1 00:00:10,960 --> 00:00:15,944 It is quite a powerful thing to do. So, I do think it's worth 2 00:00:15,944 --> 00:00:20,216 deeply getting into it. And a quarterly basis is kind of about 3 00:00:20,216 --> 00:00:24,844 right, but it's quite helpful to frame it with a little bit of 4 00:00:24,844 --> 00:00:29,116 humility to kind of say, well look, we better understand what the 5 00:00:29,116 --> 00:00:31,964 consensus is and better acknowledge that's probably priced 6 00:00:31,964 --> 00:00:35,880 in and has quite a good chance of actually being right. So,you 7 00:00:12,878 --> 00:00:22,468 know, where do we actually have conviction in something that's 8 00:00:22,468 --> 00:00:31,099 differentiated from consensus is the question that everyone's got 9 00:00:31,099 --> 00:00:35,894 to answer really, isn't it? 10 00:00:38,060 --> 00:00:46,810 Imagine spending an hour with the world's greatest traders. Imagine 11 00:00:46,810 --> 00:00:52,935 learning from their experiences, their successes, and 12 00:00:52,935 --> 00:01:01,685 their failures. Imagine no more. Welcome to Top Traders Unplugged, 13 00:01:01,685 --> 00:01:12,185 the place where you can learn from the best hedge fund managers 14 00:01:12,185 --> 00:01:23,560 in the world so you can take your manager due diligence or investment 15 00:01:23,560 --> 00:01:27,935 career to the next level. Beforewe begin today's conversation, 16 00:00:41,475 --> 00:00:49,671 remember to keep two things in mind. All the discussion with have 17 00:00:49,671 --> 00:00:56,501 about investment performance is about the past and past performance 18 00:00:56,501 --> 00:01:03,331 does not guarantee or even infer anything about future performance. 19 00:01:03,331 --> 00:01:10,161 Also understand that there's a significant risk of financial loss 20 00:01:10,161 --> 00:01:17,674 with all investment strategies and you need to request and understand 21 00:01:17,674 --> 00:01:24,504 the specific risks from the investment manager about their products 22 00:01:24,504 --> 00:01:27,919 before you make investment decisions. Here'syour host, veteran 23 00:01:00,236 --> 00:01:27,956 hedge fund manager Niels Kaastrup-Larsen. 24 00:01:33,480 --> 00:01:37,280 Welcome and welcome back to another conversation in our series 25 00:01:37,280 --> 00:01:41,460 of episodes that focuses on markets and investing from a global 26 00:01:41,460 --> 00:01:46,020 macro perspective. This is a series that I not only find incredibly 27 00:01:46,020 --> 00:01:49,060 interesting as well as intellectually challenging, but also 28 00:01:49,060 --> 00:01:53,620 very important given where we are in the global economy and the 29 00:01:53,620 --> 00:01:58,560 geopolitical cycle. We want to dig deep into the minds of some of 30 00:01:58,560 --> 00:02:02,740 the most prominent experts to help us better understand what this 31 00:02:02,740 --> 00:02:06,920 new global macro-driven world may look like. We want to explore 32 00:02:06,920 --> 00:02:11,100 their perspectives on a host of game changing issues and hopefully 33 00:02:11,100 --> 00:02:14,520 dig out nuances in their work through meaningful conversations. 34 00:01:33,480 --> 00:02:14,560 Pleaseenjoy today's episode hosted by Alan Dunne. 35 00:02:17,920 --> 00:02:26,885 Thanks for that introduction, Niels. Today I'm joined by Dan Mikulskis. 36 00:02:26,885 --> 00:02:34,220 Dan is Chief Investment Officer at People's Partnership in 37 00:02:34,220 --> 00:02:43,185 the UK. It's one of the largest UK pension providers managing 38 00:02:43,185 --> 00:02:48,075 £40 billion in assets under management. Danhas been in the markets 39 00:02:23,242 --> 00:02:32,999 a number of years previously an extensive career as a consultant 40 00:02:32,999 --> 00:02:42,756 with Lane, Clark; and Peacock, Reddington and Mercer, and also experience 41 00:02:42,756 --> 00:02:48,078 in the sell side in trading. Dan,great to have you with us. How 42 00:02:39,856 --> 00:02:48,082 are you doing? 43 00:02:48,410 --> 00:02:51,140 Oh, great, Alan, thank you so much for having me. I'm really looking 44 00:02:51,140 --> 00:02:52,400 forward to the conversation. Thank you. 45 00:02:52,650 --> 00:02:57,030 Not at all. Great to have you, and I didn't mention, I am a reader 46 00:02:57,030 --> 00:02:59,366 of your LinkedIn blog. How often is that? 47 00:03:00,320 --> 00:03:03,890 Oh, it slips a little bit more recently. I used to do it every couple 48 00:03:03,890 --> 00:03:07,460 of weeks. Now it's more like once a month. I try and make it worth 49 00:03:07,460 --> 00:03:10,316 reading, so, when I've got enough good stuff to go into it, 50 00:03:10,316 --> 00:03:11,506 I try to publish one. 51 00:03:11,680 --> 00:03:14,870 Absolutely. We all start off very ambitiously thinking in terms 52 00:03:14,870 --> 00:03:19,017 of weekly or bi-weekly, and it does slip, but it's always an enjoyable 53 00:03:19,017 --> 00:03:23,164 read that covers a lot of topics, so I enjoy that. I mentioned 54 00:03:23,164 --> 00:03:26,354 your career trajectory a little bit in terms of background, 55 00:03:26,354 --> 00:03:30,501 in consulting, and we always like to start off by getting a sense 56 00:03:30,501 --> 00:03:34,329 on how people got interested in investing in markets in the first 57 00:03:34,329 --> 00:03:37,519 place. So, what got you interested in investing to start? 58 00:03:38,170 --> 00:03:58,390 Well, yeah, I suppose my career sort of started off on an 59 00:03:58,390 --> 00:04:16,925 actuarial route, really. I mean, yeah, most of my career, as 60 00:04:16,925 --> 00:04:35,460 you say, has been in consulting. I did have that little 61 00:04:35,460 --> 00:04:53,995 diversion when I moved to Australia and worked more in investment 62 00:04:53,995 --> 00:05:12,530 banking, and we can talk more about that if you like. ButI mean, 63 00:03:42,103 --> 00:03:57,835 most of my career has been in consulting and I studied actuarial 64 00:03:57,835 --> 00:04:13,567 qualification as a graduate. I was doing my master's degree at university, 65 00:04:13,567 --> 00:04:29,299 and did an actuarial science module there, and for my sins was 66 00:04:29,299 --> 00:04:47,653 quite drawn to it in terms of, I think, the sort of practical applications 67 00:04:47,653 --> 00:05:04,696 of some of the mathematics. And I was also quite drawn to the 68 00:05:04,696 --> 00:05:12,570 idea of doing a professional qualification. Imean,if I'd known 69 00:03:47,245 --> 00:04:10,840 how many sort of weekends in my early 20s I'd end up spending 70 00:04:10,840 --> 00:04:28,990 studying rather than going out, then I might have reconsidered 71 00:04:28,990 --> 00:04:52,585 that. But anyway, I considered it a bonus that you could study for 72 00:04:52,585 --> 00:05:12,550 a professional qualification. Sounds a bit mad to say that now. 73 00:03:38,170 --> 00:03:46,678 Butanyway, that was where things started off. I was sort of 74 00:03:46,678 --> 00:03:53,768 directed to the investment consulting side of those firms. And 75 00:03:53,768 --> 00:04:00,149 then actually, it's very interesting, the time period we're 76 00:04:00,149 --> 00:04:09,366 talking here was sort of early 2000s. It was almost in the early 77 00:04:09,366 --> 00:04:17,165 years really of investment consulting as a thing. I mean, that 78 00:04:17,165 --> 00:04:26,382 was sort of brought into being by the Pensions Act 1995. So, it 79 00:04:26,382 --> 00:04:34,181 was probably late ‘90s, early 2000s, that these firms were considering 80 00:04:34,181 --> 00:04:40,562 having an investment consulting sort of practice as separate 81 00:04:40,562 --> 00:04:48,361 from the sort of actuarial piece. So, they were reasonably well 82 00:04:48,361 --> 00:04:56,160 established at the time, they weren't brand new. But looking back 83 00:04:56,160 --> 00:05:06,795 now, it was still the kind of early years of that as a branch of 84 00:05:06,795 --> 00:05:12,467 the sort of actuarial genre, if you like. 85 00:05:13,050 --> 00:05:18,010 Interesting. And then over time, obviously, you've transitioned 86 00:05:18,010 --> 00:05:24,830 more from consulting into being a CIO. And that People's Partnership, 87 00:05:24,830 --> 00:05:31,650 it's obviously a business that has grown quite rapidly. I mentioned 88 00:05:31,650 --> 00:05:38,470 £40 billion in assets under management. I think when we chatted 89 00:05:38,470 --> 00:05:45,290 previously it was only £20 billion a year or two ago. Butit 90 00:05:14,948 --> 00:05:25,387 definitely would be helpful, I think, for our listeners just to 91 00:05:25,387 --> 00:05:35,826 give us a sense of what People's Partnership does and kind 92 00:05:35,826 --> 00:05:45,316 of the history behind, you know, its origin and evolution. 93 00:05:45,810 --> 00:06:12,702 Yeah, absolutely. I’d love to. I mean, I've been at People's Partnership 94 00:06:12,702 --> 00:06:41,835 for about two and a half years now and it's been fascinating learning 95 00:06:41,835 --> 00:07:04,245 some of the history of the organization, which, obviously, I've 96 00:07:04,245 --> 00:07:37,860 not been part of for most of its history. But it is a really interesting 97 00:07:37,860 --> 00:08:06,993 organization and, you know, I think it's a sort of a model that 98 00:08:06,993 --> 00:08:18,198 has a lot wider applicability. ButPeople's Partnership used to 99 00:05:53,750 --> 00:06:11,218 be known as B&CE, which stood for Buildings and Civil Engineering. 100 00:06:11,218 --> 00:06:25,510 And it was a sort of industries, multi-employer, kind 101 00:06:25,510 --> 00:06:42,978 of federated employer, trade union kind of roots, in terms of 102 00:06:42,978 --> 00:06:58,858 a group of employers in the construction sector coming together 103 00:06:58,858 --> 00:07:14,738 and creating an entity that could offer financial products to 104 00:07:14,738 --> 00:07:33,794 the workers, in that industry, on a profit for member basis, and 105 00:07:33,794 --> 00:07:44,910 effectively offer financial products to underserved communities, 106 00:07:44,910 --> 00:08:03,966 you might say, at that time. And the genesis of the organization 107 00:08:03,966 --> 00:08:18,258 was in the 1940s, so, quite a while ago. Andsort of the first 108 00:05:53,280 --> 00:06:08,220 products were holiday pay stamps which weren't common at the 109 00:06:08,220 --> 00:06:21,666 time. But then, over the decades, obviously, the construction 110 00:06:21,666 --> 00:06:38,100 industry, in the UK, grew massively. And various sorts of other 111 00:06:38,100 --> 00:06:54,534 products were offered; I think things like insurance and those sort 112 00:06:54,534 --> 00:07:10,968 of things, and culminating in a sort of a multi-employer stakeholder 113 00:07:10,968 --> 00:07:27,402 pension scheme. Which, then, sort of gave rise to the People's 114 00:07:27,402 --> 00:07:45,330 Pension. Which was sort of set up in response to auto enrollment 115 00:07:45,330 --> 00:08:01,764 in 2012, which is where regulations changed in the UK so 116 00:08:01,764 --> 00:08:18,198 that employers had to enroll all their staff into a scheme. Andbecause 117 00:05:49,874 --> 00:06:14,258 of the profit for member ethos, rather than a profit for shareholder 118 00:06:14,258 --> 00:06:36,610 type thing, the organization was able to offer that pension to 119 00:06:36,610 --> 00:06:56,930 organizations of all different sizes, from big employers down to 120 00:06:56,930 --> 00:07:19,282 the much smaller kind of SMEs - two three person organizations. 121 00:07:19,282 --> 00:07:45,698 And that, really, was key, I think, to our success in that we 122 00:07:45,698 --> 00:08:08,050 were able to bring on-board 100,000 employers that use us as 123 00:08:08,050 --> 00:08:18,210 their vehicle for auto enrollment. Andthat's led to a huge 124 00:06:11,214 --> 00:06:57,788 amount of members, a huge amount of people around the country 125 00:06:57,788 --> 00:07:40,128 paying into People's Pension every month, really, which has sort 126 00:07:40,128 --> 00:08:18,234 of compounded. These things compound over time, don't they? Whatthat 127 00:05:49,986 --> 00:06:15,042 has meant, over the last few years, is quite an astronomical growth, 128 00:06:15,042 --> 00:06:48,450 in terms of the AUM. As I say, I joined the business two and a half 129 00:06:48,450 --> 00:07:11,418 years ago. We'd just gone through £20 billion AUM and recently 130 00:07:11,418 --> 00:07:38,562 we just crossed £40. So that's just the last couple of years, really, 131 00:07:38,562 --> 00:08:03,618 in terms of the growth. And that sort of trajectory is what's 132 00:08:03,618 --> 00:08:18,234 going out into the future as well. 133 00:08:18,660 --> 00:08:22,701 Great. So about 100,000 employers, and how many ultimate 134 00:08:22,701 --> 00:08:24,497 members would you say? 135 00:08:24,740 --> 00:08:25,380 Seven million. 