1
00:00:00,018 --> 00:00:00,948
Hello, ladies.

2
00:00:00,948 --> 00:00:02,568
Welcome to
the Hourly to

3
00:00:02,568 --> 00:00:04,008
Exit podcast.

4
00:00:04,111 --> 00:00:06,395
today we tackle
artificial

5
00:00:06,395 --> 00:00:07,325
intelligence.

6
00:00:07,530 --> 00:00:09,761
Now, there's no one
more surprised than

7
00:00:09,761 --> 00:00:12,101
me that artificial
intelligence

8
00:00:12,270 --> 00:00:14,231
has become part
of my life.

9
00:00:14,504 --> 00:00:17,788
I am a proud
technology Luddite.

10
00:00:17,989 --> 00:00:19,609
if it was up to
me, I'd still be

11
00:00:19,609 --> 00:00:20,809
using a Blackberry.

12
00:00:21,056 --> 00:00:21,747
To me, they're, the.

13
00:00:22,047 --> 00:00:23,024
Things ever.

14
00:00:23,167 --> 00:00:24,731
but there's
no denying the

15
00:00:24,731 --> 00:00:27,971
fact that AI is
everywhere and we

16
00:00:27,971 --> 00:00:30,637
can no longer put
our heads in the

17
00:00:30,637 --> 00:00:31,837
sand regarding this.

18
00:00:32,073 --> 00:00:34,692
there are some
dire concerns

19
00:00:34,692 --> 00:00:35,382
regarding it.

20
00:00:35,576 --> 00:00:36,771
I know that there
are some tech

21
00:00:36,771 --> 00:00:38,971
leaders who have
gone so far as a

22
00:00:38,971 --> 00:00:41,671
call for a pause
in AI development.

23
00:00:41,900 --> 00:00:42,747
I did not know.

24
00:00:42,747 --> 00:00:44,307
I'd agree with
Elon Musk.

25
00:00:44,706 --> 00:00:45,591
Pretty much
anything.

26
00:00:45,777 --> 00:00:49,701
But I do agree on
this point, today,

27
00:00:49,701 --> 00:00:53,151
in fact, as I record
this, there was an

28
00:00:53,151 --> 00:00:56,521
article about an
episode of the Joe

29
00:00:56,526 --> 00:00:59,282
Rogan experience
that was completely

30
00:00:59,282 --> 00:01:01,506
AI generated, and
apparently I've

31
00:01:01,511 --> 00:01:03,096
not listened to
it, but according

32
00:01:03,096 --> 00:01:04,836
to the article,
you could not

33
00:01:04,836 --> 00:01:05,946
tell that it was.

34
00:01:06,548 --> 00:01:08,741
The true thing, the
true, recording,

35
00:01:08,802 --> 00:01:10,313
live recording,
and that's

36
00:01:10,401 --> 00:01:11,241
kind of scary.

37
00:01:11,461 --> 00:01:13,951
I have seen online.

38
00:01:14,604 --> 00:01:15,774
completely.

39
00:01:15,774 --> 00:01:19,378
AI created YouTube
videos, so they use,

40
00:01:19,378 --> 00:01:22,532
image and a voice
stamp, and they're

41
00:01:22,532 --> 00:01:24,632
able to create
an entire video.

42
00:01:24,774 --> 00:01:27,274
I will say that the
AI generated YouTube

43
00:01:27,274 --> 00:01:29,127
video that, I saw
looked like it had

44
00:01:29,127 --> 00:01:31,109
a few problems, but
it's just a matter

45
00:01:31,109 --> 00:01:33,239
of time before
it will be truly

46
00:01:33,239 --> 00:01:35,286
indistinguishable
from live

47
00:01:35,286 --> 00:01:36,036
recordings.

48
00:01:36,213 --> 00:01:38,166
And so there
are concerns.

49
00:01:38,854 --> 00:01:41,892
Now I am not
going to address

50
00:01:41,892 --> 00:01:42,792
those issues.

51
00:01:42,792 --> 00:01:44,622
They're beyond
my expertise.

52
00:01:44,820 --> 00:01:46,555
What we're gonna
talk about today

53
00:01:46,775 --> 00:01:48,292
is the issue that
people have been

54
00:01:48,292 --> 00:01:51,068
asking me, which
is, what impact

55
00:01:51,068 --> 00:01:53,048
will AI have on
my intellectual

56
00:01:53,048 --> 00:01:53,858
property?

57
00:01:54,205 --> 00:01:56,655
people be, will
I be replaced by?

58
00:01:57,637 --> 00:01:59,827
So the answer
to will you be

59
00:01:59,827 --> 00:02:01,297
replaced by ai?

60
00:02:01,417 --> 00:02:03,127
The answer to
that is no.

61
00:02:03,366 --> 00:02:05,227
as an expertise
based service

62
00:02:05,227 --> 00:02:07,087
provider, I
understand your

63
00:02:07,087 --> 00:02:10,647
concerns about the
impact of AI on

64
00:02:10,647 --> 00:02:12,507
your intellectual
property, but

65
00:02:12,547 --> 00:02:13,207
they aren't.

66
00:02:13,836 --> 00:02:17,211
Any greater than
kind of the general

67
00:02:17,212 --> 00:02:20,066
of accessibility
of our expertise

68
00:02:20,096 --> 00:02:21,326
online these days.

69
00:02:21,541 --> 00:02:22,919
So let's, just start
from the beginning.

70
00:02:23,199 --> 00:02:25,442
So let's look
at how AI works.

71
00:02:25,630 --> 00:02:30,116
when an ai, System
like chat, g p T.

72
00:02:30,289 --> 00:02:32,093
Now I'm going to
talk about chat, g

73
00:02:32,093 --> 00:02:33,893
p t mostly today.

74
00:02:34,063 --> 00:02:36,246
That's the AI that
I'm familiar with.

75
00:02:36,246 --> 00:02:38,526
It's the one that is
publicly available.

76
00:02:38,664 --> 00:02:40,452
probably the most
advanced publicly

77
00:02:40,457 --> 00:02:41,112
available one.

78
00:02:41,112 --> 00:02:43,105
There are others
like Bard I believe,

79
00:02:43,105 --> 00:02:44,314
and there's a
couple, that

80
00:02:44,314 --> 00:02:46,333
aren't as advanced
as chat g b.

