1 00:00:07,000 --> 00:00:10,119 Evan Troxel: This episode of the TRXL podcast is made possible 2 00:00:10,119 --> 00:00:11,700 with support from ArchIT. 3 00:00:12,086 --> 00:00:14,906 Are you tired of standard IT services that missed the mark. 4 00:00:15,116 --> 00:00:20,546 Choose ArchIT for specialized proactive, IT management, BIM support and robust 5 00:00:20,546 --> 00:00:22,886 data security tailored for architects. 6 00:00:23,186 --> 00:00:27,396 Whether you're a team of 10 or a growing firm of 50+, ArchIT understands 7 00:00:27,416 --> 00:00:31,106 the architecture industry and will empower your unique, creative vision 8 00:00:31,286 --> 00:00:33,296 to enable you to do your best work. 9 00:00:33,606 --> 00:00:38,106 Embrace a technology team that enhances, not hinders, your design process. 10 00:00:38,406 --> 00:00:44,226 Visit GetArchIT.com for your free IT assessment and start transforming your 11 00:00:44,226 --> 00:00:46,446 firm and your tech experience today. 12 00:00:46,776 --> 00:00:51,126 That's GetArchIT.com. 13 00:00:52,642 --> 00:00:54,442 Welcome to the TRXL podcast. 14 00:00:54,562 --> 00:00:55,492 I'm Evan Troxel. 15 00:00:55,942 --> 00:00:59,962 If you are a regular listener and are enjoying these episodes, please 16 00:00:59,962 --> 00:01:04,762 subscribe both on YouTube and in your preferred podcast app, to let me know 17 00:01:04,792 --> 00:01:09,442 that you're a fan of the show, being a subscriber, which is completely free 18 00:01:09,502 --> 00:01:14,482 directly influences my ability to attract sponsors that help keep this show going. 19 00:01:14,962 --> 00:01:18,562 And my ability to attract the guests that you want to hear from. 20 00:01:19,079 --> 00:01:22,349 My goal is to deliver quality episodes that provide value 21 00:01:22,349 --> 00:01:23,939 to you and our industry. 22 00:01:24,299 --> 00:01:27,359 So if you haven't subscribed, I encourage you to do so. 23 00:01:27,629 --> 00:01:29,158 As I mentioned, it's free. 24 00:01:29,489 --> 00:01:33,689 And it's a great way to support TRXL and for those of you who are 25 00:01:33,689 --> 00:01:38,489 in a position to support my work directly, you can become a member. 26 00:01:38,769 --> 00:01:42,819 To learn more about the perks of membership and to join simply click 27 00:01:42,819 --> 00:01:46,799 on the join us button at trxl.co. 28 00:01:47,109 --> 00:01:50,619 Your support is incredibly valuable for the sustainability of this show. 29 00:01:51,009 --> 00:01:52,449 And I deeply appreciate it. 30 00:01:53,269 --> 00:01:58,209 In this episode, I welcome Roderick Bates back to the podcast for the third time. 31 00:01:58,239 --> 00:02:03,009 And this time we are joined by his colleague Kam Star Roderick is the 32 00:02:03,009 --> 00:02:08,199 Director of Corporate Development and Kam is the Chief Product Officer at Chaos. 33 00:02:08,689 --> 00:02:13,209 In this episode, we have a casual and candid conversation about what's going 34 00:02:13,209 --> 00:02:15,699 on in the visualization space in AEC. 35 00:02:16,179 --> 00:02:21,728 How AI and spatial computing is and will be affecting the profession, and 36 00:02:21,728 --> 00:02:24,039 what's on the horizon at Chaos Enscape 37 00:02:24,399 --> 00:02:27,999 We also explore how real time technologies can enhance workflows 38 00:02:28,029 --> 00:02:32,409 beyond just visualization tools for informed decision-making on 39 00:02:32,409 --> 00:02:34,418 energy use and building performance. 40 00:02:34,839 --> 00:02:38,949 We also discuss their new partnership with the illuminating Engineering 41 00:02:38,949 --> 00:02:43,629 Society also known as IES to enhance their tool's capabilities, 42 00:02:43,659 --> 00:02:45,819 and steer it in a new direction. 43 00:02:46,239 --> 00:02:49,869 This was a fantastic conversation with Roderick and Kam and I hope 44 00:02:49,899 --> 00:02:53,379 you'll not only find value in it for yourself, but that you'll help add 45 00:02:53,379 --> 00:02:57,459 value to the profession at large, by sharing it with your network. 46 00:02:57,819 --> 00:03:01,599 So without further ado, I bring you my conversation with 47 00:03:01,599 --> 00:03:03,559 Roderick Bates and Kam Star 48 00:03:11,681 --> 00:03:14,241 Kam Star: honestly, I, I don't, I don't understand how people say it 49 00:03:14,241 --> 00:03:18,681 goes faster as you get older because that, that is not my experience. 50 00:03:19,361 --> 00:03:23,731 Like, oh boy, the things, like, it's not that the days are long, 51 00:03:24,661 --> 00:03:26,161 but there's a lot going on. 52 00:03:26,781 --> 00:03:29,761 And even if I was to summarize like, what, what happened in the last 53 00:03:30,311 --> 00:03:34,641 four weeks, it feels like it's a whole year's worth of work stuff. 54 00:03:34,861 --> 00:03:36,801 So, yeah, I don't, 55 00:03:37,031 --> 00:03:37,251 Roderick Bates: Oh, 56 00:03:37,491 --> 00:03:40,081 Kam Star: maybe, maybe it's because, I don't know, maybe people say it goes 57 00:03:40,081 --> 00:03:43,441 faster when you, you know, oh, you know, the days go slow, the years go fast. 58 00:03:43,661 --> 00:03:45,321 No, everything goes really slowly. 59 00:03:45,321 --> 00:03:49,371 Whatcha talking about, you know, it's just, I don't know. 60 00:03:50,371 --> 00:03:52,941 Evan Troxel: What what made sense to me was when I heard it explained 61 00:03:52,941 --> 00:03:56,581 like this, it was, uh, okay, so when you're, when you're 16, right? 62 00:03:56,861 --> 00:03:58,581 A year is a 16th of your life. 63 00:03:59,361 --> 00:04:03,781 And now I'm 49, so a year is a 49th, right? 64 00:04:03,801 --> 00:04:08,996 And so, and so just that compression right there is what Why it feels 65 00:04:08,996 --> 00:04:10,436 like it goes so fast because 66 00:04:10,496 --> 00:04:11,436 the older you get, 67 00:04:11,706 --> 00:04:12,356 it's a smaller 68 00:04:12,681 --> 00:04:15,921 Kam Star: like a good, that sounds like a good story, Evan, but I'm sorry. 69 00:04:15,921 --> 00:04:17,761 There's absolutely no truth in it whatsoever. 70 00:04:18,351 --> 00:04:22,591 I think what you'll find is it depends on how much you learn and what new 71 00:04:22,661 --> 00:04:27,351 experiences you have, because, you know, at your age, you could spend this year. 72 00:04:27,931 --> 00:04:31,781 Traveling the world and seeing a different city every single day, 73 00:04:32,121 --> 00:04:34,821 or you could be 16 and be stuck in a, in a 74 00:04:34,881 --> 00:04:37,621 in, you know, in a, in somewhere experiencing the same thing. 75 00:04:37,761 --> 00:04:41,021 You cannot tell me that, oh, that felt like a much longer time. 76 00:04:41,081 --> 00:04:45,701 No, it's the number of new experiences that you have, uh, on a kind of a, 77 00:04:45,881 --> 00:04:48,941 you know, in, in one year, how much, how many new experiences do you have? 78 00:04:48,961 --> 00:04:50,181 How many new things do you learn? 79 00:04:50,241 --> 00:04:55,741 How many new th things do you think about or do you see if those are reduced? 80 00:04:55,761 --> 00:04:59,861 And when you are 16, there's an awful lot out there in the world which you haven't 81 00:04:59,861 --> 00:05:01,421 heard or seen, and everything seems 82 00:05:01,521 --> 00:05:01,741 new. 83 00:05:01,801 --> 00:05:06,221 And so your experience of the world is that, oh my god, so much happened. 84 00:05:06,601 --> 00:05:10,461 And maybe, you know, maybe you, you know, if you're my age 49, about to be 85 00:05:10,461 --> 00:05:13,381 50, like, uh, it could feel like, well. 86 00:05:13,956 --> 00:05:15,116 I didn't learn anything last year. 87 00:05:15,136 --> 00:05:19,556 Now that's definitely not true for me, uh, because, you know, I'm, I'm ferocious 88 00:05:19,556 --> 00:05:23,996 when it comes to, to, to, to reading and picking up new things and whether 89 00:05:24,026 --> 00:05:25,996 it's a language or a topic or whatever. 90 00:05:26,496 --> 00:05:30,836 Um, and actually as I get older, I do that even more and more and more. 91 00:05:31,036 --> 00:05:34,756 I read, I've read more books every year than I'd done the previous year. 92 00:05:34,786 --> 00:05:37,876 It's like, it's, you know, not quite hitting the exponential 93 00:05:38,156 --> 00:05:39,636 'cause it's not possible humanly. 94 00:05:40,176 --> 00:05:42,876 Um, but, you know, I think, I think that's what it comes down to. 95 00:05:42,906 --> 00:05:46,716 It's, it's, it's not the number, and I know, I know exactly what you're 96 00:05:46,716 --> 00:05:50,236 saying, but it's not that, it's how many new experiences did you have? 97 00:05:50,256 --> 00:05:54,076 And certainly at 16 you are bound to have many more experiences. 98 00:05:54,676 --> 00:06:00,776 For the first time, uh, whereas it's kind of hard to get to our age and have 99 00:06:00,856 --> 00:06:05,216 a brand new, like, uh, you know, eating food that you'd never had before or come 100 00:06:05,216 --> 00:06:09,736 across a new, you know, scientific or political, historic, cultural, some new 101 00:06:09,806 --> 00:06:11,536 idea that you'd never heard of before. 102 00:06:12,236 --> 00:06:16,896 So it becomes harder to live that kind of a life of new 103 00:06:17,456 --> 00:06:19,936 insights and untrodden paths. 104 00:06:20,886 --> 00:06:23,336 Roderick Bates: What I think is unique about you though Kam, is that 105 00:06:23,436 --> 00:06:26,963 for most people, they get into that sort of that repetitious groove. 106 00:06:27,823 --> 00:06:31,713 Then there's the reduced anticipation of what's next or the uncertainty. 107 00:06:31,813 --> 00:06:34,313 And so that's part of where you're like, oh, that year went 108 00:06:34,313 --> 00:06:38,073 by in a blink because of, of what exactly what you're describing. 109 00:06:38,073 --> 00:06:41,393 Whereas when you're young and and foolish and whatnot, everything 110 00:06:41,493 --> 00:06:45,113 is these experiences that, that seem to be so massively consuming 111 00:06:45,213 --> 00:06:46,873 and emotionally consuming as well. 112 00:06:47,413 --> 00:06:50,673 You know, you get to my age or our age and, and things are kind of like, eh, 113 00:06:51,693 --> 00:06:55,953 you know, the emotional ups and downs really start to compress to some degree. 114 00:06:56,133 --> 00:06:59,673 And I think that's part of like with my kids, like say, when's Christmas coming? 115 00:07:00,373 --> 00:07:02,993 It is truly anticipated for months. 116 00:07:03,383 --> 00:07:06,193 Whereas for me, the Christmas anticipation is, 117 00:07:06,533 --> 00:07:06,753 uh, 118 00:07:07,168 --> 00:07:07,518 Evan Troxel: Right? 119 00:07:07,943 --> 00:07:08,753 Roderick Bates: it's pretty modest. 120 00:07:10,393 --> 00:07:13,693 And so as a result, you know, it's like, because you don't, you don't have all 121 00:07:13,693 --> 00:07:16,453 that thinking about it, it seems to go by faster, but you, it's the opposite 122 00:07:16,453 --> 00:07:20,773 effect, which I think is, is quite interesting that for you, like, you know, 123 00:07:20,773 --> 00:07:24,413 the more you have going on, at least on your end, regardless of anticipation 124 00:07:24,413 --> 00:07:26,853 or not, it makes it feel longer. 125 00:07:26,853 --> 00:07:30,853 Whereas for me, the busyness and all of that, in fact would make it feel faster. 126 00:07:32,123 --> 00:07:34,733 Like my weeks go by short because I can't complete everything 127 00:07:34,978 --> 00:07:36,328 Evan Troxel: Right yeah. 128 00:07:36,358 --> 00:07:38,808 It's like when you're young, you have your whole life ahead of you. 129 00:07:38,948 --> 00:07:42,648 My, my, my youngest is 17 and he's constantly kicking the can down the road 130 00:07:42,828 --> 00:07:44,128 for ev It doesn't matter what it is. 131 00:07:44,188 --> 00:07:47,928 It could be putting the plate into the dishwasher, or it could be a, a 132 00:07:47,928 --> 00:07:49,408 bigger, like getting a driver's license. 133 00:07:49,533 --> 00:07:51,473 Roderick Bates: So you're telling me I got 10 more years of, of 134 00:07:51,473 --> 00:07:52,633 this to look forward to, huh? 135 00:07:52,658 --> 00:07:52,948 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 136 00:07:52,968 --> 00:07:56,108 So, so he's always like, yeah, I got plenty of time to do that. 137 00:07:56,108 --> 00:07:56,748 And now look at us. 138 00:07:56,748 --> 00:07:58,348 We're like, we we're out of time. 139 00:07:58,488 --> 00:07:59,948 We, we I 140 00:07:59,948 --> 00:08:00,988 gotta cram it all in. 141 00:08:01,028 --> 00:08:04,788 I gotta live five lives at the same time because I gotta, I want to do it all. 142 00:08:05,288 --> 00:08:05,508 And, 143 00:08:05,663 --> 00:08:06,783 Roderick Bates: yeah, you gotta learn fly fishing. 144 00:08:06,803 --> 00:08:07,823 You gotta do the road trip. 145 00:08:07,843 --> 00:08:11,463 You know, you, you, gotta master the next, uh, task or read the next book. 146 00:08:11,678 --> 00:08:11,938 Evan Troxel: All right. 147 00:08:12,468 --> 00:08:12,818 Right. 148 00:08:12,968 --> 00:08:15,898 Yeah, I, I think that there's something to all of this, 149 00:08:15,898 --> 00:08:17,418 that, that is playing into it. 150 00:08:18,128 --> 00:08:20,578 Well, maybe we can just kick this off and I can 151 00:08:20,578 --> 00:08:21,098 welcome you 152 00:08:21,098 --> 00:08:22,178 both to the show. 153 00:08:22,528 --> 00:08:24,378 It's great to see you again, Roderick. 154 00:08:24,448 --> 00:08:27,038 This is, third time around the, the TRXL, 155 00:08:27,143 --> 00:08:28,523 Roderick Bates: people are gonna start getting bored of me. 156 00:08:28,658 --> 00:08:29,408 Evan Troxel: solar system. 157 00:08:29,538 --> 00:08:29,888 Never. 158 00:08:29,938 --> 00:08:30,288 Never. 159 00:08:30,508 --> 00:08:33,808 And, and Kam, welcome to the podcast for the first time. 160 00:08:33,878 --> 00:08:35,408 It's great to have you both here today. 161 00:08:35,837 --> 00:08:36,188 Kam Star: Great. 162 00:08:36,548 --> 00:08:36,768 Evan Troxel: So, 163 00:08:36,868 --> 00:08:36,948 Kam Star: here. 164 00:08:37,554 --> 00:08:40,453 Evan Troxel: we got to catch up a little bit at Autodesk University 165 00:08:40,874 --> 00:08:45,454 at the Chaos Enscape booth, and you were both gracious to kind of share 166 00:08:45,994 --> 00:08:51,334 things that are going on in, in the world of architectural visualization. 167 00:08:51,364 --> 00:08:52,174 There's a lot. 168 00:08:52,174 --> 00:08:53,374 going on at, at Chaos. 169 00:08:53,694 --> 00:08:59,374 I recently spoke with Petr Mitev, uh, who you both know well and obviously 170 00:08:59,374 --> 00:09:03,014 have had some nice conversations with, with Dan Monaghan as well, 171 00:09:03,354 --> 00:09:09,774 and this is just a little, another opportunity to share what's going on. 172 00:09:10,514 --> 00:09:14,014 Before we go there, because I'm really interested in what you guys are seeing. 173 00:09:14,014 --> 00:09:15,934 You're, you're super tied into. 174 00:09:17,539 --> 00:09:22,659 A cross section of a EC that I think is a lot of people are 175 00:09:22,659 --> 00:09:23,699 interested in hearing about. 176 00:09:23,789 --> 00:09:29,059 We're seeing so much happen right now, uh, especially in the AI side of things, but 177 00:09:29,559 --> 00:09:31,219 the visualization landscape is changing. 178 00:09:31,229 --> 00:09:31,579 Right. 179 00:09:32,079 --> 00:09:36,539 And, uh, I'm, I'm interested to talk about that, but before we do, and, 180 00:09:36,639 --> 00:09:42,619 and maybe Kam will kick off with you, just give us an idea of where you've 181 00:09:42,619 --> 00:09:47,579 been, what you're working on, what makes this problem interesting to you. 182 00:09:47,839 --> 00:09:49,819 Why, why are you operating in this space? 183 00:09:50,854 --> 00:09:51,014 Kam Star: Mm-Hmm. 184 00:09:51,604 --> 00:09:51,894 Sure. 185 00:09:52,554 --> 00:09:57,854 Um, you know, I started early, uh, I've been into 3D since before 3D. 186 00:09:57,874 --> 00:09:58,814 That's how it feels. 187 00:09:59,574 --> 00:10:03,974 I was playing around, kicking around, making, uh, little 3D simulations 188 00:10:03,974 --> 00:10:05,974 on a graphic scalor in the eighties. 189 00:10:06,754 --> 00:10:10,574 Uh, you know, and then in the nineties, uh, even late eighties, 190 00:10:10,574 --> 00:10:13,294 getting into the Omega a and, and, and playing around with that. 191 00:10:13,354 --> 00:10:18,894 And, um, for my sins, I studied architecture, which, uh, you know, is 192 00:10:18,894 --> 00:10:23,534 the kind of, uh, forces you to think about space, forces you to think about 193 00:10:23,754 --> 00:10:30,094 design the intersection, and how to, how to really effectively communicate it. 194 00:10:30,759 --> 00:10:35,019 Not to just your, you know, end client, but to everyone else who's, who's 195 00:10:35,019 --> 00:10:40,899 engaged in that process and how to better help folks understand what your 196 00:10:40,899 --> 00:10:42,699 intention is, what the outcome would be. 197 00:10:43,319 --> 00:10:50,959 Um, I, um, I only remembered this just a very short while ago that actually 198 00:10:50,959 --> 00:10:57,279 my master thesis in, in, in the mid nineties and that's the 1990s, uh, was, 199 00:10:57,419 --> 00:11:01,559 uh, the title of my thesis was Artificial Intelligence in the Built Environment. 200 00:11:02,339 --> 00:11:04,679 Um, and, and I went and dug it up. 201 00:11:04,749 --> 00:11:09,559 It's still, you know, printed in, uh, Sheffield University and, and, 202 00:11:09,559 --> 00:11:14,039 and it was just like, oh my God, I really thought we would have AI in 203 00:11:14,039 --> 00:11:15,919 the built environment in the nineties. 204 00:11:16,609 --> 00:11:16,829 Wow. 205 00:11:17,279 --> 00:11:19,149 Where is the AI in the built environment? 206 00:11:19,649 --> 00:11:24,669 Um, and, uh, of course the last few years it's been a huge 207 00:11:24,849 --> 00:11:26,869 ex explore explosion of that. 208 00:11:27,289 --> 00:11:31,269 But, you know, my journey was, um, through architecture, then 209 00:11:31,269 --> 00:11:37,719 architectural visualization, uh, and really where I was face to face with 210 00:11:37,719 --> 00:11:42,719 people who were drawing perspectives and coloring it in with watercolors. 211 00:11:43,179 --> 00:11:47,279 And I sat with some of them and they would kind of look and go, oh, this computer 212 00:11:47,369 --> 00:11:50,959 stuff, no one's, you know, it is never gonna be as, as interesting as what we do. 213 00:11:51,539 --> 00:11:58,519 Um, but actually that, that beKame one of the most effective ways to, uh, and, 214 00:11:58,519 --> 00:12:02,079 and I don't mean to belittle this because it's a really important thing to sell 215 00:12:02,319 --> 00:12:05,799 buildings, to sell them to customers, to sell them, to planning people, to 216 00:12:05,799 --> 00:12:09,439 sell them, to potential, uh, folks who would, who would have to live with it. 217 00:12:10,179 --> 00:12:16,109 Um, after quite a few years of that, about four years of that, i, I, I just. 218 00:12:16,724 --> 00:12:17,934 Felt there's gotta be more. 219 00:12:18,314 --> 00:12:21,454 And I wanted to start to apply gaming technology into this space. 220 00:12:21,634 --> 00:12:28,654 So I ended up late twenties setting up a company, uh, uh, that was focused 221 00:12:28,714 --> 00:12:31,974 on the use of gaming technology outside of pure entertainment. 222 00:12:32,714 --> 00:12:37,414 So actually the very first project that we did was a, was a large 223 00:12:37,414 --> 00:12:41,134 scale visualization of a very large, um, I wanna say very large. 224 00:12:41,134 --> 00:12:43,694 It was a very large site of 2000 buildings. 