1 00:00:03,086 --> 00:00:05,036 Welcome to the Resolution Room podcast. 2 00:00:05,036 --> 00:00:09,145 This is part of my collaboration with M-L-C-O-A law Medicine 3 00:00:09,145 --> 00:00:10,286 and everything in between. 4 00:00:10,766 --> 00:00:12,926 I'm joined by Vanessa Daniel of M-L-C-O-A. 5 00:00:12,956 --> 00:00:14,066 Thanks for joining us, Vanessa. 6 00:00:14,066 --> 00:00:14,516 Thank you. 7 00:00:14,521 --> 00:00:14,931 Damien. 8 00:00:15,146 --> 00:00:18,956 M-L-C-O-A is one of the largest medicolegal providers, um, in Australia 9 00:00:18,956 --> 00:00:20,726 with 300 specialists on their books. 10 00:00:20,726 --> 00:00:22,016 And I have two with me today. 11 00:00:22,285 --> 00:00:27,715 The topic today is Spine In the Mind, what really determines Recovery To address 12 00:00:27,715 --> 00:00:29,575 this issue, we have two specialists. 13 00:00:29,575 --> 00:00:32,186 We have Dr. Simon Clark, who's a neurosurgeon. 14 00:00:32,456 --> 00:00:36,266 Welcome Simon Morning, and we have Shiver pu a psychiatrist. 15 00:00:36,326 --> 00:00:36,686 Good morning. 16 00:00:36,896 --> 00:00:39,416 Now, I don't wanna spend the whole podcast talking about Dr. 17 00:00:39,416 --> 00:00:43,766 Simon Clark's qualifications, but I will give you some, uh, the highlight reel. 18 00:00:44,096 --> 00:00:48,596 Uh, Dr. Simon Clark is a neurosurgeon with expertise in complex spinal disorders. 19 00:00:49,016 --> 00:00:50,126 He's dual qualified. 20 00:00:50,126 --> 00:00:53,635 He has is a fellow of the Royal College in Edinburgh and also in Australia. 21 00:00:53,846 --> 00:00:55,766 He works here in Adelaide as a consultant. 22 00:00:55,766 --> 00:00:58,976 He also works out at the Prince Alfred Hospital in Melbourne. 23 00:00:59,336 --> 00:01:04,286 He does a extensive medicolegal, uh, uh, practise as well addressing personal 24 00:01:04,286 --> 00:01:08,066 injury, uh, medical negligence and the like as well of, of course, still 25 00:01:08,306 --> 00:01:10,016 conducting complex spinal surgery. 26 00:01:10,016 --> 00:01:13,136 Is that a fair summary of your, sounds busier than it really is, isn't it? 27 00:01:13,136 --> 00:01:15,086 But I suppose it is. 28 00:01:15,776 --> 00:01:17,456 And shiver Gutter, whos with us? 29 00:01:17,486 --> 00:01:18,686 Uh, I met Shiva yesterday. 30 00:01:18,686 --> 00:01:22,616 We did a, a session with, with Shiva in, in a part of a conference. 31 00:01:22,616 --> 00:01:26,336 He's a psychiatrist, a fellow of the, of course, of the college has a 32 00:01:26,336 --> 00:01:30,716 private practise as well as works for Ramsay Health, which is a large private 33 00:01:30,716 --> 00:01:32,066 health provider and mental health. 34 00:01:32,456 --> 00:01:35,066 He and his wife also have a really interesting business called 35 00:01:35,066 --> 00:01:39,146 Mind Speak, looking at workplace wellness training and the like. 36 00:01:39,206 --> 00:01:43,166 And that stems from a personal interest growing up as a doctor and seeing how 37 00:01:43,346 --> 00:01:46,346 things could be done better or differently in your workplace, in your early training. 38 00:01:46,346 --> 00:01:47,696 Indeed, that was influential. 39 00:01:48,326 --> 00:01:49,106 Absolutely. 40 00:01:49,316 --> 00:01:51,536 And Vanessa, of course, who she's a regular guest here. 41 00:01:52,136 --> 00:01:52,226 I am. 42 00:01:52,226 --> 00:01:53,096 So thanks for joining us. 43 00:01:53,096 --> 00:01:56,786 Vanessa Vanessa's work is a liaison officer at M-L-C-O-A. 44 00:01:56,786 --> 00:02:00,146 So she's the person that people go to ask various questions around. 45 00:02:00,326 --> 00:02:02,396 For example, what specialists should I use? 46 00:02:02,606 --> 00:02:04,886 What are the type of issues that are alive in this case? 47 00:02:04,886 --> 00:02:07,076 And Vanessa directs traffic accordingly. 48 00:02:07,076 --> 00:02:07,706 Is that a fair? 49 00:02:07,711 --> 00:02:08,051 That's right. 50 00:02:08,121 --> 00:02:08,696 Fair summary. 51 00:02:08,756 --> 00:02:12,686 Alright, Simon, because we're talking about the spine and the mine, let's 52 00:02:12,686 --> 00:02:13,796 of course start with the spine. 53 00:02:14,538 --> 00:02:19,848 Um, which is your area, what spinal injuries commonly come across your desk? 54 00:02:20,208 --> 00:02:24,318 Um, and in, in what respect are they commonly work related? 55 00:02:24,678 --> 00:02:26,538 Spinal disorders are super common. 56 00:02:26,808 --> 00:02:30,438 So if you think about everyone in the world as a, as a generalisation, 57 00:02:30,438 --> 00:02:32,628 everyone's gonna have sciatica, leg pain at some point. 58 00:02:32,958 --> 00:02:37,218 Everyone's gonna have back pain at some point, and everyone who comes across with 59 00:02:37,218 --> 00:02:41,838 all of these problems, the issue therefore is, was this a work-related injury? 60 00:02:42,018 --> 00:02:42,168 Yeah. 61 00:02:42,228 --> 00:02:43,308 Was it preexisting? 62 00:02:44,268 --> 00:02:45,678 What does a scan mean? 63 00:02:46,098 --> 00:02:47,568 What does the patient understand? 64 00:02:47,598 --> 00:02:50,148 And then we've gotta kind of explore all these little bits. 65 00:02:50,688 --> 00:02:54,108 The problem I have in a lot of, a lot of cases, and, and we were talking 66 00:02:54,108 --> 00:02:58,608 about this before, trying to connect the, like the psychological mind 67 00:02:58,608 --> 00:03:01,668 side of things with the spinal side of things is the patient perception. 68 00:03:01,908 --> 00:03:01,998 Yeah. 69 00:03:02,178 --> 00:03:07,338 And so a lot of my job, unfortunately, and I, and I, and I say that in, in a 70 00:03:07,338 --> 00:03:10,818 real way, unfortunately, is trying to unpack what has happened before they've 71 00:03:10,818 --> 00:03:12,858 come to see me as a spinal expert. 72 00:03:12,978 --> 00:03:13,218 Yeah. 73 00:03:13,518 --> 00:03:16,788 And so therefore, the amount of information on the internet is a 74 00:03:16,788 --> 00:03:20,538 fantastic thing, and the amount of thing on the internet is a terrible thing. 75 00:03:20,543 --> 00:03:20,643 Yeah. 76 00:03:20,808 --> 00:03:23,778 And that is the, the real problem we have, isn't it? 77 00:03:23,778 --> 00:03:28,788 It's that dichotomy of too much information and misinformation. 78 00:03:29,208 --> 00:03:35,388 So your normal person, unfortunately, will not go to see their GP or their 79 00:03:35,388 --> 00:03:37,458 specialist for information discussion. 80 00:03:37,758 --> 00:03:40,548 They'll get it from a AI source. 81 00:03:40,608 --> 00:03:41,058 Yeah. 82 00:03:41,298 --> 00:03:42,228 And what does that mean? 83 00:03:42,468 --> 00:03:46,308 AI source, when it is regulated, when it is within a 84 00:03:46,308 --> 00:03:47,838 framework, is incredibly useful. 85 00:03:47,838 --> 00:03:51,528 I use it to look at, uh, journal articles, papers, and all this sort of stuff. 86 00:03:51,888 --> 00:03:55,068 When it's thrown out there, it picks up Reddit, it picks 87 00:03:55,068 --> 00:03:56,148 up all of the other things. 88 00:03:56,148 --> 00:04:00,348 It picks up the forums where it's not necessarily regulated as much. 89 00:04:00,498 --> 00:04:04,488 And so therefore the patient comes to see me with a perception 90 00:04:04,488 --> 00:04:05,868 of what their problem is. 91 00:04:06,198 --> 00:04:10,278 And perhaps in terms of bringing in shiver in terms of the pain aspect, 92 00:04:10,488 --> 00:04:15,498 perhaps with an identification aspect of a diagnosis, as helpful as a diagnosis 93 00:04:15,498 --> 00:04:19,368 may be, there might, will be an undue identification with it, which may 94 00:04:19,368 --> 00:04:21,648 impede recovery at sometimes the issue. 95 00:04:21,648 --> 00:04:23,658 Mainly, uh, and I, and I totally agree with that. 96 00:04:23,658 --> 00:04:25,848 The issue mainly for me is the diagnosis. 