We're wrapping up a six part series here on Transit Unplugged.
Speaker:I'm Paul Comfort and we've taken, uh, the last six weeks to look at the
Speaker:state of transit, uh, across North America and really across the world.
Speaker:We've looked at what's happened with the federal government, with the Canada.
Speaker:With America and rural and small urban, and a good look at the overall future
Speaker:of transit and a look back at 2025.
Speaker:I wanted to wrap up this series as we start the year 2026 with someone who could
Speaker:join me on the show and talk about the big ticket items, transit automation, AI and
Speaker:public transportation, privatization, the return of night trains, what's happening
Speaker:with Amtrak and station renovation.
Speaker:What about wayfinding?
Speaker:Can we do any better than that?
Speaker:Where are we at now when it comes to ridership, post pandemic,
Speaker:and I found someone great to have this conversation with.
Speaker:His name is Hayden Clarkin.
Speaker:He may be new to some of our listeners here.
Speaker:Hayden is a transportation engineer and a mobility consultant.
Speaker:He was one of Mass Transit Magazine's Top 40 under 40 winners.
Speaker:And he is a transit influencer.
Speaker:He has thousands of followers online, both on LinkedIn and Instagram and
Speaker:other platforms, and he puts out very interesting and provocative, uh,
Speaker:discussion points on what's happening with transit from a big ticket item.
Speaker:And so I invited him to come with me on this episode and talk about all
Speaker:those items and more we break 'em down for you as we wrap up our six
Speaker:part series on the state of transit.
Speaker:As we punch into 2026 and onto the future, enjoy this
Speaker:conversation with Hayden Clarkin.
Speaker:Great to be with Hayden Clarkin, who is, uh, colloquially known as the Transit guy.
Speaker:What a great person to help us wrap up our six part series on the state of transit.
Speaker:Welcome, Hayden.
Speaker:Thank you for having me.
Speaker:I really appreciate this, Paul.
Speaker:Yeah, absolutely.
Speaker:Hayden, you're in New York City, the capital of transit in America, and you
Speaker:told me you just got to meet your hero.
Speaker:The Train Daddy, Andy Byford.
Speaker:Yeah, it was really cool.
Speaker:I, he doesn't know who I am, which is great.
Speaker:And, uh, we got to talk about Penn Station rebuild and whatnot.
Speaker:And, uh, he's, very passionate and excited about it.
Speaker:And, I am very excited to meet him.
Speaker:But I did keep it in to like, not look weird, and then I thought, oh,
Speaker:maybe I'll ask him for a picture.
Speaker:And then I was like, yeah, but we're at a conference and that might be a little odd.
Speaker:So I didn't, I, I, I kept it all in.
Speaker:But yeah, it was wonderful to meet him and, Talk about a
Speaker:person with a, an amazing career.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Yeah, he does, hasn't he?
Speaker:He told me, you know, I think I mentioned to you, he's been on the show a few times.
Speaker:one of our only multiple guest has been here multiple times, but his
Speaker:career, Hayden is very interesting.
Speaker:Some of us kind of flow with the river of life and go where it takes us he was very,
Speaker:uh, didactic about what he was gonna do.
Speaker:He knew he wanted to be a CEO.
Speaker:He told me so he said, all right, I need to spend some time in safety, some
Speaker:time in operations, some time over here.
Speaker:You know, so he went around to multiple locations and learned all the backdrop,
Speaker:jobs of running a transit agency.
Speaker:So when he got to the captain's chair, as they say, you know, in Star Trek, he was
Speaker:able to know how that ship functioned.
Speaker:So I think it's a pretty brilliant strategy if your mind thinks that way.
Speaker:Yeah, I mean, not to call anyone out, but it's been very evident of CEOs or
Speaker:transit CEOs that, have a background in transit versus those who are like just
Speaker:appointed by a governor or whatnot.
Speaker:You know, it's very obvious as to sometimes the results or
Speaker:the, the, the lack of knowledge.
Speaker:So you really, transit is really that, that that industry where,
Speaker:like you really can't phone it in.
Speaker:You really need to know and understand the product and, everything that goes in.
Speaker:You know, with that product.
Speaker:That's right.
Speaker:Yep.
Speaker:I agree with you.
Speaker:Uh, wholeheartedly.
Speaker:Okay, so today we're gonna dive into some big ticket items with transit.
Speaker:We've spent the last few weeks on the podcast talking about the
Speaker:state of transit, what's happening in Washington, DC, then a national
Speaker:view and a, and the view of Canada.
