I now have the pleasure of introducing Deborah Recnix.
Speaker ADeborah has provided consulting services to privately owned, medium and small businesses for over 40 years.
Speaker AHer work, her work took her to four continents to share her knowledge and experience and help businesses grow, improve profitability and increase their value.
Speaker ADeborah wrote her first book, Success in Small Business to share the experiences, hopes and dreams of hardworking business owners and their individual path to success.
Speaker ANow Deborah is able to spend her time with her grandchildren and other young children and finds that our newest generation is missing out on strong financial education.
Speaker AKids see money as free, easy to come by, easy to spend, no thought to other options, and not much interest in learning more.
Speaker AIn addition, parents find it hard to explain most financial principles.
Speaker AGrandma Deb was born a pen name for her first book in a series.
Speaker AHer slogan, money, Money, how to earn it, spend it and save it Wisely is her primary focus.
Speaker AWelcome Deborah, it is a pleasure to have you here today.
Speaker AThank you very much for being here.
Speaker AAnd I do realize that I got the last two words in that title backwards, but it will be all in the show notes and it will be there.
Speaker ASo thank you very much for joining us today.
Speaker AIt is a pleasure to have you here today.
Speaker AMoney is such an important topic around the world, especially today.
Speaker AWe really do need to get our children more involved with it.
Speaker ASo thank you for being here today.
Speaker BIt's a pleasure to be here.
Speaker BI'm very happy to be able to talk about this today.
Speaker CSo do we call you Deborah or do we call you Grandma Deb?
Speaker BYou know, I answer to most anything and since the last name is a bit hard, Deborah, Grandma Deb is just perfect.
Speaker CPerfect.
Speaker CYes.
Speaker CAnd like Herb was saying, you know, we really enjoy bringing on people like you who are focused on families and kids and really helping all of our families up level, like take that next step into their family adventure, whether it be a different kind of education, a different kind of movement forward like finances, nutrition, all those kinds of things.
Speaker CSo again, thank you for being here.
Speaker CWe want to start with the question of why this passion.
Speaker CWe know you have the corporate and this other business background and now your grandkids.
Speaker CWhat was that pivotal point was like I really need to do something in this area.
Speaker BWell, I, I have to tell you the story that was that pivotal point and what happened is a bunch of kids, the kids were all about 12 years old, they were given some money by their parents, like $5, $10 bills and they went to a store, they literally slapped the bill on the counter and said didn't ask and Said, just give me the candy that I can spend with this money.
Speaker BSo in their minds, there was no concept of how much does $5 buy, what has value.
Speaker BIt was basically, here it is and give me what I want.
Speaker BAnd it took me so aback that that was common.
Speaker BI mean, there were, there were lots of kids that were handling money that way.
Speaker BAnd it was so frustrating.
Speaker BAnd it isn't their fault.
Speaker BI can't blame them.
Speaker BThat's not what we're doing here.
Speaker BBut I realized after digging a little bit that there is nothing in the educational system.
Speaker BThere's nothing, almost nothing in writing.
Speaker BIt's not in the formal system, it's not in the informal learning system.
Speaker BFor them to grasp these concepts and learn them before they need them.
Speaker BAnd that was the moment for me.
Speaker BI had to find some way to contribute for these kids education.
Speaker AYeah, I remember because I was in high school when they took out home economics from the curriculum because it's like, oh, that's cooking.
Speaker AIt's like, it's not just cooking.
Speaker AThere's like changing tires and, and how to, and, and balancing checkbooks and a budget.
Speaker ASo that was all part of it.
Speaker ASo I, I was one of the last classes that actually got to have that in high school.
Speaker AAnd ever since then, it's like the generations just are less and less and less.
Speaker AEspecially now with how easy that buying on plastic is.
Speaker AYou just walk by and you swipe a card and it's just.
Speaker AThere's no physical exchange anymore.
Speaker BAnd those were the issues I had to come to terms with is how do you explain what a debit card is?
Speaker BIt's pretty much magic.
Speaker BIt's just tap and go.
Speaker BAnd so to explain to smaller children that, well, where does it come from and how do you use it and how do you know what happens to it?
Speaker BAll those are issues that never had to be discussed before.
Speaker BThese kids don't see dollar bills, they don't see co. See tap and go.
Speaker BAnd so the whole thing is, is a very hard concept to talk about.
Speaker CAnd you know, sometimes, and we were guilty of it as we were raising our boys is like sometimes when families are struggling with money, right, they try not to share all of those struggles with the kids because it might not be age appropriate.
Speaker AWe don't need to stress out the kids.
Speaker AWe don't want them to know.
Speaker AWe don't want them to know how poor we are.
Speaker AWe don't want that stigma over them while they're out with their friends.
Speaker AWe want to have them be as normal as possible.
Speaker ASo you know, but at the same
Speaker Ctime, we're taking away that value of the learning.
Speaker CYou don't have to go into the stress of it, but you can go into, oh, we're watching our budget this month.
Speaker CWe're watching this because this didn't add up the same way it has in months past.
Speaker CIt's a knowledge base instead of a stress thing.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ASo to kids, Ma or money is magic, and we need to.
Speaker AMagic take that away from them.
Speaker AAnd like, no, it's not magic.
Speaker AThis is.
