourselves, with a double cab ute and another 474 00:32:48,150 --> 00:32:51,990 car and then a batch and it'll be brilliant. Yeah, well, that doesn't 475 00:32:51,990 --> 00:32:55,070 make for a rich country. It also means there's a whole bunch 476 00:32:55,070 --> 00:32:57,710 of people who don't benefit from that. In fact, they're doing 477 00:32:58,310 --> 00:33:02,470 really tough. And so that's what I invest in. Because that will 478 00:33:02,470 --> 00:33:07,590 make us richer and happier and healthier and forces us to think 479 00:33:08,390 --> 00:33:12,070 differently about what success looks like. Because at the moment 480 00:33:12,070 --> 00:33:16,390 what we think success look like is selling a house for 10 times 481 00:33:16,390 --> 00:33:22,790 more than we bought it and using the unearned, untaxed capital 482 00:33:22,790 --> 00:33:27,130 gains to get rich and make sure that our kids are rich, which 483 00:33:27,130 --> 00:33:30,930 is fine, you know, but you can't have an economy where everyone 484 00:33:30,930 --> 00:33:37,130 aspires to be a landlord and is a landlord, otherwise we'd all 485 00:33:37,130 --> 00:33:40,490 be landlords and there'd be no tenants, which doesn't work. Of course. 486 00:33:41,130 --> 00:33:44,730 You've touched a bit on sort of intergenerational issues and I 487 00:33:44,730 --> 00:33:47,530 want to lean on that a bit more because I do think, I mean, 488 00:33:47,850 --> 00:33:50,730 I was talking to you a bit off mic about this that I was watching 489 00:33:50,730 --> 00:33:53,790 one of the official cash rate announcements and and I saw you going 490 00:33:53,790 --> 00:33:56,910 quite hard on the youth unemployment stats that were contained 491 00:33:56,910 --> 00:33:59,910 in there and I thought, thank goodness someone else pushing hard 492 00:33:59,910 --> 00:34:03,630 on this and raising this stat. That is really looking scary. The 493 00:34:03,630 --> 00:34:07,790 youth unemployment has shot right up. I find it quite a concerning 494 00:34:07,790 --> 00:34:10,870 canary in the coal mine. If we don't have opportunities for young 495 00:34:10,870 --> 00:34:13,990 people, of course they'll leave. But also what's going to happen 496 00:34:13,990 --> 00:34:16,990 to the economy long term? You know, people need to get their foot 497 00:34:16,990 --> 00:34:21,490 in the jaw on highly skilled jobs. What do you see on the youth 498 00:34:21,490 --> 00:34:24,050 unemployment stats and what do you think's driving it? 499 00:34:24,290 --> 00:34:29,250 We've got a generation who graduated into the workforce around 500 00:34:30,290 --> 00:34:34,570 20, 20 and onwards. You know, anyone who was in school at the age 501 00:34:34,570 --> 00:34:39,410 of 12 or 13 and it was tough during COVID those two Covid years, 502 00:34:39,970 --> 00:34:45,130 their education was damaged. They then graduated into a very tough, 503 00:34:45,200 --> 00:34:49,080 tumultuous labor market. At times it was very tight and everyone 504 00:34:49,080 --> 00:34:52,680 could get jobs and wages were rising. But that didn't last for 505 00:34:52,680 --> 00:35:00,040 that long. And often it's an unfortunate but true fact of economies 506 00:35:00,040 --> 00:35:03,080 that go up and down is that when they go down and unemployment 507 00:35:03,080 --> 00:35:07,560 is high, the unfortunate generation who are graduating at 508 00:35:07,560 --> 00:35:11,240 that time are the ones that get scarred for the rest of their 509 00:35:11,240 --> 00:35:14,820 lives. They're scarred. You know, it's a really ugly thing to 510 00:35:14,820 --> 00:35:19,780 essentially have a lottery in which when you are born and when 511 00:35:19,780 --> 00:35:24,540 you graduate