1 00:00:42,001 --> 00:00:46,000 Steve Grumbine: All right, folks, this is Steve with Macro N Cheese. Today's 2 00:00:46,001 --> 00:00:51,000 guest is an author. He is also a professor, and more 3 00:00:51,001 --> 00:00:56,000 importantly, he is an activist. And he's got a great analytical 4 00:00:56,001 --> 00:01:01,000 framework for understanding the suppression and the social media censorship, quite 5 00:01:01,001 --> 00:01:06,000 frankly, that has gone on regarding the Palestinian struggle for liberation 6 00:01:06,001 --> 00:01:11,000 and quite honestly, the genocide of the people of Gaza that 7 00:01:11,001 --> 00:01:16,000 we've been able to watch live streamed mostly for the last 8 00:01:16,001 --> 00:01:21,000 couple years. And he's written a book called Terms of Servitude: 9 00:01:21,001 --> 00:01:26,000 Zionism, Silicon Valley and Digital/Settler-Colonialism in the Palestinian Liberation Struggle. My 10 00:01:26,001 --> 00:01:31,000 guest, who you may have heard of before, is Omar Zahzah. 11 00:01:31,001 --> 00:01:36,000 He's assistant professor of Arab, Muslim, Ethnicities, and Diasporas (AMED) Studies 12 00:01:36,001 --> 00:01:41,000 at San Francisco State University. And the book traces the timeline 13 00:01:41,001 --> 00:01:46,000 from the Sheikh Jarrah uprisings of 2021 to the beginning of 14 00:01:46,001 --> 00:01:51,000 October 2023 to the most current developments to explain social media's 15 00:01:51,001 --> 00:01:56,000 role in advancing and suppressing Palestinian narratives. So without further ado, 16 00:01:56,001 --> 00:02:01,000 let me bring on my guest, Omar. Welcome to the show. 17 00:02:01,001 --> 00:02:03,000 Omar Zahzah: Thank you so much for having me. 18 00:02:03,001 --> 00:02:08,000 Steve Grumbine: Absolutely. We have tried really hard over the years to cover this in the 19 00:02:08,001 --> 00:02:13,000 best way we could. We are a macroeconomics podcast that does the interdisciplinary natures 20 00:02:13,001 --> 00:02:18,000 of struggle. We are also a podcast that focuses on class struggle. And this 21 00:02:18,001 --> 00:02:23,000 is very much a class issue. This is very much an issue that people 22 00:02:23,001 --> 00:02:28,000 with a socialist worldview would find incredibly important to their way of life, their 23 00:02:28,001 --> 00:02:33,000 ideological framework for how they view the world. A dialectical perspective, for sure, here 24 00:02:33,001 --> 00:02:38,000 will allow people to understand how we got here, not just "Whatever happened on 25 00:02:38,001 --> 00:02:43,000 October 6th?" They will really, truly understand all the things that led up to 26 00:02:43,001 --> 00:02:48,000 the point where we are. And your book is really fantastic. We've covered a 27 00:02:48,001 --> 00:02:53,000 lot of AI issues and we've covered a lot of social media suppression issues, 28 00:02:53,001 --> 00:02:58,000 algorithm issues, censorship, et cetera. But this is at a whole different level because 29 00:02:58,001 --> 00:03:03,000 this is covering up for a genocide. This is literally silencing people who are 30 00:03:03,001 --> 00:03:08,000 in a desperate attempt trying to feed themselves, much less get healthcare and just 31 00:03:08,001 --> 00:03:13,000 make it to the next day. We're not even talking about, "Hey, I'd like 32 00:03:13,001 --> 00:03:18,000 a career. Hey, I'd like to be able to buy a ping pong table 33 00:03:18,001 --> 00:03:23,000 or I'd like to enjoy video game." We're talking about people trying to survive 34 00:03:23,001 --> 00:03:28,000 one day to the next being literally silenced by huge, huge media companies with 35 00:03:28,001 --> 00:03:33,000 government intervention and a whole host of actors that are working collectively together, from 36 00:03:33,001 --> 00:03:38,000 Silicon Valley to the White House. And obviously the least able, if you will, 37 00:03:38,001 --> 00:03:43,000 the least financed, the least capable of resistance, are forced to not only resist 38 00:03:43,001 --> 00:03:48,000 the oppression that they feel on a daily basis from the bombs and from 39 00:03:48,001 --> 00:03:53,000 the other militarization of the region, but also from these tech oligarchs who have 40 00:03:53,001 --> 00:03:58,000 silenced the cries for justice. Tell us about what brought this book into being 41 00:03:58,001 --> 00:04:03,000 and give us a little bit of background for why we should be paying 42 00:04:03,001 --> 00:04:08,000 attention to this. 43 00:04:08,001 --> 00:04:13,000 Omar Zahzah: Thank you so much for that question. As you noted in your introduction of 44 00:04:13,001 --> 00:04:18,000 the text, this really began for me in 2021. Some of your viewers may 45 00:04:18,001 --> 00:04:23,000 recall that it was at this time that you started to see protests by 46 00:04:23,001 --> 00:04:28,000 Palestinians who were opposing their looming expulsion from the occupied East Jerusalem neighborhood of 47 00:04:28,001 --> 00:04:33,000 Sheikh Jarrah. And a big part of their demonstrations, their protests, their activism, was 48 00:04:33,001 --> 00:04:38,000 the use of social media. Now keep in mind that this followed on the 49 00:04:38,001 --> 00:04:43,000 heels of the 2020 George Floyd uprisings, which I think had also kind of 50 00:04:43,001 --> 00:04:48,000 primed us globally for broader structural conversations about racism. Not just being a question 51 00:04:48,001 --> 00:04:53,000 of interpersonal attitudes, but really about a system, an overall structure of oppression, exploitation 52 00:04:53,001 --> 00:04:58,000 and ultimately state-sanctioned violence and even death. And so all of that's to say 53 00:04:58,001 --> 00:05:03,000 that by the time 2021 comes around in a kind of larger global sense, 54 00:05:03,001 --> 00:05:08,000 people, the general public here, I'm saying, I think were already primed for related 55 00:05:08,001 --> 00:05:13,000 conversations about other forms of systemic and structural oppression. And so 2021, the timing 56 00:05:13,001 --> 00:05:19,000 of it I think lines up very nicely in this regard because people are 57 00:05:19,001 --> 00:05:24,000 ready to hear differing perspectives on what the nature of the Palestinian struggle really 58 00:05:24,001 --> 00:05:29,000 is. And shifting it from a lot of the liberal bromides or honestly the 59 00:05:29,001 --> 00:05:34,000 Zionist propaganda that is perpetrated by the legacy corporate media towards really shifting our 60 00:05:34,001 --> 00:05:39,000 perspective to understanding that first and foremost this is about settler colonization. And this 61 00:05:39,001 --> 00:05:44,000 is about a process that has been in place since the Nakba of 1948. 62 00:05:44,001 --> 00:05:49,000 And even prior to that, when you have preceding regime of British imperialism that 63 00:05:49,001 --> 00:05:54,000 first begins to welcome and work to institute what will become the ascension of 64 00:05:54,001 --> 00:05:59,000 the Zionist project in Palestine during its own mandate. So it's been an unrelenting 65 00:05:59,001 --> 00:06:04,000 process of settler colonization that is abetted by imperialism and shifting from the imperial 66 00:06:04,001 --> 00:06:09,000 mandate of Great Britain at the time, now the United States, which is entered 67 00:06:09,001 --> 00:06:14,000 as the current global superpower. So a lot of background. But what happens is 68 00:06:14,001 --> 00:06:19,000 essentially that these organizers, these activists, take to social media in 2021, protesting their 69 00:06:19,001 --> 00:06:25,000 situation, but also protesting the way that the Palestinian narrative has been consistently misrepresented 70 00:06:25,001 --> 00:06:30,000 within legacy corporate media, within the sphere of politics at large. And they're effective. 71 00:06:30,001 --> 00:06:35,000 They do start to affect narrative shifts. And they're so effective at it through 72 00:06:35,001 --> 00:06:40,000 using platforms like Instagram, Facebook, Twitter at the time, now X, that legacy corporate 73 00:06:40,001 --> 00:06:45,000 media begins to take note, begins to platform them increasingly more. And they also 74 00:06:45,001 --> 00:06:50,000 prove themselves to be savvy at navigating those terrains, redirecting the questions, right, rejecting 75 00:06:50,001 --> 00:06:55,000 the propaganda, or what the critic Steven Salaita has referred to as the prerequisite 76 00:06:55,001 --> 00:07:00,000 to speaking that Arab individuals are often confronted with. Like you need to speak 77 00:07:00,001 --> 00:07:05,000 on a particular script, you need to condemn a particular project before we will 78 00:07:05,001 --> 00:07:10,000 allow you to say what you really came to say, to challenge the injustice 79 00:07:10,001 --> 00:07:15,000 that you're facing. They turn all of that on its head and they expose 80 00:07:15,001 --> 00:07:20,000 it for what it is in real time. And so all of this continues 81 00:07:20,001 --> 00:07:25,000 to have vast gains for shifting perceptions of what the Palestinian struggle is really 82 00:07:25,001 --> 00:07:31,000 about. And of course, as a result of this success, these same Big Tech 83 00:07:31,001 --> 00:07:36,000 companies that had initially made these counter-hegemonic opportunities possible try to roll back those 84 00:07:36,001 --> 00:07:41,000 gains by engaging in increasingly collective forms of censorship. So you see blanket censorship 85 00:07:41,001 --> 00:07:46,000 of posts about Sheikh Jarrah, of posts about the Israeli occupation forces incursion into 86 00:07:46,001 --> 00:07:51,000 the Al-Aqsa Mosque, of the bombing of Gaza that happens in 2022. You start 87 00:07:51,001 --> 00:07:56,000 to see an increasing social media blackout, the suspension of accounts, the deleting of 88 00:07:56,001 --> 00:08:01,000 posts, the banning of prominent Palestinian accounts. All of this happening at such a 89 00:08:01,001 --> 00:08:06,000 rapid scale