1 00:00:25,944 --> 00:00:29,274 Here I am at the Adelaide Entertainment Centre for the Self-Insure of 2 00:00:29,274 --> 00:00:30,714 South Australia conference. 3 00:00:31,104 --> 00:00:34,284 The Resolution Room podcast in collaboration with M-L-C-O-A 4 00:00:34,284 --> 00:00:35,874 is on the road in Adelaide. 5 00:00:36,624 --> 00:00:40,074 We've got a great panel conversation coming up between a psychiatrist, 6 00:00:40,374 --> 00:00:44,004 a neuropsychologist and occupation physician, and a lawyer talking about 7 00:00:44,004 --> 00:00:48,774 cognition, the ageing workplace, and all those pressure and pain points. 8 00:00:48,834 --> 00:00:49,734 Let's get into it. 9 00:00:50,304 --> 00:00:52,494 Please welcome Damien Van Bru shot. 10 00:00:59,224 --> 00:01:01,024 Let me introduce our sterling panel. 11 00:01:01,054 --> 00:01:03,574 Welcome to the stage, uh, Dr. Tim Huang. 12 00:01:03,994 --> 00:01:05,824 Tim is an occupational physician. 13 00:01:06,754 --> 00:01:11,224 He's a fellow of the Australian Faculty of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 14 00:01:11,644 --> 00:01:17,254 and he's worked both in-house in places like Ford and at Melbourne Airport. 15 00:01:17,254 --> 00:01:20,584 And now he has a extensive private consulting career. 16 00:01:20,824 --> 00:01:23,554 Occupational medicine is such an interesting discipline. 17 00:01:23,794 --> 00:01:28,594 It brings together all things about work, the broad variety of work and 18 00:01:28,594 --> 00:01:32,314 the interplay between capacity, and we are gonna really pick his brains 19 00:01:32,314 --> 00:01:35,794 about that, particularly in the context of an ageing population and some 20 00:01:35,794 --> 00:01:37,834 of the case studies in front of us. 21 00:01:37,894 --> 00:01:40,144 So thanks for your time, Tim, and good luck tomorrow. 22 00:01:40,144 --> 00:01:43,054 Tim's competing on a TaeKwonDo competition, so good luck 23 00:01:43,054 --> 00:01:44,104 tomorrow as well, Tim, for that. 24 00:01:44,104 --> 00:01:44,629 Thank you very much. 25 00:01:44,794 --> 00:01:49,144 Okay, welcome to the stage Shiva Pu. 26 00:01:49,144 --> 00:01:53,284 Dr. Shiva Gunna is a psychiatrist and he's an adult psychiatrist. 27 00:01:53,674 --> 00:01:58,384 We are gonna pick his brain about the mental aspect, uh, of 28 00:01:58,384 --> 00:02:00,604 return to work, what that means. 29 00:02:00,604 --> 00:02:03,334 And of course, we all know across all schemes there's a rise of 30 00:02:03,334 --> 00:02:06,214 secondary psychological injuries causing a lot of pressure. 31 00:02:06,574 --> 00:02:11,524 The de-stigmatization of mental health is great, but it it has come at a cost of 32 00:02:11,524 --> 00:02:14,554 course, and we're gonna be examining some of those issues in these case studies. 33 00:02:14,824 --> 00:02:18,544 Dr. GPA as well as being an extensive medicolegal consultant 34 00:02:18,544 --> 00:02:20,764 now also has an executive hat on. 35 00:02:20,764 --> 00:02:24,244 He works for Ramsay Health in an executive capacity, which is a large 36 00:02:24,244 --> 00:02:25,894 private hospital in mental health. 37 00:02:25,894 --> 00:02:28,384 So thank you, Dr. Shiva for your time and expertise. 38 00:02:28,774 --> 00:02:32,044 Neuropsychologist, Dr. Sarah Lucas, welcome to the stage. 39 00:02:32,824 --> 00:02:33,334 I like this. 40 00:02:33,334 --> 00:02:36,304 I didn't expect to do the, the welcome, but now they're backstage. 41 00:02:36,304 --> 00:02:39,904 I think it adds dramatic effect, so I'm, I'm glad to do it this way. 42 00:02:40,144 --> 00:02:43,894 Dr. Sarah Lucas has a PhD, a doctorate in neuropsychology. 43 00:02:44,314 --> 00:02:45,964 What a wonderful discipline that is. 44 00:02:46,024 --> 00:02:50,014 We are gonna talk to Dr. Lucas about age, cognition, attention, 45 00:02:50,014 --> 00:02:51,754 memory, all the wonderful things. 46 00:02:51,754 --> 00:02:55,474 I'm 55 and I'm looking down the barrel of it at times, so this is 47 00:02:55,474 --> 00:02:56,884 a really important conversation. 48 00:02:57,154 --> 00:03:01,504 Dr. Lucas has an extensive medicolegal practise assessing capacity. 49 00:03:01,504 --> 00:03:03,304 For example, testamentary capacity. 50 00:03:03,484 --> 00:03:06,694 She works across South Australia, nt and also in some 51 00:03:06,694 --> 00:03:07,774 of the eastern states as well. 52 00:03:07,774 --> 00:03:09,244 Has been doing this for a long time. 53 00:03:09,454 --> 00:03:12,334 She did have a background in a hospital setting as well before 54 00:03:12,334 --> 00:03:17,284 recently, um, branching out for some years now as, as an expert. 55 00:03:17,824 --> 00:03:22,324 Last but not least now, I've, I've left Allison last because she wasn't 56 00:03:22,324 --> 00:03:25,714 included in the brochure and she's not at all precious about it, but 57 00:03:25,714 --> 00:03:26,914 we're gonna make a big deal of her. 58 00:03:27,094 --> 00:03:28,384 Thank you Alison, for coming. 59 00:03:28,624 --> 00:03:29,764 Allison is our, um. 60 00:03:31,704 --> 00:03:34,374 Allison is our resident lawyer for my sins. 61 00:03:34,374 --> 00:03:36,774 I'm also a lawyer but not an employment one. 62 00:03:36,774 --> 00:03:39,594 Perhaps in my next life I'll come back as an employment lawyer because 63 00:03:40,014 --> 00:03:41,544 what Allison brings is unique. 64 00:03:41,544 --> 00:03:43,614 As an employment lawyer, you look at all things in the 65 00:03:43,614 --> 00:03:45,234 workplace, such a broad field. 66 00:03:45,654 --> 00:03:49,794 One of the wonderful things about her work is that you do a broad range of clients. 67 00:03:49,794 --> 00:03:51,654 You works for public sector, private clients. 68 00:03:51,654 --> 00:03:54,504 They're quite different, quite different sectors, quite different ways of 69 00:03:54,504 --> 00:03:57,324 looking at the world and a lot of the advice you give as an employment lawyer 70 00:03:57,324 --> 00:03:59,004 is very strategic and commercial. 71 00:03:59,154 --> 00:04:02,184 You obviously know the law, you know the legal landscape, but you're often 72 00:04:02,214 --> 00:04:05,454 navigating some really commercial imperatives and understanding the client. 73 00:04:05,814 --> 00:04:09,444 Allison has been a Hall and Wilcox for 20 years and as an expert in that 74 00:04:09,534 --> 00:04:13,764 uh, space, she's been recognised in best lawyers and in Doyles for her 75 00:04:13,764 --> 00:04:15,384 unique expertise in employment law. 76 00:04:15,384 --> 00:04:16,914 So welcome Alison. 77 00:04:17,484 --> 00:04:20,604 Uh, now you don't feel like you've missed out on the on the schedule. 78 00:04:20,664 --> 00:04:22,464 Alright guys, we've got a case study. 79 00:04:22,464 --> 00:04:25,974 I'm gonna take a seat, but I'll read out this case study quickly. 80 00:04:26,244 --> 00:04:29,484 The case study is only intended to stimulate conversations. 81 00:04:29,484 --> 00:04:31,704 There's a lot of unknowns, but let's go David. 82 00:04:31,704 --> 00:04:33,714 He's 62, Michael's 39. 83 00:04:34,044 --> 00:04:37,944 They work in similar occupa operational roles for a large self-insured employer. 84 00:04:38,334 --> 00:04:42,264 Both sustain relatively uncomplicated lower back injuries involving 85 00:04:42,264 --> 00:04:43,524 similar physical restrictions. 86 00:04:43,524 --> 00:04:45,714 It seems strikes to me as a soft tissue type injury. 87 00:04:45,714 --> 00:04:47,874 Uncomplicated, neither surgery. 88 00:04:48,354 --> 00:04:52,374 David the senior, has worked in his role for 34, 24 years. 89 00:04:52,374 --> 00:04:52,734 Sorry. 90 00:04:52,884 --> 00:04:55,314 He's initially frustrated by the injury but wants to 91 00:04:55,314 --> 00:04:57,684 remain connected, um, to work. 92 00:04:57,834 --> 00:05:01,164 He accepts modified duty, gradually increases his activity and tells his 93 00:05:01,164 --> 00:05:05,934 manager, I know I'm not 30 anymore, I just need to work out what I can safely do. 94 00:05:06,984 --> 00:05:11,424 Michael, the junior 39, he's been with the organisation for six years. 95 00:05:11,664 --> 00:05:14,214 He becomes increasingly concerned about re-injury. 96 00:05:14,214 --> 00:05:15,504 So his path is different. 97 00:05:15,714 --> 00:05:18,864 He avoids lifting, bending and prolonged sitting and believes 98 00:05:18,864 --> 00:05:23,664 returning before he's completely pain free, could cause permanent damage. 99 00:05:23,664 --> 00:05:25,494 So we have a level of anxiety surfacing. 100 00:05:26,004 --> 00:05:28,524 He's sleeping poorly, he's increasingly anxious. 101 00:05:28,584 --> 00:05:32,634 His treating team continues to certify significant restrictions. 102 00:05:32,634 --> 00:05:33,144 So there you go. 103 00:05:33,144 --> 00:05:36,774 Four months later, David's Mr. 62-year-old getting back to work. 104 00:05:36,774 --> 00:05:39,714 Perhaps he's a bit concerned about being on the scrap heap, but he's had 105 00:05:39,714 --> 00:05:43,764 a long term in this work and Michael remains largely absent from work. 106 00:05:43,824 --> 00:05:45,684 Okay, that's the case study. 107 00:05:45,864 --> 00:05:48,294 We've got limited time so I don't wanna linger too much on it. 108 00:05:48,564 --> 00:05:53,034 There is a question I think who would you have predicted would've had more difficult 109 00:05:53,034 --> 00:05:54,834 recovery when the injuries first occurred? 110 00:05:54,834 --> 00:05:58,944 So David, uh, Michael, don't you dunno? 111 00:05:58,944 --> 00:05:59,844 Enough, et cetera. 112 00:06:00,144 --> 00:06:03,834 For what it's worth, I'm in the category of, I don't quite know enough, but 113 00:06:03,834 --> 00:06:05,304 maybe that's just the lawyer in me. 114 00:06:06,776 --> 00:06:07,166 There we go. 115 00:06:07,166 --> 00:06:07,526 There we go. 116 00:06:07,526 --> 00:06:12,386 The numbers, understandably, people think David, I mean, 60 two's, um, 117 00:06:12,716 --> 00:06:15,506 pretty old to have an injury and it can be pretty life changing. 118 00:06:15,956 --> 00:06:18,416 As I said, I'm probably on the, there's not enough information 119 00:06:18,656 --> 00:06:22,466 bandwagon, but anyway, Michael, the 39-year-old and about the same. 120 00:06:22,466 --> 00:06:23,126 So there you go. 121 00:06:23,396 --> 00:06:24,566 There's some interesting numbers there. 122 00:06:24,566 --> 00:06:26,846 Alright, so that's the case study. 