97 00:04:26,058 --> 00:04:26,268 Yeah. 98 00:04:26,268 --> 00:04:30,738 So look, as doctors and, you know, we, we were always trained the same way. 99 00:04:30,978 --> 00:04:35,658 Myself, Shiva, everyone, you see a patient, you take a history, you 100 00:04:35,658 --> 00:04:38,928 do an examination, you formulate a plan, you get a diagnosis, and 101 00:04:38,957 --> 00:04:40,248 then you use all the other stuff. 102 00:04:40,728 --> 00:04:45,738 Unfortunately, we're in the world of instant diagnosis and access to 103 00:04:45,738 --> 00:04:47,418 scans and access to information. 104 00:04:47,418 --> 00:04:51,588 So therefore, some of this bit in the middle gets muddied and actually 105 00:04:51,588 --> 00:04:55,428 bringing people back to, well, what is the history behind this? 106 00:04:55,428 --> 00:04:56,298 What happened? 107 00:04:56,808 --> 00:04:57,888 What's the examination? 108 00:04:57,918 --> 00:04:59,838 Does it fit yes or no? 109 00:05:00,078 --> 00:05:03,288 What special tests can I use to try and get a diagnosis will 110 00:05:03,288 --> 00:05:07,938 inform me and the patient and then your treatment stems from that. 111 00:05:08,298 --> 00:05:12,768 Unfortunately, if there's a less than adequate assessment. 112 00:05:13,454 --> 00:05:14,954 We don't really know the history. 113 00:05:15,314 --> 00:05:16,844 Multiple scans are done. 114 00:05:17,084 --> 00:05:22,094 The patient turns up with scan reports, um, from various 115 00:05:22,094 --> 00:05:24,134 sources and misinformation. 116 00:05:24,284 --> 00:05:26,234 We are at the wrong end of the spectrum here. 117 00:05:26,294 --> 00:05:30,584 We're not starting with this patient focused, patient centred. 118 00:05:30,734 --> 00:05:31,634 What happened to you? 119 00:05:31,634 --> 00:05:32,714 How does it affect you? 120 00:05:33,134 --> 00:05:34,424 What is the examination? 121 00:05:34,814 --> 00:05:37,844 We've got some imaging and a person. 122 00:05:38,114 --> 00:05:38,414 Yeah. 123 00:05:38,714 --> 00:05:43,274 And remember that if you scan everyone in this room, we will all have a 124 00:05:43,274 --> 00:05:44,924 degree of degeneration in our spine. 125 00:05:44,929 --> 00:05:45,059 Yeah. 126 00:05:45,104 --> 00:05:45,344 Yeah. 127 00:05:45,404 --> 00:05:46,124 That's the issue. 128 00:05:46,124 --> 00:05:52,304 There's this great study back in 2015, I think, where they, uh, took 129 00:05:52,304 --> 00:05:56,924 loads of, uh, papers and of people with a little bit of back pain, but 130 00:05:56,924 --> 00:05:59,834 not presenting to their GP for that reason, and looked at all of the scans. 131 00:06:00,194 --> 00:06:03,734 And by the time you get to 50, 50% of people will have 132 00:06:03,734 --> 00:06:04,994 degenerative change on the scan. 133 00:06:05,084 --> 00:06:05,324 Yeah. 134 00:06:05,534 --> 00:06:08,414 And so if you add that into a injured worker Yeah. 135 00:06:10,062 --> 00:06:11,742 What, what are we, what are we doing here? 136 00:06:11,742 --> 00:06:17,352 This is, this is a mess of preexisting degeneration with some exacerbation. 137 00:06:17,352 --> 00:06:21,402 So that history, that examination is key because the scans Yeah. 138 00:06:21,432 --> 00:06:22,422 Are going to show problems. 139 00:06:22,482 --> 00:06:26,172 So on that point, uh, Dr. Simon, the scans are of course really important 140 00:06:26,382 --> 00:06:27,582 for, I love the way you say Dr. Simon. 141 00:06:28,092 --> 00:06:29,322 That's such an, that's such an Australian thing. 142 00:06:29,917 --> 00:06:31,347 Australian in It's very Australian. 143 00:06:31,347 --> 00:06:32,292 It's very Australian, isn't it? 144 00:06:32,292 --> 00:06:32,472 Yeah. 145 00:06:32,502 --> 00:06:36,192 Because we're very informal, but we still put the doctor in and I'm, I'm 146 00:06:36,192 --> 00:06:37,032 still trying to get my head around. 147 00:06:37,032 --> 00:06:38,052 I've been here like five years. 148 00:06:38,052 --> 00:06:38,862 I still can't work it out. 149 00:06:39,042 --> 00:06:39,402 Sorry. 150 00:06:39,727 --> 00:06:43,842 The, the scans are the best diagnostic tool still in terms 151 00:06:43,842 --> 00:06:47,682 of MRIs, but they're still to be treated with a level of caution. 152 00:06:47,682 --> 00:06:50,592 Because what you're saying is you treat the patient in front of you 153 00:06:50,592 --> 00:06:54,582 in terms of their symptomatology, their history, what they tell you. 154 00:06:54,642 --> 00:06:55,242 Oh, a hundred percent. 155 00:06:55,272 --> 00:06:56,352 Yeah, a hundred percent. 156 00:06:56,352 --> 00:07:01,152 And the mistake is to skip from some of these, uh, steps at the start, 157 00:07:01,422 --> 00:07:05,652 not get the, and, and psychiatry is, is exactly the same, just with 158 00:07:05,652 --> 00:07:07,632 the scans are even less useful. 159 00:07:07,722 --> 00:07:08,082 Yeah. 160 00:07:08,172 --> 00:07:11,562 But that is, that is key consistent with my work as a mediator and a lawyer. 161 00:07:11,952 --> 00:07:15,162 A lot of the questions that then pos to you in the medicolegal context 162 00:07:15,162 --> 00:07:16,842 around issues of causation, of course. 163 00:07:16,872 --> 00:07:17,112 Yes. 164 00:07:17,112 --> 00:07:21,102 Unfortunately, because you, you take on one view of it in the lawyer, of 165 00:07:21,102 --> 00:07:23,592 course, you take your plaintiff as you find them, as, you know, we're 166 00:07:23,592 --> 00:07:24,972 all got a level of degeneration. 167 00:07:24,972 --> 00:07:28,482 I'm not, I'm comforted by the fact that 55, I'm, I've got a level 168 00:07:28,482 --> 00:07:29,982 of degeneration, I dunno about. 169 00:07:30,192 --> 00:07:34,572 You take your plan because you find, but you have to assess forensically to what 170 00:07:34,572 --> 00:07:38,622 extent, say a mechanism of injury may have produced an aggravation, an exacerbation. 171 00:07:38,652 --> 00:07:38,922 Yes. 172 00:07:38,922 --> 00:07:41,292 To what extent those symptoms may have developed in any event 173 00:07:41,292 --> 00:07:42,672 is always a relevant question. 174 00:07:42,677 --> 00:07:46,902 And, and it and it is, and remember that degeneration disc prolapses and all that 175 00:07:46,902 --> 00:07:48,912 sort of thing is rarely due to one event. 176 00:07:49,092 --> 00:07:49,332 Yeah. 177 00:07:49,392 --> 00:07:51,522 It's cumulative events over time. 178 00:07:51,732 --> 00:07:54,762 Now that might be entirely relevant to the medical legal sphere in 179 00:07:54,762 --> 00:07:58,242 that they've been doing this job and exposing their spine to this a 180 00:07:58,362 --> 00:07:59,982 thousand times over the last 15 years. 181 00:07:59,982 --> 00:08:00,432 That's fine. 182 00:08:00,852 --> 00:08:05,022 But it's very rarely Mr. X slipped over in coals Yeah. 183 00:08:05,052 --> 00:08:08,232 On a grape and suddenly has got this massive disc prolapse. 184 00:08:08,237 --> 00:08:08,267 Yeah. 185 00:08:08,267 --> 00:08:08,947 That's not a thing. 186 00:08:09,192 --> 00:08:09,582 Yeah. 187 00:08:09,762 --> 00:08:12,342 But is that the straw that brought the camels back on the background 188 00:08:12,342 --> 00:08:14,862 of the, all the degeneration and that's why it's really hard. 189 00:08:15,072 --> 00:08:15,492 Yeah, that's right. 190 00:08:15,492 --> 00:08:18,372 It's tough and tough for lawyers too in that space as well. 191 00:08:18,552 --> 00:08:23,352 And I think probably like dis degeneration or those terms create a lot of anxiety. 192 00:08:23,352 --> 00:08:23,442 Yes. 193 00:08:23,682 --> 00:08:24,792 For people as well too. 194 00:08:24,792 --> 00:08:26,172 They don't know how to interpret it. 195 00:08:26,232 --> 00:08:28,812 And that's another thing we have to manage, isn't it? 196 00:08:28,812 --> 00:08:29,187 Um, yes. 197 00:08:29,287 --> 00:08:29,947 Dr. Shiva. 198 00:08:29,977 --> 00:08:30,267 Yeah. 199 00:08:30,287 --> 00:08:31,212 Yes, yes indeed. 