- [Voice Over] The Dementia
Researcher podcast,
Speaker:talking careers, research,
conference highlights,
Speaker:and so much more.
Speaker:- Hello and welcome to the
Dementia Researcher Podcast.
Speaker:I am Dr. Robyn Dowlen and
it's my absolute pleasure
Speaker:to be guest hosting today's show.
Speaker:In this episode, we'll be exploring
Speaker:the beautiful intersections
where music, arts,
Speaker:and inclusivity meet, and how
they transform the experiences
Speaker:of those living with Dementia.
Speaker:Joining me are three fantastic guests
Speaker:who've been at the forefront
of weaving Dementia friendly
Speaker:initiatives into the rich
tapestry of the arts.
Speaker:So we have Holly Marland,
who has enriched lives
Speaker:through her commitment to
community music projects.
Speaker:Dr. Andy Northcott from the
University of West London,
Speaker:bringing us insights from
academia on the impact
Speaker:of the arts and opera.
Speaker:And Liv McLennan from
Sounds Better Community
Speaker:Interest Company, an
innovator known for her work
Speaker:in using music as a
bridge to memory and joy.
Speaker:Together we'll uncover the stories
Speaker:behind their inspiring projects
from festivals to operas
Speaker:and discuss how their crafting
spaces where every note
Speaker:opens doors to accessibility
and understanding.
Speaker:And before we get
started, just to tell you
Speaker:a little bit about me as well,
Speaker:I'm a researcher at the
University of Manchester.
Speaker:And in my work I look at how
we understand and capture
Speaker:the in the moment musical experiences
Speaker:of people with Dementia.
Speaker:But that's enough from
me. Let's meet our guests.
Speaker:(bright music)
Speaker:So before we talk about
their individual work,
Speaker:let's get some proper introductions.
Speaker:Holly, can you start us off?
Speaker:Can you tell us a bit about yourself?
Speaker:- Well hi there Robyn.
It's lovely to be here.
Speaker:I am a freelance professional musician
Speaker:and a music for health specialist,
Speaker:and I work in hospitals, care
homes and daycare settings
Speaker:with people of all ages.
Speaker:I've been learning and playing the kora,
Speaker:which is a traditional West African harp.
Speaker:And I've been playing
for about 13 years now,
Speaker:supported by my amazing
teacher, Mohammed Saho
Speaker:who lives in The Gambia.
Speaker:And I started my musical
journey on the piano
Speaker:and in the local church choir.
Speaker:And I've always written music
Speaker:and I've always felt that I wanted
Speaker:to bridge the performer audience divide,
Speaker:which I felt was always a
culturally imposed thing.
Speaker:So I love working within
different communities
Speaker:to co-create music and
to share ideas together.
Speaker:- Thank you, Holly. That sounds wonderful.
Speaker:I'm looking forward to
unpicking all of those things
Speaker:with you later in the episode.
Speaker:Andy, can I come to you next?
Speaker:- Yeah, of course you can.
So I'm Dr. Andy Northcott.
Speaker:I hate how long winded my job title is.
Speaker:I'm a Senior Lecturer
of Sociology of Medicine
Speaker:at the Geller Institute
of Ageing and Medicine
Speaker:at the University of West London.
Speaker:Takes a deep breath.
Speaker:My main research is sort
of unrelated to the arts.
Speaker:If anyone googles me,
you'll find lots of stuff
Speaker:about hospitals.
Speaker:For the last almost 10 years,
I've been doing ethnographies
Speaker:of hospital care and observing
people living with Dementia
Speaker:during unplanned acute
hospital admissions.
Speaker:And kind of my side second job,
Speaker:because that doesn't take
up enough of my time,
Speaker:is trying to make social
spaces more accessible
Speaker:for people with Dementia.
Speaker:So that started with about seven years ago
Speaker:looking at making cinemas
Dementia friendly.
Speaker:And in the last year I've been
working on Dementia friendly
Speaker:operas, which I'll be
talking to you about later.
Speaker:- Amazing, and welcome
to this wonderful field
Speaker:of arts and Dementia, we're
a friendly bunch (chuckles).
Speaker:Liv, can I ask you to
introduce yourself as well?
Speaker:- Thank you, Robyn. Great to be here.
Speaker:So my name's Liv McLennan
and I'm a musician
Speaker:and community musician.
Speaker:I'm based in Wilshire now.
Speaker:I play the cello and
the Highland bagpipes.
Speaker:But more recently the ukuleles
become quite important to me
Speaker:and in my work as well.
Speaker:And also in my research, I'm a
part-time doctoral researcher
Speaker:at the Guild Hall School
of Music and Drama,
Speaker:and they also run a
community interest company
Speaker:called Sounds Better.
Speaker:- Thank you so much.
Speaker:It's just wonderful to have
such an array of expertise
Speaker:within the virtual room.
Speaker:(bright music)
Speaker:Okay, I think it is time
that we heard a bit more
Speaker:about your individual work.
Speaker:So Andy, if I come to you first,
Speaker:I know opera isn't your
first look into Dementia,
Speaker:but I'd love to hear
about how that came about.
Speaker:How have you become immersed in this area?
Speaker:- It's kind of funny because
been doing ethnographies
Speaker:of hospitals for about 10 years
Speaker:and nobody's ever really cared.
Speaker:I've suddenly got into opera
Speaker:and I've had to make all these
various media appearances
Speaker:and just hope nobody ever
asks me anything about opera
Speaker:because I've only ever been to two operas
Speaker:and I produced one of them.
