Why is it that in healthcare we so often blame ourselves if we
Speaker:are burning out or we minimize our feelings, telling ourselves we just
Speaker:need to keep calm and carry on?
Speaker:More often than not, it's a system that causes burnout and blaming
Speaker:ourselves is just gonna drive us further into feeling anxious or depressed.
Speaker:This week I'm joined by Dr. Richard Duggins,, who's just written a book
Speaker:specifically to help healthcare professionals avoid burnout.
Speaker:This episode is jam packed with insights to help you figure out whether
Speaker:you are in danger of burnout or if you're simply working through it to
Speaker:the detriment of other vital parts of your life, like your relationships,
Speaker:or frankly, your own happiness
Speaker:Burnout doesn't always look like a dramatic event.
Speaker:Stress and moral injury can build up over time.
Speaker:So if you find yourself irritable or you've noticed a change in empathy for
Speaker:your patients, this episode has got some really practical steps for you to follow.
Speaker:There's loads more information in the show notes, which you can find on our website.
Speaker:If you're in a high stress, high stakes, still blank medicine, and you're feeling
Speaker:stressed or overwhelmed, burning out or getting out are not your only options.
Speaker:I'm Dr. Rachel Morris, and welcome to You Are Not a Frog.
Speaker:I'm Dr. Richard Duggins.
Speaker:I'm an NHS Psychiatrist and Consultant psychotherapist, and I work for and lead
Speaker:our regional north east and North Cumbia staff mental health and wellbeing hub.
Speaker:And I also work as a psychiatrist in the outstanding NHS Practitioner Health.
Speaker:I'm also the author of a new book, Burnout Free Working, and I'm
Speaker:really pleased to be here today.
Speaker:the book is really great, and I would encourage any listener to
Speaker:check it out, and it's absolutely packed with such useful information.
Speaker:And the thing I really liked about your book is it is talking about the workplace
Speaker:and also stuff you can do as well.
Speaker:Because the biggest issue with burnout and with resilience training with wellbeing
Speaker:and stuff is people feel like they're being blamed, resilience, victim blaming.
Speaker:And that's something you talk about in your, in your book.
Speaker:How, how do you see resilience, victim blaming, showing up?
Speaker:It's one of the motivations for writing the book because the people coming
Speaker:to see me often feel it's a personal weakness, that it's some strength,
Speaker:they're letting their team down.
Speaker:And actually that's not what we see.
Speaker:And when we speak to people and they tell their histories and they can start
Speaker:to see it, what we really see is what's going on is something in the system.
Speaker:It's a change or some change in the balance of what's going on around people
Speaker:rather than what's going on inside people.
Speaker:So I often talk about radiators and drains.
Speaker:So what are the things that are radiating energy and keeping people resilient,
Speaker:but also what are the things that are draining their energy and, um,
Speaker:making them more likely to burn out?
Speaker:And what we see clinically is a tip in these radiators and drains.
Speaker:And I, I did laugh in the book 'cause you talked about the fact when you
Speaker:talk about this and you show people the stress curve, which we use all
Speaker:the time, which simply plots your performance against, uh, pressure and
Speaker:as the pressure increases initially.
Speaker:,You get this good stress, don't you, where you perform well.
Speaker:But then as the pressure increases, you tip off the, uh, the top of the curve
Speaker:and your performance starts to decrease.
Speaker:And you said you often hear sort of audible gasps when you talk
Speaker:about this as people realize.
Speaker:That happened to me in a training session.
Speaker:We, I, a woman, um, it was a non-medical training session actually,
Speaker:but a woman ran out of the room, um, really in distress, and I caught
Speaker:up with her at the break time.
Speaker:I said, I'm, I'm so sorry, ar you okay?
Speaker:Is that something I said?
Speaker:She said she'd recently, recently been off upset with burnout, and it was such a
Speaker:relief for her to know it wasn't her fault and there wasn't anything wrong with her.
Speaker:So why, why is it that we do blame ourselves?
Speaker:And do you think people in healthcare blame themselves
Speaker:more readily than other people?
Speaker:I think it's a narrative throughout many professions in high stress.
Speaker:I think it's certainly there within healthcare, but I think
Speaker:it's there within teaching.
Speaker:I think it's there within social work.
Speaker:It's there within law.
Speaker:I've done some work with the police.
Speaker:It's certainly there within the police.
Speaker:So it's, um, I think it's a misunderstanding.
Speaker:I don't think resilience and burnout are understood very well, so I think it's a
Speaker:misunderstanding and, you know, that's why your podcast and, and things like that are
Speaker:so important, 'cause they, you know, they, they correct these misunderstandings.
Speaker:But I also think organizations at times have found it more convenient
Speaker:when people are struggling with burnout in their mental health to say,
Speaker:actually it's that individual and to scapegoat them rather than to ask the
Speaker:harder questions, which is what are we doing that's burning out our staff?
Speaker:What, what could we change?
Speaker:It's, it is easier to blame the individual, I think.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And as medics, I mean, we have been used to pretty high pressure for
Speaker:most of our careers, haven't we?
Speaker:You know, starting with doing a Levels, quite frankly, and then med school with
Speaker:all those exams and working much harder than it seemed like, than anybody else
Speaker:who only had, you know, my husband only had like three lectures a week at uni.
Speaker:He was there nine to five every single day.
Speaker:And then you go straight into house jobs, which were incredibly pressurized.
Speaker:So do you think we have a, that our normal pressure gauge is just set a bit
Speaker:higher than everybody else's perhaps?
Speaker:It's certainly the case that, um, the medics I meet in my clinic
Speaker:are incredibly resilient people.
Speaker:They can manage a lot of stress, but we are all human and we
Speaker:can all only take so much.
Speaker:And at times there will be too much stress at work, often combined with
Speaker:too much stress at home, combined with too little support or a change in
Speaker:support, and we all reach our limits and at that stage we'll start to develop
Speaker:problem stress or, or burnout and may even progress to anxiety, depression,
Speaker:or some physical complications.
Speaker:So it's, um, I agree we are used to and trained to manage high stress, but too
Speaker:much for too long will burn us all out.
Speaker:And do you think in the people that you've seen, it's a problem
Speaker:with the drains have increased?
Speaker:Or is it a problem that the radiators have de decreased?
Speaker:And actually it might be quite helpful for you to just tell us what
Speaker:you think the drains and radiators are, particularly in healthcare.
Speaker:Yeah, absolutely.
Speaker:So the drains are, there's three drains, um, typically they are, um,
Speaker:work stress, both the hours worked and the intensities of those hours worked.
Speaker:They're home pressures.
Speaker:So that's also, you know, what's going on at home.
Speaker:Are there changes?
Speaker:Are there disputes?
Speaker:Have we suffered a bereavement?
Speaker:All sorts.
Speaker:Pressures that are at home, caring responsibilities.
Speaker:And then the other drain, which is a really interesting one, is
Speaker:negative experiences about work.
Speaker:So this is about how we feel about work, and this is very much the culture of work.
Speaker:This is our support at work, how we're treated at work, how
Speaker:investigations are handled at work, how we feel valued at work.
Speaker:when you talk about negative experiences of work, are you talking
Speaker:about what, what the HR department would call employee engagement?
Speaker:It's related, but.
Speaker:In my mind is slightly different.
Speaker:So certainly negative experiences at work do stop employee engagement.
Speaker:But, but no, I'm talking more about the way we feel our work treats us.
Speaker:So how we feel treated by our organization, our line management,
Speaker:our colleagues, how fair work is.
Speaker:So it's more of a cultural thing about, about work if we're exposed to moral
Speaker:injury, those sort of things that affect our relationship with work.
Speaker:so it's not just about the hours and the workload.
Speaker:It's not just about the pressures at home, it's actually about how we
Speaker:are treated by people if we feel the culture is supporting us and is fair.
Speaker:So you can have a high load of hours and high workload, high load of home
Speaker:pressures, and be just about coping, but then suddenly you start to get these
Speaker:negative experiences at work and that can then tip you over into burnout.
Speaker:Yeah, that's, that's what we see.
Speaker:that's interesting.
Speaker:So do you get patients coming in, going, well, the workload hasn't
Speaker:changed, you know, so I don't quite understand what's going on here.
Speaker:You know, we've sort of got the same workload, but for some reason
Speaker:things are much, much harder.
Speaker:absolutely.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Absolutely.
Speaker:And, uh, and people tend to just look at the workload.
Speaker:They don't tend to look at the other drains.
Speaker:So the, the radiators are, are how much support we've got.
Speaker:Um, and we're doubly blessed if we've got support at work and at home.
Speaker:So this again, is the culture of work, line management, but also our colleagues,
Speaker:you know, have we got a buddy at work, but also have we got support at home.
Speaker:The, the second one is, um, whether we've got any.
Speaker:Opportunity for fun and social time.
Speaker:So, um, that, that's often done outside work.
