1 00:00:01,440 --> 00:00:12,321 Welcome to Top Traders Unplugged. In markets success doesn’t 2 00:00:12,321 --> 00:00:24,411 come from predicting what happens next, it comes from being 3 00:00:24,411 --> 00:00:31,665 prepared for what you can’t predict. Ineach episode we go deep 4 00:00:04,620 --> 00:00:10,450 with some of the world’s most thoughtful minds in investing, economics, 5 00:00:10,450 --> 00:00:16,280 and beyond to understand how they think, how they prepare, and 6 00:00:16,280 --> 00:00:21,580 how they decide, and the experiences that shaped how they 7 00:00:21,580 --> 00:00:26,880 see the world. No noise, no short-cuts, just real conversations 8 00:00:26,880 --> 00:00:31,650 to help you think better and invest with confidence. 9 00:00:35,900 --> 00:00:46,603 Welcomeand welcome back to this week's edition of the Systematic 10 00:00:46,603 --> 00:00:55,360 Investor series with Mark Rzepczynski and I, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, 11 00:00:55,360 --> 00:01:07,036 where each week we take the polls of the global markets through 12 00:01:07,036 --> 00:01:12,874 the lens of a rules-based investor. Mark,we've got a pretty 13 00:00:38,125 --> 00:00:42,575 good, very solid actually lineup of topics that you kindly 14 00:00:42,575 --> 00:00:47,470 brought along. It'll be exciting to get into that. And before 15 00:00:47,470 --> 00:00:53,255 we do so, I'm always curious to hear a little bit about what's 16 00:00:53,255 --> 00:00:59,040 kind of come across your desk in terms of maybe other topics. we're 17 00:00:59,040 --> 00:01:03,935 not going to talk about. Is there anything you found interesting 18 00:01:03,935 --> 00:01:09,720 in the last few weeks? I've got a few observations, but I'd love 19 00:01:09,720 --> 00:01:12,835 to hear whatever has caught your attention. 20 00:01:14,030 --> 00:01:23,130 Well, you know that I've talked to you in the past about being 21 00:01:23,130 --> 00:01:30,130 in a VUCA world. You know, it's volatility, uncertainty, complexity, 22 00:01:30,130 --> 00:01:38,530 and ambiguity. And we're living in a VUCA world now. And I 23 00:01:38,530 --> 00:01:46,930 think that's going to be what our discussion for the most part 24 00:01:46,930 --> 00:01:51,830 is, that we're living in uncharted territories. Andthe question 25 00:01:16,730 --> 00:01:28,430 is how do you navigate that? Especially if you might be a quant 26 00:01:28,430 --> 00:01:38,330 investor, how do you navigate this kind of environment? So that's 27 00:01:38,330 --> 00:01:49,130 what has been the focus of my attention, especially for the last 28 00:01:49,130 --> 00:01:51,830 couple of weeks. 29 00:01:52,880 --> 00:02:03,452 Okay. So, I'll throw in a few observations, myself, that I’ve noticed, 30 00:02:03,452 --> 00:02:14,905 let's put it that way. But they're kind of on the same line, 31 00:02:14,905 --> 00:02:22,834 in terms of uncharted territory, when you mention that 32 00:02:22,834 --> 00:02:33,406 word. One thing that caught my attention was the new record set 33 00:02:33,406 --> 00:02:40,460 in the London Marathon; less than two hours. Imean,I don't know 34 00:01:56,275 --> 00:02:05,102 if you've seen the guy running that, and anyone who was close, but 35 00:02:05,102 --> 00:02:11,892 they run so fast. I mean, literally, they're like sprinting. 36 00:02:11,892 --> 00:02:20,040 In my world it's like sprinting, and they do it for two 37 00:02:20,040 --> 00:02:28,867 hours. And I think even the guy who came second, he was like 38 00:02:28,867 --> 00:02:37,694 a world record, but he only got second place. Which is kind of 39 00:02:37,694 --> 00:02:40,410 crazy to think about. 40 00:02:40,620 --> 00:02:46,476 When you really think about it, are there bounds by which we 41 00:02:46,476 --> 00:02:50,868 could behave, let's say physically, mentally? And it seems 42 00:02:50,868 --> 00:02:54,284 like we're constantly challenging those outer bounds. 43 00:02:55,610 --> 00:02:59,874 Yeah. I mentioned to Cem last week, when we were on, in ‘what's 44 00:02:59,874 --> 00:03:03,810 been on my radar’, I mentioned actually that there was also, now, 45 00:03:03,810 --> 00:03:08,074 a record in terms of a robot now running a half marathon quicker 46 00:03:08,074 --> 00:03:11,354 than any human, which is also kind of uncharted territory. 47 00:03:11,450 --> 00:03:15,320 Right, right. I've seen those…the dancing robots, and the 48 00:03:15,320 --> 00:03:20,480 robots chasing boars. I think there's a meme out there that we 49 00:03:20,480 --> 00:03:24,780 want to show robots as becoming more and more human. 50 00:03:26,340 --> 00:03:30,795 Yeah. The other thing that's somewhat uncharted was just a headline. 51 00:03:30,795 --> 00:03:34,440 There's no focus, specifically, on the firm. And so, 52 00:03:34,440 --> 00:03:39,300 maybe I shouldn't mention the firm, but there was, I think, the 53 00:03:39,300 --> 00:03:44,160 biggest redemption (at least that I'm aware of) in the hedge fund 54 00:03:44,160 --> 00:03:48,615 world, very recently, where there was a client who redeemed US$6 55 00:03:48,615 --> 00:03:53,070 billion from a hedge fund. And the name will remain unmentioned, 56 00:03:53,070 --> 00:03:57,930 but I mean, that's a massive redemption to receive on your fax 57 00:03:57,930 --> 00:03:59,550 one morning, I imagine. 