Hello, and welcome to The Get.
Erica Seidel:I'm your host, Erica Seidel.
Erica Seidel:This season we examine the relationship between CMOs and Boards.
Erica Seidel:How can that relationship go from fraught to functional,
Erica Seidel:and maybe even to fantastic?
Erica Seidel:Today's episode is special.
Erica Seidel:I've invited a CMO and her Board member together to talk, not just
Erica Seidel:about each other, but with each other.
Erica Seidel:You'll see what a good partnership looks like in an actual CMO Board member pair.
Erica Seidel:We talk with Jen Dimas, the Chief Marketing and Experience Officer
Erica Seidel:of Telarus, and Evan DeCorte, a Board member from Columbia
Erica Seidel:Capital, which backs Telarus.
Erica Seidel:Some things to listen for, realize investors have reptile brains.
Erica Seidel:They are focusing on Big V versus Little V value, so you as a CMO will
Erica Seidel:need to do some context switching.
Erica Seidel:Jen offers a guide for that.
Erica Seidel:You'll learn what to do starting during your interview process to set
Erica Seidel:yourself up for a successful standing with the Board, and you'll learn a
Erica Seidel:simple framing that will help you as you prepare your Board meetings.
Erica Seidel:Before we get started, a quick disclaimer as requested by
Erica Seidel:Evan's friends in Compliance.
Evo Terra:This interview should not be considered investment
Evo Terra:advice or a solicitation to invest.
Evo Terra:And the views and opinions expressed herein are those of the speakers and
Evo Terra:do not necessarily reflect the views or positions of any entities they represent.
Erica Seidel:Let's go.
Erica Seidel:Welcome to the next session of The Get.
Erica Seidel:This season, as we know, is all about the CMO Board relationship,
Erica Seidel:and I thought, what better than to have a CMO and one of their Board
Erica Seidel:members together for this podcast?
Erica Seidel:So for this one, we welcome Jen Dimas, who is the Chief Marketing
Erica Seidel:and Experience Officer for Telarus.
Erica Seidel:And Telarus is a global technology solutions brokerage.
Erica Seidel:And I actually placed Jen in her role.
Erica Seidel:It was a really fun search.
Erica Seidel:And I worked alongside Evan DeCorte from Columbia Capital.
Erica Seidel:He is our other guest.
Erica Seidel:He is, uh, a Board member for Telarus and is representing that perspective.
Erica Seidel:They are a PE entity that backs Telarus.
Erica Seidel:So let us get started.
Erica Seidel:Um, I would love to know, the two of you just seem to get along really well,
Erica Seidel:and as we have talked about before, you have a pretty strong Board partnership
Erica Seidel:and sometimes the CMO and Board partnership can be a little fraught.
Erica Seidel:So what makes your partnership special compared to other, uh, kind of, uh,
Erica Seidel:dyads of CMO and Board members that you have seen or been a part of?
Erica Seidel:Maybe Jen, we'll start with you?
Jen Pockell Dimas:I think part of the reason our, uh, relationship is
Jen Pockell Dimas:so strong and functional is because we were just really, we, we're
Jen Pockell Dimas:both kind of transparent humans.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So when we first met, we both sort of just laid all the cards on the
Jen Pockell Dimas:table about what was going on.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Evan was really clean and clear what was necessary in the role, what he had
Jen Pockell Dimas:observed during diligence, uh, looking at Telarus as an investment opportunity and
Jen Pockell Dimas:kind of had done a ton of research and had a really strong thesis of what was
Jen Pockell Dimas:necessary for the company moving forward.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And he also knew what he didn't know.
Jen Pockell Dimas:He's like, I think I need this thing, but tell me something different.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Um, this is what I see in the market.
Jen Pockell Dimas:This is what I see as an opportunity.
Jen Pockell Dimas:There happened to be a great overlap with what was necessary and what I'm good at.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And I think we had a nice development of our relationship just because we
Jen Pockell Dimas:both say things that we're good at, things that we, uh, we, things that
Jen Pockell Dimas:we know, things that we don't know and we're, um, honest with each other.
Evan DeCorte:It's really, for me, it's about transparency.
Evan DeCorte:It, I think it's hard to develop a meaningful and productive relationship
Evan DeCorte:if you can't be straightforward about, you know, what you need
Evan DeCorte:and want and what you expect.
Evan DeCorte:And, and also it's being receptive to beat back and hearing from the
Evan DeCorte:company and its executives what they didn't want from us as, as investors.
Evan DeCorte:And, and then there can be a temptation from the Board to treat it as a one-way
Evan DeCorte:street to, to sort of dictate outcomes.
Evan DeCorte:And it turns out that's actually not, not really how it works.
Evan DeCorte:Um, people build businesses and, and we're part of that conversation, but
Evan DeCorte:I think ultimately we're facilitators.
Evan DeCorte:And so if you don't, if you don't come to that table with that approach, right,
Evan DeCorte:and you think you can sort of just tell people what to do instead building a
Evan DeCorte:business with them and alongside them, you're gonna set yourself up for, for
Evan DeCorte:trouble and a lot of disappointment.
Erica Seidel:Jen, you mentioned Evan and you got to know each other
Erica Seidel:through the recruiting process.
Erica Seidel:And I know Evan, you and I worked together along with the CEO of
Erica Seidel:Telarus for the recruiting of Jen.
Erica Seidel:Is that, is that unusual?
Jen Pockell Dimas:It's not unusual at all.
Jen Pockell Dimas:I've always met with at least a Board member, um, during recruitment
Jen Pockell Dimas:for a marketing leadership role.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And frankly, I'd be really concerned if that wasn't part of the conversation.
