Have faith.
Speaker AHave faith.
Speaker ABelieve in your source.
Speaker BHave faith.
Speaker AI refer often to Martin Luther King in the context of the civil rights movement.
Speaker AHe said.
Speaker AHe said, I have no plan for the tranquilizing drugs, for the tranquilizing drum of gradualism and incrementalism.
Speaker AHave faith.
Speaker ABelieve in the source.
Speaker AHave faith.
Speaker AHere's another episode of Macaron Cheese with your host, Steve Grumby.
Speaker BAll right, folks, this is Steve with Macaron Cheese.
Speaker BFolks, it's been a hot minute.
Speaker BAnd when I say a hot minute, I'm talking about maybe more than a year, maybe two years since we have my next guest on.
Speaker BAnd my next guest is somebody who I did an awful lot of work with, the New Untouchables and several other podcasts about elite control fraud and the history of some of the insanity that goes into the financial regulations in this country and the history of those regulations.
Speaker BAnd, folks, Bill Black is just an absolute gunslinger when it comes to getting things done.
Speaker BHe doesn't mince words, and I'm really, really happy to have him on.
Speaker BWe've talked about the unstable genius act with Bob Hockett here a few episodes ago, and there's still more meat on the bone we got to talk about.
Speaker BAnd we're going to really talk about some of the motivations and some of the things that really caught my eye about why in the world will we give a rat's patootie about cryptocurrency in terms of the government backing it and so forth.
Speaker BAnd just when you think that it's some great, wonderful win for the LOL bergarians, you realize in the end that there's always a hegemonic reason for it.
Speaker BWe're going to uncover some of those things here.
Speaker BBill is a distinguished scholar in residence for Financial regulation at the University of Minnesota School of Law.
Speaker BAnd let me just say William K. Black, you probably have heard of him a few times, definitely from us anyway, and I'm very excited to have him back on.
Speaker BBill, welcome back to the show, sir.
Speaker AThank you.
Speaker AIt's great to be back.
Speaker BAbsolutely.
Speaker BAnd folks, if you guys skip Macro and Chill, shame on you.
Speaker BWe need folks like you out there that are in the know already, that understand modern monetary theory, understand the legal, and so forth.
Speaker BFolks, we're building community out there, and we need to talk through this stuff with people that maybe are just getting exposed the first time.
Speaker BDon't assume somebody else is going to show up and do it.
Speaker BYou come, please.
Speaker BJust like Bill did.
Speaker BHe shows up at Macro and Chill and everybody about dropped the mic, they were like, oh, my goodness, we have a celebrity in house here.
Speaker BIt was really nice.
Speaker BI mean, only partially joking on that.
Speaker BIt really was wonderful to have you come, man.
Speaker BI appreciate it immensely.
Speaker AOh, it was great.
Speaker AYou had one of our alums doing our thing as well.
Speaker ASo we support you and we support UMKC and everybody in the community that works on these issues.
Speaker BIt was absolutely wonderful, and I'm so glad we have you back on.
Speaker BLet's get to the meat of the thing here.
Speaker BThis crypto stuff, it fits a very interesting profile.
Speaker BAnd remembering how you broke down Gresham's Law and you talked very much about the idea of elite control fraud with the mortgage crisis, here we are once again with another financial kind of black market product.
Speaker BAnd once again, we're dealing with fraud and we're dealing with a whole bunch of other things.
Speaker BAnd this time, quite frankly, purely state sponsored.
Speaker BCan you kind of set the stage?
Speaker BI know you're teaching this stuff at University of Minnesota.
Speaker BTell me a little bit about this whole idea of control fraud within the crypto space.
Speaker ASure.
Speaker AControl fraud includes the government, by the way.
Speaker AIt's both the sectors and they most typically work together.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AIn both cases, the people that control a seemingly legitimate either government or business entity.
Speaker AAnd by the way, it can be done from nonprofits as well.
Speaker AThey use it as camouflage and a sword and a shield to defraud with very substantial impunity.
Speaker AAnd in the case that we're currently looking at, of course, almost total impunity.
Speaker ADonald Trump was always somewhere between a C minus and a D plus as a control fraud guy.
Speaker ANot very sophisticated, not particularly successful because he's crushingly stupid.
Speaker ABut that doesn't mean that the grifters around him, the robber barons, are stupid.
Speaker AThey're not.
Speaker AAnd so he is the useful idiot and they'll make him rich for the first time.
Speaker ATrump always wanted to be a billionaire and never was before the corruption.
Speaker AAnd this was sort of his gateway drug, right?
Speaker AWas the sovereign wealth funds.
Speaker ABut he saw his son in law get the billions, Right.
Speaker AJared Kushner, who knows nothing about finance, was hired to be the financial advisor of this massive Saudi sovereign wealth fund.
Speaker BOh, my.
Speaker AAnd they actually have a committee, you know, of experts that is supposed to prevent this.
Speaker AAnd they said, no, do not do this.
Speaker AAnd of course, it's Saudi Arabia or the, in the modern era, the United States.
Speaker AWhat the experts have to say, you know, real experts has absolutely nothing to do with it.
Speaker ASo they just walked right through it, gave Kushner billions of dollars in his portfolio to invest for them and such.
Speaker AAnd Trump immediately had son in law envy.
Speaker AHe came back around this time and this time pretty clearly he doesn't run the thing.
Speaker AYou know, it's Stephen Miller and Besant and the folks at OMB and such that do these things.
Speaker ASo the old guard he had the first term actually would say no to him.
Speaker ANo, we will not shoot the protesters.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker AThat's a wrong and B, a crime.
Speaker AAnd you know, they would have resigned instantly and blasted it if he had tried to do so.
Speaker ABut the folks that use Trump as their useful idiot realize that the ultimate, the absolute paramount form of control fraud is President of the United States of America.
Speaker AAnd they set about optimizing it as soon as they got in power.
Speaker ARemember all those executive orders and things that Trump would sign?
Speaker AHe had no idea what was in them.
Speaker AOh, yes, he turned to Stephen Miller and say, what's this Stephen?
Speaker AAnd Stephen would give some bullshit and Trump would do that signature that looks a whole lot like that, you know, that birthday card, but that must be a mistake and such.
Speaker ASo immediately with the Trump administration, what did they do?
Speaker AWhat were their top priorities?
Speaker AAmong their very first acts was to say, we will no longer enforce the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act.
