Romans 15, verses 5 through 9, reads, now may the God who gives perseverance and encouragement grant you to be of the same mind with one another according to Christ Jesus, so that with one purpose and one voice, you may glorify the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ.
Speaker ATherefore accept one another, just as Christ has also accepted us for the glory of God.
Speaker AFor I say that Christ has become a servant to the circumcision in behalf of the truth of God, to confirm the promises given to the Fathers and for the Gentiles to glorify God for his mercy.
Speaker AHere St. Paul is writing to the Church at Rome about salvation.
Speaker AHe's getting ready to wrap up his letter by reminding the Church what salvation means for their relationships to one another.
Speaker AIn this pericope, he ties acceptance of each other to Christ's servitude with his disciples.
Speaker ADr. Chris Hansen, how could this understanding help with our relationships with one another today?
Speaker BWhen you talk about their Jesus and his disciples, I naturally think, you know, kind of to the story where a couple of them come and say, hey, can we be at your right and you're left, and when you come into your kingdom.
Speaker BAnd he.
Speaker BAnd he says, wait a minute, you guys are missing the point.
Speaker BIt's really about what this passage says, that we need to be about one purpose and one voice.
Speaker BAnd.
Speaker BAnd he leads into the first shall be last, and the last shall be first.
Speaker BAnd that idea of serving others toward that one purpose and one voice.
Speaker BAnd so I think that says an awful lot about our relationships and our relationships in unity and our relationships toward a shared purpose.
Speaker AYeah, yeah.
Speaker ANo, I like that a lot.
Speaker AHey, everybody.
Speaker AWelcome to the Whole Church Podcast.
Speaker APossibly your favorite church unity podcast.
Speaker AIt's cool if it's not, though, because Unity Podcast can't really be in competition without the Unity podcast.
Speaker AIt gets to like this weird, like, you know, paradox, loop conundrum stuff.
Speaker AIt doesn't work.
Speaker ABut what does work is acknowledging the presence.
Speaker AWhen you're standing in his presence, your voice trembles at the pot.
Speaker AAlmighty.
Speaker AThe one and only TJ type of ear.
Speaker ASwan Blackwell.
Speaker AWelcome to your show.
Speaker BThanks.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAnd of course, we are also here today with an exciting guest.
Speaker AAs always, we have a lot of exciting guests, but this one I come to know and love at Orton.
Speaker ALast year up in the mountains, I got to meet him.
Speaker AIt was a lot of fun.
Speaker AOn the one only Dr. Chris Hansen.
Speaker AHe is the author of Open and Relational Parenting, Loving Parents Reflecting a Loving God.
Speaker CAnd Chris Hansen, M.D.
Speaker Ctheology D. Smart Guy, Real smart fellow.
Speaker COver Here Pediatrician.
Speaker CHe has guided families through the joys and challenges of parenting for nearly 30 years.
Speaker CAs the father of two grown daughters, his personal and professional experiences sparked a deep interest in how theology shapes parenting.
Speaker CSo naturally, when we meet brilliant people, we like to have them on our show to make us seem smarter.
Speaker ASo that's what we do.
Speaker CIt's what we do.
Speaker CAnd if you like that, you'll probably like to check out the Anazel Podcast network website.
Speaker CThe link is below.
Speaker CBelow for shows that are like ours, who know how to get the most out of other people in a non.
Speaker CExploitative way.
Speaker CI was going to say.
Speaker AIt just sounds so bad.
Speaker CMaybe it is.
Speaker CMaybe we should quit.
Speaker ATJ and I have argued about exploiting others before.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker CBut speaking of exploiting others, you can leave us a one time tip or subscribe for monthly.
Speaker CYou can buy extras.
Speaker CThere's merch on fourth wall that is also in the show's description.
Speaker CTo check that out.
Speaker CYou can also not do any of that.
Speaker CAnd just like the show.
Speaker CThat's super helpful.
Speaker CThat's just as helpful as buying the shirts.
Speaker CEven though the shirts look a lot cooler.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAlso, yeah, the shirts get worn out too.
Speaker AAnd it's nice.
Speaker AAnd yeah.
Speaker ALots of ways you can support.
Speaker AAnd we support you supporting us.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker AAll right.
Speaker AAnd as always, one of my favorite things to do to make unity inevitable is to practice a holy, sacred sacrament of silliness.
Speaker ABecause you can't be divided when you're being as silly as I like to be.
Speaker ASo here we go.
Speaker AToday's silly question.
Speaker AIf animals did theology, which animals do we think would be most likely to lean into open and relational stuff?
Speaker AI'm gonna make TJ Go first.
Speaker AHe's smarter when it comes to animals than me.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CSo it's a question.
Speaker CIt certainly is a question.
Speaker CI was thinking probably like tardigrades.
Speaker CIf you count those as animals.
Speaker CI understand if you don't.
Speaker CAnd if not, I would say like a hedgehog.
Speaker CThey've always been like a little counterculture.
Speaker AJust.
Speaker CJust a little guy.
Speaker CYou know, they have their own beliefs about the world.
Speaker CTiny little predators.
Speaker CThey're awesome.
Speaker CSo probably hedgehogs is where I'm gonna land.
Speaker AMm.
Speaker ASee, I want to try and do something smart and do like some kind of like ants or something that form, like a community together and always work together.
Speaker ABut instead I'm just gonna be really basic here.
Speaker ADogs.
Speaker AI just can see my dog being like, you know what?
Speaker AYeah, of course.