58 00:03:59,760 --> 00:04:10,210 Well, I think that, as investors, over the time that I've 59 00:04:10,210 --> 00:04:19,710 been working in the investment world, investors have become more 60 00:04:19,710 --> 00:04:28,260 and more sophisticated, and as their sophistication has increased, 61 00:04:28,260 --> 00:04:37,760 they demand more from the managers that they invest with. Andso, 62 00:04:02,064 --> 00:04:14,736 you know, I think that there's competition across firms, but then 63 00:04:14,736 --> 00:04:25,104 there's also the competition of just meeting the expectations 64 00:04:25,104 --> 00:04:36,624 of investors, and it's pretty high because they're fairly sophisticated 65 00:04:36,624 --> 00:04:37,776 themselves. 66 00:04:39,150 --> 00:04:43,540 Yeah, absolutely. And of course, another thing that did hit 67 00:04:43,540 --> 00:04:47,930 my radar yesterday was, I think, the last press conference 68 00:04:47,930 --> 00:04:53,198 from Jerome Powell as Fed Chair, but the fact that he's staying 69 00:04:53,198 --> 00:04:58,466 on the board, I don't know if that's completely uncharted, if it's 70 00:04:58,466 --> 00:05:03,295 happened before, but kind of interesting. And also the other thing 71 00:05:03,295 --> 00:05:08,563 that was a little bit uncharted was it was an 8/4 vote, 72 00:05:08,563 --> 00:05:13,831 which I think is the first time since October 1992. So, quite 73 00:05:13,831 --> 00:05:19,538 a few things happening. But, you know, he was the Fed Chair from 74 00:05:19,538 --> 00:05:24,806 February 2018 to May 2026. And for sure, it's been an interesting 75 00:05:24,806 --> 00:05:30,074 time to have to navigate the interest rate levels in the world. 76 00:05:30,720 --> 00:05:46,720 It is a very interesting precedent because usually, if you're 77 00:05:46,720 --> 00:06:04,320 done being chairman, you might still have extended time on your 78 00:06:04,320 --> 00:06:23,520 appointment, but you don't go back to being just a member. So, 79 00:06:23,520 --> 00:06:36,320 this is somewhat unprecedented. Most people sort of 80 00:06:36,320 --> 00:06:45,920 say I should just resign now. Ithinkthat while everyone focuses 81 00:05:39,228 --> 00:05:56,244 on Powell, and this won't be the focus of our discussion today, 82 00:05:56,244 --> 00:06:10,424 probably my discussion with many smart investors has been what 83 00:06:10,424 --> 00:06:30,276 kind of Chairman Warsh will we have? Are you going to have the Warsh 84 00:06:30,276 --> 00:06:45,874 that's sort of following a Trump lead of lowering interest rates? 85 00:05:30,720 --> 00:05:45,180 Orare we going to have the Warsh of the past who has been somewhat 86 00:05:45,180 --> 00:05:54,820 negative about quantitative easing and thinks that the Fed balance 87 00:05:54,820 --> 00:06:06,388 sheet should be shrunk? That makes a huge difference on what kind 88 00:06:06,388 --> 00:06:18,920 of Warsh you're going to get and it makes a huge difference on 89 00:06:18,920 --> 00:06:31,452 how markets will behave, if we really have a Fed Chairman who believes 90 00:06:31,452 --> 00:06:44,948 that the balance sheet is too large and is going to have to be 91 00:06:44,948 --> 00:06:45,912 shrunk. 92 00:06:47,200 --> 00:06:53,284 Yeah, absolutely. I guess the final thing I noticed, that I guess 93 00:06:53,284 --> 00:06:58,861 you could also say is in uncharted territory, was the fact 94 00:06:58,861 --> 00:07:04,438 that the UAE left OPEC. That's kind of an interesting development 95 00:07:04,438 --> 00:07:11,029 as well because they're not a small member, so to speak. So, does 96 00:07:11,029 --> 00:07:16,606 that mean even more volatility in that sector? I don't know. 97 00:07:16,770 --> 00:07:22,110 That, again, is a very dynamic environment. They do have a pipeline 98 00:07:22,110 --> 00:07:27,450 that avoids the Straits of Hormuz. It can handle up to, some 99 00:07:27,450 --> 00:07:32,790 people say, 2 million barrels a day. That has been reported to 100 00:07:32,790 --> 00:07:38,575 be a little high. It might be about, you know, 1.5 million barrels, 101 00:07:38,575 --> 00:07:44,360 but that's a big number. And so, they're going to say we're going 102 00:07:44,360 --> 00:07:51,035 to push out as much oil as we can, while this crisis is going on. 103 00:07:51,035 --> 00:07:52,370 Because we can. 104 00:07:53,340 --> 00:08:17,595 Yeah, exactly. I think that that's what the speculation is, that 105 00:08:17,595 --> 00:08:46,260 if they're not a member they can even put out more. However, they 106 00:08:46,260 --> 00:09:14,925 still need to get it out physically, so to speak. So, if the 107 00:09:14,925 --> 00:09:41,385 limitation is the pipeline, then I'm not too sure how much more 108 00:09:41,385 --> 00:10:14,460 they can pump. But I'm not