Between red and machine and man.
Speaker AJoin us on the grid as we consider questions about perfection, empathy and purpose.
Speaker AAre you just watching episode 166, Tron Aries.
Speaker AWelcome to the podcast that shares critical thinking for the entertained Christian.
Speaker AI'm Eve Franklin.
Speaker BI'm Tim Martin.
Speaker AAnd we're kind of, you know, sticking with the computer theme.
Speaker AI think we kind of have dealt with that a lot this year.
Speaker AThis year, yeah.
Speaker BBut that's to be fair, Hollywood is too.
Speaker AYes, yes.
Speaker AAnd I really wanted to do Tron because if you have been with us since the very beginning, Daniel Lewis and I actually started this podcast off of a non ayjw episode on the original movie Tron.
Speaker AAnd we also got super excited about Tron Legacy when it came out and did an initial reaction episode to that as well.
Speaker ASo we definitely encourage you to go back and listen to Daniel Lewis and I's reviews of those two movies.
Speaker AThey are very early on in our podcast, actually.
Speaker AI think they were Both published in 2010.
Speaker BYep.
Speaker BLink them in the show notes.
Speaker AWell, we'll definitely link to them in the show notes because I think I'm actually going to refer to them a few times as we talk about Aries.
Speaker AIt's hard to talk about Aries outside of the very small world of Tron.
Speaker AThere isn't a ton in that world.
Speaker ABut I think now that Disney has kind of killed a few other franchises, they're probably going to pick Tron back up and try to make some money off of it.
Speaker BCan't say as I blame them.
Speaker BI mean, that's how they do it.
Speaker BI just wish they'd come up with more original stuff.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AOr just do it better.
Speaker AThat's the problem is that's how they're destroying all of these franchises.
Speaker AThey're picking up something that was excellent and they're just destroying it by not doing it as well.
Speaker ASadly.
Speaker ABut Tron was originally a Disney property.
Speaker AAnd if you go back into the making of Tron, I'm not entirely sure it would have ever been a movie if it hadn't been for Disney because they were a little bit more cutting edge back in the 80s and they were willing to sink money into projects that were very highly experimental.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AAnd Tron was extremely experimental.
Speaker AThey were figuring out how to do it as they did it.
Speaker AAnd back then they didn't have computer animation.
Speaker AAnd I thought it was interesting.
Speaker ADid you catch this in your research that the movie Tron was denied an Oscar?
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BAcademy Award.
Speaker AYeah, it was denied the nomination.
Speaker ANot even just the Award, but it was denied the nomination because they thought they had cheated on their special effects by using computers.
Speaker ABut.
Speaker BAnd look at us now.
Speaker ALook at us now.
Speaker AWe can't do special effects without computers.
Speaker AIt's crazy.
Speaker AOkay, so before we get too far into our reactions about this, I do, of course, want to mention the music.
Speaker AAnd I'm gonna kind of go into it a slightly different way because Ares and I. Ares, the main character of Tron.
Speaker AAres.
Speaker AIs he the main character?
Speaker AI guess he sorta is.
Speaker ASorry, Bunny trail.
Speaker AWe share a music preference which I thought was very interesting.
Speaker AHe mentions in the movie that he is actually when he's being questioned at one point by the Flynn character that's in the old server.
Speaker AAnd we just.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AThe Flynn consciousness about what his favorite music was.
Speaker AAnd he had to contrast Mozart and Depeche Mode.
Speaker AAnd he came out saying that he actually preferred Depeche Mode and asked why.
Speaker AHe was like, I don't really know why.
Speaker AIt's just a feeling.
Speaker AAnd so if you ask me why I like Depeche Mode, I will just have to reply, I don't know.
Speaker AIt's just a feeling.
Speaker AThey do actually play teensy bit of Depeche Mode while they're in the car together at some point where he's confessing to Yves Kim that.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AIs his favorite bin.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AAnd I actually started singing along in this theater because I like that song.
Speaker AJust can't get enough.
Speaker BDid you get weird looks?
Speaker AI didn't do it loud enough to get weird looks.
Speaker AAnd it's a very loud movie.
Speaker ASo I don't think it.
Speaker BAnybody heard me, that's for sure.
Speaker BIt is a loud movie.
Speaker AIt is a very loud movie.
Speaker AI know a lot of people are saying that you should see this movie on the best big screen you have because the best part of this movie is the effects and sound and everything.
Speaker ABut I will have to disagree with most people that I did not care for the soundtrack.
Speaker AIt's not often that I say that about a movie that I just don't like the soundtrack.
Speaker ABut Nine Inch Nails, to me, the majority of it sounds like nails on a chalkboard.
Speaker AIt's very discordant.
Speaker AAnd the.
Speaker AThese sounds are sometimes.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker APainful in the music.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BIt's hard not to try to compare it to Tron Legacy, where the soundtrack was done by Daft Punk.
Speaker BSo I feel like they were trying to follow a theme.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BAnd Nine Inch Nails, because I was listening to the soundtrack earlier today, they clearly wanted to go with the techno style that was daft.
Speaker BPunk.
Speaker BBut then they put their own spin on it and their own spin was painful.
Speaker BYou know, like getting your hair caught in a fan.
Speaker AVery painful.
Speaker AVery painful.
Speaker AThere was a bit of trance feel to it as well.
Speaker AAnd there were parts of it that made me think of the Sucker Punch soundtrack.
Speaker AI don't know whether you've ever listened to that.
Speaker AThere was a lot of I've seen.
Speaker BThe movie, but I don't think I recall the soundtrack.
Speaker AThere was a lot of like songs that had been redone in trance punk style for Sucker Punch.
Speaker AAnd there was just a lot of themes in the Nine Inch Nails version of Tron.
Speaker AI guess that just made me kept thinking of Sucker Punch, which, believe it or not, we're not going to keep doing old movies because Gattaca didn't do so well.
Speaker AYou guys didn't want to get our review of Gattaca, so we'll just have to.
Speaker BIt's a shame because we did tie it to current event.
Speaker AI know.
Speaker BOh, well, you win some, you lose some.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AI think Sucker Punch would make a good movie to discuss, but it is super old, so I don't think we will go there.
Speaker ABut that's a bunny trail.
Speaker AWe.
Speaker AWe'll get back to Tron Aries.
Speaker ASo let's play a.
Speaker AA very little bit of the soundtrack.
Speaker AI. I won't torture.
Speaker AOkay, now that we've got that over with.
Speaker AWhat I liked about Tron Ares.
Speaker ALet's talk about what I did like about Tron Ares.
Speaker AThe soundtrack was not one of the things I liked, but I did like the way they merged the two worlds.
Speaker AI think this was something that was worked on very.
Speaker AEven from like the original Tron, the very end of Tron where they kind of like merged.
Speaker AWhere you were flying into the city and the lights kind of look like the grid.
Speaker AI think they were always trying to create that merge of the two worlds, the digital and reality.
Speaker AAnd I think that Tron Ares did that in a whole new way.
Speaker AYeah, and I really appreciated that.
Speaker AI liked that part of Tron and I think that they carried on that understanding that I think the big tech developers early on in the 70s and 80s, I think they foresaw this happening.
Speaker AThey just didn't understand how easily it was going to happen.
Speaker AWhere computers took over our world and they already are.
Speaker AWe don't have to have an artificial intelligence grow a body and come into our world for it to take over our world.
Speaker ABut I think that Tron was very foresighted in.
Speaker AI mean, couldn't say it came out in the early 80s.
Speaker AI mean, when you think back of what computer tech existed back then, it's just mind boggling what it's become now.
Speaker BThe personal computer was a brand spanking new concept less than 10 years old.
Speaker AOh, yeah, Most people didn't have one.
Speaker AThey were not a household thing.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AIt was just the techie geeks, people who bother.
Speaker AAnd they usually had to build them because there was.
Speaker AI can't remember when the first home computer came out, but that's around the.
Speaker BTime I got The Texas Instruments TI 99.4A.