225 00:12:44,354 --> 00:12:47,974 Uh, and, and we used gaming technology to not just visualize it, but to, 226 00:12:48,034 --> 00:12:52,974 to let you drive around it in a kind of a GTA style with a little map. 227 00:12:53,194 --> 00:12:57,694 So you could kind of go around and, and have little missions to find various 228 00:12:58,054 --> 00:13:04,534 buildings on this enormous site, which has normally about 120,000 people on it. 229 00:13:04,594 --> 00:13:05,694 But you can imagine it's just 230 00:13:05,724 --> 00:13:06,014 huge. 231 00:13:06,664 --> 00:13:06,954 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 232 00:13:07,034 --> 00:13:08,774 Kam Star: Um, that kind of got. 233 00:13:09,914 --> 00:13:18,204 Into this whole idea of gaming and gaming tech used for communicating concepts, 234 00:13:18,414 --> 00:13:23,964 ideas, whether they are about history or whether they're about science or 235 00:13:23,964 --> 00:13:29,724 they're about health, or they're about finance or politics, really applying this 236 00:13:29,724 --> 00:13:34,484 kind of simulation thinking, but then always coming back to gaming technology. 237 00:13:34,484 --> 00:13:35,644 And why gaming technology? 238 00:13:36,354 --> 00:13:40,724 Well, frankly, for up until quite recently, that's where 239 00:13:40,724 --> 00:13:42,924 you found the best realtime 3D. 240 00:13:43,464 --> 00:13:48,404 That's where you found, you know, the, the, uh, and the, the, the mechanisms 241 00:13:48,404 --> 00:13:50,884 of gaming, uh, lend themselves well. 242 00:13:51,354 --> 00:13:56,474 They kind of require, not lend themselves well, but they require like the best, 243 00:13:56,534 --> 00:14:00,874 the highest fidelity the technology can kind of bring to bear and on a, on a, 244 00:14:00,894 --> 00:14:03,834 on a consumer level, accessible level. 245 00:14:04,734 --> 00:14:09,974 Um, so I've got, I, I'll go completely enthralled into that and um, Over the 246 00:14:09,974 --> 00:14:14,174 years that kind of grew into, Ooh. 247 00:14:14,174 --> 00:14:15,014 What about ai? 248 00:14:15,874 --> 00:14:21,334 Um, now I've always had a real keen interest on people, um, 249 00:14:21,644 --> 00:14:23,174 from a behavioral perspective. 250 00:14:23,514 --> 00:14:26,414 I'm a kind of an armchair behavioral economic economist. 251 00:14:27,114 --> 00:14:32,534 Um, I ended up doing a PhD around, um, competition, collaboration and, and 252 00:14:32,534 --> 00:14:35,974 groups of people, teams up with people working together and personalities 253 00:14:36,194 --> 00:14:41,534 and, and how you could best use things like gamification or framing to get 254 00:14:41,534 --> 00:14:42,774 people to work really well together. 255 00:14:43,784 --> 00:14:48,684 Um, and that kind of led into the, this space of affective ai. 256 00:14:49,184 --> 00:14:55,444 And can, can computers decide, give you a better understanding of, um, how 257 00:14:55,444 --> 00:14:57,644 you are feeling than maybe an expert? 258 00:14:59,354 --> 00:15:05,494 it turns out really surprisingly, computers can be trained or a 259 00:15:05,574 --> 00:15:07,694 computer model can be trained to. 260 00:15:08,924 --> 00:15:12,234 Recognize emotion better than any other human can. 261 00:15:13,054 --> 00:15:13,274 Why? 262 00:15:13,274 --> 00:15:18,634 Because that computer model can contain tens of thousands, perhaps even hundreds 263 00:15:18,634 --> 00:15:22,754 of thousands of hours of training, whereas the human would only have a lifetime 264 00:15:23,374 --> 00:15:23,874 of training. 265 00:15:24,634 --> 00:15:27,174 Um, and that was really fascinating. 266 00:15:27,174 --> 00:15:30,254 It's really interesting in how you bring that to life, how you visualize that. 267 00:15:31,474 --> 00:15:34,894 And then life took a little bit of a change and I faceted 268 00:15:34,934 --> 00:15:35,734 a little bit of a change. 269 00:15:35,914 --> 00:15:40,694 So I helped grow an automation company, um, for a few years. 270 00:15:40,754 --> 00:15:45,414 And, and after that, actually chaos Kame along, but I had got a knock on the door, 271 00:15:45,884 --> 00:15:47,774 said, Hey, you know, we're doing 3D. 272 00:15:47,854 --> 00:15:51,694 I said, well, what kind of 3D Yeah, architectural visualization I kinda 273 00:15:51,694 --> 00:15:53,934 looked at and went, oh, that's what I was doing 20 years ago. 274 00:15:54,314 --> 00:15:57,614 Um, it's, uh, what's happening in this space. 275 00:15:57,634 --> 00:16:03,334 And the more I looked, um, the more it was clear that this space is going through 276 00:16:04,054 --> 00:16:07,254 probably one of the biggest revolutions that it has done since it started. 277 00:16:08,144 --> 00:16:10,684 Uh, from using computers to visualize. 278 00:16:11,344 --> 00:16:16,004 And the reason, and I don't say that lightly, um, the, the, the 279 00:16:16,004 --> 00:16:20,604 really step change in software like scape, and of course Vera has been 280 00:16:20,604 --> 00:16:22,084 around for, what, 25 years now. 281 00:16:22,504 --> 00:16:26,004 Uh, but you know, something like scape comes along and it, and 282 00:16:26,004 --> 00:16:29,004 it democratizes visualization. 283 00:16:29,544 --> 00:16:32,284 and, and and I, again, that's not said lightly. 284 00:16:32,554 --> 00:16:35,164 This is the idea of something that was really specialist. 285 00:16:35,784 --> 00:16:41,164 You really had to have, go and trained, understood, learn the software, figure 286 00:16:41,164 --> 00:16:45,484 out how, you know, to light things, how to apply materials, how to set all of that. 287 00:16:45,824 --> 00:16:49,964 And suddenly, hey, I'm, I've just, I'm just doing my design in SketchUp, 288 00:16:49,964 --> 00:16:53,124 or I'm just doing my design in, in, in Revit or, or what have you. 289 00:16:53,704 --> 00:16:58,204 And I can get something that is good enough that looks pretty damn good. 290 00:16:58,754 --> 00:17:00,204 This, this stuff looks really good 291 00:17:00,904 --> 00:17:01,964 and, and, and that 292 00:17:02,419 --> 00:17:04,989 Roderick Bates: Nevermind the, the technical side of even setting 293 00:17:04,989 --> 00:17:06,429 up the deployments to render 294 00:17:07,118 --> 00:17:07,358 Kam Star: Right. 295 00:17:07,509 --> 00:17:08,509 Roderick Bates: a good V-Ray scene. 296 00:17:08,839 --> 00:17:09,189 Evan Troxel: right? 297 00:17:09,579 --> 00:17:10,429 Kam Star: Real time, right? 298 00:17:10,479 --> 00:17:11,509 60 frames a second. 299 00:17:12,598 --> 00:17:19,729 Um, and of course in the last two years finally AI is getting some airtime. 300 00:17:20,589 --> 00:17:25,249 Um, for those who've been very close to it for very many years, we've 301 00:17:25,249 --> 00:17:30,169 been kind of watching it and maybe involved in some ways, but it's that 302 00:17:30,169 --> 00:17:32,289 kind of a nature of the exponential. 303 00:17:32,389 --> 00:17:38,359 You know, two years ago we get the first inklings of GPT and people are 304 00:17:38,359 --> 00:17:41,559 like, ah, that's never gonna replace somebody who can write a good sentence. 305 00:17:42,179 --> 00:17:42,599 You sure? 306 00:17:42,959 --> 00:17:44,839 I think, do you know, do you know how exponential works? 307 00:17:45,199 --> 00:17:46,919 'cause that looked like 5%. 308 00:17:48,199 --> 00:17:50,359 But that'll be another 10 years before it's any good. 309 00:17:50,669 --> 00:17:50,959 Yeah. 310 00:17:50,959 --> 00:17:54,359 But you don't understand this is not a linear progression. 311 00:17:54,829 --> 00:17:55,959 This is exponential. 312 00:17:56,179 --> 00:17:58,159 And, and, and we we're starting to see that. 313 00:17:59,369 --> 00:18:03,019 Even more and more so with, with the rise of the la large language models, 314 00:18:03,079 --> 00:18:07,379 but then applying that in the, and, and seeing that in the visualization domain. 315 00:18:08,529 --> 00:18:13,139 It's, it's getting to the point where anybody should be able to visualize 316 00:18:13,419 --> 00:18:14,339 whatever they've got in their head. 317 00:18:15,149 --> 00:18:19,129 Um, and that's the kind of expectation, but that's also the challenge of 318 00:18:19,159 --> 00:18:23,699 what was in your head, because is what you're seeing on the screen 319 00:18:24,299 --> 00:18:28,499 Kame out of a latent space of, uh, a stability or a mid journey? 320 00:18:29,039 --> 00:18:31,099 Is that what you really had in mind? 321 00:18:31,479 --> 00:18:34,739 Or is that just what you're seeing out of, end of a prompt and you kind of 322 00:18:34,739 --> 00:18:36,779 say to yourself, yeah, yeah, that's what I had in mind. 323 00:18:37,159 --> 00:18:38,739 And I think that's, that's, 324 00:18:38,739 --> 00:18:40,339 that's that's the real challenge, right? 325 00:18:40,614 --> 00:18:40,904 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 326 00:18:40,934 --> 00:18:42,514 Roderick Bates: But that's the challenge for us too, right? 327 00:18:42,514 --> 00:18:44,874 It's, it's threading that needle between those two pieces. 328 00:18:45,134 --> 00:18:50,114 How do we as a company ride that exponential curve, uh, or exponential 329 00:18:50,114 --> 00:18:54,834 growth and or alternatively, how do we avoid becoming cast to the wayside 330 00:18:54,834 --> 00:18:58,714 and becoming like the, the telephone switchboard operators of your right? 331 00:18:59,154 --> 00:19:01,554 I mean, that's the, the challenge that we have. 332 00:19:01,574 --> 00:19:04,954 And I think what's great about having someone like him here who's been tracking 333 00:19:04,984 --> 00:19:09,794 this industry for so long is that it puts us in a position to sort of ride 334 00:19:09,794 --> 00:19:14,474 the lightning, so to speak here as opposed to, uh, becoming a, a dinosaur. 335 00:19:14,534 --> 00:19:17,674 And it's really put us into a much more proactive position, 336 00:19:18,404 --> 00:19:21,954 thank goodness, because it frankly will be an industry that will be 337 00:19:21,954 --> 00:19:23,994 fundamentally different in a few years. 338 00:19:25,209 --> 00:19:25,909 Kam Star: We, we, we 339 00:19:25,909 --> 00:19:26,069 owe 340 00:19:26,109 --> 00:19:29,469 Evan Troxel: to think about how fast this has come on, and I mean. 341 00:19:29,994 --> 00:19:33,284 Real-time rendering isn't that old, and you're already talking about it, 342 00:19:33,284 --> 00:19:35,264 like it could be thrown to the wayside. 343 00:19:35,499 --> 00:19:40,519 And because new technologies have come along and that, that timeframe 344 00:19:40,519 --> 00:19:44,519 just keeps getting shorter and shorter and shorter of what is the, the, the 345 00:19:44,519 --> 00:19:46,759 next wave, uh, that, that's coming. 346 00:19:46,939 --> 00:19:50,759 That's, it's very interesting to see that happen at play out during our lifetimes 347 00:19:51,104 --> 00:19:53,404 Roderick Bates: And I, I think that's the question too. 348 00:19:53,404 --> 00:19:57,124 Like I say, is it cast to the wayside or has this become a combination of the two? 349 00:19:57,134 --> 00:19:57,484 Right. 350 00:19:57,484 --> 00:20:01,804 Sort of this, this Borg, if you will, half human, uh, half AI type 351 00:20:01,804 --> 00:20:02,324 interface. 352 00:20:02,344 --> 00:20:06,444 And I think from our perspective, that gets to what Kam was talking about, where 353 00:20:06,444 --> 00:20:10,004 there's the real opportunity there is like, is this exactly what you intended? 354 00:20:10,584 --> 00:20:14,524 You know, there's no way that a machine can infer intent necessarily, right? 355 00:20:14,594 --> 00:20:16,964 It's just, you know, that's, that's in the mind of the designer. 356 00:20:17,504 --> 00:20:19,524 But at the same time, there's so many things that we're 357 00:20:19,524 --> 00:20:20,764 seeing that AI does faster, 358 00:20:21,394 --> 00:20:25,644 just faster, um, and it has all that experience. 359 00:20:25,644 --> 00:20:28,244 So how do you combine those two pieces effectively? 360 00:20:29,184 --> 00:20:33,164 To help our users get to where they want their visualization, they want 361 00:20:33,264 --> 00:20:35,484 as faster or as quickly as possible. 362 00:20:36,224 --> 00:20:39,884 And I think that's really the angle that that we're taking with this, is that 363 00:20:39,884 --> 00:20:44,524 it's the combination of those two forces that has the best opportunity for success 364 00:20:44,624 --> 00:20:46,524 as opposed to complete supplanting. 365 00:20:47,244 --> 00:20:51,164 Although I do think there will be a lot of, of replacement of things that 366 00:20:51,224 --> 00:20:55,484 are, say very low quality or tools that are very crude and things like that. 367 00:20:55,504 --> 00:20:57,444 And then why not just go for a full AI 368 00:20:57,724 --> 00:20:58,364 solution if it's better? 369 00:20:58,674 --> 00:20:59,094 Evan Troxel: mm-Hmm. 370 00:20:59,874 --> 00:21:02,254 Kam Star: And the expectation keeps rising, you know, the 371 00:21:02,254 --> 00:21:07,374 expectation of variety, the exp expectation of, of insight. 372 00:21:08,034 --> 00:21:13,374 Um, one of the things that we saw pretty much out of the gate where instability 373 00:21:13,514 --> 00:21:17,454 and, and, and, and, uh, mid journey were in the early phases, and I don't think 374 00:21:17,454 --> 00:21:18,974 they're in their late phases, by the way. 375 00:21:19,254 --> 00:21:23,814 I we're still in the relative early phases, but, you know, a year ago, 376 00:21:24,874 --> 00:21:29,334 the, the, those who were, uh, blazing a trail in this space were already 377 00:21:29,344 --> 00:21:31,134 using these tools for ideation. 378 00:21:31,644 --> 00:21:33,214 They were already using them to generate. 379 00:21:34,144 --> 00:21:39,304 A whole variety of very interesting looking things, some of which you 380 00:21:39,304 --> 00:21:42,984 definitely would never be able or maybe never would want to build. 381 00:21:43,724 --> 00:21:48,704 Uh, but you know, they would defy gravity, uh, or, you know, just the, 382 00:21:48,724 --> 00:21:51,344 the pure laws of physics or usability. 383 00:21:52,364 --> 00:21:58,504 Um, and, and, and as we, we are seeing more and more focused effort in this space 384 00:21:58,854 --> 00:22:04,784 from the use of generalized tools to more specifically, specifically trained tools 385 00:22:04,814 --> 00:22:08,504 that, you know, you, you could take a, a, a latent space, an image generation, 386 00:22:08,504 --> 00:22:14,104 and then train it on a particular, um, artist or a particular architect 387 00:22:14,364 --> 00:22:16,784 or a particular designer's works. 388 00:22:17,564 --> 00:22:20,664 Um, and if, depending on how deep you go, you could get to the 389 00:22:20,664 --> 00:22:24,584 point where you could then say, okay, now apply it to this shape. 390 00:22:24,764 --> 00:22:30,144 Now apply it to this design where this kind of a design style transfer. 391 00:22:30,884 --> 00:22:32,984 And we we're starting to see that, um. 392 00:22:34,574 --> 00:22:41,654 I, I was playing today, uh, with a, with a video video remix that is open 393 00:22:41,654 --> 00:22:42,894 source, that's just been released. 394 00:22:43,444 --> 00:22:44,414 It's on hugging face. 395 00:22:44,434 --> 00:22:48,534 You can kind of play with it, uh, where you can put in an input video. 396 00:22:49,434 --> 00:22:51,614 Um, and that could be anything that you like. 397 00:22:51,614 --> 00:22:57,094 And then you can put in a prompt, um, and it will take that video and it will then 398 00:22:57,854 --> 00:22:59,734 reimagine that video with your prompt. 399 00:22:59,914 --> 00:23:05,694 So I took, uh, the, the, one of the, um, samples that it has is a wolf 400 00:23:05,714 --> 00:23:08,854 that's kind of looking, it's a real wolf out in the wilderness that's looking 401 00:23:08,854 --> 00:23:15,174 around, and you can just put in a prawn sheep and it turns the wolf into a 402 00:23:15,184 --> 00:23:17,774 sheep, but the sheep is still outside. 403 00:23:17,964 --> 00:23:20,494 It's still in the same environment, it has the same lighting, 404 00:23:21,574 --> 00:23:22,734 the sheep is looking around. 405 00:23:23,034 --> 00:23:24,614 So you just replace the subject. 406 00:23:25,704 --> 00:23:27,604 Um, I think that's it. 407 00:23:27,604 --> 00:23:33,244 This, this creates an enormous opportunity for even further democratization. 408 00:23:33,314 --> 00:23:37,524 It's then, and I don't mean just for the users that we have today, but for great 409 00:23:37,634 --> 00:23:40,764 many new people to be able to experiment. 410 00:23:41,424 --> 00:23:48,044 Um, not just with visuals, but you know, crossing this chasm that 411 00:23:48,044 --> 00:23:53,044 we have right now, we've, we've got words that can be wordsmith. 412 00:23:53,654 --> 00:23:56,844 We've got images that can be image smith, I dunno if that's a word, 413 00:23:56,984 --> 00:23:58,404 but, you know, generated images. 414 00:23:58,734 --> 00:24:00,404 We've got video being generated. 415 00:24:00,894 --> 00:24:04,764 There are a few startups and few, you know, on the, on the very 416 00:24:04,854 --> 00:24:06,724 edges who are now creating 3D. 417 00:24:07,154 --> 00:24:10,844 Because when it comes down to, and that's, that's again, that's all okay. 418 00:24:11,584 --> 00:24:15,724 Um, in terms of something that's beautiful to look at. 419 00:24:16,594 --> 00:24:20,294 But if you are a designer and you, you work with the real world. 420 00:24:21,449 --> 00:24:24,739 with real physics and real materials that need to be joined together 421 00:24:25,519 --> 00:24:30,339 and things that actually need to work there, there is something more 422 00:24:30,889 --> 00:24:33,019 than just the pure latent space. 423 00:24:33,279 --> 00:24:34,299 The generative space. 424 00:24:34,299 --> 00:24:37,259 Something more that needs to be added into these models. 425 00:24:37,489 --> 00:24:40,219 It's not that it's not coming, it's not that people haven't thought it. 426 00:24:40,919 --> 00:24:45,819 Um, it's certainly on, you know, the, the, the, the sharpest minds who are working 427 00:24:45,839 --> 00:24:50,579 in this space are fully aware that the models to come will not only be able to 428 00:24:50,779 --> 00:24:54,499 generate images for you, but they'll also have a deep understanding of the physical 429 00:24:54,499 --> 00:25:00,019 world and how things work in the physical world and how reality actually operates. 430 00:25:00,759 --> 00:25:00,979 Um, 431 00:25:01,559 --> 00:25:01,779 we 432 00:25:01,779 --> 00:25:02,059 haven't 433 00:25:02,109 --> 00:25:03,429 Roderick Bates: doesn't have to be complicated, right? 434 00:25:03,549 --> 00:25:06,229 I mean, we're talking about things like water management in 435 00:25:06,229 --> 00:25:07,189 the case of buildings, right? 436 00:25:07,189 --> 00:25:07,509 You know, 437 00:25:07,669 --> 00:25:08,989 , um, structural loads. 438 00:25:09,029 --> 00:25:11,989 I mean, these are things that they're not, at least in the context of 439 00:25:12,109 --> 00:25:13,669 buildings, terribly complicated. 440 00:25:14,389 --> 00:25:16,389 I mean, there's a limited number of parameters that have to 441 00:25:16,389 --> 00:25:17,509 be taken into consideration. 442 00:25:18,149 --> 00:25:18,269 I. 443 00:25:18,819 --> 00:25:20,839 Evan Troxel: And those have been solved time and time again. 444 00:25:20,839 --> 00:25:21,119 Right? 445 00:25:21,119 --> 00:25:24,079 Like the, the engineering side of it that you're referencing 446 00:25:24,079 --> 00:25:26,479 there, it, it has a set of rules. 447 00:25:26,699 --> 00:25:29,399 And I think that was something in architecture that we were always 448 00:25:30,319 --> 00:25:34,049 kind of aware of tangentially, which was, you know, that Kam, to go 449 00:25:34,049 --> 00:25:36,609 back to one of your points earlier, it's like, this is never gonna take 450 00:25:36,609 --> 00:25:38,409 over the, the job of a creative. 