Speaker:But, but you know, to be honest, why can't work be fun?
Speaker:It should be fun at times, but, um, but, you know, the, these
Speaker:are our hobbies and activities.
Speaker:And then the third one, which I think is really helpful for
Speaker:medics to think about particularly is, is there some intellectual
Speaker:stimulation in our working week?
Speaker:So this is, do we feel stretched and developed within our working week?
Speaker:And some people can have extremely busy jobs, but there's something
Speaker:in that week where they really look forward to, they really enjoy a
Speaker:particular clinic, a particular role, an education role, or something like that.
Speaker:And that really helps us keep going.
Speaker:So that can be a radiator.
Speaker:I love that.
Speaker:I remember in one of my, uh, GP jobs, I was incredibly stressed but
Speaker:incredibly bored at the same time.
Speaker:And I was like, how can that, how could those two coexist?
Speaker:But you fit the nail on the head.
Speaker:Yeah, the, there was a lot of, the workload was really, really
Speaker:high, but there was really, at that point, no intellectual stimulation.
Speaker:And actually I fixed that not by changing jobs or changing the workload, 'cause I
Speaker:actually, I think started to doing a, a, a master's or doing some more training.
Speaker:So that was something that suddenly started to intellectually
Speaker:stimulate a bit more.
Speaker:So we, we don't often think about that, do we?
Speaker:No, absolutely.
Speaker:And it's important to think about.
Speaker:It's also one of the things when people get busy at work and they start to burn
Speaker:out, the thing they often drop is that what they see is that optional extra,
Speaker:which might be the most intellectually stimulating bit of their week.
Speaker:So they might stop the teaching or the additional clinic they offer or the
Speaker:minor surgery or something like that.
Speaker:And actually, that's a real mistake because you are, you're dropping
Speaker:the thing that's keeping you going.
Speaker:But, but you see it quite often 'cause people retreat back to doing
Speaker:the core, often the bit that isn't that stimulating and enjoyable.
Speaker:And you talk about that in the book, don't you, with the, uh, funnel of exhaustion.
Speaker:I think Mary Asberg, um, uh.
Speaker:Where yes, you just give up doing everything that you need to
Speaker:survive mentally and physically.
Speaker:And yes, I certainly talk about that a lot, but more in relation to the, the
Speaker:wellbeing factors, but actually learning and growing that is a wellbeing factor.
Speaker:So, um, often I think about, well, we just give up exercising, don't we?
Speaker:We give up the yoga class and resting, but, but you are right.
Speaker:Often because the learning and the developing feels like an optional extra,
Speaker:that is just put on the back burner.
Speaker:And I have lost count of the amount of doctors who've said to me, well, I just
Speaker:haven't got time to do that masters or do that course that I really want to
Speaker:do when actually what you are saying is that could actually be the thing
Speaker:that saves them from burnout weirdly.
Speaker:But how do you do that though?
Speaker:Without, without it just becoming one extra thing to do?
Speaker:One extra pressure on workload and time, because that is the
Speaker:real crux of it, isn't it?
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Well, avoiding burnout and then managing burnout, well, I don't need to tell you.
Speaker:It's, it's really hard.
Speaker:I mean I, I run a, um, a therapy group for, professionals who've, burnt out.
Speaker:And, these are great professionals, very creative, and they'd have solved
Speaker:their problem on their own if they could have done, but it's, these problems
Speaker:are really difficult to solve, and that's what were the group's so helpful
Speaker:'cause people get to think together.
Speaker:And sometimes it requires really difficult decisions and courageous conversations
Speaker:and to try and get that balance back.
Speaker:Um, the balance between the radiators and the drains back.
Speaker:And I think, um, one thing I certainly see with the patients, uh, and the
Speaker:professionals I'm working with is, is that that often requires not them having
Speaker:to solve it all on their own, because they would've done all that already
Speaker:if they could have done, but having to reach out and have those conversations
Speaker:about how do I get this balance back?
Speaker:Uh, you know, who can support me with this?
Speaker:Who, who can help that balance in my work.
Speaker:So I'm, I'm not just burning myself out doing lots and lots of hours of
Speaker:unstimulating work, um, when I know I can contribute in other ways too?
Speaker:But then we've got another problem, haven't we?
Speaker:And I know all throughout the whole of your book, I've noticed the theme
Speaker:is reach out, reach out, get support connects, which I, I totally agree with.
Speaker:But the problem I see is that in healthcare, often the people that you
Speaker:reach out to are your colleagues who are in the same boat, and often they
Speaker:have a vested interest in you keeping on, churning through the workload
Speaker:that might not be simulating to you to, you know, to keeping you going
Speaker:so you can do the service delivery.
Speaker:You can reach out, reach out to your manager, who is probably even more
Speaker:stress and burnout than, than you.
Speaker:Um, so that's another problem for them to deal with.
Speaker:So I'm not sure you're going to get the best support and unbiased
Speaker:support from people at work.
Speaker:So then the question is, well, yeah, you can reach out to your friends
Speaker:and family, but they don't really understand the workplace and what, what
Speaker:you're going through, particularly if they're not in a healthcare context.
Speaker:So, so who wanna do you reach out to for this support?
Speaker:Yeah, and it's, yeah, there, there are, there aren't simple, easy answers
Speaker:and, and I think it requires quite a lot of courage, assertiveness.
Speaker:Persistence.
Speaker:I think a, I think a key thing that people start to accept when they come
Speaker:forward for support and help is actually, this is really serious, what's going on.
Speaker:Burnout is horrible.
Speaker:It's a terrible feeling and it can lead if you don't manage it to
Speaker:anxiety, depression, physical health problems, like high blood pressure.
Speaker:So it needs managing.
Speaker:And as good work is good for us, bad work is bad for us.
Speaker:And, uh, I think it requires us in a way to take a stance where we're
Speaker:saying, actually, I can't sustain this.
Speaker:I need changes to happen.. And, and that can feel very difficult.
Speaker:But actually you burning yourself out, having to take time off work or.
Speaker:Performing poorly because you're burnt out and making errors or mistakes
Speaker:or having poor conversations with patients or colleagues isn't worth it.
Speaker:It's not helping anyone, and, uh, it's not really, it's not helping your
Speaker:colleagues, although it may feel like it.
Speaker:So although organizations and colleagues might want to turn a blind eye at times,
Speaker:they might want to just keep us going until we burn out, we, we really aren't
Speaker:doing us any favors in that, but we're also not doing them any favors for that.
Speaker:We're not doing our patients any favors.
Speaker:I, I totally agree.
Speaker:And, and it's this sort of weird cycle of people saying, well, I haven't got
Speaker:time to do anything about this because there's so many patients I've got to see,
Speaker:or I can't say no because it will let people down and it pass the stress on.
Speaker:Or I'll get a complaint and then I'll say, okay, fine, well you may get a complaint
Speaker:if you say no, but what's gonna be worse?
Speaker:The complaint when you've said a well thought through, no, or your colleagues
Speaker:may be thinking you are letting them down.
Speaker:We don't have any control over that, or properly letting them down
Speaker:when you are off for six months.
Speaker:I mean, I'm not saying, you know, and that's not a judgment, but you won't be
Speaker:there to do the work, or getting an even worse complaint because your judgment's
Speaker:gone and, and we know that doctors that are near a burnout get, make many more
Speaker:mistakes than than people who aren't.
Speaker:So then you're gonna get that complaint and let people down anyway.
Speaker:It would be better to have that difficult conversation in the first place.
Speaker:So that's one whole thing about, you know, setting boundaries, saying
Speaker:no, having those conversations.
Speaker:And as you were talking, I was thinking about the difficulty of
Speaker:finding people to reach out to.
Speaker:But I've had this, a situation, not about stress, but there's been a situation where
Speaker:I want to find out about something and I'm really not sure about who to contact.
Speaker:I'm thinking, oh, oh gosh.
Speaker:And my other half said, Rachel, you know, lots of people you could contact.
Speaker:And I thought, okay.
Speaker:And I just sat down and I wrote a list.
Speaker:So it turns out having said, oh, I don't know what to do, I don't know
Speaker:who to buy advice from, there are at least 10 people I could literally
Speaker:email and ask some advice from.
Speaker:But it takes a bit of thinking, a bit of putting my neck out there and a
Speaker:bit of being ready for people to say, actually no, I can't help you type thing.
Speaker:So yeah, I don't, it probably isn't that We don't know anyone
Speaker:who can support us, right?
Speaker:Well, absolutely.
Speaker:And for me, it's one of the joys of being a doctor, uh, and being in the NHS.
Speaker:And for me, one of the key values and why I do this work, really for being a doctor
Speaker:and in the NHS is we help our colleagues.
Speaker:We are there for our colleagues.
Speaker:And I increasingly believe that actually helping our colleagues stay
Speaker:well is, for all of us, whatever our roles is, the best way we help
Speaker:patients because healthy, thriving colleagues deliver great services.
