Mendel Skulski:

Hey! Welcome back. This is part two of our

Mendel Skulski:

two part series on dams. We're calling this episode Rushing

Mendel Skulski:

Downriver.

Music:

[Sploosh, with watery noises underscoring]

Mendel Skulski:

If you haven't already listened to part one,

Mendel Skulski:

you might want to put this on pause while you go get caught

Music:

[Watery noise picks up into steady, synthy music with

Music:

up.

Music:

gusts of wind and cunching of sand coming in the interview]

Anne Shaffer:

But you guys should see this, I mean-

Dave Parks:

So right here was there shore face, prior to dam

Dave Parks:

removal.

Mendel Skulski:

Wow . . . wow.

Dave Parks:

Yeah. So prior to the dam removal, this was the-we

Dave Parks:

would be in about 10 feet of water right here and the beach

Dave Parks:

ended right there, former shoreline.

Mendel Skulski:

This is something like 400 or 500 feet

Mendel Skulski:

of sandbar sedimentation has come in the last six years.

Anne Shaffer:

[The riverbed] was raised by three meters and then

Anne Shaffer:

pushed off 100 meters. So the actual river mouth is 100 meters

Anne Shaffer:

North of where it was and then deposited this delta of about

Anne Shaffer:

100 acres.

Mendel Skulski:

That's interesting.

Adam Huggins:

In that protective nook.

Mendel Skulski:

Okay, perfect. Ok what's the best? Best to have

Mendel Skulski:

the mic in the nook and then...

Adam Huggins:

Oh my goodness, yes. That's a great spot.

Mendel Skulski:

[Laughs] There we go.

Mendel Skulski:

[Only the steady, synthy music underscores now]

Anne Shaffer:

So there are a few, there like a fistful of

Anne Shaffer:

lessons, that have come from the Elwha. And the two that I try to

Anne Shaffer:

impart every time I talk to somebody about the project is:

Anne Shaffer:

these projects take a long time. They take a long time-they

Anne Shaffer:

shouldn't-they're-it's not rocket science, this isn't, but

Anne Shaffer:

they do. So-so you can't give up. You just can't.

Music:

[Music deepens with popping before dropping into an

Music:

intense, chilling electronic song with ecoing snaps and

Music:

seagulls]

Introduction voiceover:

Broadcasting from Vancouver, British

Introduction voiceover:

Columbia, on the unseeded territories of the Musqueam,

Introduction voiceover:

Squamish, and Tsleil-Waututh Peoples, this is Future

Introduction voiceover:

Ecologies, where your hosts, Adam Huggins and Mendel Skulski,

Introduction voiceover:

explore the future of human habitation on planet earth

Introduction voiceover:

through ecology, design, and sound.

Mendel Skulski:

Before the break, you heard Adam and I

Mendel Skulski:

getting introduced to the Pacific Northwest's newest

Mendel Skulski:

beach. It's located at the mouth of the Elwha River, which is on

Mendel Skulski:

the northern end of the Olympic Peninsula in Washington state.

Mendel Skulski:

Elwha's scenario is actually quite different from the

Mendel Skulski:

Klamath. This whole battle took place inside of a national park,

Mendel Skulski:

plus the nearshore, with a very different set of stakeholders.

Mendel Skulski:

It wasn't a case of farmers versus fishermen. In fact, in

Mendel Skulski:

some ways, it may have been much simpler. But still, the dam

Mendel Skulski:

removal wasn't settled practically until the walls came

Mendel Skulski:

down. In this episode, we'll move from the uncertain future

Mendel Skulski:

of the Klamath River to a watershed in the midst of

Mendel Skulski:

recovery, examining what it took to reach dam removal, and what

Mendel Skulski:

happened afterwards.

Music:

[Water over riverrocks washes over previous music]

Mendel Skulski:

Our tour guides were Anne Shaffer:

Anne Shaffer:

I'm Anne Shaffer, I'm the lead scientist and

Anne Shaffer:

executive director of the Coastal Watershed Institute...

Mendel Skulski:

...and her husband, Dave Parks:

Dave Parks:

I'm Dave Parks. I'm a geologist with the Washington

Dave Parks:

Department of Natural Resources and a cooperator with the

Dave Parks:

Coastal Watershed Institute.

Music:

[Cyclical, tapping music underscores]

Mendel Skulski:

The Elwha River was host to two dams, known as

Mendel Skulski:

the Elwha and the Glines Canyon Dams. Both were built in the

Mendel Skulski:

early 20th century in the hydroelectric craze which swept

Mendel Skulski:

North America, and they were demolished in 2012 and 2014, at

Mendel Skulski:

the conclusion of a bitter, multi-decade fight for their

Mendel Skulski:

removal. The Elwha Dam was constructed between 1910 and

Mendel Skulski:

1914, six years before the existence of the Federal Power

Mendel Skulski:

Commission, so the Elwha Dam predated the requirement for an

Mendel Skulski:

operating license. It didn't, however, predate the laws

Mendel Skulski:

requiring fish passage; it just ignored them.