123 00:06:27,776 --> 00:06:30,506 To stimulate the conversation, I might start with you Dr. Tim 124 00:06:30,506 --> 00:06:32,306 Huang, two similar injuries. 125 00:06:32,306 --> 00:06:33,986 Why do we have such different outcomes? 126 00:06:34,046 --> 00:06:39,776 So this is a scenario that I think, uh, a lot of us have seen before in that 127 00:06:40,226 --> 00:06:46,166 people with the same or similar injuries end up having quite different outcomes. 128 00:06:46,646 --> 00:06:52,586 What it highlights is that the diagnosis, um, of one particular injury does 129 00:06:52,586 --> 00:06:56,636 not really tell us how they're gonna respond, how they're gonna return to 130 00:06:56,636 --> 00:06:59,576 work, um, and the long-term outcome. 131 00:06:59,786 --> 00:07:03,356 Obviously, there are many, many factors affecting how someone 132 00:07:03,356 --> 00:07:07,526 responds to an injury and their recovery and the return to work. 133 00:07:07,946 --> 00:07:14,726 As an occupational physician, I'm not an expert in, uh, deciphering all the 134 00:07:14,996 --> 00:07:19,406 individual psychosocial type of factors, but on the other hand, I have to be 135 00:07:19,406 --> 00:07:25,796 aware of these things and be able to recognise it and make a note of these 136 00:07:25,796 --> 00:07:27,656 things so that they can be addressed. 137 00:07:28,526 --> 00:07:33,566 In terms of, uh, factors that affect how people respond, there's individual 138 00:07:33,566 --> 00:07:40,556 factors, there's factors such as, um, negative, uh, input, negative 139 00:07:40,556 --> 00:07:46,676 reinforcement messages that people have been getting, uh, motivation, fear. 140 00:07:47,246 --> 00:07:52,556 So, um, what we've got here is, um, in one case, someone who feels 141 00:07:52,556 --> 00:07:57,656 that they shouldn't be getting back to doing anything until 142 00:07:57,656 --> 00:08:00,506 their pain, free pain is a threat. 143 00:08:00,746 --> 00:08:06,056 If I do something that is painful, it is going to, uh, retard my 144 00:08:06,086 --> 00:08:08,816 recovery and make things worse. 145 00:08:09,116 --> 00:08:13,856 On the other hand, we've got, um, David, the older gentleman who seems 146 00:08:13,856 --> 00:08:16,556 to have a fairly common sense approach. 147 00:08:17,066 --> 00:08:19,706 He doesn't seem to be, uh. 148 00:08:21,304 --> 00:08:22,684 Uh, trying to be a hero. 149 00:08:23,074 --> 00:08:29,254 Um, but he wants to find out what he can do and maximise his, uh, capacity. 150 00:08:29,584 --> 00:08:33,454 So on one hand we can see people who are really, really scared, and on the 151 00:08:33,454 --> 00:08:37,954 other hand, we might be at risk of seeing people who are so driven that they want 152 00:08:37,954 --> 00:08:39,994 to get back and push themselves too hard. 153 00:08:39,994 --> 00:08:40,474 That's right. 154 00:08:40,684 --> 00:08:44,884 And that was a good example of that, his, his, his mindset of getting 155 00:08:44,884 --> 00:08:46,744 back, bringing in Dr. Shiver here. 156 00:08:46,744 --> 00:08:51,844 In terms of the psychiatric component, we're seeing some signs here, uh, poor 157 00:08:51,844 --> 00:08:56,884 sleep, anxiety, Dr. Tim mentioned, uh, the subjective nature of pain. 158 00:08:57,154 --> 00:08:59,884 What are you picking up in this case study that could, you 159 00:08:59,884 --> 00:09:00,904 could see potentially emerge? 160 00:09:00,904 --> 00:09:03,424 I know it's early days and we probably don't have enough information. 161 00:09:03,754 --> 00:09:07,444 And just from the poll and how the room polled for this question and, 162 00:09:07,444 --> 00:09:12,004 and generally what we see, um, sometimes outcomes can surprises and 163 00:09:12,004 --> 00:09:16,864 that sort of highlights the point around mind of a matter what is going 164 00:09:16,864 --> 00:09:21,424 on in your mind, uh, inside your head and how you look at the injury, 165 00:09:21,424 --> 00:09:23,284 how you process it is a big factor. 166 00:09:23,794 --> 00:09:27,604 It does have influence on functional outcomes and general outcomes. 167 00:09:28,204 --> 00:09:31,924 So one concept we, I'm sure many in the room know about it is that 168 00:09:31,984 --> 00:09:35,284 whole, um, fear avoidance cycle. 169 00:09:35,494 --> 00:09:40,474 You catastrophize what might be the best or what might be the worst of this 170 00:09:40,474 --> 00:09:43,024 situation, of this particular injury. 171 00:09:43,324 --> 00:09:46,354 You build on it and you become vigilant around whatever triggers 172 00:09:46,354 --> 00:09:48,874 those or brings on that pain. 173 00:09:48,874 --> 00:09:52,864 So then you start avoiding it and that's reinforcing because you find some comfort. 174 00:09:52,864 --> 00:09:54,154 There's no anxiety. 175 00:09:54,394 --> 00:09:55,834 So it's like a vicious cycle. 176 00:09:55,864 --> 00:09:59,524 You are vigilant, you're avoiding, and then you're less anxious, 177 00:09:59,524 --> 00:10:00,664 therefore you keep doing that. 178 00:10:01,054 --> 00:10:04,744 The moment you push yourself, the vigilance increases, you become 179 00:10:04,744 --> 00:10:06,094 more anxious, more painful. 180 00:10:06,394 --> 00:10:09,694 So there's a natural fear avoidance cycle which builds up. 181 00:10:10,204 --> 00:10:12,574 So that could be one issue which might be playing here. 182 00:10:12,994 --> 00:10:16,714 The other concept, again, many of in the room might know about it. 183 00:10:16,744 --> 00:10:19,894 It's originally described by Professor Polowski, who was an 184 00:10:19,894 --> 00:10:23,824 Adelaide University professor from seventies up until nineties. 185 00:10:23,824 --> 00:10:29,374 So, and this model became quite popular in the psychiatric um, academy 186 00:10:29,374 --> 00:10:33,934 and then later on in clinical is the model of illness behaviours. 187 00:10:35,032 --> 00:10:39,502 So everyone, all of us, when we get sick day to day, we 188 00:10:39,502 --> 00:10:40,852 get a flu, we get an injury. 189 00:10:40,852 --> 00:10:42,742 We, we, we have a bug. 190 00:10:43,072 --> 00:10:44,332 We all take on a role. 191 00:10:44,572 --> 00:10:45,892 We deal with it differently. 192 00:10:45,922 --> 00:10:47,902 It's our way of dealing with illness. 193 00:10:47,902 --> 00:10:51,772 Some people might just decide to lay down in the bed and read a book. 194 00:10:51,772 --> 00:10:55,402 Some might just go for a light jog, some might go watch tv. 195 00:10:55,402 --> 00:10:58,792 So it's the way we, we take on a role, it's called a sick role. 196 00:10:59,002 --> 00:11:00,352 It's nothing abnormal about it. 197 00:11:00,352 --> 00:11:03,532 It's, it's a role you take on when you're told you're sick 198 00:11:03,562 --> 00:11:04,552 or you believe you're sick. 199 00:11:05,212 --> 00:11:08,002 So that role you take on is very normative. 200 00:11:08,032 --> 00:11:10,012 It helps in healing and, and recovery. 201 00:11:10,282 --> 00:11:16,192 But when that becomes abnormal or you start taking on that role 202 00:11:16,192 --> 00:11:19,942 much more persistently, a lot more seriously, and for prolonged periods 203 00:11:19,942 --> 00:11:24,382 of time, that's when it becomes an abnormal illness behaviour, a IB. 204 00:11:24,382 --> 00:11:27,292 So we kind of, when, when we look at cases like this, we look at what 205 00:11:27,292 --> 00:11:31,462 is the potential of this progressing into an abnormal illness behaviour 206 00:11:31,972 --> 00:11:33,862 and how do you cut that off at the past? 207 00:11:34,012 --> 00:11:36,562 I mean, it's very early days, but you don't want to, you don't 208 00:11:36,562 --> 00:11:40,522 wanna solidify the identity of the illness behaviour early. 209 00:11:40,912 --> 00:11:43,642 So this is the interesting part in cases like this and, and it's very 210 00:11:43,642 --> 00:11:47,962 surprising when I do the work, I actually ask, I see patients, obviously, 211 00:11:48,022 --> 00:11:52,312 uh, claimant's patients say two years down the track, sometimes six months, 212 00:11:52,312 --> 00:11:53,872 sometimes five years down the track. 213 00:11:53,902 --> 00:11:56,962 And it's very fascinating the question when I ask them. 214 00:11:57,816 --> 00:12:00,456 What do you think is causing you this pain? 215 00:12:00,516 --> 00:12:01,596 And it's fascinating. 216 00:12:01,596 --> 00:12:04,866 The answer you get is completely different from what's been in the 217 00:12:04,866 --> 00:12:07,416 reports, what's been told by the gp. 218 00:12:07,446 --> 00:12:10,416 It's, they just develop their own illness model. 219 00:12:11,196 --> 00:12:14,586 It doesn't sometimes doesn't fit anatomy doesn't fit physiology, 220 00:12:14,586 --> 00:12:15,996 it doesn't fit common sense. 221 00:12:16,236 --> 00:12:20,196 Sometimes it's, it's just an exaggerated understanding of what's happened. 222 00:12:20,766 --> 00:12:23,856 And it's fascinating when you break it down, that's the first step. 223 00:12:23,856 --> 00:12:28,836 You say, well, hang on, that, that doesn't make sense and surely anxious about this. 224 00:12:28,836 --> 00:12:29,886 This must not be that bad. 225 00:12:29,916 --> 00:12:32,676 I mean, there's all sorts of language, like you said, they've 226 00:12:32,676 --> 00:12:35,766 been given feedback and, and they add their own knowledge to that. 227 00:12:36,126 --> 00:12:37,506 So that's a good starting point. 228 00:12:37,806 --> 00:12:38,886 Thanks for that, Dr. Shiva. 229 00:12:38,886 --> 00:12:41,916 Now I'm gonna bring in the neuropsychologist, Dr. Lucas here. 230 00:12:42,066 --> 00:12:47,706 Can you help us explain why pain, anxiety, uh, medication and poor sleep can affect 231 00:12:48,126 --> 00:12:49,926 attention, memory and concentration? 232 00:12:49,926 --> 00:12:51,576 Is there something happening here? 233 00:12:51,906 --> 00:12:53,826 Yeah, so I guess there's a few elements to it. 234 00:12:53,826 --> 00:12:57,756 Firstly, we do know from a lot of research that's been done that they, these 235 00:12:57,756 --> 00:13:02,526 can, people with these conditions will experience cognitive difficulties, and 236 00:13:02,526 --> 00:13:04,746 that is on objective measures sometimes. 237 00:13:05,076 --> 00:13:07,326 The other element to it though, is the subjective. 238 00:13:07,326 --> 00:13:08,676 So their experience. 