that it's very clear that there is a coordinated attempt to silence 90 00:08:06,001 --> 00:08:11,000 these dissenting voices. Again, what is unique about this moment in time, we're still 91 00:08:11,001 --> 00:08:16,000 in 2021, 2022, is that this happens at such a scale that legacy corporate 92 00:08:16,001 --> 00:08:21,000 media also has to take note of this silencing. So they begin to report 93 00:08:21,001 --> 00:08:26,000 on it. So we start to get our first peek behind the curtain, our 94 00:08:26,001 --> 00:08:31,000 glimpse into the fact that these Big Tech companies that had really branded themselves 95 00:08:31,001 --> 00:08:37,000 on providing the instruments of democracy, are engaging in a mass censorship of people 96 00:08:37,001 --> 00:08:42,000 righteously resisting their colonial dispossession at the hands of a settler colonial state. And 97 00:08:42,001 --> 00:08:47,000 this kind of contrast between, on the one hand, the promise, and if you 98 00:08:47,001 --> 00:08:52,000 want to get a little cynical about it, the false branding, but also arguably, 99 00:08:52,001 --> 00:08:57,000 the potential of these platforms to work in a certain way, to be re-appropriated 100 00:08:57,001 --> 00:09:02,000 in a particular form by activists, and the actual practices of these companies when 101 00:09:02,001 --> 00:09:07,000 they see their platforms utilized too successfully for purposes to which they were never 102 00:09:07,001 --> 00:09:12,000 intended to be put. Because, of course, the point of these products is to 103 00:09:12,001 --> 00:09:17,000 keep us passively consuming, just mindlessly scrolling. And they often try to discourage political 104 00:09:17,001 --> 00:09:22,000 engagement in general, or at least political engagement that is serious, that is sustained, 105 00:09:22,001 --> 00:09:27,000 instead of something that will work towards sensationalism and keep us kind of anxiously 106 00:09:27,001 --> 00:09:32,000 glued in that regard. So that contrast became really intriguing to me, and I 107 00:09:32,001 --> 00:09:37,000 started to think there was something to this dynamic that not only needed to 108 00:09:37,001 --> 00:09:43,000 be commented upon, because we had a lot of writing already coming out about 109 00:09:43,001 --> 00:09:48,000 this seeming contradiction between what social media could be and how it's actually being 110 00:09:48,001 --> 00:09:53,000 implemented and what that means for Palestine, but I was thinking that it would 111 00:09:53,001 --> 00:09:58,000 be important to start to think about a larger project that put the clearly 112 00:09:58,001 --> 00:10:03,000 targeted censorship that Palestinians are facing on these platforms into conversation with other interventions 113 00:10:03,001 --> 00:10:08,000 about Big Tech and how Big Tech fortifies systems and structures of racism and 114 00:10:08,001 --> 00:10:13,000 dispossession. So I'm thinking here of studies like Ruha Benjamin's Race After Technology, studies 115 00:10:13,001 --> 00:10:18,000 that really talked about how despite its propaganda, Big Tech is often the main 116 00:10:18,001 --> 00:10:23,000 culprit in fortifying the various systems that it claims its products will allow for 117 00:10:23,001 --> 00:10:28,000 people to challenge. And I felt that what was happening to Palestinians needed to 118 00:10:28,001 --> 00:10:33,000 be engaged in a sustained way in this broader context and put into conversations 119 00:10:33,001 --> 00:10:38,000 with these broader interventions into the oppressive machinations of Big Tech as it is, 120 00:10:38,001 --> 00:10:43,000 precisely because what these companies are doing is digitally amplifying a physical process of 121 00:10:43,001 --> 00:10:49,000 settler colonial dispossession. 122 00:10:49,001 --> 00:10:54,000 Steve Grumbine: That is very powerful. I was trying to figure out how to frame the 123 00:10:54,001 --> 00:10:59,000 digital colonization, the settler colonialism. And it just dawned on me. You said a 124 00:10:59,001 --> 00:11:05,000 couple words in there that I think tie together really, really well and are 125 00:11:05,001 --> 00:11:10,000 super important. One of them, you said hegemony, and that harkens back to Antonio 126 00:11:10,001 --> 00:11:15,000 Gramsci. And we have been focused on very heavily on the impact of cultural 127 00:11:15,001 --> 00:11:21,000 hegemony lately, not only in the economic space where these frames and these kinds 128 00:11:21,001 --> 00:11:26,000 of statements and concepts and institutions all reinforce the hegemonic view of neoliberalism. In 129 00:11:26,001 --> 00:11:32,000 fact, the ruling class uses these things as a means of disciplining us and 130 00:11:32,001 --> 00:11:37,000 so forth. And we could see this kind of rise of a fascism in 131 00:11:37,001 --> 00:11:42,000 terms of the brutality and crackdown on people with differing opinions outside of that 132 00:11:42,001 --> 00:11:48,000 hegemonic state. I'm curious, could you speak a little bit to hegemony here and 133 00:11:48,001 --> 00:11:53,000 how this kind of dynamic is playing out in terms of the common sense. 134 00:11:53,001 --> 00:11:58,000 Of course, we all are kind of led to believe that Israel is the 135 00:11:58,001 --> 00:12:04,000 victim here, which is rather comical if you've had any historical framework of the 136 00:12:04,001 --> 00:12:09,000 comings and goings of the region. What are your thoughts on how cultural hegemony 137 00:12:09,001 --> 00:12:15,000 and in particular some Gramscian views of how this is playing out? 138 00:12:15,001 --> 00:12:20,000 Omar Zahzah: Yeah, it's a really rich and at the same time very important dynamic to understand 139 00:12:20,001 --> 00:12:25,000 classically the concept of hegemony, referring to how systems of belief that are most beneficial 140 00:12:25,001 --> 00:12:30,000 to the political sphere are replicated and sort of maintained within the cultural realm, the 141 00:12:30,001 --> 00:12:35,000 one that is seemingly disconnected from politics. In the Palestinian context, I think we put 142 00:12:35,001 --> 00:12:40,000 rightfully as critics a lot of emphasis on legacy corporate media because it's the main 143 00:12:40,001 --> 00:12:46,000 instrument of manufacturing consent for various imperial projects that the US either directly undertakes or 144 00:12:46,001 --> 00:12:51,000 supports as part of its broader program of geo-imperial domination. And the Palestinian context is 145 00:12:51,001 --> 00:12:56,000 one of those. And it's a very unique case in point in the sense that 146 00:12:56,001 --> 00:13:01,000 what types of media maneuvering the Palestinian context has resulted in oftentimes an outright erasure 147 00:13:01,001 --> 00:13:06,000 of Palestinian perspectives and voices within the corporate legacy media channels. And when they are 148 00:13:06,001 --> 00:13:12,000 engaged in this very piecemeal, sensationalized way that ultimately continues to reaffirm the larger Zionist 149 00:13:12,001 --> 00:13:17,000 narrative. Things like thinking of the Israeli state as this poor besieged bastion of democracy 150 00:13:17,001 --> 00:13:22,000 that is simply trying to do the best that it can while being confronted by 151 00:13:22,001 --> 00:13:27,000 all of these aggressive and hateful and subhuman anti-Semitic peoples who have no culture aside 152 00:13:27,001 --> 00:13:32,000 from hate. And you can keep tropifying this on and on and on because I 153 00:13:32,001 --> 00:13:38,000 think it's been so culturally distributed that we understand how it works, even if we 154 00:13:38,001 --> 00:13:43,000 are also critical of it. So that had been one of the main instruments of 155 00:13:43,001 --> 00:13:48,000 maintaining this broader cultural normalization of thinking about Israel and the Palestinians or even just 156 00:13:48,001 --> 00:13:53,000 the Arabs, because oftentimes Palestine is erased. We don't call it Palestine. Right? But thinking 157 00:13:53,001 --> 00:13:58,000 it in a particular way. And then you start to have the sort of introduction 158 00:13:58,001 --> 00:14:04,000 of these other platforms that are supposedly able to kind of allow for us to 159 00:14:04,001 --> 00:14:09,000 redirect that so ostensibly provide an opening to enable people to somewhat subvert some of 160 00:14:09,001 --> 00:14:14,000 the terms of the hegemonic worldview as we have come to know it, as it 161 00:14:14,001 --> 00:14:19,000 has come to be normalized. But then of course, what you start to see is 162 00:14:19,001 --> 00:14:24,000 precisely these very platforms are actually just as invested in perpetuating the ultimate implications of 163 00:14:24,001 --> 00:14:29,000 this initial form of hegemony. Now they can't do it as overtly. They can't do 164 00:14:29,001 --> 00:14:35,000 it as directly. First of all, because there's so many people actually using these platforms. 165 00:14:35,001 --> 00:14:40,000 Secondly, because there have been so many gains in terms of the dissemination of different 166 00:14:40,001 --> 00:14:45,000 materials that show people conditions that do contravene some of the more basic tenets of 167 00:14:45,001 --> 00:14:50,000 what this initial propagandistic narrative had been. So they can't necessarily always engage with the 168 00:14:50,001 --> 00:14:55,000 same maneuvers, but they can do things like they can censor. They can shadow ban. 169 00:14:55,001 --> 00:15:01,000 They can blacklist. And that erasure can also still have implications. One of the other 170 00:15:01,001 --> 00:15:06,000 ways that I think about hegemony in the book, and I write about this a 171 00:15:06,001 --> 00:15:11,000 little bit in the introduction, is, in addition to that particular political definition, which also, 172 00:15:11,001 --> 00:15:16,000 of course, entails the need to mount a counter-hegemonic cultural offensive to spread these counter 173 00:15:16,001 --> 00:15:21,000 narratives that are going to advance vis-a-vis a word position. One of the other ways 174 00:15:21,001 --> 00:15:27,000 I get into it, though, is just the fact that there's so much capture that 175 00:15:27,001 --> 00:15:32,000 these platforms have on our social imaginations, on our understanding of how we think about 176 00:15:32,001 --> 00:15:37,000 the world around us. This is going to sound maybe a little bit almost supernatural 177 00:15:37,001 --> 00:15:42,000 or so, but the different newsfeeds that we have kind of become their own kind 178 00:15:42,001 --> 00:15:47,000 of default for how we conceptualize the organizing of discourse or how we think about 179 00:15:47,001 --> 00:15:53,000 how can we put information together in a readily accessible way? Because they provide a 180 00:15:53,001 --> 00:15:58,000 template for us to think about newer forms of communication and the dissemination of information. 