451 00:25:38,459 --> 00:25:38,809 Right. 452 00:25:38,869 --> 00:25:42,529 And now, like the things that we're seeing come out of it are absolutely 453 00:25:42,849 --> 00:25:45,289 creative in ways that we didn't expect. 454 00:25:45,869 --> 00:25:49,874 and and I think, you know, one of the, one of the big I don't wanna call 455 00:25:49,874 --> 00:25:53,234 it a lie, but one of the things that we believed was like the engineering 456 00:25:53,234 --> 00:25:55,194 problems were solvable by automation. 457 00:25:55,474 --> 00:26:00,914 A lot more so than the creative problems being solved through systems like this. 458 00:26:01,074 --> 00:26:05,034 I mean, AI is not automation, but it's, it's also not too 459 00:26:05,174 --> 00:26:06,914 far divorce from automation. 460 00:26:06,914 --> 00:26:08,634 Like, you can, you can tie those things together. 461 00:26:08,794 --> 00:26:12,394 I think it's really interesting to see this come and you chaos. 462 00:26:12,544 --> 00:26:16,474 Inscape is concerned about its future, uh, developing products 463 00:26:16,474 --> 00:26:17,594 that are used by people. 464 00:26:18,914 --> 00:26:20,194 professionals are too, right? 465 00:26:20,194 --> 00:26:23,394 Like we're, we're, we're also concerned about it uprooting 466 00:26:24,224 --> 00:26:25,874 what we do, what we deliver. 467 00:26:26,034 --> 00:26:30,314 I think one of the things that, I had a long conversation yesterday about 468 00:26:30,614 --> 00:26:34,354 the new era of spatial computing that is, you know, uh, branded 469 00:26:34,354 --> 00:26:35,114 by Apple and. 470 00:26:35,134 --> 00:26:40,234 and it's now landing and the the headsets are, are going to become a 471 00:26:40,234 --> 00:26:44,314 lot more, I don't know, there's just gonna be a lot more of them out there. 472 00:26:45,909 --> 00:26:48,849 The way that people are going to spend more time in these environments 473 00:26:48,909 --> 00:26:52,889 and creating these digital environments is going to then inform 474 00:26:53,309 --> 00:26:54,809 the physical world once again. 475 00:26:54,809 --> 00:26:55,049 Right? 476 00:26:55,049 --> 00:26:58,689 People are gonna come out of these headsets and absolutely 477 00:26:58,709 --> 00:27:02,289 be disappointed in the office that they are sitting in, right? 478 00:27:02,839 --> 00:27:03,489 They, they are. 479 00:27:03,519 --> 00:27:08,529 I've, I've already experienced that many years ago, being inside of my designs 480 00:27:08,529 --> 00:27:11,729 in a VR headset and then coming back out into my office and it's like, well, it 481 00:27:11,729 --> 00:27:13,369 was better in there and it wasn't perfect. 482 00:27:13,549 --> 00:27:20,129 It wasn't even photorealistic, but it was good enough to really make me feel like I 483 00:27:20,129 --> 00:27:27,449 was there and, and that is going to inform the physical world in substantial ways. 484 00:27:27,609 --> 00:27:27,809 I think. 485 00:27:27,809 --> 00:27:30,889 Like we're going to go into these environments that are going to be created 486 00:27:31,029 --> 00:27:34,129 and they're gonna be augmented with tools and AI and all of these things. 487 00:27:34,159 --> 00:27:38,529 Like maybe we define the base and then it fills in details and we're 488 00:27:38,529 --> 00:27:39,609 gonna come back out and be like. 489 00:27:40,564 --> 00:27:43,084 I wanna do something like that here, because it's just like 490 00:27:43,084 --> 00:27:44,564 what Covid did to the office. 491 00:27:44,674 --> 00:27:46,564 Like, I don't have a gym in my house. 492 00:27:46,784 --> 00:27:47,644 It was at the office. 493 00:27:47,904 --> 00:27:49,764 Now I want a gym in my house, right? 494 00:27:49,764 --> 00:27:51,564 Because this is where I'm spending my time. 495 00:27:52,204 --> 00:27:55,764 I don't think it's gonna be unlike that with the influence that it's 496 00:27:55,764 --> 00:27:58,404 gonna have and the impact it's gonna have back on the physical world. 497 00:27:58,704 --> 00:28:04,164 And, and so to see this technology develop and especially at the pace that 498 00:28:04,164 --> 00:28:07,924 it's developing, I think it's going to start, it's, it's gonna create new 499 00:28:07,924 --> 00:28:09,324 opportunities that have never existed. 500 00:28:09,504 --> 00:28:12,924 We, we will be spending more time designing digital environments 501 00:28:12,954 --> 00:28:16,804 just for digital environment's sake, just to go there, call 502 00:28:16,804 --> 00:28:19,444 it escapism, call it the design 503 00:28:19,444 --> 00:28:19,804 challenge 504 00:28:19,904 --> 00:28:22,064 Roderick Bates: you're saying that, um, rumors of the Metaverse 505 00:28:22,244 --> 00:28:24,384 demise were greatly exaggerated 506 00:28:24,534 --> 00:28:24,654 Evan Troxel: I 507 00:28:25,789 --> 00:28:26,689 Kam Star: We can see it, you can 508 00:28:26,689 --> 00:28:27,049 see it in, 509 00:28:27,174 --> 00:28:28,334 Evan Troxel: I think you could speak to that 510 00:28:28,849 --> 00:28:32,749 Kam Star: We could see it in the way our kids, um, you know, um, and if you 511 00:28:32,749 --> 00:28:37,029 have kids of a certain age, they are probably really engaged with Minecraft 512 00:28:37,289 --> 00:28:39,109 or with one of the other world building 513 00:28:39,649 --> 00:28:41,749 things, and they invite their 514 00:28:41,894 --> 00:28:43,114 Roderick Bates: And they're playing with people. 515 00:28:43,384 --> 00:28:47,194 Like for my kids, they have, uh, family members, you know, all over the place 516 00:28:47,534 --> 00:28:49,114 and they play with them. 517 00:28:49,354 --> 00:28:51,954 I think roadblocks is sort of their preferred platform mostly. 518 00:28:52,154 --> 00:28:55,154 'cause it's the easiest one to collaborate with, although it's not necessarily 519 00:28:55,154 --> 00:28:56,834 their preferred platform to play in. 520 00:28:57,414 --> 00:28:59,834 Uh, but it's easiest one to play together and, and 521 00:28:59,899 --> 00:29:00,719 Evan Troxel: Mm mm-Hmm. 522 00:29:00,914 --> 00:29:02,874 Roderick Bates: sort of like their, the neighborhood sandbox, 523 00:29:02,894 --> 00:29:05,794 so to speak, which is pretty wild Fortnite as they get older. 524 00:29:06,014 --> 00:29:07,354 Um, similar functionality. 525 00:29:08,254 --> 00:29:09,434 So what is it for the office? 526 00:29:09,909 --> 00:29:10,329 Evan Troxel: Mm-Hmm. 527 00:29:10,824 --> 00:29:13,264 Roderick Bates: I mean, if the kids can spend hours in Fortnite, I'm 528 00:29:13,344 --> 00:29:15,584 assuming there's an office that I wouldn't mind spending hours and, 529 00:29:16,799 --> 00:29:17,089 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 530 00:29:17,089 --> 00:29:17,369 And I 531 00:29:17,469 --> 00:29:17,829 Kam Star: do you think, 532 00:29:17,829 --> 00:29:22,989 do you think in 10 years time we will, we won't be asked to prepare 533 00:29:23,069 --> 00:29:26,629 a PowerPoint presentation or that we won't be asking somebody to, 534 00:29:26,809 --> 00:29:28,629 to put together a set of slides? 535 00:29:29,469 --> 00:29:30,029 I really hope. 536 00:29:30,429 --> 00:29:30,949 I really hope 537 00:29:30,949 --> 00:29:31,149 we 538 00:29:31,169 --> 00:29:31,529 Evan Troxel: hope so. 539 00:29:31,559 --> 00:29:31,849 Yeah. 540 00:29:31,974 --> 00:29:32,424 Roderick Bates: Well, it's, 541 00:29:32,469 --> 00:29:33,069 Kam Star: nothing against 542 00:29:33,144 --> 00:29:34,264 Roderick Bates: with our customers though, 543 00:29:34,349 --> 00:29:37,389 Kam Star: presentation, but it's just like, come on, there's gotta be a better 544 00:29:37,404 --> 00:29:38,944 Roderick Bates: We have, uh, we have a customer. 545 00:29:39,014 --> 00:29:43,104 It's a fairly large construction firm, and I was talking to them about how they use 546 00:29:43,104 --> 00:29:46,584 our software just to get a better sense of how that particular market segment, 547 00:29:47,404 --> 00:29:50,904 um, utilizes visualization and you knows a lot of the things you'd expect. 548 00:29:51,044 --> 00:29:55,024 Um, you know, they have a little bit of a, a business that actually designs 549 00:29:55,224 --> 00:29:58,024 buildings, so they have to respond, but they also do logistics and testing. 550 00:29:58,244 --> 00:30:01,104 Can we drive trucks around or fit behind certain equipment? 551 00:30:01,404 --> 00:30:04,944 But the one that really caught my attention is they actually used, uh, 552 00:30:04,944 --> 00:30:06,904 the scape software to visualize data. 553 00:30:07,324 --> 00:30:10,744 So if they had an RFP response and it was like a, a really boring graph 554 00:30:10,744 --> 00:30:13,984 or something like that, or some type of like a, a Gantt chart or 555 00:30:13,984 --> 00:30:17,944 something, instead of just putting it in the RFP, they would have a link. 556 00:30:18,164 --> 00:30:21,664 The person would scan it and then they would go to an immersive view of the data. 557 00:30:22,004 --> 00:30:26,184 And they said, it really doesn't help the data communication all that much. 558 00:30:26,294 --> 00:30:28,664 It's the same data, but we found that people actually 559 00:30:28,664 --> 00:30:30,344 looked at it once we did this. 560 00:30:30,344 --> 00:30:32,184 Whereas before, they'd just be like, eh, 561 00:30:32,644 --> 00:30:33,664 you know, next 562 00:30:33,799 --> 00:30:34,199 Evan Troxel: of the same. 563 00:30:34,509 --> 00:30:34,799 Yeah. 564 00:30:34,829 --> 00:30:35,119 Yeah. 565 00:30:35,119 --> 00:30:36,199 Because it's not the same. 566 00:30:36,259 --> 00:30:39,719 And I, I, I find that being, that's a really intriguing 567 00:30:39,719 --> 00:30:40,919 thing that's, that's happening. 568 00:30:42,455 --> 00:30:45,635 This episode is made possible with support from AVAIL. 569 00:30:45,995 --> 00:30:49,835 In a world where precision meets creativity, where every line drawn, 570 00:30:49,835 --> 00:30:53,405 holds the power to innovate people like you are shaping the future, but 571 00:30:53,405 --> 00:30:55,625 let's face it in the realm of design. 572 00:30:55,655 --> 00:30:58,295 The unknown is your least favorite companion. 573 00:30:58,745 --> 00:31:03,035 You've been stranded on the island of inefficient software, lost in the fog of 574 00:31:03,035 --> 00:31:05,015 endless searching for the right content. 575 00:31:05,375 --> 00:31:08,945 It's time to embark on a new journey, a journey to clarity, 576 00:31:09,155 --> 00:31:11,315 efficiency, and design excellence. 577 00:31:11,585 --> 00:31:14,435 It's time to get off that island and away from the unknown. 578 00:31:14,945 --> 00:31:18,395 Introducing AVAIL, the beacon in your design Odyssey. 579 00:31:18,695 --> 00:31:22,775 Say goodbye to the daunting 10 to 20 minutes wasted per search. 580 00:31:22,955 --> 00:31:25,625 The costly interruptions in your creative flow. 581 00:31:25,952 --> 00:31:29,882 With avail, your team will zip through content discovery, focusing more 582 00:31:29,882 --> 00:31:31,772 on designing and less on searching. 583 00:31:32,762 --> 00:31:36,152 a world where you can stop constantly fighting the costly fires caused 584 00:31:36,152 --> 00:31:39,392 by pulling content from past projects, building from scratch. 585 00:31:39,632 --> 00:31:41,582 Or relying on personal libraries. 586 00:31:41,942 --> 00:31:43,472 AVAIL isn't just a tool. 587 00:31:43,472 --> 00:31:48,122 It's a revolution for AECO firms, organize, manage, and navigate 588 00:31:48,122 --> 00:31:51,332 your project information with a leader that's proven in reliability 589 00:31:51,572 --> 00:31:53,462 relate-ability and success. 590 00:31:53,792 --> 00:31:56,042 Join the ranks of the top AECO firms. 591 00:31:56,042 --> 00:31:57,572 Who've already chosen a veil. 592 00:31:57,962 --> 00:32:01,322 And just 30 days you could deploy a veil and witness a dramatic 593 00:32:01,322 --> 00:32:03,032 reduction in costly design errors. 594 00:32:03,362 --> 00:32:06,242 Whether it's your first CMS or you're considering a switch. 595 00:32:06,512 --> 00:32:10,982 There is someone you should meet Will Rouse, your guide to all things AVAIL. 596 00:32:11,282 --> 00:32:15,032 Schedule an appointment and explore AVAIL's capabilities, onboarding 597 00:32:15,032 --> 00:32:17,342 programs, and professional services. 598 00:32:17,702 --> 00:32:20,222 Don't let your designs be clouded by inefficiency. 599 00:32:20,462 --> 00:32:22,412 Clear skies are just a click away. 600 00:32:22,682 --> 00:32:28,052 Go to getavail.com/stranded and book a meeting with Will to 601 00:32:28,052 --> 00:32:29,972 start your AVAIL journey today. 602 00:32:30,482 --> 00:32:33,962 AVAIL, where your best design is just a search away. 603 00:32:34,506 --> 00:32:38,136 My thanks to AVAIL for supporting this episode of the TRXL podcast. 604 00:32:38,526 --> 00:32:40,536 And now let's get back to the conversation. 605 00:32:41,513 --> 00:32:45,813 One of the, the things that I was reading about, uh, just, just yesterday, I think, 606 00:32:45,813 --> 00:32:49,813 is that on the, on the Apple Vision Pro, there's a Disney Plus app, and the Disney 607 00:32:50,083 --> 00:32:52,693 Plus app lets you watch a Star Wars movie. 608 00:32:53,663 --> 00:32:57,763 In a Star Wars setting, so you can actually be sitting in Luke's land 609 00:32:57,763 --> 00:33:02,883 speeder and watching Star Wars and, and it's like, I've seen that move before. 610 00:33:03,013 --> 00:33:03,363 Right? 611 00:33:03,523 --> 00:33:07,523 I, I've, I've watched it many times, but I've never watched it like that. 612 00:33:07,863 --> 00:33:12,643 And I, I feel like there's going to be a lot of, and people might say, 613 00:33:12,643 --> 00:33:14,243 well, you know, it's just novelty. 614 00:33:14,393 --> 00:33:16,203 It's like, well, and that's okay. 615 00:33:16,293 --> 00:33:16,643 Right. 616 00:33:16,723 --> 00:33:17,323 I, I feel 617 00:33:17,323 --> 00:33:17,483 like 618 00:33:17,483 --> 00:33:17,843 this is 619 00:33:18,053 --> 00:33:18,413 Roderick Bates: has value. 620 00:33:18,453 --> 00:33:19,333 I mean, people go to a bar 621 00:33:19,333 --> 00:33:20,053 to watch the game. 622 00:33:21,033 --> 00:33:21,383 Evan Troxel: Right, 623 00:33:21,483 --> 00:33:21,773 Roderick Bates: Yeah. 624 00:33:22,133 --> 00:33:22,483 Evan Troxel: right. 625 00:33:22,633 --> 00:33:26,443 It's, it's gonna be a thing where there's gonna be new layers of fun. 626 00:33:27,143 --> 00:33:27,443 You know? 627 00:33:27,543 --> 00:33:28,603 It won't be a dirty word. 628 00:33:28,603 --> 00:33:31,643 It'll be like, no, it's, that's, that's why I go, that's why I participate. 629 00:33:31,643 --> 00:33:34,483 That's why I'm here is 'cause I wanna have fun doing it. 630 00:33:34,483 --> 00:33:36,963 Because you've found a creative way to communicate these ideas. 631 00:33:37,063 --> 00:33:41,203 To me, I think that there is, there's so much untapped potential 632 00:33:41,623 --> 00:33:43,713 Roderick Bates: Well, I guess the gamification you're talking 633 00:33:43,713 --> 00:33:46,313 about, Kam, you know, can we make all of this more engaging, 634 00:33:46,863 --> 00:33:47,083 Evan Troxel: Mm. 635 00:33:47,573 --> 00:33:47,793 Roderick Bates: not 636 00:33:47,938 --> 00:33:51,498 Kam Star: much, how much engagement is too much engagement though, because, uh, 637 00:33:51,838 --> 00:33:58,778 you know, as, as, as, uh, at some point engagement becomes passe because, 638 00:33:59,198 --> 00:34:04,738 and I'm starting to see that a little bit just in the AI news space, you 639 00:34:04,738 --> 00:34:07,218 know, like, Hey look, we can do this. 640 00:34:07,678 --> 00:34:10,418 And literally five minutes later, ah, yeah, we can do that. 641 00:34:10,958 --> 00:34:12,378 Uh, what else have you got? 642 00:34:12,757 --> 00:34:13,058 You know? 643 00:34:13,058 --> 00:34:14,777 And then a day later we can do this. 644 00:34:15,128 --> 00:34:20,898 Yeah, I was, I was, this week on Monday, I was talking to, um, our head of ai, 645 00:34:21,398 --> 00:34:23,697 uh, Jan Ring, who's just an awesome guy. 646 00:34:24,277 --> 00:34:28,658 And, you know, we were, we were having a bit of a debate, not too dissimilar 647 00:34:28,757 --> 00:34:31,938 to right now, we were talking about the, the, we were talking about the 648 00:34:31,938 --> 00:34:34,898 vision of five-year vision and the kind of, where is this space going? 649 00:34:34,947 --> 00:34:37,697 Especially well in that conversation it was about, about 650 00:34:37,898 --> 00:34:40,618 VFX space and and making movies. 651 00:34:41,993 --> 00:34:46,172 And, and I was saying to Dan, you know, there's, there's this trajectory that 652 00:34:46,563 --> 00:34:52,213 that basically means that most of what we consider is, is a workflow Right now. 653 00:34:52,803 --> 00:34:56,773 It's kind of, oh wow, you're still doing it like that you 654 00:34:56,773 --> 00:34:58,813 know, kind of, that's, wow. 655 00:34:59,033 --> 00:35:05,013 Do you really have to put ink in your, you know, in your quill pen to, to write? 656 00:35:05,353 --> 00:35:07,453 That's, um, that's interesting. 657 00:35:07,993 --> 00:35:09,413 Um, because, you know, 658 00:35:09,518 --> 00:35:09,798 Evan Troxel: say that. 659 00:35:09,958 --> 00:35:13,318 I, this is not an ad, but yeah, I've, I've got my bottle of ink right here 660 00:35:13,393 --> 00:35:13,983 Kam Star: there you go. 661 00:35:14,313 --> 00:35:14,903 there you go. 662 00:35:15,643 --> 00:35:15,863 And 663 00:35:16,063 --> 00:35:17,103 Roderick Bates: Only for the best ideas. 664 00:35:17,283 --> 00:35:17,743 Kam Star: for the best. 665 00:35:18,578 --> 00:35:18,998 Evan Troxel: that's 666 00:35:18,998 --> 00:35:20,078 a bottle of ideas right there. 667 00:35:20,078 --> 00:35:20,358 Yeah. 668 00:35:21,263 --> 00:35:21,753 Kam Star: Amazing. 669 00:35:22,273 --> 00:35:22,713 I like that. 670 00:35:22,713 --> 00:35:23,273 That's good. 671 00:35:23,493 --> 00:35:24,833 That's, that's spot on. 672 00:35:25,373 --> 00:35:29,473 And, and lo and behold, we were having this debate around control. 673 00:35:29,713 --> 00:35:32,153 'cause one of the things that a lot of our customers tell 674 00:35:32,153 --> 00:35:34,233 us is, I want to have control. 675 00:35:34,873 --> 00:35:35,953 I want to be able to specify 676 00:35:36,863 --> 00:35:38,553 exactly the thing that I want. 677 00:35:38,613 --> 00:35:40,473 And just for, for the machine. 678 00:35:41,098 --> 00:35:46,798 For my copilot to not just take the plane and take it to some place I didn't want 679 00:35:46,798 --> 00:35:49,558 to go to just take care of the boring bits 680 00:35:49,858 --> 00:35:52,638 the bits that it's kind of going a bit flat or I'm just gonna get tired 681 00:35:52,698 --> 00:35:55,838 and, you know, and, and, and I don't even necessarily want it to take me 682 00:35:55,838 --> 00:35:57,278 to a land I'd never known before. 683 00:35:57,958 --> 00:36:00,558 I kind of want to go where I want to go and I want my 684 00:36:00,588 --> 00:36:02,078 copilot to be there to help me. 685 00:36:02,858 --> 00:36:06,358 And, and we were having this debate about a, a a a startup that's 686 00:36:06,358 --> 00:36:13,518 kind of doing ideas to video and Oh, well, yes, temporarily, not 687 00:36:13,758 --> 00:36:14,998 entirely as consistent it should be. 688 00:36:15,458 --> 00:36:19,358 You know, and that's by, by that I mean, you know, over a period of 15 seconds, 689 00:36:19,858 --> 00:36:21,278 the character can change a little bit. 690 00:36:21,278 --> 00:36:22,598 The background can change a little bit. 691 00:36:22,628 --> 00:36:23,478 It's a bit different. 