0:00

HR Party of One is brought to you by BerniePortal.

0:03

Congrats!! If you’re watching this

0:05

episode, then you are in the position to tell a deserving employee they are getting promoted.

0:10

But before you share the good news, ask yourself: is my car’s fuel tank full of gas?

0:16

When you go on a trip, there is a checklist of essentials you tick off before stepping foot out

0:21

the front door. You pack clothes, toiletries, electronics, and maybe snacks and drinks. You

0:27

ensure no appliances are plugged in, arrange animal or childcare if needed, lock all the doors,

0:34

and more. Additionally, you fill your car up with gas to reach the destination.

0:39

Your trip checklist is unique, just as your organization’s needs

0:43

are unique. The purpose of a checklist or standardized process is to prevent

0:48

skipping an important item or task that hampers your success. Following a routine

0:53

ensures your end goal is accomplished in an organized, evidential manner.

0:57

In this episode, we’ll cover the process you should follow to reach your destination without

1:01

missing anything critical. At the end, I’ll tell you about how having a half-empty gas

1:06

tank equates to one organization’s mistake in their promotion process.

1:12

In this episode, we’ll cover: -The What,

1:14

-The Why, -The When,

1:15

-And the How of promoting someone in your organization.

1:18

Alright, let’s get started!

1:20

-The “What” in Promotions.

1:23

While you’re excited about the prospect of promoting an employee,

1:26

you know there are more miles to cover between here and your destination. Your first pitstop?

1:32

Identifying the “what” in this equation. You already know WHO you want to promote:

1:39

It’s likely someone who shows competency, is willing to take on more,

1:43

and has strong communication and leadership skills. So, let’s skip

1:47

that step and focus on the most important consideration: your “what.” What, exactly,

1:53

does this promotion entail? What does it mean when someone at your organization is promoted?

1:59

A promotion is more than just a new title; it’s a statement of trust. It’s telling someone,

2:04

“I trust you to take on more responsibility

2:07

and apply your skill set to the evolved competencies required of your new role.”

2:11

At its core, a promotion is a celebration. Approach internal

2:16

promotions with this mindset to set the stage for growth and opportunity,

2:20

even if the individual wasn’t expecting one. It can be an affirmation of their

2:25

hard work and a signal to the rest of the team that dedication and skill are rewarded.

2:30

To make this process fair and transparent, it's essential to couple your instincts about

2:35

a person with objective standards for promotion. Let’s say you’re considering

2:40

Emily for a promotion. You’ve seen Emily’s work ethic throughout the past two years,

2:45

and you know she’s hardworking, punctual, and a positive person to be around. These

2:49

soft skills are crucial but must be balanced with clear, objective criteria.

2:55

Using a levels document can help you decide “what” exactly a promotion entails. Levels documents play

3:01

an important role in an organization’s pay transparency efforts and help standardize

3:06

promotion decisions. This document typically consists of three parts: scope, skill, and salary.

3:14

-Scope: Defines the responsibilities and

3:17

expectations for each level within the organization. It answers the question,

3:22

“What additional responsibilities will Emily be taking on in her new role?”

3:26

-Skill: Outlines the specific skills and competencies required at each level. This

3:32

helps ensure that Emily has, or can develop, the necessary skills for her new position.

3:38

-Salary: Provides transparency about the pay associated with each level. This

3:44

ensures that Emily’s compensation is fair and aligned with her new responsibilities.

3:50

By asking, “What level do employees need to reach to earn a promotion?” you can create a

3:56

clear path for advancement. This clarity helps in setting expectations and allows employees

4:01

to understand what they need to achieve to move up in the organization. Check out

4:06

our HR Party of One episode on Levels docs. I’ll link it in the description.

4:12

If you don’t narrow down your “what,” you risk creating inconsistencies and

4:17

potential dissatisfaction. Without a clear understanding of what a promotion entails,

4:22

you might end up paying someone more without them fully understanding their new responsibilities

4:28

or without aligning their skills to the needs of the organization. This can lead

4:33

to inefficiencies and potential frustration both for the promoted employee and their colleagues.

