1 00:00:02,266 --> 00:00:04,596 Welcome to the Mastering Therapy podcast. 2 00:00:05,156 --> 00:00:09,766 This is a show for psychologists, psychotherapists, and counselors who are 3 00:00:09,766 --> 00:00:14,196 looking to build on their therapy skills, increase confidence in working with 4 00:00:14,196 --> 00:00:19,275 clients, and be inspired by alternative models, tools, and ways of working. 5 00:00:19,536 --> 00:00:20,666 I'm your host, Dr. 6 00:00:20,666 --> 00:00:21,325 Natalie Stott. 7 00:00:21,765 --> 00:00:25,896 I'm a clinical psychologist and founder of Supervisor Platform, a 8 00:00:25,896 --> 00:00:29,196 directory that supports clinicians to showcase their supervision 9 00:00:29,505 --> 00:00:31,175 and training to other therapists. 10 00:00:31,335 --> 00:00:35,236 Join my guests and me as we learn from one another and aim to take our 11 00:00:35,236 --> 00:00:37,245 insights and put them into action. 12 00:00:37,306 --> 00:00:38,425 This is season five. 13 00:00:38,626 --> 00:00:39,035 Let's go. 14 00:00:39,345 --> 00:00:42,285 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Welcome everybody to this week of Mastering Therapy. 15 00:00:42,315 --> 00:00:44,515 I have with me Professor Paul Gilbert. 16 00:00:44,925 --> 00:00:50,045 Many of you will be familiar with him, but in case you are not, he is a professor of 17 00:00:50,075 --> 00:00:52,345 clinical psychology at Derby University. 18 00:00:52,645 --> 00:00:56,475 He's the founder of Compassion Focused Therapy and of the Compassionate Mind 19 00:00:56,495 --> 00:01:03,065 Foundation, and has shaped the way that many of us see compassion in our clinical 20 00:01:03,065 --> 00:01:06,215 work, understand shame and threat. 21 00:01:06,575 --> 00:01:09,675 So really thrilled that you are here, Paul. 22 00:01:09,715 --> 00:01:13,835 Thank you so much for sharing your time with us and hopefully your wisdom 23 00:01:15,085 --> 00:01:15,515 Prof Paul Gilbert: Yes, hopefully. 24 00:01:17,213 --> 00:01:18,723 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Undoubtedly your wisdom. 25 00:01:20,553 --> 00:01:26,173 We're gonna jump straight in because something I have seen in my own practice 26 00:01:26,203 --> 00:01:31,443 and seen in forums and discussions with clinicians, many of us will be familiar 27 00:01:31,443 --> 00:01:36,093 with the concept of clients needing to be more compassionate to themselves. 28 00:01:36,093 --> 00:01:39,613 I mean, what human doesn't need more compassion in their life? 29 00:01:40,023 --> 00:01:44,793 But it, it's just not always as simple as that, there might need to be 50 steps 30 00:01:44,793 --> 00:01:49,113 before we actually get to the place of somebody recognizing that they're 31 00:01:49,113 --> 00:01:53,333 worthy, deserving, or even having the insight of what compassion is. 32 00:01:53,803 --> 00:01:59,803 I was wondering what you feel are the main errors that you've seen clinicians 33 00:01:59,803 --> 00:02:04,453 make when jumping straight into, "Oh, well, you need to be more compassionate. 34 00:02:04,453 --> 00:02:06,153 Look how critical you are to yourself. 35 00:02:06,163 --> 00:02:07,713 How would you talk to a friend?" 36 00:02:08,323 --> 00:02:12,553 You often see these questions and things being used, but it's just 37 00:02:12,553 --> 00:02:13,733 not quite as simple as that, is it? 38 00:02:14,199 --> 00:02:14,589 Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah 39 00:02:17,471 --> 00:02:17,551 No, it's not. 40 00:02:17,551 --> 00:02:19,421 So first of all, thank you so much for inviting me, Natalie. 41 00:02:19,421 --> 00:02:21,531 It's a delight to be with you to talk to you. 42 00:02:21,981 --> 00:02:25,561 So, I think it's quite useful to think about how CFT began because 43 00:02:25,571 --> 00:02:29,821 it began with what we call the three shocks, and mostly compassion was 44 00:02:29,821 --> 00:02:33,781 developed for people who can't do it, or actually when you start doing it, 45 00:02:33,781 --> 00:02:35,871 it creates quite a negative reaction. 46 00:02:36,871 --> 00:02:41,930 I was-- my area was depression, and I did my PhD in depression in the '70s, and 47 00:02:42,041 --> 00:02:46,261 we did a lot of cognitive therapy, and I think cognitive therapy is great, but I 48 00:02:46,261 --> 00:02:50,001 was often working with quite chronically depressed people and people who have, 49 00:02:50,430 --> 00:02:52,031 had trauma and that sort of thing. 50 00:02:52,641 --> 00:02:52,651 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. 51 00:02:52,881 --> 00:02:55,941 Prof Paul Gilbert: so you would do your cognitive interventions, and they'd 52 00:02:55,941 --> 00:03:00,441 say, "Yes, I, I can see the logic of what, of why my negative thinking 53 00:03:00,441 --> 00:03:03,271 is not really accurate or whatever, but it doesn't really help me." 54 00:03:03,981 --> 00:03:06,411 So you know, you have people who say, "I'm inferior, I'm this, 55 00:03:06,411 --> 00:03:08,401 I'm that," and you say, "Okay, well, let's have a look and see. 56 00:03:08,401 --> 00:03:09,521 Would you talk to a friend like that? 57 00:03:09,521 --> 00:03:12,251 What would you say to a friend who had those same ideas that you 58 00:03:12,251 --> 00:03:13,931 had," and all that sort of thing. 59 00:03:14,511 --> 00:03:14,851 Great. 60 00:03:14,981 --> 00:03:17,521 And, and sometimes when you have people stand back and become a 61 00:03:17,521 --> 00:03:20,221 little bit more mindful, like that, that was really helpful. 62 00:03:20,941 --> 00:03:25,181 But sometimes people would say, "Yes, I can see that, but it doesn't really help." 63 00:03:25,191 --> 00:03:29,481 So one lady who was, had a, quite a nasty depression actually, we 64 00:03:29,631 --> 00:03:32,901 had a idea that she shouldn't have been born, wasn't lovable, wasn't 65 00:03:33,471 --> 00:03:34,651 wantable, wasn't, wasn't wanted. 66 00:03:35,041 --> 00:03:37,871 But she had a very good relationship with her husband, and she had three 67 00:03:37,871 --> 00:03:42,651 lovely children, but she was very stuck in this idea about that because was 68 00:03:42,771 --> 00:03:46,041 adopted and it was a very difficult adoption and, "You're lucky that we 69 00:03:46,041 --> 00:03:49,081 d- adopted you 'cause you weren't wanted," that sort of thing or whatever. 70 00:03:49,301 --> 00:03:50,691 And so it was very stuck, right? 71 00:03:50,761 --> 00:03:53,381 So but anyway, we could do this, said, "Well, let's stand back from that and 72 00:03:53,391 --> 00:03:56,871 say, 'Okay, but today, look, you, you have a husband who loves you and these three 73 00:03:56,871 --> 00:03:58,401 children, and you can bring that to mind. 74 00:03:59,281 --> 00:04:00,151 How, how is that?'" 75 00:04:00,171 --> 00:04:02,311 She says, "Yes, I know that, but I can't really feel it." 76 00:04:02,781 --> 00:04:06,321 So I said to her, "Well, how do you hear it in your mind? 77 00:04:06,331 --> 00:04:09,551 When you kind of play that in your mind, you're looking at the evidence for the 78 00:04:09,601 --> 00:04:11,601 fact that your husband is caring for you." 79 00:04:12,291 --> 00:04:13,201 She said, "Well, what do you mean?" 80 00:04:13,201 --> 00:04:15,321 I said, "Well, speak it out as you actually hear it. 81 00:04:15,321 --> 00:04:15,651 Can I?" 82 00:04:16,351 --> 00:04:17,961 said, said, "Really?" 83 00:04:18,021 --> 00:04:18,591 I said, "Yes." 84 00:04:18,911 --> 00:04:19,771 So this is what happened. 85 00:04:19,771 --> 00:04:22,941 She said, "Come on, you're doing cognitive therapy, aren't ya? 86 00:04:23,431 --> 00:04:24,601 You got a husband who loves you. 87 00:04:24,601 --> 00:04:26,061 You got three lovely children." 88 00:04:27,601 --> 00:04:30,451 So the emotional tone was very hostile. 89 00:04:30,701 --> 00:04:34,241 And so I began to explore that with other clients, and I found that even when they 90 00:04:34,241 --> 00:04:39,991 were trying to come up with ideas of reappraisal, re-evaluation, reframing, 91 00:04:40,411 --> 00:04:44,891 they could come up with the ideas, but the emotional textures of their thinking 92 00:04:45,341 --> 00:04:49,941 was often either cold or indifferent or sometimes contemptuous or hostile. 93 00:04:50,751 --> 00:04:55,671 so I started to invite them to change specifically the emotional tone of 94 00:04:55,671 --> 00:04:59,291 what they were thinking, not just the content, but the emotional tone. 95 00:04:59,981 --> 00:05:04,019 So the first shot was the real hostility Which I hadn't recognized. 96 00:05:04,049 --> 00:05:07,809 Now, another lady about the same time actually, that when people are depressed 97 00:05:07,809 --> 00:05:12,659 and they lay in bed ruminating, you have to help them get out of bed, do some yoga 98 00:05:12,659 --> 00:05:17,749 exercises or whatever, and so they, they do movement, and that can be quite useful. 99 00:05:17,749 --> 00:05:19,209 And we'd been doing that for many years. 100 00:05:20,009 --> 00:05:24,739 so this was a lady many, many years ago, to get her out of bed 101 00:05:24,739 --> 00:05:27,909 so she wasn't ruminating, she put a little card on the side of her bed. 102 00:05:27,909 --> 00:05:29,839 Okay, when you wake up, don't lay ruminating. 103 00:05:29,849 --> 00:05:32,399 Get out of bed, do some stretches, bit of yoga. 104 00:05:32,399 --> 00:05:32,689 Great. 105 00:05:33,069 --> 00:05:33,799 Came back next week. 106 00:05:33,999 --> 00:05:35,089 How did you get on? 107 00:05:35,169 --> 00:05:36,729 Yeah, she said that, that was all right. 108 00:05:36,729 --> 00:05:37,519 I tried to do that. 109 00:05:37,789 --> 00:05:38,609 So what happened then? 110 00:05:38,609 --> 00:05:39,739 You woke up, you saw your note. 111 00:05:39,739 --> 00:05:42,349 Yeah, she said, I saw my note, and I said to myself, "Come on, 112 00:05:42,369 --> 00:05:43,909 get out of bed you lazy bastard. 113 00:05:43,919 --> 00:05:44,449 Do some…" 114 00:05:45,199 --> 00:05:45,989 "Well, hang on a minute. 115 00:05:45,999 --> 00:05:47,089 Where did that come from?" 116 00:05:47,099 --> 00:05:48,229 She said, "Well, that's what I have to do. 117 00:05:48,229 --> 00:05:49,359 I have to force myself. 118 00:05:49,359 --> 00:05:50,189 I have to make myself." 119 00:05:50,929 --> 00:05:54,449 this idea I have to make myself, to force myself, to convince myself, blah, 120 00:05:54,449 --> 00:06:00,039 blah, blah, all of that stuff is very common in depressed people because that's 121 00:06:00,079 --> 00:06:02,259 part of what the criticism is about. 122 00:06:03,169 --> 00:06:05,149 okay, so we got to this point, and then you've got all this. 123 00:06:05,279 --> 00:06:09,669 So let's try and do some, develop some warmth. 124 00:06:09,789 --> 00:06:11,169 Imagine you were talking to a friend. 125 00:06:11,179 --> 00:06:14,969 It's what would your textures, what would your vo- voice tone be like 126 00:06:15,859 --> 00:06:21,099 if you brought in a, a kind, warm to- tone to the cognitive things? 127 00:06:22,567 --> 00:06:23,827 And she said, "No, I'm not doing that." 128 00:06:23,827 --> 00:06:25,762 I said, "Well, okay. 129 00:06:25,762 --> 00:06:26,245 Well…" 130 00:06:26,245 --> 00:06:28,547 "No," she goes, "I can't see that that's… 131 00:06:28,997 --> 00:06:29,667 I, I… 132 00:06:30,057 --> 00:06:31,197 What are you talking about?" 133 00:06:31,685 --> 00:06:32,215 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Yeah 134 00:06:32,237 --> 00:06:33,817 Prof Paul Gilbert: got her on tape saying, "That's just… 135 00:06:34,087 --> 00:06:36,787 I mean, okay, it'll be nice, but it's not gonna help me any." 136 00:06:36,787 --> 00:06:38,627 "So stronger," she says, "Stronger. 137 00:06:38,627 --> 00:06:40,797 You've gotta help me believe all these things." 138 00:06:41,597 --> 00:06:42,807 So there was a lot of resistance. 139 00:06:42,817 --> 00:06:44,927 She didn't wanna do it, and she really didn't like this 140 00:06:44,927 --> 00:06:46,467 idea of being kind to myself. 141 00:06:46,467 --> 00:06:47,497 Are you serious? 142 00:06:48,317 --> 00:06:49,447 mean, all that stuff. 143 00:06:49,467 --> 00:06:54,087 And a lot of people really, particularly highly hostile people to themselves, 144 00:06:54,087 --> 00:06:55,967 you mentioned kindness, it's like toxic. 145 00:06:55,987 --> 00:06:57,137 It's like a poison, right? 