692 00:36:24,218 --> 00:36:29,038 Um, and, and, and I, I don't really have control on which direction 693 00:36:29,038 --> 00:36:32,318 this thing is going 'cause it's just generating something and, uh. 694 00:36:33,368 --> 00:36:35,118 Quite literally the next day. 695 00:36:35,498 --> 00:36:38,638 So this had that conversation on the Monday, on Tuesday, there was 696 00:36:38,678 --> 00:36:42,638 a announcement by this particular company saying, now you can 697 00:36:42,638 --> 00:36:44,918 control like how things are moving. 698 00:36:45,308 --> 00:36:49,358 Like, and, and you can control these things and decide what the trajectory 699 00:36:49,358 --> 00:36:50,798 within on, you know, on screen is. 700 00:36:51,698 --> 00:36:54,678 And I'm sending this to Dan and saying, Dan, you know, the thing 701 00:36:54,678 --> 00:36:57,558 that we talked about on Monday looks like they've solved it. 702 00:36:57,818 --> 00:36:59,958 And literally today we were having a conversation. 703 00:36:59,958 --> 00:37:00,798 Is it, is, it is. 704 00:37:00,818 --> 00:37:01,038 No. 705 00:37:01,038 --> 00:37:04,358 Yesterday we were having a conversation, so like a day after. 706 00:37:05,138 --> 00:37:08,838 And it, for both of us, it's, it's already like, yeah, we can do that now, but yeah. 707 00:37:08,838 --> 00:37:10,518 But what we really need, right? 708 00:37:10,938 --> 00:37:11,158 And, 709 00:37:11,348 --> 00:37:11,638 Roderick Bates: Yeah. 710 00:37:11,638 --> 00:37:12,918 That goalpost keeps moving, 711 00:37:13,168 --> 00:37:13,388 Kam Star: it? 712 00:37:13,388 --> 00:37:13,868 keeps moving. 713 00:37:13,928 --> 00:37:16,828 But what seems, what, what, what, what you gotta remember when you 714 00:37:16,828 --> 00:37:24,498 look at this space is whatever it is that you think it's not doing, don't 715 00:37:24,498 --> 00:37:27,218 say it can't do it, it just can't do 716 00:37:27,218 --> 00:37:27,338 it 717 00:37:27,578 --> 00:37:27,868 Evan Troxel: it's 718 00:37:27,868 --> 00:37:27,988 just 719 00:37:28,138 --> 00:37:30,458 Kam Star: And there's someone working on it right now so 720 00:37:30,458 --> 00:37:30,978 that it can. 721 00:37:31,703 --> 00:37:37,563 And it, and it will because there's no, there's no magic in being able 722 00:37:37,563 --> 00:37:42,523 to represent thinking, okay, maybe. 723 00:37:42,853 --> 00:37:43,803 Maybe that's a big thing. 724 00:37:43,903 --> 00:37:45,243 I'm not talking about consciousness here. 725 00:37:45,343 --> 00:37:48,283 I'm think I'm talking about kind of focused thinking around something, 726 00:37:48,343 --> 00:37:50,563 the kind of cogni cog cognition. 727 00:37:51,223 --> 00:37:55,203 So I'll leave consciousness to philosophers, just cognition, 728 00:37:55,273 --> 00:37:56,723 just thinking about something. 729 00:37:57,153 --> 00:38:03,163 There's no magic anymore in being able to systematize that because at the end of 730 00:38:03,163 --> 00:38:05,163 the day, what is our cognitive process? 731 00:38:06,153 --> 00:38:08,853 Our cognitive process is, is, can be described. 732 00:38:08,853 --> 00:38:13,173 It's not that dissimilar to what happens, you know, in the, in, in a, in the 733 00:38:13,173 --> 00:38:18,653 brains of a, um, a creature that lived several hundred million years ago. 734 00:38:18,833 --> 00:38:19,053 We, 735 00:38:19,313 --> 00:38:23,613 our brain physiology is still pretty much the same as the squid, you know, 736 00:38:23,753 --> 00:38:28,853 and, and, and it's not that different, of course, it's far more complex and it 737 00:38:28,853 --> 00:38:30,933 has many other aspects playing into it. 738 00:38:31,753 --> 00:38:37,493 Um, you know, one of the interesting things that I, I believe will probably, 739 00:38:38,033 --> 00:38:42,573 uh, win the Nobel Prize, hopefully I'll see it in my life, uh, is a, is 740 00:38:42,573 --> 00:38:48,693 an incredible piece of research, um, that has, has been carried out for, 741 00:38:48,833 --> 00:38:52,853 for, for a number of decades, which was just published last year at the end of 742 00:38:52,853 --> 00:38:58,253 last year in, in nature, where these researchers were very keen to understand 743 00:38:58,713 --> 00:39:01,453 the human brain and the nature of neurons. 744 00:39:01,953 --> 00:39:04,533 And many of us who are not in biology, including me. 745 00:39:05,283 --> 00:39:08,623 we kind of think, well, yeah, neurons, you know, these things that, synapses 746 00:39:08,623 --> 00:39:10,583 and connections and that's what it is. 747 00:39:11,243 --> 00:39:15,343 Um, well it turns out the human brain has, and this is what the 748 00:39:15,503 --> 00:39:19,543 research had published, they wanted to know how many different types of 749 00:39:19,683 --> 00:39:21,143 neuron are there in the human brain. 750 00:39:21,443 --> 00:39:23,943 And if you'd asked me before this, I would've gone, what do you 751 00:39:24,143 --> 00:39:25,303 mean it's just a neuron, right? 752 00:39:25,723 --> 00:39:26,343 It turns out 753 00:39:26,343 --> 00:39:34,223 that, you know, the average human brain has 3000 different kinds of neurons, 754 00:39:34,643 --> 00:39:36,343 and we don't actually know what, 755 00:39:36,973 --> 00:39:38,863 what, why are they different and how they all do. 756 00:39:38,863 --> 00:39:42,823 But we have 3000 different kinds of neurons that operate differently. 757 00:39:43,203 --> 00:39:46,383 Um, and it's almost like these neurons, you could kind of think 758 00:39:46,383 --> 00:39:47,743 of them as different appendages. 759 00:39:48,133 --> 00:39:49,703 Like we thought we had five fingers. 760 00:39:50,283 --> 00:39:52,663 It turns out we have 3000 different fingers. 761 00:39:53,403 --> 00:39:56,903 Um, and and not only that, what was really interesting about that 762 00:39:56,923 --> 00:40:03,063 was that the, um, the portion of the types of neurons that you have. 763 00:40:03,803 --> 00:40:08,063 Are as unique to you as your face and your fingerprint. 764 00:40:08,843 --> 00:40:14,263 So maybe I have 2% more of this kind of neuron and you 765 00:40:14,263 --> 00:40:16,143 know, one, 2% less than that. 766 00:40:16,683 --> 00:40:20,783 And this, these will have any huge impact on the way that we think and we 767 00:40:20,973 --> 00:40:25,703 feel and we experience the world, what we take in, what we can then produce. 768 00:40:26,563 --> 00:40:33,923 Um, and I'm sure that that at some point our systems and our mechanisms 769 00:40:34,023 --> 00:40:38,483 can be sophisticated enough to start to really model even some of those 770 00:40:38,913 --> 00:40:41,523 nuances of how these neurons can work. 771 00:40:41,523 --> 00:40:44,843 And again, this is not science fiction. 772 00:40:44,843 --> 00:40:47,763 There is some, some work in this space. 773 00:40:48,103 --> 00:40:53,083 New ways to think about neural networks, um, and new topologies. 774 00:40:54,328 --> 00:40:59,308 Get, get us close to this horrible feeling that the machine is alive. 775 00:41:00,048 --> 00:41:04,668 And you know, we, we are now in the domain of the conscious machines, uh, 776 00:41:04,873 --> 00:41:07,453 Roderick Bates: But maybe short of just being alive, that brings up 777 00:41:07,803 --> 00:41:11,453 some, one of the aspects of a lot of the AI tools that are out there 778 00:41:11,453 --> 00:41:12,653 is that they're, they're one flavor. 779 00:41:13,123 --> 00:41:19,918 They're one . Set of neuron types or maybe one proportion of neurons, and that's it. 780 00:41:19,918 --> 00:41:22,238 And it's like, you know, you don't get your version of these. 781 00:41:22,238 --> 00:41:24,038 And it gets to that idea of the training set. 782 00:41:24,038 --> 00:41:28,838 People want to be able to get the machine to think the way they want it to think 783 00:41:29,458 --> 00:41:30,878 in some way, shape, or form, right? 784 00:41:30,878 --> 00:41:33,238 They want to train it so that sort of, it's in their image 785 00:41:33,398 --> 00:41:34,558 maybe, or what have you. 786 00:41:35,378 --> 00:41:38,038 Uh, and it seems like that's a, a pretty fertile ground. 787 00:41:38,038 --> 00:41:40,798 And we actually got a lot of comments along those lines. 788 00:41:40,868 --> 00:41:43,878 Kam, at Autodesk University, we presented some of our concepts. 789 00:41:43,878 --> 00:41:46,518 People like, we like this, but we wanna make it ours. 790 00:41:47,098 --> 00:41:50,558 Um, and frankly, we get to some degree, the same feedback on our 791 00:41:50,558 --> 00:41:53,158 easier to use software scape. 792 00:41:53,578 --> 00:41:56,878 So people say, you know, like, great visualizations, but if I go into an 793 00:41:56,878 --> 00:42:01,278 interview and the last firm used scape and I'm using scape, sometimes people 794 00:42:01,278 --> 00:42:03,158 say, Hey, I, I saw that person before. 795 00:42:03,338 --> 00:42:06,198 Or, you know, the, the way it looks, the style, the sort of. 796 00:42:07,228 --> 00:42:07,718 It's similar. 797 00:42:08,178 --> 00:42:11,038 Um, and, and the mind picks that up and they wanna make, create 798 00:42:11,038 --> 00:42:12,158 something that's their own. 799 00:42:12,218 --> 00:42:16,438 So even though they're using a tool, they still want the individuality out of it. 800 00:42:17,063 --> 00:42:22,603 Evan Troxel: Well, I mean that is the final of democratized tools is that 801 00:42:22,603 --> 00:42:24,483 everybody has the same tools and therefore 802 00:42:24,483 --> 00:42:24,683 they 803 00:42:24,818 --> 00:42:26,538 Roderick Bates: Next thing you know, we're all wearing overalls and 804 00:42:26,538 --> 00:42:27,258 eating the same food. 805 00:42:27,288 --> 00:42:27,578 Yeah. 806 00:42:28,103 --> 00:42:30,373 Evan Troxel: we're all, we're all wearing black Nikes and 807 00:42:30,488 --> 00:42:30,778 Roderick Bates: Yeah, 808 00:42:30,903 --> 00:42:31,253 Evan Troxel: we're 809 00:42:31,438 --> 00:42:31,978 Roderick Bates: that's right. 810 00:42:33,098 --> 00:42:33,898 Drinking Kool-Aid. 811 00:42:34,763 --> 00:42:38,373 Evan Troxel: Well, Roderick, you, you mentioned, you brought it up, uh, we 812 00:42:38,423 --> 00:42:44,173 maybe, uh, prematurely announced the death of the Metaverse before it was time. 813 00:42:44,513 --> 00:42:46,893 Uh, where, where, are we with that? 814 00:42:46,893 --> 00:42:50,213 Because the last time that you and I talked on the podcast, it was really 815 00:42:50,223 --> 00:42:55,973 about tools, workflows, putting things into the metaverse, and, and 816 00:42:56,033 --> 00:43:00,133 now again, a new hardware is coming out where the interaction with 817 00:43:00,963 --> 00:43:04,013 digital space is, is going to change. 818 00:43:04,273 --> 00:43:06,773 And it's not like Apple's the first one there. 819 00:43:06,773 --> 00:43:10,293 Obviously there's been a lot going on there, but I do think that they're gonna, 820 00:43:10,593 --> 00:43:14,173 uh, they're going to present it very differently to people and it's gonna 821 00:43:14,383 --> 00:43:15,963 Roderick Bates: And they're not gonna call it the metaverse, 822 00:43:16,248 --> 00:43:16,538 Evan Troxel: They, 823 00:43:16,538 --> 00:43:17,258 they haven't yet. 824 00:43:17,348 --> 00:43:17,698 Right. 825 00:43:18,038 --> 00:43:21,978 Uh, and, and so and so where, where are we with, with that? 826 00:43:22,118 --> 00:43:24,658 I'm sure that you're still tracking that with your, your background 827 00:43:24,753 --> 00:43:27,333 Roderick Bates: For sure I'm tracking it and it's also still contentious. 828 00:43:27,373 --> 00:43:30,093 I know that Kam and I have different opinions on this, which is good, right. 829 00:43:30,093 --> 00:43:32,613 You know, you want to have some of that productive friction around it. 830 00:43:32,953 --> 00:43:35,333 But when I look at the, the larger industry, I mean, there's 831 00:43:35,333 --> 00:43:37,333 one thing that's obvious is no one's saying metaverse anymore. 832 00:43:37,333 --> 00:43:38,333 It's become a dirty word. 833 00:43:38,393 --> 00:43:42,813 Uh, if you look at the price of like a plot of land and, um, to central 834 00:43:42,883 --> 00:43:46,733 land, I think it's gone from like 9,000 down to a couple hundred dollars or 835 00:43:46,733 --> 00:43:48,133 something like that for a plot of land. 836 00:43:48,133 --> 00:43:49,293 Like, you know, if it was peaked down. 837 00:43:49,753 --> 00:43:53,933 So, um, clearly the, the people I've spoken the technical problems 838 00:43:53,933 --> 00:43:57,413 though, that I, I felt at the time were inhibiting some of the aspects 839 00:43:57,413 --> 00:43:58,453 of the metaverse was still there. 840 00:43:58,713 --> 00:44:01,933 You know, it still takes a lot of computational power to. 841 00:44:02,868 --> 00:44:04,478 Support an environment like that. 842 00:44:05,058 --> 00:44:06,838 Um, and that hasn't changed. 843 00:44:07,098 --> 00:44:08,678 And so what do you have in a metaverse? 844 00:44:08,678 --> 00:44:11,598 Well, you, you have a place of, visually speaking just isn't 845 00:44:11,618 --> 00:44:12,918 as compelling as it should be. 846 00:44:12,918 --> 00:44:16,038 You know, compared to a video game environment, it's pretty flat. 847 00:44:16,498 --> 00:44:17,998 Um, well, who wants to spend time there? 848 00:44:17,998 --> 00:44:18,318 Right. 849 00:44:18,338 --> 00:44:20,798 You know, it's like going into an office with fluorescent lights 850 00:44:20,818 --> 00:44:22,558 in a, a stained drop ceiling. 851 00:44:22,718 --> 00:44:23,798 I mean, it's just no fun at all. 852 00:44:24,458 --> 00:44:27,798 So there's that aspect of it that I think still hasn't changed. 853 00:44:28,298 --> 00:44:31,078 But what we are seeing though is places that maybe aren't metaverse 854 00:44:31,178 --> 00:44:34,998 by name but are metaverse by experience are continuing to grow. 855 00:44:35,578 --> 00:44:37,838 Uh, one of them is, um, I. 856 00:44:38,963 --> 00:44:42,303 As I mentioned earlier, Roblox, it's seen actually pretty tremendous growth. 857 00:44:42,483 --> 00:44:45,343 Um, you know, we're talking, I think it's something like 70 million users, 858 00:44:45,403 --> 00:44:46,943 active users or something like that. 859 00:44:46,983 --> 00:44:51,343 I mean, it's pretty phenomenal when you think about it, but it, what has it done? 860 00:44:51,373 --> 00:44:53,703 Well, it's, it's captured a particular segment of the market, 861 00:44:53,703 --> 00:44:56,943 you know, kids, um, it's made a very safe place for them to play. 862 00:44:57,123 --> 00:45:00,223 Um, allows for interaction and it's. 863 00:45:00,223 --> 00:45:04,148 Appropriately dynamic, which I think for a lot of people is exactly what they want. 864 00:45:04,648 --> 00:45:07,908 So that one, I'd say, yeah, it's, it's still functioning and functioning 865 00:45:07,908 --> 00:45:09,108 really well and it, it's vital. 866 00:45:09,688 --> 00:45:13,508 Um, but we're also seeing something else and it's, I wouldn't say it's 867 00:45:13,508 --> 00:45:16,068 a strong trend at this point, but we're starting to see more and more, 868 00:45:16,608 --> 00:45:21,348 um, sort of immersive shopping type experiences that are coming up. 869 00:45:21,808 --> 00:45:26,028 Um, something that we saw recently, a Crate and Barrel has a immersive store. 870 00:45:26,448 --> 00:45:27,228 Macy's has one. 871 00:45:27,228 --> 00:45:29,108 So maybe a little bit more of like a video game. 872 00:45:29,688 --> 00:45:32,228 And we've talked to a lot of companies in this space and some 873 00:45:32,228 --> 00:45:34,668 that are in 3D commerce, and they're saying, they're hearing from, a lot 874 00:45:34,668 --> 00:45:38,228 of people are asking about, Hey, how can I get an immersive store? 875 00:45:38,328 --> 00:45:42,668 So it's not just scanning a grid of products, but it's something that's more 876 00:45:42,698 --> 00:45:46,788 interactive in the sense that perhaps, um, you're actually going into it. 877 00:45:47,568 --> 00:45:51,948 And what's interesting about that is that so far it's not necessarily a, a. 878 00:45:52,958 --> 00:45:54,458 Big money making commerce play. 879 00:45:54,488 --> 00:45:55,978 It's almost more of a marketing play. 880 00:45:55,978 --> 00:45:58,538 It's a little bit of a, of a unique opportunity. 881 00:45:58,718 --> 00:46:01,858 But just like you were saying with Vision Pro, a lot of people are 882 00:46:01,858 --> 00:46:05,418 saying, you know, is that gonna be the technology that proves the catalyst? 883 00:46:05,418 --> 00:46:08,178 You know, is it gonna be kind of like that iPhone moment that takes smartphones 884 00:46:08,178 --> 00:46:09,898 from something that's kind of neat? 885 00:46:10,238 --> 00:46:12,938 Um, and maybe some people have palm pilots and things like that, 886 00:46:12,998 --> 00:46:16,818 or you know, handheld devices to something that's truly ubiquitous. 887 00:46:17,388 --> 00:46:18,458 Maybe, maybe not. 888 00:46:18,838 --> 00:46:22,458 But um, I think for a lot of people they say, well, will commerce be 889 00:46:22,458 --> 00:46:25,658 exactly the same in the sense that we're going through those grids 890 00:46:25,658 --> 00:46:27,978 of products five years from now? 891 00:46:28,808 --> 00:46:30,378 Most people say probably not. 892 00:46:30,598 --> 00:46:30,818 No. 893 00:46:30,818 --> 00:46:32,378 They're gonna have something that's more dynamic. 894 00:46:32,478 --> 00:46:34,018 That's an increased conversion rates. 895 00:46:35,148 --> 00:46:35,828 Evan Troxel: I think the, the 896 00:46:35,908 --> 00:46:38,348 Kam Star: you say, I think maybe you and I are. 897 00:46:39,548 --> 00:46:45,958 Not entirely on the same page, because I heard all of this 15 years ago on second 898 00:46:45,988 --> 00:46:49,878 Life I saw all of these same stories. 899 00:46:50,678 --> 00:46:52,718 I heard them all exactly almost verbatim. 900 00:46:53,308 --> 00:46:57,718 Like, you know, hey, this, this company McKinsey's got a thing and BA's got a 901 00:46:57,718 --> 00:47:02,598 thing and Nike's got a store and you know, McDonald's has got a store and you can go. 902 00:47:02,598 --> 00:47:05,598 And the the reality of it is, nah. 903 00:47:06,098 --> 00:47:08,478 And I don't think that what we've got right now is it either. 904 00:47:08,898 --> 00:47:12,838 And the the, and the reason you you mentioned is, is computation is true, 905 00:47:12,938 --> 00:47:18,638 but the, the, as long as I have to wear something that's like heavier 906 00:47:18,708 --> 00:47:23,118 than these glasses, more intrusive, like literally this is probably the, 907 00:47:23,118 --> 00:47:26,038 the, the limit or maybe a little bit thicker than this, but that's about it. 908 00:47:26,538 --> 00:47:31,258 Uh, and, and do not remove me from reality, you know, so, and 909 00:47:31,258 --> 00:47:32,258 right now we're not there yet. 910 00:47:32,608 --> 00:47:35,458 Even the latest Apple headset is this giant thing that I 911 00:47:35,458 --> 00:47:36,418 have to stick on my head, 912 00:47:36,573 --> 00:47:37,833 Roderick Bates: Oh, it's still big man. 913 00:47:38,373 --> 00:47:39,233 So that's the question. 914 00:47:39,233 --> 00:47:42,593 Do you think it's the technology or concept, right, that's holding it back? 915 00:47:42,673 --> 00:47:44,793 I mean, if it's the concept, right, that's never gonna change. 916 00:47:45,413 --> 00:47:48,033 Um, but on the flip side, if it's the technology. 917 00:47:50,138 --> 00:47:52,148 . Then obviously people are pushing in that direction. 918 00:47:52,148 --> 00:47:52,908 Is it here today? 919 00:47:53,088 --> 00:47:53,308 No. 920 00:47:53,398 --> 00:47:54,788 Would it be here in several years? 921 00:47:54,858 --> 00:47:57,108 Well, honestly, that's, it's a little bit like fusion, right? 