181 00:15:58,001 --> 00:16:03,000 So they also have a hegemonic influence in terms of how they relate to the 182 00:16:03,001 --> 00:16:08,000 way that we see and understand the organization of the world. And so when they 183 00:16:08,001 --> 00:16:13,000 practice these forms of censorship, they can also have, even if it's a less-noticed influence, 184 00:16:13,001 --> 00:16:18,000 they can still have an influence in our sense of, okay, what do we prioritize? 185 00:16:18,001 --> 00:16:24,000 What do we think more or less about? What are we seeing more in our 186 00:16:24,001 --> 00:16:29,000 algorithmically curated feeds? What are we not seeing as much of? What happened to that 187 00:16:29,001 --> 00:16:34,000 Palestinian journalist I followed a few months ago? I haven't heard anything from them. I 188 00:16:34,001 --> 00:16:39,000 haven't seen them. Maybe you'll remember to seek out their page, but maybe you'll forget. 189 00:16:39,001 --> 00:16:44,000 And that's also going to subtly start to code your own sense of political urgency, 190 00:16:44,001 --> 00:16:50,000 your sense of the need to take immediate action. So they have, I would say, 191 00:16:50,001 --> 00:16:55,000 seemingly more subtle means of still advancing a particular hegemonic understanding in line with what 192 00:16:55,001 --> 00:17:00,000 the status quo requires for people within the West to think. Because ultimately we need 193 00:17:00,001 --> 00:17:05,000 to come back to supporting the Israeli colonial project. But I would say that precisely 194 00:17:05,001 --> 00:17:10,000 because of their subtlety, I felt it was important to mount kind of a sustained 195 00:17:10,001 --> 00:17:16,000 engagement with them and exposing them for what they are, which is still an instrument 196 00:17:16,001 --> 00:17:21,000 of advancing a hegemonic understanding that through these practices that disabuse the Palestinians engaged in 197 00:17:21,001 --> 00:17:26,000 righteous dissent from being able to advance their own counter-hegemonic narratives that, as we've seen 198 00:17:26,001 --> 00:17:31,000 over the past few years, have been increasingly successful in changing perceptions of Palestine, even 199 00:17:31,001 --> 00:17:36,000 as the situation itself on the ground continues to remain dire and unfold in newly 200 00:17:36,001 --> 00:17:42,000 horrific ways as the genocide continues. 201 00:17:42,001 --> 00:17:47,000 Steve Grumbine: You said something really important, and I want to touch on this as a follow up. Gramsci did 202 00:17:47,001 --> 00:17:52,000 talk about a war of position and a war of maneuver. And I'm curious, what do you mean 203 00:17:52,001 --> 00:17:57,000 by that when you're referencing it here? Because I think it's fascinating. I still would really love to 204 00:17:57,001 --> 00:18:02,000 know a deeper understanding of that whole framework of those two. I know one is kind of appealing 205 00:18:02,001 --> 00:18:07,000 to the elites, trying to get them to change the way they behave. And I know the other 206 00:18:07,001 --> 00:18:12,000 one is just straight-up revolution. Can you help me better understand what you mean by that? 207 00:18:12,001 --> 00:18:17,000 Omar Zahzah: Yeah, definitely. In this context, I'm using it loosely. And the reason that I'm 208 00:18:17,001 --> 00:18:22,000 using it loosely is I'm referring to, I would argue it's operating on multiple 209 00:18:22,001 --> 00:18:27,000 senses of the term, because on the one hand, there is a broader Palestinian 210 00:18:27,001 --> 00:18:32,000 undertaking to shift the narrative and for supporters of the Palestinian liberation struggle to 211 00:18:32,001 --> 00:18:37,000 really continue to try to attack the centers of power and shift and challenge 212 00:18:37,001 --> 00:18:42,000 and repurpose a lot of the ways that those centers of power have framed 213 00:18:42,001 --> 00:18:47,000 our understanding of these political conditions up to this point in time. So I 214 00:18:47,001 --> 00:18:53,000 think that probably converges with the first instance that you're referring to, which is 215 00:18:53,001 --> 00:18:58,000 perhaps the swaying of elites, the shifting of their perspective, because certainly there is 216 00:18:58,001 --> 00:19:03,000 this idea that the more people that are activated, that see things for what 217 00:19:03,001 --> 00:19:08,000 they really are, the more potential you have for making change. I would also 218 00:19:08,001 --> 00:19:13,000 say that in my writing, and just in general in my journalistic career, I've 219 00:19:13,001 --> 00:19:18,000 been very influenced by the Palestinian journalist Ramzy Baroud, who himself is also very 220 00:19:18,001 --> 00:19:23,000 much a Gramscian and has an important book, I believe, called These Chains Will 221 00:19:23,001 --> 00:19:29,000 Be Broken that's about Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails. And he talks about these 222 00:19:29,001 --> 00:19:34,000 prisoners as Palestine's organic intellectuals. So that's referring to another Gramscian concept of the 223 00:19:34,001 --> 00:19:39,000 organic intellectual, somebody who emerges from particular situations to become the kind of spontaneous, 224 00:19:39,001 --> 00:19:44,000 embodied intellectual that represents a particular form, form of dispossession within a particular social 225 00:19:44,001 --> 00:19:49,000 context. So in this case, Baroud talking about Palestinian Prisoners as the organic intellectuals 226 00:19:49,001 --> 00:19:54,000 of Palestinian struggle. That kind of gets me to the second point, which is 227 00:19:54,001 --> 00:19:59,000 that Palestinians as a colonized and occupied people are engaged in multiple forms of 228 00:19:59,001 --> 00:20:05,000 resistance, all of them legitimate, because again, this is an anti-colonial struggle. 229 00:20:05,001 --> 00:20:06,000 Steve Grumbine: Sure. 230 00:20:06,001 --> 00:20:11,000 Omar Zahzah: So there are some who are engaged in revolutionary military, anti-colonial struggle, and then 231 00:20:11,001 --> 00:20:16,000 there's the grassroots and different activists all over the world, Palestinian journalists. So it's 232 00:20:16,001 --> 00:20:21,000 working on all multiple aspects of kind of cultural agitation. So I do think 233 00:20:21,001 --> 00:20:27,000 that obviously there is a direct revolutionary component to it as well, but I 234 00:20:27,001 --> 00:20:32,000 think we need to understand it in the multiple senses precisely because we have 235 00:20:32,001 --> 00:20:37,000 a full and diverse array of Palestinian cultural resistance that is being practiced and 236 00:20:37,001 --> 00:20:43,000 all of it to advance the ultimate goal of Palestinian liberation. 237 00:20:43,001 --> 00:20:48,000 Steve Grumbine: Thank you for that. It was excellent. Very well stated. You talk about breeding trolls 238 00:20:48,001 --> 00:20:53,000 for the startup colony, and we have a person on our team who was raised 239 00:20:53,001 --> 00:20:58,000 up in the Hasbara. You know, it really was put through the kibbutz and through 240 00:20:58,001 --> 00:21:03,000 all the other things that trained him up to be kind of in that space. 241 00:21:03,001 --> 00:21:08,000 And then he broke free and now he's an advocate. His name's Jonathan Kadman. He's 242 00:21:08,001 --> 00:21:13,000 one of the people on our team here at Real Progressives and works on this 243 00:21:13,001 --> 00:21:18,000 podcast, Macro N Cheese with us as well. It just sort of was a shocker 244 00:21:18,001 --> 00:21:23,000 to me, even though I knew some of this stuff. It was just really shocking 245 00:21:23,001 --> 00:21:28,000 the level of depth that they go with this kind of approach to, I don't 246 00:21:28,001 --> 00:21:33,000 know, brainwashing, creating a narrative, if you will, that suits Israel, suits the Zionist project. 247 00:21:33,001 --> 00:21:38,000 And it always brings to mind the concept of counter revolution. People always wonder why 248 00:21:38,001 --> 00:21:43,000 revolutions end up violent. Why? "Oh, you know, when this guy took over, it was 249 00:21:43,001 --> 00:21:48,000 like totalitarian," or it was this or it was that. But they never go back 250 00:21:48,001 --> 00:21:53,000 to. To understand what a counter-revolutionary force does and how it rips apart the gains 251 00:21:53,001 --> 00:21:58,000 of the revolution, so to speak. And in this case, you watch the Palestinians and 252 00:21:58,001 --> 00:22:03,000 the activists that are fighting to bring awareness to this using TikTok and other things. 