Music:

[Music shines through with brighter tonal chords]

Mendel Skulski:

And construction was shoddy. The dam was built on

Mendel Skulski:

gravel, not bedrock. The lower section blew out after a heavy

Mendel Skulski:

rain in 1912. In case you don't already know, the Elwha

Mendel Skulski:

Watershed is the homeland of the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe, a

Mendel Skulski:

sovereign nation recognized by the US Federal Government. The

Mendel Skulski:

1912 failure of the Elwha Dam is known to the Klallam as "the day

Mendel Skulski:

the fish were in the trees"-several homes were

Mendel Skulski:

destroyed in the flood. And despite this, the dam was a

Mendel Skulski:

financial success. The owners of the Elwha Dam courted investors

Mendel Skulski:

to build a second dam, further upriver. The Glines Canyon Dam

Mendel Skulski:

was built by 1927. While the Elwha Dam put the Klallam under

Mendel Skulski:

personal peril, the Glines Canyon Dam delivered spiritual

violence:

flooding the valley where it was said, the creator

violence:

pulled the Klallam from the Earth.

Music:

[A mournful nighttime howl or birdcall is heard, then

Music:

the music is replaced with only undercurrents of water and

Music:

dripping]

Adam HugginsFirst::

Darkness.

Music:

[Angelic tones, like stained glass and summertime

Music:

join in the following audio]

Adam HugginsThen slowly:

Speaker:

Orange. There is only Orange and

Music:

[Deep synthy tones harmonize the angelic ones]

Music:

the taste of Salt, the taste of Yearning. Your whole world is a

Music:

sphere; jostled gently by the current, but your Waters are

Music:

still. Your body is not still, you wiggle and stretch, testing

Music:

your limits, pining to be free

Adam Huggins:

Beyond your sphere, your eyes resolve the

Adam Huggins:

movements of others. Your Sisters, your Brothers,

Adam Huggins:

thousands of siblings, quietly growing in the cold water, in

Adam Huggins:

the gravel bed, biding their time.

Adam Huggins:

[Music resolves into a meloncholy piano]

Mendel Skulski:

As early as the 1960s the effect of the Elwha

Mendel Skulski:

and Glines Canyon Dams on salmon populations was already clear.

Mendel Skulski:

As with the Klamath Dams, the opportunity for any sort of

Mendel Skulski:

change would come with a cycle of FERC relicensing. Remember,

Mendel Skulski:

all dams need to be periodically relicensed by the Federal Energy

Mendel Skulski:

Regulatory Commission, or FERC, for short.

Ryan Hilperts:

As the relicensing date was coming up,

Ryan Hilperts:

there was this-there was this coalition of people that came

Ryan Hilperts:

together in favor of making recommendations for the salmon

Ryan Hilperts:

to be returned. And so, it was the Sierra Club, the Friends of

Ryan Hilperts:

the Earth, Seattle Audubon and Olympic Park associates, which

Ryan Hilperts:

is an organization, that's a citizen organization that's

Ryan Hilperts:

interested in preserving and helping out the Olympic Park.

Ryan Hilperts:

They collaborated together to intervene in the FERC

Ryan Hilperts:

relicensing so it didn't just get to be a rubber stamp

Ryan Hilperts:

operation, these-these groups of activists and people had made a

Ryan Hilperts:

coalition and they intervened there. And so it sparked a big

Ryan Hilperts:

debate and so it was through, the through the 80s that that,

Ryan Hilperts:

as the licensing process was happening, there was this big

Ryan Hilperts:

debate being built about whether or not the dams could be made

Ryan Hilperts:

reasonable for ecological health or if they should be taken out

Ryan Hilperts:

altogether.

Music:

[Heavy beat with echoing claps starts underscoring]

Mendel Skulski:

That's Ryan Hilperts. She's an instructor at

Mendel Skulski:

the School of Environmental Studies at the University of

Mendel Skulski:

Victoria, and director of the Red Fish School of Change. You

Mendel Skulski:

may recall her voice from the top of part one, speaking about

Mendel Skulski:

restory-ing landscapes, as a way to build our relationships with

Mendel Skulski:

the places around us, but more on that later. In the lead up to

Mendel Skulski:

the demolition of the Elwha Dams, Ryan researched the

Mendel Skulski:

relationship between community engagement and the long term

Mendel Skulski:

success of large-scale ecological restoration projects.

Mendel Skulski:

Generations had passed since the dams had been built. Locals on

Mendel Skulski:

the Olympic Peninsula had grown up with the reservoirs and had

Mendel Skulski:

fond memories of swimming and fishing on these young lakes,

Mendel Skulski:

the electricity the dams provided had supported the

Mendel Skulski:

regional industry through the 20th century: forestry

Mendel Skulski:

especially.