922 00:47:57,108 --> 00:47:59,988 You know that really lightweight wearables, immersive tech is 923 00:47:59,988 --> 00:48:02,228 always, uh, the next thing. 924 00:48:03,153 --> 00:48:05,123 Kam Star: It's making it easier and easier. 925 00:48:05,203 --> 00:48:10,313 I mean, honestly I can see, and I dunno, maybe of, some of the views and listeners 926 00:48:10,313 --> 00:48:15,793 have, have seen the rabbit one, that the launch of this new way to be able to 927 00:48:16,193 --> 00:48:21,553 interact with software and with interfaces and the idea of going from a large 928 00:48:21,833 --> 00:48:26,113 language model to a large action model where you can ask it to do stuff for you. 929 00:48:27,083 --> 00:48:32,023 And, and I watched the whole um, rabbit one presentation and the entire time I 930 00:48:32,023 --> 00:48:36,663 was thinking Why can't just, that can't, why can't that just be an app on my phone? 931 00:48:36,773 --> 00:48:37,303 Like, you know, 932 00:48:37,303 --> 00:48:41,303 why do I need to have a device come on, I can just have my phone be 933 00:48:41,573 --> 00:48:46,343 that, that I can just, just converse with it in a natural language, in a 934 00:48:46,543 --> 00:48:49,903 conversation, um, and get what I want. 935 00:48:50,123 --> 00:48:56,973 And, and I think that is, that is a much 'cause for me, maybe I'm a dinosaur, 936 00:48:57,723 --> 00:49:01,623 but, uh, you know, for every time the VR thing is comes up and it's just like the 937 00:49:01,623 --> 00:49:03,463 world is going to be in virtual reality. 938 00:49:03,573 --> 00:49:09,223 Hell, it was 1997 and I was working on VR ML and uh, you'd have to be 939 00:49:09,503 --> 00:49:11,303 probably as old as me or maybe older to 940 00:49:11,663 --> 00:49:11,943 remember VR 941 00:49:12,098 --> 00:49:15,358 Evan Troxel: I'm raise my hand, I know exactly what you're talking about. 942 00:49:15,408 --> 00:49:15,868 Kam Star: And vr. 943 00:49:15,868 --> 00:49:20,228 RML in 1997 was supposed to trans transform 944 00:49:20,528 --> 00:49:25,468 the shopping experience into a web front end where you entered the shop and you 945 00:49:25,468 --> 00:49:26,948 went around and you could see the stuff. 946 00:49:27,288 --> 00:49:29,388 It looked crap compared to what we've got today. 947 00:49:29,688 --> 00:49:31,988 We were to do it today, it would look so much better. 948 00:49:32,648 --> 00:49:37,038 But I still feel that, think there's something there around in 949 00:49:37,038 --> 00:49:38,958 terms of is it a technology thing? 950 00:49:39,038 --> 00:49:44,558 I think it's, it is partially a technology thing, but in the same, in the same 951 00:49:44,738 --> 00:49:52,398 way as when information and access to these things to music beKame so be 952 00:49:52,448 --> 00:49:56,638 ubiquitous that you could just download any MP three or you could just pay a 953 00:49:56,798 --> 00:50:00,878 subscription to Spotify or iTunes and just listen to absolutely any artist 954 00:50:01,058 --> 00:50:03,598 pretty much within limits, right? 955 00:50:03,918 --> 00:50:04,438 Whenever you want. 956 00:50:04,618 --> 00:50:07,998 The thing that was then valuable is actually going to the concert. 957 00:50:08,968 --> 00:50:13,058 It's the real physical experience of actually experiencing it. 958 00:50:13,398 --> 00:50:14,898 That's what beKame valuable 959 00:50:15,158 --> 00:50:15,578 in music. 960 00:50:16,148 --> 00:50:16,498 Right. 961 00:50:16,678 --> 00:50:18,658 You know, that, that the phys Yeah, exactly. 962 00:50:19,038 --> 00:50:21,358 The physicality beKame 963 00:50:21,378 --> 00:50:21,538 valuable. 964 00:50:21,878 --> 00:50:28,138 And I, and I wonder if in if in this space we are still, we, we, we 965 00:50:28,138 --> 00:50:29,658 need to be thinking about this too. 966 00:50:30,238 --> 00:50:33,458 You know, I'm, I'm amazed that the bookshops in Central London, that, 967 00:50:33,518 --> 00:50:37,698 you know, one of the highest, at least in Europe, I don't know about the US 968 00:50:37,698 --> 00:50:43,498 or Japan, but in terms of, uh, per square foot, um, rent, these, these 969 00:50:43,498 --> 00:50:45,178 numbers are eye watering, right? 970 00:50:45,178 --> 00:50:46,698 They're just like, what you pay, 971 00:50:46,918 --> 00:50:47,618 how much for rent? 972 00:50:47,878 --> 00:50:53,058 That's how much, you know, whole house costs, um, you know, per, per square foot. 973 00:50:53,558 --> 00:50:56,018 Uh, but these bookshops are filled with people. 974 00:50:56,758 --> 00:50:58,338 People want to go to the bookshop. 975 00:50:58,368 --> 00:51:00,178 Yeah, of course they can go to Amazon. 976 00:51:00,198 --> 00:51:01,338 Of course they've got that Kindle. 977 00:51:01,338 --> 00:51:04,818 Of course, they can consume media, uh, in a, in whilst they're 978 00:51:04,818 --> 00:51:06,298 laying on their bed, right. 979 00:51:06,803 --> 00:51:10,983 But they don't, they they go and walk into the bookshop 'cause they want to be there. 980 00:51:10,983 --> 00:51:15,583 They wanna pick up the book physically and amazingly physical books sold 981 00:51:15,583 --> 00:51:20,303 more, at least in the UK last year than have ever before in the history 982 00:51:20,303 --> 00:51:21,623 of selling books in this country. 983 00:51:21,958 --> 00:51:24,798 Evan Troxel: But are they just, but are they just a showroom for Amazon? 984 00:51:24,798 --> 00:51:25,078 Right. 985 00:51:25,683 --> 00:51:28,453 Kam Star: well, yeah, yeah, of course there is that you, you always 986 00:51:28,478 --> 00:51:29,038 Evan Troxel: stores are, 987 00:51:29,093 --> 00:51:31,973 Kam Star: kind of going, oh, I can buy it for 50 p cheaper here. 988 00:51:32,033 --> 00:51:32,253 So 989 00:51:32,288 --> 00:51:32,818 Evan Troxel: well, yeah. 990 00:51:32,818 --> 00:51:33,618 Everything's getting more 991 00:51:33,618 --> 00:51:34,018 expensive. 992 00:51:34,193 --> 00:51:35,353 Roderick Bates: things to unpack there though. 993 00:51:35,453 --> 00:51:39,433 Um, you know, one I think is people's desire to have the, the physical, right? 994 00:51:39,473 --> 00:51:41,873 I mean, at the end of the end of the day, we are living in the real 995 00:51:41,873 --> 00:51:43,433 world and people, I think there is a. 996 00:51:44,628 --> 00:51:46,508 A desire for that authentic interaction. 997 00:51:46,508 --> 00:51:49,188 Fundamentally, like it is, it is more desirable. 998 00:51:49,258 --> 00:51:52,428 It's like telling someone you went on vacation and it turned out that 999 00:51:52,428 --> 00:51:57,068 you, you bought a, um, a slide tour to go to the Azores just isn't gonna 1000 00:51:57,068 --> 00:51:59,148 be the same as actually going there. 1001 00:51:59,408 --> 00:52:00,628 So there's no doubt about it, right? 1002 00:52:00,628 --> 00:52:03,628 There's a value in that authenticity, smelling things, you know, feeling them 1003 00:52:03,628 --> 00:52:06,988 and, and maybe the ups and downs that go along with those sort of things as well. 1004 00:52:07,648 --> 00:52:12,868 But the other side of it too is it's not just about, uh, some of the technologies 1005 00:52:13,148 --> 00:52:14,708 actually are really, are well developed. 1006 00:52:15,488 --> 00:52:18,588 Um, like it doesn't have to be a VR experience, you know, people aren't 1007 00:52:18,588 --> 00:52:21,428 playing Fortnite or entering robots 1008 00:52:21,688 --> 00:52:22,228 and, um, 1009 00:52:22,423 --> 00:52:22,843 Evan Troxel: In vr. 1010 00:52:23,128 --> 00:52:24,028 Roderick Bates: in vr, right? 1011 00:52:24,028 --> 00:52:25,828 It's a traditional screen experience. 1012 00:52:26,528 --> 00:52:30,908 So in some ways, you know, maybe the technology's it's there, um, and what 1013 00:52:30,908 --> 00:52:31,948 we're seeing is what we're seeing. 1014 00:52:32,828 --> 00:52:37,888 And maybe a improvement in immersion isn't gonna move the needle in any way. 1015 00:52:38,648 --> 00:52:38,768 I. 1016 00:52:39,438 --> 00:52:39,678 Kam Star: I wonder 1017 00:52:39,753 --> 00:52:40,233 Evan Troxel: I think it, 1018 00:52:40,408 --> 00:52:40,758 Kam Star: sorry. 1019 00:52:40,778 --> 00:52:41,118 Go ahead. 1020 00:52:41,203 --> 00:52:43,083 Evan Troxel: I was just gonna say at some level I think you get 1021 00:52:43,083 --> 00:52:44,283 to walk away from that screen. 1022 00:52:44,333 --> 00:52:44,683 Right. 1023 00:52:44,883 --> 00:52:46,683 I, you would walk away from a headset too. 1024 00:52:46,743 --> 00:52:49,683 But, but I think there is kind of like a, a nice, it's 1025 00:52:49,683 --> 00:52:50,963 like a compartment of my life. 1026 00:52:50,963 --> 00:52:55,683 It isn't my life and I like to turn it on when I want to feel that and I can turn 1027 00:52:55,683 --> 00:52:57,403 it off when I need to do something else. 1028 00:52:57,683 --> 00:53:00,963 I think that there's, there's something else there that's not just about 1029 00:53:01,123 --> 00:53:02,683 experiencing something all the time. 1030 00:53:03,708 --> 00:53:05,308 Roderick Bates: I agree with that, although you always hear 1031 00:53:05,308 --> 00:53:07,668 about phone addiction and things like that, that people have. 1032 00:53:07,968 --> 00:53:11,708 So, um, and I guess in those, an addiction obviously implies that people 1033 00:53:11,708 --> 00:53:14,348 would rather turn it off if they had 1034 00:53:15,858 --> 00:53:16,148 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1035 00:53:16,308 --> 00:53:16,628 I, I, 1036 00:53:16,908 --> 00:53:17,868 I kind of see the opposite. 1037 00:53:18,458 --> 00:53:18,748 yeah. 1038 00:53:19,298 --> 00:53:21,468 Just to go back to something you said earlier, Kam, one of the 1039 00:53:21,548 --> 00:53:25,388 reasons that, that the R one, the rabbit R one, can't be an app is 1040 00:53:25,388 --> 00:53:27,148 because that's a gatekeeper for them. 1041 00:53:27,388 --> 00:53:31,788 I mean, you basically have to ask for, for permission to make something cool from 1042 00:53:31,808 --> 00:53:33,628 the two big gatekeepers on the planet. 1043 00:53:33,678 --> 00:53:34,028 Right. 1044 00:53:34,048 --> 00:53:37,668 And, and for you to only be able to deliver what they want to deliver. 1045 00:53:38,638 --> 00:53:41,528 They're at, they, they're under the thumb of somebody else. 1046 00:53:41,628 --> 00:53:43,768 And that, that's just something that I heard the founders say. 1047 00:53:43,768 --> 00:53:47,408 It's like, I, I, I'm swinging for the fences because I can, in this way. 1048 00:53:47,648 --> 00:53:49,128 I can't if I do it through them. 1049 00:53:49,783 --> 00:53:53,083 Kam Star: Uh, no, I, yeah, I, I can completely understand that by the, 1050 00:53:53,223 --> 00:53:55,723 and, you know, I'm, that I, I saw it. 1051 00:53:55,723 --> 00:54:00,243 I thought that, but I also thought, well, Samsung is gonna be doing this, 1052 00:54:00,553 --> 00:54:03,763 There's gonna be devices if, you know, LG is gonna be doing this, all those guys. 1053 00:54:04,043 --> 00:54:07,203 I wanna go back to the question of authenticity, because I think it, um, 1054 00:54:07,703 --> 00:54:13,083 it, for me, when I think about the future of designers and the future of creators, 1055 00:54:13,943 --> 00:54:18,163 um, there is something, and I know it's not, it's not directly related to the, 1056 00:54:18,263 --> 00:54:22,203 the space of vr, but for me, this is something about design, communicating, 1057 00:54:22,223 --> 00:54:26,683 design, understanding design, being able to create something that your 1058 00:54:26,923 --> 00:54:28,883 customer, your client, really wants. 1059 00:54:29,783 --> 00:54:33,723 And, and I'm, whilst it's feasible. 1060 00:54:34,803 --> 00:54:38,843 Somebody could automate the entire process of maybe designing a building. 1061 00:54:39,543 --> 00:54:46,293 Um, I, I'm really doubtful whether that would ever come to fruition in the 1062 00:54:46,293 --> 00:54:48,013 way that people pretend that it would. 1063 00:54:48,553 --> 00:54:48,773 Um, 1064 00:54:49,098 --> 00:54:49,218 Evan Troxel: Hmm. 1065 00:54:50,403 --> 00:54:55,813 Kam Star: because there's something more just giving somebody the ability 1066 00:54:55,913 --> 00:55:00,933 to write a prompt and have the full set of drawings, uh, and, and the, you 1067 00:55:00,933 --> 00:55:04,973 know, the building schedule or if it's a, if it's a product, you know, all of 1068 00:55:04,973 --> 00:55:09,693 the kind of specifications are ready to go and to be printed and and assembled. 1069 00:55:10,433 --> 00:55:15,533 Um, there's something here about the role of the designer is as, as, not 1070 00:55:15,533 --> 00:55:20,493 just a conductor, but, I'm struggling to find the right word, but the person, 1071 00:55:20,553 --> 00:55:29,143 the individual who navigates the design space for you at or with you to arrive at 1072 00:55:29,163 --> 00:55:32,463 the thing that you actually really want. 1073 00:55:33,368 --> 00:55:37,428 To tease out and think about it in the process of designing a house for someone. 1074 00:55:38,578 --> 00:55:38,868 Sure. 1075 00:55:38,868 --> 00:55:43,188 Maybe at some point I could ask a prompt and say, I've got a land that is this 1076 00:55:43,188 --> 00:55:45,708 meter or, or here's a aerial photograph. 1077 00:55:45,968 --> 00:55:46,828 Create me something. 1078 00:55:47,168 --> 00:55:55,128 But I, I can't see that being, and maybe, again, I'm showing my age right now. 1079 00:55:55,208 --> 00:55:58,928 I can't imagine why that would be better than sitting with an architect 1080 00:55:58,928 --> 00:56:02,888 or sitting with a designer explaining to them the feeling that I want, 1081 00:56:03,178 --> 00:56:06,368 explaining to them what the things that are really important to me. 1082 00:56:06,848 --> 00:56:06,968 I. 1083 00:56:07,118 --> 00:56:10,548 Going through a process, and maybe that process is augmented with ai, and 1084 00:56:10,548 --> 00:56:13,428 certainly this is some of the tools that we're creating, right, to help 1085 00:56:13,428 --> 00:56:15,348 you get there faster as a co-pilot. 1086 00:56:15,728 --> 00:56:20,068 But for the role of the designer, for the creator, they are the conduit. 1087 00:56:20,608 --> 00:56:25,188 Um, and perhaps they're not always necessarily the original originator, but 1088 00:56:25,188 --> 00:56:29,228 they're the ones who make sense of what it is the customer wants, the client wants 1089 00:56:29,808 --> 00:56:36,148 and helps to, to then bring that to bear, um, in, in a design, you know, of course 1090 00:56:36,148 --> 00:56:40,988 with assistance, which to me is a, again, goes back to this idea of authenticity. 1091 00:56:41,728 --> 00:56:47,548 Um, like, um, the, another way that I've thought about it is, um, any fool 1092 00:56:48,128 --> 00:56:52,588 can, can go and buy a load of clothes and, and stick it on someone, but, 1093 00:56:52,808 --> 00:56:57,588 you know, not everyone can, can, can actually put together a really good 1094 00:56:57,688 --> 00:57:00,108 outfit, you know, and, and, and that 1095 00:57:00,413 --> 00:57:03,693 Roderick Bates: A really good outfit is one that maybe breaks 1096 00:57:03,693 --> 00:57:04,773 the rules a little bit too. 1097 00:57:04,808 --> 00:57:05,158 Kam Star: right. 1098 00:57:06,803 --> 00:57:07,023 Roderick Bates: Um, 1099 00:57:07,343 --> 00:57:08,063 I think part of what 1100 00:57:08,193 --> 00:57:09,993 Evan Troxel: a lot of architecture is breaking the rules. 1101 00:57:10,003 --> 00:57:10,353 Right. 1102 00:57:10,353 --> 00:57:14,513 Like that that's the whole, the, the, the, the building code is 1103 00:57:14,513 --> 00:57:18,073 something that we are constantly navigating and finding workarounds 1104 00:57:18,143 --> 00:57:19,263 Roderick Bates: one ever takes a sitting down. 1105 00:57:19,443 --> 00:57:20,023 Um, in 1106 00:57:20,023 --> 00:57:20,863 the, in the design process. 1107 00:57:20,863 --> 00:57:22,623 Everything's, everything's negotiated. 1108 00:57:23,443 --> 00:57:27,573 And I think what you're describing is almost a bit of a therapist Kam. 1109 00:57:27,593 --> 00:57:27,943 Right. 1110 00:57:27,943 --> 00:57:29,543 You know, they're, they're listening to, they're interpreting. 1111 00:57:29,543 --> 00:57:29,663 Right. 1112 00:57:29,663 --> 00:57:31,863 And then they're also helping you navigate what are gonna be 1113 00:57:31,953 --> 00:57:33,943 inherently a series of compromises. 1114 00:57:33,943 --> 00:57:39,943 You know, everyone goes in with a BMW, uh, aspiration and a and a Pontiac budget. 1115 00:57:40,133 --> 00:57:42,743 It's just, there's always an, a mismatch between the 1116 00:57:42,743 --> 00:57:42,903 two. 1117 00:57:43,523 --> 00:57:46,263 And your job is to help them navigate those. 1118 00:57:46,283 --> 00:57:49,783 But the other thing that I always thought of when I was in, in practice is that 1119 00:57:50,363 --> 00:57:52,423 people really should enjoy this process. 1120 00:57:52,783 --> 00:57:56,223 'cause the, this might be the most money they'll ever spend on anything, 1121 00:57:56,893 --> 00:57:57,183 ever. 1122 00:57:57,963 --> 00:57:59,783 And, well, yeah, they should have fun. 1123 00:57:59,783 --> 00:58:02,143 This shouldn't be like pulling teeth or going to the dentist 1124 00:58:02,243 --> 00:58:02,943 or something like that. 1125 00:58:02,973 --> 00:58:06,783 This should be something where in fact, they, they enjoy this process 'cause 1126 00:58:06,783 --> 00:58:08,303 they were paying a lot of money for it. 1127 00:58:10,975 --> 00:58:14,035 This episode is made possible with support from confluence. 1128 00:58:14,425 --> 00:58:18,055 Picture this October, 2019 Lexington, Kentucky. 1129 00:58:18,355 --> 00:58:19,915 The birthplace of confluence. 1130 00:58:20,275 --> 00:58:24,715 A place where tech leaders, AEC product developers and practitioners came 1131 00:58:24,715 --> 00:58:26,755 together for three transformative days. 1132 00:58:27,115 --> 00:58:28,375 It was more than a conference. 1133 00:58:28,435 --> 00:58:33,595 It was a confluence of ideas, discussions, and unforgettable social experiences. 1134 00:58:33,822 --> 00:58:37,872 Since then over 200 attendees have experienced the magic of confluence. 1135 00:58:38,412 --> 00:58:41,832 had the privilege of being part of three of these remarkable gatherings, 1136 00:58:42,012 --> 00:58:46,152 two in Kentucky and one in orange county, each one, a melting pot of 1137 00:58:46,152 --> 00:58:50,562 learning collaboration and comradery around a topic, shaping our industry. 1138 00:58:51,087 --> 00:58:56,187 now we're thrilled to announce the next regional confluence event in April, 2024 1139 00:58:56,277 --> 00:58:58,197 in the vibrant heart of New York city. 1140 00:58:58,446 --> 00:59:03,306 This time, we dive deep into the realms of AI and machine learning, unraveling their 1141 00:59:03,306 --> 00:59:05,106 mysteries and potentials in our industry. 1142 00:59:05,399 --> 00:59:08,609 Are you interested in being part of this exciting journey to continue the 1143 00:59:08,609 --> 00:59:10,709 conversation, to shape the future? 1144 00:59:10,996 --> 00:59:13,636 Visit the link in the show notes for more details. 1145 00:59:13,970 --> 00:59:19,490 Confluence where ideas flow, connections form and the future of AEC technology 1146 00:59:19,490 --> 00:59:22,010 is shaped one conversation at a time. 1147 00:59:23,030 --> 00:59:26,960 My thanks to confluence for supporting this episode of the Troxell podcast. 1148 00:59:27,440 --> 00:59:29,510 And now let's get back to the conversation. 1149 00:59:31,460 --> 00:59:31,740 Evan Troxel: Absolutely. 