Speaker AMy owner responds to me the same way that I respond to him.
Speaker AAnd we love one another.
Speaker AWhat?
Speaker AThat just sounds right, because, you know, dogs just long for.
Speaker AFor love in relationship, and I just.
Speaker AI don't know.
Speaker AMakes sense, you know?
Speaker AGood dog.
Speaker ADr. Hanson, you're the only one with PhD or the HD, so you thd you can tell us the correct answer, so.
Speaker BWell, I don't know if it's the correct answer.
Speaker BI'll Dog was up on my list to.
Speaker BTo maybe bring up, but.
Speaker BBut I.
Speaker BSo I think that was a good answer.
Speaker BI. I kind of want to say I thought about lemur, because that's just a co.
Speaker BCool word to say, and it's fun and it's silly.
Speaker BCorrect.
Speaker AAnd they like to move meerkat.
Speaker BYeah, they do.
Speaker BAnd.
Speaker BAnd then you think of meerkats just because of Timon and that.
Speaker BThat's cool.
Speaker ACorrect.
Speaker BBut I. I think I landed on dolphins because, hey, they're pretty smart, and.
Speaker BAnd they like to have a lot of goofy fun all at the same time.
Speaker BThey're not particularly controlling, and they work really together well in relationships.
Speaker BSo I think.
Speaker BI think dolphins.
Speaker CYeah, I think that's probably just the correct answer.
Speaker AIt's funny, though.
Speaker CI could absolutely see, like, dolphins listening to Homebrewed Christianity.
Speaker CAt least maybe not our show.
Speaker AWhat's funny is the only thing that I think of when I think dolphins are, one, dolphins attacking people, because more dolphins attack people than sharks.
Speaker AAnd two, that one scene at Hitchhiker's Guide of the Galaxy when they're like, you know what?
Speaker AYou guys are stupid.
Speaker AThanks for all the fish.
Speaker AAnd just launch into space.
Speaker AYeah, Smart animals.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker CYeah, that happens.
Speaker CBut one thing that we have found that always helps with church unity if the silly question doesn't get it done is to hear one another's stories.
Speaker CSo, Dr. Hansen, would you mind sharing with us some about your faith journey and how you got interested in pediatrics?
Speaker CLike, how did you end up where you are now?
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BSo this will probably kind of.
Speaker BKind of overlap into just some things about the.
Speaker BAbout the book and what I've been doing lately, too.
Speaker BBut, yeah, I finished training in pediatrics in the mid-1990s, and about the same time we had our own first child in 1994, and around, I guess, maybe my second or third year out in practice, I started hearing things at our church, which was a fairly conservative, fundamental church that I'd grown up in, and they decided they were going to have a parenting weekend, so parenting seminar type weekend, and they brought in some curriculum, and they kind of showed the advance kind of layout of what the weekend would be like.
Speaker BAnd I start reading through it, and I realize, wait a minute.
Speaker BWhat they're going to be talking about doesn't line up with what I've learned and what I'm teaching other young parents to do as best practices in parenting.
Speaker BIn my practice, in my profession, the approach that they were taking was just not aligned with that at all.
Speaker BSo that led to several years where I think I just lived in kind of a discordant situation and just couldn't make those two things match where what the church was saying that should be happening with parenting and what I was teaching people on a regular basis.
Speaker BSo fast forward to other points in life, and people talk about whether it's deconstruction.
Speaker BI don't really think that's really the right.
Speaker BRight term for me.
Speaker BI think it's a little bit more of just like developing faith in a different way.
Speaker BAnd I think I've gone through at least two of those times in my life.
Speaker BOne around 2005 and one probably around the mid-2010s to 2015 or something like that.
Speaker BAnd each one of those led me to question different things.
Speaker BThe one in 2015 was spurred on, or 2018 was spurred on by getting to hear Pete N. Speak.
Speaker BAnd our church at the time, we had kind of gone through some church changes, and we had actually arrived at the church where we are at now.
Speaker BAnd they had Pete come in to do it, to do a lecture series.
Speaker BAnd I was very pessimistic because I said, oh, wow, this guy's gonna kind of tell us to, like, read the Bible every day and give us a path through to read the whole Bible in 365 days or something like that.
Speaker BAnd that is not what I found.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BAnd Pete.
Speaker BPete opened my eyes to.
Speaker BTo a whole world of some new possibilities which.
Speaker BWhich led to hearing lots of the folks that we've even mentioned, whether it's home bre our.
Speaker BYou guys are Josh Patterson, or a whole host of folks.
Speaker BWhich then led me to beer camp the first year that it was back in session after the pandemic.
Speaker BSo when we were in Chapel Church.
Speaker BOh, yes.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BWhich was a great time, and it's a great congregation.
Speaker BReally enjoyed being there.
Speaker BSo that led me to meet Tom Ward, which then eventually led me to learn a lot more about open relational theology.
Speaker BAnd as I did.
Speaker BWait a minute.
Speaker BI see things here that are compatible with the way that I teach parents to parent and the way that science says are best practices about parenting.
Speaker BAnd it made me think, wait A minute.
Speaker BI think there's something here I should explore more.
Speaker BSo, so that led me to, to holler at Tom and say, hey, I don't know if I fit as a potential student of yours, but I'm kind of, kind of, I'm kind of interested.
Speaker BI probably am too old, as it turns out.
Speaker BNot at all.
Speaker BAnd, and I said, I probably don't have the prerequisites.
Speaker BAnd he said, sure you do.