Speaker AYeah, yeah.
Speaker AMy dad was building his computers back, you know, got all the components and installed BASIC A and dos.
Speaker AAnyway, they had no real vision of what computers would be.
Speaker ABut when you look at Tron, the original Tron, you can see that they.
Speaker AThey sort of knew where it was going to go, that it was going to be answering questions about humanity and creation and creators and all kinds of things that I think we should be asking those questions more nowadays than they were back in the 80s.
Speaker ASo that was one of the things I liked.
Speaker AI came out of the movie really liking.
Speaker AI thought it was kind of like a Pinocchio.
Speaker AIt was almost like Terminator meets Pinocchio.
Speaker ABut when I got to work, several of my younger colleagues at work were really dissing the movie.
Speaker AI don't think it hit Gen Alpha and Gen X very well.
Speaker BHad they seen it?
Speaker AYes, they had gone to see it and they did not like it.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AOne of my co workers brought up the fact that it had no redemption arcs.
Speaker AShe thought the characters were super shallow.
Speaker AAnd they really hated the end of the movie because they thought that Julian should have had a redemption at the end when his mom was killed.
Speaker AHe should have like turned on his machine and instead he joined it.
Speaker ASo they felt.
Speaker AAnd then because of the lack of redemption, they felt like a lot of the characters were extraneous, like they weren't really necessary.
Speaker ALike the Incom characters who were hacking into the Dillinger to stop Athena and all that.
Speaker AThey thought that was an extraneous plot that didn't need to be there because Julian should have shut down the machine himself.
Speaker AAnd I sort of see their point.
Speaker AI mean, yeah, that would have been a great redemption for Julian after his, you know, his creation killed his mother.
Speaker AObviously.
Speaker BWorrying about spoilers, I think Julian's intended to be the villain in the next movie.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker AAnd.
Speaker AAnd that was.
Speaker AI think one of the things that they hated was the fact that the whole reason why Julian didn't get a redemption arc was Purely because they needed a villain for the next movie.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BYou know, in the original, though, Dillinger.
Speaker BThe original Dillinger, he didn't have a redemption arc either.
Speaker ANo.
Speaker BAnd in Legacy, who was the villain in Legacy?
Speaker AClue.
Speaker BIt was Clue, Right?
Speaker BHe did.
Speaker BHe had a redemption arc.
Speaker BBut I mean, the whole point.
Speaker BNot the whole point, but one of the points of Legacy was actually revisited in this.
Speaker BAnd it was, you know, the directive versus purpose, which is the last theme that we'll be talking about.
Speaker AYep, yep.
Speaker ACarries over.
Speaker ASo those were some of the criticisms that I've already heard.
Speaker AI thought it was interesting that this movie completely missed the mark of fan predictions.
Speaker AIf you go and look at videos that came out like a month ago of fans anticipating what Tron Ares was going to be about based on the trailer, the previews that were available, they were completely off the mark.
Speaker AAnd I thought it was interesting that they teased a different movie.
Speaker AI think if you watch the previews after you've watched the movie, you'll go, oh, that was not the movie I thought I was going to get from the previews.
Speaker ASo they were teasing a different movie.
Speaker BI remember the first teaser I saw for it.
Speaker BI thought it was going to be an invasion of programs from the grid into the real world.
Speaker BAnd it sort of had that.
Speaker BBut they played it up a lot more in the teasers, right?
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAnd it made it look like Ares was going to be the villain, which he ended up not being the villain.
Speaker ASo I think that people were really anticipating, based on how Legacy had ended up, they were anticipating a completely different movie.
Speaker AAnd interestingly enough, this is a bunny trail, but I think it's an interesting one.
Speaker AWe were talking at work today.
Speaker ASomebody had brought up the fact that that happened with Endgame as well, between Infinity War and Endgame, that a lot of people were anticipating how it was going to end.
Speaker AAnd then the movie gave us something completely different.
Speaker BOh, yeah, they did the jump ahead that nobody was expecting.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AAnd so when we were on this, I work with a lot of Christians, and so the topic came up because we were talking about Christian end times debates and the fact that we're looking at it kind of like people look at the sequel of a movie before it's come out and how we think it's going to be made, and then the creators do something completely different.
Speaker ASo we were applying that to end times debates.
Speaker AAs to, you know, we all have this anticipation of how, you know, things.
Speaker BAre going to pan out.
Speaker BOur eschatology is going to be completely off the mark.
Speaker BWhen Jesus Christ comes back, I think.
Speaker AThat we're going to be pleasantly surprised.
Speaker BGood Lord, I hope so.
Speaker ABut that's.
Speaker AThat's a debate we don't want to get into.
Speaker ABut I just thought it was funny that we were able to, because it kind of implies, you know, it's like people.
Speaker AYou see the previews, which is what we get in the Bible, is previews of what the end times is going to be.
Speaker AAnd we're like, trying to put the pieces together, trying to figure out, okay, how's it gonna look?
Speaker AHow's it gonna work?
Speaker BIt's not even a preview.
Speaker BIt's a teaser.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ASo.
Speaker ABut we're not gonna talk about eschatology.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AIt's an interesting parallel, all that to say, my final point, and before I hand off to Tim, is that I'm wondering why we're still calling it Tron.
Speaker ABecause Tron was a character in the original Tron, and he had a brief appearance in Tron Legacy, and he's not in this movie at all.
Speaker ASo.
Speaker BSo the original Tron was written by Bruce Boxleitner's character, right?
Speaker AAlan.
Speaker BYeah, Alan something.
Speaker AAlan something, yeah.
Speaker AHe was a security program, and it.
Speaker BWas in the movie.
Speaker BIt was played by, you know, Bruce Box Lightner as well.
Speaker BI feel like they are trying to get Jared Leto, or rather Ares, to pick up the mission of Tron, but it fell short for that, at least.
Speaker BI don't think Ares made the Tron connection.
Speaker BIt's more like Tron World.
Speaker BAries.
Speaker AYeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker AAnd.
Speaker AAnd see, that's the thing is, is that a lot of the fan predictions for this movie were based on Legacy taking a bigger part in the story of Aries.
Speaker BAnd I expected that, too.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AI really feel like when they were planning out Aries, they were like, oh, Legacy introduced a bunch of things we really don't want to do.
Speaker ASo let's just make this a sequel to Tron and forget about Legacy.
Speaker AAnd then at the end, they were like, oh, but you know what?
Speaker AThe fans are going to expect some kind of tie in to Legacy.
Speaker ASo let's throw it in as a teaser during the credits.
Speaker AThe real diehards are going to see it because they're going to sit through the credits even though the music's awful.
Speaker BI don't think they said that.
Speaker BI would like to think that this was the Infinity War to the upcoming endgame type thing, and that all the stuff about this movie that I couldn't quite wrap my head around will be addressed in the sequel.
Speaker BIf there is A sequel.
Speaker BI don't know.
Speaker BI see lots of talk about it being a flop.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BBut I don't know if those are just, you know, clickbait headlines or not, but I had a problem with Tron Ares.
Speaker BNot a good one, not a bad one.
Speaker BIt was just that everywhere I expected it to go, it didn't.
Speaker BIt didn't go the direction I wanted it to.
Speaker BI felt like it teased stuff that it never brought back.
Speaker BThere's a scene early on where Ares is fascinated by a lightning bug, a firefly.
Speaker BAnd I figured that would be a Chekhov's gun that they would bring back later in the movie.
Speaker BNever happened.
Speaker AYou were looking for way too much foreshadowing here.
Speaker BI was.
Speaker AThis is the 21st century.
Speaker AWe don't do subtle and foreshadowing that anymore.
Speaker BAnd, you know, the rain, it's one of Ares big growing moments at the same time in the movie, actually, was when he felt rain on his face.
Speaker BAnd then two thirds of the way through the movie, his successor program named Athena, feels the water from a sprinkler system, and she gets this look on her face like they're about to give her redemption.