Speaker:For those of you who don't follow you on social media, I encourage you.
Speaker:Follow Hayden Clarkin on LinkedIn and on other social media sites,
Speaker:Instagram, et cetera, where he puts out some really good pieces.
Speaker:And also you're active on Substack, right?
Speaker:Yep.
Speaker:The Transit Guy on all of those things.
Speaker:Our listeners know that I post nearly every day something about public transit.
Speaker:I like your posts.
Speaker:They're like big ticket thought items.
Speaker:So I thought of you when I thought about somebody who could kind of be
Speaker:the cleanup batter for this six part series, and talk about big items.
Speaker:Why don't we just jump right in.
Speaker:Are you game?
Speaker:I'm game.
Speaker:So I just was in Montreal.
Speaker:And, this month of January, our episode of our Transit Unplugged TV show is
Speaker:from my visit to Montreal, and I rode the REM and I got to meet the people in
Speaker:charge of the REM, and so tell us about the REM and tell us transit automation.
Speaker:What's going on?
Speaker:Yeah, I mean, I haven't ridden the REM yet.
Speaker:I've been invited to, and I just was not able to get up there, but I am very, very
Speaker:excited about it and I'm also excited to talk about the REM in relation to Toronto,
Speaker:which I think has been like a really interesting backdrop of seeing two totally
Speaker:different case studies and one, you know, obviously being, uh, the line, line six
Speaker:I think, which is like the Finch line and the issues that have already come up
Speaker:from that and, and what that looks like and the lack of priority versus a fully
Speaker:grade separated automated metro that runs, you know, within minutes of each other.
Speaker:yeah, I think the REM has really opened people's eyes with respect to
Speaker:automation and what that looks like and what that can look like going forward.
Speaker:I mean, a lot of people in New York City have made argument that like, we can't
Speaker:be building IVX from, you know, the, the new, uh, transit line that we're gonna
Speaker:be building between Brooklyn and Queens.
Speaker:We can't be doing that if it's not automated.
Speaker:Year, you know, 2025.
Speaker:and so there's been a lot of conversation of like, well, what would that look like?
Speaker:And even if we're not able to retrofit systems like the MTA, or
Speaker:other legacy systems, at least the idea that like new systems that we
Speaker:bring online should be automated.
Speaker:it's just kind of transit malpractice not to do so.
Speaker:Interesting.
Speaker:And what's happening with WMATA, with their ATO?
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:So, the cool thing that's been going on with WMATA is that they've actually
Speaker:been really, really, uh, pushing their, train automation and that they've
Speaker:noticed, uh, I think there was a graphic that came out last week that they're
Speaker:able to actually push 20% more trains, through capacity-wise in an hour.
Speaker:and also run trains quicker given that, what they call it, ATO,
Speaker:uh, automatic train operation.
Speaker:and as a result of that, they need less trains to run the same frequencies
Speaker:that they were running before.
Speaker:And so they're saving that money and then they can add that service
Speaker:onto other lines and whatnot.
Speaker:And so that's been really, really cool to see of, You know, even if we're not
Speaker:able to get to, full automation, at least getting to a place where the trains
Speaker:are almost running fully automatic, with a human, at the helm is, has been
Speaker:really, really cool to see because, I mean, I think everyone would agree.
Speaker:The reason we have car accidents.
Speaker:And the reason that like automation is a good idea when it comes to autonomous
Speaker:vehicles is that, you know, removing human error, as to just driving normally
Speaker:or otherwise is, is really, really gonna help with efficiencies without really
Speaker:having to, make such crazy changes.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:So it sounds like you're bullish on automation and transit heading into 2026.
Speaker:You think that's a, big thing that transit agencies are gonna look at?
Speaker:Yeah, I think automation is going to be, very important as well as
Speaker:not just automation of the actual
Speaker:operation of the trains, but also just as to way how we plan and the actual
Speaker:mechanics of the transit agency and how it operates from like both the C-suite
Speaker:side and, from just the lower level.
Speaker:I think a fully, uh, autonomous transit agency could happen at one time.
Speaker:Like, obviously not soon, but like, I think the idea of a lot of like
Speaker:the paper pushing that we see and a lot of like, kind of that I, I don't
Speaker:want the right words bloat, but a lot of that slack that we've seen from
Speaker:like customer to, planner or planner to their boss or whatnot, can really
Speaker:be cut down with, proper automation.
