And when they dug up the body, . The commission wrote in its official
Jenn:report, even though the impression had long prevailed that Lewis died by
Jenn:his own hand, it seemed more probable he died by the hand of assassins.
Jenn:And that's what opened up this whole idea that
Scott:Welcome to Talk With History.
Scott:I'm your host, Scott, here with my wife and historian, Jenn.
Scott:On this podcast, we give you insights to our history inspired world travels,
Scott:YouTube channel journey, and examine history Through deeper conversations
Scott:with the curious, the explorers and the history lovers out there.
Scott:Now, Jenn, before we get into this episode intro here, I do want to
Scott:mention if folks are listening to this for the first time, this is our 99th.
Scott:episode
Jenn:Yeah.
Scott:and so this is our 99th episode so you're gonna naturally if you're
Scott:well what are you guys doing for your hundredth episode well you guys are just
Scott:gonna have to subscribe and follow us to find out the guest the very special guest
Scott:that we have we have for our hundredth episode it's a truly legit celebrity
Jenn:and big
Scott:and in a big one especially in her history circle so make sure
Scott:that you tell your friends and make sure you're following us, either
Scott:Apple podcast, Spotify, wherever you listen, because a hundredth episode, I
Scott:actually already finished editing it.
Scott:So that one is scheduled as we are recording this, but this one will
Scott:come out and our hundredth episode.
Scott:We'll have a very special guest that I think our listeners are
Scott:getting almost guaranteed to enjoy.
Scott:Today, we're setting sail, well, technically we're setting off on
Scott:horseback, on a journey to explore the life and untimely demise of Meriwether
Scott:Lewis, the intrepid co captain of the Lewis and Clark You know him as the
Scott:guy who explored the vast unknown of the American West alongside William Clark.
Scott:But Lewis's story takes a dark turn after their triumphant return.
Scott:In 1809, at the young age of 35, Lewis was found dead under mysterious Was it
Scott:a tragic case of suicide, or was there a foul play that led to his demise?
Scott:The evidence is murky, and the debate rages on.
Scott:We'll be diving deep into the final days of Lewis's life, examining the
Scott:clues and exploring the theories behind this historical whodunit.
Scott:So saddle up history detectives.
Scott:Join me as we untangle the truth about the mysterious death of Meriwether Lewis.
Scott:All right, Jenn.
Scott:Meriwether Lewis, Lewis and Clark.
Jenn:I know, Big
Jenn:name in American history,
Scott:names.
Jenn:big name, first name, right?
Jenn:He's the beginning of the Lewis and Clark expedition.
Jenn:And really when it comes down to it, Lewis is Jefferson's secretary.
Jenn:When Jefferson buys the Louisiana Purchase.
Scott:know how I remember that?
Scott:is the
Jenn:Oh my gosh
Scott:History.
Scott:The Drunk, there was a Drunk
Jenn:There is a junk history
Scott:and it wasn't about Meriwether Lewis or Jefferson, but it was about who
Scott:was that kind of newspaper article writer?
Scott:Calendar, James Calendar.
Jenn:we made a
Scott:It was a Drunk History about James Calendar and they mentioned
Scott:very briefly that Meriwether Lewis is the secretary for Jefferson at the
Jenn:So they're close, right?
Jenn:They're both from the same area of Virginia.
Jenn:They've kind of run in the same circles and they're close and he's helped
Jenn:squash like the Whiskey Rebellion.
Jenn:He's part of the Virginia militia and he's just a very trusted ally.
Jenn:advisor to Jefferson, and he's kind of an outdoorsy guy.
Jenn:And so it's really Lewis who brings Clark on board, because Jefferson picks
Jenn:Lewis, and Lewis is like, Who have I worked with before that I really liked?
Jenn:I liked Clark when I when we were in the military
Scott:had just finished up the Louisiana purchase.
Scott:So Jefferson's Hey,
Jenn:We need someone to go out and see what I
Scott:you're out doorsy.
Scott:Go explore all
Scott:that, you
Jenn:go see what I bought.
Scott:a jillion acres of land that I just bought.
Jenn:And really, I have to give Lewis a lot of credit, and I love his first
Jenn:name, Meriwether, it's super cool.
Jenn:But he's the one who brings
Jenn:the people together.
Jenn:He's the one who kind of hires Sacagawea's husband, who's a French
Jenn:trader, trapper, who knows the area,
Jenn:sees the knowledge of Sacagawea, sees her importance.
Jenn:Clark who brings his enslaved man York with him, but it's Lewis who's very
Jenn:adamant that we are not going to treat enslaved like enslaved on this trip.
Jenn:Everyone's going to get a fair vote.