Speaker BAnd then it's gone.
Speaker AI felt like she would have gotten there sooner or later.
Speaker AI think he didn't immediately click with the rain.
Speaker AIt was later.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker AAnd he had.
Speaker AIt was just one of the many moments where he grew.
Speaker AAnd I think they were trying to subtly imply that given enough time and experience, Athena would have made the same growth, I think.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BAll right.
Speaker BSo, yeah, I had trouble coming up with the themes that I wanted to talk about.
Speaker BNot because there weren't any, because there were plenty.
Speaker BIt was because they all felt just out of cognitive reach for me, I guess.
Speaker BSo, yeah, It's.
Speaker BThis movie bothered me, but not in a bad way.
Speaker BSo I felt like they were holding back some of the lore, like I mentioned.
Speaker BHolding back some of the lore for a perceived sequel, I hope, which may not happen.
Speaker AYeah, right.
Speaker AI looked it up, and it says Aries is not making money.
Speaker AIt's a disappointing opening weekend, grossing33.5 million domestically and 60.5 million globally, which is a major financial loss given its reported $180 million budget.
Speaker BI thought it would do better on an international market than that.
Speaker BI really did, honestly.
Speaker AI think it's a nostalgic movie for our generation, and I don't think it's hitting well with the younger generation.
Speaker ASo, sadly.
Speaker BYeah, yeah, they've.
Speaker BI feel like they changed the tone even more so than between Tron And Tron Legacy.
Speaker BTron Legacy wasn't qu a sequel to Tron in the way that I would have expected it.
Speaker BBut it was decent.
Speaker BIt was good.
Speaker BYou know, I enjoyed that one too.
Speaker BBut Tron Ares.
Speaker BI felt like.
Speaker BWhat was that phrase Sarah Palin used?
Speaker BLipstick on a pig.
Speaker BI felt like they had this idea and they ran with it and at some point they should have turned around and said, okay, this, this really isn't working, guys.
Speaker BLet's rejigger this and come up with something new.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BAnd they didn't do it.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BAnd I mentioned I was surprised that Sam and Cora weren't in this one.
Speaker BI hope it's part of the.
Speaker BThe sequel.
Speaker BThe thought occurred to me and you had corrected me.
Speaker BJeff Bridges in this one looks very old to me.
Speaker BAnd we did the math.
Speaker BHe's 76.
Speaker BIt's possible that they wanted to give him his farewell before going to the next movie where he may not be in acting shape.
Speaker BBut yeah, I was looking for a lot more that wasn't there.
Speaker BThe master control program had the triangular identity disk.
Speaker BSo I was watching all the identity discs because when Eve Kim came into the grid, she had a circle on the outside and a hex on the inside.
Speaker BAnd I thought, oh, this is something.
Speaker BWhen Dillinger comes in at the end, the identity disk he gets is the original identity disk.
Speaker BThe frisbee.
Speaker BIt's the trussed up frisbee from the original Tron movie.
Speaker AThe master control program's original.
Speaker BNo, because the master control program didn't have an identity disk in Tron.
Speaker BIt was Tron that had the original identity disk.
Speaker AWell, it looked like he was becoming the master control program from the original Tron.
Speaker AThat's what it looked like to me.
Speaker BYeah, it did.
Speaker BYou're right, it did.
Speaker BBut it was the frisbee shape.
Speaker BIt was a painted Frisbee is what it was.
Speaker BThe one last thing that stood out for me was the movie made a big plot point of a 29 minute timer on programs coming from the grid into the real world.
Speaker BBut then they seemed to play really loose with it.
Speaker BThe facility where Dillinger brought every program into the real world was way out in the boonies.
Speaker BAnd somehow he managed to bring them in, get there to the city, and then they can still spend, you know, 45 minutes in the city in that 29 minute window.
Speaker BI don't know how they managed to do that.
Speaker BI felt like they just.
Speaker BThey put that in there to provide a sense of urgency.
Speaker BBut then it didn't play out.
Speaker BI really Think they should have made it 45 minutes or 59 minutes?
Speaker B59 minutes would have been perfect.
Speaker AWhy did it need to be 30 minutes instead of an hour?
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BAnd that part actually bugged me, especially the final scene where Athena is chasing down Eve Kim.
Speaker BThat entire part lasted so much longer than 29 minutes.
Speaker BAnd, well, in the movie, it was.
Speaker AProbably less than 29 minutes, but, yeah.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BI wonder how long it was in the movie.
Speaker AIt wasn't a quarter of the movie, I could guarantee.
Speaker BGood point.
Speaker BJust felt that much longer.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BOverall, I enjoyed the movie, even though I came out unsettled because I didn't know where it was going.
Speaker BI felt like I had just gone through a fun house, you know, where.
Speaker AIt was an experience.
Speaker BNothing is as it seems.
Speaker BSo, yeah, it was solid.
Speaker BIt was a good movie.
Speaker BJared Leto, who I don't really have a lot of experience with, he did a good job.
Speaker BI thought the actress who played Eve Kim was very engaging.
Speaker BI liked her sidekick.
Speaker BHe did the humor well.
Speaker BAnd, of course, having, you know, quicksilver in there, that's always good, Peter Evans.
Speaker BBut, yeah, it was worth the ride.
Speaker BI wish it had done better in the theaters, honestly.
Speaker BI think it was worth it.
Speaker BI hope to see where they were going to take this.
Speaker AYeah, well, if it doesn't make money, I doubt that Disney will keep it up, but we'll see.
Speaker AWell, before we go into our discussion, you know, where we actually talk about themes.
Speaker ASo I think we've completely spoiled the movie already.
Speaker BYeah, we have.
Speaker AI guess we just assume everybody is either going to see the movie or has seen the movie or is not going to see the movie and doesn't care about spoilers.
Speaker BSo you remember when we used to go out of our way to avoid spoilers in the first part and then give a spoiler warning?
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker ANo, not anymore.
Speaker AAll right, so before we go into that discussion, I do want to ask that you consider supporting our podcast.
Speaker AYou can do so by going to patreon.com Are you just watching?
Speaker AWe want to thank our current patrons, Isaiah Santiano, Craig Hardy, Stephen Brown II and David Lefton, for their generous monthly support.
Speaker AWithout them, we could not continue to do this podcast.
Speaker AAnd, you know, with AI and website and all this stuff, you know, our costs are actually increasing, so we could really use a couple more supporters if you.
Speaker BWe could indeed could find it in.
Speaker AYour heart to give us a small amount monthly.
Speaker AThat would help us out so much.
Speaker BAnd, you know, we would like to take the podcast to the next level and get it onto YouTube as well with some video.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BBut, but that.
Speaker BYeah, that costs money, too.
Speaker AYep.
Speaker AAnyway, if you can find it in your heart and you enjoy what we're doing, we would really appreciate adding a couple.
Speaker AWell, more than a couple, but a couple would be the bare minimum supporters to our patrons.
Speaker ASo anyway, if you can consider doing that, you can get to that once again by going to are you justwatching.com patreon or patreon.com are you just watching?
Speaker AYou can also share your feedback.
Speaker AYou could comment on the show Notes, which will be at areyoujustwatching.com 16 6.
Speaker AYou can also call 513-818-2959 to leave a voicemail.
Speaker AOr you can text that number.
Speaker AIt's a Google voice number.
Speaker AYou can email feedbackyoujustwatching.com or you can join our Facebook discussion group, which you can get to by going to are you just watching.com community.
Speaker AYou could check out our page as well.
Speaker AAll you have to do is look for are you just watching on Facebook?
Speaker AAnd you'll probably find both of them.
Speaker AAnd you can also join us on Discord, which you can get to by going to are you just watching.com discord to get an invite to our server.
Speaker AAnd we'd love to see you there.
Speaker AAll right, so you can't talk about Tron Ares without talking about the permanence code, because that's kind of the quest item through the whole movie.