146 00:06:57,523 --> 00:06:57,793 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm. 147 00:06:57,827 --> 00:06:58,717 Prof Paul Gilbert: You serious? 148 00:06:59,747 --> 00:07:02,567 You w- if you knew the real me, you would not think I deserve 149 00:07:02,567 --> 00:07:03,527 kindness, all that stuff. 150 00:07:03,707 --> 00:07:04,887 So that was the second shot. 151 00:07:05,957 --> 00:07:09,687 And the third shot was that when we did start to do it, and the way in 152 00:07:09,687 --> 00:07:14,047 which you do that is you have to be the compassionate other to begin with, you 153 00:07:14,057 --> 00:07:18,867 have to bridge into their experience, because quite a lot of individuals 154 00:07:18,867 --> 00:07:22,787 with these very complicated depressions and things, they have unprocessed 155 00:07:23,167 --> 00:07:27,107 trauma in all kinds of ways, often neglect or emotional disengagement. 156 00:07:28,347 --> 00:07:31,017 When you do that, then you're going to run into all of the 157 00:07:31,017 --> 00:07:32,947 traumas carried in the care system. 158 00:07:32,947 --> 00:07:38,237 Now, the key here is that all motivational systems carry their own trauma. 159 00:07:38,247 --> 00:07:42,027 So if you are somebody who likes going on holidays, you're very motivated for 160 00:07:42,027 --> 00:07:46,507 exploration, you're an explorative type, and off you go doing your holidays, 161 00:07:46,507 --> 00:07:51,177 have wonderful times, and then one year you get badly beaten up or have a 162 00:07:51,177 --> 00:07:54,767 terrible illness or something, you have to be flown home, something terrible. 163 00:07:55,977 --> 00:08:00,617 what will happen the next time your thoughts of a holiday are triggered is 164 00:08:00,617 --> 00:08:02,217 you won't remember all the good times. 165 00:08:02,217 --> 00:08:05,857 You'll im- your body will immediately go into the experience of the trauma. 166 00:08:06,607 --> 00:08:10,167 It's like if you have a, cheesecake and it makes you very sick, you're very ill, 167 00:08:10,487 --> 00:08:13,957 the next time you smell a cheesecake, your body will immediately react. 168 00:08:14,567 --> 00:08:20,147 So, know, when there are traumas in motivational systems like care systems 169 00:08:20,247 --> 00:08:24,387 or whatever, you start triggering that and the body will then react. 170 00:08:24,677 --> 00:08:28,257 So they're not gonna respond to, "Oh, this is great," and, "Be kind to myself." 171 00:08:28,327 --> 00:08:29,407 They're not gonna respond to that. 172 00:08:29,407 --> 00:08:31,267 What happens is you trigger the trauma. 173 00:08:31,837 --> 00:08:33,597 And so what would happen is that they… 174 00:08:33,756 --> 00:08:36,817 clients would start saying, "No, I, no, I don't, don't like this. 175 00:08:36,817 --> 00:08:36,977 I… 176 00:08:37,157 --> 00:08:38,647 This, this compassion stuff. 177 00:08:38,647 --> 00:08:39,287 No, I don't like it. 178 00:08:39,287 --> 00:08:40,947 It makes me feel b- I feel terrible, actually. 179 00:08:40,947 --> 00:08:42,417 The more I try and do it, the worse I feel." 180 00:08:42,917 --> 00:08:43,496 And so you… 181 00:08:43,537 --> 00:08:46,457 Part of it, you have to explain this to them, and then you have to 182 00:08:46,457 --> 00:08:50,537 explain that therefore part of the issue is how we detox your attachment 183 00:08:50,537 --> 00:08:53,437 system, detoxify it, help you with the trauma memories in there. 184 00:08:53,437 --> 00:08:56,747 Now you're in a little bit of a catch-22 because you obviously want 185 00:08:57,945 --> 00:09:01,385 to have a compassionate position when you're going into the trauma. 186 00:09:01,385 --> 00:09:05,245 But on the other hand, it's difficult for them to develop a compassionate position 187 00:09:05,245 --> 00:09:06,965 till they've done some work on the trauma. 188 00:09:07,205 --> 00:09:12,585 So it's a bit of a tricky one, but one of the ways you do it is by you acting as the 189 00:09:12,585 --> 00:09:16,785 compassionate other, and one of the ways you do that is with empathic bridging. 190 00:09:16,895 --> 00:09:20,985 Now, empathic bridging in the early stages of compassionate focused 191 00:09:20,985 --> 00:09:22,605 therapy is extremely important. 192 00:09:22,925 --> 00:09:27,195 And what that means is that when people tell you things that are tricky or 193 00:09:27,195 --> 00:09:31,285 distressing to you, you help them pay attention to the emotion behind them. 194 00:09:31,655 --> 00:09:34,635 Now, Freud talked about what he called de-affected memory. 195 00:09:34,995 --> 00:09:38,245 What he meant by that is memory without emotion, that people tell you these 196 00:09:38,255 --> 00:09:40,335 stories of abuse, but there's no emotion. 197 00:09:41,215 --> 00:09:44,465 kind of detached themselves from the emotion. 198 00:09:46,135 --> 00:09:48,465 So what you do is you, you connect it. 199 00:09:48,975 --> 00:09:53,715 So this lady would say about, excuse me, times that she was hit by her 200 00:09:53,715 --> 00:09:56,565 mother and sent to her bedroom, left there all alone at night. 201 00:09:56,975 --> 00:09:58,785 And I'd say, "That must have been terribly frightening. 202 00:09:58,785 --> 00:10:02,435 That must have been really distressing to you and very upsetting." 203 00:10:02,435 --> 00:10:05,035 She said, "Yes, I suppose it was, but you know, that's how it was. 204 00:10:05,035 --> 00:10:06,155 You just had to get on with it." 205 00:10:07,005 --> 00:10:11,105 And another time she said about, having a a birthday party when she 206 00:10:11,105 --> 00:10:14,425 was young, and the day of the party, mom said, "I've got a headache. 207 00:10:14,425 --> 00:10:15,005 I'm not gonna do it. 208 00:10:15,015 --> 00:10:15,665 Send all the kids home." 209 00:10:15,665 --> 00:10:18,715 I said, "Oh my God, that must have been so disappointing to you." 210 00:10:19,135 --> 00:10:21,165 "I suppose it was, but that kind of thing happened all the time. 211 00:10:21,165 --> 00:10:22,045 You just had to get on with it." 212 00:10:22,175 --> 00:10:23,565 So all the time, right? 213 00:10:25,097 --> 00:10:27,577 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): And would you see this as protective? 214 00:10:27,917 --> 00:10:31,337 Would you be using the language of, I guess what I'm thinking in from 215 00:10:31,337 --> 00:10:33,587 an IFS perspective, protectors here? 216 00:10:33,857 --> 00:10:38,567 There is a block to allowing that part of herself to feel it, like 217 00:10:38,567 --> 00:10:39,717 it's serving a function, right? 218 00:10:40,353 --> 00:10:40,603 Prof Paul Gilbert: Yes. 219 00:10:40,603 --> 00:10:44,353 We have a very different model to IFS, as but so it's not a deliberate block. 220 00:10:44,353 --> 00:10:45,963 It's not set up as a protector. 221 00:10:46,143 --> 00:10:50,023 It's just, it's a, it's a biological you just can't, 222 00:10:50,075 --> 00:10:50,375 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm-hmm. 223 00:10:50,383 --> 00:10:51,263 Prof Paul Gilbert: know, it's a condition. 224 00:10:51,673 --> 00:10:55,123 It, it's like saying that, when you vomit after having a bad cheese, 225 00:10:55,243 --> 00:10:57,033 smell of cheesecake, it somehow it's 226 00:10:57,253 --> 00:11:01,503 Well, sort of, but it's basically an automatic reaction as well. 227 00:11:01,763 --> 00:11:04,153 Anyway, so the point is so you keep doing this. 228 00:11:04,153 --> 00:11:08,323 So, a- and gradually what you see is the, that you, you're watching the 229 00:11:08,323 --> 00:11:11,083 non-verbal communication start to change. 230 00:11:11,523 --> 00:11:16,733 And then one time she was talking to me about time when she'd hurt, and she 231 00:11:16,733 --> 00:11:21,463 went to her room, and she was crying, and she looked out at the stars, and 232 00:11:21,473 --> 00:11:25,153 she could see them twinkling, and she imagined her biological mother out there 233 00:11:25,153 --> 00:11:28,603 amongst the stars, and the- it would form a chariot, and this chariot was gonna 234 00:11:28,603 --> 00:11:29,953 come through the window and take her. 235 00:11:30,753 --> 00:11:32,123 And so you empathically bridge. 236 00:11:32,123 --> 00:11:33,973 Now you have to use your emotion. 237 00:11:34,443 --> 00:11:37,613 And so we said to her at the time when she was thinking about that, "So I can 238 00:11:37,613 --> 00:11:42,383 just feel in you that yearning, 'Please, Mommy, please, Mommy, come and find me. 239 00:11:42,763 --> 00:11:44,343 Please, Mommy, please, Mommy.'" 240 00:11:44,573 --> 00:11:48,173 So that, that, your empathic connecting in the way that you're 241 00:11:48,183 --> 00:11:50,163 connecting opens the system. 242 00:11:50,163 --> 00:11:53,783 And of course at that point she just then began sobbing, and that 243 00:11:54,113 --> 00:11:55,113 carried on for quite a while. 244 00:11:55,373 --> 00:11:59,223 And that was the beginning then of her being able to process this immense 245 00:11:59,523 --> 00:12:04,763 grief that was in the system that she was absolutely terrified of. 246 00:12:04,763 --> 00:12:07,233 And also if she ever touched it, she became so overwhelmed 247 00:12:07,233 --> 00:12:08,833 by it, she closed it down. 248 00:12:09,603 --> 00:12:14,483 Now, so the key point then to come finish your story, finish the story, 249 00:12:14,893 --> 00:12:18,883 is always remember that CFT was developed for people who can't do it. 250 00:12:19,653 --> 00:12:20,493 the whole point of it. 251 00:12:20,503 --> 00:12:22,653 If you can do it, you can go and do compassion to yourself. 252 00:12:22,653 --> 00:12:23,273 It's in the birth. 253 00:12:23,273 --> 00:12:24,463 Oh, yes, I feel so much better. 254 00:12:24,643 --> 00:12:25,113 That's great. 255 00:12:25,143 --> 00:12:25,883 Go off and do that. 256 00:12:25,953 --> 00:12:28,263 But you don't need CFT as such. 257 00:12:28,583 --> 00:12:33,153 CFT is for the people who can't do it, and when you try and do it, they get 258 00:12:33,153 --> 00:12:35,813 frightened of it, they get distressed by it, they get overwhelmed by it. 259 00:12:36,953 --> 00:12:39,693 so, and the, the fact that they can't do it means that those 260 00:12:39,713 --> 00:12:41,543 brain systems don't work for them. 261 00:12:41,543 --> 00:12:42,693 They can't activate them. 262 00:12:43,753 --> 00:12:45,943 So anyway, that's the, that's the long story. 263 00:12:47,687 --> 00:12:47,697 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm. 264 00:12:47,707 --> 00:12:47,727 Yeah. 265 00:12:47,737 --> 00:12:50,647 And y- y- what you're describing, and I, I think you've talked about in some of your 266 00:12:50,647 --> 00:12:52,947 writing around the head and the heart lag. 267 00:12:53,287 --> 00:12:57,847 What I think's interesting with these clients is that if you were to have a 268 00:12:57,847 --> 00:13:01,587 conversation about compassion or you were thinking about somebody else, 269 00:13:01,957 --> 00:13:03,767 they often would have the words, 270 00:13:03,777 --> 00:13:04,057 Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah 271 00:13:04,277 --> 00:13:07,937 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): have the feeling towards another, but it's 272 00:13:07,987 --> 00:13:11,327 like when it comes to themselves, they're a separate other. 273 00:13:11,425 --> 00:13:11,705 Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah 274 00:13:11,907 --> 00:13:14,857 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): isn't that same rule for themselves as they 275 00:13:14,857 --> 00:13:16,587 might feel towards other people. 276 00:13:16,947 --> 00:13:20,607 And so I think clinically when we're working with people, we have to be 277 00:13:20,607 --> 00:13:24,357 careful that we don't just buy the language because people are really 278 00:13:24,357 --> 00:13:26,837 good at saying the right thing. 279 00:13:27,217 --> 00:13:30,777 But when-- I really liked what you were saying about the, like, y- 280 00:13:30,787 --> 00:13:33,697 you do have to get to the emotion because people logically know, 281 00:13:34,297 --> 00:13:36,077 "Oh, well, I guess that was bad." 282 00:13:36,447 --> 00:13:36,657 Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah, yeah. 283 00:13:36,833 --> 00:13:39,273 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): and you need a strong therapeutic relationship 284 00:13:39,273 --> 00:13:41,053 to be able to contain that, right? 