Speaker:Alright, let's just dive into the next hot topic, which really coming out of 2025
Speaker:into 26 has dominated conversations and that's AI, uh, artificial intelligence.
Speaker:talk about where it's genuinely, you think useful today and
Speaker:where it's still speculative.
Speaker:Yeah, I, I think I don't think AI is going to help with respect
Speaker:to transit operations in 2026.
Speaker:Um, I think what is very interesting is that there are, scheduling software and,
Speaker:and products that schedulers are using, that automatically, help them build out
Speaker:timetables and schedules the idea that AI could help iterate and make those more
Speaker:efficient, is a really interesting idea.
Speaker:I don't know if that's fully like using some sort of LLM to do it, or if it's just
Speaker:these existing legacy vendors, creating an option for AI to look at a, you know
Speaker:how WMATA or how the CTA in Chicago or whatever, how they operate in their bus
Speaker:scheduling and going like, Hey, actually we can even make it more efficient.
Speaker:Or we could run more buses, and looking at it holistically.
Speaker:I think that's gonna be something that's really interesting to see.
Speaker:I think AI is not in a place of like replacing people.
Speaker:I think it's really good at replacing.
Speaker:paper pushing.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And I think there's a lot of paper pushing in transit that I
Speaker:think all of us would agree on.
Speaker:And if we're able to automate that and have everyone focus on, providing
Speaker:better service and looking forward, I think that's gonna be huge.
Speaker:Yep.
Speaker:Well, working for, uh, one of the world's largest transit software
Speaker:companies, I can tell you that that's big on, on, uh, everybody's agenda
Speaker:is putting AI into the software to optimize it and to help our customers.
Speaker:So I think you're, you're spot on there.
Speaker:So one of the other things
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Uh, that I'd like to talk to you about is you're, is
Speaker:something that I've noticed too.
Speaker:You know, I just got back from Italy where we filmed our Transit Unplugged
Speaker:TV show and I got to ride high speed rail there and I noticed they were all
Speaker:run by private companies, in Italy.
Speaker:And when I see transit in Europe and in Latin America, largely operated by
Speaker:big private companies, whether they're RATP Dev, Keolis, Transdev, these big,
Speaker:you know, international companies or companies like Brightline here in America
Speaker:that are really building our first high speed rail project out in LA to Vegas.
Speaker:privatization and alternate delivery model seems to work.
Speaker:What are your thoughts on that?
Speaker:Yeah, I mean, like, I, I think the jury is still out on whether Brightline
Speaker:is a, is a financial, success.
Speaker:I think it is still, you know, especially the in, in Orlando and Florida.
Speaker:I think there's still, the jury is out on that even though I do think they
Speaker:provide a great service and utility.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:I am definitely looking forward to what privatization looks like.
Speaker:I don't know if some of your listeners might know, but, in LA right now
Speaker:they're trying to build a, a gondola, an urban gondola, and that is a fully
Speaker:privatized project and that has taken a lot of the wind out of the opposition
Speaker:because it's not on taxpayer dime.
Speaker:And so I do see this idea of like, maybe there is a lane
Speaker:for more privatization of rail.
Speaker:or if not, I think private operators running on existing tracks outside
Speaker:of public transit agencies.
Speaker:We can talk about that actually in our, uh, our next, item.
Speaker:But yeah, I, I think that there is a lane for operators, or private run
Speaker:operators to, run, alternative service or just kind of fill in the gaps.
Speaker:Very interesting.
Speaker:Yeah, I think, um.
Speaker:Most of our listeners know there's a, there's a clear differentiation between
Speaker:contractors and private operators.
Speaker:So a contractor would be like, Keolis runs the MBTA's commuter
Speaker:rail line in Boston, so they have a contract with the agency to do it.
Speaker:What you're talking about it sounds like, is even more like private
Speaker:companies, doing it on their own.
Speaker:Like what happens in Latin America where private companies, like I was in Brazil.
Speaker:And all the bus companies are privately owned and they decide the
Speaker:routes, kinda like the old school, what happened in the United Kingdom.
Speaker:They get approval from somebody eventually, you know, the government
Speaker:has to approve it, but they kind of take the revenue risk, which is what
Speaker:Brightline's doing now in Florida.
Speaker:Right?
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And I think, I wanna be clear, 'cause I do get a lot of pushback when I do
Speaker:talk about the privatization of transit.
Speaker:JR railways is a great example of this.
Speaker:In Japan, they run almost fully privatized.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:However, they do operate like a quasi public agency because the federal
Speaker:government there does pay a large portion of their capital budget.