81
00:02:46,678 --> 00:02:48,239
So if you've been
fooling around with

82
00:02:48,239 --> 00:02:49,289
it, the way I've
been fooling around

83
00:02:49,289 --> 00:02:50,279
with it, you've
probably been doing

84
00:02:50,279 --> 00:02:52,936
it on chat, G B
T and that is, it

85
00:02:52,936 --> 00:02:56,009
generates responses
from available data.

86
00:02:56,163 --> 00:02:59,275
So I understood
that there was a

87
00:02:59,275 --> 00:03:00,435
source of data.

88
00:03:01,141 --> 00:03:02,918
That they copy
from the internet

89
00:03:02,978 --> 00:03:05,708
and then it's
saved by, open ai,

90
00:03:05,708 --> 00:03:07,542
that's the creator
of Chat, G B T.

91
00:03:07,822 --> 00:03:10,252
and that the date
of that saving is

92
00:03:10,320 --> 00:03:11,514
September, 2021.

93
00:03:11,777 --> 00:03:14,265
So it doesn't
know about

94
00:03:14,265 --> 00:03:15,575
anything that's
happened since

95
00:03:15,735 --> 00:03:17,445
September, 2021.

96
00:03:17,693 --> 00:03:19,301
And so to understand
this a little

97
00:03:19,301 --> 00:03:22,345
better, I asked
Chad, G b t I

98
00:03:22,345 --> 00:03:22,585
don't know if.

99
00:03:23,003 --> 00:03:24,223
Had these
conversations

100
00:03:24,223 --> 00:03:24,583
with them.

101
00:03:24,583 --> 00:03:26,653
I encourage you to
go on if you haven't

102
00:03:26,653 --> 00:03:28,836
and just ask some
questions so you can

103
00:03:28,836 --> 00:03:29,826
see how it works.

104
00:03:29,826 --> 00:03:30,773
It's really.

105
00:03:31,433 --> 00:03:31,713
interesting.

106
00:03:31,713 --> 00:03:33,903
It is different than
a Google inquiry.

107
00:03:33,903 --> 00:03:36,143
It absolutely seems
to be talking to

108
00:03:36,143 --> 00:03:38,183
you that we call
them conversations

109
00:03:38,384 --> 00:03:39,194
or chats.

110
00:03:39,453 --> 00:03:42,376
so I asked chat g p
t for confirmation

111
00:03:42,376 --> 00:03:44,839
about, what's
the last copy of

112
00:03:44,839 --> 00:03:47,253
the internet that
it has, and so

113
00:03:47,258 --> 00:03:48,018
it's response.

114
00:03:48,566 --> 00:03:51,506
As an AI language
model, I do not

115
00:03:51,506 --> 00:03:53,516
browse or access
the internet in

116
00:03:53,516 --> 00:03:56,093
the same way that
humans do, and I do

117
00:03:56,093 --> 00:03:57,713
not have a quote.

118
00:03:57,931 --> 00:04:00,481
Unquote copy of
the internet.

119
00:04:00,738 --> 00:04:03,828
Instead, I rely
on my preexisting

120
00:04:03,828 --> 00:04:05,961
knowledge base,
which was last

121
00:04:06,021 --> 00:04:08,861
updated based on
data and information

122
00:04:08,921 --> 00:04:12,071
available up to
September, 2021.

123
00:04:12,335 --> 00:04:14,980
So, this was,
as of yesterday,

124
00:04:14,985 --> 00:04:18,010
which would be,
April 13th, 2023.

125
00:04:18,206 --> 00:04:20,510
And so that will.

126
00:04:20,672 --> 00:04:23,042
in the near future
understand that

127
00:04:23,266 --> 00:04:25,575
the next generation
of AI will be

128
00:04:25,575 --> 00:04:27,645
able to collect
data in real time.

129
00:04:27,828 --> 00:04:29,595
So it won't just
be the preexisting

130
00:04:29,595 --> 00:04:31,935
knowledge base that
was loaded into it.

131
00:04:32,115 --> 00:04:34,365
It will be able
to comb the,

132
00:04:34,365 --> 00:04:36,945
internet live to
find its answers.

133
00:04:37,682 --> 00:04:40,188
So obviously that
will make it much

134
00:04:40,188 --> 00:04:41,258
more powerful.

135
00:04:41,621 --> 00:04:43,705
So the implications
for you as

136
00:04:43,705 --> 00:04:44,365
an expert.

137
00:04:44,942 --> 00:04:48,216
First AI will be
using your ip.

138
00:04:48,524 --> 00:04:51,824
AI will be accessing
any information

139
00:04:51,824 --> 00:04:54,895
available on the
web, so currently

140
00:04:54,895 --> 00:04:55,277
available.

141
00:04:56,435 --> 00:04:58,224
Assuming that it
was downloaded, as

142
00:04:58,224 --> 00:04:59,754
of September, 2021.

143
00:04:59,949 --> 00:05:02,398
So the interesting
thing about the

144
00:05:02,398 --> 00:05:04,288
answer that it
gave me that it

145
00:05:04,288 --> 00:05:06,298
has a preexisting
knowledge base.

146
00:05:06,779 --> 00:05:08,429
Well, that means
someone had to

147
00:05:08,429 --> 00:05:09,389
load that on there.

148
00:05:09,389 --> 00:05:10,649
It had to
decide what

149
00:05:10,649 --> 00:05:12,539
information they
wanted to input.

150
00:05:12,906 --> 00:05:16,363
So maybe your
IP got into its

151
00:05:16,363 --> 00:05:18,153
knowledge base, but
maybe it didn't.

152
00:05:18,364 --> 00:05:21,566
But when AI is able
to just kind of

153
00:05:21,836 --> 00:05:24,426
comb the, internet
live, then obviously

154
00:05:24,426 --> 00:05:26,646
it will be able to
access whatever,

155
00:05:26,929 --> 00:05:29,320
is publicly
available on the.

156
00:05:30,125 --> 00:05:31,613
And so that
would include,

157
00:05:31,793 --> 00:05:33,670
publications on
your website and

158
00:05:33,670 --> 00:05:34,810
other platforms.

159
00:05:35,154 --> 00:05:37,673
And so while that
may sound a little

160
00:05:37,673 --> 00:05:40,540
bit terrifying,
that happens without

161
00:05:40,600 --> 00:05:41,740
AI right now.