Speaker BAnd so next thing you know, I'm signed up and paid tuition again and studying under Tom for the last few years.
Speaker BAnd that led to this whole project.
Speaker ANice, nice.
Speaker BYou know what led to pediatrics?
Speaker BYou know, when medical students are going through usually the third year nowadays, the second or third year of medical school, they get exposure to lots of different areas and fields.
Speaker BAnd I really didn't know what I was, what I was going to do.
Speaker BI came in with a pretty open mind.
Speaker BSo I went to internal medicine, which is kind of like general adult medicine first.
Speaker BAnd I thought that was really cool.
Speaker BAnd then, and then I went to pediatrics and.
Speaker BOh, I thought that was pretty cool.
Speaker BAnd so I was actually introduced, interested in doing kind of a combination of the two.
Speaker BAnd then, and then the kids just won my heart over.
Speaker BAnd ever since then it's been though that that was definitely the right, the right choice.
Speaker BAnd no part of it do I regret.
Speaker BI love everything that I do.
Speaker BIt's just really, really fun.
Speaker CNice, Nice.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AReal quick.
Speaker AFor those listening or watching or depending on things come out.
Speaker AIf you do hear children screaming.
Speaker ADr. Henson isn't showing you what happens during other theological models of parenting.
Speaker AHe just, he works at a hospital with children.
Speaker ASo that just, that's the background noise.
Speaker AInstead of dogs barking, you hear children's getting shots.
Speaker AIt's fine.
Speaker AAlso, I got to say, you know, we love, we love Pete Inns.
Speaker AWe love all them.
Speaker ASo love, love all that.
Speaker AI forget what the follow up question that I was going to ask was, so I'm going to jump to the next thing here.
Speaker AYou mentioned some about the churches and stuff that you've gone to, some of the changes you've seen.
Speaker ACan you tell us about the faith community you're in now?
Speaker BSure, yeah.
Speaker BSo when our youngest daughter, her name's Carrie, when she went off to college in 2018, we, we made a little move in town geographically and that led to moving our church affiliation just because it didn't make sense to drive as far as we would have been.
Speaker BThat led us to actually look at a whole bunch of different churches.
Speaker BIn our city because we wanted to kind of, kind of see an open view of, hey, what is the Kingdom of Heaven doing in our city?
Speaker BBy the way, I live in Memphis, Tennessee.
Speaker BSo we went to 10 different churches of 10 different denominations.
Speaker BAnd after six months of kind of looking, we landed at a church that at the time was a non denominational church.
Speaker BWe just celebrated our 15th year.
Speaker BSo they were a fairly young church back then.
Speaker BInterestingly, right about the time the pandemic came on, the church decided that they were interested in seeking denominational affiliation, which is not necessarily a common situation these days.
Speaker BThey started looking and because of the pandemic, that kind of got put on hold.
Speaker BAnd then this year that started back up in earnest.
Speaker BAnd just a few months ago, our church aligned with the Disciples of Christ.
Speaker BWe are a, we're a, I would say a casual liturgical church.
Speaker BWe follow the lectionary series and we, and we do liturgies, but certainly in a, in a more casual way, if that makes sense.
Speaker BNot certainly a high church kind of way, but we do preach through the lectionary and, and those kind of things.
Speaker BOur, our, our children's program is, is a godly play program that you may or may not be familiar with.
Speaker BAnd it's kind of, it's kind of a Montessori based Sunday school type curriculum.
Speaker BAnd so I get to participate in that as well, which is a lot of fun.
Speaker AYeah, that's really neat.
Speaker CI was about to say, like, I assume you were pretty critical of like the children's programs at these churches.
Speaker BAt some of them I've been sometimes critical of those.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AWell, that actually is the follow up I wanted to ask.
Speaker AEarlier you mentioned some of how you didn't like what some of the other churches were saying, how it didn't match up what you know, from your work.
Speaker ACould you give us an example?
Speaker ABecause, you know, I don't want to just be kind of vague and like, oh, these things are bad, these things are good.
Speaker ALike, what's an example of something, you know from your work that this doesn't work, that maybe teach it in some churches?
Speaker BYeah, absolutely.
Speaker BAnd as we get talking, we'll talk, we'll probably talk more about the way that I think about different styles of parenting and so forth.
Speaker BBut those approaches, well, they were specifically growing kids.
Speaker BGod's Way, which was kind of a really popular program back in the late 90s.
Speaker BAnd even today you still buy that curriculum kind of is based on a very authoritarian view of parenting in a way that parents see their responsibility as being God's ambassadors to their children.
Speaker BAnd so they seek to teach them obedience to their authority so that someday the children will obey God's authority.
Speaker BSo this idea of an authoritarian control is very, very high in those systems.
Speaker BSo they tend to be not very responsive and they tend to be highly demanding.
Speaker BAnd they tend to look at children as naturally sinful and flawed and see that that needs to be corrected out of them as their responsibility as parents.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BWhere that doesn't line up with better practices is scientific literature, psychological literature, pediatric literature, all says that what would be much preferable is what I refer to as a nurturant style of parenting, which is going to be a parent that's much more responsive.
Speaker BThey still have high goals and aspirations and desires for what their children will be.
Speaker BThe way they lead them there is a little differently.
Speaker BAnd the way they respond to them along that path is a little bit different.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker CSo how would you describe open and relational theology to parents who have never heard the term before?
Speaker BOkay, good.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BSo when people first hear open relational theology, I think they sometimes don't know what we mean by open.
Speaker BAnd I know you guys know this, but many of the listeners may not necessarily know that.