into the workforce determines your outcome 512 00:35:24,620 --> 00:35:28,540 or at least part of your outcome. Because we allow economies 513 00:35:28,619 --> 00:35:35,180 to run cold, we allow our economies to have a margin of unemployment, 514 00:35:35,180 --> 00:35:37,620 which we think is a good thing. I actually don't think we 515 00:35:37,620 --> 00:35:40,150 should have any unemployment employment and that we should run 516 00:35:40,150 --> 00:35:43,230 our economies at full employment and that should be our 517 00:35:43,230 --> 00:35:48,070 priority. The moment we have a priority which is all about inflation. 518 00:35:48,230 --> 00:35:52,510 So we have a single target. Keep inflation between 1 and 3% and 519 00:35:52,510 --> 00:35:56,470 effectively use increased unemployment to slow down your economy 520 00:35:56,790 --> 00:36:01,150 to take heat out of it. We have 5.6% unemployment overall. We 521 00:36:01,150 --> 00:36:05,070 have underutilization rates. So that's unemployment. Plus I'd 522 00:36:05,070 --> 00:36:09,360 like to more work or I need more work or more jobs combined for 523 00:36:09,360 --> 00:36:13,320 that for youth, underutilization is well into the 524 00:36:13,320 --> 00:36:19,120 double digits in some parts of the country. 30, 40, 50%. We should 525 00:36:19,120 --> 00:36:22,040 do better than that. The way we're running our economy at the 526 00:36:22,040 --> 00:36:25,760 moment is we're saying everything should be sacrificed for 527 00:36:25,760 --> 00:36:29,080 this target of getting inflation down between 1 and 3%. 528 00:36:29,400 --> 00:36:33,610 I get it. High inflation is bad. The problem is we have a Reserve 529 00:36:33,610 --> 00:36:38,410 bank and a government which has sliced responsibility for low 530 00:36:38,410 --> 00:36:42,570 inflation up. Between Reserve bank totally responsible for getting 531 00:36:42,570 --> 00:36:45,690 inflation down, the government not responsible at all. And what 532 00:36:45,690 --> 00:36:49,130 that unfortunately means is that the government can do things 533 00:36:49,770 --> 00:36:53,810 which actually deliberately increase inflation, and the Reserve 534 00:36:53,810 --> 00:36:57,540 bank have to react to that by making more people unemployed. We 535 00:36:57,540 --> 00:37:00,820 have an inflation problem right now which is largely caused 536 00:37:00,820 --> 00:37:05,380 by, wait for it, Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps and Donald 537 00:37:05,380 --> 00:37:10,300 Trump. So we have young people who are unemployed and who are being 538 00:37:10,300 --> 00:37:16,100 more and more unemployed, paying a price for the bad decisions, 539 00:37:16,100 --> 00:37:20,340 let's say, of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps and their 540 00:37:20,340 --> 00:37:24,020 allies and Donald Trump, because that's what's caused this 541 00:37:24,420 --> 00:37:28,380 jump in fuel prices. And we have the people who can least afford 542 00:37:28,380 --> 00:37:33,060 to pay the price of beating inflation having to pay the price. 543 00:37:33,780 --> 00:37:37,020 We're also taking actions which will not change, which will 544 00:37:37,020 --> 00:37:40,499 not get rid of that inflation. The Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps 545 00:37:40,499 --> 00:37:43,180 are not waiting on the actions of the Reserve Bank Governor of New 546 00:37:43,180 --> 00:37:45,220 Zealand or any other Reserve bank governor. They're going to do 547 00:37:45,220 --> 00:37:48,740 their thing. Donald Trump doesn't give a toss. So the idea 548 00:37:48,740 --> 00:37:53,770 that we should use the Reserve bank and monetary policy to attack 549 00:37:53,770 --> 00:37:57,370 inflation when the tools you're using are not solving that 550 00:37:57,370 --> 00:38:00,650 problem and are actually punishing those who can least afford 551 00:38:00,650 --> 00:38:04,330 it the most. I think it's worth debating how we run our economy. 