1 00:00:43,140 --> 00:00:46,340 All right, folks, this is Steve with Macro and Cheese. My guest 2 00:00:46,340 --> 00:00:49,540 today is a returning guest. It's been a hot minute. We did some 3 00:00:49,540 --> 00:00:53,620 RP lives with him. We have gotten his book around. We've talked 4 00:00:53,620 --> 00:00:57,180 about it, and we allowed it to, I don't know what you want to 5 00:00:57,180 --> 00:01:00,930 call it, like, seep. We allowed this book to seep like a 6 00:01:00,930 --> 00:01:04,450 good tea. We allowed it to seep and we thought about it. And 7 00:01:04,450 --> 00:01:07,850 we're at a next level with this next conversation. And this 8 00:01:07,850 --> 00:01:12,330 is regarding fiat socialism, achieving the goals of socialism 9 00:01:12,330 --> 00:01:15,930 through modern monetary theory. The author of the book will 10 00:01:15,930 --> 00:01:19,890 be my guest today, Carlos Garcia Hernandez. And Carlos has 11 00:01:19,890 --> 00:01:23,530 been with me several times. Again, we've done RP lives, we've 12 00:01:23,530 --> 00:01:28,890 done podcasts, we've talked behind the scenes. And I think that 13 00:01:28,890 --> 00:01:33,330 he and I are largely aligned. I think there may be some areas where 14 00:01:33,330 --> 00:01:37,890 maybe we don't agree, but I think we're like, in that 95 percentile 15 00:01:37,890 --> 00:01:40,850 where I'm going to say, hot diggity dog, there's somebody I agree 16 00:01:40,850 --> 00:01:44,970 with out there. So with that, the author of the book again is Carlos 17 00:01:44,970 --> 00:01:48,970 Garcia Hernandez. The book is called Fiat Socialism. And now that 18 00:01:48,970 --> 00:01:51,970 we've had a year or so to think about it, and we've talked 19 00:01:51,970 --> 00:01:56,530 to all kinds of different socialist theorists as well, this 20 00:01:56,530 --> 00:02:00,330 is kind of us coming back together and talking through some 21 00:02:00,330 --> 00:02:03,890 of what I consider to be the obvious problems we see in the world 22 00:02:03,890 --> 00:02:09,610 today in achieving any of these kinds of goals. Also understanding 23 00:02:09,610 --> 00:02:13,370 China and some of the other roles of the various countries and 24 00:02:13,690 --> 00:02:17,130 what we can do to make this happen, I mean, I'm beyond the point 25 00:02:17,130 --> 00:02:20,630 of talking about, hey, guys, maybe we can go ahead and vote for 26 00:02:20,630 --> 00:02:24,390 a few more progressives and we'll have a Green New Deal. We already 27 00:02:24,390 --> 00:02:29,270 have seen how capital works to destroy movements. We can pretend 28 00:02:29,270 --> 00:02:32,470 capitalism doesn't exist if that makes you feel better, but then 29 00:02:32,470 --> 00:02:36,150 that means your government hates you. Okay? So that means your 30 00:02:36,150 --> 00:02:39,630 government hates you. But in reality, when you think about it, 31 00:02:39,630 --> 00:02:44,920 your government is in bed, hand in glove with capital and all 32 00:02:44,920 --> 00:02:48,720 the big money makers and the big money shakers out there. The 33 00:02:48,720 --> 00:02:52,440 revolving door in industry, man. Well, we had Bill Black on talking 34 00:02:52,440 --> 00:02:56,640 about the revolving door and all the elite, control fraud and 35 00:02:56,640 --> 00:03:00,440 stuff. Hey, we're just going to go to these institutions and we're 36 00:03:00,440 --> 00:03:02,800 going to put them in jail. We're going to, we're going to go 37 00:03:02,800 --> 00:03:06,680 after them. But these institutions have not once but twice 38 00:03:07,240 --> 00:03:11,800 impeached Donald Trump, have literally giving him a felony. And 39 00:03:11,800 --> 00:03:15,600 the man is the President of the United States right now. If you 40 00:03:15,600 --> 00:03:20,320 still believe in this fake democracy, man, oh man, I want some 41 00:03:20,320 --> 00:03:22,800 of the drugs you're taking because I've taken all the illegal 42 00:03:22,800 --> 00:03:25,960 ones in the past and they never got me there. So I need some 43 00:03:25,960 --> 00:03:28,920 of that other Hopi and weird stuff that people are huffing on 44 00:03:28,920 --> 00:03:31,600 that makes them think that they're going to vote their way out 45 00:03:31,600 --> 00:03:35,640 of this. So without further ado, let me bring home my guest, 46 00:03:36,040 --> 00:03:38,520 Carlos. Welcome to the show, sir. 47 00:03:38,920 --> 00:03:43,000 Thank you very much. It's such a huge pleasure to be with you here. 48 00:03:43,000 --> 00:03:44,920 I thank you very much for this invitation. 49 00:03:45,480 --> 00:03:48,840 Now, be careful. I must have the cooties or something like that, 50 00:03:49,080 --> 00:03:52,880 because I'm saying tough things. And I know that most people 51 00:03:52,880 --> 00:03:56,840 within the MMT space are extremely careful. They still believe 52 00:03:56,840 --> 00:04:01,120 in institutions, they still believe in the politicians that can 53 00:04:01,120 --> 00:04:06,120 make these things happen. And I think that's where my nearly 15 54 00:04:06,200 --> 00:04:10,200 years of advocacy for modern monetary theory has a little bit 55 00:04:10,200 --> 00:04:14,120 of a rupture, because I can't stand thinking of Joe Biden sticking 56 00:04:14,120 --> 00:04:18,040 the landing after calling people illegals and sitting there 57 00:04:18,040 --> 00:04:22,120 committing a genocide in Gaza. There's just too many differences. 58 00:04:22,280 --> 00:04:26,680 I just don't know how to fix that gap. And this book that you've 59 00:04:26,680 --> 00:04:29,960 written, while I'm not going to say I don't agree with it because 60 00:04:29,960 --> 00:04:33,880 I think I agree with it more than not. But I want to ferret through 61 00:04:33,880 --> 00:04:37,440 some of these ideas, and we talked about it offline, and I really 62 00:04:37,440 --> 00:04:40,480 appreciate your candor. I really appreciate the fact that you 63 00:04:40,480 --> 00:04:45,720 see things pretty clearly with that. Carlos, what do you think is 64 00:04:45,720 --> 00:04:51,360 the main barrier to us achieving any form of socialism? 65 00:04:51,360 --> 00:04:54,680 Any form of progress, really? I mean, you're talking about fiat 66 00:04:54,680 --> 00:04:59,880 socialism here, but where we are today is just 100% unadulterated 67 00:05:00,410 --> 00:05:04,970 finance capitalism on steroids with a dose of fascism to keep us 68 00:05:04,970 --> 00:05:08,530 in line, xenophobia to freaking make everybody scared to 69 00:05:08,530 --> 00:05:12,810 come out of their houses and a bunch of militarized police to terrorize 70 00:05:12,810 --> 00:05:17,530 people, especially university students, etc. I see a whole bunch 71 00:05:17,530 --> 00:05:20,930 of hate, I see a whole bunch of fascism, and I don't see a whole 72 00:05:20,930 --> 00:05:25,490 lot of this vaunted democracy that everybody swears about literally 73 00:05:25,490 --> 00:05:30,040 will not Even engage with you when you bring up Gillens and Page 74 00:05:30,200 --> 00:05:35,800 the Princeton study that shows there is 0.0% impact on public policy 75 00:05:36,040 --> 00:05:39,560 for what the working class wants. It is literally only the elite, 76 00:05:39,560 --> 00:05:43,080 the wealthy that have any sway your thoughts? 77 00:05:43,800 --> 00:05:48,520 Well, in my opinion the answer is very clear. The main obstacle 78 00:05:48,520 --> 00:05:52,120 we have for a socialist transformation of society is the 79 00:05:52,120 --> 00:05:58,510 knowledge about how economy works, especially the monetary production 80 00:05:58,510 --> 00:06:02,870 economies we live in. You know, so basically understanding 81 00:06:02,870 --> 00:06:07,670 what money is, I think that the majority of the population doesn't 82 00:06:07,670 --> 00:06:11,550 understand. And that is exactly what modern monetary theory 83 00:06:11,550 --> 00:06:17,510 does. It explains how monetary production economies work. I really 84 00:06:17,510 --> 00:06:22,740 think that if the population would understand how it really works, 85 00:06:22,740 --> 00:06:29,020 what money is and what does it imply, I think that everything else 86 00:06:29,020 --> 00:06:34,260 would very much be a very little problem. We would find a way 87 00:06:34,260 --> 00:06:38,860 out. Absolutely. The problem is that there is a very big misconception 88 00:06:38,860 --> 00:06:42,780 about what money is and how the economy works. I think that is 89 00:06:42,780 --> 00:06:43,460 the main problem. 90 00:06:43,940 --> 00:06:47,700 So I want to throw a structural problem at you. The nature 91 00:06:47,700 --> 00:06:53,260 of capitalism and the nature of institutions. Gramsci, when he 92 00:06:53,260 --> 00:06:58,180 spoke of institutions, talked about the cultural hegemon, the hegemonic 93 00:06:58,180 --> 00:07:01,980 thought, the fact that institutions are a representation 94 00:07:02,300 --> 00:07:06,500 of the ruling class. So all of the institutions that make up the 95 00:07:06,500 --> 00:07:12,300 things we think we know are guided directly by the elite institution 96 00:07:12,300 --> 00:07:16,560 makers, those folks that raise run the country, the oligarchy. And 97 00:07:16,560 --> 00:07:21,120 all fingers and all facts and all signs point to the fact that 98 00:07:21,120 --> 00:07:24,520 the United States, and I'm using the US only right now, because 99 00:07:24,520 --> 00:07:28,800 we're an empire and we have direct impact on the global South. 