285 00:13:41,143 --> 00:13:41,593 Prof Paul Gilbert: that's right. 286 00:13:42,333 --> 00:13:46,103 mean, the point is, as you know from attachment theory, in which children 287 00:13:46,113 --> 00:13:49,833 deal with threat is to go to mommy or daddy, and they-- So that is 288 00:13:49,833 --> 00:13:51,793 a resolution through connection. 289 00:13:52,495 --> 00:13:53,075 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm-hmm. 290 00:13:53,113 --> 00:13:53,963 Prof Paul Gilbert: how children do it right from the word go. 291 00:13:54,353 --> 00:13:58,003 But if you can't resolve threat through connection, if you can't resolve threat 292 00:13:58,003 --> 00:14:02,823 by receiving care coming to you from the other, that system simply doesn't work. 293 00:14:02,863 --> 00:14:07,263 And so the child is left to try to self-regulate, but without the natural 294 00:14:07,263 --> 00:14:09,273 regulator that they were born to need 295 00:14:09,991 --> 00:14:10,221 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. 296 00:14:12,131 --> 00:14:17,071 When you were talking about when you said to her, "Oh, I need you to… 297 00:14:17,421 --> 00:14:21,221 Like, let's, let's offer some warmth or kindness," and she was like, "No, 298 00:14:21,221 --> 00:14:22,741 I don't, like, I don't want that." 299 00:14:23,731 --> 00:14:26,011 Are you talking there about a block? 300 00:14:26,121 --> 00:14:30,141 And do you think that's something that before you do any kind of compassion 301 00:14:30,141 --> 00:14:34,681 work with somebody, you're assessing what their beliefs are around compassion? 302 00:14:34,691 --> 00:14:38,011 You know, do they believe it's weak and pathetic? 303 00:14:38,021 --> 00:14:42,051 Do they see it as being too needy or self-pitying? 304 00:14:42,421 --> 00:14:46,731 Is that kind of a core part before you start any kind of empathetic 305 00:14:46,781 --> 00:14:48,251 bridging or intervention? 306 00:14:48,733 --> 00:14:50,953 Prof Paul Gilbert: It's a great question because again, it depends 307 00:14:50,953 --> 00:14:52,443 on how you start off your therapy. 308 00:14:52,443 --> 00:14:56,163 Now, all therapies usually have some explanation about what the 309 00:14:56,163 --> 00:14:57,673 therapy's about at the beginning. 310 00:14:58,053 --> 00:15:00,773 So if you're a psychodynamic therapist, you say, "Okay, what we're gonna be 311 00:15:00,773 --> 00:15:04,473 doing is you're gonna free associate, and I will make, pass comment on it. 312 00:15:04,473 --> 00:15:05,943 Just lay here on the couch," or whatever. 313 00:15:06,653 --> 00:15:09,083 you're a CBT therapist, we're gonna monitor your thoughts and 314 00:15:09,083 --> 00:15:10,023 help you see the connection. 315 00:15:10,313 --> 00:15:11,543 So that's important. 316 00:15:11,563 --> 00:15:15,663 So what we do in CFT is we say, "Well, you've come into 317 00:15:15,663 --> 00:15:17,693 a compassion-focused therapy. 318 00:15:17,903 --> 00:15:19,173 What do you think about that? 319 00:15:19,823 --> 00:15:21,623 know, what's your ideas about compassion?" 320 00:15:22,363 --> 00:15:22,853 Okay. 321 00:15:22,953 --> 00:15:26,063 And so they say, "Well, it's about being kind to yourself," whatever, whatever. 322 00:15:26,473 --> 00:15:27,303 It's very nice. 323 00:15:27,593 --> 00:15:28,773 "Do you think that's gonna help you?" 324 00:15:28,773 --> 00:15:30,433 "Well, to be honest, I don't know really. 325 00:15:30,433 --> 00:15:31,033 I'm not sure." 326 00:15:31,133 --> 00:15:31,593 Okay. 327 00:15:31,993 --> 00:15:37,383 So then we say, "Well, actually, you have intuitive wisdom that's very 328 00:15:37,383 --> 00:15:39,153 different to what you've just said to me." 329 00:15:39,453 --> 00:15:39,823 "Really?" 330 00:15:39,963 --> 00:15:40,353 "Yes. 331 00:15:40,633 --> 00:15:41,943 You know what compassion is. 332 00:15:41,943 --> 00:15:43,253 You just don't realize it." 333 00:15:43,483 --> 00:15:43,843 "Really?" 334 00:15:44,223 --> 00:15:44,673 "Yes. 335 00:15:44,873 --> 00:15:46,863 Let me do what is called a guided discovery, which 336 00:15:46,863 --> 00:15:48,503 in CBT is very important." 337 00:15:48,843 --> 00:15:49,243 "Okay. 338 00:15:49,243 --> 00:15:50,163 Is that okay?" 339 00:15:50,213 --> 00:15:50,403 "Yeah." 340 00:15:50,503 --> 00:15:50,763 "Okay. 341 00:15:50,783 --> 00:15:52,323 So I want you to bring to mind a friend. 342 00:15:53,103 --> 00:15:53,603 You got a friend? 343 00:15:53,803 --> 00:15:54,513 You think a great friend? 344 00:15:55,453 --> 00:15:55,843 Okay. 345 00:15:56,653 --> 00:15:57,513 What is it you like about them?" 346 00:15:57,533 --> 00:16:00,393 So you prime, this is called priming, so you're priming. 347 00:16:00,393 --> 00:16:03,003 So you're priming the memory of the friend, so they get the feeling, 348 00:16:03,003 --> 00:16:06,703 stimulate the feeling, and then you say to them, "Okay, now supposing your 349 00:16:06,703 --> 00:16:11,143 friend phones you up one day and they're very distressed because they have to go 350 00:16:11,143 --> 00:16:13,783 to hospital for a, a, a, an assessment. 351 00:16:13,783 --> 00:16:16,113 It's not a major thing, but it's important they go. 352 00:16:16,963 --> 00:16:19,343 But they're hospital-phobic, maybe 'cause of things that 353 00:16:19,343 --> 00:16:19,913 happened when they were a child. 354 00:16:19,923 --> 00:16:21,513 Well, they can't g- they're panicking. 355 00:16:21,513 --> 00:16:22,553 They're having panic attacks. 356 00:16:22,563 --> 00:16:24,743 H- how would you be with them?" 357 00:16:26,287 --> 00:16:27,857 Oh, I'd understand that. 358 00:16:27,907 --> 00:16:30,947 Yes, I could see that, and I would be c- would you be concerned for them? 359 00:16:31,017 --> 00:16:31,377 Yeah. 360 00:16:31,377 --> 00:16:33,017 Would you be sensitive to their… 361 00:16:33,437 --> 00:16:34,277 Oh, absolutely. 362 00:16:34,277 --> 00:16:35,177 Well, of course you would. 363 00:16:35,177 --> 00:16:36,297 Anybody would be, wouldn't they? 364 00:16:36,307 --> 00:16:37,547 See somebody struggling like that. 365 00:16:37,637 --> 00:16:38,387 Oh, that's interesting. 366 00:16:39,507 --> 00:16:40,297 What would you do? 367 00:16:40,307 --> 00:16:41,797 Would you-- don't know. 368 00:16:41,797 --> 00:16:42,717 Maybe I'd go and see them. 369 00:16:42,787 --> 00:16:43,107 Okay. 370 00:16:43,107 --> 00:16:43,627 Anything else? 371 00:16:43,967 --> 00:16:45,407 Well, perhaps I'd offer to go with them. 372 00:16:45,527 --> 00:16:46,127 Oh, I see. 373 00:16:46,127 --> 00:16:47,267 So why would you go with them? 374 00:16:47,837 --> 00:16:50,287 Well, because if you're that, like that and you have somebody that 375 00:16:50,287 --> 00:16:51,667 supports you and cares about you. 376 00:16:52,127 --> 00:16:52,807 Oh, I see. 377 00:16:52,807 --> 00:16:54,767 So that you'd give them the courage to go. 378 00:16:54,777 --> 00:16:55,407 Is that right? 379 00:16:55,657 --> 00:16:58,807 So when you have support and care, you get courage to face things that are tricky? 380 00:16:58,807 --> 00:16:59,747 Yes, of course you do. 381 00:17:00,147 --> 00:17:00,677 I see. 382 00:17:00,717 --> 00:17:01,187 Okay. 383 00:17:01,967 --> 00:17:03,537 You've understood compassion, haven't you? 384 00:17:03,867 --> 00:17:07,837 Compassion is developing the courage and wisdom to face things that are painful. 385 00:17:08,547 --> 00:17:09,597 That's what it is, right? 386 00:17:09,887 --> 00:17:10,737 Kindness and all that. 387 00:17:10,737 --> 00:17:12,307 Those are ways you can be compassionate. 388 00:17:12,567 --> 00:17:13,146 They're good ways. 389 00:17:13,497 --> 00:17:17,747 But actually, it's how we develop the compassi- courage and wisdom 390 00:17:18,017 --> 00:17:20,547 to be able to face the things that are so painful for you. 391 00:17:20,597 --> 00:17:21,777 That's what we're gonna be doing. 392 00:17:21,797 --> 00:17:22,646 That's what it is. 393 00:17:23,777 --> 00:17:24,166 Okay. 394 00:17:24,196 --> 00:17:26,936 And you've already discovered that when you're caring and you 395 00:17:26,946 --> 00:17:31,707 have that caring orientation, that gives you courage and wisdom, okay? 396 00:17:32,027 --> 00:17:36,177 That's what we're after, how we use compassion to help 397 00:17:36,177 --> 00:17:37,147 us with courage and wisdom. 398 00:17:37,417 --> 00:17:42,347 So basically have a discussion around that because it's such a key 399 00:17:42,347 --> 00:17:47,887 issue, and the number of times I've individuals and they haven't really 400 00:17:47,887 --> 00:17:50,657 helped the client understand what they're doing and why they're doing it. 401 00:17:50,977 --> 00:17:56,017 But if you use examples like that then they can see, yeah, for friends, know, 402 00:17:56,017 --> 00:17:59,657 if, if you're very frightened that somebody comes with you, helps you. 403 00:17:59,677 --> 00:18:00,257 Why? 404 00:18:00,697 --> 00:18:05,657 Because you're biologically designed to be helped by care and compassion. 405 00:18:06,027 --> 00:18:07,077 Your brain is set up for it 406 00:18:08,387 --> 00:18:08,787 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm-hmm. 407 00:18:09,587 --> 00:18:14,517 I think this is also where, and I have definitely made this error, where you 408 00:18:14,517 --> 00:18:19,457 move too quickly into, "Oh, okay, this would really help my client, and so I'm 409 00:18:19,457 --> 00:18:22,747 gonna try and really help them see this." 410 00:18:22,777 --> 00:18:27,087 Almost they haven't got the insight, but as the therapist you do, so you're 411 00:18:27,087 --> 00:18:30,767 trying to bring in compassionate imagery or soothing rhythm breathing, 412 00:18:30,777 --> 00:18:32,907 but it's kind of backfiring. 413 00:18:33,237 --> 00:18:36,827 I think that's, it, it's quite interesting that you-- the, the 414 00:18:36,827 --> 00:18:38,987 client has to get there themselves. 415 00:18:38,987 --> 00:18:42,277 I think you talk about the, they have to have the insight. 416 00:18:42,397 --> 00:18:46,467 You have to have that awareness first of either the head-heart lag or the 417 00:18:46,467 --> 00:18:50,917 awareness that, oh yeah, there is a f- I can easily be compassionate to others. 418 00:18:50,917 --> 00:18:55,007 And so in an exercise like that, of course they can think the perfect 419 00:18:55,007 --> 00:18:58,597 words that they'd say to the friend going in for those tests, but for 420 00:18:58,597 --> 00:19:02,507 them to recognize there's a disparity then between that and how they relate 421 00:19:02,617 --> 00:19:07,147 to themselves, because I think you'd then change how you work, right? 422 00:19:07,157 --> 00:19:12,847 You'd be working on the block there of, I guess, helping them recognize 423 00:19:12,887 --> 00:19:15,827 that for whatever reason they don't feel like they're worthy or 424 00:19:15,857 --> 00:19:20,057 maybe some of their beliefs are, "I'm undeserving of compassion," 425 00:19:20,357 --> 00:19:21,987 whereas everybody else is deserving 426 00:19:23,179 --> 00:19:23,759 Prof Paul Gilbert: Yes, that's right. 427 00:19:23,759 --> 00:19:26,159 And you're always working around it. 428 00:19:26,179 --> 00:19:28,769 For example, if you have people who say, "I'm not deserving, I'm 429 00:19:28,819 --> 00:19:32,799 not worthy," as we all in CFT, we always got the big three, anger, 430 00:19:32,799 --> 00:19:35,509 anxiety, and, and grieving, sadness. 431 00:19:35,509 --> 00:19:36,289 Those are the big three. 432 00:19:36,309 --> 00:19:40,439 They-- Sometimes people can do one or two of them, but not all three. 433 00:19:40,459 --> 00:19:43,439 So some people are very into the grieving, they're not very good with the anger. 434 00:19:43,759 --> 00:19:48,409 So some individuals who've got this worthy issue, actually they're in a rage, 435 00:19:48,769 --> 00:19:52,839 and they're absolutely terrified of it because raging makes them unlovable. 436 00:19:52,839 --> 00:19:55,669 Now, if you've spent your whole life trying to be lovable, trying to do 437 00:19:55,669 --> 00:19:58,369 the right things for people who like you, the one thing you do not wanna 438 00:19:58,369 --> 00:20:00,619 have to b- face up to is your shadow. 439 00:20:00,619 --> 00:20:02,149 You don't want it, right? 