Speaker:

Hi, welcome to another special edition of Transit Unplugged.

Speaker:

I'm Tris Hussey editor of the podcast.

Speaker:

And this week we have Metro perspectives from Metro magazine.

Speaker:

Metro magazine, executive editor, Elle Truman interviews, Paul and

Speaker:

frequent transit unplugged guest, Davey Kim, but some of the hottest issues

Speaker:

going on in transit right now, like funding and just, how are we going

Speaker:

to wean ourselves off the gas tax?

Speaker:

As people stop using gas.

Speaker:

So stay tuned for this whole episode.

Speaker:

Hope you enjoy it.

Speaker:

Hi, I'm Alex Roman, Executive Editor for Metro Magazine, and

Speaker:

welcome back to Metrospectives.

Speaker:

Today, my guests are Transit Evangelist, Paul Comfort, and WSP USA's Davie Kim.

Speaker:

Today, the guys joined me to discuss Paul's new book, The New

Speaker:

Future of Public Transportation, as well as Davie's chapter in on the

Speaker:

future of public transit funding.

Speaker:

This is a great talk.

Speaker:

Both of these guys got a ton of experience.

Speaker:

Hope you enjoy it.

Speaker:

Thanks for tuning in.

Speaker:

Well, thanks for joining me today, guys.

Speaker:

Uh, how's it going?

Speaker:

Excellent.

Speaker:

Doing great.

Speaker:

Thanks, Alex.

Speaker:

Good, good.

Speaker:

So we're here on the occasion of another Paul Comfort book.

Speaker:

Uh, Paul, can you talk a little bit about, uh, the book you have coming up and, and.

Speaker:

You know what, what you tried to capture in this one.

Speaker:

Boom, baby.

Speaker:

Six books in six years.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And uh, thanks to guys like Davey Kim.

Speaker:

Uh, this one is as back to number one on Amazon.

Speaker:

So very happy about that.

Speaker:

Uh, basically the idea behind all my books, Alex, and this one in

Speaker:

particular is, um, I like to highlight Trans in the industry and, and talk

Speaker:

to the most, you know, the most, uh, experienced and people with the most

Speaker:

expertise in the industry about it.

Speaker:

So that's what this book is.

Speaker:

Uh, we, I'd written a book called the future of public

Speaker:

transportation that was published.

Speaker:

If people will remember back, it was published in March of 2020, you know,

Speaker:

the month that the pandemic hit the country, and so much has changed since

Speaker:

then for public transportation, uh, that, uh, SAE, the publisher, Society

Speaker:

of Automotive Engineers, reached out to me about nine months ago and said, Paul,

Speaker:

you know, we, we loved your first book.

Speaker:

We'd like you, we'd like to publish one for you now, um,

Speaker:

on what the new topics are.

Speaker:

I mean, you know, five years ago, You didn't hear about every month a

Speaker:

transit system having a, um, cyber attack where they were hacked and

Speaker:

had to have, you know, uh, with ransomware and that kind of thing.

Speaker:

Five years ago, you weren't even thinking about how AI was going to,

Speaker:

uh, impact public transportation.

Speaker:

Five years ago We weren't thinking about new ways to fund public transportation,

Speaker:

such as Dave is going to talk about today.

Speaker:

There's so many new things that have happened.

Speaker:

So that's what the book is.

Speaker:

30 chapters broken into five categories.

Speaker:

One category is all about people.

Speaker:

The next is about what our modal futures are going to be.

Speaker:

You know, what autonomous vehicles, what's integrated mobility, what's

Speaker:

the future of paratransit, what's the future of mobility as a service.

Speaker:

That's a term that's kind of fallen off in its usage in our

Speaker:

industry, but It still is active.

Speaker:

What's the future of zero emission fuels?

Speaker:

There's another one, right?

Speaker:

Nobody was talking about hydrogen fuel four or five years ago.

Speaker:

Now it's the hottest topic, you know, literally, it's explosive,

Speaker:

let's say, in the industry.

Speaker:

And, uh, and then data funding and faring, which is what Davies

Speaker:

is, and then geographic future.

Speaker:

So it's a great way to look at, uh, what's happening around the world.

Speaker:

With a focus on the United States, I would say most of the chapters

Speaker:

are focused on North America, but we have chapters from all around, uh,

Speaker:

to say what is happening right now.