Speaker AThis is how it comes and why it takes.
Speaker BIt takes parents.
Speaker BIt's a very scary subject because that pressure is there every week, every month.
Speaker BYou got to pay the bills.
Speaker BYou don't want them to feel that stress, and yet they need to learn it at the level that they're ready for.
Speaker BAnd that's.
Speaker BThat's the challenge, the tightrope that we end up walking.
Speaker BBut what you do realize is that the parents know all about finance.
Speaker BFinance is a fancy term for money, for earning it, saving it, spending it.
Speaker BAnd so they really know a lot more than they realize.
Speaker BSo it's just picking the subject, picking the time, and slowly feeding the education.
Speaker CYeah, exactly.
Speaker AIt's amazing because they also know a lot less than they think they do as well, because they think of currency as money.
Speaker AAnd there is so many other ways to look at money than just what is in dollars.
Speaker AAnd so then to add that extra layer on top of it, then you're going to, like, blow away almost like 90% of the rest of America.
Speaker CSo it's like we're doing basic finances.
Speaker ABasic finances.
Speaker ABut again, it's like if you give them, like, something, like, substantial and then give them a dollar bill, they will say, this is something and this is nothing, and that is actually closer to what money is than.
Speaker AThan anything else.
Speaker ASo, yeah, kids get it conceptually, and that's why it's hard when they're looking at.
Speaker AAt dollars and stuff, because it's not.
Speaker AIt's not real to them.
Speaker ASo it's not real.
Speaker AReally, really confusing for kids, but.
Speaker ABut very, very important to at least get the understanding so they can grow into it.
Speaker BThat's right.
Speaker BIf we can get them the basics, then as new information comes, they're able to absorb it or learn it or put it in some framework that we've already given them, and they don't even have that framework to get started.
Speaker CSo going back to your story, were you able to help those kiddos understand a little bit, or was that just the impetus for everything else?
Speaker CThat you're doing.
Speaker BI think those kids were already 12 and I decided to start with the 4 year olds.
Speaker B4 to 8 year olds was my first target.
Speaker BAnd that's where the book focuses.
Speaker BAnd the next one is 8 to 12 year olds and that's where the debit card, credit cards, banks really start to.
Speaker BYou could talk about those things, but no, I started with the, the ones that still have a piggy bank.
Speaker CAwesome.
Speaker CSo let's give that parent.
Speaker AYeah, that was going to be our question.
Speaker AYeah, how do we get started in that?
Speaker ASo how, how do we get parents to start learning the very first, like first step, like, oh man, we don't know.
Speaker AWe got to get started in this.
Speaker AWe have to get this under control.
Speaker AStep one.
Speaker BSo I'll give you step one in, in just a moment.
Speaker BThe question is, how old is the child?
Speaker BBecause I, I found that the four to six year old counts the money and the six to eight year old collects the money.
Speaker BAnd then the Next group, the 8 to 10 year old, is willing to wait for some money.
Speaker BSo counting really is the Piggy Bank.
Speaker BIt's 1, 2, 3.
Speaker BBut I don't think it's important to count quarters and nickels and dimes.
Speaker BThat's all very complicated.
Speaker BBut a piggy bank that has a window in it or just a glass jar allows me to count.
Speaker BAnd the reason I, I struggled with a lot of the books talk about counting coins and counting.
Speaker BAnd I thought realistically, in the next generation there won't be any.
Speaker BA lot of countries there isn't any.
Speaker BThere's no checks, there's no coins, there are no bills.
Speaker BWhat they need to understand is value.
Speaker BWhat does it buy?
Speaker BAs you said before, Herb, So the piggy bank is step one.
Speaker BThen, then they can start dealing with the value.
Speaker BAnd that starts, goes into what's the very first discussion point?
Speaker BAnd I chose money doesn't grow on trees because I have an editor for the book who is 8 years old now, he's 9.
Speaker BAnd I asked him, he says, I don't know what that means.
Speaker BSo that's brilliant because he asked a question which means he might listen to the answer.
Speaker BMoney.
Speaker BAnd I didn't realize, you know, adults have always heard money doesn't grow on trees.
Speaker AOh yeah.
Speaker BBut the kids, the kids don't have a clue what that means.
Speaker BSo it provides the opportunity.
Speaker BWell, I can't just grab money and it's not a leaf and it's not off the tree and then go spend it.
Speaker BI go to work and that's the explanation I give, I go to work, then I have to pay bills like that.
Speaker BHe will understand the gas because he goes to the gas station, and the groceries because he goes to groceries.
Speaker BAnd so parents understand that.
Speaker BThey then understand money and can talk about money to the kids.
Speaker BBut money doesn't grow on trees.
Speaker BThat's why I go to work.
Speaker BSo that's where I start.
Speaker BI start with, money doesn't grow on trees.
Speaker CAnd I love that because it's a different take on that saying than what we grew up.
Speaker AOh, I hated that saying.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CWhen we grew up as, like, you know, it wasn't easy to get or whatever.
Speaker CThat's what it meant for us.
Speaker CBut for you, you're changing the meaning of that a little bit.
Speaker CIt's like, no, it's something that we work towards that we can't just pick up like a leaf.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CSo I love that shift on that meaning.
Speaker AAnd I also like how you talked about talking with children about value.