552 00:38:04,410 --> 00:38:08,050 In my view, for example, the government should help the Reserve 553 00:38:08,050 --> 00:38:11,250 bank fight inflation. One way to do that is not to put up fees 554 00:38:11,250 --> 00:38:14,930 and charges at a council level or at a government level and use 555 00:38:14,930 --> 00:38:18,650 the Crown and Council balance sheets to fund a lot of this growth 556 00:38:18,890 --> 00:38:24,530 because we have an unsustainable situation. And the 557 00:38:24,530 --> 00:38:28,650 two core pillars of how we run our economy and our society at the 558 00:38:28,650 --> 00:38:32,410 moment, they are the Reserve bank act and the Public Finance Act. 559 00:38:32,890 --> 00:38:36,690 And both of those were put in Place in 1989. They are still at 560 00:38:36,690 --> 00:38:39,570 the heart of everything. They are the pillars that hold up how 561 00:38:39,570 --> 00:38:43,380 our government operates and how our economy runs. And in my view, 562 00:38:44,740 --> 00:38:48,980 they're not working. You could argue maybe they never worked. They're 563 00:38:48,980 --> 00:38:54,340 certainly not working now, and they should be repealed. Now, we're 564 00:38:54,340 --> 00:39:01,300 talking about some pretty hardcore big topics here. I sadly 565 00:39:01,300 --> 00:39:07,300 think the only way we're going to get dramatic, necessary reform 566 00:39:07,300 --> 00:39:14,970 in our political economy is in the event of a geopolitical catastrophe. 567 00:39:15,290 --> 00:39:17,210 Well, this is what I was just going to say. I mean, some of the 568 00:39:17,210 --> 00:39:20,490 things that you've identified so far, I mean, we're talking about 569 00:39:20,490 --> 00:39:22,890 big issues for sure, and at least they're being talked about. 570 00:39:22,890 --> 00:39:25,850 You know, cost of living, cost of food, planning for the future. 571 00:39:25,850 --> 00:39:28,690 With kiwisaver, you've mentioned a lot of the infrastructure 572 00:39:28,690 --> 00:39:32,010 issues. And yes, these things are being talked about. They're not 573 00:39:32,010 --> 00:39:35,490 being talked about in terms of the big structural changes that you're 574 00:39:35,490 --> 00:39:38,400 talking about. And do you think there's any possibility of 575 00:39:38,400 --> 00:39:39,320 these things happening? 576 00:39:39,720 --> 00:39:42,440 Not in the absence of some sort of catastrophe. 577 00:39:42,440 --> 00:39:43,800 What would be required for that? 578 00:39:43,800 --> 00:39:44,680 A nuclear war. 579 00:39:45,000 --> 00:39:46,520 Wow. Do you think that's possible? 580 00:39:46,520 --> 00:39:51,280 Yep. Next year China has said that it'll be ready to attack and 581 00:39:51,280 --> 00:39:55,480 take over Taiwan. Donald Trump at various points has threatened 582 00:39:55,480 --> 00:39:59,760 to attack Iran with nuclear weapons. Pakistan has nuclear weapons 583 00:39:59,760 --> 00:40:03,770 that could use in response to Israel, which also has nuclear weapons. 