Speaker:So I, I almost think it should be our priority.
Speaker:The, the, the other thing I was reminded of when you were talking
Speaker:was, um, how we change culture.
Speaker:And I think we have an op we have an opportunity sometimes, especially if
Speaker:we're reasonably senior to do that.
Speaker:And I was thinking about, there was a service I worked in about 10 years ago,
Speaker:and we used to see all sorts of doctors.
Speaker:It was a self-referral service.
Speaker:Lots of doctors came to us, really popular, but no surgeons came to us.
Speaker:So, and I was like, well, these surgeons are under a lot of pressure.
Speaker:I know that I've got friends who are surgeons, but they never came to us.
Speaker:And then one day a very senior surgeon came to us.
Speaker:He was burnt out, he'd become depressed.
Speaker:He referred into our service.
Speaker:He did very well, 'cause most people do.
Speaker:And then he went back and this was the remarkable thing he did.
Speaker:He talked to all the other surgeons in the region and says, look, this
Speaker:happened to me, I was overworking.
Speaker:There was a lot going on at home, I went through to this service.
Speaker:I'm much better, you can see I'm much better.
Speaker:And then the flood gates opened, and we never, ever had any problems with
Speaker:surgeons coming through to our service.
Speaker:So that person, I'm sure he doesn't know it, but probably saved a lot of people's
Speaker:careers, will have benefited patients and maybe saved some people's lives.
Speaker:So I, I do think there's something else about just battling on and waiting for
Speaker:burnout to hit us, and doing it silently doesn't help our colleagues either.
Speaker:No, it really doesn't.
Speaker:And, and the minute you share something, the shame dissipates, doesn't it?
Speaker:And let's face it, we still all feel shame when we think we're not coping because we
Speaker:feel I'm not good enough as a doctor, I should be able to cope with everything,
Speaker:which is totally bonkers thinking.
Speaker:It's a superhero thinking that it is so unhelpful for us, but the minute someone's
Speaker:senior tells their story, it's like, okay.
Speaker:Yeah, we can do it.
Speaker:And we've been involved in coaching programs for new to GP fellowships
Speaker:and there's coaching programs around the country that are fully funded
Speaker:for doctors and not being used by anybody, which is total madness.
Speaker:Now either people just don't know about them, that could be one thing, but I
Speaker:think people firstly feel they haven't got time, which is again, total madness,
Speaker:we'll talk about that in a minute.
Speaker:Or, or people maybe don't want to admit how bad things have got.
Speaker:Why do you think people aren't using these services that are
Speaker:available to them that are out there?
Speaker:I mean, there's a lot of talk about how far we've come on about mental
Speaker:health and de-stigmatizing it.
Speaker:And yet a lot of, the lot of professionals I still meet with, a lot
Speaker:of doctors I still meet with, they're really ashamed to be meeting with me.
Speaker:They're, you know, the, the, the line usually is, I'm, you know,
Speaker:I'm sorry to be wasting your time.
Speaker:I'm sure you see people a lot worse than me, and a sense of a weakness, a
Speaker:failure, letting their colleagues down.
Speaker:And it's still there.
Speaker:And, um, and it's a miss, you know, as I said earlier, it's a
Speaker:misunderstanding of what burnout is.
Speaker:It's a, you know, it's not true what they're saying.
Speaker:And when they tell their stories, they can see it's not true, but that's there.
Speaker:The other thing is I think people need to trust these services.
Speaker:They need to trust that the services will be, be for them, that they'll be rapid
Speaker:to access, that they'll be confidential, and the outcomes are really good.
Speaker:I mean, NHS Practitioner Health is a fantastic example of that in the UK.
Speaker:So I, when Clare Gerada set it up, she said, if we build this, people will come.
Speaker:And I'm not sure people were sure about that at the beginning, but it was built.
Speaker:People come to NHS Practitioner Health, they get really, really well, they
Speaker:start thriving, they then go back and tell their teams about their positive
Speaker:experiences, and the service has grown into the kind of, you know, massive
Speaker:trusted services at the moment.
Speaker:So I, I, I think it, it does take a little bit of time to make people trust things.
Speaker:I think people can worry that if they come through to help that it will be
Speaker:opening a kind of Pandora's box and that they'll suddenly be off work and
Speaker:they won't be able to get back to work.
Speaker:And that's not true at all.
Speaker:You come through to help, you'll do really, really well.
Speaker:It's when you don't come through to help that the problems can come.
Speaker:I think as well, when some of these services were first set up, um, I'm
Speaker:thinking of a, a particular coaching service, it was like, oh yeah, come
Speaker:and see us, and they'd give like one day of training to people and then so
Speaker:people would use it and think, well, actually that wasn't very helpful
Speaker:because actually they saw someone that wasn't very experienced and also almost
Speaker:felt like they were just trying to persuade them to stay working rather
Speaker:than, or, or they were doing mentoring, which is great, but probably what,
Speaker:what wasn't needed at, at the time.
Speaker:And so they're put off.
Speaker:But I think things have very much developed and, and improved since then.
Speaker:I think one of the reasons why people do put off getting help
Speaker:is they don't recognize it.
Speaker:And you talk about this in your book, that the burnout cliff, that people
Speaker:go along, along, along think, well, I, I can't be, I can't be burnt out.
Speaker:But you know, I've spoken to someone who's a director of medical, director of
Speaker:wellbeing and a, a local hospital trust.
Speaker:They surveyed their doctors recently, using, I think
Speaker:there's a Maslach inventory.
Speaker:50% of their doctors are working in burnout.
Speaker:And we are led to believe that actually burnout is so severe, you'd
Speaker:know when you're in it, uh, you can't carry on when you're in it.
Speaker:But actually a lot of people are actually working in it, so, absolutely.
Speaker:And I've had those sorts just the same as your patients.
Speaker:Well, I think I might be wasting your time because I don't think I'm actually
Speaker:that bad, but you actually are, but almost you felt like that for such a long
Speaker:time, or even, dare I say it, for most of your career, it's become normal to you.
Speaker:So.
Speaker:is it true that we've almost normalized burnout and a lot of it are working
Speaker:in burnout without even knowing it?
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:I, I think that's right.
Speaker:And I think, um, I think I talk about a culture, in high stress
Speaker:professions, particularly in the NHS where we keep calm and carry on.
Speaker:We, we listen to, uh, Dory in Finding Nemo.
Speaker:We, we just keep swimming that that's what we do.
Speaker:And that is terrible burnout advice.
Speaker:It's a way to get through a difficult night shift, but, you know, it's like,
Speaker:it's like trying to run a marathon in the way that you handle a sprint.
Speaker:So, so keeping calm and carrying on doesn't work, but it's the
Speaker:way that it's our go-to, I think in high stress professions.
Speaker:So we keep our heads down despite, you know, feeling a lot of problem,
Speaker:stress, early signs of burnout, even even quite severe burnout,
Speaker:and we just try and keep going.
Speaker:What we do is we try and protect our work and the core work.
Speaker:And often other things are, are, you know, we're neglecting home life.
Speaker:We're neglecting, uh, social activities, we're becoming quite
Speaker:isolated from our community, but, but we do try and keep calm and carry on.
Speaker:And some of that I think is because doctors and I see this all the time, are
Speaker:really quite hopeful, optimistic people.
Speaker:And they say to me, it will get better.
Speaker:It's just a really busy
Speaker:yeah.
Speaker:Next year when I get my new colleague, it'll be
Speaker:Yeah, absolutely.
Speaker:So you, you hear a lot of that and you know, and hopefulness is wonderful.
Speaker:We need that when we work with our patients, but it can get to the
Speaker:point where it's fooling yourself.
Speaker:And, um, and the danger with the, um, that stage is what I call the plateau,
Speaker:where people are just putting their heads down hoping it'll get better.
Speaker:But the danger with the plateau is you end up sleep walking
Speaker:towards the burnout cliff.
Speaker:So it comes to a point where things go, there's too much for too long,
Speaker:and then there's one thing, the straw that breaks the camel's back and that
Speaker:will potentially take you off work or you'll have to, um, you'll have
Speaker:to then, um, reduce your commitments.
Speaker:And that's where we really don't want to get to.
Speaker:So it's much better for people to act early to try and recognize things.
Speaker:I, I also think you're right that people don't necessarily look out for them.
Speaker:So one of the things I do when I'm lucky enough to be able to do some
Speaker:workshops with people is spend a bit of time saying, you know, what
Speaker:are your signs of problem stress?
Speaker:Do you know them?
Speaker:Do you know them as a tick list?
Speaker:And, and often people don't know them, but, but really, they,
Speaker:they should be on our dashboard.
Speaker:We should be monitoring them.
Speaker:And, uh, you know, we should be watching out when we're not sleeping as
Speaker:well, when we're withdrawing, whether we're, when we're becoming irritable,
Speaker:when we're getting muscle tension.