253 00:22:03,001 --> 00:22:08,000 And lo and behold, the hegemon, the counter revolution, kicks in. The monarchist, it's a 254 00:22:08,001 --> 00:22:13,000 bad term, but you get the gist. They decide, okay, let's use our power within 255 00:22:13,001 --> 00:22:18,000 the kind of blending of state and industry with Silicon Valley and these AI firms 256 00:22:18,001 --> 00:22:23,000 and these other Silicon Valley kind of cyber warfare units, and they ratchet up and 257 00:22:23,001 --> 00:22:28,000 now all of a sudden they counter the gains through TikTok and through everything else. 258 00:22:28,001 --> 00:22:33,000 But they use, of course, hegemonic words to make it seem like "We're doing this 259 00:22:33,001 --> 00:22:38,000 to protect the children from really bad actors on TikTok and we're saving us from 260 00:22:38,001 --> 00:22:43,000 China, who's abusing their access and so forth." But they're not really telling the truth 261 00:22:43,001 --> 00:22:48,000 because at the end of the day what they're doing is silencing resistance, silencing struggle. 262 00:22:48,001 --> 00:22:53,000 Trying to put a wet blanket on that. Breeding trolls for the startup colony. I 263 00:22:53,001 --> 00:22:58,000 love that. Cyber warfare in the age of Hasbara 2.0. Can you talk about that? 264 00:22:58,001 --> 00:23:03,000 Omar Zahzah: Thank you so much for that question. So, starting with the title, it was a 265 00:23:03,001 --> 00:23:08,000 little bit of a punny sort of tongue in cheek, but it was a refutation 266 00:23:08,001 --> 00:23:13,000 of one of the big lines of Zionist tech propaganda, which is to think of 267 00:23:13,001 --> 00:23:19,000 Israel as the startup nation. And I talk a little bit about that book, that 268 00:23:19,001 --> 00:23:24,000 so-called study that really is basically just a paean to Israeli tech and startup culture 269 00:23:24,001 --> 00:23:29,000 and basically talking about how its militarism is part of what gives it, you know, 270 00:23:29,001 --> 00:23:34,000 this "innovative capability," like culturally, of course, because it is a work of propaganda. It's 271 00:23:34,001 --> 00:23:40,000 not going to acknowledge that the conditions that it's describing and the things that it's 272 00:23:40,001 --> 00:23:45,000 referring to are all processes of colonization. So I was saying in that chapter, hey, 273 00:23:45,001 --> 00:23:50,000 you know, we're not dealing with a startup nation. Israel's a settler-colonial state. This is 274 00:23:50,001 --> 00:23:55,000 the startup colony. And part of the strategy that this colony uses is to breed 275 00:23:55,001 --> 00:24:01,000 trolls again because we have this adage of, "Don't feed the trolls. Don't engage with 276 00:24:01,001 --> 00:24:06,000 trolling." But trolling is really a top-tier strategy of Zionist cyber warfare. And I talk 277 00:24:06,001 --> 00:24:11,000 about this constant barrage of propaganda as a form of cyber warfare. Hasbara 2.0, you 278 00:24:11,001 --> 00:24:16,000 know, there I pull from the digital anthropologist Miriyam Aouragh, who wrote this essay called 279 00:24:16,001 --> 00:24:22,000 Hasbara 2.0. And basically she was reflecting on what happens when you see, let's say, 280 00:24:22,001 --> 00:24:27,000 the mostly complete capture by Zionism of legacy corporate media narrative. Right? And I say 281 00:24:27,001 --> 00:24:32,000 mostly because she reworks Herman and Chomsky's concept of manufacturing consent a little bit to 282 00:24:32,001 --> 00:24:37,000 say that the very fact that the legacy corporate media is so driven by numbers 283 00:24:37,001 --> 00:24:43,000 is a capitalist venture in and of itself, sometimes predisposes it to platform dissenting views 284 00:24:43,001 --> 00:24:48,000 for the sake of increasing its ratings. So they'll never literally eliminate every dissenting voice 285 00:24:48,001 --> 00:24:53,000 possible, but they can by and large have this capture by Zionist propaganda because this 286 00:24:53,001 --> 00:24:58,000 supports the imperial project. So she talked about Hasbara 2.0 as the continuing attempt to 287 00:24:58,001 --> 00:25:04,000 by Israeli state actors, Zionist forces to maintain the narrative control the generally largely unchallenging 288 00:25:04,001 --> 00:25:09,000 narrative control they saw in legacy corporate media to bring it into the emerging Internet 289 00:25:09,001 --> 00:25:14,000 technological context. So when you start to have the rise of blogging, where it's no 290 00:25:14,001 --> 00:25:19,000 longer, for example, just the news channel, but maybe those reporters start to be able 291 00:25:19,001 --> 00:25:25,000 to have blogs. They can start to report things more in real time. So she 292 00:25:25,001 --> 00:25:30,000 talked about the informational strategies, the propaganda strategies that Zionists use and how they are 293 00:25:30,001 --> 00:25:35,000 specific to the increasingly rising moment of the Internet as we were seeing it at 294 00:25:35,001 --> 00:25:40,000 that point in time. So essentially what I was describing in that chapter is how 295 00:25:40,001 --> 00:25:46,000 we can think about Internet trolling. The direct and intentional encouraging of Zionists, of Israelis, 296 00:25:46,001 --> 00:25:51,000 often of young Israelis, to take to prominent sites to engage in pro-Israel messaging through 297 00:25:51,001 --> 00:25:56,000 institutions like Hasbara Fellowships. These are often paid undertakings. You have the Israeli military itself, 298 00:25:56,001 --> 00:26:01,000 the occupation forces, maintaining various websites engaging in propaganda through their various digital platforms. And 299 00:26:01,001 --> 00:26:07,000 a lot of this also entails putting emphasis on making sure that you have a 300 00:26:07,001 --> 00:26:12,000 large amount of people who are going to sites that are platforming a dissenting view 301 00:26:12,001 --> 00:26:17,000 about the Palestinian struggle and attacking them, essentially delegitimizing them, engaging exactly in the type 302 00:26:17,001 --> 00:26:22,000 of what I would say gaslighting that you were describing earlier. You know, "Israel is 303 00:26:22,001 --> 00:26:28,000 a democracy. Israel was attacked. Israel is a beacon of hope, et cetera, et cetera, 304 00:26:28,001 --> 00:26:33,000 et cetera. This is pro-terrorism, et cetera." And to kind of engage in this, perhaps 305 00:26:33,001 --> 00:26:38,000 you could think of it as a kind of digital war of attrition. Right? [Hmm 306 00:26:38,001 --> 00:26:43,000 mmm] Because there's two things that can happen. Maybe you get somebody to disengage a 307 00:26:43,001 --> 00:26:49,000 little bit or to reconsider. I think that's less likely, especially when you're attacking a 308 00:26:49,001 --> 00:26:54,000 very outspoken prominent voice who's informed on what's happening. But you could potentially scare off 309 00:26:54,001 --> 00:26:59,000 other potential supporters or you could wear those people down. And so one of the 310 00:26:59,001 --> 00:27:04,000 things that we've seen, especially since the start of the latest genocide, and some of 311 00:27:04,001 --> 00:27:10,000 the people I've interviewed in the book have dealt with this at length. They describe 312 00:27:10,001 --> 00:27:15,000 how there's been a real refinement of the ability to create AI bots. And they 313 00:27:15,001 --> 00:27:20,000 took these Palestinian content creators, described how their page would be swarmed with these bots 314 00:27:20,001 --> 00:27:25,000 when they would post anything about the genocide. And they said, it's very clear they 315 00:27:25,001 --> 00:27:31,000 were bots. I mean, this was too coordinated. It was happening too quickly, too fast. 316 00:27:31,001 --> 00:27:36,000 And they're all just almost copy-paste the same type of comment. But they're happening on 317 00:27:36,001 --> 00:27:41,000 such a scale that it's overwhelming. You can't delete all of them. You can't block 318 00:27:41,001 --> 00:27:46,000 every single account. And then you go and look at them and they don't even 319 00:27:46,001 --> 00:27:52,000 seem like they're a real person. But again, there's so many of them. So I 320 00:27:52,001 --> 00:27:57,000 was saying, you know, this is trolling as a strategy for the startup colony. To 321 00:27:57,001 --> 00:28:02,000 what extent is it successful at the literal level of numbers? It's a little bit 322 00:28:02,001 --> 00:28:07,000 hard to say, but it's very clear that it does take a toll and it 323 00:28:07,001 --> 00:28:13,000 does force you expend energy in directions that take away from your ability to continue 324 00:28:13,001 --> 00:28:18,000 to do the type of messaging that you're doing. Or even perhaps it may chip 325 00:28:18,001 --> 00:28:23,000 away a little bit at some of the viewers who may get a little bit 326 00:28:23,001 --> 00:28:28,000 nervous about what's happening. And we've even seen. I believe it's in this chapter that 327 00:28:28,001 --> 00:28:34,000 I talk about, too, how the Israeli government just invested. I forget the exact number, 328 00:28:34,001 --> 00:28:39,000 but it was, I believe, over a hundred million in its Hasbara efforts. Right. Its 329 00:28:39,001 --> 00:28:44,000 propaganda efforts digitally, with a huge emphasis on the Internet. So it's clear that this 330 00:28:44,001 --> 00:28:50,000 isn't going away. It's only escalating. 331 00:28:50,001 --> 00:28:55,000 At the same time, I do think it remains to be seen just how successful those 332 00:28:55,001 --> 00:29:00,000 efforts are really going to be, especially at this moment in time. I feel like sometimes 333 00:29:00,001 --> 00:29:05,000 as, and I just say this as somebody who's been looking at statements over the years 334 00:29:05,001 --> 00:29:10,000 that thinkers have made where, okay, now we've crossed the Rubicon, everybody has seen all there 335 00:29:10,001 --> 00:29:15,000 is to be seen, there's no turning back. And yet you see that the status quo 336 00:29:15,001 --> 00:29:20,000 kind of continues. And yet I still feel like there's just something to this moment. The 337 00:29:20,001 --> 00:29:25,000 genocide is so blatant. The damage, the destruction, the violence, the viciousness, the sadism. It's clear 338 00:29:25,001 --> 00:29:31,000 that there's no rationale other than complete and utter wanton destruction and obliteration of an entire 339 00:29:31,001 --> 00:29:36,000 people. I don't really know how much getting a bunch of people to swarm a Palestinian's 340 00:29:36,001 --> 00:29:41,000 Instagram page is going to change at this point. You can't really take away the fact 341 00:29:41,001 --> 00:29:46,000 that so many of us have seen those images coming out of Gaza. It is important, 342 00:29:46,001 --> 00:29:51,000 I think, to identify trolling as a strategy and also as I talk about in other 343 00:29:51,001 --> 00:29:56,000 chapters, how it's directly practiced by sites like Canary Mission or Stop Antisemitism, these blacklist sites. 