an oil expert, so I will leave it with 109 00:10:14,460 --> 00:10:16,665 that. Speakingof oil, Mark, let's get into some trend following 110 00:08:08,750 --> 00:08:28,783 update. You and I are speaking on the last trading day of April, 111 00:08:28,783 --> 00:08:51,898 and if all goes well for the next eight or ten hours or so, it 112 00:08:51,898 --> 00:09:10,390 looks like it's a pretty good month for trend followers and CTAs. 113 00:09:10,390 --> 00:09:30,423 In fact, and I haven't checked this, I would not be surprised if 114 00:09:30,423 --> 00:09:50,456 the SocGen Trend index makes a new all-time high. I would not be 115 00:09:50,456 --> 00:10:15,112 surprised if a lot of CTAs are going to end the Month at a new all-time 116 00:10:15,112 --> 00:10:16,653 high. So,among all this turbulence, among all this uncertainty, 117 00:08:17,226 --> 00:08:54,382 even though it also is a very strong month, as we will learn in 118 00:08:54,382 --> 00:09:20,922 a second, for equities, these strategies are coming out pretty 119 00:09:20,922 --> 00:09:50,116 strong after of course, March, which was, you know, a correction 120 00:09:50,116 --> 00:10:16,656 month because of the “surprise attack” in the Middle East. ButI 121 00:07:57,682 --> 00:08:21,563 guess it just reminds me that sometimes, you know, people want 122 00:08:21,563 --> 00:08:47,615 to pin down the strategy as something like, oh, it's a crisis 123 00:08:47,615 --> 00:09:11,496 alpha, or it only makes money when everything else goes pear-shaped. 124 00:09:11,496 --> 00:09:41,890 But you know, we should stop and also just take note of the fact 125 00:09:41,890 --> 00:10:05,771 that even in one of the strongest equity months we've had 126 00:10:05,771 --> 00:10:16,626 for a long, long time. Actually,it's also pretty strong 127 00:08:02,895 --> 00:08:22,005 CTA month and, of course, performance which, at least from 128 00:08:22,005 --> 00:08:43,026 my vantage point, looks pretty broad-based in terms of sector participation, 129 00:08:43,026 --> 00:09:05,958 despite the fact that we can't get around that the energy sector 130 00:09:05,958 --> 00:09:28,890 is most likely going to be dominant. And of course, there are 131 00:09:28,890 --> 00:09:48,000 some complete outliers in terms of people with massive oil 132 00:09:48,000 --> 00:10:07,110 exposure who are up significantly this year. But as an 133 00:10:07,110 --> 00:10:16,665 industry it looks pretty good. Whathave your observations been 134 00:09:35,715 --> 00:10:16,665 so far? 135 00:10:16,750 --> 00:10:27,390 Well, you know, we've often talked about the Goldilocks conditions 136 00:10:27,390 --> 00:10:40,158 for trend following in the sense that you can't have it too 137 00:10:40,158 --> 00:10:55,054 short, it can't be too long. But what we do find, from all the 138 00:10:55,054 --> 00:11:09,950 research we have, is that the more that you have a length of some 139 00:11:09,950 --> 00:11:23,782 type of crisis, the longer the length on the crisis, the time that 140 00:11:23,782 --> 00:11:35,486 we're in crisis, the better it’ll be for a trend follower. So,let's 141 00:10:18,582 --> 00:10:29,574 take for example, the pandemic in March 2020. You know, there was 142 00:10:29,574 --> 00:10:40,566 a huge market move, huge correction. A lot of CTAs were negatively 143 00:10:40,566 --> 00:10:52,474 affected by that because we had that huge dip and then it came 144 00:10:52,474 --> 00:11:03,466 right back in less than a month's time. So, from the Goldilocks 145 00:11:03,466 --> 00:11:14,458 effect, it was a crisis, but it really didn't have enough time 146 00:11:14,458 --> 00:11:26,366 to sort of, you know, show up for longer term trends. Not unless 147 00:11:26,366 --> 00:11:35,526 you were a trend follower who looked through certain events. Thisis 148 00:10:20,790 --> 00:10:45,030 now playing out as we move through time. This crisis lasts longer 149 00:10:45,030 --> 00:11:09,270 and longer. Then it allows more for the price behavior to be 150 00:11:09,270 --> 00:11:31,490 displayed in trends so that the trend follower could take advantage 151 00:11:31,490 --> 00:11:35,530 of it. 152 00:11:36,670 --> 00:12:27,968 Yeah, what's interesting to me about it is that yes, March was certainly 153 00:12:27,968 --> 00:13:19,266 a month where we had to trim equity exposure because of the reversals. 154 00:13:19,266 --> 00:13:54,780 It probably, for some managers, meant getting out more 155 00:13:54,780 --> 00:14:06,618 or less completely. Italso meant, maybe for some getting slightly 156 00:12:01,654 --> 00:12:36,007 short, but also for the many longer term trend followers they 157 00:12:36,007 --> 00:13:10,360 remained long. There are a couple of things that I noticed. 