100 00:07:28,800 --> 00:07:33,320 We have a direct impact, as you see, in Europe, the vassalization 101 00:07:33,400 --> 00:07:38,400 of Europe to the United States interests, et cetera. And within 102 00:07:38,400 --> 00:07:42,720 that oligarchy, within that elite group of people that are running 103 00:07:42,720 --> 00:07:47,140 around with AI and weaponizing nanobots and I mean literally domestic 104 00:07:47,140 --> 00:07:50,820 spying, literally the turning of the Department of Defense into 105 00:07:51,460 --> 00:07:56,380 domestic terror group. Really at this point, I don't know how you 106 00:07:56,380 --> 00:08:02,820 overcome that hegemony, that absolute iron fist of control that 107 00:08:02,820 --> 00:08:07,380 the oligarchy has without a rupture, without some sort of tipping 108 00:08:07,380 --> 00:08:11,460 point for the people. You think just teaching them about modern 109 00:08:11,460 --> 00:08:16,550 monetary theory will fix voting? How will their knowledge 110 00:08:16,550 --> 00:08:20,990 of MMT help them overcome those structural barriers? 111 00:08:21,710 --> 00:08:25,630 I think that if people understood economy and understood 112 00:08:25,630 --> 00:08:30,870 mmt, we would find a way out of the rest of the problems. That's 113 00:08:30,870 --> 00:08:34,510 why I say it is the main problem. I don't mean it is the only 114 00:08:34,510 --> 00:08:40,940 problem. I agree with you that in my opinion the big hope for humanity 115 00:08:41,260 --> 00:08:46,300 is not in the West. In my opinion, the big Hope for humanity 116 00:08:46,620 --> 00:08:51,100 is absolutely outside of the West. I think that the European Union, 117 00:08:51,900 --> 00:08:57,860 NATO and the United States is absolutely rotten to the core. I 118 00:08:57,860 --> 00:09:02,740 feel that this is an ending empire. And I think that we have 119 00:09:02,740 --> 00:09:06,300 to look outside of the European Union and the United States 120 00:09:06,850 --> 00:09:11,410 to find a little bit of hope. I am a big defender of what is going 121 00:09:11,410 --> 00:09:16,130 on with the brics. I come from Spain. I have defended it publicly. 122 00:09:16,370 --> 00:09:20,130 I think that the best way to vote would be to leave the European 123 00:09:20,130 --> 00:09:25,890 Union and to join brics, and of course, by all means leave NATO, 124 00:09:26,130 --> 00:09:30,330 which is the biggest terrorist organization in the history of the 125 00:09:30,330 --> 00:09:35,630 humankind. But that is a another sphere. I think that we have 126 00:09:35,630 --> 00:09:41,190 to differentiate about three different spheres. First is our program, 127 00:09:41,510 --> 00:09:46,350 the goals we want to have. That is our final goals. And we have 128 00:09:46,350 --> 00:09:51,430 to differentiate that from the strategy and the tactics. That is 129 00:09:51,430 --> 00:09:56,590 exactly what Gramsci also told us. We have a strategy, we have tactics, 130 00:09:56,590 --> 00:10:02,140 and then we have our final program. So I think that depending 131 00:10:02,140 --> 00:10:07,220 on where you are, it's not the same to be in Belarus or to be in 132 00:10:07,220 --> 00:10:11,740 China, or to be Russia or to be in the United States or Spain. 133 00:10:12,140 --> 00:10:16,540 Depending on where you are, you have to find the right strategy 134 00:10:16,540 --> 00:10:21,060 and the right tactics to get to your goals. And the goals, in 135 00:10:21,060 --> 00:10:25,980 my opinion, should always be the same. And those goals are socialism. 136 00:10:26,300 --> 00:10:32,740 Now, why do I propose a new way of understanding what socialism 137 00:10:32,740 --> 00:10:37,260 is? I propose a new way because in my opinion we have to 138 00:10:37,260 --> 00:10:43,180 follow the idea defended by David Greber when he talks about 139 00:10:43,340 --> 00:10:48,740 baseline communism. But we can find in my book Fiat Socialism, and 140 00:10:48,740 --> 00:10:54,020 I talk about it extensively. The book is a version of what David 141 00:10:54,020 --> 00:10:58,060 Greber calls baseline communism. What is the difference 142 00:10:58,060 --> 00:11:02,740 between this kind of communism and the communism we used to have 143 00:11:02,740 --> 00:11:06,580 at the beginning of the 20th century? Well, the main idea is that 144 00:11:06,740 --> 00:11:10,660 socialism or communism, I don't really differentiate a lot 145 00:11:10,980 --> 00:11:15,220 between these two words. The main idea is not the property of 146 00:11:15,220 --> 00:11:19,620 the means of production, but the access to products and services. 147 00:11:20,510 --> 00:11:25,150 So the main question is who has access to what and under what 148 00:11:25,150 --> 00:11:30,750 condition. The size of the private sector could and should be 149 00:11:31,150 --> 00:11:36,070 decided democratically. And it should be the size that we decide 150 00:11:36,070 --> 00:11:41,790 is socially useful. And I defend this idea in my book saying 151 00:11:41,870 --> 00:11:47,310 that the law of the tendency of profit to fall, defended by Marx 152 00:11:47,310 --> 00:11:52,360 in the third book of the Capital, is wrong there. What he 153 00:11:52,360 --> 00:11:58,600 wants to prove is that if you allow the private sector to be bigger 154 00:11:58,600 --> 00:12:03,880 than merely families, your system is going to collapse. And 155 00:12:03,880 --> 00:12:09,200 the way he defends this idea is through commodity based money. 156 00:12:09,600 --> 00:12:17,050 For him, money was gold or silver always and in my opinion, 157 00:12:17,050 --> 00:12:21,530 that is absolutely wrong. What modern monetary theory teaches us 158 00:12:21,530 --> 00:12:26,490 is that money is not a commodity. Money is typing in the 159 00:12:27,610 --> 00:12:32,530 Excel files of their central bank. It's not a commodity. And that 160 00:12:32,530 --> 00:12:37,450 is why you can have private enterprise. And that doesn't mean 161 00:12:37,530 --> 00:12:42,750 that your system is doomed to collapse. And I also talk about how 162 00:12:42,990 --> 00:12:48,990 the 20th century have proven this. Only when the governments were 163 00:12:49,070 --> 00:12:53,430 absolutely incapable of running the economy, like was the 164 00:12:53,430 --> 00:12:58,910 case in China and in Russia and in Germany, the system collapsed. 165 00:12:59,230 --> 00:13:05,630 If you had some things, like for example, the New Deal or K mechanism, 166 00:13:06,030 --> 00:13:10,110 the system that allows private enterprise doesn't have to collapse. 167 00:13:10,370 --> 00:13:14,610 And that is a fact. That is a fact that this prophecy which says 168 00:13:14,610 --> 00:13:19,170 that if you allow private enterprise to have a room and to 169 00:13:19,170 --> 00:13:23,770 exist means that your economic system is going to collapse, is not 170 00:13:23,770 --> 00:13:27,210 true. It's not true. So in that sense, I think that we have 171 00:13:27,210 --> 00:13:32,930 to move forward from that prophecy that we find in Marx's work 172 00:13:33,170 --> 00:13:39,260 and go more towards what David Greber called baseline communism. 173 00:13:39,420 --> 00:13:43,460 Who has access to what and under what conditions? And that is 174 00:13:43,460 --> 00:13:47,780 exactly what I explained in my book. And I think that is the main 175 00:13:47,780 --> 00:13:52,340 question. The size of the private sector should be the size 176 00:13:52,340 --> 00:13:57,580 that we consider socially useful. That could also mean that 177 00:13:57,580 --> 00:14:03,070 we get rid of private enterprise. Absolutely. Because we 178 00:14:03,070 --> 00:14:07,990 have, for example, in the West, a reactionary bourgeoisie that 179 00:14:07,990 --> 00:14:12,630 doesn't allow at all any kind of social progress, any kind of social 180 00:14:12,710 --> 00:14:18,150 transformation, and is very much ready to kill anybody who tries 181 00:14:18,150 --> 00:14:22,750 to bring forward socialist policies, then you might very well 182 00:14:22,750 --> 00:14:27,270 say, well, you know what? In this moment of this historical period, 183 00:14:27,840 --> 00:14:31,440 we are going to get rid of private enterprise because it is 184 00:14:31,440 --> 00:14:36,320 not socially useful. Again, we have to have different strategies, 185 00:14:36,320 --> 00:14:40,560 different tactics, depending on where we are. But the main idea 186 00:14:40,560 --> 00:14:45,520 is that if you allow the private enterprise to exist, that 187 00:14:45,520 --> 00:14:50,240 doesn't mean that your system will have to collapse. That is the 188 00:14:50,240 --> 00:14:51,200 main idea. 189 00:14:52,240 --> 00:14:57,230 I think we can look at China and see for certain exactly when 190 00:14:57,310 --> 00:15:03,870 the state decides it's within its best interest to allow a private 191 00:15:04,030 --> 00:15:10,390 sector role. But make no mistake, if she decides, or democratic 192 00:15:10,390 --> 00:15:14,950 centralism of sorts, I mean, if they decide that it doesn't serve 193 00:15:14,950 --> 00:15:16,990 their purpose, it's gone. 194 00:15:17,310 --> 00:15:18,190 Absolutely. 195 00:15:18,430 --> 00:15:22,470 Wealthy people decide that they want to screw the workers over 196 00:15:22,470 --> 00:15:27,600 or hurt whatever, they will be killed, they will be imprisoned, 197 00:15:27,760 --> 00:15:31,640 something will happen. It will not just be, ah, it's too big to 198 00:15:31,640 --> 00:15:32,880 fail, you know. 199 00:15:32,960 --> 00:15:33,720 Absolutely. 200 00:15:33,720 --> 00:15:36,720 I just want to make it clear because there's an element to me 201 00:15:36,720 --> 00:15:41,920 that sees a lot of folks very willing to pretend, I mean, cosplay 202 00:15:41,920 --> 00:15:46,600 a Democracy, cosplay, that we can do these things. But in reality 203 00:15:46,600 --> 00:15:51,490 none of these situations currently exist. And I'm looking 204 00:15:51,490 --> 00:15:56,930 at Europe even. I mean Europe is under the gun of neoliberal elites. 