Speaker AAnd.
Speaker AAnd because then that does lead to another thing about what money is, is.
Speaker AMoney is a store of value.
Speaker AIt is not a valuable thing in and of itself.
Speaker AIt's like, I have eggs.
Speaker AI want bread.
Speaker AThe guy who has the bread doesn't want eggs.
Speaker ASo instead of doing, like, five trades to get to the bread, there is this one thing in the middle that I can trade for and I can get that value, and then I can give that value to somebody else.
Speaker AThat's.
Speaker AThat is the money thing that even.
Speaker AEven adults don't get because they all just come to the.
Speaker ATo the.
Speaker ASo, but.
Speaker ASo, yeah, getting that idea to kids through the barter system first, tremendously beneficial.
Speaker BYeah, yeah.
Speaker BAnd they learn that and they remember it because it does have a bit of a slang to it.
Speaker BMoney doesn't grow on trees.
Speaker BEverybody can say that.
Speaker BSo that.
Speaker BThat.
Speaker BThat's where I started.
Speaker CI love that.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CAnd then, like you said, as they're growing and maturing, they can finally start waiting for the money.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CThey want to buy something.
Speaker CAnd you're able to explain, well, you don't have enough money for that yet.
Speaker CWhat can you do to get the money?
Speaker COr can you wait until your next birthday to get the money, et cetera.
Speaker CSo go ahead and explain a little bit more around that.
Speaker BThat's exactly right.
Speaker BSo it's interesting that then can also work into a math program.
Speaker BSo if you're on an allowance, which some people are, it says, well, you want this?
Speaker BIt costs $10.
Speaker BHow many weeks do you have to wait in order to do your Chores get the money and then buy it.
Speaker BAnd so that's their waiting period.
Speaker BBut they also know there's something at the end for them.
Speaker BThey're not just doing it for no good reason, they're doing it for something that they want.
Speaker BSo that becomes the issue of allowance.
Speaker BDo you pay it?
Speaker BDon't you pay it?
Speaker BAnd there's a debate on both sides.
Speaker BBut what I find is if a family says, well, it's all family money and we spend it together, and so I'm not paying for chores, that's one solid argument.
Speaker BIt also means there should be some sharing in decision making, because if it's family money, I'm part of the family.
Speaker BThe other side of it is when the parent pays a child an allowance because they earned it, what is interesting is now they have to make a decision.
Speaker BAnd the decisions can be giving it back to the family because they need to pay the bills.
Speaker BAnd then there's another discussion point, or it's mine, I still have to make a decision.
Speaker BWhat do I do with it?
Speaker BWhat are my choices?
Speaker BAnd then they start absorbing that and owning that decision, which I kind of like that, that approach.
Speaker BThey act totally different when it's their decision.
Speaker BBut we've.
Speaker BI've got a.
Speaker BThere's a child, he.
Speaker BHe's got more money and his parents keep borrowing from him.
Speaker BSo now he's learning and he's 10.
Speaker BHe's learning about loans and maybe interest earned and all sorts of secondary issues that come with that.
Speaker BSo the whole thing becomes a game, which is great, but it's also a point of learning.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AI remember when I started first working, it was like my first paycheck.
Speaker AI went out and spent it all.
Speaker AI actually, like took my whole family out to dinner and wiped it out.
Speaker ATwo weeks worth of work gone in one day.
Speaker AAnd it was like, oh, that was interesting.
Speaker AAnd then, then there was the, oh, I want this.
Speaker AAnd it's like as, as I'm building towards that big thing is like, oh, there's this thing I want.
Speaker AThere's this thing and these.
Speaker AAnd it kept taking up.
Speaker ASo there is this learning process.
Speaker AAnd then by the time I got enough money to the thing that I wanted, I didn't even want it anymore.
Speaker BRight, right.
Speaker ASo there is, there is so much learning in that, in value, in, oh, it's going to take me this time.
Speaker AOh, I. I have to do stuff.
Speaker AIt's not just there and then prioritizing.
Speaker AThat is.
Speaker AThat is incredibly valuable for a young mind to go through that process early.
Speaker BAnd the nice part about early is there will be mistakes along the way, but nobody is badly hurt from those mistakes.
Speaker AIt costs a lot less when you're 10, when you're 20 or 30.
Speaker BExactly.
Speaker BI wasted it all on candy and now I'm sad about that.
Speaker BWell, that's okay.
Speaker BThat's how we learn and we can make those mistakes at those ages.
Speaker BBut I have to give them the opportunity to make that mistake and not give them my opinion saying, you know, this is really a bad idea.
Speaker BOf course it's a bad idea.
Speaker BBut I'll keep my mouth shut and let them explore and experience that bad idea.
Speaker ALet them get hurt responsibly when they're young.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker AAnd then it hurts less and they have ways to get around it when they're older.
Speaker A35 year old who's got all the stuff he wants, the cars and the toys and suddenly stuff happens and, and have a job.
Speaker AHe doesn't have a job anymore.
Speaker AThen, then.
Speaker ASo yeah, don't do that at 35, do that at 10, do that at 12 and then figure out.
Speaker AAnd don't do that at 35.
Speaker BRight, exactly.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker CSo I actually had a question about the allowance, right.