Speaker:

And the last thing I want to mention about the kind of the way it works is There's

Speaker:

30 chapters about 30 different topics.

Speaker:

Like I mentioned, you don't necessarily need to read this straight

Speaker:

through like a novel, you know.

Speaker:

My suggestion to people is look at the table of contents and find

Speaker:

the five or six chapters in areas that you might be interested in.

Speaker:

For instance, um, you know, Mohammed Mezghani takes a look at the global,

Speaker:

Uh, view of public transportation.

Speaker:

He's the head of UITP.

Speaker:

Dr.

Speaker:

Karen Philbrick talks about workforce shortages.

Speaker:

So you may grab a chapter about something that interests you or maybe you're looking

Speaker:

at your transportation trust fund in your state and you're like, crap, it's

Speaker:

go, we're going, uh, it's going dry because we're only relying on gas tax.

Speaker:

Well, then you need to read the chapter that David Kim wrote about

Speaker:

some new ways we're funding transit.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

And, you know, I think both of you have been in the transit

Speaker:

and public transportation industry for quite some time.

Speaker:

And you mentioned, I mean, a lot has changed in 5 years, 4 or 5 years.

Speaker:

Can you talk a little bit, both of you, maybe Davey could start with how

Speaker:

much transit has changed in 5 years and what are some of the reasons?

Speaker:

Because we're used to Kind of a, um, you know, slow going with people not really,

Speaker:

uh, quick to, you know, grasp on to technology and, and really take leaps.

Speaker:

Um, you know, what's changed and, and, you know, what do you think

Speaker:

are some of the reasons for that?

Speaker:

Well, I guess the first and most obvious one would be something along the lines

Speaker:

of ridership changes, uh, due to the pandemic, due to, uh, work from home,

Speaker:

teleworking, flexible work schedules.

Speaker:

And so transit agencies are having to completely redesign their service

Speaker:

models and operations and rely less on the traditional, uh, morning and p.

Speaker:

m.

Speaker:

commute and offer service at different times of the day and on weekends and

Speaker:

really try to make it more of a, um, Not so much of a commuter system, but a system

Speaker:

that can meet the needs of everybody.

Speaker:

And so we're seeing those changes in a way that did not exist prior to the pandemic.

Speaker:

There are so many changes, but clearly, um, this is a different transit space

Speaker:

than what it was five years ago.

Speaker:

And just really quickly on Paul's book, I can't wait to read all

Speaker:

of these chapters, 30 of them.

Speaker:

Well, 29, I don't need to read my own book.

Speaker:

29

Speaker:

chapters.

Speaker:

29 really interesting, fascinating topics and, uh, such important areas

Speaker:

that we need to better understand.

Speaker:

I'm especially interested in reading about the role of AI in

Speaker:

transit operations and service.

Speaker:

High speed rail, bus rapid transit, zero emission bus,

Speaker:

workforce development challenges.

Speaker:

All of those and so many others are so important and so I'm really

Speaker:

excited to dive into all those chapters and learn from our peers.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

And, and Paul, what do you think's changed?

Speaker:

I mean, I'm sure 10 years ago, you would have heard AI and been like,

Speaker:

Hey, get out of here with that.

Speaker:

Um, you know, what do you think has changed kind of the, you know,

Speaker:

transit taking on innovation a little bit more and being a little

Speaker:

more, uh, uh, forward in that?

Speaker:

Yeah, you know, this may be a little esoteric, but I really think what's

Speaker:

changed is we're in a different environment today than we were four

Speaker:

or five years ago as a society.

Speaker:

Um, the, the pandemic was a gut punch to public transit,

Speaker:

but also to society as a whole.

Speaker:

So we've seen all kinds of societal problems spill over

Speaker:

into public transportation in a way they haven't before.

Speaker:

Such as crime and people experiencing homelessness that now have become

Speaker:

issues that public transit leaders are grappling with and trying to figure out

Speaker:

what's the best way to approach this.

Speaker:

I want to be, you know, humane, but we also, uh, we, we also have to

Speaker:

run a, you know, we have to make the buses run on time, as they

Speaker:

say, or the trains run on time.

Speaker:

So this whole environment, while keeping in mind.

Speaker:

The subject of my chapter that really the heart that all of us need to be

Speaker:

operating from is a heart of compassion.

Speaker:

You know, I love the quote from Martin Luther King who said everybody

Speaker:

can be great and any everybody can be great because anybody can serve

Speaker:

And I just think that's so good.