205 00:15:57,090 --> 00:15:57,730 Absolutely. 206 00:15:58,050 --> 00:16:01,530 It is in no way, shape or form a democratic society. And I feel 207 00:16:01,530 --> 00:16:04,850 bad because I see a lot of good people I care a great deal about 208 00:16:05,570 --> 00:16:09,170 acting like they can vote their way out of this. And occasionally 209 00:16:09,170 --> 00:16:12,450 there'll be this random politician that will pop up out of 210 00:16:12,450 --> 00:16:17,320 the blue. And we had a guy here who, you know, retired the minute 211 00:16:17,320 --> 00:16:22,480 he acknowledged mmt and that's it. The rest of the politicians here, 212 00:16:22,480 --> 00:16:26,280 and I believe my personal beliefs, I believe it's a big old 213 00:16:26,280 --> 00:16:30,320 theater. I believe that the ruling elites don't really care about 214 00:16:30,320 --> 00:16:34,760 government. Government serves as a means of manufacturing consent 215 00:16:35,160 --> 00:16:39,640 and it literally pushes the agenda of those elites. I don't get 216 00:16:39,640 --> 00:16:42,760 emotional about their stuff anymore, I don't really follow their 217 00:16:42,760 --> 00:16:47,170 stuff anymore because each time there's always a parliamentarian 218 00:16:47,170 --> 00:16:50,690 around the corner or a rotating villain to snatch the ball 219 00:16:50,690 --> 00:16:54,210 away from Charlie Brown right when he goes to kick the field goal. 220 00:16:54,610 --> 00:16:59,490 So as far as I'm concerned, there needs to be a revolutionary 221 00:16:59,570 --> 00:17:03,770 vanguard of some sort. There needs to be some form of group of 222 00:17:03,770 --> 00:17:07,810 people that are not mealy mouth, are not seeking access politics, 223 00:17:08,210 --> 00:17:11,410 are not sitting there pretending like these folks are good 224 00:17:11,410 --> 00:17:16,759 people and this system itself is ripe to fail. This system itself, 225 00:17:16,759 --> 00:17:20,559 the only reason why it doesn't fail is because they've got guns, 226 00:17:20,559 --> 00:17:25,599 they've got weapons, they have got the power of fascism using these 227 00:17:25,759 --> 00:17:30,719 techniques to silence and squelch and diminish what the working 228 00:17:30,719 --> 00:17:34,839 class could ever achieve. And with that I see people that will 229 00:17:34,839 --> 00:17:39,170 defend capital and make excuses for the elites. And I fundamentally 230 00:17:39,170 --> 00:17:42,850 don't understand it. Obviously each country is different, but you 231 00:17:42,850 --> 00:17:45,610 live in Europe, you already know. What do you think it would 232 00:17:45,610 --> 00:17:50,170 take for you guys to break free from that neoliberal stranglehold? 233 00:17:50,650 --> 00:17:55,050 I mean the cultural hegemony that allowed everybody to believe 234 00:17:55,130 --> 00:18:00,210 that system was good, pretty damn strong. The vast majority of 235 00:18:00,210 --> 00:18:04,220 people didn't take the time to learn about anything and just bobbleheaded 236 00:18:04,220 --> 00:18:07,500 along and went along with it. What are your thoughts on how you 237 00:18:07,500 --> 00:18:10,940 would even bring that to be beyond the United States? And then 238 00:18:10,940 --> 00:18:13,700 we can talk about how empire might have a say in that too. 239 00:18:14,260 --> 00:18:18,580 Again, I think that the key point is that people understand how 240 00:18:18,820 --> 00:18:23,180 the economy works. I think that is the main point. I mean, going 241 00:18:23,180 --> 00:18:27,620 back to strategy and program, I think that what you are really 242 00:18:27,620 --> 00:18:32,040 saying or that is the way I Understand, it is that we need a 243 00:18:32,040 --> 00:18:38,840 political sphere that is above the economic sphere, that has the 244 00:18:38,840 --> 00:18:43,480 ruling part of the total economy. I mean, it cannot be that 245 00:18:43,800 --> 00:18:48,160 economic powers control the political powers. It has to be the 246 00:18:48,160 --> 00:18:52,240 other way around, just like it happens in China. In China, there 247 00:18:52,240 --> 00:18:56,600 is a political sphere that controls the economy, not the other 248 00:18:56,600 --> 00:19:00,840 way around. The other way around is what happens in the European 249 00:19:00,840 --> 00:19:05,280 Union and the United States. There, the economic sphere, meaning 250 00:19:05,280 --> 00:19:09,840 the oligarchy, controls the political sphere. The political sphere 251 00:19:09,840 --> 00:19:15,320 is under or below the economic sphere. And that is the main problem. 252 00:19:15,800 --> 00:19:20,520 We always have to have a political sphere which is independent 253 00:19:21,000 --> 00:19:26,290 from the economic oligarchy that decides what to do and what 254 00:19:26,290 --> 00:19:30,490 not to do. And that is, in my opinion, the main idea. The main 255 00:19:30,490 --> 00:19:34,770 idea is that politics should be above the oligarchy always. 256 00:19:35,730 --> 00:19:38,490 So let's examine that, because I agree with you. I believe that 257 00:19:38,490 --> 00:19:41,490 oligarchy should be eradicated. Let me be on record, 258 00:19:41,490 --> 00:19:46,210 if I'm not already on record. That said, how would you go about 259 00:19:46,850 --> 00:19:51,770 making that happen? And then I want to get into more of an MMT angle 260 00:19:51,770 --> 00:19:56,000 here, but go ahead and tell me your mind, because I think people 261 00:19:56,000 --> 00:20:01,120 genuinely think that once we talk about mmt, they slap an I voted 262 00:20:01,120 --> 00:20:04,160 sticker on their forehead and they think somehow or another miracles 263 00:20:04,160 --> 00:20:04,880 are going to happen. 264 00:20:05,520 --> 00:20:09,680 Well, in a way, I am more pessimist than you are. I mean, you 265 00:20:09,680 --> 00:20:13,320 say, well, the reason why they survive and the reason why they can 266 00:20:13,320 --> 00:20:16,760 do whatever they want is because they have the Arabs and they 267 00:20:16,760 --> 00:20:20,840 have the military and they have the army. Which is true. But 268 00:20:20,840 --> 00:20:25,440 in my opinion, the reality is sadder than that. It's more sad than 269 00:20:25,440 --> 00:20:29,720 that. In my opinion, they also have the majority of the population. 270 00:20:30,120 --> 00:20:34,800 I mean, they have the minds and hearts of almost everybody. I 271 00:20:34,800 --> 00:20:39,760 mean, seeing what the people think in Spain or in Germany, the 272 00:20:39,760 --> 00:20:44,560 two countries where I live, think about, for example, what's 273 00:20:44,560 --> 00:20:49,230 going on in Ukraine or what's going on in Palestine, not so much 274 00:20:49,230 --> 00:20:53,150 in Spain, but in Germany. It's really heartbreaking. They have been 275 00:20:53,150 --> 00:20:58,070 brainwashed to the point that they cannot really see what the reality 276 00:20:58,070 --> 00:21:02,150 is. So it is not only that they have the arms and they have 277 00:21:02,150 --> 00:21:06,470 the army, they also have the hearts and minds of the majority 278 00:21:06,470 --> 00:21:10,790 of the population. And why is that? Well, it's because the economic 279 00:21:10,950 --> 00:21:15,230 system that we live in doesn't allow the majority of the people 280 00:21:15,230 --> 00:21:20,270 to understand very basic things that the MMT really explains. 281 00:21:20,270 --> 00:21:25,510 For example, taxes don't fund public spending. This is very little 282 00:21:25,510 --> 00:21:29,310 information. This is very few bytes of information. Well, good 283 00:21:29,310 --> 00:21:32,910 luck. If you Try to explain that to the majority of the population. 284 00:21:33,390 --> 00:21:37,630 You can say that, you can explain that, you can clarify what 285 00:21:37,710 --> 00:21:42,530 MMT means, and you can put all the evidence on the table. They will 286 00:21:42,530 --> 00:21:47,530 not believe it. They will defend to the very bitter end that 287 00:21:47,530 --> 00:21:51,490 you have to collect taxes if you want to spend. Not even this 288 00:21:51,490 --> 00:21:55,210 very little piece of information comes through, not even 289 00:21:55,370 --> 00:21:59,490 the most basic things of economic activity gets through the 290 00:21:59,490 --> 00:22:03,530 school. And that is, in my opinion, the biggest problem we have. 291 00:22:03,610 --> 00:22:07,370 Because if they could understand this, if they could understand 292 00:22:07,370 --> 00:22:12,330 these basics, everything after that is pretty simple. Once you understand 293 00:22:12,410 --> 00:22:16,330 this, it's pretty simple to understand that unemployment and 294 00:22:16,330 --> 00:22:20,530 Spain is the country in the European Union with the highest unemployment 295 00:22:20,530 --> 00:22:25,690 rate. Unemployment is a monetary phenomenon. It depends on 296 00:22:25,690 --> 00:22:30,010 how much the government is willing to spend on national currency. 297 00:22:30,730 --> 00:22:37,050 That is what unemployment is. So the governments that are monetary 298 00:22:37,130 --> 00:22:42,330 sovereign decide what level of unemployment they will have in their 299 00:22:42,330 --> 00:22:46,930 economies because they can always hire everybody that doesn't 300 00:22:46,930 --> 00:22:49,130 have a job in national currency. 