Speaker ANow this is an act that says, no, it's not okay to bribe public officials in other countries.
Speaker BOh, my God.
Speaker AIt's actually a crime.
Speaker AAnd Trump is way back in time, long before he even was talking about the presidency, of how we shouldn't have a Foreign Corrupt Practices Act.
Speaker AThat was stupid.
Speaker AOf course you should be able to bribe people.
Speaker AIt's good for business.
Speaker AAnd if you think that's bad, the New York Bar association took the same position.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker ABecause they were the commercial lawyers for all the firms that were bribing folks all over the world.
Speaker AAnd in fact, the Foreign Corrupt Practices act has been an amazing success.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BWow.
Speaker AI'm not that it's ended corruption, but it has actually done an enormous amount.
Speaker AAnd it wasn't just Trump that made fun of it originally.
Speaker AIt was most everybody liked Trump.
Speaker ASo all the robber barons who controlled, you know, like the German government and such, and they made fun of the US but you know what?
Speaker AThey've all adopted their own version of it.
Speaker ASo we got to get rid of enforcement of that because, well, first they could go after my son in law.
Speaker AOh, on his grift.
Speaker BKushner Law.
Speaker AYes, the Kushner cushion shot the third rail.
Speaker ABut better yet, I'm back in.
Speaker AI never expected to be back in as president I'm back in.
Speaker AAnd this time around, I ain't gonna leave it to my son in law, baby.
Speaker AThey're gonna come and give me the money.
Speaker AAnd everybody knows the game plan, except the Democratic leadership pretends it doesn't.
Speaker AAnd the mainstream media pretends they don't understand this.
Speaker BI'm so glad you said pretend, by the way, because it's kayfabe.
Speaker BIt is 100% WWE wrestling.
Speaker BYes, keep going.
Speaker BI just.
Speaker AYes, yes, absolutely.
Speaker AAnd indeed, I've always talked in the past about how control frauds, the art of it is this camouflage, this seeming respectability, but that's when there's a risk of prosecution, when you are the ultimate version of La Cosa Nostra.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AOur thing now is the United States and leveraging its power to make money all over the world and to hurt people that we hate.
Speaker AAnd boy, you know, as he says, he hates lots of folks.
Speaker BYes, he does.
Speaker AAnd he wishes them ill. And he wants to use the government as a weapon to hurt people because they're honest, because they're moral.
Speaker BJesus.
Speaker ABecause they stand up to him.
Speaker AAnd of course, it also serves the purpose of intimidating folks.
Speaker AAnd this is the whole thing about surrendering in advance that people rightly say you need to resist as you descend into a totalitarian government.
Speaker ASo right away, these sovereign wealth funds started doing deals with him and his sons.
Speaker BJesus.
Speaker BGod.
Speaker AAnd these are huge deals.
Speaker ASo what I've realized is there's like a final stage of elite control fraud, which is where you don't hide it.
Speaker AAnd the reason you don't hide it is you want everyone to know that you're corrupt.
Speaker AAnd you want it for two reasons.
Speaker AOne, it's free advertising, right?
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AThere ain't nobody so stupid that they haven't figured out that they can solve any problem in the United States if they give enough money to the Trump family.
Speaker AAnd.
Speaker BInteresting.
Speaker BYes.
Speaker AThe ultimate taco trade.
Speaker BWow.
Speaker ASecond, you create a price war that ratchets up.
Speaker AWell, you know, the Kuwaitis gave me 2 billion and a hotel site.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker BWow.
Speaker AAnd now he's even going further and extorting other nations.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AAnd says there's got to be something in this off book.
Speaker ARight?
Speaker ARight.
Speaker ASo, you know, you got to create a fund.
Speaker AYou go, what are you talking about?
Speaker AWe're doing trade deals.
Speaker AWe're talking about tariff reduction.
Speaker ANo, no, no, no, no.
Speaker AI want a fund.
Speaker BYes.
Speaker ASo he wants sovereign wealth created by other nations.
Speaker AHe wants to use the threat of the US Military to extort the Japans and Koreas.
Speaker AAnd Canadas of the world and the EU to give him billions of dollars.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker AAnd he's doing it again in plain sight.
Speaker AHe doesn't hide it, he chortles.
Speaker AThese are his triumphs that he does.
Speaker APress conferences.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AHe even lies when they don't do it.
Speaker AHe says they didn't because again, it ratchets up the price.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker AAnd he knows he has complete impunity because in the second worst decision in the history of the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court said, knowing.
Speaker AKnowing he was a crook, knowing he was a thug.
Speaker AThe Supreme Court said, yeah, you know what you need?
Speaker AImmunity.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker AExecutive immunity forever.
Speaker AIt isn't just that they can't try you while you're president.
Speaker AAfter you leave the presidency, you have immunity, which can include killing people who are your opponents.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker ASo remember the Supreme Court argument where they said, you know, this could mean assassinating your political opponent.
Speaker AThey should have said, you.
Speaker AYou know, this could mean assassinating you Supreme Court Justice.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AIf you don't vote the right way.
Speaker ABecause I guarantee you they knew it meant it.
Speaker BNow, didn't this happen during the Biden administration, though?
Speaker BWasn't this part of that?
Speaker BAnd then Biden didn't take advantage of the immunity to be able to go do things.
Speaker BAnd I'm just trying to place history of this.
Speaker AYeah, the decision comes down during the Biden administration because that's the only time you're going to have a case allowed to proceed against Trump.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker AHe certainly wasn't going to allow cases to proceed.
Speaker AOkay, so now we have this new world in which we want to scream the corruption and strut like we make our bribes, trophies.
Speaker ANow you have to come and like a thousand years ago, bring gold, but really tacky gold, know, whorehouse style gold, which is now the Oval Office.
Speaker AIt's a bordello again, to advertise.
Speaker AYou see, this is what the Canadians refused to give me, so I went elsewhere.
Speaker BOh, my God.
Speaker AHere's what.
Speaker ALook what Italy did.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker ALook at this one I got from the king.
Speaker AEngland.
Speaker AIt's just like trophies of prostitute in chief of the United States of America.
Speaker BA little like Dexter, huh?
Speaker BYou know, the kill trophies you got, the blood splatter.
Speaker BAnd yet.
Speaker BAnyway, I. I love Dexter.