136 00:08:26,500 --> 00:08:26,980 Seven million, yeah. 137 00:08:26,980 --> 00:08:32,488 So, it's a huge proportion, and about 2 million of those are 138 00:08:32,488 --> 00:08:37,078 actively contributing every month. We have a lot of deferred 139 00:08:37,078 --> 00:08:42,586 members as well. That's partly because a lot of the employers that 140 00:08:42,586 --> 00:08:48,553 we service are in the sort of sectors of the economy like retail, 141 00:08:48,553 --> 00:08:52,225 hospitality, construction, where people might do contract work. 142 00:08:52,225 --> 00:08:57,274 So, three to six months contract, they pick up a pension 143 00:08:57,274 --> 00:09:02,323 with us and then they'll leave and go to another job. So,by the 144 00:08:29,392 --> 00:08:40,648 nature of the kind of segments of the economy, you end up with a 145 00:08:40,648 --> 00:08:49,492 lot of deferred members who have relatively small pots, and then 146 00:08:49,492 --> 00:08:59,140 you've got that core of the active members. So, 2 million kind 147 00:08:59,140 --> 00:09:02,356 of contributing every month. 148 00:09:03,100 --> 00:09:06,279 Great. And I mean, are there parallels to this model elsewhere 149 00:09:06,279 --> 00:09:10,036 or was it. I mean, obviously it has origins going back to the 150 00:09:10,036 --> 00:09:13,793 1940s. That's not a new idea. But we see auto enrollment has come 151 00:09:13,793 --> 00:09:18,128 in in the last decade or so. I mean, is it modeled on the Canadian 152 00:09:18,128 --> 00:09:21,596 model or models elsewhere or would you say it's more unique to 153 00:09:21,596 --> 00:09:22,174 the UK? 154 00:09:23,320 --> 00:09:31,438 Well, that's a very good question. I mean, it's very similar 155 00:09:31,438 --> 00:09:41,032 to how the Australian super funds are set up. So, there is Cbus, 156 00:09:41,032 --> 00:09:47,674 which is the construction industry super fund in Australia. 157 00:09:47,674 --> 00:09:56,530 You could view that as a pretty close cousin of us, really. 158 00:09:56,530 --> 00:10:05,386 And yeah, in Australia you've got a much bigger grouping of these 159 00:10:05,386 --> 00:10:12,028 industry super funds that came up around particular industries. 160 00:10:12,028 --> 00:10:19,408 Obviously, you've got Hostplus in the hospitality space, Rest in 161 00:10:19,408 --> 00:10:26,788 the retail space, and so forth. And they're operating the 162 00:10:26,788 --> 00:10:36,382 same kind of profit for member model. So, I think it's a little 163 00:10:36,382 --> 00:10:40,072 bit more common in Australia. Youalso see it a little bit in the 164 00:09:36,361 --> 00:09:55,198 Netherlands. So, some of the funds there are sort of on an industry 165 00:09:55,198 --> 00:10:12,586 basis. I forget the exact names now, but one of the larger 166 00:10:12,586 --> 00:10:27,076 ones there is a sort of healthcare industry fund, which, 167 00:10:27,076 --> 00:10:40,117 again, is set up on that kind of basis. So,yeah, it is models 168 00:09:28,375 --> 00:09:38,485 that you see elsewhere. Actually, it's maybe been a little 169 00:09:38,485 --> 00:09:50,617 bit underappreciated in the UK. I suppose you can view that auto 170 00:09:50,617 --> 00:10:02,749 enrollment was sort of grafted on top of the existing pensions landscape 171 00:10:02,749 --> 00:10:15,892 in the UK, which was mainly a commercial sort of retail sort of 172 00:10:15,892 --> 00:10:27,013 landscape, without necessarily a lot of thought being put into the 173 00:10:27,013 --> 00:10:39,145 nature of the institutions that were going to grow up out of 174 00:10:39,145 --> 00:10:40,156 that. 175 00:10:40,480 --> 00:10:44,992 Very good. So, I mean, in practical terms, you are a large, 176 00:10:44,992 --> 00:10:48,752 basically DC pension serving 7 million clients effectively. I guess 177 00:10:48,752 --> 00:10:54,016 that puts you in the category of asset owner. Is that fair to say? 178 00:10:54,016 --> 00:10:58,904 I know that's a term that we increasingly hear these days is the 179 00:10:58,904 --> 00:11:04,168 kind of the power of the asset owners and how they think about managing 180 00:11:04,168 --> 00:11:09,056 funds. I mean, does that shape your thinking in terms of how you 181 00:11:09,056 --> 00:11:12,064 organize the business and set your investment strategy? 182 00:11:12,620 --> 00:11:20,900 Yeah, absolutely. And that was my big kind of thing, I suppose, 183 00:11:20,900 --> 00:11:30,560 when I joined the business two and a half years ago was that we 184 00:11:30,560 --> 00:11:38,150 should consider ourselves to be an asset owner and should set 185 00:11:38,150 --> 00:11:45,050 ourselves up very deliberately with our asset ownership model at 186 00:11:45,050 --> 00:11:53,330 the forefront of our thinking. Now, that might sound like the most 187 00:11:53,330 --> 00:12:01,610 obvious sort of statement ever, but it is kind of not. Because 188 00:12:01,610 --> 00:12:10,580 where UK DC Trust came from, they came from, you know, they were 189 00:12:10,580 --> 00:12:18,170 sort of a startup in some ways. They're starting from ground 190 00:12:18,170 --> 00:12:26,450 zero in terms of assets. And obviously, when you do that, you 191 00:12:26,450 --> 00:12:34,040 have to set yourself up with the most efficient, cost effective, 192 00:12:34,040 --> 00:12:40,250 cheapest, simplest model you can, for very understandable reasons. 193 00:12:40,250 --> 00:12:48,530 So, UK DC grew, from necessity, out of a very basic approach 194 00:12:48,530 --> 00:12:55,430 to asset ownership, which was basically, you know, passive pooled 195 00:12:55,430 --> 00:13:02,330 funds, single provider. And, to be honest, that worked really 196 00:13:02,330 --> 00:13:11,300 well. I mean, passive has done pretty damn well for the last 10, 197 00:13:11,300 --> 00:13:12,680 15 years. So,you know, good investment outcomes, good value for 198 00:11:27,434 --> 00:11:47,186 money, you know, cheap to oversight - what's not to like sort 199 00:11:47,186 --> 00:12:08,584 of thing. And so, certainly, that has got us pretty far. But my 200 00:12:08,584 --> 00:12:33,274 view was, at £20 billion, it was time to sort of move on and grow 201 00:12:33,274 --> 00:12:54,672 up that model. And, certainly, at £40 billion, I think you can and 202 00:12:54,672 --> 00:13:12,778 should have a bit of a different approach to asset ownership. 203 00:11:12,620 --> 00:11:30,011 Andthere are a variety of approaches to asset ownership model 204 00:11:30,011 --> 00:11:48,983 actually. And, I guess, part of my point was your decisions around 205 00:11:48,983 --> 00:12:07,955 your asset ownership model are kind of upstream from all your other 206 00:12:07,955 --> 00:12:26,927 investment decisions. You can talk about, do you want to be in 207 00:12:26,927 --> 00:12:41,156 US equities, private equities, emerging markets, private debt, infrastructure, 208 00:12:41,156 --> 00:13:00,128 what have you. Upstream from all of that is your ownership model 209 00:13:00,128 --> 00:13:12,776 and how you want to set yourself up. So,I suppose my thing 210 00:11:24,405 --> 00:11:52,689 is that you ought to spend some time thinking about that and 211 00:11:52,689 --> 00:12:18,616 kind of getting that right first before you start trying to 212 00:12:18,616 --> 00:12:46,900 grab all the nice shiny things and talk about your latest ideas, 213 00:12:46,900 --> 00:13:12,827 whether you want to be long, this, that or the other. 214 00:13:13,560 --> 00:13:17,070 Yeah, and I mean, so, what are some of the kind of considerations 215 00:13:17,070 --> 00:13:20,580 that you have to think about when you're in that setup phase or, 216 00:13:20,580 --> 00:13:23,550 you know, what are the different routes you could go down 217 00:13:23,550 --> 00:13:24,360 that you've considered? 218 00:13:24,920 --> 00:13:38,609 I think the first one was team. That was the first sort of 219 00:13:38,609 --> 00:13:54,404 key plank of it. I mean, we sort of took it down to about four 220 00:13:54,404 --> 00:14:05,987 or five different pillars there, but the team was one, partnerships 221 00:14:05,987 --> 00:14:14,411 was another, segregated mandate, sort of direct ownership 222 00:14:14,411 --> 00:14:23,888 was another, systems was another one, and governance being 223 00:14:23,888 --> 00:14:37,577 another one. So those are the kind of main areas that you have 224 00:14:37,577 --> 00:14:52,319 got to consider and you have got to decide where you sort of land 225 00:14:52,319 --> 00:14:54,425 on it. Butyeah, team has to come before everything. And I, sort 226 00:13:46,810 --> 00:14:08,700 of, my viewers, we wanted a pretty specialized kind of senior, 227 00:14:08,700 --> 00:14:26,610 seasoned investing team that could have specialists across all 228 00:14:26,610 --> 00:14:54,470 areas, but we wanted that team to stay pretty kind of lean and focused. 229 00:13:24,920 --> 00:13:37,229 So,we're at about 30 individuals at the moment, 30 people 230 00:13:37,229 --> 00:13:49,538 full-time on the investment team, which is a lovely number because 231 00:13:49,538 --> 00:14:05,204 we can get all of us in a large conference room, which we do 232 00:14:05,204 --> 00:14:20,870 that twice a week and just get all on the same page. It's really, 233 00:14:20,870 --> 00:14:33,179 really nice. So, we'll probably grow a little bit from that. 234 00:14:33,179 --> 00:14:49,964 But that kind of 30 to 50 number I just think is a real sweet 235 00:14:49,964 --> 00:14:54,440 spot for a team. Andobviously the asset management is an outsourced 236 00:13:32,968 --> 00:13:43,028 model, and we're deliberately, as part of our philosophy, relying 237 00:13:43,028 --> 00:13:54,094 really heavily on those managers to get a lot of resource 238 00:13:54,094 --> 00:14:09,184 out of them and do a lot of the work that, in a different world, 239 00:14:09,184 --> 00:14:23,268 we might have a large team of analysts set up to do, but we're 240 00:14:23,268 --> 00:14:36,346 trying to run it sort of very efficiently, if you like, with that 241 00:14:36,346 --> 00:14:46,406 relatively focused team of kind of senior investors. So that 242 00:14:46,406 --> 00:14:54,454 was the starting point, getting the team right. 243 00:14:55,210 --> 00:14:59,900 And, I mean, obviously, as you say, a key element to it. I mean, 244 00:14:59,900 --> 00:15:04,255 what's the kind of attraction or the pros and cons of working in 245 00:15:04,255 --> 00:15:08,945 a kind of a large asset owner in this space? You know, in terms 246 00:15:08,945 --> 00:15:12,965 of, is that an attractive place to go, are you finding, for 247 00:15:12,965 --> 00:15:16,985 investors? Or does it attract a certain type of person or what 248 00:15:16,985 --> 00:15:18,660 would you say about that? 249 00:15:19,630 --> 00:15:29,123 Yeah, absolutely, it is an attractive place to work. He says, 250 00:15:29,123 --> 00:15:36,890 extremely self servingly. Obviously, you know, I've seen, our 251 00:15:36,890 --> 00:15:47,246 profile has changed massively over the last two, two and a half 252 00:15:47,246 --> 00:15:57,602 years and we've, yeah, I think we've really put ourselves on the 253 00:15:57,602 --> 00:16:06,232 map. We had a fantastic advertising campaign back end of 254 00:16:06,232 --> 00:16:17,451 last year, that I think I can't take any credit for. I wasn't 255 00:16:17,451 --> 00:16:20,040 involved in that. Butthat's really put ourselves on the map as 256 00:15:31,996 --> 00:15:49,858 well as just the growth and some of the headlines. So, a lot 257 00:15:49,858 --> 00:16:09,094 of things have come together to make it just, I think, a far more 258 00:16:09,094 --> 00:16:20,086 well-known proposition now, and therefore far more attractive. 259 00:15:19,630 --> 00:15:28,254 WhenI joined the business there was a bit of a sense of gosh, 260 00:15:28,254 --> 00:15:35,030 wow, these people seem really big, but I've never really heard 261 00:15:35,030 --> 00:15:42,422 of them. Is it actually real? What are they actually doing, kind 262 00:15:42,422 --> 00:15:49,814 of thing? And we're well past that now. Certainly, when we talk 263 00:15:49,814 --> 00:15:57,206 to asset managers, everyone knows who we are, and gets it, and 264 00:15:57,206 --> 00:16:03,982 gets the growth. And when you're talking to people who might 265 00:16:03,982 --> 00:16:11,374 want to come onto the team, it's the same now. They've really 266 00:16:11,374 --> 00:16:19,998 kind of seen that. So, that's changed a lot over the last two years. 267 00:16:20,410 --> 00:16:24,226 Yeah, and obviously what comes with size and scale is more clout 268 00:16:24,226 --> 00:16:28,042 and, I guess, more flexibility as you say, more recognition in the 269 00:16:28,042 --> 00:16:31,540 market. I mean, obviously, you can see the ability to negotiate 270 00:16:31,540 --> 00:16:35,674 on things like fees, I guess. I mean outside of that, what else 271 00:16:35,674 --> 00:16:38,218 is that kind of size and scale bring? 272 00:16:39,350 --> 00:16:51,170 I think, yeah, the ability to negotiate with managers is a big 273 00:16:51,170 --> 00:17:03,975 unlock for quite a lot of things. It's not just, ‘give me cheaper 274 00:17:03,975 --> 00:17:15,795 fees’, although that is obviously a part of it. It's a lot 275 00:17:15,795 --> 00:17:28,600 of other things as well. It's about how bespoke you can get the 276 00:17:28,600 --> 00:17:41,405 structuring on the fees. It's not just, ‘give me the fund for slightly 277 00:17:41,405 --> 00:17:53,225 cheaper’, it’s, ‘can we talk about some kind of SMA where the 278 00:17:53,225 --> 00:18:04,060 whole structuring of the fees is completely bespoke to what we 279 00:18:04,060 --> 00:18:16,865 want’. And that takes a lot of time, and effort, and focus from 280 00:18:16,865 --> 00:18:29,670 a manager to deliver that. So, you need the bigger size to kind 281 00:18:29,670 --> 00:18:34,595 of get them interested there. Butyeah, you also get a lot of access 282 00:16:55,307 --> 00:17:16,583 to other sorts of areas that the managers can deliver. So, doing 283 00:17:16,583 --> 00:17:32,540 research projects, getting insights in strategy and macro, even 284 00:17:32,540 --> 00:17:52,043 collaborating with managers on policy work, We have a huge number 285 00:17:52,043 --> 00:18:13,319 of touch points with the managers that we work with and people, 286 00:18:13,319 --> 00:18:34,595 throughout their business, give us a lot of their time and effort. 