Ryan Hilperts:

I did get the sense that . . . that there's a

Ryan Hilperts:

bit of a cultural shift happening on the Olympic

Ryan Hilperts:

Peninsula. And people have lived who have lived there for

Ryan Hilperts:

generations had the-had the memories in their families of

Ryan Hilperts:

the Park's annexation of a lot of private land. And, you know,

Ryan Hilperts:

so, so, aside from the whole Elwha project, the National Park

Ryan Hilperts:

well, you know, it wasn't always just a national park, people

Ryan Hilperts:

live there. And as the National Parks' boundaries sort of

Ryan Hilperts:

expanded over the years, they would, they bought a bunch of

Ryan Hilperts:

inholdings in the park. And people have opinions about that,

Ryan Hilperts:

you know, and so I think there's a bit of that, there's a thread

Ryan Hilperts:

of that that was a part of what people felt in opposition. And

Ryan Hilperts:

then also, you know, in the 90s, logging on the peninsula, was a

Ryan Hilperts:

really important industry and then through the 90s there was

Ryan Hilperts:

this whole thing that happened with the Spotted Owl in the

Ryan Hilperts:

forest [Spotted Owl cry] there, it's on the endangered species

Ryan Hilperts:

list and it created-the creation of the Northwest Forest Plan and

Ryan Hilperts:

really severely impacted the logging industry on the

Ryan Hilperts:

peninsula. And there's a perception here, I think a

Ryan Hilperts:

pretty accurate perception, that those changes came about from

Ryan Hilperts:

federal agencies and organizations, of people,

Ryan Hilperts:

environmental organizations, people who don't actually live

Ryan Hilperts:

on the Olympic Peninsula who live in Seattle, and live in

Ryan Hilperts:

Washington, DC, and organize for conservation purposes. And I

Ryan Hilperts:

think people on the Peninsula in the 90s and into the 2000s . . .

Ryan Hilperts:

still felt that they were in the crosshairs of-of that struggle

Ryan Hilperts:

over what can be done on the land.

Mendel Skulski:

Tensions over the removal of the dams

Mendel Skulski:

eventually grew into a national, partisan battle. Many people of

Mendel Skulski:

Port Angeles felt threatened by the changes called for by

Mendel Skulski:

environmentalists. They appeared as outsiders, happy to cast

Mendel Skulski:

opinions about a cloudy coast, they may never have visited,

Mendel Skulski:

homesteads and lands had once been annexed and absorbed into

Mendel Skulski:

Olympic National Park, and the memory of that loss had not yet

Ryan Hilperts:

And people love the Peninsula because they love

Ryan Hilperts:

faded.

Ryan Hilperts:

the place and they love the land and they love the forest and

Ryan Hilperts:

they engage with the land, you know. And then the park is

Ryan Hilperts:

a-park is a magnet for people from all these other places to

Ryan Hilperts:

come. And it's managed by people from other places and people who

Ryan Hilperts:

work the park. Some of them stay there for their whole careers,

Ryan Hilperts:

but a lot of you know the Parkies, in Port Angeles, come

Ryan Hilperts:

in seasonally, and leave so there's a bit of a-I don't want

Ryan Hilperts:

to over characterize that divide-but-but there is a bit of

Ryan Hilperts:

a divide there that I think . . . breeds a bit of a . . .

Ryan Hilperts:

suspicion or . . . resentment is kind of a strong word, but just

Ryan Hilperts:

protectiveness of autonomy that's challenged by having big

Ryan Hilperts:

federal agency control, like a majority of the land that's near

Ryan Hilperts:

where you live.

Music:

[Silence, then a gentle trickling of a riffle

Adam Huggins:

Weeks have passed. The Yolk is gone. Your egg,

Adam Huggins:

dissolved. The light of the shallows beckons. You and your

Adam Huggins:

fellow fry have developed a taste for insects humming at the

Adam Huggins:

water's surface. Life is easy and playful. The water is sweet

Adam Huggins:

and fresh. After only days, a few impatient siblings head

Adam Huggins:

downriver into the unknown. [Bubble noise] You will stay for

Adam Huggins:

a few months. Some may linger for several years.

Music:

[Trickling riffle gives way into an upbeat electronic

Music:

beat]

Mendel Skulski:

But after decades of debate, the National

Mendel Skulski:

Park Service finally came out in favor of dam removal in the

Mendel Skulski:

early 1990s.

Ryan Hilperts:

Some of the arguments that were really

Ryan Hilperts:

effectively made were that the cost of bringing it up to code

Ryan Hilperts:

essentially, out, you know, outweighed any of the benefits

Ryan Hilperts:

of having the dams in place. They weren't, by that point,

Ryan Hilperts:

they weren't producing very much electricity for the North

Ryan Hilperts:

Olympic Peninsula. They had originally been built to help

Ryan Hilperts:

kind of prop up this timber industry. And they were

Ryan Hilperts:

supplying electricity to the mills and things like that. And

Ryan Hilperts:

at this-by this point in history, that power was coming

Ryan Hilperts:

from someplace else, and there wasn't as much, as much need for

Ryan Hilperts:

them. So there's-there were pragmatic reasons that it didn't

Ryan Hilperts:

make sense to upgrade the dams.

Mendel Skulski:

Then in 1992, president George H.W. Bush

Mendel Skulski:

signed the Elwha River Ecosystem and Fisheries Restoration Act.

Mendel Skulski:

With that, came federal authorization to identify a path

Mendel Skulski:

to full restoration of the river.

Music:

[Upbeat electronic beat breaks through]

Mendel Skulski:

Rivers are the link between land and sea. No

Mendel Skulski:

ecosystem could ever be considered simple, but rivers

Mendel Skulski:

present uniquely challenging restoration projects. Rivers

Mendel Skulski:

pass sediment, wood, and nutrients downstream, dropping

Mendel Skulski:

debris along their banks-home to staggering biodiversity. And

Mendel Skulski:

some nutrients return to the l nd, in the form of salmon and

Mendel Skulski:

ther anadromous fish migrating p the river to spawn and die.