158 00:13:10,360 --> 00:13:47,836 One is that there has been a flurry of predictions, let's call 159 00:13:47,836 --> 00:14:06,574 it that, by the investment banks. AndI have to say, I mean 160 00:11:55,409 --> 00:12:30,210 Goldman Sachs has been quoted a lot about this, and that is about 161 00:12:30,210 --> 00:13:02,334 these, you know, all CTAs are going to buy US$86 billion worth 162 00:13:02,334 --> 00:13:37,135 of equity exposure in the next week, or they're going to sell. I 163 00:13:37,135 --> 00:14:03,905 mean, all this speculation about what managers are going to 164 00:14:03,905 --> 00:14:06,582 do. WhenI see them come out, and maybe they're not the ones putting 165 00:11:58,562 --> 00:12:18,770 them in the media but they are producing these observations in the 166 00:12:18,770 --> 00:12:38,978 first place for the media to distribute, guess. It kind of boggles 167 00:12:38,978 --> 00:13:02,554 me, a little bit, that there is so much attention on it and often 168 00:13:02,554 --> 00:13:26,130 it's not very accurate, at least when I look at how we are changing 169 00:13:26,130 --> 00:13:44,654 our exposures and positioning. So, I don't think it's very useful 170 00:13:44,654 --> 00:14:01,494 information. But it certainly is something that has caught the 171 00:14:01,494 --> 00:14:06,546 attention of many. Whathas got my attention is more, actually, 172 00:11:53,326 --> 00:12:20,392 the changes within, I think, the CTA space and that's to do with 173 00:12:20,392 --> 00:12:43,294 fixed income. It looks to me like fixed income positioning did 174 00:12:43,294 --> 00:13:10,360 change in March to the short side and that we've kind of been 175 00:13:10,360 --> 00:13:35,344 building on that and with, you know, recent expectations to an ongoing 176 00:13:35,344 --> 00:13:49,918 conflict, you know, inflationary pressures are mounting. 177 00:13:49,918 --> 00:14:06,574 Maybe we'll talk about that later as well. ButI think that's 178 00:11:43,726 --> 00:12:04,894 been the big change. Maybe, to some extent, also the dollar exposure 179 00:12:04,894 --> 00:12:24,298 might have changed as well, but certainly fixed income. And fixed 180 00:12:24,298 --> 00:12:43,702 income has been difficult for trend followers for quite a while. 181 00:12:43,702 --> 00:13:01,342 You know, long/short exposure, changing every sort of six, eight 182 00:13:01,342 --> 00:13:26,038 weeks. So, not an easy sector. But we'll see if this one is going 183 00:13:26,038 --> 00:13:48,970 to stick around for a little bit in terms of more downwards pressure 184 00:13:48,970 --> 00:14:06,610 on fixed income prices and upwards pressure on interest rates. 185 00:14:06,700 --> 00:14:20,934 Now Niels, this whole issue is very interesting because, I guess, 186 00:14:20,934 --> 00:14:36,462 one of the problems with aging is that you remember from things 187 00:14:36,462 --> 00:14:54,578 from the past in your career. And I will sort of say that, you 188 00:14:54,578 --> 00:15:07,518 know, prime brokers, brokers in general have, for decades, been 189 00:15:07,518 --> 00:15:20,458 trying to reverse engineer trend following programs in an effort 190 00:15:20,458 --> 00:15:34,692 to sort of say can I understand what they're doing or 191 00:15:34,692 --> 00:15:48,926 when they're going to enter the market or when they're going 192 00:15:48,926 --> 00:15:57,984 to exit. So, this is nothing new. Whatis new, and I think that 193 00:14:26,678 --> 00:15:03,780 is important, is that people are now using more AI to help them 194 00:15:03,780 --> 00:15:29,466 with this reverse engineering. In particular, there's been some 195 00:15:29,466 --> 00:15:55,152 recent work, it was an interesting paper called Mimicking 196 00:15:55,152 --> 00:15:58,006 Finance. Andwhat they did is they said that it took a lot of portfolio 197 00:14:25,026 --> 00:14:40,734 managers and they said, well, I'm going to sort of create agents, 198 00:14:40,734 --> 00:14:56,442 AI agents to try to replicate their behavior. And what they find 199 00:14:56,442 --> 00:15:13,459 out is that oftentimes they could get about 70% plus of the behavior 200 00:15:13,459 --> 00:15:27,858 of managers by using some AI agents to describe training strategy 201 00:15:27,858 --> 00:15:43,566 and behavior. What they find is that even though they could replicate 202 00:15:43,566 --> 00:15:55,347 it fairly closely, their performance is generally under the 203 00:15:55,347 --> 00:15:57,965 best managers. Andwhat they find is that the best managers are 204 00:14:31,440 --> 00:14:58,654 fairly dynamic, or that they have, they have rules or behavior 205 00:14:58,654 --> 00:15:30,816 that is hard to mimic. So you can mimic the average, but generally, 206 00:15:30,816 --> 00:15:58,030 you're going to underperform, but you can't mimic the best managers. 