287 00:16:39,350 --> 00:18:34,610 Ithinkthat's partly because we have big mandates with them that 288 00:17:11,510 --> 00:17:46,350 are growing fast and they see the value in kind of investing in 289 00:17:46,350 --> 00:18:23,870 that relationship as well. So, I think, yes, you can get a lot of 290 00:18:23,870 --> 00:18:34,590 value out of it. Anotherpoint to make is on systems. So, with the 291 00:16:52,590 --> 00:17:07,154 managers we've worked with, we have kind of developed and delivered 292 00:17:07,154 --> 00:17:21,718 systems and portals. So, we have various views into the portfolios 293 00:17:21,718 --> 00:17:38,930 that they run for us, which is just really helpful from our perspective. 294 00:17:38,930 --> 00:17:56,142 It makes it so much more efficient and easier to stay on top 295 00:17:56,142 --> 00:18:10,706 of those portfolios given a larger proportion of our assets is 296 00:18:10,706 --> 00:18:29,242 with the manager. And then we have a system that can give us a 297 00:18:29,242 --> 00:18:34,538 direct view into it. It'sa really nice setup. Much easier than 298 00:17:10,086 --> 00:17:48,506 if we had 10 dozen managers, and trafficking Excel spreadsheets 299 00:17:48,506 --> 00:18:34,610 back and forth, sort of thing, to get a sense of it. 300 00:18:34,850 --> 00:18:38,594 Yeah, and obviously, I guess, as well, what comes with size is 301 00:18:38,594 --> 00:18:41,714 the possibility of running strategies in house. So, I guess 302 00:18:41,714 --> 00:18:44,834 if you have sufficient assets it can become commercially feasible 303 00:18:44,834 --> 00:18:48,890 or plausible to run in house as opposed to going out to market. 304 00:18:48,890 --> 00:18:52,634 How do you think about that? Is that something that could become 305 00:18:52,634 --> 00:18:56,378 even more of a consideration if assets grow again more or not? 306 00:18:56,378 --> 00:18:59,186 Or are you very much in the outsource model? 307 00:19:00,050 --> 00:19:30,652 I mean, it's a road that some large global asset owners have gone 308 00:19:30,652 --> 00:20:01,254 down. You know, I spent a bit time in Australia talking to the 309 00:20:01,254 --> 00:20:34,210 Aussie super funds, and a lot of them have decided to go down that 310 00:20:34,210 --> 00:21:00,104 model where they look to insource a proportion of the asset 311 00:21:00,104 --> 00:21:23,644 management. I think there are typically, sort of, three reasons 312 00:21:23,644 --> 00:21:54,246 why people do that. One is cost. But that's not the only one. 313 00:21:54,246 --> 00:22:17,786 I think it's cost, probably control, and then alignment. And 314 00:22:17,786 --> 00:22:46,034 I think it's sort of, yeah, I think some combination of those, 315 00:22:46,034 --> 00:22:57,820 really, are coming into play. Ithinkpeople don't want to give 316 00:19:26,055 --> 00:20:06,920 the impression it's just a cost thing because that can sound 317 00:20:06,920 --> 00:20:55,215 a little bit, I don't know, a little bit kind of excessively kind 318 00:20:55,215 --> 00:21:36,080 of capitalistic about it, I suppose. But the cost thing, that 319 00:21:36,080 --> 00:22:20,660 depends a lot on what your current baseline is, in terms of 320 00:22:20,660 --> 00:22:57,810 the fees you're paying. And that baseline varies a lot. So,yeah, 321 00:19:06,390 --> 00:19:41,260 if you're paying decent fees, active management, then I can see 322 00:19:41,260 --> 00:20:22,470 why there'd be a big saving. But equally, if you've got your fees 323 00:20:22,470 --> 00:21:00,510 baselined in an already pretty low level, the cost one might not 324 00:21:00,510 --> 00:21:35,380 actually be as big as you think, in listed markets, certainly. 325 00:21:35,380 --> 00:22:13,420 So that's an interesting one to explore. That varies a lot whether 326 00:22:13,420 --> 00:22:51,460 that's a good trade-off or not. And the other ones are equally 327 00:22:51,460 --> 00:22:57,800 as interesting. So,alignment is a key one because, you know, these 328 00:19:36,070 --> 00:20:04,886 principal agent issues, they're really real in investing. 329 00:20:04,886 --> 00:20:44,508 And, you know, I've often talked before about, you get this 330 00:20:44,508 --> 00:21:20,528 sort of traditional view of investing where an investor owns 331 00:21:20,528 --> 00:22:07,354 stocks in companies, and it's as simple as that. And then the investor 332 00:22:07,354 --> 00:22:43,374 makes all the decisions, you know, about asset classes, sectors, 333 00:22:43,374 --> 00:22:57,782 buy, sell, all that. Whereasin practice, there is quite 334 00:19:11,840 --> 00:19:33,455 an elongated chain of providers and so forth, in the mix. 335 00:19:33,455 --> 00:19:57,035 In some cases you might have something like, you know, a trustee, 336 00:19:57,035 --> 00:20:18,650 a consultant, a provider, a platform, a manager, an index provider, 337 00:20:18,650 --> 00:20:36,335 all sitting between an investor and what they're investing 338 00:20:36,335 --> 00:20:57,950 in. You could easily have seven or eight layers between. And 339 00:20:57,950 --> 00:21:19,565 when you’ve got a chain like that, the principal agent problems 340 00:21:19,565 --> 00:21:47,075 at each link in the chain can really mount up and can really end 341 00:21:47,075 --> 00:22:08,690 up meaning that some things aren't actually being done in the 342 00:22:08,690 --> 00:22:36,200 interests of the end saver, at the end of the day. So, getting alignment 343 00:22:36,200 --> 00:22:55,850 in that chain is really important and collapsing down that 344 00:22:55,850 --> 00:22:57,815 chain. So,I thought about that. I think asset owners can collapse 345 00:19:45,139 --> 00:20:34,327 the chain down a little bit by having direct control in segregated 346 00:20:34,327 --> 00:21:19,416 mandates and bringing some of that decision making in house. There 347 00:21:19,416 --> 00:21:56,307 is the thinking that in-housing asset management is kind 348 00:21:56,307 --> 00:22:33,198 of the ultimate alignment because you're doing it internally, 349 00:22:33,198 --> 00:22:57,792 and I would say yes, probably. ButI think it is also possible to 350 00:19:23,530 --> 00:19:49,945 really work hard on the alignment with external managers 351 00:19:49,945 --> 00:20:31,035 as well. And that has, up to now, been our focus, to be honest 352 00:20:31,035 --> 00:21:09,190 with you, is trying to say, can we really rethink the way we're 353 00:21:09,190 --> 00:21:35,605 allocating these assets, how we're choosing our managers, really, 354 00:21:35,605 --> 00:22:07,890 really get max alignment? We can with an external manager. And 355 00:22:07,890 --> 00:22:46,045 I think you could go quite far there actually. You really can, if 356 00:22:46,045 --> 00:22:57,785 you do that right. Youknow, it's a very different situation than 357 00:19:37,346 --> 00:20:33,290 allocating to a pooled fund and a manager versus sort of crafting 358 00:20:33,290 --> 00:21:24,572 an SMA with a manager that's just deeply, deeply aligned with 359 00:21:24,572 --> 00:22:29,840 you in so many different kinds of ways. So yeah, I think the insource 360 00:22:29,840 --> 00:22:57,812 versus outsource is an interesting discussion. Yeah,we're 361 00:19:06,654 --> 00:19:42,976 more focused on an outsourced model over the current planning horizon. 362 00:19:42,976 --> 00:20:25,902 And I think, when you chisel away at them, some of the benefits 363 00:20:25,902 --> 00:21:05,526 of insourcing are not always as big as might be perceived because 364 00:21:05,526 --> 00:21:55,056 you can bear down a lot on the costs and you can actually do more 365 00:21:55,056 --> 00:22:31,378 on alignment than you think. So, you shouldn't sort of knee-jerk 366 00:22:31,378 --> 00:22:57,794 think that it's all about bringing it internal. 367 00:22:59,371 --> 00:23:03,999 Yeah, interesting. I mean, you touched a lot on the kind of external 368 00:23:03,999 --> 00:23:07,559 managers, it being very much a partnership. Obviously, when you 369 00:23:07,559 --> 00:23:11,831 have such a large amount of assets, all asset managers are presumably 370 00:23:11,831 --> 00:23:16,103 queuing up outside to do business. So, there's a lot of choice. 371 00:23:16,103 --> 00:23:20,375 How do you think about, you know, going from that global universe 372 00:23:20,375 --> 00:23:24,291 of managers down to a more manageable, you know, shortlist to 373 00:23:24,291 --> 00:23:24,647 consider? 374 00:23:25,641 --> 00:24:05,673 Yeah, that’s a fantastic question. We've been through that 375 00:24:05,673 --> 00:24:54,601 process now about four times and yeah, obviously, the big ones 376 00:24:54,601 --> 00:25:43,529 there, that got announced last year, where we appointed Amundi to 377 00:25:43,529 --> 00:26:19,113 manage, develop market equities; Invesco on fixed income; 378 00:26:19,113 --> 00:27:08,041 and Rubico on emerging market equities. All of those were quite 379 00:27:08,041 --> 00:27:16,937 lengthy processes. Partof that process (probably familiar to 380 00:23:58,023 --> 00:24:44,283 anyone who's done a manager selection piece), there's some common 381 00:24:44,283 --> 00:25:39,795 elements to it. You want to have some kind of starting point 382 00:25:39,795 --> 00:26:44,559 in terms of a universe tool. You know, we use the likes of investment 383 00:26:44,559 --> 00:27:16,941 on the liquid side, global fund search. Youneed somewhere to 384 00:23:33,757 --> 00:23:56,076 start with the universe. You need some basic kind of screening 385 00:23:56,076 --> 00:24:22,453 to get you down to a sort of fairly large but manageable number. 386 00:24:22,453 --> 00:24:44,772 So, 20 odd, something like that. And then we would typically 387 00:24:44,772 --> 00:25:11,149 do a kind of model portfolio sort of exercise with the 20 odd, 388 00:25:11,149 --> 00:25:39,555 and then look to cut that down to a sort of shorter list, ultimately 389 00:25:39,555 --> 00:26:07,961 getting down to a short list of about 6 to 10 managers. Then you're 390 00:26:07,961 --> 00:26:28,251 going really deep with the multiple meetings over the course 391 00:26:28,251 --> 00:26:56,657 of a long period of time. And yeah, we come up with a balanced 392 00:26:56,657 --> 00:27:16,947 scorecard and score them, and all sorts of things there. Butend 393 00:23:29,561 --> 00:23:55,041 to end, that process, for us, has taken us about nine months. And 394 00:23:55,041 --> 00:24:18,561 yeah, you learn a lot about the managers over that period of 395 00:24:18,561 --> 00:24:38,161 time. It's really interesting. That's where the kind of partnership 396 00:24:38,161 --> 00:24:57,761 bit really comes through because that's not so much about 397 00:24:57,761 --> 00:25:27,161 ticking boxes, but you do just learn a lot by how they show up in 398 00:25:27,161 --> 00:25:46,761 every single interaction. You know, are the people briefed? Do 399 00:25:46,761 --> 00:26:10,281 the people understand what you want the whole time? Is there consistency 400 00:26:10,281 --> 00:26:29,881 in terms of who you're speaking to, what's being talked 401 00:26:29,881 --> 00:26:51,441 about? And that doesn't come through on a one-off meeting, obviously, 402 00:26:51,441 --> 00:27:16,921 but over a nine month period of time it sort of comes through. 403 00:23:25,641 --> 00:24:10,991 Andobviously the managers, I just sort of mentioned, generate 404 00:24:10,991 --> 00:24:56,341 the larger end of the spectrum. Obviously, Amundi and Invesco, 405 00:24:56,341 --> 00:25:46,226 probably both are in the largest 20 managers in the world 406 00:25:46,226 --> 00:26:31,576 kind of thing. So, we're talking big organizations here. All 407 00:26:31,576 --> 00:27:16,926 the managers we were talking to there were big organizations. 408 00:23:25,641 --> 00:23:53,474 Andthat, that comes with its pros and cons, doesn't it? Big organization 409 00:23:53,474 --> 00:24:17,025 means you've got loads of cool stuff, but big organization means 410 00:24:17,025 --> 00:24:44,858 it's big and it just can be tricky to navigate. So, seeing how 411 00:24:44,858 --> 00:25:06,268 our key relationship point person navigated that for us, over 412 00:25:06,268 --> 00:25:31,960 the period of time we were assessing them, was also quite important. 