Jen Pockell Dimas:If I, I would have requested it had it not happened organically.
Jen Pockell Dimas:But it's a very important relationship.
Jen Pockell Dimas:The, the executive team in general, delivering on the promise to their
Jen Pockell Dimas:investors, that's a big deal.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And so knowing what the dynamic is there and understanding that relationship
Jen Pockell Dimas:is incredibly important to, to be able to set yourself up for success.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So, no, I don't think it's unusual.
Jen Pockell Dimas:I think what was unusual here is just how well-aligned we all
Jen Pockell Dimas:were and like how quickly we established fluency with each other.
Erica Seidel:Yeah.
Erica Seidel:My take on having investors in, involved in searches is, I'd rather
Erica Seidel:have somebody who is helping be a chef at the beginning of a process
Erica Seidel:than being like the restaurant critic and at the end of a process.
Erica Seidel:So sometimes I've done searches where an investor comes in way at the end and
Erica Seidel:they're like, oh, thumbs up, thumbs down.
Erica Seidel:And it's not as helpful as if they're kind of involved early on.
Jen Pockell Dimas:There's, there's something else I just wanted to say, um,
Jen Pockell Dimas:Erica, that I think is, is special here.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Because Evan and Columbia had done such incredibly thorough work on diligence
Jen Pockell Dimas:about Telarus, like they really understood the market in which Telarus is operating.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So they had really strong opinions about what could be done and what was necessary.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And so I think it's a, it was important that they were at the table, like
Jen Pockell Dimas:they saw the market opportunity for doing things differently.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And they knew that, that doing this right was gonna be a real
Jen Pockell Dimas:lever for success of the org.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And so I'm glad they were so involved and they were really well informed.
Erica Seidel:Evan, I'm gonna actually ask you this, like what do Boards want
Erica Seidel:from a CMO and what don't they want?
Evan DeCorte:I think what we don't want is hand waving.
Evan DeCorte:As I sort of think about it, it's like a lot of vagueries and, and talk like
Evan DeCorte:big talk about what could be or the things that are in motion and what things
Evan DeCorte:maybe should look like in the future.
Evan DeCorte:But it's hard to know.
Evan DeCorte:I mean, I think Erica, you, you sort point out and say this all the time, but
Evan DeCorte:like we have very simple reptile brains.
Evan DeCorte:We are investors, right?
Evan DeCorte:And our, our goal is to invest money in the company and then to sell or recap as a
Evan DeCorte:business some way and get money back out.
Evan DeCorte:And our goal is to have that pile of money at the end be a lot bigger
Evan DeCorte:than the pile at the beginning.
Evan DeCorte:And so a lot of what we are focused on is what is the result of the
Evan DeCorte:actions that you're taking as a CMO?
Evan DeCorte:How do they intersect with the strategy of the overall business?
Evan DeCorte:And how do they correlate with value creation?
Evan DeCorte:I, I think as investors we can probably, we're probably pretty thoughtful
Evan DeCorte:about function and we maybe have some thoughts on sales and operation.
Evan DeCorte:I think it's a rare investor that is, uh, you know, a marketing
Evan DeCorte:expert that probably approaches nearly 0% of the, of the population.
Evan DeCorte:And so we just need things in many ways think brought back to the basics, which is
Evan DeCorte:we are doing X and here's how it aligns to the plan and here's how it creates value.
Evan DeCorte:If you can sort of link all of those points in a clean way, you're gonna
Evan DeCorte:have a very easy conversation with the Board and the investor syndicate.
Evan DeCorte:I think where conversations break down is pointing to activity and
Evan DeCorte:describing the value it will create without either data or, uh, an
Evan DeCorte:obvious linkage to a strategic plan.
Evan DeCorte:You know, activity doesn't create value necessarily.
Evan DeCorte:Some activity does, but, but not all.
Evan DeCorte:And so then confusing lots of moving pieces and lots of activity for
Evan DeCorte:the process of sort of building the business like that, that's, I think,
Evan DeCorte:where things get a little shaky.
Erica Seidel:I love this reptilian brain concept.
Erica Seidel:I find that so hilarious and so accurate, and I, uh, thank you
Erica Seidel:for, thank you for saying that.
Erica Seidel:So it seems like, and Evan is, I mean, I think you're, you're right, I heard the
Erica Seidel:stat the other day that fewer than 5% of Board members have marketing backgrounds.
Erica Seidel:So it's, as you say, it's kind of like approaches zero.
Erica Seidel:So it seems to me that investors are asking for CMOs to kind
Erica Seidel:of context switch for them.
Erica Seidel:It's not like the Board members are not going to context
Erica Seidel:switch for marketing leaders.
Erica Seidel:So, Jen, I'm curious, there is this kind of translation between
Erica Seidel:here's what I'm doing and, and how value gets created here.
Erica Seidel:So can you talk more about that context switching and, and also
Erica Seidel:like why is it incumbent upon you to do it if you believe that it is?
Jen Pockell Dimas:Uh, well, yes, I do think it is important for me to
Jen Pockell Dimas:be able to speak to the value that I'm driving in the business in a way
Jen Pockell Dimas:that our investors would care about.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Uh, a hundred percent I believe that's important.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And I think, um, one of the ways that Evan and I sometimes talk about this
Jen Pockell Dimas:is "Big V value" and "Little V value."
Jen Pockell Dimas:And I think the Little V value, a lot of times people are really attached to
Jen Pockell Dimas:that, like that's the, what am I doing today that helps to drive pipeline and
Jen Pockell Dimas:like the things that I'm measuring on the daily, weekly, monthly to say I
Jen Pockell Dimas:am doing these activities and they're creating value in the business.