Speaker:and so a lot of their capital budget does come from taxpayers.
Speaker:and then the actual operation of the trains, the planning, the
Speaker:maintenance, all of the other things are done by JR Railways.
Speaker:And so that is a, a, a good, distinction because yeah, I mean,
Speaker:if, if, uh, high speed rail tracks were built between two major cities,
Speaker:many operators might wanna do that.
Speaker:But if they have to then also build the tracks between the two cities, that's a
Speaker:huge, a different, risk profile, right?
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:That reminds you of Hong Kong with MTR, where, you know, they're, they're
Speaker:running service almost subsidy free, but they've got massive real estate
Speaker:holdings, which helps support it.
Speaker:And that's, you know, Patrick, the president of Brightline told me
Speaker:a while ago when we interviewed him, that they did that in Miami.
Speaker:You know, they've got that big station with all that, uh, all the
Speaker:real estate development around it.
Speaker:And so it is an interesting approach.
Speaker:you mentioned, our next bullet point we wanna talk about was the return
Speaker:of overnight trains or night trains.
Speaker:That's big in Europe, right?
Speaker:I mean, I've ridden them before.
Speaker:Very big right now.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:The train that goes from Hamburg down to Vienna and uh, it's one of our episodes
Speaker:on the TV show and it's fantastic.
Speaker:What are your thoughts on the return of night trains internationally
Speaker:and you know, really the potential relevance here in North America?
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:So, um, I definitely have seen over the last year, uh, a big focus on
Speaker:night trains in Europe, from both the private side as well as the, the, the
Speaker:governmental side, EU regulatory body side pushing to, have night trains.
Speaker:and so that has been expanding slowly and I know that there's a company,
Speaker:called NOX Mobility, N-O-X Mobility, that is actually working on creating
Speaker:this sort of rail model throughout the, of, of providing almost like a
Speaker:luxury hotel-like, amenity for people.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And, and, and using existing trains and refitting like, retrofitting those
Speaker:cars to then be able to provide service between, you know major cities and, and
Speaker:maybe smaller cities between Europe.
Speaker:And I think that model could work in America, especially
Speaker:given like inner city bus.
Speaker:Um, inner city buses have been actually, uh, seeing a boon, a
Speaker:small boon, but nothing too crazy.
Speaker:But I do think that that does spell, some blood in the water to come to
Speaker:the United States and test that model, especially because freight rail is not
Speaker:usually operating overnight in a way that like passenger rails can, could run.
Speaker:and so I think that there is some sort of, I think it would be quite easy
Speaker:to stand up some sort of night rail service that, you know, takes, I don't
Speaker:know, 12 hours between, uh, a Raleigh or Chicago or Chicago to wherever.
Speaker:And then, you know, you go to sleep and then you wake up and you're in
Speaker:Chicago the next morning, right?
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Um, so I think that there's definitely, uh, a lane there and I am gonna be
Speaker:interested to see kind of what these mobility operators, if they do ever
Speaker:come to, uh, to the states or Canada.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:What about Amtrak?
Speaker:What do you think their role is and new routes and, you know,
Speaker:their new trains and all that?
Speaker:You know it's funny, the expansion of Amtrak or anticipated Amtrak
Speaker:expansion, was such a monumental move for under the Biden administration.
Speaker:I was really, really nervous that under the new administration, that
Speaker:that would kind of just all be set aside as a, as a means of just kind
Speaker:of political, political fighting.
Speaker:Uh, so far there has still been a good amount of money for long
Speaker:distance Amtrak, uh service, that, that has not been largely touched.
Speaker:and the corridor ID program, which I think was like, I think.
Speaker:60 something routes were, were chosen to be studied under the corridor ID program.
Speaker:that is still happening.
Speaker:And that was actually, I just saw that like Chattanooga, Nashville
Speaker:to Atlanta via Chattanooga is still like full steam ahead.
Speaker:Um, so I think.
Speaker:There is still going to be expansion.
Speaker:Um, I, I, I don't know if you had asked me at the beginning of the year or the middle
Speaker:of the year, if I thought Amtrak was gonna expand, I probably would've told you no.
Speaker:I think the big problem, which has been a massive, massive, massive, massive
Speaker:problem for transit in America is that all of these are being planned
Speaker:at a state level with each DOT.
Speaker:And so the expertise of 50 states or, uh, 48 states, arguing about, how to run
Speaker:their own transit service that will then be like under Amtrak is kind of crazy.