200 00:08:31,512 --> 00:08:32,562 Very valid points. 201 00:08:32,562 --> 00:08:37,572 Um, some, um, importantly what I find striking when I, when 202 00:08:37,572 --> 00:08:42,222 I see, uh, people with spinal injuries or any chronic injuries 203 00:08:42,672 --> 00:08:44,772 particularly, is the, is the model of. 204 00:08:45,614 --> 00:08:46,724 Illness they have in the head. 205 00:08:47,474 --> 00:08:48,104 Yeah, definitely. 206 00:08:48,159 --> 00:08:53,114 It, it, it's, it's not necessarily what is actually happened anatomically 207 00:08:53,684 --> 00:08:56,804 or physiologically or through the mechanism or the biomechanics 208 00:08:56,804 --> 00:08:59,024 of the injury can explain. 209 00:08:59,324 --> 00:09:03,914 So it's interesting that illness model is very crucial and how that's evolved. 210 00:09:04,244 --> 00:09:05,444 Is it through wrong information? 211 00:09:05,774 --> 00:09:09,314 Is it through, uh, getting wrong source of information or is it being 212 00:09:09,314 --> 00:09:14,564 just they, they just didn't have the sophistication or guidance to 213 00:09:14,564 --> 00:09:16,034 put all the information together? 214 00:09:16,034 --> 00:09:18,344 They just put it in a way that makes sense to them. 215 00:09:18,344 --> 00:09:19,484 Yeah, number of times. 216 00:09:20,366 --> 00:09:24,026 Seen, I, I've seen, uh, patients five years into the claim, two years 217 00:09:24,026 --> 00:09:28,136 into the claim or post-injury or, you know, six months post-injury. 218 00:09:28,736 --> 00:09:34,526 Everyone has, uh, interesting understanding of how, what the injury is. 219 00:09:34,531 --> 00:09:34,611 Yeah. 220 00:09:34,736 --> 00:09:35,006 Yeah. 221 00:09:35,096 --> 00:09:37,226 You ask them this, oh, I have nerve damage. 222 00:09:37,856 --> 00:09:37,976 Yeah. 223 00:09:37,976 --> 00:09:40,165 You ask them, for example, they say, I have nerve damage. 224 00:09:40,165 --> 00:09:42,116 And then you see there's actually no nerve damage. 225 00:09:42,566 --> 00:09:43,496 Uh, what's happened? 226 00:09:43,526 --> 00:09:47,306 Oh, I think my, my disc is worn out or something. 227 00:09:47,306 --> 00:09:48,571 But yeah, I hear that a lot too. 228 00:09:48,711 --> 00:09:51,626 Um, but then when you look at it, it's some soft tissue injury, for 229 00:09:51,626 --> 00:09:52,886 example, is what has happened. 230 00:09:53,246 --> 00:09:57,056 So it's the illness model that's very crucial and that, like you said, um, 231 00:09:57,086 --> 00:09:59,456 illness model generates that anxiety. 232 00:09:59,726 --> 00:10:03,686 I've got this, this is chronic, this is bad, it's not getting better. 233 00:10:04,436 --> 00:10:08,186 One of the things, uh, we also look at is hypervigilance. 234 00:10:08,186 --> 00:10:13,106 So once you have a symptom, which has not been the case for some years, for 235 00:10:13,106 --> 00:10:16,976 example, if it's a, like someone was saying they, they might have had a 236 00:10:17,096 --> 00:10:20,966 level of degeneration, they have fall and then that, that sets off pain for 237 00:10:20,966 --> 00:10:22,616 the first time ever, for instance. 238 00:10:22,856 --> 00:10:26,336 So they're pain-free, relatively pain-free, and then you have the pain 239 00:10:26,665 --> 00:10:30,716 and they've been told all this, um, information about what's wrong with 240 00:10:30,716 --> 00:10:32,786 them, then you're going to be vigilant. 241 00:10:32,786 --> 00:10:36,476 So you're constantly scanning that and you know, back or yeah, 242 00:10:36,716 --> 00:10:38,486 thinking about it, processing it. 243 00:10:38,486 --> 00:10:41,006 How is it, how are you sitting, how are you standing? 244 00:10:41,516 --> 00:10:45,266 And then you're making your own interpretation of, of what aggravates 245 00:10:45,266 --> 00:10:47,066 it without that appropriate guidance. 246 00:10:47,066 --> 00:10:51,836 So the initial, um, understanding of what is their illness model 247 00:10:52,136 --> 00:10:53,726 is such a crucial aspect. 248 00:10:53,876 --> 00:10:57,506 When I intervene or when I try to understand these cases, 249 00:10:57,536 --> 00:10:58,736 that's where I start usually. 250 00:10:58,796 --> 00:10:59,066 Yeah. 251 00:10:59,096 --> 00:11:00,266 What do you think is wrong? 252 00:11:00,266 --> 00:11:04,946 Can you explain to me in your terms, forget about all this technical jargon, 253 00:11:05,036 --> 00:11:06,896 just tell me what is happened to you. 254 00:11:06,896 --> 00:11:08,696 What do you think is going wrong? 255 00:11:08,756 --> 00:11:08,935 Yeah. 256 00:11:08,935 --> 00:11:08,945 Yeah. 257 00:11:09,056 --> 00:11:12,116 And that's a good starting point for a psychiatrist to look at. 258 00:11:12,236 --> 00:11:15,776 And do you think that, um, once they've identified with those words or the 259 00:11:15,776 --> 00:11:18,896 terms, it inhibits recovery as well too? 260 00:11:18,896 --> 00:11:19,165 Absolutely. 261 00:11:19,496 --> 00:11:21,956 If we can't change it, change the norms then. 262 00:11:21,956 --> 00:11:23,396 So there's an identification as well. 263 00:11:23,396 --> 00:11:23,456 Yeah. 264 00:11:23,456 --> 00:11:26,425 And yes, this is the interesting part of pain, right? 265 00:11:26,425 --> 00:11:27,746 It's experienced in the brain. 266 00:11:27,986 --> 00:11:31,706 At the end of the day, there's a pathological tissue damage of 267 00:11:31,706 --> 00:11:37,076 somewhere in spine or nerves or the bones, uh uh, or anywhere between 268 00:11:37,226 --> 00:11:38,846 the spine and the brain, right? 269 00:11:38,846 --> 00:11:40,316 It could be any at any level. 270 00:11:40,316 --> 00:11:43,226 And but pain perception happens in the brain. 271 00:11:43,226 --> 00:11:43,316 Mm-hmm. 272 00:11:43,886 --> 00:11:47,846 So therefore the brain, which is then absorbing what's happening 273 00:11:47,906 --> 00:11:49,856 in their social circumstances. 274 00:11:49,856 --> 00:11:50,096 Yeah. 275 00:11:50,156 --> 00:11:54,806 What has changing in their psychological circumstances, it's absorbing that. 276 00:11:55,118 --> 00:11:57,458 This pain is being experienced in that context. 277 00:11:57,968 --> 00:11:58,028 Yeah. 278 00:11:58,088 --> 00:12:02,258 So the pain amplification when the brain is already anxious 279 00:12:02,468 --> 00:12:03,968 is a very non phenomenon. 280 00:12:04,328 --> 00:12:04,418 Right? 281 00:12:04,418 --> 00:12:08,468 So, so what, what we call as disproportionate pain experience, right? 282 00:12:08,473 --> 00:12:08,483 Yeah. 283 00:12:08,558 --> 00:12:11,648 So, which can sometimes be abnormal illness behaviour or in the 284 00:12:11,648 --> 00:12:13,208 old speak somatoform disorder. 285 00:12:13,238 --> 00:12:13,658 Yes. 286 00:12:13,808 --> 00:12:14,138 Yes. 287 00:12:14,408 --> 00:12:18,728 The understanding of unexplained symptoms dates back to ancient history, right? 288 00:12:18,758 --> 00:12:23,078 Like the, you know, uh, Greek, uh, people called it the wandering womb. 289 00:12:23,078 --> 00:12:23,798 The hysteria. 290 00:12:23,828 --> 00:12:24,158 Yeah. 291 00:12:24,158 --> 00:12:24,308 Yeah. 292 00:12:24,308 --> 00:12:24,843 They did. 293 00:12:25,063 --> 00:12:25,523 For women. 294 00:12:25,743 --> 00:12:27,278 For women they said women in pain. 295 00:12:27,278 --> 00:12:28,148 We could get into this. 296 00:12:28,148 --> 00:12:31,448 I think we have to do another episode ship about women in pain. 297 00:12:31,448 --> 00:12:33,883 I can tell you wandering, what do they call wandering room? 298 00:12:34,058 --> 00:12:34,748 Hysteria. 299 00:12:34,808 --> 00:12:37,748 You know, the unexplained behaviours of including pain. 300 00:12:38,108 --> 00:12:39,548 Hysterical, there's a word for it. 301 00:12:39,608 --> 00:12:44,078 Uh, so that, that took, uh, I guess it stayed in that way for years. 