Jen Pockell Dimas:It would be easy - it's not easy, by the way, lots of people aren't
Jen Pockell Dimas:comfortable with that kind of a conversation or that flow, but that's
Jen Pockell Dimas:not - Evan does care about that.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Believe me, he cares about pipeline and booking that are happening.
Jen Pockell Dimas:What Evan cares about is the thing he told you about five minutes ago when
Jen Pockell Dimas:he said, I put some money in and three to five years from now, I want it to
Jen Pockell Dimas:be more money that I'm getting out.
Jen Pockell Dimas:That's Big V value.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So it's a really, it has been hard in B2B marketing historically
Jen Pockell Dimas:to draw a direct line from the activities that you're making to
Jen Pockell Dimas:the outcomes that they're driving.
Jen Pockell Dimas:But now we're actually talking about Big V value, the value of
Jen Pockell Dimas:this company, not just the value of these marketing activities that I'm
Jen Pockell Dimas:driving, this, this my contribution to pipeline, whatever those things are.
Jen Pockell Dimas:This is about how am I increasing the value of this company in market?
Jen Pockell Dimas:And that is not a conversation that is necessarily one that many
Jen Pockell Dimas:are comfortable or fluent in, and that's the code switching that needs
Jen Pockell Dimas:to happen between the operational plan and how I'm executing today.
Jen Pockell Dimas:That's also important, by the way, and Evan cares a ton about that, too.
Jen Pockell Dimas:But how am I changing the program that I'm running, the team, the, um, the efforts
Jen Pockell Dimas:where I'm investing in order to increase that Big V value for the company at large.
Erica Seidel:Can you say more about that Big V value?
Erica Seidel:Like when you're at a Board meeting, what does that look like
Erica Seidel:when you are describing that?
Erica Seidel:Can you say like, oh, the, the value of the company just went up X percent?
Jen Pockell Dimas:I wish I could do that.
Jen Pockell Dimas:That would be cool, but no, that, that's why part of this is hard is this, that's
Jen Pockell Dimas:the hardest thing to measure, right?
Jen Pockell Dimas:In marketing, the, the easiest thing to measure, which honestly years ago you
Jen Pockell Dimas:couldn't even do this is I did these activities, I created this pipeline.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Right?
Jen Pockell Dimas:Those are, those are the, the kinds of things that you can
Jen Pockell Dimas:draw straight lines to now.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Even those things used to be difficult.
Jen Pockell Dimas:But in terms of value creation of a brand or a category that's
Jen Pockell Dimas:really squishy and difficult.
Jen Pockell Dimas:If you're not spend, if you're not spending tons of money on a
Jen Pockell Dimas:share of voice, share a wallet, what's going on out there?
Jen Pockell Dimas:And for a company in our stage of growth, those kinds of, um,
Jen Pockell Dimas:studies don't make any sense.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Um, and by the way, even if you spent hundreds of thousands of
Jen Pockell Dimas:dollars to do those studies in five minutes, that data would old.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So it, it's not a good investment to do those studies
Jen Pockell Dimas:to understand your Big V value.
Jen Pockell Dimas:But in our particular case, we have understandings about how we want this
Jen Pockell Dimas:company to be understood and valued and what new markets we want to open.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And we'll be able to see that we're having success there because we will
Jen Pockell Dimas:begin to create revenue in new directions.
Jen Pockell Dimas:We will open up, uh, we will see consistency in, uh, bookings
Jen Pockell Dimas:creation, in, in directions we haven't seen historically.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Maybe into a new geo, maybe a new, new product offering, maybe
Jen Pockell Dimas:in a new revenue source that we hadn't considered historically.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Those kinds of things would increase our value.
Jen Pockell Dimas:The squishy ways that this would show up, and every marketer hates this, but
Jen Pockell Dimas:one of the things that we knew was a challenge here is our own customers saying
Jen Pockell Dimas:to us, "Oh, I didn't know you did that."
Jen Pockell Dimas:That breaks every marketer's heart.
Jen Pockell Dimas:We don't want that.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So addressing those kinds of things, those are, those are the squishy
Jen Pockell Dimas:things that are hard to measure, right?
Jen Pockell Dimas:How do we make sure that where we are understood, um, where we are in
Jen Pockell Dimas:the consideration set of our future customers, that that is, that market
Jen Pockell Dimas:is expanding, and that more folks are understanding the ways that
Jen Pockell Dimas:Telarus can drive value for them.
Erica Seidel:So, Evan, let me ask you, if Jen or a different marketing leader
Erica Seidel:from a different port co brought up these kind of squishy things, which
Erica Seidel:it's, it's, I don't know if I would say squishy, but kind of like directional
Erica Seidel:things, like in a Board meeting.
Erica Seidel:So, for instance, people are, are not saying that they, um, knew that such and
Erica Seidel:such a company did X, Y, Z, like, do you think that's valid for a Board meeting?
Evan DeCorte:It's very rarely the case in a complex operating business that you
Evan DeCorte:have one-to-one correlations everywhere across the company where you can directly
Evan DeCorte:tie specific actions to specific outcomes.
Evan DeCorte:Right?
Evan DeCorte:And so this idea that we're gonna have perfect knowledge, it's like,
Evan DeCorte:I don't really think it makes sense.
Evan DeCorte:And it seems like an impossible goal.