Speaker BIt's not just a vague kind of open to open to a lot of ideas.
Speaker BIt's really specifically talking about open.
Speaker BThat the future is open and that we are moving into a future that is undetermined and so far unwritten, and that God is moving with us through time toward that undetermined future.
Speaker BSo that's the, the open aspect of it.
Speaker BAnd then the relational aspect views that as we do that God is guiding us toward what I like to use the term divine aspirations for what can be in the future.
Speaker BAnd then we make our choices and decisions along that path, God responds to them, and then this becomes a relational co creation of our world and of every moment as we move into the future.
Speaker BSo open, the future is open and relational.
Speaker BWe are co creating with God to create that future.
Speaker AYeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker ABut how does love understood as freely given but not controlling?
Speaker AKind of a little bit what you're describing there translate into parenting practices?
Speaker BYeah, I think, yeah, let's talk about that a little bit more.
Speaker BI talked a little bit about styles.
Speaker BI wanted to find that just a little bit more.
Speaker BWhen people, if you just like hop on Google and say parenting styles, you're going to often find kind of a grid of four common styles.
Speaker BAnd the grid is bisected by two axes.
Speaker BSo one that kind of runs horizontally and can be defined as Parental responsiveness.
Speaker BSo if you can kind of imagine to my right, your left, as the grid moves across, then those parents become more responsive to the right and less responsive to the left.
Speaker BThere's also an axis that moves vertically that classically is referred to as parental demandingness.
Speaker BBut I think it also means, like I was describing before, those parental aspirations for what we're going to do.
Speaker BIt's like what we want our kids to do in the short term and the long term it may be as simple as please don't spill the nail polish on the floor to let's pee in the potty, let's learn how to ride a bike, let's eventually go to college.
Speaker BSo short term and long term aspirations.
Speaker BSo if you can imagine the low demanding and low responsive parents.
Speaker BSo that's going to be the left lower quadrant is going to be the absent parent.
Speaker BWe're not going to talk a lot about that.
Speaker BBut those are parents that for some reason, death, divorce, disinterest, other reasons just aren't involved in a particular child's life.
Speaker BIf you switch just up one quadrant, so you've got a highly demanding but low responsive parent.
Speaker BThat's the authoritarian parent that I was talking about just a little bit ago.
Speaker BThat's the classic parent who says, who if asked why, responds by saying because I said so.
Speaker BSo the parent's authority is, is really strong and, and their responsiveness to the children's input and needs, not so much.
Speaker BIf we switch one to the right, then we get what classically has been described as authoritative parents.
Speaker BThat's extremely confusing to have the word authoritative and the word authoritarian in the same kind of nomenclature.
Speaker BSo I much prefer the term nurturant, which actually John Sanders first kind of utilized in, in his Prodigal's book.
Speaker BIf you've read that, I borrow that from him.
Speaker BI think it fits really well there.
Speaker BSo those parents are, have high expectations for their children, but they're also highly responsive to their children.
Speaker BSo those are nurturing parents.
Speaker BAnd then flip down to the last quadrant.
Speaker BHighly responsive but low demanding parents.
Speaker BThat's your classic permissive parent.
Speaker BSo parent who pretty much lets the children kind of run the show and do the things that they want to do, set the agenda and so forth.
Speaker BSo for most parents, this, this question of love that's not controlling really has to do with are we falling into that authoritarian model?
Speaker BAre we falling into that nurturant model?
Speaker BSo there's, there's a couple different kinds of ways we can think of power and control and if, if you want to be just a little bit nerdy with me.
Speaker BThe Bernard Loomer, who's a theologian and philosopher from 1900s, kind of defined two types of control here.
Speaker BOne he called linear or unilateral control, and then another that he called relational control.
Speaker BAnd unilateral control would say that I have control over someone else if I can affect a change in them without being changed myself.
Speaker BSo that would be this classic model of an authoritarian parent.
Speaker BIt might be an authoritarian leader who says, hey, I'm going to tell you what to do, but I'm not going to change myself in response to that at all.
Speaker BAnd Loomer proposed that maybe a better model is relational control, which says that I first want to see your situation, empathize with it, and be changed by that, and then use that to better understand where we can go together and to affect a change in you.
Speaker BSo I'm both changed and can exert a change on someone else.
Speaker BThe natural next.
Speaker BThe natural next step to that is you start to realize, wait a minute, this isn't about changing or being changed as much as it's about developing relationship, and that the power becomes the power to empower the other in the relationship.
Speaker BSo when I think about.
Speaker BBack to your question.
Speaker BFreely given but not controlling.
Speaker BYeah, I think.
Speaker BI think not controlling means that we're empowering and we're understanding where our children are, and we're leading them to the best outcome that we can see and that they can see, kind of with that idea of co creating our relationship and our future with our children together.
Speaker CAll right, so what was the original inspiration for the book, other than some.
Speaker COr rather than some other means of communicating this idea, like, why a book?
Speaker BYeah, I think that's a really good question.
Speaker BI think as I started to learn about open and relational theology, it just really hit me how that that aligns with parenting.
Speaker BAnd then the more I saw other folks and the work that they're doing in open and relational theology, you find that other people find this area of science really aligns with this, or another area of science really aligns with this.
Speaker BIt's one of those areas of thinking about God that really lets us think about the microbiome, as John Paul might discuss or talk about, or evolution, as somebody else might talk about, or as Tracy Tucker might talk about the science of.