440 00:20:02,469 --> 00:20:06,139 But the problem with it is, is that your anger system is also the system 441 00:20:06,139 --> 00:20:09,869 that will defend you, that will stand up and say, "No, no, no, this 442 00:20:09,869 --> 00:20:11,579 is not-- I'm worth more than this. 443 00:20:11,579 --> 00:20:12,849 You're not gonna treat me like that." 444 00:20:13,259 --> 00:20:17,119 It's the assertive aspect of the self as well as the self-promoting aspect. 445 00:20:17,409 --> 00:20:18,959 Self-promoting is, "I think this is good. 446 00:20:18,959 --> 00:20:19,779 I'd like to do this. 447 00:20:19,779 --> 00:20:20,679 I'd like to do that." 448 00:20:20,679 --> 00:20:25,859 So, when you lose your capacity for being able to maintain your boundaries and deal 449 00:20:25,859 --> 00:20:30,599 with rage, life becomes a bit tricky and you're constantly trying to be appeased 450 00:20:30,599 --> 00:20:32,279 and pleased, and appeased and pleased. 451 00:20:32,969 --> 00:20:35,279 the rage in that is, is huge. 452 00:20:35,309 --> 00:20:38,239 And so you-- the point that you're making is very important 453 00:20:38,249 --> 00:20:39,639 because it's compassionate. 454 00:20:39,649 --> 00:20:44,809 This point is not about soothing, it's about engaging with rage. 455 00:20:44,869 --> 00:20:48,029 It's finding the courage and the wisdom to be able to recognize, "Yes, 456 00:20:48,029 --> 00:20:53,729 there is a part of me very injured and very enraged about happened to me, 457 00:20:53,729 --> 00:20:55,079 and that should not have happened." 458 00:20:55,209 --> 00:21:00,759 So the, the key is you say that if you start, particularly with these clients, 459 00:21:00,759 --> 00:21:03,539 if you start just throwing techniques at them, let's do some compassion 460 00:21:03,539 --> 00:21:05,439 imagery or soothing rhythm breathing. 461 00:21:05,439 --> 00:21:08,199 Soothing rhythm breathing in particular for the rage inhibitors 462 00:21:08,379 --> 00:21:10,349 is pretty useless actually. 463 00:21:11,049 --> 00:21:13,129 They don't need blah, blah, blah, blah. 464 00:21:13,489 --> 00:21:17,549 They, they, they can use it if they're prepared to engage, 465 00:21:17,559 --> 00:21:18,999 when they're prepared to engage. 466 00:21:19,469 --> 00:21:22,469 It's like, the diver on the high diving board, then you ground 467 00:21:22,469 --> 00:21:23,809 yourself in order to dive. 468 00:21:23,829 --> 00:21:26,969 Or the firefighter, you breathe in order to go to the fire. 469 00:21:26,969 --> 00:21:27,399 You don't just 470 00:21:28,019 --> 00:21:28,299 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): do 471 00:21:28,299 --> 00:21:29,369 Prof Paul Gilbert: it just for the sake of it. 472 00:21:29,631 --> 00:21:30,121 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. 473 00:21:30,329 --> 00:21:33,339 Prof Paul Gilbert: so it's learning to do your breathing exercises in 474 00:21:33,339 --> 00:21:37,539 order to steady yourself, in order then to face what you need to face. 475 00:21:39,389 --> 00:21:42,819 So, certainly with a lot of clients and with depression and self-criticism, 476 00:21:43,619 --> 00:21:46,969 hostile, h-harsh self-criticism, they're sitting on a lot of 477 00:21:47,139 --> 00:21:50,819 unprocessed rage, and helping them work, helping find the courage to work 478 00:21:50,819 --> 00:21:53,119 through that is very, very important 479 00:21:53,791 --> 00:21:54,331 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. 480 00:21:54,801 --> 00:22:00,521 Something that I think is I mean, when a client makes that transition from, uh, 481 00:22:00,531 --> 00:22:06,091 the way that lady spoke to about herself to you to then suddenly recognizing 482 00:22:06,091 --> 00:22:10,481 like, "Oh wow, this, you know, being sent to my room like this was awful." 483 00:22:10,851 --> 00:22:15,731 That grief part, i- maybe this is just me drawing on like personal experience 484 00:22:15,731 --> 00:22:19,811 of working with people, it's a bit of a supervision question, but the, the, 485 00:22:19,851 --> 00:22:21,821 the grief can feel quite overwhelming. 486 00:22:21,891 --> 00:22:25,721 So how, how do we work with that when that starts to happen? 487 00:22:28,417 --> 00:22:29,913 Prof Paul Gilbert: Well, and you're not pushing people into 488 00:22:29,913 --> 00:22:31,503 them, you kind of guided them. 489 00:22:31,503 --> 00:22:35,963 And CBT skills, Socratic questioning, guided discovery, these are 490 00:22:35,993 --> 00:22:37,523 very, very important skills. 491 00:22:37,523 --> 00:22:41,003 You go very slowly, so you can say to people, "Okay, so 492 00:22:41,043 --> 00:22:41,873 let's have a look at this. 493 00:22:41,873 --> 00:22:45,313 So what happens when you try to be compassionate to yourself? 494 00:22:46,093 --> 00:22:48,803 see what arises, can you just stick with what arises? 495 00:22:50,203 --> 00:22:51,573 And supposing you found…" 496 00:22:51,673 --> 00:22:55,013 I've, I've got a, a video on the members area actually talking to 497 00:22:55,013 --> 00:22:57,383 a client who does exactly this. 498 00:22:57,883 --> 00:23:00,783 Supposing that you would have feelings of anger about that, 499 00:23:00,783 --> 00:23:02,073 how would you feel about that? 500 00:23:02,073 --> 00:23:04,053 And this lady goes, "Oh, no, no, no." 501 00:23:04,053 --> 00:23:04,713 And she could see it. 502 00:23:04,753 --> 00:23:06,323 She goes back at the … "No, no, no, no. 503 00:23:06,323 --> 00:23:08,853 I w- no, I don't-- Anger's not a good emotion. 504 00:23:08,853 --> 00:23:09,113 I don't…" 505 00:23:09,373 --> 00:23:11,833 And so, so you could say, "Okay, well, so what is it that you 506 00:23:11,833 --> 00:23:13,273 would be worried about then?" 507 00:23:13,593 --> 00:23:17,423 So you can look at the beliefs about if I began to experience 508 00:23:17,423 --> 00:23:18,263 this, what would happen? 509 00:23:19,053 --> 00:23:19,713 It could be grief. 510 00:23:19,723 --> 00:23:23,693 If you began to experience this and you allowed yourself to tolerate, 511 00:23:23,733 --> 00:23:28,063 'cause, like ACT really, it's all emotional tolerance in a way non-avo- 512 00:23:28,103 --> 00:23:29,403 non-avoidance, what would happen? 513 00:23:29,663 --> 00:23:33,553 And of course, in all forms of emotional avoidance, it's because it's too intense 514 00:23:33,773 --> 00:23:37,293 or it carries a meaning that this emotion means you're a bad person or something. 515 00:23:37,593 --> 00:23:41,553 So the m- the intensity of the emotion and the meaning people put on it, 516 00:23:41,553 --> 00:23:44,813 those are the two things that usually are the pa- k- kind of the issue. 517 00:23:45,043 --> 00:23:49,883 So you, you kind of look at that and invite them to start to explore that. 518 00:23:50,743 --> 00:23:54,183 Supposing you could tolerate this, how would that be for you and so forth. 519 00:23:54,563 --> 00:23:56,973 And gradually you lead them to the recognition that actually at 520 00:23:56,993 --> 00:24:00,363 some point I'm gonna have to learn how to deal with this side of me. 521 00:24:00,683 --> 00:24:04,433 But the whole point of compassion is to do it in a way that's not overwhelming. 522 00:24:04,813 --> 00:24:08,523 Challenging, yes, but not overwhelming. 523 00:24:08,653 --> 00:24:09,043 Okay. 524 00:24:09,053 --> 00:24:10,893 It's like everything, learning to swim, right? 525 00:24:10,893 --> 00:24:13,093 We don't just chuck you overboard in the storm. 526 00:24:13,833 --> 00:24:16,493 it's a good idea to start off with the paddling pool. 527 00:24:16,933 --> 00:24:17,173 But- 528 00:24:17,755 --> 00:24:17,875 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm-hmm. 529 00:24:19,359 --> 00:24:21,969 Prof Paul Gilbert: We are moving up the scale of tolerance and 530 00:24:21,969 --> 00:24:23,759 ability to work with things. 531 00:24:24,659 --> 00:24:27,599 So all these com- all these cognitive behaviour skills are very, very 532 00:24:27,599 --> 00:24:31,529 useful because this guided discovery, people begin to see things. 533 00:24:31,539 --> 00:24:36,599 So supposing you say to somebody, "Look, know, you, you haven't felt anger towards 534 00:24:36,599 --> 00:24:40,979 what happened to you as a child, but imagine that you a child your sort of age. 535 00:24:40,989 --> 00:24:44,879 Can you bring to mind like, young girl or something, full of joy and play, just 536 00:24:44,879 --> 00:24:46,419 wants to be loved, and then this happens? 537 00:24:46,689 --> 00:24:47,959 How would you feel about them?" 538 00:24:48,129 --> 00:24:49,589 And they say, "Oh, X and Y. 539 00:24:49,589 --> 00:24:51,169 I'd be very angry," or whatever. 540 00:24:51,269 --> 00:24:51,959 And you say, "Okay. 541 00:24:53,629 --> 00:24:57,289 Now, what is it in you do you think that blocks that for you? 542 00:24:57,309 --> 00:24:58,709 What are you frightened about? 543 00:24:58,709 --> 00:25:03,319 If you allowed yourself to feel the exactly the same wisdom, the 544 00:25:03,319 --> 00:25:07,259 same courage that you have for seeing that little girl or whatever 545 00:25:07,979 --> 00:25:09,779 yourself, what is it that blocks you? 546 00:25:09,889 --> 00:25:10,209 What is it?" 547 00:25:10,259 --> 00:25:14,999 And so you begin to help them begin to explore that as a slow 548 00:25:14,999 --> 00:25:17,389 process of guided discovery, okay? 549 00:25:18,169 --> 00:25:19,009 let's imagine that. 550 00:25:19,009 --> 00:25:21,899 So imagine now that in this room you would say, "Actually, yes, Paul. 551 00:25:22,669 --> 00:25:23,419 I do feel it." 552 00:25:24,169 --> 00:25:28,539 And I, I often ac- ac- activate it out in a friendly way, because if you do a 553 00:25:28,539 --> 00:25:31,639 friendly way of doing it, you're sending the nonverbal communication that this 554 00:25:31,639 --> 00:25:35,369 is safe with your facial expression, but you're giving the message, right? 555 00:25:35,739 --> 00:25:38,309 So I'd say to them, "Supposing there was a part of you that actually one 556 00:25:38,309 --> 00:25:40,389 day just thought, 'Well, just fuck you. 557 00:25:40,469 --> 00:25:41,089 Fuck you.'" 558 00:25:41,399 --> 00:25:43,209 And you smile, right? 559 00:25:43,459 --> 00:25:44,409 How would that be? 560 00:25:45,719 --> 00:25:52,339 The point about it is, is helping them hear you say to them what 561 00:25:52,339 --> 00:25:53,399 they're frightened to hear, 562 00:25:54,155 --> 00:25:54,645 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. 563 00:25:55,949 --> 00:25:56,439 Prof Paul Gilbert: Okay? 564 00:25:56,529 --> 00:25:59,189 So I remember a client saying to me, "Oh, when you spoke like 565 00:25:59,199 --> 00:26:00,259 that, it used to really worry me. 566 00:26:00,259 --> 00:26:03,459 But then I thought to myself, 'I actually probably do have those 567 00:26:03,459 --> 00:26:04,519 thoughts, but I don't wanna have them.'" 568 00:26:04,519 --> 00:26:06,999 And then you say, "Well, yeah, but they're natural, aren't they? 569 00:26:07,009 --> 00:26:08,289 They're the ways we feel." 570 00:26:08,509 --> 00:26:15,069 So the ways in which you create sufficient safety and safeness in order to experience 571 00:26:15,409 --> 00:26:20,179 frightening emotions is part of what m- a lot of therapies, CBT, ACT, all 572 00:26:20,179 --> 00:26:25,529 of them are basically about how do we help people tolerate emotions they're 573 00:26:25,529 --> 00:26:27,599 frightened of and are blocked off from. 574 00:26:28,329 --> 00:26:31,849 All, all compassion-focused therapy does is, oh, this is one way you can 575 00:26:31,849 --> 00:26:36,009 do it by creating a compassionate mind state, 'cause that mind state 576 00:26:36,029 --> 00:26:37,759 has oxytocin, blah, blah, blah. 577 00:26:38,239 --> 00:26:41,209 All of those stuff will help tolerance. 578 00:26:41,689 --> 00:26:48,009 But in other ways, CFT uses a lot of pretty standard, evidence-based 579 00:26:48,009 --> 00:26:51,889 therapies of engagement, imagery, exposure, all that stuff. 580 00:26:52,669 --> 00:26:53,059 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm. 581 00:26:54,559 --> 00:26:59,339 On I guess we're mainly talking-- Well, we've talked a little bit about how people 582 00:26:59,399 --> 00:27:01,709 relate to others and that being easier. 583 00:27:01,979 --> 00:27:05,299 One of the things that you're-- Well, you're known for a lot of things, but 584 00:27:05,299 --> 00:27:09,719 the flows of compassion I did wanna touch on because I think clients can 585 00:27:09,739 --> 00:27:14,609 often connect with that as a concept, and it can be quite a helpful way of 586 00:27:14,609 --> 00:27:18,489 moving them from, "Oh, yeah, I haven't really thought about this," to, "Oh, wow, 587 00:27:18,489 --> 00:27:21,719 there is a difference in how I connect myself to how I connect with others." 