162
00:05:41,898 --> 00:05:44,443
I mean, Google
and other, search

163
00:05:44,448 --> 00:05:47,582
engines does live
comb the internet

164
00:05:47,612 --> 00:05:50,202
and can access
your intellectual

165
00:05:50,202 --> 00:05:51,682
property right now.

166
00:05:51,947 --> 00:05:53,082
So it can find.

167
00:05:53,739 --> 00:05:55,213
what you put on
LinkedIn, it can

168
00:05:55,213 --> 00:05:56,503
find out what's
on your website.

169
00:05:56,503 --> 00:05:58,590
It can find
out, copies of,

170
00:05:58,590 --> 00:06:02,136
your speeches on
YouTube so people

171
00:06:02,136 --> 00:06:04,626
can do that right
now without ai.

172
00:06:04,879 --> 00:06:08,419
And so if someone
live, without any

173
00:06:08,419 --> 00:06:10,669
intermediary, goes
on the internet

174
00:06:10,669 --> 00:06:13,646
and sees that you
wrote something and

175
00:06:13,646 --> 00:06:15,566
decides to write
something similar,

176
00:06:15,816 --> 00:06:17,608
We hear all the time
about people are

177
00:06:17,608 --> 00:06:18,928
copying my ideas.

178
00:06:18,928 --> 00:06:20,398
There's nothing
new about that.

179
00:06:20,761 --> 00:06:24,056
so AI will be
able to see what

180
00:06:24,056 --> 00:06:26,066
you're doing and
incorporate it

181
00:06:26,066 --> 00:06:28,226
into an answer
that they provide

182
00:06:28,763 --> 00:06:30,228
But what we need
to understand is

183
00:06:30,228 --> 00:06:33,012
that in both cases,
being inspired to

184
00:06:33,012 --> 00:06:35,332
write something
similar or even

185
00:06:35,912 --> 00:06:38,680
stealing your ideas
is not copyright

186
00:06:38,685 --> 00:06:39,310
infringement.

187
00:06:39,623 --> 00:06:41,870
copyright
infringement is the

188
00:06:41,875 --> 00:06:44,644
same, whether it's
a human reading your

189
00:06:44,644 --> 00:06:46,714
stuff and taking
it, or AI reading

190
00:06:46,714 --> 00:06:48,304
your stuff and
taking it Copyright

191
00:06:48,304 --> 00:06:50,044
infringement
means that they

192
00:06:50,044 --> 00:06:52,204
have to have ex
to violate your

193
00:06:52,204 --> 00:06:53,854
exclusive rights
as a copyright.

194
00:06:54,652 --> 00:06:57,108
So as a copyright
owner, these

195
00:06:57,108 --> 00:06:57,648
are your rights.

196
00:06:57,648 --> 00:06:58,968
You have the
exclusive right

197
00:06:59,085 --> 00:07:01,162
to reproduce,
distribute,

198
00:07:01,162 --> 00:07:03,255
publicly, perform,
and publicly

199
00:07:03,255 --> 00:07:04,695
display your works.

200
00:07:04,949 --> 00:07:07,255
So anyone who
engages in any of

201
00:07:07,255 --> 00:07:09,714
these activities
without your

202
00:07:09,719 --> 00:07:11,480
permission, they
would be liable

203
00:07:11,480 --> 00:07:12,550
for copyright
infringement.

204
00:07:13,014 --> 00:07:14,354
So copyright
infringement

205
00:07:14,354 --> 00:07:17,434
means that as the
copyright owner, you

206
00:07:17,434 --> 00:07:20,719
can show that one,
you are the owner

207
00:07:20,719 --> 00:07:22,836
of a valid copyright
in the work in

208
00:07:22,836 --> 00:07:26,498
question two,
that the infringer

209
00:07:26,498 --> 00:07:28,946
has actually
copied your work

210
00:07:29,006 --> 00:07:30,596
or a substantial
portion of it.

211
00:07:30,890 --> 00:07:32,834
And three, that
the copying isn't

212
00:07:32,834 --> 00:07:35,024
protected by an
applicable defense

213
00:07:35,024 --> 00:07:36,394
such as fair use.

214
00:07:36,655 --> 00:07:37,677
if you have a
question about

215
00:07:37,677 --> 00:07:39,751
fair use, I have,
written about it

216
00:07:39,811 --> 00:07:42,211
and done a LinkedIn
live about it,

217
00:07:42,211 --> 00:07:42,901
which you can find.

218
00:07:43,224 --> 00:07:44,883
but copyright
infringement

219
00:07:44,883 --> 00:07:47,523
again, is not about
stealing your ideas,

220
00:07:47,758 --> 00:07:50,417
but it is about
actual copying.

221
00:07:50,685 --> 00:07:53,263
And so if you can
prove that they

222
00:07:53,833 --> 00:07:55,933
actually copied
your work, then

223
00:07:55,933 --> 00:07:57,592
they would be able
to take, you be

224
00:07:57,592 --> 00:07:58,372
entitled to damage.

225
00:07:58,915 --> 00:08:00,415
And I'm not
gonna say that

226
00:08:00,415 --> 00:08:01,525
proven copyright
infringement

227
00:08:01,525 --> 00:08:02,845
cases is easy.

228
00:08:02,845 --> 00:08:05,305
It's not, it's
complicated and it

229
00:08:05,335 --> 00:08:06,655
typically involves
a fair amount

230
00:08:06,660 --> 00:08:07,435
of legal fees.

231
00:08:07,742 --> 00:08:10,262
So you do need
to make sure that

232
00:08:10,262 --> 00:08:13,185
it is valuable
enough to you to

233
00:08:13,226 --> 00:08:15,412
devote those types
of resources to.

234
00:08:15,704 --> 00:08:17,474
Prosecuting an
infringement case.

235
00:08:27,464 --> 00:08:30,431
So, but if you are
concerned about

236
00:08:30,431 --> 00:08:33,881
the use of your IP
by a third party,

237
00:08:33,911 --> 00:08:37,131
whether that third
party is human or

238
00:08:37,131 --> 00:08:40,100
an AI tool, then
you need to take

239
00:08:40,105 --> 00:08:41,780
the steps required
to protect it.