584 00:40:04,650 --> 00:40:12,010 Russia has threatened various NATO nations on its border with attacks 585 00:40:12,090 --> 00:40:15,930 that would require NATO responses. And there's a very high 586 00:40:15,930 --> 00:40:20,010 risk of nuclear exchange there. This is something that people 587 00:40:20,010 --> 00:40:23,850 don't talk about in public because it's quite frightening. And 588 00:40:24,250 --> 00:40:28,410 frankly, I grew up in the 1980s worried about these things 589 00:40:28,490 --> 00:40:31,610 and that's why we have a nuclear free zone and that's why 590 00:40:31,610 --> 00:40:35,140 we thought we had solved those issues when the Cold War ended. But 591 00:40:35,140 --> 00:40:41,340 it's clear we haven't. And we have now nations willing to use their 592 00:40:41,340 --> 00:40:46,300 military to achieve their aims. And we have a fairly hot war 593 00:40:46,300 --> 00:40:48,700 going on in the Middle east which is affecting us day to day. 594 00:40:48,940 --> 00:40:53,260 And of course then you have the not quite so visible but just 595 00:40:53,260 --> 00:40:56,860 as catastrophic effects of climate change that are happening. 596 00:40:57,100 --> 00:41:01,620 We're about to go into an El Nino, which is is off the charts 597 00:41:03,300 --> 00:41:10,260 so scary. High temperatures that serious people are worried about 598 00:41:11,140 --> 00:41:15,659 tipping points being triggered that would lead to extraordinary 599 00:41:15,659 --> 00:41:19,740 events. Now let's hope it doesn't happen anytime soon. But 600 00:41:19,740 --> 00:41:22,620 you can see why people don't want to have kids. There is a risk 601 00:41:22,620 --> 00:41:25,580 that various risks that something catastrophic could happen 602 00:41:25,580 --> 00:41:30,360 in the next few years. If that goes on, then New Zealand has to 603 00:41:30,360 --> 00:41:33,000 respond. And actually you could argue New Zealand is in one 604 00:41:33,000 --> 00:41:36,680 of the strongest places in the world to deal with something like 605 00:41:36,680 --> 00:41:42,239 some sort of nuclear exchange or some sort of massively catastrophic 606 00:41:42,239 --> 00:41:47,080 climate event. Because we are the only country in the world which 607 00:41:47,080 --> 00:41:53,570 has a moat that is so big and dangerous that no one can come here 608 00:41:53,570 --> 00:41:57,130 in a rubber Dinghy. The only way you can get here is if you hitchhike 609 00:41:57,130 --> 00:42:02,090 on a cruise ship and they can be pretty easily stopped. Jump on 610 00:42:02,090 --> 00:42:06,170 a plane, well, you're not getting through customs. You cannot 611 00:42:06,170 --> 00:42:08,650 just decide, I'm going to go to New Zealand because I need to 612 00:42:08,650 --> 00:42:11,570 live there now. In most other countries in the world that is possible. 613 00:42:11,730 --> 00:42:16,290 You can walk across a river, you can jump on a rubber boat and 614 00:42:16,290 --> 00:42:20,620 go across the English Channel. You can move from one country in 615 00:42:20,620 --> 00:42:25,420 Africa to another country in Africa. The Australians get very 616 00:42:25,420 --> 00:42:28,780 nervous about people jumping on boats in Indonesia. New Zealand 617 00:42:28,780 --> 00:42:34,020 is the only place in the world where we could literally survive 618 00:42:34,740 --> 00:42:41,380 without having connections or trade because we are rich in soil 619 00:42:41,380 --> 00:42:45,930 which we can use to grow food for ourselves. We, we could also, 620 00:42:45,930 --> 00:42:50,650 if we properly fitted out the economy with solar panels and batteries 621 00:42:50,650 --> 00:42:57,010 and properly used our hydroelectric and geothermal electricity 622 00:42:57,010 --> 00:43:01,690 generation, we could be energy self sufficient for transport as 623 00:43:01,690 --> 00:43:07,410 well as for electricity. And unfortunately it wouldn't take that 624 00:43:07,410 --> 00:43:14,420 much to get there. This is why my view, we should be buying up Chinese 625 00:43:14,500 --> 00:43:18,820 batteries and panels and EVs and trucks and buses and everything 626 00:43:18,820 --> 00:43:22,860 they've got as fast as we can and get it shipped