Speaker:I kind of looked into being able
Speaker:to put on a Dementia friendly
opera in that I'm friends
Speaker:with people who run an
opera company in Wiltshire.
Speaker:So probably not far from where
I live is The Music Troop
Speaker:with Edward Lambert.
Speaker:And just sort of over dinner,
Speaker:we were talking about him
looking for new audiences
Speaker:and I suggested, well, have
you thought about doing
Speaker:Dementia friendly performances?
Speaker:And sort of from there,
probably a glass of wine,
Speaker:too many this escalated
and before, you know,
Speaker:we were putting on a production.
Speaker:So beyond my lack of knowledge of opera,
Speaker:I'm much better on sort
of hip hop and '80's pop
Speaker:than I am opera.
Speaker:But for me it's that communal thing.
Speaker:And it doesn't really matter if it's opera
Speaker:or if it's a rock gig or
if it's standup comedy
Speaker:or it could be reggae or
heavy metal or anything.
Speaker:It's that communal thing
of being in a place,
Speaker:sharing musicians, giving you
something powerful, visceral,
Speaker:that you latch onto and takes
you away from where you are.
Speaker:And also that thing of just
being out of the house,
Speaker:I have this big thing of,
to use one in the media so,
Speaker:so Bobby Charlton died
a couple of weeks ago
Speaker:and all obituaries sort of talked about
Speaker:how he lived in the shadow of Dementia
Speaker:and this shadow kept coming up.
Speaker:And it's taking that out of that that yes,
Speaker:you have that diagnosis of Dementia,
Speaker:but that shouldn't mean
that you are stuck in,
Speaker:to quote another musician
with David Bowie.
Speaker:It shouldn't be, "Pale
blinds drawn all day,
Speaker:nothing to do, nothing to say."
Speaker:You've still got years to
go and you've got family
Speaker:and friends and people to see
Speaker:and you should be able to go and see them.
Speaker:And if music was part of your life before,
Speaker:or even if it wasn't,
it should still be that
Speaker:really up until the point
Speaker:that it really physically can't be.
Speaker:And so we did an opera and I
think if you can do an opera,
Speaker:you can do anything.
Speaker:- Thank you so much.
Speaker:And I think it speaks to the
real importance of, yeah,
Speaker:not as you say, not simulating these,
Speaker:but actually giving real
opportunities for people
Speaker:with Dementia to engage
with high quality arts
Speaker:in the real world.
Speaker:So I'd love to hear a bit
more about the process.
Speaker:You said you've got this
kind of full audience.
Speaker:How was that process for you?
Speaker:- So the opera, we came up
with the sort of basic idea
Speaker:of the music troupe had a new opera
Speaker:they were going to premier
at the Tete a Tete Festival.
Speaker:It was called The Last Siren.
Speaker:It's a sort of small
contemporary chamber opera
Speaker:based on the Greek myth
Sisyphus and the sirens
Speaker:willing the ships onto the rocks.
Speaker:And the opera itself, we didn't change
Speaker:it was gonna be performed the next day.
Speaker:We had the musicians, we had the singers.
Speaker:So it was how do we put this
on and make it accessible
Speaker:to people living with Dementia?
Speaker:That was kind of the tricky bit.
Speaker:That was when I had to put
on my challenge Anneka hat
Speaker:and start cold calling venues
and seeing what could be done.
Speaker:And we really struggled with sort of,
Speaker:and answered emails and
venues that wanted to help
Speaker:but weren't quite sure.
Speaker:And then I stumbled on
by the biggest accident,
Speaker:I emailed the London College of Music
Speaker:and I hadn't realised
they were actually part
Speaker:of University of West
London and even weirder
Speaker:or I didn't realise
that they had a theatre
Speaker:and it was next door to my office
Speaker:had I ever ventured slightly
further down the corridor,
Speaker:like literally three doors down.
Speaker:We had Lawrence Hall, this fantastic,
Speaker:so looks like an old school theatre,
Speaker:the sort of, we always joke,
Speaker:it looks like it's where
the kids from "Fame,"
Speaker:would hang out, it's just
full of all these young people
Speaker:playing music and being very good looking
Speaker:and enjoying themselves.
Speaker:And we were like, okay,
so can we use this space?
Speaker:And they didn't ask any questions.
Speaker:They were just like, yes,
please. How would it work?
Speaker:Can we come in?
Speaker:Everything moves around, what
can we do to facilitate this?
Speaker:And once we had a venue,
it was really quite easy.
Speaker:I mean, I say easy, I'm an academic
Speaker:and it was in a university.
Speaker:So I then I spent two months going through
Speaker:every health and safety and
risk and prevent procedure
Speaker:you can think of.
Speaker:But beyond the normal university
stuff, the actual hosting
Speaker:of the event was okay actually, in fact,
Speaker:possibly the hardest thing we
had was getting an audience.
Speaker:So we had a venue, we had a production,
Speaker:we had everything in place.
Speaker:But then it's how do you communicate
Speaker:to people living with Dementia?
Speaker:Especially if they're
already feeling cut off,
Speaker:like I discussed before,
Speaker:I'm worried I'm rambling
now, but I'll keep going.
Speaker:It's that you can't just stick
it on Facebook or Twitter
Speaker:because not everybody's online and people
Speaker:aren't looking for things.
Speaker:And we timed it just for the moment
Speaker:where the Twitter
algorithm kind of fell away
Speaker:and all the people that
used to see your tweets
Speaker:stop seeing your tweets anyway.