240
00:08:42,118 --> 00:08:44,590
So if we go
back to proving

241
00:08:44,590 --> 00:08:45,850
infringement,
you have to

242
00:08:45,850 --> 00:08:47,780
be the valid,
owner of a valid

243
00:08:47,780 --> 00:08:48,980
copyright question.

244
00:08:49,731 --> 00:08:52,229
Chain of title
regarding ownership

245
00:08:52,349 --> 00:08:54,702
starts from the
time of creation.

246
00:08:55,036 --> 00:08:56,769
So you'll hear
me talk over and

247
00:08:56,774 --> 00:08:58,149
over again about
the importance of

248
00:08:58,149 --> 00:09:00,565
your contracts and
making sure that

249
00:09:00,570 --> 00:09:01,555
you own things.

250
00:09:01,555 --> 00:09:03,505
If you didn't create
it personally, if

251
00:09:03,505 --> 00:09:05,005
the third party
created it for you,

252
00:09:05,005 --> 00:09:06,595
if you created it
in connection with

253
00:09:06,751 --> 00:09:09,116
an engagement,
then ownership

254
00:09:09,116 --> 00:09:10,896
will depend on what
those contracts.

255
00:09:11,435 --> 00:09:14,699
And then, when you
are the sole owner,

256
00:09:14,759 --> 00:09:16,319
then registration.

257
00:09:16,550 --> 00:09:18,029
So these are the
two ways we make

258
00:09:18,029 --> 00:09:20,725
sure that we
have a defense.

259
00:09:20,911 --> 00:09:23,006
we can, enforce
our copyright

260
00:09:23,006 --> 00:09:26,142
against third party
infringers ownership

261
00:09:26,142 --> 00:09:27,576
and registration.

262
00:09:27,943 --> 00:09:30,409
and then, again,
it would have to

263
00:09:30,409 --> 00:09:32,719
be a copying of
your work and not.

264
00:09:33,563 --> 00:09:35,794
Taking the idea
of your work.

265
00:09:36,204 --> 00:09:38,634
So it is not in
your power to

266
00:09:38,634 --> 00:09:41,394
stop someone from
accessing your IP

267
00:09:41,634 --> 00:09:44,208
on the internet by
humans or by ai,

268
00:09:44,538 --> 00:09:46,368
but it is in your
power to put the

269
00:09:46,368 --> 00:09:49,098
pieces in place to
put yourself in the

270
00:09:49,098 --> 00:09:51,708
best position to
enforce your rights

271
00:09:51,768 --> 00:09:52,638
if it comes to that.

272
00:09:53,137 --> 00:09:55,815
So on the other
end of that is when

273
00:09:55,815 --> 00:09:59,874
you're using ai,
And AI is doing

274
00:09:59,874 --> 00:10:00,894
work for you.

275
00:10:01,230 --> 00:10:04,197
It will be accessing
other people's

276
00:10:04,197 --> 00:10:05,980
intellectual
property on the

277
00:10:05,980 --> 00:10:07,450
internet when
it's creating

278
00:10:07,570 --> 00:10:08,560
its responses.

279
00:10:08,860 --> 00:10:10,377
Now, when you,
go ahead and,

280
00:10:10,377 --> 00:10:12,322
play with it, you
will see it will

281
00:10:12,322 --> 00:10:13,732
send you answers.

282
00:10:13,905 --> 00:10:16,689
It does not provide
any attribution.

283
00:10:16,689 --> 00:10:18,939
So that is different
than if you do

284
00:10:18,939 --> 00:10:20,019
a Google search
where you know

285
00:10:20,019 --> 00:10:21,189
exactly where
the information

286
00:10:21,189 --> 00:10:21,519
is coming.

287
00:10:22,420 --> 00:10:22,990
Here.

288
00:10:23,214 --> 00:10:25,381
It just goes
wherever it

289
00:10:25,386 --> 00:10:27,020
goes and it's.

290
00:10:27,174 --> 00:10:29,934
Knowledge base and
finds answers, and

291
00:10:29,934 --> 00:10:33,737
then it, sends it
back to you in a,

292
00:10:33,737 --> 00:10:35,370
if you asked for
to write an article

293
00:10:35,370 --> 00:10:37,350
for you or to write
a script for you,

294
00:10:37,569 --> 00:10:39,870
it will present it
in that form and,

295
00:10:39,920 --> 00:10:42,047
typically without
attribution, so you

296
00:10:42,047 --> 00:10:43,727
won't have any way
of knowing where

297
00:10:43,847 --> 00:10:45,407
that information
is coming from.

298
00:10:45,790 --> 00:10:50,096
So, That puts
you in danger of

299
00:10:50,096 --> 00:10:53,276
being a copyright
infringer if you

300
00:10:53,276 --> 00:10:54,746
don't know where
that came from.

301
00:10:54,945 --> 00:10:59,387
So I asked chat, G B
T what to do if I'm

302
00:10:59,387 --> 00:11:02,207
worried that it's
response infringes

303
00:11:02,207 --> 00:11:04,616
a third party's
copyright, and its

304
00:11:05,096 --> 00:11:05,846
response was this.

305
00:11:06,174 --> 00:11:09,202
As an AI language
model, I provide

306
00:11:09,672 --> 00:11:11,422
responses based
on my preexisting

307
00:11:11,422 --> 00:11:12,935
knowledge
and language

308
00:11:12,935 --> 00:11:13,835
capabilities.

309
00:11:14,051 --> 00:11:16,031
However, I am
not able to

310
00:11:16,031 --> 00:11:19,200
review or assess
specific content

311
00:11:19,230 --> 00:11:21,630
or material for
potential copyright

312
00:11:21,630 --> 00:11:22,260
infringement.

313
00:11:22,490 --> 00:11:23,855
If you are
concerned about

314
00:11:23,855 --> 00:11:25,535
potential copyright
infringement related

315
00:11:25,535 --> 00:11:27,971
to your own content
and material, you

316
00:11:27,971 --> 00:11:29,351
may wanna consult
with a legal

317
00:11:29,351 --> 00:11:31,271
professional who
can provide guidance

318
00:11:31,271 --> 00:11:33,557
and advice specific
to your situation.

319
00:11:33,788 --> 00:11:35,930
They can review
your material and

320
00:11:35,930 --> 00:11:37,640
assess whether
any potential

321
00:11:37,645 --> 00:11:39,170
infringement has
occurred or is

322
00:11:39,175 --> 00:11:40,520
likely to occur.