207 00:15:59,080 --> 00:16:10,247 Well, the last line kind of goes to a point that I respectfully 208 00:16:10,247 --> 00:16:18,837 made to one of Andrew's colleagues who was posting about 209 00:16:18,837 --> 00:16:29,145 their returns and comparing that to (I would say not very that 210 00:16:29,145 --> 00:16:36,876 super relevant, but I'm biased, let's remember that) not 211 00:16:36,876 --> 00:16:48,043 the best indices that I could think of. If you want to compare 212 00:16:48,043 --> 00:16:55,774 yourself to that - some Morningstar type trend following 213 00:16:55,774 --> 00:16:56,633 systematic. It'snot really the indices that I would compare 214 00:16:08,503 --> 00:16:20,020 to. But anyway, I mean, the whole thing about replication, I 215 00:16:20,020 --> 00:16:34,678 wonder do you really need an AI nowadays to do that? If you can 216 00:16:34,678 --> 00:16:46,195 just look up the replicators positions in the ETF space every 217 00:16:46,195 --> 00:16:56,690 single day, do you really need an AI for that? Iknowwhy they're 218 00:16:13,480 --> 00:16:56,680 trying to do it, but it's kind of funny. I mean, wow. 219 00:16:58,210 --> 00:17:24,509 Now part of that is that you actually bring a good point. And 220 00:17:24,509 --> 00:17:48,785 this has been another ongoing issue, do we need the added complexity? 221 00:17:48,785 --> 00:18:15,084 And you actually had this in one of your past TTUs. What happens 222 00:18:15,084 --> 00:18:41,383 when we add more complexity to models? Do we really get an advantage? 223 00:16:58,210 --> 00:17:21,130 So,with hedge fund replication, the idea is, since AI 224 00:17:21,130 --> 00:17:44,050 agents can actually sort of be used to include non-linearities, 225 00:17:44,050 --> 00:18:06,970 include other behaviors, can you improve it? The question is, 226 00:18:06,970 --> 00:18:29,890 how do you compare that against hedge fund replication or 227 00:18:29,890 --> 00:18:41,350 replication strategies that are simpler? Ingeneral, because 228 00:17:06,808 --> 00:17:41,200 I've worked in this area a little bit in terms of research, 229 00:17:41,200 --> 00:18:06,994 the hard part for replication is capturing the non-linearities 230 00:18:06,994 --> 00:18:32,788 associated with trend following behavior. And what do we 231 00:18:32,788 --> 00:18:41,386 mean by nonlinearities? IfI'm looking at some replicating a moving 232 00:17:07,482 --> 00:17:19,072 average strategy, I'm not saying it's easy, but it's relatively 233 00:17:19,072 --> 00:17:35,298 easy. The hard part is that, when you think about a lot of managers 234 00:17:35,298 --> 00:17:46,888 who use breakout systems, a breakout system is somewhat nonlinear 235 00:17:46,888 --> 00:18:01,955 in the sense that you're dormant until you see a move in the 236 00:18:01,955 --> 00:18:13,545 market, and then when that move reaches some threshold, then 237 00:18:13,545 --> 00:18:25,135 you'll kick in with positions - somewhat non-linear. The non-linearity 238 00:18:25,135 --> 00:18:40,202 is the hard part in hedge fund and, we'll call it, trend following 239 00:18:40,202 --> 00:18:41,361 replication. 240 00:18:44,001 --> 00:19:19,566 Yeah, I mean that brings up a good point. Not that it was one of 241 00:19:19,566 --> 00:19:50,389 the points I had expected to discuss with you today, but I mean, 242 00:19:50,389 --> 00:20:16,470 as you know, I voiced my concern about the narrative about 243 00:20:16,470 --> 00:20:44,922 replication being simpler than what we do. On the other hand, I 244 00:20:44,922 --> 00:21:11,003 completely agree with you that, in my opinion it's not quite 245 00:21:11,003 --> 00:21:22,858 the same that they capture. ButI mean, it is interesting what 246 00:18:57,084 --> 00:19:19,512 you mentioned because I don't know that many CTAs of the larger 247 00:19:19,512 --> 00:19:40,071 ones still use breakout. Actually, I think we, as an industry, 248 00:19:40,071 --> 00:19:56,892 have moved towards more continuous signaling. And the reason 249 00:19:56,892 --> 00:20:23,058 I say that is I see some of these, you know, they're not small 250 00:20:23,058 --> 00:20:47,355 but they are smaller managers where I do think they use sort of 251 00:20:47,355 --> 00:21:07,914 breakout type style and then they also use some very different 252 00:21:07,914 --> 00:21:22,866 risk management techniques, much more static position sizing. 253 00:18:44,001 --> 00:19:12,679 Someof them are shooting it definitely, out of the park at the 254 00:19:12,679 --> 00:19:34,739 moment, this year, way above anything that replication will capture. 255 00:19:34,739 --> 00:19:56,799 On the other hand, we obviously have to recognize that 256 00:19:56,799 --> 00:20:18,859 replication in the relatively short period it's been around has 257 00:20:18,859 --> 00:20:43,125 kept up overall performance wise and in some cases also outperform 258 00:20:43,125 --> 00:21:05,185 the indices, but not necessarily. And that was the point 259 00:21:05,185 --> 00:21:22,833 I was making to one of Andrew's colleagues. Notall. It 260 00:18:54,141 --> 00:19:27,941 certainly hasn't outperformed some of the best managers. And obviously, 261 00:19:27,941 --> 00:20:11,881 I can just look at our own equivalent funds and there was no 262 00:20:11,881 --> 00:20:42,301 outperformance. In fact, there was much more downside volatility 263 00:20:42,301 --> 00:21:22,861 and drawdown in the replicator in comparison. So, I agree with you. 264 00:18:44,001 --> 00:21:22,891 Ithinkfor me, what the conversation… (and I don't have the 265 00:19:15,249 --> 