Speaker:So getting the message out
was kind of the tricky part.
Speaker:And we had to reach out
to lots of organisations
Speaker:and begged for publicity and support,
Speaker:but everybody was really helpful with it.
Speaker:And we managed to put on
the production, fill it,
Speaker:sell out all the seats,
yeah, it was great.
Speaker:- Yeah, I think that's such
a wonderful kind of vision
Speaker:for the world and communities
to be more Dementia friendly
Speaker:so that people can kind
of cross those thresholds
Speaker:as it were into these
spaces and feel confident
Speaker:that they're gonna be supported
when they're there no matter
Speaker:what's going on.
Speaker:And perhaps this is a good
point at which to come
Speaker:to you Holly, in terms of the
So Many Beauties festival,
Speaker:I know this is another event that happened
Speaker:within a very established
arts venue as well.
Speaker:So I'd love to hear about
your kind of your process
Speaker:for developing the
festival and how it went.
Speaker:- I just wanna start off
by saying that people
Speaker:living with Dementia have
taught me so much about the joy
Speaker:and potential of being
in the present moment
Speaker:and they're constantly
amazing me with their wit,
Speaker:wisdom and creativity.
Speaker:So I set up the So Many
Beauties project in 2017,
Speaker:with funding from the
Arts Council England.
Speaker:To work co-creatively with
people living with Dementia
Speaker:in their communities of care.
Speaker:To harness this incredible creativity.
Speaker:And so we work together
to compose new music
Speaker:and we work together to devise
large scale cultural events
Speaker:that counter as Andy and yourself
Speaker:have just been talking
about the tragedy narrative.
Speaker:And what we're doing is
showcasing what people
Speaker:living with Dementia can
do rather than focusing
Speaker:on what they can't do anymore.
Speaker:So we're currently working
on our second large scale
Speaker:Dementia friendly music festival,
Speaker:which is gonna be at the
Bridgewater Hall in Manchester
Speaker:and it's next September,
on Friday the 20th.
Speaker:So everyone get your
diaries out now put that in.
Speaker:And what we've done is
we've brought together
Speaker:a stakeholder group of
18 cultural organisations
Speaker:and Dementia support organisations
Speaker:who are working across Greater Manchester
Speaker:and we're gonna be working with members
Speaker:of their Dementia support groups to devise
Speaker:all the content for this one day festival.
Speaker:So this includes working
with support groups
Speaker:that are for members of the South Asian
Speaker:and African Caribbean communities,
Speaker:as well as with Manchester's
LGBTQ+ communities.
Speaker:You're probably familiar with the work
Speaker:that the Baring Foundation has been doing
Speaker:around increasing
representation in the Dementia
Speaker:and mental health workforces.
Speaker:And so during the pandemic
I formed a collective
Speaker:of musicians from different
ethnic backgrounds
Speaker:who are going to be
developing their skills
Speaker:in this co-creative
practise working with people
Speaker:living with Dementia.
Speaker:And the So Many Beauties
collective recently featured
Speaker:we had a brilliant project
launch at the Bridgewater Hall,
Speaker:a smaller event, just a half day event.
Speaker:And the collective accompanied
new music that they'd written
Speaker:and they performed with the Age UK
Speaker:Salford's brilliant Buddy Club.
Speaker:And we were so pleased to see the audience
Speaker:who were a complete mix of
people living with Dementia.
Speaker:We had four different
Dementia support groups come,
Speaker:we had researchers, we had
strategic decision makers
Speaker:from Manchester City Council and everyone
Speaker:was just really positive about
this intercultural co-created
Speaker:programme premier, no lyric sheets needed.
Speaker:Buddy Club remembered
all their new song lyrics
Speaker:and rhythms with no need for prompts.
Speaker:So this really combated the popular belief
Speaker:that only old familiar songs will do.
Speaker:So the festival itself is
actually gonna be very diverse.
Speaker:We are taking over the
entire Bridgewater Hall.
Speaker:And we're going to be curating
a programme of new music,
Speaker:dance, theatre workshops,
discussions, cabaret,
Speaker:intercultural afternoon tea,
Speaker:whatever our wonderful participants
Speaker:decide that they want to see
developed or commissioned.
Speaker:So watch this space (chuckles).
Speaker:- That sounds absolutely wonderful
Speaker:and I've made a note in
my diary for next year
Speaker:so that I can hopefully come along.
Speaker:I'm really interested, we hear
this word kind of co-creation
Speaker:a lot within this field.
Speaker:What does it look like in practise?
Speaker:- So musically speaking, because
we are devising new music,
Speaker:we are using musical
improvisation as a starting point
Speaker:for creating new songs
and new pieces of music.
Speaker:So we will probably
build from simple songs
Speaker:and we'll try and evolve those.
Speaker:We'll have lyrical development sessions
Speaker:throwing ideas into the pot,
Speaker:but it's very much about
being in the moment
Speaker:and being spontaneous.
Speaker:We don't want people to
feel hindered, you know,
Speaker:if they say, I don't know,
that becomes a song lyric.
Speaker:You know, you are validating
everybody's responses
Speaker:and this enables people's
creativity to come tumbling out.
Speaker:So musical improvisation,
we use small handheld
Speaker:tuned and untuned percussion
instruments as the impetus
Speaker:for creating rhythms and melodies.
Speaker:And then we weave this all
together into something
Speaker:that is a high quality
piece of public art.