413 00:25:31,960 --> 00:25:53,370 And then the role of that relationship point person became 414 00:25:53,370 --> 00:26:19,062 really key over that period of time. And so, understanding how they 415 00:26:19,062 --> 00:26:40,472 operated, seeing how effective they were at getting the resources 416 00:26:40,472 --> 00:27:04,023 of the organization and bringing it to bear, was quite interesting 417 00:27:04,023 --> 00:27:16,869 and quite a big differentiator, actually. Yeah,I 418 00:23:30,409 --> 00:23:59,017 just think some managers that have done that well, some have sort 419 00:23:59,017 --> 00:24:30,009 of underappreciated maybe that side of it. And I get why. I guess, 420 00:24:30,009 --> 00:25:03,385 as I've been a consultant for a while, I think there was a time 421 00:25:03,385 --> 00:25:31,993 there when it was very much a product-led sort of marketplace where 422 00:25:31,993 --> 00:25:58,217 consultants were very focused on, give us your best product, give 423 00:25:58,217 --> 00:26:24,441 us your best product in this category, your best global active 424 00:26:24,441 --> 00:26:45,897 bond fund, your best multifactor equity fund. And this 425 00:26:45,897 --> 00:27:09,737 wasn't particularly a focus on the relationship and extracting the 426 00:27:09,737 --> 00:27:16,889 value from that. ButI think things are shifting there with more 427 00:23:47,322 --> 00:24:11,412 bigger asset owners and the partnerships being able to deliver 428 00:24:11,412 --> 00:24:40,320 those relationships, I think, is a real, real skill. And it's brilliant 429 00:24:40,320 --> 00:25:14,046 when it's done well, it really is. And there's quite a lot of dispersion 430 00:25:14,046 --> 00:25:42,954 across the industry in terms of how effectively that can be delivered. 431 00:25:42,954 --> 00:26:14,271 And yeah, as I say, you don't discover that in a one-off meeting 432 00:26:14,271 --> 00:26:40,770 because everyone looks great in a one-off. It's the nine months 433 00:26:40,770 --> 00:27:09,678 of interaction and the back and forth that sort of reveals that, 434 00:27:09,678 --> 00:27:16,905 to some extent. 435 00:27:17,371 --> 00:27:21,847 Yeah, interesting. I mean, I guess most or all large asset managers 436 00:27:21,847 --> 00:27:24,831 would talk about their solutions capability and, internally, 437 00:27:24,831 --> 00:27:29,307 we talk in terms of kind of consultative sales, but it sounds 438 00:27:29,307 --> 00:27:33,410 like there are quite notable differences in how good but they 439 00:27:33,410 --> 00:27:35,648 are delivering that. Is that it? 440 00:27:35,931 --> 00:27:40,931 Yeah, that's been our experience for sure. And yeah, it 441 00:27:40,931 --> 00:27:45,931 certainly depends on the individuals that you've got and how 442 00:27:45,931 --> 00:27:52,431 that sort of process works. It also reflected a little bit of the 443 00:27:52,431 --> 00:27:57,931 culture of the managers, I think, a little bit. Again, when 444 00:27:57,931 --> 00:28:05,431 you go through a long process, you do sort of get a sense of the 445 00:28:05,431 --> 00:28:10,431 culture, how flat is the culture, is it hierarchical, how 446 00:28:10,431 --> 00:28:14,931 sort of clunky and bureaucratic is it internally to 447 00:28:14,931 --> 00:28:20,931 get things done? These are things where I think it's very tempting, 448 00:28:20,931 --> 00:28:26,431 as a manager, to feel like your internal kind of inefficiencies 449 00:28:26,431 --> 00:28:31,431 are somehow invisible, but they absolutely do, over a period 450 00:28:31,431 --> 00:28:33,931 of time they come through. Andas a client you can sort of sense 451 00:27:42,222 --> 00:27:50,610 if it's really clunky going from one side of the business to 452 00:27:50,610 --> 00:28:00,396 the other, or in trying to go from one office to another, or from 453 00:28:00,396 --> 00:28:07,386 one function to another. Whereas, other ones who are flatter, 454 00:28:07,386 --> 00:28:16,473 or have a more open culture, or whatever, can make that a little 455 00:28:16,473 --> 00:28:24,861 bit easier. So yeah, I think there's a whole load of considerations 456 00:28:24,861 --> 00:28:33,948 there that are worth focusing on and perhaps have been a bit underappreciated. 457 00:28:34,291 --> 00:28:37,844 Yeah, I mean, there is that kind of trade-off between building 458 00:28:37,844 --> 00:28:41,074 deeper relationships with a smaller number of managers, and keeping 459 00:28:41,074 --> 00:28:44,304 the kind of the perspective broader, and considering lots of 460 00:28:44,304 --> 00:28:48,180 managers all the time. How do you think about that trade-off for 461 00:28:48,180 --> 00:28:51,733 what is the kind of correct number of relationships you want 462 00:28:51,733 --> 00:28:55,609 to maintain? I mean, could you use one asset manager across multiple 463 00:28:55,609 --> 00:28:59,162 asset classes or not? Or how do you think about that? 464 00:28:59,591 --> 00:29:14,036 Yeah, we've been constantly debating that, honestly, where the 465 00:29:14,036 --> 00:29:34,901 right thing is there. I sort of had this quite strong view that 466 00:29:34,901 --> 00:29:52,556 the right number of manager relationships is less than most asset 467 00:29:52,556 --> 00:30:08,606 owners have, basically. And yeah, it was pretty common, like 468 00:30:08,606 --> 00:30:27,866 in the UK, even a modestly sized asset owner could easily have 469 00:30:27,866 --> 00:30:43,916 two dozen managers on the roster. That happens very frequently. 470 00:30:43,916 --> 00:30:53,546 I do think that's too many. Butwe started to have those conversations 471 00:29:10,518 --> 00:29:30,811 around that there is a limit to that. There are some areas we're 472 00:29:30,811 --> 00:29:47,982 looking at where I've become convinced that you do lose something 473 00:29:47,982 --> 00:30:06,714 if you're trying to get a manager to stretch over too many 474 00:30:06,714 --> 00:30:20,763 different areas. And also, yeah, what about boutique managers? 475 00:30:20,763 --> 00:30:36,373 Smaller managers have something to offer and you sort of 476 00:30:36,373 --> 00:30:53,544 struggle to fit them into the sort of thing I've described. Soyeah, 477 00:29:01,459 --> 00:29:09,865 we're starting to develop approaches to saying, well, okay, 478 00:29:09,865 --> 00:29:20,139 this is our core number of really core partnerships. And that 479 00:29:20,139 --> 00:29:31,347 number, I think, might be quite small. I can see that maybe 480 00:29:31,347 --> 00:29:42,555 never being above maybe half a dozen kind of really, really core… 481 00:29:42,555 --> 00:29:53,763 because we have to invest in those as well. We absolutely need 482 00:29:53,763 --> 00:30:08,707 to spend a lot of time. People on my team will be talking on a daily 483 00:30:08,707 --> 00:30:18,047 basis to some of these managers. We have these structures 484 00:30:18,047 --> 00:30:29,255 set up for all the meetings that we're holding with them over 485 00:30:29,255 --> 00:30:42,331 an entire year. We kind of set that all up. So, we absolutely need 486 00:30:42,331 --> 00:30:53,539 to invest outside, and you can't do that with a big number. 487 00:28:59,591 --> 00:29:19,703 Butthen there's a second question of, can we find ways of 488 00:29:19,703 --> 00:29:33,111 slotting in smaller, more specialist allocations into that 489 00:29:33,111 --> 00:29:48,195 without breaking the model, which is something we're looking 490 00:29:48,195 --> 00:30:08,307 into at the moment, some really sort of exciting kind of operational, 491 00:30:08,307 --> 00:30:23,391 potentially ideas, some ways of delivering slightly more specialist 492 00:30:23,391 --> 00:30:41,827 managers in a way that still preserves some of those efficiencies 493 00:30:41,827 --> 00:30:53,559 and doesn't kind of break that model. Because,yeah, you're right, 494 00:29:17,123 --> 00:30:00,953 even big managers can't do everything. There's some really good 495 00:30:00,953 --> 00:30:53,549 stuff that you can go to if you can access the specialists. 496 00:30:53,811 --> 00:30:57,161 Yeah, and I mean, you're talking about partnerships. So, presumably 497 00:30:57,161 --> 00:31:00,176 they're providing more than just, obviously, running a portfolio 498 00:31:00,176 --> 00:31:03,191 in the segregated mandate. It's, I suppose, research assistance 499 00:31:03,191 --> 00:31:07,211 or bespoke projects, things like that, is that part of the value 500 00:31:07,211 --> 00:31:07,546 added? 501 00:31:08,421 --> 00:31:13,581 Yeah, absolutely. And one example we used a lot early on, when 502 00:31:13,581 --> 00:31:20,031 we were talking to them to try and bring it to life was that this 503 00:31:20,031 --> 00:31:25,191 question of macro insights, if you like, as a general thing. And 504 00:31:25,191 --> 00:31:30,781 the sense that… Obviously I can say to any manager, can I get 505 00:31:30,781 --> 00:31:35,511 a call with your chief macro strategist? Everyone will say yes, 506 00:31:35,511 --> 00:31:40,241 and then there'll be a bunch of emails backwards and forwards 507 00:31:40,241 --> 00:31:46,261 trying to find a time, that will go in the diary, in, like, four 508 00:31:46,261 --> 00:31:51,851 weeks time. We'll both dial into the meeting. I'll be a bit of 509 00:31:51,851 --> 00:31:57,011 a, well, why are we here again? And then they'll slot into 510 00:31:57,011 --> 00:32:02,171 their usual kind of patter, which they've done a load of times, 511 00:32:02,171 --> 00:32:07,331 and they’ll be very good. But, you know, probably on average, 50% 512 00:32:07,331 --> 00:32:13,351 of it will be relevant to me and 50% won’t, and that’s it. And 513 00:32:13,351 --> 00:32:18,081 then it'll be a lovely meeting. We'll say, thanks very much, 514 00:32:18,081 --> 00:32:23,241 close the meeting, and that'll be it. That's one version of it. 515 00:31:08,421 --> 00:31:18,782 WhereasI was saying, what the partnership is more like is, if we 516 00:31:18,782 --> 00:31:28,346 have someone on their macro team who's kind of, you know, going 517 00:31:28,346 --> 00:31:37,113 into the office in the morning, kind of thinking, ah, we've 518 00:31:37,113 --> 00:31:45,880 just changed our view on European equities, I must get on 519 00:31:45,880 --> 00:31:57,835 the phone to Dan and his team and let him know because I know they 520 00:31:57,835 --> 00:32:06,602 care about that and that's something they can do. It's having 521 00:32:06,602 --> 00:32:15,369 that ongoing thing in the diary where every single month we're 522 00:32:15,369 --> 00:32:23,339 keeping up to say, okay, you've changed your view there. 523 00:32:23,841 --> 00:33:19,000 Okay, what do you think about Japan? Are you still neutral on the 524 00:33:19,000 --> 00:34:05,673 US? What are you thinking about this? What about the dollar? 525 00:32:23,841 --> 00:32:37,547 Andjust keeping tabs on it, all the time, so that we can sort 526 00:32:37,547 --> 00:32:48,316 of synthesize that information and make it far more relevant to 527 00:32:48,316 --> 00:33:01,043 us. Because it's very easy for someone to pop up and say, yeah, 528 00:33:01,043 --> 00:33:11,812 short the dollar kind of thing. But it's different to say, 529 00:33:11,812 --> 00:33:24,539 well, okay, but what did you say three months ago, and six months 530 00:33:24,539 --> 00:33:35,308 ago, and when did you change, and what's your conviction level 531 00:33:35,308 --> 00:33:47,056 and what's your time horizon? And you only learn all that stuff 532 00:33:47,056 --> 00:33:56,846 by having an ongoing conversation with them over a period 533 00:33:56,846 --> 00:34:05,657 of time, really understanding how they think about it. Evento 534 00:32:25,961 --> 00:32:38,681 the point where, you know, with the managers we work with, for 535 00:32:38,681 --> 00:32:49,281 example, we get input from their sort of central strategist 536 00:32:49,281 --> 00:33:00,941 teams and then also some of their multi-asset risk takers. Now, 537 00:33:00,941 --> 00:33:12,601 those are different viewpoints and they might not always agree and 538 00:33:12,601 --> 00:33:25,321 that's fine. But it's really interesting to know, is that a strategist 539 00:33:25,321 --> 00:33:39,101 call or is that the multi asset risk takers call? And so, you're 540 00:33:39,101 --> 00:33:49,701 starting to tune into the different ways those different teams 541 00:33:49,701 --> 00:34:00,301 work, the different way their incentives operate. So, it's really 542 00:34:00,301 --> 00:34:05,601 interesting and that's been great. AndI think all that comes 543 00:32:28,725 --> 00:32:37,679 down to us kind of synthesizing all that in an effective 544 00:32:37,679 --> 00:32:45,005 way and bringing that information together, you know, into 545 00:32:45,005 --> 00:32:53,145 the meetings that we have, every quarter, where we're looking 546 00:32:53,145 --> 00:33:02,913 at our allocations. And it's just far more useful when my team 547 00:33:02,913 --> 00:33:12,681 has been in almost constant contact with a small number of these 548 00:33:12,681 --> 00:33:23,263 kind of strategists, and then my team can kind of come into the 549 00:33:23,263 --> 00:33:33,031 room and represent all that rather than us just having a one-off 550 00:33:33,031 --> 00:33:42,799 call with a strategist who says, buy this, sell that, buy the 551 00:33:42,799 --> 00:33:53,381 other kind of thing. But we never spoke to them before, so we 552 00:33:53,381 --> 00:34:02,335 don't know if that's new views or something they've been talking 553 00:34:02,335 --> 00:34:05,591 about for 10 years. 