323
00:11:40,778 --> 00:11:42,458
In general, it is
important to be

324
00:11:42,458 --> 00:11:44,738
aware of copyright
laws and to obtain

325
00:11:44,743 --> 00:11:47,198
permission or
authorization before

326
00:11:47,198 --> 00:11:49,658
using or reproducing
any copyrighted

327
00:11:49,658 --> 00:11:50,408
material.

328
00:11:51,383 --> 00:11:52,783
Additionally, it is
advisable to seek

329
00:11:52,783 --> 00:11:54,883
legal advice if you
are uncertain about

330
00:11:54,883 --> 00:11:56,443
whether your use
of someone else's

331
00:11:56,448 --> 00:11:58,363
copyrighted material
may infringe on

332
00:11:58,368 --> 00:11:59,053
their rights.

333
00:11:59,281 --> 00:12:01,352
Well, in other
words, user beware.

334
00:12:01,465 --> 00:12:03,239
I mean, that's
all very fine

335
00:12:03,239 --> 00:12:05,485
to say, but if
you have receiv.

336
00:12:05,792 --> 00:12:08,662
A response that
doesn't provide any

337
00:12:08,662 --> 00:12:09,682
type of attribution.

338
00:12:09,682 --> 00:12:11,408
All we know is
it came from chat

339
00:12:12,001 --> 00:12:14,041
GPTs preexisting
knowledge base.

340
00:12:14,041 --> 00:12:17,225
Like how does
that tell me what

341
00:12:17,225 --> 00:12:18,155
the source is?

342
00:12:18,215 --> 00:12:19,715
How do I know
if I need to,

343
00:12:19,715 --> 00:12:20,975
if this is a
potential copyright

344
00:12:20,975 --> 00:12:21,515
infringement?

345
00:12:21,755 --> 00:12:22,835
Again, you
know, copyright

346
00:12:22,835 --> 00:12:24,665
infringement
requires copying

347
00:12:24,665 --> 00:12:27,395
and not just
inspiration or.

348
00:12:27,623 --> 00:12:28,703
taking an idea.

349
00:12:28,959 --> 00:12:31,113
So did they
completely take

350
00:12:31,118 --> 00:12:33,243
a whole chunk of
somebody else's,

351
00:12:33,463 --> 00:12:36,576
work and stick it in
into your response?

352
00:12:36,802 --> 00:12:40,396
Or did they, take a
variety of sources

353
00:12:40,686 --> 00:12:42,816
and kind of put
them together in

354
00:12:42,816 --> 00:12:44,136
a way that creates
something new?

355
00:12:44,609 --> 00:12:47,872
So if chat G p t
Plagiarizes from

356
00:12:47,872 --> 00:12:50,022
source materials,
You won't know that

357
00:12:50,052 --> 00:12:52,932
unless you do your
own due diligence

358
00:12:53,222 --> 00:12:54,752
and you are the one
who'll be liable

359
00:12:54,752 --> 00:12:56,072
for copyright
infringement,

360
00:12:56,077 --> 00:12:56,932
not chat.

361
00:12:56,932 --> 00:12:57,634
G P T.

362
00:12:57,978 --> 00:12:59,832
So if you plan to
use AI for your

363
00:12:59,832 --> 00:13:02,486
work, you need to
use some sort of

364
00:13:02,486 --> 00:13:05,069
plagiarism check,
like Grammarly,

365
00:13:05,308 --> 00:13:06,596
and you need
to track your

366
00:13:06,596 --> 00:13:08,539
process carefully
to demonstrate

367
00:13:08,539 --> 00:13:10,339
your unique
input when you're

368
00:13:10,339 --> 00:13:11,359
creating content.

369
00:13:11,359 --> 00:13:14,179
So you can't just,
copy and paste

370
00:13:14,179 --> 00:13:17,419
what comes out
of your AI chat.

371
00:13:17,909 --> 00:13:22,242
There also are some
privacy issues, so.

372
00:13:22,276 --> 00:13:25,665
When I asked chat
G b T, whether or

373
00:13:25,665 --> 00:13:27,821
not the information
I provide to it

374
00:13:27,851 --> 00:13:28,841
becomes public.

375
00:13:29,046 --> 00:13:31,144
The response was,
your information

376
00:13:31,174 --> 00:13:33,154
is not made
public and is

377
00:13:33,154 --> 00:13:34,444
kept confidential.

378
00:13:34,756 --> 00:13:37,987
However, if you go
to the fax page,

379
00:13:38,156 --> 00:13:41,130
it warns you don't
share any sensitive

380
00:13:41,130 --> 00:13:42,630
information
in your chats.

381
00:13:42,960 --> 00:13:45,480
Your conversations
may be reviewed

382
00:13:45,540 --> 00:13:48,120
by RA ai trainers
to improve our.

383
00:13:49,219 --> 00:13:51,679
So remember the
way that AI works

384
00:13:51,709 --> 00:13:55,906
is that what you
put into the chat

385
00:13:55,953 --> 00:13:59,089
becomes part of
its knowledge base,

386
00:13:59,362 --> 00:14:01,213
cuz that's the only
way that it can

387
00:14:01,218 --> 00:14:03,743
continue to improve
your responses.

388
00:14:04,359 --> 00:14:07,269
So again, if you
go in there and,

389
00:14:07,539 --> 00:14:09,176
maybe you put in.

390
00:14:09,421 --> 00:14:12,031
A draft of something
and ask it to

391
00:14:12,031 --> 00:14:14,631
improve the draft,
it will, maybe you

392
00:14:14,631 --> 00:14:16,401
put in notes, put
some bullet points

393
00:14:16,406 --> 00:14:18,471
in, and ask it to
create an article

394
00:14:18,471 --> 00:14:19,851
based on these
bullet points.

395
00:14:20,096 --> 00:14:22,176
It will use your
bullet points.

396
00:14:22,176 --> 00:14:23,286
It will use
its preexisting

397
00:14:23,286 --> 00:14:24,576
knowledge, and
it will come

398
00:14:24,576 --> 00:14:25,474
up with, a.

399
00:14:26,132 --> 00:14:28,339
Something in article
form and then you

400
00:14:28,339 --> 00:14:30,789
say, eh, and you
ask it to regenerate

401
00:14:30,946 --> 00:14:32,506
and then it will
go back and it

402
00:14:32,506 --> 00:14:33,556
will improve on it.