1150 00:59:32,180 --> 00:59:36,060 I, I, I agree with, with what you're talking about here because, and I, I 1151 00:59:36,060 --> 00:59:42,180 guess my question for you both is, do you see a point in time, maybe the near 1152 00:59:42,180 --> 00:59:48,570 future, uh, where there's a huge backlash against a lot of this AI generated 1153 00:59:48,620 --> 00:59:52,930 stuff, and, and it's like there's gonna be a push back to authenticity or a 1154 00:59:52,930 --> 00:59:57,370 stamp or something that says like, this is a hundred percent organic 1155 00:59:58,050 --> 00:59:58,790 Roderick Bates: That's what I was saying. 1156 00:59:58,790 --> 01:00:00,350 It sounds like USDA organic 1157 01:00:00,410 --> 01:00:01,790 and you know, I think that there would be, right. 1158 01:00:01,830 --> 01:00:03,390 I think there's some value in craft. 1159 01:00:04,100 --> 01:00:08,590 It's like you can buy a knife that's probably just as well made out of a 1160 01:00:08,590 --> 01:00:10,150 factory as one that's made by hand. 1161 01:00:10,150 --> 01:00:14,230 But people are absolutely willing to pay hundreds of dollars for a handmade knife. 1162 01:00:15,035 --> 01:00:16,135 Evan Troxel: That's funny that you say that. 1163 01:00:16,295 --> 01:00:20,815 I just watched a, a YouTube video of a, of a guy who makes $200 knives 1164 01:00:20,845 --> 01:00:25,655 basically by hand, and, and he's, he blacksmiths it from the beginning 1165 01:00:25,715 --> 01:00:29,895 to the end, and it's like, yeah, you can buy the $20 one on Amazon. 1166 01:00:30,495 --> 01:00:30,895 Absolutely you can. 1167 01:00:31,355 --> 01:00:33,815 It won't fit your hand like this one fits your hand. 1168 01:00:33,875 --> 01:00:37,855 It won't, it won't go into the sheath the way this one snaps into the sheath. 1169 01:00:37,875 --> 01:00:41,975 It won't, it won't hold its edge as long as this one will hold its edge. 1170 01:00:42,115 --> 01:00:45,895 And there's so many little decisions that were made along the way that were 1171 01:00:45,895 --> 01:00:51,415 gained through wisdom and experience and, and application of technique over 1172 01:00:51,415 --> 01:00:58,615 years and years of craft to establish the outcome of this process like there 1173 01:00:58,615 --> 01:01:04,435 is in a The $20 version on Amazon, and, and it's like once somebody buys 1174 01:01:04,435 --> 01:01:07,715 that knife, they're never gonna want to use another kind of knife again. 1175 01:01:08,620 --> 01:01:09,000 Roderick Bates: But what 1176 01:01:09,075 --> 01:01:10,695 Evan Troxel: not to say that people will want to build 1177 01:01:10,695 --> 01:01:11,815 another building and work with 1178 01:01:11,815 --> 01:01:12,495 an architect again. 1179 01:01:12,615 --> 01:01:12,735 I 1180 01:01:13,645 --> 01:01:15,505 Roderick Bates: that's right for some people once is enough. 1181 01:01:15,765 --> 01:01:17,545 But what about when it's indistinguishable? 1182 01:01:17,625 --> 01:01:18,785 I think that's a little bit of the 1183 01:01:18,785 --> 01:01:19,385 challenge too. 1184 01:01:19,965 --> 01:01:23,665 Uh, when, and I think I still feel like there's an inherent value in craft. 1185 01:01:23,745 --> 01:01:24,425 I mean, you can buy, 1186 01:01:24,565 --> 01:01:27,265 get a print of all sorts of paintings, but there's a, people 1187 01:01:27,665 --> 01:01:28,865 absolutely value the original. 1188 01:01:29,555 --> 01:01:29,975 Evan Troxel: Mm-Hmm. 1189 01:01:30,405 --> 01:01:31,825 Roderick Bates: Um, it's the same thing with cars. 1190 01:01:31,845 --> 01:01:36,145 You know, you can get a reproduction Cobra, um, Shelby Cobra, and 1191 01:01:36,145 --> 01:01:38,985 it's gonna be worth a heck of a lot less than the real deal. 1192 01:01:39,465 --> 01:01:39,755 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1193 01:01:40,105 --> 01:01:40,395 Yeah. 1194 01:01:40,415 --> 01:01:42,555 Roderick Bates: And in fact, it might be better than the original. 1195 01:01:43,305 --> 01:01:46,065 Evan Troxel: I, I just see that the, there's going to be a kind 1196 01:01:46,065 --> 01:01:51,305 of an organization of, or a bifurcation of spaces online and 1197 01:01:51,325 --> 01:01:52,505 in the real world where it's like. 1198 01:01:53,260 --> 01:01:54,030 Only organic. 1199 01:01:54,030 --> 01:01:54,350 Right. 1200 01:01:54,350 --> 01:01:56,270 It's, it's just, this is done by hand. 1201 01:01:56,380 --> 01:01:59,270 This is, these are things that have been thought of by people. 1202 01:01:59,270 --> 01:01:59,790 They're not. 1203 01:02:00,260 --> 01:02:01,310 It's, it's interesting, right? 1204 01:02:01,310 --> 01:02:05,390 Because you, you can see communities like the Amish community is an example of this. 1205 01:02:05,450 --> 01:02:07,190 Not that they totally shun technology. 1206 01:02:07,260 --> 01:02:09,910 They, but they study it intensely and then 1207 01:02:09,910 --> 01:02:15,350 they only accept technologies that reinforce their values and don't, 1208 01:02:15,640 --> 01:02:18,830 don't break up the values that they've established as a community. 1209 01:02:18,830 --> 01:02:20,150 Those are the ones that stick. 1210 01:02:20,200 --> 01:02:20,550 Right? 1211 01:02:20,810 --> 01:02:25,790 And I could see that similarly happening in this space where it's like we, and 1212 01:02:25,790 --> 01:02:30,030 I think it's really gonna ha show up a lot this year because of the, you know, 1213 01:02:30,130 --> 01:02:35,150 the elections are coming, we're, we're seeing so much generated content, right. 1214 01:02:35,660 --> 01:02:37,230 That it's just gonna be like, what's real? 1215 01:02:37,390 --> 01:02:38,430 I can't even tell anymore. 1216 01:02:38,620 --> 01:02:39,430 It's so good. 1217 01:02:40,070 --> 01:02:41,190 I can't tell if somebody really 1218 01:02:41,355 --> 01:02:41,645 Roderick Bates: Yeah. 1219 01:02:41,645 --> 01:02:43,925 That's, that's terrifying in some ways, right. 1220 01:02:43,945 --> 01:02:44,245 You know? 1221 01:02:44,245 --> 01:02:46,285 And so what is your, your best option in that case? 1222 01:02:46,445 --> 01:02:48,485 I mean, think of, you know, fraud and whatnot as well. 1223 01:02:49,105 --> 01:02:54,125 Um, it is, it's needless to say, absolutely disconcerting, but I 1224 01:02:54,125 --> 01:02:56,725 still also think you can't turn your back on on these tools. 1225 01:02:56,925 --> 01:02:58,725 I mean, they're, they're gonna be there no matter what. 1226 01:02:59,505 --> 01:03:03,285 Um, and what we're trying to do is, is, like I was saying before, we're trying 1227 01:03:03,285 --> 01:03:09,005 to thread that needle and say, okay, how do we take these tools to help you? 1228 01:03:10,620 --> 01:03:12,720 become better, a better artist. 1229 01:03:12,780 --> 01:03:15,040 You know, it's like, okay, we're not trying to replace the crafts 1230 01:03:15,040 --> 01:03:17,320 of making the knife, we're just trying to help give them, like, 1231 01:03:17,340 --> 01:03:22,520 say, um, a fan that automatically blows on the, on the, uh, the coals. 1232 01:03:22,520 --> 01:03:22,720 You know? 1233 01:03:22,720 --> 01:03:25,840 So replacing say hand, hand blown bellows or something like that, you know, it's, 1234 01:03:26,020 --> 01:03:27,840 that's that sort of thing where that's 1235 01:03:27,840 --> 01:03:29,880 what we think is Yeah, exactly. 1236 01:03:29,890 --> 01:03:30,680 crank it in a way. 1237 01:03:30,680 --> 01:03:30,880 Right? 1238 01:03:30,950 --> 01:03:35,640 It's, and if we can do that, then we think that's the ideal compromise. 1239 01:03:36,060 --> 01:03:37,880 That's the balance that we want to achieve. 1240 01:03:38,120 --> 01:03:40,880 'cause then you get the human creativity and maybe the human flaws. 1241 01:03:41,540 --> 01:03:44,120 You get the, uh, the nuance of the artist. 1242 01:03:44,140 --> 01:03:48,480 You get all of that intent and that inspiration, but you get it, 1243 01:03:49,020 --> 01:03:52,960 um, in a way that people aren't having to waste that inspiration 1244 01:03:52,970 --> 01:03:54,840 doing things that can be automated. 1245 01:03:55,590 --> 01:03:55,930 And I 1246 01:03:55,930 --> 01:03:57,170 think that's what can happen right now. 1247 01:03:57,605 --> 01:03:57,895 Kam Star: Yeah. 1248 01:03:57,970 --> 01:03:58,690 Evan Troxel: let's talk about this. 1249 01:03:58,690 --> 01:04:02,370 Maybe this is the third act of our conversation, which is what, what 1250 01:04:02,750 --> 01:04:06,650 in which ways is that, do you have a vision for that manifesting? 1251 01:04:06,670 --> 01:04:09,410 And I'd love for you guys to talk about whatever you're willing to talk 1252 01:04:09,410 --> 01:04:14,130 about when it comes to products or ideas or explorations or research, 1253 01:04:14,350 --> 01:04:19,529 but, but what are those, in those co-piloting kind of things that 1254 01:04:19,529 --> 01:04:25,970 you're looking at that make sense in expanding or, you know, really diving 1255 01:04:25,970 --> 01:04:27,850 deeper into the visualization space? 1256 01:04:29,225 --> 01:04:37,095 Kam Star: we've, um, tried to, to put at a high level, kind of define three 1257 01:04:37,125 --> 01:04:39,055 main domains that we're focusing on. 1258 01:04:40,415 --> 01:04:43,555 And I know three sounded like a lot, but then again, there's 1259 01:04:43,555 --> 01:04:44,475 a lot of things you could do. 1260 01:04:45,415 --> 01:04:46,035 Um, the. 1261 01:04:47,154 --> 01:04:48,855 And these in, in no particular order. 1262 01:04:49,115 --> 01:04:51,015 But, you know, the first one we're gonna talk about is, 1263 01:04:51,075 --> 01:04:53,975 is around assets and assets. 1264 01:04:54,035 --> 01:04:56,255 You know, creating assets and capturing assets. 1265 01:04:57,505 --> 01:05:02,665 takes a long time to create an a, a, a very unique asset that be that a, a 1266 01:05:02,904 --> 01:05:08,185 material or be that a, a particular chair or a table or a, some kind of a scene 1267 01:05:08,365 --> 01:05:12,545 or something like that, that you want to, you wanna generate, um, you know, 1268 01:05:12,865 --> 01:05:14,305 modeling that takes a lot of effort. 1269 01:05:14,745 --> 01:05:18,345 Creating a material that looks really realistic, that looks 1270 01:05:18,365 --> 01:05:19,785 as realistic as the real thing. 1271 01:05:19,785 --> 01:05:23,065 This is what, you know, some of our software is best known for. 1272 01:05:23,325 --> 01:05:26,145 You use V Rave because you want to have photorealism, 1273 01:05:26,590 --> 01:05:27,010 Evan Troxel: Mm-Hmm. 1274 01:05:27,105 --> 01:05:27,665 Kam Star: guess what? 1275 01:05:27,885 --> 01:05:31,625 You, you, you can't just, just, just, start rendering because, 1276 01:05:32,295 --> 01:05:33,665 well, what about the material? 1277 01:05:34,085 --> 01:05:34,425 You know? 1278 01:05:34,525 --> 01:05:35,705 And, and, 1279 01:05:35,779 --> 01:05:36,940 Roderick Bates: and there's a ton of materials 1280 01:05:37,340 --> 01:05:40,455 Kam Star: a ton of materials but you know, the, the, the, complexity 1281 01:05:40,455 --> 01:05:43,535 of a material take what looks like a, oh, that's just wood. 1282 01:05:43,635 --> 01:05:44,695 Oh, that's just a flaw. 1283 01:05:44,955 --> 01:05:46,855 That's just a, you know, parquet floor. 1284 01:05:47,485 --> 01:05:51,385 Well, if you were gonna create that so it looks photorealistic, 1285 01:05:52,125 --> 01:05:54,105 you might have 20 or 30 layers. 1286 01:05:54,575 --> 01:05:55,665 It's not just a texture. 1287 01:05:56,335 --> 01:06:00,785 It's the ity, it's the bums, it's the interplay of all the different things. 1288 01:06:00,815 --> 01:06:03,945 It's the idiosyncrasies of the, the, the, the tiling. 1289 01:06:03,975 --> 01:06:05,025 It's the fact that you, 1290 01:06:05,255 --> 01:06:05,545 Roderick Bates: Yeah. 1291 01:06:05,545 --> 01:06:09,265 How it go butts up against the edge of the wall properly, so it looks natural. 1292 01:06:09,415 --> 01:06:10,065 Yeah, it's. 1293 01:06:10,665 --> 01:06:11,345 Kam Star: absolutely all of that. 1294 01:06:11,805 --> 01:06:16,585 Um, and that takes a huge amount of effort where really, as a designer, I 1295 01:06:16,705 --> 01:06:20,505 just wanted a really good looking wood in the way that, that I was thinking. 1296 01:06:21,105 --> 01:06:25,925 I don't wanna spend two or three or four hours even as a 1297 01:06:25,925 --> 01:06:29,365 professional having to create this, 'cause this is just the floor. 1298 01:06:29,465 --> 01:06:30,805 And of course it needs to look right. 1299 01:06:31,265 --> 01:06:32,925 But I wanted to focus on the space. 1300 01:06:33,865 --> 01:06:34,085 Um. 1301 01:06:35,265 --> 01:06:39,885 So some of the work that we are doing is, is actually very much aligned and we've 1302 01:06:39,885 --> 01:06:45,685 got a project which is, should be launched this year, um, which is around giving 1303 01:06:45,685 --> 01:06:49,845 you that ability to be able to create materials just through conversation. 1304 01:06:50,585 --> 01:06:56,445 But the outcome is not, is not a, is not an image, uh, it's not a black box. 1305 01:06:57,265 --> 01:07:01,285 You actually get the full material with all its layers, with all its settings. 1306 01:07:01,285 --> 01:07:04,725 So if you want it a little bit browner, a little bit darker here, a little bit 1307 01:07:04,795 --> 01:07:05,685 more, you know, 1308 01:07:05,845 --> 01:07:06,135 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1309 01:07:06,590 --> 01:07:06,880 Roderick Bates: Yeah. 1310 01:07:07,045 --> 01:07:07,645 Kam Star: can tweak it. 1311 01:07:07,825 --> 01:07:08,165 You can 1312 01:07:08,165 --> 01:07:11,325 tweak it to get it exactly where you want, but it'll do 90% 1313 01:07:11,325 --> 01:07:13,245 of the heavy lifting for you. 1314 01:07:13,350 --> 01:07:15,840 Roderick Bates: Yeah, I mean, it's indistinguishable from material that 1315 01:07:15,900 --> 01:07:17,760 you could have created manually, 1316 01:07:18,140 --> 01:07:19,520 if you will, taken hours 1317 01:07:20,055 --> 01:07:22,015 Evan Troxel: I was thinking Roderick, when you said there's, 1318 01:07:22,015 --> 01:07:23,015 there's so many materials. 1319 01:07:23,075 --> 01:07:23,495 I'm like, yeah. 1320 01:07:23,495 --> 01:07:24,535 And none of them are right. 1321 01:07:24,545 --> 01:07:24,895 Right. 1322 01:07:25,410 --> 01:07:25,610 Roderick Bates: Yeah. 1323 01:07:25,760 --> 01:07:26,330 Well, and that's 1324 01:07:26,330 --> 01:07:26,650 the part of 1325 01:07:26,650 --> 01:07:28,650 where you think of, you know, the conversation, right? 1326 01:07:28,650 --> 01:07:29,490 And that's the idea. 1327 01:07:29,520 --> 01:07:32,970 It's like, no, just just a little bit this, a little bit that, and 1328 01:07:32,970 --> 01:07:36,410 all of a sudden you, it, you're iteration loop is near instantaneous. 1329 01:07:36,815 --> 01:07:37,165 Evan Troxel: right? 1330 01:07:38,810 --> 01:07:41,190 Kam Star: So that's, that's, that's one of the, one of the spaces. 1331 01:07:41,810 --> 01:07:44,390 And of course there are others who are working at kind of creating 1332 01:07:44,400 --> 01:07:46,110 3D models and things like that. 1333 01:07:46,170 --> 01:07:50,430 And I think, I think that's also quite interesting. 1334 01:07:50,529 --> 01:07:55,150 But for us, the thing that our customers were asking for is, can you please cut 1335 01:07:55,150 --> 01:07:58,470 down the amount of time it takes us to create the material that I want? 1336 01:07:58,610 --> 01:07:59,190 To your 1337 01:07:59,190 --> 01:08:01,029 point, because the library, Yeah. 1338 01:08:01,070 --> 01:08:01,710 I don't want that. 1339 01:08:02,050 --> 01:08:02,270 But 1340 01:08:02,315 --> 01:08:02,735 Evan Troxel: Mm-Hmm. 1341 01:08:02,910 --> 01:08:04,910 Kam Star: you could start with that and I can then explain 1342 01:08:05,650 --> 01:08:07,750 how I want that changed and evolved. 1343 01:08:08,315 --> 01:08:12,120 Which is the, you know, the, the, the, the next, the next iteration 1344 01:08:12,120 --> 01:08:16,279 of this project is you don't even have to start from scratch. 1345 01:08:16,540 --> 01:08:20,600 You start from something and then you converse to refine it. 1346 01:08:20,899 --> 01:08:22,000 and, and augment it. 1347 01:08:22,060 --> 01:08:26,080 And then you still get back something that you can still control and, and, you know, 1348 01:08:26,750 --> 01:08:34,120 very fine tune, um, accurately control, um, the, the, and that's, there's, there's 1349 01:08:34,120 --> 01:08:36,760 a, there's a whole bunch of things in there, but that's, that's one that we, 1350 01:08:36,940 --> 01:08:39,440 we will be, uh, releasing this year. 1351 01:08:39,710 --> 01:08:43,399 Another one that we are working on, or rather another space that 1352 01:08:43,399 --> 01:08:51,720 we're working on generally is what we called, um, intelligent scene 1353 01:08:52,260 --> 01:08:55,840 or intelligent scene understanding or being able to understand scenes. 1354 01:08:55,910 --> 01:09:00,960 Basically providing the use software that can understand 1355 01:09:01,420 --> 01:09:02,840 the scene that you're creating. 1356 01:09:03,779 --> 01:09:05,559 Now, why would we wanna do that? 1357 01:09:05,910 --> 01:09:06,200 Well. 1358 01:09:07,265 --> 01:09:08,510 There's quite a few things. 1359 01:09:08,729 --> 01:09:13,430 If the machine could understand what it is that you're trying to do, or at 1360 01:09:13,430 --> 01:09:16,990 least you could say to it, Hey, um, this is, this is a kitchen, right? 1361 01:09:17,890 --> 01:09:20,510 Um, lay out the furniture for me. 1362 01:09:21,410 --> 01:09:24,149 So it could, it could then in a, you know, kind of a smart 1363 01:09:24,170 --> 01:09:26,350 way populate the scene for you. 1364 01:09:27,050 --> 01:09:31,990 And that may come from a set of, um, assets you already have. 1365 01:09:33,200 --> 01:09:36,540 Or you may, it may be generated, but it, you know, in the first 1366 01:09:36,859 --> 01:09:39,059 instance we're going with the assets that we there is in the library. 1367 01:09:39,520 --> 01:09:43,740 So if you wanna set up the kitchen, um, well I've designed the kitchen, 1368 01:09:44,399 --> 01:09:46,100 but it's gonna put a table in there. 1369 01:09:46,609 --> 01:09:52,370 It's gonna put a bowl on the table, it's gonna put fruit, you know, in, in the 1370 01:09:52,370 --> 01:09:55,809 bowl it's gonna put cups and things, it's gonna make it look lived in. 1371 01:09:56,430 --> 01:10:01,470 And so all of that set dressing, all of that designed to Help you breathe 1372 01:10:01,660 --> 01:10:04,550 life into that space is done for you. 1373 01:10:04,850 --> 01:10:06,830 But again, it's, that's not an image. 1374 01:10:07,420 --> 01:10:08,870 It's the 3D content. 1375 01:10:09,050 --> 01:10:11,870 So then if, you know, the chair's not quite where I want it to be 1376 01:10:12,410 --> 01:10:16,070 or this is not exactly where I want, but it, it does all of that heavy lifting 1377 01:10:16,130 --> 01:10:18,350 of, here we go, we've set it up for you. 1378 01:10:18,850 --> 01:10:21,030 Do you want this setup or this setup? 1379 01:10:21,220 --> 01:10:23,750 Okay, I'll start with this setup and then I tweak it. 1380 01:10:24,500 --> 01:10:29,760 So, and, and that's kinda one application which we're working on in 1381 01:10:29,760 --> 01:10:34,710 that space though, if once the system can understand, or at least your 1382 01:10:34,770 --> 01:10:40,640 intent, well, with intelligence and understanding, you could do lighting. 1383 01:10:41,530 --> 01:10:43,710 Um, create a particular mood. 1384 01:10:43,930 --> 01:10:46,950 Hey, it takes, you know, you have to be, people go to university and 1385 01:10:46,950 --> 01:10:49,830 spend years trying to figure out exactly what the perfect lighting is. 1386 01:10:49,830 --> 01:10:51,030 And I don't mean just for rendering. 1387 01:10:51,070 --> 01:10:54,750 I mean, back in the real world, you know, lighting design is a, is a thing. 