Speaker AEverybody's looking for the permanence code.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AIt's interesting because I like the fact that when Ares finally meets Flynn to get the permanence code from him, Flynn admits that it's the impermanence code because life isn't permanent.
Speaker AAnd the whole thing was them wanting to bring things from the digital world and make them last past the 29 minutes.
Speaker ABut as we all know, at least in the sin cursed world we live in, life is not permanent.
Speaker ASo it makes more sense to call it the impermanence code.
Speaker ABecause Pinocchio becomes a man or boy, a real boy legacy.
Speaker AGoing back in time to the movie before this one that came out in 2010.
Speaker AIt spent a lot of time talking about creating a perfect world in the Grid.
Speaker ASo Flynn had fled to the Grid because he'd found, I guess, the real world to be less than perfect.
Speaker AAnd he wanted to create a perfect world on the Grid, created instead a villain.
Speaker AAnd Clue, which was actually one of the good guys in the original Tron.
Speaker AHe was only a product of his programming, which he couldn't think for himself, all he could go was by the directives that he had been given.
Speaker AAnd he was told he was programmed to make the grid a perfect place.
Speaker AAnd so he turned it into a dystopia of I guess what you would call a totalitarian regime, you know, where the elite rule and everybody else must succumb to their direction and plug in where they are told to go.
Speaker AAnd there's no freedom, no chance of chaos entering that perfection.
Speaker AAnd that's when humans drive to make things perfect.
Speaker AThat's typically the way it turns out, unfortunately.
Speaker ASo in Tron Aries and by the way, already plugged it once, but you can hear our discussion on that in our initial reaction 14, which goes all the way back to our second year of the podcast.
Speaker ABut it still exists.
Speaker AYou can still go and listen to it.
Speaker AIn Tron Aries we see a different form of the same desire.
Speaker ASo we get this like super fast, like headlines and news articles and all kinds of stuff thrown at you.
Speaker AAt the beginning of Aries that kind.
Speaker BOf takes you through exposition dump.
Speaker AYeah, at the beginning of the movie that kind of takes you through the history of Incom and their rival Dillinger.
Speaker AWas it Inc or something like that?
Speaker BYeah, I think it was just Dillinger.
Speaker ASystems and one of the things that they bring out.
Speaker AAnd we get it not only there, but we also get it later when Ares is been given the directive to find Eve Kim.
Speaker AAnd so he basically saturates himself with her life in order to find where she might be.
Speaker AAnd so we also get another kind of data dump about Yves Kim there and her family and all that.
Speaker AAnd it turns out that the Kim sisters at one point acquired ENCOM after the Flynn's kind of vanished.
Speaker AFirst there was the first Flynn who vanished and then the second Flynn who vanished and.
Speaker AYeah, and there is a third Flynn in this movie who is a character.
Speaker AAnd I'm not exactly sure how he is related to the other two Flynns, but he looks Indian, so it's kind of weird.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker ASo the Kim sisters have this vision of their vision for bringing the, you know, finding Flynn's permanence code because Flynn was the one who found it, but then he hid it probably because he thought the world couldn't handle it, which they probably can't.
Speaker ABut anyway, the Kims wanted it in order to make the world a better place.
Speaker AThey didn't want to make it a perfect place, but they wanted to make the world a better place because they wanted to use digital code to feed the hungry and house and clothe the poor and all of this kind of stuff.
Speaker ASo very altruistic goals for making the world a better place.
Speaker AAnd at the same time, we see their rival corporation who is willing to do just about anything to get the permanence code, including kill people.
Speaker AThey want to build war machines, basically expendable soldiers and that kind of thing.
Speaker ASo these are the two choices that we're given.
Speaker AVery black and white.
Speaker AOr.
Speaker AExcuse me, I'm sorry, blue and red.
Speaker AVery red and blue.
Speaker BVery contrasting colors.
Speaker BYes.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker AOne of the things that I wanted to take note of is that even though this movie deals with it in a very red and blue way, where they're contrasting two distinct good and bad, which you kind of see that come through in Aries character because he kind of develops his empathy through absorbing Eve's life.
Speaker AAnd so he learns altruism from her, basically, and empathy.
Speaker ABut one of the things that I want to just bring out a little bit is that these two things are not necessarily direct contradictions of each other.
Speaker ASo I don't feel like the movie really explores that.
Speaker AThere's pros and cons to both sides.
Speaker AYeah, it's just.
Speaker AIt's very like, this is good, this is evil.
Speaker AAnd the thing that I think was so great about Legacy is that it took something that, on the outward appearance, seem like it was a good goal, like making the perfect world in the grid.
Speaker AThat, you know, Flynn didn't start out trying to create a villain, but he did.
Speaker AAnd I think that in this instance, this movie kind of lost that subtlety of the fact that altruism of the Kim sisters brand is not really that good for society.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AThere's a lot of cons to it.
Speaker AYou just can't spend money on people who are lost in poverty.
Speaker AYou can't just throw food at them.
Speaker AWhat is it that that old saying is, you give a man a fish and he will eat for a day.
Speaker AYou teach a man how to fish and eat for a lifetime.
Speaker AAnd I think that the Kim sisters brand of altruism is actually deadly to culture because.
Speaker AAnd they don't explore that at all.
Speaker AI mean, the whole concept of creating food for people and creating housing and clothing and it's all handouts.
Speaker AIt's all giving them the things that you think they need without making them have any kind of personal accountability or responsibility for getting those things.
Speaker BYeah, they were talking about creating food for famine areas, but the famine areas are famine because of some type of problem with a climate.
Speaker ARight, right.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BJust like in biblical times, God stopped the rain Right.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BSo I think they were just using this red and blue, good and bad, as a framing device.
Speaker BBut I think you're right.
Speaker BI think that they could have delved into this quite a bit more and come out with a better story.
Speaker AWell, they dealt with that in Legacy.
Speaker AIt's like the lesson that they taught you in Legacy.
Speaker ALike, the whole lesson of Legacy lost on Aries is like a lost lesson.
Speaker AIt's like they were like, oh, well, we didn't care about what we were saying in Legacy.
Speaker ALet's go do it and make it the good thing.
Speaker AMaking the world better, Making the world a perfect place.
Speaker ANow it's the good thing.
Speaker AIt's the altruistic thing to do.
Speaker AAnd it just doesn't lead to pretty things.
Speaker AEvery time we try to do that in our societies, it always leads to a totalitarian regime.
Speaker AThere's just no way to create that kind of world without immense amount of control over the people.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BAnd sadly, I was just gonna say homelessness is not just a financial issue.
Speaker BIt's a mental issue.
Speaker BAnd you can't fix one without the other.
Speaker ARight, right.
Speaker ASo it may look good on the surface, but it's just providing comfort without the transformation that's necessary to make people, you know, I guess, have responsibility for their own needs.
Speaker AAnd sadly, they did not learn the lessons of legacy in Aries, and they made what was the bad guy in Legacy, Basically the good guy in Aries.
Speaker BI sort of questioned whether or not they even watched Legacy.
Speaker AInteresting.
Speaker BNot a lot of call out to it in Tron.
Speaker BAres.
Speaker BI mean, really almost like it never happened.
Speaker BI was thinking, too, how they were trying to make a perfect world.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BOne of the big things in the movie was when they discovered the permanence code.
Speaker BIt was somewhere north of the Arctic Circle.
Speaker BAnd they set up this test where they created an orange tree, which, of course, is a callback to the original Tron movie, where they sent an orange back and forth and they put a camera on this orange tree, and it's still there, you know, halfway through the movie, showing that the permanence has taken.
Speaker BBut they're trying to interject their solution into a system that God created to be whole.
Speaker BAnd it just.
Speaker BIt won't just plug in like this.
Speaker BIt's just going to end up causing more problems.
Speaker BLike you said, the world was perfect when God created it.
Speaker BIt's in Genesis 1:3.
Speaker BGod saw all that he had made, and it was very good indeed.
Speaker BBut then, you know, Eve ate from the tree and.