302 00:12:44,138 --> 00:12:44,678 Um. 303 00:12:45,358 --> 00:12:51,208 Until French, Dr. Quet, he tried to reason it out, saying there are a 304 00:12:51,208 --> 00:12:55,858 group of people who have unexplained symptoms early 19th century. 305 00:12:55,858 --> 00:12:59,098 Then, um, that was the case in 20th century. 306 00:12:59,127 --> 00:13:02,698 Freud then brings up the con concept of conversion. 307 00:13:02,848 --> 00:13:03,147 Yeah. 308 00:13:03,328 --> 00:13:07,468 That is, oh, you can have emotional distress, which can manifest as physical. 309 00:13:07,738 --> 00:13:08,247 Right. 310 00:13:08,907 --> 00:13:11,247 The mind and the body are so connected. 311 00:13:11,247 --> 00:13:11,438 They're connected. 312 00:13:11,438 --> 00:13:15,027 They're not, this is not necessarily hysteria or in a 313 00:13:15,027 --> 00:13:16,438 classic sense, unexplainable. 314 00:13:16,438 --> 00:13:20,608 There's some sort of explanation and then come to DSM three, DSM four, 315 00:13:20,608 --> 00:13:24,747 DSM five, seventies and eighties, and later on, uh, the current version 316 00:13:24,747 --> 00:13:27,147 we have using the term somatoform. 317 00:13:27,777 --> 00:13:28,402 Yeah, okay. 318 00:13:28,407 --> 00:13:29,348 Somato of the body. 319 00:13:29,367 --> 00:13:29,907 Of the body. 320 00:13:30,417 --> 00:13:31,048 Somatoform, yeah. 321 00:13:31,108 --> 00:13:32,247 Soma meaning body. 322 00:13:32,277 --> 00:13:37,377 So it is a bodily manifestation of psychological distress. 323 00:13:37,617 --> 00:13:39,537 That's the, that's the, that's the explanation. 324 00:13:40,017 --> 00:13:43,978 The thing we have stepped away from, from, say, from DSM four 325 00:13:43,978 --> 00:13:48,838 and DSM three, there was, um, a concept of medically unexplainable. 326 00:13:49,348 --> 00:13:49,767 Right. 327 00:13:50,098 --> 00:13:50,488 Right. 328 00:13:50,488 --> 00:13:55,677 Now in the Somatoform context, we think of even if there is a medical explanation for 329 00:13:55,677 --> 00:14:02,308 the pain, if it is disproportionate and if it's beyond what is expected and disabling 330 00:14:02,578 --> 00:14:08,308 the person's has associated anxiety, it still can be somatoform disorder on top of 331 00:14:08,667 --> 00:14:14,308 actually a genuine, some sort of a injury pathology or, or, so the disproportionate 332 00:14:14,397 --> 00:14:16,468 of that response is still under. 333 00:14:16,468 --> 00:14:18,867 So we've, we've kind of stepped away from that. 334 00:14:19,407 --> 00:14:21,718 It doesn't have to be no medical problems. 335 00:14:21,747 --> 00:14:21,808 Yeah. 336 00:14:21,808 --> 00:14:24,747 You can still have a somatoform aspect. 337 00:14:25,288 --> 00:14:30,568 Um, on top of that, and to what extent does work serve such an important 338 00:14:30,568 --> 00:14:32,757 social function and provide purpose? 339 00:14:32,997 --> 00:14:37,677 To what extent does, do you see people in both your practises that are away 340 00:14:37,677 --> 00:14:40,948 from work for a variety of reasons, usually from a spinal injury or from 341 00:14:40,948 --> 00:14:45,238 a secondary psychological, does that really impact the ability to not work? 342 00:14:45,238 --> 00:14:46,798 Does that really adversely impact? 343 00:14:47,068 --> 00:14:50,757 Does that make you more prone to spiral? 344 00:14:50,818 --> 00:14:51,808 Yeah, absolutely. 345 00:14:51,808 --> 00:14:52,377 Absolutely. 346 00:14:52,438 --> 00:14:56,877 Work is such a strong feedback to who you are. 347 00:14:56,938 --> 00:14:57,267 Yeah. 348 00:14:57,328 --> 00:14:57,538 Okay. 349 00:14:57,538 --> 00:14:58,167 Identification. 350 00:14:58,167 --> 00:15:00,777 Identification and what your purpose and meaning. 351 00:15:00,777 --> 00:15:02,038 It's an automatic purpose. 352 00:15:02,068 --> 00:15:03,358 You don't have to think about it. 353 00:15:03,358 --> 00:15:07,558 You have a schedule, you have a automatic sort of a set schedule. 354 00:15:07,563 --> 00:15:09,117 You, you know the meaning of the day. 355 00:15:09,117 --> 00:15:12,568 You want to get this eight hours of the day done, and then there's rest of life. 356 00:15:12,598 --> 00:15:12,867 Right. 357 00:15:13,228 --> 00:15:16,438 Once that changes, you're throwing the circadian rhythm outta whack. 358 00:15:16,617 --> 00:15:16,798 Yeah. 359 00:15:16,828 --> 00:15:19,948 When they sleep, when they, how much exhaustion they have through the day. 360 00:15:19,948 --> 00:15:20,247 Yeah. 361 00:15:20,308 --> 00:15:21,208 Through the normal workday. 362 00:15:21,208 --> 00:15:22,917 So that throws up the sleep patterns. 363 00:15:23,308 --> 00:15:25,318 Then there's pain medication involved, right. 364 00:15:25,647 --> 00:15:30,027 That changes the cognitions that can D down can bring on some dysphoria. 365 00:15:30,027 --> 00:15:34,017 You can have withdrawals from strong pain medications, even if they're prescribed. 366 00:15:34,017 --> 00:15:37,948 You can have minor withdrawals for a few hours that can mess up your mood. 367 00:15:38,720 --> 00:15:42,350 And then the, not for everyone, but particularly some group of 368 00:15:42,350 --> 00:15:46,430 people strongly identify with the sense of being the provider. 369 00:15:46,580 --> 00:15:47,155 Yeah, yeah. 370 00:15:47,540 --> 00:15:50,330 In the, in the household or in the family context. 371 00:15:50,510 --> 00:15:51,950 They strongly rooted to that. 372 00:15:51,950 --> 00:15:54,950 That could be cultural, that could be their own background, what 373 00:15:54,950 --> 00:15:56,210 they've seen their parents do. 374 00:15:56,210 --> 00:16:00,439 And it's very much becomes a very much strong unconscious part. 375 00:16:00,439 --> 00:16:03,830 And that loss of that capacity feeds into that. 376 00:16:04,490 --> 00:16:09,380 Then, I mean, Simon could speak about the deconditioning aspects, it itself 377 00:16:09,380 --> 00:16:14,090 not working and what happens to your Yeah, I think all of this is incredibly, 378 00:16:14,300 --> 00:16:15,800 uh, insightful and very important. 379 00:16:15,920 --> 00:16:20,090 I think what we see and, and we can obviously just almost do a case 380 00:16:20,090 --> 00:16:21,470 study on the rest of our practises. 381 00:16:21,470 --> 00:16:24,980 So if you see people in private practise who have. 382 00:16:26,094 --> 00:16:29,454 Just had a degenerative problem and have a disc prolapse, for instance, the communist 383 00:16:29,454 --> 00:16:31,794 thing that we see who get to see you soon. 384 00:16:32,094 --> 00:16:33,564 Get the information early. 385 00:16:33,714 --> 00:16:33,864 Yeah. 386 00:16:33,864 --> 00:16:35,304 No delays, get the appropriate investigations. 387 00:16:35,304 --> 00:16:37,854 Don't have this psychological spiralling Yeah. 388 00:16:38,304 --> 00:16:39,474 Their outcome is better. 389 00:16:39,564 --> 00:16:39,924 Yeah. 390 00:16:40,014 --> 00:16:42,114 That's been tried and tested for years. 391 00:16:42,144 --> 00:16:42,504 Yeah. 392 00:16:43,194 --> 00:16:47,394 In the medical legal space as either as an independent medical examiner 393 00:16:47,394 --> 00:16:51,054 where you're seeing people maybe 6, 12, 18 months down the line. 394 00:16:51,054 --> 00:16:51,414 Yeah. 395 00:16:51,564 --> 00:16:54,864 Where you're seeing all these problems that have been stored up, or even when 396 00:16:54,864 --> 00:16:58,884 you're seeing a work cover patient at three to six months, by the time they've 397 00:16:58,884 --> 00:17:03,204 got to there, all of the psychological time bombers started ticking. 398 00:17:03,234 --> 00:17:03,564 Yeah. 399 00:17:03,744 --> 00:17:07,674 The misinformations there psychologically they're, as you say, they're not 400 00:17:07,674 --> 00:17:09,384 a provider for the family anymore. 401 00:17:09,534 --> 00:17:11,844 They've got money worries, they've got anxiety. 