00:19:51,705 skills or the time to kind of dig deep enough into this) I think 266 00:19:51,705 --> 00:20:22,953 what the conversation lacks is that we kind of just conclude that, 267 00:20:22,953 --> 00:20:54,201 just because the performance looks the same, it must be the same. 268 00:20:54,201 --> 00:21:22,845 But this is where I just don't think that is true. Andeven with 269 00:18:52,992 --> 00:19:28,956 a correlation of 0.75, 0.8 I still think that doesn't prove the 270 00:19:28,956 --> 00:20:01,923 point about, oh yeah, we can just easily replicate these managers, 271 00:20:01,923 --> 00:20:40,884 and we do it in a more efficient way, so we will always 272 00:20:40,884 --> 00:21:16,848 outperform over time. I just find it so difficult to buy into 273 00:21:16,848 --> 00:21:22,842 that narrative. 274 00:21:22,891 --> 00:21:42,999 Well, two important points are, when I use the word breakout 275 00:21:42,999 --> 00:22:04,935 system we'll probably say, no one's going to walk into an office 276 00:22:04,935 --> 00:22:26,871 of an investor and say I'm using a breakout system. That's more 277 00:22:26,871 --> 00:22:39,667 of a catch-all for threshold-based or trigger-based 278 00:22:39,667 --> 00:22:41,495 signaling. So,in the sense, instead of having a continuous signal, 279 00:21:36,441 --> 00:21:52,701 there may be some threshold by which you'll take action and then 280 00:21:52,701 --> 00:22:07,606 a threshold where take off action. But in a replication issue 281 00:22:07,606 --> 00:22:23,866 you could have a pretty high correlation but you could still have 282 00:22:23,866 --> 00:22:38,771 a negative beta relative to the set of managers you're trying 283 00:22:38,771 --> 00:22:41,481 to replicate. So,correlation may not be the best guide for a replication 284 00:21:35,244 --> 00:21:46,474 strategy. And going back to basics, it's that alpha component 285 00:21:46,474 --> 00:21:59,950 that is the intangible that's not being picked up by some factors 286 00:21:59,950 --> 00:22:13,426 which you can't replicate and is also what people will be paying 287 00:22:13,426 --> 00:22:26,902 a premium for in terms of someone that will, they'll be willing 288 00:22:26,902 --> 00:22:40,378 to give money, they're willing to pay fees, and pay the incentive 289 00:22:40,378 --> 00:22:41,501 fee. 290 00:22:42,321 --> 00:23:01,494 Yeah, absolutely. Mark, I'm going to give a quick trend following 291 00:23:01,494 --> 00:23:24,153 update. As I mentioned, it's a strong month, so far in April, and 292 00:23:24,153 --> 00:23:43,326 my trend barometer yesterday closed at 55. So, that's pretty solid 293 00:23:43,326 --> 00:24:04,242 and I think that reflects well the performance we're seeing at the 294 00:24:04,242 --> 00:24:14,700 moment, as of Tuesday, 28th April. Andby the way, I think yesterday 295 00:22:48,250 --> 00:22:58,414 was another positive day. Maybe not a huge day but a positive 296 00:22:58,414 --> 00:23:11,119 day. We have the BTOP 50 index up 1.84% in April, up 9.46% so far 297 00:23:11,119 --> 00:23:22,977 for the year. SocGen CTA index up 2.31% in April, up 9.92% for the 298 00:23:22,977 --> 00:23:32,294 year. SocGen Trend, very similar, up 2.45% for April, up 9.71% 299 00:23:32,294 --> 00:23:41,611 for the year. And the Short-Term Traders index up 56 basis 300 00:23:41,611 --> 00:23:51,775 points, and up about 5% so far this year. The British Alternatives 301 00:23:51,775 --> 00:24:01,092 (which is a flat fee trend following index of fewer managers) 302 00:24:01,092 --> 00:24:14,644 up 4%, as far as I can tell, in April up 12.39% so far this year. 303 00:22:42,321 --> 00:23:00,201 MSCIWorld, as I mentioned, it's a great equity month, up 8.35% 304 00:23:00,201 --> 00:23:21,061 as of last night, up 4.59% for the year. The S&P US Aggregate Bond 305 00:23:21,061 --> 00:23:38,941 index pretty flat in April, and pretty flat so far the year-to-date, 306 00:23:38,941 --> 00:23:59,801 only a few basis points. And The S&P 500 Total Return up a whopping 307 00:23:59,801 --> 00:24:14,701 9.37% in April and up 4.63% so far this year. 308 00:24:20,791 --> 00:24:25,887 All right, Mark, we are now at a point where we're going to talk 309 00:24:25,887 --> 00:24:30,255 about your very long list of topics and I'm completely at your 310 00:24:30,255 --> 00:24:34,987 mercy where we're going to go with this. But it is somewhat geopolitical 311 00:24:34,987 --> 00:24:40,447 in its flavor, as far as I can tell. So why don't you take over 312 00:24:40,447 --> 00:24:44,451 and, and tell us what we're going to learn about today? 