Evan DeCorte:In many ways, I, I think the Board meeting, and this is not exactly what
Evan DeCorte:you asked, but I think the Board meeting and the, and the conversation in the
Evan DeCorte:Boardroom can act as like a bit of a forcing function to, to cause all of the
Evan DeCorte:executives in the business to stop and reflect on this very specific operational
Evan DeCorte:activities that they've been carrying out and ask how does this create value?
Evan DeCorte:Right?
Evan DeCorte:Why are we doing these things?
Evan DeCorte:How do we know that they are successful?
Evan DeCorte:And sometimes we can, all we can do is get a sense where we're directionally
Evan DeCorte:correct and like, that's okay.
Evan DeCorte:I think what, what doesn't work, though, and where I think really, I
Evan DeCorte:don't think it should be a, a question of, of code switching where marketers
Evan DeCorte:think about marketing things and investors think about investment things.
Evan DeCorte:We are united in a common goal, right?
Evan DeCorte:Which is creating, creating value for the employees, for the shareholders,
Evan DeCorte:and creating valuable business.
Evan DeCorte:If we don't look at the, all of our activities through that lens, I, I think
Evan DeCorte:we've sort of failed the enterprise.
Evan DeCorte:And so I, I just, I think in a really simple example, right?
Evan DeCorte:Every CMO in our portfolio is a shareholder, right?
Evan DeCorte:I mean, either through a management incentive plan or direct
Evan DeCorte:ownership, they participate in the value that's being created.
Evan DeCorte:And I don't actually think that that the worlds are too,
Evan DeCorte:they're, they're too different.
Evan DeCorte:It's just where you focus and where you apply your efforts.
Erica Seidel:Evan, is there something that you admit that you
Erica Seidel:don't understand about marketing that you'd be willing to share?
Evan DeCorte:I don't know anything about marketing.
Evan DeCorte:I mean, like, there's not like, like so many things I don't know.
Evan DeCorte:I mean, I, I don't even know, I don't even know how start answering that.
Evan DeCorte:I mean, at, at one point in a, in a life long, long ago, I, I, I had some
Evan DeCorte:marketing experience and like, I'm not even sure I was very good at it.
Evan DeCorte:And I wouldn't even pretend to give, um, relevant operational advice.
Evan DeCorte:Right?
Evan DeCorte:I mean, I think the world in which Jen says, like, I'm, I'm thinking
Evan DeCorte:about running this campaign and here are the various ads in front of me.
Evan DeCorte:What should you choose?
Evan DeCorte:It's like, well, like that's very misguided to ask me because like
Evan DeCorte:what of worth could I tell you?
Evan DeCorte:I think this just kind of goes back to like what is the, what is the relationship
Evan DeCorte:between the Board, the investor syndicate, and the executive team?
Evan DeCorte:It's, hey Jen, like show me with your track record.
Evan DeCorte:Right?
Evan DeCorte:So you've told me that you wanted to pursue these things, that they would
Evan DeCorte:be valuable in the past you did them.
Evan DeCorte:What was the outcome?
Evan DeCorte:I think that feedback loop is just as valuable when things are working
Evan DeCorte:as it is when they're not working.
Evan DeCorte:In fact, it's probably more valuable when it's not working right.
Evan DeCorte:So, to the extent that we can see team hypothesis test and then
Evan DeCorte:course correct, that's great too.
Evan DeCorte:We don't expect everyone to be right a hundred percent of the time.
Evan DeCorte:What we, what we care about is that we're measuring the activity as best
Evan DeCorte:we can and knowing that it's probably imperfect at best, and then using
Evan DeCorte:that data to inform our next action.
Evan DeCorte:And so, I mean, I don't know, Jen, correct me if I'm wrong, but, like,
Evan DeCorte:the number of times I've given any kind of meaningful, substantive advice in
Evan DeCorte:the Board meeting around some specific marketing tactic, like I, I probably
Evan DeCorte:could count on one hand and every time I gave it was probably wrong.
Evan DeCorte:So our, our goal is not to be smart marketers.
Evan DeCorte:That's why we recruit great people to work with our businesses.
Evan DeCorte:So we don't, we don't have to do it.
Evan DeCorte:We're getting involved it's because something's gone horribly wrong.
Jen Pockell Dimas:I do think now there was something, um, underneath what Evan
Jen Pockell Dimas:just said, that that has changed who marketers are, who CMOs are, Erica,
Jen Pockell Dimas:and that is this preponderance of data that allows us to understand now
Jen Pockell Dimas:digital buying behavior, to be able to see how people are engaging with
Jen Pockell Dimas:the brand and how they become engaged when they're in the consideration set.
Jen Pockell Dimas:What their purchase journey looks like.
Jen Pockell Dimas:What happens after.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Now that we can understand these things, it, we, we must, right?
Erica Seidel:Mm-hmm.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So what Evan didn't say is like, that's why he wants
Jen Pockell Dimas:data-driven marketers to help him because he speaks with his reptile brain.
Jen Pockell Dimas:He wants to understand, if I put in a dollar here, how many dollars
Jen Pockell Dimas:am I getting out on the other side?
Jen Pockell Dimas:And that's hard to do if you're talking about squishy, you know, arts and crafts
Jen Pockell Dimas:marketing, which that, that's why the profile of who leads marketing has
Jen Pockell Dimas:changed so much because the data exists to be able to tell more informed stories.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And so that's why folks are looking for that profile from a leader today.
Erica Seidel:So, Jen, let me ask you, we asked Evan what he wants from a CMO.
Erica Seidel:What do you want from a Board and what don't you want?
Jen Pockell Dimas:I love that they know what they know and
Jen Pockell Dimas:they know what they don't know.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Um, and they're just so that, that's super helpful because it
Jen Pockell Dimas:hasn't always been like that for me.