344 00:29:56,001 --> 00:30:01,000 But is it really going to convince people that what is happening right now is not 345 00:30:01,001 --> 00:30:06,000 a genocide? And is it really going to be able to shift public perspective back toward 346 00:30:06,001 --> 00:30:12,000 the initial hegemonic, propagandistic view? I'm pretty doubtful of that. 347 00:30:12,001 --> 00:30:17,000 Steve Grumbine: One of the things I can assure you of just having been, you know, 348 00:30:17,001 --> 00:30:22,000 in my own way, deep in fighting to get eyes on the situation, there 349 00:30:22,001 --> 00:30:27,000 is a fatigue that kicks in. There is a there-is-no-hope kind of approach to 350 00:30:27,001 --> 00:30:32,000 things, because every door is locked with a terms of service or locked with 351 00:30:32,001 --> 00:30:38,000 a shadow ban or locked with gatekeepers. And after a little bit of time, 352 00:30:38,001 --> 00:30:43,000 you figure you see all these college students rising up. You see all these 353 00:30:43,001 --> 00:30:48,000 teachers rising up. And then you see teachers simultaneously getting fired, students expelled, and 354 00:30:48,001 --> 00:30:53,000 police, militarized police in the US in particular, washing these people right out of 355 00:30:53,001 --> 00:30:59,000 the picture and making, once again, First Amendment speech illegal because the cry bullying 356 00:30:59,001 --> 00:31:04,000 that goes on in the Zionist project. "No, I don't feel safe." "I don't know 357 00:31:04,001 --> 00:31:09,000 what to tell you there, man. I mean, are you the one that's killing 358 00:31:09,001 --> 00:31:14,000 people? Are you over there pushing people in a direction that causes pain yourself? 359 00:31:14,001 --> 00:31:19,000 Is this a little bit of you telling on yourself here, or is this 360 00:31:19,001 --> 00:31:25,000 just a strategy?" But ultimately, the idea of silencing is real. I know when 361 00:31:25,001 --> 00:31:30,000 we started our Facebook page, we had 125,000 followers. We had 30 million people 362 00:31:30,001 --> 00:31:35,000 come through the door whenever we would put stuff out there, whether it was 363 00:31:35,001 --> 00:31:40,000 live streams or whether it was posts or articles or memes, whatever. And little 364 00:31:40,001 --> 00:31:46,000 by little, Facebook kept hitting us with terms of service violations, and they took 365 00:31:46,001 --> 00:31:51,000 away our nonprofit status in terms of our ability to fundraise on the platform. 366 00:31:51,001 --> 00:31:56,000 And then people just started to say, "Well, it's because, you know, you guys 367 00:31:56,001 --> 00:32:01,000 are too..." You know, they would always come up with some reason why it 368 00:32:01,001 --> 00:32:06,000 was our fault that we were being silenced. And that's just a microcosm of 369 00:32:06,001 --> 00:32:12,000 a larger issue. It really is a tactic in this new connected internet phase, 370 00:32:12,001 --> 00:32:17,000 where social media is used both as a means of collecting information on us, 371 00:32:17,001 --> 00:32:22,000 but also as a means of trying to organize. I'm curious, as you move 372 00:32:22,001 --> 00:32:27,000 forward, how do you see terms of service being used to weaponize against those 373 00:32:27,001 --> 00:32:33,000 voices fighting for Palestinian liberation? 374 00:32:33,001 --> 00:32:38,000 Omar Zahzah: I think you've really hit the nail on the head because terms of service, 375 00:32:38,001 --> 00:32:43,000 or also community standards, which is sort of an affiliated concept, a lot of 376 00:32:43,001 --> 00:32:48,000 these platforms, all these platforms draw particular conditions under which people can use their 377 00:32:48,001 --> 00:32:53,000 products. And these include conditions that you are not allowed to transgress. Although these 378 00:32:53,001 --> 00:32:58,000 are ostensibly free products to use, we know that that's not really the case. 379 00:32:58,001 --> 00:33:03,000 We know all of the data that they collect on us. We know all 380 00:33:03,001 --> 00:33:08,000 of the things we pay for in terms of time, in terms of attention, 381 00:33:08,001 --> 00:33:13,000 in terms of the targeted advertisements that is being served up to us and 382 00:33:13,001 --> 00:33:18,000 the impact that can have. But, you know, ostensibly these are free platforms and 383 00:33:18,001 --> 00:33:23,000 we are allowed to access them according to their terms as private companies by 384 00:33:23,001 --> 00:33:28,000 meeting particular conditions which include how we engage. And so what we're seeing increasingly 385 00:33:28,001 --> 00:33:33,000 is a growing explicitness with which these companies are applying concepts like you described 386 00:33:33,001 --> 00:33:39,000 earlier, like the feelings of safety or the protecting people from harassment or attack, 387 00:33:39,001 --> 00:33:44,000 to inoculate against the possibility of criticism of Zionism, a settler-colonial ideology, a political 388 00:33:44,001 --> 00:33:49,000 ideology being entertained. So one of the things that I wrote about is Meta's 389 00:33:49,001 --> 00:33:54,000 updated guidelines on how it will permit criticism of Zionism to occur on its 390 00:33:54,001 --> 00:33:59,000 platforms.   Now, the ostensible terms of this are, you know, Zionism cannot be 391 00:33:59,001 --> 00:34:04,000 used as a proxy for Jewish people. So you cannot have anti-Semitism, hatred of 392 00:34:04,001 --> 00:34:09,000 Jews, bigotry against Jews, that's fine. But this concept is really being stretched in 393 00:34:09,001 --> 00:34:14,000 a way to where it's patently clear, if you actually look at the literal 394 00:34:14,001 --> 00:34:19,000 level of language, that in a lot of ways it's already accepting this false 395 00:34:19,001 --> 00:34:24,000 conflation of anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism. Meta is a prominent company, prominent big tech company. 396 00:34:24,001 --> 00:34:29,000 It's a giant. And the fact that it came out with these guidelines, one 397 00:34:29,001 --> 00:34:34,000 of the things I write about is, I believe the phrasing is "denial of 398 00:34:34,001 --> 00:34:39,000 right to exist." I need to look at the exact wording. But it did 399 00:34:39,001 --> 00:34:45,000 have something against right to exist, which ultimately refers to this point about, you 400 00:34:45,001 --> 00:34:50,000 know, Israel's so-called right to exist. And so you can't even access this platform 401 00:34:50,001 --> 00:34:55,000 unless you tacitly agree to this rhetorical trap, this false construction that talks about 402 00:34:55,001 --> 00:35:00,000 the right of a settler-colonial state to exist, which is bizarre. That's completely outlandish. 403 00:35:00,001 --> 00:35:05,000 It's bizarre, but it's not totally surprising because, you know, again, we've seen Big 404 00:35:05,001 --> 00:35:10,000 Tech as an industry increasingly lean into the normalization of Zionism and the suppression 405 00:35:10,001 --> 00:35:15,000 of Palestinian voices. And after this happened, I also wrote about how later on 406 00:35:15,001 --> 00:35:20,000 you had the game streaming platform Twitch also published their own policy regarding the 407 00:35:20,001 --> 00:35:25,000 criticism of Zionism on their platform, which is, if you have the misfortune of 408 00:35:25,001 --> 00:35:30,000 sitting down to read it, you know, I feel like I should buy you 409 00:35:30,001 --> 00:35:35,000 some Tylenol or something because it's just so mealy mouth[ed]. It's so contradictory. But 410 00:35:35,001 --> 00:35:40,000 ultimately what the impact of even these convoluted expressions do is to create a 411 00:35:40,001 --> 00:35:45,000 sense of anxiety or discomfort. Okay, maybe this is a little too complicated. Maybe 412 00:35:45,001 --> 00:35:51,000 I shouldn't be wading into it, right? So these terms of servitude or these 413 00:35:51,001 --> 00:35:56,000 community standards, particularly when they're applied in this deceptive way that is meant to 414 00:35:56,001 --> 00:36:01,000 gently condition us toward a particular political direction or away from a particular political 415 00:36:01,001 --> 00:36:06,000 direction, they do have an impact on our sense of political understanding and our 416 00:36:06,001 --> 00:36:11,000 sense of the actual political status quo. So that's why I was also interested, 417 00:36:11,001 --> 00:36:16,000 in the book, and looking at academics who had thought about content moderation not 418 00:36:16,001 --> 00:36:21,000 just as literal removal of posts, but also as something that has a direct 419 00:36:21,001 --> 00:36:26,000 tie to the way that we engage in and practice discourse. You know, in 420 00:36:26,001 --> 00:36:31,000 the so-called real world or the offline world. These things can have larger impacts 421 00:36:31,001 --> 00:36:36,000 than just the specific usage of the platform. Even though in the specific usage 422 00:36:36,001 --> 00:36:41,000 of the platform we're already seeing this creep of the acceptance of the relative 423 00:36:41,001 --> 00:36:46,000 impunity of the settler-colonial state and the inability to criticize its conduct, or else 424 00:36:46,001 --> 00:36:51,000 as Zionist rhetorical tactics practiced for years before