Speaker:I always bring up the idea of like, imagine going to Disney
Speaker:World with 48 people and all 48 people are given equal amounts of
Speaker:money to plan this trip together.
Speaker:That would be really insane, and that's kind of how federal
Speaker:transit dollars have worked.
Speaker:And so that is the only thing that does give me pause of like a lack
Speaker:of central planning when it comes to the expansion of all of these routes.
Speaker:Because right now we're basically hoping that, you know, Georgia's, DOT and
Speaker:Tennessee's DOT and New Hampshire's DOT all have like the same rail planning
Speaker:capacity as like a New York or California.
Speaker:And I think you and I could agree that that's not true.
Speaker:and so what does that look like and how do those services all fit under an
Speaker:Amtrak umbrella and look and feel the same is going to be a big question.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Roger Harris, the president, uh, the new president.
Speaker:I've talked to some of his team and, um, yeah, I have big hopes for Amtrak.
Speaker:I mean, there's a lot they could do and they, like you said, they
Speaker:got a big infusion of cash under the last administration, and so a
Speaker:lot of good things have happened.
Speaker:I've ridden it in the last year or so and was impressed, you know, uh,
Speaker:yeah.
Speaker:With some of the amenities they brought back, et cetera, so.
Speaker:Mm-hmm.
Speaker:It's really our only national rail, right.
Speaker:And so we need it to work well.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And the new trains have been great.
Speaker:Thanks for listening to the Transit Unplugged Podcast.
Speaker:We are so glad you're here.
Speaker:If you're enjoying this show, we know you'll love our other transit industry
Speaker:programs on Transit Unplugged TV paul Comfort explores the food culture
Speaker:and transit systems around the globe.
Speaker:You get to see everything.
Speaker:You'll love this show, and every week we also offer up the Transit
Speaker:Unplugged News Minute where you can get the latest industry
Speaker:headlines in less than 60 seconds.
Speaker:You can find out more at transitunplugged.com Now back to
Speaker:Paul Comfort for this edition of the award-winning Transit Unplugged podcast.
Speaker:So, one of the other great things that's happened across the country is
Speaker:the retrofitting and restoration and reinvestment in old train stations.
Speaker:Speaking about Amtrak, you know?
Speaker:Mm-hmm.
Speaker:I remember my boss, Rod Jones, and I went to Detroit a few months ago and got to
Speaker:see what they did there with the Ford
Speaker:oh, that's cool.
Speaker:Company and all that.
Speaker:I mean, it's just.
Speaker:It, it was almost emotional for him when he saw what it used to be, this
Speaker:old, broken down, ramshackle building.
Speaker:Horrible.
Speaker:Which was, you know, demonstrating what, where Detroit was then to what it is now.
Speaker:Talk to us about that and some of these, these new, um, you
Speaker:know, new station restorations.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:So if I would urge everyone to pause this, and Google search
Speaker:South Bend, Indiana, Amtrak.
Speaker:You will see arguably the most saddest train station you have
Speaker:ever seen in your entire life.
Speaker:To the point of like, actually you kind of wanna cry as like a taxpayer of like, this
Speaker:is the result of like the current, the current iteration of trains in America.
Speaker:It's really, really bad.
Speaker:It's a cinder block building that's like like a dark royal blue.
Speaker:Um, and it has like a padlock on it.
Speaker:It's really, really sad.
Speaker:Um, this week while we're talking, South Bend, Indiana Council just
Speaker:unanimously approved a study to bring back the old train station,
Speaker:which is this gorgeous old granite.
Speaker:Like, I mean, you know, you've seen them from the 1940s and 1930s.
Speaker:They're always the backdrop of every kind of movie, of this
Speaker:beautiful old train station.
Speaker:and they're currently studying rerouting Amtrak to, and the south shoreline
Speaker:to stop there, and bring back that train station that's, that sat there,
Speaker:you know, dormant or underutilized as something else for so long
Speaker:again, you just brought up Detroit.
Speaker:Detroit being that, I do have some hesitations about why we're
Speaker:not running trains to that train station that we just restored.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Kansas City.
Speaker:They've got a great one and they're running trains in it.
Speaker:So, yeah.
Speaker:And so that's another one that gives me a little bit of pause of
Speaker:like, how can we not stop right at the train station instead of this
Speaker:like random site across the street?
Speaker:That, and then, even if train service doesn't come back to them, the Buffalo
Speaker:train station, the old Buffalo terminal, which is one of the most beautiful
Speaker:buildings, that just got restored.