Music:

[Upbeat music then fades into riffle trickling noises]

Adam Huggins:

You and your fellow fry learn quickly in the

Adam Huggins:

clear, cold, sweet waters of your home. For now, you look

Adam Huggins:

more like a tiny glimmer of silver than the King Salmon you

Adam Huggins:

will become. To survive until then, you must be fast. The

Adam Huggins:

Goals will not reach you behind boulders, the mouths of hungry

Adam Huggins:

Bass and Sculpins can't chase you under branches. Gifts of

Adam Huggins:

safety from upriver. Floods threatened to wash you away

Adam Huggins:

before your time, but you find refuge in the many side

Adam Huggins:

channels. Life is dangerous, but the river provides.

Mendel Skulski:

At the northern edge of the Olympic Peninsula,

Mendel Skulski:

just across the Strait of Juan de Fuca from Vancouver Island,

Mendel Skulski:

Port Angeles is 15 minutes from the Elwha River. Living and

Mendel Skulski:

working in Port Angeles since the early 1990s, Anne Schaefer

Mendel Skulski:

and Dave Parks have been studying the Elwha nearshore,

Mendel Skulski:

where the river meets the ocean.

Music:

[Gentle wind and waves backdrop the audio]

Anne Shaffer:

The first time I heard about the dam removal

Anne Shaffer:

project, we were living in Seattle, and I think I don't

Anne Shaffer:

even remember who I'd heard about it from. But I was

Anne Shaffer:

interested in doing a study looking at the estuary prior to

Anne Shaffer:

the dam removal happening. This was-this was prior to the actual

Anne Shaffer:

enabling legislation, which was in 1992. And one of my first

Anne Shaffer:

recollections of the project was arguing with the project

Anne Shaffer:

manager, Brian Winter, at the National Park, who, and I'll

Anne Shaffer:

never forget it, stated, quote, unquote, "that the near shore

Anne Shaffer:

was not a part of the project". And so from that day forward, it

Anne Shaffer:

was a very keen focus of mine, as a marine biologist, to-to

Anne Shaffer:

really get a handle and some vision on the near shore aspect

Anne Shaffer:

of the dam removal project.

Mendel Skulski:

Biodiversity flourishes at boundaries, where

Mendel Skulski:

different environments blur together. The nearshore is no

Mendel Skulski:

exception.

Anne Shaffer:

And the nearshore system is such a critical

Anne Shaffer:

component to all the species that are at the heart of the

Anne Shaffer:

rest-or ecosystem restoration project.

Mendel Skulski:

The nearshore is a place for young anadromous

Mendel Skulski:

fish to adapt from river life to the open ocean. It's hosts to

Mendel Skulski:

incredible numbers of algae, invertebrates and plants. And

Mendel Skulski:

it's the foundation of the food web for many birds; the

Mendel Skulski:

jurisdiction for dam removal had been defined by the borders of

Mendel Skulski:

the Olympic National Park, which does not include the river mouth

Mendel Skulski:

and the nearshore. Despite that, Anne knew that categorically

Mendel Skulski:

ignoring the estuary would be a glaring omission in the project,

Mendel Skulski:

and a huge missed opportunity for research.

Anne Shaffer:

There were elements to it that nobody was

Anne Shaffer:

looking at, and one of the most basic questions of what is the

Anne Shaffer:

relative contribution of the river and the bluffs to the

Anne Shaffer:

sediment dynamics of the littoral system? And nobody

Anne Shaffer:

could answer that, which is shocking when you think about

Anne Shaffer:

the scale of the project and that was going to unfold and in

Anne Shaffer:

the important thing to remember with the Elwha project is it's a

Anne Shaffer:

sediment project. And so when you release two dams, you do

Anne Shaffer:

restore the fish passage aspect but that's not the critical

Anne Shaffer:

ecosystem component to it, it's the real linking of the

Anne Shaffer:

hydrodynamic processes, and that translates to the nearshore as

Anne Shaffer:

well.

Adam Huggins:

When you say, you say, "littoral", you're not

Adam Huggins:

meaning literally?

Anne Shaffer:

The littoral system.

Dave ParksLittoral:

Speaker:

L-I-T-T-O-R-A-L.

Music:

[Electronic swaying music enters]

Mendel Skulski:

The littoral system essentially means: the

Mendel Skulski:

shoreline. It includes the waters of the intertidal and the

Mendel Skulski:

shallow edge of the ocean.

Music:

[Holds a slightly, discordant tone, rising in pitch

Music:

before fading into a triumphant piano]

Adam Huggins:

One night-restless-you feel a call

Adam Huggins:

for change.

Adam Huggins:

Tail first, by moonlight. You let the current carry you.

Adam Huggins:

You wind downriver past eddies, over riffles, rapids, and falls.

Music:

[Piano fades under and plays steadily with riverwater

Music:

sounds]

Adam Huggins:

You notice a new taste . . . No.

An old taste. The first taste:

Speaker:

Salt. You've reached the

An old taste. The first taste:

Speaker:

estuary, where Sweetwater meets the Sea. You'll rest here a

An old taste. The first taste:

Speaker:

while, learn to eat crustaceans and grow.