Speaker:But I, I'm not sure people are monitoring those and, or if they do recognize
Speaker:them, sometimes they're ignoring them.
Speaker:and I've just had this real realization as I've been talking to you, because
Speaker:this burnout cliff is really interesting.
Speaker:And you, you have it in the book 'cause you know, you have this
Speaker:wiggly line, you go along and then suddenly you go into burnout.
Speaker:Because the question I've had for a long time is, okay, why is so many doctors able
Speaker:to work in burnout when the traditional advice is their performance will go down?
Speaker:You know, so you can't perform if you're in burnout yet, they
Speaker:are still just about performing.
Speaker:That's right.
Speaker:And I, and I think it's, um, there's two people I think of in the kind of history
Speaker:of burnout that I often go back to.
Speaker:And the first one is he's got a wonderful name.
Speaker:He's Dr. Herbert Freudenberger.
Speaker:And he was a psychoanalyst in New York in the 1960s, and he burnt
Speaker:out , um, and then he coined the phrase to describe his burnout.
Speaker:And, um, and he, he was doing a public addictions clinic during the day and doing
Speaker:a private clinic at ,night and too much for too long with too little support.
Speaker:And he, he coined the word burnout because it reminded him of what he was
Speaker:saying in New York at that time, which was there were burnt out buildings.
Speaker:And he said, if you look at a burnt out building, it looks okay from
Speaker:the outside, but inside there's a kind of desolation and emptiness.
Speaker:And he said, that's what I feel like.
Speaker:People, people look at me, they think, I think I'm fine,
Speaker:but inside I'm feel terrible.
Speaker:And, uh, and that is, I think the burnt out clinician at work.
Speaker:They're, they're protecting their work, they look okay, but inside something
Speaker:really quite serious is going on.
Speaker:But when they, when the straw that breaks come off back and they need to
Speaker:take work time off work, it sometimes takes them by surprise, but almost
Speaker:always takes their colleagues by surprise, they don't see it coming.
Speaker:The other key name is the name you've already mentioned, professor Christina
Speaker:Maslach, who did the Maslach Inventory and she described burnout as three things.
Speaker:So I think at that stage she didn't talk about performance, but what she
Speaker:talked about is emotional exhaustion.
Speaker:So that kind of absolutely exhausted at the end of the day, all you
Speaker:can do is sit on the sofa and have a glass of wine and fall asleep.
Speaker:Emotional detachment, so that kind of robotic, kind of compassion
Speaker:fatigue, feel not there for your colleagues and your patients.
Speaker:And then the third thing she said was a loss of joy in work.
Speaker:So that kind of where you don't feel those, that joy that brought us into
Speaker:medicine or these high stress professions, you don't feel those small wins anymore.
Speaker:And lots of people have those three symptoms and are
Speaker:still at work and manage it.
Speaker:And it's only, I think, much later in the burnout kind of well warm
Speaker:path that you get the drop in work performance, but because people stay
Speaker:off so long, you get a sudden drop, you get this kind of slow burnout and
Speaker:they're then a very quick burnout.
Speaker:And this is diagrams in your book that you've got this plateau, um, which
Speaker:is slowly going down, which is your performance, and then suddenly the
Speaker:burnout cliff suddenly drops down.
Speaker:But what really struck me about what you said, Richard, is that actually
Speaker:your performance isn't carrying on well.
Speaker:Your performance at work is so you protect your work.
Speaker:But if you look at your performance at home, so I've drawn another
Speaker:wiggly line underneath, and that is your relationships,
Speaker:that's your thriving in life.
Speaker:That's your family life.
Speaker:That's any friendships, your exercise, your wellbeing, all that, your
Speaker:performance in terms of thriving in life, well that is starting to go down
Speaker:and you'll, you'll drop all of those as long as you are protecting your work.
Speaker:Well, thinking, well, I can't be burnt out 'cause I'm still performing fine even
Speaker:though, like you said, joy has completely gone, you're this hollow, empty show with
Speaker:nothing in your life, but work because you've given up doing anything that brings
Speaker:you happiness, joy, or whatever, so that you can protect your performance at work.
Speaker:And then something happens, the straw that breaks the camel's back, be it a complaint
Speaker:or a tricky patient or a colleague going off sick or maybe something happening
Speaker:at home, and then suddenly boom, your performance everywhere plummets.
Speaker:Is that a good interpretation of, of, of what you've
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:I mean, it's, exactly right and that's what we see.
Speaker:We see people protecting work at far too heavy a cost to them
Speaker:personally, um, and, and to their families and, and ultimately to work.
Speaker:So you might see somebody, in fact, I'm, I'm thinking about somebody who,
Speaker:know, example of somebody who's just had a baby, but they've also just
Speaker:had a promotion, so that's great.
Speaker:These, these are great things, but massive increase in home and work stress.
Speaker:Because they've had a promotion, they've also changed line manager and their
Speaker:new line manager isn't very supportive, they're expecting them to get on with it.
Speaker:So there's been a decrease in support, but the, the way they
Speaker:manage that is focusing on work.
Speaker:So working really hard, focusing at home, but absolutely no
Speaker:time anymore for themselves.
Speaker:So they've stopped running.
Speaker:Uh, you know, they, they've stopped seeing their friends, um, they become
Speaker:more isolated, they don't come outta their office much, so they're not talking to
Speaker:their colleagues unless it's in a Teams meeting, and they're not doing anything
Speaker:fun at work or enjoyable or stimulating.
Speaker:And that's where it tips.
Speaker:So, so you get a change and then the way people manage that change gets
Speaker:things even more out of balance.
Speaker:That makes a lot of sense.
Speaker:And the problem is that just the time where you are being promoted, where
Speaker:you are taking on leadership experience often coincides with life stuff going
Speaker:on, babies, kids, teenagers, elderly parents, all that, all that sort of stuff.
Speaker:So you can see there's a lot of things that are gonna break
Speaker:the camels back, as it were.
Speaker:And you also talk about curve balls in the book.
Speaker:Are these things that will also like plummet you down that cliff quicker?
Speaker:Yeah, absolutely.
Speaker:And I, I talk about these cause a lot of people who come and see me in
Speaker:these conversations, the conversation initially is all about work.
Speaker:And work is really important.
Speaker:And they probably wouldn't be seeing me unless things were very demanding at work.
Speaker:But there's also often things at home and, and, and it's only at home, only
Speaker:comes in when I often ask about it.
Speaker:Well, you know, what's happening at home?
Speaker:And, and you, I talk about curve balls 'cause there's typically kind of four
Speaker:home curve balls that are important.
Speaker:also we can have strategies to, to manage.
Speaker:And, um, these curve balls come from interpersonal therapy, a type of therapy
Speaker:that I'm trained in, but, but the, the big curve balls to watch out for are
Speaker:change, so has something changed at home?
Speaker:So the example I gave there, new baby.
Speaker:Big change at home,
Speaker:moving house would be one.
Speaker:Even though it's a positive change, it is emotionally very draining,
Speaker:Yeah, absolutely.
Speaker:And yeah, so lots and lots of changes happen in people's lives.
Speaker:Um, caring responsibilities, as you've said.
Speaker:Um, the, the menopause is a massive, massive physical change.
Speaker:So the other thing that's going on is, is maybe disagreements at
Speaker:work, but disagreements at home.
Speaker:So, you know, if you're working very hard, very long hours, things can
Speaker:often be a bit difficult at home.
Speaker:How, how do you manage those disagreements at home with a partner
Speaker:or sometimes with parents or sometimes with children, they're very stressful.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Just say that I, I had some friends who there was a massive dispute going
Speaker:on with their neighbors and that, i, I just couldn't quite work out
Speaker:why it was affecting them so much.
Speaker:I mean, it's not very nice thing to happen, but it absolutely
Speaker:knocked them sideways.
Speaker:For six months they couldn't think or talk about anything else.
Speaker:So it's, it's a big thing, isn't it?
Speaker:Whether it's with parents, families, partners, or neighbors
Speaker:or, or anything else really.
Speaker:And absolutely.
Speaker:And you throw that in alongside a very busy job or a job where you're not
Speaker:particularly supportive from, that, that will be the thing that will tip it.
Speaker:So we've got change, disputes.
Speaker:The third one is bereavement.
Speaker:And natural process losing people, natural process grief, but do we ever
Speaker:allow any time for it in healthcare?
Speaker:Sometimes you might get five days off or something like that.
Speaker:And people are expected to work just the same alongside being bereaved.
Speaker:And that is a very big ask and often not very possible.
Speaker:And then the fourth, um, the fourth curve ball I put in is, is loneliness.
Speaker:And, and this is, this is something we don't talk about a great deal within
Speaker:high stress professions, but we, we do see people can become quite isolated,
Speaker:because 'cause of how many hours they're working and how intense they're working.
Speaker:But, uh, a, a group that I particularly think about here are
Speaker:international healthcare graduates who are coming over to the UK.