1388 01:10:54,809 --> 01:10:55,870 It takes a lot of 1389 01:10:55,870 --> 01:10:56,190 effort. 1390 01:10:56,540 --> 01:10:56,830 Roderick Bates: Yeah. 1391 01:10:56,945 --> 01:10:57,235 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1392 01:10:57,770 --> 01:11:02,630 Kam Star: why why couldn't I say, Hey, I want this kind of a mood and, and for it 1393 01:11:02,630 --> 01:11:07,790 to, to create me a whole set of different potential options for me to choose from. 1394 01:11:08,570 --> 01:11:10,630 Um, and, and then to refine. 1395 01:11:10,890 --> 01:11:14,950 So again, the outcome is, the outcome is not just a picture on the screen, 1396 01:11:14,950 --> 01:11:16,270 but actually is your lighting setup. 1397 01:11:17,150 --> 01:11:18,890 Uh, and now I can refine it. 1398 01:11:19,630 --> 01:11:19,850 Um. 1399 01:11:21,070 --> 01:11:23,570 Roderick Bates: And there's a lot of interest within that of saying, well, 1400 01:11:23,570 --> 01:11:27,650 can I replicate a particular style of a visual artist or a particular 1401 01:11:27,650 --> 01:11:29,410 firm that has great renderings and 1402 01:11:29,410 --> 01:11:29,890 things like that? 1403 01:11:29,990 --> 01:11:32,450 So there's an interesting angle that that can go. 1404 01:11:32,490 --> 01:11:36,170 I mean, there's no one perfect lighting solution, but I think there's a really 1405 01:11:36,170 --> 01:11:41,930 great way of, in that case, maybe not just, um, improving workflows, 1406 01:11:41,930 --> 01:11:45,290 making it e um, faster for someone to get to the conclusion, but also even 1407 01:11:45,290 --> 01:11:50,410 giving someone who, as Kam was saying, it takes a, has a real mastery and 1408 01:11:50,610 --> 01:11:54,170 actually making that mastery accessible to people that, that simply just 1409 01:11:54,170 --> 01:11:56,090 wouldn't know how to manipulate the. 1410 01:11:57,350 --> 01:12:00,550 Absolute myriad of options that you have, and a pretty sophisticated 1411 01:12:00,550 --> 01:12:04,070 piece of visualization software like Vray to achieve those, you 1412 01:12:04,070 --> 01:12:05,230 know, perfect levels of lighting. 1413 01:12:05,465 --> 01:12:05,885 Evan Troxel: Mm-Hmm. 1414 01:12:06,510 --> 01:12:09,230 Kam Star: And you could also apply it on something that it, we all need to do. 1415 01:12:09,610 --> 01:12:14,550 And yet, you know, I kind of, it's, it's a, it's fear. 1416 01:12:14,550 --> 01:12:19,270 Like, you know, hey, anyone can hold Kamera, but can anyone frame a shot? 1417 01:12:20,165 --> 01:12:24,375 Just the, you know, just having that composition, having the eye to be able to 1418 01:12:24,375 --> 01:12:26,655 create that composition is what we have. 1419 01:12:26,655 --> 01:12:32,535 Professional photographers who spend years experimenting with the perfect framing, 1420 01:12:32,845 --> 01:12:36,575 with the perfect moment at the perfect angle to capture the, the essence of what 1421 01:12:36,575 --> 01:12:37,975 it is that they're trying to communicate. 1422 01:12:38,515 --> 01:12:43,015 And somehow we just expect people to be able to go, yeah, you just 1423 01:12:43,015 --> 01:12:45,335 put a Kamera in the scene and you just point it at what you want. 1424 01:12:46,115 --> 01:12:49,735 Um, why, why is that the best outcome? 1425 01:12:49,835 --> 01:12:55,455 And, and actually I would argue unless the person is, is, is, has some level 1426 01:12:55,455 --> 01:12:59,655 of skill in being able to pick the right depth of field, pick the right app, 1427 01:12:59,675 --> 01:13:02,735 you know, not, not the right aperture, but the right lens size, the right. 1428 01:13:02,995 --> 01:13:07,255 You, you, it's gonna be hit and miss, but why can't that be something that 1429 01:13:07,255 --> 01:13:10,375 could be supported and which is another, another project that we're working 1430 01:13:10,375 --> 01:13:14,535 on to just help you set up Kameras and set up shots in a way that, that 1431 01:13:14,885 --> 01:13:22,040 deliver interesting composition, um, and Again, make it easier for you to 1432 01:13:22,280 --> 01:13:26,070 communicate just what you can see. 1433 01:13:26,230 --> 01:13:28,910 'cause we can all see, and we can all go, well, that, that looks like a good shot. 1434 01:13:28,930 --> 01:13:31,750 But really, you know, it takes a real, real specialist 1435 01:13:32,615 --> 01:13:32,905 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1436 01:13:34,540 --> 01:13:39,770 Kam Star: Yeah, so, so that there's a whole load in there terms 1437 01:13:39,890 --> 01:13:42,530 of projects and ideas and things that we're working on. 1438 01:13:43,550 --> 01:13:50,190 And the third kind of category for us is, and this kind of goes a little 1439 01:13:50,190 --> 01:13:54,350 bit back to the rabbit one, um, you know, internally we, we, it's 1440 01:13:54,370 --> 01:13:58,030 for us is intuitive interfaces or intuitive collaborative interfaces. 1441 01:13:58,460 --> 01:13:59,990 What do we mean by intuitive? 1442 01:14:00,710 --> 01:14:06,950 I mean, I don't have to remember which screen I have to go to and 1443 01:14:06,950 --> 01:14:10,430 which option I have to pick in order to do the thing that I want. 1444 01:14:10,830 --> 01:14:14,670 I should just be able to intuitively say, uh, I wanna modify this 1445 01:14:14,670 --> 01:14:17,030 thing or help me do this thing. 1446 01:14:17,934 --> 01:14:21,475 And there, there, there is an expectation, and this is generally 1447 01:14:21,475 --> 01:14:25,755 the trajectory is you'll be able to talk to your software in a way that is 1448 01:14:25,755 --> 01:14:31,555 much more intuitive than navigating a, a, a, a, a very complex menu system. 1449 01:14:32,175 --> 01:14:37,715 Um, even if it's a simple menu system in order to do something, sometimes 1450 01:14:38,615 --> 01:14:44,075 we underestimate how much time you're spending just clicking to get 1451 01:14:44,095 --> 01:14:49,434 to the right thing so that you can then, oh, you know, play with it in 1452 01:14:49,434 --> 01:14:52,635 order to, you know, that there's a huge amount of time that that takes 1453 01:14:53,575 --> 01:14:58,035 and, and an intuitive interface should allow you to just say, 1454 01:14:58,095 --> 01:14:59,434 Hey, I'm trying to do this. 1455 01:14:59,855 --> 01:15:05,475 And either it just brings up this, the, the right screen, or ideally it 1456 01:15:05,475 --> 01:15:09,355 kind of does it for you and just brings you up the, the only points of control 1457 01:15:09,825 --> 01:15:10,835 that, that you need. 1458 01:15:11,335 --> 01:15:11,555 Um, 1459 01:15:11,900 --> 01:15:12,670 Evan Troxel: it's contextual. 1460 01:15:12,690 --> 01:15:13,190 in that way. 1461 01:15:13,190 --> 01:15:13,470 Yeah. 1462 01:15:13,620 --> 01:15:17,790 It's like recommending, uh, or, or even learning from how things 1463 01:15:17,790 --> 01:15:21,190 you've done in the past and saying, okay, I've seen this pattern before. 1464 01:15:21,730 --> 01:15:24,309 Here's probably what's coming next, kind of a thing. 1465 01:15:25,405 --> 01:15:28,015 Kam Star: That, That, that, that, is, that would be absolutely amazing 1466 01:15:28,115 --> 01:15:32,735 to, to, for, to, to, to have the kind of, the history of the way that you 1467 01:15:33,055 --> 01:15:37,805 interact and to be able to preempt you in a way that doesn't feel, um, 1468 01:15:38,275 --> 01:15:40,325 intrusive, actually feels quite helpful. 1469 01:15:41,225 --> 01:15:47,005 Um, and, and that's, you know, again, we see some of that in the way that 1470 01:15:47,005 --> 01:15:50,805 maybe if you use the Google Gmail suite is now kind of predicting the 1471 01:15:50,805 --> 01:15:52,125 next few words that you're gonna say. 1472 01:15:52,125 --> 01:15:52,805 So you can just press 1473 01:15:52,905 --> 01:15:53,125 tab. 1474 01:15:53,735 --> 01:15:54,085 Right. 1475 01:15:54,825 --> 01:15:58,045 Um, or, or if you tend to respond in the same way. 1476 01:15:58,605 --> 01:15:58,725 I. 1477 01:15:58,725 --> 01:16:02,200 And a message comes through, one of the options is the way you talk. 1478 01:16:02,980 --> 01:16:06,960 Um, but apply that into the, the kind of, into, into the 1479 01:16:07,120 --> 01:16:08,120 software, into the interface. 1480 01:16:08,580 --> 01:16:12,470 And of course that's, those are kind of more application oriented. 1481 01:16:13,170 --> 01:16:19,390 Um, and that's not to say just using machine learning to improve the visual 1482 01:16:19,750 --> 01:16:24,470 fidelity, the, the level of noise that you might have in a, on a thing or, 1483 01:16:24,470 --> 01:16:25,790 you know, and everything around it. 1484 01:16:26,450 --> 01:16:33,950 Um, we continuously go back to our roots, which is to focus on the workflow. 1485 01:16:34,410 --> 01:16:35,710 To focus on the workflow. 1486 01:16:35,910 --> 01:16:41,630 I identified, identified bottlenecks, identify friction points, things 1487 01:16:41,700 --> 01:16:45,140 that are the works of a specialist. 1488 01:16:46,140 --> 01:16:50,960 And you know, this year we'll be doing some, we'll bring out 1489 01:16:50,960 --> 01:16:55,920 some amazing capabilities that allow you to visualize what. 1490 01:16:56,885 --> 01:17:01,455 Your building does in the real world when it comes to energy use, um, and, 1491 01:17:02,075 --> 01:17:09,445 and comfort and lighting and all of those factors at design time in real time. 1492 01:17:10,785 --> 01:17:14,365 How much carbon is my building using as I'm designing it in real time? 1493 01:17:14,695 --> 01:17:15,045 Evan Troxel: Right. 1494 01:17:15,355 --> 01:17:15,645 Yeah. 1495 01:17:16,225 --> 01:17:19,125 Kam Star: and, and, and these, these are, again, go back to kind of the 1496 01:17:19,365 --> 01:17:24,715 workflow and the way that, that, what happens today, it's laborious. 1497 01:17:25,415 --> 01:17:28,675 You design something as an architect, you have to then give it to somebody 1498 01:17:28,675 --> 01:17:30,195 else to go and analyze it for you. 1499 01:17:30,195 --> 01:17:33,395 And maybe they'll come back to you two weeks later and give you a number 1500 01:17:34,455 --> 01:17:38,155 and you have to guess how I'm gonna be able to improve that number. 1501 01:17:38,655 --> 01:17:41,315 You have no dial that, that, that you can see in real time. 1502 01:17:41,815 --> 01:17:45,875 If I just turn this building a little bit more or extend this, sunshade 1503 01:17:45,875 --> 01:17:49,035 it a little bit more, or, or angle this or shorten this, this is the 1504 01:17:49,035 --> 01:17:50,875 impact I'm gonna have immediate 1505 01:17:50,905 --> 01:17:53,875 Roderick Bates: Yeah, I, nevermind communicating that data to those that 1506 01:17:53,875 --> 01:17:58,115 aren't trained in the field, you know, how do you show a person a, like, I 1507 01:17:58,115 --> 01:18:02,195 don't know, a chart that represents this energy performance data, and they're 1508 01:18:02,195 --> 01:18:03,275 saying, I've never seen this before. 1509 01:18:03,345 --> 01:18:04,035 What does it mean? 1510 01:18:04,575 --> 01:18:04,875 You know? 1511 01:18:04,895 --> 01:18:05,115 So 1512 01:18:05,275 --> 01:18:07,555 Evan Troxel: I mean, and that kind of information is so useful. 1513 01:18:07,895 --> 01:18:10,915 Uh, I mean, it seems like a lot of these things that you're talking 1514 01:18:10,915 --> 01:18:17,315 about, Kam and, and Roderick go back to helping me as a designer sell design. 1515 01:18:18,055 --> 01:18:20,955 And there's some designers who are allergic to that concept 1516 01:18:21,095 --> 01:18:25,075 of, of framing, but at the same, that's what it actually is, right? 1517 01:18:25,255 --> 01:18:30,075 And to link data to decisions that were made during the design process 1518 01:18:30,105 --> 01:18:33,555 because, uh, everybody's been through a really bad VE process. 1519 01:18:33,955 --> 01:18:34,075 right? 1520 01:18:34,145 --> 01:18:37,275 It's like, let's delete those sunshades off the building 1521 01:18:37,275 --> 01:18:38,395 because they're expensive. 1522 01:18:38,395 --> 01:18:42,434 And it's like, well, actually they're linked to the energy model and the 1523 01:18:42,434 --> 01:18:46,155 way that the building performs is only possible because of those. 1524 01:18:46,255 --> 01:18:47,635 So that's off the table. 1525 01:18:47,635 --> 01:18:47,955 Right? 1526 01:18:47,975 --> 01:18:48,755 And for me 1527 01:18:48,755 --> 01:18:48,915 to 1528 01:18:48,915 --> 01:18:49,155 be able 1529 01:18:49,184 --> 01:18:50,705 Roderick Bates: need all these pieces at once though, right? 1530 01:18:50,725 --> 01:18:50,945 You 1531 01:18:50,945 --> 01:18:51,905 know, you need how it looks. 1532 01:18:52,405 --> 01:18:55,825 Um, and you need to know the, the impact on glare and can I actually 1533 01:18:55,825 --> 01:18:56,865 experience the glare? 1534 01:18:57,025 --> 01:18:59,865 'cause if I show someone sort of a rainbow projection, they'll be 1535 01:18:59,865 --> 01:19:00,745 like, well, I don't really know. 1536 01:19:00,765 --> 01:19:03,385 But if you put 'em, say like they look at a view and they can see that every 1537 01:19:03,625 --> 01:19:07,145 computer's completely washed out and no one's gonna be able to see anything 1538 01:19:07,215 --> 01:19:10,385 from eight to 1130 in the morning, then that's a very different deal. 1539 01:19:11,045 --> 01:19:14,745 And you can also bring into that a, um, energy intensity and a comfort 1540 01:19:15,145 --> 01:19:18,985 analysis that's spatially relevant and viewable within a rendering. 1541 01:19:20,125 --> 01:19:21,825 You know, you have a pretty powerful argument there 1542 01:19:21,995 --> 01:19:22,415 Evan Troxel: You do. 1543 01:19:22,415 --> 01:19:25,375 And, and when that client or that contractor or whoever 1544 01:19:25,375 --> 01:19:28,415 it is who's questioning says, wow, you thought about that? 1545 01:19:28,725 --> 01:19:29,135 Like, yep. 1546 01:19:29,775 --> 01:19:30,515 That's what we do. 1547 01:19:30,575 --> 01:19:36,195 That's why you paid us to do this, because we thought about all of that stuff. 1548 01:19:36,295 --> 01:19:40,755 And if I have a, a copilot helping me along the way that is kind of tallying 1549 01:19:40,755 --> 01:19:45,795 these things and giving me feedback, like I'm watching the RPM gauge and 1550 01:19:45,795 --> 01:19:50,315 the speedometer and the oil pressure and when I'm driving, like that 1551 01:19:50,335 --> 01:19:51,075 to me is 1552 01:19:51,255 --> 01:19:51,475 is. 1553 01:19:51,684 --> 01:19:52,675 super valuable. 1554 01:19:52,915 --> 01:19:56,075 I think that that's a, it's, it sounds incredible 1555 01:19:56,365 --> 01:19:59,345 Roderick Bates: Oh, I we're really excited about this one, honestly. 1556 01:19:59,405 --> 01:20:02,705 And, uh, it's something that one of the challenges that just like 1557 01:20:02,705 --> 01:20:05,665 with visualization is that you need to have real quality to it. 1558 01:20:05,805 --> 01:20:07,025 For it to have value. 1559 01:20:07,245 --> 01:20:11,145 You just can't have telling someone, this is what your energy performance is. 1560 01:20:11,205 --> 01:20:12,625 That's not backed up by 1561 01:20:13,375 --> 01:20:15,755 Uh, a very powerful analysis engine. 1562 01:20:16,095 --> 01:20:18,555 The proper inputs and things like that, it's meaningless. 1563 01:20:18,615 --> 01:20:21,275 So one of the things that we're particularly excited about is for that 1564 01:20:21,275 --> 01:20:25,635 initiative that we partner with an outside entity called IES outta Scotland, and they 1565 01:20:25,635 --> 01:20:27,155 have a great reputation in the industry. 1566 01:20:27,455 --> 01:20:31,075 And so we're able to really combine sort of two cla best in class technologies, 1567 01:20:31,495 --> 01:20:33,155 us and the visualization side. 1568 01:20:33,655 --> 01:20:37,475 Um, and then their, them with the, um, the building performance side 1569 01:20:37,475 --> 01:20:41,195 and then bringing 'em together in a way that maintains our ease of use, 1570 01:20:41,934 --> 01:20:47,315 um, and our mechanisms for visual communication with sort of their, their 1571 01:20:47,315 --> 01:20:50,675 computational power when it comes to the building performance analysis. 1572 01:20:50,675 --> 01:20:52,275 It's a really nice combination. 1573 01:20:53,605 --> 01:20:55,335 Evan Troxel: when I saw you demo that. 1574 01:20:56,725 --> 01:20:59,825 or I don't, I don't know how it's gonna work its way into one when it finally 1575 01:20:59,825 --> 01:21:04,905 gets released, but when, when I saw that I am particularly interested in it, 1576 01:21:05,005 --> 01:21:09,785 in the same way that I was interested in what real-time rendering did to, I. 1577 01:21:10,395 --> 01:21:16,125 Give designers the ability to use a tool, a new tool to make decisions 1578 01:21:16,625 --> 01:21:18,725 in their already normal process. 1579 01:21:18,855 --> 01:21:19,205 Right? 1580 01:21:19,205 --> 01:21:23,925 Because if I have the visual fidelity, I understand light and shade and shadow 1581 01:21:24,025 --> 01:21:25,725 in real time as I'm modeling and making 1582 01:21:25,965 --> 01:21:29,645 decisions about heights of walls, locations of things, how big is the 1583 01:21:29,765 --> 01:21:32,365 aperture for the window to go outside? 1584 01:21:32,745 --> 01:21:36,845 And I can see the impact of that and, and use that as a tool rather 1585 01:21:36,845 --> 01:21:39,845 than at the end of a process, which you and I have talked about before, 1586 01:21:39,845 --> 01:21:40,525 Roderick, right? 1587 01:21:40,525 --> 01:21:43,125 Which is, this was a deliverable at the end of a process. 1588 01:21:43,265 --> 01:21:46,925 Now it's actually front loaded and I'm using it to help me make decisions. 1589 01:21:47,385 --> 01:21:50,965 The energy part of that is, this is a big deal, right? 1590 01:21:51,025 --> 01:21:56,085 To be able to use that tool in real time as I'm designing to give me feedback 1591 01:21:56,395 --> 01:22:00,445 when it, when it comes to understanding, building performance. 1592 01:22:01,145 --> 01:22:04,125 And I never thought that would come through a visualization tool, but it makes 1593 01:22:04,125 --> 01:22:08,165 total sense because that's how, that's the language I speak is very visual, right? 1594 01:22:08,355 --> 01:22:09,035 Roderick Bates: what we figured, right? 1595 01:22:09,035 --> 01:22:10,035 It's, it's the same language. 1596 01:22:10,035 --> 01:22:10,395 People speak. 1597 01:22:10,395 --> 01:22:13,195 Well, I will say that most, we actually went to a lot of different potential 1598 01:22:13,195 --> 01:22:16,795 technology partners and, and asked them about potentially partner on this. 1599 01:22:16,795 --> 01:22:20,595 And we were told by all of 'em until we got to is, uh, that this wasn't possible. 1600 01:22:21,055 --> 01:22:23,035 Um, so that's how you know you're onto something good 1601 01:22:23,035 --> 01:22:23,915 when it comes to innovation. 1602 01:22:24,175 --> 01:22:25,715 Uh, that's when people say, nah, I can't be done. 1603 01:22:25,715 --> 01:22:26,035 Sorry. 1604 01:22:26,615 --> 01:22:27,515 Um, too hard. 1605 01:22:27,895 --> 01:22:33,465 And so I think what's fun about this one is that, um, we are aligning 1606 01:22:33,775 --> 01:22:38,210 sort of philosophically with . Um, the, our intent as a software, you 1607 01:22:38,210 --> 01:22:41,450 know, maintaining that ease of use and what that does all of a sudden is 1608 01:22:41,450 --> 01:22:44,730 it greatly expands the accessibility of, of the energy performance. 1609 01:22:44,730 --> 01:22:47,730 So Kam said, you know, maybe wait two weeks to get back your 1610 01:22:47,890 --> 01:22:48,730 building performance model. 1611 01:22:48,730 --> 01:22:51,610 As I can assure you, it's a heck of a lot longer than that usually. 