402 00:17:12,144 --> 00:17:13,704 They've lost that sense of self. 403 00:17:13,764 --> 00:17:14,094 Yeah. 404 00:17:14,094 --> 00:17:17,544 Because that's their, their importance in their family or cultural group, whatever. 405 00:17:18,354 --> 00:17:21,144 And so you can almost, you can almost pick these people and you 406 00:17:21,144 --> 00:17:25,494 know that the medical-legal ones at 18 months as an IME Yeah. 407 00:17:25,494 --> 00:17:29,064 Have significant problems and probably the symptoms or the issue that they 408 00:17:29,064 --> 00:17:31,014 had at the start has gone away. 409 00:17:31,104 --> 00:17:31,344 Yeah. 410 00:17:31,349 --> 00:17:31,419 Yeah. 411 00:17:31,554 --> 00:17:33,264 That's probably, that's probably well healed up. 412 00:17:33,264 --> 00:17:36,114 The soft tissue injury or the bulging disco one. 413 00:17:36,114 --> 00:17:37,464 All these things that's just gone away. 414 00:17:37,734 --> 00:17:42,804 However, all of this catastrophization, all of this heightened anxiety 415 00:17:42,804 --> 00:17:46,074 is to such a level now that these people are disabled. 416 00:17:46,089 --> 00:17:46,494 Yeah, yeah. 417 00:17:46,494 --> 00:17:49,824 Physically disabled because of the psychological issue of having a 418 00:17:49,824 --> 00:17:52,164 claim too, of a, a delayed claim. 419 00:17:52,164 --> 00:17:55,194 And we know that ongoing claim is a massive factor. 420 00:17:55,194 --> 00:17:56,004 It it is indeed. 421 00:17:56,004 --> 00:17:58,374 Isn't for them not getting over these things. 422 00:17:58,404 --> 00:17:58,644 Yeah. 423 00:17:59,154 --> 00:18:03,654 That claim experience invalidating that in that, that that drive that. 424 00:18:03,654 --> 00:18:03,984 Yeah. 425 00:18:04,014 --> 00:18:07,254 I am actually experiencing these, I'm in distress. 426 00:18:07,259 --> 00:18:07,299 Yeah. 427 00:18:07,464 --> 00:18:07,614 Yeah. 428 00:18:07,614 --> 00:18:10,614 Which may be psychological more than physical. 429 00:18:10,884 --> 00:18:11,004 Yeah. 430 00:18:11,004 --> 00:18:11,094 Yes. 431 00:18:11,094 --> 00:18:15,084 But the language in the head for the person is that I'm in distress. 432 00:18:15,354 --> 00:18:16,344 It is from the injury. 433 00:18:16,374 --> 00:18:16,614 Yeah. 434 00:18:16,704 --> 00:18:19,019 They're unable to tease out that there is and people need 435 00:18:19,019 --> 00:18:20,064 to, believe me, believe me. 436 00:18:20,064 --> 00:18:23,454 That invalidating part of it then pushes, and then there's 437 00:18:23,454 --> 00:18:25,224 this litigation attached to it. 438 00:18:25,764 --> 00:18:29,184 Then that drives them to have a narration of how bad they are 439 00:18:29,184 --> 00:18:33,444 actually, how the language as well of what they then complain of. 440 00:18:33,954 --> 00:18:36,174 And then they're repeatedly saying the same thing. 441 00:18:36,174 --> 00:18:38,334 It's, it's almost like I have to be consistent. 442 00:18:38,694 --> 00:18:42,084 I am actually suffering, therefore I'm having these symptoms. 443 00:18:42,084 --> 00:18:44,904 And that builds on and there's the litigation pressures of, you 444 00:18:44,904 --> 00:18:48,384 know, and you wonder how that that identity then moves from. 445 00:18:49,102 --> 00:18:53,992 Them being the worker in the workplace providing to the injured worker. 446 00:18:53,997 --> 00:18:54,107 Injured worker. 447 00:18:54,112 --> 00:18:54,892 Yeah, that's right. 448 00:18:54,892 --> 00:18:55,747 A badly injured worker. 449 00:18:55,847 --> 00:18:56,207 The bad injured worker. 450 00:18:56,632 --> 00:18:56,872 Yeah. 451 00:18:56,872 --> 00:18:57,202 Yeah. 452 00:18:57,412 --> 00:18:58,552 Who's not gonna get over it? 453 00:18:58,552 --> 00:19:00,502 Who is just in the middle of this process. 454 00:19:00,532 --> 00:19:00,592 Yeah. 455 00:19:00,952 --> 00:19:04,432 That it's when you're like a kid and you, you know, you injure your arm or 456 00:19:04,432 --> 00:19:08,512 something and because you have no context of things just getting better, you think 457 00:19:08,512 --> 00:19:09,772 this is gonna last forever, don't you? 458 00:19:09,772 --> 00:19:09,952 Yeah. 459 00:19:09,952 --> 00:19:11,902 You know, or you sprain your ankle as a child. 460 00:19:11,902 --> 00:19:12,472 Oh my goodness. 461 00:19:12,472 --> 00:19:12,712 That's it. 462 00:19:12,712 --> 00:19:12,772 Yeah. 463 00:19:12,772 --> 00:19:14,062 I'm never gonna be able to play footy again. 464 00:19:14,122 --> 00:19:14,422 Yeah. 465 00:19:14,572 --> 00:19:18,742 These are, I think these injured workers fall into this like deep, dark hole of 466 00:19:19,282 --> 00:19:23,722 depression or anxiety, whatever they are, because they don't know where the end is. 467 00:19:23,782 --> 00:19:23,962 Yeah. 468 00:19:23,962 --> 00:19:27,652 No, they, they've not had the information to say, this is a normal response. 469 00:19:27,832 --> 00:19:29,212 You will get better in a couple of months. 470 00:19:29,212 --> 00:19:32,212 Your scans are fine, we can deal with the anxiety and we can 471 00:19:32,212 --> 00:19:33,412 bring you down off the ceiling. 472 00:19:33,802 --> 00:19:37,792 They're just in this hole of IME followed by IME, followed 473 00:19:37,792 --> 00:19:38,872 by all of these specialists. 474 00:19:39,227 --> 00:19:41,182 So, and talking about it, reliving it Yeah. 475 00:19:41,182 --> 00:19:41,842 And stuff as well. 476 00:19:41,842 --> 00:19:43,132 And what could we do better? 477 00:19:43,252 --> 00:19:46,672 Do they do adjustment to injury counselling in sa Do they, 478 00:19:46,672 --> 00:19:48,442 is that part of the scheme? 479 00:19:48,442 --> 00:19:50,782 Is there stuff we can do early, we can do to help them? 480 00:19:50,872 --> 00:19:52,432 Can early is exactly the, the key. 481 00:19:52,432 --> 00:19:53,402 I reckon it's the early, like Yeah, yeah. 482 00:19:53,452 --> 00:19:56,272 So early access to a sensible opinion. 483 00:19:56,277 --> 00:19:56,507 Yeah. 484 00:19:57,202 --> 00:19:57,502 Yeah. 485 00:19:57,562 --> 00:19:59,067 And appropriate investigations. 486 00:19:59,072 --> 00:19:59,902 Investigations, yeah. 487 00:19:59,902 --> 00:20:04,252 Lack of inappropriate, you know, bombarding scatter gun investigations. 488 00:20:04,702 --> 00:20:07,432 And really people have gotta use the right language here. 489 00:20:07,642 --> 00:20:08,872 So you mentioned it before. 490 00:20:08,902 --> 00:20:09,172 Yeah. 491 00:20:09,232 --> 00:20:12,622 If you start telling someone they have degenerative disc disease, 492 00:20:12,742 --> 00:20:13,972 suddenly you've got a disease. 493 00:20:14,332 --> 00:20:16,792 No, you've not, you've got normal wear and tear that we all have. 494 00:20:16,822 --> 00:20:17,122 Yeah. 495 00:20:17,287 --> 00:20:20,392 You, you call it a language that promotes agency in a sense, or 496 00:20:20,392 --> 00:20:23,992 promotes, and you, you've, you know, you get a, you get a, a scan report. 497 00:20:24,382 --> 00:20:28,822 Oh, it's severe on this scan report, but it's just moderate on this scan report. 498 00:20:29,092 --> 00:20:32,032 But people don't understand A scan is like anything else. 499 00:20:32,032 --> 00:20:32,872 It's a perception. 500 00:20:32,872 --> 00:20:33,952 It's, I see. 501 00:20:33,982 --> 00:20:36,142 I go to an art gallery and I see a painting differently 502 00:20:36,142 --> 00:20:37,642 from you and you Yeah. 503 00:20:37,732 --> 00:20:38,702 It's about, that's all it is. 504 00:20:38,702 --> 00:20:38,987 Perception. 505 00:20:39,112 --> 00:20:42,472 It's a radiologist in a dark room looking at a picture saying what they think. 506 00:20:42,772 --> 00:20:44,452 It's not scientific really. 507 00:20:44,457 --> 00:20:45,227 Yeah, it's not emotional. 508 00:20:45,352 --> 00:20:45,652 Yeah. 509 00:20:45,712 --> 00:20:47,572 But the patient takes it very emotional. 