Jesse Hirsch

Hi, I'm Jesse Hirsch.

Jesse Hirsch

Welcome to Metaviews, recorded live in front of an automated audience.

Jesse Hirsch

And today we're gonna talk about what I think is a crucial subject of our times, the power of community and the role that community can play, not just in connecting us with our humanity, our nature, but forging a better society.

Jesse Hirsch

Now, you know, this is where I should start, John, by telling you we have a few segments that are meant as kind of icebreakers to start the show.

Jesse Hirsch

Although I'm going to do something with you now that I haven't done with any other guest, which is to give you a bit of context on our audience, because on the one hand, I would say the majority of our audience is not American.

Jesse Hirsch

And that's important because America has very rigid narratives and meaning when it comes to words.

Jesse Hirsch

And I would say we're more diverse in that regard.

Jesse Hirsch

But we also have a lot of people in our audience, my parents in particular, but others as well, who have experience in intentional communities, who have spent time living.

Jesse Hirsch

In my parents case, it was in the seventies in northern Ontario in the bush with a lot of others.

Jesse Hirsch

Again, these are people either in the boomer generation or younger, who have had some experience in the kind of intentional communities that we will be discussing on today's episode.

Jesse Hirsch

So I wanted to kind of prime you and say you can go into advanced mode, right?

Jesse Hirsch

You can eschew the normal, this is what's going on, and get to the synthesis of what you think is important, what you want to share, and we'll get into perhaps a more in depth conversation as a result.

Jesse Hirsch

But we like to start every episode of Meta Views with the news, partly because we publish our own daily newsletter.

Jesse Hirsch

And today's issue is what we're phrasing as AI nationalism.

Jesse Hirsch

And we're sort of looking at the way in which the new Trump administration has really aligned themselves with big tech, and how normally in an inauguration, the seats that are reserved for key governors were occupied by the CEOs of the big technology company.

Jesse Hirsch

So we're trying to flesh out this concept that nationalism seems paradoxical, contradictory in the age of the Internet, and yet it seems that AI is being used to bolster it, to amplify it.

Jesse Hirsch

This is something, again, we encourage our listeners and readers to check out.

Jesse Hirsch

But the real purpose of this segment, John, is to offer our guest an opportunity to share some news that they've heard.

Jesse Hirsch

Could be personal news, could be professional news, could be world news.

Jesse Hirsch

The goal here, on an intuitive level, is to ask the question, is there something that you're paying attention to that you think other people should know about, and in particular, that our audience should know about.

John

Yeah, yeah.

John

Thank you.

John

I mean, obviously, there's so many things happening right now on the planet, especially in my country here with Trump coming into power.

John

You know, the thing that has caught my eye more than anything in kind of also the same context, what you shared is Trump's sweeping pardons for the January 6th rioters, many of whom were complicit in killing law enforcement officers.

John

And I'd say that for, like, me, you know, your podcast is called Meta Views.

John

We, like, made a film about a very meta existential situation.

John

And, you know, as somebody who is a American who's also Jewish, it is definitely striking the resemblance between Trump Musk and what is happening and Nazism and Hitler back in the 30s.

John

And it feels like in one swoop, Trump freed all of his main, very criminal cronies who I think that is not just like him keeping a campaign promise, but it's him strategically trying to place people in the public in certain realms of his influence so that he can hold on to power even beyond what might be legal or ethical or normal for a president of the United States to, like, do.

John

He's actually putting people in power in the populace to keep kind of a enforcement of his code.

John

And I think we're on a very wild ride of what this fascist rise is and how that's also going to create a counter effect of community.

John

And really, I also trust it's part of a bigger design of earth towards us going towards healing.

John

But this is a moment of maximum polarization.

Jesse Hirsch

Well, and, you know, ironically, that's part of why we put the news out front, because you start with the bad news, and hopefully we get to the positive and the feeling better what we got to do about this stuff later in the show.

Jesse Hirsch

But specifically what I read it the same way.

Jesse Hirsch

He's creating brown shirts, right?

Jesse Hirsch

He's creating this type of vigilante fascist force.

Jesse Hirsch

And the example, like they stated, the administration stated they wanted to target Chicago as kind of the pilot project for ICE raids, Right.

Jesse Hirsch

And for deportations.

Jesse Hirsch

But because they said that before they did it, a lot of activists in Chicago, a lot of municipal officials in Chicago are preventing it.

Jesse Hirsch

Right?

Jesse Hirsch

They got the jump.

Jesse Hirsch

They've been able to, through their own political will, but also through legal means, prevent these raids from happening place and prevent these deportations from happening.

Jesse Hirsch

But to your point, if you have paralegal forces, if you have illegal militias that don't care about what ICE is going to do, but will target immigrants in Chicago or target marginalized people in Chicago.

Jesse Hirsch

From a policy perspective, it accomplishes the same thing.

Jesse Hirsch

So it is, you're quite correct, a really scary precedent of the way in which this regime is going to use outside of government forces and authority to terrorize people to try to enforce their will.

Jesse Hirsch

So our second segment is what we call wtf, which is what's the future?

Jesse Hirsch

Because we are a future centric podcast, we try to empower people to anticipate what's coming next.

Jesse Hirsch

And so we like to ask our guests, what is something about the future that you've got your eyes on that is part of your event horizon that you want our audience to know about?

Jesse Hirsch

And this is where I will disclose.

Jesse Hirsch

We tend to have the position that the future is largely fictional.

Jesse Hirsch

It's a target, a goal that we aim for, but the process is the purpose.

Jesse Hirsch

Right?

Jesse Hirsch

It's the journey that matters.

Jesse Hirsch

So in this sense, indulge in your imagination.

Jesse Hirsch

But at the same time, we're looking for an intuitive answer of, you know, for you, John, where do you see the future?