Speaker BIt just reminded me of the most recent season of resurrection, where all the different serial killers and all their different trophies were on display.
Speaker BAnd this just fits right in there, doesn't it?
Speaker BI mean, just deep different, but the same.
Speaker BIt really is.
Speaker BThat's disgusting and gross and.
Speaker AWell, but again, it's free advertising.
Speaker AAnd it's raising the stakes.
Speaker AYou got to come up with more gold than the last guy.
Speaker BWow.
Speaker AYou get a favorable mention and favorable treatment for a day or two type of thing.
Speaker AOkay, so in this world, what would we want to do in addition to getting rid of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act?
Speaker ABecause we want them to come and bribe us.
Speaker BYeah, exactly.
Speaker AYou got that one.
Speaker AThat was easy.
Speaker AWe want to gut law enforcement that actually potentially deals with elite white collar crime.
Speaker AAnd again, what people need to know is that there are roughly a million Americans employed in the law enforcement nationwide.
Speaker ABallparkish right.
Speaker AOf those, what used to be about 1200 now when he started the term, maybe about 800, actually looked at white collar crime.
Speaker AThat's for the entire nation.
Speaker AWe have over a thousand industries in the United States, so we had fewer than one per industry by the pretty much the start of this term.
Speaker AWhat's the first thing?
Speaker BIt's good underfund under resource, you name it.
Speaker BRight, Right.
Speaker ABut now we get rid of all of those folks as well.
Speaker BJesus.
Speaker AAmong the first thing he does is bring in this incredible dag, that's a deputy assistant General.
Speaker AAnd Kuhn and I, June Carbone, my spouse, were both Justice Department attorneys as part of our career in the Federal programs branch of the Civil Division that defends the constitutionality of federal programs and such.
Speaker ASo the DAG is actually the most powerful person in the Justice Department.
Speaker AThe Attorney General is a more of a figurehead that gives speeches.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker ABut the DAG is actually does the stuff.
Speaker AAnd the dag, of course, is a really distinguished thing until Trump, where it's actually.
Speaker AIt's his personal defense lawyer, Jiminy Christmas, in charge of keeping him out of prison, which it says function.
Speaker ANow.
Speaker ASo this is the DAG that went over and did that incredible quote unquote interview playing Maxwell, where as to give credit, this was actually pointed out on msnbc.
Speaker AThe transcript isn't a real transcript because it doesn't include laughter and there's a tape recording.
Speaker AAnd this moron was repeatedly laughing with her.
Speaker BJesus.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AA pedophile ring where she was actually like the person that did much of the dirty work.
Speaker AAnd he was just having the jolliest time.
Speaker ABut he was smart enough to realize it wouldn't look good to have bracket laughter close bracket a hundred times.
Speaker BWow.
Speaker ASo that's our dag.
Speaker BWow.
Speaker AWho again is just here.
Speaker ASo he's already dramatically reduced.
Speaker AThe guidance is you really shouldn't be going after elite white collar criminals.
Speaker AThe government has been oppressive.
Speaker AWe've had way too Much prosecution of elite white collar criminals.
Speaker AAnd you go, what?
Speaker AWow.
Speaker AWe virtually ceased.
Speaker AWe did.
Speaker AWe completely ceased prosecuting them in the great financial crisis, the greatest epidemic of elite by color crime, pre Trump presidency, to be more precise.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker AAnd he says that's not enough.
Speaker ASomebody occasionally still investigated, God forbid.
Speaker ASo they also, if you noticed, have gutted the FBI.
Speaker BWow.
Speaker AAnd in particular, to get rid of anyone who isn't a complete yes man.
Speaker ALet me load a foot down, by the way.
Speaker AAnd Trump is always raving about the FBI and their terrible leftists and such.
Speaker AThey're all overwhelmingly right wing.
Speaker AI dealt with the FBI all the time.
Speaker AThey're ex military, they're Latter Day Saints, they're deeply conservative Republicans.
Speaker AThat didn't mean they were bad people or bad investigators.
Speaker ABut the idea that this is a cabal of leftists.
Speaker BKind of hilarious.
Speaker BYes.
Speaker AOkay, so he's already didn't have that much to worry about it, but he's made sure by his appointments, by gutting the Department of Justice, gutting the FBI, and in particular getting rid of anyone unwilling to kiss the ring he has produced.
Speaker AHe has destroyed our ability that was built up over 40 years to prosecute elite crimes, where as bad as we were in many environments, we were still by far the best in the world.
Speaker AEven under Trump, we were the best in the world.
Speaker AThat's how bad the rest of the world is in all those regards.
Speaker AOkay, so we're going to gut that kind of enforcement.
Speaker AWhat else are we going to do?
Speaker AOh, we're going to say when you do in the rare cases, look, you shouldn't really prosecute folks.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AYou should sign an agreement that says you won't do bad things.
Speaker BSternly worded agreement, huh?
Speaker ANo, no.
Speaker AThey wanted to get rid of the sternly worded ones because.
Speaker BWow.
Speaker BSo it's a gentleman's agreement now.
Speaker AYou're right.
Speaker ANo.
Speaker AThey used to have a monitor requirement.
Speaker AOh, my.
Speaker AThat you couldn't just say, yes, I will be pure and wonderful and I will turn over a new leaf.
Speaker ASomeone actually was supposed to kick the tires and was in charge of that and occasionally did.
Speaker AThat's gone.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker AAll you have to do is say, oh, yes.
Speaker AAnd we go, oh.
Speaker AIn the new Trump administration.
Speaker AWell, thank you.
Speaker AWe're so sorry we bothered you by pointing out that you were committing these crimes.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AAnd they've also rejiggered the whole.
Speaker AWhen they do any corruption stuff, it's only if it really hurts your business.
Speaker BWow.
Speaker ABut of course, the bribes usually help your business, so they're not going to prosecute that kind of stuff.
Speaker AOkay, what else?
Speaker ABoth parties in the run up to this latest presidential election went enormously in terms of crypto money.
Speaker ANow, this got masked by musk.
Speaker BOh, yeah.
Speaker AThese famous contributions.
Speaker ABut for the great bulk of the cycle, and all the early money, which is critical in politics, more than half of it, it looks like, to both parties, came from crypto.
Speaker AJust crypto.
Speaker AThey give far more than the Koch brothers.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker AAnd the Coke brothers are rightfully infamous.