403
00:14:33,556 --> 00:14:35,146
And you'll see that
each time you ask

404
00:14:35,146 --> 00:14:37,396
it to regenerate,
it gets better.

405
00:14:37,396 --> 00:14:39,176
Cuz it kind of goes
deeper into its,

406
00:14:39,176 --> 00:14:42,087
knowledge base and
it's got, what you

407
00:14:42,147 --> 00:14:44,727
asked it to use as
a starting point

408
00:14:44,957 --> 00:14:46,157
and it gets better.

409
00:14:46,465 --> 00:14:49,637
So somehow, What
you have input

410
00:14:49,787 --> 00:14:51,167
is being added
to its knowledge

411
00:14:51,167 --> 00:14:52,647
base, so it can
give you better.

412
00:14:53,663 --> 00:14:56,355
So, as a lawyer,
you know, my ethical

413
00:14:56,355 --> 00:14:58,905
duties means that
I cannot share any

414
00:14:58,905 --> 00:15:01,182
confidential client
information with

415
00:15:01,182 --> 00:15:04,177
a public, AI tool
such as chat, G p T.

416
00:15:04,444 --> 00:15:07,017
So I recommend the
same diligence for

417
00:15:07,017 --> 00:15:09,237
you with respect to
your confidential

418
00:15:09,237 --> 00:15:10,437
information,
and of course,

419
00:15:10,442 --> 00:15:11,547
your client's
confidential

420
00:15:11,547 --> 00:15:12,447
information.

421
00:15:12,807 --> 00:15:16,693
You need to protect
it and assume that

422
00:15:16,693 --> 00:15:19,617
at some point,
if not now, then

423
00:15:19,617 --> 00:15:22,024
certainly later
that anything that

424
00:15:22,029 --> 00:15:25,423
you put into a chat
will be accessible.

425
00:15:25,767 --> 00:15:29,682
So finally, there
is kind of the issue

426
00:15:29,784 --> 00:15:32,892
about ownership
of content that is

427
00:15:32,897 --> 00:15:34,632
generated by ai.

428
00:15:34,941 --> 00:15:36,992
So the US
copyright office

429
00:15:36,992 --> 00:15:38,222
is working out.

430
00:15:38,648 --> 00:15:40,898
Whether content
generated by AI

431
00:15:40,898 --> 00:15:42,158
can be protected.

432
00:15:42,423 --> 00:15:46,567
chat, G B t, says
that the answers

433
00:15:46,572 --> 00:15:48,907
are owned by
the requester.

434
00:15:49,160 --> 00:15:49,582
but that.

435
00:15:49,737 --> 00:15:51,207
Make some
assumptions that

436
00:15:51,357 --> 00:15:52,977
I don't think
you can rely on.

437
00:15:52,977 --> 00:15:55,017
Again, we don't
know the source

438
00:15:55,271 --> 00:15:57,851
of the answers
of the responses.

439
00:15:57,941 --> 00:15:59,291
So without
knowing that,

440
00:15:59,291 --> 00:16:00,911
how can you know
that you own it?

441
00:16:01,234 --> 00:16:04,326
copyright law does
not protect ideas.

442
00:16:04,506 --> 00:16:06,456
It doesn't protect
facts, it doesn't

443
00:16:06,456 --> 00:16:07,896
protect information.

444
00:16:08,196 --> 00:16:11,061
so a lot of AI
generated responses

445
00:16:11,066 --> 00:16:13,341
fall into those
categories.

446
00:16:13,623 --> 00:16:15,423
However, there are.

447
00:16:15,913 --> 00:16:17,593
creative
uses for ai.

448
00:16:18,040 --> 00:16:20,493
sometimes, you can
ask it to write a

449
00:16:20,493 --> 00:16:22,773
poem or you can ask
it to write a script

450
00:16:22,970 --> 00:16:25,134
and you can, ask
it to write songs.

451
00:16:25,375 --> 00:16:27,114
And certainly
there is AI that

452
00:16:27,119 --> 00:16:30,408
can create, images
and paintings

453
00:16:30,413 --> 00:16:32,888
that would be
considered original

454
00:16:33,078 --> 00:16:34,068
and creative.

455
00:16:34,530 --> 00:16:37,744
So there are
some real valid

456
00:16:38,464 --> 00:16:40,974
questions about
ownership of AI

457
00:16:40,979 --> 00:16:42,451
generated content.

458
00:16:42,781 --> 00:16:44,401
I describe
intellectual

459
00:16:44,871 --> 00:16:46,047
property as the
product of human

460
00:16:46,051 --> 00:16:49,444
intellect, and
AI is not human,

461
00:16:49,944 --> 00:16:50,874
at least not yet.

462
00:16:51,440 --> 00:16:54,430
At the beginning
of ai, there had

463
00:16:54,435 --> 00:16:55,060
to be humans.

464
00:16:55,060 --> 00:16:57,330
There always has to
be a human at the

465
00:16:57,330 --> 00:17:00,090
very beginning of
any idea, right?

466
00:17:00,338 --> 00:17:01,641
at least a
recorded idea.

467
00:17:01,931 --> 00:17:05,343
so this is just,
another one of

468
00:17:05,343 --> 00:17:07,233
these conundrums
that AI presents

469
00:17:07,233 --> 00:17:09,179
to us that will
need to be worked

470
00:17:09,179 --> 00:17:11,439
out as AI becomes
more prevalent.

471
00:17:11,844 --> 00:17:14,198
So, When we
talk about your

472
00:17:14,198 --> 00:17:16,314
expertise, your
intellectual

473
00:17:16,314 --> 00:17:19,382
property and the
dangers of it being

474
00:17:19,382 --> 00:17:22,662
exposed in, more
scenarios through

475
00:17:22,662 --> 00:17:23,562
the use of ai.

476
00:17:24,055 --> 00:17:26,556
I talk about the
distinction between

477
00:17:26,646 --> 00:17:27,890
a cook and a chef.

478
00:17:28,107 --> 00:17:30,900
a cook can follow a
recipe and produce

479
00:17:30,930 --> 00:17:33,660
edible and maybe
even delicious food.