588 00:27:22,209 --> 00:27:27,799 And the most common way that I have seen it played out is that somebody finds it a 589 00:27:27,799 --> 00:27:33,269 lot easier to give compassion to others, but not only do they have maybe a lot of 590 00:27:33,269 --> 00:27:38,139 self-criticism and a lack of compassion towards themselves, but they also really 591 00:27:38,139 --> 00:27:41,039 struggle to receive it from other people. 592 00:27:41,439 --> 00:27:46,059 And the way I tend to describe it to a client is that there's something 593 00:27:46,059 --> 00:27:50,069 quite v- like, there's a vulnerability there that recognizing that you might 594 00:27:50,069 --> 00:27:54,439 need something from somebody else activates a threat state, and so 595 00:27:54,459 --> 00:27:56,709 they-- it's easier to shu-shut it down. 596 00:27:56,869 --> 00:27:59,899 I mean, it's quite a difficult question, but why is that? 597 00:27:59,969 --> 00:28:06,279 And is it easier to then start with allowing them to have other people 598 00:28:06,319 --> 00:28:07,709 deliver compassion to themselves? 599 00:28:07,709 --> 00:28:10,819 Than starting with self-to-self relating? 600 00:28:11,239 --> 00:28:12,169 Prof Paul Gilbert: Well, it's a great question. 601 00:28:12,189 --> 00:28:12,739 Depends. 602 00:28:12,749 --> 00:28:14,879 Sometimes, sometimes not, actually. 603 00:28:15,329 --> 00:28:20,209 So of the key themes with that really is social trust. 604 00:28:20,229 --> 00:28:21,749 Now you could say, "Oh, well, it's difficult." 605 00:28:22,059 --> 00:28:24,259 And I would say to a client, "Well, you don't trust them, do you really?" 606 00:28:26,099 --> 00:28:26,839 "What do you mean you don't trust them?" 607 00:28:26,839 --> 00:28:29,989 "Well, you don't trust them because y- you're worried that if they got closer 608 00:28:29,989 --> 00:28:33,199 to you or they got to find out about you, then they'd stop being kind to you. 609 00:28:33,799 --> 00:28:37,469 Or you could-- if you trusted them and you relied on them and they let you down, 610 00:28:37,469 --> 00:28:38,639 where are you gonna be then, right?" 611 00:28:39,349 --> 00:28:43,169 you direct them to the issue that part of not allowing compassion is, 612 00:28:43,179 --> 00:28:47,019 is because I don't deserve it or whatever, but it's also distrust. 613 00:28:47,109 --> 00:28:51,729 I don't, I don't believe people will care about me if they kn- know about me, if 614 00:28:51,729 --> 00:28:55,419 they know what goes on in my mind, if they know about things that I've done 615 00:28:55,419 --> 00:28:59,759 or thought, 'cause cl- some of these clients do have quite dark thoughts. 616 00:29:00,229 --> 00:29:04,519 So talking about the issue of distrust is quite important. 617 00:29:04,609 --> 00:29:04,959 All right? 618 00:29:05,309 --> 00:29:07,649 What, what would it mean to actually trust somebody if they 619 00:29:07,649 --> 00:29:10,749 say they wanna be helpful to you? 620 00:29:10,979 --> 00:29:12,479 What would you immediately think? 621 00:29:13,369 --> 00:29:14,379 "Oh, I don't wanna be a burden." 622 00:29:14,429 --> 00:29:14,879 Okay. 623 00:29:14,969 --> 00:29:17,159 So would you worry that they'd see you as a burden? 624 00:29:17,159 --> 00:29:17,629 "Well, yes." 625 00:29:17,679 --> 00:29:18,109 Okay. 626 00:29:18,289 --> 00:29:21,189 So it's all about helping them recognize that process of, 627 00:29:21,619 --> 00:29:24,359 of distrust and, and so on. 628 00:29:24,789 --> 00:29:29,069 And also, as we've talked earlier about, it, it stimulates the yearning then when 629 00:29:29,069 --> 00:29:32,369 you begin to realize, "Actually, no, I do want people to care about me, and I've 630 00:29:32,369 --> 00:29:33,759 been yearning for that for a long time." 631 00:29:34,019 --> 00:29:38,749 So there's all these different elements in it as they begin to experience being 632 00:29:38,829 --> 00:29:40,459 open to the compassion for others. 633 00:29:40,459 --> 00:29:43,479 But our research, and you're right about this, Natalie, our research 634 00:29:43,479 --> 00:29:49,269 shows that the fears of compassion from others is more predictive of depression 635 00:29:49,269 --> 00:29:51,009 and anxiety than self-compassion. 636 00:29:51,469 --> 00:29:55,279 And self-compassion's a big thing obviously, but actually the ability 637 00:29:55,279 --> 00:29:59,099 to be open and receive compassion because we're a social being. 638 00:29:59,389 --> 00:30:03,249 Our brains are designed for social relating, so our ability to feel 639 00:30:03,259 --> 00:30:07,959 socially embedded is more important to us than self-compassion. 640 00:30:09,067 --> 00:30:09,507 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. 641 00:30:10,059 --> 00:30:11,229 Prof Paul Gilbert: But it's just, yeah 642 00:30:11,997 --> 00:30:15,667 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): I always d-- I, I do always feel a little bit encouraged 643 00:30:15,687 --> 00:30:21,427 because I, I also work a lot with ACT, and I think often when some-someone 644 00:30:21,427 --> 00:30:25,727 is able to be so compassionate, and ironically it's often the people that 645 00:30:25,977 --> 00:30:29,987 aim-- are most self-critical that you find in caring professions, like 646 00:30:29,987 --> 00:30:34,237 they're a doctor or a nurse or they, they give their lives for other people, 647 00:30:34,457 --> 00:30:38,947 and they're so compassionate to other people, yet to themselves they're not. 648 00:30:39,467 --> 00:30:42,527 I'm not always put off by that because I guess I see it as 649 00:30:42,647 --> 00:30:43,547 there's something in them. 650 00:30:43,547 --> 00:30:46,067 They, they have a value for compassion. 651 00:30:46,067 --> 00:30:50,527 It just hasn't quite translated towards themselves, and that, I mean, is great 652 00:30:50,537 --> 00:30:52,457 information in and of itself, isn't it? 653 00:30:52,467 --> 00:30:57,467 To then think about where you might begin to, to work with somebody to help 654 00:30:57,467 --> 00:31:02,687 them recognize that because it is so transformational when somebody moves from 655 00:31:02,687 --> 00:31:09,467 that place of not caring, being completely numb, to recognizing and nurturing 656 00:31:09,467 --> 00:31:11,967 within themselves a different voice. 657 00:31:12,437 --> 00:31:15,737 One of the things I like to do with clients is obviously you're doing 658 00:31:15,737 --> 00:31:19,917 a lot of practice in sessions, but because you see someone for such a 659 00:31:19,917 --> 00:31:24,277 short amount of time, what they do in their life, what they're observing 660 00:31:24,277 --> 00:31:27,007 and doing, I think really does count. 661 00:31:27,467 --> 00:31:30,927 Are there-- and obviously it depends on the client, but are there certain 662 00:31:31,407 --> 00:31:35,107 practices or things that you have found to be really helpful when 663 00:31:35,527 --> 00:31:39,857 you're working with clients to maybe develop a more compassionate view of 664 00:31:39,857 --> 00:31:43,997 themselves that you might encourage them to do outside of sessions? 665 00:31:45,777 --> 00:31:46,047 Yeah 666 00:31:46,331 --> 00:31:46,601 Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah. 667 00:31:47,021 --> 00:31:52,457 So the key thing is where we started this, voice tone Which is one thing, 668 00:31:53,127 --> 00:31:54,847 develop a friendly voice in your head. 669 00:31:55,047 --> 00:31:55,797 That's one thing. 670 00:31:55,807 --> 00:31:59,327 And if you notice, I've got a client at the moment who's really struggled 671 00:31:59,327 --> 00:32:02,217 with this, but he just today emailed me, said, "I think I've got it. 672 00:32:02,217 --> 00:32:03,347 It really helped me the other day." 673 00:32:03,843 --> 00:32:04,563 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Oh, great 674 00:32:04,667 --> 00:32:07,277 Prof Paul Gilbert: He gets frustrated with things and then says it's because 675 00:32:07,277 --> 00:32:09,587 he's stupid and he's made silly mistakes. 676 00:32:10,037 --> 00:32:15,467 So when you notice this, right, just take a breath, ground, and create a friendly 677 00:32:15,467 --> 00:32:19,037 face and just focus on, okay, well, this is distressing, it's upsetting, 678 00:32:19,067 --> 00:32:21,387 and practice the emotional tone. 679 00:32:21,667 --> 00:32:22,847 Change your emotional tone. 680 00:32:23,057 --> 00:32:24,727 Switch, switch your brain state. 681 00:32:24,747 --> 00:32:25,477 Switch your brain state. 682 00:32:25,477 --> 00:32:27,707 You practicing switching. 683 00:32:27,887 --> 00:32:30,907 Don't worry too much about getting the right cognitive views. 684 00:32:30,907 --> 00:32:35,347 Just refocus and try as best you can to be a little bit more 685 00:32:35,347 --> 00:32:36,627 friendly, a little bit more playful. 686 00:32:37,157 --> 00:32:42,157 So changing the tone of what you're thinking is, is, is extremely important. 687 00:32:42,967 --> 00:32:45,807 thing with compassion is guided practice. 688 00:32:45,867 --> 00:32:47,257 Again, a good CBT thing. 689 00:32:47,457 --> 00:32:51,527 So we would say to clients, "Okay, think about f- three or four things 690 00:32:51,537 --> 00:32:54,997 that you think would help you with compassion," things that you, you know. 691 00:32:55,097 --> 00:32:57,677 They say, "Well, maybe I could be more empathic," or, "I could be more 692 00:32:57,677 --> 00:33:00,187 patient," or, "I could be more assertive." 693 00:33:00,187 --> 00:33:02,367 And you say, "Okay, so what we're gonna do is we're gonna 694 00:33:02,367 --> 00:33:04,867 practice one skill for this week. 695 00:33:04,917 --> 00:33:05,947 Only one, right? 696 00:33:06,807 --> 00:33:10,247 Okay, so this week is Okay? 697 00:33:10,347 --> 00:33:11,297 So we're gonna practice." 698 00:33:11,297 --> 00:33:15,007 So then we do standard, pretty standard assertiveness training. 699 00:33:15,667 --> 00:33:17,617 know, we don't do the fierce compassion of that. 700 00:33:17,617 --> 00:33:22,257 We do s- pretty standard assertiveness training, but with the focus on compassion 701 00:33:22,607 --> 00:33:25,817 and with the focus on respectfulness for the other, with the ability to 702 00:33:25,847 --> 00:33:29,507 empathize with the other if you're in conflict with them, to mentalize, but 703 00:33:29,507 --> 00:33:31,277 at the same time hold your position. 704 00:33:31,277 --> 00:33:33,887 So we, we-- and then we say, "Off, off you go. 705 00:33:34,127 --> 00:33:36,317 Practice for the week and see what happens," right? 706 00:33:36,877 --> 00:33:38,337 And so they practice that one. 707 00:33:38,437 --> 00:33:42,567 Or they could be, I want to practice being less easily frustrated. 708 00:33:42,617 --> 00:33:43,097 Okay. 709 00:33:43,317 --> 00:33:44,347 The first thing is mindfulness. 710 00:33:44,877 --> 00:33:49,417 We're gonna being mindful when you notice the body starting to react. 711 00:33:49,587 --> 00:33:52,217 We're getting frustrated, that, that shit feeling, the oh, 712 00:33:52,217 --> 00:33:54,217 shit, that arises within you. 713 00:33:54,447 --> 00:33:56,887 Noticing that take a breath and s- and pull out. 714 00:33:56,927 --> 00:33:57,817 Take a breath and pull out. 715 00:33:57,817 --> 00:34:03,107 Just this practice, that one skill, noticing when that, oh, shit feeling 716 00:34:03,117 --> 00:34:05,447 arises in your mind and switching. 717 00:34:05,547 --> 00:34:10,226 So compassion, otherwise it gets too, a bit too all over the place, so you're 718 00:34:10,226 --> 00:34:15,917 bringing your skills into focusing on particular themes and letting them 719 00:34:15,917 --> 00:34:18,107 practice and then come back to you. 720 00:34:18,127 --> 00:34:23,617 Now, in CBT, there's a very nice assertiveness one, which anxious 721 00:34:23,726 --> 00:34:25,077 clients are not so keen on. 722 00:34:25,327 --> 00:34:29,937 You ask them to go into a shop, for a demonstration of a washing 723 00:34:29,937 --> 00:34:33,587 machine or whatever it is, take up the time of the assistant and 724 00:34:33,587 --> 00:34:34,657 then say, "Thank you very much. 725 00:34:34,817 --> 00:34:36,476 I'll give it some thought," and walk out. 726 00:34:37,266 --> 00:34:39,827 S- Anxious people do not like doing that. 727 00:34:40,297 --> 00:34:42,117 But you're very friendly, and you say, "Thank you. 728 00:34:42,117 --> 00:34:42,847 That's been great. 