Speaker:It did not get restored as a train station.
Speaker:but it did get restored in its former glory.
Speaker:And so I am excited to kind of see those stations come back at some point.
Speaker:And I will say that's a good step forward.
Speaker:and as well as like, even though all of the stations that replace them.
Speaker:Are all in terrible locations relative to where the population centers are.
Speaker:And so, if we're able to also restore to these beautiful train stations,
Speaker:we're also restoring to a better, more connected spot within a city.
Speaker:And I think that's even a bigger, boon or, or a bigger benefit than
Speaker:just, you know, the architecture.
Speaker:That's great.
Speaker:I agree there.
Speaker:These union stations in so many cities across the country have so much to
Speaker:offer us and to, to make transit, uh, give it a sense of place, and a sense
Speaker:of character that we've been lacking.
Speaker:I remember two years ago, my wife and I were down in South Florida.
Speaker:I was filming an episode of our TV show with our videographer, and she stayed at
Speaker:the hotel and with my daughter, and she said, you know, when I got back, Paul, I
Speaker:would've ridden the bus outside the hotel.
Speaker:But there was no information about where the bus is going, where
Speaker:it's coming from, how often it runs, what it costs, anything.
Speaker:It's just a, a bus stop sign stuck in the mud.
Speaker:And, um, I remember talking to people in Florida saying, you know, at least
Speaker:put QR codes on your signs bare minimum 1990s technology so that somebody
Speaker:could click on it and go to your website and see when the bus is coming.
Speaker:I mean, this really is, an issue for trying to get more people in transit.
Speaker:Isn't it Hayden?
Speaker:Clear way finding clear passenger information?
Speaker:Talk to us your thoughts about that.
Speaker:Yeah, I, I mean, like You could go to the worst airport in America.
Speaker:You'll still figure out how to get the baggage claim when you land.
Speaker:Right?
Speaker:You'll always will.
Speaker:I mean, it doesn't matter how ugly the airport is, how, how gross the
Speaker:terminal is, how outdated it is.
Speaker:You'll always figure out how to get around because the FAA requires pretty
Speaker:good and robust way finding programs that is not something that the FTA does,
Speaker:and as a result you kind of don't have a wonderful way finding experience.
Speaker:I will say that's obviously been changing quite a lot in the last
Speaker:five years, especially post pandemic.
Speaker:Um.
Speaker:But one of the things immediately after COVID was this idea of like, well, how
Speaker:do we bring people back to transit?
Speaker:And there was always these conversations like, well, they want wifi, or they
Speaker:want the station to be like much nicer and all this kind of stuff.
Speaker:And maybe there's some, truth to that.
Speaker:But really like every survey was always like, we just need better information.
Speaker:We want better information.
Speaker:If my bus is not here because I mean, you know, there was a huge ghost
Speaker:bus problem that we had, uh, yes.
Speaker:During the pandemic and immediately after of like not having enough, bus drivers
Speaker:and having a huge shortage that like buses sometimes, or a lot of times, especially
Speaker:in LA they said that they were coming, but then they wouldn't because they didn't
Speaker:have a bus driver called out that morning.
Speaker:and so people were like, we need better.
Speaker:operation, and this really kind of got spearheaded by the Transit App.
Speaker:a lot of transit agencies kind of saw like, wow, this is the North Star.
Speaker:This is the creme de la creme of like giving riders the most
Speaker:accurate information possible.
Speaker:and therefore a lot of agencies, the MBTA, the MTA, DC LA Metro, San
Speaker:Francisco, a lot of them have been really spearheading better, signage, especially
Speaker:when it comes to digital signage.
Speaker:Uh, WMATA has in DC has done a full redo of their wayfinding program,
Speaker:and that's been helpful a lot.
Speaker:And I'll give you a fun example of, of one of the things that a lot of
Speaker:transit agencies have been exploring.
Speaker:If you go to Korea, you'll notice if you Google map, you know,
Speaker:A to B, wherever you're going.
Speaker:If you Google map, somewhere within New York City and you're using the
Speaker:subway, it will just tell you get off at the northwest corner of Broadway
Speaker:and Bleecker, people don't know where that is when you're underground, right?
Speaker:I don't know where that is.
Speaker:Right, right.
Speaker:and in Korea, what they do actually is they'll be like,
Speaker:get out at exit number one.
Speaker:And so I'm following signs for exit or entrance number one,
Speaker:and I get out there and great.