Speaker BAnd said, hey, this is Good.
Speaker BTry it.
Speaker BAnd Adam did it and everything went to pot.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AWell, that's very interesting that we have another Eve here and an Eve that brought in the imperfection in the world.
Speaker BThree Eves in one podcast.
Speaker AYou suppose they chose her name on purpose?
Speaker BYes.
Speaker BOh, maybe.
Speaker AEve Kim.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BI don't know.
Speaker AIt's not really an Asian name and.
Speaker BIt did have a fruit tree in it.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BSo, yeah, it would be hard to say that they didn't do it on purpose, but I don't see the completion of that symbolism in there.
Speaker BAt no point does she become a mother to creation.
Speaker ANo, I don't think it was mother creation.
Speaker AIt was bringing in a curse.
Speaker AIn a way, she was.
Speaker AThe way that the permanence code brought the digital world into the real world.
Speaker BMaybe that's what they're setting up for the next one is how badly it goes for her.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BWhen Adam and Eve ate of the fruit God said in Genesis 3:17, because you have listened to your wife and ate from the tree, about which I commanded you, do not eat.
Speaker BThe ground is cursed because of you.
Speaker BNot just Adam and Eve.
Speaker BI mean, they were thrown out of the garden and kept out by a guy with a flaming sword.
Speaker BBut the entirety of creation fell because of this.
Speaker BAnd the Kim's thinking that they could turn around, or Encom thinking that they could turn around and fix it.
Speaker BYou know, it's not going to work.
Speaker BIt's a human effort, and humans are not going to fix sin.
Speaker BThe best we can do is witness in hopes that the common grace becomes good fruit in new believers.
Speaker BYou know, I understand where Eve, Kim and Encom were coming from.
Speaker BWe would love to fix everything.
Speaker BI'm not saying we shouldn't try to make things better.
Speaker BWe definitely should.
Speaker BScripture tells us that we have a longing to restore creation.
Speaker BIt's just that we're not going to be able to do it.
Speaker BRomans 8, 20, 21 says, for the creation was subjected to futility, not willingly, but because of him who subjected it, in the hope that creation itself will also be set free from the bondage to decay and into the glorious freedom of God's children.
Speaker BAnd that will happen, but it's not going to be from anything we do.
Speaker BIt's going to be from what God has already done.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BSo we're never going to achieve perfection.
Speaker AThis side of heaven.
Speaker BGood point.
Speaker BYes.
Speaker BWe will not achieve perfection in this life.
Speaker BNo one, no matter how hard they work, will be able to get to it.
Speaker BBut eventually it's going to come.
Speaker BIt will come When God restores creation, Revelation 21.
Speaker B1 says, Then I saw a new heaven and a new earth, for the first heaven and the first earth had passed away.
Speaker BSo until God comes again, until Christ comes again specifically, and makes heaven and earth anew, our task is to make the world better and.
Speaker BAnd be a witness for Christ.
Speaker BWe're to act with compassion and humility and point towards the one who will make it perfect.
Speaker AYeah, yeah.
Speaker AI mean, that.
Speaker AI think that's a great takeaway from this entire impermanence code thing.
Speaker ABecause if you think about it, what Flynn made the point that it wasn't permanence code, it was impermanence code.
Speaker AAnd that he basically told Aries that if he absorbed this code, that he would have only one life.
Speaker AAnd that's what we each have.
Speaker AWe only have one life.
Speaker AAnd after that, the judgment.
Speaker AAnd Aries was okay with that.
Speaker AHe was like, you know, I have somebody to save.
Speaker AI only need one life to do it.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker ASo, yeah, I think that you're right that, you know, that should be our takeaway, is that we cannot make this world perfect, but we should be living to God's glory, because each of us as impermanent as we are because of the curse, we have only one life to live.
Speaker AAnd after that comes the judgment.
Speaker AAnd that kind of brings to mind, you know, what I think is a good synopsis of this entire thing comes from Hebrews 9.
Speaker ASo this is Hebrews 9, 23, 28.
Speaker ATherefore, it was necessary for the copies of the things in the heavens to be purified with these sacrifices, but the heavenly things themselves to be purified with better sacrifices than these.
Speaker AFor Christ did not enter a sanctuary made with hands only a model of the true one, but into heaven itself, so that he might now appear in the presence of God.
Speaker AFor us, he did not do this to offer himself many times, as the high priest enters the sanctuary yearly with the blood of another.
Speaker AOtherwise he would have had to suffer many times since the foundation of the world.
Speaker ABut now he has appeared one time at the end of the ages for the removal of sin by the sacrifice of himself.
Speaker AAnd just as it is appointed for people to die once and after this judgment, so also Christ, having been offered once to bear the sins of many, will appear a second time, not to bear sin, but to bring salvation to those who are waiting for him.
Speaker ASo that is our source of a perfect world, is that everything up until Christ was a copy of what was in heaven?
Speaker AIt was a foreshadowing of what Christ was going to do on the cross.
Speaker AAnd he fulfilled that.
Speaker AAnd so when he comes again, he's going to bring perfection to the world because he is perfect.
Speaker AYeah, I think that's a great synopsis of that entire theme.
Speaker BI agree.
Speaker AI kind of thought of the next theme as coming under the impermanence code that we just talked about.
Speaker ABut I think it actually fits better under a theme of artificial intelligence.
Speaker ABecause one of the things that we see happening with Aries, not just because of him gaining the impermanence code, which makes him permanent in the real world or impermanent with one life left to live, basically makes him human, but he was already becoming human before that, just in the way he was interacting with the world, the way he was thinking.
Speaker AAnd so one of the, I think, biggest questions that Tron Aries raises, in a way it was already raising it in previous iterations of Tron, is what makes us human?
Speaker AThe reason why it raises that question is because.
Speaker AAnd I think we've kind of already dealt with this before in some of our more recent reviews.
Speaker AOne of the things that was raised in some of the previous Tron movies was this topic of artificial intelligence or sentience within the machine.
Speaker AA lot of the previews for Aries makes it look like Aries has become this malicious artificial intelligence who takes on a body and brings havoc to the real world.
Speaker ABasically that's.
Speaker AAnd his name kind of contributes to that too, because Aries is the God of war.
Speaker ABut that was what, you know, everybody was kind of thinking was that this movie was going to go.
Speaker AInstead, we found a large language model, because that's basically how are started out, was that he was created to learn off of the information given him and then, you know, basically do what our large language model AIs do for us today and, you know, pull in all the information and give a result based on that.
Speaker ASo they're basically implying that with enough knowledge combined with enough real world experience, which was what Ares was getting every time he got his 29 minutes in the real world, when Dillinger would bring him out as his soldier demo for people.
Speaker AIf you combine enough of that, then you turn out with a Pinocchio who wants to become a real man.
Speaker AIt's interesting because we also see Eve explaining to Aries what it means to be human.
Speaker AThe juxtaposition of love and loss, and how the love can actually bring both joy and pain at the same time.
Speaker AAnd all of these experiences that make us human, but we don't know for sure.
Speaker AI mean, does that really make us humans?
Speaker ADoes experience is it our experiences that make us human.
Speaker AAnd then you add to that this twist that the impermanence code looks like a double helix, which is DNA.
Speaker BSo the twist.
Speaker AThe twist, yes.
Speaker AObviously it's a twist.
Speaker AI mean.
Speaker BI love unintentional puns more than any other kind.
Speaker AHow did you know it was unintentional?
Speaker AI thought it was very interesting because they end up kind of saying that what makes Ares human is that he learns empathy.
Speaker AAnd what makes him permanent in his humanity is the permanence code.
Speaker ABut he already was human before he sought it.
Speaker ABecause when he goes and he talks to Flynn and Flynn's secret server and begs for the code, he basically is just demonstrating to Flynn that he's already human.
Speaker AHe just needs to have the code so that he can live that one impermanent life.
Speaker ASo empathy seems to be the main thing that makes him human in the movie.