Speaker BYes.
Speaker ASo this is, again, your metaphor.
Speaker AIt's on steroids.
Speaker AThis is like coke amped.
Speaker AGee, that works.
Speaker AThat'd be the other alternative spelling of coke.
Speaker BYeah, right.
Speaker BOh, my God.
Speaker AAnd when Pamela came in, she announced a reappraisal, a rejiggering, and they began heavily taking crypto money as well.
Speaker ABut the crypto folks specifically targeted, Gee, I don't know.
Speaker AOhio Senate race and one where Tester was running Montana, I think, at Sherrod, Brown and Tester.
Speaker ASo they found these two vulnerable Democrats in red states and help ensure their demise with their very large contributions.
Speaker ASo it was super targeted.
Speaker AAnd I know this will shock you, because I know, like me, when you think of honor and strength and the willingness to speak truth to power, you think of the Democratic congressional leadership.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker ASo Schumer said publicly.
Speaker AOh, yes.
Speaker AWe are now all in support of crypto.
Speaker AOh, really?
Speaker BFrom Zionism to crypto, you can count on the Democrats to be on the right side of things.
Speaker BYou got it?
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AThe phrase they used to use in reverse, you know, never miss an opportunity.
Speaker ATo miss an opportunity.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BWhat's that saying?
Speaker BIt's hard to get somebody to do something that their paycheck depends upon not doing.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BI mean, these guys right here.
Speaker BArk, I'll just be honest with you, man.
Speaker BI am.
Speaker BI don't call myself a cynic because I don't believe that's the case.
Speaker BI believe that we are so far beyond the pale of a legitimate people.
Speaker BOf the people.
Speaker BWe the people, quote, unquote, democracy.
Speaker BThat the oligarchy is outrageously large and in charge and in your face.
Speaker BAnd both sides are saying, yeah, you know, we're not even going to hide it anymore.
Speaker BWe're not even going to pretend.
Speaker BAnd so when I hear this stuff, I always try to assess it through who's winning.
Speaker BAnd it ain't we the people.
Speaker BIt ain't the working class.
Speaker BIt ain't people that depend on a paycheck.
Speaker BIt is definitely the other side of the coin.
Speaker BPeople that live a life that I will never Even dream of understanding.
Speaker BAnd it is coming at a great price for the average family, the average person, et cetera.
Speaker BWe are watching ICE raid apartment buildings with impunity.
Speaker BPeople thrown to the ground, hurt jackbooted thugs taking down people.
Speaker BPeople that are selling out their brothers and sisters for a buck.
Speaker ABut that's okay because they self identify as Christians.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BYou know, and this is the most.
Speaker AChristian thing I can imagine.
Speaker BLet me speak to that momentary because this is very near and dear to my heart.
Speaker BOne of the important things.
Speaker BI'm a recovering drunk.
Speaker BOkay.
Speaker BNext year will be 20 years without a drink.
Speaker BSo I'm really one day at a time in it and all that good stuff.
Speaker BBut I became a Christian when I started recovering.
Speaker BNow I didn't become Republican Jesus worshiper.
Speaker BI was a grace and mercy kind of guy.
Speaker BI was somebody who didn't feel that I deserved the second chance.
Speaker BI was trash, street trash, homeless, at times a derelict.
Speaker BSo for me that means something very different.
Speaker BAnd to see it bastardized into this immigrant hating kind of just hate mongering.
Speaker BLet me break out my assault weapon to kill people because they stepped on my.
Speaker BThere's none of that whole tie a millstone around your neck if you mislead one of my little ones.
Speaker BThere's no he without sin cast the first stone.
Speaker BThere's just a whole bunch of weird, bizarre rhetoric masking itself as Jesus that isn't anything to do with the red letters.
Speaker BAnd if you're not a Christian, forgive me for speaking this way, but I am not going to give up my faith just so that the right wing can take it.
Speaker BI'm just saying that out for anybody that's listening.
Speaker BI that's not the way it is.
Speaker BThat's the way they are, but that's not the way it is.
Speaker BAnd it's really brutally gross to see the perversion of that faith twisted this way for us.
Speaker AAnd when I say us, I mean June and I.
Speaker AOne of the former Southern Baptist leaders, very conservative guy who's been cast aside because he wasn't willing to pervert Christianity into this hellscape.
Speaker ABut what he's the vignettes that are so telling to us is that he says that pastor after pastor he's spoken to have had members of their congregation come to them in the last two years and say, why are you in the sermon doing all that woke shit.
Speaker BYep.
Speaker AI'm quoting Jesus.
Speaker BYep.
Speaker AAnd I said, we don't like that part.
Speaker BI want to throw this at you, my children.
Speaker BWe used to go to a church I used to live in the Beltway, man.
Speaker BI was part of the Beltway blitz, right?
Speaker BAnd we used to go to a place called McLean Bible Church.
Speaker BAnd McLean is a huge mega church.
Speaker BJoe Gibbs would go there.
Speaker BI actually sat behind Kenneth Starr at church, if you can imagine.
Speaker BOkay.
Speaker BLiterally right during the time where he, you know, had gone after Bill Clinton, I was sitting there in church behind him.
Speaker BNow you know my story.
Speaker BI came from a Republican background, so this is not shocking.
Speaker BBut what is shocking is many, many years later, Lon Solomon, who was the pastor there, you know, he retired and the new guy that took over, quote, unquote, was doing the woke shit.
Speaker BAnd so there was this huge legal battle and fight about Lon Solomon, who was very much a Zionist and much a MAGA kind of guy.
Speaker BAnd the entire rupture in that church and that church had 30,000 plus members.
Speaker BI really found it to be great.
Speaker BFor the longest time, it was very, very not political.
Speaker BYou didn't feel the politics.
Speaker BYou didn't see the politics.
Speaker BIt was very, very beginner friendly.
Speaker BYou know, for a guy in recovery, it was great, Right?
Speaker BBut it has totally.
Speaker BI mean, like, somebody can look it up.
Speaker BBut this whole rupture at McLean Bible Church was wild.
Speaker BIt was in the news.
Speaker AHuge deal.
Speaker BAnyway, I just wanted to throw that out there because this whole woke thing is exactly what's killing it.
Speaker ATwo things about Ken Starr.
Speaker ATwo stories.
Speaker BYep.