Speaker:Now I'm still going towards my destination.
Speaker:This has been something that was like such a simple thing.
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:However, it is kind of hard in data with using our GTFS to be
Speaker:able to like, add all of that in.
Speaker:It it is a good project to work on.
Speaker:And so, DC's actually done that now where, they've been piloting,
Speaker:especially at like L'enfant.
Speaker:actually like astronauts, like there is these beautiful images of like astronauts
Speaker:on the corn- at the ends of, uh, if anyone has been a DC metro station,
Speaker:especially one that has a transfer, you'll know that you could see all four
Speaker:walls at the end because it's across.
Speaker:And so you're able to actually see, you'll say A, B, C, D. And
Speaker:so now you're able to understand.
Speaker:Now that it's hardwired in, oh, I have to take entrance D or exit
Speaker:D to get to where I'm trying to go.
Speaker:And that's hard-coded, now into our, our transit data so that
Speaker:riders can see that better.
Speaker:And that's been a really, really cool.
Speaker:And then the last thing I would say is, there's been a lot of work, especially
Speaker:with like outside vendors, thinking of companies like Swiftly that have been
Speaker:doing a great job with respect to like, on time, or, or in the moment delays.
Speaker:And how does that work and how do we update the information instead
Speaker:of saying to people, oops, sorry.
Speaker:good luck.
Speaker:Uh, how do we update that information for the rider that's sitting in the bus?
Speaker:That just got, you know, delayed.
Speaker:and also for the person who's two blocks away waiting for that bus, how do we like
Speaker:tell them that information in both ways?
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Um, and so that's been a huge, huge, uh, focus on a lot of transit
Speaker:agencies right now, and I think they're doing a beautiful job of it.
Speaker:The big problem that I see is a lot of smaller transit agencies do
Speaker:not have the resources to do this.
Speaker:And so how do they find either an open source template or whatnot for them to
Speaker:replicate it because Cape Cod Transit Agency does not have the resources
Speaker:that an MTA or a, Boston MBTA has.
Speaker:And how do they get that same information now that riders are,
Speaker:riding MBTA and then all of a sudden they get off a Cape Cod and want to
Speaker:transfer and they've got a completely different information, experience.
Speaker:Yeah, At this last year's Boston, I hosted a panel with the general manager,
Speaker:Vontas, the head of swiftly and one of the big guys at the transit app,
Speaker:and they've all now joined together.
Speaker:Vontas is now with their CAD AVL, sending it through Swiftly, who then
Speaker:provides it to the agency, and then that's sent to the Transit app, which
Speaker:is open to the public, which they can then see, oh, something's running late.
Speaker:So they've, they've figured out these three really, you know, they're not
Speaker:really competitors, but they're not partners either, but they it up to
Speaker:provide information for the public, which goes to write what you're talking
Speaker:about, Hayden, that you've gotta get the information to the public.
Speaker:I remember when I was at MTA in Baltimore, we would push out
Speaker:service delays through Twitter.
Speaker:that was the tool, you know?
Speaker:Mm-hmm.
Speaker:The software everybody used, and I think a lot of banks still do
Speaker:it, but it is very important.
Speaker:I, I love the way finding examples you gave, and I'm,
Speaker:I'm hoping more people do that.
Speaker:The easier transit it is for people to use for the first time, the more
Speaker:likely they are to keep trying it.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And also just like, uh, and in person, like bus shelters are also
Speaker:really important with this as well.
Speaker:Yeah, you were just bringing that up.
Speaker:We're like bus shelters.
Speaker:I always like bring up the idea of like the, the best use case you could ever,
Speaker:ever, ever, ever, like try to do is like, someone who's drunk at 1130 at night and
Speaker:stumbles upon a bus shelter and like, does not wanna drive, but they need to figure
Speaker:out how they can get to their destination.
Speaker:Like how can you help them?
Speaker:Oh, and their phone is dead because they were partying at the club.
Speaker:Like, we really need to think of a lot of like, you know, not
Speaker:everyone always has a phone.
Speaker:You know, we're talking about like elderly people.
Speaker:My grandfather never did have a phone.
Speaker:so like, how do we make sure we're like thinking of all of these use
Speaker:cases at every touch point within a, a service area is really important.
Speaker:That's good.
Speaker:Last topic is kind of a forward looking thing.
Speaker:We know that pandemic and work for home has changed the demand for transit.
Speaker:Talk to that and where you think things are going in 26.