239 00:13:08,736 --> 00:13:12,216 And of course, if you are in pain, if you're highly anxious and you're 240 00:13:12,216 --> 00:13:16,806 thinking about something repeatedly, you don't have room in your brain for other 241 00:13:16,896 --> 00:13:19,026 aspects that you need to be focusing on. 242 00:13:19,356 --> 00:13:23,946 So that's why we'll often see people who report, uh, problems with, you know, 243 00:13:23,946 --> 00:13:28,116 concentrating at work, uh, difficulties, remembering information that they need. 244 00:13:28,386 --> 00:13:30,906 They'll say, I went into a meeting and I came out and I just can't remember 245 00:13:30,906 --> 00:13:35,256 anything from the meeting because their mind goes elsewhere to focusing on the 246 00:13:35,256 --> 00:13:37,266 other issues that they're experiencing. 247 00:13:37,716 --> 00:13:41,256 Um, sometimes in pain conditions, it also depends on medications. 248 00:13:41,256 --> 00:13:45,036 So we do know that the medications, if they're on strong medications, can also 249 00:13:45,036 --> 00:13:49,056 have an impact on cognition, but we often see a really significant discrepancy 250 00:13:49,056 --> 00:13:53,346 in these cases between objective cognition and subjective cognition. 251 00:13:53,646 --> 00:13:56,796 And so often it's a matter of, I guess, ruling out that there's 252 00:13:56,796 --> 00:14:00,336 anything more serious going on, but then helping that person understand 253 00:14:00,606 --> 00:14:03,096 why they're having troubles focusing. 254 00:14:03,366 --> 00:14:06,906 Um, and a lot of the issues that come up in chronic pain come up in other areas. 255 00:14:06,906 --> 00:14:09,846 So, um, you know, concussion obviously is a big one. 256 00:14:09,846 --> 00:14:10,986 Persisting concussion. 257 00:14:11,256 --> 00:14:15,786 Um, also long COVID, um, a lot of these other conditions that can 258 00:14:15,786 --> 00:14:18,756 have nothing to do sometimes with how the brain is even working. 259 00:14:19,026 --> 00:14:22,506 And people will still experience problems with concentration and memory. 260 00:14:23,032 --> 00:14:24,412 Thank you so much for that. 261 00:14:24,682 --> 00:14:28,222 Now, last but not least, the lawyer in the room and lawyers, why do we always 262 00:14:28,222 --> 00:14:29,782 come in last and clean up the mess? 263 00:14:29,842 --> 00:14:31,312 But a question for you, Alison. 264 00:14:31,582 --> 00:14:34,882 Um, what are the risks, uh, for this employer? 265 00:14:35,482 --> 00:14:39,442 If they assume that David, Mr. Senior needs greater protection simply 266 00:14:39,442 --> 00:14:42,802 because he's 62, are there, what, what does that bring to, into play? 267 00:14:43,162 --> 00:14:44,002 Thanks, Damien. 268 00:14:44,452 --> 00:14:48,382 It jumps out straight away that they're making a decision on the basis of David's 269 00:14:48,382 --> 00:14:51,472 age and age is a protected attribute. 270 00:14:51,472 --> 00:14:55,312 So if you're making a decision on the basis of a protected attribute, 271 00:14:55,702 --> 00:14:57,682 it sounds like it's discrimination. 272 00:14:58,072 --> 00:15:01,552 Um, and there are a number of avenues that David could take against the 273 00:15:01,552 --> 00:15:06,862 employer, um, whether it's under state legislation or, uh, the Federal Age 274 00:15:06,862 --> 00:15:11,692 Discrimination Act, or even, um, under the federal court system through the Fair 275 00:15:11,692 --> 00:15:13,852 Work Act as a general protections claim. 276 00:15:13,852 --> 00:15:17,992 So making a decision on the basis of age is highly problematic. 277 00:15:18,424 --> 00:15:21,604 Listening to my fellow panel members, you know, they're talking 278 00:15:21,604 --> 00:15:25,324 about actually working through the individual circumstances. 279 00:15:25,324 --> 00:15:30,544 So I think don't focus on particular attributes, actually look at what 280 00:15:30,544 --> 00:15:34,474 are the key considerations here around, um, first of all, what are 281 00:15:34,474 --> 00:15:38,644 your obligations under workers' compensation laws to assist people 282 00:15:38,644 --> 00:15:42,934 to be able to return to work and make sure you meet all of those obligations. 283 00:15:42,994 --> 00:15:46,294 And then assessing what are the requirements of the role 284 00:15:46,294 --> 00:15:49,804 and can the individual perform those inherent requirements? 285 00:15:49,804 --> 00:15:53,914 And it seems like David was a real success story in that he 286 00:15:53,914 --> 00:15:55,954 was able to perform the role. 287 00:15:56,194 --> 00:15:58,384 Um, I think the other person was Michael. 288 00:15:58,389 --> 00:15:58,469 Yeah. 289 00:15:58,474 --> 00:16:02,374 Um, Michael, um, sounds like he was struggling far more. 290 00:16:02,734 --> 00:16:06,304 So at some point you get to the stage where you say, well, have 291 00:16:06,304 --> 00:16:09,904 we met all our requirements under workers' compensation law? 292 00:16:10,294 --> 00:16:14,884 And if you have and Michael's still not returning to the workplace, then is 293 00:16:14,884 --> 00:16:16,834 that something now we need to manage? 294 00:16:16,834 --> 00:16:19,654 Is it having a bigger impact on the workplace because we've got 295 00:16:19,654 --> 00:16:23,554 a staff member who's not at work and not able to do their role. 296 00:16:23,674 --> 00:16:29,044 And so that then lends itself to other considerations around when Michael might 297 00:16:29,044 --> 00:16:33,244 be able to perform the role and come back to work and do it successfully. 298 00:16:33,244 --> 00:16:37,624 And if it's a long term issue, then you can look at whether or not he will in 299 00:16:37,624 --> 00:16:42,427 the foreseeable future be able to perform the role and if not manage that process. 300 00:16:42,435 --> 00:16:47,044 But even manageing that requires appropriate medical evidence. 301 00:16:47,134 --> 00:16:47,224 Yep. 302 00:16:47,284 --> 00:16:50,974 And looking at each of the aspects of the requirements of the role, 303 00:16:51,124 --> 00:16:54,964 assessing Michael's capacity against that before you would make a decision. 304 00:16:54,964 --> 00:16:55,204 That's right. 305 00:16:55,384 --> 00:16:59,434 And there's obviously a lot of employment law that needs to be followed if you were 306 00:16:59,434 --> 00:17:01,594 to exit Michael from the organisation, 307 00:17:01,624 --> 00:17:05,464 so it's early days, but down the track, you'd want to assess that 308 00:17:05,494 --> 00:17:08,374 with objective medical evidence from say, an OC fears about the 309 00:17:08,374 --> 00:17:09,784 inherent requirements of the job, for 310 00:17:09,784 --> 00:17:10,024 example. 311 00:17:10,024 --> 00:17:10,174 Correct. 312 00:17:10,384 --> 00:17:13,354 And it would need to be separate to how you've managed the workers' 313 00:17:13,354 --> 00:17:17,104 compensation claim because it has a slightly different focus. 314 00:17:17,104 --> 00:17:20,644 It's not about returning to work, it's then about going forward. 315 00:17:20,764 --> 00:17:22,594 Can he perform the inherent requirements? 316 00:17:22,594 --> 00:17:22,864 Absolutely. 317 00:17:22,864 --> 00:17:24,784 Alright, well that's case study one. 318 00:17:24,784 --> 00:17:25,474 Thank you Allison. 319 00:17:25,474 --> 00:17:26,104 Thank you for that. 320 00:17:26,344 --> 00:17:27,184 Uh, that was useful. 321 00:17:27,184 --> 00:17:30,784 Now obviously the key, uh, takeaway if there is one, is don't 322 00:17:30,784 --> 00:17:34,774 predict capacity from the workers' age or even from a diagnosis. 323 00:17:34,774 --> 00:17:37,714 As useful as a diagnosis may be as a label, you've gotta 324 00:17:37,714 --> 00:17:41,014 understand the individual factors influencing recovery and that case 325 00:17:41,014 --> 00:17:42,394 study brings that to the fore. 326 00:17:42,784 --> 00:17:45,394 And as I said, there's lots of, um, information that we 327 00:17:45,394 --> 00:17:47,494 don't know, but that's useful. 328 00:17:47,644 --> 00:17:51,424 And as I said, we will have some time at the end for some questions 329 00:17:51,424 --> 00:17:53,674 'cause we've got some great experts here and I want you to be able 330 00:17:53,674 --> 00:17:55,354 to ask the questions you needed. 331 00:17:55,594 --> 00:17:57,604 Let's go to, uh, case study two. 332 00:17:58,296 --> 00:18:00,096 The worker hasn't changed. 333 00:18:00,096 --> 00:18:01,446 His job has, or sorry, her 334 00:18:01,446 --> 00:18:03,726 job has, this is a scenario. 335 00:18:03,726 --> 00:18:05,316 Susan is 59. 336 00:18:05,586 --> 00:18:08,856 She's worked for the organisation for 22 years and has consistently 337 00:18:08,856 --> 00:18:13,056 been regarded as an excellent employee Following a restructure, 338 00:18:13,236 --> 00:18:15,366 her role changes substantially. 339 00:18:15,666 --> 00:18:17,706 New digital platform is introduced. 340 00:18:17,706 --> 00:18:18,186 There you go. 341 00:18:18,186 --> 00:18:22,716 Change reporting requirements, increase decisions are expected more quickly. 342 00:18:22,986 --> 00:18:24,906 She has multiple communication channels. 343 00:18:24,906 --> 00:18:29,196 I know what that's like as a bit of a boomer, you know, teams Slack email. 344 00:18:29,196 --> 00:18:32,796 I thought it's hard enough for me to manage an inbox operating simultaneously. 345 00:18:32,798 --> 00:18:35,766 And as they're manageing a younger team accustomed to very different 346 00:18:35,766 --> 00:18:39,876 ways of working, Susan starts making occasional errors and takes 347 00:18:39,876 --> 00:18:41,346 longer to learn the new systems. 348 00:18:41,706 --> 00:18:46,926 Her manager says she has become resistant to change and increasingly rigid. 349 00:18:47,286 --> 00:18:49,116 Susan, of course, sees it very differently. 350 00:18:49,116 --> 00:18:53,856 The story she's telling herself is, I've done this job successfully for 22 years. 351 00:18:54,456 --> 00:18:55,626 What's the fuss about? 352 00:18:55,686 --> 00:18:57,246 Suddenly I'm told I'm the problem. 353 00:18:58,326 --> 00:19:00,576 She's increasingly anxious about work. 354 00:19:00,636 --> 00:19:01,956 She's sleeping poorly. 