John

Yeah.

John

Thank you.

John

You know, we're actually hosting a summit in two weeks called Fugitive Futures.

John

Far out.

John

Something we think about a lot.

John

And the future is also, like I said, it's fictional.

John

It is a story.

John

But I also have a quote on the end of my email that says the future will be built by those who can tell the most meaningful story that we can be a part of.

John

And at an almost like spiritual level, similar to what was happening around 2012, 2025 has been prophesied in various traditions as really the inflection point of this great turning towards hopefully global regenerative culture.

John

And that this year, as both the.

John

As both, the turning point is also going to be the height of crisis.

John

And I think, again, there's going to be that polarized, like, I think this year, in the very near future, I think things at Covid level and beyond are going to be happening maybe not all at once, but in different waves.

John

And I think, though, that because the public has lived through everything we've lived through, including a past Trump presidency, that not just the.

John

Not just the, like, other side, because I think it's actually a moment also of a lot more unity is going to be happening.

John

But I think there will be a response of people banding together in community at a organic level in a way never before seen.

John

Like, everybody I know wants community, even my, like, parents that are very not in the alternative world that I'm in And I think this year is going to be a tipping point of dominoes for things to really happen towards people being like, oh, now we actually need this.

John

And this is just the healthier way to, to, to like, live in every single regard.

John

So I see a lot of crisis and a lot of upwelling of like, connection and community happening that is actually bridging divides right on.

Jesse Hirsch

And, and you know, let me get you to unpack what you said at the start.

Jesse Hirsch

Only because we've always here at Metaviews had the philosophy that in a surveillance society we're all outlaws because 100% compliance with the law is impossible.

Jesse Hirsch

Right.

Jesse Hirsch

Like you see cars coming to rolling stops on stop signs, and there's always a kind of gray area that in an analog world we accepted, but in the digital world it's more a matter of enforcement.

Jesse Hirsch

So what was the summit you mentioned?

Jesse Hirsch

And can you unpack it a bit in terms of what its kind of mission or agenda is?

John

So this summit is really the integration space.

Jesse Hirsch

And remind me, the name, it was.

John

So good it blew my mind is Fugitive Futures.

John

And so this is coming out of the film we, like, made.

John

But actually we need to take the film and inspiration into really a global conversation.

John

And the idea of fugitive futures is that, you know, we've known for a while the world's messed up, things aren't quite right, out of balance.

John

And people have been trying very, I think the whole 2010 to 2020 where like people earnestly trying to make a change, we're going to stop the CO2 and all the things, right?

John

And yet not really on a big scale much change happened.

John

Things really just got in, some is worse.

John

And I think what we're recognizing is that the way we have tried to create change is still operating from some of the base narratives and paradigms that caused the problem to begin with.

John

So that actually any regenerative future is going to have to be more fugitive in that we're actually going to have to create more of a space of uncertainty, of not knowing of beginner's mind and really holding space for the shadow, for the grief, for the, for the like reckoning.

John

And from the not knowing, it isn't like, let's have a plan in charge.

John

It's like, hey, let's sit together and feel and talk and listen and be a little bit more unmade and unmoored.

John

And maybe from that unmaking we can become alive to new possibilities that we couldn't have otherwise.

John

That's what makes the future that's coming fugitive yes, it is not authorized.

John

This is not the mainstream status quo.

John

This is definitely something that we have to be willing to dance on the edges with and be uncomfortable with.

John

It will come from our capacity to hold discomfort.

John

The actual solutions will come.

Jesse Hirsch

Now, I have to say, John, I have been wanting to use these sound effects in an episode for as long as I've been podcasting.

Jesse Hirsch

And you are the first guest who has earned the reaction of our automated audience.

Jesse Hirsch

So more power to you and what we do.

Jesse Hirsch

I love the way in which, again, the news and the future are really a setup for.

Jesse Hirsch

For what is fundamentally our feature conversation, where our guest comes into our lair and settles down.

Jesse Hirsch

For each guest.

Jesse Hirsch

I take kind of three pillars that I want to use as the conversation to kind of weave it through.

Jesse Hirsch

And you've already teased out all three.

Jesse Hirsch

And again, this conversation does not have to be nonlinear.

Jesse Hirsch

It's ideally we take it where it goes.

Jesse Hirsch

But I thought the pillars of community and then Tamara, the community and then conflict would be a good way to kind of allow us to really get as deep as we can in the modest time that we have and give the audience a kind of provocation.

Jesse Hirsch

Right?

Jesse Hirsch

For, as you said in our future segment to prepare for what's coming next.

Jesse Hirsch

Because where I thought you were right on is while we are witnessing the ascendance of fascism and a kind of fascism that while comparable to Nazi Germany, I think potentially could be even worse, we are at the same time already seeing it's the future past it, right?

Jesse Hirsch

And our substack is called the future of authority because we are living in authoritarianism.

Jesse Hirsch

And God damn it, we need to see a future past that.

Jesse Hirsch

Right?

Jesse Hirsch

And that is what I really heard in your narrative.

Jesse Hirsch

And your point about the power of stories, I thought was also crucial.

Jesse Hirsch

So let's start with community, because community strikes me as both one of the most powerful aspects of human organization.

Jesse Hirsch

I like to say that we've evolved to live in community, right?

Jesse Hirsch

That to be an individual is almost contrary to the hard wiring of our biology and our culture.

Jesse Hirsch

But you also said something in terms of everyone wants it, and I think they want it because it is so scarce.

Jesse Hirsch

We've become so alienated in the kind of late stage capitalism, especially as social media has kind of created this faux community, right?

Jesse Hirsch

Or this fake community that again, speaks to our desire for it, but like junk food never allows us feeling satisfied, right?