510 00:20:47,572 --> 00:20:52,642 So I am severe, I have disease, therefore I am injured, therefore I am validated. 511 00:20:52,647 --> 00:20:52,867 Yeah. 512 00:20:52,972 --> 00:20:53,272 Yeah. 513 00:20:53,332 --> 00:20:55,067 Whereas opposed to actually, you know what? 514 00:20:55,822 --> 00:20:56,782 That's pretty normal. 515 00:20:56,786 --> 00:20:58,762 We, we all have that, so don't worry about it. 516 00:20:58,972 --> 00:21:04,101 So to explore Vanessa's point, um, earlier intervention, the right opinion, the 517 00:21:04,131 --> 00:21:08,242 targeted investigations, getting someone across your desk sooner rather than later. 518 00:21:08,421 --> 00:21:10,222 What about from a psychological perspective? 519 00:21:10,762 --> 00:21:13,822 Yeah, I think, I think people dealing with case managers or whoever's seeing 520 00:21:13,822 --> 00:21:17,482 early gps, et cetera, they need to be a little bit more perceptive about 521 00:21:17,482 --> 00:21:19,191 the person's psychological profile. 522 00:21:19,191 --> 00:21:19,587 Yeah, I agree. 523 00:21:19,591 --> 00:21:22,462 If they're vulnerable, individuals look vulnerable. 524 00:21:22,462 --> 00:21:25,581 The social situation's already vulnerable, they've been already struggling. 525 00:21:25,581 --> 00:21:29,212 Maybe they have preexisting conditions, maybe they don't, sometimes you don't 526 00:21:29,212 --> 00:21:30,712 have to have a psychiatric illness. 527 00:21:30,712 --> 00:21:35,331 You can tell someone's in a vulnerable social space and their jobs in jeopardy. 528 00:21:35,331 --> 00:21:36,651 Jobs in jeopardy, yeah. 529 00:21:36,651 --> 00:21:39,621 Those all the other things, and it's probably cumulative injury 530 00:21:39,621 --> 00:21:43,282 of some form, but it's not looking good or whatever that might be. 531 00:21:43,282 --> 00:21:48,621 It's that ability to tease that out early on and say there needs some clear 532 00:21:48,621 --> 00:21:53,962 language, which is, doesn't catastrophize because the whole thing about pain is 533 00:21:53,962 --> 00:21:56,931 that pain avoidance, fear avoidance cycle. 534 00:21:57,351 --> 00:21:59,812 You know, we don't want to set off fear. 535 00:22:00,087 --> 00:22:00,742 No, no. 536 00:22:00,891 --> 00:22:05,062 If you can't or threat the, if you can't smoothen that out, don't 537 00:22:05,062 --> 00:22:06,651 bring fear into the equation. 538 00:22:06,891 --> 00:22:06,951 Yeah. 539 00:22:07,012 --> 00:22:09,742 If you can do that early on, you know. 540 00:22:09,742 --> 00:22:10,131 Right. 541 00:22:10,192 --> 00:22:11,032 Advise. 542 00:22:11,062 --> 00:22:11,302 Uh. 543 00:22:11,331 --> 00:22:11,661 Right. 544 00:22:11,661 --> 00:22:17,242 Professionals even in, you know, they're eligible for psychology sessions, so, 545 00:22:17,242 --> 00:22:20,871 so four four, they get four sessions irrespective of the status of the claim. 546 00:22:21,022 --> 00:22:21,232 Help them. 547 00:22:21,232 --> 00:22:21,242 Yeah. 548 00:22:21,442 --> 00:22:21,591 Yeah. 549 00:22:21,651 --> 00:22:23,692 Um, finding that right information. 550 00:22:23,962 --> 00:22:26,841 Once the fear sets in, then the avoidance will set in. 551 00:22:26,871 --> 00:22:27,022 Yes. 552 00:22:27,052 --> 00:22:30,411 Then the hypervigilance sets in and then they just need to get that. 553 00:22:31,086 --> 00:22:34,956 One bit of bad information and then the illness model develops 554 00:22:34,956 --> 00:22:38,106 and then the psychological stuff comes in and then that's a trap. 555 00:22:38,106 --> 00:22:39,126 It doesn't take long. 556 00:22:39,396 --> 00:22:40,506 So it's early intervention. 557 00:22:40,506 --> 00:22:40,746 Right. 558 00:22:40,746 --> 00:22:42,036 Information, right language. 559 00:22:42,126 --> 00:22:45,186 Avoid that fear from evolving into the situation. 560 00:22:45,186 --> 00:22:45,906 That's the key. 561 00:22:45,906 --> 00:22:46,086 Yeah. 562 00:22:46,086 --> 00:22:50,286 And try to try to step in early before that becomes the story that people 563 00:22:50,286 --> 00:22:52,026 are telling, telling themselves. 564 00:22:52,206 --> 00:22:55,806 So to go back to your medicolegal experience, then, 565 00:22:56,076 --> 00:22:57,486 Dr. Simon, I'll use that again. 566 00:22:57,486 --> 00:22:58,206 'cause you liked it. 567 00:22:58,356 --> 00:23:00,131 Um, uh, the, I'm not sure it did. 568 00:23:01,471 --> 00:23:01,891 Please. 569 00:23:02,151 --> 00:23:05,676 You, you, you talk a lot about, um, or your ask opinion a lot 570 00:23:05,676 --> 00:23:07,026 about the causation aspect. 571 00:23:07,026 --> 00:23:07,146 Yeah. 572 00:23:07,146 --> 00:23:11,286 It's so critical and because we've all gone underlying degenerative conditions. 573 00:23:11,526 --> 00:23:15,126 Um, so, so you use to, to provide that opinion. 574 00:23:15,126 --> 00:23:18,876 You look at, for example, the mechanism of injury, what the scans will tell 575 00:23:18,876 --> 00:23:22,746 you what the patient tells you, and knowing it's imprecise, but you do 576 00:23:22,746 --> 00:23:27,216 your best to provide an honest opinion addressing those types of aspects. 577 00:23:27,246 --> 00:23:27,576 I do. 578 00:23:27,581 --> 00:23:28,716 I I just have to do it. 579 00:23:28,806 --> 00:23:32,196 Um, you know, in the standards balance of probabilities, legal tests, don't I? 580 00:23:32,196 --> 00:23:32,531 Yeah, yeah. 581 00:23:32,556 --> 00:23:33,906 This is, this is civil law. 582 00:23:33,906 --> 00:23:36,216 So that's the, that's where I fall. 583 00:23:36,276 --> 00:23:40,296 Um, and I have to just give my, my honest appraisal and honest opinion 584 00:23:40,296 --> 00:23:45,246 of, of where the claimant client patient is at that particular point. 585 00:23:45,726 --> 00:23:50,016 I think the, it's interesting the independent me medical examiner kind of 586 00:23:50,166 --> 00:23:56,556 place, uh, in, in the world here because coming from a different space in the UK 587 00:23:56,556 --> 00:23:58,686 where there isn't a work cover scheme. 588 00:23:58,806 --> 00:23:59,406 Yeah. 589 00:23:59,796 --> 00:24:04,416 So my work was predominantly, um, high value medical negligence work. 590 00:24:04,446 --> 00:24:04,656 Yeah. 591 00:24:05,346 --> 00:24:08,946 And in fact, the causation arguments there are very, very different. 592 00:24:09,006 --> 00:24:09,126 Yeah. 593 00:24:09,126 --> 00:24:12,036 They, because it's very, it's, it's not easier. 594 00:24:12,036 --> 00:24:15,876 It's difficult sometimes, but at least there's a chronology of something 595 00:24:15,876 --> 00:24:18,666 might have gone wrong, something was missed, all that sort of thing. 596 00:24:18,666 --> 00:24:18,726 Yeah. 597 00:24:18,726 --> 00:24:23,376 And so there's usually a sentinel event or two, uh, that will lead 598 00:24:23,376 --> 00:24:24,456 it down this path to causation. 599 00:24:24,456 --> 00:24:30,486 Whereas the medical-legal space here with injured workers is very, very difficult 600 00:24:30,486 --> 00:24:35,016 because of all this, uh, physical, psychological package that we have to deal 601 00:24:35,016 --> 00:24:37,596 with and a claims process that can Yeah. 602 00:24:37,596 --> 00:24:37,606 Yeah. 603 00:24:38,016 --> 00:24:41,136 But the, the claims process, I, I mean, I, I feel for the, for the 604 00:24:41,136 --> 00:24:44,616 patients, because I think by the time they get to see experts like 605 00:24:44,676 --> 00:24:46,686 us in our medical legal world. 606 00:24:47,534 --> 00:24:49,004 All of this stuff is entrenched. 607 00:24:49,364 --> 00:24:49,454 Mm-hmm. 608 00:24:49,694 --> 00:24:53,144 The, the, the, the illness model is, is well and truly stamped. 