Speaker CBecause when we were raising our boys, it was one of those things that.
Speaker CNo, it's family money.
Speaker CWe didn't believe in allowances just for allowance sake because that was very common at that time.
Speaker COh, everybody gets, you know, $2 and 50 cents a week no matter what.
Speaker CAnd we were like, no, no, no, no, that doesn't work.
Speaker CIf they're going to earn money, they're going to actually earn it by doing chores.
Speaker AWe didn't get allowances.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker AWhen we were growing, we were also a poverty mindset.
Speaker AOur parents were really poor.
Speaker ASo that, that has a whole nother realm to it.
Speaker ASo the whole money is just always there.
Speaker AThat's, that's for only like 30% of the population.
Speaker AThere's another 30% that there is no money.
Speaker CBut, but.
Speaker CSo my question was going to be, where do you kind of come down on it?
Speaker CDo you think that they should have chores where they can earn money or it should be like a family?
Speaker CI don't know.
Speaker CWhat, which side do you kind of come down on?
Speaker BI'm not sure there's a right and wrong side, but I think both of them comes with responsibilities by the parents.
Speaker BSo if it's all family money, and frequently that's the case because there is not a lot of excess money, then I think that also needs to be shared because their friends might be Getting chores and might be getting an allowance.
Speaker BAnd it's nice to know why you're not getting it.
Speaker BAnd I think sharing it, as you say, without the stress, which is challenging, no question about it, is just fine if we can share it.
Speaker BAnd one of the ways to do that is while parents pay bills, which is an interesting concept.
Speaker BWe usually pay bills at night after the kids go to sleep.
Speaker CIt's quieter.
Speaker BIt's quieter.
Speaker AYou know what?
Speaker AActually now most of it's all just handled once a year and you don't even have to look at it.
Speaker BWell, that's true.
Speaker BUnless it's tight, you see?
Speaker BAnd when it's tight, you look at it every week or every month, depending on its tightness.
Speaker BAnd so if a, if a parent can take just one issue or one week and do it a little differently and pick one topic, we're not going to pay this this week because.
Speaker BOr I'm trying to save this much money, but I can't do it this week because.
Speaker BAnd that discussion, then it becomes family money, family decisions.
Speaker BAnd that's just fine if you do that instead of an allowance, but either way, I'm trying to build a moment in which to have those discussions.
Speaker BDoesn't matter how you have those discussions.
Speaker CYeah, absolutely.
Speaker CLove that.
Speaker CYou know, one of the things that we really try to help families think about is either a family meeting or a family get together where we discuss those kinds of things.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CIs it, is it budgeting week?
Speaker CIs it vacation planning week?
Speaker CIs it, you know, change of schedules from winter schedule to a summer schedule kind of thing?
Speaker CHaving those meetings and having those discussions around your children and with your children really gives them that knowledge base, like you said, for later in life or later decisions.
Speaker BAnd I really look for the teachable moments.
Speaker BThe, the meetings become probably multiple topics in discussion where if I fall into a teachable moment, somebody might be listening to me.
Speaker BAnd the number one is the weekly grocery shopping, which is brilliant for money and choices and values.
Speaker BSo if the child is walking the.
Speaker BThe cheapest.
Speaker BAnd cereal with the most sugar is usually at their level that they walk through in the grocery store.
Speaker BAnd the, the cereal that I might want, which has the, the oats and some nutrition maybe is much higher on the shelf.
Speaker BSo they want the one on the bottom, I want the one on top.
Speaker BMine may be more expensive than theirs.
Speaker BAnd so I have a teachable moment.
Speaker BWhy am I choosing the one on the top shelf?
Speaker AWell, you got to start going into nutritional density and sugar and all that stuff.
Speaker AThat's a whole Nother conversation.
Speaker CWe'll have that discussion the next week.
Speaker BIt is, I only want to focus on the money and the value, perhaps.
Speaker BAnd alternatively, if this box is twice as big as that box, but it's not twice as expensive, which one should we get?
Speaker BThat's their decision.
Speaker BThey're going to think it through.
Speaker BIt has a bit of math to it, but it's all about money and value.
Speaker BAnd so the grocery store is great for that sort of moment.
Speaker AIt's also great because you could, you could put in an artificial budget.
Speaker ALike today we're going to go spend this amount of money.
Speaker AWe're not going to go over that.
Speaker AEven if you can set that amount and then start teaching the kids to prioritize what they get and then deal with the consequences for a week, let them deal with the consequences of their decisions.
Speaker AAnd it's amazing how well that can actually start training in as well.
Speaker BYeah, that's perfect.
Speaker BThat's absolutely perfect.
Speaker BAnd, and similarly, if they're making a list, whether it's a list that they want for their birthday or Christmas and holidays, they all seem to make lists.
Speaker BAnd, and so they have no idea the value of those items on the list.
Speaker BAnd these days those things cost a lot of money.
Speaker BSo if I said, well, you can have the number one item or you can have two and three because they don't cost nearly as much.
Speaker BAnd we can certainly go online and price all this these days.
Speaker BNow they have to think about it.
Speaker BThey have to make a choice.
Speaker BAnd again, they're really talking about money all the time.
Speaker BThat way they just don't realize it and they don't have to talk about it and call it finance.