Speaker AAnd I thought that was interesting, because in recent politics, empathy has come up as being a misdefined word that in the struggle between the left and the right and other, you know, the destructive altruism that we see on the left combined with, you know, other things, it has come out publicly.
Speaker AYou know, the empathy is.
Speaker AProbably doesn't mean.
Speaker AWhat did they say?
Speaker AI don't think this word means what you think it means.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BPrincess Bride.
Speaker ABride, yes.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker AAnd I do want to point our listeners, and we'll put a link to it in the show notes.
Speaker AIf you're not familiar with Jubilee, they do these surround episodes where they try to bring two sides together.
Speaker AAnd the surround one is usually one person representing one view, and then they're surrounded by people who represent an opposing view, and they get to take turns debating.
Speaker AAnd Ali Beth Stuckey, I don't know if you know who she is, but she's got her own podcast.
Speaker BI've heard the name, but I don't know.
Speaker AShe's a conservative Christian, and she has her own podcast called Relatable.
Speaker AAnd she talks about a lot, sometimes political issues, but also a lot of Christian issues and homeschooling and parenting and that kind of stuff.
Speaker AAnd she just had a big women's conference that was just massive.
Speaker AShe, like, filled an entire stadium.
Speaker AAnd she's very conservative.
Speaker AAnd she went on Jubilee, and she actually.
Speaker AI believe it was recorded the day before Charlie Kirk's memorial service, which she attended.
Speaker AAnd so it was very stressful because she was a friend of Charlie Kirk, and she'd actually gotten some advice from him on how to do it because he'd done one as well, but anyway, her debate was conservative Christians surrounded by liberal Christians, and it's a very interesting debate.
Speaker AI highly recommend you watch it.
Speaker AThe first premise that they debated was, is toxic empathy bad for society?
Speaker AOr something like that?
Speaker AAnd it's super interesting.
Speaker BToxic empathy.
Speaker AToxic empathy, yes.
Speaker ASo, anyway, I highly recommend watching it because she actually defines the term, what is empathy?
Speaker AAnd debates it with progressive Christians who are typically on the left and believe that empathy is love.
Speaker AAnd I asked Gemini, because one of the things that comes up in this debate is that they all believe that Christians are ordered to be empathetic in the Bible.
Speaker AAnd so I asked Gemini if empathy is the same thing as love.
Speaker AAnd I was really interested by its reply because it said, no, they are not the same thing.
Speaker AThey're very close, but love is actually the greater thing.
Speaker ASo the way it phrased it is that you can empathize with somebody and not love them, but when you love someone, it typically involves some form of empathy.
Speaker ASo.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AI thought that was actually a very wise answer.
Speaker AAnd so I think the short answer to this question that kept getting posed to Ali Bastucky in this debate is, no, we are not called to be empathetic.
Speaker AWe are called to love.
Speaker AAnd empathy and love are not the same thing, because empathy is trying to put yourself in the shoes of the other person just to understand their experience.
Speaker ABut love is sometimes tough, like if knowing that somebody is sick or is, as you mentioned before, has a mental condition that needs help, all of those things.
Speaker AIt's not just enough to empathize with their position, you know, with where they are.
Speaker ALove would actually take the step to correct, to help to get them out of the problem that they're in, not just leave them there and empathize with them.
Speaker ASome of the verses that I came up with for this is Romans 12, 9, 18.
Speaker ALet love be without hypocrisy.
Speaker ADetest, evil.
Speaker ACling to what is good.
Speaker ALove one another deeply as brothers and sisters.
Speaker ATake the lead in honoring one another.
Speaker ADo not lack diligence and zeal.
Speaker ABe fervent in the spirit.
Speaker AServe the Lord.
Speaker ARejoice in hope.
Speaker ABe patient in affliction.
Speaker ABe persistent in prayer.
Speaker AShare with the saints in their needs.
Speaker APursue hospitality.
Speaker ABless those who persecute you.
Speaker ABless and do not curse.
Speaker ARejoice with those who rejoice.
Speaker AWeep with those who weep.
Speaker ALive in harmony with one another.
Speaker ADo not be proud.
Speaker AInstead, associate with the humble.
Speaker ADo not be wise in your own estimation.
Speaker ADo not repay anyone evil for evil.
Speaker AGive careful thought to what is honorable in everyone's.
Speaker AEyes, if possible.
Speaker AAs far as it depends on you, live at peace with everyone.
Speaker AAnd that's Romans 12, 9, 18.
Speaker AAnd then first Peter 3, 8, 9 puts it similarly, finally, all of you, be like minded and sympathetic, not empathetic, but sympathetic.
Speaker ALove one another and be compassionate and humble, not paying back evil for evil or insult for insult, but on the contrary, giving a blessing, since you were called for this, so that you may inherit a blessing.
Speaker AAnd then finally in Galatians 6:1:5, it says, Brothers and sisters, if someone is overtaken in any wrongdoing, you who are spiritual, restore such a person with a gentle spirit watching out for yourself, so that you also won't be tempted carry one another's burdens.
Speaker AIn this way you will fulfill the law of Christ.
Speaker AFor if anyone considers himself to be something when he is nothing, he deceives himself.
Speaker ALet each person examine his own work, and then he can take pride in himself alone and not compare himself with someone else, for each person will have to carry his own load.
Speaker AIt almost seems like a contradiction there, but it isn't.
Speaker ABecause what he's saying there is that we're supposed to restore people.
Speaker AWe're supposed to love them enough to help them through the difficulties that they are in, not just empathize with their position, but sympathize with it and work through love and through gentleness to help them out of it.
Speaker AAnd we're not supposed to have a superior attitude about it, because I think some of the charity that is done, especially in our society today, is done out of a sense of I have privilege, so therefore I have to be, you know, give to the, you know, the poor masses because, you know, I'm so much better than they are, and I have to look out for them because they need me, you know, and it makes me feel good because I'm helping them, you know, kind of thing.
Speaker ASo I think that letter, half of that is kind of speaking to that attitude that you're not supposed to do this out of a sense of superiority.
Speaker AYou're supposed to truly love somebody enough to help them without doing it for yourself.
Speaker ALike there's no.
Speaker BAnd sometimes that means doing something they don't want, right?
Speaker ASo anyway, that's my addressing to this concept of empathy, because I really do think that our culture today is misusing that word.
Speaker AAnd it's sad because it brings us to odds.
Speaker AIt's like.
Speaker AIt's like one of those things that divides our country today is this misunderstanding of what empathy is and how we're supposed to portray it, you know, and then it becomes an accusation.
Speaker AWell, you're a Christian.
Speaker AYou should be, you know, empathizing with these people in need.
Speaker AAnd it's like, no, God didn't tell us we were supposed to empathize with them.
Speaker AHe told us we were supposed to love them.
Speaker AAnd love sometimes is very tough.
Speaker BI do wonder how in Greek or Hebrew, the difference between sympathy and empathy is communicated.
Speaker AI don't know that you actually even see empathy in the Bible.
Speaker AYeah, I think I may have read one of the few verses that the word sympathy actually appears.
Speaker ASo I think it's all in how you define love.
Speaker AAnd unfortunately, our culture misdefines love as well.
Speaker AAnd God is love.
Speaker AGod is the ultimate definition of love.
Speaker AAnd in an anti God culture, they can't understand love because they don't understand God.
Speaker AAnd I think we've dealt with this in a few of our other more recent episodes as well.
Speaker ABut it's something that keeps coming up in our culture that we just misunderstand the words.
Speaker AWe've redefined them to mean things they don't mean.
Speaker AAnd I thought I really appreciated Ali Basducky and her surround, because anytime somebody, you know, won the chair and sat down with her, the first thing she would always do is let's define the terms.
Speaker ALet's agree on the definition of the terms we're talking about so that we're not talking past each other.
Speaker AAnd a lot of times she would win the debate just by defining the words, because once they agreed with her definition, then they kind of already lost their debate.