Speaker:

And that really what we're about in public transportation has not changed.

Speaker:

We are about service Uh, service to people who maybe can afford another

Speaker:

way, but we want them to get off the road and less, have less congestion.

Speaker:

Service to people with disabilities who maybe have no other way

Speaker:

to get where they're going.

Speaker:

Or service to my grandmother who may, uh, you know, just not be sure about

Speaker:

driving at night anymore and wants to, wants to take public mobility.

Speaker:

Uh, so we need to always remember what is at the core has not changed, which is

Speaker:

service to others motivated by compassion.

Speaker:

And then how do we, um, All these different things that Davey

Speaker:

just mentioned, all these new technologies, how do we put them

Speaker:

in service of our core mission?

Speaker:

Great.

Speaker:

And Davey, let's get into Davey's chapter on your book.

Speaker:

I know that, um, it's a big one as far as public transit.

Speaker:

I think, um, you know, we're solving innovation, we're finding

Speaker:

new ways to move passengers, to build, uh, transportation systems.

Speaker:

Um, public transit itself, though, is funded by the Highway Trust Fund.

Speaker:

And, um, we all know about the issues with that.

Speaker:

So can you talk a little bit about your chapter?

Speaker:

Um, and you know, how you delved into that subject.

Speaker:

Sure.

Speaker:

Well, let me start with a really high level comment and then

Speaker:

we'll get into the chapter.

Speaker:

Great.

Speaker:

At a high level, and you can ask any transit agency executive, funding for

Speaker:

transit is a perennial and annual slog.

Speaker:

It is a challenge.

Speaker:

Uh, Paul, I'm sure you felt like a professional fundraiser when

Speaker:

you were running the agency.

Speaker:

Pass around the tin cup, scrape up, scrape enough dollars to keep your operations

Speaker:

and systems and services running, not to mention capital improvements.

Speaker:

It's a, it's a real challenge.

Speaker:

And quite frankly, and I'm going to be candid here, transit is oftentimes

Speaker:

seen by many, many policymakers.

Speaker:

As a stepchild or second class citizen relative to other modes of transportation,

Speaker:

highways and roads in particular, and there are exceptions, of course,

Speaker:

uh, but that is oftentimes the case.

Speaker:

And so from a pure political standpoint, transit, um, does not, uh, compete

Speaker:

at the same level as highways and roads, not a reflection of transit.

Speaker:

It's a reflection of priorities among policymakers.

Speaker:

Now on the chapter itself.

Speaker:

Um, I talk about the looming crisis, and that is, uh, that, that is facing

Speaker:

the gas tax at the federal level, but also at the state level, too.

Speaker:

The gas tax is dying a slow death.

Speaker:

Its days are numbered, uh, and that's, and everyone knows that.

Speaker:

It's no secret.

Speaker:

And, uh, it's time to pivot away from the gas tax.

Speaker:

And a lot of states have been doing pilot programs looking at a road

Speaker:

usage charge or mileage based user fee where you pay by the mile instead of

Speaker:

per gallon when you fill up your car.

Speaker:

And so many states have been doing pilot programs.

Speaker:

The federal government is about to do a national pilot as they are required

Speaker:

to do under the infrastructure law.

Speaker:

They haven't done it yet, but they will.

Speaker:

Uh, probably in the next couple of years, and that will demonstrate

Speaker:

at a very large scale the viability of a road usage charge, and that's

Speaker:

going to be a really important test.

Speaker:

Uh, now to be sure, transitioning from the gas tax, which has been

Speaker:

the method, the revenue method for literally a hundred years, To, uh,

Speaker:

something new, uh, will not be easy.

Speaker:

It will come with a lot of pain.

Speaker:

Uh, there are public acceptance questions.

Speaker:

There is, uh, the question of political viability, political

Speaker:

support, or maybe lack thereof.

Speaker:

Uh, and change is just plain of the word.

Speaker:

It's hard for most people.

Speaker:

We're wired, humans are wired to maintain the status quo.

Speaker:

We humans do not like change.

Speaker:

And so this isn't going to be a painful change, but it must happen because

Speaker:

everyone knows, it's no secret, that the gas tax is pretty much dead.

Speaker:

Every year, gas tax revenues go down and down and down.

Speaker:

And that's no way to run a transportation system whether you're on the highway or

Speaker:

roadside or transit side or anywhere else.