Speaker BIt's just making choices.
Speaker AYeah, we're just coming out of one of the worst money decision for children type stuff right now in the world.
Speaker ABecause children, children don't understand that.
Speaker AAnd so how come Santa Claus brings that kid over there like a bicycle and I got a pair of socks.
Speaker ASo yeah, that, that conversation around money and Christmas time, that, that can be really brutal.
Speaker BIt can be.
Speaker BYes, exactly.
Speaker BSo if I pull them into wasn't nearly as painful.
Speaker BI said, you realize this costs a thousand dollars and you know, whatever that means, it means that's a lot.
Speaker BAnd this one costs a hundred dollars.
Speaker BYou can have 10 of those that I understand.
Speaker BI can have 10 of those and one of those.
Speaker BWhich ones do I want?
Speaker AAnd you asked for a doll and you asked for a phone.
Speaker AYou could have 5,000 of these for the price of one of these.
Speaker AThey're not equivalent.
Speaker BIt's, it's a perfect teaching moment.
Speaker BYeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker CAnd when you're talking about that list, the other thing that I always like to do a little bit was have the kids guess the price and then actually go look it up.
Speaker CBecause then all of a sudden like they're like, oh wait a minute, I'm way off.
Speaker CYou know, I thought, you know, I thought that toy was going to be like $5 and we go look it up and it's $55.
Speaker CThey also get to see those differences and learn that value a little bit more.
Speaker AOh, that happens to me all the time.
Speaker AIt's like, oh, I want one of these and I'll go look.
Speaker AIt's like, oh, I can make one of those myself.
Speaker BYeah, I don't need it that badly.
Speaker AI don't need it that bad.
Speaker CExactly.
Speaker BOh, awesome.
Speaker CSo we cover that 4 year old to 10 year old kind of chunk and level.
Speaker CAnd then you said the next one is kind of like that 10 to 12 or 12, 14ish age.
Speaker CWhat's something that we can do for those parents?
Speaker BSo then we talk about banks.
Speaker BNow that presumes that the children have a little bit of their own money.
Speaker BAnd the question is, what is a bank good for?
Speaker BWhich actually I struggled with the answer to that.
Speaker AYeah, there's not a lot that her banks are good for.
Speaker BWell, that's exactly right.
Speaker BAnd that's what we need to tell parents because they, they're looking at it as well.
Speaker BThere's only really one thing that a bank offers today or, or businesses that are like banks and that's the debit card.
Speaker BBecause I need an account transactional ease that has money in it.
Speaker BThat's my money.
Speaker BAnd then they give me a debit card.
Speaker BAnd so I need to have a conversation of what is it, how is it used?
Speaker BIt's my money and I can only use it as long as I've got my money in the bank.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker ADebit cards are a little bit safer than credit cards in that way.
Speaker AIn the same way that checks used to be.
Speaker AI still have checks, I still have money.
Speaker AThat's not true.
Speaker BWell, I'm still looking for checks these days because those are going away as well.
Speaker BIt's interesting that credit cards are very difficult because in this country you have to be.
Speaker BIt's either 16 or 18 years old before they will give you your own credit card.
Speaker BSo for kids to understand the downsides to a credit card, they never have an opportunity to do so.
Speaker CIt's a family structure.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BNot even as an independent until they're old enough to get into a lot of trouble, which explains why they get into so much trouble.
Speaker BAnd, and that's the difficulty with a credit card.
Speaker BThey can get one on your account, which doesn't help them and it doesn't help you either.
Speaker BSo it has to just be discussed in theory, and that's then on the older child after they've used the debit card, and then to explain the differences, but it's all theoretical until they get into trouble.
Speaker AAnd the hard part is, is our, our whole society is based on debt.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AYou know, we, we don't have a cash flow society.
Speaker AWe have, ours is based on debt.
Speaker ASo to not go into debt is actually hard in this country to stay cash flow positive because of, of how our system is actually designed.
Speaker ASo like the, the personal debt in this, in this country is astronomical.
Speaker AIt's in the, it's in the trillions of dollars of how much money is borrowed.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BAnd, and if you borrow it on a credit card, understanding how expensive that is, and it's not only the interest, but then there's also fees, Associates say
Speaker Apayment over time and of the late, late amounts.
Speaker BSo it becomes, I can only do it with a discussion and an article.
Speaker BAnd until they experience the debit cards, they can't really understand the credit card, which is sort of one level past that.
Speaker CI remember going off to college and one of the very first things in the packet of papers when we got to college was your first credit card application.
Speaker CAnd they would give us a credit card.
Speaker CLike the first year of school, it's like, oh, well, you might need to help you buy some books or you might need to, you know, buy, buy some food if, if the commissary is closed.
Speaker ABack then it was a $500 limit,
Speaker Cbut it was a limit.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CIt didn't let us get into too much.
Speaker ATell you what, that $500, when I hit it, that caused me some problems.
Speaker AHoly moly, did that cause problems.
Speaker A$500, you're supposed to pay it back.
Speaker BNobody told you that.
Speaker CThey're just like.
Speaker CYeah, yeah, exactly.
Speaker BAnd now we're so used to tap and go.
Speaker BWell, you just tap and go, what's the difference?
Speaker BAnd as you said, the cards look nearly identical.