Speaker:it's a wonderful opportunity to come over here and develop, develop their
Speaker:career, but they're quite isolated and expecting to do really difficult
Speaker:work without the normal support.
Speaker:So isolation can be really important.
Speaker:We can really feel it when we've got a good friend we rely on,
Speaker:um, a good buddy moves away.
Speaker:You know, that can be the difference.
Speaker:Um, so, so isolation's a really important curve ball to think about as well.
Speaker:If you can tell someone's heading toward that, that burnout cliff, how
Speaker:do we get people to, to take action?
Speaker:Because I'm presuming most people leave it till it's too late
Speaker:They do, they do.
Speaker:Or leave it too late.
Speaker:Not till it's too late.
Speaker:Nothing's ever too
Speaker:No, nothing's no.
Speaker:And, and absolutely.
Speaker:And people, people come forward to services for support when they're
Speaker:very burnt out, they're an, you know, they're anxious, they're depressed,
Speaker:and they still do really well.
Speaker:You know, I mean, it's an important message here.
Speaker:But, yes, we can avoid an awful lot of distress of ourselves, our families,
Speaker:our colleagues, our organization, if we come forward earlier.
Speaker:The group that are really good at coming forward, forward earlier are
Speaker:the people who've burnt out previously.
Speaker:And I, um, I love seeing people have burnt out earlier in my, in my clinic
Speaker:because they, they say, they say, I'm coming forward because I'm starting to
Speaker:feel these symptoms of problem stress, they've been with me for a few weeks now.
Speaker:I'm, I'm a bit worried 'cause I'm not kind of caring quite as much for my PA
Speaker:patients, I used to feeling a bit robotic.
Speaker:I'm not going down the roof to burnout again.
Speaker:I'm coming forward for some support.
Speaker:And that's exactly the great thing to do.
Speaker:So what, what would be wonderful, and one of the motivations for writing
Speaker:the book was can people do that?
Speaker:Can people learn from all of the people who come forward
Speaker:later to come forward earlier?
Speaker:Because if you come forward earlier, it's much easier to get things back
Speaker:in balance, to balance out your radiators and drains, to, to make
Speaker:changes that protect you from burnout.
Speaker:it's much easier, it's much more effective.
Speaker:It's much quicker and it's much less disruptive to everyone.
Speaker:But it's something about self-monitoring.
Speaker:It's about, it's about recognizing those symptoms, but equally important, it's
Speaker:about taking those symptoms seriously.
Speaker:Don't just ignore them and keep, keep calm and carry on.
Speaker:Don't just keep swimming.
Speaker:Stop, reflect, but also act, do something about it.
Speaker:I think people put off coming A, because they're not recognizing it and
Speaker:because everyone is in the same boat as then everyone's working in burnout.
Speaker:B, they think they're only deserving of treatment when they are in full burnout.
Speaker:They actually, no one wants to see me now.
Speaker:And to be honest, there have been anecdotal reports from people that have
Speaker:written in, um, to the podcast saying, well, I was feeling really stressed and
Speaker:overwhelmed, I went to see occupational health, they said, the only thing we
Speaker:can do is sign you off, that was it.
Speaker:Or they see the GP, he goes.
Speaker:And to be honest, with most GPs, the only thing they can do is say, well, do you
Speaker:wanna take time off with, you know, they can point people towards, well there's
Speaker:Practitioner Health and there's some other services, but they, they themselves, that
Speaker:is the only, they don't have time in 10 minutes to go through, okay, let's look
Speaker:at your radiators and drains and coping mechanisms and all that sort of stuff.
Speaker:So people are very fearful that they're told, they're just gonna be told to
Speaker:take time off and then they'll be going about against medical advice.
Speaker:And I think it's a real conundrum because we've seen, if you look at
Speaker:the stress curve, I think if you are going to get some help when you are at
Speaker:stress and just before overwhelm and someone takes, tells you to take time
Speaker:off, then actually sometimes, sometimes it's absolutely what they need to do.
Speaker:But sometimes it's like the the last thing you want to do and it'll
Speaker:make things a lot worse for you.
Speaker:Yes, you need to rest and make some changes, but this prolonged time, time off
Speaker:that most people are just told to do as a sort of panacea for burnout management.
Speaker:That's just like, that's not gonna work for me right, right now, and
Speaker:so let's wait until I a hundred percent can't actually go into work
Speaker:just to be told to take time off.
Speaker:Now, I know I'm being a little bit harsh, but I think that's genuinely some
Speaker:of the experiences of our listeners.
Speaker:Yeah, and I, I, and I, I've heard people report that to me as well, and, um,
Speaker:who've gone to other services and, um, you know, and other services are limited.
Speaker:They haven't got the knowledge.
Speaker:I mean, you know, we we're still quite early with our
Speaker:understanding of burnout, I think.
Speaker:And it's not, you know, it's not, it's not greatly understood.
Speaker:It's, um, it's still not considered a medical condition.
Speaker:I don't really understand that, but, but it isn't, so I think you're right.
Speaker:But, what I would say is that, if you can come forward early.
Speaker:it is much easier.
Speaker:It's what you should be doing.
Speaker:To take, uh, examples of us as doctors, we don't really say to our patients,
Speaker:let's not sort this out early on before, while it's mild, let's just
Speaker:come back when it's really, really bad, and then, then we'll tackle it.
Speaker:'cause it's much easier to sort things out when they are mild.
Speaker:It's mu you know, and you'll need much less input and, you know, and
Speaker:there's a greater range of people who can help you when it's mild and
Speaker:it, you know, it, it may not be that you want to come through to service,
Speaker:you might want to do some, coaching.
Speaker:Or you may, you may have some peer support or things like that.
Speaker:The, there can be other things, so it is, you know, I, I would
Speaker:say it's really important people
Speaker:I mean, this is why we have our Shapes Toolkit system because we think there is
Speaker:nothing between stress and burnout for people often even to help themselves.
Speaker:Because with the best will in the world, getting an appointment to talk
Speaker:to people that might be a few, few days away or even a few weeks away.
Speaker:But there are things that we know help, like staying in your zone of control,
Speaker:you're of power working out what you control, of what you're not actually
Speaker:facing reality, having conversations, learning to put some boundaries around
Speaker:your time and, and workload, things like that, which are really, really helpful
Speaker:and can just pull you back up that curve and away from the burnout cliff.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And, and if you act early, I dunno whether this metaphor work, but sometimes I think
Speaker:of it a bit like driving a car, that if you steer a little bit and use your
Speaker:brake a little bit, that's how you drive.
Speaker:What you don't drive is wait until you hit the corner and then just go
Speaker:like that and slam your brake on.
Speaker:So, so so actually if, if you do, if you do take things seriously and you
Speaker:do monitor things and you do come forward and make the sort of changes
Speaker:that you're suggesting, they often don't need to be massive changes.
Speaker:What you want to be doing is self-correcting and making these small
Speaker:changes and learning these small, these ways of doing it, um, early on.
Speaker:So what do you wish your patients had done or been able to do or had
Speaker:support to do to self-correct early?
Speaker:Well, what I see, I, what I see people doing, uh, when they recover,
Speaker:I mean, it's, it's individual and it, but, but I think there's five,
Speaker:five key things that I see people do.
Speaker:The first one is that if their basic needs are out of whack,
Speaker:they do something to attend to it.
Speaker:So that is, if they are working massive hours, intense hours, they're
Speaker:not getting any time to talk to their colleagues, not taking their annual leave.
Speaker:Or if it's something at home that is out of whack, they try and address it.
Speaker:Because the danger is if you take time off and you come forward
Speaker:for help, you will get better.
Speaker:But if you go back to the same problems, it only lasts so long.
Speaker:And there's good research evidence that shows that too.
Speaker:So I, I think if it is about basic needs that are making you become
Speaker:unwell, then you need to address it.
Speaker:The second one is decompression activities.
Speaker:So this is the idea that stress builds up on us every day, so we need to do
Speaker:something regularly to manage that stress.
Speaker:And that could be something that's active, like running, joining a choir, or it
Speaker:could be something that's quieter, a restorative niche like, um, you know,
Speaker:might be reading, might be mindfulness.
Speaker:I've heard you speak to Paula Redmond, she talks about knitting.
Speaker:You know, these are all really important things and they're
Speaker:different for different people.
Speaker:So you know, Don't listen to somebody who says, oh, you should go running
Speaker:if that's not what you wanna do.
Speaker:My idea of
Speaker:yeah, but, but, but do do something that you like to do, that.
Speaker:Now, um, Matt Morgan is an ICU consultant, and I love the way
Speaker:Matt Morgan talks about this.
Speaker:So he talks about early on in his consultant career, he was sort of
Speaker:soaking up this stress and he, and he found himself perhaps drinking a little
Speaker:bit too much or more than he wanted to, and, uh, and also being a bit irritable.