here as quickly 627 00:43:22,860 --> 00:43:28,980 as we can because there may come a time when it can't get here. 628 00:43:29,460 --> 00:43:32,220 It's about this point in the podcast where the ones people who 629 00:43:32,220 --> 00:43:35,580 haven't left already are going, oh my goodness, this is not 630 00:43:35,580 --> 00:43:39,590 what I was expecting. But. But if we are going to be serious about 631 00:43:39,590 --> 00:43:44,150 it. When you look at the sweep of history, we've only had really 632 00:43:44,150 --> 00:43:49,630 major responses to the problems of our age when the usual 633 00:43:49,630 --> 00:43:53,509 rules hadn't applied in democracies. When you have a war, 634 00:43:53,990 --> 00:43:59,390 you don't have political party politics. There is no parliament 635 00:43:59,390 --> 00:44:01,510 where people have a go at each other in opposition and they have 636 00:44:01,510 --> 00:44:07,470 an election every three years. You have unified governments where 637 00:44:08,910 --> 00:44:14,750 as in Britain and New Zealand, both major parties were in cabinet 638 00:44:15,070 --> 00:44:20,630 and you didn't have that sort of usual political infighting that 639 00:44:20,630 --> 00:44:26,190 went on and a lot of stuff happened and it was often good. Now 640 00:44:27,550 --> 00:44:33,120 when or if easy for me to say I'm unelectable, unemployable and 641 00:44:33,120 --> 00:44:36,880 unappointable, but something we should think about and I hope 642 00:44:36,880 --> 00:44:40,360 that someone is doing some work on the background. Right, so 643 00:44:40,360 --> 00:44:45,680 mfat, for example, they should have a paper written that they can 644 00:44:45,680 --> 00:44:50,760 hand over to a government and say, right, China just attacked Taiwan 645 00:44:50,920 --> 00:44:55,380 to take it over last night. This will mean China will say we 646 00:44:55,380 --> 00:44:57,940 have to stop trading with America. America says we have to 647 00:44:57,940 --> 00:45:04,100 stop trading with China. Most of our goods and services go through 648 00:45:05,060 --> 00:45:08,020 the Straits of Taiwan or through the South China Sea. That's 649 00:45:08,020 --> 00:45:11,180 now an active war zone. A lot of the Asian refineries have stopped 650 00:45:11,180 --> 00:45:19,100 sending fossil fuel, refined fossil fuel to us. Global GDP is 651 00:45:19,100 --> 00:45:24,870 going to drop. Trade's going to do this. Here's what we think 652 00:45:24,870 --> 00:45:29,910 should happen or this is how we should have prepared. I hope someone's 653 00:45:29,910 --> 00:45:36,390 doing that because we need to. We're so complacent about these sorts 654 00:45:36,390 --> 00:45:42,790 of things. After a long period of relative stability and peace since 655 00:45:42,790 --> 00:45:49,190 1945 at least now part of the world world but we forget from 1914-18 656 00:45:49,190 --> 00:45:53,350 and 39 to 45 and you could argue during a good chunk of the 657 00:45:53,350 --> 00:46:02,310 Cold War we didn't think of ourselves as a completely free and 658 00:46:02,310 --> 00:46:07,990 independent member of a global free trading, free capital movements, 659 00:46:08,070 --> 00:46:12,360 free movements economy. People weren't having middle of the winter 660 00:46:12,360 --> 00:46:18,760 holidays in Europe in 1943. Now you may say, well that was a 661 00:46:18,760 --> 00:46:21,960 long time ago and hardly any of us were born or alive then. Well, 662 00:46:22,760 --> 00:46:27,720 there's a few people who were. And the party that is the natural 663 00:46:27,720 --> 00:46:32,680 successor to the Nazi party just won an election in East Germany. 664 00:46:33,080 --> 00:46:33,880 Terrifying. 