Jen Pockell Dimas:I'll, I'll be honest, like there are a lot of people who read something
Jen Pockell Dimas:about marketing and, and then send you a note saying, you should do this
Jen Pockell Dimas:with your SEO strategy, or you should go on Twitter and say these things.
Jen Pockell Dimas:There are a lot of people who sort of like play at operating, and that's not bad.
Jen Pockell Dimas:I mean, it's, you get good ideas from all over the place.
Jen Pockell Dimas:It's not a bad thing to have that, but it, it's really powerful to know where
Jen Pockell Dimas:you add value and where you don't.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Like Evan and I have had many conversations about me understanding
Jen Pockell Dimas:his financial perspective on things and what good looks like and what success
Jen Pockell Dimas:looks like for the company and things like that so that we remain aligned.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So I like, I like that kind of openness.
Jen Pockell Dimas:I like that we have open channels of communication.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Like that's another thing is I like ungated access to Board.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Uh, sometimes you have, uh, leadership that, that's really
Jen Pockell Dimas:protective of that relationship, and we don't have that at Telarus.
Jen Pockell Dimas:We are, we are allowed and encouraged to have direct relationships with Board
Jen Pockell Dimas:and I think that is really healthy.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So that's something that I would want is open access.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And feedback like when things are going well or when things aren't going well.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Just like Evan wants me to tell him, hey, I, I ran this play and oops,
Jen Pockell Dimas:that didn't work out well, so now I'm gonna do it this way next time.
Jen Pockell Dimas:This is what I'm gonna change and this is how, this is what I learned
Jen Pockell Dimas:and how I'm gonna do it differently.
Jen Pockell Dimas:I also want them to be like, hey, by the way, when you presented
Jen Pockell Dimas:information the following way is this did not, um, meet our expectations.
Jen Pockell Dimas:It would be better if it was like this, and this is what I really meant
Jen Pockell Dimas:when I said I wanted this thing.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Like real open, honest feedback is super helpful.
Jen Pockell Dimas:'Cause I've definitely had it where it's not that and that I've
Jen Pockell Dimas:been surprised by Board reactions.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So I think that that's sort of me as a human, um, wanting that.
Jen Pockell Dimas:I want more open communication anyway.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And having that from a Board is very important.
Jen Pockell Dimas:I, I believe I have that with Evan and with the rest of the
Jen Pockell Dimas:Columbia Capital Board, too.
Erica Seidel:So Jen, what would be your advice to another CMO who is facing that
Erica Seidel:challenge that a Board member, you know, saw something, you know, like, oh, go
Erica Seidel:do this thing on Twitter, or, you know, why don't you, why don't you do X, Y, Z?
Erica Seidel:How, how would you advise them?
Jen Pockell Dimas:Well, what I've said, I really believe.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Like good ideas come from anywhere.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So part of the guidance there is listening, uh, you know, being open-minded
Jen Pockell Dimas:to things, but the other part is to, it's an opportunity in some cases to
Jen Pockell Dimas:remind folks about what your priorities and where your areas of focus are.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So it, it would be great in, in, in the case when someone came up with
Jen Pockell Dimas:a thing and said, "Hey, why don't you go do the thing over there?"
Jen Pockell Dimas:You could say, oh, that's a really interesting idea, and remember this year
Jen Pockell Dimas:we're focused on these three priorities.
Jen Pockell Dimas:These are the things that my programs are driving toward.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And I, we could, um, we could take some of our focus away to try that experiment,
Jen Pockell Dimas:but I'm not sure it would have the same impact on the bottom line as these
Jen Pockell Dimas:things that we're doing or whatever.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Bringing information back to what are the like top line objectives
Jen Pockell Dimas:that you're trying to drive through the business is one way to do that.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Because there's always a lot of ideas and keeping focused and, uh, and trying
Jen Pockell Dimas:things is good or, or keeping a carve out for ex-experian, like, uh, experiment,
Jen Pockell Dimas:pardon me, is is also not a bad idea because there are often ideas that
Jen Pockell Dimas:come at you from lots of directions and it's not a bad idea to try things.
Erica Seidel:Right.
Evan DeCorte:I actually think it's funny, like, I hadn't really thought about
Evan DeCorte:it that way, but I, I do think framing things for the investor or the Board
Evan DeCorte:around this idea of constrained resources.
Evan DeCorte:Like we only have so many people.
Evan DeCorte:We have to pick the things that we're gonna do and we wanna
Evan DeCorte:be best in the world at them.
Evan DeCorte:In order for us to do that, this is what we have to do.
Evan DeCorte:Like that, that is, that's language that resonates, right?
Evan DeCorte:So we, I always sort of ask people like, what are you best in the world at?
Evan DeCorte:What is the company best in the world at?
Evan DeCorte:How do we do more of that thing and do less things you're not?
Evan DeCorte:I think investors and finance folks understand this idea of constrained
Evan DeCorte:resources and tradeoffs really well, but somehow, like when we talk with
Evan DeCorte:the companies with which we invested, we have this expectation that people
Evan DeCorte:do endless amounts of work with, you know, very limited resources.
Evan DeCorte:And then there's also this question about budget, right?
Evan DeCorte:So we like the idea of endless work, but without endless budget.
Evan DeCorte:And, and like turns out those are, like, contradictory ideas.
Evan DeCorte:And so, you know, I think framing the priorities around, you know, what we can
Evan DeCorte:do well and what we need to focus on, I think is also, is always a, a helpful
Evan DeCorte:way to ground and frame the conversation.
Erica Seidel:Thank you.
Erica Seidel:So any tips on when things are not going well?