Music:

[Piano plays with some small oceanic noises and long,

Music:

sustained tones, then into watery noises]

Anne Shaffer:

So many of the species that are central to the

Anne Shaffer:

nearshore ecosystem restoration project have life history phases

Anne Shaffer:

that are literally dependent on the nearshore. So the juvenile

Anne Shaffer:

salmon that are outmigrating from the river, use the near

Anne Shaffer:

shore to rear, to feed, to rest, and to transition into their

Anne Shaffer:

marine and offshore phases. There are smelt species that are

Anne Shaffer:

anadromous that will migrate along the shoreline and then

Anne Shaffer:

come up the river to spawn, there are lamprey species that

Anne Shaffer:

are very critical to the ecosystem of the watershed. And

Anne Shaffer:

then there are also smelt species that will use the

Anne Shaffer:

shoreline for migration and spawning-they actually spawn on

Anne Shaffer:

intertidal beaches, as do Sand Lance-and those are collectively

Anne Shaffer:

called forage fish, and forage fish are the basis, for again,

Anne Shaffer:

our coastal system, everything from, you know, salmon to killer

Anne Shaffer:

whales depend on them. So and, without the nearshore, we don't

Anne Shaffer:

have the species, we just don't have them.

Mendel Skulski:

The nearshore, the estuary is built out of

Mendel Skulski:

sediment, erosion in the watershed, which ends up at the

Mendel Skulski:

river mouth as silt and sand. The amount of sediment at the

Mendel Skulski:

nearshore is in equilibrium; it's replenished by the river

Mendel Skulski:

and washed away by the tides. When a dam is built, this

Mendel Skulski:

balance is lost; sediment accumulates behind the dam and

Mendel Skulski:

the beautiful, complex nearshore ebbs away.

Anne Shaffer:

It's a key component to the ecosystem. It's

Anne Shaffer:

its own zone in the ecosystem, and without it, the rest of the

Anne Shaffer:

watershed doesn't function.

Mendel Skulski:

Of course, to understand the estuary and the

Mendel Skulski:

pressures put upon it by the dam, it takes significant

resources:

time, personnel, and of course, funding.

Music:

[Deep, echoing electronic music with snaps is recalled]

Mendel Skulski:

Anne and Dave made a personal commitment to

Mendel Skulski:

study the nearshore and the Klallan were doing the same. But

Mendel Skulski:

as long as funding remained uncertain, no university would

Mendel Skulski:

spare a grad student. There was no institutional support to

Mendel Skulski:

study the Elwha nearshore.

Music:

[Music fades back to running water]

Anne Shaffer:

Enabling legislation was enacted in 1992.

Anne Shaffer:

That legislation was actually the resolution of a lawsuit by

Anne Shaffer:

the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe against the Olympic National

Anne Shaffer:

Park for violating their Treaty Trust Responsibility. The dam

Anne Shaffer:

removal legislation was a settlement of that lawsuit. So

Anne Shaffer:

that was enacted in 1992, and then it took 25 years of

Anne Shaffer:

planning and political, you know, shenanigans, and it was a

Anne Shaffer:

long, long process, it took 13 appropriations. And for those of

Anne Shaffer:

us that worked on the project over its entirety, we never knew

Anne Shaffer:

if or when the project was actually going to happen.

Mendel Skulski:

Then in 2009, the Obama administration issued

Mendel Skulski:

an economic stimulus package, which included $54 million for

Mendel Skulski:

the Olympic National Park, much of which was earmarked for the

Mendel Skulski:

dam removals. From there, the race was on, to collect as much

Mendel Skulski:

baseline data as possible.

Anne Shaffer:

But as soon as the final pieces of funding dropped

Anne Shaffer:

into place, everybody was out here. So a lot of the data sets

Anne Shaffer:

start about two years before the dam removal. And there, we

Anne Shaffer:

started getting a lot of the nearshore data. So then you

Anne Shaffer:

start seeing some of these other richer data sets. And so that

Anne Shaffer:

was really what did it-it was-it was that last gap in the

Anne Shaffer:

funding, when that dropped into place, bam, everybody was out

Anne Shaffer:

here.

Mendel Skulski:

Most of what we know about the state of the

Mendel Skulski:

river prior to dam removal comes from only 18 months of data

Mendel Skulski:

between the stimulus package and the start of demolition.

Mendel Skulski:

Finally, almost exactly a century after they were built,

Mendel Skulski:

the Elwha and Glines Canyon Dams were carefully broken apart.

Mendel Skulski:

Once again, the Elwha River flowed free and 100 years of

Mendel Skulski:

sediment was released.

Anne Shaffer:

And I have to say ever since that project, every

Anne Shaffer:

time I hear a jackhammer, [Jackhammer rattles away] I

Anne Shaffer:

just, it just warms my heart, [Laughs] you know which I've

Anne Shaffer:

never had that attitude before, so.

Music:

[Deep, clacking tones from the depths echo into

Music:

silence]

Adam Huggins:

You make your rounds through the shallows and

sandbanks:

patterns that shift, but always repeat. You notice

sandbanks:

some krill in the shallows, but they're not worth your while. A

sandbanks:

shimmer catches your eye, a school of smelt, you flank them,

sandbanks:

deftly into a corner and snatch one to make your meal. It dawns

sandbanks:

on you that you no longer fit as easily into the side channels,

sandbanks:

under the branches, or behind the boulders. It hardly matters.

sandbanks:

Predators rarely bother you these days. You've grown, and

sandbanks:

your power has grown with you. Your estuary once so large and

sandbanks:

Labyrinthine has softened in its mystery, your next move is upon

sandbanks:

you, and you venture out into the depths.