609 00:24:53,204 --> 00:24:55,244 They've bought the illness model and is there Yeah. 610 00:24:55,244 --> 00:24:58,754 The physical side of things, even if there is still an ongoing physical 611 00:24:58,754 --> 00:25:03,254 side of things, no matter what I do, it's probably not gonna work now. 612 00:25:03,494 --> 00:25:03,764 Yeah. 613 00:25:03,824 --> 00:25:07,604 Until all of the psychological stuff has been, uh, has been dealt with. 614 00:25:07,784 --> 00:25:07,994 Yeah. 615 00:25:07,994 --> 00:25:11,594 And I, and I think we see a lot of that with work injuries. 616 00:25:11,594 --> 00:25:16,244 When the claim has gone on two and three years and they've seen multiple experts, 617 00:25:16,904 --> 00:25:20,804 um, oh, I'll, I'll see a shoulder surgeon and a knee surgeon and an ankle surgeon 618 00:25:20,804 --> 00:25:23,954 and a left hand surgeon and a right hand surgeon and a spine and a brain. 619 00:25:24,284 --> 00:25:27,314 And by the time they've gone through all of this process and said the same 620 00:25:27,314 --> 00:25:32,924 thing 400 times, they're, they're believing everything they say. 621 00:25:33,074 --> 00:25:33,554 Exactly. 622 00:25:33,554 --> 00:25:35,924 And I should say, as a mediator, I believe you too, because I 623 00:25:35,924 --> 00:25:37,154 have to read all the reports. 624 00:25:37,214 --> 00:25:39,944 So, and there's lots of them from all different specialties. 625 00:25:40,124 --> 00:25:41,864 That's quite common in protracted claims. 626 00:25:41,894 --> 00:25:43,244 You, you're quite right about that. 627 00:25:43,514 --> 00:25:46,424 Uh, 'cause people are constantly then in the illness model looking 628 00:25:46,424 --> 00:25:47,474 for an answer, aren't they? 629 00:25:47,474 --> 00:25:50,174 So, and their lawyers are doing their best to go, well where is this? 630 00:25:50,174 --> 00:25:53,954 And so you often find there's multiple experts that have, that have looked 631 00:25:53,954 --> 00:25:57,524 at and it's not helpful in the majority of cases because your primary 632 00:25:57,524 --> 00:25:59,984 diagnosis probably was never there. 633 00:26:00,584 --> 00:26:04,334 However, you've got a huge psychological component now, which overrides everything. 634 00:26:04,754 --> 00:26:05,204 Yeah, yeah, yeah. 635 00:26:05,204 --> 00:26:05,984 It's the biggest one now. 636 00:26:05,989 --> 00:26:08,804 And, and sending someone for a shoulder reconstruction or they're 637 00:26:08,804 --> 00:26:10,034 gonna tinker away this and this. 638 00:26:10,958 --> 00:26:12,518 It's just not the right way to do it. 639 00:26:12,968 --> 00:26:16,538 The deescalating, the psychological harm, the catastrophization, all of 640 00:26:16,538 --> 00:26:20,678 that stuff is the, has to be the primary mechanism of treating these people. 641 00:26:20,738 --> 00:26:22,778 And then you can start picking out what's the problem and 642 00:26:22,778 --> 00:26:24,098 what the primary driver was. 643 00:26:24,423 --> 00:26:28,778 You, you can't start, you know, operating here, there, and everywhere in a person 644 00:26:29,138 --> 00:26:31,328 who clearly needs a psychiatrist. 645 00:26:31,718 --> 00:26:31,808 Yeah. 646 00:26:32,378 --> 00:26:34,478 And expecting, expecting this all to go away. 647 00:26:34,478 --> 00:26:34,538 Yeah. 648 00:26:34,568 --> 00:26:38,378 Expecting all of this, all of this baggage just to disappear into the ether, because 649 00:26:38,378 --> 00:26:40,208 it's not going to, it's too entrenched. 650 00:26:40,238 --> 00:26:43,988 And even in your world of psychological injury, secondary psych, you might have 651 00:26:43,988 --> 00:26:48,128 p you might have, for example, adjustment disorder that stems or another diagnosis. 652 00:26:48,368 --> 00:26:52,058 You've also gotta disentangle causation too, in terms of, but it's more 653 00:26:52,058 --> 00:26:56,168 difficult too in terms of people's vulnerabilities potentially driven from 654 00:26:56,288 --> 00:27:01,268 adverse childhood experiences or other, um, other sort of background issues. 655 00:27:01,268 --> 00:27:02,768 How do you disentangle? 656 00:27:02,828 --> 00:27:03,158 Yeah. 657 00:27:03,163 --> 00:27:03,243 Yeah. 658 00:27:03,278 --> 00:27:04,388 That, that's quite complex. 659 00:27:04,388 --> 00:27:05,648 It's very complex work. 660 00:27:05,648 --> 00:27:12,608 It's very complex work usually, you know, um, it involves first of, I guess to, to 661 00:27:12,608 --> 00:27:17,918 very clearly make sure there is nothing diagnostically which has been missed. 662 00:27:17,918 --> 00:27:17,978 Yeah. 663 00:27:18,068 --> 00:27:23,168 And sometimes if, if there's a, you know, serious injury car crash and the sort 664 00:27:23,168 --> 00:27:29,228 of things PTSD sometimes can be missed, um, may have been missed, I make sure 665 00:27:29,228 --> 00:27:31,418 that part is sort of looked after first. 666 00:27:31,448 --> 00:27:34,448 Uh, I make sure that there's no serious diagnosis missed. 667 00:27:34,958 --> 00:27:39,368 Consequently, sometimes from the injury over a period of time through 668 00:27:39,368 --> 00:27:42,158 the litigation process or, or waiting for things to happen, they 669 00:27:42,158 --> 00:27:43,778 can have major depressive disorder. 670 00:27:43,868 --> 00:27:44,228 Mm. Yeah. 671 00:27:44,438 --> 00:27:49,688 Um, or treatable, uh, conditions which have evolved during 672 00:27:49,688 --> 00:27:50,708 the process of the claim. 673 00:27:50,708 --> 00:27:55,388 So one thing is to make sure what I'm seeing today, when the patient 674 00:27:55,388 --> 00:27:59,978 present, when the claimant presence to me is not because they're sick. 675 00:28:00,558 --> 00:28:04,488 From an actual condition, which is impairing how they're presenting. 676 00:28:04,488 --> 00:28:08,598 So that'll be my first bit to rule out, make sure that's sort of apportioned. 677 00:28:09,678 --> 00:28:12,828 Am I seeing a person with PTS who's not been picked up before? 678 00:28:12,828 --> 00:28:13,008 Yeah. 679 00:28:13,458 --> 00:28:15,018 You know, or depression. 680 00:28:15,018 --> 00:28:16,278 So that, that's one bit. 681 00:28:16,608 --> 00:28:21,738 I, I look at, um, the substance abuse that can be in the closet, sometimes 682 00:28:22,038 --> 00:28:26,778 missed easily, you know, you know, can be easily missed, easily missed. 683 00:28:26,778 --> 00:28:30,258 So I may spend some time understanding there's such a, once you have substances 684 00:28:30,258 --> 00:28:32,718 in the mix, it influences everything. 685 00:28:33,258 --> 00:28:38,238 You know, sleep, recovery, mood, motivation, and interaction with 686 00:28:38,268 --> 00:28:41,388 medications, pain medications that can be prescribed. 687 00:28:41,568 --> 00:28:45,558 Medications, overuse or alcohol or other substances. 688 00:28:46,068 --> 00:28:49,068 We look into that, make sure that is not playing a part in it. 689 00:28:49,398 --> 00:28:54,468 And then I tend to, um, beyond that look at any other medication side 690 00:28:54,468 --> 00:28:57,138 effects, which may be influencing their mood and stuff so forth. 691 00:28:57,768 --> 00:29:03,318 And then the backstory is so crucial, you know, how did they come to this point? 692 00:29:03,378 --> 00:29:07,368 What was going on preceding, what were the stresses and strains in 693 00:29:07,368 --> 00:29:12,618 their life and why did this snap from this apparently minuscule? 694 00:29:12,618 --> 00:29:16,278 For example, if it is a minuscule injury, why did this snap so badly? 695 00:29:16,368 --> 00:29:18,858 Did they have injuries before and how did they recover from it? 696 00:29:19,128 --> 00:29:21,858 It tells you so much if they have previous injuries. 697 00:29:21,948 --> 00:29:22,038 Yeah. 698 00:29:22,488 --> 00:29:25,788 Uh, childhood, youth, other, other, and how did they recover? 699 00:29:25,788 --> 00:29:26,718 What's the difference? 700 00:29:26,718 --> 00:29:31,548 And then, um, lots of times when we have such a detailed chat, I 701 00:29:31,548 --> 00:29:35,328 mean, I could be having a 90 minute interview, it's probably, uh, one of 702 00:29:35,388 --> 00:29:38,238 the longest interviews they might have had with a specialist, for example. 