Speaker:Yeah, I think, right after lockdown when a lot of people started
Speaker:going back and transit agencies were really trying to rebound.
Speaker:there was a lot of conversation about how transit was down, and that was a
Speaker:hundred percent correct, but transit was really down we noticed in areas like with
Speaker:the, with the New York City, uh, transit system was really down at the peaks, but
Speaker:didn't really taper off too much off peak.
Speaker:and then on the weekends, the, the regional rail systems, the Metro
Speaker:North, the Long Island Railroads and the New Jersey Transit were
Speaker:actually larger than they had been previous to the pandemic or equal to.
Speaker:And it was a very interesting phenomenon.
Speaker:And what we realized and BART definitely, had realized this was, that people
Speaker:were not not wanting to take transit.
Speaker:They wanted to take transit at different times because the, way
Speaker:that we had been living, I dunno what the right word is, but like, our
Speaker:conventional nine to five was dead.
Speaker:It was dead when a lot of us were working from home.
Speaker:But that didn't mean, I still didn't wanna take the, you know,
Speaker:the train to, to Broadway at night or I, I wanted to take it to go get
Speaker:groceries or go shopping or something.
Speaker:It was just that I didn't need it at 5:15.
Speaker:like I did previous.
Speaker:And so, um, there was a huge kind of focus, around clock face schedules of,
Speaker:Hey, instead of us providing the most service we do at peak, we're actually
Speaker:gonna provide service throughout the day.
Speaker:That was something that the MBTA did with the installation of clock face,
Speaker:schedulings on almost all of their lines.
Speaker:Clock face for people is, you know, it comes at, you know,
Speaker:if it comes at 2:42, it's gonna come at 3:42, it's gonna at 4:42.
Speaker:So that's the idea of clock face scheduling.
Speaker:and so we really focused on that, like as an industry, and doing that helped kind
Speaker:of, push out, the demand for transit so that people could take it at all times of
Speaker:the day in a way that was like not robbing the people wanted to get to work at like
Speaker:8:00 PM for a third shift instead of just like focusing on, on the five o'clock.
Speaker:And then on the weekends, people just figured they wanted to take transit
Speaker:on the weekends more but service was not conducive to that service was
Speaker:still, I mean, if you're on a regional rail on a weekend, I think everyone
Speaker:knows that your service is lower.
Speaker:And so the changes to bring those schedules up to the weekend
Speaker:has been really interesting.
Speaker:it's going to be interesting looking forward as to if return to office still
Speaker:sees that kind of surge that we saw a little bit in 2025, we did see a lot of
Speaker:people rejecting work from home for, or at least employers rejecting work from home.
Speaker:So that will be an interesting development to see, especially as the economy's a
Speaker:little bit on shaky ground of, are we gonna start seeing people to come back
Speaker:and then need that nine to five again?
Speaker:and what will that look like?
Speaker:Will we then break what we just did?
Speaker:Yeah, it'll be really interesting.
Speaker:To be determined as they say.
Speaker:Right.
Speaker:TBD, but I guess we're gonna look out for it, right?
Speaker:Yeah, that's right.
Speaker:Hey, this has been great, a great kind of helicopter view of eight of the
Speaker:hottest topics as we head into this year.
Speaker:Thank you so much for sharing with us and I encourage our listeners
Speaker:to, uh, check you out, tell us how they can connect with you.
Speaker:The Transit Guy everywhere.
Speaker:So yeah, I try to make it easy.
Speaker:There you go.
Speaker:Thank you for having me, Paul.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Thanks for sharing your insights, brother.
Speaker:Good luck in the new year.
Speaker:Thank you for listening to this episode of Transit Unplugged, the world's
Speaker:number one transit executive podcast.
Speaker:I'm Julie Gates, executive producer of the podcast.
Speaker:Many thanks to the team that makes this show happen.
Speaker:Host and producer Paul Comfort, producer Chris O'Keeffe, editor Patrick
Speaker:Emil, associate producer Cyndi Raskin
Speaker:Transit Unplugged is being brought to you by Modaxo.
Speaker:Passionate about moving the world's people.
Speaker:If you would enjoy behind the scenes insights and updates from the show,
Speaker:sign up for our weekly newsletter, which has links to can't miss conversations
Speaker:with the biggest names in mobility.
Speaker:Head to transitunplugged.com and scroll to the bottom of the page to sign up.
Speaker:Thanks for listening, and we'll catch you on the next episode of Transit Unplugged.