Jesse Hirsch

Or fulfilled.

Jesse Hirsch

So where to really get you to get into that big picture?

Jesse Hirsch

Where do you see community at this moment?

Jesse Hirsch

Right?

Jesse Hirsch

How.

Jesse Hirsch

How does it exist within not just the supply and demand of our economic centric society, but the culture of alienation.

Jesse Hirsch

Right.

Jesse Hirsch

The pandemic of loneliness that.

Jesse Hirsch

That a lot of people describe.

John

Yeah.

John

I mean, there's so many threads I want to touch on here.

John

I mean, one, yes.

John

Like, just by basic health, the reason everybody wants communities by basic health metrics.

John

It's clear, like, science has proven that social connection is like, or lack thereof is the number one marker of health.

John

Or like, not like, it is the thing that will kill you the fastest is not being able to be connected and feel that, like, relational health.

John

I think the second important point in community, as you said, is that it's not just like, want action at the.

John

Like a desire like, I want Pepsi or I want whatever.

John

This is a deep biological imperative.

John

That was the.

John

It was like the base structure that humans evolved in for 98.5% of our species evolution.

John

It's like we are literally biologically hardwired to thrive in communities.

John

There's also, I think, a longing people can't quite name.

John

And that also goes beyond just having friends, because a community.

John

And again, I really want to define, because you said that, that, like, the word community of most other words can be really misunderstood.

John

People throw that word around all the time.

John

Community is not your friendship group.

John

It's not just like the guys you hang out with and drink beer, play, like, sports with or whatever.

John

It actually is a place of solidarity and mutual care.

John

And actually, in real community, you don't like everybody.

John

You don't agree with everybody.

John

But because you have a common shared interest and care and really understand that your life depends on everybody else's life, you show up in solidarity to support.

John

I mean, this is what, you know, extended family is in its best regard at some level.

John

So I think one, we're in a really interesting point on planet Earth, where we are in this globalized world.

John

So it's not just we have to.

John

We can't just be local and tribal.

John

And for.

John

And why, Tamara, the community we made a film about is so unique.

John

Is that one of the core differences from them and the other communes, like your parents ones in the 70, that most of them failed, like, one of the highest failure rates of any endeavor is that.

John

Well, there's really two things.

John

But one is that they weren't like, we're gonna go.

Jesse Hirsch

And just quickly, not only did they fail, but they left their participants with trauma that skewed their politics, which is no surprise.

Jesse Hirsch

That's why a lot of boomers are supporting Trump, because they may have been Lefties when they were young.

Jesse Hirsch

But to your point, they had such a bad experience that that influenced their politics.

Jesse Hirsch

Please continue.

John

And that.

John

Which is interesting, because that doesn't mean it was the wrong approach, but it wasn't culturally mature enough yet.

John

But one of the things that makes Tamara mature and functional is that they aren't like, we're gonna go make a little, like, enclave and hide.

John

Because they recognize very intelligently, we are on one Earth and you can't hide.

John

We are on, you know, some kind of, like, sinking ship and that.

John

So they recognize that their vision, which is part of what keeps people also together in that solidarity, is having a common vision.

John

Their vision was like, hey, we need to make this functional, but as a model for what global peace culture could be like.

John

And we need to understand how what we're doing at this very local interpersonal level is also deep activism towards a global system change.

John

And they spent 50 years in the deep thinking and research and a really.

John

A really profound theory of really how change can happen through field effects, which is a whole thing we could go in, go like, into.

John

But the other thing they figured out, and I want to say also in this moment of fascism rising here in the US and really around the world, why we should be learning from the people that survived and how to deal with the aftermath of fascism.

John

Prior and Tamara is a German project that came out of World War II.

John

Germany.

John

It was the next generation of kids being like, what the happened?

John

Like that incredible guilt and responsibility put something in the founders and the early, early people in Tamara that was like, this can never happen again.

John

We have to actually find a different way.

John

And what they found was that fascism happens primarily through othering and through, like, repressed psychological, emotional content.

John

So their community, and any community is going to have to deal with this pretty much has to be organic, like, vestibule of healing, shadow of digesting trauma and pain.

John

And shadow.

John

And Tamara went straight in there and put shadow in the center in a very held way and continually healed and is still doing that work.

Jesse Hirsch

Yeah, I.

Jesse Hirsch

I want to pick.

Jesse Hirsch

I want to get you to double down on something you just said.

Jesse Hirsch

And while also not just citing the German experience, but the Spanish and Portuguese experience, because both the Spanish and Portuguese, of course, had extended fascist regimes that survived the Second World War.

Jesse Hirsch

Right.

Jesse Hirsch

So it went even longer.

Jesse Hirsch

And I think that has incubated a much different community centric culture that we don't have here in North America.

Jesse Hirsch

And that's why I want you to spend a bit of time unpacking the Othering.

Jesse Hirsch

Because so much of contemporary American culture is based on othering.

Jesse Hirsch

And the kind of connection I made when you said that is the extent to which.

Jesse Hirsch

And again, I'm using North America as the context.

Jesse Hirsch

This may be happening elsewhere, but it strikes me so much of community in North America is centered around othering, right?

Jesse Hirsch

We are who we are because we're not them, right?

Jesse Hirsch

We are the Democrats because we're not the deplorables.

Jesse Hirsch

We are the maga because we're not the elite, right?

Jesse Hirsch

And so much of that community construction of identity and the narratives and stories that go with it reinforce this culture of othering.

Jesse Hirsch

So I'd love for your thoughts on that, but in particular thoughts on how we reverse that, right?

Jesse Hirsch

Thoughts on how we bring it back to inclusive notions of community.

Jesse Hirsch

Especially when that fucker in the White House like he did an executive order against diversity, you know, inclusion and equity, like they are so vehemently committed to othering, right?