Speaker BOf walking people into death, not from creating their death, but people who are in.
Speaker BHe's a hospice chaplain, so he deals with science from that standpoint.
Speaker BSo so many folks are recognizing that science and God Align really well through this way of looking at God.
Speaker BSo that's a big inspiration for me.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AI'll try to put a link in the show notes.
Speaker AWe just finished a Faith in Science series back in December for those listening, so check that out.
Speaker AAnd John Paul was on one of those episodes, so make sure you check out that playlist.
Speaker ABut I did want to know, is there anything else in the future, like, down the line as far as you're concerned, when it comes to like maybe your own children's church programming or something like that, or where do you see this going?
Speaker BOh, yeah, good question.
Speaker BYeah, I think I want to.
Speaker BIt's interesting already.
Speaker BI'm able to use what I'm doing with theology and parenting in my practice on a daily basis.
Speaker BSometimes that looks like full on talking about theology and pulling that into practice.
Speaker BSometimes it is taking some of those ideas and trying to weave them in.
Speaker BAnd that varies a lot.
Speaker BI think part of it has to do with seeing someone where they are and seeing someone in their faith walk, seeing someone in their own maturity and, and then learning how can, how can I incorporate some of this to help somebody see God in a subtly different way and maybe see their parenting in a little, a little bit different way?
Speaker BSo that's, that's one of the ways that it has some real practical implications.
Speaker BI think there are.
Speaker BThere, there are some other writing projects that are going on.
Speaker BI, I write on substack and usually hit parenting topics and theology topics and try to balance those back and forth with each other.
Speaker BSo that's, that's one of my platforms and I'm starting to think about, about maybe a next book.
Speaker BThere's some interesting discussion that's going on in the, in the country today that's very divisive over vaccines and over the questions about should we vaccinate or not.
Speaker BAnd there's a really interesting study that the NIH did in, I think, 2015 that looked at the five primarily primary reasons that people choose not to vaccinate their children on religious basis.
Speaker BSo it looks at the five religious grounds that people might oppose vaccines, which, A, I find very interesting.
Speaker BB, I've seen all of those described by some of my parents, my patient's parents, and then, and then I think there's some space to start, start educating people on, wow, there's some different ways to see God that might argue differently when it comes to those, those areas that people think, oh, my church says it's not best to vaccinate, but maybe there's other ways we can look at those.
Speaker BThat God.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker CSo is it.
Speaker CDo you think it's possible for churches with diverse theological leanings, whether they're, you know, open theists or Lutherans or Presbyterians or Baptists or.
Speaker CI could read the whole list, but we'd be here for six hours.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker CDo you think it's possible for those to find common ground and how we support the families in our local communities?
Speaker BYeah, I really think it is.
Speaker BI think there are obviously some quadrants of that whole religious spectrum that we have in our country that becomes a bit more challenging.
Speaker BBut I think a wide range of churches and faiths and traditions really can come to this idea of we want to respond to our children and we want to guide them.
Speaker BI think part of it that also then has to do with where are we guiding them?
Speaker BAnd, you know, when.
Speaker BWhen Tom Ord describes his definition of love, the end point of that is this idea of overall well being.
Speaker BOther people say flourishing, other people will use other words for that.
Speaker BShalom.
Speaker BBut that this idea of an overall well being, if that can be a common end point both for families and churches and communities, then I think we can work together better than sometimes we've done in the past.
Speaker BSometimes it's been our community's well being as opposed to an overall well being that we want to work toward.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAwesome.
Speaker AAwesome.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ADo you think, though, that people from other faith traditions who may not be totally on board with open and relational theology might still benefit from reading your book about open and relational parenting?
Speaker BYeah, I really think so.
Speaker BAnd I think so in a real practical way.
Speaker BRight before the book came out, I did a little parenting seminar here in the practice and kind of hand selected a few families that I knew had an interesting and high level of faith and high level of participation in their own faith communities.
Speaker BAnd we walk through a lot of the things that I talk about in the book and, and a lot of the theological ideas, and we get to the very end.
Speaker BAnd one of.
Speaker BOne of my patients, moms, who is one of my favorite patients moms, says, okay, I just want to let you know I disagree with your theology.
Speaker BAnd I'm like, that's totally okay, let's talk about that and see where.
Speaker BAnd she is a member of a Presbyterian church and really struggles with the way that open and relational theology would present that God changes.
Speaker BSo just to clarify that, it's a little bit, you know, in open relational theology, we talk about God as having a nature that's unchanging, like God's essential nature is Love.
Speaker BAnd that's not going to change.
Speaker BBut that God's experience of how God loves does change because our lives change and we face different circumstances.
Speaker BWe're different people now than we were three years, five years, even yesterday ago.
Speaker BAnd so the way God responds to us in love changes over time in response.
Speaker BResponse to us.
Speaker BThat's a big concept for some people to.
Speaker BTo be able to grab theologically.
Speaker BAnd sometimes it seems antithetical to what they've been taught before.
Speaker BThat said, right at the end of that conversation, she and I could easily agree.
Speaker BHey, but there's so many things that we've talked about here today that are really practical for me and I can really take home and I don't really have to grab every little point, at least at this point.
Speaker BAnd us being in agreement with.
Speaker CYeah, I feel like what a lot of people struggle with when they get close to open and relational stuff is a lot of the points that people take issue with are based on the idea that God is not omnipresent in open relational.
Speaker CAnd that is where people be like, I don't know if I can get behind that.
Speaker CBut it's.
Speaker AWait.