301 00:22:49,930 --> 00:22:52,810 Let me ask you this real quick, because this is where class, 302 00:22:53,210 --> 00:22:57,290 in my opinion, kicks in. And a lot of people ignore clas. And I 303 00:22:57,290 --> 00:23:00,720 noticed it online, a lot of people try to say that, no, no, I 304 00:23:00,720 --> 00:23:04,760 got a class lens. I really do, honest to goodness. And it's just 305 00:23:04,760 --> 00:23:10,120 simply not a class analysis that I see. You know, really, in 306 00:23:10,280 --> 00:23:15,560 fairness, the class interests of the elite, the bourgeois, the 307 00:23:15,960 --> 00:23:20,920 ruling class, their interests are not about making everybody happy 308 00:23:20,920 --> 00:23:25,920 and whole. Their interests are in fact, power and control. And, 309 00:23:26,150 --> 00:23:29,990 and at the end of the day, I mean, we've seen here recently the 310 00:23:29,990 --> 00:23:33,710 evidence of this through the global phenomenon known as Jeffrey 311 00:23:33,710 --> 00:23:38,630 Epstein and all the elites and all the money movers, even our famous 312 00:23:38,630 --> 00:23:43,910 Noam Chomsky, who is a famous anti communist and also pedophile 313 00:23:43,990 --> 00:23:49,870 defender, the idea of a job guarantee and the idea of us being 314 00:23:49,870 --> 00:23:54,640 able to spend to eradicate poverty and to eradicate joblessness 315 00:23:54,640 --> 00:23:58,640 and to stabilize the lives of people, well, that's in the class 316 00:23:58,720 --> 00:24:02,320 interest of working class people. But working class people 317 00:24:02,320 --> 00:24:06,880 aren't at the top and their interests are not being represented. 318 00:24:06,880 --> 00:24:12,840 I think this is a major divide here in terms of beyond going, you 319 00:24:12,840 --> 00:24:16,040 know, to say, hey, you know, we can do these things. Of course 320 00:24:16,040 --> 00:24:20,930 we can. Of course we could do those things. But the class interest 321 00:24:20,930 --> 00:24:25,290 of the people making those decisions is not to make us happy, 322 00:24:25,290 --> 00:24:26,250 healthy and whole. 323 00:24:26,330 --> 00:24:29,370 The problem is worse than that. It's not that the interest 324 00:24:29,450 --> 00:24:33,329 of the working class is not being defended. The problem is that 325 00:24:33,329 --> 00:24:37,850 the working class is not demanding its rights to be defended. 326 00:24:38,090 --> 00:24:43,690 That is the problem. They have sided with their masters. And that 327 00:24:43,690 --> 00:24:49,290 is the main problem. I mean, the day that they discover that we 328 00:24:49,290 --> 00:24:53,970 can all have a society without unemployment and without poverty 329 00:24:54,130 --> 00:24:58,130 and with very nice standards for everybody and with permanent 330 00:24:58,130 --> 00:25:02,330 full employment, the day that they understand it, everything will 331 00:25:02,330 --> 00:25:07,650 be very easy. The problem is that the bad guys win when they are 332 00:25:07,650 --> 00:25:11,020 more than the good guys. It's always like that. It's like in a 333 00:25:11,020 --> 00:25:14,980 movie. If the bad guys are outnumbered, the good guys, they 334 00:25:14,980 --> 00:25:19,620 win. They win. The question is, when the working class understands 335 00:25:19,700 --> 00:25:24,100 how society works and how the economic system works, it's over. 336 00:25:24,180 --> 00:25:24,740 It's over. 337 00:25:25,380 --> 00:25:28,980 Well, Carlos, let me pause there, because I agree with you in 338 00:25:28,980 --> 00:25:34,420 principle. But the actual network of information that we are 339 00:25:34,420 --> 00:25:38,210 all prey to, I mean, we all live on social media. I mean, there 340 00:25:38,210 --> 00:25:42,610 is this snobbery that goes into not sharing people's stuff, 341 00:25:42,610 --> 00:25:46,490 which is just revolting to me. But there's a deeper one than that, 342 00:25:46,490 --> 00:25:51,930 and that is that the rich, these elite people, these sickos 343 00:25:51,930 --> 00:25:57,610 like the guys at Palantir and guys at Oracle, these folks own TikTok, 344 00:25:57,610 --> 00:26:02,010 they own Facebook, they own Amazon, they own Netflix, they own 345 00:26:02,090 --> 00:26:05,330 all the different movie outlets, they own the radio waves, 346 00:26:05,330 --> 00:26:10,630 they own everything. And then these freemium services like Substack, 347 00:26:10,630 --> 00:26:15,390 which I love, they are also there to do the devil's work, if 348 00:26:15,390 --> 00:26:19,590 you will, for these elites. This is not like conspiracy. I mean, 349 00:26:19,590 --> 00:26:24,390 they've narrowed it down to where I think five people own almost 350 00:26:24,470 --> 00:26:28,230 all of the media that there is. So the way people get taught, 351 00:26:28,630 --> 00:26:32,350 the way people hear information, is directly impacted 352 00:26:32,350 --> 00:26:35,230 by that. And then we've got this weirdo group that's the tone 353 00:26:35,230 --> 00:26:38,520 police that runs around scolding folks, trying to remind 354 00:26:38,520 --> 00:26:42,560 them to be polite. And so within this space, we have got a 355 00:26:42,560 --> 00:26:48,240 horrible gap between the desire to change the world and the 356 00:26:48,240 --> 00:26:52,880 ability to change minds. And being able to get this information 357 00:26:53,120 --> 00:26:57,480 in front of people is not just a desire. I mean, I put in 24 by 358 00:26:57,480 --> 00:27:02,200 7 trying. And a lot of the folks I work with put the same amount 359 00:27:02,200 --> 00:27:05,790 of time in themselves, and they're frustrated because their 360 00:27:05,790 --> 00:27:08,830 work doesn't get noticed. It doesn't get out there. The people 361 00:27:08,830 --> 00:27:12,310 that are supposed to be fellow travelers can't be bothered to share 362 00:27:12,310 --> 00:27:16,030 their work, can't be bothered to comment, can't be bothered to 363 00:27:16,110 --> 00:27:20,870 give algorithm feeding likes and so forth. Whether it be Substack, 364 00:27:20,870 --> 00:27:23,710 whether it be Twitter, whether it be Facebook, whether it be Instagram, 365 00:27:23,790 --> 00:27:28,190 wherever it is that we have pathways to get information out there, 366 00:27:28,510 --> 00:27:32,800 there's a weird resistance to doing the thing that is necessary 367 00:27:32,800 --> 00:27:37,080 to make that happen. I don't see the willingness of the people 368 00:27:37,080 --> 00:27:40,840 that do know this stuff to actually say, hey, it's really important 369 00:27:40,840 --> 00:27:45,280 that I share this stuff. And I also don't see the actual ability 370 00:27:45,280 --> 00:27:50,000 within their system to overcome their system. I'm looking 371 00:27:50,000 --> 00:27:53,280 for a path, man. I'm like in a. In a maze, and I'm looking for 372 00:27:53,440 --> 00:27:57,740 doorway that gets out of the maze. And, you know, it's like that 373 00:27:57,740 --> 00:28:00,780 saying, we're both in the maze. How do we get to the cheese? 374 00:28:01,420 --> 00:28:05,820 How do you get past all of the barricades to knowledge transfer? 375 00:28:06,220 --> 00:28:10,620 I mean, we've got almost 400 podcasts, all of which are the best 376 00:28:10,620 --> 00:28:16,300 and brightest of mmt, of social theory of history, you name 377 00:28:16,300 --> 00:28:21,740 it. And we struggle mightily to get that word out there. How do 378 00:28:21,740 --> 00:28:22,220 you do it? 379 00:28:22,710 --> 00:28:26,110 If I could answer that question, I mean, I hope I could 380 00:28:26,110 --> 00:28:30,070 answer that question. But I think we can say that, number one, 381 00:28:30,070 --> 00:28:34,950 in the west, their strategy, coming back to the difference between 382 00:28:35,030 --> 00:28:38,870 program and strategy, their strategy has been very successful. 383 00:28:39,190 --> 00:28:43,230 They have brainwashed most of the population. So their strategy 384 00:28:43,230 --> 00:28:46,950 in order to defend their privilege has been very successful. 385 00:28:47,350 --> 00:28:50,870 That is, number one. Number two, the situation is very difficult. 386 00:28:51,110 --> 00:28:55,430 There is no magic balance. I mean, if we say, oh, we have found 387 00:28:55,430 --> 00:28:59,030 the solution and now we just have to go through it, and the solution 388 00:28:59,030 --> 00:29:02,790 is going to be very hard, the solution is going to be very painful, 389 00:29:02,950 --> 00:29:06,630 and the solution is going to take a long time. That is, number 390 00:29:06,630 --> 00:29:10,870 two. And number three, we have to look at things from other perspectives. 391 00:29:11,350 --> 00:29:15,590 If you live in the United States, it's very reasonable to have 392 00:29:15,590 --> 00:29:19,150 the opinion that you have. But things don't look like that if you 393 00:29:19,150 --> 00:29:23,030 are in Belarus or if you are in Russia, or if you are in China, 394 00:29:23,190 --> 00:29:27,870 or if you are in North Korea, or if you are somewhere in the BRICs, 395 00:29:27,870 --> 00:29:31,070 or even if you are in the developing countries that are getting 396 00:29:31,070 --> 00:29:35,390 closer and closer to the BRICs. This kind of rhetoric from 397 00:29:35,390 --> 00:29:40,510 the west is not selling anymore in Africa. Africa is putting 398 00:29:40,510 --> 00:29:45,290 out the colonial powers. It is not selling in lots and lots of countries 399 00:29:45,370 --> 00:29:49,610 in South America, you know, so we have to look at those countries 400 00:29:49,850 --> 00:29:55,610 outside of the horror that the west has become and start working 401 00:29:55,610 --> 00:29:56,170 with them. 402 00:29:57,690 --> 00:30:01,850 You are listening to Macro N Cheese, a podcast by Real Progressives. 403 00:30:02,170 --> 00:30:07,330 We are a 501c3 nonprofit organization. All donations are tax 404 00:30:07,330 --> 00:30:11,460 deductible. Plea consider becoming a monthly donor on Patreon 405 00:30:11,780 --> 00:30:16,020 Substack or our website, realprogressives.org now back to 406 00:30:16,020 --> 00:30:16,180 the podcast. 