Speaker:

So, what I say in the book is that if you care about the future of

Speaker:

transit funding, you better keep a close eye on the federal gas tax and

Speaker:

what it's, what's going to happen and what will eventually replace it.

Speaker:

Because the Highway Trust Fund has been an important source of

Speaker:

funding for highways and transit.

Speaker:

Uh, and uh, that's going to, that's going to be a big test in the years to come.

Speaker:

And Alex, um, as, as you haven't mentioned it yet, but, uh, I'm sure you

Speaker:

did it in the opening, uh, you know, both Davey and I led statewide agencies.

Speaker:

Davey was basically the Secretary of Transportation for the state of

Speaker:

California, and I was head of the Maryland Transit Administration, and we

Speaker:

both relied on our state transportation funding, trust funds, and so, like, for

Speaker:

instance, in Maryland, where I'm at, It was the gas tax, it was corporate

Speaker:

income tax, it was MVA, Motor Vehicle Administration, fees that all went

Speaker:

into this, and um, and there were some other fees that went into it as well.

Speaker:

But the reason that it's going down is actually a positive.

Speaker:

The positive is that cars are getting better and better mileage.

Speaker:

Uh, you know, cars are getting 30, 35 miles to the gallon, whereas, you know,

Speaker:

we remember, Davey and I remember, maybe you do, Alex, back in the days

Speaker:

when, you know, a big 8 cylinder car might get 12 miles to the gallon or 15,

Speaker:

you know, and those days are no more.

Speaker:

And so people don't have to fill up as much, plus add on to that the

Speaker:

people that are getting electric cars, who aren't getting any gas.

Speaker:

And it's not really fair for people that, for them not to pay

Speaker:

anything for the roads and for transit, and everybody else has to.

Speaker:

So it's really a fairness and an equity issue, uh, as we

Speaker:

look at how to transition.

Speaker:

I think the one thing that people are going to be scared about is, uh,

Speaker:

and I'd be interested in your take on this, Davey, is that, you know,

Speaker:

We don't want to get taxed twice.

Speaker:

We don't want to have gas tax and a road charge.

Speaker:

And I think some people are afraid that, you know, once the government gets

Speaker:

their hands in something, it's going to be very hard for them to get it out.

Speaker:

And so how, how are people addressing that, Davey?

Speaker:

Not to take your job, Alex, but.

Speaker:

Yeah, yeah, no, that's a good question.

Speaker:

I, especially here in California, I think people, um, we voted in for some

Speaker:

of these gas taxes and now We're paying five dollars, close to five dollars

Speaker:

regularly, and people are like, hey, what did I agree to pay for this?

Speaker:

And you know, in fact, we did.

Speaker:

So yeah.

Speaker:

Yeah,

Speaker:

and so we have a messaging challenge, and here's a a funny anecdote.

Speaker:

When I was transportation secretary in California, there was a legislative

Speaker:

hearing on transportation funding, and a legislator who shall remain unnamed

Speaker:

basically said, I cannot believe.

Speaker:

The state of California is looking at enacting a road usage charge.

Speaker:

We already pay so much in gas tax.

Speaker:

This amounts to double taxation.

Speaker:

What the legislator didn't realize is that a road usage charge would

Speaker:

eventually replace the gas tax, so it is not a case of double taxation.

Speaker:

If a legislator believes that's the case, um, that is also, uh, that will

Speaker:

also be true with the general public.

Speaker:

And so we have a lot of educating to do.

Speaker:

The messaging is very complicated, especially when you layer on top

Speaker:

of that congestion pricing, toll roads, and all of those things.

Speaker:

Pricing in general is very complicated.

Speaker:

Bridge tolls, um, people feel like they're paying way too much.

Speaker:

And so we have to come up with a better, more simple way to explain why it is.

Speaker:

People are paying or will pay all these different fees and what is it going

Speaker:

for and how do they benefit from it?

Speaker:

What's in it for them?

Speaker:

So that's our collective messaging challenge how to How to make it

Speaker:

easier to digest and understand.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

And I'm curious because, um, you know, we've talked about, with

Speaker:

Metro, we've talked about this quite a bit, uh, over the years.

Speaker:

Talked to Jeff Booth about, um, the Highway Trust Fund and

Speaker:

just that there's no solutions.

Speaker:

But there's also been a reticence.