355 00:19:02,586 --> 00:19:06,336 She's feeling her younger colleagues are dismissive of her experience, her 356 00:19:06,336 --> 00:19:11,346 judgement , her expertise, and her manager, of course wonders whether Susan 357 00:19:11,346 --> 00:19:14,316 is simply struggling because of her age. 358 00:19:15,036 --> 00:19:15,666 Okay. 359 00:19:15,696 --> 00:19:20,496 The question then, for the audience, what do you think is most likely happening? 360 00:19:21,006 --> 00:19:25,026 A normal ageing BA performance management issue. 361 00:19:25,026 --> 00:19:27,486 She certainly seems to be struggling with this new change. 362 00:19:27,966 --> 00:19:29,646 C, psychological distress. 363 00:19:29,646 --> 00:19:31,416 There's anxiety there, there's poor sleeping. 364 00:19:31,416 --> 00:19:31,836 Here we go. 365 00:19:31,836 --> 00:19:32,826 The numbers are coming in. 366 00:19:33,366 --> 00:19:34,626 I feel like I'm an election night. 367 00:19:34,896 --> 00:19:37,296 Um, d early cognitive impairment. 368 00:19:38,346 --> 00:19:41,856 E the job has changed beyond Susan's, Susan's current ca capability 369 00:19:41,856 --> 00:19:42,906 and we don't know enough yet. 370 00:19:42,936 --> 00:19:43,086 Okay. 371 00:19:43,086 --> 00:19:43,806 Where are we sitting? 372 00:19:44,496 --> 00:19:47,526 Seems to be the large majority of the job has changed beyond Susan's 373 00:19:47,526 --> 00:19:49,356 current capacity or capability. 374 00:19:49,356 --> 00:19:51,666 It seems to jump out potentially at you. 375 00:19:52,506 --> 00:19:54,636 Numbers are coming in on the, we don't know, and another seems 376 00:19:54,636 --> 00:19:56,256 to be reducing and fluctuating. 377 00:19:56,586 --> 00:19:58,296 Psychological distress is up there. 378 00:19:58,716 --> 00:20:00,216 Uh, performance management issue. 379 00:20:00,276 --> 00:20:02,796 That's interesting that it's as low as that, but I get that 380 00:20:02,796 --> 00:20:05,046 normal ageing, um, et cetera. 381 00:20:05,046 --> 00:20:06,336 So there you go. 382 00:20:06,336 --> 00:20:07,146 That's a good scenario. 383 00:20:07,176 --> 00:20:07,536 Thanks. 384 00:20:07,596 --> 00:20:08,136 Thanks for that. 385 00:20:08,136 --> 00:20:10,176 Let's get the experts involved in this case study. 386 00:20:10,866 --> 00:20:13,596 The psychiatrist in the room, Dr. Gunna p um. 387 00:20:14,744 --> 00:20:18,614 Can people become less psychologically flexible as they age? 388 00:20:19,964 --> 00:20:20,174 Yeah. 389 00:20:20,564 --> 00:20:21,434 Good, good question. 390 00:20:21,434 --> 00:20:24,854 And on the face of it, it looks like a pejorative question, but we, let's, 391 00:20:24,854 --> 00:20:28,514 let's look at it, uh, biologically there is, there is a change. 392 00:20:28,574 --> 00:20:33,464 Human body ages changes, muscles change, tissues change, brain changes. 393 00:20:33,854 --> 00:20:36,014 We know we, we find it easy to accept. 394 00:20:36,044 --> 00:20:39,644 We have muscle, you know, degradation or weakness as we age. 395 00:20:40,064 --> 00:20:42,134 Similarly, brain does do its thing. 396 00:20:42,344 --> 00:20:46,304 One of the things which is notable in, uh, ageing brain, normal, normal ageing, 397 00:20:46,844 --> 00:20:49,934 um, is that set, we call it set shifting. 398 00:20:50,024 --> 00:20:51,974 Set shifting is an executive function. 399 00:20:51,974 --> 00:20:56,384 It involves the prefrontal cortex, so front of the brain, the cortex, 400 00:20:56,624 --> 00:21:00,284 the prefrontal, the part of it, the side, and the, this part of it, 401 00:21:00,374 --> 00:21:02,384 um, is involved in set shifting. 402 00:21:02,564 --> 00:21:06,164 It's, it's where you learn new rules of the game. 403 00:21:06,494 --> 00:21:11,234 Where, where, when you suddenly the rules of the game change or the formula change, 404 00:21:11,564 --> 00:21:13,244 or you have to do things differently. 405 00:21:13,514 --> 00:21:15,944 You just have to stop the, always start the new waste. 406 00:21:15,944 --> 00:21:17,714 That set shifting is an issue. 407 00:21:18,224 --> 00:21:19,814 Uh, and, and you can adapt to it. 408 00:21:19,814 --> 00:21:23,114 It, it's not a permanent, uh, brain's still neuro adaptable. 409 00:21:23,504 --> 00:21:26,984 It is neuroplastic, it's less so, but it is still neuroplastic. 410 00:21:26,984 --> 00:21:30,674 So you could train with appropriate supports and, and all that. 411 00:21:30,734 --> 00:21:33,044 And I think, uh, Sarah will speak more about that. 412 00:21:33,314 --> 00:21:35,054 So that's, yes, that does happen. 413 00:21:35,204 --> 00:21:38,204 Before I bring in, Sarah, I'll just bring in Dr. Huang on this question. 414 00:21:38,714 --> 00:21:41,054 You do a lot of functional capacity assessments. 415 00:21:41,384 --> 00:21:45,434 A job that's often given to an occupational physician saying, Hey, as 416 00:21:45,434 --> 00:21:49,034 Allison foreshadowed earlier, if you've got a situation that's playing out at 417 00:21:49,034 --> 00:21:52,574 the end of it and you're wanting to assess your options as an employer, you 418 00:21:52,574 --> 00:21:54,524 might go down that path, understandably. 419 00:21:54,584 --> 00:21:56,114 And you need it to be based on evidence. 420 00:21:56,114 --> 00:21:57,974 So what are we missing here? 421 00:21:58,034 --> 00:21:59,924 'cause has the job changed? 422 00:21:59,924 --> 00:22:03,794 I mean, are we, can we assess the current capacity of the old job or the new job? 423 00:22:03,824 --> 00:22:04,934 What do we do in this scenario? 424 00:22:04,964 --> 00:22:07,514 'cause it's potentially, it's pretty different job, isn't it? 425 00:22:07,514 --> 00:22:08,144 At some level, 426 00:22:08,174 --> 00:22:14,204 what we've got here is, uh, someone who's asked to do a job 427 00:22:14,294 --> 00:22:16,604 that, um, seems to be different. 428 00:22:16,964 --> 00:22:23,024 This example is, um, obviously to do with cognitive and to a 429 00:22:23,024 --> 00:22:25,154 certain degree, uh, learning. 430 00:22:25,844 --> 00:22:30,164 I can draw a parallel to physical limitations as well. 431 00:22:30,164 --> 00:22:35,174 In cases such as someone working in a warehouse, for example, who's expected 432 00:22:35,174 --> 00:22:39,314 to do certain things, and then a change in process comes and they need 433 00:22:39,314 --> 00:22:45,884 to start double handling things, um, moving apart perhaps two to three 434 00:22:45,884 --> 00:22:48,524 times because of a change of workflow. 435 00:22:48,884 --> 00:22:52,814 And suddenly they get pain in their shoulders, pain in the neck. 436 00:22:53,624 --> 00:23:00,824 So at what stage Is it an injury or at what stage is it simply that 437 00:23:00,824 --> 00:23:06,674 the, uh, required task exceeds what is reasonably expected of someone? 438 00:23:07,214 --> 00:23:09,734 So this is always an important question. 439 00:23:10,154 --> 00:23:14,444 Just because you don't have an injury doesn't mean you don't get pain. 440 00:23:14,444 --> 00:23:16,394 And you can perform at a very high level. 441 00:23:16,604 --> 00:23:19,484 At some stage when we perform at a certain level, we'll get 442 00:23:19,484 --> 00:23:21,014 some difficulties and pains. 443 00:23:21,644 --> 00:23:22,604 Thank you for that doctor. 444 00:23:22,604 --> 00:23:25,754 Now, Dr. Sarah, this is where you come into, we've got someone here 445 00:23:25,754 --> 00:23:29,834 who's struggling with a different cognitive load, a level of flexibility 446 00:23:29,834 --> 00:23:33,974 required to process and learn something quite new in a job that she's been 447 00:23:33,974 --> 00:23:38,264 very comfortable with and has been held in relatively high esteem. 448 00:23:38,264 --> 00:23:41,264 It seems what's going on, uh, what could be going on? 449 00:23:41,354 --> 00:23:45,554 Talk us through it from a ageing and a cognitive, uh, perspective. 450 00:23:45,854 --> 00:23:49,424 If we could go back to that slide with the ageing, that'd be great. 451 00:23:50,144 --> 00:23:53,954 I just wanted to highlight with this slide, not to depress everybody in the 452 00:23:53,954 --> 00:23:57,884 room, but just really to highlight, I guess what does happen with normal ageing. 453 00:23:58,274 --> 00:24:03,164 Um, and so as Shiva had commented on, there are areas of cognition 454 00:24:03,164 --> 00:24:04,634 that unfortunately do decline. 455 00:24:04,754 --> 00:24:05,384 Uh. 456 00:24:06,136 --> 00:24:08,386 Memory goes downhill from about the age of 30. 457 00:24:08,836 --> 00:24:12,406 Um, and really when we hit that, as you can see from the slide, when we hit 458 00:24:12,406 --> 00:24:17,326 that 65, age 65 onwards, then you do get more decline in especially those 459 00:24:17,326 --> 00:24:19,336 areas of memory and processing speed. 460 00:24:19,576 --> 00:24:22,426 And as Shiva was explaining before, what we would call executive 461 00:24:22,426 --> 00:24:25,546 function, so it's referred to as reasoning in this particular slide, 462 00:24:25,966 --> 00:24:28,486 but we do become more inflexible. 463 00:24:28,696 --> 00:24:32,026 Um, and we do have more trouble reasoning in certain areas. 464 00:24:32,356 --> 00:24:35,746 I guess the thing is though, that in a lot of, um, jobs that's not really 465 00:24:35,746 --> 00:24:37,396 necessarily gonna be that noticeable. 466 00:24:37,606 --> 00:24:41,626 It is often when the goalposts move, um, especially when people are being 467 00:24:41,626 --> 00:24:42,976 compared to much younger people. 468 00:24:43,006 --> 00:24:48,046 'cause of course we know processing speed is much better at age 25 than age 65. 469 00:24:48,586 --> 00:24:52,006 Um, so there are those elements, but it is also then a question of course 470 00:24:52,006 --> 00:24:55,666 of whether this is a clinic, a, a, a medically significant problem, which 471 00:24:55,666 --> 00:24:59,776 is where we would come in versus a, a problem of within the workplace. 472 00:25:00,076 --> 00:25:04,306 Um, I will throw back to Shiva about the, um, intergenerational bias 473 00:25:04,366 --> 00:25:05,626 aspect you were talking about before. 474 00:25:05,626 --> 00:25:05,901 Yeah, yeah. 475 00:25:06,376 --> 00:25:10,846 So one thing which struck me in this case also just, just being aware that 476 00:25:10,906 --> 00:25:16,096 normal ageing, healthy ageing, normative ageing is where you have a natural 477 00:25:16,096 --> 00:25:20,956 tendency to, while you acquire a lot of wisdom, having lived life and seen 478 00:25:20,956 --> 00:25:24,436 a lot of things and been through a lot of changes and all that, and there's a 479 00:25:24,436 --> 00:25:28,996 natural force in all of us to give that past that wisdom to the next generation. 