Jesse Hirsch

That it has infected our notion of community.

Jesse Hirsch

How do we counter that?

John

That's why I think also we should not fear because there, there's no real power in othering.

John

Yes, Hitler did heinous things, but at the end of the day there is a spiritual strike.

John

There's actually a really great book I recommend called the Fifth Sacred Thing by Starhawk who's actually speaking.

John

It's an incredible novel that really shows the political possibility of like a spiritual stance of inclusion.

John

It's an incredible book.

John

Just that's like a kind of a side thing.

John

But most people again think of community as like minded people.

John

And that couldn't be further.

John

This is not your interest group.

John

That's great to have, but that is not community was always a diversity.

John

That has to really be a holistic frackle, a holistic fractal of really the entire earth.

John

And not saying you need to have one person from every place, but it actually like diversity in any ecological system is what builds resilience.

John

And community is there to build social resilience.

John

Which again is why the nuclear family doesn't work.

John

It's just not resilient.

John

It is just inherently not a resilient thing.

John

And community is.

John

Which is a whole other thing we could go into.

John

But on the topic of othering and what we do about it.

John

So one I want to say that it is both a political pathway and a spiritual pathway.

John

So it's like yes, I do it because I care about the world and I do it because this makes me more fulfilled.

John

Because every time we are like othering, we're Actually othering a part of ourselves because what we other is repressed psychological is repressed parts of us.

John

So we therefore are not as whole and we are more innerly divided and full of essentially angst.

John

That's the opposite really of peace or like happiness or a contentment.

John

And you know, I want her to talk with this man, Daniel Schmachtenberger, who's like one of the most incredible existential thinkers.

John

Like this dude is tracking existential threat on the biggest level on planet Earth.

John

And when asked what is the most important thing we can do to like deal with existential threat at the largest level?

John

And what he said was go and have an open minded conversation with people that think differently than you and truly be curious.

John

Listen, do not come in again.

John

We need to also evolve to a place where our identity structure is not our beliefs.

John

That's also was also what makes Trump and Maga and those things weak and not real power is that there isn't real power in identity because it's not very actually a very like strong thing.

John

And so can you hold your beliefs in front of you loosely and actually talk to somebody who you might even hate and really consider there's a good reason they believe what they believe and if you had their life experience, you'd likely believe the exact same thing.

John

And where can you actually seek to grow understanding?

John

You don't have to necessarily agree with them, but to really hear people is the start of the revolution.

Jesse Hirsch

And there's an interesting kind of tangent to that on the research side, which is that persuasion doesn't work.

Jesse Hirsch

Like if you go into a situation wanting to persuade something of someone, best case scenario they're going to ignore you.

Jesse Hirsch

Worst case scenario, they're going to double down on the opposite just to piss you off.

Jesse Hirsch

And we mistake advertising for persuasion when advertising is just reaching out to the converted already and activating them.

Jesse Hirsch

Your point about community?

Jesse Hirsch

I've often had the definition that community are the people who will wipe my ass when I'm not able to.

Jesse Hirsch

I use that to be vulgar.

Jesse Hirsch

I use that to kind of give a sense that there's a commitment to community that I think in our consumer society, in our convenience society society, not a lot of people get to.

Jesse Hirsch

But I want you to talk about Tamara and I want you to talk about kind of the film that you did around it.

Jesse Hirsch

Partly because what we've been describing so far, while you and I fundamentally believe in it, it can still be a little abstract or even radical for some people.

Jesse Hirsch

But stories are real.

Jesse Hirsch

And I think in Tamara this is an example of community that, to your point, is not only mature, but is inspiring.

Jesse Hirsch

Right.

Jesse Hirsch

At a level.

Jesse Hirsch

Yeah.

Jesse Hirsch

That I think we need right now at a moment where people, quite frankly, are anxious.

Jesse Hirsch

Right.

Jesse Hirsch

And concerned about what comes next.

John

Thank you.

John

Yeah.

John

I mean, this film came through, really our souls in terms of.

John

I went to Tamara 11 years ago and I was like.

John

And I at the time, been a social change filmmaker seeking solutions to the crisis we.

John

We were in, are in.

John

And at Tamara, it was like, oh, it's not people just, like, doing some activism, maybe doing some cool permaculture.

John

It is like these people built a completely different society from the ground up.

John

And in that, what they figured out.

Jesse Hirsch

Can you give a sense of timeline?

John

Yeah.

John

So Tamara started really in the 60s, like, student movement.

John

One of their founders, Dieter Doom, wrote a book called Fear and Capitalism and really was talking about the way capitalism is built from fear and, like, othering.

John

And then in 1978, met his two other co founders and they started like, a community research.

John

Community research experiment that, like 20 people live together in a farmhouse for three years.

John

And it just slowly grew.

John

And at some point they're in Germany.

John

They actually got kicked out of Germany because one of the things that does make them very radical but also very successful, which is probably the most controversial, is that in their community, they don't operate from, like, morals.

John

They actually believe that getting past morality is part of the evolution of our species, because that's founded in static ideology.

John

But they have ethical principles.

John

The first and foremost are truth and transparency, all to build trust.

John

And when they found.

John

When they started actually doing this deep shadow work, the place of most conflict, you know, along really with power and money, is love and sexuality.

John

Because we've been programmed.

John

I'm saying that intentionally because of the loss of village over thousands of years, the idea of nuclear family and the story of the one has become like the Hollywood.

John

Hollywood injected trauma response at a cultural level to the loss of village.

Jesse Hirsch

Although I would go further, I mean, you're correct in evoking Hollywood as a powerful storyteller.

Jesse Hirsch

But let's not forget the church.

Jesse Hirsch

Right.

Jesse Hirsch

It's more than Hollywood.