313 00:24:44,631 --> 00:25:16,680 Well, it's geopolitical in its flavor only because geopolitical 314 00:25:16,680 --> 00:25:52,290 events are what has been driving the markets. Obviously, we 315 00:25:52,290 --> 00:26:24,339 just talked about the performance of trend following and 316 00:26:24,339 --> 00:26:59,949 we see that as this geopolitical event in the Middle 317 00:26:59,949 --> 00:27:46,242 East, as it extends, then what we're going to see the chance that 318 00:27:46,242 --> 00:28:18,291 dislocations are going to have stronger effects, longer effects, 319 00:28:18,291 --> 00:28:53,901 and is then going to be displayed out in prices. So,a perfect 320 00:24:59,586 --> 00:26:09,376 example is that we had a shock to oil prices. There are some reversals 321 00:26:09,376 --> 00:27:04,211 at different times based on comments that were made, but surprisingly 322 00:27:04,211 --> 00:27:59,046 the markets have stayed higher. If you got long early in 323 00:27:59,046 --> 00:28:43,911 March, even though you're facing more volatility, you've done 324 00:28:43,911 --> 00:28:53,881 reasonably well. Theother thing that's important about this 325 00:25:05,911 --> 00:25:45,431 particular event is that it is a supply shock. And we'll sort of 326 00:25:45,431 --> 00:26:15,831 say that the global economy has difficulty with supply shocks 327 00:26:15,831 --> 00:26:52,311 over demand shocks. And the reason why is that with a demand 328 00:26:52,311 --> 00:27:22,711 shock, central banks are pretty… the playbook is pretty well 329 00:27:22,711 --> 00:27:53,111 scripted, we lower interest rates, boost demand, we could then 330 00:27:53,111 --> 00:28:29,591 be able to reverse the problem. It could be on the fiscal 331 00:28:29,591 --> 00:28:53,911 side, certainly on the central bank, monetary side. Butif you have 332 00:24:57,411 --> 00:25:42,141 a supply shock, what do you do about that? It becomes a little bit 333 00:25:42,141 --> 00:26:17,286 more difficult to deal with because, do you accommodate a supply 334 00:26:17,286 --> 00:26:58,821 shock which would then add to inflation? I know we just had Eurozone 335 00:26:58,821 --> 00:27:33,966 inflation. It's coming in at about 3%. We'll say US inflation, 336 00:27:33,966 --> 00:28:15,501 a new Fed chairman might have a different way to view it, some 337 00:28:15,501 --> 00:28:44,256 untrimmed mean inflation, but we're seeing that it's persistent 338 00:28:44,256 --> 00:28:53,841 at above 2%. So,you have a problem that the central bank doesn't 339 00:25:12,631 --> 00:25:49,031 know what to do, or central banks don't know what to do because 340 00:25:49,031 --> 00:26:28,231 of what we see as a supply shock. So that gets us into more 341 00:26:28,231 --> 00:27:10,231 of a ‘70s kind of world. And if you have a 70s type world then 342 00:27:10,231 --> 00:27:41,031 you could be able to have extended price trends across many 343 00:27:41,031 --> 00:28:09,031 different markets. The other thing we forget about this geopolitical 344 00:28:09,031 --> 00:28:37,031 is it's having an impact across all commodity markets, some 345 00:28:37,031 --> 00:28:53,831 of which we haven't seen yet. Takefor example fertilizer. A lot 346 00:25:36,201 --> 00:27:27,936 of fertilizer comes out of the Middle East. So, the Strait of Hormuz 347 00:27:27,936 --> 00:28:53,886 is closed, you know, fertilizer is not available for plantings. 348 00:24:44,631 --> 00:28:53,911 Ithinkwe're seeing that there are shortages of propane, butane, 349 00:25:45,560 --> 00:26:40,950 and other refined products, especially in Asia. Which means some 350 00:26:40,950 --> 00:27:30,801 restaurants are closing down, other businesses are closing down. 351 00:27:30,801 --> 00:28:37,269 So that's going to have real effects on equity markets and in 352 00:28:37,269 --> 00:28:53,886 the macro markets. So,we're going to see that this is going to 353 00:25:26,171 --> 00:26:16,019 have long ranges of effect. Now, the interesting part is I always 354 00:26:16,019 --> 00:27:05,867 go back to Sherlock Holmes and remember this story where he said, 355 00:27:05,867 --> 00:27:55,715 the dog that didn't bark. So, the real question comes in, with 356 00:27:55,715 --> 00:28:37,255 all of the shock that we've seen, surprisingly, equity markets 357 00:28:37,255 --> 00:28:53,871 have held in well. We'veseen some movement on fixed income. We've 358 00:25:22,255 --> 00:26:18,691 seen the behavior in energy, but it seems as though that there 359 00:26:18,691 --> 00:27:05,721 has not been the proper discounting of this large event. 360 00:27:05,721 --> 00:28:11,563 And what I mean by that, when you say a market is not discounting 361 00:28:11,563 --> 00:28:53,890 the markets, it means that you have an opinion. Butyou know, Niels, 362 00:25:09,559 --> 00:26:36,807 I'll ask you, if I told you you're going to have this kind of 363 00:26:36,807 --> 00:27:51,591 energy shock and then said, tell me what you would have predicted 364 00:27:51,591 --> 00:28:53,911 would happen to equity markets, what would you tell me? 365 00:28:54,981 --> 00:29:00,609 I think it's often the case that people think that okay, higher 366 00:29:00,609 --> 00:29:04,361 inflation means higher interest rates, means lower equity 367 00:29:04,361 --> 00:29:09,520 prices. But as far as I know/remember, I think that actually 368 00:29:09,520 --> 00:29:14,679 plays out a little bit later. Meaning the initial inflation period 369 00:29:14,679 --> 00:29:17,493 is not necessarily bad for equity. 