Speaker CI think it's better to work from the smaller stuff.
Speaker AI'm not sure if you misspoke or if I misunderstand.
Speaker AI think they're okay with omnipresent, but not okay with omniscient and omnipotent.
Speaker CYeah, omniscience.
Speaker BOkay.
Speaker AYeah, that makes sense.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CAnd his relation to time and stuff is like, what?
Speaker CWell, why does he have to change if he already knows?
Speaker CThat's because an open relationally doesn't.
Speaker AYeah, yeah.
Speaker AWhich to critique Tom Ward.
Speaker AI was gonna say not to critique Tom Ward, but to critique Com Ward.
Speaker AHe knows I like to do that.
Speaker AHe's aware.
Speaker AI don't actually think it's about what God can't do as much as it is about a philosophical view of reality.
Speaker ASo I think it less has to do with how they're viewing God and God's ability and more to do with what reality is.
Speaker AIf we're going to say reality means the future doesn't exist yet, an open and relational theology has to be true.
Speaker AIf we're saying the future already exists, then God must know what the future is because he knows everything.
Speaker ASo I actually think you can hold omniscience if you're going to say that the future is unknowable because he knows everything there is to know.
Speaker AAnd then that gets into weird etymological arguments that Tom is smarter than me.
Speaker AOn and then tells me why I'm dumb, and then I continue to hold my dumb beliefs.
Speaker CYeah, that's what Tom's for.
Speaker CI'm like Tom's favorite punching bag.
Speaker BJoshua.
Speaker BI think you just said that really well.
Speaker BI think that's exactly right.
Speaker AThanks.
Speaker BIf your first point is the future doesn't exist, or at least the future only exists as possibilities, if you want to say it that way.
Speaker BAnd then the future is unknowable and God inherently doesn't know the future, the flip of that is the challenge of if the future does exist and God completely knows the future, then how is it not a deterministic view?
Speaker BAnd how do our choices, actions, decisions matter whatsoever?
Speaker BAnd then, just to clarify, I think this is.
Speaker BI think this is exactly what you meant, T.J. but, yeah, so God in open relational theology, God is omnipresent and would be everywhere, but just would not be in the future from the way that you were describing it.
Speaker CYeah, I end up talking to Tom about that pretty much every time I see him now.
Speaker CSo it's a lot of fun.
Speaker BYeah, it's a lot of fun.
Speaker CBut is there anything that you feel like that our listeners should know about you or your podcast or your book?
Speaker CWhat does the whole church need to know about Chris Hansen?
Speaker ASure.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BI think I'll go back to the book for just a minute and just kind of COVID some of the things that I cover there because I think there's a lot of useful information.
Speaker BThe very first chapter, I spend quite a bit of time looking at parenting research and parenting typography that I kind of described briefly here, what's been done over the last 50 years or so in, in the world of parenting, both how that looks on that typography and then how that might apply to different cultures, how it applies in different circumstances and so forth.
Speaker ASo that.
Speaker BThat's heavy on.
Speaker BOn parenting.
Speaker BThen I move into kind of an interesting look at if we imagined God as any one of those types of parents.
Speaker BSo if we imagine God as, as an authoritarian parent, then what kind of theology would go with that?
Speaker BAnd then, and then we do the same thing with what would God be if God was a disengaged parent, and what would God be if God was a permissive, and what would our theology look like?
Speaker BAnd then ultimately, in the third chapter, I spend quite a bit of time on open and relational theology looking at, okay, if God is a nurturant parent, then then what does that God look like?
Speaker BAnd we, and we kind of walk through a lot of those Pillars of Open Relational Theology.
Speaker BFourth chapter is a deep dive into the, into the question that you ask about kind of what was wrong with some of the church based parenting stuff that I was running into back years ago and that you can still find out there.
Speaker BIf you just type into Amazon Christian Parenting, you can still still find a lot of that same.
Speaker BSame stuff.
Speaker BSo both Dobson and then, and then some of his followers kind of fall under that.
Speaker BAnd, and so we kind of talk about that.
Speaker BAnd then in the fifth chapter, we talk about an open and relational parenting approach and really apply this first very high level to parenting, kind of thinking about general ideas.
Speaker BAnd then the last chapter, which was not part of my dissertation but was added just for the book, is the six.
Speaker BThe sixth chapter really deals with some practical examples and walks people through.
Speaker BHow would you practically apply this in your life with your kids?
Speaker BAll right, so do, do you ever.
Speaker CLike, you ever have a patient parent and you're like, you know, I think you should check out this book?
Speaker BYou know, I'm not shy about that.
Speaker BLike, we have little bulletin boards up in our, in our exam rooms and all of my exam rooms have, have it up in my bulletin, on the bulletin board words.
Speaker BAnd the book came out in August, so, so now we've gotten to a point where several of them have bought it.
Speaker BAnd I walked in on Friday and I was kind of flabbergasted because this, this mom said, well, I've got your book and I'm reading through it.
Speaker BI'm really enjoying it.
Speaker BAnd I'm like, okay, that's great.
Speaker BThat means you don't hate my theology.
Speaker BAnd, and you're getting something out of it.
Speaker BAnd so then that led to a whole conversation about some other things.
Speaker BSo no, I think some, some of them are finding it to be a helpful resource on, on a lot of different bases.
Speaker BAwesome.
Speaker AYeah, nice.
Speaker CSo is it, is it easier now?
Speaker CDo you think the book makes it easier to be a podiatrist?
Speaker CCan you just.