407 00:30:20,420 --> 00:30:25,300 I think we have to work much more closely with the political forces 408 00:30:25,300 --> 00:30:29,780 of China, the political forces of Russia and the political forces 409 00:30:29,780 --> 00:30:34,580 of Africa, for example. Tauri I think we have to join forces with 410 00:30:34,580 --> 00:30:39,800 them and come up with a new strategy that defeats the strategy 411 00:30:39,800 --> 00:30:44,520 that the oligarchy is actually implementing in the west that is 412 00:30:44,520 --> 00:30:49,440 stopping any kind of change in the socialist endeavor. And that 413 00:30:49,440 --> 00:30:52,720 is what we have to do. We have to talk to Russia, we have to talk 414 00:30:52,720 --> 00:30:56,720 to China, we have to talk to the developing countries in South 415 00:30:56,720 --> 00:31:01,320 America and in Africa. And together we have to find a new strategy 416 00:31:01,810 --> 00:31:05,450 that is better than the strategy that the oligarchy in the 417 00:31:05,450 --> 00:31:11,290 west is currently using and that is outnumbering us. People don't 418 00:31:11,290 --> 00:31:16,930 see in China or in Russia or anywhere else an alternative to the 419 00:31:17,010 --> 00:31:21,410 economic system that we have in the West. As horrible as it is 420 00:31:21,490 --> 00:31:26,250 and as bad as it sounds, people just don't see it. And this 421 00:31:26,250 --> 00:31:29,200 is not to say that the economic system and the political 422 00:31:29,360 --> 00:31:33,280 system in the BRIC countries is wonderful. I don't think so. I 423 00:31:33,280 --> 00:31:36,600 think they also have a lot of problems. I think China has a lot 424 00:31:36,600 --> 00:31:39,360 of problems. There are many things that the Chinese government 425 00:31:39,360 --> 00:31:42,480 does that I don't like. There are many things that the Russian 426 00:31:42,480 --> 00:31:46,480 government does that I don't like. But I think that the economic 427 00:31:46,640 --> 00:31:50,960 model and the political model that they are implementing is much 428 00:31:50,960 --> 00:31:55,820 better because they have a political sphere that controls the 429 00:31:55,820 --> 00:31:59,860 economic sphere. It is the political powers, the democratic 430 00:32:00,020 --> 00:32:03,860 political powers of those countries that control the oligarchy. 431 00:32:03,860 --> 00:32:07,580 The oligarchy cannot do anything without the approval of 432 00:32:07,580 --> 00:32:10,619 the political sphere because they know that the next day they 433 00:32:10,619 --> 00:32:14,820 will be outed. That's it. If the government decides that you are 434 00:32:14,820 --> 00:32:18,900 not socially useful, you are out, you disappear. And that is the 435 00:32:18,900 --> 00:32:22,270 way it should be. And that is the main thing we have to come up. 436 00:32:22,350 --> 00:32:25,590 And I don't know how to do it. I wish I could tell you. I think 437 00:32:25,590 --> 00:32:28,350 it's very easy. We have to do this. I don't know how to do it. 438 00:32:28,510 --> 00:32:32,670 In my opinion, the struggle is to explain people modern monetary 439 00:32:32,670 --> 00:32:34,830 theory and how it really works. 440 00:32:36,109 --> 00:32:39,510 Okay, so with that in mind, and you know what? I don't have the 441 00:32:39,510 --> 00:32:42,990 answers either. I just know that pretending like Ro Khanna is 442 00:32:42,990 --> 00:32:45,990 going to save us isn't the answer. No, you know what I mean? 443 00:32:45,990 --> 00:32:50,970 I just. These are things that I can say empirically. And what. 444 00:32:50,970 --> 00:32:55,010 I guess my question to you then comes back and we'll roll it 445 00:32:55,010 --> 00:32:59,530 back a little bit away from some of the negative. Well, it's 446 00:32:59,530 --> 00:33:02,130 all going to be negative because right now I don't think you 447 00:33:02,130 --> 00:33:06,730 can fix anything unless you've got a very sober analysis, a sober 448 00:33:07,290 --> 00:33:12,250 assessment, Pollyanna niceties, things like that isn't 449 00:33:12,250 --> 00:33:16,770 to me, I feel like it's lying at this point. I feel like it's telling 450 00:33:16,770 --> 00:33:21,650 a big whopper of a lie and people's lives are dangling in the 451 00:33:21,650 --> 00:33:26,530 balance on Hopium based on fraudulent, fake. Yeah, we're going 452 00:33:26,530 --> 00:33:29,210 to source the vote. We're going to overcome this bourgeois 453 00:33:29,210 --> 00:33:32,330 democracy and pretend like it's a real democracy when in reality 454 00:33:32,330 --> 00:33:36,810 it's not. It doesn't even have characteristics of real democracy. 455 00:33:36,970 --> 00:33:40,970 And I think defining democracy at this point is really important. 456 00:33:41,460 --> 00:33:45,020 I think understanding what it is that we are seeking is really 457 00:33:45,020 --> 00:33:49,940 important. And so for me, I've come to believe that there is another 458 00:33:50,180 --> 00:33:54,100 way of presenting modern monetary theory other than the hey, 459 00:33:54,100 --> 00:33:58,500 we could do Green New Deal and talking about balance of trade and 460 00:33:58,500 --> 00:34:01,860 things like that. While important, I think it's important 461 00:34:01,860 --> 00:34:06,980 to show what is possible and then making people make them like 462 00:34:06,980 --> 00:34:10,100 taking a dog to make them smell the poop they left on the floor. 463 00:34:10,710 --> 00:34:15,030 I think we need to make people really wrestle with the idea of this 464 00:34:15,030 --> 00:34:21,110 is what is possible. Why isn't it happening? Why is this politician 465 00:34:21,430 --> 00:34:25,470 somebody told you to celebrate, who is just an absolute 466 00:34:25,470 --> 00:34:29,910 waste of life. Why are you sitting there and allowing them to 467 00:34:29,910 --> 00:34:33,710 lie to you about debt and deficits? Why are you allowing them 468 00:34:33,710 --> 00:34:37,550 to lie to you? I don't think it's effective anymore to pretend 469 00:34:37,550 --> 00:34:40,990 like let's teach a modern monetary theory and and then everybody's 470 00:34:40,990 --> 00:34:43,910 going to vote better and then we'll win. Because I think that is 471 00:34:43,910 --> 00:34:48,870 a complete lie. It's just a lie. At this point, from my vantage 472 00:34:48,870 --> 00:34:52,310 point, if you think about people trying to wake them up, people 473 00:34:52,310 --> 00:34:55,910 are very upset in general, but they just don't know why. And so 474 00:34:55,910 --> 00:34:59,750 I do believe that helping people understand mmt, teaching them 475 00:34:59,750 --> 00:35:03,630 mmt, teaching them how it works in each country that they live 476 00:35:03,630 --> 00:35:07,870 in and showing them what is possible and then asking them why 477 00:35:07,870 --> 00:35:11,810 isn't it happening. Unfortunately, you've got to overcome 478 00:35:11,810 --> 00:35:15,690 the person goes, well, there's only about 30% of the people that 479 00:35:15,690 --> 00:35:18,450 voted and if we can get everybody to vote, it'll change everything. 480 00:35:18,930 --> 00:35:23,730 That has just. I don't think I can handle any more normiesms, you 481 00:35:23,730 --> 00:35:27,450 know what I'm saying? Like I think MMT we can give the positive 482 00:35:27,450 --> 00:35:30,450 view of we'll have a Green New Deal and here's these great things 483 00:35:30,450 --> 00:35:34,290 that we can do. That's one angle, but that's an angle that I 484 00:35:34,290 --> 00:35:38,790 Believe sets MMT knowledge up for failure because it misses the 485 00:35:38,790 --> 00:35:42,470 point that we do not live in a God blessed democracy. And the people 486 00:35:42,470 --> 00:35:47,070 that pretend like we do have really fundamentally, they've definitely 487 00:35:47,070 --> 00:35:51,470 made me feel a different type of way. And I have been a 24 by 7 488 00:35:51,470 --> 00:35:56,510 by 365 advocate of this stuff. And I've grown to be very disillusioned 489 00:35:56,510 --> 00:36:00,230 with that kind of normie thinking. What do you think about 490 00:36:00,230 --> 00:36:03,880 the alternative view as opposed to here's what we could do 491 00:36:03,880 --> 00:36:07,000 like, because people's false consciousness, who they think they 492 00:36:07,000 --> 00:36:10,120 are and what they think they're doing today stems from a 493 00:36:10,120 --> 00:36:13,440 very fundamentally flawed understanding of economics for sure. 494 00:36:13,680 --> 00:36:17,120 And you could see this within socialist movements as well. They 495 00:36:17,120 --> 00:36:21,040 got great sensibilities, but they got terrible economics. Help 496 00:36:21,040 --> 00:36:25,800 me understand in your mind what you think would be a good wake 497 00:36:25,800 --> 00:36:30,180 up call, a good way of presenting MMT in a real way, in 498 00:36:30,180 --> 00:36:34,180 a realist way where you have realism when you say, well, you know, 499 00:36:34,180 --> 00:36:37,420 you don't live in a democracy or whatever. How would you present 500 00:36:37,660 --> 00:36:38,380 mmt? 501 00:36:39,260 --> 00:36:43,340 Steve, the real socialist revolutions that have succeeded, 502 00:36:43,340 --> 00:36:48,060 I'm talking about the October Revolution and the Chinese revolution 503 00:36:48,300 --> 00:36:52,140 and of course the Cuban revolution. Why did they succeed? 504 00:36:52,300 --> 00:36:55,660 Because they were the majority. Because most of the people 505 00:36:56,290 --> 00:36:59,970 supported the revolution. Most of the people supported the real 506 00:37:00,050 --> 00:37:03,890 change that the revolutionaries were defending. And 507 00:37:03,970 --> 00:37:08,370 once they were a majority, they took power one way or another. 