480 00:25:29,026 --> 00:25:32,566 You know, we want to nurture the next generation, pass our wisdom knowledge 481 00:25:33,046 --> 00:25:34,306 and it's a very normative thing. 482 00:25:34,396 --> 00:25:38,146 But in this case, for example, there is that block of that this stagnation 483 00:25:38,326 --> 00:25:41,986 that creates a lot of internal anxiety because now it's the other way around. 484 00:25:41,986 --> 00:25:44,746 You are being now asked to learn something. 485 00:25:44,746 --> 00:25:45,976 You are not wise. 486 00:25:46,426 --> 00:25:48,016 This is the wrong way of doing the job. 487 00:25:48,016 --> 00:25:50,026 So that creates the internal anxiety. 488 00:25:50,836 --> 00:25:54,466 And there is that intergenerational bias around, oh, if you are old, 489 00:25:54,466 --> 00:25:59,356 you're probably not digitally fluent, which is a bias, rightly or wrongly. 490 00:25:59,356 --> 00:26:02,236 In this case, we don't know enough details of how much this person 491 00:26:02,236 --> 00:26:07,306 knew or used technology beforehand, but this, this awareness that this 492 00:26:07,306 --> 00:26:10,726 natural flow, wisdom and knowledge is not happening, it's kind of the 493 00:26:10,726 --> 00:26:12,316 other way around, creates the tension. 494 00:26:12,826 --> 00:26:16,216 Anxiety is, is an important sort of point also. 495 00:26:16,276 --> 00:26:21,016 Um, once the anxiety sets in, so now you're going to work every day, you've 496 00:26:21,016 --> 00:26:24,916 already been flagged with concerns and now you have performance anxiety. 497 00:26:25,186 --> 00:26:29,566 So you can add another 20, 30% level of cognitive problems just from that anxiety. 498 00:26:30,296 --> 00:26:33,866 So that, that's probably is happening in this case as well. 499 00:26:34,106 --> 00:26:35,456 Yeah, yeah, for sure. 500 00:26:35,636 --> 00:26:36,596 Anything to add? 501 00:26:36,686 --> 00:26:40,556 Yeah, I just wanted to say, um, I think the thing to remember is that a lot 502 00:26:40,556 --> 00:26:44,786 of, um, older people and, and people of all different level, 'cause sometimes 503 00:26:44,996 --> 00:26:48,116 jobs change and it's beyond their own intellectual capabilities as well, or, 504 00:26:48,116 --> 00:26:49,706 or it's gonna be a challenge for them. 505 00:26:49,946 --> 00:26:53,756 So they might just need a bit more time, a bit more support, um, a bit 506 00:26:53,756 --> 00:26:57,086 more, you know, individual training and then that might be enough for them. 507 00:26:57,416 --> 00:27:01,736 Um, but if they're not able to access that or they feel that they're going 508 00:27:01,736 --> 00:27:04,316 to be singled out, if they access that, then that can be where it 509 00:27:04,316 --> 00:27:05,996 can become quite tricky as well. 510 00:27:05,996 --> 00:27:09,896 So I think it's just really important to consider, you know, is this maybe 511 00:27:09,896 --> 00:27:13,946 beyond a person's capabilities for whatever reason, whether it's ageing or 512 00:27:14,036 --> 00:27:18,896 another reason, um, or can they learn with some extra strategies and supports? 513 00:27:18,896 --> 00:27:21,656 And that's certainly something that I often get asked in some 514 00:27:21,656 --> 00:27:22,646 of the assessments that I do. 515 00:27:23,306 --> 00:27:24,926 Yeah, it goes to the heart of it, doesn't it? 516 00:27:24,956 --> 00:27:27,656 Um, well now we'll bring in Allison. 517 00:27:27,686 --> 00:27:32,336 Um, I'm Susan's manager, Allison, I've, I just think she can't get with the 518 00:27:32,336 --> 00:27:34,616 programme, can't work out this new system. 519 00:27:35,336 --> 00:27:36,536 So I'm gonna take her aside. 520 00:27:36,536 --> 00:27:39,326 I'm gonna say, Susan, you've had a fantastic career. 521 00:27:39,866 --> 00:27:43,286 Um, have you thought about whether it's time to retire now? 522 00:27:43,526 --> 00:27:46,226 Um, is that problematic if I approach her on that basis? 523 00:27:46,226 --> 00:27:46,706 Alison. 524 00:27:47,576 --> 00:27:49,226 I think it is problematic. 525 00:27:49,286 --> 00:27:53,486 Um, I don't think an employer should ever be the first to 526 00:27:53,486 --> 00:27:55,796 raise a retirement question. 527 00:27:55,796 --> 00:28:00,056 I think that should be the employee who, um, brings that into the equation. 528 00:28:00,536 --> 00:28:03,596 I think with this matter, there's a couple of things that play from 529 00:28:03,596 --> 00:28:07,766 an employer perspective and a risk, um, exposure perspective. 530 00:28:07,826 --> 00:28:11,426 And that is, first of all, has the role actually changed so 531 00:28:11,426 --> 00:28:13,106 much that it's a different role. 532 00:28:13,226 --> 00:28:17,366 And if it's a different role, it's actually probably not satisfactory to 533 00:28:17,366 --> 00:28:20,186 expect that Suzanne can can do the role. 534 00:28:20,516 --> 00:28:26,156 So, um, perhaps it needed to be that the employer, um, before implementing 535 00:28:26,156 --> 00:28:30,386 the new digital platform did an assessment as to whether or not it is a 536 00:28:30,386 --> 00:28:32,336 restructure and it's a different role. 537 00:28:32,636 --> 00:28:36,536 And if that was the case, there are requirements under industrial laws to 538 00:28:36,536 --> 00:28:42,536 go through consultation with impacted staff and also now more than ever under 539 00:28:42,536 --> 00:28:47,606 work health and safety law to consider the psychosocial hazards and risks that 540 00:28:47,606 --> 00:28:50,246 come with certain changes in workplaces. 541 00:28:50,246 --> 00:28:55,886 So I think it may have been the case that consultation was needed if it's 542 00:28:56,126 --> 00:28:58,406 that it's not that substantial a change. 543 00:28:58,406 --> 00:29:02,216 It's still Susan's role, but she's now struggling with it. 544 00:29:02,726 --> 00:29:07,556 Um, then it comes down to as some of the things, um, that have been mentioned 545 00:29:07,556 --> 00:29:10,166 around appropriate support and training. 546 00:29:10,496 --> 00:29:13,646 Um, and employers do have obligations to look after the 547 00:29:13,646 --> 00:29:15,626 psychosocial health of their staff. 548 00:29:15,656 --> 00:29:21,326 And that means training staff when you're in introducing, you know, new ways of 549 00:29:21,326 --> 00:29:23,996 doing work so that they feel supported. 550 00:29:24,326 --> 00:29:29,156 If it gets to the point where Susan is just not performing in the role. 551 00:29:29,186 --> 00:29:32,846 So it, it's the employer's done everything they can to try and support 552 00:29:32,846 --> 00:29:37,766 her, but she's not performing, then it becomes a performance management issue. 553 00:29:37,766 --> 00:29:42,566 And that again, needs to be appropriately managed with, um, proper procedural 554 00:29:42,566 --> 00:29:47,576 fairness, um, and, you know, proper direction and assistance to Susan. 555 00:29:48,056 --> 00:29:48,236 Yeah. 556 00:29:48,236 --> 00:29:48,986 Thank you for that. 557 00:29:48,986 --> 00:29:54,146 Um, I think that's a really useful, uh, case study that highlights the 558 00:29:54,146 --> 00:29:59,606 reality around ageing, the cognitive issues that play a very different role. 559 00:29:59,636 --> 00:30:00,926 What does that mean legally? 560 00:30:01,136 --> 00:30:04,196 What does that mean from the perspective of fitness for work and capacity? 561 00:30:04,256 --> 00:30:08,456 And I get some comfort from someone who's approaching, uh, five years away 562 00:30:08,456 --> 00:30:12,626 from 60 that although my processing speed might decline, my strategy and 563 00:30:12,626 --> 00:30:16,586 judgement skills can still be at a four, which I'm gonna dine out on in 564 00:30:16,586 --> 00:30:18,596 for the next 15 years as a mediator. 565 00:30:18,776 --> 00:30:21,236 So, uh, that's, there's some good news there. 566 00:30:21,716 --> 00:30:24,956 Alright, let's go on to, um, case study three. 567 00:30:25,226 --> 00:30:27,116 Is this normal ageing 568 00:30:27,746 --> 00:30:29,186 or something else? 569 00:30:29,880 --> 00:30:32,130 Now this is a scenario involving Robert. 570 00:30:32,790 --> 00:30:34,890 He's, uh, 64. 571 00:30:35,340 --> 00:30:38,550 He's a highly regarded senior manager who has been with his 572 00:30:38,550 --> 00:30:40,320 organisation for 30 years. 573 00:30:40,470 --> 00:30:43,530 Bit of a lifer over the past 12 months. 574 00:30:43,530 --> 00:30:45,450 His team has noticed small changes. 575 00:30:45,900 --> 00:30:47,910 He occasionally forgets discussions. 576 00:30:48,180 --> 00:30:50,310 He asked for information to be repeated. 577 00:30:50,640 --> 00:30:54,930 He takes longer to make decisions and increasingly relies on established 578 00:30:54,990 --> 00:30:58,320 processes rather than adapting when the circumstances change. 579 00:30:58,980 --> 00:31:03,330 His executive noticed that Robert has become more irritable when challenged 580 00:31:03,660 --> 00:31:05,550 behaviour that seemed out of character. 581 00:31:06,570 --> 00:31:07,470 There's no catastrophic 582 00:31:07,470 --> 00:31:08,610 mistakes I might add. 583 00:31:09,360 --> 00:31:10,645 There's no single incident. 584 00:31:11,345 --> 00:31:14,760 And of course Robert believes that nothing's really wrong. 585 00:31:14,760 --> 00:31:16,800 Hell, I'm 64, everyone forgets things. 586 00:31:16,800 --> 00:31:17,940 I'm not 24 anymore. 587 00:31:19,230 --> 00:31:23,610 Uh, he's also sleeping poorly and he's had a cardiovascular episode 588 00:31:23,610 --> 00:31:28,230 six months earlier from which he was medically, he has medically recovered 589 00:31:29,280 --> 00:31:30,810 in the sense that he's back at work. 590 00:31:30,810 --> 00:31:33,030 There might be other issues at play, but anyway, he's back. 591 00:31:33,480 --> 00:31:37,920 His manager doesn't know whether they are witnessing normal ageing 592 00:31:38,250 --> 00:31:43,350 stress, poor sleep, potentially performance problem rearing its 593 00:31:43,350 --> 00:31:46,080 head or something more significant. 594 00:31:46,740 --> 00:31:51,480 Now, the question posed of you as you are Robert's manager, what would you do next? 595 00:31:52,200 --> 00:31:52,680 A, nothing. 