Jesse Hirsch

It's Western culture as a whole.

John

Yes.

Jesse Hirsch

I think has embraced that narrative and promoted it.

John

And it makes so much sense.

John

The same way that in your own inner healing journey as a child, you grasped on to, like, survival.

John

Survival strategies that maybe don't actually serve you long term, but worked then.

John

It's like, yeah, it made sense in the loss of village to grab on to nuclear family, to Grab onto this idea of the one, the one and only, who's going to save you.

John

But that's just not a resilient system.

John

So the reason love and sexuality became so central is that the thing that prevents community.

John

I see this again and again and again, is people get in fear that they're going to lose their, like, mythic narrative of the one.

John

Or, you know, think of Trumpism.

John

It's all about family first.

John

But again, family as some isolated, separate unit from really, the community.

John

There's a deep coupling between, like, nuclear family first and nationalism, because there's no community in the center, which is where resilience and health actually works.

John

So, Tamara, over time, and they're often called a polyamorous village, but that isn't true.

John

They don't operate in these identities of, I'm polyamorous, I'm monogamous.

John

They operate in truth.

John

And when you're in a safe enough container with 150 people, it's often very true that you are attracted to or love more than one person.

John

It doesn't also mean that always has to equate to sexual love.

John

But even that, even in most, like, couples I know in the modern world, like, it's often people can't even have, like, friends of the.

John

Of the other sex, of the partner getting jealous and afraid.

John

So they really realize, okay, this is going to be the biggest block to actually building a community of solidarity.

John

So they had to put that in the center and do a lot of work.

John

So eventually they moved out of Germany, they moved to Portugal, and actually one of the most, like, communist parts of southern Portugal.

John

And they've been there the last 30 years, and they have been thriving.

John

They've been attracting young people, which is often hard for.

John

For projects that started 50, like, years ago.

John

They've been.

John

They've been regenerating their, like, land.

John

They have sister projects.

John

So the other, other thing is, again, with their imperative for global healing.

John

They've done work in crisis areas like Israel, Palestine, like Colombia, like India, like Africa.

John

And they have sister projects because they see these crisis areas as acupuncture points on planet Earth.

John

And they've had to stay because they do have a lot of privilege, but not even necessarily financial privilege, but it's the privilege of community, of a healthy society.

Jesse Hirsch

I'll go further.

Jesse Hirsch

Right.

Jesse Hirsch

Privilege is a word we tend to use in our liberal society to be polite.

Jesse Hirsch

What they have is power, right?

Jesse Hirsch

And they have this power partly because they've built a foundation upon which their ideas, their methodologies, because it is often about a more cooperative methodology, a collaborative methodology, than an exploitative one.

Jesse Hirsch

But as someone who has spent a lot of time in kind of anarchist milieus over the last several decades, I've certainly recognized that the people who are successful at polyamory are the people who are successful at conflict resolution.

Jesse Hirsch

Right.

Jesse Hirsch

Because to your point, conflict does tend to come up in things of love, in things of faith, in things of vulnerability.

Jesse Hirsch

And so when I say power, it strikes me that what you're describing is in developing skills of conflict resolution, in developing skills of mediation, that that in itself is a kind of power.

Jesse Hirsch

And we do have a shout out section at the end, but I will circumvent it and say a shout out to my comrade Josh Haner, who for years promoted this concept of the disarmy.

Jesse Hirsch

And the disarmy were a bunch of basically non violent conflict mediators who would willingly put themselves in harm's way between parties at conflict as a way to use their humanity to try to stop that conflict.

Jesse Hirsch

Tamara is obviously not at that level of martyrdom or heroism, but the reason I find this story so compelling is it provides a model of community that is not only successful and resilient, but is different.

Jesse Hirsch

Right.

Jesse Hirsch

Is radically different from what we see elsewhere.

Jesse Hirsch

And this leads me to ask you the question, as you've been showcasing this film, as you've been sharing this story, what are the kinds of reactions that you've been getting?

Jesse Hirsch

And I don't mean just the envy and people saying, oh, that's fucking awesome, sign me up.

Jesse Hirsch

I mean the more complicated reactions, even the hostile reactions.

Jesse Hirsch

And I say this as a fellow traveler wanting to anticipate where this dialogue is going now that we have a very clear, viable alternative that we can point to.

John

Yeah.

John

You know, I want to say that, you know, definitely most of the reactions are positive and most of the people, it's actually this sensation of like, oh my God, you've put into like, film.

John

And this place is doing something I, like in my heart knew as possible, but I couldn't even conceive of it yet.

John

Just the power of film.

John

We are broadcasting a vision for what's possible.

John

And we're also not saying, everybody go be Tamara.

John

It's going to look different everywhere.

John

But.

John

But their principles are things that they are.

John

They were trying to make a model or a blueprint.

John

And certainly we get people that have been like your parents, people have been hurt by community that see it as a pipe dream or they, they are curious or like.

John

But you're not showing all the shadow and we're like, well, the whole thing we actually were like showing is how they're digesting the shadow.

John

But like, they have, they have essentially a container way they have conflict all the time, but it's in a held container, like centralized as.

John

Like, this is what we do because it is power.

John

And certainly we get people that you can feel have a really deep ideology that this butts up against kind of the hetero cis, normative, like monogamy mandate that that is the only way possible.

John

And the thing is, and for the.

Jesse Hirsch

Record, we did see a fascist government elected partly on that assertion.

Jesse Hirsch

Like, they are so insecure about their identity, to your point, because we as a society are evolving our sexuality, we're evolving our sense of gender, we're evolving our sense of identity.

Jesse Hirsch

And.

Jesse Hirsch

And these reactionaries are so scared of what will be unleashed in their own mind even that they've elected this terror to office just to assert their traditional family values, which have no rooting in tradition whatsoever.