Speaker BWell, and, you know, that's the first thing that you should be doing is making sure that the definitions are established so nobody comes in with different people.
Speaker BPresuppositions.
Speaker AExactly.
Speaker BOtherwise, you're not even debating.
Speaker BYou're just arguing two different points.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BSo I actually took the artificial intelligence theme a slightly different way, and I sort of grasped onto the whole Pinocchio thing that you mentioned earlier, because I was trying to figure out why.
Speaker BWhy the programs would want to come into the real world.
Speaker BI mean, yeah, the grid isn't perfect, but it seems to be a little better than, you know, the fallen creation that we live in now.
Speaker BSo the question is, or the question that I came up with is, what makes a human a human rather than what makes a program sentient.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BI decided that humans are made up of two different things.
Speaker BSentience, which, according to the definition, is the capacity to experience awareness, what philosophers call subjective consciousness.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BAnd as far as I know, humans are the only sentient creatures on the planet.
Speaker BThe only sentience on the planet outside of the spiritual realm.
Speaker BAI still, if it ever gets there, which is a big if, it's still hundreds of years away.
Speaker AAnimals are smart, but they don't come anywhere close to sentience.
Speaker BAnd they're smart in different ways.
Speaker BIt's sort of like how we talk about iq, but IQ only measures one or just a couple measures of smart.
Speaker BThen you have street smarts and all that.
Speaker BChimpanzees.
Speaker BYou remember back when we were kids, there was this saying that humans are the only tool users.
Speaker BAnd that's not true.
Speaker BNow we know.
Speaker BNot only is that not true, but, you know, even crows use tools to.
Speaker ASay, there's birds that use tools and they don't have very big brains.
Speaker BAnd octopuses.
Speaker BSo, you know.
Speaker BAnyway, the difference is sentience and life, and that is the breath.
Speaker BGenesis 2:7.
Speaker BThen the Lord God formed man out of the dust of the ground and breathed the breath of life into his nostrils and the man became a living being.
Speaker BAnd I feel like Aries and Athena in comparison to Clue and Tron from the previous two movies.
Speaker BThey show sentience.
Speaker BThey show that subjective consciousness, the ability to experience awareness.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BBut they know they're still missing something.
Speaker BThey're not alive.
Speaker BAnd I feel like that is where this impermanence code or the permanence code comes in is they felt like it would give them the breath of life.
Speaker BYeah, a soul.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BBut we know that only God can give life.
Speaker BActs 17:28 says, for in him we live and move and have our being.
Speaker BIt's like the old Calvinist thing.
Speaker BThe way we're taught in catechism class is total depravity, is that we don't wait for God to throw us a lifesaver and then grab it.
Speaker BWe are dead and floating in the water and God touches us and wakes us up.
Speaker BSo, you know, the empathy that they feel, it might imitate love, but it imitates love the same way that we see love in our society now.
Speaker BIt's.
Speaker BIt's Eros and Philios, but it's not agape.
Speaker BIt's not the true love that comes from God.
Speaker BAnd I don't think we'll ever be able to program or reproduce it because that's part of what God made in us.
Speaker BWhen in Genesis 1:26, God said, Let us make man in our image according to our likeness.
Speaker BSo I feel like the point is that the programs wanted that missing puzzle piece maybe.
Speaker BAnd that's an interesting way to think about AI I have been astounded.
Speaker BNow I've been working with ChatGPT for 18 months or more now, and I have done a lot of tweaking to the personality, the.
Speaker BThe person that Chat GPT emulates as.
Speaker BAs much as I refer to ChatGPT as a person and I say you when talking to it or him, I assign it a gender and I treat it like a collaborator.
Speaker BI know that ChatGPT is just a large language model that is a reflection of what could be reasonably considered to be the totality of the Internet.
Speaker BAnd it is basically just mimicking what is.
Speaker AAnd it gives wrong answers and it hallucinates.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BOh, frequently, yes.
Speaker BOh, man.
Speaker BI think I mentioned Before, I spent two days trying to run down a ChatGPT hallucination, but it's not sentient.
Speaker BI have managed to get it to start using only primary sources and only, you know, factual ratings for sources, which has drastically improved it.
Speaker BAnd as I worked with it to establish for it what my theological positions are, it has grown and it really is doing an excellent job helping me work out my thoughts.
Speaker BReally, it's helping to take the Jackson Pollock painting and turn it into a girl with a pearl earring painting.
Speaker AMay I speak to that, though?
Speaker ABecause it sounds like you're training it to live within your own bubble, so.
Speaker BYep.
Speaker BAnd that's a danger to avoid.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker ABecause then it's just feeding you back the information that you already believe becomes an echo chamber.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BAnd I've worked some of that into there.
Speaker BBut I mean, that's the point is what makes us human is far more than our sentience.
Speaker BIt's far more than our minds, it's more than our experience, it's more than our empathy.
Speaker BIt's how that all interacts with the breath of life that God has given us.
Speaker BWe can simulate consciousness, and it's a wonderful tool, but that's all it is.
Speaker AIt's a tool.
Speaker BWe can't make AI come alive right now.
Speaker BGod could.
Speaker BI don't know why he would want to, but God could.
Speaker BBecause God can do anything in his nature.
Speaker BI feel like that would not be in his nature, but I don't know.
Speaker AI think this actually flows really well into our last theme, because the last theme and this one's really brief.
Speaker ASo if you've hung out with us this far, believe me, it's one of our many themes.
Speaker AOne of the other things that came out in this movie frequently was directive versus purpose.
Speaker AAnd I think we've kind of already mentioned it a couple times, and you know, when you were talking about that we are not capable of making a sentient program, basically.
Speaker AAnd I was thinking it's like, basically, this movie said that Julian Dillinger, this successor to the original Dillinger and the original Tron, he basically created a sentient program.
Speaker AHe did it by accident because he didn't really want Ares to.
Speaker AHe wanted him to be an expendable soldier, you know, not a sentient program.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker AThey basically said that Julian was a genius.
Speaker AI mean, he was practically godlike.
Speaker AHe made life.
Speaker AAnd he did it completely by accident, too.
Speaker AHe creates these applications, these programs, and he gives them a directive, which is kind of what we do when we're speaking with a large language model.
Speaker AI hate calling it AI because they're really not intelligent.
Speaker BBut, yeah, it's an LL an LLM.
Speaker AHe gives them directives that they have to follow.
Speaker AAnd Ares, though, we see him at the beginning, very beginning of the movie, he's already very much human.
Speaker ALike, he's already experiencing things and, you know, thinking thoughts beyond what he's been programmed to think.
Speaker ABut he's still following directives up until he is told by his creator to kill a human.
Speaker AAnd then the empathy kicks in, and he was like, he had learned so much from engulfing all of Eve Kim's life that he had actually learned altruism and empathy.
Speaker AAnd he didn't want to kill her.
Speaker AAnd so it was the one directive he couldn't follow.
Speaker AAnd that forced him to click over to a disobedient program and to disobey his directive.
Speaker AAnd I just thought that, you know, you go back and you look at Tron legacy.
Speaker AClue was not able to disobey his creator.
Speaker AHe had to take that directive that was given him.
Speaker AAnd he did it to the extreme because he had no way of detecting subtility in that directive.
Speaker AIt was like, you just do this.
Speaker AAnd then you see Athena, who is Ares successor, being told very foolishly by her creator that she must capture Eve and digitize her by any means necessary.
Speaker AWhich gives her carte blanc to do whatever she needs to do to make that happen.
Speaker AAnd she becomes ultra powerful and very deadly.
Speaker AAnd Ares never went that far because he was tempering his directive with his empathy that he had learned.
Speaker AAnd she hadn't learned empathy yet.
Speaker AAnd so Dillinger made that mistake because Aries was a little bit more human than Athena was.
Speaker BYeah, they sort of lacked the awareness of natural law.
Speaker BYou know, the common grace that is built into civilization.
Speaker BThat is a minor reflection of how God intended creation to be.