Speaker:In our first project we
actually created an oratorio
Speaker:specifically to challenge this
elitist idea of an oratorio
Speaker:and who could write and perform it.
Speaker:And we had an intergenerational
choir of age five
Speaker:I think to 98, a group of 150
people performing that work.
Speaker:So co-creativity is often using
present moment improvisation
Speaker:to create something
that's much larger scale
Speaker:that can be presented publicly.
Speaker:But we're also doing co-creation
Speaker:around evaluation tools as well.
Speaker:I think there's a saying, I'm
not sure of the exact wording,
Speaker:nothing for us, without us,
Speaker:everything that is being
developed for people
Speaker:living with Dementia should
be developed with people
Speaker:living with Dementia.
Speaker:So this co-creation comes into play
Speaker:even with the project
inception for this festival,
Speaker:we actually spoke to
people living with Dementia
Speaker:about what they wanted.
Speaker:- That's fantastic, and
I think it kind of speaks
Speaker:to some of what Andy was saying as well.
Speaker:We're kind of looking at
involvement and participation
Speaker:in the arts through this
kind of lens of citizenship
Speaker:as it were, it's creating
spaces where people
Speaker:can have their voices heard and yeah,
Speaker:feeling listened to within the process
Speaker:I think it's incredibly
important in a Dementia context
Speaker:because so many decisions
get taken away from people.
Speaker:So maybe this is a good point Liv,
Speaker:to bring you in and your work with people.
Speaker:Could you tell us a
bit about Sounds Better
Speaker:as the organisation and
yeah, how you are approaching
Speaker:using creativity and music
and arts with people.
Speaker:- Yeah, so Sounds Better.
Speaker:Grew out of a collective
of freelancers actually.
Speaker:And we just wanted a bit
more control over our work
Speaker:and you know, being able to set up things
Speaker:in our local communities.
Speaker:It's really important to
us to really live and work
Speaker:and be based and to work with
the people we live alongside.
Speaker:So I'm based in Wilshire,
one of my colleagues
Speaker:is based in London and we have
projects in our communities.
Speaker:So our work with people with Dementia
Speaker:is focused in Wilshire.
Speaker:And one of the challenges that
we really face in Wilshire
Speaker:is that it's a very rural county.
Speaker:And there are so many issues around that.
Speaker:There's transport, there's
isolation, you know,
Speaker:all of these things that
aren't easily rectified.
Speaker:Bigger cities obviously
have their own issues too,
Speaker:but yeah, the challenge of rural living.
Speaker:Well our Dementia work is
based in a little village
Speaker:called Downton and it kind of
has echoes of what both Holly
Speaker:and Andy were saying is
that we work alongside
Speaker:and with people and very
much try and shape the group
Speaker:as to what they want to do.
Speaker:Music is at its core and it started off
Speaker:as a kind of pure music project.
Speaker:One where we sang songs
that were familiar,
Speaker:did pieces of music that were familiar
Speaker:but also wrote our own based
on our own experiences of life
Speaker:and our memories.
Speaker:So we've got kind of more
than an album's worth it.
Speaker:I'd love to get recording, but
at the moment we are working
Speaker:towards a mini performance.
Speaker:It's very much on a very
small scale, you know,
Speaker:nothing compared to
Holly's amazing festivals,
Speaker:but we are going to be part
of a Christmas tree festival
Speaker:in Salisbury, which is, we
are really exciting for me,
Speaker:we're writing our own Christmas carol
Speaker:but because our group
also works with people
Speaker:with other health conditions,
we are bringing them together.
Speaker:They are writing parts of
the Christmas carol together,
Speaker:we are gonna have a practise
and then we'll perform together
Speaker:as well, so we're connecting people across
Speaker:different health conditions,
different communities as well.
Speaker:So we see as our music
and our music making
Speaker:and it's all participatory.
Speaker:And I suppose co-created, I
do shy away from that term
Speaker:a little bit, but you
know, we work with people.
Speaker:Yeah to try, that's the bridge really.
Speaker:The music is the bridge to
bring people to together
Speaker:and it's so lovely to hear
about the intergenerational work
Speaker:and the opera work as well
Speaker:and just see how so many
different forms of music
Speaker:and musicing and different styles
Speaker:can just bring people together.
Speaker:So in essence it's music with
people and music to bridge
Speaker:any divides that might be there.
Speaker:- That sounds really
wonderful and it's kind of,
Speaker:it sparked this kind
of question in my mind.
Speaker:We've kind of been talking
about Dementia friendly
Speaker:initiatives, whereas some of the language
Speaker:that you are all using
Speaker:comes down to this kind
of Dementia inclusive,
Speaker:so it's beyond the kind
of Dementia friendly
Speaker:it seems the work that you're doing.
Speaker:So in terms of that rural context,
Speaker:could you tell me a bit
more about the kind of,
Speaker:yeah, how you develop
those sense of connection
Speaker:through music when people
are kind of not next door
Speaker:to each other say in terms
of physical location?
Speaker:- Good question, it's
around experience I think
Speaker:and life experience and what you find
Speaker:when you get people in a room together,
Speaker:no matter where they're
from or where they live,
Speaker:there's always a commonality
and that's obviously
Speaker:our humanness but we have experiences
Speaker:that we can draw on that
are probably similar
Speaker:to someone sat next to
us, whether that's travel
Speaker:or whether that's having
a family or throughout
Speaker:the life course there are
things that connect us.