Speaker AOne, his dad was a minister and he infamously used a sermon to denounce a parishioner, a woman, a married woman, who in the backyard, which was not visible from the street, was so brazen that she was cutting the grass in shorts.
Speaker AYes, I knew you would understand.
Speaker BOh, my goodness.
Speaker AAnd second, when Ken Starr eventually ended up top guy at a major Texas university and people came and said, we're violating the consent decree with the NCAA and continuing to pay off the people to lie and such.
Speaker AAnd that blew up again.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker AYou are listening to Macro N Cheese, a podcast by Real Progressives.
Speaker AWe are a 501c3 nonprofit organization.
Speaker AAll donations are tax deductible.
Speaker APlease consider becoming a monthly donor on Patreon Substack or our website, realprogressives.org now back to the podcast.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker AWith those things in mind, back to the tale of how they're really going to optimize this time and how it's going to have multiple macro implications.
Speaker ASo, one, what I've always struggled with to get people to understand is it ain't just when the bubble collapses that there's an economic problem.
Speaker AThere's an economic problem the entire time a bubble is expanding because assets, particularly investments, are being systematically misallocated from any societal standpoint.
Speaker AAfterwards, you get the systemic shock, and that causes all kinds of incredible stuff as well.
Speaker ABut remember that title, perhaps, the Unbearable Likeness.
Speaker BYep.
Speaker AThat's what a bubble is.
Speaker BOkay.
Speaker AIt's just wonderful.
Speaker AEverything works.
Speaker AYou do stupid things, they work.
Speaker AYou do more stupid things, it works brilliantly.
Speaker AYou think you're a genius, and so you do more and more and more stupid things more and more rapidly.
Speaker AOn top of that, when bubbles crash, for reasons that I'll defer to other talks, but systemic risk is a really big deal in terms of how terrible it is.
Speaker AAnd it isn't just terrible in a macro sense.
Speaker AIt redistributes income horrifically, and it reduces growth enormously.
Speaker AThe best estimate of the great financial crisis, of the growth reduction because of that episode of epidemic fraud, the present value is $41.7 trillion.
Speaker AThat's actually the present value about seven years ago.
Speaker ASo it would be bigger now.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BOh, my.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker ASo staggering.
Speaker AThese things are staggeringly big.
Speaker AYou don't leave stuff.
Speaker ASo this is where I diverge maybe a little from at least how some of the people are interpreting some of the things Randy Ray says.
Speaker AI get it, that if Trump does something as a policy that isn't necessarily stupid under macro, if it's under mmt, if it's done intelligently, we should still criticize it because it's not being done intelligently and it will cause enormous harm.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AWhether or not Trump is right about the interest rate in any given time, he will produce evil.
Speaker BYes.
Speaker AAnd he is doing it to produce evil.
Speaker AAnd so it may be perfectly appropriate in this context to say, no, he's about to do terrible things with that fiscal capacity that is going to destroy democracy.
Speaker AAnd, you know, he now uses the government openly as a weapon.
Speaker AIndeed, as of five, four days ago or whatever, three days, I guess it is, he is now openly saying that he is delighted with the government shutdown so that he can use the government as a weapon and that he will selectively go against any state that had the temerity, a majority of its voters to vote against him.
Speaker AWow, they should be punished.
Speaker AI mean, think of how outrageous that is, and think of whatever percentage it is of Americans that are going, yeah, that's a great idea.
Speaker AHot damn.
Speaker AScrew those folks.
Speaker AEspecially right after, you know, the Kirk stuff and such about how one should never glory in the evil done to others.
Speaker AOkay, so that's what's coming.
Speaker AThey're going to produce all kinds of bubbles.
Speaker ASo, very briefly, the cryptocurrencies have no basis for value.
Speaker AThat doesn't mean that they won't trade at times for value or that they won't have substantial price appreciation.
Speaker ABut it does mean that they are some variant of pump, certainly.
Speaker AAnd most of them end up in dumps.
Speaker AThat's what rug pulls are and such.
Speaker AYou know, that's Argentina.
Speaker AWhich, by the way, we are bailing.
Speaker BI know.
Speaker BIsn't that insane?
Speaker ATaking somebody because he likes chiefs of state who are corrupt Milie and who defraud people through crypto because that's his plan for America.
Speaker BYep.
Speaker BJesus, Flip.
Speaker ASo how do you get the price of crypto to surge?
Speaker AAnd how do you work the timing?
Speaker AThis is simplicity itself under having the presidency and using it as he is in this term to time these events.
Speaker AYou want two things to make the price surge.
Speaker AOne, you want to dramatically reduce sales.
Speaker AYou don't want people to sell when crypto is falling because that will exacerbate the fall.
Speaker ADo you know hodl?
Speaker AIs that familiar?
Speaker BYep.
Speaker BIt's screwed up for Hold Hold, Hold Hold.
Speaker ALiterally just a mistyping of somebody.
Speaker ABut it's become their slogan.
Speaker AThey do hats and shirts and such, and they've even created a phrase, hold on for dear life.
Speaker ABut that's after the fact.
Speaker AAs you say, it was just a typing error.
Speaker BYep.
Speaker AAnd this is where economists are so blind.
Speaker AThey never study anthropology or psychology.
Speaker BCan I just jump in there for a minute?
Speaker BI want to make clear what you just said is so important.
Speaker BOkay.
Speaker BWe have led for almost a decade now and being activist level, MMT oriented organization, and we have strived to be targeted towards that.
Speaker BBut many of the MMT people that are learning it today didn't learn the intersectional interdisciplinary approach that the UMKC crew learned and taught.
Speaker BAnd the things that I cut my teeth on were far more than just ledgers.
Speaker BOkay?
Speaker BIt was a lot more than just freaking ledgers.
Speaker BAnd so when we talk about these things, there's a new crop of quote unquote, MMT ers out there.
Speaker BThey're like, I don't want to hear nothing about no class and I don't want to hear nothing about them.
Speaker BThat crypto stuff, I don't see how it's relevant to mmt.
Speaker BAnd I'm like, what are you doing?
Speaker BDid you think that I didn't learn?
Speaker BI talked to Warren Mosler and I talked to everyone.
Speaker BRandall Ray, Bill Mitchell.
Speaker BI had Stephanie, on.
Speaker BI've talked to all the second tiers with Fotl, Ava, Pavlina, all of them.
Speaker BI mean, like, inside and out.