554 00:34:06,251 --> 00:34:09,163 Yeah, interesting. I mean, obviously you’re long-term investors, 555 00:34:09,163 --> 00:34:13,895 you have to be cognizant of the news flow, but I guess you're 556 00:34:13,895 --> 00:34:18,263 not overly reactive. So, to what extent are you using those macro 557 00:34:18,263 --> 00:34:22,631 insights, day to day, week to week, in kind of asset allocation 558 00:34:22,631 --> 00:34:25,179 or even within asset classes at all? 559 00:34:26,091 --> 00:34:50,245 Yeah, it's a really good question. I mean I spend a lot of 560 00:34:50,245 --> 00:35:14,399 time trying to make the point that it is important to step away 561 00:35:14,399 --> 00:35:36,695 from the noise. And when it comes to most headlines in markets, 562 00:35:36,695 --> 00:35:58,991 most headlines you see coming across Bloomberg, I do think a decent 563 00:35:58,991 --> 00:36:19,429 starting point is it's pretty much all noise, actually, and you've 564 00:36:19,429 --> 00:36:43,583 got to remind yourself of that. And I also try and remind my 565 00:36:43,583 --> 00:37:04,021 team that most of the time consensus is probably about right 566 00:37:04,021 --> 00:37:15,169 and it's probably already priced in. So,I think markets do 567 00:34:45,301 --> 00:35:39,089 a decent job of pricing stuff in, and you better know what is priced 568 00:35:39,089 --> 00:36:25,193 in. There's no point sitting there saying, oh, you know, I love 569 00:36:25,193 --> 00:36:59,771 US equities, or whatever, without recognizing that that is 570 00:36:59,771 --> 00:37:15,139 already pretty well priced. So,in that sense, I'm quite far 571 00:34:33,392 --> 00:34:44,865 across the sort of efficient markets side of the world. There 572 00:34:44,865 --> 00:35:00,510 is a ‘but’, which is, I do think you can do a little bit better 573 00:35:00,510 --> 00:35:13,026 than that. Emphasis on ‘a little bit’. And it is worth doing 574 00:35:13,026 --> 00:35:25,542 that because we're a £40 billion fund, so, if we can just 575 00:35:25,542 --> 00:35:35,972 add a little bit through that dynamic allocations or whatever, 576 00:35:35,972 --> 00:35:49,531 it's worth doing. But you’ve got to have a bit of humility about 577 00:35:49,531 --> 00:36:02,047 it. I think you’ve got to set yourself some clear guardrails and 578 00:36:02,047 --> 00:36:14,563 some kind of expectations for how much you're going to really achieve. 579 00:36:14,563 --> 00:36:28,122 I think we can definitely add a little bit more by leaning into 580 00:36:28,122 --> 00:36:39,595 and out of some of those regional allocations here and there. 581 00:36:39,595 --> 00:36:53,154 But you don't want to get carried away that you can be some 582 00:36:53,154 --> 00:37:04,627 kind of active macro trader swinging around all over the place 583 00:37:04,627 --> 00:37:15,057 because, I just think that would be going too far. So,yeah, 584 00:34:32,129 --> 00:35:02,319 we do have a quarterly process. We have quarterly investment 585 00:35:02,319 --> 00:35:38,547 forum where all the key investors on the team kind of sit 586 00:35:38,547 --> 00:36:17,794 down for half a day. We try and run through all the positioning 587 00:36:17,794 --> 00:37:00,060 that we have in the portfolio. And the idea is to sort of re-underwrite 588 00:37:00,060 --> 00:37:15,155 that on a quarterly basis. Nowit doesn't mean we change it 589 00:34:40,014 --> 00:35:05,871 every quarter and quite often we don't. But I think it's a really 590 00:35:05,871 --> 00:35:31,728 helpful practice because, when you do come up and want to make a 591 00:35:31,728 --> 00:35:51,618 change, it's so much easier, having had that conversation three, 592 00:35:51,618 --> 00:36:11,508 four times, sort of flagging the indicators you're looking for, 593 00:36:11,508 --> 00:36:35,376 then it sort of happens, then you have so much more conviction 594 00:36:35,376 --> 00:36:55,266 in that change. So, we're probably only making changes like 595 00:36:55,266 --> 00:37:15,156 once a year, maybe less than that in these areas. ButI think 596 00:34:30,744 --> 00:34:46,254 to inform that, a quarterly conversation, that starts with kind 597 00:34:46,254 --> 00:35:03,315 of macroeconomics and then works its way all the way through 598 00:35:03,315 --> 00:35:15,723 to kind of regional allocations, duration, maturity allocations, 599 00:35:15,723 --> 00:35:34,335 and credit and fixed income sort of thing, is quite a powerful 600 00:35:34,335 --> 00:35:54,498 thing to do. So, I do think it's worth deeply getting into it. 601 00:35:54,498 --> 00:36:14,661 And a quarterly basis is kind of about right, but it's quite helpful 602 00:36:14,661 --> 00:36:36,375 to frame it with a little bit of humility to kind of say, well 603 00:36:36,375 --> 00:36:51,885 look, we better understand what the consensus is and better 604 00:36:51,885 --> 00:37:08,946 acknowledge that's probably priced in and has quite a good chance 605 00:37:08,946 --> 00:37:15,150 of actually being right. So,you know, where do we actually 606 00:35:11,612 --> 00:36:03,636 have conviction in something that's differentiated from consensus 607 00:36:03,636 --> 00:37:02,163 is the question that everyone's got to answer really, 608 00:37:02,163 --> 00:37:15,169 isn't it? 609 00:37:20,371 --> 00:37:23,871 So, from an asset allocation perspective, I mean, obviously I 610 00:37:23,871 --> 00:37:27,371 guess you're looking at the traditional assets, bonds and equities. 611 00:37:27,371 --> 00:37:31,921 But beyond that, is it real assets, is it all liquid, any privates, 612 00:37:31,921 --> 00:37:35,071 any alternatives or where do you draw the line? 613 00:37:35,881 --> 00:38:27,073 Yeah, so at the moment we're just sort of embarking on moving 614 00:38:27,073 --> 00:39:05,467 into private markets and illiquids, and hopefully, the next 615 00:39:05,467 --> 00:39:48,127 year or so, we'll have established a program probably across 616 00:39:48,127 --> 00:40:35,053 infrastructure and real estate to sort of move into real assets. 617 00:40:35,053 --> 00:41:17,713 But as things stand today, generally a liquid markets portfolio. 618 00:37:35,881 --> 00:38:17,676 IfI could just take a quick step back, I suppose, maybe talk 619 00:38:17,676 --> 00:38:53,041 about how we think about asset allocation. You know, in general, 620 00:38:53,041 --> 00:39:38,051 we sort of run this process to try to start with beliefs, then map 621 00:39:38,051 --> 00:40:16,631 it through to objectives, put a bit of a framework around that 622 00:40:16,631 --> 00:40:55,211 and then research, and then have a strategy that comes on the 623 00:40:55,211 --> 00:41:17,716 back. So, it's beliefs, objectives, research, strategy. Andso, 624 00:37:42,219 --> 00:38:23,416 we try to spend time on all parts of that, but particularly getting 625 00:38:23,416 --> 00:39:04,613 the beliefs right can get you quite a long way. And so, there, 626 00:39:04,613 --> 00:39:39,472 what we're trying to do, obviously, is returns in excess of 627 00:39:39,472 --> 00:40:14,331 UK inflation. I think that's what drives good outcomes for member’s 628 00:40:14,331 --> 00:40:49,190 pensions over time. That's what gives them the ability to accumulate 629 00:40:49,190 --> 00:41:17,711 a pension and then sort of spend it down. Variousbeliefs around 630 00:37:51,358 --> 00:38:42,948 needing short and long-term measures of risk and volatility is 631 00:38:42,948 --> 00:39:44,856 not really a great measure of risk. Often we're looking more at 632 00:39:44,856 --> 00:40:46,764 the chance of a member falling short of that long-term return outcome. 633 00:40:46,764 --> 00:41:17,718 So, it's kind of long-term probabilities. Insome areas we do 634 00:37:58,516 --> 00:38:34,732 care about drawdowns because members approaching retirement do 635 00:38:34,732 --> 00:39:33,583 care about falls in the value of their pension. So yeah, your beliefs 636 00:39:33,583 --> 00:40:27,907 can set out some principles around how you're going to do it 637 00:40:27,907 --> 00:41:17,704 and then you can kind of translate that into clearer objectives. 638 00:37:35,881 --> 00:38:07,571 So,in the growth phase, inflation plus 3%, inflation plus 639 00:38:07,571 --> 00:38:42,430 3%, 4%, you can generally show that at the current contribution 640 00:38:42,430 --> 00:39:20,458 levels… That is a decent kind of accumulation rate that gets people 641 00:39:20,458 --> 00:39:55,317 to a decent place. And then, when people are approaching retirement 642 00:39:55,317 --> 00:40:27,007 or at retirement, it's inflation plus a little bit, maybe 643 00:40:27,007 --> 00:40:58,697 inflation plus 1%, 1.5%. Something like that is more what 644 00:40:58,697 --> 00:41:17,711 you're sort of going for there. So,that gives you a bit of 645 00:37:53,934 --> 00:38:30,040 a return hurdle to go at. And then that sort of mirrors the two 646 00:38:30,040 --> 00:38:58,409 asset allocations that we run, really. We've got one main default 647 00:38:58,409 --> 00:39:29,357 and that has two main components to it, a sort of growth 648 00:39:29,357 --> 00:39:47,410 component and the pre-retirement component. So, it's 649 00:39:47,410 --> 00:40:15,779 a pretty clean structure. And those kinds of growth returns, say 650 00:40:15,779 --> 00:40:46,727 inflation plus 3% to 4%, that's a sort of an equity-ish return. 651 00:40:46,727 --> 00:41:17,675 And a lot of our peers are 100% equities at that point. Butwe 652 00:37:40,811 --> 00:38:12,856 sort of hold a belief that there is some value in a slightly 653 00:38:12,856 --> 00:38:37,506 smoother return stream than that. And our kind of philosophy 654 00:38:37,506 --> 00:39:07,086 there is that we would like to see different return drivers driving 655 00:39:07,086 --> 00:39:31,736 that growth, not just equities. So, trying to put together 656 00:39:31,736 --> 00:39:56,386 a growth portfolio, ideally, that leans on equities, fixed income, 657 00:39:56,386 --> 00:40:25,966 and real assets, as kind of three growth drivers that are kind 658 00:40:25,966 --> 00:40:53,081 of working together to deliver sort of equit-ish like return in 659 00:40:53,081 --> 00:41:17,731 the growth phase, which is basically what we're here for. Andthen 660 00:37:44,581 --> 00:38:28,081 the pre-retirement phase, as I say, that's quite different. That's 661 00:38:28,081 --> 00:39:15,931 much more focused on getting the drawdowns as low as possible, 662 00:39:15,931 --> 00:40:03,781 but still doing a little bit better than inflation. Not surprisingly, 663 00:40:03,781 --> 00:40:51,631 that's more of a fixed income, short, dated type allocation that 664 00:40:51,631 --> 00:41:17,731 you sort of get to there. Butwe also work in terms of trying 665 00:38:03,609 --> 00:38:45,201 to map those targets to kind of a reference portfolio which we 666 00:38:45,201 --> 00:39:33,725 can then map down as a bit of a clearer benchmark for the asset 667 00:39:33,725 --> 00:40:04,919 classes because those inflation targets are a great starting 668 00:40:04,919 --> 00:40:36,113 point. But they're obviously not investable directly. So, they 669 00:40:36,113 --> 00:41:14,239 don't give you as good a day-to-day benchmark as you might 670 00:41:14,239 --> 00:41:17,705 need. 671 00:41:18,311 --> 00:41:25,691 Yeah, interesting. I mean, obviously, you're not all-in on equities. 672 00:41:25,691 --> 00:41:33,809 You're saying you're kind of diversified growth in the sense of 673 00:41:33,809 --> 00:41:41,189 real assets and, presumably, in fixed income you're looking at 674 00:41:41,189 --> 00:41:47,831 credit as well. Then, obviously, it's been a tremendous 675 00:41:47,831 --> 00:41:57,425 run, the last 15, 16 years of bull market, since ’09, which begs 676 00:41:57,425 --> 00:42:04,805 the question, are there tougher times ahead at some point 677 00:42:04,805 --> 00:42:09,233 and what that might look like? Peoplealways point back to say 1966-‘82 678 00:41:24,254 --> 00:41:32,744 we had high inflation, asset markets went sideways and investors 679 00:41:32,744 --> 00:41:42,083 had suffered real losses, I guess, or negative real returns in 680 00:41:42,083 --> 00:41:53,120 some asset classes. I mean, I guess, that must be a key consideration 681 00:41:53,120 --> 00:42:02,459 in your mind but is there anything you tactically would do 682 00:42:02,459 --> 00:42:09,251 about the risk of that type of scenario? 683 00:42:10,881 --> 00:42:23,241 Yeah, I mean, look, we're still pretty equity heavy, right? 684 00:42:23,241 --> 00:42:36,837 So, we're, by no means, bearish or pessimists on the equity 685 00:42:36,837 --> 00:42:51,669 front. But yeah, you're right. Equities have had a great 10, 15 686 00:42:51,669 --> 00:43:04,029 years. Strategies that were 100% equities have done really well. 687 00:43:04,029 --> 00:43:18,861 So, well done to the people who embraced equities to that extent. 688 00:42:10,881 --> 00:42:20,829 WhatI would say is, looking back at longer term studies, and 689 00:42:20,829 --> 00:42:30,777 actually I just got an email that the 2026 UBS Long-Term Return 690 00:42:30,777 --> 00:42:39,896 study is out and makes this point, again, that actually, over 691 00:42:39,896 --> 00:42:46,528 the long-term, balanced portfolios that are majority equities 692 00:42:46,528 --> 00:42:56,476 but have fixed income in them as well have actually done almost 693 00:42:56,476 --> 00:43:07,253 as well as just equities. You don't give up tons of return for 694 00:43:07,253 --> 00:43:18,859 the balance, but you do have a much smoother ride on the vol front. 