Jenn:Everyone is a member of this expedition and it's Lewis who sets this precedence
Jenn:and they very much, even when Sacagawea, they're very much involved in her life
Jenn:because she's pregnant at the time.
Jenn:They're a part of her delivery.
Jenn:They all help with her child, as he's growing up.
Jenn:I mean, Clark will eventually take care of the child.
Scott:And,
Scott:and the expedition's takes two and a half
Jenn:yeah, it's a long
Scott:time
Scott:So by the end of the, the expedition, I mean, her child is probably two years old.
Scott:And,
Jenn:like I said, they're just very close and it's, it's Lewis who
Jenn:sets this whole precedence here.
Jenn:But People see Lewis's
Jenn:mental state.
Jenn:and sometimes he can be melancholy, sometimes he can
Jenn:get a little forlorn, depressed.
Scott:during the expedition as
Scott:well?
Jenn:during the expedition, and Jefferson had seen him do it sometimes as well.
Jenn:There is some family history for Lewis of his father having kind
Jenn:of a mental health deterioration.
Jenn:So there could be a family history of that.
Jenn:And that's not always hereditary, but it can be.
Jenn:So it's just, you have to, acknowledge
Scott:sure
Jenn:Also acknowledge
Jenn:that this expedition took so long.
Jenn:They doubled back a couple times.
Jenn:And in a way, as much as Meriwether,
Jenn:Lewis is
Jenn:very.
Jenn:Vital to all the drawings and all the all those things they
Jenn:are bringing back, all the
Scott:the documentation,
Jenn:he's very good at all of that.
Jenn:They aren't quite getting
Jenn:the whole, the important thing they were supposed to
Scott:get, Yes.
Jenn:which is the waterway,
Scott:They were looking for a waterway from, basically from east to
Jenn:From east to west.
Jenn:And so maybe, maybe almost not Mississippi up, they're just looking for a waterway
Jenn:that could take you from Pacific, maybe down the Mississippi, maybe to Gulf.
Jenn:So basically, you're not going completely around South America,
Jenn:because at the time, there's no Panama.
Jenn:And so you can tell that Maybe he's in that.
Jenn:And I'm a historian.
Jenn:I'm just kind of giving an idea.
Jenn:I don't know.
Jenn:He's feeling less
Jenn:optimistic
Jenn:about that.
Jenn:And so then he's the pessimism that he's not hitting the thing that he
Jenn:was really supposed to discover.
Jenn:And that's becoming more realistic as the expedition goes on.
Scott:I think it's It's something that the general public doesn't really think
Scott:about when you're learning about the whole Lewis and Clark expedition, because we see
Scott:it as a, in a, through a fairly romantic
Jenn:Mm hmm
Scott:Oh my gosh, that's so amazing.
Scott:What would it be like to be on the Lewis and Clark expedition?
Scott:Exploring this.
Scott:all this land and seeing Oregon for the first time and all the stuff that the, you
Scott:kind of, especially as someone from the West coast, learning about that, but you
Scott:don't think about, well, what was their true mission, their mission, like what
Scott:was their goal and if their goal, like the one thing that they set out to accomplish,
Scott:aside from just the general nature of the expedition that they weren't able to.
Scott:Someone like Mary Weather Lewis that might have affected
Jenn:Sure, so you can think, he's almost in charge of
Jenn:this.
Jenn:He's worked for Jefferson.
Jenn:He knows how important this is for Jefferson.
Jenn:Jefferson hasn't.
Jenn:just
Jenn:said, Oh, and if you find a waterway, that would be great.
Jenn:He's probably that's what you need to find.
Jenn:I hope I bought this with a
Jenn:waterway.
Jenn:It's a trade thing.
Jenn:And, but even when they come back like you said, it took a couple
Jenn:of years and they come back.
Jenn:They are very much treated as celebrities.
Jenn:This has made news.
Jenn:I mean, cause they've, they've seen things that never been seen before.
Jenn:They've discovered things that never been seen there by, by the English settlers.
Jenn:I know they're meeting American Indians out there.
Jenn:They've seen the
Scott:Yeah.
Scott:And, French fur
Jenn:French, which they've seen, but this is like for the general public, no one's.
Jenn:And now it's American land.
Jenn:Cause before it was all French land.
Jenn:So kind of letting all the Americans know what's out there.
Jenn:So they are seen as, as.
Jenn:celebrities, . And because of that, after they return home, Lewis is
Jenn:rewarded 1600 acres and he is made the governor of the Louisiana Territory.
Jenn:So when you think Louisiana Purchase, Louisiana Territory,
Jenn:it's bigger than the state.
Jenn:It's like that area.
Jenn:And so the capital Quotes is in st.