Erica Seidel:Evan, you brought this up earlier.
Erica Seidel:If, um, you know, say leads are down, conversion is suffering, a launch
Erica Seidel:falls flat, you know, you spend a lot of money on a campaign and it
Erica Seidel:doesn't do, doesn't go anywhere.
Erica Seidel:Like, I'm curious from, from either or both of you, how should that change
Erica Seidel:how a CMO interacts with the Board?
Jen Pockell Dimas:If you have the measurements in place, like
Jen Pockell Dimas:we were talking about, there's always something that's out.
Jen Pockell Dimas:People don't buy the way you expect them to buy.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Buying trends change, things change.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Um, and so there's never gonna be ever a time when you 100%
Jen Pockell Dimas:delivered on your promise.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So I think just being completely, first of all, managing expectations
Jen Pockell Dimas:that that's true is helpful.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Like if someone's expecting green across the Board and everything just
Jen Pockell Dimas:goes the way that they, uh, hoped it would, like, that's not rational.
Jen Pockell Dimas:It's probably not gonna go that way.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And we're probably not measuring things appropriately if everything's
Jen Pockell Dimas:always looking up and to the right.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So what we're looking for are to have the mechanisms in place that we can see when
Jen Pockell Dimas:things are out and that we can adjust.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So Evan just said, tell me early and often when things aren't going right.
Jen Pockell Dimas:I would hope, Erica, never, I mean, not never, unless Evan wants me to,
Jen Pockell Dimas:but I'm not gonna be in the business of talking to Evan about the messaging
Jen Pockell Dimas:that I have at the campaign level.
Jen Pockell Dimas:That's something, that's like too small for him.
Jen Pockell Dimas:He doesn't care about those things.
Jen Pockell Dimas:What he cares about is the outcome in a bi- much bigger sense.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So he needs to believe that I'm tracking the business in a way that I can
Jen Pockell Dimas:make adjustments, um, to my business and ma- and make those outcomes.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And that, and that I need to be out and honest with what's going
Jen Pockell Dimas:really well and also with what I'm, uh, working to correct.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And so some of that is me, um, actively managing expectations that
Jen Pockell Dimas:things will, will always be out.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And secondly, me, me showing the reds and the yellows too, not just
Jen Pockell Dimas:the greens when I'm communicating with the Board about what's going,
Jen Pockell Dimas:you know, how things are going.
Evan DeCorte:I guess just what I wanna know is that, amongst the teams that
Evan DeCorte:we back, there's enough willingness to reflect on what's going right and wrong.
Evan DeCorte:Communicate those lessons in, in an open and honest way
Evan DeCorte:that we can have a dialogue.
Evan DeCorte:What I think, I think when that breaks down, I think you get a lot of, you get a
Evan DeCorte:lot of commentary about, you know, Twitter tactics from Board members who don't
Evan DeCorte:know what they're talking about, right?
Evan DeCorte:There's like some, some interests are desired to assert control where
Evan DeCorte:maybe they feel like they don't have their arms around things.
Evan DeCorte:And I think similarly, if teams don't feel like they have an understanding
Evan DeCorte:where their investors sit and how they're thinking about the world, then maybe they,
Evan DeCorte:maybe they wanna hoard information too.
Evan DeCorte:And like if, when you get to those, those are very dark places to get and
Evan DeCorte:you really never, ever wanna be there.
Evan DeCorte:And the only way to, to avoid it is just be open, honest, every
Evan DeCorte:step, every step of the way.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Your question, um, was about what to do in these cases.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So part of my guidance would be include the Board in all of your interviews.
Jen Pockell Dimas:First of all, don't ever accept a marketing leadership position without
Jen Pockell Dimas:relationship development with that Board because you don't know what
Jen Pockell Dimas:you're walking into otherwise.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Like you're signing up for something that you don't know what that's like.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And then manage that, um, relationship actively.
Jen Pockell Dimas:I can- earlier when leadership was less comfortable to me, when it was a newer
Jen Pockell Dimas:experience of leading the functions, I don't know that I had the confidence to
Jen Pockell Dimas:push on that kind of thing as much and I didn't, um, and I didn't know that.
Jen Pockell Dimas:I don't think I developed the Board relationships as much as I
Jen Pockell Dimas:should have, like looking back.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Um, and so there was an out between expectation and, uh,
Jen Pockell Dimas:delivery and things like that.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And I think that as I've moved on, like that's an incredibly important,
Jen Pockell Dimas:uh, relationship to invest in before you even accept the job so that
Jen Pockell Dimas:you're on the same page about, um, expectations, but also certainly
Jen Pockell Dimas:to cultivate while you're in-seat.
Erica Seidel:That, that makes a ton of sense.
Erica Seidel:Jen, you were mentioning, you know, reds, yellows, and greens.
Erica Seidel:Um, which makes me wonder, what has worked and what hasn't in terms of
Erica Seidel:structuring your Board presentations?
Erica Seidel:And relatedly, is there a way that you've seen to not have Board meeting prep
Erica Seidel:take days of intensity and days of time?
Jen Pockell Dimas:Well, your Board meeting content is
Jen Pockell Dimas:always incredibly important.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And I, I'm not even a year in-seat at Telarus.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So if I am honest about how we've managed our Board conversations
Jen Pockell Dimas:to date, it's not like I have a, a rote package that I'm continuously
Jen Pockell Dimas:delivering to them every single time.
Jen Pockell Dimas:It's more complete updates to like, what are the strategic imperatives?