665 00:46:33,880 --> 00:46:39,130 Yeah. So those risks are there and, and we should not be ready for 666 00:46:39,130 --> 00:46:41,570 them and talk about them in public. I'm not talking prime time 667 00:46:41,570 --> 00:46:44,930 debates, I'm talking some bright people thinking about it in 668 00:46:44,930 --> 00:46:47,730 the background. I hope someone's doing that because it, 669 00:46:47,730 --> 00:46:48,770 you know, it shouldn't be me. 670 00:46:48,930 --> 00:46:51,130 Look, these are, as you said, these are big issues but they're 671 00:46:51,130 --> 00:46:54,610 issues that really need thinking about. Right. So as we're 672 00:46:54,930 --> 00:47:01,330 looking down the barrel of all of these huge issues, we in New Zealand 673 00:47:01,330 --> 00:47:04,780 often feels like the bottom of the world. But our own election coming 674 00:47:04,780 --> 00:47:11,220 up, somewhat of an ability to influence things somewhat not. What 675 00:47:11,220 --> 00:47:14,620 do you think people should have top of mind heading into this 676 00:47:14,620 --> 00:47:17,380 election if they're concerned about the issues that we've talked 677 00:47:17,380 --> 00:47:17,820 about today. 678 00:47:17,820 --> 00:47:21,220 You could say housing, food and energy and security of all three 679 00:47:21,220 --> 00:47:25,980 of those. So that means making sure everyone has a warm, dry, affordable 680 00:47:25,980 --> 00:47:31,940 home, has enough food to eat and has enough electricity but also 681 00:47:32,500 --> 00:47:38,700 energy to do the things they need, transport wise. And we should 682 00:47:38,700 --> 00:47:44,700 be preparing ourselves and be ready to be truly independent if 683 00:47:44,700 --> 00:47:51,540 something happens. And it's not that hard actually. We can grow 684 00:47:51,540 --> 00:47:56,110 enough food for 40 million people. There is enough sun to power 685 00:47:56,110 --> 00:48:01,750 enough solar panels and batteries and run our dams and geothermal 686 00:48:01,750 --> 00:48:04,830 in a way that means electricity is affordable and we've 687 00:48:04,830 --> 00:48:08,110 got enough of it. You know, we can do all these things. It's not 688 00:48:08,110 --> 00:48:12,150 as far away or as hard as you might think at the moment, who would 689 00:48:12,150 --> 00:48:16,990 have thought 20 years ago that we'd have $140 billion KiwiSaver 690 00:48:16,990 --> 00:48:20,870 fund scheme or that New Zealand super fund would be, you 691 00:48:20,870 --> 00:48:25,830 know, tens of billions of dollars or that we would all have 692 00:48:27,110 --> 00:48:30,230 computing devices in our pockets that was more power than 693 00:48:30,230 --> 00:48:34,470 the Apollo mission. So we could do other things that seem big 694 00:48:34,550 --> 00:48:39,790 and also are very good. And we shouldn't always think that nothing's 695 00:48:39,790 --> 00:48:43,510 ever going to change and it's always bad, but we certainly should 696 00:48:43,510 --> 00:48:48,030 be ready to do things for ourselves and not think of ourselves 697 00:48:48,030 --> 00:48:52,670 as quarks just floating on some sort of global sea because we're 698 00:48:52,670 --> 00:48:56,230 not, we have two islands, they're not going anywhere, you can't 699 00:48:56,230 --> 00:49:00,710 get to them in a rubber boat. And we're actually rich. We're rich 700 00:49:00,710 --> 00:49:05,590 in soil, we're rich in people, we're rich in sun, water, a lot richer 701 00:49:05,590 --> 00:49:08,350 than a whole bunch of other people and with a lot more options. 