Speaker:

By, um, politicians to raise the gas tax or to make any kind of changes to that,

Speaker:

um, you know, what's the climate in, in Capitol Hill and in state houses, um, to

Speaker:

actually take on some of these ideas, um, and, and move forward to find a solution.

Speaker:

Well, on Capitol Hill, there is no more talk of raising the gas tax.

Speaker:

That is dead.

Speaker:

There were efforts in recent years, I would say the past 10 or

Speaker:

20 years to increase the gas tax.

Speaker:

Lack of political support, too politically controversial.

Speaker:

Now that issue is off the table.

Speaker:

Uh, that's not being talked about anymore.

Speaker:

Now at the state level, some states have indeed raised the gas tax in

Speaker:

recent years, California being one of them and many others too, including

Speaker:

states led by Republican governors and Republican state legislatures.

Speaker:

Um, but even that will not be enough.

Speaker:

In fact, in California, Um, the Legislative Analyst's Office has,

Speaker:

uh, estimated that, uh, gas tax receipts in California will go down

Speaker:

dramatically in the next decade or so.

Speaker:

Uh, even with that gas tax increase that was enacted less than 10

Speaker:

years ago, it simply does not pay for everything the state needs.

Speaker:

Um, so, so you've got that at the state level, yeah, at the federal

Speaker:

level, there is no more talk of trying to increase the gas tax.

Speaker:

It's politically a non starter, and it's dead, and again, everyone understands,

Speaker:

it does not have a future, and it's time to move away from the gas tax, and

Speaker:

to try a different revenue mechanism.

Speaker:

Yeah,

Speaker:

and Alex, here in Maryland, uh, you know, there's a task force formed

Speaker:

by the governor and the legislature, that includes a lot of them, that

Speaker:

is looking at the exact same thing Davey's talking about, is, because

Speaker:

remember, it's not just paying for, you know, public transportation.

Speaker:

It's also paying for roads and highways, uh, and a lot of other infrastructure

Speaker:

projects, bridges, et cetera.

Speaker:

And so as that trust fund continued to dwindle because people are

Speaker:

driving less, uh, and in addition, You know, it's not, it's, um, it's

Speaker:

the hybrid work schedule, right?

Speaker:

People aren't driving into work five days a week anymore.

Speaker:

They're, they're working sometimes two or three days at home.

Speaker:

So all these factors are leading to less and less funds going into it.

Speaker:

So a lot of states and localities are doing what Davey's talking

Speaker:

about at a national and state level.

Speaker:

Yeah, and I'm just, I guess I'm just curious that the politician's willingness,

Speaker:

um, to move forward with solutions.

Speaker:

I mean, this is really, I mean, uh, it could be a hot button issue

Speaker:

in getting voted, uh, in or out.

Speaker:

So, I, I mean, I'm just curious on where we are progressively or, or not

Speaker:

in, in kind of, uh, adapting these changes and seeing that, you know,

Speaker:

something really does have to change.

Speaker:

Well, I think there's a greater awareness at the state level among state

Speaker:

legislatures and governors to tackle this and to recognize and acknowledge

Speaker:

publicly that we have a problem.

Speaker:

Our transportation revenues are dwindling.

Speaker:

We better do something about it and identify alternatives.

Speaker:

And so the task force Paul mentioned in Maryland, um, is also happening

Speaker:

in other places around the country.

Speaker:

And that's why you're seeing more and more states experimenting with

Speaker:

road usage charge demonstration programs, pilot programs.

Speaker:

And, and so, we're seeing a greater willingness on the part of states,

Speaker:

even red states, um, to doing this.

Speaker:

And so, all of those state experiments will feed into,

Speaker:

ultimately, the national pile that U.

Speaker:

S.

Speaker:

DOT will take on in the years ahead.

Speaker:

And so, it's pretty exciting to see what states are doing and their willingness

Speaker:

to, to tackle this head on, uh, because they recognize there's a problem.

Speaker:

And they, they don't need, they should not ignore it.

Speaker:

Uh, they got it.

Speaker:

They have to get ahead of the curve, acknowledge the problem, and come up

Speaker:

with some, some potential solutions.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

What kind of time frame are we talking about, uh, as far as federally and,

Speaker:

and needing to get something done?

Speaker:

And, and when do you think that, like, we can probably see something,

Speaker:

uh, actually come to fruition?

Speaker:

That's a great question, and I don't know that anyone really has the answer.