Jenn:Louis, and that's where he settles.
Jenn:So
Scott:Yeah, and remember, just for time frame here, I
Scott:mean this is the early 1800s.
Scott:So the expedition was 1803 to 1806, and so they come home, great
Scott:fanfare, and he's made the governor of the general Louisiana area.
Scott:I don't know what they call it,
Jenn:so they call it the upper upper Louisiana
Scott:Okay.
Jenn:And so he's made governor in 1807.
Jenn:So he's gotten back 1807, governor of this Louisiana Territory.
Jenn:Now, what starts to happen is he's, he's writing his journals, he wants
Jenn:to get his journals published.
Jenn:He's, he's starting to establish roads.
Jenn:He's starting to establish laws, right?
Jenn:This is a former French territory.
Jenn:This is a very much American Indian territory.
Jenn:So he has to negotiate peace among all these quarreling Indian tribes.
Jenn:And he's trying to enforce these Indian treaties.
Jenn:And he's trying to protect Western Indian lands and encroachment
Jenn:because Manifest Destiny is a big
Jenn:proponent now of this Lewis and Clark expedition because Americans realize
Jenn:that it's all this land and we want to go
Scott:want to go settle it.
Scott:historian here.
Scott:But the, the American government kind of stoked that fire, right?
Scott:It was, it was part of the whole Manifest Destiny and said, Hey, Manifest
Scott:Destiny, partly to get population out there so that they could kind of expand
Scott:the American population which would then expand everything else within
Jenn:Yeah.
Jenn:And so he's, he's fighting DC, which Jefferson's no longer president.
Jenn:After this, it's going to be Madison, who's very good friends with Jefferson.
Jenn:So it's not like Lewis still isn't, held in high esteem because he
Jenn:is because Madison and Jefferson are basically the same person.
Jenn:And then you, you're going to have these, you're going People who want
Jenn:to come out and settle, you have the American Indians, you have treaties, and
Jenn:he's trying to negotiate all of this.
Jenn:And people in D.
Jenn:C.
Jenn:are wondering, why is this so difficult?
Jenn:Why is, are you having a hard time?
Jenn:And historians have argued that he was a poor administrator, because
Jenn:he was trying to handle all of this.
Jenn:And as he's handling all of this, and bringing in different, Chiefs, he's paying
Jenn:for all of these logistics, whether it is to travel in chiefs or bring people,
Jenn:he's paying for logistics of this.
Jenn:And so he's reaching back to DC to get reimbursed for these things.
Jenn:And DC is well, you're not doing a very good job.
Jenn:And we don't believe that this is the these are accurate receipts and it's
Jenn:putting Lewis in a financial burden.
Jenn:And so this is why he's traveling to DC.
Jenn:He's going to DC to Basically be in person, make the argument, talk
Jenn:about these are the receipts for this and this is the receipts for
Jenn:this and this is what happened here.
Jenn:Now
Jenn:his letters are not very quick and timely and people equate that to his mental
Jenn:illness, that his melancholy, that all these things that he, he wasn't quick
Jenn:to respond to the inquiries from D.
Jenn:C.
Jenn:and because of that.
Jenn:He, the mental illness, and that's also what people don't trust him.
Jenn:It's also why they feel like he's a poor administrator.
Jenn:No one knows for sure.
Jenn:but it could have been other medical reasons that are happening at the
Jenn:time.
Scott:So he, does the expedition for a couple years,
Scott:is kind of disappointed.
Scott:I don't know, did he write that in his journals?
Scott:I mean, I don't remember, I don't remember, but obviously they didn't
Scott:accomplish the one primary mission.
Scott:Accomplished a lot.
Scott:Came back, I don't know if he volunteered, asked for, or was saddled
Scott:with governorship, but it sounds like he, after spending a couple years
Scott:exploring the wilderness, that's quite a shift, going from one to the other.
Scott:Becomes governor of the Upper Louisiana Territory, isn't doing a good
Jenn:good job
Scott:is Basically spending money that he doesn't
Scott:have and
Scott:trying to get reimbursed for it.
Scott:So he says, Hey, I'm going to go make my case to DC.
Scott:I'm going to go talk to Madison who's, I already know because
Scott:he's good buddies with Jefferson.
Scott:I'm going to go to DC, make my case, see if they can get them to reimburse
Scott:me for all this stuff so that I can keep the wheel spinning over
Scott:here in Upper Louisiana Territory.
Scott:Okay.
Scott:Okay.
Jenn:that's the point.
Jenn:He's, he's leaving St.
Jenn:Louis to travel to D.
Jenn:C.
Jenn:to make the argument about these receipts.
