Hey there. So when unchecked power rewrites the story of America, who lives, who thrives, who speaks, and who disappears? From the center for the Study of Art and Community, this is Art is Change, a chronicle of art and social change where activists, artists and cultural organizers share the strategies and skills they need to thrive as creative community leaders. I'm Bill Cleveland. Now, I'm going to begin with a digression too, actually, which I'm told is something you should never do with a podcast. So my first digression rises up from what has been going down in my old stomping ground, Minneapolis, and in Portland and the dozens of other places that ICE has been transforming communities from safe and friendly to fearful and lethal. More on this in a bit. My second digression, which will seem much further afield, has to do with improvisation. A lot of people who are not practicing improvisers think that it's just making stuff up, you know, whatever comes to mind in the moment. But those musicians, actors, dancers and the like who practice what I think of as the penultimate creative skill understand that imagining and manifesting things on the spur of the moment is just the start. This is because improvising combines that made up stuff with a highly disciplined and intricately structured framework that defines and actually constrains the mix of relationships, intuition, listening, language, timing, and even the physical space within which all that free flowing imaginative magic travels. The simple way of describing this weird juxtaposition of freedom and limitations is that if you don't know where the actual front edge of the stage is, you are lost as an improviser. Now back to ice. The problem with our Legion of the Immaculate and Protected border is that they have no borders. They are performing their drama of terror and intimidation on a stage with no edge, combined with the understanding that the unconstrained, untethered and totally unimaginative masquerade being performed by their Regent in the White House is the script they should be following. Which translates as your only goal is to brutalize and terrorize everyone you encounter. So make it up as you go along. And if you fuck it up, don't worry, because in this dystopian monster movie you are inoculated. So there is no such thing as a fuck up. That's right. Needless to say, you are amused because the President of the Universe has your back. Who have been murdered and injured. Needless to say, the hideous reality of India impacts all vulnerable souls who have been murdered and injured their families, their communities, and Indiana. All of us who care about having a peaceful and productive life. It also impacts the growing numbers of us who are called to push back and resist. Like murdered poet and mom Renee Macklin Goode in Minneapolis. I know a vicious story like ice let loose and the world can SAP your spirit. Please, please don't let it happen. As you may recall, over the past year we we have interspersed our interviews and conversations with episodes that take stock and report on the cultural weather in these turbulent times.
Bill ClevelandWe've been doing this because it's important.
Bill ClevelandTo take note of what's actually happening on the ground where authoritarian pressure is being applied and how artists, cultural organizations, and public media are responding. In previous episodes, we called this our weather report, but from now on we're going to call it the Arts Freedom Weather Report. So thanks for joining us. I want to start by saying this clearly. Nothing that follows is about single decision, single bills, legislation, single bad actors, or individual acts of courage and pushback. What we're dealing with right now only comes into focus when you look at it over time, when you notice how small changes stack up, how rules shift quietly, and how institutions begin recalibrating long before anybody tells them they have to. And most importantly, when you realize that there is a slowly mounting wave of revulsion and resistance that is gaining force and making its presence felt. So this episode is a reset, an arts and cultural climate baseline, something that we can come back to later and say, okay, this is where we were in 2026, at the end of the first year in the reign of the Orange Beast. We'll start with Washington, not because everything originates there, but because what happens there often sets the tone for what feels permissible everywhere else. So the National Endowment for the Arts is still functioning, and I guess that matters. Grants are still being awarded, panels still meet. But over the past year, the way the agency operates has changed in ways that are sometimes quiet and structural but deeply consequential. In February 2025, the NEA eliminated its stand alone Challenge America program and folded it into the larger Grants for Arts project category. For 2026, Challenge America was one of the few federal programs explicitly designed to reach small, rural and culturally specific organizations. Its removal didn't come with a press conference, but for many folks out there, many groups, many organizations, the impact was immediate. Some scrambled to rewrite applications under tougher competition. Others simply stepped away. Because roughly 40% of the NEA funding flows through state arts agencies, the effects didn't land evenly. States with strong arts budgets could sometimes cushion the blow. States with thinner or politically hostile arts funding couldn't. The result isn't officially partisan, but it's geographically and politically uneven. Some state arts councils shortened grant cycles or reduced staff others held steady. As a result, the cultural map is becoming more unequal, I think, by design. Now I'm going to get a little wonky here. Observers of federal policy have pointed out that the broader