Speaker BThey're all, mine are all blue, which annoys me to no end, but that's what it is.
Speaker BAnd so not only do they act the same and they look the same, but they're, they're not the same.
Speaker BSo if a child has learned along the way they may also be listening to you when that credit card comes.
Speaker BAnd that's the best we can hope for.
Speaker BYeah, we're trying to build that rapport and that discussion around money.
Speaker BA lot of people grew up saying, well, talking about money is not something this family does.
Speaker CExactly.
Speaker BAnd that was very, very common.
Speaker BSo then you can try to talk about it and you'll find, well, they're not really interested.
Speaker BSo I'm looking for these teachable moments where there's still not interest, but there might be enough interest in the cereals and in the toys and in the bike.
Speaker BAnd so that's the discussion we have of something that interests the children so that they'll listen.
Speaker BBest we can hope for.
Speaker AI'm a kind of a weird guy.
Speaker ATalked about it a little already, but there are times where, when I get into these teachable moments with kids, even sometimes when they're around their parents, is like, I'll.
Speaker AI'll go into this, like, deep explanation, and then I'll look at the kids like, you have no idea what this means.
Speaker ABut just hearing this is going to plant a seed.
Speaker AAnd now that information is in there somewhere, and when you need it, it might come out.
Speaker AAnd the parents are like, yes, that.
Speaker ASo they don't mind when I do stuff like that.
Speaker ABecause.
Speaker ABecause again, it does if you hear it once, if you hear it twice, even as a kid, when it comes back later, that seed is there, that brain is there, and it's something to build on instead of, oh, I'm just hearing it for the first time.
Speaker ARemembering a little bit is easier than learning from nothing.
Speaker BRight, Right.
Speaker BThat's it.
Speaker AKeep.
Speaker AKeep poking at your kids, even if it's not like, yeah, right there all the time.
Speaker CFormal.
Speaker BYeah, that's right.
Speaker CExactly.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CI call it marinating.
Speaker CAnd it's.
Speaker CIt's that exact same thing, you know, that idea of a little bit there, and then it grows and it grows as they hear it over and over.
Speaker CAnd, you know, if we look into brain science, it takes at least seven times, and for some people, up to 100 times to actually learn a concept.
Speaker CSo it's not a horrible thing to repeat it several times.
Speaker BRight, right.
Speaker ADon't get mad.
Speaker AI already told you this.
Speaker AIt's like, I'm reminding you of this.
Speaker AI'm reminding you of this.
Speaker AHey, I'm reminding you of this.
Speaker BWell, it happens every week.
Speaker BWe're going to the grocery store.
Speaker BYou've got the list.
Speaker BAre we going to add to the list or not?
Speaker BIs it in the Budget or is it not?
Speaker BAnd adults think about it all the time.
Speaker AOh, wait, we forgot the list this week.
Speaker ADo you remember what was on the list?
Speaker AThat's.
Speaker AThat happens with us.
Speaker CWe never forget the list.
Speaker BRemember, it's on the phone.
Speaker BJust like the.
Speaker BThe debit card is now on the phone.
Speaker BThey don't even see the card anymore.
Speaker BSo the next generation, it's.
Speaker BAll the cards are on the phone.
Speaker BAnd so that has to be discussed.
Speaker CHow do you.
Speaker BYou.
Speaker BYou know, if the money doesn't grow on the trees, it must grow out of the phone.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BSo how does that.
Speaker BHow does that actually happen?
Speaker CYeah, the Apple wallet, the Google wall, all those.
Speaker AAnd now there's these stores that don't even have people working in them.
Speaker AAnd you just put stuff in the cart and the cameras watch you, and you walk out the door and it charges you.
Speaker AIt's just like, you walk in, you pick up your stuff and you leave.
Speaker AThere's no interactions and money is gone.
Speaker BIt's free.
Speaker BRight?
Speaker BIt's all free that way.
Speaker BSo that really takes a point of discussion.
Speaker BHow did we do this?
Speaker BDo you know how we did that?
Speaker BAnd so asking those questions at least gets them thinking that if it's not free, how did we walk out of the store?
Speaker BAnd we have all this food now.
Speaker BI mean, to actually do it is a bit frightening.
Speaker BI don't know if you've done it before, but the first time I did it was absolutely frightening.
Speaker BI just walked out of the store with everything I grabbed off the counter and nobody said anything.
Speaker ALooking around is like, oh, this feels wrong.
Speaker CHe's gonna chase me down the street.
Speaker BNo bells went off.
Speaker BAnd, but to.
Speaker BAnd I, I somewhat understand this, but to explain it to somebody that's smaller and younger is.
Speaker BIs very challenging.
Speaker BOr just.
Speaker AAnd then they have somebody grab something off of the shelf and run, and people chase him and try and get it back and put them in a light with flashy cars.
Speaker AAnd how come I can walk out of the store and they can.
Speaker BThat's exactly right.
Speaker BSo I show them the credit card statement, and there you go.
Speaker BIt shows that I actually walked out and paid for it.
Speaker BBut it just.
Speaker BIt takes that amount of time to explain those things to kids.
Speaker BAnd you're right, they don't understand it the first time, and that's great.
Speaker BOr the second or the third time, and we just keep at it.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CAnd the biggest thing I want to pull out of that discussion that we just had is parents ask your child where they think or why they think what Just happened.
