With reaction and insights to the biggest stories and breaking news from the USA and a little bit of history thrown in, this Is America, A history in the Making.
LiamWelcome to this emergency episode of America, A History in the Making.
LiamIt's just me, Liam, and I wanted to jump on because the point of these episodes is to respond and discuss key events and things that are happening in America right now.
LiamAnd I think it's really important to acknowledge the unfolding story of the plane crash that happened in Washington, D.C.
Liamovernight just a matter of hours ago.
LiamAs I'm recording this now, the current story as we know it is that an American Airlines flight collided in midair with a Black Hawk helicopter over the Potomac River.
LiamThe plane went down, and As I speak, 19 of the 60 bodies that were on board that plane have been recovered.
LiamAs far as we know, no one is alive, but they're still on that recovery exercise to try and get everyone out of the wreckage.
LiamNow, the reason that I feel it's very important to do this episode and talk about this is because we talk a lot on the podcast about politics and in particular, the political division that exists within America.
LiamAnd I think there's a real risk here with stories like this that they can be intensely politicized and we lose sight of the real tragedy that's actually occurred here.
LiamSo allow me first just to read out the post that Donald Trump actually put on Truth Social from himself in response to what's just happened.
LiamSo he.
LiamHe posted, and I quote, the airplane was on a perfect and routine line of approach to the airport.
LiamThe helicopter was going straight at the airplane for an extended period of time.
LiamIt is a capital letters clear night.
LiamThe lights on the plane were blazing.
LiamWhy didn't the helicopter go up or down or turn?
LiamWhy didn't the control tower tell the helicopter what to do instead of asking if they saw the plane?
LiamThis is a bad situation that looks like it should have been prevented.
LiamCapital letters, not good with a bunch of exclamation marks.
LiamNow, we're hardly big supporters of Trump on this podcast, and I think there's a lot of issues here around the way that he puts his messaging out there.
LiamI think in moments like this, perhaps a more formal and scripted approach is probably more tactful.
LiamThat said, the sentiment of his post is something that I think we can all perhaps agree with here.
LiamAnyone that has seen the footage leading up to the crash, certainly it appears to be a very preventable accident.
LiamAnd there will be a lot of questions asked.
LiamThere will be, I would hope, a lot of investigations following what's happening right now to understand exactly what happened and how.
LiamBut here's why I want to talk about this on this episode, because this is where it gets very political.
LiamYou know, we've spoken before about Trump's power, the fact that he will be the most powerful president in history following various Supreme Court rulings that give him more immunity from criminal activity than any other president has had, if it's in the name of national security.
LiamNow, critics, and there will be critics and people that pick this apart will say that looking at the footage and looking at how the helicopter appeared to go straight towards the plane and easily could have diverted.
LiamAnd also considering that helicopters do have a height restriction within a certain radius of the airport that they were allegedly breaching when they collided with the plane.
LiamNow, critics of Trump may conspiracy theorize here that perhaps this wasn't an accident, that perhaps, maybe even Trump had something to do with it, that there were reasons why they wanted to bring that plane down.
LiamMaybe there were people on the plane that he didn't want.
LiamAnd maybe that will all come out.
LiamNow, please acknowledge this is me hypothesizing what some people might start to theorise after this.
LiamNow, it doesn't really help that just a week ago, as reported in the HuffPost and many other news outlets, Donald Trump sent a memo to members of the Aviation Security Advisory Committee saying that as part of, and I quote, a commitment to eliminating the misuse of resources and ensuring that DHS activities prioritise our national security, these advisory committees were essentially being eliminated.
LiamNow, it doesn't actually get rid of all of these people and all of these advisory committees, but what it does do is severely limit their ability to conduct investigations over aviation incidents such as this, which happened merely seven days later.
LiamSo, you know, I'm saying this because to sort of illustrate how there are many factors here at play that can all feed into this conspiracy theory that maybe Trump was involved, that maybe Trump was responsible.
LiamNow, I'm not a supporter of Trump.
LiamYou know this.
LiamI'm a very big critic of him and his policies and his.
LiamHis entire personality.
LiamBut I'm also an optimist.
LiamAnd I do not want to believe, nor will I, and buy into the theory that Trump is responsible for this in any way until there is concrete evidence to suggest that, because, frankly, the scale of this tragedy seems abhorrent to think that someone deliberately orchestrated this for any reason whatsoever, let alone a president.
LiamSo let's just.
LiamLet's just table that for a little while, shall we?
LiamNow, there will obviously be counter arguments coming from the right about this.
LiamAnd over the next few days, as there are calls for investigations which the Democrats have already called for, this will become a very politicized issue.
LiamAnd how exactly this plays out and how this is resolved and the conclusions that are found are anyone's guess.
LiamAnd this is going to take time and no doubt be the cause of endless conversation.
LiamBut I think what's really important here right now, today, as, as, as this rescue mission is still underway and as we're reeling from this tragedy, is to really focus on the fact that there are 60 people on that plane that we potentially have to assume after being, you know, after, after a mid air collision and falling into a freezing river and, and, and hours later still not being recovered, we, we probably have to assume they're not going to be found alive at this point.
LiamIt's an incredibly horrible event.
LiamAnd I think it's times like these when you know, whether you're a podcaster like me, whether you're a politician, just a staunchly political on either side, I think we have to put that just to one side every now and then.
LiamAnd this is one of those moments.
LiamSo this episode I guess isn't really much of a discussion.
LiamIt isn't really much of a, of a debate about the news so much as me pleading to all of you listeners and anyone else to just think that sometimes actually those discussions don't need to happen just yet, that there's a time and a place to think about all of this.
LiamAnd right now I think we have to focus on the recovery.
LiamAnd that's it really.
LiamSo we're going to, no doubt over the months and years that follow this incident, talk about Trump and his administration and even the direction, actions that have come out of this event and what that might mean.
LiamBut today is not the day to do that.
LiamSo my thoughts, and I'm sure anyone that's, that's involved in this podcast right now are thinking about the loss of life and the, the just the, the tragedy of the situation.
LiamI urge you to do the same.
LiamAnd we will, no doubt in time, when it's appropriate, have those discussions that need to be had.
LiamThank you everyone for listening and as always, we'll be back with bonus episodes this Saturday and our main episodes of the podcast every Tuesday.
LiamThank you for continuing to listen and follow support in the show.
LiamReally appreciated.
LiamSo until next time, goodbye.
LiamThanks so much for listening to A history in the making.
LiamIf you enjoyed this show, we're going to leave some extra links in the show notes and if you could leave us a rating and a review wherever you're listening to this, that will bump us up.
LiamThe algorithms help people find us and make us very happy indeed.
LiamYou can also support the show from as little as £1.
LiamJust follow the links on the player or wherever you're listening to this, and for £3amonth you get early access to all of our content, main episodes, bonus content, and a whole lot.
LiamThank you so much for listening and goodbye.