Speaker:And, and he talks about the idea of what he discovered, which he, a
Speaker:kind of brainwave came to him when he had his, he was kind of, um,
Speaker:bathing his young children, uh, and he talked about squeezing the sponge.
Speaker:And he said the idea that came to him was that, um, at work he was
Speaker:like a sponge for stress and he was filling up and filling up with stress.
Speaker:And, and, and because he was over full.
Speaker:that he wasn't coping very well.
Speaker:He was, uh, you know, taking out on other people sometimes.
Speaker:But he said what, what he learned was that to be a consultant and sustain his career,
Speaker:he needed to regularly squeeze the sponge.
Speaker:He needed to do something to get the stress out of him.
Speaker:And, uh, and, you know, and need, he took, he talks about the various kind
Speaker:of activities that he made routine within his week, um, to manage his
Speaker:career, so that's a really good one.
Speaker:The other thing is, um, social support.
Speaker:So, um, having your support team, you know, knowing who's there for you at
Speaker:work and home, and uh, and really, really reaching out for people.
Speaker:And it's not just about a shoulder to cry on.
Speaker:Just those normal kind of everyday social activities alongside people,
Speaker:those chats, you know, before and after meetings, those chats in the coffee room,
Speaker:or those, you know, just those chats down the pool, but in a coffee room are
Speaker:really, really important for our health.
Speaker:The fourth thing is a don't do, which is to evol to avoid false cures, to
Speaker:evolve, avoid, um, things that are unhelpful, like drinking too much.
Speaker:Um, and you know, I'm seeing a fair, some, some professionals are using
Speaker:gambling, and this is a way of kind of taking you outta things, but it
Speaker:doesn't solve the underlying problems.
Speaker:And beca can become in time a bigger problem than, than the underlying problem.
Speaker:And then the fifth thing is, what I see people do, and I've mentioned
Speaker:this already, is they keep calm, but they nip things in the bud.
Speaker:So people get really good at taking their, their wellbeing and their mental
Speaker:health seriously, and they look out for symptoms and signs in themselves of when
Speaker:things are getting out of balance, and they act quickly to do something about it.
Speaker:So they don't keep calm and carry on.
Speaker:They keep calm, nip it in the bud, do something about it, and,
Speaker:and that is a really rewarding change to see people make.
Speaker:I think we are quite bad at doing that.
Speaker:I'm thinking of people, friends that I've had in the past who,
Speaker:um, have been quite flaky.
Speaker:Like they haven't been doctors.
Speaker:Doctors always, you know, doctors turn up when they say We will, we'll go
Speaker:out when we do it, you know, but some non-doctor friends have been like, I
Speaker:can't come out this evening, i'm just feeling a bit tired and I'm like,
Speaker:gosh, I would never cancel anything.
Speaker:Just I'm feeling tired, you know, because like we've been programmed that like tide
Speaker:is just normal so you wouldn't, you know.
Speaker:But actually looking back, they were nipping it in the bud.
Speaker:They're like, actually.
Speaker:I can't do that tonight, 'cause I know I don't have the emotional capacity for it.
Speaker:I've just canceled that.
Speaker:I'm not gonna do that.
Speaker:And yeah, they, they recognize it and they do it.
Speaker:But I think in medicine we're like, oh, well that I, I can keep going
Speaker:'cause I, I always had, and when I was younger I did 120 hours a week.
Speaker:Therefore I can manage that now.
Speaker:And yet this weird mindset we have, isn't it?
Speaker:it's inter it's interesting, isn't it?
Speaker:Because the other thing that we are quite good at, at medics,
Speaker:especially if our patients is taking control and advocating and, and, and
Speaker:acting, but when it comes to our own wellbeing, we are not very good at it.
Speaker:Um, but, but we have got those medical skills to, you know, we are not,
Speaker:we're not normally afraid of acting.
Speaker:We, we, we make difficult decisions, but we need to start doing that for ourselves.
Speaker:So I think a lot of high, professionals in high profile jobs have got these skills.
Speaker:They just haven't yet harbored them for their own wellbeing.
Speaker:The other thing, it's just come to me, it's a bit of a play on the word acting.
Speaker:Um, we like to get into action.
Speaker:We're very good at getting into actions and solving problems,
Speaker:but actually sometimes the action that we need is to subtract.
Speaker:So I'm just thinking, you know, it's actually very hard for me to
Speaker:go, I actually need to sit in my hanging pod in the garden for an
Speaker:hour and read and read a magazine.
Speaker:That's what I need.
Speaker:I'd be much more, but I need to do this, this, and the other.
Speaker:So if we can change resting and subtraction into an action that
Speaker:we know is good for us, maybe we'd be more keen to do that.
Speaker:I mean, it's interesting, you, you've talked about those five things and
Speaker:actually nowhere there have, you talked about therapy and counseling
Speaker:and psychotherapy and stuff.
Speaker:So where, where does that all come in, in, in any of this?
Speaker:Yeah, no, it's a, it is a really good point.
Speaker:So, so PE-people who are coming through are making these changes.
Speaker:Um, and I don't think you have to be in therapy or in a therapeutic
Speaker:relationship to make these changes, but pe-people are, are doing that
Speaker:within a therapeutic relationship.
Speaker:And I think there is, there is something about coming through to a support service
Speaker:or a wellbeing service that allows you to stop and reflect and think,
Speaker:actually things are outta balance.
Speaker:What do I need to do to kind of correct this?
Speaker:So that sort of therapeutic support can be really helpful in helping
Speaker:people reflect, take things seriously, but start to make a plan and making
Speaker:those, those steps and goals and focus.
Speaker:And I don't think that, you know, if you're coming through
Speaker:early enough or with burnout, it doesn't have to be a long time.
Speaker:You know, you can, you can do that within, you know, a relatively
Speaker:brief therapy, six to 12 sessions, you know, maybe even less actually.
Speaker:So that's important.
Speaker:Where therapy does come in, I think is your burnout's gone on for a long time.
Speaker:So if so, some people will be on the plateau, will be prioritizing their work,
Speaker:be become really quite severely burnt out.
Speaker:And if you're still at work and you're still under a lot of stress,
Speaker:it's reasonably easy for that burnout to turn into a medical
Speaker:condition like anxiety or depression.
Speaker:So it's, um, I'd see it as rather a continuum of kind of problem stress
Speaker:to different levels of burnout.
Speaker:And then if it's still not managed, you run a quite a high risk of developing
Speaker:anxiety or depression or physical health complications like high blood pressure.
Speaker:And I think if you are moving into that anxiety depression area, then
Speaker:that's where therapy comes in and an evidence-based therapy comes in.
Speaker:It may also be, and professionals tend to be a bit resistant to
Speaker:this, it may also be a conversation about, actually I've got anxiety and
Speaker:depression, do I need to consider, um, some medication here to treat this?
Speaker:But most anxiety and depression, the first step would be therapy and it
Speaker:would be an evidence-based therapy like, um, CBT or IPT would be the top, the
Speaker:top ones in the evidence base to do.
Speaker:most of us sort of know what CBT is.
Speaker:What, what?
Speaker:Can you just explain what IPT
Speaker:is?
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:So IIPT is, um.
Speaker:type of therapy, um, developed for depression.
Speaker:It is available in the uk.
Speaker:It's available in, um, pri in most primary care, uh, services
Speaker:for anxiety and depression.
Speaker:Um, it's also developed in some secondary care.
Speaker:Um, we have got, uh, an IPT specialist within NHS Practitioner health, and, and
Speaker:within the service I work in regionally,
Speaker:it's an interesting, um, therapy because it was developed by somebody,
Speaker:um, asking therapists, if you're treating somebody for depression, what
Speaker:do we need to have in this therapy?
Speaker:What's it need to look like?
Speaker:And they, they offer a big list, and the therapy of IPT was designed upon that.
Speaker:And, um, CBT tends to be about Modifying your thoughts, distorted
Speaker:thoughts, um, and then that leading to a change in your feelings and behavior.
Speaker:IPT is, um, much more about looking at your social support and your
Speaker:relationships and who's there for you.
Speaker:And also, um, we talk about, um, in IPT, the idea of antidepressant activities.
Speaker:So often when people become depressed, they stop doing the
Speaker:things that are good for them.
Speaker:So they become very tired.
Speaker:They think they're no good, they're not good company anymore so they stop seeing
Speaker:friends, they stop doing those nice things because they're too exhausted to do it.
Speaker:So we focus on people getting those things back into their life as well.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:That makes, that makes a lot of sense.
Speaker:And can I quickly ask you about the relationship between
Speaker:anxiety, depression, and burnout?
Speaker:Do you think that all burnout, if it gets severe enough, turns
Speaker:into an anxiety and depression?
Speaker:No, I don't, I don't think all burnout does.
Speaker:Um, I think all problem stressed us.
Speaker:So if, if we start off with problem stress, if we're in problem stress
Speaker:for too long, we'll become burnt out.