Jen Pockell Dimas:The first 120 days I was like sitting and looking and evaluating the business
Jen Pockell Dimas:and deciding what priorities were, and it was aligning on priorities and it
Jen Pockell Dimas:was restructuring and doing all that.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So there's been a lot of higher level updates, but my goal ultimately
Jen Pockell Dimas:when I get the business to where it is, is to have more of a regular
Jen Pockell Dimas:package, which is data driven.
Jen Pockell Dimas:I have, at this point, um, developed a dashboard, but it, it is a dashboard
Jen Pockell Dimas:that I am just now reporting on regularly to the internal business.
Jen Pockell Dimas:It's not even Board ready.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Like, I'll, Evan, I could, I I would show it to you in a private meeting right
Jen Pockell Dimas:now, but it's not consistent enough.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Um, I haven't had enough months in-seat, like measuring the same
Jen Pockell Dimas:things that I believe it's Board ready.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And so I think by partway through this year we'll be in that place,
Jen Pockell Dimas:Erica, where I'll have a more standard Board reporting package where Evan
Jen Pockell Dimas:can be like, aha, these, this is what I expect to see from Jen.
Erica Seidel:Evan, anything to add on how Board meeting prep can be less intensive?
Evan DeCorte:I don't actually know if that's the right question.
Evan DeCorte:Like, I mean, I think that the sort of frames Board meeting prep as like
Evan DeCorte:eating, eating your vegetables, right?
Erica Seidel:Yeah.
Evan DeCorte:It's like what's the least painful way to do this?
Evan DeCorte:It, it's, something's that's kind of a pain and it takes a lot time,
Evan DeCorte:and could we be more efficient?
Evan DeCorte:Because it, I, I think it treats the, the Board reporting as
Evan DeCorte:perfunctory and as reporting.
Evan DeCorte:And I think if that's the where you are, well then just send out the deck.
Evan DeCorte:We don't need a Board meeting, right?
Evan DeCorte:I mean, send some materials.
Evan DeCorte:Tell me, show me the same thing every month or every quarter, whatever.
Evan DeCorte:And we don't need to get together and burn up a bunch of time.
Evan DeCorte:If that's what you're doing, I, I think Board meetings, Board meetings probably
Evan DeCorte:were being run pretty poorly, right?
Evan DeCorte:It's not good use of everyone's time.
Evan DeCorte:I think Board meeting prep takes time because it is, I think, for the business,
Evan DeCorte:like a moment of self-reflection.
Evan DeCorte:What have we done?
Evan DeCorte:What were the outcomes?
Evan DeCorte:What are we gonna do differently?
Evan DeCorte:How does this impact our view on strategy or the market?
Evan DeCorte:And those are not always easy questions to answer.
Evan DeCorte:And if they are really easy, like I, I might, might think it's time
Evan DeCorte:for a little more self-reflection.
Evan DeCorte:Right?
Evan DeCorte:Because it, because they're, these are like, it very rarely are the things
Evan DeCorte:that we're doing, even in businesses that are just really doing well, easy.
Evan DeCorte:We face tough questions that take time to grapple with, right?
Evan DeCorte:We are conducting a lot of activities and hiring people and running new
Evan DeCorte:strategies and evaluating them and measuring them against the alternatives.
Evan DeCorte:Like those are complex questions.
Erica Seidel:Yeah.
Evan DeCorte:If the answer is obvious and easy, and it's the same every
Evan DeCorte:quarter, like something's not working.
Evan DeCorte:So I, I encourage the companies that we work with, and I think this, you know,
Evan DeCorte:extends all the way to the marketing function to look at the Board meeting as a
Evan DeCorte:way to just pause and to, to kind of think about what you've been spending time on
Evan DeCorte:and you know, what you wanna accomplish and, and what you have accomplished.
Evan DeCorte:I think for, just given where Columbia invests, a lot of times we'll get involved
Evan DeCorte:in the business that maybe has actually never even had a formal Board meeting.
Evan DeCorte:And I think there's sometimes a little bit of, like, a allergic reaction idea.
Evan DeCorte:We'll write all the things working down piece of paper then talk about them.
Evan DeCorte:But over time, I, I, I would say the universal, in your universal
Evan DeCorte:view from the executives that we partner with, the Board meeting
Evan DeCorte:itself is a highly valuable exercise.
Evan DeCorte:It is not just to give an update to the investor group.
Jen Pockell Dimas:It does force you to look with outside
Jen Pockell Dimas:eyes at your business, right?
Jen Pockell Dimas:'Cause you can get so in the weeds on a regular day, to say, okay,
Jen Pockell Dimas:wait a minute, now I'm looking at this from a different perspective.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Uh, what's the story?
Jen Pockell Dimas:How are things going?
Jen Pockell Dimas:And so I, I completely agree that it, and, and also you wanna use
Jen Pockell Dimas:the Board for the guidance that they're good at giving you, right?
Jen Pockell Dimas:You wanna be able to say, these are the things that are happening, and
Jen Pockell Dimas:ask them for the guidance, um, in the places where you need it or, or buy in
Jen Pockell Dimas:for the decisions that you're making.
Jen Pockell Dimas:If they, you know, like, this is my strategy.
Jen Pockell Dimas:This is something I learned, this is what I'm gonna do differently.
Jen Pockell Dimas:Is this something you're familiar with?
Jen Pockell Dimas:Is this, does this make sense?
Jen Pockell Dimas:Like, use the Board for making good decisions too.
Erica Seidel:Right.
Evan DeCorte:And I think, you know, the, the more informed we are, the
Evan DeCorte:better we are at providing support.
Evan DeCorte:And that support is not in the form of, you know, this
Evan DeCorte:marketing tactic versus that.