Speaker CEvery once in a while you're like, oh, you have my book, right?
Speaker CIt's in chapter two.
Speaker CYou assign your patients homework.
Speaker BIt's actually really interesting, you know, having it out there.
Speaker BIt does give a landing spot.
Speaker BAnd so does the, the, so does the substack kind of gives a landing spot.
Speaker BLike one of my substack articles just walks through the, the parenting quadrants.
Speaker BAnd so I, I can link that, I can refer to it, I can refer somebody there just, just about that.
Speaker BAnd then where, where we talked about Loomer and his two Conceptions of power.
Speaker BI've got two specific substack articles that just came out that are kind of talking about that.
Speaker BSo I'm trying to let, let some of those ideas start coming out in substack as well.
Speaker BSo we've got a few different reference points so that people can grab onto a single idea or they can get the book and kind of grab onto the larger, larger scale idea as well.
Speaker CThat's awesome.
Speaker AAnd we'll, we'll try to link the substack in book and everything in the show notes as well.
Speaker BYeah, perfect.
Speaker BSounds great.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ASo one thing we do like to always do at the end of our episodes is just to ask for a single tangible action.
Speaker ASomething our listeners could go do right now that would help better engender Christian unity in the world, you know, at large.
Speaker AYeah, something they could stop and do something physical or I guess it doesn't have to be physical, but something they can actually go, you know, right now, not like, listen in general.
Speaker AYeah, tangible.
Speaker BYeah, something tangible they could do to engender Christian unity.
Speaker BI'm going to start just in the family because, because I think that's, that's where it starts in this relation and it relates to, to where I am.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BAnd, and I think the first thing might be go and see where your children were today.
Speaker BTry to understand how they felt about what they did today and see if you can have a conversation with them about what that makes them want to do next.
Speaker BSo I think I'm trying to encourage this idea of empathizing, sympathizing, and also taking input from the kids and saying, where are we?
Speaker BWhere are we as a family going to go next?
Speaker BAnd how can I get your input as part of that?
Speaker BAnd I think that moves the church farther toward unity because I think if we can move the family further toward unity, then we can move the church further toward unity as well.
Speaker CAll right, so you, so what do you think we would see change in the world around us if everyone started doing that?
Speaker CAre like, is the family diner going to come back in a big way?
Speaker CIs Denny's going to take over the world?
Speaker BI don't know if it's going to be, quote, family values in that way, but I think we're going to see and, and the data actually says we're going to see stronger children who are better equipped to make their own decisions as they move forward.
Speaker BSometimes I talk about, you know, a seventh grader, a 12, 12 year old, 13 year old is just in the process where they're starting to Say, I want to make my own decisions, and I want to.
Speaker BI want to kind of determine my own way.
Speaker BAnd if the parent will sit back and think, wow, by the time they get to college, I really want them to be able to do that.
Speaker BI want them to be able to go off to college and be able to.
Speaker BTo decide when I'm going to go to class and what food I'm going to eat and am I going to do my laundry and all of those things that you have to do.
Speaker BWell, that's a gradual process, and it's a gradual process of guiding them to gradually more freedom in those decisions.
Speaker BAnd it's going to take those kind of interactive conversations to be able to understand where they are and how can we move them closer to that.
Speaker BAnd if we are listening to our children and guiding them with relational guidance, then we are going to create kids that are better prepared to hit college, to hit young professional life, to hit communities, and be able to participate in their churches and their communities in healthier ways.
Speaker AAll right, so good stuff.
Speaker CYeah, I like that a lot.
Speaker BI.
Speaker CMine was actually pretty recent, the transition from, you know, not.
Speaker COr having to do my own laundry.
Speaker CSo that was rough.
Speaker CDoing it all at once.
Speaker CI didn't have to.
Speaker CThere's no weaning process.
Speaker CI was just like, man, I. I have to clean my clothes.
Speaker CThis is messed up.
Speaker BI will not name my college roommate.
Speaker BBut he.
Speaker BHe just kept going to buy more clothes so that he didn't have to wash them.
Speaker CAnd so, yeah, hey, if I was rich, I probably would have done the same thing.
Speaker BYeah, I mean, I think he just went buying clothes.
Speaker BI think that was his problem.
Speaker CYeah, If I'd had a credit card, I might have done that.
Speaker BYeah, I think he did.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BYeah, yeah.
Speaker CBut before we wrap up, we like to do what we call our God moment, where we just ask everyone to share a moment they saw God in recently, whether it be in a blessing or a challenge, a mode of worship, a curse, whatever it might be.
Speaker CWhere have you seen God at?
Speaker CAnd I always like to make Josh go first to give the rest of us more time to think.
Speaker CSo, Josh, do you have a God moment for us this week?
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AWork is a struggle sometimes, and recently it's been a lot of struggle, and I've been really irritated, thinking, man, there's all this stuff I'm going to have to do that I don't want to have to do.
Speaker AIf only we had a manager that could work these specific hours, make my life so much easier then that day.
Speaker ASomeone came in who used to be manager at Chipotle and applied, but said, I only want to work these specific hours.
Speaker AAnd I was like, oh, perfect.
Speaker AThat's exactly what I just kind of was hoping we had.
Speaker ASo just worked out really weirdly good.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker CYou know, I've had the exact opposite experience.
Speaker CPretty much every time I've thought that.
Speaker ASomebody with hours you don't need.
Speaker CYeah, every time.
Speaker AYeah, perfect.
Speaker CEvery time.
Speaker CThey're like, I'm gonna work your shifts.