John

Right?

John

But the interesting thing is, and this is the kicker is like, even those people at the film screens or at Tamara, this is now a single line from that book, the fifth Sacred thing I mentioned.

John

But there is a seat for them at the table.

John

Because if that's your honest truth in that moment, Tamara and us will accept you and say, hey, brother, sister, whoever, whatever, like, come sit with us in that truth.

John

We're not here to change you, but we're also here to recognize that truth is ever changing.

John

And we're here just to be in that.

John

You don't have to protect that as your be all like static identity, but we welcome you with it.

John

And we also welcome you as you want to examine it or change or like, not.

John

And that's the thing, Tamara, isn't about an ideology.

John

It's about having a culture of transparency and truth.

John

Recognizing truth is not capital T, because that doesn't really necessarily exist, I think, at least in the form humans can speak about or conceive of or write down.

John

But in like, you can be in the ever flowing emergent expression.

John

And that's where you get to real community.

Jesse Hirsch

And this is where, you know, to play one of my own kind of personal theories.

Jesse Hirsch

I've often felt that the Internet defeats ideology.

Jesse Hirsch

And the reason that the Internet defeats ideology is because ideology is based on constraints and the Internet kind of abolishes constraints.

Jesse Hirsch

Because you're going to hear from everybody, right?

Jesse Hirsch

Anything is possible.

Jesse Hirsch

So instead, I kind of feel that we're entering a moment where politics is defined by methodology, right?

Jesse Hirsch

And that's what Temera has.

Jesse Hirsch

Tamara has a methodology, right?

Jesse Hirsch

A way of approaching the truth, a way of approaching community, a way of approaching conflict.

Jesse Hirsch

And still so much of contemporary society is obsessed with ideology, even the purity of ideology, when instead, and this is the old anarchist in me coming back, it's not about authorities, it's about process, right?

Jesse Hirsch

It's about how you engage the community and how you empower the community in an inclusive, participatory manner.

Jesse Hirsch

But, and here's where I kind of want to push you a little.

Jesse Hirsch

We do find ourselves in one hell of a conflict currently, right?

Jesse Hirsch

I often used to joke the class war is waged by the rich, right?

Jesse Hirsch

It's not as if the people are saying, oh, we need to rise up.

Jesse Hirsch

No, we are being waged war against constantly.

Jesse Hirsch

And we are now in a conflict with a fascist regime who, as a Canadian, they're already essentially declaring war on us and saying they're going to invade, right?

Jesse Hirsch

And crash our economy.

Jesse Hirsch

And our entire political system now is collapsing, ending chaos.

Jesse Hirsch

That's a literal hostile act to a so called NATO ally.

Jesse Hirsch

How do we respond?

Jesse Hirsch

And here I'm putting you on the spot and saying, how do you in America respond to your fellow Americans in this time of conflict?

Jesse Hirsch

Either so that we can create functional community that works now that we've kind of got not a blueprint, but a model that can be riffed on, iterated, improvised upon.

Jesse Hirsch

But how do you see yourself engaging other Americans around these topics when so many of them are intoxicated by the lies of fascism?

John

Yep, totally.

John

And again, I wanted to get to this.

John

I want to tell just a bit of a cultural story around initiation, which has been a big part of also my career work, because in traditional, healthy cultures, like indigenous ancestral cultures, cultures we all came from, at one point there were initiations to become a mature adult in that village.

John

And I think the bigger crisis we're seeing and the conflict at some scale, and I don't want to say this to excuse any of the mayhem happening to people like in Gaza or elsewhere or in this country, in your country.

John

And I think we are in a grand initiation that is trying to mature us.

John

So I think the way to respond, which I am calling culturally mature, a initiated way, is that you have boundaries, you know, you have boundaries against anything that's causing you harm.

John

And beyond having just boundaries, I personally just don't give if somebody's coming at me with a lot of, like, bigotry.

John

I don't, I don't, I don't talk back at them.

John

I mean, if they're, if they're up in my place, I need to set a boundary.

John

I'll set a boundary, which usually is me leaving or setting a boundary if it's, like, in my personal space.

John

But often it's not to engage because that's the hook.

John

We can't get hooked in the online fighting.

John

It's actually just don't resonate that Tamara has understood deeply about the principle of resonance, like the actual vibrational frequency.

John

So I just don't vibrate with it.

John

And that could sound a little bit esoteric, but I actually mean that in, like a second scientific kind of, like, way.

Jesse Hirsch

And even, even culturally, you know, the kids are all using the word vibes.

Jesse Hirsch

Right?

Jesse Hirsch

Like, the vibe's not right.

John

Yeah.

John

So again, if somebody comes at me with, like, bad vibes, like, kind of bigoted or othering vibes, I will hold my.

John

I will double down in my frequency, which is I'm bounded, I'm secure, and I have a, like, open heart and I see them with compassion and love, and I'm willing to engage them, but not at that frequency.

John

I will not engage somebody.

John

So I think we.

John

I think that Canada to the U.S.

John

i think we should.

John

Like, the thing about Trump, everybody plays his game because they.

John

Because they are afraid.

John

But if you're not afraid, you just don't have to, you know, like, Michelle Obama was very, very intelligent.

John

She was like the vibes of the whole thing.

John

She just didn't show up to the inauguration.

John

Like, that is just, for me, that's the answer.

John

Just don't, don't, don't.

John

Just play, play the game.

John

And yes, if somebody's coming at you, you need to set a boundary.

John

And, like, I'm not even against human beings setting a boundary by force.

John

Like, I would protect myself and my community from violence if I, like, needed to.

John

That's definitely my last resort.

John

So I'm not in this leftist.

John

Like, we just have an open heart.

John

We're going to, like, vibrate them to a new level.