702 00:49:10,030 --> 00:49:14,110 And we should be aware of that. We've tuned ourselves and our 703 00:49:14,110 --> 00:49:19,790 entire society to be dependent, interlinked, intertwined 704 00:49:19,790 --> 00:49:22,750 with the rest of the world in a way that thinks, well, we have 705 00:49:22,750 --> 00:49:27,470 to be connected. We can't just turn it all off because then we wouldn't 706 00:49:27,470 --> 00:49:30,630 have enough food or well actually we could have enough food 707 00:49:30,790 --> 00:49:36,030 and we should take control. We shouldn't just cede control of our 708 00:49:36,030 --> 00:49:40,160 future to some sort of global politics. That doesn't have to happen. 709 00:49:42,160 --> 00:49:46,720 And we should think a bit higher. We've probably gone way beyond 710 00:49:46,880 --> 00:49:49,920 the scope of where you were thinking we did,. 711 00:49:49,920 --> 00:49:51,760 But you've given me so much food for thought. 712 00:49:51,920 --> 00:49:54,720 Yeah. And the people who got to the end of this must be thinking, 713 00:49:54,960 --> 00:49:58,640 wow, either I'm really happy I got to the end of that or I need 714 00:49:58,640 --> 00:49:59,760 some medication now. 715 00:50:00,000 --> 00:50:04,280 What a wild ride. No, I truly mean it. You've given me so much 716 00:50:04,280 --> 00:50:09,170 food for thought and a lot to weigh up. Look, if people do want 717 00:50:09,170 --> 00:50:12,650 more from you, you of course run your own independent media these 718 00:50:12,650 --> 00:50:14,450 days. Where can people find you? 719 00:50:15,090 --> 00:50:22,210 So you can go to the Kaka T H E K A K A as in the bird.substack.com 720 00:50:22,370 --> 00:50:24,850 and one of the reasons I'm able to do this sort of thing is 721 00:50:24,850 --> 00:50:30,530 that people are paying a subscription for me to keep doing 722 00:50:30,530 --> 00:50:34,760 this sort of work. And that's something I'm very grateful for. 723 00:50:34,760 --> 00:50:39,840 And I keep trying to do as much as I can in public, as much 724 00:50:39,840 --> 00:50:48,600 as I can. Because one of the sad things, one of the problems with 725 00:50:48,760 --> 00:50:53,160 subscription funded media is that the tree fell in the forest 726 00:50:53,160 --> 00:50:57,320 Problem? You do lots of work, but only the people who pay can see 727 00:50:57,320 --> 00:51:03,090 it. And I sort of walk a delicate line between putting some 728 00:51:03,090 --> 00:51:06,090 stuff behind the paywall and having a lot of it outside the paywall, 729 00:51:06,090 --> 00:51:09,570 or doing a lot of work in other media, freely available media, 730 00:51:10,130 --> 00:51:13,810 to make sure that some of the work I do is out there and useful. 731 00:51:13,810 --> 00:51:16,570 Yeah, no, I totally agree. It's difficult, isn't it, when you 732 00:51:16,570 --> 00:51:18,490 feel like the work is important and it needs to reach as 733 00:51:18,490 --> 00:51:21,730 many people as possible, but you also have to make an actual business 734 00:51:21,730 --> 00:51:22,130 run. 735 00:51:22,770 --> 00:51:23,250 Yeah. 736 00:51:23,420 --> 00:51:26,100 Well, thank you very much for coming on here and sharing all of 737 00:51:26,100 --> 00:51:28,940 your thoughts and your analysis. Bernard Hickey from the 738 00:51:28,940 --> 00:51:32,540 Kaka. Now, if this was helpful to you, send it to a friend so we 739 00:51:32,540 --> 00:51:35,740 can all level up with money together. Like I said, lots of food 740 00:51:35,740 --> 00:51:40,300 for thought in this one. Until next time, have a great day. This 741 00:51:40,300 --> 00:51:43,340 podcast can only give you general information about how things 742 00:51:43,340 --> 00:51:47,340 work in most situations. It's not individual financial advice. 743 00:51:47,660 --> 00:51:51,060 If you're after that, a financial advisor is always the best 744 00:51:51,060 --> 00:51:51,420 bet.