480
00:17:33,876 --> 00:17:36,753
However, a chef
has that skill,

481
00:17:36,758 --> 00:17:38,463
the experience,
the creativity,

482
00:17:38,468 --> 00:17:40,577
and the talent that
makes people wanna

483
00:17:40,577 --> 00:17:43,067
pay the big bucks
to go join, to

484
00:17:43,067 --> 00:17:45,133
pay them to, have
that experience at

485
00:17:45,133 --> 00:17:45,833
their restaurant.

486
00:17:46,120 --> 00:17:48,420
So this is the same
with your expertise,

487
00:17:48,727 --> 00:17:50,433
so an AI solution?

488
00:17:50,728 --> 00:17:51,130
Yes.

489
00:17:51,130 --> 00:17:52,720
It can replicate,
you know, run

490
00:17:52,720 --> 00:17:53,260
of the mill.

491
00:17:54,318 --> 00:17:56,913
Of what you do,
it can scrape the

492
00:17:56,913 --> 00:17:59,937
internet for freely
available content.

493
00:18:00,310 --> 00:18:02,598
AI is basically a
generalist though,

494
00:18:02,808 --> 00:18:04,248
and it doesn't
understand the

495
00:18:04,248 --> 00:18:07,338
nuances the way
that an expert does.

496
00:18:07,738 --> 00:18:08,878
And when it's
scraping the

497
00:18:08,878 --> 00:18:10,228
internet, it
won't be able

498
00:18:10,228 --> 00:18:12,524
to differentiate
between, what is

499
00:18:12,614 --> 00:18:14,654
thought leadership
versus what is

500
00:18:14,654 --> 00:18:17,514
just someone's
random ramblings,

501
00:18:17,784 --> 00:18:18,661
on the internet.

502
00:18:18,751 --> 00:18:21,481
And so that
is why today.

503
00:18:21,834 --> 00:18:24,037
You'll get some
nonsense answers

504
00:18:24,037 --> 00:18:26,214
from AI cuz it,
can find something

505
00:18:26,214 --> 00:18:28,764
that matches your
keywords, but it

506
00:18:28,764 --> 00:18:31,061
can't tell whether
or not this is

507
00:18:31,243 --> 00:18:33,094
well-researched
information or if

508
00:18:33,094 --> 00:18:36,088
it's just something,
someone's musings

509
00:18:36,438 --> 00:18:39,607
so it cannot, kind
of synthesize.

510
00:18:39,883 --> 00:18:42,093
Experience the way
that you can, I

511
00:18:42,093 --> 00:18:44,841
mean, experience
and being able to

512
00:18:44,841 --> 00:18:47,241
kind of pull on
that is a uniquely

513
00:18:47,241 --> 00:18:48,538
human skill.

514
00:18:48,944 --> 00:18:51,651
So it can only pull
on what has been

515
00:18:51,651 --> 00:18:54,825
recorded and it
can't always apply.

516
00:18:55,526 --> 00:18:56,990
Context either.

517
00:18:57,072 --> 00:19:00,920
So as a chef, as
the expert, you

518
00:19:00,920 --> 00:19:03,740
know when to go
with a standard

519
00:19:03,740 --> 00:19:07,180
ingredients or when
to add something

520
00:19:07,180 --> 00:19:09,850
else, you can taste
it and go, eh, it's

521
00:19:09,850 --> 00:19:12,743
too sweet, it's too
salty, and know how

522
00:19:12,773 --> 00:19:15,244
to tweak it to make
it taste better.

523
00:19:15,581 --> 00:19:18,551
Another metaphor
is with respect to,

524
00:19:18,575 --> 00:19:20,554
the doctor-patient
relationship.

525
00:19:20,834 --> 00:19:23,404
Yes, AI can
ask diagnostic

526
00:19:23,404 --> 00:19:25,654
questions, it can
review lab results,

527
00:19:25,894 --> 00:19:29,248
and it can provide
a, diagnosis

528
00:19:29,248 --> 00:19:32,348
based on that and
propose solutions

529
00:19:32,348 --> 00:19:33,248
based on that.

530
00:19:33,713 --> 00:19:36,148
What it can't do is
it can't observe the

531
00:19:36,148 --> 00:19:37,288
patient's demeanor.

532
00:19:37,331 --> 00:19:39,777
is sweating, is
their leg shaking?

533
00:19:39,994 --> 00:19:42,492
can they notice that
maybe it's, someone

534
00:19:42,492 --> 00:19:44,622
who has a parent
in the room with

535
00:19:44,622 --> 00:19:46,602
them and asked, you
know, can I talk

536
00:19:46,602 --> 00:19:48,535
to, your son alone?

537
00:19:48,748 --> 00:19:50,998
they can't ask the
follow up questions.

538
00:19:50,998 --> 00:19:52,258
They can't put
him at ease.

539
00:19:52,258 --> 00:19:54,032
Sometimes having
your blood pressure

540
00:19:54,032 --> 00:19:55,112
taken and you're
like, you know, why

541
00:19:55,112 --> 00:19:56,342
don't you lay down
for a second and

542
00:19:56,342 --> 00:19:57,122
we'll do it again.

543
00:19:57,365 --> 00:19:59,192
These are a number
of things that

544
00:19:59,192 --> 00:20:02,335
require kind of
the human touch.

545
00:20:02,635 --> 00:20:04,831
And some people will
accuse doctors of

546
00:20:04,831 --> 00:20:07,261
not having a bedside
manner, but most

547
00:20:07,261 --> 00:20:08,821
doctors do have
a bedside manner.

548
00:20:09,074 --> 00:20:11,137
AI can never
have a bedside

549
00:20:11,137 --> 00:20:11,797
manner, right?

550
00:20:12,106 --> 00:20:14,921
And so those things
where you as an

551
00:20:14,921 --> 00:20:16,841
expert can use
your instinct.

552
00:20:17,103 --> 00:20:19,767
To take, what you
know about a client,

553
00:20:19,767 --> 00:20:21,079
what you know about
their, problems

554
00:20:21,079 --> 00:20:22,999
they had with their
last consultant.

555
00:20:23,369 --> 00:20:26,669
these are things
that AI cannot do.

556
00:20:26,975 --> 00:20:29,548
So ai, yes, it can
be an excellent

557
00:20:29,553 --> 00:20:32,058
support for your
work, but only you

558
00:20:32,058 --> 00:20:34,938
kind of know how
to tweak things

559
00:20:34,938 --> 00:20:36,828
and make those
little shifts

560
00:20:36,828 --> 00:20:38,968
that come from
years of experie.