4:39

-The “Why” in Promotions. Just as you typically pack

4:43

your bags for a trip with a "why" in mind—Why do I need this much sunscreen? Why should I

4:49

bring an extra pair of shoes?—the "why" also justifies your decision to promote

4:55

an employee. It’s not enough to recognize that an employee works hard or adds value;

5:00

it’s essential to understand what specific skills or capabilities qualify that employee

5:06

for a promotion and how their advancement aligns with the organization’s strategic goals.

5:11

Consider your organization’s needs: According to SHRM,

5:15

“Often companies find themselves top-heavy because they promote associates based on

5:19

their hard work and value to the organization and not necessarily because the company needs

5:24

more of these higher-level positions.” So, a promotion isn’t just about rewarding individual

5:30

achievements—it’s about aligning promotions with the actual needs of the organization.

5:36

When considering an internal promotion, ask yourself:

5:39

-Why does this promotion support the strategic goals of the organization?

5:43

Think about how the promotion fits into the long-term plans of the company. For instance,

5:48

if your goal is to expand your business into the global market, promoting someone with expertise

5:54

in international business makes perfect sense. Is the role truly necessary? Creating

6:01

higher-level positions without a clear need can lead to inefficiencies and a bloated structure.

6:07

Conducting a gap analysis can help ensure this promotion aligns with your strategic goals.

6:12

This process helps identify your team's current capabilities and compare them with the skills

6:17

and roles needed for future success. Doing this lets you pinpoint areas where internal

6:22

talent can fill critical gaps, ensuring the promotion supports your objectives.

6:28

-Why is this employee the right fit for the new role?

6:31

Consider the unique skills and talents the employee brings to the

6:34

table. If they’ve shown exceptional leadership in project management,

6:38

it’s logical to promote them to oversee larger, more complex projects.

6:44

Why should this individual be chosen over external candidates for the role? What can they offer

6:50

that an external candidate can’t offer, such as comprehension of the organization and knowledge

6:56

of company culture? While sometimes hiring externally is necessary because there aren't

7:02

any qualified internal candidates, there are significant benefits to promoting from

7:07

within. Joblist surveyed 1,000 full-time workers about their preferences regarding their bosses

7:14

and found striking differences between internal promotions and external hires:

7:20

-Employees passed over for a promotion by an external hire were 15% more likely to

7:26

quit or consider quitting than those passed over for an internal hire.

7:31

-Managers promoted from within were 10% more likely than external hires

7:36

to report having a highly productive team. AND

7:39

-71% of employees believed hiring from within is better for scaling a business.

7:45

While not every promotion will be to a managerial position,

7:49

the same concept applies across various roles. Employees generally prefer to be

7:55

led by someone who has grown within the organization rather than an external hire.

8:01

-Why will this promotion positively impact the team and company culture?

8:06

Think about how the promotion will affect team dynamics and morale. Promoting from within

8:11

can be a great motivator, showing that hard work and dedication are recognized. However,

8:16

it’s crucial to ensure that the promoted individual has the support and training

8:21

needed to succeed, preventing any negative impact on the team.

8:25

By keeping these "why" questions in mind, you can make more strategic promotion

8:29

decisions that benefit both the employee and the organization.

8:33

This thoughtful approach ensures that promotions are meaningful.

8:37

-The “When” in Promotions.

8:40

There’s no “perfect” time for a promotion, but understanding the right timing can make

8:44

a huge difference. Most organizations don’t plan for internal promotions in advance,

8:50

but it's wise to do so. Promotions often happen suddenly when a higher-level

8:56

position becomes vacant, or when the company experiences significant growth.

9:00

Company growth is a major factor in the timing of promotions. As a company expands– from 10 to

9:07

20 to 50 people– there is a need for more leaders and the formation of new departments. This growth

9:14

creates opportunities for promotions as new teams and leadership roles become necessary.

9:20

Having a clear succession plan is like filling your car’s fuel tank

9:24

before a trip—it ensures you’re ready to go when the time comes.