Music:

[The same tones are sounded again, gently

Music:

underscoring]

Mendel Skulski:

And just as soon as the dam came down, the fish

Mendel Skulski:

were back.

Dave Parks:

As soon as, as soon as you pull the dam out, those

Dave Parks:

the fish are in there, just how fast these habitats become used.

Dave Parks:

They they make use of the available habitat very quickly.

Dave Parks:

Some within, literally within hours-

Anne Shaffer:

-We've seen a transition. And almost

Anne Shaffer:

immediately, we saw this whole new . . . It was like Christmas.

Mendel Skulski:

Animals that had never been seen before in the

Mendel Skulski:

nearshore were suddenly being documented. Fish like hooligan,

Mendel Skulski:

redside shiner and lamprey.

Anne Shaffer:

Now the sense is, my intuition, just from working

Anne Shaffer:

out here for so long-and the data are starting to show

Anne Shaffer:

it-things seem to be stabilizing.

Mendel Skulski:

But the story of a river renewal is almost as

Mendel Skulski:

nuanced as the river itself.

Anne Shaffer:

But the other feature that dominates, and this

Anne Shaffer:

is what we've seen from our sampling, that dominates the

Anne Shaffer:

system are the hatcheries. We have two hatcheries that operate

Anne Shaffer:

in the Lower Elwha. One's operated by the Lower Elwha

Anne Shaffer:

Klallam Tribe, and they release Coho and Steelhead, and then the

Anne Shaffer:

other is the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife

Anne Shaffer:

hatchery and they release upwards of 2 million.

Mendel Skulski:

And the return of the nearshore has created

Mendel Skulski:

habitat for more than just fish and shorebirds. The Pacific

Mendel Skulski:

Northwest's newest beach has become a quick hit with the

Mendel Skulski:

local human population.

Anne Shaffer:

As this delta evolves and grows-it's grown by

Anne Shaffer:

just about 80 acres-it's become very popular for people, and

Anne Shaffer:

it's basically become a dog park. And so now we're having

Anne Shaffer:

this intersection between the evolving and restoring

Anne Shaffer:

ecosystem-

Adam Huggins:

-and canines-

Anne Shaffer:

-and people that own them.

Music:

[Dogs barking, then pointed synth music fades in]

Mendel Skulski:

It's all too easy to think of ecosystem

Mendel Skulski:

restoration as a time machine, a way to turn back the clock and

Mendel Skulski:

undo the damage we've sown in our Industrial Age. But that's

Mendel Skulski:

not how dynamic systems work. The conditions are different

Mendel Skulski:

now. And change, begets change.

Anne Shaffer:

The thing that we really have to now again, we're

Anne Shaffer:

having to manage for, is because this has become such a

Anne Shaffer:

destination. Now, like I say, immediately what's happening is

Anne Shaffer:

people are challenging it again. So in ways that I don't think

Anne Shaffer:

they would have otherwise because there is such a nice

Anne Shaffer:

beach here and it, you know, it does have the caché, the Elwha

Anne Shaffer:

caché. So now we are seeing, you know, extra development, extra,

Anne Shaffer:

you know, increase in real estate rates.

Mendel Skulski:

The near shoreprovides all sorts of

Mendel Skulski:

ecosystem services, some of which have direct impacts to

Mendel Skulski:

human capital. A healthy near shore comes with flood

Mendel Skulski:

protection and short breaks, making coastal development that

Mendel Skulski:

much more appealing.

Music:

[Music breaks through before dropping and flattening

Music:

into a deep twinkling night like the depths of the sea]

Adam Huggins:

Out at sea, the world is deep and boundless.

Adam Huggins:

Your juvenile years are a distant memory. you've traveled,

Adam Huggins:

seen wonders, monsters, and sights beyond imagination. You

Adam Huggins:

rise towards the waves and feel a small tug inside of you. A

Adam Huggins:

magnet in your mind, your blood pulses with new hormones, and

Adam Huggins:

you can feel them rebuilding your body one cell at a time.

Adam Huggins:

You recall a faraway taste.

Adam Huggins:

You're going home.

Music:

[Low, profound tones underscore]

Mendel Skulski:

In as much as ecosystem restoration is a human

Mendel Skulski:

project, the measure of its success lives in the minds of

Mendel Skulski:

people, especially those who call that land home. This kind

Mendel Skulski:

of success is not based on data points, and checklists, and

Mendel Skulski:

mandates. It's sustained by the stories we tell our personal

Mendel Skulski:

connection to our world. Ryan Hilperts explains:

Music:

[Deep, pulsing music from Part 1: Swimming Upstream is

Music:

recalled]

Ryan Hilperts:

As we build relationships with each other

Ryan Hilperts:

through story, we build relationship with place through

Ryan Hilperts:

story. And, you know, the places where people are building

Ryan Hilperts:

stories. And building relationship with place I think

Ryan Hilperts:

is, this sort of like, the connective tissue of of what the

Ryan Hilperts:

potential focal restoration can be, you know, in the, in the: we

Ryan Hilperts:

build a web and a reciprocity with land when we and water when

Ryan Hilperts:

we-when we know it in the way that it's a character in our

Ryan Hilperts:

stories and we're a character in its story.