Speaker ACall them Younger Generation, Next Generation.
Speaker BI don't mean secondaries, unlike their.
Speaker BLike the first, the OGs.
Speaker AI know exactly what you mean.
Speaker AExactly.
Speaker BThe Next Generation.
Speaker BThey're Star Trek, the Next Generation.
Speaker AIt was a friendly amendment, Steve.
Speaker BYes, but the idea that somehow or another people don't realize that if you're going to tell me that MMT matters, and MMT is a lens, you use a lens to analyze, and you analyze these things through an understanding of history, through an understanding of law, because money is a creature of law.
Speaker BAnd you understand it through a whole host of other things.
Speaker BThe things I learned from Ron Gray, specifically the idea of law as the core component.
Speaker BAnd when you think about hyperinflation and things like that, these are not things of.
Speaker BOh, they're just printing money.
Speaker BThis is stuff from elite corruption that causes hyperinflation.
Speaker BThis is stuff for supply sharks.
Speaker BYou've got to know more than ledgers for MMT to matter.
Speaker BAnd I'm telling you right now, there's a new crop out there that doesn't think those things matter.
Speaker BAnd it is deeply disturbing.
Speaker BAnd there's a rift.
Speaker BI ain't gonna lie.
Speaker BThere's a rift.
Speaker BAnyway, Go ahead.
Speaker BI'm sorry, I just had to throw that in there.
Speaker AWell, not at all, but that's exactly.
Speaker AI'm building on your point.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BYes.
Speaker AOr illustrating your point.
Speaker AAnd that is it does matter.
Speaker AAnd you have to have a culture arise to keep something like this alive.
Speaker BYes.
Speaker ABut now, one of the things that was destabilizing for bitcoin prices, of course, was the federal government, and not in the ways that MMT thinks about, typically, and certainly the people you talked about as, you know, third generation MMT folks, but for the following reason, which has to do with crime.
Speaker BYep.
Speaker AOne of the things Trump did immediately, again, or almost immediately upon resuming his presidency, was to say that we were no longer going to sell the crypto that we seized from Criminal Operations.
Speaker ADo you know this?
Speaker BI did not know this.
Speaker AAnd guess who the biggest governmental holder of crypto is as a result?
Speaker BJared Kushner.
Speaker ANo, government holder.
Speaker ADirect government.
Speaker AYou.
Speaker AThe US Government is now, as a result, we have created a reserve like Fort Knox.
Speaker AOh, my God.
Speaker AWhere we're just going to sit on the bitcoins.
Speaker AAnd all the other crypto that we see is from Criminal Operations.
Speaker ANormally we sold it.
Speaker AAnd because these were huge fraud and corruption Schemes.
Speaker AOur sales were big enough to potentially prompt a significant drop in bitcoin prices, for example, repeatedly.
Speaker BWow.
Speaker ATheir dream is to end that.
Speaker AAnd Trump gave it to him within days.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AHe also gave a pardon right at the beginning of his term to their great hero.
Speaker AAnd you should be done by your heroes.
Speaker ADo you know their great hero that they lobbied intensely to get this pardon is.
Speaker AWho's that Silk Road guy?
Speaker BOh, the young guy that went to the Virgin Islands or whatever.
Speaker BOh, I know you're talking about Sam or something like that.
Speaker ANo, not Sam.
Speaker ABankman.
Speaker AFried.
Speaker ANo, Silk Road.
Speaker ASilk Road was a predecessor.
Speaker ASilk Road was the dark web.
Speaker ASilk Road was the one that was doing the heroin and fentanyl sales.
Speaker BOh, my.
Speaker AIt was doing the child porn.
Speaker AIt was doing Hitman.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AThe guy they pardoned tried to hire somebody using his service to kill a rival.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker AAnd he was sentenced to an enormous term because it was, you know, he ended up killing lots of folks.
Speaker AAnd just the worst in terms of pedophiles and such.
Speaker AJust an utterly disgusting person.
Speaker AAnd you know what Trump did after he.
Speaker AImmediately upon freeing him, Trump denounced the, and I quote, scum who prosecuted and convicted him.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker ANot Trump, but this guy.
Speaker BIsn't it time to release the Epstein files?
Speaker BBy the way?
Speaker AAnyone who took him on was, quote, unquote, scum.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ASo again, these folks are the worst of the worst.
Speaker AYou know, in the fancy Greek word is cachistocracy, ruled by the worst.
Speaker AAnd we saw with musk.
Speaker AThey're not even technically competent, all this cultivated genius crap.
Speaker AThey're not only non geniuses, they're, you know, moral degenerates and they're nasty people, but they just lie.
Speaker ASo let me give that a moment.
Speaker AYou run a business, You've run businesses, right?
Speaker BKinda, yes, you could say that.
Speaker AYou run one now, right?
Speaker BYep.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AVery small, right?
Speaker ALots of businesses are small.
Speaker BFair enough.
Speaker AAs you get bigger in particular, though, you have to hire people that you haven't known for many years.
Speaker AMaybe worked as a volunteer before you could actually pay them.
Speaker AMaybe you're still working as a volunteers, you can't pay them.
Speaker AIn any event, it's hard to screen out people that are going to do bad things, because people are going to do bad things, know that they need to hide it.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker ABut it is super, super simple to screen effectively for pond scum.
Speaker AAnd one of the easiest is you can't work at any meaningful position in my administration unless you agree that Jan6 was a scandal and an outrage where my rightful reelection was stolen and, you know, whatever, the FBI or something created this fake riot.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker ASome absolutely blatant lie.
Speaker AWell, no honest person is going to sign on to that unless they're, you know, like a spy, a foreign intelligence person.
Speaker AWhich is one of the advantages of being a foreign intelligence person is I.
Speaker ASo Trump screens through these actions and then he does these deliberately outrageous actions super publicly so that anyone who literally rolls their eyes, there's a picture of them rolling their eyes, covering their face in embarrassment.
Speaker AThose people will be targeted and removed.
Speaker BLike the generals.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker AThat's why probably they had the meeting.
Speaker AThere's doubtless a videotape of the crowd.
Speaker AWe've all seen a number of tape from the crowd where you can see people obviously being distressed.
Speaker BYep.
Speaker AThey're going to be gone and they're going to be hurt on the way out as a lesson for the others to make sure that we get rid not just of competent people, but courageous people.