508 00:37:09,010 --> 00:37:12,570 Of course, it was very naive to say that we are going to vote 509 00:37:12,570 --> 00:37:17,490 our way out with the Russian royal family in power. It is absolutely 510 00:37:17,730 --> 00:37:22,650 naive to think that that was possible. Well, then the people opted 511 00:37:22,650 --> 00:37:26,170 for the revolution. They were the majority and they did it and 512 00:37:26,170 --> 00:37:30,650 they found a way to do it. Same thing in China. China was a 513 00:37:30,650 --> 00:37:35,490 disaster before the Communist revolution and they were the majority. 514 00:37:35,570 --> 00:37:40,250 The majority of people were back in the Communist Party and at 515 00:37:40,250 --> 00:37:45,530 the end they won. One way or another, they won. And the main point 516 00:37:45,530 --> 00:37:50,490 is that they knew exactly what the economic program of the Communist 517 00:37:50,490 --> 00:37:56,130 Party was. Lenin explained exactly what he wanted to do. They 518 00:37:56,130 --> 00:37:59,850 knew exactly what they were going to expect and they supported 519 00:37:59,850 --> 00:38:03,530 it. They understood what the message was, they understood what 520 00:38:03,530 --> 00:38:07,930 the economic problem was and they said, yeah, let's do it, let's 521 00:38:07,930 --> 00:38:11,770 do it. We cannot do it through peaceful means. We are going to do 522 00:38:11,770 --> 00:38:15,050 it through revolutionary means. We are going to do it through 523 00:38:15,050 --> 00:38:18,590 the means that we can use in order to find our goals. But the 524 00:38:18,590 --> 00:38:22,830 main point is that they were the majority of the society and they 525 00:38:22,830 --> 00:38:27,470 had a very clear economic program that they were going to follow 526 00:38:27,710 --> 00:38:32,150 because the party explained Very, very clearly what they were 527 00:38:32,150 --> 00:38:35,230 going to do with the economy and how they were going to do it. 528 00:38:35,470 --> 00:38:39,070 And that is the way to go. First of all, we have to be a majority. 529 00:38:39,470 --> 00:38:42,710 You cannot say no, we are going to take the arms from the army 530 00:38:42,710 --> 00:38:45,920 or whatever and we are going to do a violent revolution because 531 00:38:45,920 --> 00:38:49,720 people are not going to follow you. You have to have the majority 532 00:38:49,720 --> 00:38:54,040 of the population behind you. Behind you means behind an economic 533 00:38:54,120 --> 00:38:58,480 program. Once we have an economic program, people defend it, 534 00:38:58,480 --> 00:39:02,200 people identify themselves with it, then that's it. We will 535 00:39:02,200 --> 00:39:06,200 find a solution. It would be much better, in my opinion, if that 536 00:39:06,200 --> 00:39:10,840 solution was peaceful and there is no need of using violence. 537 00:39:11,270 --> 00:39:15,550 But if that is not possible, well, then we will find a revolutionary 538 00:39:15,550 --> 00:39:19,110 solution that is not peaceful. It doesn't matter. The important 539 00:39:19,270 --> 00:39:22,630 thing is that people understand what they want and they 540 00:39:22,630 --> 00:39:26,630 have an economic program to follow. Once they understand that 541 00:39:26,630 --> 00:39:30,750 that program represents its interest, then we will find a way, 542 00:39:30,750 --> 00:39:35,190 one way or another. In my opinion, the biggest risk or the 543 00:39:35,190 --> 00:39:42,220 biggest danger on the side of MMT is revisionism. Now we are experiencing 544 00:39:42,540 --> 00:39:47,820 a watering down of mmt. All of the sudden, even some founders, not 545 00:39:47,820 --> 00:39:52,700 all of them of MMT say, well, you know, monetary sovereignty is 546 00:39:52,700 --> 00:39:57,020 not that important. Having your own currency is not that important. 547 00:39:57,900 --> 00:40:01,660 You can defend MMT and you can at the same time defend the euro 548 00:40:01,660 --> 00:40:06,350 system and the European Union. No, you can't. No, you can't. If 549 00:40:06,350 --> 00:40:10,710 you don't have monetary sovereignty, you cannot defend mmt 550 00:40:10,710 --> 00:40:16,150 mnt and the Euro is absolutely incompatible. And the problem is 551 00:40:16,150 --> 00:40:20,750 that we have reactionary supremacist forces on the side of 552 00:40:20,750 --> 00:40:26,590 MMT that are watering down the potential of MMT or at least how 553 00:40:26,590 --> 00:40:30,910 MMT was born. And they are trying to do the same thing they 554 00:40:30,910 --> 00:40:35,380 did with key nationism. Keynesianism was a way to find the 555 00:40:35,380 --> 00:40:39,180 economic means to have full employment. And all of a sudden, 556 00:40:39,420 --> 00:40:45,020 some years after that, we find neo Keynesianism. And neo Keynesianism 557 00:40:45,260 --> 00:40:49,460 nowadays is the same as neoliberalism. And that is what is 558 00:40:49,460 --> 00:40:54,540 happening with mmt. We used to have MMT based on monetary sovereignty. 559 00:40:54,700 --> 00:40:58,620 The book that Randall Ray wrote, it's called Modern Money Theory, 560 00:40:59,150 --> 00:41:03,710 A Handbook for Monetary Sovereign Countries. You know, monetary 561 00:41:03,710 --> 00:41:09,470 sovereignty is a must for any kind of MMT proposal that we have. 562 00:41:09,710 --> 00:41:16,270 And now we have a NEO MMT that is saying, oh no, let's have a neoclassical 563 00:41:16,910 --> 00:41:20,990 mixture here. Let's put together neoclassical economics and 564 00:41:20,990 --> 00:41:25,950 mmt. And now what we are facing is that many people are defending 565 00:41:25,950 --> 00:41:30,290 some kind of NEO MMT that doesn't have anything to do with 566 00:41:30,290 --> 00:41:35,690 the original mmt. And that is actually reactionary in its proposals 567 00:41:36,490 --> 00:41:40,610 and that is the risk we are facing now. That is actually what 568 00:41:40,610 --> 00:41:45,850 is happening right now. I see people that call themselves MMTRs 569 00:41:45,850 --> 00:41:50,610 that defend the European Union and the Euro. It is insane and nobody 570 00:41:50,610 --> 00:41:55,920 says anything. I find everything that MMT was based on 571 00:41:56,080 --> 00:42:01,320 has been perverted in order to make a neoclassical mixture, put 572 00:42:01,320 --> 00:42:05,240 everything in the same basket and now all of a sudden everything 573 00:42:05,240 --> 00:42:10,960 is mmt. Euro is mmt. European Union is mmt. Everything is mmt. 574 00:42:11,360 --> 00:42:16,160 No it isn't. That is, in my opinion the biggest danger that we 575 00:42:16,160 --> 00:42:20,400 face now on the files of mmt. It has been watered down to make 576 00:42:20,400 --> 00:42:25,760 a neoclassical fusion that has nothing to do with the original message 577 00:42:25,760 --> 00:42:27,480 and potential of mmt. 578 00:42:28,840 --> 00:42:34,920 I have found myself really pulling deeply into historical socialism 579 00:42:34,920 --> 00:42:39,720 and really getting into theory and better understanding capital 580 00:42:40,040 --> 00:42:45,000 and class. And it has become important to me that I bridge that 581 00:42:45,000 --> 00:42:48,220 gap for people. And that's one of the reasons why I brought you 582 00:42:48,220 --> 00:42:52,420 back on Carlos. And next time we talk I want to have an even harsher, 583 00:42:52,420 --> 00:42:56,580 more fine tuned, like really, really dig in even deeper next time. 584 00:42:56,580 --> 00:43:00,940 We have you on, but for this time let's talk to Marxist Leninist 585 00:43:00,940 --> 00:43:05,420 Maoists for a moment. People that have a true understanding of 586 00:43:05,740 --> 00:43:11,180 class and class struggle but maybe don't understand fiat currency. 587 00:43:11,740 --> 00:43:18,220 Can we give them an MMT 101 with the understanding we're not 588 00:43:18,220 --> 00:43:21,300 trying to break them, we're trying to bring them into the fold, 589 00:43:21,540 --> 00:43:25,620 we're trying to give them this tool. How would you present that 590 00:43:25,620 --> 00:43:27,540 to Marxist Lennox Maoists? 591 00:43:28,660 --> 00:43:33,860 Well, I think that everybody should read an essay by Lenin called 592 00:43:34,260 --> 00:43:39,380 Will the Bolsheviks stay in power? Written in 1917. I think that 593 00:43:39,380 --> 00:43:42,620 is the right translation I hope. If it is not that it's very 594 00:43:42,620 --> 00:43:48,180 similar. Will the Bolsheviks stay in power there? Lenin explains 595 00:43:48,260 --> 00:43:52,860 the role of the central bank of the Soviet Union and he says we 596 00:43:52,860 --> 00:43:57,540 are going to take the central bank of Russia now, the central bank 597 00:43:57,860 --> 00:44:02,420 of the Soviet Union and we are going to implement a full employment 598 00:44:02,420 --> 00:44:07,220 policy. Everybody will have a job. We will have a planification 599 00:44:07,380 --> 00:44:11,110 committee called the Gospel Plan. We are going to build an economic 600 00:44:11,270 --> 00:44:15,950 strategy. Everybody will have a job and we will pay them with rubles 601 00:44:15,950 --> 00:44:20,430 from the central bank. And that is exactly what he explains 602 00:44:20,430 --> 00:44:24,190 there. Through the central bank we will have a full employment 603 00:44:24,190 --> 00:44:29,670 policy and we will determine what goals we want to achieve. And 604 00:44:29,670 --> 00:44:34,830 a couple of decades later, a very poor country and a very undeveloped 605 00:44:34,830 --> 00:44:39,500 country called Russia. Now the Soviet Union put a guy in space and 606 00:44:39,500 --> 00:44:43,900 was an economic Superpower exactly the way he says. And that 607 00:44:43,900 --> 00:44:49,380 is absolutely compatible. That is actually the same that MMT defends. 