this. You know, we're going to 425 00:36:51,001 --> 00:36:57,000 be accused with weaponized accusations of things like harassment, even discrimination, when the irony 426 00:36:57,001 --> 00:37:02,000 being that we are the ones calling out discrimination and oppression and racism in 427 00:37:02,001 --> 00:37:07,000 the first place. We're having the logics of anti-racism, of protecting marginalized communities be 428 00:37:07,001 --> 00:37:12,000 weaponized precisely to work in the service of racism and marginalization. And I will 429 00:37:12,001 --> 00:37:17,000 just say that's, I think to me, really part of the insidiousness of the 430 00:37:17,001 --> 00:37:22,000 Zionist project in general and how it's been able to weaponize various cultural aspects 431 00:37:22,001 --> 00:37:27,000 of our engagement with social justice struggles. It's a tendency that has pre-dated the 432 00:37:27,001 --> 00:37:32,000 digital sphere. And so it should, I guess, be no surprise that it has 433 00:37:32,001 --> 00:37:37,000 now infiltrated the digital sphere so effectively. But it has done so also at 434 00:37:37,001 --> 00:37:42,000 the discretion of corporate elites who want to protect their bottom line above all 435 00:37:42,001 --> 00:37:47,000 else and who have made the conscious choice. This gets into my usage of 436 00:37:47,001 --> 00:37:52,000 the term digital settler colonialism. Part of what I emphasize is that we need 437 00:37:52,001 --> 00:37:57,000 to see this as the constant, as the explicit and direct choice of the 438 00:37:57,001 --> 00:38:03,000 big tech oligarchs to partner with a project of settler colonialism, dispossession and genocide. 439 00:38:03,001 --> 00:38:08,000 Steve Grumbine: Each accusation is basically a confession, isn't it? I hate to bring up Orwell. 440 00:38:08,001 --> 00:38:13,000 It's so easy and low-hanging fruit and I'm not going to use the book 441 00:38:13,001 --> 00:38:18,000 here. I'll use the movie. When they're burning pieces of news or burning old 442 00:38:18,001 --> 00:38:23,000 thoughts that they're trying to erase from the current narrative so that you can't 443 00:38:23,001 --> 00:38:28,000 go back and you're destroying history. You're rewriting history. You're rewriting words. You're eliminating 444 00:38:28,001 --> 00:38:33,000 words. And it goes back to your "Hey, you know this one Palestinian reporter 445 00:38:33,001 --> 00:38:38,000 I was following suddenly been silent for a couple months. Wonder if he's alive 446 00:38:38,001 --> 00:38:43,000 anymore?" And most people don't have the brain space to be able to hold 447 00:38:43,001 --> 00:38:48,000 that. And it's just gone. It just doesn't exist anymore. And you have no 448 00:38:48,001 --> 00:38:54,000 breadcrumb trail how to find back to where you were. And a lot of 449 00:38:54,001 --> 00:38:59,000 just erasing. And we talked about kind of erasing the Palestinian history. I mean, 450 00:38:59,001 --> 00:39:04,000 we've talked about it many times how the bombing of birth records, you name 451 00:39:04,001 --> 00:39:09,000 it, has basically sought to erase the Palestinian people altogether. But I want to 452 00:39:09,001 --> 00:39:14,000 kind of lump that concept in of erasing Palestine, which is another one of 453 00:39:14,001 --> 00:39:19,000 your well-written chapters, to kind of go in with another component here. I want 454 00:39:19,001 --> 00:39:24,000 to blend these two thoughts together. And that's the TikTok ban that you talk 455 00:39:24,001 --> 00:39:29,000 about later in the book. Because I want to bring Gramsci back, that kind 456 00:39:29,001 --> 00:39:34,000 of crisis of hegemony. He spoke very, very eloquently about the crisis of hegemony. 457 00:39:34,001 --> 00:39:40,000 And this is kind of what happens when the hegemon feels like their power 458 00:39:40,001 --> 00:39:45,000 over the narrative is loosening. And so what do they do? They use fascism. 459 00:39:45,001 --> 00:39:50,000 They bring fascism's tactic. They bring fascism into the mix here. Relating the TikTok 460 00:39:50,001 --> 00:39:55,000 ban, as you decry "US imperial anxiety here," right? That right there speaks to 461 00:39:55,001 --> 00:40:00,000 hegemonic crisis and the crisis of hegemony. And it also some of those Orwellian 462 00:40:00,001 --> 00:40:05,000 themes where they're basically erasing the people. They're trying to gain control of the 463 00:40:05,001 --> 00:40:10,000 platforms. That's a lot there, but I think there's meat on the bone. What 464 00:40:10,001 --> 00:40:15,000 are your thoughts as it pertains to that crisis of hegemony and the tactics 465 00:40:15,001 --> 00:40:20,000 they use to play with the TikTok ban and sell it to these Zionist 466 00:40:20,001 --> 00:40:26,000 oligarchs and so forth? I would just love to hear your insights. 467 00:40:26,001 --> 00:40:31,000 Omar Zahzah: We're in a moment where so many things are being besieged. But I also think 468 00:40:31,001 --> 00:40:36,000 one of the fascinating things about this moment is precisely that we are kind of 469 00:40:36,001 --> 00:40:41,000 getting a peek behind the curtain into how hegemony works, precisely because it is not 470 00:40:41,001 --> 00:40:46,000 working in certain spaces where there had been the expectation that it would. I mean, 471 00:40:46,001 --> 00:40:51,000 the TikTok ban really emerges within a broader context of politicians raising an uproar about 472 00:40:51,001 --> 00:40:56,000 the fact that the youth, you know, younger people, are getting exposed to or even 473 00:40:56,001 --> 00:41:01,000 creating content of their own that is critical of the hegemonic Zionist narrative. And they're 474 00:41:01,001 --> 00:41:06,000 so concerned with the fact that this is happening that they're calling for bans of 475 00:41:06,001 --> 00:41:11,000 the platform. And this directly, of course, converges with the broader US imperial competition with 476 00:41:11,001 --> 00:41:16,000 China, which is emerging as a powerful rival. And of course, part of the terms 477 00:41:16,001 --> 00:41:21,000 of the ban to sell to an American company, of course, that's just literally the 478 00:41:21,001 --> 00:41:27,000 consolidation of platform capitalism, right? 479 00:41:27,001 --> 00:41:28,000 Steve Grumbine: Yes. 480 00:41:28,001 --> 00:41:33,000 Omar Zahzah: That's a different aspect of digital colonialism altogether. We need to be the hegemon digitally. 481 00:41:33,001 --> 00:41:38,000 So I find that so fascinating, very telling. And you know, of course you had 482 00:41:38,001 --> 00:41:43,000 things like Greenblatt from the ADL saying, "We have a TikTok problem. We need to 483 00:41:43,001 --> 00:41:48,000 get our best minds, you know, to work countering this slew of messaging that the 484 00:41:48,001 --> 00:41:53,000 youth are increasingly seeing and creating." So I definitely think it's a really fascinating real 485 00:41:53,001 --> 00:41:58,000 time peek behind the curtain about how hegemony is supposed to work and what happens 486 00:41:58,001 --> 00:42:03,000 when it starts to fail. What do you do? You resort to measures like this. 487 00:42:03,001 --> 00:42:08,000 "We're going to ban the platform. We're going to have it sell to an American 488 00:42:08,001 --> 00:42:13,000 company. We are going to appoint more people affiliated with the Israeli project to moderate." 489 00:42:13,001 --> 00:42:18,000 And this is of course also part and parcel of the broader dynamic that I 490 00:42:18,001 --> 00:42:23,000 refer to as "erasing Palestine" in the chapter that you mentioned. And what I meant 491 00:42:23,001 --> 00:42:28,000 by that is that it's not just Palestinians and Palestinian voices and perspectives that are 492 00:42:28,001 --> 00:42:33,000 erased. It's the very concept or the idea of something called Palestine that gives all 493 00:42:33,001 --> 00:42:38,000 of us, all of those people, something that binds us. This idea of a homeland, 494 00:42:38,001 --> 00:42:43,000 this idea of being engaged in an anti-colonial struggle for a homeland that eventually will 495 00:42:43,001 --> 00:42:48,000 be liberated, part of the broader project is to erase the very existence of that 496 00:42:48,001 --> 00:42:53,000 idea as well as to erase as many Palestinian voices, records and perspectives as possible. 497 00:42:53,001 --> 00:42:58,000 So what I was arguing is that in the digital sphere, in the same way 498 00:42:58,001 --> 00:43:03,000 that settler colonialism in other physical context has meant the destruction of universities, the bombing 499 00:43:03,001 --> 00:43:08,000 of libraries, the assassination of intellectuals and scholars, all of that, the digital sphere also 500 00:43:08,001 --> 00:43:13,000 needs to undergo a total erasure of anything related to Palestine, not just because of 501 00:43:13,001 --> 00:43:18,000 the holding of Palestinian identity, but because of the presentation of this broader anti-colonial ideal 502 00:43:18,001 --> 00:43:22,000 that binds an indigenous people in resistance together. The point is to expunge that completely 503 00:43:22,001 --> 00:43:28,000 from all platforms that's the process that I was referring to as "erasing Palestine." The 504 00:43:28,001 --> 00:43:33,000 TikTok ban, I think, is a really good example of the powers that be mobilizing 505 00:43:33,001 --> 00:43:38,000 in real time to make sure that happens. And we're getting such an interesting view 506 00:43:38,001 --> 00:43:43,000 into it precisely because we don't get to see behind the curtain quite as much 507 00:43:43,001 --> 00:43:48,000 as we have now. Whenever I talk about this, I always think it's really important 508 00:43:48,001 --> 00:43:53,000 to reaffirm that this total erasure is never really going to be possible. They can 509 00:43:53,001 --> 00:43:58,000 ban an app. They can ban a platform. The organizers, dissenters are always going to 510 00:43:58,001 --> 00:44:03,000 find a new means of re-appropriating a particular form of media to advance a narrative 511 00:44:03,001 --> 00:44:08,000 of dissent. I mean, the very fact that 2021 played out in the way that 512 00:44:08,001 --> 00:44:13,000 it did is a testament to that. And that was at a slightly different moment 513 00:44:13,001 --> 00:44:18,000 of the broader hegemony that social media held on our cultural understanding of the world 514 00:44:18,001 --> 00:44:23,000 around us. And now we're seeing a different kind of timbre and character to big 515 00:44:23,001 --> 00:44:28,000 tech social media as an industry under the current administration that we have. But nevertheless, 516 00:44:28,001 --> 00:44:33,000 Palestinians were able to do it before and to do it brilliantly and to do 517 00:44:33,001 --> 00:44:38,000 it in such a way that it had real impact. They're continuing to do it 518 00:44:38,001 --> 00:44:43,000 now, even in spite of all of this opposition. So erasing Palestine is never going 519 00:44:43,001 --> 00:44:48,000 to be a complete fait accompli, even as there's going to be a lot of 520 00:44:48,001 --> 00:44:53,000 gains in terms of the ability of the powers that be to do that. They 521 00:44:53,001 --> 00:44:58,000 will not be able to quell resistance and the savvy, creative insurgency of Palestinians engaged 522 00:44:58,001 --> 00:45:03,000 in narrative resistance. 