blueprint for driving this moment, known as Project 2025, is not just about trimming budgets but about recasting the role of the federal government itself. This 900 page conservative agenda, championed by allies of the current administration, envisions remaking federal agencies to embody and advance a particular narrative of American identity and heritage, rather than serving as neutral patrons of diverse political, social, and cultural expression. While Project 2025 doesn't explicitly list arts funding line items, its logic consolidating executive control over bureaucratic institutions and aligning them with a singular historic vision helps explain why agencies like the NEA and Nehemiah remain technically funded even as their grant practices and internal priorities are shifted. In other words, culture isn't untouched it's being weaponized in the war over American story and meaning, with federal institutions recast not just as funders but as vehicles for a prescribed national narrative. So the tide of cultural change is both overt and covert, leaving many unsure and unclear. And often, when uncertainty becomes the operating condition, one of the places culture inevitably ends up is the courts. On March 6, 2025, Rhode Island Latino Arts National Queer Theater, the Theater Offensive and Theater Communications Group represent by the aclu, filed suit against the nea. They challenged a grant certification requirement tied to Executive Order 14168, which barred funding for projects deemed to promote something called gender ideology. In September 2025, a federal court ruled in favor of the artists, finding the policy likely unconstitutional and a form of viewpoint discrimination. As a result, the NEA withdrew the requirement. That ruling mattered not just because artists won, but because it reaffirmed something foundational Federal cultural funding cannot be conditioned on ideological conformity. At nearly the same time, in May 2025, the NEA abruptly terminated dozens of previously awarded grants, including ones already made affecting organizations and intermediary part reports tally hundreds of canceled NEA grants, with millions of dollars in awards revoked. For many organizations, the shock wasn't just financial it was existential. What does it mean when funding is awarded, celebrated, and then withdrawn because priorities shift midstream? That same instability has landed hard in public media. In 2025, Congress passed the Rescissions act, clawing back more than $1.1 billion from the corporation for Public Broadcasting. For large urban stations, this was painful. For rural stations, it was existential. Many depend on CPB for a quarter to a third of their operating budgets. Stations responded by laying off staff, cutting local reporting, and reducing community programming in places with no commercial alternatives. Public radio and television aren't just culture, they're emergency infrastructure. Well, listeners noticed. Donations surged. Philanthropy stepped in with emergency bridge funding. But no one pretended this was a long term fix. Once you start seeing this pattern in public media, you notice it elsewhere, especially where losses happen quietly. In June 2025, the American alliance of Museums reported that nearly One third of U.S. museums had already lost federal grant funding. They were counting on more than 20% cancelled or scaled back programs serving high need audiences. Rural communities, veterans, students, people with disabilities. You know, the building stays open, but the program shrinks. What's lost first is the open invitation. Now, federal signals don't stay federal for long. They get picked up and amplified. At the state level. In Ohio, Senate Bill 1 restricted DEI programs and barred public universities from engaging with what the law calls controversial beliefs. Faculty testified that the language chilled teaching in art history, theater and cultural studies. Students protested under the banner shred SB1, warning lawmakers the law would drive talent out of the state. In Indiana, budget mandates tied to enrollment thresholds forced public universities to eliminate or suspend degree programs in art history, dance, theater and comparative literature, narrowing the pipeline that produces artists and cultural workers for decades to come. Whenever public systems contract, the question becomes not who fills the gap, but how. Some philanthropy has acted as emergency ballast. Others are taking a longer view. The Andrew W. Mellon foundation committed $50 million to strengthen literary and humanities infrastructure. The Kettering foundation has centered artists as democratic practitioners, not messengers, but co creators of civic life explicitly supporting artistic voice as essential to democracy itself. I think that distinction matters. And it helps explain why something unexpected happened this winter. Not in a courtroom or a budget hearing, but on a stage. Now, once upon a time, not long ago, there was a place we called the Kennedy Center, a living memorial to a president who believed the arts were essential to democracy. Not a brand, a public trust. Then came the decision to graft another name onto it. Not through Congress, not through public debate, but through boardroom muscle. A memorial turned into a marquee. Hey, few artists notice. First quietly, then publicly. And then the names began to gather. Sonio de los Santos stepped away from her concert, saying the space no longer felt welcoming to her or her community. Stephen Schwartz, the composer behind Wicked, withdrew from a gala that once would have been a crowning honor. Banjo master Bella Fleck canceled his appearances, saying the music had been drafted into a political fight. He never signed up for. Bandleader Chuck Red, whose winter wonderland you just heard, called off his long running Christmas Eve jam. The