596 00:31:52,680 --> 00:31:55,380 B, commence performance management. 597 00:31:55,380 --> 00:31:57,360 C. Suggest C is gp. 598 00:31:58,260 --> 00:32:02,520 D. Seek as fitness for work capacity assessment, discuss retirement. 599 00:32:02,550 --> 00:32:05,520 E. Well, thanks Allison for covering that off last time. 600 00:32:05,940 --> 00:32:10,590 And F I'm not sure, I'm not surprised too much by this. 601 00:32:10,590 --> 00:32:11,040 Um. 602 00:32:12,536 --> 00:32:14,876 You know, he's been with you for 30 years and there's something 603 00:32:14,876 --> 00:32:15,866 that that's a bit amiss. 604 00:32:15,866 --> 00:32:17,816 So you, you'd wanna check if he's okay. 605 00:32:17,816 --> 00:32:18,116 Huh? 606 00:32:18,476 --> 00:32:21,926 So I can understand why a lot of people are landing on, see his gp. 607 00:32:22,586 --> 00:32:25,496 Um, other people say there's nothing much of a problem here. 608 00:32:25,496 --> 00:32:27,296 You know, he's 64, give him some slack. 609 00:32:27,296 --> 00:32:32,101 I'll assume there's, there's a 14% at the moment saying, seek a 610 00:32:32,141 --> 00:32:33,866 fitness for work capacity assessment. 611 00:32:34,526 --> 00:32:35,846 Um, I don't know. 612 00:32:35,846 --> 00:32:38,216 We'll have to pick Allison's brain and others as whether that's 613 00:32:38,216 --> 00:32:40,586 potentially too early for that or whether you need to do some 614 00:32:40,586 --> 00:32:41,426 things first. 615 00:32:41,816 --> 00:32:44,396 But I understand that perspective as well. 616 00:32:44,546 --> 00:32:45,896 Let's get into this case study. 617 00:32:45,896 --> 00:32:48,686 It's about, I guess, ageing more generally, but someone who's 618 00:32:48,896 --> 00:32:50,846 very well regarded, 30 years. 619 00:32:51,236 --> 00:32:56,336 Um, but irritability jumps out at me some anxiety, poor sleep. 620 00:32:56,996 --> 00:32:59,816 It's an interesting health issue, a cardiovascular episode. 621 00:32:59,816 --> 00:33:00,506 What does that mean? 622 00:33:00,776 --> 00:33:03,026 What, what does that place in from a health perspective? 623 00:33:03,626 --> 00:33:07,871 I think, uh, Dr. Lucas, you've already introduced the idea of what actually 624 00:33:07,871 --> 00:33:10,016 happens to cognition as we age. 625 00:33:10,076 --> 00:33:14,126 What are you picking up in this case study in terms of dealing with Robert? 626 00:33:14,636 --> 00:33:15,176 Yeah. 627 00:33:15,386 --> 00:33:19,556 Um, well I guess there are, um, firstly if, and again, coming at it from a medical 628 00:33:19,556 --> 00:33:24,266 viewpoint rather than a legal viewpoint, I would, um, often want to have seen 629 00:33:24,266 --> 00:33:27,746 that they've, you know, if there are concerns that it might be a medical issue. 630 00:33:28,016 --> 00:33:29,846 Um, and given he is had the cardiovascular. 631 00:33:30,796 --> 00:33:35,026 Um, condition that raises the possibility of, um, vascular or 632 00:33:35,026 --> 00:33:38,536 cerebrovascular in particular, which is small brain changes that can occur. 633 00:33:39,076 --> 00:33:42,766 It would be helpful if he's seen his GP and had any reversible 634 00:33:42,766 --> 00:33:46,786 causes of cognitive difficulty ruled out, and that would include things 635 00:33:46,786 --> 00:33:52,936 like, um, depression, um, sometimes certain, um, vitamin deficiencies. 636 00:33:53,236 --> 00:33:54,616 There can be quite a few different causes. 637 00:33:54,616 --> 00:33:58,936 Obviously the other element for women can be menopause, so that can have 638 00:33:58,936 --> 00:34:02,296 an impact on memory, sleep, brain fog, all those sorts of symptoms 639 00:34:02,296 --> 00:34:05,566 as well, which is certainly being recognised a bit more these days. 640 00:34:06,196 --> 00:34:10,876 Um, often I'm down the track so people come to me when there's really 641 00:34:10,936 --> 00:34:14,056 continuing concern and it might be that things have been tried in the 642 00:34:14,056 --> 00:34:18,046 workplace and they haven't worked, uh, and there's still cognitive concerns. 643 00:34:18,046 --> 00:34:22,756 So that's when they'll come to me for the question of, is this a something organic? 644 00:34:22,756 --> 00:34:26,956 Is this some sort of neurodegenerative condition or, uh, other medical, other 645 00:34:26,956 --> 00:34:31,126 medical condition, or is this part of normal ageing normal processes? 646 00:34:31,126 --> 00:34:34,216 In which case then it would go down the performance management side. 647 00:34:34,456 --> 00:34:39,376 Um, if the issues are continuing, I guess within that age bracket, especially that 648 00:34:39,376 --> 00:34:46,006 again, that sort of 65 ish to 69 age bracket, um, about 1% of people will be 649 00:34:46,006 --> 00:34:48,286 diagnosed with dementia during that time. 650 00:34:48,586 --> 00:34:52,096 Um, unfortunately earlier onset dementias have increased, 651 00:34:52,156 --> 00:34:54,226 um, in the last few decades. 652 00:34:54,796 --> 00:34:57,526 It could also be, you know, silent stroke effects. 653 00:34:57,526 --> 00:34:59,746 Again, again, especially in someone with cardiovascular. 654 00:34:59,746 --> 00:35:02,596 So there are medical aspects that do need to be explored and ruled out. 655 00:35:03,166 --> 00:35:07,096 Um, what MyFitness for duty assessments would really help with is determining is 656 00:35:07,096 --> 00:35:11,506 there an objective cognitive impairment or a cognitive problem and what does that 657 00:35:11,506 --> 00:35:13,576 look like and what might it indicate? 658 00:35:13,936 --> 00:35:17,536 Obviously, depending on how much medical information I have, sometimes I have none. 659 00:35:18,106 --> 00:35:19,396 Sometimes I have quite a lot. 660 00:35:19,636 --> 00:35:23,026 That would also help determine what might be going on and then I'd be making 661 00:35:23,026 --> 00:35:28,066 recommendations around what is going to help clarify that particular situation. 662 00:35:28,606 --> 00:35:32,386 Um, but I guess the, the thing is that there are other various conditions 663 00:35:32,386 --> 00:35:34,996 that need to be ruled out before we jump to, you know, dementia. 664 00:35:35,386 --> 00:35:39,676 Um, but that is unfortunately a consideration that we do see sometimes. 665 00:35:40,066 --> 00:35:40,876 Thank you for that. 666 00:35:40,876 --> 00:35:41,476 Dr. Sarah. 667 00:35:41,476 --> 00:35:45,496 Um, Dr. Gunna Poo, if I can bring you in here, irritability, some 668 00:35:45,496 --> 00:35:49,366 personality changes, anxiety, poor sleep. 669 00:35:50,776 --> 00:35:53,056 What's, uh, jumping out at you in this case study? 670 00:35:53,506 --> 00:35:58,576 It's a case where I think you rightly said at the, at the top, uh, someone's 671 00:35:58,576 --> 00:36:00,256 been doing so well, something's different. 672 00:36:00,256 --> 00:36:01,246 People are picking on it. 673 00:36:01,816 --> 00:36:06,256 So something's changed and I think the majority voted for a, a medical 674 00:36:06,256 --> 00:36:07,786 screening and go and see your gp. 675 00:36:07,786 --> 00:36:09,106 I think that's a good call. 676 00:36:09,406 --> 00:36:11,926 In terms of the number of reversible things, I mean, it could be 677 00:36:11,926 --> 00:36:16,006 thyroid issues, it could be, could be alcoholism, we don't know. 678 00:36:16,006 --> 00:36:20,386 Silent, you know, closet drinking sometimes can be missed at work. 679 00:36:20,416 --> 00:36:22,036 You know, it can can be the case. 680 00:36:22,306 --> 00:36:23,566 These are all reversible. 681 00:36:23,566 --> 00:36:26,596 So there are reversible causes like, um, alcoholism, 682 00:36:26,596 --> 00:36:28,636 nutritional vitamin B deficiency. 683 00:36:28,696 --> 00:36:32,026 Sometimes you see very low B12, especially if they change their 684 00:36:32,026 --> 00:36:33,856 diet, et cetera, B12, B one. 685 00:36:34,156 --> 00:36:38,086 And that can cause surprisingly, uh, problematic cognitive. 686 00:36:38,266 --> 00:36:41,926 It's so surprising to see that just as a thymine levels can be low and 687 00:36:41,926 --> 00:36:43,456 you can just change your cognitions. 688 00:36:44,386 --> 00:36:45,736 So all those needs to be ruled out. 689 00:36:45,766 --> 00:36:46,696 That's striking out. 690 00:36:46,696 --> 00:36:48,826 So I would definitely get a GP involved. 691 00:36:49,096 --> 00:36:49,966 Get all the screens. 692 00:36:50,356 --> 00:36:54,406 We know after a cardiovascular episode, within the first six weeks, 693 00:36:54,406 --> 00:36:57,736 there are higher rates of depression anxiety, and within the first six to 694 00:36:57,736 --> 00:37:02,836 12 months, there's two to three times likely compared to a normal person who 695 00:37:02,836 --> 00:37:04,396 doesn't have a cardiovascular episode. 696 00:37:04,756 --> 00:37:08,656 Chances of anxiety or depression, particularly depression, it's 697 00:37:08,656 --> 00:37:13,426 multifactorial depression from combination of being sick, losing functionality, 698 00:37:13,456 --> 00:37:16,996 and coming close to death and on all those sort of factors play into that. 699 00:37:17,356 --> 00:37:21,196 So that may be a thing to be addressed by the GP at the onset to see how 700 00:37:21,226 --> 00:37:22,846 much anxiety lies around that. 701 00:37:23,056 --> 00:37:24,796 How bad was the cardiovascular episode? 702 00:37:24,796 --> 00:37:28,156 Was it, was it really a near miss sort of a situation? 703 00:37:28,156 --> 00:37:30,946 Is that the worrying the person and is losing sleep about it? 704 00:37:31,276 --> 00:37:33,916 I've seen few cases where people simply can't sleep because they're 705 00:37:33,916 --> 00:37:37,066 worried about the chest pain coming and they imagine they have chest 706 00:37:37,066 --> 00:37:39,316 pain at night and something will go wrong when they're sleeping. 707 00:37:39,796 --> 00:37:41,506 So that's not an uncommon scenario. 708 00:37:41,776 --> 00:37:46,486 The other pointer I wanted to bring out around early, I mean dementia, we need to 709 00:37:46,486 --> 00:37:49,246 know generally is a progressive condition. 710 00:37:49,246 --> 00:37:50,206 So I'll underline the word. 711 00:37:50,236 --> 00:37:53,356 It's progressive, so it is going to progress, it's going 712 00:37:53,356 --> 00:37:55,276 to keep getting worse, right? 