Speaker:

Um, let's start with this national pilot.

Speaker:

That will be a really important test of scalability, uh, where every

Speaker:

state will be expected to include participants on a voluntary basis.

Speaker:

And, um, there will need to be a lot of coordination between

Speaker:

the Treasury Department and U.

Speaker:

S.

Speaker:

DOT, uh, in terms of collection and without getting into the technical

Speaker:

details, there is so much to iron out.

Speaker:

And so it could be a while before there is a full scale pivot from the

Speaker:

federal gas tax to a federal RUC system.

Speaker:

It could be, it could be a long time.

Speaker:

A decade, two decades, three decades, who knows, but, um, it's going

Speaker:

to be a transition and it's going to be a complicated one at that.

Speaker:

Yeah, and both of you have mentioned kind of states taking on this, uh, this kind

Speaker:

of, I'm not going to say burden, but this challenge, uh, of, of, of changing things.

Speaker:

Um, are we talking about any states in particular that we've seen positive

Speaker:

results or, or, Have seen, uh, something that is, is positive toward, uh, maybe

Speaker:

being adapted on a, on a federal level?

Speaker:

Yes, and I'd like to, to, um, call attention to a couple of red

Speaker:

states that are really seen as pioneers in, in the world of RUC.

Speaker:

They are Utah and Oklahoma, not progressive states by any means.

Speaker:

But I love what Carlos Braceras, uh, talks about a lot.

Speaker:

He's the director of Utah DOT.

Speaker:

Um, he's asked this question all the time.

Speaker:

You represent a conservative state, and a road usage charge

Speaker:

is a form of taxation which goes against conservative principles.

Speaker:

And a road usage charge, um, requires the tracking of people's mileage, which could

Speaker:

be seen as an invasion of privacy, which is a violation of conservative principles.

Speaker:

Why are you doing this?

Speaker:

And I love his answer.

Speaker:

He said, well, we believe in the user pays principle.

Speaker:

If you benefit from the system, you pay for it, and we also

Speaker:

believe in pay as you go.

Speaker:

We're not, we need, we have so many transportation investment needs in Utah.

Speaker:

We're a growing state, and, uh, we're not going to burden future generations

Speaker:

with, with debt and other expenses.

Speaker:

We have to, if we want something, we're going to pay for it now, and we're

Speaker:

going to find a way to pay for it now.

Speaker:

That's, um, that's a conservative principle, and that's why we're doing it.

Speaker:

I love that answer.

Speaker:

Because it shows that no matter what kind of state you are, politically speaking,

Speaker:

conservative, liberal, moderate, there is a rationale for doing this system.

Speaker:

It's not about double taxation, it's not about socking people with additional

Speaker:

fees, it's about paying for what's needed.

Speaker:

Um, in order to keep up with needs now and into the future.

Speaker:

And Oklahoma is doing the same thing.

Speaker:

And Oklahoma has a really interesting situation where they

Speaker:

have a huge network of toll roads.

Speaker:

And so, Oklahoma DOT, um, very much believes that because they have a

Speaker:

long standing history when it comes to toll roads, their citizens are

Speaker:

a little more open to the idea.

Speaker:

of road usage charge because they've been paying, uh, for the privilege

Speaker:

of using toll roads for, for so long.

Speaker:

So it's, it's not so much of a foreign concept to them.

Speaker:

They, they sort of understand it.

Speaker:

And so they're getting their, their arms around the idea of road usage

Speaker:

charge in addition to toll roads.

Speaker:

And again, another conservative state willing to really lead the way when

Speaker:

it comes to, um, uh, pricing systems.

Speaker:

Yeah, it seems that there's going to be some kind of a chasm in between finding a

Speaker:

solution and implementing that solution.

Speaker:

So, so Paul, I mean, from an industry perspective, um, you know, what can public

Speaker:

transit do to kind of keep funding going?

Speaker:

And, and.

Speaker:

Is there a kind of, um, is there a possibility that, you know, the, the

Speaker:

current funding that we experienced, uh, from through the Biden administration.

Speaker:

Can carry on, you know, at a bipartisan level, uh, whether we get

Speaker:

a new president this year or not.

Speaker:

Sure, so I'll, I'll, I'll unpack that a little bit.

Speaker:

Uh, answer the last part first.

Speaker:

The answer is no.