1612 01:22:52,150 --> 01:22:55,809 And that's the, the beauty of something like this is now we're making it 1613 01:22:55,809 --> 01:22:59,290 just like with rendering, where you used to have to send it out to 1614 01:22:59,360 --> 01:23:01,730 potentially a outside specialist firm. 1615 01:23:02,309 --> 01:23:02,530 Um, 1616 01:23:03,070 --> 01:23:03,290 or 1617 01:23:03,290 --> 01:23:04,850 maybe it was just so complicated. 1618 01:23:04,910 --> 01:23:08,570 You only did it once for a phase, you know, for like sort of the, the big thing 1619 01:23:08,570 --> 01:23:11,330 to get the donors on board, if you will, for the project or something like that. 1620 01:23:11,910 --> 01:23:14,690 You know, now you can do it iteratively and all of a sudden that changes, right? 1621 01:23:14,690 --> 01:23:18,330 It changes the nature of what visualization means in design is that 1622 01:23:18,330 --> 01:23:22,730 it's actually a tool for all the little decisions you have to make as opposed to 1623 01:23:22,730 --> 01:23:24,650 just sort of a, a big fade of complete. 1624 01:23:25,190 --> 01:23:27,610 And same thing with building performance, you know, now it's not 1625 01:23:27,610 --> 01:23:29,570 just like, well, that's where we landed. 1626 01:23:30,540 --> 01:23:31,130 Tough deal. 1627 01:23:31,580 --> 01:23:32,680 Evan Troxel: now, let's justify it. 1628 01:23:33,015 --> 01:23:33,825 Roderick Bates: Yeah, exactly 1629 01:23:34,150 --> 01:23:35,080 Evan Troxel: Pros, justification. 1630 01:23:35,440 --> 01:23:38,520 I, I mean, I, and really it takes, it takes tools like this. 1631 01:23:38,600 --> 01:23:45,040 I think there would be people who will be nervous about this because, um, it, it, to 1632 01:23:45,040 --> 01:23:48,280 our point earlier about it, democratizing it and it just becomes table stakes. 1633 01:23:48,280 --> 01:23:50,840 Everybody's gotta do this in this regard. 1634 01:23:50,840 --> 01:23:55,520 That's, this is a really huge benefit for the entire industry to get tools like this 1635 01:23:55,990 --> 01:23:57,800 informing the design as they go along. 1636 01:23:58,280 --> 01:23:59,480 I don't have to send it out. 1637 01:23:59,840 --> 01:24:00,960 I don't have to wait two weeks. 1638 01:24:01,360 --> 01:24:02,920 I get the feedback immediately. 1639 01:24:02,960 --> 01:24:06,480 I know if that decision is good or bad immediately, and we can move 1640 01:24:06,480 --> 01:24:12,240 forward and use that tool to make our buildings better immediately. 1641 01:24:12,360 --> 01:24:15,415 I think that that is the kind of thing that, that . Shouldn't scare anybody. 1642 01:24:15,470 --> 01:24:20,010 And the democratization of tools like this is really gonna help the industry move 1643 01:24:20,010 --> 01:24:21,690 forward in meaningful ways very quickly. 1644 01:24:22,025 --> 01:24:22,805 Roderick Bates: But we don't want to. 1645 01:24:24,220 --> 01:24:25,350 Just like with ai, right? 1646 01:24:25,350 --> 01:24:28,150 We don't want to take away people's jobs, um, here, right? 1647 01:24:28,150 --> 01:24:32,710 We wanna preserve certain knowledge that aspects of the industry have. 1648 01:24:33,090 --> 01:24:36,190 Um, and engineers in particular, you know, they're incredibly knowledgeable. 1649 01:24:36,570 --> 01:24:40,830 The great thing about partnering with IES is that they have an outstanding 1650 01:24:41,590 --> 01:24:43,710 engineering grade analysis tool. 1651 01:24:44,330 --> 01:24:45,910 And so we use the same engine 1652 01:24:46,570 --> 01:24:48,470 as they use in their tool. 1653 01:24:48,970 --> 01:24:51,110 Um, and we also use the same inputs. 1654 01:24:51,130 --> 01:24:54,510 We just happen to package them up into template files that are 1655 01:24:54,510 --> 01:24:58,809 sort of presorted, if you will, um, with . A more limited array of 1656 01:24:58,809 --> 01:25:01,010 manipulation for a particular context. 1657 01:25:01,710 --> 01:25:05,570 But what's really fascinating is it opens up a particularly unique workflow 1658 01:25:06,180 --> 01:25:10,610 where an engineer that's using the IES sort of professional grade software, 1659 01:25:10,610 --> 01:25:15,130 the I-E-S-V-E software, can actually create one of these template files for 1660 01:25:15,130 --> 01:25:19,250 the project that they're doing for their sort of certification level analysis. 1661 01:25:19,670 --> 01:25:23,050 And they can actually share that with the architect as an input 1662 01:25:23,750 --> 01:25:26,809 for the analysis that they're performing in real time and scape. 1663 01:25:27,430 --> 01:25:31,809 And so all of a sudden now it opens up an opportunity where your building 1664 01:25:31,809 --> 01:25:37,290 performance analysis and scape can happen in real time at the same fidelity and 1665 01:25:37,290 --> 01:25:41,170 using the same assumptions and inputs and things like that as the engineering level 1666 01:25:41,220 --> 01:25:45,720 model, which that's never happened before. 1667 01:25:45,820 --> 01:25:46,040 And 1668 01:25:46,040 --> 01:25:49,360 I think what's great about that is it preserves the expertise of the engineer, 1669 01:25:49,900 --> 01:25:55,960 um, but brings that same level of quality of real time to the architect. 1670 01:25:56,875 --> 01:25:57,455 Evan Troxel: And it, and 1671 01:25:57,455 --> 01:26:01,375 it gives that engineer when it ends up back on their desk later, 1672 01:26:01,565 --> 01:26:03,255 some assurance that it's gonna be 1673 01:26:03,559 --> 01:26:05,090 Roderick Bates: Well, it's more than some assurance, right? 1674 01:26:05,190 --> 01:26:05,809 You know, it's 1675 01:26:06,360 --> 01:26:06,650 yeah. 1676 01:26:07,025 --> 01:26:07,375 Evan Troxel: right? 1677 01:26:07,845 --> 01:26:08,335 Exactly. 1678 01:26:09,220 --> 01:26:09,510 Roderick Bates: Yeah. 1679 01:26:09,880 --> 01:26:13,620 Kam Star: And this is, this is, this is so, um, it, it may, maybe 1680 01:26:13,620 --> 01:26:15,380 it's implied in our conversation. 1681 01:26:16,120 --> 01:26:18,860 Uh, but this is so much more than just justifying our design. 1682 01:26:18,890 --> 01:26:21,700 This is our imperative to make sure that we build 1683 01:26:21,740 --> 01:26:23,180 a world that uses less energy. 1684 01:26:23,250 --> 01:26:23,820 That, that 1685 01:26:24,320 --> 01:26:29,059 we, we address the, the, the real, uh, it's more than an elephant, right? 1686 01:26:29,180 --> 01:26:33,780 It's the entire zoo that's in the room, which is, which is climate change and 1687 01:26:33,800 --> 01:26:38,980 the, the, the impact of, of the, uh, greenhouse gases that, that are having 1688 01:26:39,120 --> 01:26:43,140 on our planet and will continue to do so, certainly for the remainder of my life. 1689 01:26:43,559 --> 01:26:47,620 Um, and, and whatever it is that we can do to address this in, in, in, 1690 01:26:47,760 --> 01:26:49,820 as, as in as many ways as possible. 1691 01:26:50,480 --> 01:26:56,260 Um, and having tools like this will are certainly going to have a huge impact 1692 01:26:56,840 --> 01:27:00,305 on being able to Make better decisions, 1693 01:27:00,725 --> 01:27:04,025 not just for the, not just for the, design, for the, for the 1694 01:27:04,025 --> 01:27:05,345 architect, but for the planet. 1695 01:27:05,485 --> 01:27:06,105 And I know that 1696 01:27:06,105 --> 01:27:09,825 sounds really grandiose, but really that is what it is, right? 1697 01:27:10,205 --> 01:27:10,745 And, and it 1698 01:27:10,745 --> 01:27:14,485 Evan Troxel: Making better decisions sooner only helps the process. 1699 01:27:14,875 --> 01:27:18,684 Like making a great decision late in the game that has to undo or 1700 01:27:18,795 --> 01:27:22,125 redo a bunch of stuff is not, it's cost a lot of money to do that, 1701 01:27:22,135 --> 01:27:22,485 right? 1702 01:27:22,545 --> 01:27:22,925 And so, 1703 01:27:23,000 --> 01:27:24,820 Roderick Bates: but the, but how do you make those decisions, right? 1704 01:27:25,010 --> 01:27:28,780 It's not just the data, it's how that data is presented, how that story is told. 1705 01:27:28,800 --> 01:27:32,980 And what's great is that scape is already used to tell that visual story and that 1706 01:27:32,980 --> 01:27:36,900 we're one of the key components we'll be launching with is that visual story. 1707 01:27:37,200 --> 01:27:39,940 One of those visual stories you can tell now is not just how it looks in 1708 01:27:39,980 --> 01:27:44,700 a purely aesthetic term, but within that same environment, how it performs. 1709 01:27:45,280 --> 01:27:49,059 Uh, so you can see in a building, you know, the same rendered view, say, you 1710 01:27:49,059 --> 01:27:50,700 know, where are your energy hotspots? 1711 01:27:50,960 --> 01:27:52,140 You know, where are my problem areas? 1712 01:27:52,150 --> 01:27:52,980 Where are things great? 1713 01:27:52,980 --> 01:27:54,020 Where are people comfortable? 1714 01:27:54,020 --> 01:27:54,980 Where are they uncomfortable? 1715 01:27:55,440 --> 01:28:00,059 Um, it makes it a much easier to essentially sell, because at 1716 01:28:00,059 --> 01:28:02,260 the end of the day, someone's writing a check for all of this 1717 01:28:02,385 --> 01:28:02,735 Evan Troxel: right. 1718 01:28:03,120 --> 01:28:03,620 Roderick Bates: and Right. 1719 01:28:03,620 --> 01:28:06,100 And if they don't understand the data, they don't understand the 1720 01:28:06,100 --> 01:28:07,140 story that you're telling them. 1721 01:28:07,900 --> 01:28:11,110 Then how are you gonna get them to, to go along with a certain decision 1722 01:28:11,110 --> 01:28:12,110 that you're trying to advocate? 1723 01:28:13,100 --> 01:28:13,390 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1724 01:28:13,540 --> 01:28:13,830 Yeah. 1725 01:28:13,890 --> 01:28:16,350 I'm glad you brought that up about that because the, the, the data 1726 01:28:16,350 --> 01:28:19,590 presentation is one thing, but the, the way it's, it can be communicated 1727 01:28:19,690 --> 01:28:21,230 and, and ultimately understood 1728 01:28:21,809 --> 01:28:23,590 is where the rubber meets the road, right? 1729 01:28:23,590 --> 01:28:26,190 Because if, if you can't build it, it doesn't count, right? 1730 01:28:26,350 --> 01:28:26,550 , it's 1731 01:28:26,550 --> 01:28:27,470 just paper architecture. 1732 01:28:27,770 --> 01:28:29,830 And, and the point here is to build better buildings. 1733 01:28:29,890 --> 01:28:30,309 And so 1734 01:28:30,470 --> 01:28:34,550 I, I'm surprised to see tools like this coming from a visualization company 1735 01:28:34,890 --> 01:28:38,670 and, and, uh, I shouldn't be surprised because of the people I'm talking to 1736 01:28:38,670 --> 01:28:43,309 because you, you're thinking much bigger about the problem and the challenges 1737 01:28:43,540 --> 01:28:46,190 than, than we've ever experienced before. 1738 01:28:46,309 --> 01:28:49,030 I know that there's, there's a lot of people in our industry who are wicked 1739 01:28:49,030 --> 01:28:53,070 smart and, and doing the, the same caliber type of thing that you're doing. 1740 01:28:53,210 --> 01:28:56,350 I'm, I'm really excited to see that coming from you and I, 1741 01:28:56,500 --> 01:28:59,990 it's coming from an unexpected place, but I'm, I'm happy that it's coming at all. 1742 01:29:00,350 --> 01:29:01,990 Roderick Bates: I think it's coming from the place that had 1743 01:29:01,990 --> 01:29:03,030 the hardest problem to solve. 1744 01:29:04,380 --> 01:29:07,850 , which was that visual side, you know, how do you tell the story with this data? 1745 01:29:08,070 --> 01:29:12,559 Um, there's a lot of, of, there's a lot of different tools out 1746 01:29:12,559 --> 01:29:14,080 there and, and energy analysis. 1747 01:29:14,080 --> 01:29:18,670 And the biggest difference among them is sort of a, the, the, well it's the 1748 01:29:18,670 --> 01:29:24,730 calculation engine, obviously, but it's also, um, how complex or like what 1749 01:29:24,730 --> 01:29:25,970 kind of user interface you might have. 1750 01:29:26,090 --> 01:29:27,650 I mean, some of them are just spreadsheets, right. 1751 01:29:27,650 --> 01:29:27,850 you 1752 01:29:27,850 --> 01:29:28,530 know, some of them are, 1753 01:29:28,790 --> 01:29:30,240 Evan Troxel: It's like flying at 7 47. 1754 01:29:30,430 --> 01:29:30,720 Yeah. 1755 01:29:30,960 --> 01:29:31,450 Roderick Bates: exactly. 1756 01:29:32,190 --> 01:29:35,490 So I think that what we are, what, why it's coming from a company like 1757 01:29:35,490 --> 01:29:39,170 us and why I think it had to is that we just brought this imperative of 1758 01:29:39,170 --> 01:29:41,210 ease of use and visual communication 1759 01:29:41,760 --> 01:29:45,010 that you just wouldn't see from sort of a, um, an engineering, 1760 01:29:45,910 --> 01:29:47,809 um, energy model first company. 1761 01:29:48,835 --> 01:29:53,735 Kam Star: And, you know, our, our, our, driving force is, you know, to, 1762 01:29:53,875 --> 01:30:01,015 to really focus on workflow and, and to democratize, you know, make things that 1763 01:30:01,015 --> 01:30:06,415 are for specialist as easy to use for designers so that, so that they can really 1764 01:30:06,895 --> 01:30:11,055 leverage it in their decision making process and, and to focus on the workflow. 1765 01:30:11,055 --> 01:30:16,375 And this is this, of course, it's, it's easy to say, well now we 1766 01:30:16,375 --> 01:30:19,975 know, of course it's obvious, but this is, this is the approach. 1767 01:30:20,125 --> 01:30:21,015 Look at the workflow. 1768 01:30:22,390 --> 01:30:26,730 And identify elements of friction, identify pieces where you think, 1769 01:30:27,070 --> 01:30:28,650 oh, well that's a real specialist. 1770 01:30:28,950 --> 01:30:31,730 To Rod's earlier point, I have to send this off for someone 1771 01:30:31,730 --> 01:30:32,809 to do the visualization. 1772 01:30:33,130 --> 01:30:35,410 I have to send it off to someone to calculate this piece 1773 01:30:35,730 --> 01:30:36,170 I have to send. 1774 01:30:36,260 --> 01:30:37,190 Evan Troxel: talk about loss of 1775 01:30:37,330 --> 01:30:37,490 Kam Star: that, 1776 01:30:37,920 --> 01:30:38,270 Evan Troxel: right? 1777 01:30:38,460 --> 01:30:41,970 Kam Star: every time we hear that and we see that the kind of ears prick 1778 01:30:41,970 --> 01:30:47,650 up, hang on a minute, can this be made so that you can, you can flex it 1779 01:30:47,830 --> 01:30:49,970 as a part of your design experience. 1780 01:30:50,890 --> 01:30:55,970 I mean, you know, and it's, um, maybe this is, maybe this is, this is because, 1781 01:30:56,070 --> 01:31:00,370 and I, and I know, I mean, mean the company of friends, but you know, maybe 1782 01:31:00,370 --> 01:31:05,930 this is the architect in me, uh, kind of looking at our profession over the 1783 01:31:05,930 --> 01:31:08,770 last decades and, and, and maybe longer. 1784 01:31:08,870 --> 01:31:15,280 And seeing how it went from the architect who Um, had complete control over that 1785 01:31:15,380 --> 01:31:22,200 ev every component, the, the structure, the design, the, the every piece to it 1786 01:31:22,440 --> 01:31:29,120 becoming compartmentalized into a series of very narrowly defined disciplines. 1787 01:31:29,660 --> 01:31:34,440 So the architect is now no longer in charge of the structure, in charge 1788 01:31:34,460 --> 01:31:37,200 of the services, in charge of the lighting, in charge of the material? 1789 01:31:37,300 --> 01:31:37,720 No, no. 1790 01:31:37,720 --> 01:31:40,680 It's just no longer, you know, it's kind of, and then, and then they're looking 1791 01:31:40,710 --> 01:31:45,040 back at technology and going, hang on, can we just bring some of this back into 1792 01:31:45,040 --> 01:31:51,280 the design so that we can really flex what a building looks like, feels like? 1793 01:31:51,740 --> 01:31:57,490 Um, and, and perhaps even how it's built as we're designing, as we're 1794 01:31:57,490 --> 01:31:59,490 thinking about the design itself. 1795 01:32:00,145 --> 01:32:03,085 Um, that that'll be an awesome outcome. 1796 01:32:03,155 --> 01:32:08,205 Just, just then, you know, uh, I'm, I, I'm not making apologies, but that would be a 1797 01:32:08,205 --> 01:32:14,045 great thing as an architect, seeing tools that really help somebody make better 1798 01:32:14,325 --> 01:32:19,485 decisions from the multifaceted angle that we have historically have meant to have, 1799 01:32:20,105 --> 01:32:21,045 and, you know, uh, 1800 01:32:21,385 --> 01:32:21,805 should 1801 01:32:21,930 --> 01:32:23,410 Evan Troxel: it's a cohesive solution, 1802 01:32:23,410 --> 01:32:23,730 right? 1803 01:32:23,730 --> 01:32:24,809 It's not just Yeah. 1804 01:32:25,010 --> 01:32:29,370 A a a bunch of parts that have been stuck together because, so, I mean, if, if you 1805 01:32:29,370 --> 01:32:33,410 have that, you know, we, we've used the term all over, you know, for decades and 1806 01:32:33,410 --> 01:32:37,570 decades about the master builder, but this idea of somebody who is the orchestrator. 1807 01:32:39,105 --> 01:32:42,365 And that could be a team of a small team of people, or it could be a person, but 1808 01:32:42,365 --> 01:32:47,125 it's, it's that kind of thinking to bring the level of craft of really making sure 1809 01:32:47,125 --> 01:32:48,845 all those puzzle pieces fit together. 1810 01:32:49,355 --> 01:32:50,365 Exactly like how 1811 01:32:50,365 --> 01:32:51,525 they, they intend. 1812 01:32:52,565 --> 01:32:55,065 Roderick Bates: And maybe to bring it down to the sad reality too, 1813 01:32:55,065 --> 01:32:59,425 of calling back some fee because that's the other side of it that's, 1814 01:32:59,425 --> 01:33:00,785 that's, that's been hurting, uh, 1815 01:33:01,065 --> 01:33:01,545 Evan Troxel: worth something. 1816 01:33:01,715 --> 01:33:02,945 Right, right. 1817 01:33:03,695 --> 01:33:08,184 Well, gentlemen, I appreciate you sharing these visions with us and sharing a bit 1818 01:33:08,184 --> 01:33:12,385 of the roadmap of, of things that are to come and maybe some unexpected things 1819 01:33:12,455 --> 01:33:13,745 that are, that are gonna be coming. 1820 01:33:14,285 --> 01:33:17,905 Uh, I, I appreciate you taking that time to spend with and, and 1821 01:33:17,905 --> 01:33:20,905 elaborate on the things that we were talking about at Autodesk University 1822 01:33:20,975 --> 01:33:24,065 with the audience here, because we didn't get to record that one. 1823 01:33:24,165 --> 01:33:27,105 So that's the whole point of, of doing this is to, to 1824 01:33:27,105 --> 01:33:28,305 bring it to a wider audience. 1825 01:33:28,405 --> 01:33:31,865 And, and it's been fantastic hanging out with you guys today. 1826 01:33:32,065 --> 01:33:35,985 I, I'm gonna provide links to everywhere that people can find you, so they 1827 01:33:35,985 --> 01:33:41,785 can connect with you online, uh, on LinkedIn to your website, places like 1828 01:33:41,785 --> 01:33:42,825 that, where they can find out more 1829 01:33:42,895 --> 01:33:43,355 Roderick Bates: And chaos. 1830 01:33:43,545 --> 01:33:49,434 Next of course, um, is chaos.com/next is the particular website where you'll 1831 01:33:49,434 --> 01:33:50,995 find a lot of our AI initiatives. 1832 01:33:51,425 --> 01:33:51,715 Evan Troxel: Nice. 1833 01:33:51,985 --> 01:33:52,275 Nice. 1834 01:33:52,455 --> 01:33:52,755 All right. 1835 01:33:52,755 --> 01:33:54,235 Well that'll go in the show notes as well. 1836 01:33:54,455 --> 01:33:58,195 So Kim and Roderick, thank you so much for spending time with me today. 1837 01:33:58,195 --> 01:33:58,715 It's been great. 1838 01:33:58,825 --> 01:33:59,125 Kam Star: So much. 1839 01:33:59,835 --> 01:34:00,615 Roderick Bates: Oh, our pleasure.