Jenn:To get reimbursed, so he's not in financial ruin, to kind
Jenn:of defend his governorship.
Jenn:And he's fighting with the former Louisiana governor, who's down
Jenn:in the lower Louisiana territory.
Jenn:There are differences in governing.
Jenn:Decides
Jenn:to travel from St.
Jenn:Louis.
Jenn:to New Orleans where he's going to get on a big ship and then travel from
Jenn:New Orleans across the Gulf over to
Scott:Okay, so take the Mississippi down to the, basically the Gulf
Scott:and Ocean go up around the coast.
Jenn:And with him, he's bringing I think it was like four big
Jenn:trunks, six big trunks of all of his journals to get published.
Jenn:So finally, that was everybody wanted to see what do these fish look like?
Jenn:What does this fauna
Scott:look
Scott:like, Yeah, it's been a couple years.
Jenn:It's been a couple years, right?
Jenn:And he's finally got them finished.
Jenn:He's going to bring them to DC as well.
Jenn:So it's very precious cargo.
Jenn:So when he hits Memphis, 18.
Jenn:09.
Jenn:This
Jenn:is around the time when the British are starting to act up with impressments.
Jenn:This is going to lead us into the War of 1812.
Jenn:So he's getting a little nervous about going to New Orleans.
Jenn:He's getting nervous about putting his trunks on a ship and, and traveling
Jenn:around Hatteras, North Carolina.
Scott:Yeah, and if you've heard any of our past episodes, like that's
Scott:very dangerous sailing out there
Scott:sometimes.
Jenn:there.
Jenn:Important documents can be lost forever.
Jenn:Aaron Burr.
Jenn:And so he gets nervous and he's when he hits Memphis and he's
Jenn:I'm going to travel from Memphis.
Jenn:Cause you're like, why doesn't he travel from St.
Jenn:Louis across?
Jenn:Why?
Jenn:Why does he go down to Memphis?
Jenn:And then, so for Memphis, he goes, I'm going to go across to DC and I'm going to
Scott:so, he's I'm going to go across Tennessee, kind of take that route
Jenn:I'm going to get on the Natchez trace, which is a trail that's easily
Jenn:traveled and I'm going to go to DC.
Scott:Gotcha.
Jenn:So he hits Memphis.
Jenn:He gets malaria.
Jenn:He gets sick.
Jenn:And if we know anything about Memphis, mosquitoes, yellow fever, right?
Jenn:And he gets sick.
Jenn:Malaria can make you delirious.
Jenn:He's taking opium.
Jenn:Those are the kind of pills that you took to combat the
Jenn:fever that you get with malaria.
Jenn:And he He has a suicide attempt or that's what they claim.
Jenn:He was trying to jump off the side of the ship
Scott:Yeah.
Scott:He was probably just like super high or hallucinating.
Jenn:they stop him from doing that and they're like, he had a suicide attempt.
Jenn:So this is, these are the things that kind of
Jenn:back the case of the future
Jenn:Suicide claim.
Jenn:So
Jenn:he's there for a couple of weeks.
Jenn:He, It gets a travel buddy.
Jenn:Basically, his name is Neely, and he's a Chickasaw Indian agent.
Jenn:He will bring his enslaved man with him.
Jenn:Lewis is traveling with a free black servant, Perna.
Jenn:He's not.
Jenn:enslaved.
Jenn:He's, but he's, hasn't been paid in a while.
Jenn:So he's owed like 200, so he's traveling with Louis still but he hasn't been paid.
Jenn:Because Louis doesn't have any money, because it's all tied up in his receipts.
Jenn:Neely comes with him, they take, they take, two big trunks with
Jenn:them, two goes with Lewis, two goes with Neely on a a wagon.
Jenn:And they start to travel from Memphis about two weeks later after he gets better
Jenn:to up the Natchez trace up to Nashville.
Jenn:Cause the Natchez trace takes you from Natchez, Mississippi to Nashville.
Jenn:And he hits grinder stand alone because two of the horses have run
Jenn:away and Neely goes looking for those two horses and he goes by himself.
Jenn:The two servants, the one enslaved man and the one free man of color travel
Jenn:behind Lewis with the four trunks.
Scott:Okay.
Scott:And Grindr stand was like, basically like an inn, like a
Scott:place for the people to stop.
Jenn:So Grinders stand is a stand or an inn.
Jenn:They call it a stand is kind of a word for in,
Scott:Oh, okay.
Jenn:and it's located on the Natchez Trace.
Jenn:It was owned by the grinder.
Jenn:So Robert grinder and Priscilla grinder, but there was no D in their name.
Jenn:So it's Grinner,
Scott:Oh, okay.
Jenn:but the D was added for the stand.