Speaker:

Do not expect any more extraordinary federal funding for operating

Speaker:

dollars coming out of Washington.

Speaker:

Would you agree with me, Davey?

Speaker:

Absolutely, yes.

Speaker:

Look at what Randy has to do at WMATA, Washington Metro, right, Randy Clark,

Speaker:

where he has to go around because there's no dedicated funding source.

Speaker:

There's no, you know, millage on sales tax or property tax in the Washington, D.

Speaker:

C.

Speaker:

area.

Speaker:

So he's got to go every year, hat in hand, as Davey said, to

Speaker:

the Maryland Legislature, to the Virginia Legislature, to the D.

Speaker:

C.

Speaker:

City Council, and the federal government This is a four part funding source.

Speaker:

I mean, he spends his time basically, I don't want to say a

Speaker:

professional fundraiser because he's doing a lot more than that.

Speaker:

He's leading one of the most dramatic recoveries from COVID of any major transit

Speaker:

system in the country, but he's having to spend way too much time on trying to, um,

Speaker:

you know, get these folks to pony up money every year out of their general fund.

Speaker:

So.

Speaker:

The fiscal cliff is here.

Speaker:

The fiscal cliff is real.

Speaker:

We have been subsidized with operating dollars from Washington at a very

Speaker:

high level for the last three years, which we're very thankful for.

Speaker:

But now we have to come off an off ramp onto that and The things that

Speaker:

Davey's talking about are just one of many solutions that transit agencies

Speaker:

and governments are looking at is, how can I continue to operate, you

Speaker:

know, keep the fares low enough so that everyone can afford it, right?

Speaker:

You know, commuter trains, commuter services in the past have had 56

Speaker:

percent farebox recovery, but their ridership is down dramatically too.

Speaker:

And so it is a, um, It's a real issue.

Speaker:

And then you combine it up with the issues we're having with our OEMs, the

Speaker:

equipment manufacturers, where a year ago we had five bus manufacturers.

Speaker:

Now we're down to two or three, depending on if you count the

Speaker:

third one as full operational.

Speaker:

And we are in a storm in public transit.

Speaker:

And what we need is strong, consistent leadership, visionary leadership to help

Speaker:

us kind of navigate what comes next.

Speaker:

And that's what this book is about.

Speaker:

It's chapters from 30 of the world's top leaders, helping us to navigate

Speaker:

things like, uh, road uses charging and what, uh, and some of, some of the

Speaker:

concepts are so new that people may not have even heard of them before.

Speaker:

So it's an opportunity for them to get, uh, acclimated to these new ideas

Speaker:

and get some understanding about them.

Speaker:

But where's kind of the, the new thought leadership coming from you, Phil?

Speaker:

I mean,

Speaker:

Are they being raised in today's kind of transit environment?

Speaker:

Or do you think they may come from, come from, uh, you know,

Speaker:

a different kind of area?

Speaker:

I mean, you know, where, where's kind of the new thought leaders,

Speaker:

uh, you think coming from, uh, to help kind of solve these issues?

Speaker:

What do you think, Davey?

Speaker:

Then I'll

Speaker:

answer.

Speaker:

Oh boy, that's a, that's a tough one.

Speaker:

And I, Paul, I feel like you have a much better handle on that.

Speaker:

So why don't you go ahead?

Speaker:

All right,

Speaker:

I'll do it.

Speaker:

I didn't want to just keep, be the one talking.

Speaker:

Um, so it's funny, you know, I just interviewed, um, Andy Lord, right?

Speaker:

The, the executive who's the Transport for London Commissioner.

Speaker:

He's the head of really the Western world's largest transit system.

Speaker:

He spent 20 years at British Airways.

Speaker:

25 years, something like that, and brought so many interesting, um,

Speaker:

you know, transferable leadership skills, et cetera, to our industry.

Speaker:

I think that, you know, uh, APTA and ENO and CTAA and so many groups have

Speaker:

young leader, uh, programs where they're training up young leaders in the industry.

Speaker:

One of the things that I find that is true, especially with young people

Speaker:

in their 20s I have children that age, uh, is that they are passionate

Speaker:

about, you know, And they want a job which isn't just about a paycheck.

Speaker:

They want a job that intersects with their interests and their passions.

Speaker:

And so many of them are focused on, you know, a cleaner, better environment, a

Speaker:

better, brighter tomorrow for everyone.

Speaker:

And public transit.