Speaker:And then if we stay in burnout too long, we'll become increasingly burnt out.
Speaker:Burnout.
Speaker:Burnout is a spectrum.
Speaker:But some people will then, if they're, if they're severely burnt out,
Speaker:will have a high risk of developing anxiety and depression, but not
Speaker:everyone will but quite a lot will.
Speaker:And the longer you are burnt out, the higher your risk of developing
Speaker:anxiety and depression is.
Speaker:And is the other way round true that if you suffer with anxiety
Speaker:and depression anyway, are you at high risk of burning out?
Speaker:I wouldn't say necessarily.
Speaker:So, because, what determines whether you're at risk of burnout
Speaker:is what's going on around you.
Speaker:So, so we burn out because of those balances between our radiators and drains.
Speaker:Um, you know, when the drains are high and the support is low, and
Speaker:that is the same for ev everyone.
Speaker:So we, you know, whether you've got a history of anxiety or depression or
Speaker:whether you haven't, whether you're gonna become burnt out or not is
Speaker:because of what's going on around you.
Speaker:And what for you would be the red flags that someone in burnout is tipping
Speaker:also over into anxiety and depression?
Speaker:So it's the diagnostic factors for, um, anxiety and depression.
Speaker:So, for, for anxiety it would be, you know, feeling worry and anxiety over
Speaker:most days for, for several weeks.
Speaker:You know, probably over, uh, you know, to a couple of months really.
Speaker:That's kind of, there often goes alongside, um, physical symptoms
Speaker:such as heart racings, sweaty palms, those kind of things.
Speaker:Um, so the, that kind of feeling, that protracted, constant feeling.
Speaker:And along alongside those physical feelings as well.
Speaker:Depression is a feeling of being low or a feeling of not really being able to enjoy
Speaker:things most days for at least two weeks.
Speaker:Um, and often depression also affects both the way that we see the world.
Speaker:So we tend to see the world through the opposite of rose tinted glasses.
Speaker:So we tend to see the world as viewing us as worthless, we might feel guilty,
Speaker:uh, we might lose our optimism.
Speaker:Uh, we might feel hopeless, you know, um, thoughts that, um, actually I
Speaker:might better, the world might be better off if I wasn't here, or I
Speaker:might be better if I wasn't here, quite common within depression.
Speaker:Um, so they're the feelings.
Speaker:But the other, the other kind of hard signs, uh, to look
Speaker:out for are physical signs.
Speaker:So people's sleep goes off.
Speaker:There's a change in their appetite either reducing or increasing.
Speaker:People often feel worse in the mornings.
Speaker:Um, there's a lack, lack of energy.
Speaker:So there's the, the, those are kind of key, key signs to look for for depression.
Speaker:As I say, you only really need those signs for most days, for a few weeks and at
Speaker:that stage, I, I would start to wonder if I'm depressed and, um, and I might seek
Speaker:further advice and treatment for that.
Speaker:It doesn't help to ignore those for too long.
Speaker:And, and if talking therapy was the first step.
Speaker:There are some screening tools available free on the, um, on the web.
Speaker:Um, and I link to them in the book as well, but anyone can find them.
Speaker:The PHQ9, for depression, really good screening tool, very simple to use.
Speaker:And the GAD7 is for anxiety.
Speaker:So if you are thinking, oh, am I tipping into anxiety or depression,
Speaker:just do one of those and you'll get a score and that score will give you,
Speaker:um, some advice about what to do next.
Speaker:That's really, really helpful.
Speaker:We also provide a free toolkit called, Am I Stressed, Overwhelmed or Burnt Out?
Speaker:And it contains all the burnout, uh, free inventories as well.
Speaker:But what I might do is add into that the GAD7 and the PHQ9 that people can
Speaker:access just to make sure, and obviously getting your book would be really good.
Speaker:As you said that I'm thinking, well, gosh, it's actually very difficult
Speaker:to tell because you get fatigue and burnout, you get fatigue and depression.
Speaker:You get this sort of cynicism, don't you, an emotional detachment in burnout,
Speaker:and then you get this hopelessness in depression, which is probably why
Speaker:it's so important to actually seek professional help because they'll be
Speaker:able to sort of tease it out and, and work out what's really going on for you.
Speaker:Yes, and it is important, it's teased out because, burnout is different from,
Speaker:um, from anxiety and depression, and, and we'd use a different approach.
Speaker:So I, you know, for example, I wouldn't consider antidepressants in burnout.
Speaker:But if, uh, a talking therapy hasn't resolved a depression or anxiety, or it's
Speaker:very severe, then it's worth considering.
Speaker:I think if you're getting, if you're wondering if you're depressed and you're
Speaker:getting those physical symptoms, so your sleep's going off, your appetite's going
Speaker:off, you might be losing weight, you are got a, an awful lot of kind of fatigue,
Speaker:especially in the mornings, it might push you a little bit more to, to, to
Speaker:thinking I'm, this might have tipped into depression, but once again, depression,
Speaker:anxiety, really easily treated, so don't worry, you know, just come fu for help.
Speaker:And a lot of the treatments are very similar to the treatments
Speaker:of burnout, aren't they?
Speaker:Which is which, which is good news, which is really good news, which
Speaker:shows why it's so important, go.
Speaker:This might be again, talking about some of these talking therapies, but
Speaker:there's a chapter in your book all about what we bring to the table,
Speaker:which I, I found fascinating because we know that not all burnout is the same.
Speaker:Um, as Paula Redmond said that there's different causes.
Speaker:It might be due to moral injury or it might be due to just pure
Speaker:work overload, or it might be due to sort of under confidence in
Speaker:ourselves and things like that.
Speaker:So what other things are these sort of, could be some of the underlying causes?
Speaker:I know you mentioned attachment theory and then there's moral
Speaker:injury and, and things like that.
Speaker:But what do you typically see in your, some of your patients?
Speaker:so I'm, I'm gonna start this with a kind of warning, which is I firmly
Speaker:believe when I'm meeting people in my clinic that they've burnt out
Speaker:because of some change in the system.
Speaker:So, you know, whatever their personalities or coping systems are, they've often
Speaker:been doing perfectly fine for many years, and then something's changed.
Speaker:So it's not the cause of burnout.
Speaker:Um, so I want to be that, but we do see some, some things.
Speaker:So Herbert Freudenberger, who I mentioned, who was the, the,
Speaker:the wonderful psychoanalyst who first coined the term burnout.
Speaker:One of the first terms he toyed with around burnout was super achiever
Speaker:syndrome, and, and the reason he did that is because he said there are some
Speaker:people who are really dedicated, work really hard, really want to make a
Speaker:difference, and for them they will, they will work very hard, they'll try and do
Speaker:a lot at home, they won't necessarily reach out for support, and that is a
Speaker:group that are vulnerable for burnout.
Speaker:And the group that are vulnerable for burnout in the NHSI think because
Speaker:I think our organizations take advantage of those super achievers.
Speaker:So I'm utterly amazed when I meet healthcare professionals who are
Speaker:allowed to work ridiculous hours, allowed to wear too many hats.
Speaker:These are super achievers and, and they've been allowed by
Speaker:their organization to burn out.
Speaker:And I kind of think, you know, how did the organization
Speaker:think this was gonna turn out?
Speaker:What did they think was gonna happen here?
Speaker:Um, but, but that happened.
Speaker:So, so there is this idea.
Speaker:The other thing I think is really interesting, and then I'll move on to
Speaker:attachment is there's a double edged sword in, um, high performing professionals.
Speaker:So, high performing professionals tend to be conscientious, they
Speaker:tend to be determined, and they tend to be quite outgoing.
Speaker:Not always, but they tend to be.
Speaker:Now that's good, you know, that, that they're the sort of
Speaker:people you wanna accrue often.
Speaker:But under pressure, those same characteristics can become
Speaker:a kind of achilles heel.
Speaker:So your conscientiousness can become perfectionism.
Speaker:Your determination can become obsessionality and your, um,
Speaker:outgoingness can become kind of a little bit of narcissism, so you stop
Speaker:listening to people stop taking advice.
Speaker:So, so it, it's interesting that the things that make us really good at our
Speaker:job under stress can also get in the way of us doing our job really well.
Speaker:And, and then the final thing I'll talk about is attachment theory,
Speaker:um, which is, um, something I'm interested in for various reasons.
Speaker:But, uh, one things that I tend to see in doctors particularly, but other, uh, you
Speaker:know, other high level professions, uh, you know, I've seen lawyers like this is
Speaker:a couple of typical attachment patterns.
Speaker:One is a dismissive attachment pattern where we play down our
Speaker:emotions and our relationships.
Speaker:So this is the, the doctor who just kind of, keeps a, stiff upper
Speaker:lip and just gets on with it, just kind of, um, uh, manages things.
Speaker:Often very effective, but the problem is with this, is this doctor isn't
Speaker:necessarily processing their emotions.