Cookers canceled their New Year's Eve production, Wayne Tucker pulled his trumpet from the lineup, Doug Verone and dancers stepped away from their dates. The Brentano Quartet rescinded their booking and others followed singers, composers, bandleaders, storytellers, each one choosing integrity over prestige, principle over paycheck. It wasn't a boycott so much as a quiet chorus of refusal, a reminder that sometimes the bravest performance is the one you never give. All of this helps explain why preparation and prevention keeps coming up as an important aspect of the resistance, particularly for nonprofits. Not as fear, but as capacity building. In a previous artist change episode, which we'll note in our show notes, we outlined basic steps nonprofits can take to protect themselves clarifying mission, language, understanding governance responsibilities, documenting decisions and building alliances before crises hit. One such alliance that you can connect to right away is the National Artists Safety Survey, which is gathering information anonymously from artists and arts organizations across the US about their experiences with censorship, persecution, harassment and other threats. If you're an artist or work with an arts organization, I encourage you to just take a few minutes to complete the survey. And if you're not an artist, just as importantly, share the survey link in our show notes and help them reach as many artists as possible. We'll be sharing their results when they become available later this year. Preparation doesn't make organizations cautious, it makes them steadier. And steadiness is shaping today's resistance. Resistance right now isn't improvised, it's being taught. The organization Beautiful Trouble has spent more than a decade training artists and organizers in the craft of creative resistance, treating art as strategy, not as decoration. The center for Artistic Activism helps artists design interventions that apply pressure where power actually lives. Shifting from expression to effectiveness on the ground, groups like Free DC have been integrated music, visual art, performance, and ritual into all their organizing, insisting on visibility and shared authorship. In a city where politics can easily become abstract.
Free DC RepresentativeUtilizing percussion and the drum always has uplifted the spirits of the community. It's the crank of the bounce beat opponents of the federal surge using the powerful spirit of Go go music from TLB to heal.
Bill ClevelandEvery resistance step is a good step.
Bill ClevelandMovements like no Kings have centered culture, humor, imagery, performance to assert democracy as something you practice, not something you petition for. When you lay all of this side by side, a few things stop looking accidental culture is being targeted because it works. Institutions with trust are strategic choke points, and the strongest responses blend legal defense with imagination and relationships. And it's important to note places that invested in community before crisis are holding up better than those that didn't. That's not ideology, that's observation. As we move forward, our Arts Freedom Weather Report will keep tracking changes at the NEA and state arts agencies, court cases affecting cultural funding, public media vulnerability in rural America, state level legislation shaping arts and humanities education, and artist led efforts that are actively building anti authoritarian and democratic practice. As I said, this episode is the 2026 baseline and we'll keep coming back to it. Before we sign off, here are a few takeaways. First, culture isn't under pressure because it's fragile. It's under pressure because it shapes how people understand power, belonging and possibility, and it threatens oligarchs and kings. Second, resistance that lasts is isn't just loud. It's strategic, relational and learned. And artists are learning and teaching those skills every day. Third, democracy doesn't survive on policy alone. It survives where people practice it together in stories, rituals, shared spaces and acts of imagination. In closing, I'd like to reinforce that sentiment by sharing an excerpt from a poem by Minneapolis poet Renee Macklin Goode.
Bill ClevelandMay her soul rest in peace.
Bill ClevelandFrom on learning to dissect fetal pigs under.
Bill ClevelandClippings of the moon at 2:45am I studying and repeat ribosome endoplasmic lactic acid stamen at the IHOP on the corner of Powers and Stetson Hills. I repeated and scribbled until it picked.
Bill ClevelandIts way and stagnated.
Bill ClevelandSomewhere I can't point to anymore, maybe my gut, maybe there in between my pancreas and large intestine, is the piddly brook of my soul. It's the ruler by which I reduce all things. Now hard edge and splintering from knowledge that used to sit a cloth against fevered forehead. Can I let them both be this fickled faith and this college science that.
Bill ClevelandHeckles me from the back of the classroom.
Bill ClevelandNow I can't believe that the Bible and Quran and Bhagavad Gita are sliding.
Bill ClevelandLong hairs behind my ear like mom.
Bill ClevelandUsed to, and exhaling from their mouths make room for wonder.
Bill ClevelandAll my understanding dribbles down the chin onto the chest and is summarized as.
Bill ClevelandLife is merely ovum and sperm and where those two meet and how often and how well and what dies there.
Bill ClevelandArt IS Change is a production of the center for the Study of Art and Community, our theme and soundscapes spring forth from the head, heart and hand of the maestro. Judy Munson. Our text editing is by Andre Neppe. Our effects come from freesound.org and our inspiration comes from the ever present spirit of UKE235. So until next time, stay well, do good and spread the good word. Once again, please know this episode has been 100% human.