695 00:42:10,881 --> 00:42:22,211 So,I think that's probably where we're coming from. It's not 696 00:42:22,211 --> 00:42:34,571 so much saying, oh my gosh, terrible things could happen to equities. 697 00:42:34,571 --> 00:42:46,931 We're bearish and we're going to get all defensive. It's more just 698 00:42:46,931 --> 00:42:59,291 saying, well, equities are great but maybe there is a bit of 699 00:42:59,291 --> 00:43:10,621 value in just trying to take a slightly more balanced perspective 700 00:43:10,621 --> 00:43:18,861 on it than being 100% kind of equities. 701 00:43:20,701 --> 00:43:25,419 I mean, there's a whole raft of issues, even for a long only equity 702 00:43:25,419 --> 00:43:29,800 investor, in terms of you’re UK based, and a lot of talk about 703 00:43:29,800 --> 00:43:33,507 the UK market has been abandoned by UK investors, etc. Equally, 704 00:43:33,507 --> 00:43:38,562 you know, you take a global index, you end up with a lot of US 705 00:43:38,562 --> 00:43:41,595 exposure, a lot of concentrated exposure in high growth 706 00:43:41,595 --> 00:43:44,628 technology stocks. So, what's your starting point about what's 707 00:43:44,628 --> 00:43:47,661 the sensible way to think about your equity allocation? 708 00:43:48,431 --> 00:44:12,897 Yeah, so the starting point is the right question, and ours is global 709 00:44:12,897 --> 00:44:33,599 market cap starting point. That's a clear sort of belief that 710 00:44:33,599 --> 00:44:56,183 we have there. And I'm pretty, yeah, I'm definitely on the side 711 00:44:56,183 --> 00:45:16,885 of, as I've sort of said, market efficiency, in that sense, 712 00:45:16,885 --> 00:45:35,705 that the starting point in global listed equities should be 713 00:45:35,705 --> 00:46:00,171 global. I think in other asset classes, by the way, you can justify 714 00:46:00,171 --> 00:46:20,873 more of a home bias for different reasons. But in global 715 00:46:20,873 --> 00:46:45,339 listed equities I think they do a pretty good job of pricing in 716 00:46:45,339 --> 00:47:07,923 the future if a particular region is going to have better revenue 717 00:47:07,923 --> 00:47:30,507 growth, or EPS growth, that will be reflected in the prices and 718 00:47:30,507 --> 00:47:39,917 therefore reflected in the allocations. Thestarting point is 719 00:44:00,007 --> 00:44:37,629 global but, like in so many areas, we do set ourselves up so 720 00:44:37,629 --> 00:45:06,569 that we can control those allocations ourselves if we want, 721 00:45:06,569 --> 00:45:44,191 and make changes to them. So, we have a regional approach to our 722 00:45:44,191 --> 00:46:16,025 equity benchmarks for example. So, we have a North American portfolio, 723 00:46:16,025 --> 00:46:42,071 European, Japanese, UK, Asia Pacific, emerging markets sort of 724 00:46:42,071 --> 00:47:16,799 thing, and we allow ourselves a bit of a tracking error budget 725 00:47:16,799 --> 00:47:39,951 to lean into those allocations a little bit. Butwe try and keep 726 00:44:03,276 --> 00:44:38,904 ourselves honest by not trying to deviate too much from the sort 727 00:44:38,904 --> 00:45:08,594 of global portfolio. Because obviously we've seen, over the last 728 00:45:08,594 --> 00:45:44,222 10 years, it was very fashionable for a large part of the 729 00:45:44,222 --> 00:46:16,881 last decade to be underweight in the US, overweight emerging markets, 730 00:46:16,881 --> 00:46:49,540 and, until recently, that had been a very, very painful trade. 731 00:46:49,540 --> 00:47:31,106 So, I think you’ve got to be really cautious in the sort of way 732 00:47:31,106 --> 00:47:40,013 you're doing it. Butthe concentration point is a really good 733 00:44:13,127 --> 00:44:53,258 one. So, I will take that, although I'm sort of quite far on 734 00:44:53,258 --> 00:45:36,476 the efficient market side. I think that is a sort of a legit knock 735 00:45:36,476 --> 00:46:16,607 on the global index approach to the world that there isn't a great 736 00:46:16,607 --> 00:46:50,564 answer to. It would appear that those global indices are somewhat 737 00:46:50,564 --> 00:47:24,521 lacking in diversification, you might say, which is a bit of 738 00:47:24,521 --> 00:47:40,021 an odd thing to say. Soyeah,thereare a few levers you've 739 00:44:16,079 --> 00:45:04,463 got, to kind of lean against that, but one of them is yeah, to 740 00:45:04,463 --> 00:45:45,935 sort of cap your… If you've got that regional approach that we've 741 00:45:45,935 --> 00:46:37,775 got, you can sort of put a cap on your US exposure, let's say, half 742 00:46:37,775 --> 00:47:15,791 the portfolio, let's say, which then kind of waters down the 743 00:47:15,791 --> 00:47:39,983 effect of that concentration a little bit. So,I think concentration 744 00:44:02,051 --> 00:44:42,911 is something to think about. It's difficult to come up with a 745 00:44:42,911 --> 00:45:13,556 good sort of theoretical market efficiency type argument around 746 00:45:13,556 --> 00:45:54,416 it. And so, I think people will have their own approaches to 747 00:45:54,416 --> 00:46:35,276 it. But that's certainly one of the things that's in our mind 748 00:46:35,276 --> 00:47:09,326 when we're looking at those regional allocations and the concentration 749 00:47:09,326 --> 00:47:39,971 there, trying to get, you know, proper diversification in. 750 00:43:48,431 --> 00:47:40,021 Ithink,the way things have gone, your US versus rest of world 751 00:44:17,941 --> 00:44:45,181 allocation is one of your top level strategic decisions as an asset 752 00:44:45,181 --> 00:45:12,421 own owner these days. It's going to make a big difference. It 753 00:45:12,421 --> 00:45:37,391 has made a massive difference over the last 10 years. Obviously, 754 00:45:37,391 --> 00:46:02,361 last 10 years, more US, the better. You know, going forward, 755 00:46:02,361 --> 00:46:34,141 that's going to be a big kind of decision. And our stance has been 756 00:46:34,141 --> 00:47:03,651 lean slightly away from the US and more towards rest of the world, 757 00:47:03,651 --> 00:47:35,431 which I've sort of done okay I suppose the last year or so, but 758 00:47:35,431 --> 00:47:39,971 we'll see. Andanother one is obviously what you do with the dollar, 759 00:44:13,643 --> 00:44:38,855 and your currency hedging there in terms of that the global 760 00:44:38,855 --> 00:45:01,775 indices as well as being concentrated in technology and, in 761 00:45:01,775 --> 00:45:24,695 certain companies, obviously gives you a lot of dollar exposure. 762 00:45:24,695 --> 00:45:49,907 And yeah, written multiple very long papers on what that means 763 00:45:49,907 --> 00:46:19,703 and what you should do with it. I think there's quite a good 764 00:46:19,703 --> 00:46:40,331 argument that, from a UK investor perspective, it's actually 765 00:46:40,331 --> 00:47:07,835 a pretty decent hedging asset to hold dollars. And so, you should 766 00:47:07,835 --> 00:47:39,923 think hard about how much of that you want to sort of hedge away. 767 00:43:48,431 --> 00:44:50,183 Itmight be quite nice to hold dollars. There have been certain 768 00:44:50,183 --> 00:45:41,643 regimes, post ’08, where holding dollars is kind of almost 769 00:45:41,643 --> 00:46:43,395 like a free tail-risk hedge. So, that's another thing we do, we 770 00:46:43,395 --> 00:47:40,001 do think a lot about what we're doing with those dollars. 771 00:47:41,572 --> 00:47:45,888 And is that something that you would review, as part of your kind 772 00:47:45,888 --> 00:47:48,876 of quarterly process? Obviously, there's a lot of, now, 773 00:47:48,876 --> 00:47:53,192 debate about the dollar. As you say, it has had that role risk-off 774 00:47:53,192 --> 00:47:55,848 characteristic in stress periods which has been beneficial, 775 00:47:55,848 --> 00:47:59,500 say, for non-US investors. But obviously, we've seen the shift in 776 00:47:59,500 --> 00:48:02,820 sentiment in the last year, people questioning will that always 777 00:48:02,820 --> 00:48:07,136 be the case? You can get carried away by the news and the 778 00:48:07,136 --> 00:48:10,456 short-term sentiment but there is a structural argument there that 779 00:48:10,456 --> 00:48:14,108 might play out over many years. What's your thinking on that? 780 00:48:14,982 --> 00:48:33,234 Yeah, I mean it's something we review. We've been doing quite a 781 00:48:33,234 --> 00:48:49,965 lot of work around it recently. It's always such a hard 782 00:48:49,965 --> 00:49:08,217 topic to pin down because there are so many ways of approaching 783 00:49:08,217 --> 00:49:29,511 it, so many angles to it. We can't take the view that you've got 784 00:49:29,511 --> 00:49:52,326 to try and step away a little bit from just a view on the levels 785 00:49:52,326 --> 00:50:10,578 of the currencies because, you know, who knows on that really? They 786 00:50:10,578 --> 00:50:19,712 really can go in any direction. Ithinkthe analysis we've 787 00:48:26,527 --> 00:48:56,544 seen that, you know, managers have done for us and so forth, unless 788 00:48:56,544 --> 00:49:21,943 sterling is at very extreme valuation level, it is quite hard 789 00:49:21,943 --> 00:49:49,651 to forecast the trend. What you can get a bit more confident 790 00:49:49,651 --> 00:50:17,359 on are the risk properties. So, what happens to the dollar in 791 00:50:17,359 --> 00:50:19,668 sell-offs? Butagain, there you've got very much a sort of a 792 00:48:35,761 --> 00:48:56,540 regime type thing at play where, since ‘08, which is nearly 793 00:48:56,540 --> 00:49:17,319 20 years now, the dollar's been a really good risk-off hedge, 794 00:49:17,319 --> 00:49:41,876 generally. Between sort of 1970 and ‘08 it was sort of of fine-ish. 795 00:49:41,876 --> 00:50:04,544 Actually, there was some stuff on this in that latest UBS yearbook, 796 00:50:04,544 --> 00:50:19,656 as well. I was looking at it yesterday. Ifyou want to go even 797 00:48:23,484 --> 00:48:39,071 back before 1970s, which is a bit questionable how relevant that 798 00:48:39,071 --> 00:48:54,658 might be, it's got different properties again. So, even with the 799 00:48:54,658 --> 00:49:15,913 risk side, you've got a bit of a sense of, well, are we still in 800 00:49:15,913 --> 00:49:34,334 that kind of post ‘08 regime in terms of how it's behaving? There 801 00:49:34,334 --> 00:49:49,921 are some arguments that it might have changed but, you know, 802 00:49:49,921 --> 00:50:08,342 has it really? Do we really think the dollar is not going to 803 00:50:08,342 --> 00:50:19,678 strengthen if there's a big kind of sell-off? Andobviously, 804 00:48:18,398 --> 00:48:40,602 the other point is you don't have to choose all or nothing, in 805 00:48:40,602 --> 00:49:01,098 terms of the hedging, you can have a percentage level. And then 806 00:49:01,098 --> 00:49:25,010 it's just kind of, well, what sort of range do we think is decent? 807 00:49:25,010 --> 00:49:48,922 Where do we want to be in that range? How much flexibility do we 808 00:49:48,922 --> 00:50:07,710 want to sort of give ourselves? So, those are sort of 809 00:50:07,710 --> 00:50:19,666 the things we're trying to nail down. Butwhether the pound 810 00:48:23,582 --> 00:48:51,532 goes up or down against the dollar is something we try not to 811 00:48:51,532 --> 00:49:21,632 stake too much of a view on, unless it was at really extreme levels. 812 00:49:21,632 --> 00:49:49,582 Which, to be fair, it was a couple of years ago, obviously. But 813 00:49:49,582 --> 00:50:15,382 more recently, I think it's not really been extremes in the last 814 00:50:15,382 --> 00:50:19,682 little while. 815 00:50:20,272 --> 00:50:26,265 I mean, the other area… You talk a bit on efficient markets hypothesis, 816 00:50:26,265 --> 00:50:31,336 I suppose the other areas where it might have been breached 817 00:50:31,336 --> 00:50:36,868 is with kind of factors, and style, premia, quality, or size and 818 00:50:36,868 --> 00:50:41,478 momentum, and things like that. What are your thoughts about 819 00:50:41,478 --> 00:50:46,088 integrating those kind of factors into the long equity portfolio? 820 00:50:46,742 --> 00:51:00,557 Yeah, that's certainly something we're doing a little bit 821 00:51:00,557 --> 00:51:15,907 to some extent. I mean, our emerging market equity portfolio, 822 00:51:15,907 --> 00:51:31,257 that we've got with Rubico, integrates factors and it's something 823 00:51:31,257 --> 00:51:49,677 we're looking at more widely. I mean, I've got a decent amount, 824 00:51:49,677 --> 00:52:09,632 I'd say, now, of experience with that over the last 10, 15 years. 