523 00:45:03,001 --> 00:45:08,000 Steve Grumbine: Yeah, very well stated.  Omar, I want to lead us to the end here, 524 00:45:08,001 --> 00:45:13,000 and I want to make a couple statements and I want to let you 525 00:45:13,001 --> 00:45:18,000 have the last word, but one of the things that I have also been 526 00:45:18,001 --> 00:45:23,000 focused on this podcast is the lack of real democracy in the world, quite 527 00:45:23,001 --> 00:45:28,000 frankly. But in the US in particular, in the US being an empire, its 528 00:45:28,001 --> 00:45:33,000 lack of democracy has a broader impact, a broader footprint on the world as 529 00:45:33,001 --> 00:45:38,000 a whole, in that the people that live here, they may get a black 530 00:45:38,001 --> 00:45:43,000 eye for the people that are in power. But the more you dig into 531 00:45:43,001 --> 00:45:49,000 the US democracy, the less it looks like a democracy and the more you 532 00:45:49,001 --> 00:45:54,000 realize that it's not a democracy at all. Gilens and Page study came out 533 00:45:54,001 --> 00:45:59,000 back in 2014 from Princeton showed quite frankly that voter populist ideas have a 534 00:45:59,001 --> 00:46:04,000 "near zero impact" on public policy in any way, shape or form. We can 535 00:46:04,001 --> 00:46:09,000 see that those of us have eyes to see that are not trapped in 536 00:46:09,001 --> 00:46:14,000 the Matrix can clearly see that we can't vote our way out of this. 537 00:46:14,001 --> 00:46:19,000 If we could have all the students around the country protesting to end a 538 00:46:19,001 --> 00:46:24,000 genocide or end funding of a genocide, or end the kind of censorship that 539 00:46:24,001 --> 00:46:29,000 is occurring, it would be gone by now. But alas, that's just not happening. 540 00:46:29,001 --> 00:46:35,000 There are powerful interests at play that dwarf and trump any other ideas or 541 00:46:35,001 --> 00:46:40,000 hopes and aspirations. And people keep pouring themselves into what I believe is a 542 00:46:40,001 --> 00:46:45,000 tool for manufacturing consent for manufacturing and maintaining that hegemonic control. People have convinced 543 00:46:45,001 --> 00:46:50,000 themselves, because that's the way hegemony works, that this is their own ideas, that 544 00:46:50,001 --> 00:46:55,000 they are the masters of their universe, failing to understand the impact of these 545 00:46:55,001 --> 00:47:00,000 tools and these apparatus. I don't even know the right way of framing that. 546 00:47:00,001 --> 00:47:05,000 But the tools of hegemony that keep folks in control.  How do you envision 547 00:47:05,001 --> 00:47:10,000 real, meaningful winning of this? I mean, these are resistance without necessarily a goal 548 00:47:10,001 --> 00:47:15,000 of victory. They're resistance because what else are you going to do? You have 549 00:47:15,001 --> 00:47:21,000 to resist. But I'm curious, what do you think defines victory in this space? 550 00:47:21,001 --> 00:47:24,000 Omar Zahzah: Wow, that's a great question. A lot to work with there. 551 00:47:24,001 --> 00:47:26,000 Steve Grumbine: Sorry about that. It's my MO. 552 00:47:26,001 --> 00:47:30,000 Omar Zahzah: No, no, yeah, no, no worries. I think first and foremost, the ultimate real goal has 553 00:47:30,001 --> 00:47:35,000 to be the total liberation of Palestine from the river to the sea, the full right 554 00:47:35,001 --> 00:47:40,000 of return of all Palestinians. I mean, the end of the genocide, all of that. The 555 00:47:40,001 --> 00:47:45,000 end of the latest genocide, I should say, because, you know, the Israeli state was forged 556 00:47:45,001 --> 00:47:50,000 and maintained through genocide. I think that needs to be thought of as the ultimate goal 557 00:47:50,001 --> 00:47:55,000 in terms of thinking about the Palestinian struggle. As far as the broader political narrative battles, 558 00:47:55,001 --> 00:48:00,000 I don't know if I can speak to what a total victory would look like within 559 00:48:00,001 --> 00:48:05,000 that context, but it certainly has to mean the ability for shifts in consciousness to realize 560 00:48:05,001 --> 00:48:10,000 meaningful consequences in terms of action. We don't just need to raise people's consciousness. We also 561 00:48:10,001 --> 00:48:15,000 need to make sure that shift in consciousness leads to real consequences in terms of action 562 00:48:15,001 --> 00:48:20,000 that go beyond-I don't know if I should call it the voting trap-but let's say, like 563 00:48:20,001 --> 00:48:25,000 the kind of the voting bubble that I think you were describing, where it's just a 564 00:48:25,001 --> 00:48:30,000 matter of, "Let's get the right people in office and then everything will be better." Because 565 00:48:30,001 --> 00:48:35,000 we've seen time and time again that investment in Palestinian death and dispossession is very much 566 00:48:35,001 --> 00:48:40,000 a bipartisan product. It is baked into the US imperial project, and it is therefore baked 567 00:48:40,001 --> 00:48:45,000 into the very character of US electoral politics as we know it. The idea that we 568 00:48:45,001 --> 00:48:50,000 simply vote in the right person and, you know, that's where we have to hang our 569 00:48:50,001 --> 00:48:55,000 hats in terms of the ultimate outcome, I think is completely misguided for that reason. What 570 00:48:55,001 --> 00:49:00,000 we need to do is continue to make sure that we are advancing narrative shifts and 571 00:49:00,001 --> 00:49:05,000 also engaging in meaningful organizing and activism of all forms that shut down business as usual 572 00:49:05,001 --> 00:49:10,000 and really force people to take account of what is happening. And that forces politicians to 573 00:49:10,001 --> 00:49:15,000 use the power that they do have to actually dissent in meaningful ways and not just 574 00:49:15,001 --> 00:49:20,000 give us mealy-mouthed PR statements that don't say anything while using far too many words and 575 00:49:20,001 --> 00:49:25,000 make us feel better about ourselves. I know that's not a specific, explicit outcome in terms 576 00:49:25,001 --> 00:49:30,000 of victory, which I think you were asking, but I definitely think that we need to 577 00:49:30,001 --> 00:49:35,000 not lose sight of the fact that all of these shifts in consciousness that are made 578 00:49:35,001 --> 00:49:40,000 possible and facilitated by the savvy re-appropriation of digital technologies, we need to continue to make 579 00:49:40,001 --> 00:49:45,000 sure that they are translated into meaningful action and consequences that forces the powers that be 580 00:49:45,001 --> 00:49:50,000 to take note and act accordingly. The only power we really have is people power. And 581 00:49:50,001 --> 00:49:55,000 so long as we continue to surrender that to this empty hope that one politician within 582 00:49:55,001 --> 00:50:00,000 this inherently corrupt system is going to come around and change things, I think the more 583 00:50:00,001 --> 00:50:05,000 we continue to sell ourselves short and to shortchange the Palestinian struggle for freedom, justice and 584 00:50:05,001 --> 00:50:10,000 liberation. 585 00:50:10,001 --> 00:50:14,000 Steve Grumbine: Yeah, you know, I don't want to expand this beyond the scope, but let's 586 00:50:14,001 --> 00:50:19,000 just be fair. We all are oppressed. We all, as working people, are oppressed. 