Speaker CHappened.
Speaker CSo maybe it is walking out of the store.
Speaker CWhy were we able to take the stuff out of the store when we didn't really talk to anybody?
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CAsk that question.
Speaker CAsk that process.
Speaker CWhenever you're cooking something on the stove.
Speaker CWhy do you think that this part got hotter than this part?
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CYou're asking those questions with curiosity and seeing what they're thinking and then you're able to correct the misunderstanding as you're having those conversations.
Speaker CDon't just assume that they're absorbing it through osmosis because they were standing there beside you.
Speaker AThey are absorbing a lot through osmosis.
Speaker CA lot.
Speaker CAnd yes, point of discussions, right?
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BNot necessarily the correct answer.
Speaker BThe money flies through the air is the best experience explanation that I was able to come up with.
Speaker BBecause it does.
Speaker BIt flies from the bank and then of course it goes up to the satellite and back down.
Speaker BAnd they understand satellites these days, right?
Speaker BThey do.
Speaker BAnd it goes back down to the store and it misses me altogether.
Speaker BAnd that's somewhat the explanation that we have for kids.
Speaker BSomething they can understand and we can sort of explain and not look, you know, too stupid about.
Speaker BRight?
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ATalk about trust and honor in that as well.
Speaker CYeah, exactly.
Speaker AThose kind of.
Speaker AThose kind of stores can only exist in a trust and honor society where that is really high.
Speaker AIf you put that in somewhere where there's not trust and honor, then those stores get emptied really quick.
Speaker ASo.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker AAgain, it's situational as well, and societal and area.
Speaker AAnd there's all sorts of factors.
Speaker AAnd all of this is so individual and still needs to be.
Speaker ATalk to the kids and why it's like we are not all the same.
Speaker AThere's 6 billion people on this planet and every single one of them is different than every other one of them.
Speaker BThat's absolutely right.
Speaker BAnd even talking about money, we have to decide are they ready for this discussion or are we still on that discussion?
Speaker BAnd I think if we miss a few steps, then we have to go back and fix those as well.
Speaker BSo I have to start with the piggy bank and then I have to go to the list of things I want for presents and then I have to go to the next step of, well, you're.
Speaker BYou're working in the neighborhood, earning money.
Speaker BWhat do you.
Speaker BWhat do you want to use it for?
Speaker BSo that's the next step.
Speaker BAnd interesting.
Speaker BI get the answer of.
Speaker BYeah, I don't know.
Speaker BI haven't actually got anything in mind.
Speaker BWhich is an interesting answer.
Speaker CThen how do you save it?
Speaker COr how do you Donate it.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CBecause then we bring in the charity and helping other people as well.
Speaker BCorrect.
Speaker BBecause they have to do some work in the neighborhood for people who maybe won't pay them and learn what that feels like because it feels really good at the end of the day and realize that that was a really good thing to do.
Speaker BAnd there'll always be other people who will maybe pay them for those activities, but there's people that can't.
Speaker BAnd, and that works into the.
Speaker BHow else do you use your money rather than just spending it on yourself?
Speaker AAnd, and one of the things that we really try and talk about is about giving value or, or getting, getting the value out of the effort in the work, not out of the reward.
Speaker ASo the money at the end isn't the prize, isn't the cherry, the doing the work, the doing it right, the feelings you get.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker ABecause if you're going to do it, do it right, then the money becomes not the important thing, it's the work doing it right that you feel.
Speaker ASo.
Speaker ABecause if you're only doing it for money, then your life is going to go badly.
Speaker BAnd they, and they get that feeling when they do that.
Speaker BThat's why they don't really have anything they're, they're working towards.
Speaker BThey just discover.
Speaker BIt's just, it's just kind of a fun thing to do.
Speaker BYou know, pick up the leaves for the neighbors and shovel the snow.
Speaker BYou don't get to do much of that but shovel the snow for the neighbors.
Speaker AAnd then you get to build one of those things where the money just kind of keeps climbing and climbing and you just for the fun of it, not because it's money, but because that's right.
Speaker AIf you were collecting rocks, your rock collection would keep getting bigger.
Speaker AAnd you're collecting money, your money collection keeps getting bigger.
Speaker BExactly.
Speaker BBut so.
Speaker BAnd then they share it back with the family, which is also a very positive thing.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BIf they have that opportunity.
Speaker BSo it's, it's, it's a challenge, it's a work in process to watch all these kids and, and, and try and get the message out, which is what you're contributing to today.
Speaker CExactly.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CThis has been a great conversation.
Speaker CHave you, did you have anything written down that we haven't been able to share that you really wanted to share today?
Speaker AI usually talk about this.
Speaker AI always get to this point.
Speaker AOh, I didn't get there today.
Speaker AWhat is that?
Speaker BNo, I, I think what I wanted to share is that what we're trying to do with this book and the Next book is to distribute as many copies to as many people as we want as we can.
Speaker BSo today, for instance, we just got a grant for a housing, a low income housing community that has 800 residents.
Speaker BThey got 50 kids, we estimate under 8 years old, and they're all getting a book.
Speaker CAwesome.
Speaker BI know, I'm, I'm so excited about it.