825 00:52:09,632 --> 00:52:23,447 And in previous roles have advocated reasonably strongly for 826 00:52:23,447 --> 00:52:37,262 factor-based strategies and then, obviously, saw there was some 827 00:52:37,262 --> 00:52:55,682 pretty ugly performance there in that kind of, I don't know, what 828 00:52:55,682 --> 00:53:03,357 was it, 2018-2022 type window? So,I think any sensible strategy 829 00:50:57,116 --> 00:51:21,322 there has to learn the lessons of that period of time and has to 830 00:51:21,322 --> 00:51:42,070 have a sensible answer for what went wrong there, and why, and 831 00:51:42,070 --> 00:52:01,089 what have you done differently. My take on it is that 832 00:52:01,089 --> 00:52:21,837 yeah, it was particularly value in the US that got very badly 833 00:52:21,837 --> 00:52:42,585 hammered over that period of time and some of the multi factor 834 00:52:42,585 --> 00:52:59,875 approaches, in hindsight, were a little bit too overweighted to 835 00:52:59,875 --> 00:53:03,333 US value. Andso, it's something that really ensures it's 836 00:51:05,582 --> 00:51:33,842 not suddenly getting over its skis to any one factor, and also 837 00:51:33,842 --> 00:52:02,102 feel that momentum was the thing that has sort of saved some 838 00:52:02,102 --> 00:52:20,942 of those multi-factor things recently. And sometimes momentum 839 00:52:20,942 --> 00:52:46,847 gets underplayed because there's a bit of a sense, like, is 840 00:52:46,847 --> 00:53:03,332 it a real factor sort of thing. Butthe data would show you, 841 00:50:55,190 --> 00:51:12,086 over the last few years, that you definitely need that there. You 842 00:51:12,086 --> 00:51:30,390 want that to be there and have a strong presence in the signal, 843 00:51:30,390 --> 00:51:51,510 as well, to be able to sort of work. So, you know, I'm not sitting 844 00:51:51,510 --> 00:52:05,590 here saying I've got the best factor models myself. Obviously, 845 00:52:05,590 --> 00:52:21,078 we're an allocator, so, we're looking to managers to say, well, 846 00:52:21,078 --> 00:52:36,566 have you learned something from that period of time? What have 847 00:52:36,566 --> 00:52:54,870 you learned? How can you sort of be sure that your factors are 848 00:52:54,870 --> 00:53:03,318 more sort of evenly spread today? Butlooking around the world, 849 00:51:00,402 --> 00:51:33,186 I mean, actually, factors work pretty decently in EM for most of 850 00:51:33,186 --> 00:52:14,166 that time. So, when you look back at the data it was the US experience 851 00:52:14,166 --> 00:52:46,950 that just really clouded a lot of European values that worked pretty 852 00:52:46,950 --> 00:53:03,342 well for the last few years. So,it's about trying to make sure 853 00:51:18,620 --> 00:51:59,606 that you're genuinely balanced, and if one factor fails 854 00:51:59,606 --> 00:52:45,146 in one region that doesn't somehow drag down the performance 855 00:52:45,146 --> 00:53:03,362 of the whole product. 856 00:53:04,012 --> 00:53:06,700 Yeah, and what about alternative investment strategies, 857 00:53:06,700 --> 00:53:11,308 liquid alts, hedge funds? I mean in theory, we can access strategies 858 00:53:11,308 --> 00:53:15,916 that have a low correlation to equities and boost the Sharpe ratio, 859 00:53:15,916 --> 00:53:20,140 more stable risk adjusted returns if you believe all the literature, 860 00:53:20,140 --> 00:53:24,748 and the marketing, etc. Is it that they are not appropriate for 861 00:53:24,748 --> 00:53:28,588 an asset owner, for a structure like yourselves, or is 862 00:53:28,588 --> 00:53:31,276 it costs, or would you consider them? 863 00:53:32,292 --> 00:53:57,614 I think we certainly are considering it and starting to look 864 00:53:57,614 --> 00:54:29,842 at it. I think it comes down, a little bit, to the asset ownership 865 00:54:29,842 --> 00:54:55,164 model. Again, because DC has evolved from a basic asset ownership 866 00:54:55,164 --> 00:55:18,184 model, those strategies are basically just off the table because 867 00:55:18,184 --> 00:55:43,506 the ownership model and the cost constraints just ruled it out 868 00:55:43,506 --> 00:55:52,714 from the get go. Thatisn't the case anymore, I don't think, 869 00:53:52,348 --> 00:54:17,418 because we've got a more sophisticated model. I'm pretty sure, 870 00:54:17,418 --> 00:54:50,009 at our scale, we could access versions of it that would work in 871 00:54:50,009 --> 00:55:20,093 the cost constrained way as well. But I do think, again, you've 872 00:55:20,093 --> 00:55:50,177 got to face into some of the issues that those strategies have 873 00:55:50,177 --> 00:55:52,684 experienced. Andagain, a few of my reflections would be that some 874 00:53:54,677 --> 00:54:15,027 of those strategies that did badly were where allocators imposed 875 00:54:15,027 --> 00:54:39,447 quite a lot of constraints or implemented a more kind of watered-down 876 00:54:39,447 --> 00:55:03,867 version of it to satisfy cost constraints. Those were some of the 877 00:55:03,867 --> 00:55:30,322 versions that didn't do well. So, I think you’ve got to be quite 878 00:55:30,322 --> 00:55:52,707 wary of watered-down versions of it just to satisfy your approach. 879 00:53:32,292 --> 00:53:51,355 Theright approach is to get your model sophisticated enough to 880 00:53:51,355 --> 00:54:13,884 do the proper versions of it rather than do the kind of dumbed 881 00:54:13,884 --> 00:54:38,146 down ones would be one point. And then there just has to be enough 882 00:54:38,146 --> 00:54:57,209 recognition that, generally, equities do go up and do well. So, 883 00:54:57,209 --> 00:55:14,539 they shouldn't be about totally trying to hedge and shouldn't 884 00:55:14,539 --> 00:55:37,068 focus too much on spending a lot of premium on reducing risk because, 885 00:55:37,068 --> 00:55:52,665 over the long term, that is just a drag. So,you've got to find 886 00:53:40,852 --> 00:53:57,972 strategies that make sense in that long-term growth context. We're 887 00:53:57,972 --> 00:54:13,380 not looking at hedging this quarter's returns, we're looking 888 00:54:13,380 --> 00:54:32,212 at something that works over the long-term. And I think, again, 889 00:54:32,212 --> 00:54:49,332 some of the strategies that have underwhelmed, in the 2010s, 890 00:54:49,332 --> 00:55:11,588 got a little bit obsessed with trying to control risk to the nth 891 00:55:11,588 --> 00:55:35,556 degree, to the point where you pay it all away in premiums and you're 892 00:55:35,556 --> 00:55:52,676 left with something that doesn't really do much after fees. 893 00:53:32,292 --> 00:55:52,732 Istillthink there's some good there, and I would love to look 894 00:53:56,953 --> 00:54:21,614 more at how we could bring some of those kinds of hedges into 895 00:54:21,614 --> 00:54:44,378 play, a little bit, in a sensible way, in a construct that 896 00:54:44,378 --> 00:55:03,348 doesn't bleed away too much premium, doesn't pay excessive fees, 897 00:55:03,348 --> 00:55:20,421 and works against that longer-term, that kind of equity 898 00:55:20,421 --> 00:55:43,185 stream. But that's definitely a sort of next couple of years type 899 00:55:43,185 --> 00:55:52,670 project, I'd say, for us. 900 00:55:53,292 --> 00:55:57,408 Okay. I mean, the big buzzword in pensions and public pensions has 901 00:55:57,408 --> 00:56:00,495 been TPA, total portfolio approach. Is there something relevant 902 00:56:00,495 --> 00:56:04,611 in your model? You know, being a DC provider, but obviously you 903 00:56:04,611 --> 00:56:08,727 do have the kind of flight path offerings. How do you think 904 00:56:08,727 --> 00:56:09,413 about TPA? 905 00:56:10,732 --> 00:56:25,902 It's definitely relevant. It's a helpful framing to think about 906 00:56:25,902 --> 00:56:45,623 some of it because, again, it just goes back to the asset ownership 907 00:56:45,623 --> 00:57:03,827 model point. You know, one of my sort of views (maybe slightly 908 00:57:03,827 --> 00:57:20,514 pushy views), is, I think the concept of TPA almost originated 909 00:57:20,514 --> 00:57:38,718 with some of these much larger asset owners where the internal team 910 00:57:38,718 --> 00:57:53,888 became very large and things became awfully siloed between the 911 00:57:53,888 --> 00:58:12,092 different asset classes. And so, they needed a way of kind of 912 00:58:12,092 --> 00:58:28,779 reinventing a more centralized process that could be a little bit 913 00:58:28,779 --> 00:58:31,813 more nimble. Nowif you set yourselves up with a smaller, more 914 00:56:29,542 --> 00:56:53,995 focused internal team, like I said at the start, then I think you're 915 00:56:53,995 --> 00:57:18,448 naturally thinking in that way a lot more. Just the way we've kind 916 00:57:18,448 --> 00:57:42,901 of set the team up naturally sort of engenders that kind of cross 917 00:57:42,901 --> 00:57:59,830 asset collaboration and the kind of single centralized group 918 00:57:59,830 --> 00:58:18,640 that's taking decisions across the portfolio. Yeah, it's not far 919 00:58:18,640 --> 00:58:31,807 away from what we're trying to do. But,on the other hand, DC members, 920 00:56:24,641 --> 00:56:50,472 I think, broadly, do want an SAA type thing. I don't think you 921 00:56:50,472 --> 00:57:16,303 can take it to the extremes. DC members, I think that they have 922 00:57:16,303 --> 00:57:42,134 a right to expect a certain sort of asset allocation and to be 923 00:57:42,134 --> 00:58:09,952 able to have a sense of this is what the equity bond real asset 924 00:58:09,952 --> 00:58:27,835 split is. I think intrinsically that the members do 925 00:58:27,835 --> 00:58:31,809 want that. So,I don't think you can take it to the nth degree 926 00:56:28,360 --> 00:56:45,988 of saying, oh no, we'll deliver CPI plus 3%, but it could 927 00:56:45,988 --> 00:57:05,085 be anything in that portfolio, from one day to the next, is probably 928 00:57:05,085 --> 00:57:25,651 not the way to see it. But yeah, as soon as you're working in 929 00:57:25,651 --> 00:57:43,279 an internal team, you become quite tuned in to this balance of 930 00:57:43,279 --> 00:57:57,969 governance between it being team centric and board centric approaches. 931 00:57:57,969 --> 00:58:12,659 With the board centric approach being very much here's the 932 00:58:12,659 --> 00:58:31,756 SEA, we sign it off with some ranges, you go and implement it. 933 00:56:10,732 --> 00:56:33,304 Theteam centric approach being where you have a lot more freedom. 934 00:56:33,304 --> 00:56:50,233 And yeah, when you're operating in that environment like 935 00:56:50,233 --> 00:57:14,686 we are, you get quite tuned in to the differences there. And we're 936 00:57:14,686 --> 00:57:37,258 definitely debating where we want to sit on that, where is the 937 00:57:37,258 --> 00:57:59,830 comfort that we have with our trustee and with our governance as 938 00:57:59,830 --> 00:58:24,283 to how far we could move on it, where do our regulatory permissions 939 00:58:24,283 --> 00:58:31,807 allow us to sit? So,I think it's a very useful spectrum as you're 940 00:56:38,952 --> 00:57:04,350 considering your ownership model and your governance. But I 941 00:57:04,350 --> 00:57:41,036 think, in some ways, I has been sort of invented as a solution 942 00:57:41,036 --> 00:58:17,722 to a problem that we don't have at the moment as a relatively 943 00:58:17,722 --> 00:58:31,832 smaller, more flatter asset owner. 944 00:58:33,122 --> 00:58:36,902 Fair enough. I mean, you talked about balance scorecard in 945 00:58:36,902 --> 00:58:40,304 terms of evaluation of external managers, the manager selection 946 00:58:40,304 --> 00:58:44,462 process. In terms of how you think, you know, People's Partnership, 947 00:58:44,462 --> 00:58:47,864 that the investment team themselves should be evaluated, how 948 00:58:47,864 --> 00:58:52,022 do you think about that and is it balanced scorecard? Presumably 949 00:58:52,022 --> 00:58:55,802 it's not just returns. Performance, over what kind of time 950 00:58:55,802 --> 00:58:58,448 period, and what other factors are relevant? 951 00:58:58,872 --> 00:59:49,224 Yeah, I mean in terms of the performance, it's a three lenses 952 00:59:49,224 --> 01:00:26,988 approach and, even just looking at performance, is quite 953 01:00:26,988 --> 01:01:00,556 complicated and nuanced because you’ve got three different 954 01:01:00,556 --> 01:01:38,320 benchmarks, effectively, and then you've probably got at least 955 01:01:38,320 --> 01:02:24,476 two different time periods that you care about. So, you've got 956 01:02:24,476 --> 01:02:58,044 at least a six-factor scorecard just on performance. Butthe 957 00:59:03,752 --> 00:59:25,712 three lenses on performance are peers, reference portfolio, and 958 00:59:25,712 --> 00:59:52,552 the inflation targets of the funds. So, those are three different 959 00:59:52,552 --> 01:00:14,512 comparators. They all give you different but useful information. 960 01:00:14,512 --> 01:00:41,352 They can all tell you slightly different things at different times. 961 01:00:41,352 --> 01:01:08,192 So, I think you need to synthesize all those together. And 962 01:01:08,192 --> 01:01:44,792 then, in terms of time scales, yeah, I am a fan of looking at long-term 963 01:01:44,792 --> 01:02:06,752 returns, which I think generally means at least trailing 964 01:02:06,752 --> 01:02:36,032 five years. So, I love to focus on a trailing five-year number. 