Speaker:So it's really trying to draw on those
Speaker:and draw on our togetherness,
our humanness, our connections
Speaker:and using that as the basis
to then take that forward
Speaker:to a group song or piece
of music or production,
Speaker:whatever that looks like,
whatever the group decides.
Speaker:So we are kind of going
from individuals to a group,
Speaker:of really kind of using
that sense of relationship
Speaker:and relational music making
to bring people together.
Speaker:- That's really fantastic,
I love the kind of, yeah,
Speaker:the different ways in which
people can connect without words
Speaker:as well in those situations
music can provide opportunities
Speaker:for that self-expression.
Speaker:So just picking up on that
and maybe it's something
Speaker:that you are kind of
thinking about more widely
Speaker:in your role outside of this as the CIC.
Speaker:I'd love to hear more about
how what you've learned
Speaker:doing the kind of practical
on the grounds grassroots
Speaker:music making with people with Dementia
Speaker:has it kind of impacted on
you in your kind of research
Speaker:when you've put your research hat on.
Speaker:- Yes, so my own research is
intergenerational music making
Speaker:in care homes some as we
know, a huge proportion
Speaker:of people in care homes
live with Dementia.
Speaker:So in terms of the impact on research,
Speaker:I think the way I see it is
that it has to be meaningful
Speaker:for the people taking part,
the subjects I suppose,
Speaker:or mine's practise research.
Speaker:So actually I take
everything from my practise
Speaker:and it becomes my research
Speaker:when I'm in that kind of
project context anyway.
Speaker:So it is things, you know, like ensuring
Speaker:that everyone understands
what we're doing,
Speaker:that everyone can participate to a level
Speaker:that they are comfortable with
Speaker:if they choose to and if they want to.
Speaker:The ability to say no and withdraw
Speaker:absolutely fine with that.
Speaker:So all this kind of
underpinning values I have
Speaker:as a practitioner I take
into my research as well.
Speaker:And I think one of the things
that I find interesting
Speaker:when people talk about
oh, doing the ethics form
Speaker:and that kind of thing, well for me
Speaker:that's absolutely common
sense and it's just, you know,
Speaker:I have to put it in
slightly different language
Speaker:for my ethics form, but I'm like,
Speaker:well this is what I do every
day and it always surprises me
Speaker:when people aren't working in that way
Speaker:and that inclusive, in that
mindful way about other people.
Speaker:So yeah, it's that kind
of taking those values,
Speaker:those underpinning values of
social justice and inclusion
Speaker:and yeah really being
intrigued about other people
Speaker:and then transferring that
exactly into my research.
Speaker:- Absolutely fascinating
and resonates a lot with
Speaker:I'm sure both Holly and Andy
as well in terms of the work
Speaker:that they've been doing.
Speaker:I'm really interested just
as kind of a broad question
Speaker:and I can come to you
each in turn about this,
Speaker:but obviously we've talked
about the kind of the process
Speaker:of it happening, but I'm
just interested to know
Speaker:what was your biggest kind of takeaway
Speaker:at this moment in time
from a recent project
Speaker:or something like that,
something that's just stood out
Speaker:to you in terms of the
impacts that this work
Speaker:can have on people with Dementia?
Speaker:So maybe Holly if I come to you first,
Speaker:- Crikey, I've got a takeaway
bag the size of the moon,
Speaker:but I think it was people's responses
Speaker:to hearing different types of music
Speaker:when I worked with
members of the collective,
Speaker:we took wonderful Egyptian
musician Mina Salama,
Speaker:brought all his incredible
ouds and ney flutes
Speaker:and all these sounds that
people might have heard
Speaker:on film soundtracks,
Speaker:but they'd never actually
experienced close to.
Speaker:And to see the delight and intrigue
Speaker:of predominantly white British group
Speaker:that we were working
with in hearing sounds
Speaker:from other cultures and the gospel music,
Speaker:the Turkish song and just how
that sparked conversations
Speaker:around intercultural collaboration.
Speaker:And I think that's
something that our world
Speaker:needs so much at the moment.
Speaker:So this open dialogue,
as you were saying Liv,
Speaker:this sort of interest and appreciation
Speaker:for each other's cultural differences
Speaker:as well as our humans similarities.
Speaker:So I think for me, seeing an audience
Speaker:that was quite ethnically diverse itself
Speaker:respond so positively to
something new and intercultural
Speaker:and having conversations was
really what was fantastic
Speaker:from our September launch.
Speaker:- Wow, that's amazing and
really speaks to how we define
Speaker:community in this day and age
Speaker:when we have so many different
people, different voices
Speaker:who can be part of these conversations
Speaker:and creative activities.
Speaker:How about you Andy?
Speaker:What's your kind of biggest
thing that you've taken away
Speaker:in terms of the impacts?
Speaker:- The key takeaway you
always take away is,
Speaker:kind of what you just
said, it's when you witness
Speaker:the power that music has on an audience
Speaker:and an audience living with
Dementia is no different
Speaker:to any of our audience.
Speaker:They're taken to another
place while that's happening.
Speaker:I think the biggest takeaway
I've had from putting on events
Speaker:is getting over...
Speaker:So we talk about making
things Dementia friendly
Speaker:and you have all these
things around risk and things
Speaker:and you have to go through all of this.
Speaker:Okay so we're gonna have
a quiet space over here,
Speaker:we're gonna signpost the
toilets, we wanna make sure
Speaker:this, this, this happens and
if this happens we can do it.