9:28

Succession planning is your roadmap for smoothly passing leadership responsibilities to the

9:34

next person in line. It’s all about making sure there’s no chaos when someone leaves,

9:39

whether they retire, move to another company, or leave for other reasons.

9:43

This process helps experienced employees transition seamlessly into new roles.

9:49

Sure, succession planning takes some effort upfront, but the payoff is huge when an

9:55

employee leaves. You won’t need to scramble to find a replacement because you’ll already

9:59

have a well-trained and capable person ready to step in. Planning for succession means you’re

10:05

planning for success, creating a proactive rather than reactive work environment. Plus,

10:11

it’s a great tool for boosting retention and morale. When employees see that hard

10:16

work and dedication are rewarded, they’re more motivated to grow with the company.

10:21

For more details on succession planning, check out this HR FAQ– I’ll link it in the description.

10:28

Remember, a fresh perspective can be just as valuable as experience. Just because an employee

10:34

has tenure doesn’t mean they should be “next in line” for a promotion or that they’re ready for

10:39

one. Even if you’re uncertain about who might be the next candidate for promotion, investing

10:45

in training and coaching existing employees for future opportunities is crucial. This ensures

10:51

that when promotion opportunities arise down the road, your team members are well-prepared.

10:57

When it’s time to think about promotions, having solid documentation of employee progress

11:03

gives you real evidence of how well they’re doing and growing in their role. Encourage

11:09

managers to cross-train team members on essential department functions and keep

11:13

tabs on their progress with regular 1:1s. With BerniePortal’s performance management feature,

11:19

managers can easily track and document each employee’s development. This makes it easier

11:24

to make smart decisions that benefit both the employee and the company.

11:28

-The “How” in Promotions.

11:31

Now that we’ve covered the what, why, and when of internal promotions, let’s delve into how you can

11:37

effectively execute them! Your internal promotion process can be streamlined into 4 main steps:

11:45

-Step 1: Identify Candidates:

11:48

Start by identifying individuals within your organization whose skills,

11:52

experience, and potential closely align with the requirements of the role you’re looking to fill.

11:58

-Step 2: Evaluate against objective criteria:

12:02

Ensure fairness and transparency in your decision-making by evaluating candidates against

12:08

clear, objective criteria. This ensures fairness and transparency in your decision-making process.

12:14

-Step 3: Consider Organizational Needs: Beyond individual qualifications, consider

12:21

how each candidate’s promotion will contribute to meeting your organization’s strategic goals. Just

12:27

as you wouldn’t bring your snowsuit to Aruba, aligning promotions with organizational needs

12:33

ensures a smooth journey. And ...

12:36

-Step 4: Communicate with the candidate: When you share the news of a promotion,

12:41

lay out all the details: what’s expected in the new role, the responsibilities they’ll take on,

12:47

and the exciting growth opportunities ahead. If there’s a change in salary or benefits,

12:52

make sure it’s crystal clear. Sometimes, a promotion might be what we call a "dry

12:58

promotion." That’s when someone steps up to a higher role or more responsibilities without an

13:03

immediate bump in pay or perks. It’s important to explain this upfront so there are no surprises.

13:10

A "dry promotion" means the job title or responsibilities change, but the paycheck

13:15

and benefits stay the same—for now. It’s a way to recognize potential and give new challenges

13:21

while waiting to adjust compensation based on performance in the new role.

13:26

Once your promoted team member is on board, share the news with the rest of the team.

13:31

Transparency builds trust and keeps everyone motivated. Explain why this person was chosen,

13:37

how it fits into your company's bigger picture, and what it means for the

13:41

team’s goals. Invite questions and address any concerns openly to keep the team spirit strong.

13:47

Let’s talk about an organization that found itself with a half-empty gas tank—Enron. Their downfall

13:54

in 2001 exposed significant corporate governance failures, including unethical promotion practices.

14:01

Instead of prioritizing sustainable growth and integrity, Enron focused on short-term

14:07

financial gains in its promotion decisions. They didn't align their promotion practices with

14:13

organizational needs or take an ethical approach. This shortsighted strategy ultimately contributed

14:19

to its eventual collapse and bankruptcy. Remember—your role is as strategic as you make it!