Jenn:Grinder stand, but they're Grinner.
Jenn:And so kind of a, when you're looking for their names in the, in the
Jenn:archive, there's no D in their names,
Scott:classic historian switcheroo,
Jenn:is hard for historians.
Jenn:There's a lot of these names that we use here are misspelled
Jenn:or the spelling is changed.
Jenn:It was two rough log cabins.
Jenn:And this is the whole reason why we do this video is we stopped at that
Jenn:location where they have recreated grinder stand along the trace.
Jenn:And there is Merriweather Lewis's grave.
Jenn:There were two cabins that kind of were adjoined at right angles.
Jenn:There was kind of a dog trot between them, so they weren't connected.
Jenn:And that's why when you hear Priscilla Grinder doesn't sleep in the same
Jenn:cabin as Merriweather Lewis that night, it's because she's in the other one.
Jenn:A dog trot between them is not a lot, right?
Jenn:And with wood planks, there's not a lot.
Jenn:You can hear, right?
Jenn:So just, just bear in mind,
Scott:And that's that's what, that's why she's able to hear what
Jenn:Yes.
Jenn:Even though she's going to give three separate accounts.
Jenn:over the years of what happened that
Scott:Like three different
Jenn:three different
Scott:ones,
Scott:Oh,
Jenn:even though she really is the only witness, besides the two men
Jenn:who are traveling with them, the two men of color, which we'll talk about.
Jenn:So Meriwether Lewis gets there on the night of October 10th,
Jenn:1809.
Jenn:He
Jenn:gets there about six o'clock and He asks for a room, and she gives him
Jenn:the one whole cabin, and then she with her children are in another room.
Jenn:Now, where's Robert, where's her husband?
Jenn:There's a family folklore from the Grinder family that Robert
Jenn:caught Priscilla and Louis in bed
Jenn:together.
Jenn:And Robert was will be the one to shoot Lewis and then he runs away to Texas
Jenn:and that really did happen right after Meriwether Lewis is killed at the log
Jenn:cabin.
Jenn:Robert is gone to Texas.
Jenn:He runs away.
Scott:I didn't know that.
Jenn:So this stand used to be called
Jenn:Indian Line
Jenn:stand, and they had just opened it because the Chickasaw had seceded this
Jenn:land to Tennessee in 1805, and they had just established this stand in 1807.
Jenn:So it's only been around for two years.
Jenn:But Robert Grinder made his money by selling alcohol to the American Indians.
Jenn:That's the whole, that's what he, that was his business there.
Jenn:So he's not like the most upstanding guy.
Jenn:You have to understand, the trace, too, is not a very, lawful area.
Scott:Yeah, I mean, it's a wilderness path.
Jenn:Yes.
Jenn:And so you're going to get highwaymen, you're going to get bandits,
Jenn:because most people are traveling with some kind of means with them.
Jenn:And it's just think of Robin Hood.
Jenn:It's a very easy way to rob people because who are they going to rob?
Jenn:We're going to get right here along this middle of nowhere path.
Jenn:So Meriwether Lewis gets there before his enslaved men who are coming behind
Jenn:him with these four trunks, gets a room.
Jenn:He gets, he eats dinner, Priscilla and the children go to the other room.
Jenn:cabin and he's there in the night or before the end of the night, the two
Jenn:men of color get there and they're put up in like a barn, like a lean to
Jenn:that's a little bit away from the house.
Jenn:Not far, but because we've been there, if you want to see our video, it's
Jenn:probably where the parking lot is.
Jenn:So it's not
Scott:Yeah, everything's pretty
Scott:close
Jenn:pretty close.
Jenn:And they there and there for the night.
Jenn:Well, about two o'clock in the middle of the night, two gunshots
Jenn:pretty close together go off.
Jenn:Now, Priscilla like I said, there's three different stories that she gives.
Jenn:She gives a story right away when Neely gets there,
Jenn:the day later, Neely will get there after he's died.
Jenn:Neely will be the one who will be the eyewitness to, he'll
Jenn:hear Priscilla's first story.
Jenn:Her first story is, she heard the two gunshots.
Jenn:She had her children go wake the servants, the two men, the two men went to Lewis.
Jenn:Lewis was distraught and he's, he gave these great like last lines,
Jenn:like I am too strong to die.
Jenn:The Lord take me.
Jenn:He was begging for water.
Jenn:They gave him water.
Jenn:He basically bled out and died.
Jenn:About six years later, she's interviewed again for a newspaper and she
Jenn:claims that Louis came to her door.
Jenn:After she heard the two gunshots, knocked on her door, screaming and
Jenn:like moaning, asking for water.
Jenn:She was too afraid to give him water.