608 00:44:49,620 --> 00:44:53,580 We are going to take our monetary sovereignty, we are going 609 00:44:53,580 --> 00:44:57,140 to have a permanent full employment policy, and we are going 610 00:44:57,140 --> 00:45:00,140 to achieve the goals of socialism. I mean, not in the case 611 00:45:00,140 --> 00:45:04,100 of mmt, but in the case of fiat socialism. What do you want 612 00:45:04,100 --> 00:45:07,660 full employment for? Well, it's very simple to achieve the goals 613 00:45:07,660 --> 00:45:11,260 of socialism, to achieve the living standards that you cannot 614 00:45:11,260 --> 00:45:15,140 achieve in capitalism. Capitalism will never have permanent 615 00:45:15,140 --> 00:45:18,980 full employment. Capitalism will never have permanent housing. 616 00:45:19,380 --> 00:45:23,300 Capitalism will never have permanent healthcare, et cetera. 617 00:45:23,620 --> 00:45:28,420 Once you have full employment policies, and you use that in order 618 00:45:28,420 --> 00:45:32,750 to achieve the socialist living standards that cannot be achieved 619 00:45:32,750 --> 00:45:37,870 in capitalism is when you can overcome capitalism through modern 620 00:45:37,870 --> 00:45:41,870 monetary theory. If we begin to water this down and say, no, you 621 00:45:41,870 --> 00:45:46,510 know what, the European Union, the shoe cleaners of NATO are the 622 00:45:46,510 --> 00:45:49,990 good guys, and we are going to go to the European Parliament, and 623 00:45:50,150 --> 00:45:53,270 even though we have the euro and that means that we don't have 624 00:45:53,270 --> 00:45:57,280 monetary sovereignty, they are going to help us out. We are going, 625 00:45:57,280 --> 00:46:01,120 no, no, no. That is not the way. That is absolutely not the way. 626 00:46:01,440 --> 00:46:06,280 So I would tell everybody to read that piece by Lenin and compare 627 00:46:06,280 --> 00:46:10,200 it to what modern monetary theory proposes, and I think they 628 00:46:10,200 --> 00:46:12,240 will find a very clear way forward. 629 00:46:12,960 --> 00:46:16,000 I love it, man. That's really good. And just so you all know, we're 630 00:46:16,000 --> 00:46:19,000 going to look behind the scenes when we put this episode out 631 00:46:19,000 --> 00:46:23,020 and hopefully we'll be able to add it to our show. Notes, Carlos, 632 00:46:23,020 --> 00:46:27,180 we're getting up near time and, you know, for me, I want to 633 00:46:27,180 --> 00:46:31,380 make a quick statement. I appreciate the level of rigor that 634 00:46:31,380 --> 00:46:36,260 you put into researching your book. My biggest problem with it 635 00:46:36,260 --> 00:46:41,060 had been I am living in the United States and the United States 636 00:46:41,060 --> 00:46:46,700 is the largest neoliberal project on the planet. We are 100% 637 00:46:46,780 --> 00:46:51,300 about privatizing absolutely everything, down to drinking water 638 00:46:51,940 --> 00:46:57,460 and the trash that people put forward as good candidates are stupid 639 00:46:57,460 --> 00:47:01,180 enough to go along with it or bought off enough to go along with 640 00:47:01,180 --> 00:47:05,220 it. So for me, it was very, very hard as I'm fighting against 641 00:47:05,220 --> 00:47:09,260 mass privatization and my own little teeny world that I inhabit 642 00:47:09,260 --> 00:47:13,780 here at Real Progressives and this podcast, Macro and Cheese, I 643 00:47:13,780 --> 00:47:19,080 couldn't see past the idea of allowing private sector. But looking 644 00:47:19,080 --> 00:47:24,000 at what China does and understanding that while I don't 645 00:47:24,000 --> 00:47:26,800 agree with everything China, I want to be clear, this is not like 646 00:47:26,800 --> 00:47:31,720 me being a sycophant for China. But if I just take Lenin as 647 00:47:31,720 --> 00:47:34,920 you brought up at his word, and think of State and revolution 648 00:47:34,920 --> 00:47:40,440 and the withering away of the state do we come administers. You 649 00:47:40,440 --> 00:47:44,200 know, basically we eliminate class. We eliminate that component 650 00:47:44,200 --> 00:47:47,420 as time goes on. But it doesn't start that way. There's an 651 00:47:47,420 --> 00:47:52,020 entire taking over of the proletariat of society. And in order 652 00:47:52,020 --> 00:47:56,940 for fiat socialism to occur, I believe the proletariat, as you say, 653 00:47:56,940 --> 00:48:00,220 needs to outnumber. But these are the details, man, that we've 654 00:48:00,220 --> 00:48:03,620 got to get through. And how do we overcome them? And I know we don't 655 00:48:03,620 --> 00:48:07,740 have an answer 100%. It's very challenging. And the one thing about 656 00:48:07,740 --> 00:48:12,500 capitalism is it morphs and it changes and it learns from its mistakes. 657 00:48:12,500 --> 00:48:15,780 It's a system. It's not the good or bad people. It's a system 658 00:48:16,430 --> 00:48:21,150 that literally demands a lot of bad things. So you can't buff 659 00:48:21,150 --> 00:48:25,070 the edges off of capitalism. You've got to kill capitalism. And 660 00:48:25,070 --> 00:48:30,030 in the sense of how do we get to fiat socialism, I think this is 661 00:48:30,030 --> 00:48:34,670 really. This is where I'm stuck. This is the sticking point 662 00:48:34,670 --> 00:48:38,110 for all of it. Because most people don't want to go past the 663 00:48:38,110 --> 00:48:41,590 idea that they can put an I voted sticker on their forehead and 664 00:48:41,590 --> 00:48:45,230 walk away. In fact, I've got friends who think that by me calling 665 00:48:45,230 --> 00:48:49,570 out these truths that somehow or another that because they're struggling 666 00:48:49,570 --> 00:48:53,610 for Social Security or they're struggling for other things, they 667 00:48:53,610 --> 00:48:56,530 think somehow or another by speaking the truth, that that is 668 00:48:56,530 --> 00:49:01,050 in some way a violation of their ability to survive. When in 669 00:49:01,050 --> 00:49:04,530 reality, I think as a transitional strategy, we need to 670 00:49:04,530 --> 00:49:08,170 be looking at building community resiliency outside of the 671 00:49:08,170 --> 00:49:11,570 system. We need to be building parallel systems outside the system 672 00:49:11,890 --> 00:49:15,940 so people can do a general strike, so that people can take direct 673 00:49:15,940 --> 00:49:21,260 action, so people can overcome the stranglehold that these systems 674 00:49:21,260 --> 00:49:25,420 and capital and the absolute marriage and intertwining of state 675 00:49:25,420 --> 00:49:28,980 and capital that has occurred can be overcome. I don't see any 676 00:49:28,980 --> 00:49:31,980 other way around it. But your final thoughts on that, sir? 677 00:49:32,300 --> 00:49:35,980 No, I agree with you. I agree with you. In my opinion, the most 678 00:49:35,980 --> 00:49:40,860 important economic sectors should be public and should be nationalized. 679 00:49:41,480 --> 00:49:44,360 I think health should be nationalized. I think energy should 680 00:49:44,360 --> 00:49:48,920 be nationalized. And I think that the public enterprises should 681 00:49:48,920 --> 00:49:55,280 control the strategic economic sectors. What I mean is that I don't 682 00:49:55,280 --> 00:49:59,720 see any use in making Macro and Cheese or real progressives or 683 00:49:59,720 --> 00:50:03,640 my company, Lola Books, public. I think that is something 684 00:50:03,720 --> 00:50:07,160 that, you know, it is really not important. I don't think that 685 00:50:07,680 --> 00:50:11,920 my company, Lola Books, will function better if we make it public 686 00:50:11,920 --> 00:50:16,200 or we nationalize it. I think that I run my company pretty well. 687 00:50:16,200 --> 00:50:19,760 And I think that you do the same with your company. So I don't 688 00:50:19,760 --> 00:50:23,360 see any problem with letting that kind of enterprise to exist. 689 00:50:23,760 --> 00:50:28,480 But I agree with you that at least in Spain, and I think that 690 00:50:28,640 --> 00:50:33,880 in the US the same, the strategic economic sectors should 691 00:50:33,880 --> 00:50:39,720 be nationalized. Health, education, water, energy, all these 692 00:50:39,720 --> 00:50:43,480 should be in public hands. Absolutely, absolutely. But at the 693 00:50:43,480 --> 00:50:47,360 end, it is up for the people to decide. That is my opinion. And 694 00:50:47,360 --> 00:50:50,400 why do I think that is the right thing to do? Well, because 695 00:50:50,400 --> 00:50:55,840 it helps to achieve socialist goals. You cannot have full housing 696 00:50:55,840 --> 00:50:59,840 of people if you don't have the public sector taking over most 697 00:50:59,840 --> 00:51:02,920 of the land. You know, most of the land should be in the hands of 698 00:51:02,920 --> 00:51:06,880 the public sector so everybody can have decent housing, things like 699 00:51:06,880 --> 00:51:10,360 that. I think it's very simple. If you want to access the 700 00:51:10,360 --> 00:51:14,240 services and the goals of socialism, you have to have a very 701 00:51:14,240 --> 00:51:17,680 big public sector, you know, but that doesn't mean that it has 702 00:51:17,680 --> 00:51:22,840 to be 100% of the economy. No. Does it mean that the private sector 703 00:51:23,160 --> 00:51:26,840 in Spain and in the United States has to have the same size? 704 00:51:26,840 --> 00:51:31,330 No. It can have different sizes, it can have different companies, 705 00:51:31,650 --> 00:51:35,050 we can have different strategies. And that is what I mean 706 00:51:35,050 --> 00:51:39,490 when I talk about flexible socialism. But I agree with you that 707 00:51:39,490 --> 00:51:42,890 the strategic and most important economic sectors should 708 00:51:42,890 --> 00:51:45,050 be nationalized. Absolutely, yeah. 709 00:51:45,050 --> 00:51:48,650 I mean, I can think back to workers guilds and stuff like that 710 00:51:48,650 --> 00:51:53,410 and co ops and other things of that variety where people in general 711 00:51:54,000 --> 00:51:57,720 do own the means of their own production, but it's controlled, 712 00:51:57,720 --> 00:52:02,000 if you will, by the state. The state doesn't allow predatory behavior. 