John

No, sometimes you have to have a boundary, but you can always stay anchored in that open heart and set a boundary with yourself.

John

Not.

John

And I would even say this is the real ticket.

John

This is the thing I've been thinking about a lot.

John

Like, I really think part of the answer is to love Trump.

John

It's not to not hold him accountable.

John

It's not to not be like, dude, that's fucking messed up, and I'm saying no, but it's to be like, ultimately, man, I see that Deep down you're hurting and you're scared and you're really like insecure and like, oh, you know, because that is disarming.

John

That's part of that disarming you're talking about.

John

Because if I come back at him trying to play his game, I'm gonna lose because that game is a win lose game.

John

So I always lose because there are losers.

John

If you play the win win game, which is like, man, I see you're hurting.

John

Like, oh, dude, you don't have to do that.

John

You don't have to like do all that big talk because you're, you know, if you just kind of like, if you rise to a different level and don't vibrate, it can actually change people without the fight.

Jesse Hirsch

Well, and, and to your point, the, the win win requires empathy.

Jesse Hirsch

And unfortunately, empathy is not something a lot of people are practicing as regularly as they should.

Jesse Hirsch

So let, let me ask one last question before, please, I, I get you to talk about fugitive futures and how people can check out the film.

Jesse Hirsch

I think to go back to a phrase I used earlier, the kind of pandemic of loneliness.

Jesse Hirsch

I think there are a lot of people who desire community, but they don't know where to start.

Jesse Hirsch

And not only do they don't know where to start, but maybe they should be the one to start.

Jesse Hirsch

Maybe there are other people who would benefit from them initiating that community.

Jesse Hirsch

And paradoxically, even though I think we would both agree that the best communities are face to face, you still can have somewhat meaningful community using the digital technology we have, 100%.

Jesse Hirsch

So I'm curious again, not to get too deep into it.

Jesse Hirsch

This is more kind of a high level surface stuff.

Jesse Hirsch

But what advice would you have for people who, you know, you've a couple times been really provocative and I think quite correct in saying community is not an interest group.

Jesse Hirsch

It's not about people who you agree with.

Jesse Hirsch

What are your tips on helping people create and sustain meaningful community?

John

Yeah, totally.

John

There's a few different things.

John

I mean, what I want to say, there isn't necessarily a recipe or a formula, but there are best practices.

John

I want to say also community isn't out there.

John

It's not even necessarily to build.

John

It's like inner place to recognize you already are in community.

John

You already live around people.

John

And not just with people, with the plants, the animals, the trees are literally Exchanging Oxygen and CO2 with you, the sun.

John

And once you recognize I am in community and you start acting as if that is so.

John

For me, that's the first step which would Mean, say hi to your, like, neighbors, maybe invite them over for dinner, even if they're different or, like, weird.

John

Because it's not just going to be about the cool people you find either at some cool event or on the Internet.

John

And I'd say also be willing.

John

Community also comes in.

John

You create, like, a suction into it through your vulnerability.

John

And it's vulnerable to name.

John

Man, I'm lonely.

John

Like, in a healthy culture, in community, suffering is an opportunity for companionship.

John

So if you can also be vulnerable by saying, hey, I'm hurting, or I.

John

I really, like, want.

John

It's also vulnerable to say, I want this.

John

Like, I want community even, Right.

John

If you just wrote on Facebook, you know what people.

John

I'm recognizing, I want a different kind of life.

John

And I just want to put it out there that, like, I'm seeking more connection, more.

John

See what happens.

Jesse Hirsch

Let me push back there a little, only to get you to double down.

Jesse Hirsch

Because I have often used the phrase vulnerability is power.

Jesse Hirsch

And there's often nothing more powerful than being vulnerable.

Jesse Hirsch

And I have had so much shit thrown at me in response to that.

Jesse Hirsch

People are like, no, you're wrong, or, no, that's terrible.

Jesse Hirsch

And I still believe it.

Jesse Hirsch

It's still something I say.

Jesse Hirsch

But I have gotten a lot of blowback by trying to argue exactly what you just argued.

Jesse Hirsch

Because I think that vulnerability is not only the heart of community, it's the heart of trust.

Jesse Hirsch

Right.

Jesse Hirsch

And how we.

Jesse Hirsch

Yeah.

Jesse Hirsch

So please elaborate.

John

Yeah, Well, I say, like, if you're actually being vulnerable, you need to expect you're gonna get blowback.

John

That's what makes it vulnerable.

John

Right.

John

In various ways.

John

Because you being vulnerable is going to press on other people's vulnerabilities.

John

So you do at some level.

John

Also.

John

The thing is, you have to be like one.

John

You have to be intelligently vulnerable.

John

You need to actually check in what are my resources to be vulnerable in the way I'm wanting to be vulnerable.

John

And I want to say you can't be vulnerable as a.

John

As a manipulation.

John

There is a lot of people, especially in the kind of, like, alternative coaching world, that use vulnerability purely to sell.

John

And so I want to say there is ways that that actually isn't even real being vulnerable, but I want to say that you will find the power in that being resonated with.

John

And people are going to resonate with you.

John

And you need to also, as you come out into your own power, your own power is predicated on other people not liking you, disagreeing with you, and you don't waver.

John

You don't start fawning to appease people.

John

You just say like, hey.

John

So I want to say it's like also, it isn't like go jump into the deep end of being vulnerable.

John

It's like, what's the, what's the, what's the easiest, lowest hanging fruit of a vulnerable next step where you could be more honest.

John

Because that's what all it's about.

John

It's about vulnerability is you being more honest.

John

So where could you be more honest with your parents, with your partner, with your friends, about what you really want and what you're really afraid of or the grief you have?

John

Like, that's the step.