965 01:02:36,032 --> 01:02:57,992 But the issue is, that doesn't change very fast. So,you also need 966 00:59:10,536 --> 00:59:48,444 to have a pulse on what's going into the front end of that 967 00:59:48,444 --> 01:00:20,520 five-year. So, I'd often like to look at the one-year, five-year. 968 01:00:20,520 --> 01:00:52,596 So, you look at the last one-year and the trailing five-years 969 01:00:52,596 --> 01:01:30,504 against each of those kind of measures, and you can sort of put 970 01:01:30,504 --> 01:02:08,412 that into like a red, amber, green type scorecard to get a pulse 971 01:02:08,412 --> 01:02:46,320 of where you are. And then, again, we have to do that across 972 01:02:46,320 --> 01:02:57,984 the two different products. So,you start to see how the returns 973 00:59:31,296 --> 01:00:15,879 monitoring thing becomes quite complicated. But I'm a big fan of 974 01:00:15,879 --> 01:00:52,356 having a clear, repeatable framework on that stuff. Because 975 01:00:52,356 --> 01:01:40,992 the worry in investing is you can just show your stakeholders a 976 01:01:40,992 --> 01:02:21,522 slightly different picture of returns every quarter. You can always 977 01:02:21,522 --> 01:02:57,999 find the number that looks good and show it. Andyou really 978 00:59:10,260 --> 00:59:48,220 shouldn't do that because what's, what's better is to say, 979 00:59:48,220 --> 01:00:29,976 let's agree that this is the framework. Every quarter will show 980 01:00:29,976 --> 01:01:19,324 you the same thing, and we'll stare at the same 12 numbers, and 981 01:01:19,324 --> 01:02:01,080 over time we'll sort of get some really useful information out 982 01:02:01,080 --> 01:02:58,020 of that. So yeah, it took us a little while to settle on that perspective. 983 00:58:58,872 --> 00:59:37,656 Butthat's similar to I think how the Aussie superfunds would do 984 00:59:37,656 --> 01:00:19,672 it in terms of that peer view, the reference portfolio and the inflation 985 01:00:19,672 --> 01:00:58,456 targets view. And obviously, yeah, as I say, out of those the 986 01:00:58,456 --> 01:01:17,848 reference portfolio is obviously completely investable. 987 01:01:17,848 --> 01:01:56,632 So, that very clearly drills down to the exact benefit that the 988 01:01:56,632 --> 01:02:28,952 team has sort of delivered versus something else that could 989 01:02:28,952 --> 01:02:58,040 have been pursued. It's a very, very clear counterfactual. 990 00:58:58,872 --> 00:59:46,704 Youknow, the peer group is also more or less a counterfactual. 991 00:59:46,704 --> 01:00:34,536 So, I think it's quite helpful to know what would our portfolio 992 01:00:34,536 --> 01:01:22,368 have done had we sort of outsourced it to the peer group? 993 01:01:22,368 --> 01:02:02,228 Yeah, albeit not quite as directly invested. It's harder to 994 01:02:02,228 --> 01:02:58,032 stick that into a barer model and get a tracking error out of it. 995 00:58:58,872 --> 00:59:54,060 Butyou've got a rough idea. Then you've got the inflation targets 996 00:59:54,060 --> 01:00:44,649 which are sort of, they're obviously more of a longer-term kind 997 01:00:44,649 --> 01:01:26,040 of guide and they're absolutely not investable. I would 998 01:01:26,040 --> 01:02:25,827 love to be able to invest in something that could do CPI plus 999 01:02:25,827 --> 01:02:58,020 3% but of course that doesn't exist. Butthey're the sort of longer-term 1000 00:59:12,156 --> 00:59:38,724 yardstick that you want to be near to. But obviously, recent years, 1001 00:59:38,724 --> 01:00:00,864 those have been really challenged. So, that's been one of 1002 01:00:00,864 --> 01:00:23,004 the issues. So, 2022 being still within the five-year window, 1003 01:00:23,004 --> 01:00:51,786 it's been a real struggle to get funds in line with even quite 1004 01:00:51,786 --> 01:01:13,926 modest inflation related targets. Even if all the theory says 1005 01:01:13,926 --> 01:01:38,280 that it should be very achievable to do sort of inflation 1006 01:01:38,280 --> 01:02:07,062 plus 3%. No one was doing that during 2022, ‘23. Over the five-year, 1007 01:02:07,062 --> 01:02:31,416 now, because equities have been strong, we are just about ahead 1008 01:02:31,416 --> 01:02:55,770 of that, over the five-year view now, which is obviously really 1009 01:02:55,770 --> 01:02:57,984 nice. Thatwas tricky during that period of time as well, which 1010 00:59:25,173 --> 00:59:58,647 is why you need to have the other views on it because if you're 1011 00:59:58,647 --> 01:00:24,948 offside on that measure you might not be doing anything wrong 1012 01:00:24,948 --> 01:00:48,858 because the peers and the reference portfolio might have the 1013 01:00:48,858 --> 01:01:17,550 same issue inherent in them and you might have even done slightly 1014 01:01:17,550 --> 01:01:41,460 better than peers but worse than the reference portfolio kind 1015 01:01:41,460 --> 01:02:05,370 of thing. So, those three perspectives have been quite helpful 1016 01:02:05,370 --> 01:02:36,453 in looking at returns. But it means that it's a slightly more nuanced 1017 01:02:36,453 --> 01:02:57,972 conversation than just are you up on the down? 1018 01:02:59,012 --> 01:03:02,228 Very good. Well, we're just conscious of time. We do like to 1019 01:03:02,228 --> 01:03:04,640 wrap up just getting some perspective. Obviously, you've been 1020 01:03:04,640 --> 01:03:07,856 in the markets a while on the consulting, the investing side, I 1021 01:03:07,856 --> 01:03:10,804 mean for people earlier in their career are looking to develop 1022 01:03:10,804 --> 01:03:14,556 a career as a CIO either as an asset owner or elsewhere. I mean 1023 01:03:14,556 --> 01:03:17,772 what would you suggest or what are the things that were helpful 1024 01:03:17,772 --> 01:03:19,916 for you through your career, would you say? 1025 01:03:20,932 --> 01:03:55,759 Yeah, a few things. I mean, I get asked that question a little 1026 01:03:55,759 --> 01:04:30,586 bit. I mean, one thing that was really helpful for me, you know, 1027 01:04:30,586 --> 01:05:00,055 starting my career at a consulting firm and a global firm 1028 01:05:00,055 --> 01:05:26,845 was really, really beneficial, especially in that period of time. 1029 01:05:26,845 --> 01:05:58,993 I got all sorts of insight into how loads of different pension 1030 01:05:58,993 --> 01:06:25,783 schemes operated. As a consultant you get exposure to loads 1031 01:06:25,783 --> 01:06:57,931 of managers. So, that breadth of exposure, for me, was super helpful. 1032 01:03:20,932 --> 01:03:56,608 Butyou know, not everyone's going to be in that position. So, 1033 01:03:56,608 --> 01:04:32,284 a sort of more general piece of career advice that always served 1034 01:04:32,284 --> 01:05:10,933 me well is I think really making the most of every kind of 1035 01:05:10,933 --> 01:05:37,690 opportunity you're in and really, really learning your craft 1036 01:05:37,690 --> 01:06:13,366 in every single role. Because I think sometimes people can be very 1037 01:06:13,366 --> 01:06:49,042 focused on, right, I've got a role, what's the next thing, what's 1038 01:06:49,042 --> 01:06:57,961 the next thing? Andpeople, you know, might do a year, 18 months 1039 01:03:49,482 --> 01:04:29,452 in a role and be very keen to move on. Whereas, I think there's 1040 01:04:29,452 --> 01:05:06,567 real value in, as I say, taking out at least three, four years 1041 01:05:06,567 --> 01:05:49,392 in a role, I think is what it takes to learn the craft of that 1042 01:05:49,392 --> 01:06:17,942 role. Really deeply learn it, and understand it, and appreciate 1043 01:06:17,942 --> 01:06:43,637 the situation you're in. Because every situation is going 1044 01:06:43,637 --> 01:06:57,912 to be a bit unique. Forexample, you might be in a global 1045 01:03:44,388 --> 01:04:28,368 firm, in an overseas office. You might be in a UK firm, in a UK 1046 01:04:28,368 --> 01:05:03,552 office. It could be a founder led growth company with very particular 1047 01:05:03,552 --> 01:05:35,804 kind of company. It could be an employee owned partnership. It 1048 01:05:35,804 --> 01:06:08,056 could be a profit for member organization. I've worked for all 1049 01:06:08,056 --> 01:06:37,376 those kind of organizations. They're all brilliant in their own 1050 01:06:37,376 --> 01:06:57,900 ways, they all have their own issues. Andunless you spend real 1051 01:03:33,697 --> 01:04:11,992 time in it and really kind of absorb it, I think you can risk not 1052 01:04:11,992 --> 01:04:42,628 really taking that lesson on properly in your career as to what 1053 01:04:42,628 --> 01:05:13,264 it's like to work in the overseas office of a European company, 1054 01:05:13,264 --> 01:05:49,006 or the UK office of a US company, or work for a cyclical or 1055 01:05:49,006 --> 01:06:14,536 countercyclical part of the business. So, I think learning your 1056 01:06:14,536 --> 01:06:45,172 craft in each area is really important and then sort of developing 1057 01:06:45,172 --> 01:06:57,962 that a little bit more. Ithink,when I interview people, what 1058 01:03:42,632 --> 01:04:22,932 is often deeply impressive to me is when someone is sort of able 1059 01:04:22,932 --> 01:05:00,132 to say, right, here's my philosophy of how you should do XYZ 1060 01:05:00,132 --> 01:05:40,432 thing. And in some ways the more simple that XYZ thing is, the 1061 01:05:40,432 --> 01:06:08,332 better. Because it shows they've really thought about something 1062 01:06:08,332 --> 01:06:45,532 quite simple, and it shows a lot of agency, and curiosity, and 1063 01:06:45,532 --> 01:06:57,932 loads of good things. So,it's one thing debating your philosophy 1064 01:03:48,057 --> 01:04:30,682 of investing, but let's say something as simple as what makes 1065 01:04:30,682 --> 01:05:32,682 a good end of day email to go out to an asset owner? Yeah, it really 1066 01:05:32,682 --> 01:06:11,432 impressive if someone says, hey, here's my philosophy, what should 1067 01:06:11,432 --> 01:06:57,932 that be on that email? Because I've spent time thinking about that. 1068 01:03:20,932 --> 01:06:57,962 Ididn'tjust do what my boss told me to do. I thought to myself, 1069 01:04:22,342 --> 01:05:07,376 what are the people reading? What helps? What decisions are they 1070 01:05:07,376 --> 01:05:56,504 going to make? What is the information that they need to make 1071 01:05:56,504 --> 01:06:49,726 those decisions? How can I make it quicker? How can I make it 1072 01:06:49,726 --> 01:06:57,914 more accurate? So,a lot of people will just sit there, do what 1073 01:03:49,686 --> 01:04:26,282 their boss told them to do, and then pass it on. Whereas if you 1074 01:04:26,282 --> 01:04:55,036 spend that time learning your craft and really think, you know, 1075 01:04:55,036 --> 01:05:29,018 what is my philosophy of how to do this very specific thing? I 1076 01:05:29,018 --> 01:05:57,772 actually think that's very impressive to people, as you go through 1077 01:05:57,772 --> 01:06:31,754 your career and you build up a series of those sort of philosophies. 1078 01:06:31,754 --> 01:06:57,894 And obviously, you can sort of go up the ladder. Whenyou're early 1079 01:03:26,098 --> 01:03:48,484 in your career it might be, what's the philosophy of how to send 1080 01:03:48,484 --> 01:04:10,870 out this email or do this very specific process? As you get further 1081 01:04:10,870 --> 01:04:34,978 along in your career, it could be a philosophy of how you run a 1082 01:04:34,978 --> 01:04:55,642 team, how you run a portfolio, how you build an organization. You 1083 01:04:55,642 --> 01:05:18,028 know, you can't jump straight to that. I think you've got to learn 1084 01:05:18,028 --> 01:05:43,858 how to build it up by thinking that. But it is a different way of 1085 01:05:43,858 --> 01:06:06,244 thinking that sort of, yeah, as I say, shows a bit of curiosity 1086 01:06:06,244 --> 01:06:30,352 but also a bit of agency that you can actually go and own something 1087 01:06:30,352 --> 01:06:51,016 and change something. And that to me, I think, is always differentiated 1088 01:06:51,016 --> 01:06:57,904 and is always impressive. 1089 01:06:59,002 --> 01:07:05,812 Very good. Well, I think that's definitely good advice and 1090 01:07:05,812 --> 01:07:13,303 we should all reflect on our end-of-day emails now and develop 1091 01:07:13,303 --> 01:07:20,794 our philosophy. But thanks very much for coming on, Dan. It's 1092 01:07:20,794 --> 01:07:28,966 great to get that perspective on the DC Pension landscape and the 1093 01:07:28,966 --> 01:07:33,733 tremendous growth in that side as well. Andfor anybody who wants 1094 01:07:02,102 --> 01:07:08,302 to keep abreast of your work, obviously your LinkedIn newsletter, 1095 01:07:08,302 --> 01:07:14,502 I think it's called, Your Thursday Investment Fix, is probably 1096 01:07:14,502 --> 01:07:23,182 the place to find you, but thanks a lot, and from all of us 1097 01:07:23,182 --> 01:07:30,622 here at Top Traders Unplugged, thanks for tuning in. We'll be back 1098 01:07:30,622 --> 01:07:33,722 again soon with more content. 1099 01:07:35,042 --> 01:07:37,946 Thanks for listening to Top Traders Unplugged. If you feel you 1100 01:07:37,946 --> 01:07:40,586 learned something of value from today's episode, the best way 1101 01:07:40,586 --> 01:07:44,282 to stay updated is to go on over to iTunes and subscribe to the 1102 01:07:44,282 --> 01:07:47,978 show so that you'll be sure to get all the new episodes as they're 1103 01:07:47,978 --> 01:07:51,410 released. We have some amazing guests lined up for you, and to ensure 1104 01:07:51,410 --> 01:07:54,314 our show continues to grow, please leave us an honest rating 1105 01:07:54,314 --> 01:07:57,746 and review in iTunes. It only takes a minute, and it's the best 1106 01:07:57,746 --> 01:08:01,178 way to show us you love the podcast. We'll see you next time 1107 01:08:01,178 --> 01:08:02,234 on Top Traders Unplugged.