Music:

[Resonant, acoustic notes begin and reverberate]

Mendel Skulski:

Realistically, major projects such as dam

Mendel Skulski:

removals, require huge budgets, planning and clear definitions.

Mendel Skulski:

These projects can only be taken on by government-scale entities.

Mendel Skulski:

Their approach to restoration is necessarily bureaucratic and

Mendel Skulski:

technological, and it seems like the only way to marshal the

Mendel Skulski:

people and the resources required.

Ryan Hilperts:

That's not to say that people who work

Ryan Hilperts:

professionally in restoration, don't have stories with place,

Ryan Hilperts:

you know, but if we, but if we can see the restoration in the

Ryan Hilperts:

way it excludes people who aren't engaged with it

Ryan Hilperts:

professionally, then-then we lose this opportunity to build

all that:

that web of support for a place, for communities to.

Mendel Skulski:

So, focal community engagement means

Mendel Skulski:

talking about the land, making art about the land, and above

Mendel Skulski:

all, getting as many people as possible to have experiences

Mendel Skulski:

with the land.

Ryan Hilperts:

Partnerships with unlikely partners I think is

Ryan Hilperts:

important. So, partnerships with elementary schools, and

Ryan Hilperts:

environmental education programs, and math classes,

Ryan Hilperts:

and-you know-organizations for new immigrants, like refugee

Ryan Hilperts:

support agencies, I mean, thinking outside of the box of

Ryan Hilperts:

just your conservation groups, to, to think about who, who

Ryan Hilperts:

cares for this place now and who will care for this place like,

Ryan Hilperts:

you know, finding ways to have all the different kinds of

Ryan Hilperts:

knowledge and all the different kinds of wisdom and all the

Ryan Hilperts:

different kinds of stories be a part of how decisions get made

Ryan Hilperts:

about restoration is probably what we should be aiming for.

Ryan Hilperts:

Because diversity is better. Yeah, and it's we can't be-it's

Ryan Hilperts:

like you can really put that on a checklist for restoration.

Music:

[Soft, resonant acoustic notes play, before a wave washes

Music:

over and somber piano from music from Part 1: Swimming Upstream

Music:

is recalled]

Mendel Skulski:

So, with so much uncertainty, what's the story

Mendel Skulski:

with the Klamath now?

Adam Huggins:

Well, the dams are still there. And salmon

Adam Huggins:

populations have reached historic lows in recent years.

Adam Huggins:

But even though the Klamath Basin restoration agreement fell

Adam Huggins:

apart after Congress blocked it, it looks like the dams might

Adam Huggins:

still come out. Ironically, though, some of the concessions

Adam Huggins:

and measures to protect farmers and irrigation districts-that

Adam Huggins:

were a big part of that deal-they died with it in

Adam Huggins:

Congress. And without those measures, many of the

Adam Huggins:

constituents of the representatives that torpedoed

Adam Huggins:

the deal are going to suffer. You might say that ideology

Adam Huggins:

trumps self-interest in this case.

Erica Terrence:

It is a really interesting political

Erica Terrence:

phenomenon, and it hasn't completely played itself out,

Erica Terrence:

right? Like some of those guys are still in office. But there

Erica Terrence:

was a lot of frustration on the part of these Federal Irrigation

Erica Terrence:

Districts that were trying really hard to bridge this gulf

Erica Terrence:

between communities, and, you know, here, all these people

Erica Terrence:

overcame their differences and went to Congress people and

Erica Terrence:

said, here, we did it for you.

Adam Huggins:

And even though Congress passed, there was still

Adam Huggins:

so much momentum for dam removal, that the primary

Adam Huggins:

stakeholders sat down again to figure out how to at least take

Adam Huggins:

the dams out, which resulted in the Klamath Hydroelectric

Adam Huggins:

Settlement Agreement.

Erica Terrence:

So now, there is an amended Klamath Hydroelectric

Erica Terrence:

Settlement Agreement, which is the KHSA you were talking about,

Erica Terrence:

and basically what happened, you know, there was a lot of

Erica Terrence:

campaigning political pressure put on PacifiCore that owns the

Erica Terrence:

dams, to the point where PacifiCore eventually said, this

Erica Terrence:

is not worth the bad press, we'll take dams out. So what we

Erica Terrence:

did as a mechanism, you know, the legislation failed in

Erica Terrence:

Congress. So who's gonna actually do the work? Who's

Erica Terrence:

going to take the dams out? It's not going to be the feds. It's

Erica Terrence:

not going to be tribes. So who is it going to be? And what they

Erica Terrence:

ended up doing was forming a corporation, right? That could

Erica Terrence:

take liability, that could accrue the funds, you know, and

Erica Terrence:

handle the money. And that's what happened. So now we have

Erica Terrence:

this Klamath River Renewal Corperation, which is crazy, but

Erica Terrence:

kind of cool, too. I mean, it is this corporate model, right?

Erica Terrence:

It's like a corporation built those dams and a corporation's

Erica Terrence:

gonna take those dams down!