Jesse Hirsch

And I think that starts by being honest with yourself.

Jesse Hirsch

And in late stage capitalism, a lot of people are lying to themselves because you're often rewarded for doing so.

Jesse Hirsch

So being honest about yourself, that you desire community, that you'll thrive in community, and that community takes work, that it's not like everything else in the convenient society, designed for you.

Jesse Hirsch

Quite the opposite.

Jesse Hirsch

You are designed for community.

Jesse Hirsch

And that means that there's much work that needs to be done.

Jesse Hirsch

Which brings us to the last segment we have on every Meta views, which is the shout outs because I think it's really important to recognize that we all stand on the shoulders of giants.

Jesse Hirsch

And I want to shout out my friend Tamika, who I'm going to message the moment that this interview is done to let her know about Fugitive Futures, because I think she is going to get a kick out of what you're doing.

Jesse Hirsch

So before we do the shout outs, actually give us a quick promo again on Fugitive Futures and then another promo about the film and how people can connect.

John

So actually I'll start with the film, just because I think it's.

John

The film is the village of lovers and we committed 10 years ago to give this film away as a gift.

John

So it's available on our website on Gift Economy, which is our experiment with a different economical way.

John

We have a suggested donation, but you can pay zero.

John

And the film is going to like be one of the most inspiring things you have ever seen.

John

I fucking guarantee it.

John

I'm not saying you're still going to agree with it all or like it, but it is definitely something to expand your mind in a way different than it ever has been.

John

And so I want to say watch it with a friend, watch it with community, share it with your people.

John

Because it's meant to be a thing that inspires connection.

John

And we did it to ask better questions, not even necessarily give answers.

John

So that's Our prayer and fugitive futures is like, okay, we actually need a place where we can come together.

John

We're gathering some of the best thought leaders, whatever, I don't really like that term, but some of the best leaders who are doing all different wild facets of regenerative culture.

John

And we're gathering over a five day arc.

John

And you don't necessarily need to be there all five days, but there is an arc of experience where we're going through reckoning, through, through grief, through repair, through vision, through emergence.

John

We're really building a very open blueprint to what approaching the future in a more fugitive way would look like.

John

I also must say we're also doing it under ethical economics.

John

So we have ticket prices, but we also.

John

It's completely accessible to anybody if you just like, write us.

John

And if you need a different pricing structure, write us.

John

If people are like, you know what?

John

I can't pay anything.

John

We will still give it to you because we are trusting.

Jesse Hirsch

I will say that those prices are also quite reasonable.

Jesse Hirsch

Like in the world of events and conferences, it's accessible to begin with just from the pricing.

Jesse Hirsch

But it's great that you're providing that kind of pay what you can back door.

John

And I want to say we did something similar a year ago, but not even as good as we really learned from last year.

John

Last year we had 6,000 people come.

John

Not all at once.

John

People signed up and they were blown away.

John

Like, it really is something to be like, you know what we need to do?

John

We need to get fucking together and sit in the uncertainty.

John

And that's future.

John

The futures is like, let's sit together in the not knowing and see what happens.

John

And that's a lot more edgy and exciting than like come hear a bunch of answers.

John

It's like, no.

John

Bring your own questions, your own grief, your own longing.

John

We're going to like meet you there, have some deep inspirations, but we have speakers, we have like butterfly TED style talks, we have integration spaces every single day.

John

We have practical workshops.

John

Because that's also not just talk, but learn some practical skills.

John

It's really actually what we're saying is like this is part of the consciousness shift.

John

Come be part of it.

John

Your consciousness will be transformed.

John

Even if you come one day, like you will be transformed.

John

That is what we are creating and that comes from like the willingness to be in that uncertainty.

Jesse Hirsch

Right on.

Jesse Hirsch

So shout outs, anyone, living or dead, that you think our audience should know more about.

Jesse Hirsch

And you know one or two names, you don't need to get into your.

John

Entire yeah, I'm gonna say life story, four names.

John

I want to shout out to my dad, Blair Trotwine, who I'm living in his house right now.

John

I've been helping him and his in his retirement journey and his healing journey.

John

He's been helping me as I've been putting out this film the last year.

John

Shout out to my deceased mother, Suzanne Elizabeth Wilson Trotwind.

John

She's my guardian angel.

John

Me and her did not have an easy thing in life and in death has been a lot of healing.

John

So I want to say, just like ancestors matter.

John

And I also want to shout out to my two film partners, Ian McKenzie and Julia Marianska.

John

I've been on a 10 year journey with them as a team of three, and that has been the most revolutionary, like sticking together for 10 years, like bowing down to those two and us three for many ruptures, many repairs, many having to practice what we're preaching about conflict and community.

Jesse Hirsch

Right on.

Jesse Hirsch

Right on.

Jesse Hirsch

Well, thank you, John.

Jesse Hirsch

This has been a fantastic conversation.

Jesse Hirsch

I suspect a lot of our audience members, especially those who were part of intentional communities in the 70s, were probably leaning in and really being inspired by the way that our generations, newer generations, are picking up the cause, as it were.

Jesse Hirsch

And maybe we'll have you back in a few months to talk about fugitive futures and talk about how this stuff is moving on.

Jesse Hirsch

Because the main thing I've been wanting to hear, and I will want to hear, to hear, is how people are responding to all of this, because I think this is a ray of hope.

Jesse Hirsch

So that's been today's episode of Meta Views.

Jesse Hirsch

You can find us on the usual socials, but we'll be back soon with hopefully it probably won't be as good as an episode as this one.

Jesse Hirsch

We can't do this all the time, but nonetheless, we will be back with more good stuff.

Jesse Hirsch

Although Rick Salutin, I think, is our next episode, so it'll be almost as good as John.

Jesse Hirsch

But again, we'll see you all soon.