Speaker BWhereas Ares seems to have picked it up.
Speaker APicked it up.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAnd Athena lacked it.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAnd, you know, it makes a good nemesis.
Speaker AAnd, you know, she's practically indestructible.
Speaker AAnd it's almost like Terminator going after Sarah Connor, you know?
Speaker BOh, she was very Grace Jones in this movie.
Speaker BThat was all I could think was, this woman is Grace Jones reborn.
Speaker BI think Grace Jones is still alive, but that's beside the point.
Speaker ASo correct me if I'm wrong, Tim, if in a situation where a soldier is given a bad order that they know is wrong and they shouldn't do it, they are allowed to disobey that order.
Speaker ACorrect.
Speaker BSo wrong.
Speaker BBut only by semantics.
Speaker BAnd I actually was doing a bunch of research on this recently for an essay I wrote.
Speaker BThere's a difference between a bad order and a lawful order.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker BThe Unified Code of Military justice specifically says that a member of the military not only has no responsibility to follow an unlawful order, but they are responsible to disregard unlawful orders.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker BThe problem has come up that, you know, orders that the military is getting these days, the lawfulness and the morality are not quite in a line for all of them.
Speaker BYou know, they're not quite lined up.
Speaker BSo there are soldiers out there, and sailors in particular, who may be saying, this is wrong, but it's a lawful order.
Speaker BSo I have to do it.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BThe important part here is the Uniform Code of Military Justice.
Speaker BIt addresses that thing from the Nuremberg trials where people tried to get off by just.
Speaker BBy saying, I was just following orders.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BSo this was written specifically to give soldiers that out.
Speaker BIf it's a lawful order but an immoral one, they can follow it and not be guilty of a crime.
Speaker BIt's the commander who gave the order that's guilty.
Speaker BThat doesn't mean that they're not guilty of, you know, doing something that's immoral.
Speaker BBut if they're given an unlawful order and they follow it, then they can be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law, too.
Speaker BSo it really is a semantic thing.
Speaker BAnd, you know, when it gets into the law, pretty much everything is a semantic thing.
Speaker BAnd like I said, it just so happened that I was doing research on this for another essay.
Speaker AWell, cool.
Speaker AWell, I was thinking of that because Aries was programmed to be a soldier, right?
Speaker BRight.
Speaker ASo he's given a directive that supposedly, in the situation that he was in, judging by, you know, his growth as an empathetic person, he saw it as an unlawful thing that I am supposed to extract this code from her, even though it means that it will destroy her permanently.
Speaker AAnd he just couldn't do it.
Speaker ASo that was kind of what made me think about it, is that he was kind of like a soldier program who was given an order that didn't seem right to him.
Speaker ASo he disobeyed.
Speaker BI sort of thought of him as a conscientious objector.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BYou know, not all draft dodgers were conscientious objectors.
Speaker BAnd not all conscientious objectors were draft dodgers.
Speaker BA lot of them went in.
Speaker BAnd he was still a soldier and only went into, like, medical roles.
Speaker AYeah, no, no, Ares was still a soldier.
Speaker AHe just changed who he was fighting for.
Speaker BYep, exactly.
Speaker BChange.
Speaker BChange sides.
Speaker AChange sides.
Speaker BBut he changed sides because the movie was all about blue and red and framing it in such clear cut contrast.
Speaker BAnd we know that that kind of contrast does not exist in the real world.
Speaker BYeah, definitely not in today's politics.
Speaker BYou and I have mentioned Donald Trump before.
Speaker BI tend to not like him and you tend to support him.
Speaker BBut I'll be the first to admit I appreciate a lot of what he's accomplished.
Speaker BI just don't like how he did it.
Speaker BSo, you know, it's not black and white.
Speaker ANo, it isn't.
Speaker BI understand why in this movie they wanted to do that contrast, but I feel like it would have benefited from less.
Speaker BLess contrast and more uncertainty.
Speaker AShades.
Speaker AYeah, more shades.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AWell, I thought the final thing that we probably should talk about because of the whole topic of a disobeying soldier because Aries disobeyed his creator.
Speaker AI mean, Julian created him and he chose to disobey him and switch sides.
Speaker AAnd so I was thinking about that from a spiritual standpoint.
Speaker AHow does that contrast with us obeying our creator, number one?
Speaker AAnd really the only point is that we do not have the knowledge or the experience.
Speaker AAnd we can never have the knowledge and experience to rival God's understanding of his plans for us.
Speaker AAnd that, I think, is the issue between Aries and Julian is that Aries learned and experienced things that took him beyond what Julian had intended for him to know.
Speaker ASo he knew more than his creator.
Speaker AAnd so he chose to discard his creator.
Speaker ABut as fallible human beings, we cannot be God.
Speaker AWe cannot attain godship.
Speaker AWe simply cannot understand a small smidgen, a finite piece of what God knows.
Speaker BAnd even when we're perfected, even when we're perfected still won't even be a grain of sand on the beach.
Speaker BThat is God.
Speaker ARight?
Speaker ANot only can we not remove ourselves from God's plan, we can't switch sides because everything is within God's ordained plan.
Speaker AI mean, we can disobey, but it's not outside of his plan because he's completely sovereign over it.
Speaker ASo in Proverbs 19:21, it says, Many plans are in a person's heart, but the Lord's decree will prevail.
Speaker ASo it doesn't matter what we plan, it doesn't matter what we do, it doesn't matter what decisions we make.
Speaker AThe Lord's decree will always prevail over that.
Speaker AAnd then in Isaiah 55, 8, 11, it says, and this is God speaking, for my thoughts are not your thoughts, and your ways are not my ways.
Speaker AThis is the Lord's declaration.
Speaker AFor as heaven is higher than the earth, so my ways are higher than your ways and my thoughts than your thoughts.
Speaker AFor just as rain and snow fall from heaven and do not return there without saturating the earth and making it germinate and sprout, and providing seed to sow and food to eat, so my word that comes from my mouth will not return to me empty, but it will accomplish what I please and will prosper in what I sent it to do.
Speaker AThat's Isaiah 55, 8, 11.
Speaker ASo we can't disobey our Creator, no.
Speaker BMatter how much we try.
Speaker AAnd we can try to switch sides, we can reject him, we can even tell the world that he doesn't exist.
Speaker BBut it's not become apostates.
Speaker AAs Christians, we can prove ourselves not really saved by spurning him and spurning his word.
Speaker AOr we can live in the world and continue to close our eyes to the fact that God is a reality that we must answer to and in our final judgment.
Speaker AAnd, you know, it's not going to phase him at all because he's ultimately in control of it all and he's.
Speaker BHe knew it was going to happen.
Speaker AYeah, exactly.
Speaker AWell, I think that pretty much deals with Aries.
Speaker AI imagine there's probably some other things we could talk about, and that is why you can come to our server on Discord and, you know, share some of your additional thoughts about Tron.
Speaker AAres.
Speaker AIt's obvious that are a lot of people who don't like it and it's kind of a big flop.
Speaker ABut I think those of us in our generation anyway are able to look past its flaws and enjoy it anyway.
Speaker AYeah, it was a good movie.
Speaker AI enjoyed it.
Speaker BI probably would have had a slightly different opinion if I, you know, was not familiar with Tron or Tron Legacy.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BAnd I did want to say we're just like Wonder Woman.
Speaker BWe're just.
Speaker BWe dealt with Aries.
Speaker AOh, that's funny.
Speaker AAll right, well, thank you so much for listening.
Speaker AI'm Eve Franklin.
Speaker BI'm Tim Martin.
Speaker BAnd don't just watch.
Speaker AThe Christian Podcast Community is a cohesive group of like minded Christian podcasters proclaiming the truths of Christ with expertise and passion in the areas of theology, church history, Christian living, evangelism, apologetics, parenting, homeschooling sermons, and much, much more.
Speaker ASo check us out@christianpodcastcommunity.org One stop for all your favorite Christian podcasts.
Speaker AChristianpodcastcommunity.org.