Speaker:

It has the solution to so many of those areas, and so I think that people that

Speaker:

are passionate for our industry are streaming in from all sorts of areas,

Speaker:

whether it's in, you know, the parking, they came out of the parking world,

Speaker:

come out of the aviation world, come out of transit, come out of some other

Speaker:

industry, maybe it's tech, high tech, there's a lot of people that, you know,

Speaker:

because so much of our industry is tech driven, and I work for a tech company,

Speaker:

so it's all those areas, but I think most of the young people that are coming

Speaker:

in, are not doing it for a paycheck.

Speaker:

They're doing it for a better future.

Speaker:

They want their job to actually contribute to the world's betterment,

Speaker:

and I can't think of a better place for them to put their efforts than

Speaker:

in the world of public transit.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

Yeah, and I'll echo Paul's comment.

Speaker:

I have the great privilege of working with a lot of 20 and 30 somethings,

Speaker:

both in my own company and externally, and they bring so much energy and

Speaker:

passion, and I am very hopeful for the They will be tomorrow's transit CEOs.

Speaker:

They'll be tomorrow's version of Randy Clark and others, and the dedication

Speaker:

they bring, the new ideas, innovative thinking, focus on customer service,

Speaker:

ease of use, that's where some of the great ideas are coming from and will

Speaker:

come from, and so I feel tomorrow.

Speaker:

I'm hopeful about the future and I think the future of transit is in good hands,

Speaker:

especially when we look at today's emerging leaders in their 20s and 30s

Speaker:

who will go on to positions of, of top leadership in the, in the years to come.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

Well, great.

Speaker:

Thanks for taking the time, guys.

Speaker:

Uh, Paul, uh, how can people get this book?

Speaker:

Uh, well, thanks.

Speaker:

Uh, the book is available, uh, at, on Amazon.

Speaker:

It's available at Barnes Noble.

Speaker:

It's available at SAE.

Speaker:

com, which is the publisher.

Speaker:

Uh, you can just Google it and look it up.

Speaker:

Um, and, uh, we're going to be doing a series of events, Alex, like we

Speaker:

always do, uh, around the world.

Speaker:

Doing a book launch, uh, international book launch next month in Vienna, Austria.

Speaker:

We'll be at the APTA event in, um, uh, in Anaheim.

Speaker:

Hopefully Dave, you will be there with me and a bunch of other folks.

Speaker:

And we'll be signing the book, giving away copies of it there.

Speaker:

Vontas has already stepped up and said they'll do that.

Speaker:

So lots of great ways to interact with the authors.

Speaker:

Um, and, uh, we're interested in, in more ideas.

Speaker:

And so, uh, we appreciate the opportunity to be on your show,

Speaker:

Alex, to kind of spread, uh, the.

Speaker:

What I call the gospel of transit.

Speaker:

It really is, um, as we mentioned earlier, it really is Uh, I don't

Speaker:

want to use the word silver bullet, but I can't think of any other term.

Speaker:

It's kind of like an anachronism from an older, an older era.

Speaker:

Uh, but, uh, it really does solve so many of society's issues.

Speaker:

And it is being buffeted right now, like I said, by so many areas.

Speaker:

But coming out of this, you know, we're, we're coming out of it Phoenix like

Speaker:

with all kinds of great ideas that these top leaders in this book talk about.

Speaker:

So thank you for the opportunity to share a light on some of these best practices

Speaker:

so that we can improve our society.

Speaker:

I appreciate your guys' time.

Speaker:

Thanks for the conversation.

Speaker:

Thanks for listening to this special transit unplugged episode.

Speaker:

We're back to regular programming next week.

Speaker:

episode Paul recorded live and on location in Sacramento, talking with Sacramento

Speaker:

regional transit CEO, Henry Lee, about his agency and everything that SAC RT is

Speaker:

doing, which frankly is pretty amazing.

Speaker:

We hope you've been enjoying these special episodes.

Speaker:

We've been bringing you lately.

Speaker:

And if you have ideas for other special episodes, Just send us an email.

Speaker:

Email us that.

Speaker:

info@transitunplugged.com and we'll take it from there.

Speaker:

Trends and unplugged is brought to you by Modaxo.

Speaker:

At Modaxo, we're passionate about moving the world's people.

Speaker:

And a transit unplugged.

Speaker:

We're passionate about telling those stories.

Speaker:

So until next week, ride safe and ride happy.