713 00:52:02,480 --> 00:52:03,200 Exactly. 714 00:52:03,840 --> 00:52:07,240 Like we can all be against it, but when you're really against it, 715 00:52:07,240 --> 00:52:10,440 you start behaving differently. The things that you 716 00:52:10,440 --> 00:52:14,000 put forward are different. The kinds of strategies that you put 717 00:52:14,000 --> 00:52:17,920 forward are very different. And I see a lot of folks that are 718 00:52:18,000 --> 00:52:22,040 willing to play within the capitalist system, within the oligarchy, 719 00:52:22,040 --> 00:52:26,610 and play access politics. Be very careful in how they frame things, 720 00:52:27,410 --> 00:52:31,930 not speak so that working class people can hear. I mean, one 721 00:52:31,930 --> 00:52:35,890 of the biggest challenges of them all is looking at paywalls. 722 00:52:35,890 --> 00:52:39,210 People paywalling their content, paywalling every. If you 723 00:52:39,210 --> 00:52:42,690 really want change, then you need to make your information accessible 724 00:52:42,690 --> 00:52:46,810 to people. You know, I mean, it can't be gatekept. And I think 725 00:52:46,810 --> 00:52:50,530 there's a lot of gatekeepers out there that knowingly block voices 726 00:52:50,530 --> 00:52:55,650 that maybe are a little bit more coarse and radical in desiring 727 00:52:55,650 --> 00:52:59,930 change and a little bit too much inside voice, outside voice. 728 00:52:59,930 --> 00:53:04,210 Kind of like Hillary Clinton's I have my public and I have my private. 729 00:53:04,690 --> 00:53:08,810 I think these kinds of things maybe work well within neoliberal 730 00:53:08,810 --> 00:53:12,610 elite society, but I think that they are really, really harming 731 00:53:12,690 --> 00:53:16,770 working class people in a way that I don't think people fully realize. 732 00:53:16,850 --> 00:53:20,210 So I will give you the final thought to take us out. Carlos, what 733 00:53:20,210 --> 00:53:23,640 do you want people to get from this conversation and what do you 734 00:53:23,640 --> 00:53:24,800 want them to take forward? 735 00:53:25,520 --> 00:53:29,520 I think we agree in most of the things that we have talked about. 736 00:53:29,920 --> 00:53:36,160 I just want to reiterate the idea of baseline communism. Who has 737 00:53:36,160 --> 00:53:40,160 access to what and under what conditions? That is the main question 738 00:53:40,160 --> 00:53:44,320 we have to answer, and that is the main strategy we have to develop 739 00:53:44,400 --> 00:53:48,560 in order to overcome capitalism and achieve the goals 740 00:53:48,560 --> 00:53:52,930 of socialism. In that sense, I think that the property of the production 741 00:53:52,930 --> 00:53:56,330 of means is not the main question. I think that the main question 742 00:53:56,330 --> 00:54:00,970 is the access and we can manage the economic system in order 743 00:54:00,970 --> 00:54:05,850 to have a size of the private sector that is socially useful, so 744 00:54:05,850 --> 00:54:09,890 to speak. So in order to do that, we have to have an economic 745 00:54:10,050 --> 00:54:14,090 sphere that is always below the political sphere. I think that 746 00:54:14,090 --> 00:54:18,190 the political powers should be in charge and they should decide 747 00:54:18,430 --> 00:54:23,990 above and over the economic sphere. If we have a system that 748 00:54:23,990 --> 00:54:26,790 is the other way around, like in the European Union and in the 749 00:54:26,790 --> 00:54:31,789 United States is when all the problems are not solvable. If the 750 00:54:31,789 --> 00:54:37,070 economic sphere and the elites and the oligarchy controls the political 751 00:54:37,390 --> 00:54:40,430 powers, there is no way out. We have to change that. 752 00:54:40,830 --> 00:54:44,100 Amen, brother. I'm with you on that. All right, so I'm going to 753 00:54:44,100 --> 00:54:48,060 go ahead and first of all, thank you for taking the time to 754 00:54:48,060 --> 00:54:52,180 do this. We will do this again, my friend. We are fellow travelers 755 00:54:52,500 --> 00:54:55,540 and I want to figure out what I disagree with you on. I don't know, 756 00:54:55,540 --> 00:54:57,580 everything, you know, I mean, like, I want to find out where we 757 00:54:57,580 --> 00:55:01,100 agree. I want to wrestle with this, buddy. I don't want this to 758 00:55:01,100 --> 00:55:05,780 be like, I'm tired of being a zombie, just marching around saying 759 00:55:05,780 --> 00:55:07,220 textual fund spending. 760 00:55:07,630 --> 00:55:08,190 I get it. 761 00:55:08,510 --> 00:55:12,030 I'm with you. I've said it more than anybody I know. But at 762 00:55:12,030 --> 00:55:15,230 the same time, it's so much more than that. And I think getting 763 00:55:15,310 --> 00:55:19,710 to that and finding that sweet spot and figuring it out and documenting 764 00:55:19,710 --> 00:55:22,990 it and moving forward, I think that's powerful. And I'm going to 765 00:55:22,990 --> 00:55:25,350 look forward to working with you in the future on that. Carlos, 766 00:55:25,350 --> 00:55:27,150 I mean that from the bottom of my heart. 767 00:55:27,790 --> 00:55:30,870 Steve, thank you very much. It means a lot for me to be here with 768 00:55:30,870 --> 00:55:34,880 you. I think you are doing an excellent job and I really appreciate 769 00:55:34,880 --> 00:55:39,120 this time with you. And Mao Zedong used to say, patience is the 770 00:55:39,120 --> 00:55:42,920 most revolutionary virtue. We have to be patient and keep on going. 771 00:55:43,480 --> 00:55:46,400 Amen, brother. All right, well, I lack that, so I've got to 772 00:55:46,400 --> 00:55:50,080 get some patience banked up here, bro. All right, without further 773 00:55:50,080 --> 00:55:53,440 ado, folks, my name is Steve Grumbine. I am the host of Macro 774 00:55:53,440 --> 00:55:57,000 and Cheese and the founder of Real progressives. We are a 501C3, 775 00:55:57,000 --> 00:56:01,300 not for profit. We are desperate for your donations. We 776 00:56:01,300 --> 00:56:05,220 do not pay all our stuff. So wherever you are, you'll be able 777 00:56:05,220 --> 00:56:08,580 to get our stuff and you won't have to pay a fee. So that means 778 00:56:08,580 --> 00:56:12,380 that we've got to ask those who do have the ability to consider 779 00:56:12,540 --> 00:56:16,619 donating to the cause. We are not rolling in it. We need your help. 780 00:56:17,180 --> 00:56:23,140 You can go to patreon.com real progressives, make a one time or 781 00:56:23,140 --> 00:56:28,370 a monthly donation. You can go to our substack, which is Real Progressives, 782 00:56:28,770 --> 00:56:32,210 and find all of our podcast material there. But you can also 783 00:56:32,290 --> 00:56:36,410 donate and become a subscriber there as well. You can also do it 784 00:56:36,410 --> 00:56:41,730 at our website, real progressives.org and become a monthly 785 00:56:41,730 --> 00:56:46,290 or a one time donor. Folks, we really do need your contributions. 786 00:56:46,610 --> 00:56:50,330 And I do want to say one more thing, Carlos, I know it's a little 787 00:56:50,330 --> 00:56:55,890 late for you, but we do a Tuesday night meeting every single 788 00:56:55,890 --> 00:57:00,770 week called Macro and Chill, where we get together on a zoom call 789 00:57:01,090 --> 00:57:05,250 where we have everybody that wants to come show up and build community, 790 00:57:05,810 --> 00:57:09,770 listen to the podcast in 15 minute segments. We have it done 791 00:57:09,770 --> 00:57:14,090 in a video format, so it's kind of fun and cheeky and we sit 792 00:57:14,090 --> 00:57:17,810 there and we discuss it in between things. Sometimes it's spirited. 793 00:57:18,050 --> 00:57:22,210 It's always, always, always beneficial. Especially when we get 794 00:57:22,210 --> 00:57:27,340 people that are willing to talk and look for solutions. And 795 00:57:27,580 --> 00:57:30,420 Carlos, you're welcome anytime. But when we do this one, 796 00:57:30,420 --> 00:57:32,820 I'll give you a special invitation, see if we can get you 797 00:57:32,820 --> 00:57:35,700 to come and join us again. I know it's late for you, buddy, so 798 00:57:35,700 --> 00:57:38,140 I won't be offended if you say, sorry, man, I can't. 799 00:57:38,460 --> 00:57:41,380 No, no. It will be a pleasure. It will be a pleasure to be with 800 00:57:41,380 --> 00:57:42,700 you. Thank you so much. 801 00:57:43,260 --> 00:57:46,860 You got it. All right, folks, on that, on behalf of Macro and Cheese, 802 00:57:46,860 --> 00:57:51,740 my guest, Carlos Garcia Hernandez, we are out of here. 803 00:57:59,420 --> 00:58:03,140 Production transcripts, graphics, sound engineering, extras 804 00:58:03,140 --> 00:58:06,420 and show notes for macroencies are done by our volunteer team at 805 00:58:06,420 --> 00:58:09,940 Real Progressives, serving in solidarity with the working class 806 00:58:09,940 --> 00:58:16,762 since 2015. To become a donor, please go to patreon.com/real progressives, 807 00:58:17,131 --> 00:58:20,790 realprogressives.substack.com or realprogressives.org.