Speaker BIt's in, it's in the state of Michigan.
Speaker BI don't care where it is.
Speaker BIt could be anywhere at all.
Speaker BAnd this book was, the first book was crowdfunded by people of like minds who simply wanted.
Speaker BThey bought 15 books each and distributed everywhere they could.
Speaker BBoys and girls clubs and whatever.
Speaker BAnd so.
Speaker BAnd the other, the one part I probably didn't talk about is for the little, little kids, the parents read the book and then they'll say, oh, I didn't know that.
Speaker BOh yeah, that's really good.
Speaker BAnd so parents who aren't terribly comfortable even talking about this by reading the book, they know this stuff, but they might not have been able to verbalize it quite or confidently even though they know all this stuff because they experience it every day, the frustrations and the anxieties and stress.
Speaker BAnd so by reading the book, the little kids learn about it and the, the bigger kids and the adults just grow confident.
Speaker BAnd so that's what we're trying to do with this book and, and the next one as well.
Speaker AYeah, because the words financial literacy, when you, when you hear those, it's like, oh, that's for rich people because poor people don't need it because they don't have any finances to be littered about.
Speaker AThat's the absolute wrong way to look at it.
Speaker CIt's everybody.
Speaker ASo going into the, into the disadvantaged neighborhoods, into the poorer neighborhoods and teaching them about financial literacy and how money works, that's, that's more important to, to society than teaching wealthy people how to do it better, teach poor people how to do it right in the first
Speaker Cand what you aspire towards.
Speaker CI will be able to save money.
Speaker CI will be able to do these kinds of things.
Speaker BYeah, absolutely.
Speaker BAnd to gain some, some personal confidence and.
Speaker BYeah, just know you can do whatever Billy did in the book and, and make everybody happy.
Speaker BAnd that's all we want to do, make some choices.
Speaker AAnd we're not saying that we got it right.
Speaker AWe did a lot wrong.
Speaker AWe banged around a lot.
Speaker AWe've blown so much money.
Speaker AWe're also entrepreneurs and you know, you always, you don't do it this way.
Speaker AWell, we did it that way and found out why not to do it that way.
Speaker ANot to do it.
Speaker ASo you know, we started with bad financial literacy and and we've proven that we had bad financial literacy and we've gotten somewhat stable.
Speaker AAnd so still, even at 55 years old, there are still because, because it was such a rough entry.
Speaker AThere's still things that we're learning.
Speaker BWe're always learning.
Speaker BAbsolutely.
Speaker BSo yeah.
Speaker CSo Grandma Deb, right now make sure you share.
Speaker CHow do people get a hold of you?
Speaker CHow do people get a hold of this book?
Speaker CSay the name of the book one more time for us also, please.
Speaker BBilly and the sweet surprise.
Speaker BAnd if they send me an email, I will send them coloring book from the book.
Speaker BColoring pages that come directly from the book.
Speaker BI'll just email and PDFs and they can download and color to their heart's content.
Speaker BAnd my email is just the first letter of my first name D and my last name R, E, C H, n I t z mail.com recknets that's it.
Speaker BThat's it.
Speaker CBeautiful.
Speaker CAnd of course all of that is down in the show notes and it's there for you.
Speaker CFamilies take advantage of this, right?
Speaker CEvery time one of our guests can comes on, they give value to you and strategies and tips as we're talking and then they always give or almost always give a gift at the end.
Speaker CConnect with these experts.
Speaker CLet them know that you that what they've given us is valuable and helpful to the family.
Speaker CBut also then take it and use it.
Speaker CRight?
Speaker CWe say don't just pick up the gold nuggets and put them in your pocket.
Speaker CPick up the gold nuggets and get them out and look at them and use them and help your family grow and be happy, healthy and successful.
Speaker CDeborah, thank you for joining us today.
Speaker CIt has been such a pleasure chatting with you and having these options and ideas for families to be able to, you know, get this discussion out there and really help their families.
Speaker CSo thank you so very, very much
Speaker Bfor being here today and thank you for having me.
Speaker BAppreciate it.
Speaker AAnd I would like to thank you as well.
Speaker ASo many people do have problems and with finances and so many people have tried and usually when they get successful like oh, buy my book on how to do finances and that's about it.
Speaker ABut you are actually reaching out to the younger children to and giving away books at times and trying to improve financial literacy where it counts instead of trying to make money on the big outside of it.
Speaker AAnd that is something that not a lot of people do and that makes you a hero.
Speaker AYou went out and you found a dragon.
Speaker AYou fought the dragon.
Speaker AYou got this information, you got your gold, and now you are bringing it back to the community and sharing it with the world.
Speaker AThat is the hero's journey.
Speaker AAnd thank you for stepping into it.
Speaker AThank you for jumping out front and being willing to lead because so many people aren't willing.
Speaker ASo thank you for being here today.
Speaker AAnd thank you.
Speaker BThank you, hero.
Speaker BThank you very much.
Speaker BTake care.
Speaker CAll right, audience, you know what to do.
Speaker CMake sure that you like, you review and you share, because every single one of these episodes at Bring the education home and is for you, the families, and to help you and all your children be happy, healthy and successful.
Speaker CUntil next time.
Speaker CBye for now.
Speaker AFor now.
Speaker BBye.