713 00:37:55,636 --> 00:37:57,106 That's the first thing about dementia. 714 00:37:57,106 --> 00:38:02,236 The second thing about dementia is it'll be there in all circumstances, home. 715 00:38:03,254 --> 00:38:06,734 Outside home work when they're on recreational, when 716 00:38:06,734 --> 00:38:08,384 they're on holiday travelling. 717 00:38:08,654 --> 00:38:12,584 So if it's dementia like picture and it's not work related stress, 718 00:38:12,584 --> 00:38:13,814 that's one way of looking at it. 719 00:38:14,084 --> 00:38:16,364 Whether it's global, whether it's progressive. 720 00:38:17,114 --> 00:38:21,194 The other point with Sarah raised about early dementia, there are, 721 00:38:21,224 --> 00:38:24,194 we are getting better at picking up dementia earlier and earlier. 722 00:38:25,004 --> 00:38:29,144 One of the ways to pick up dementia early is what we call a soft science. 723 00:38:29,654 --> 00:38:32,714 Uh, behavioural changes, uh, early behavioural changes. 724 00:38:32,714 --> 00:38:37,634 So one of the things which is striking and probably 30 to 40% of people, if 725 00:38:37,634 --> 00:38:41,504 you really look closely once they're diagnosed dementia and you go back in time 726 00:38:41,504 --> 00:38:46,004 and look at it, one of the things you'll see and commonly up to 30% is apathy. 727 00:38:46,394 --> 00:38:48,674 Apathy is like, I don't care. 728 00:38:48,974 --> 00:38:50,204 Don't care what happens. 729 00:38:50,444 --> 00:38:52,604 Dunno not that interested. 730 00:38:52,904 --> 00:38:53,804 Do you want to do this? 731 00:38:53,804 --> 00:38:55,034 Uh, it's okay. 732 00:38:55,214 --> 00:38:56,324 It's not depression. 733 00:38:56,324 --> 00:38:59,594 You won't see it as someone withdrawn and crying and sad. 734 00:38:59,834 --> 00:39:03,584 You see that as a case of me, kind of a feeling about what 735 00:39:03,584 --> 00:39:06,194 they used to be passionate about or what they did regularly. 736 00:39:06,494 --> 00:39:08,744 So you see apathy as a common presentation. 737 00:39:09,404 --> 00:39:12,044 Uh, so we are getting good at that sort of thing so that we'll keep 738 00:39:12,044 --> 00:39:13,904 that in mind in this case as well. 739 00:39:13,964 --> 00:39:17,444 Other common thing, the second common thing is depression, anxiety, which 740 00:39:17,444 --> 00:39:22,544 might be anxiety, is already in this case, uh, irritability can be in 20% 741 00:39:22,544 --> 00:39:27,314 of people, uh, getting, losing, cool, frustrated than they've never been. 742 00:39:27,344 --> 00:39:29,174 I mean that can be part of depression as well. 743 00:39:29,174 --> 00:39:34,394 Irritability, uh, and sleep changes are also, can be an early change of dementia. 744 00:39:34,394 --> 00:39:38,114 Then smell change in inability to smell like they used to. 745 00:39:38,474 --> 00:39:41,894 Losing that, uh, visual accuracy, like the perception of some 746 00:39:41,894 --> 00:39:43,784 other visual depth or clarity. 747 00:39:43,784 --> 00:39:45,224 This can be some early signs. 748 00:39:45,614 --> 00:39:49,244 We, in psychiatry, always, when we have cases like this, we always think 749 00:39:49,244 --> 00:39:50,864 of a concept called pseudo dementia. 750 00:39:50,864 --> 00:39:54,404 So it looks like dementia, but it's not dementia. 751 00:39:54,404 --> 00:39:55,394 We have to rule out. 752 00:39:55,394 --> 00:39:57,284 The assumption is it's pseudo dementia. 753 00:39:57,284 --> 00:39:58,994 We never jump to that diagnosis. 754 00:39:59,354 --> 00:40:01,544 We always go, this might be a false dementia. 755 00:40:01,544 --> 00:40:03,734 It looks like dementia, but it's not dementia. 756 00:40:03,734 --> 00:40:05,414 Let's look at all the reversible. 757 00:40:05,714 --> 00:40:07,304 Let's look at all the early changes. 758 00:40:07,304 --> 00:40:11,234 Let's look at any psychiatric conditions which may be existing. 759 00:40:11,264 --> 00:40:12,134 Is it nutritional? 760 00:40:12,134 --> 00:40:14,054 Is it hormonal, cardiovascular? 761 00:40:14,054 --> 00:40:14,864 Is there a stroke? 762 00:40:14,864 --> 00:40:16,514 Is that just from the cardiovascular? 763 00:40:16,514 --> 00:40:20,414 Is it fear of death and dying and seeing death close and, and 764 00:40:20,414 --> 00:40:22,244 how bad it was, the recovery. 765 00:40:22,364 --> 00:40:26,204 So those would be the issues which will, I would like to get a good grasp on that. 766 00:40:26,414 --> 00:40:26,624 Yeah, 767 00:40:26,684 --> 00:40:28,784 so I think medical screening is a good idea to 768 00:40:28,784 --> 00:40:28,994 start. 769 00:40:28,994 --> 00:40:29,054 Yeah. 770 00:40:29,054 --> 00:40:29,984 Thank you for that, Shiva. 771 00:40:30,254 --> 00:40:32,744 'cause obviously Robert believes he can do his job. 772 00:40:33,826 --> 00:40:38,296 But his employer isn't so sure, and maybe it's too early to know, but who is right? 773 00:40:38,836 --> 00:40:41,896 Is this the sort of work you would do in due course doing 774 00:40:41,896 --> 00:40:43,546 a, a work capacity assessment? 775 00:40:43,966 --> 00:40:48,886 So cases like this, um, in, in this case we've got a few elements. 776 00:40:48,886 --> 00:40:55,846 We've got, um, psychological, um, cognitive behavioural, and the concern 777 00:40:55,846 --> 00:40:58,786 is being raised in the work environment. 778 00:40:59,476 --> 00:41:02,896 Usually a case like this would be sent for assessment by a 779 00:41:02,896 --> 00:41:05,176 psychiatrist or neuropsychologist. 780 00:41:05,176 --> 00:41:05,236 Yeah. 781 00:41:05,326 --> 00:41:07,126 Due to the nature of the symptoms. 782 00:41:07,246 --> 00:41:14,656 However, um, as pointed out, um, by Sarah and Shiva, um, there are medical 783 00:41:14,656 --> 00:41:20,986 courses, so my involvement in such cases may be, um, as an extra assessor 784 00:41:20,986 --> 00:41:26,746 to look at medical courses working carefully together to determine whether 785 00:41:26,746 --> 00:41:28,876 there are medical courses for this. 786 00:41:30,002 --> 00:41:35,102 Um, when I see a case like this, I would also be mindful of what's 787 00:41:35,582 --> 00:41:37,442 happening in the background at work. 788 00:41:37,952 --> 00:41:41,762 This is a referral from a manager who has raised his concerns. 789 00:41:42,482 --> 00:41:45,632 Um, but does he really have such concerns at home? 790 00:41:46,142 --> 00:41:48,092 Is there anything happening at work? 791 00:41:48,452 --> 00:41:53,072 Could he be irritable because of certain things that are changing at work? 792 00:41:53,342 --> 00:41:54,812 Uh, other people irritable? 793 00:41:55,142 --> 00:41:57,902 It could be a whole workforce that have become irritable, 794 00:41:58,292 --> 00:42:00,302 um, due to certain things. 795 00:42:00,662 --> 00:42:02,522 Um, workplace conflict. 796 00:42:02,882 --> 00:42:06,962 So there are so many different things to explore, but uh, we have 797 00:42:06,962 --> 00:42:11,852 to take into consideration the input of information from all sources. 798 00:42:11,852 --> 00:42:12,392 Absolutely. 799 00:42:12,692 --> 00:42:12,842 Yeah. 800 00:42:12,842 --> 00:42:13,712 Thanks for that doctor. 801 00:42:13,712 --> 00:42:17,192 And you're right, it probably falls more squarely in the domain, this 802 00:42:17,192 --> 00:42:21,062 case in terms of expertise of a neuropsychologist and a psychiatrist. 803 00:42:21,062 --> 00:42:25,382 But we're bringing Allison now for the legal minefield here because obviously 804 00:42:25,382 --> 00:42:28,532 Allison has explained that yeah, it's 64. 805 00:42:28,532 --> 00:42:31,682 We've gotta be careful around age discrimination, but there's also 806 00:42:31,682 --> 00:42:34,232 some privacy issues at play here, aren't they, in terms of he might 807 00:42:34,232 --> 00:42:39,302 wanna protect, um, his own health concerns around his cardiac episode. 808 00:42:39,632 --> 00:42:42,722 So what should the employer do here in a case like this? 809 00:42:42,722 --> 00:42:43,142 Allison? 810 00:42:44,042 --> 00:42:47,492 Yeah, it is a sensitive issue, particularly if Robert's sort 811 00:42:47,492 --> 00:42:52,322 of not receptive to hearing that maybe his behaviour is changing. 812 00:42:52,322 --> 00:42:55,772 And I think an employer has to address that and if they've got 813 00:42:55,802 --> 00:43:00,182 safety and health concerns, they've got obligations under work health and 814 00:43:00,182 --> 00:43:02,312 safety law to address it with Robert. 815 00:43:02,612 --> 00:43:06,722 But I think doing it in a really sensitive way, making sure that any 816 00:43:06,722 --> 00:43:11,522 of his health information is kept confidential, um, and only people 817 00:43:11,522 --> 00:43:15,842 within the organisation who need to have access to it do have access to it. 818 00:43:16,232 --> 00:43:20,642 Making sure that they have Robert's consent, um, in terms 819 00:43:20,642 --> 00:43:24,032 of getting information from his treating general practitioner. 820 00:43:24,422 --> 00:43:30,032 Um, and also just, yeah, I think really having a conversation with him, if it 821 00:43:30,032 --> 00:43:34,712 gets to the point where they've got real concerns about his health and he's not 822 00:43:34,712 --> 00:43:39,752 receptive to addressing it, well then you move more into, well, it's a lawful 823 00:43:39,752 --> 00:43:43,862 and reasonable direction now that you go and see your general practitioner, 824 00:43:44,192 --> 00:43:47,732 um, and you're required to make an appointment and you go through all of 825 00:43:47,732 --> 00:43:51,392 that process, but you know, you wanna manage it in a very sensitive way. 826 00:43:51,392 --> 00:43:57,182 And Robert's been there for 30 years, so, um, that in itself I think requires a 827 00:43:57,182 --> 00:43:59,642 certain amount of respect towards Robert. 828 00:43:59,877 --> 00:44:00,197 Absolutely. 829 00:44:00,197 --> 00:44:03,542 But if there are real health and safety concerns, they have to be addressed. 830 00:44:03,692 --> 00:44:04,382 Thank you, Allison. 831 00:44:04,622 --> 00:44:06,122 Alright, well those are the case studies. 832 00:44:06,122 --> 00:44:08,132 Thank you for your participation in them. 833 00:44:08,252 --> 00:44:12,002 Well, it's not every day that you'll have a neuropsychologist, an 834 00:44:12,002 --> 00:44:15,062 occupational physician, a lawyer, and a psychiatrist together. 