729 00:34:42,847 --> 00:34:43,937 You've been very helpful to me. 730 00:34:43,937 --> 00:34:44,337 Thank you very much." 731 00:34:45,369 --> 00:34:46,049 And then walk out. 732 00:34:46,079 --> 00:34:49,789 So there is all kinds of things that you can help people 733 00:34:49,839 --> 00:34:51,668 engage in behavioral practice. 734 00:34:52,119 --> 00:34:56,768 It could be things like, s- making a request. 735 00:34:56,958 --> 00:34:58,899 Are there any requests that you would like? 736 00:34:59,669 --> 00:35:02,119 know, if somebody says, "What would you like to eat for dinner?" 737 00:35:02,119 --> 00:35:03,849 And you say, "I don't mind, you choose, darling." 738 00:35:04,279 --> 00:35:06,749 Okay, so over this week, if anybody asks you anything, 739 00:35:06,759 --> 00:35:07,909 you're gonna make a decision. 740 00:35:08,619 --> 00:35:08,669 right. 741 00:35:08,709 --> 00:35:10,849 Oh, yeah, but suppose they don't like what I've chosen. 742 00:35:10,899 --> 00:35:12,469 Okay, we're gonna work with that. 743 00:35:12,509 --> 00:35:16,079 But this week, whenever you're asked, what would you like to do? 744 00:35:16,079 --> 00:35:16,469 What would you… 745 00:35:16,809 --> 00:35:18,219 You're going to make a decision. 746 00:35:18,549 --> 00:35:19,559 You're gonna make a decision. 747 00:35:19,749 --> 00:35:20,089 Okay? 748 00:35:21,639 --> 00:35:24,479 it, it may be in your physical relationship, learning to make 749 00:35:24,579 --> 00:35:26,379 s- the first move, not wait. 750 00:35:26,769 --> 00:35:31,279 So there can be many, many areas where y- you teach them assertiveness 751 00:35:31,279 --> 00:35:33,969 training of actually making the positive choice, blah, blah, blah. 752 00:35:33,969 --> 00:35:35,849 Always being respectful of other people, of course. 753 00:35:36,279 --> 00:35:40,319 So the key thing is that, but you do it with this, I'm going to develop 754 00:35:40,319 --> 00:35:43,989 my compassionate wisdom and courage now, and you do it in a friendly way, 755 00:35:44,049 --> 00:35:45,619 and I'm going to make this request. 756 00:35:46,829 --> 00:35:47,089 See? 757 00:35:47,129 --> 00:35:52,419 So you create this emotional texture all the time if you can, order to engage with 758 00:35:52,439 --> 00:35:53,779 the thing that you're struggling with 759 00:35:54,805 --> 00:35:58,115 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): I love those examples because sometimes I think 760 00:35:58,125 --> 00:36:02,385 we f- clinicians can feel a little bit hesitant in leading the client, 761 00:36:02,435 --> 00:36:06,535 and obviously some modalities, with CBT, you'd maybe spend the session 762 00:36:06,535 --> 00:36:08,645 setting up a behavioral experiment. 763 00:36:08,695 --> 00:36:08,875 But 764 00:36:08,947 --> 00:36:09,037 Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah, 765 00:36:09,175 --> 00:36:10,905 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): I think it's important for people to have 766 00:36:10,905 --> 00:36:14,255 the permission that, if you give that to the client, like, "Okay, 767 00:36:14,255 --> 00:36:15,915 so what could you try this week?" 768 00:36:16,425 --> 00:36:19,565 That they can draw blanks because that can feel quite overwhelming. 769 00:36:19,565 --> 00:36:23,605 So I think those are some really practical ways, and hopefully will give people 770 00:36:23,665 --> 00:36:28,025 permission to think, "Oh yeah, we can make it something like, going to a shop." 771 00:36:28,305 --> 00:36:33,875 It doesn't have to always be, going away and practicing your compassionate other 772 00:36:34,195 --> 00:36:36,285 script or soothing rhythm breathing. 773 00:36:36,295 --> 00:36:39,805 It, it can be the, the practical shop example. 774 00:36:40,045 --> 00:36:43,515 Something I found with a client, just in case it's helpful anyone listening, 775 00:36:43,905 --> 00:36:49,065 with a client who really struggled with the tone we started with writing because 776 00:36:49,065 --> 00:36:56,385 writing they were able to generate really amazing, compassionate sentences, and 777 00:36:56,535 --> 00:37:01,115 it was only after quite a few weeks of them doing that in their own time 778 00:37:01,595 --> 00:37:03,905 that it began to then change the tone. 779 00:37:03,905 --> 00:37:09,865 So it was almost like the writing un- unlocked something and, uh, so just in 780 00:37:09,865 --> 00:37:14,165 case somebody else is struggling with that, sometimes changing the method by 781 00:37:14,165 --> 00:37:20,665 which compassion is heard, in the mind, maybe how it's read can help sometimes. 782 00:37:21,111 --> 00:37:21,471 Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah. 783 00:37:21,911 --> 00:37:25,451 I think that's-- And one of the-- 'cause you, the key thing is like when you're 784 00:37:25,451 --> 00:37:29,341 doing your compassion, making them, helping them feel it in the body, 'cause 785 00:37:29,341 --> 00:37:32,831 if they don't feel it in the body, we often say it's like sexual fantasies. 786 00:37:32,831 --> 00:37:36,151 You can have fantastic fantasies, but if nothing's happening in your body, it's 787 00:37:36,171 --> 00:37:37,741 not, they're not really any use, are they? 788 00:37:37,991 --> 00:37:42,791 And you're only using fantasy because your brain can change your blood flow. 789 00:37:42,791 --> 00:37:44,181 Your brain can release hormones. 790 00:37:44,181 --> 00:37:48,491 That's why you use fantasy, 'cause it's a powerful physiological stimulator. 791 00:37:48,511 --> 00:37:50,251 But so with compassion imagery. 792 00:37:51,061 --> 00:37:55,311 this is, very important about learning how to use these kind of 793 00:37:55,321 --> 00:37:58,081 images to, to stimulate the body. 794 00:37:58,641 --> 00:37:59,021 And 795 00:37:59,259 --> 00:37:59,479 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm-hmm. 796 00:38:00,111 --> 00:38:00,791 Prof Paul Gilbert: So that's one thing. 797 00:38:00,791 --> 00:38:03,791 And the other thing is getting people, having people practice 798 00:38:03,861 --> 00:38:04,951 relating to themselves. 799 00:38:04,961 --> 00:38:08,701 So one of the things I do a lot is create a compassionate self. 800 00:38:08,701 --> 00:38:12,611 Now imagine a part of yourself that's struggling, maybe the anxious self. 801 00:38:13,081 --> 00:38:13,521 Okay? 802 00:38:13,731 --> 00:38:17,121 Now then, the first thing that we always do as a compassionate 803 00:38:17,121 --> 00:38:18,921 self is called validation. 804 00:38:20,341 --> 00:38:20,801 Okay? 805 00:38:21,121 --> 00:38:25,481 So I'm gonna ask you now just to say to that self, "I can understand 806 00:38:25,481 --> 00:38:27,881 what you're feeling and why you're feeling," and name yourself. 807 00:38:27,881 --> 00:38:31,601 So if I was doing it to myself, I'd say, "Paul, I can understand why 808 00:38:31,601 --> 00:38:35,401 you're really anxious and that's so difficult for you because these are 809 00:38:35,431 --> 00:38:38,381 things you've experienced a lot, you know, and you've really struggled with." 810 00:38:38,521 --> 00:38:42,201 So I'd validate it, and I'd have them practice it, and then say 811 00:38:42,201 --> 00:38:43,671 to them, "Let's hear you say it. 812 00:38:43,691 --> 00:38:46,251 Now when you say that from the compassionate mind to that part 813 00:38:46,251 --> 00:38:47,351 of you, what are you feeling?" 814 00:38:47,841 --> 00:38:51,451 So you're getting them to actually develop this dialogue and practicing the dialogue 815 00:38:51,451 --> 00:38:55,161 and the therapy so they can practice being in the compassionate mind and then 816 00:38:55,901 --> 00:38:57,831 dialoguing, so they get the hang of that. 817 00:38:58,281 --> 00:39:04,531 And I often give them an example that, you know, I was younger, in my 40s, and I give 818 00:39:04,531 --> 00:39:07,061 them an example that the compassionate mind can often help you understand 819 00:39:07,331 --> 00:39:09,591 emotions that perhaps you're denying. 820 00:39:10,361 --> 00:39:12,971 I was in my 40s, I used to love playing cricket, and that was great, 821 00:39:12,971 --> 00:39:16,271 and I-- 'cause I was at boarding school, so being part of the boys' 822 00:39:16,271 --> 00:39:17,761 teams was always important for me. 823 00:39:18,221 --> 00:39:20,731 But as I got older, I wasn't getting, I wasn't getting any 824 00:39:20,771 --> 00:39:21,771 better , I was getting worse. 825 00:39:22,041 --> 00:39:24,091 And of course, younger people were coming into the team. 826 00:39:24,401 --> 00:39:25,421 It was quite a good team. 827 00:39:25,871 --> 00:39:28,741 And I knew that probably within the next year or two, I'm not, 828 00:39:28,861 --> 00:39:30,261 wasn't gonna be chosen anymore. 829 00:39:30,711 --> 00:39:31,881 And I was struggling with that. 830 00:39:31,881 --> 00:39:34,581 And then one day, we had this quite important match, and 831 00:39:34,581 --> 00:39:36,461 I dropped a very easy catch. 832 00:39:37,141 --> 00:39:38,631 was so angry at myself. 833 00:39:38,631 --> 00:39:41,691 I was really angry and I was really fury, fuming. 834 00:39:41,791 --> 00:39:45,201 And I got home and I thought, "Well, I'm just, Let me do a compassionate self." 835 00:39:45,201 --> 00:39:49,821 So I s- said, "Paul, I can see why you're distressed because you dropped the catch. 836 00:39:49,831 --> 00:39:51,151 That's very upsetting for you." 837 00:39:53,421 --> 00:39:57,041 And then the compassionate self said, "The real relationsh- the real problem, 838 00:39:57,041 --> 00:40:00,571 isn't it, is that you can't come to terms with getting old and you're 839 00:40:00,581 --> 00:40:03,541 grieving for what you're about to lose. 840 00:40:04,171 --> 00:40:04,901 You're grieving." 841 00:40:06,161 --> 00:40:09,211 And I was very qui- I felt quite tearful at that point and I thought, 842 00:40:09,211 --> 00:40:10,371 "Yeah, that's actually true." 843 00:40:11,091 --> 00:40:11,101 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. 844 00:40:11,201 --> 00:40:13,131 Prof Paul Gilbert: this raging and everything because underneath 845 00:40:13,931 --> 00:40:15,121 these days are finished. 846 00:40:15,881 --> 00:40:17,341 I won't be able to play like that anymore. 847 00:40:17,371 --> 00:40:18,971 I won't be in a team like that anymore. 848 00:40:19,621 --> 00:40:21,611 not gonna be wanted anymore 'cause I'm not good enough 849 00:40:23,831 --> 00:40:25,561 But that is the reality, right? 850 00:40:25,581 --> 00:40:27,771 So now compassion says, "Yes, that's reality. 851 00:40:27,901 --> 00:40:30,551 We have to face that, and that's part of growing up and getting old." 852 00:40:31,351 --> 00:40:36,861 so compassion allowed me then just to settle it down and say, "Actually, the 853 00:40:36,861 --> 00:40:41,151 real pain is the reality of growing old and losing your abilities to 854 00:40:41,861 --> 00:40:43,131 perform at the way that you were." 855 00:40:43,511 --> 00:40:48,231 So compassion, when you teach people how to have a compassionate mind that 856 00:40:48,231 --> 00:40:53,021 validates the mind, they begin to sense things going on, not just the 857 00:40:53,021 --> 00:40:55,131 anxiety, but things behind the anxiety. 858 00:40:55,451 --> 00:40:58,441 So you teach them that, and that you can do that in five minutes. 859 00:40:58,781 --> 00:41:00,101 Come into your compassionate self. 860 00:41:00,461 --> 00:41:03,611 Now imagine this part of you, your grief part or your upset or your 861 00:41:03,611 --> 00:41:05,771 angry part, and validate that. 862 00:41:05,841 --> 00:41:07,631 "I can see why you're so angry because…" 863 00:41:07,661 --> 00:41:09,381 or, "I can see why you're so distressed because…" 864 00:41:09,741 --> 00:41:13,271 And that act of learning to validate themselves in a compassionate 865 00:41:13,271 --> 00:41:15,241 voice is very powerful, actually. 866 00:41:15,621 --> 00:41:16,141 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. 867 00:41:17,091 --> 00:41:17,491 Hmm. 868 00:41:18,131 --> 00:41:21,801 How much of a role do you feel clinicians-- We spoke about it at the 869 00:41:21,801 --> 00:41:23,471 beginning with the empathetic bridging. 