Evan DeCorte:It's, hey Jen, like we have ten other portfolio companies
Evan DeCorte:that face similar problems.
Evan DeCorte:I have an idea about how they solve them.
Evan DeCorte:I'm probably not the best person to describe them to you.
Evan DeCorte:Why don't you talk to them?
Evan DeCorte:Right?
Evan DeCorte:So we, I think we can facilitate connections and conversations that
Evan DeCorte:ultimately are useful, that help get to resolution, but without us being
Evan DeCorte:the ones actually dictating the result.
Erica Seidel:That's a great conversation.
Erica Seidel:Thank you.
Erica Seidel:So final question for each of you is just what one piece of final
Erica Seidel:advice would you have for a new CMO or a CMO that's new to a role to
Erica Seidel:optimize their Board relationship?
Jen Pockell Dimas:I think I'll just go back to the thing that I said before.
Jen Pockell Dimas:One is ensure that the Board is included in your, in your interview process.
Jen Pockell Dimas:I wouldn't allow it otherwise.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And then cultivate that relate, actively cultivate that relationship as someone
Jen Pockell Dimas:who's their partner with you and the success of the business, and help you
Jen Pockell Dimas:see things from a different direction.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And they have skills and abilities to help you be more successful at your job.
Jen Pockell Dimas:So leverage them.
Jen Pockell Dimas:And also they can help you in some very clear ways understand
Jen Pockell Dimas:what is the Big V value?
Jen Pockell Dimas:What, why are you there?
Jen Pockell Dimas:What is the outcome that you're really trying to drive?
Jen Pockell Dimas:And, and have that perspective from, from a different, a different lens.
Erica Seidel:Evan, anything to add?
Evan DeCorte:Yeah, I mean, I think without, um, I'll just say just
Evan DeCorte:transparency is, is, is absolutely key.
Evan DeCorte:But I think maybe this, the specific thing I would recommend and something
Evan DeCorte:we try and do though, though not always successfully, is to make sure
Evan DeCorte:that we are sharing our view on how value gets created in these businesses
Evan DeCorte:and being very specific about it.
Evan DeCorte:And that's not necessarily to like prescribe a playbook, but I think, you
Evan DeCorte:know, even very early on, you know, Jen, Jen and I sat down, you know, we
Evan DeCorte:went through our deck, like how do we think value gets created at Telarus?
Evan DeCorte:And how do we think the market will think about value?
Evan DeCorte:How do we think that intersects with mark, intersects with marketing?
Evan DeCorte:And here's some example numbers.
Evan DeCorte:Like it's not, it's not as if it was the crystal ball where we
Evan DeCorte:outline exactly what's gonna happen for the next couple of years.
Evan DeCorte:But it allows us to align, I think, but Jen will tell me if it'll work
Evan DeCorte:not, on the common vocabulary, so that when we talk about value, we are
Evan DeCorte:actually talking about the same thing.
Evan DeCorte:I think sometimes that step can get skipped because we assume that we're
Evan DeCorte:all speaking the same language, when in fact we very rarely are.
Evan DeCorte:Just because we come with different sets of experiences and different
Evan DeCorte:priors, look doesn't mean we're gonna agree on everything.
Evan DeCorte:But I think it's important that we understand each person's worldview so
Evan DeCorte:that we can iterate quickly as we develop a relationship around what does value
Evan DeCorte:creation mean in a, you know, private equity backed or venture-backed business.
Erica Seidel:Well, this has been awesome.
Erica Seidel:Thank you both for sharing these fabulous perspectives.
Erica Seidel:I have this image in my mind of reptilian brains and, you know,
Erica Seidel:awesome reptiles and, um, and also just a, just such a nice, uh,
Erica Seidel:connection between the two of you.
Erica Seidel:So, thank you so much, Jen Dimas and Evan DeCorte for joining The Get.
Erica Seidel:That was Jen Dimas, Chief Marketing and Experience Officer from Telarus,
Erica Seidel:and Evan DeCorte, one of her Board members from Columbia Capital.
Erica Seidel:Maybe you have a Board member with a reptilian brain.
Erica Seidel:Think about how you can translate marketing speak for them based
Erica Seidel:on what you learned today.
Erica Seidel:Next time on The Get, we will hear from two SaaS marketing leaders from
Erica Seidel:PE-backed companies about their hard-won learnings on working with Boards,
Erica Seidel:Alison Dancy and Madeline O'Phelan.
Erica Seidel:You'll hear about the relative importance of the three Cs - context,
Erica Seidel:content, and confidence when interacting with the Board.
Erica Seidel:And we talk about how Boards have glommed onto some key marketing concepts like
Erica Seidel:ABM and ICP, but not others, like brand.
Erica Seidel:How do you leverage that in your Board interactions?
Erica Seidel:Don't miss it.
Erica Seidel:Thanks for listening to The Get.
Erica Seidel:I'm your host, Erica Seidel.
Erica Seidel:The Get is here to drive smart decisions around recruiting and
Erica Seidel:leadership in B2B SaaS marketing.
Erica Seidel:We explore the trends, tribulations, and triumphs of today's top
Erica Seidel:marketing leaders in B2B SaaS.
Erica Seidel:If you liked this episode, please share it.
Erica Seidel:For more about The Get, visit thegetpodcast.com.
Erica Seidel:To learn more about my executive search practice, which focuses on recruiting the
Erica Seidel:make-money marketing leaders rather than the make-it-pretty ones, follow me on
Erica Seidel:LinkedIn or visit theconnectivegood.com.
Erica Seidel:The Get is produced by Evo Terra of Simpler Media Productions.