Speaker AI was like, they're mine.
Speaker CI work, too.
Speaker CBut for me, my God.
Speaker CMoment.
Speaker CI woke up this morning, my dad texted me, like, right after I woke up, which is, you know, convenient.
Speaker CYou know, I don't like to miss texts, so if he's gonna politely wait until I'm awake somehow, that's awesome.
Speaker CBut he texted me to ask if I'd spoken to my mom, and, like, no, of course not.
Speaker CYou know, if I just woke up.
Speaker CBut she went to the hospital last night with a GI bleed, and instead of, you know, telling everyone I'm in the hospital at, like, midnight, she just wanted to wait.
Speaker CShe made him swear to secrecy.
Speaker CBut she's okay?
Speaker CGod, you know, as okay as you can be with a GI bleed.
Speaker CYeah, but she's fine.
Speaker CShe's nowhere we haven't been before.
Speaker CAnd I'm grateful that she felt secure enough with the hospital to wait to tell us because she knows she's not going to die.
Speaker AAlthough you would have preferred her still tell you, I assume.
Speaker CI would have preferred to have known when it happened.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker CI was awake.
Speaker CI could have went there.
Speaker AYeah, but if any of my parents are listening, I know before it happens.
Speaker AText me before the doctor tells you.
Speaker CYou have it beforehand.
Speaker AI'll be there when it happens.
Speaker CYeah, but they're actually.
Speaker CShe's in the same hospital as her mom currently, and I think she's trying to not let her find out.
Speaker CSays to not worry her mom.
Speaker AThat's funny, actually.
Speaker CWhich is pretty funny.
Speaker CYou know, I mean, it sucks, but also, they're both in the hospital, but.
Speaker CYeah, but it's pretty funny that she's not trying to.
Speaker CI'm just thankful that they are both being cared for in a place that they trust.
Speaker ALike, if all these humans are just characters on a sitcom, it would be hilarious.
Speaker CIt would be hilarious.
Speaker CYou got to see it when it happens, you know?
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker CDr. Hanson, do you have a God moment for us?
Speaker BYeah, I think.
Speaker BI think I'm just gonna go to last night.
Speaker BSo our.
Speaker BOur church kind of functionalize many churches with with small groups.
Speaker BWe call them story groups because the idea is to share.
Speaker BShare the story of your life with other people.
Speaker BAnd, and we lead one of those groups.
Speaker BAnd, and we had a new member to our group last night who I. I've known.
Speaker BShe's a single young lady at our church that, that expressed that she wanted to come and, and she fit in so incredibly well.
Speaker BAnd, and it wasn't very long that she was throwing in comments and, and, and just was part of the conversation as if she had been there a long time.
Speaker BSo just kind of, kind of, wow.
Speaker BA really nice new relationship that I think we'll all benefit from and I'll get to learn from her and hopefully she gets to learn a little bit from us.
Speaker ANice.
Speaker CIt's awesome to meet a new group that you click with immediately.
Speaker BThat's.
Speaker CThat's rare for a lot of people.
Speaker CBut thank you so much for your time.
Speaker CThank you.
Speaker CIf you're listening for your time, please consider sharing the episode with a friend if you liked it or an enemy if you liked it or didn't like it.
Speaker CWe're cousins, no matter what you thought, especially your cousins.
Speaker CSuper helpful.
Speaker CWe encourage strong familial systems here.
Speaker CAnd if you are listening on the YouTube channel, hit, like hit subscribe.
Speaker CIf you're not listening on YouTube, rate and view the show.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker CWherever you are listening.
Speaker CThat's Super Helpful on YouTube.
Speaker CPut us out there.
Speaker AComment or whatever you're supposed to say.
Speaker AYeah, yeah.
Speaker CTell us what you think about Josh's shirt.
Speaker AOh, that's right.
Speaker CRing the bell.
Speaker CYeah, that's what they say.
Speaker CThat's what the YouTube.
Speaker AI like this color green.
Speaker AI accidentally got two shirts and I was gonna give one of them away, but then I just like this green on me a lot, so I'm not giving it away.
Speaker CYeah, more shirts means less laundry.
Speaker ATrue.
Speaker AWe learned that in the episode.
Speaker ABut also, guys, try to remember to check out the other shows.
Speaker ALansalle Podcast Network link is down below.
Speaker AYou can check out Letting a Thunder with youh Chris Nashley.
Speaker AYou checking out My Seminary Life with Brandon Knight or your Matter Matters with Pastor Will Rose and Pastor Thomas Johnston.
Speaker AIt's a.
Speaker AA little educational miniseries we did with the in association with the elca.
Speaker ASo it's good stuff.
Speaker CAll right.
Speaker CAnd we do hope you enjoyed it.
Speaker CComing up, we'll be interviewing Russ Petrus once again to discuss another Catholic organization that he helps with called Future Church.
Speaker CAnd then we're going to be having on the one and only mentioned many times in this show, Dr. Thomas J.
Speaker CBoard back with us to discuss how our views have changed or grown over the last couple of years.
Speaker CI think he'll be sorely disappointed in me, as always.
Speaker CAnd finally, at the end of season one, Francis Chan will be on the show.
Speaker AProbably he doesn't know about it.
Speaker AMaybe it'll probably happen eventually.
Speaker AIf someone does tell him about it.
Speaker AMaybe it could be you.
Speaker AYou tell him about it.
Speaker AListener.
Speaker AWe believe in you, listener.
Speaker CSmokey the Bear.