Jenn:She heard him scratching the, the gourd of the bucket at
Jenn:the well, trying to get water.
Jenn:And she's still too afraid to go out and give him water.
Jenn:He comes to her door again, knocking for water.
Jenn:Please help me get some water.
Jenn:He , wanders around, they see him like, fall down.
Jenn:He falls over a tree stump, he falls down, and then, and then she sends her
Jenn:two kids to go get the two servants.
Jenn:And then two servants come and help him.
Jenn:And same thing, he's asking for water, they give him water and he dies.
Jenn:And then the end of her life it's, it's a It's, he was the night
Jenn:he was screaming and yelling.
Jenn:He was like talking to himself.
Jenn:He, it was almost like he was having a conversation with himself at dinner.
Jenn:And then he got very aggressive.
Jenn:He looked out the window and was like talking to someone
Jenn:who was very aggressive.
Jenn:And she asked him questions and he like just stared at her and she
Jenn:didn't understand what was happening.
Jenn:And he was, he was just very like, someone's following me.
Jenn:Like he was very anxious.
Jenn:And.
Jenn:She wasn't sure what that was all and that's like the end of her life.
Jenn:She's telling this
Jenn:story.
Jenn:So three separate
Jenn:stories Even though she really is the only eyewitness and then the
Jenn:family story is Robert grinder
Jenn:. When the ser when when Perna and Neely's servant find the Lewis in the room.
Jenn:He's conscious, but a piece of his forehead is blown
Jenn:away, exposing his brain.
Jenn:And it says without having blood much, which I find very hard to believe,
Jenn:but he was wearing a Buffalo robe, Buffalo skin robe, probably what he
Jenn:got from his expedition, because he probably gathered a lot of things.
Jenn:He's I bet the blood, you couldn't tell from the Buffalo skin.
Jenn:And he had uncovered the side with, he showed the, but a bullet
Jenn:had entered right under his chest.
Jenn:So when I say he was shot in the gut, like he was shot in the
Jenn:gut, like right under his chest.
Jenn:It was the second and he begged them to take his rifle and blow out his brain.
Jenn:So he had asked them to finish the job.
Jenn:And in return, he'd give him all the money he had in his trunk.
Jenn:He said, I'm no coward, but I'm so strong, so hard to die.
Jenn:He told Perna, not to be afraid that he would not hurt him, but
Jenn:two hours later he had died just as the sun rose above the trees.
Jenn:They kind of just let him die.
Jenn:He will bury him in the Pioneer Cemetery, which is right beside
Jenn:the cabin, if you see our
Scott:like 50
Jenn:So Pioneer Cemetery what are you talking about?
Jenn:When people take this Natchez Trace, think of it a lot like the Oregon Trail.
Jenn:Think of people are settling, right?
Jenn:They're moving their families and people will die along the trail
Jenn:because of disease and sickness.
Jenn:And it's very sad even when we looked at some of them that are marked, which I'm
Jenn:sure that is very few that are marked.
Jenn:But do you see
Jenn:infant?
Scott:I think we saw
Jenn:Yes.
Jenn:Do you see a whole families?
Jenn:You see it, so it very much is reminiscent of the Oregon Trail, where people will
Jenn:get sick, it'll take out a whole family.
Jenn:You probably have different kind of massacres that are
Jenn:happening along the trace.
Jenn:I mean, this is still very volatile, white settlers, American Indians.
Jenn:And it's just a, a cemetery that was along the trace there.
Jenn:And so he's buried there in that cemetery.
Jenn:Neely wrote a letter to Jefferson saying that he decently buried him
Jenn:as I could in that place, and if there's anything else they'd like him
Jenn:to do, he's, he waited instructions.
Jenn:So the only doctor to examine Lewis's body did not do so
Jenn:until 40 years later in 1848.
Jenn:The Tennessee State Commission, including Dr.
Jenn:Samuel Moore, was charged with locating Lewis's grave.
Jenn:So there was some guy who ran the cemetery who knew where Lewis's grave was.
Jenn:It's it's over here.
Jenn:And when they dug up the body, they verified that there was a
Jenn:gunshot to the head and to the gut.
Jenn:The commission wrote in its official report, even though the impression
Jenn:had long prevailed that Lewis died by his own hand, it seemed more probable
Jenn:he died by the hand of assassins.
Jenn:And that's what opened up this whole idea that it wasn't suicide.
Jenn:It
Scott:Well, to be perfectly just from a common sense perspective, it, it
Scott:seems unlikely to me that someone would try to shoot themselves in the gut.
Scott:And then in the head, right?
Scott:Like he would do this himself.