Speaker AThe whole thing, you know, about the warrior mentality.
Speaker AThey hate warriors.
Speaker AThey're not warriors.
Speaker AThere is.
Speaker AYou said they're the ICE guy.
Speaker AThey're the scum of the police department on their third job.
Speaker AWho are they literally advertising for, by the way?
Speaker AICE has a programmed thing that it's showing in blue states of you hate your governor.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker ABasically come and work for us.
Speaker BWow.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AThey want to select for evil and then they want to send you out.
Speaker AAnd if you body slam a 65 year old woman into the pavement, that is a plus, a big plus.
Speaker AYou are our kind of guy.
Speaker ASo this selection process combined with this grievance culture is going to make things massively worse over the course of the next three plus years.
Speaker AOkay, so back to the close the loop on the financials part of the crypto.
Speaker ABut what we could really, really do is two more things to absolutely supercharge this.
Speaker ALike the big thing on the front of the hood that brings in an incredible amount of oxygen into our V8.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker ASo first we're going to create our own thing, the Cosa Nostra.
Speaker AIt's going to be a stablecoin, which is an oxymoron created by regular morons.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AThe last one, which was famous, lost its peg within two months and thereupon there were four months of ever increasing fraud to hide the fact and then the collapse.
Speaker BWow.
Speaker ASo real good idea.
Speaker AWhy do we want this?
Speaker AWhat benefit Back to economics, what efficiency gain is there?
Speaker AThey're all more inefficient and they're going to put them in uninsured, virtually unregulated entities.
Speaker AAnd there's going to be a Gresham's dynamic, a race to the bottom, a nail, and they're not going to actually be stable because, you know, the whole alleged safety is that they'll be collateralized with Treasuries.
Speaker ABut those Treasuries can be three plus months immaturity.
Speaker AWhat happens to the market value of those when inflation rises or interest rate rises?
Speaker BJust real quick, does this look like Silicon Valley Bank?
Speaker ANo, it looks like the moron child of Silicon Valley Bank.
Speaker AThis is stupider than stupid, which is why they named it the Genius act, because it is in all caps, mind you.
Speaker AReally?
Speaker ANewsom has to do trolling on this?
Speaker AThis is just made for a creative person to do the trolling.
Speaker ABut here's the final one.
Speaker AOn top of all this insanity, that's not insane.
Speaker ANot from Trump's perspective.
Speaker BRight on.
Speaker AIt's what's going to make him finally a true multi, multi billionaire.
Speaker AWe're going to add a sovereign wealth fund.
Speaker AA sovereign wealth fund, slush fund.
Speaker AWell, corruption fund, right?
Speaker BYes.
Speaker AAll over the world, with one big exception, which is Norway.
Speaker AVery Nordic, very Lutheran type of stuff, this.
Speaker AYou say sovereign wealth and that means corruption.
Speaker AEverybody understands that it means corruption.
Speaker ABy the way, Charles Keating used the Kuwaiti sovereign wealth fund to do his scams in the United States of America.
Speaker AAnd then the Kuwaitis bought this hotel, or half the hotel interest at massively above market value so that he could massively overstate the value of all of this.
Speaker AAnd then the law firm began urgently researching to tie together the loop, the Foreign Corrupt Practices act, because there was a $21.5 million fee to get this investment from the Kuwaiti Investment office.
Speaker AThat's the size of the bribes in this world.
Speaker AOkay, so now we have a way to dramatically reduce sales of bitcoins and other crypto because the US Government is going to stop selling what would otherwise be large stuff and it's going to stop seizing the bitcoins and other things used in the course of crimes, because we don't do that kind of enforcement anymore, especially if it's used as bribes.
Speaker BJesus Christ.
Speaker ANow we're going to have the sovereign wealth fund buy a ton of crypto because after all, we've already created a strategic reserve under the grounds that this is an enormous way to create wealth.
Speaker AWell, if it is, what should our sovereign wealth fund invest in?
Speaker ACrypto.
Speaker BWow.
Speaker AAnd then since crypto is very thin market, what will happen to the price of crypto?
Speaker BIt's going to shoot Straight up.
Speaker AIt will shoot straight up.
Speaker ANext point, timing.
Speaker AWho will know it's about to do so?
Speaker AYeah, yeah, you got it.
Speaker AFront run that puppy.
Speaker APeople will make a ton of money for every billion dollars that Trump gets, the smart guys, you know, the robber barons will get 10 to 20 billion.
Speaker AHe's a bad thief, he's a terrible negotiator, as we all know.
Speaker ASo once you've done that, you'll purchase the crypto at say, 8 billion.
Speaker ALet's say they went in and bought 8 billion of crypto, which would be enough, by the way, to cause an enormous surge in bitcoin prices.
Speaker ABut we might be using an accounting regime in which it's still on the books for 8 billion.
Speaker ABut now the market price, quote, unquote, has risen to 200 billion.
Speaker ASo we're going to have to obviously go to mark to market accounting and whatever the budget deficit, if he finds it embarrassing politically, he can use massive purchases of bitcoins, producing this bubble of all history in bitcoins, and then Mark to market accounting to make even the most conservative Republican thrilled that he's made the budget deficit disappear.
Speaker BWow.
Speaker AAnd then this will all end catastrophically.
Speaker ABut not on his watch, because he can keep on buying.
Speaker BWith immunity.
Speaker AWith immunity because he's got the frigging U.S. treasury.
Speaker AAnd he can, of course, borrow as well, because the US can borrow like crazy.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AAgain, back to MMT being right.
Speaker AHave you noticed how our credit rating, you know, we can no longer borrow in the United States.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AU.S. government can't borrow anymore.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BIt's clown show.
Speaker BI mean, why do.
Speaker BAnyway, yeah.
Speaker AMmt again, started as sort of simply empirical.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AThe money system doesn't work in the way that the economic fables purport.
Speaker BThat's correct.
Speaker ASo that's what's coming, ladies and gents.
Speaker BNow, how does this impact to quote, unquote, world reserve currency?
Speaker BBecause this is what these freakazoids on the libertarian side, the crypto folks, talk about, oh, wait till the end of the reserve currency.
Speaker BWhat does this do to our reserves?
Speaker BWhat is the intent behind this in regards to reserve?
Speaker ATo make money for Trump has nothing to do with anything else.
Speaker AAnd more precisely, it's not to make money for Trump, it's to make money for the donors.