870 00:41:23,921 --> 00:41:29,261 Do you think there's a risk of overdoing that as a therapist offering 871 00:41:29,281 --> 00:41:36,781 too much encouragement, praise, or is there kind of no limit to that? 872 00:41:37,399 --> 00:41:39,149 Prof Paul Gilbert: Well, I think like everything really, you're 873 00:41:39,159 --> 00:41:40,869 using your clinical skills. 874 00:41:40,869 --> 00:41:43,449 I mean, anything applies just across the board. 875 00:41:43,889 --> 00:41:47,789 Some people need it more intensely than others, and so on and so on. 876 00:41:47,799 --> 00:41:49,449 Some people can go faster than others. 877 00:41:49,459 --> 00:41:54,699 So you're always using your clinical skills, to make judgments about that 878 00:41:54,699 --> 00:41:56,389 and checking out with your clients. 879 00:41:56,399 --> 00:42:00,299 I mean, one of the great things about CBT is the collaborative 880 00:42:00,299 --> 00:42:01,439 checking out all the time. 881 00:42:01,439 --> 00:42:02,149 How is that for you? 882 00:42:02,149 --> 00:42:03,119 Does that make sense to you? 883 00:42:03,129 --> 00:42:04,109 Would you like to change it? 884 00:42:04,119 --> 00:42:04,989 Do you wanna have another go? 885 00:42:05,759 --> 00:42:06,369 All of that 886 00:42:06,381 --> 00:42:06,671 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Yeah. 887 00:42:06,749 --> 00:42:07,049 Prof Paul Gilbert: stuff. 888 00:42:07,129 --> 00:42:12,649 So you're building your journey together as opposed to trying to 889 00:42:12,649 --> 00:42:13,839 get them there or get them there. 890 00:42:14,119 --> 00:42:18,209 You're, you're building a collaborative journey, and that's actually quite 891 00:42:18,209 --> 00:42:21,279 a skill 'cause you often want them to be miles ahead of where they are. 892 00:42:21,279 --> 00:42:26,909 But this collaborative process, I think, is such an important element of therapy. 893 00:42:27,303 --> 00:42:27,703 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. 894 00:42:28,753 --> 00:42:31,923 Paul, it's gonna be a crime if I don't talk about three circles 895 00:42:31,953 --> 00:42:35,553 model with you, given I have you on and we haven't got there yet. 896 00:42:36,143 --> 00:42:40,873 I think it's probably the, the one thing that even if you're not CFT trained, you 897 00:42:40,923 --> 00:42:45,003 probably have come across this diagram, and for those of you that don't know what 898 00:42:45,043 --> 00:42:46,743 that is you're gonna have to look it up. 899 00:42:46,983 --> 00:42:49,773 But essentially, it's documented as three circles. 900 00:42:49,773 --> 00:42:52,233 You've got your threat, drive, and soothing system. 901 00:42:52,693 --> 00:43:00,003 Now, when, when I was taught this and began looking into it, I, I often 902 00:43:00,393 --> 00:43:04,103 thought about this system as, like, the three circles being like, well, 903 00:43:04,213 --> 00:43:05,823 you need, we need to have balance. 904 00:43:06,053 --> 00:43:07,723 You know, you can't just have threat and drive. 905 00:43:07,723 --> 00:43:09,253 You need soothing as well. 906 00:43:09,653 --> 00:43:16,723 But my take on it now a bit, a few years on, is that it isn't about balance. 907 00:43:16,733 --> 00:43:21,783 It's about ensuring that you have all of those systems, and you are 908 00:43:21,973 --> 00:43:25,593 able to be in threat, but you can mitigate threat with soothing. 909 00:43:26,053 --> 00:43:30,493 Not that we should all be balanced all of the time, and I guess I just-- 910 00:43:30,593 --> 00:43:34,073 I think because it's such a model that connects with people, you know. 911 00:43:34,073 --> 00:43:37,453 You mention to most clients this idea of being in threat mode and 912 00:43:37,463 --> 00:43:41,803 being in drive and sooth, people get it quite quickly, in my experience. 913 00:43:41,823 --> 00:43:46,783 But I do think there's a little bit of a risk that we kind of use it as a tool 914 00:43:47,053 --> 00:43:49,073 that, you know, people can connect with. 915 00:43:49,103 --> 00:43:54,093 We kind of then feel like, it's made sense to somebody, but we might be missing 916 00:43:54,493 --> 00:43:58,733 that actually what somebody might be showing us is that they permanently live 917 00:43:58,733 --> 00:44:03,423 in, like, this threat and drive state, and what is completely lacking from 918 00:44:03,423 --> 00:44:09,323 their life is an ability to actually come out of drive using the soothing 919 00:44:09,323 --> 00:44:12,923 system, that when they fail, they go straight back into that threat state. 920 00:44:13,373 --> 00:44:16,813 So in your experience, what do you, what do you think the errors are of, 921 00:44:16,913 --> 00:44:22,803 that you have seen clinicians make when using the three circles, and how 922 00:44:22,803 --> 00:44:24,473 sh- how we should use it properly? 923 00:44:24,811 --> 00:44:26,701 Prof Paul Gilbert: Yes, I think that's a great question. 924 00:44:27,061 --> 00:44:31,251 I mean, so the first thing is that, and sometimes this is not always explained 925 00:44:31,401 --> 00:44:35,851 terribly well is we have the, the what we call the, the two, three, and five. 926 00:44:36,281 --> 00:44:38,071 So I'm trying to do this better now. 927 00:44:38,091 --> 00:44:40,371 We did it in Human Nature and Suffering, but nobody reads that 928 00:44:40,471 --> 00:44:42,181 because it's too complicated in '99. 929 00:44:42,451 --> 00:44:46,221 So the two, all living things are designed for survival and reproduction. 930 00:44:46,481 --> 00:44:47,721 Basically, that's the thing, right? 931 00:44:48,581 --> 00:44:52,511 a result of doing that, you have three tasks. 932 00:44:52,541 --> 00:44:55,901 One is all living things need to be able to detect threats to their 933 00:44:55,901 --> 00:44:58,051 existence and do something about it. 934 00:44:58,061 --> 00:44:59,891 There's no point in detecting the threat and not being 935 00:44:59,891 --> 00:45:00,801 able to do anything about it. 936 00:45:01,271 --> 00:45:04,571 Even the bacteria in your gut can move away from toxic areas. 937 00:45:04,571 --> 00:45:05,381 They have a movement. 938 00:45:05,521 --> 00:45:09,609 So there's some species that move and some species that don't. 939 00:45:09,609 --> 00:45:11,361 Plants obviously don't move, but they have other ways of protecting 940 00:45:11,361 --> 00:45:14,101 themselves, like curling their leaves if there's not enough water. 941 00:45:14,531 --> 00:45:17,251 Some of them have evolved sap, which is poisonous to 942 00:45:17,251 --> 00:45:18,251 insects and that sort of thing. 943 00:45:18,971 --> 00:45:20,991 Okay, that's the first thing. 944 00:45:21,241 --> 00:45:25,121 All living things need an ability to detect threat and respond to it. 945 00:45:25,191 --> 00:45:28,541 Now, on the, on the whole, threats come to you. 946 00:45:28,541 --> 00:45:29,901 You don't go looking for them. 947 00:45:29,901 --> 00:45:33,031 You don't go out, "Oh, I think I'll go out and see if I can 948 00:45:33,041 --> 00:45:34,441 find a lion to play with." 949 00:45:34,441 --> 00:45:35,951 I don't think that's what happens. 950 00:45:37,011 --> 00:45:41,641 The second major to life task is you have to obtain things. 951 00:45:41,641 --> 00:45:45,731 You have to go out and obtain food and find mates and build shelters 952 00:45:45,731 --> 00:45:49,161 and find a, a burrow to live in or something or build a house, whatever. 953 00:45:50,001 --> 00:45:51,241 So that's a going out. 954 00:45:51,261 --> 00:45:51,651 That's a… 955 00:45:51,921 --> 00:45:57,201 And tho-those are r-rooted in positive emotions to do, to, to be rewarded 956 00:45:57,201 --> 00:45:58,631 for the behaviors that you do. 957 00:45:59,091 --> 00:46:03,041 Your threat system is primarily to keep you safe, so those are 958 00:46:03,041 --> 00:46:05,311 unpleasant emotions, so you have to take action, right? 959 00:46:06,171 --> 00:46:11,451 there's a third one, which interestingly enough, we often talked about it as rest 960 00:46:11,451 --> 00:46:14,691 and digest, and that's when the other two, so you're not under threat, you 961 00:46:14,691 --> 00:46:18,731 don't need to be activated, and you're not out struggling to find food and all 962 00:46:18,731 --> 00:46:20,711 that, so you don't need to be activated. 963 00:46:20,901 --> 00:46:24,631 So it allows the system to settle and bring you back into homeostasis. 964 00:46:24,651 --> 00:46:28,281 Now, in homeostasis, body settles into a pattern which 965 00:46:28,291 --> 00:46:30,091 allows it to recover and repair. 966 00:46:30,481 --> 00:46:34,291 Now, the vagus nerve is quite important for that, but many other systems are 967 00:46:34,291 --> 00:46:38,241 as well, because all living things need to find states of homeostasis 968 00:46:38,461 --> 00:46:42,701 where they can operate functionally and where the repair systems work. 969 00:46:43,171 --> 00:46:47,271 Now, it is linked to rest and digest because you're not having to achieve 970 00:46:47,271 --> 00:46:48,611 anything and you're not under any threat. 971 00:46:49,101 --> 00:46:53,141 But what's very interesting and very important is that with the 972 00:46:53,451 --> 00:47:00,683 evolution of attachment, you didn't need to do that for yourself You 973 00:47:00,683 --> 00:47:02,413 didn't resolve threat, your mum did. 974 00:47:02,903 --> 00:47:06,233 You didn't need to go out and get resources, they were brought to you. 975 00:47:08,473 --> 00:47:12,433 So whenever you were under need, they would arrive, and that means that the 976 00:47:12,473 --> 00:47:18,083 caring system became a, a means of bringing you back into homeostasis. 977 00:47:18,083 --> 00:47:19,873 It brings you back into homeostasis. 978 00:47:20,103 --> 00:47:22,663 So if you're distressed and somebody gives you a hug and 979 00:47:22,663 --> 00:47:26,393 you feel supported, that will automatically calm your threat system. 980 00:47:26,673 --> 00:47:30,083 So you don't have to wait for your threat system to calm down 981 00:47:30,083 --> 00:47:34,843 or your drive system, you actually can be supported in homeostasis. 982 00:47:35,743 --> 00:47:39,803 Now, interestingly enough, when you're supported in homeostasis through 983 00:47:39,803 --> 00:47:44,623 relationships, caring relationships, you don't just rest and relax, 984 00:47:44,783 --> 00:47:46,733 you actually become activated. 985 00:47:46,733 --> 00:47:49,993 You get an endorphin oxytocin hit. 986 00:47:50,103 --> 00:47:50,603 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. 987 00:47:50,693 --> 00:47:54,943 Prof Paul Gilbert: you also have a sense of joyfulness, positive aff- it's 988 00:47:54,943 --> 00:47:57,103 a different type of positive affect. 989 00:47:57,423 --> 00:48:02,003 So if you read Compassionate Mind, it, it says that types of positive affect. 990 00:48:02,023 --> 00:48:05,623 One is achieving, doing the dopamine, winning the lottery, getting excited. 991 00:48:05,903 --> 00:48:09,013 The other one comes from that sense of connectedness. 992 00:48:09,753 --> 00:48:10,643 people would call it love. 993 00:48:10,643 --> 00:48:12,503 You can call it that in close relationships if you want 994 00:48:12,503 --> 00:48:15,763 to, but it's that sense of just, "Ah, this is wonderful. 995 00:48:15,763 --> 00:48:20,183 I just feel," so it's not purely just resting and digesting. 996 00:48:20,433 --> 00:48:22,023 That, that can be an element of it. 997 00:48:22,493 --> 00:48:26,923 And so this element of the third system, the-- what we call the soothing system, 998 00:48:26,923 --> 00:48:29,783 and I kind of regret it a little bit calling it that because there is… 999 00:48:29,783 --> 00:48:30,753 Oh, it's about, just about 1000 00:48:30,795 --> 00:48:32,155 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): What would you call it instead? 1001 00:48:32,235 --> 00:48:33,115 Attachment system? 1002 00:48:33,203 --> 00:48:35,943 Prof Paul Gilbert: I think we would call it social connectedness system, yeah. 1003 00:48:35,943 --> 00:48:38,733 We do actually, if you look at the original diagrams, we say 1004 00:48:38,983 --> 00:48:41,463 kindness and connectedness, non-wanting, that sort of thing. 