561
00:20:39,582 --> 00:20:42,268
So I had one more
question for chat

562
00:20:42,268 --> 00:20:45,728
and G B T and I
asked it, can AI

563
00:20:45,728 --> 00:20:47,408
take the place
of a management

564
00:20:47,408 --> 00:20:48,128
consultant?

565
00:20:48,418 --> 00:20:49,978
And here was
its answer.

566
00:20:50,305 --> 00:20:52,785
AI can certainly
provide valuable

567
00:20:52,790 --> 00:20:54,475
insights and
analysis that

568
00:20:54,475 --> 00:20:56,095
can be useful
for management

569
00:20:56,095 --> 00:20:58,505
decision making,
but it is unlikely

570
00:20:58,510 --> 00:21:00,185
to completely
replace the role

571
00:21:00,185 --> 00:21:01,505
of a management
consultant.

572
00:21:01,867 --> 00:21:03,281
Management
consultants bring

573
00:21:03,281 --> 00:21:05,351
a range of skills
and expertise

574
00:21:05,351 --> 00:21:07,362
to the work,
including strategic

575
00:21:07,362 --> 00:21:09,975
planning, business
analysis process,

576
00:21:10,108 --> 00:21:11,753
improvement, and
change manage.

577
00:21:12,328 --> 00:21:14,218
They often work
closely with clients

578
00:21:14,218 --> 00:21:16,468
to understand their
unique challenges

579
00:21:16,750 --> 00:21:18,728
and provide
customized solutions

580
00:21:18,878 --> 00:21:20,918
that meet their
specific need.

581
00:21:21,256 --> 00:21:22,965
Management
consultants also

582
00:21:22,965 --> 00:21:25,365
typically have
strong interpersonal

583
00:21:25,365 --> 00:21:27,308
and communication
skills, which

584
00:21:27,313 --> 00:21:29,318
allow them to
work effectively

585
00:21:29,318 --> 00:21:30,988
with a wide range
of stakeholders.

586
00:21:31,699 --> 00:21:34,100
While AI can
provide powerful

587
00:21:34,105 --> 00:21:36,816
data analysis and
insights, it may not

588
00:21:36,816 --> 00:21:39,036
be able to replicate
the nuanced

589
00:21:39,036 --> 00:21:41,110
and contextual
understanding that

590
00:21:41,110 --> 00:21:42,700
a skilled management
consultant

591
00:21:42,700 --> 00:21:43,600
can provide.

592
00:21:44,506 --> 00:21:47,016
Additionally, AI
may have limitations

593
00:21:47,016 --> 00:21:49,086
in its ability
to understand and

594
00:21:49,086 --> 00:21:52,843
respond to complex
human factors such

595
00:21:52,843 --> 00:21:55,326
as organizational
culture, individual

596
00:21:55,906 --> 00:21:58,203
personalities, and
political dynamics.

597
00:21:58,233 --> 00:21:58,863
Oh, that is so.

598
00:21:59,501 --> 00:22:02,138
That being said,
AI can certainly

599
00:22:02,138 --> 00:22:04,298
be a valuable tool
for management

600
00:22:04,298 --> 00:22:06,555
consultants helping
to automate certain

601
00:22:06,555 --> 00:22:09,368
tasks and provide
additional insights

602
00:22:09,578 --> 00:22:11,768
that can inform the
recommendations.

603
00:22:12,011 --> 00:22:14,291
Ultimately, the most
effective approach

604
00:22:14,291 --> 00:22:17,351
is likely to be a
combination of AI

605
00:22:17,441 --> 00:22:20,065
and human expertise
working together

606
00:22:20,065 --> 00:22:22,225
to provide the
most comprehensive

607
00:22:22,496 --> 00:22:23,845
and effective
solutions for.

608
00:22:24,753 --> 00:22:27,344
Yeah, that is
absolutely true.

609
00:22:27,597 --> 00:22:31,039
So I am excited by
AI's possibilities

610
00:22:31,234 --> 00:22:34,036
to support us as
experts in our work.

611
00:22:34,246 --> 00:22:36,049
It is absolutely
a time saver.

612
00:22:36,079 --> 00:22:39,003
It is a wonderful
resource, but

613
00:22:39,003 --> 00:22:42,548
ultimately, without
human touch, AI has

614
00:22:42,548 --> 00:22:45,079
its limitations,
so make it a

615
00:22:45,079 --> 00:22:46,279
fantastic tool.

616
00:22:46,894 --> 00:22:49,044
As part of your
toolbox, how you

617
00:22:49,044 --> 00:22:51,084
provide value
to your clients,

618
00:22:51,335 --> 00:22:53,255
how you make
your business

619
00:22:53,255 --> 00:22:55,175
more efficient
and therefore

620
00:22:55,175 --> 00:22:56,375
more profitable.

621
00:22:56,685 --> 00:22:58,865
But I don't want
you to worry about

622
00:22:59,015 --> 00:23:02,015
it replacing you
as an expert.

623
00:23:02,378 --> 00:23:05,247
The key to working
with A I protect

624
00:23:05,247 --> 00:23:07,027
your original ip,
protect it through

625
00:23:07,027 --> 00:23:08,167
documentation.

626
00:23:08,910 --> 00:23:11,342
Through registration
and when you're

627
00:23:11,347 --> 00:23:14,085
using AI as a
resource, make sure

628
00:23:14,085 --> 00:23:16,125
you are doing your
diligence to make

629
00:23:16,125 --> 00:23:19,942
sure that it has not
plagiarized somebody

630
00:23:19,947 --> 00:23:20,502
else's work.

631
00:23:20,697 --> 00:23:22,188
So if you have
any questions or

632
00:23:22,188 --> 00:23:25,350
concerns about how
AI impacts your

633
00:23:25,350 --> 00:23:28,063
ip, you can contact
me for consult.

634
00:23:28,745 --> 00:23:31,308
And also don't
forget the IP

635
00:23:31,313 --> 00:23:33,778
tracker as a way to
determine what steps

636
00:23:33,778 --> 00:23:36,300
you need to take
to protect yourself

637
00:23:36,390 --> 00:23:37,080
and your ip.