Scott:Like he would try
Jenn:Yeah, well, if they think he shot himself in the head first,
Scott:And then he tried to shoot
Jenn:yeah, which I think you'd be so delirious from a headshot.
Jenn:I mean, your brain is exposed.
Scott:Whole thing is just
Jenn:a gun.
Jenn:Right.
Jenn:So it just seems.
Jenn:improbable, but because Jefferson and Clark, when they both hear of
Jenn:the suicide, and because of what had happened two weeks earlier with them,
Jenn:with him trying to jump off the boat, and because they knew him to be melancholy
Jenn:at times and not good keeping up his correspondence, they weren't surprised
Jenn:by the suicide the suicide theory.
Jenn:And because of that, you get.
Jenn:Like I said, famous historian Stephen Ambrose, who wrote Undaunted Courage
Jenn:about the whole Lewis and Clark expedition, who's not questioning the
Scott:suicides.
Scott:Yeah it was just kind of universally
Jenn:very much.
Jenn:And because there could be a family component because, and for me, there is
Jenn:one thing that kind of really is strong for me that it, that it was more suicide
Jenn:than someone else is that when Lewis sees.
Jenn:the two servants.
Jenn:He doesn't say, someone shot me, right?
Jenn:He doesn't say this was someone else.
Jenn:Now, he doesn't say he was robbed, although no money is found that he
Jenn:had, he had borrowed money when he went to Fort Pickering to make the trip.
Jenn:The money's gone.
Jenn:But there could be other people.
Jenn:Plus, there are other theories.
Jenn:People have put forth James Wilkinson that was the governor of Louisiana.
Jenn:That didn't like him very much, that was kind of following him,
Jenn:that he had paid someone to do it.
Jenn:And that's kind of what he was so kind of afraid about.
Jenn:Like he knew someone was after him and that he was more mad about the situation.
Jenn:So he's not going to be like, someone shot me.
Jenn:He was more like, why can't I just die just so now there's other
Jenn:theories against the suicide that he.
Jenn:was not in his right state of mind, and the theories for that are the
Jenn:malaria because of the opium and syphilis has been put because,
Jenn:and Clark has a child with an American Indian woman while he's on the expedition.
Scott:Lewis?
Scott:Oh, Clark does.
Jenn:So it's not far fetched to think Lewis probably wasn't sleeping
Jenn:with American Indian women as well.
Scott:Yeah.
Jenn:And you see there is evidence of Lewis looking up ways to cure
Jenn:syphilis, ways to cure venereal disease.
Jenn:And he was taking, I think it was Mercury tablets or something to help and but
Jenn:if everybody knows stages of syphilis do involve mental delirium because
Jenn:it does it's a disease that affects your brain and so those are theories.
Jenn:that family has put forth about his erratic behavior, about the way he was
Jenn:acting, about the melancholy, about all of these things where he's so good in some
Jenn:essences of his job as governor, and then he'll be so backwards and not communicate.
Jenn:And then he's so good again.
Jenn:And then he's so backwards that he he's having these issues with this mental.
Jenn:health, and it's brought on by these illnesses.
Jenn:Now, the family has tried to exhume the grave, because if you can exhume
Jenn:the grave and get DNA samples, which would still be present in bone
Jenn:marrow, you can test for those things.
Jenn:And it could give some families, some closure or to try to make sense
Jenn:of these these very few eyewitness stories that you have which really
Jenn:one lady changing her story three times and Maybe putting together
Jenn:what's really going on with Lewis.
Jenn:don't know if the family feels ashamed of the suicide I don't know if that is
Jenn:the case or they just want more answers
Jenn:But the family has signed a suicide petition over 200 family members.
Jenn:Now, Lewis doesn't have any direct descendants because he
Jenn:never had any children, but he had sisters who had children.
Jenn:He has nieces and
Scott:and
Jenn:He had, and they're descendants of the Lewis family.
Jenn:So he does have
Scott:that
Jenn:that.
Jenn:They are a
Scott:and they're
Jenn:And there's like people in William and Mary or Lewis family members.
Jenn:And so they have, they're all on board with this.
Jenn:They would really love to have this body exhumed for testing.
Jenn:Now this area, and we talked about it, is owned by the National Park Service,
Jenn:and the National Park Service does not do disinterments to test for any kind of
Scott:Yeah, I think you even said that they, it was one of
Scott:those things they just can't set
Jenn:They don't want to set the precedence, and then, when you see
Jenn:our video, you see how sporadic these pioneer graves are, there really is no
Jenn:rhyme or reason to how they're buried.
Jenn:It looks very haphazard and scattered as a pioneer cemetery would be.
Jenn:And so the national park service is concerned about disrupting other
Jenn:graves, which completely makes sense.