703 00:29:38,238 --> 00:29:42,108 And then slowly stuff comes up for the first, I have heard stories of trauma. 704 00:29:43,342 --> 00:29:47,182 Things which then get unravelled and, and, and things come up. 705 00:29:47,242 --> 00:29:52,342 And it becomes then apparent that some of the background stuff's kind 706 00:29:52,342 --> 00:29:55,582 of feeding into that, the sense of helplessness, which they may have 707 00:29:55,582 --> 00:30:00,752 experienced before at various points in say, bad relationships or Yeah. 708 00:30:00,982 --> 00:30:01,222 Yeah. 709 00:30:01,222 --> 00:30:02,212 Parental abuse. 710 00:30:02,212 --> 00:30:06,592 That sense of helplessness has kicked back after long, long time after being 711 00:30:06,592 --> 00:30:08,722 dormant, dormant for 20, 30 years. 712 00:30:08,722 --> 00:30:11,812 They were highly functional, motivated, had a sense of purpose 713 00:30:12,112 --> 00:30:13,762 being a provider or doing things. 714 00:30:14,092 --> 00:30:20,032 And then that helplessness, I used to work, um, one of the public hospital rehab 715 00:30:20,032 --> 00:30:26,392 units and sometimes spinal injuries or, or serious leg injuries, patients have to be 716 00:30:26,392 --> 00:30:28,912 immobile really for four weeks to months. 717 00:30:28,912 --> 00:30:29,182 Right. 718 00:30:29,302 --> 00:30:36,502 And it's very fascinating for me to see that all the ancient traumas and stresses 719 00:30:36,502 --> 00:30:38,392 and un 'cause they're sitting in the bed. 720 00:30:38,632 --> 00:30:39,052 Yeah. 721 00:30:39,082 --> 00:30:41,812 I mean now in modern day hospitals, we have television. 722 00:30:41,812 --> 00:30:42,832 It's a bit of distraction. 723 00:30:42,832 --> 00:30:44,272 But how much television can you watch? 724 00:30:44,332 --> 00:30:44,662 Not much. 725 00:30:44,662 --> 00:30:49,042 Eventually then they, they, they, we used to get referrals saying, yeah, 726 00:30:49,042 --> 00:30:52,642 this patient, patient's remembering this, they're dreaming about this stuff. 727 00:30:52,942 --> 00:30:53,752 They're not sleeping. 728 00:30:53,752 --> 00:30:54,472 And then yeah. 729 00:30:54,472 --> 00:30:57,142 The demons so speak, they come, come surface because the first 730 00:30:57,142 --> 00:30:58,522 time in life they're immobile. 731 00:30:58,582 --> 00:30:59,387 Yeah, yeah, yeah. 732 00:30:59,512 --> 00:31:00,682 And trapped in that. 733 00:31:00,832 --> 00:31:01,282 That's all. 734 00:31:01,282 --> 00:31:01,432 Yeah. 735 00:31:01,462 --> 00:31:01,762 Role. 736 00:31:02,602 --> 00:31:02,932 That makes sense. 737 00:31:02,932 --> 00:31:05,272 Isn't isn't it fascinating though that, uh, I was reading this book the 738 00:31:05,272 --> 00:31:10,102 other day and, and it's all about the, the natural way that the brain works. 739 00:31:10,432 --> 00:31:14,572 So the brain's natural state is chaos and entropy. 740 00:31:15,022 --> 00:31:17,662 And so therefore we're using all these other distractions. 741 00:31:17,992 --> 00:31:20,332 And you might, you may or might not believe this as a psychiatrist, 742 00:31:20,332 --> 00:31:21,262 but I thought it quite fascinating. 743 00:31:21,472 --> 00:31:24,892 We're using all these other distractions and the all things are life purpose, 744 00:31:24,892 --> 00:31:31,462 work, exercise, all of the things we do to stop the mind getting back to this chaos. 745 00:31:31,462 --> 00:31:34,312 Because as soon as we remove it and you're lying in a hospital bed with a 746 00:31:34,312 --> 00:31:38,002 broken leg or a broken spine and know things, your mind starts doing these 747 00:31:38,002 --> 00:31:41,512 things and replaying all the childhood drama traumas and all that sort of thing. 748 00:31:41,782 --> 00:31:45,292 And I think that's what we see in this medical-legal space of injured 749 00:31:45,292 --> 00:31:47,602 workers because their identity's gone. 750 00:31:47,602 --> 00:31:48,382 Everything is gone. 751 00:31:48,382 --> 00:31:53,152 And the mind just feeds into all of this paranoia and this entropy and chaos. 752 00:31:53,302 --> 00:31:53,422 Yeah. 753 00:31:53,422 --> 00:31:56,332 And actually what we need is we need purpose to stop the chaos. 754 00:31:56,362 --> 00:31:56,422 Yeah. 755 00:31:56,422 --> 00:32:00,012 Which is why we go out and work, or you go out and exercise or exercise 756 00:32:00,012 --> 00:32:03,352 and do all of these things and, and you need to do things that keep us busy. 757 00:32:03,472 --> 00:32:03,772 Yeah. 758 00:32:03,862 --> 00:32:04,192 Yeah. 759 00:32:04,192 --> 00:32:08,392 And do you think that, um, once claims close, people do recover? 760 00:32:09,390 --> 00:32:12,390 Does it help once the claim's over or look if they return? 761 00:32:12,630 --> 00:32:16,110 Um, uh, just so that's another thing we don't really talk about. 762 00:32:16,155 --> 00:32:17,795 I don't, well, we don't, I don't know. 763 00:32:17,815 --> 00:32:18,675 But you, because can say it. 764 00:32:18,745 --> 00:32:19,035 Yeah. 765 00:32:19,035 --> 00:32:19,195 Yeah. 766 00:32:19,255 --> 00:32:20,955 And I give my opinion and I sense, I hope they do. 767 00:32:20,955 --> 00:32:21,115 Yeah. 768 00:32:21,135 --> 00:32:24,060 And actually right here, I'll sometimes pick up things that have been missed 769 00:32:24,150 --> 00:32:27,780 by other specialists just because that's life and it happens both ways. 770 00:32:28,050 --> 00:32:28,920 So that is a good sense. 771 00:32:28,920 --> 00:32:30,480 Check having an IME to do that. 772 00:32:31,380 --> 00:32:35,400 I don't think so, because I think by the time they've gone through 773 00:32:35,400 --> 00:32:38,940 this process as good as the, and well-meaning that the process is, 774 00:32:38,940 --> 00:32:40,560 when it's designed, it takes too long. 775 00:32:41,190 --> 00:32:41,700 Yeah. 776 00:32:41,970 --> 00:32:43,275 The horse has bolted, so to speak. 777 00:32:43,545 --> 00:32:45,150 It's too hard to get back. 778 00:32:45,270 --> 00:32:45,690 Sadly. 779 00:32:45,690 --> 00:32:47,610 We've, we've run outta time almost Vanessa. 780 00:32:47,640 --> 00:32:49,290 Um, that was an amazing conversation. 781 00:32:49,290 --> 00:32:51,180 I really appreciate your time and expertise. 782 00:32:51,180 --> 00:32:55,530 What some of my key takeaways are, obviously about very individual 783 00:32:55,530 --> 00:32:57,390 factors that drive recovery here. 784 00:32:57,390 --> 00:32:57,450 Yeah. 785 00:32:57,810 --> 00:33:02,400 Um, and we, I hope we, we explored and canvas some of that and, and the 786 00:33:02,400 --> 00:33:06,060 interplay between Simon's world of the spine and your world of the mine 787 00:33:06,060 --> 00:33:07,710 and that w we were hoping to draw out. 788 00:33:07,920 --> 00:33:10,050 So thank you for your honesty and expertise. 789 00:33:10,110 --> 00:33:13,920 Thank you for giving your morning up to be with us and hopefully there's 790 00:33:13,920 --> 00:33:15,990 some key takeaways for case managers. 791 00:33:15,990 --> 00:33:16,260 Absolutely. 792 00:33:16,680 --> 00:33:18,870 You can find in terms of their medicolegal work. 793 00:33:18,870 --> 00:33:22,680 You can find both Dr. Simon and Dr. Shiva through, um, M-L-C-O-A. 794 00:33:22,740 --> 00:33:25,950 And I'd like to thank M-L-C-O-A for their collaboration. 795 00:33:26,130 --> 00:33:28,560 This is the law medicine and everything in between series. 796 00:33:28,830 --> 00:33:32,130 Uh, thank you Dr. Simon Clark and Dr uh, Shiva gpu. 797 00:33:32,190 --> 00:33:33,090 Thank you very much. 798 00:33:33,270 --> 00:33:33,480 Thank you. 799 00:33:33,480 --> 00:33:33,930 All the best. 800 00:33:33,930 --> 00:33:34,230 Yeah. 801 00:33:34,230 --> 00:33:35,115 Thank you very much. 802 00:33:35,115 --> 00:33:35,395 Thank you.