Adam Huggins:

There's still one last major hurdle to clear. The

Adam Huggins:

FERC still has to sign off on the agreement. And right now,

Adam Huggins:

four out of the five FERC commissioners are Trump

Adam Huggins:

appointees. Not the high profile ones that show up in our news

Adam Huggins:

feeds. But still, it's enough to make me concerned that a sort of

Adam Huggins:

pro-dam ideology could prevail again.

Erica Terrence:

I think it is a worry, but what we've heard or

Erica Terrence:

had telegraphed, even out of the Trump administration,

Erica Terrence:

interestingly, is that they won't block it.

Adam Huggins:

So if everything goes smoothly, then the dam

Adam Huggins:

should be coming out in 2021.

Erica Terrence:

You know, there's a lot of ways to remove

Erica Terrence:

a dam. One of them is to like, clean everything up afterwards,

Erica Terrence:

right? Remove all the sediment and remove all the rebar and

Erica Terrence:

concrete and another one is just to like kind of blast it, leave

Erica Terrence:

the rubble and then that becomes like part of your stream

Erica Terrence:

structure, right.

Music:

[Bubbly water jet washes over then a steady clapping

Music:

track plays]

Erica Terrence:

You know, we don't really understand . . .

Erica Terrence:

how to restore a system. And a lot of times the best solution

Erica Terrence:

is the simplest solution. You know, when you put large, woody

Erica Terrence:

debris in a stream, which we do deliberately to enhance fish

Erica Terrence:

habitat, you often don't fret too much about the placement of

Erica Terrence:

the logs. Which you used to do, you used to try to like fix it

Erica Terrence:

in permanently with rebar and yeah, and the stream is gonna

Erica Terrence:

blow it out in the high water anyway and put it where it wants

Erica Terrence:

to. And then it might blow it a mile or two downstream and then

Erica Terrence:

you have these things, we call them "catcher mitts" that catch

Erica Terrence:

other wood, which is good, we want that.

Erica Terrence:

But you might as well just let the stream decide and it's

Erica Terrence:

probably a similar story with all the rubble from the dam,

Erica Terrence:

right? It's cheaper to do it that way.

Adam Huggins:

Is that-is that what's gonna happen?

Erica Terrence:

It looks very likely that's what's gonna

Erica Terrence:

happen.

Adam Huggins:

Ah! So this is more the Rambo approach

Adam Huggins:

[Laughs]-

Erica Terrence:

-yeah [Laughs]-

Adam Huggins:

-to dam removal. [Laughs] the Elwha was so

Adam Huggins:

controlled that I watched videos of it.

Erica Terrence:

Yeah! I loved atching the videos of the

Music:

[Warm, glowing notes play over the steady track]

Music:

lwha. This like, soothing, like ah, it can work, lo

Erica Terrence:

No one has, in the history of the world, has

Erica Terrence:

really done a dam removal this big, and they're still building

Erica Terrence:

them in BC and China, much larger, right? So conceivably,

Erica Terrence:

someday, we will be taking those out. But at this point the Elwha

Erica Terrence:

is the biggest in the record books and then the Klamath will

Erica Terrence:

be that much bigger, still.

Music:

[Steady clap track and intermittent glowing notes conti

Music:

ue, an auditory riffle pl

Mendel Skulski:

And that's it for our two part series on dams.

Mendel Skulski:

We'll be back in a couple of weeks. If you live near a river,

Adam Huggins:

...and make some stories together.

Adam Huggins:

dammed up or otherwise, please take some time to get to know

Adam Huggins:

it

Mendel Skulski:

If you'd like to see the photo that Anne took of

Mendel Skulski:

Adam and I in our driftwood recording studio, check out our

Mendel Skulski:

Instagram @futureecologies.

Adam Huggins:

Please tell everyone you know, subscribe,

Adam Huggins:

rate, and review the show wherever podcasts can be found.

Adam Huggins:

It really helps us get the word out.

Mendel Skulski:

In this episode, you heard Anne Schaffer, Dave

Mendel Skulski:

Parks, Ryan Hilperts and Erica Terrence.

Adam Huggins:

This has been an independent production of Future

Adam Huggins:

Ecologies. Our first season is supported in part by the

Adam Huggins:

Vancouver foundation. If you'd like to help us make the show,

Adam Huggins:

you support us on Patreon. We have a whole series of mini

Adam Huggins:

episodes available to our supporters. To get access to

Adam Huggins:

these, head over to patreon.com/futureecologies.

Mendel Skulski:

You can also follow us on Facebook,

Mendel Skulski:

Instagram, and iNaturalist, the handle is always

Mendel Skulski:

futureecologies.

Adam Huggins:

Special thanks to Jose Isordia, Christy Johnston

Adam Huggins:

Monroe Cameron,

Mendel Skulski:

Nicole Jahraus, Ilana Fonariov,

Adam Huggins:

Schuyler Lindberg, Vincent van Haaff, and Andrjez

Adam Huggins:

Kozlowski.

Mendel Skulski:

Music in this episode was produced by

Mendel Skulski:

Radioactive Bishop, Kieran Fearing, and Sunfish Moonlight.

Mendel Skulski:

You can find a full list of musical credits, show notes, and

links on our website:

Speaker:

futureecologies.net.

Music:

[Auditory riffle returns and music fades to silence]