Speaker:So there's an emotional impact of work, but they're just getting on
Speaker:with it, going from one thing to another, dismissing their emotions, and
Speaker:eventually that can catch up with you.
Speaker:The other attachment style I tend to see in medics, but less common than dismissive
Speaker:one, but it's there, it's a preoccupied attachment style, which are these medics
Speaker:who are the opposite of dismissive, they really, really prioritize emotions
Speaker:and they prioritize relationships.
Speaker:So, uh, a typical warning sign for a medic that I meet with this is they
Speaker:tell me they've never had a complaint.
Speaker:So these are the, these are these wonderful medics who keep everyone happy.
Speaker:And that is, that is great, that's great, but it takes a big emotional toll
Speaker:doing that and keeping everyone happy.
Speaker:And what these medics can do is they tend to neglect their own needs in
Speaker:the ear by prioritizing the other.
Speaker:So attachment's very interesting.
Speaker:Um.
Speaker:Um, I also think it's interesting because, um, if we recognize we're one
Speaker:of those attachment styles, it might inform what sort of therapy we want.
Speaker:So if we're dismissive, um, don't really do emotions, we might be attracted to
Speaker:CBT, let's, let's get our thinking right.
Speaker:But what we might more benefit from is a relational type therapy
Speaker:where we can actually look at our relationships and things like
Speaker:that and how we process emotions.
Speaker:And similarly, um, people who are preoccupied really in touch with
Speaker:emotions often think, well, I want a relationship therapy, I want to do
Speaker:something where I can think about my emotions, whereas actually, they might
Speaker:be, might be more beneficial from CBT because what they might benefit is
Speaker:a more structured approach that that helps them kind of prioritize their
Speaker:self-care and helps them kind of order their thinking and their relationships.
Speaker:So i, I think it's really interesting.
Speaker:That is really interesting.
Speaker:I, I re remember reading about that in your book actually, and thinking,
Speaker:gosh, I'm the sort of person, I'm an Enneagram seven, so I'm like, I like,
Speaker:don't like to feel difficult, but just like to move on and have fun.
Speaker:And actually, what I've been thinking for a while, actually, some therapy where
Speaker:you, I'm really looking, you can inter, you know, emotions, feelings, somatic,
Speaker:you know, where, where am I feeling that would be, would be really helpful rather
Speaker:than, yeah, just staying in your head and thinking it through, thinking it through.
Speaker:Just really quickly what, cause, what would have been the underlying
Speaker:cause of those two attachment styles?
Speaker:Yeah, well, a attachment tends to be, um, they, they, they tend to be styles that
Speaker:will develop from, um, that will, will start to develop from, from childhood.
Speaker:So most of us are securely attached.
Speaker:So, and, and most, most of most of the people I meet in my
Speaker:clinic are securely attached.
Speaker:But you might become dismissive of, uh, emotions and relationships if you are
Speaker:the sort of, uh, if from a young age you're kind of expected just to get on
Speaker:with it, perhaps not talk about emotions, and perhaps look after someone else.
Speaker:There's quite a lot of medics who've kind of been in a care
Speaker:role from quite a young age.
Speaker:And, and so they might need to, to have put their needs to one
Speaker:side, uh, and just get on, get on with it and, and manage things.
Speaker:And, and that could lead to a dismissive attachment style.
Speaker:We also train people, you talked about, you know, what we're doing in A levels
Speaker:and, uh, and, and med school and things.
Speaker:Unfortunately, we can sometimes train people to be dismissive.
Speaker:So we can train them just to get on with the next thing, you know,
Speaker:don't think about how you are feeling, just do the next exam or
Speaker:the next case, and things like that.
Speaker:So we, we can encourage that, unfortunately.
Speaker:Um, preoccupied people tend to be the children who, um, perhaps have been
Speaker:very sensitive, very caring for others.
Speaker:They, they again might have been in a caring role, but in a different way,
Speaker:they might need it to be particularly attuned to someone in their family
Speaker:and look after them in that way, so that, that might, might create,
Speaker:um, a preoccupied attachment style.
Speaker:But it's complicated, and some people might have features of both.
Speaker:So it's, uh, it, it's not, it's not always a straightforward thing.
Speaker:And that's probably where a skilled therapist would be really, really
Speaker:helpful to help you identify those underlying things, then
Speaker:what you can do about it, right?
Speaker:What was your top three tips be for someone who can recognize themselves
Speaker:on that plateau and thinks, oh, crumbs, okay, maybe I, I wanna do something right
Speaker:now before I get to that burnout cliff.
Speaker:Just the three, well, let's say rather than three top tips.
Speaker:'cause all your top tips are in the book, your three next actions.
Speaker:First thing is fantastic.
Speaker:They are thinking about what's going on.
Speaker:You know, have I got problem stress?
Speaker:Have I got burnout?
Speaker:So they've stopped fantastic and they've reflected.
Speaker:The next thing they should do is reach out for help, nip it in the bud.
Speaker:that could be to a support organization, you know, like NHS Practitioner Health,
Speaker:if you are a healthcare professional.
Speaker:Or it could be to a coach, or it could be just to friends and family.
Speaker:Let people know how you're feeling.
Speaker:You know, people often carry this alone and in silence, you know, don't do that.
Speaker:So stop and reflect, reach out for help.
Speaker:And the next thing is be hopeful and positive.
Speaker:Because actually, by reaching out for help, you will do incredibly well.
Speaker:People do incredibly well, they make amazing recoveries.
Speaker:And in fact, some people, quite a lot of people, if they have time to
Speaker:stop and reflect and recover, say, actually, I've developed through this.
Speaker:I feel different.
Speaker:I've made important changes and decisions, and my life feels more aligned now.
Speaker:So, be really hopeful.
Speaker:Coming through to help is a positive thing.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And that was another great chapter.
Speaker:Your book on sort of post burnout growth, posttraumatic growth.
Speaker:So actually often, yeah, the good news is that after a burnout, people
Speaker:can actually be a lot better, um, or feel a lot better than before.
Speaker:But you don't actually have to go through the whole massive
Speaker:burnout thing to get there.
Speaker:You can actually nip it in the bud and then be better, right?
Speaker:So let's avoid that massive dip, shall we?
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:that's right.
Speaker:Thank you so much, Rich.
Speaker:We'll have to get you back 'cause No doubt.
Speaker:We'll, we'll have lots more to talk about and if anyone's listening to
Speaker:this, you've Got questions for Richard, please just, just uh, email them in.
Speaker:And Richard, if we get some questions when you come back to answer them?
Speaker:Oh, I'd love to.
Speaker:That would be wonderful.
Speaker:And yeah, we would love to have you back and to talk about this more, 'cause it
Speaker:is, is such a big, big thing for doctors.
Speaker:Well, 50% of doctors working in burnout.
Speaker:So whether you're a doctor, dentist, nurse, other healthcare professional,
Speaker:we have accountants, lawyers and teachers as well, and I would think
Speaker:that their levels are pretty similar.
Speaker:But for me, the big revelation has been you might be in burnout but your
Speaker:performance is still okay at work, 'cause you're protected that, but the
Speaker:performance everywhere else is down and then suddenly you're gonna crash.
Speaker:So thank you so much for being here.
Speaker:If people want to get a hold of you, or find out more about the book, about
Speaker:you, about your work, where can they go?
Speaker:So yeah, well I haven't got a webpage, but I'm on LinkedIn.
Speaker:Always really happy to hear from people.
Speaker:So Richard Duggins and if people wanna know about the book or the
Speaker:audio book, all good bookshops.
Speaker:It's on Amazon too,
Speaker:And of course, if you are working in the NHS and you are eligible for Practitioner
Speaker:Health, it's a fantastic organization.
Speaker:Rich, can you just remind us who, who it serves?
Speaker:So it serves any healthcare professional who finds it, is finding it difficult
Speaker:to get confidential local support.
Speaker:So that's every doctor and every dentist in the NHS, can come through or it's
Speaker:any health professional who's who hasn't got local confidential support.
Speaker:So do get in touch with Practitioner Health and if you, you're not in the
Speaker:UK or you can't access that, there will be other ways for you to get h help.
Speaker:It might just take five minutes of digging around and, and Googling.
Speaker:So employee assistance program, your own GP, your family practitioner.
Speaker:Please, please don't struggle on alone, even if it's just
Speaker:telling a colleague about it.
Speaker:So, thank you Richard.
Speaker:Um, and hopefully speak again soon.
Speaker:Great.
Speaker:Thanks so much, Rachel.
Speaker:Thanks for listening.
Speaker:Don't forget, you can get extra bonus episodes and audio courses along with
Speaker:unlimited access to our library of videos and CPD workbooks by joining
Speaker:FrogXtra and FrogXtra Gold, our memberships to help busy professionals
Speaker:like you beat burnout and work happier.
Speaker:Find out more at youarenotafrog.com/members.