1005 00:48:41,913 --> 00:48:42,583 But yes. 1006 00:48:42,733 --> 00:48:45,633 But so it is a grounding, it is a settling, just like when the 1007 00:48:45,633 --> 00:48:48,723 mum does that to the baby and the baby gradually calms down. 1008 00:48:49,143 --> 00:48:51,463 So it is a very, very important system. 1009 00:48:51,463 --> 00:48:54,243 And when we do that for ourselves, when we say, "Look, Paul, struggling 1010 00:48:54,253 --> 00:48:59,147 a bit," blah, blah, blah, it has that calming Have quality to it. 1011 00:48:59,387 --> 00:49:04,327 So the three systems, right, the three emotion systems are, grounded 1012 00:49:04,357 --> 00:49:06,087 on the three tasks of life. 1013 00:49:06,277 --> 00:49:09,707 You have to defend yourself, you have to acquire resources, and you have to bring 1014 00:49:09,707 --> 00:49:14,407 your sp- your body back into Otherwise, if you don't do that, you're constantly 1015 00:49:14,507 --> 00:49:14,577 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Yeah. 1016 00:49:14,697 --> 00:49:17,137 Prof Paul Gilbert: threat all the time, or you're constantly in drive 1017 00:49:17,137 --> 00:49:19,037 all the time, it's a struggle. 1018 00:49:19,337 --> 00:49:23,027 Now, the point that you made is also a very good one, which is 1019 00:49:23,033 --> 00:49:23,363 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Thank you. 1020 00:49:24,157 --> 00:49:26,037 Prof Paul Gilbert: they make many very good, excellent points. 1021 00:49:26,517 --> 00:49:30,537 The other point is that in Western society, a lot of our 1022 00:49:30,557 --> 00:49:32,307 drive system is threat-based. 1023 00:49:32,881 --> 00:49:33,121 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. 1024 00:49:33,387 --> 00:49:35,747 Prof Paul Gilbert: It's threat-based drive 'cause we have to have a job, we've gotta 1025 00:49:35,747 --> 00:49:38,537 earn money, we've gotta do this, we've gotta achieve that, we've gotta do this. 1026 00:49:39,007 --> 00:49:47,747 So a lot of the positive emotions sort of not watered down, but are contaminated 1027 00:49:47,747 --> 00:49:51,457 a little bit by a lot of threat of what happens if you don't achieve 1028 00:49:51,457 --> 00:49:54,297 and you don't do, that's a problem. 1029 00:49:54,437 --> 00:49:56,587 That's, that's becomes a kind of serious problem. 1030 00:49:56,847 --> 00:49:59,747 So that's why a lot of people with mental health problems are 1031 00:49:59,747 --> 00:50:01,247 always worried about failing. 1032 00:50:01,257 --> 00:50:03,017 They're worried about being failures, about… 1033 00:50:03,197 --> 00:50:06,767 And, and so on and so on because it's all threat-based drive. 1034 00:50:07,027 --> 00:50:11,357 And the problem with threat-based drive is that you-- difficult to savor 1035 00:50:11,357 --> 00:50:13,447 things just for the joy of doing them. 1036 00:50:14,207 --> 00:50:17,937 Threat-based drive people have problems in play, just doing things 1037 00:50:17,937 --> 00:50:19,917 for the pure enjoyment of doing them. 1038 00:50:19,927 --> 00:50:23,607 No, you don't need to do anything, just enjoy the enjoyment. 1039 00:50:24,047 --> 00:50:27,167 Many depressed people find that very difficult 'cause they're so used 1040 00:50:27,167 --> 00:50:28,717 to having to achieve and do, and 1041 00:50:28,953 --> 00:50:29,373 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. 1042 00:50:29,387 --> 00:50:32,127 Prof Paul Gilbert: can feel good because of their achievements and so on and so on. 1043 00:50:32,927 --> 00:50:35,977 always want to do more and achieve more and do more and achieve 1044 00:50:35,977 --> 00:50:38,697 more just to take joy from life. 1045 00:50:38,697 --> 00:50:42,007 Now, in the Buddhism, of course, that's really quite important that 1046 00:50:42,017 --> 00:50:46,927 this ability just to be grounded in the moment and, and savor the moment. 1047 00:50:47,907 --> 00:50:49,967 people with mental health problems really struggle with that 1048 00:50:50,437 --> 00:50:50,887 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm. 1049 00:50:51,457 --> 00:50:55,637 With because the soothing system is so attachment-based, 1050 00:50:55,805 --> 00:50:56,195 Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah 1051 00:50:56,197 --> 00:50:58,877 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): somebody, if somebody grew up in an environment 1052 00:50:58,877 --> 00:51:01,857 where they didn't have that, so they didn't have the, the mom to give them 1053 00:51:01,857 --> 00:51:06,117 a cuddle, would it be fair to say then there's not that kind of blueprint 1054 00:51:06,127 --> 00:51:09,047 internally for them of homeostasis? 1055 00:51:09,047 --> 00:51:09,177 So 1056 00:51:09,363 --> 00:51:09,513 Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah. 1057 00:51:09,537 --> 00:51:12,027 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): they haven't really ever spent much time there, so 1058 00:51:12,367 --> 00:51:17,167 they get to adulthood, and they've got, maybe all those kind of positive feelings 1059 00:51:17,167 --> 00:51:22,367 of achieving and acquiring are met in that drive state, that then when you then 1060 00:51:22,397 --> 00:51:27,657 ask them about the things that they do for joy or pleasure that are associated 1061 00:51:27,657 --> 00:51:29,557 with achievement, they don't have that. 1062 00:51:29,567 --> 00:51:32,207 But it's, it's not because they don't need it, it's just 1063 00:51:32,207 --> 00:51:33,657 maybe they've never learnt it. 1064 00:51:34,047 --> 00:51:37,517 And this often comes out if you get people to draw the, the circles, you know. 1065 00:51:37,517 --> 00:51:40,127 It's not uncommon for people to draw their soothing circles 1066 00:51:40,507 --> 00:51:41,877 kind of really, really tiny. 1067 00:51:42,317 --> 00:51:46,557 But it does make it more complex with somebody that has never 1068 00:51:46,557 --> 00:51:50,257 had that growing up because they don't really have a grid for it. 1069 00:51:51,097 --> 00:51:55,777 And is that then where the connectedness towards themselves, so having the 1070 00:51:55,777 --> 00:52:00,707 compassion for themselves, you might begin because that's the, that's 1071 00:52:00,707 --> 00:52:04,737 the consistent part of them in their life in all of those scenarios. 1072 00:52:04,777 --> 00:52:09,357 So if they can learn to, support themselves in distress and be that, 1073 00:52:09,697 --> 00:52:14,147 the part that regulates the difficult emotion, then you're like boosting 1074 00:52:14,347 --> 00:52:16,407 the, the, the soothing system grows 1075 00:52:17,257 --> 00:52:18,417 Prof Paul Gilbert: Yes, exactly right. 1076 00:52:18,447 --> 00:52:18,507 I 1077 00:52:18,627 --> 00:52:18,947 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): But it's hard 1078 00:52:19,267 --> 00:52:20,207 Prof Paul Gilbert: I think that's exactly right. 1079 00:52:20,207 --> 00:52:23,537 And the point is, psychoeducation is very, very important in CFT, so we 1080 00:52:23,537 --> 00:52:25,327 do psychoeducation on tricky brain. 1081 00:52:25,327 --> 00:52:31,917 You've got a, a brain that evolved for you, not by you, and it's got all 1082 00:52:31,937 --> 00:52:35,057 kinds of potentials in it that you never chose, and if they get triggered, 1083 00:52:35,057 --> 00:52:36,167 you don't want them particularly. 1084 00:52:36,567 --> 00:52:40,897 So these are very, very important elements to, to, to kinda help, 1085 00:52:40,987 --> 00:52:45,467 help people with really, and guiding them through that process about how 1086 00:52:45,467 --> 00:52:48,707 they begin to tolerate some of those emotions that you're talking about 1087 00:52:53,729 --> 00:52:54,689 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. 1088 00:52:54,689 --> 00:52:56,309 Paul that we've covered so much, and anyone listening that's tried 1089 00:52:56,329 --> 00:53:00,129 to do some multitasking will have to go back and re-listen, do this 1090 00:53:00,169 --> 00:53:01,949 'cause there is a lot in here. 1091 00:53:02,609 --> 00:53:06,989 Clinicians that haven't really come across CFT or have been maybe doing 1092 00:53:06,989 --> 00:53:10,259 some off-the-shelf stuff but are a bit more inspired to understand 1093 00:53:10,259 --> 00:53:13,489 a bit more about it, where is a good place for people to go? 1094 00:53:13,641 --> 00:53:15,141 Prof Paul Gilbert: come to the website 'cause we-- you 1095 00:53:15,141 --> 00:53:16,241 can see all of our trainings. 1096 00:53:16,391 --> 00:53:18,581 We do bespoke trainings. 1097 00:53:18,631 --> 00:53:21,321 We can send trainers out into your place of work. 1098 00:53:21,371 --> 00:53:23,971 We do one-day, two-day, and three-day trainings. 1099 00:53:23,981 --> 00:53:25,621 We do evening talks and that sort of thing. 1100 00:53:25,621 --> 00:53:26,691 Come and find out about it. 1101 00:53:26,691 --> 00:53:29,861 There's quite a lot of stuff on the, on the, on the website for you. 1102 00:53:29,861 --> 00:53:34,061 And remember that you're already trained in saga therapy, then 1103 00:53:34,281 --> 00:53:37,261 we call it compassion-focused therapy, not compassion therapy. 1104 00:53:37,261 --> 00:53:40,561 It's a way of how you can use and stimulate compassion 1105 00:53:40,561 --> 00:53:45,031 motivational systems and all the physiology your therapy, right? 1106 00:53:45,031 --> 00:53:50,071 So we're not trying to, as you say Natalie, you lose a lot of ACT and 1107 00:53:50,151 --> 00:53:51,621 EMDR, and all that sort of stuff. 1108 00:53:52,241 --> 00:53:53,281 Absolutely right. 1109 00:53:53,281 --> 00:53:55,591 These, these techniques are extremely useful. 1110 00:53:55,591 --> 00:53:57,181 They've been developed over many years. 1111 00:53:57,181 --> 00:53:59,171 People worked out how to do this, that, and the other. 1112 00:53:59,591 --> 00:54:01,661 So that, that's not us. 1113 00:54:01,661 --> 00:54:06,141 We didn't, But what we suggest is that the-- what you're wanting to create is 1114 00:54:06,141 --> 00:54:10,381 a compassionate brain state, 'cause when you do that, you're stimulating things 1115 00:54:10,381 --> 00:54:14,321 like oxytocin, like the endorphins and, and dopamine systems, which will then 1116 00:54:14,551 --> 00:54:16,931 allow those interventions to really bite. 1117 00:54:17,351 --> 00:54:21,251 Whereas if you're trying to do them just as logic or whatever they're-- 1118 00:54:21,551 --> 00:54:24,721 I won't say they won't be effective, but they won't be so as effective 1119 00:54:25,537 --> 00:54:25,967 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. 1120 00:54:27,577 --> 00:54:28,137 Wonderful 1121 00:54:28,269 --> 00:54:30,749 Prof Paul Gilbert: to the website and come and join us in our trainings. 1122 00:54:30,749 --> 00:54:34,599 And we have a diploma if you wanna come and do the diploma for 1123 00:54:34,599 --> 00:54:38,309 nine months, and that's g- with supervised practice and so forth 1124 00:54:39,613 --> 00:54:40,133 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Wonderful. 1125 00:54:40,693 --> 00:54:42,883 Paul, thank you so much for your time. 1126 00:54:42,971 --> 00:54:43,271 Prof Paul Gilbert: thank you 1127 00:54:43,343 --> 00:54:43,823 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): it's been really helpful. 1128 00:54:43,921 --> 00:54:44,191 Prof Paul Gilbert: Natalie. 1129 00:54:44,191 --> 00:54:44,991 It's been a delight 1130 00:54:45,683 --> 00:54:46,063 Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Thank you 1131 00:54:49,569 --> 00:54:52,419 Thank you for listening to this episode of Mastering Therapy. 1132 00:54:53,049 --> 00:54:56,349 All of the resources mentioned are available in the show notes. 1133 00:54:57,699 --> 00:55:00,219 If you are interested in getting more information on what's been 1134 00:55:00,219 --> 00:55:03,339 covered this season, you can sign up to our mailing list or visit 1135 00:55:03,339 --> 00:55:05,259 the website, mastering therapy.com. 1136 00:55:06,669 --> 00:55:10,539 If you know someone that would be great to interview on this podcast, you can submit 1137 00:55:10,539 --> 00:55:14,679 a recommendation and I'd love to hear from you the Mastering Therapy podcast and the 1138 00:55:14,679 --> 00:55:16,294 information provided by me and my guests. 1139 00:55:16,664 --> 00:55:20,474 Is solely intended for qualified professionals for information 1140 00:55:20,474 --> 00:55:22,034 and educational purposes. 1141 00:55:23,024 --> 00:55:24,854 I look forward to joining me next time..