587 00:50:19,001 --> 00:50:24,000 We all are alienated from our work, alienated from the fulfillment of all that 588 00:50:24,001 --> 00:50:29,000 we could be as people, as cultures, as families, as communes, if you will, 589 00:50:29,001 --> 00:50:34,000 affinity groups, et cetera, we're all oppressed. But when you see the major oppression 590 00:50:34,001 --> 00:50:39,000 that you see the systematic erasure and the genocide occurring in various places, I 591 00:50:39,001 --> 00:50:44,000 mean, it's happening in Africa as well. But these are all parts of colonialism, 592 00:50:44,001 --> 00:50:49,000 imperialism, of capitalism, of hegemonic elitism, the elite capture of society. For me, I 593 00:50:49,001 --> 00:50:54,000 just... I guess I don't know how to hit the alarm clock to wake 594 00:50:54,001 --> 00:50:59,000 [up.] I mean, I'm sure there's many areas that my alarm clock needs to 595 00:50:59,001 --> 00:51:04,000 still go off on. Like, I don't think anyone has a total awareness of 596 00:51:04,001 --> 00:51:09,000 everything. They'd be some superhuman, some God, if you will. But how do we 597 00:51:09,001 --> 00:51:14,000 make people wake up and realize that while they're partaking in these things and 598 00:51:14,001 --> 00:51:19,000 they're enjoying these things, then in reality, even though they're one step above the 599 00:51:19,001 --> 00:51:24,000 pig slop, they are still amongst the pig slop. You know, they are not 600 00:51:24,001 --> 00:51:29,000 out of harm's way. I just can't express this deeply enough that just because 601 00:51:29,001 --> 00:51:34,000 you see slaughter going on over there doesn't mean that you're not an eighth 602 00:51:34,001 --> 00:51:39,000 of an inch away from a police state slaughtering you for different reasons. Like, 603 00:51:39,001 --> 00:51:44,000 they came for this group first and I didn't say anything. They came for 604 00:51:44,001 --> 00:51:49,000 this group, I didn't say anything. And then finally they came for me and 605 00:51:49,001 --> 00:51:54,000 there was no one there to help me. How do we make people realize 606 00:51:54,001 --> 00:51:59,000 this isn't just a Palestinian struggle, this is a struggle for all of us? 607 00:51:59,001 --> 00:52:04,000 Omar Zahzah: That's a great question. I think it ultimately comes down to understanding that the 608 00:52:04,001 --> 00:52:09,000 US support of the Israeli project, precisely as you're saying, it's not just about 609 00:52:09,001 --> 00:52:14,000 what happens to Palestinians in Palestine, right? If you think back to the words 610 00:52:14,001 --> 00:52:19,000 of the great anti-colonial writer/thinker Aime Cesaire, right? He talked about the imperial boomerang. 611 00:52:19,001 --> 00:52:24,000 The violence that you see practiced by Europe in terms of other continents across 612 00:52:24,001 --> 00:52:29,000 the globe comes back home. And of course, in that text, discourse on colonialism, 613 00:52:29,001 --> 00:52:35,000 Cesaire also makes clear how the endpoint of capitalism is fascism, because you have 614 00:52:35,001 --> 00:52:40,000 this process of inherent exploitation and oppression that necessitates the exploitation of large swaths 615 00:52:40,001 --> 00:52:45,000 of people and the incentivization of that exploitation and oppression. I think part of 616 00:52:45,001 --> 00:52:50,000 what has to happen, and it's not just a matter of individuals doing something 617 00:52:50,001 --> 00:52:55,000 in terms of pointing it out to other people, it's also, I think, incumbent 618 00:52:55,001 --> 00:53:00,000 upon all of us to continue to ask ourselves, "What are the real connections 619 00:53:00,001 --> 00:53:05,000 we can draw between what's happening to Palestinians and what is happening right here 620 00:53:05,001 --> 00:53:11,000 at home?" And I think, as you're saying, we're all oppressed and exploited in 621 00:53:11,001 --> 00:53:16,000 some way, of course, to differing degrees. But largely speaking, we exist in a 622 00:53:16,001 --> 00:53:21,000 capitalist society. We exist within an inherently violent imperialist political status quo. And we 623 00:53:21,001 --> 00:53:26,000 can think about things like one of the frameworks that organizers will often use 624 00:53:26,001 --> 00:53:31,000 is, "Let's think about how many billions of dollars we're giving to this settler 625 00:53:31,001 --> 00:53:36,000 colony to engage in its processes of colonization, apartheid and genocide, while, you know, 626 00:53:36,001 --> 00:53:41,000 we struggle to make rent while we face all of this medical inequalities," so 627 00:53:41,001 --> 00:53:47,000 on and so forth. So one aspect is to think about how do we 628 00:53:47,001 --> 00:53:52,000 redirect some of that because... And think about the development of community empowerment as 629 00:53:52,001 --> 00:53:57,000 opposed to the incentivization of imperial exploitation getting us to actually rally around that 630 00:53:57,001 --> 00:54:02,000 and fight for that. But secondly, to also understand how violence against Palestinians is 631 00:54:02,001 --> 00:54:07,000 inherently an act of violence against all of humanity, not just because it corrodes 632 00:54:07,001 --> 00:54:12,000 the possibility of a truly collective sense of justice, but also on a very 633 00:54:12,001 --> 00:54:17,000 practical level, because we are seeing the great damage that it wreaks upon our 634 00:54:17,001 --> 00:54:23,000 already compromised political state of affairs. Right? I'm thinking, for example, of the deportation 635 00:54:23,001 --> 00:54:28,000 of people for their views on Palestine. You know, the kidnapping of them by 636 00:54:28,001 --> 00:54:33,000 the Gestapo, the re-attempted deportation of people, you know, outspoken activists for Palestinian freedom, 637 00:54:33,001 --> 00:54:38,000 for example, Mahmoud Khalil, like all of those things are having direct impacts on 638 00:54:38,001 --> 00:54:43,000 us, on our ability to exist with a relative measure of so-called protection of 639 00:54:43,001 --> 00:54:48,000 speech, even as we know we've never fully had that and we don't exist 640 00:54:48,001 --> 00:54:53,000 in a just system or full democracy as propaganda is, want to have us 641 00:54:53,001 --> 00:54:59,000 believe we're seeing even more of a crackdown at this moment than what we 642 00:54:59,001 --> 00:55:04,000 have seen periodically throughout history happen. So I think one way is also to 643 00:55:04,001 --> 00:55:09,000 think about how the unjust and inherent violence that is inflicted upon Palestinians by 644 00:55:09,001 --> 00:55:14,000 Israel, the toll that takes to maintain in order to continue to ensure the 645 00:55:14,001 --> 00:55:19,000 US's hegemony at all costs, is inherently something that is going to continue to 646 00:55:19,001 --> 00:55:24,000 have devastating impacts upon all of us. And so we need to challenge the 647 00:55:24,001 --> 00:55:29,000 Israeli project for first and foremost what it is doing to Palestinians. But we 648 00:55:29,001 --> 00:55:35,000 also need to understand that there is no bottom to what the defense of 649 00:55:35,001 --> 00:55:40,000 settler colonialism, apartheid and genocide will resort to in order to defend itself. And 650 00:55:40,001 --> 00:55:45,000 the complete aiding and abetting of this settler colony that has become really the 651 00:55:45,001 --> 00:55:50,000 core of US electoral politics and politics as we know it. We're seeing the 652 00:55:50,001 --> 00:55:55,000 extremes that desperation can lead to. We need to fight back because if we 653 00:55:55,001 --> 00:56:00,000 don't really, in many ways all of us are going to be implicated in 654 00:56:00,001 --> 00:56:05,000 the aftermath that will necessarily entail the increasing corrosion of rights and freedoms. So 655 00:56:05,001 --> 00:56:11,000 it really is something we need to fight back on. 656 00:56:11,001 --> 00:56:15,000 Steve Grumbine: That's wonderful. And on that happy note, believe me, that was fantastic and 657 00:56:15,001 --> 00:56:20,000 well stated. I'm going to go ahead and close this out, folks. The 658 00:56:20,001 --> 00:56:24,000 book we're talking about today is Terms of Servitude: Zionism, Silicon Valley, and 659 00:56:24,001 --> 00:56:29,000 Digital Settler Colonialism in the Palestinian Liberation Struggle by Omar Zahzah, my guest. 660 00:56:29,001 --> 00:56:34,000 Omar. Where can we find more of your work? 661 00:56:34,001 --> 00:56:38,000 Omar Zahzah: So I would say I have accounts on the usual social media platforms. I'm on 662 00:56:38,001 --> 00:56:43,000 X, Dr. Omar Zahzah. I'm on Facebook and Instagram. Omar Zahzah. I have a Bluesky 663 00:56:43,001 --> 00:56:48,000 account. I believe it's also Dr. Omar Zahzah. Haven't really gotten it up and running 664 00:56:48,001 --> 00:56:53,000 very much yet I mostly use these outlets to more so to find information and 665 00:56:53,001 --> 00:56:57,000 consume news, you know as much as they will allow news at times. So I 666 00:56:57,001 --> 00:57:02,000 would say really the best place to keep a lookout for my work is to 667 00:57:02,001 --> 00:57:07,000 go to sites like the Electronic Intifada or Mondoweiss or Palestine Chronicle where my new writing usually 668 00:57:07,001 --> 00:57:12,000 appears. And of course to follow if you don't already Project Censored, where I will 669 00:57:12,001 --> 00:57:17,000 occasionally also have new media appear from. 670 00:57:17,001 --> 00:57:22,000 Steve Grumbine: Fantastic. All right, my name is Steve Grumbine. I am the host of 671 00:57:22,001 --> 00:57:27,000 Macro N Cheese and the founder of the nonprofit Real Progressives which sponsors 672 00:57:27,001 --> 00:57:32,000 this podcast. We are a 501[c]3 not for profit organization and we live 673 00:57:32,001 --> 00:57:37,000 and die on your contributions. If you feel the work that we're doing 674 00:57:37,001 --> 00:57:42,000 is worth your time and you feel it deserves to be supported, we 675 00:57:42,001 --> 00:57:47,000 welcome your support. You can find us at patreon.com/real progressives. You can go 676 00:57:47,001 --> 00:57:52,000 on Substack and follow us on Substack, which is substack.com/realprogressives. You can donate 677 00:57:52,001 --> 00:57:57,000 to us there as well. Plus you can go to our website realprogressives.org, 678 00:57:57,001 --> 00:58:02,000 go to the dropdown menu for donate and become a monthly donor there 679 00:58:02,001 --> 00:58:07,000 as well. There's no amount too small, no amount too great, and quite 680 00:58:07,001 --> 00:58:11,000 frankly it is tax deductible. So this time of the year, people looking 681 00:58:11,001 --> 00:58:17,000 for tax deductions, we're happy to take advantage of that. If you're interested 682 00:58:17,001 --> 00:58:22,000 in supporting us, we welcome your support. So on behalf of my guest 683 00:58:22,001 --> 00:58:27,000 Omar Zahzah, myself Steve Grumbine, on behalf of the podcast Macro N Cheese, 684 00:58:27,001 --> 00:58:32,000 we are outta here.