835 00:44:15,062 --> 00:44:17,822 Have we got any questions from the floor either pertaining 836 00:44:17,822 --> 00:44:19,712 to these case studies or to 837 00:44:20,102 --> 00:44:22,682 other questions relevant to their expertise? 838 00:44:23,288 --> 00:44:26,798 How much does menopause impact a woman's cognition and how can 839 00:44:26,798 --> 00:44:30,158 employers support this stage of life for their female employees? 840 00:44:30,158 --> 00:44:31,118 That's a great question. 841 00:44:31,358 --> 00:44:36,608 Perhaps it's more in the domain of, uh, you, um, Dr. Sarah and you, Dr. Shiva. 842 00:44:37,118 --> 00:44:39,428 Look, it varies a lot from, um, between women. 843 00:44:39,428 --> 00:44:41,408 Some are not really affected much at all. 844 00:44:41,558 --> 00:44:44,108 Others, um, are maybe affected more. 845 00:44:44,408 --> 00:44:47,648 Again, there are studies which have shown, especially as the oestrogen 846 00:44:47,648 --> 00:44:52,268 levels really change, that you can detect, um, memory decline. 847 00:44:52,628 --> 00:44:54,608 It is not significant. 848 00:44:54,608 --> 00:44:57,308 Well, it is significant at an individual level for some people, 849 00:44:57,308 --> 00:45:01,718 but overall in terms of um, you know, group studies, it's not that 850 00:45:01,718 --> 00:45:03,578 significant, but it is noticeable. 851 00:45:03,578 --> 00:45:08,348 And when you add it to the sleep issues and the, um, hot flushes, which can be 852 00:45:08,348 --> 00:45:12,938 very distracting and all the other factors that can come into play, it can really 853 00:45:12,938 --> 00:45:15,458 sig uh, really impact on some women. 854 00:45:15,878 --> 00:45:19,388 Um, in terms of employers supporting, um, at that stage in life. 855 00:45:19,388 --> 00:45:21,938 I think that is a bit trickier and probably a bit more of your 856 00:45:21,938 --> 00:45:23,078 question for you, I would say. 857 00:45:23,318 --> 00:45:24,728 Yeah, it's a very good question. 858 00:45:24,818 --> 00:45:29,378 Yeah, and again, I think it's quite a personal issue, so it needs to 859 00:45:29,378 --> 00:45:31,958 be dealt with in a sensitive way. 860 00:45:32,018 --> 00:45:37,088 Um, again, it might be if, if an employer's noticing a real difference in 861 00:45:37,088 --> 00:45:41,288 how, um, a woman's presenting at work, then perhaps their manager just talks to 862 00:45:41,288 --> 00:45:43,148 them and says, is there anything going on? 863 00:45:43,238 --> 00:45:44,498 How can we support? 864 00:45:44,858 --> 00:45:49,538 And then I think it's up to the individual to raise, um, those issues. 865 00:45:49,838 --> 00:45:54,488 Um, but if they do, then I think an employer has obligations to 866 00:45:54,488 --> 00:45:57,908 make reasonable accommodations, um, if somebody's dealing 867 00:45:57,908 --> 00:45:59,048 with some health issues. 868 00:45:59,048 --> 00:46:04,628 And so it might be talking about flexible work arrangements, um, changing their 869 00:46:04,628 --> 00:46:06,578 workload if that's what they need. 870 00:46:06,578 --> 00:46:10,508 But it's a consultation process, I think, and really making sure 871 00:46:10,898 --> 00:46:12,318 the individual's engaged in that. 872 00:46:12,788 --> 00:46:13,928 Yeah, it's a very good question. 873 00:46:13,928 --> 00:46:14,978 Dr. Shi, have you got anything to 874 00:46:14,978 --> 00:46:15,188 add on that? 875 00:46:15,188 --> 00:46:19,118 Yeah, I was, uh, just going to add subjectively for the person experiencing 876 00:46:19,118 --> 00:46:21,398 it, uh, it might feel like a brain fog. 877 00:46:21,428 --> 00:46:25,868 It may not feel like intense memory loss, but it's a sense of brain fog. 878 00:46:25,898 --> 00:46:27,878 Things are not as clear as before. 879 00:46:28,358 --> 00:46:32,198 You have to look at things, few more extra times to kind of retain it. 880 00:46:32,678 --> 00:46:34,688 Uh, that may be the subjective experience. 881 00:46:34,718 --> 00:46:39,368 Um, but it does matter if you had an really high cognitive demand task. 882 00:46:40,056 --> 00:46:43,146 Or a role versus a low cognitive demand role. 883 00:46:43,146 --> 00:46:47,616 So it's, it's a relative drop, even if it's a 5% drop, that can bring on stress. 884 00:46:47,856 --> 00:46:51,156 The other important thing about menopause, which is under-recognized, 885 00:46:51,576 --> 00:46:56,256 is the correlation between menopausal related psychiatric symptoms like 886 00:46:56,256 --> 00:47:01,836 anxiety, depression do not, do not correlate with hormone levels. 887 00:47:02,226 --> 00:47:04,536 They can predate by three to four years. 888 00:47:04,806 --> 00:47:08,076 There's a lot of prospective studies they've looked at, followed up to 889 00:47:08,076 --> 00:47:12,816 20,000 plus Australian studies study, which they looked at prospectively 890 00:47:12,816 --> 00:47:14,496 looking following, tracking these women. 891 00:47:14,496 --> 00:47:18,396 And they found that if we were really tuned into the anxiety depression 892 00:47:18,396 --> 00:47:21,666 side, it would have been a good marker three to four years, even 893 00:47:21,666 --> 00:47:23,976 prior to the hormone levels dropping. 894 00:47:24,276 --> 00:47:29,106 So similarly, the brain fog effects can even just predate even couple of years 895 00:47:29,106 --> 00:47:31,116 before the actual hormone levels drop. 896 00:47:31,116 --> 00:47:32,376 So that's an interesting finding. 897 00:47:32,376 --> 00:47:32,796 Thank you, Dr. 898 00:47:32,796 --> 00:47:33,066 Shiva. 899 00:47:33,066 --> 00:47:37,086 While you've got the mic, uh, I think this question is in your domain, how 900 00:47:37,086 --> 00:47:39,606 much does anxiety play a part in pain? 901 00:47:40,600 --> 00:47:41,680 Such subjective pain. 902 00:47:41,680 --> 00:47:44,890 Is it possible to feel something that technically isn't there? 903 00:47:45,160 --> 00:47:50,980 That's the title of my next book, but, so I will try to give 904 00:47:50,980 --> 00:47:52,540 you a two minute version of it. 905 00:47:53,770 --> 00:47:55,690 Look, there's a very valid point. 906 00:47:56,050 --> 00:47:58,840 You, you could imagine. 907 00:47:58,840 --> 00:48:02,770 Can you imagine pain is, is the first one, you know, if you imagine pain, 908 00:48:02,800 --> 00:48:06,490 absolutely there's no reason for it and you're completely imagining it. 909 00:48:06,825 --> 00:48:08,110 You, you could be delusional. 910 00:48:08,110 --> 00:48:10,210 I mean, we are looking at that extreme as well. 911 00:48:10,210 --> 00:48:13,870 There are hypochondriac, uh, delusions. 912 00:48:13,870 --> 00:48:14,530 We know that. 913 00:48:14,530 --> 00:48:16,000 So there is small people. 914 00:48:16,060 --> 00:48:17,980 Imagine they have bugs crawling on there. 915 00:48:18,340 --> 00:48:20,260 People imagine their things in the joint. 916 00:48:20,260 --> 00:48:21,520 People imagine lots of things. 917 00:48:21,520 --> 00:48:23,200 I mean, it could be that extreme. 918 00:48:23,680 --> 00:48:25,270 That's a very clear cut case. 919 00:48:25,270 --> 00:48:28,090 But there are the softer side of that where, where there's 920 00:48:28,090 --> 00:48:31,390 a correlation between, I think I talked about that vigilance. 921 00:48:31,390 --> 00:48:36,070 The moment you bring your mind and put it there, wherever the 922 00:48:36,070 --> 00:48:38,140 injuries, it changes the dynamic. 923 00:48:38,170 --> 00:48:42,160 It's how then you look at it, you'll be more vigilant, be more perceptive. 924 00:48:42,190 --> 00:48:44,110 You'll take more medications for it. 925 00:48:44,650 --> 00:48:48,400 Um, you'll be less distracted and therefore that happens. 926 00:48:48,400 --> 00:48:54,400 Now the question is all of this, is it conscious or unconscious? 927 00:48:54,400 --> 00:49:01,570 Is the person doing it to themselves or is it such a powerful unknown 928 00:49:02,230 --> 00:49:07,000 background force in their mind, which is kind of doing that unconsciously, 929 00:49:07,000 --> 00:49:10,300 unwillingly, even against the person's wish they don't want to. 930 00:49:10,300 --> 00:49:14,050 So that is where the assessment comes into it. 931 00:49:14,110 --> 00:49:17,200 I guess delineating, is it conscious? 932 00:49:17,440 --> 00:49:18,490 Is it unconscious? 933 00:49:18,490 --> 00:49:19,960 Is it a habitual thing? 934 00:49:19,990 --> 00:49:22,840 Is it a, is it a wrong information thing? 935 00:49:23,260 --> 00:49:28,690 Um, yes, but general rule anxiety will amplify the pain experience. 936 00:49:28,690 --> 00:49:33,460 The pain scores will go up by at least 30 to 40% minimum 937 00:49:33,460 --> 00:49:34,810 if you have bout of anxiety. 938 00:49:34,960 --> 00:49:38,020 And you'll find that sometimes patient will give you a wonderful description. 939 00:49:38,020 --> 00:49:41,050 The I have panic, I'm anxious, I'm worried my pain's gone up. 940 00:49:41,050 --> 00:49:42,520 I'm using more pain medication. 941 00:49:43,510 --> 00:49:44,200 Thank you for that. 942 00:49:44,200 --> 00:49:48,520 And shameless plug for the podcast I've had a pain specialist on in the resolution 943 00:49:48,520 --> 00:49:49,960 room, so check that out as well. 944 00:49:50,170 --> 00:49:51,010 Thank you so much. 945 00:49:51,010 --> 00:49:52,270 That was a really great session. 946 00:49:52,450 --> 00:49:53,410 Dr. Tim Huang. 947 00:49:53,410 --> 00:49:54,070 Thank you. 948 00:49:54,340 --> 00:49:55,630 Uh, thank you Dr. Shiva. 949 00:49:55,630 --> 00:49:56,590 Thank you Dr. Sarah. 950 00:49:56,590 --> 00:49:57,430 Thank you Allison. 951 00:49:57,790 --> 00:49:58,150 Um. 952 00:50:02,616 --> 00:50:04,746 I really appreciate your time and expertise. 953 00:50:04,806 --> 00:50:09,276 Um, I'm proud of the collaboration with M-L-C-O-A and the Resolution Room podcast. 954 00:50:09,516 --> 00:50:12,636 I'm always in the market for new subscribers on YouTube for the 955 00:50:12,636 --> 00:50:14,916 podcast, um, as I build a platform. 956 00:50:14,916 --> 00:50:15,696 So check it out. 957 00:50:15,906 --> 00:50:18,546 We cover off the intersection of law, medicine and everything in 958 00:50:18,546 --> 00:50:19,836 between, as the title suggests. 959 00:50:20,046 --> 00:50:20,976 Thanks for your time, everyone. 960 00:50:20,976 --> 00:50:22,026 Have a good rest of the day. 961 00:50:22,026 --> 00:50:22,656 Thank you.