Speaker:And all these things
are necessary in a way.
Speaker:But in all my time of doing
Dementia friendly opera
Speaker:and I did Dementia friendly cinema
Speaker:in Cardiff for years before.
Speaker:I've never used any of them.
Speaker:Once the event starts, people
are taken with the event,
Speaker:with the music, with the spectacle.
Speaker:And when an opera is going,
Speaker:it's very hard not to be taken in.
Speaker:It's this incredibly loud
powerful thing, it's very visceral
Speaker:to be part of and all of
our feedback said that was,
Speaker:this was something new, people
hadn't heard this before
Speaker:but it didn't matter, it
took them to a new place.
Speaker:But then when everyone's
left you have all the people
Speaker:from the venue, all the
people that you've given that,
Speaker:the sort of swift
Dementia friendly training
Speaker:and the volunteers and
they're all thinking,
Speaker:well I didn't need to be here,
well you did need to be here
Speaker:but you are a safety net
that we never really needed.
Speaker:And that says something
about why aren't more events
Speaker:Dementia accessible?
Speaker:Because when we make these
things Dementia accessible,
Speaker:we don't really use any of
the Dementia accessible stuff
Speaker:anyways, it's just sort
of there just in case.
Speaker:- Yeah, that's really
interesting and I'll tie a bit
Speaker:into the question that I've
got to kind of round us off
Speaker:in a few minutes.
Speaker:But Liv, I was just
wondering if you had any
Speaker:kind of key takeaways from
well this way of working?
Speaker:- I think because my work is participatory
Speaker:rather than focused on a performance,
Speaker:we don't have an audience in the same way,
Speaker:although we're all
performers and we're audience
Speaker:and you know, there's all
kind of underlying theories
Speaker:around that.
Speaker:But I kind of just made a
little note for myself there.
Speaker:But we have different
ways of knowing as people
Speaker:and we have different
ways of being as well.
Speaker:And I think the way my work
Speaker:or you know, any kind of music
related work in Dementia,
Speaker:you know enables those
different ways of knowing
Speaker:and different ways of being
to really come to the fore.
Speaker:And because it's relational as well,
Speaker:people can relate to
others in a different way
Speaker:and also it can help reconnect people.
Speaker:So we have a person living
Dementia and a care partners
Speaker:or care team, you know,
things can get quite tough
Speaker:and it is a way of reconnecting them
Speaker:to kind of get to their
essence and to see people
Speaker:in either a different
way or to be reminded
Speaker:of the person that that
they've fell in love with
Speaker:or that, you know, they grew up with
Speaker:whatever that relationship is.
Speaker:And that is so powerful and
it can help to give people
Speaker:the resilience and the strength
to carry on another week
Speaker:in a caring role for example.
Speaker:'Cause that can be quite tough.
Speaker:So yeah, just that way of
connecting and a different way
Speaker:of being with someone
else is so important,
Speaker:particularly with the challenges
Speaker:that Dementia can bring as well.
Speaker:- Absolutely, and I think
between the three of you,
Speaker:you've have such a wealth of kind of,
Speaker:I guess it's embodied expertise
Speaker:in terms of how you're
working with these people,
Speaker:but also the kind of
practical skills, knowledge,
Speaker:experience to be able to
facilitate things like this.
Speaker:So I know in the kind of
broader Dementia landscape
Speaker:there are more and more
initiatives that are looking
Speaker:to become Dementia friendly,
Dementia inclusive.
Speaker:So I guess one of my questions
too is to kind of flip it
Speaker:on its head and maybe
Andy this is something you
Speaker:might wanna jump in on
in terms of accessibility
Speaker:in the first instance is,
Speaker:what makes an arts venue
place space Dementia friendly
Speaker:for this work to happen in?
Speaker:What needs to be put in place
to allow for the successes
Speaker:that you've observed?
Speaker:- I think most places are accessible
Speaker:and wheelchair accessible
and everything else.
Speaker:I think an issue we have
with venues is the assumption
Speaker:that a person living with
Dementia is living in a care home,
Speaker:is not able to move around independently
Speaker:and it forgets all those
stages from diagnosis
Speaker:through to there is a group of
people living with Dementia,
Speaker:with advanced Dementia that
perhaps it would be a challenge
Speaker:to move into a venue
because of mobility issues.
Speaker:But that's a very small
section of late stage people
Speaker:living with Dementia and it's
everyone else in between.
Speaker:And it's not as if people
are coming on their own,
Speaker:most people coming to events
that are coming with somebody.
Speaker:We did have people come
to the opera on their own
Speaker:which was brilliant.
Speaker:People with early stage from
a diagnosis came on their own,
Speaker:got themselves to the venue,
came on the tube or the bus
Speaker:because Dementia is such
a wide spectrum of people,
Speaker:but you had people that did need help.
Speaker:And our biggest issue is parking.
Speaker:You go through all of these
things for Dementia friendly
Speaker:and the thing that
comes down to is parking
Speaker:close to the venue and
being able to help people
Speaker:out with cars.
Speaker:And that's not to belittle
the idea of making everything,
Speaker:we should do everything
we can to make things
Speaker:more Dementia friendly,
Dementia accessible
Speaker:and the more we can do to do that,
Speaker:to promote it and everything else.
Speaker:But the reality of it is any building
Speaker:can be Dementia friendly,
it just has to be willing
Speaker:to promote it and
hopefully we get to a part
Speaker:where don't have to promote it.