Speaker AThe huge donors.
Speaker BYep.
Speaker AThey are, of course, happy to make Trump finally a true multi billionaire.
Speaker AIt's chump change from their perspective.
Speaker ASo what it means is, that's why I wanted to emphasize bubbles are bad, not just when they collapse, they're terrible when they're hyperinflating.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker AThey systematically distort investment.
Speaker AAnd here they will also systematically reward the worst, most unethical robber barons who want to destroy democracy, who want to destroy the rule of law, and who literally could care less if hundreds of thousands of people starved to death in the United States and millions die of preventable diseases that USAID might have prevented.
Speaker AYeah, these people do literally qualify for OR the dark Tetrad, which is a psychology concept we also use in white collar criminology.
Speaker AIt's when you have the big four scummy things, right?
Speaker BYep.
Speaker AYou're a sadist and you're a psychopath, a Machiavellian.
Speaker AAnd what's that thing?
Speaker AI can't remember.
Speaker ABut when everything is about me.
Speaker AOh, Trumpism.
Speaker AI think I'm going to rename it narcissism.
Speaker BNarcissism, right?
Speaker AYeah, Narcissism.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AI think Trumpism works better.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker AAll right, Bill, on that happy note.
Speaker BYeah, we're in for a ride, aren't we?
Speaker AOh, baby, you're in for a ride.
Speaker BIt's very depressing.
Speaker AJust.
Speaker AI'll leave you folks with two things.
Speaker AOne, we can fight back about this.
Speaker AMost human beings hate corruption.
Speaker AAnd the United States has a unique corruption thing in the world.
Speaker AWe have more whistleblowers at high levels who have access to the critical inside information than the rest of the world combined.
Speaker AEvery state legislature with a Democratic majority in any of its legislative branches should be subpoenaing.
Speaker AThe whistleblowers work with us and the head of the America's leading whistleblower organization, that'll get you out of the NDAs and non disclosure agreements.
Speaker AAnd then instead of these talking politicians, we have over a thousand whistleblowers who've come forward already.
Speaker AAnd that's a figure from six weeks ago out of the government about Trump.
Speaker AHave them in every congressional district, in public meetings, not talking into some stuffed heads, but actually explaining to people in English what's being done to them from a firsthand perspective and what happened when they tried to tell the truth.
Speaker AWe have a hell of a story to tell.
Speaker AAnd by the way, the state AGs can also subpoena the testimony and defeat the NDAs.
Speaker AAnd I see none of that happening.
Speaker AAnd we've been urging this for now three months.
Speaker BI have a suspicion I know why they're not doing anything with that, but.
Speaker AWell, it's sort of a test, right?
Speaker ASort of a test.
Speaker BIt is a test.
Speaker BI'm just going to tell you, like, I hope we learn the lesson.
Speaker BWhen the test goes as I think it will go, right, I really believe we're experiencing the veneer of democracy falling off.
Speaker BAnd we are looking at the wizard behind the curtain.
Speaker BNow, we aren't seeing the great and powerful Oz.
Speaker BWe are seeing behind the curtain.
Speaker BAnd I think a lot of people, it's kind of like the Matrix when they realize it's a post nuclear wasteland.
Speaker BYou're like, man, put me back in the Matrix, man.
Speaker BI want to believe I can just put an I voted sticker on my forehead and everything will be okay.
Speaker BAnd I am.
Speaker BI'm way past that, Bill.
Speaker BI'm way past that.
Speaker BI don't see the same kind of hope in a system that does not produce any kind of outcomes for people, for regular people.
Speaker AI'll do as I send off the two mottos that we followed in the savings and loan debacle when it was objectively impossible to succeed.
Speaker AFirst is never chase mice while lions roam the campsite.
Speaker AAnd the second is it is not necessary to hope in order to persevere.
Speaker BAmen.
Speaker BI'm 100% with you on that, brother.
Speaker BBill, thank you so much for joining me today.
Speaker BWhere can we find more?
Speaker BI mean, you're now kind of retired, retired from umkc.
Speaker AAlthough I'm an excellent person, highly supportive of the UMKC faculty and the students and their work, of course.
Speaker AAnd I do most of my stuff with folks that you've worked with as well in the past.
Speaker BVery good.
Speaker ASo we're going to keep on keeping on.
Speaker BAll right, brother, well, listen, thank you so much, Bill.
Speaker BFolks, my name is Steve Grumbine.
Speaker BI am the host of Macro, and she's also the founder of the nonprofit Real Progressives.
Speaker BWe are a 501C3 not for profit, and we live and die on your contributions.
Speaker BAnd we are very, very small.
Speaker BSo if our work matters to you, consider becoming an investor.
Speaker BAs little as a dollar a month.
Speaker BWe need your Support.
Speaker BIt's@patreon.com RealProgressives.
Speaker BYou can also go to our website, RealProgressives.org and you can also go to our substack, which we feel is really a great way to interact with people.
Speaker BPlease come over there.
Speaker BWe also have, as I started the show, on Tuesday nights, we do something called Macro and Chill.
Speaker BA Macro and Chill is an opportunity for all of us to get together to discuss the episodes in a different format where we as people can ask questions and we can voice our opinions and we can discuss where things are heading.
Speaker BAnd it's all about giving us a little bit of power, a little bit of voice, a little bit of an opportunity to network with one another and learn something maybe we didn't know before.
Speaker BAnd if nothing else, I believe the podcasts produce information that many people are not covering anywhere else.
Speaker BSo if you find value in it, please consider supporting us either in showing up and being part of things.
Speaker BOr you can donate or you can volunteer as well.
Speaker BBill Black, thank you so much, sir.
Speaker BI appreciate you coming back on.
Speaker BIt's been too long.
Speaker BI hope I can have you back on again soon.
Speaker ALook forward to it.
Speaker AThank you, Steve.
Speaker BAbsolutely.
Speaker BAll right, folks, well, with that, on behalf of Bill Black, macro and cheese, Real progressives and of course myself, we are outta here.
Speaker AProduction transcripts, graphics, sound engineering, extras and show notes for macroencies are done by our volunteer team at Real Progressives, serving in solidarity with the working class since 2020 15.
Speaker BTo become a donor, please go to.
Speaker APatreon.Com realprogressives realprogressives.substack.com or realprogressives.org.
Speaker BThat.