Jenn:I don't think Stephen Ambrose did a great job.
Jenn:I think because it probably was a secondary story to what he was telling.
Jenn:And he just kind of, Because Thomas Jefferson, and William Clark
Jenn:are not questioning the suicide, he just says that is accurate.
Jenn:Instead of what, there's other stuff, if you were just investigating the
Jenn:death, there's other stuff around the death that probably could Use
Jenn:more of a lens to look through.
Jenn:And as historians today have done more, a deeper dive into those things
Jenn:and giving them more probability, which is only could be answered by,
Scott:So, how did his, his journals and all that stuff finally, I
Scott:still, do they still make it to
Scott:DC?
Scott:He still made it.
Scott:Neely took them?
Jenn:So they, what's the aftermath here?
Jenn:Clark, he has a great life.
Jenn:He lives to old age, has a bunch of kids takes care of second to be
Jenn:a son he is very much a, a mean
Jenn:enslaver, which is too bad that Lewis couldn't have been
Jenn:more of an influence on him.
Jenn:Perna, Perna tries to go to Jefferson's house to get his 200, turned away by
Jenn:Jefferson, ends up committing suicide.
Jenn:So what did he know?
Jenn:What did he not know?
Jenn:Maybe he's just, so destitute as well.
Scott:did he actually
Jenn:Yeah, did he actually commit suicide?
Jenn:His journals eventually make it to DC and he is completely
Jenn:cleared of all wrongdoing.
Scott:So he was right all
Jenn:He was
Jenn:right all along.
Jenn:All his debts are paid.
Jenn:He was right all along.
Jenn:He's completely exonerated.
Jenn:When they finally get his letters and get all of his stuff, they
Jenn:realize he has done nothing wrong.
Scott:he's been doing his best out
Jenn:He's been doing his best.
Jenn:Everything is documented and he's completely exonerated and paid.
Jenn:So really the name of Lewis as a leader holds tight today as
Jenn:an influencer holds tight today.
Jenn:It's just the end of his
Scott:of his
Jenn:that has the big question mark.
Scott:too, so much stuff going on, whether it's, it's disease or
Scott:mental or external circumstances.
Scott:It sounds like it sounds like those last couple of years were pretty tumultuous
Jenn:and like I said, for a man that's so important to American history, so
Jenn:tied, everybody learns about the Lewis and
Jenn:Clark Expedition.
Jenn:He's the first name in the Lewis and Clark Expedition.
Jenn:For his end of life to be such a question of American history,
Jenn:I just think it deserves more
Scott:of American history, I just it deserves some more answers.
Scott:Place to visit.
Scott:It's a fun video to watch.
Scott:So obviously that link will be in the show notes of this.
Scott:But I would encourage you guys about an hour outside of Nashville.
Scott:If you want to go visit it, it's kind of out there.
Scott:If you want to go do some outdoorsy stuff, but it was pretty neat.
Scott:the Lewis and Clark expedition stands as a monumental
Scott:achievement in American history.
Scott:And Lewis's role in it should not be forgotten.
Scott:Lewis alongside William Clark led the historic Corps of Discovery expedition,
Scott:forging a path westward and opening up vast new territories in the United States.
Scott:He documented countless plant and animal species, meticulously mapped
Scott:the unknown and fostered relationships with Native American tribes.
Scott:Though his final chapter remains a mystery, Lewis's legacy as a trailblazer
Scott:is undeniable, but in the end, did Lewis succumb to his own demons or was
Scott:there a more sinister plot at play?
Scott:remains shrouded in mystery.
Scott:Thank you for listening to the Talk with History podcast, and please reach out to
Scott:us at our website, talk with history.com.
Scott:But more importantly, if you know someone else that might enjoy this
Scott:podcast, please share it with shoot 'em a text and tell 'em to look us up.
Scott:We rely on you, our community to grow and we appreciate you all every day.
Scott:We'll talk to you next time.
Jenn:time.
Jenn:Thank you.
Jenn:Hey, let me record this real fast so you can cut it in.
Jenn:Nearly.
Jenn:So the guy who's traveling with Lewis, he continues for three more
Jenn:years as an agent to the Chickasaws.
Jenn:And then he's abruptly discharged by the secretary of war for incompetence.
Jenn:And then he disappears from the pages of history.
Scott:Really?
Scott:Yeah.
Scott:Just poof.
Jenn:exactly.
Scott:Huh.
Jenn:So that all these kinds of people
Scott:surrounded.
Scott:This would make such an movie.
Scott:You could totally just like kind of start from the tail end of the
Scott:expedition and follow Lewis all the way
Jenn:It's very
Scott:Huh.