Speaker:And just a cinema is both
a Dementia friendly cinema
Speaker:and a cinema, a gig venue
is Dementia friendly
Speaker:and we shouldn't have
to put a special thing
Speaker:if this is an accessible performance,
Speaker:it should just be accepted
that it's a performance.
Speaker:And some people there might have Dementia,
Speaker:but until we get there it's what we need
Speaker:but we're gonna, with my
research we're gonna keep,
Speaker:we've got another event
coming up in February,
Speaker:which we're gonna do, not
at University of West London
Speaker:at a separate venue.
Speaker:Hopefully we have the same things.
Speaker:We'll put all the Dementia
friendly things in place
Speaker:to make it safe and to manage risk,
Speaker:again hopefully we won't need them
Speaker:and then we could come up
with some sort of blueprint
Speaker:which will help venues
to be able to do this
Speaker:and to promote it further.
Speaker:And it doesn't have to be
opera, it could be anything.
Speaker:- I think that's fantastic.
Speaker:And I think you've highlighted
such an important point
Speaker:in terms of the kind of
the assumptions of others
Speaker:are often the biggest barriers
in terms of if someone
Speaker:can or can't access something.
Speaker:I mean in my own research work,
Speaker:it tends to be things like automatic taps
Speaker:and things like that that are the things
Speaker:that people pick up on
when they're auditing
Speaker:a space like this.
Speaker:And so it is actually
the performance itself
Speaker:being as inclusive as possible
Speaker:and then just putting
stuff around it to make it.
Speaker:- Yeah, and there's parts,
I know in my other research,
Speaker:with my hospital hat
on there's a big thing
Speaker:to make hospitals Dementia friendly.
Speaker:There was this big thing to
paint toilet doors yellow
Speaker:and I was thinking unless
toilet doors are yellow
Speaker:at their house, why
would yellow mean toilet?
Speaker:So sometimes we push
things too far and forget
Speaker:that the toilet's a toilet
and the toilet at the venue
Speaker:as long as there's a sign saying,
Speaker:anyway, I'm wittering now.
Speaker:I'll let you move on to everyone else.
Speaker:- Not at all, Holly or Liv,
do you have any thoughts
Speaker:on that?
Speaker:- It's really interesting
to hear Andy's experience
Speaker:and obviously recognising
that if we've met one person
Speaker:living with Dementia, we've met one person
Speaker:living with Dementia.
Speaker:I think what we tried to do
with the way we ran the festival
Speaker:was to curate the experience
so that it wasn't an overload
Speaker:from the get go.
Speaker:So as soon as people
arrived we thought about
Speaker:how to make the space tranquil
Speaker:and able to orientate
yourself in the space
Speaker:by having live harp music
just to settle people down.
Speaker:We curated the flow of the
festival so that people
Speaker:weren't over faced with choice,
but yet there were choices.
Speaker:It felt like a festival, you
know, it was quite chaotic
Speaker:and lively and loud, but we kind of built
Speaker:the whole scope of the day
so that we curated the event
Speaker:so that there were quiet
times, there were quiet rooms,
Speaker:which Andy has mentioned already.
Speaker:I think one of the most important things,
Speaker:I don't know if you can see it,
Speaker:we have these yellow Happy to Help badges
Speaker:and I think most of making
things Dementia friendly
Speaker:comes down to people's
awareness of what Dementia
Speaker:actually is and the fact
that it's an umbrella term
Speaker:for over a hundred different
diseases of the brain.
Speaker:And I think it is helpful
for people to know
Speaker:that people's visuals can be impaired
Speaker:through certain types of Dementia.
Speaker:So they might see something
on the floor if the carpets
Speaker:got some dark flooring,
they may see it as a hole.
Speaker:So just to have people
on hand who are aware
Speaker:of these things, who can
guide people and help them
Speaker:on a human level.
Speaker:I think Andy's quite right.
Speaker:Signposting with yellow signs
and all this kind of stuff
Speaker:is all very well and good,
Speaker:but what it comes down
to is people guiding
Speaker:and making people feel
comfortable in the space,
Speaker:which is what we were very careful to do.
Speaker:And we did work with the
Bridgewater Halls venue staff.
Speaker:We created a package that was drawing
Speaker:from some of the Alzheimer's
Dementia friendly
Speaker:awareness sessions, but we
also made it music specific.
Speaker:How can you help somebody
don't tower over them.
Speaker:You know, consider bringing
yourself to eye level
Speaker:with somebody, especially
if they're in a wheelchair,
Speaker:to talk to them rather
than towering over them.
Speaker:Just these tiny little
details of human interrelation
Speaker:can make a massive impact
on whether an event
Speaker:is inclusive or not.
Speaker:- You put that much better
than me, Holly. Thank you.
Speaker:- Not at all. I just
paraphrased you wildly (laughs).
Speaker:- Thank you so much, Liv. Did
you have any thoughts on this?
Speaker:- I do fully agree with Holly and Andy
Speaker:and it is just the ways of
being a venue staff really,
Speaker:because a building is a building
and there are little things
Speaker:you can do, but lighting or
having it in a particular time
Speaker:of day that might be more useful.
Speaker:But actually it is, you know,
Speaker:the people and how they
support other people
Speaker:regardless of a diagnosis or not.
Speaker:And accepting people for who
they are when they walk in.
Speaker:And not trying to put
expectations, behaviour,
Speaker:or otherwise onto those people.
Speaker:I think that's a way to
kind of be Dementia friendly
Speaker:is to accept that people
with Dementia, you know,
Speaker:they behave as, or humans do.
Speaker:We all behave differently
and like accept that
Speaker:and that's okay.
Speaker:We can be ourselves in the space,
Speaker:a welcoming, inclusive space.
Speaker:- Absolutely. So well said.
Speaker:And honestly, I could talk
about this for a lot longer
Speaker:than we have available to us today,
Speaker:but I just have one final
question about the kind of,
Speaker:so many of our listeners will
be early career researchers
Speaker:or perhaps practice-based
researchers like yourself Liv.
Speaker:And they'll be wanting to
organise events like this
Speaker:or work with communities.
Speaker:So I just really wanted
to pick your brains
Speaker:maybe a one or two sentence answer
Speaker:about what your hopes are
for research or practise
Speaker:in this space going forwards.
Speaker:Holly, maybe I'll start with you.
Speaker:- I would be really keen to,
Speaker:for researchers to address the
current under representation
Speaker:of people from different
ethnic communities
Speaker:in the research story.
Speaker:And I think the most important way is,
Speaker:not to make assumptions,
Speaker:we've talked about assumptions before.
Speaker:I think to go out and see good practise,
Speaker:go and talk to organisations
like Touchstone in Leeds
Speaker:who are really paving the
way for fantastic provision
Speaker:for their BME communities.
Speaker:Go out and observe and listen to,
Speaker:before you make any decisions
Speaker:on what your research
questions are going to be.
Speaker:And really try and listen
to and understand people
Speaker:who come from different
cultural backgrounds.
Speaker:- So important. Thank you Holly and Liv.
Speaker:- Good question, I think for
me as a community musician
Speaker:practise researcher, it would
be about how community music
Speaker:works in this space.
Speaker:So we have a lot of,
what are the outcomes,
Speaker:what are the benefits, yada yada, yada.
Speaker:What actually happens, you
know, we can't articulate,
Speaker:we're not articulating that in research
Speaker:and it's not about, oh yes,
Speaker:it's this welcome song
and that goodbye song.
Speaker:You know, what are those
processes, what actually happens?
Speaker:What underpins our sessions
with people with Dementia?
Speaker:So I'm very intrigued about that.
Speaker:What happens in rooms to get
to these outcomes, benefits.
Speaker:So if anyone else wants to
help me take on that mantle,
Speaker:let's chat.
Speaker:- Yeah, that's absolutely
music to my ears Liv.
Speaker:Andy, what would you say about this?
Speaker:- I mean, if I was speaking directly
Speaker:to early career researchers,
if you've got an idea
Speaker:for an event, my advice would
be go out there and do it.
Speaker:Go and speak to the local
theatre, the local cinema
Speaker:or local bar.
Speaker:Go and speak to local groups
of people living with Dementia
Speaker:and put on the event.
Speaker:Just go and do it.
Speaker:This is your chances to
almost do something outside
Speaker:of the boundaries and rigours of academia.
Speaker:You don't need peer review for
this, you don't need to apply
Speaker:for funding that you know,
even though your idea
Speaker:is brilliant, only 10% of
people are going to get that.
Speaker:And all of those irritants,
Speaker:sort of enhance early career academia,
Speaker:you don't need your
supervisor's permission.
Speaker:You just need to think
of what you want to do,
Speaker:and then go out there and set it up.
Speaker:And it might be something that
you want to do that you think
Speaker:of a people will enjoy
and then just be ready
Speaker:that they might not enjoy it.
Speaker:Or it might be something
that you want to co-produce
Speaker:with people living with Dementia
Speaker:and you can go and speak to them.
Speaker:And then all those
things that we talk about
Speaker:as being really difficult,
of building up networks
Speaker:of diverse people living with Dementia,
Speaker:you'll have found a shortcut to do it,
Speaker:because you've had an audience,
you've spoken to them,
Speaker:you know what they like.
Speaker:It will not only help you
and it will help people
Speaker:living with Dementia, but
it will help your research,
Speaker:it will help your networks,
it helps everybody.
Speaker:So go out and do it. Do an
event. Everyone should do it.
Speaker:- Oh, well, hopefully we've
had some people very inspired
Speaker:by what's been said during this episode
Speaker:and we'll have some
more events popping up,
Speaker:cropping up in the future.
Speaker:I'll certainly be keeping
an eye out for them myself.
Speaker:I'm afraid that's all
we have time for today.
Speaker:I really enjoyed today's discussion
Speaker:and if you wanna find out more,
Speaker:you can have a look at the
Dementia Researcher website
Speaker:where you'll find a full
transcript and biographies
Speaker:of all our guests blogs
and much more on the topic.
Speaker:So I'd just like to extend my thanks
Speaker:to our incredible guests today,
Liv McLennan, Holly Marland,
Speaker:and Andy Northcott.
Speaker:And I'm Robyn Dowlen,
and you've been listening
Speaker:to the Dementia Researcher Podcast.
Speaker:- [Voice Over] The
Dementia Researcher Podcast
Speaker:was brought to you by
University College London.
Speaker:With generous funding from
the UK National Institute
Speaker:for Health Research,
Alzheimer's Research UK,
Speaker:Alzheimer's Society,
Alzheimer's Association,
Speaker:and Race Against Dementia.
Speaker:Please subscribe, leave
us a review and register
Speaker:on our website for full access
to all our great resources.
Speaker:Dementiaresearcher.nihr.ac.uk.