370 00:29:17,501 --> 00:29:24,131 Now we'll sort of say that the one problem, or the one issue I come 371 00:29:24,131 --> 00:29:30,319 back to is that… We'll call it the World War I problem. And you 372 00:29:30,319 --> 00:29:35,181 know, what do you think happened? This is after the Arch 373 00:29:35,181 --> 00:29:40,485 Duke was shot, and there was some mobilization but we didn't start 374 00:29:40,485 --> 00:29:45,789 the all-out war yet. What do you think happened to equity, or 375 00:29:45,789 --> 00:29:50,209 what was the behavior of equity markets before September 1914? 376 00:29:51,941 --> 00:29:55,063 I love it when you ask what do you think happens? Because you know, 377 00:29:55,063 --> 00:29:56,178 I have probably no clue. 378 00:29:57,221 --> 00:30:09,938 We'll take you as a representative, an intelligent Investor 379 00:30:09,938 --> 00:30:31,133 in. And I think that when you sort of say that, yeah, I don't really 380 00:30:31,133 --> 00:30:50,915 have a clue. But you'd sort of say, well, it must have been that 381 00:30:50,915 --> 00:31:03,632 equity markets are forward thinking. They must have discounted, 382 00:31:03,632 --> 00:31:22,001 you know, the chance of war. And the answer is they didn't. You 383 00:31:22,001 --> 00:31:33,305 know, they are completely surprised by the war. AndI think 384 00:30:00,191 --> 00:30:13,061 that there are issues where you could say, are we going to be 385 00:30:13,061 --> 00:30:23,951 surprised in equity markets by what's happening in the Middle east 386 00:30:23,951 --> 00:30:36,821 ,or have we not discounted the fact that it gives me some pause. 387 00:30:36,821 --> 00:30:49,691 If you look at the VIX index, the VIX index has actually fallen. 388 00:30:49,691 --> 00:31:00,581 If you look at some of the uncertainty indices, they're still 389 00:31:00,581 --> 00:31:12,461 fairly high. Some of them haven't come out for the last month 390 00:31:12,461 --> 00:31:22,361 because they're only produced monthly. But the data suggests that 391 00:31:22,361 --> 00:31:32,261 we have relatively high uncertainty. But it seems to have 392 00:31:32,261 --> 00:31:33,251 peaked. Thedaily uncertainty indices have been very volatile. 393 00:30:17,997 --> 00:30:41,370 But VIX volatility or stock volatility has actually declined 394 00:30:41,370 --> 00:31:09,937 over the last month. It's probably a little bit higher than 395 00:31:09,937 --> 00:31:33,310 the median, but we'll say it's certainly not elevated. Andif you 396 00:30:05,012 --> 00:30:41,370 said that they were going to have a war in the Middle east like 397 00:30:41,370 --> 00:31:15,131 this, again, I think that if I asked you, as an ‘everyman’, what 398 00:31:15,131 --> 00:31:33,310 would you think would happen to volatility? 399 00:31:35,471 --> 00:31:40,946 Well, the thing is we get… I mean I think the answer is, you know, 400 00:31:40,946 --> 00:31:44,596 self-evident. But, I think also, in a sense, unfortunately it 401 00:31:44,596 --> 00:31:49,341 reflects that we are kind of getting numb to all of these messages 402 00:31:49,341 --> 00:31:53,356 coming out, left, right, and center, even though some of them 403 00:31:53,356 --> 00:31:54,086 are horrible. 404 00:31:54,651 --> 00:32:12,721 Yeah, right. And even when you get… So, we're almost like numb to 405 00:32:12,721 --> 00:32:28,011 the information that comes. But even if you get inundated with 406 00:32:28,011 --> 00:32:44,691 all of this information, it would seem as though, and we'll call 407 00:32:44,691 --> 00:32:55,811 this the Inundated with information with Conflicting Signals 408 00:32:55,811 --> 00:33:12,491 is a form of ambiguity. Okay? It's ambiguous about what is going 409 00:33:12,491 --> 00:33:13,881 on. Andin an ambiguous world, a world with high uncertainty, the 410 00:32:10,216 --> 00:32:25,781 normal expected behavior, which is going to be good for trend 411 00:32:25,781 --> 00:32:42,761 following, is that everyone is going to slow down with their decision 412 00:32:42,761 --> 00:32:59,741 making. If you're going to make a decision, and you had better 413 00:32:59,741 --> 00:33:13,891 certainty, you would act fast or you would be decisive. Whenyou 414 00:31:58,935 --> 00:32:18,213 feel that there's more ambiguity about what signals you're 415 00:32:18,213 --> 00:32:37,491 receiving, if you see that there's greater uncertainty, you 416 00:32:37,491 --> 00:33:01,053 might dollar cost average, you might hold back your behavior, you 417 00:33:01,053 --> 00:33:13,905 might wait before you take action. Andall of that behavior 418 00:32:07,861 --> 00:32:36,923 should lead to more price trends. That is what we're seeing. 419 00:32:36,923 --> 00:33:08,627 And we're seeing that's one of the reasons why trend following is 420 00:33:08,627 --> 00:33:13,911 doing well. 421 00:33:15,271 --> 00:33:26,707 You know what's fascinating about that, and I think this is something 422 00:33:26,707 --> 00:33:38,143 at least I hear from people (maybe it's something you want to 423 00:33:38,143 --> 00:33:51,485 bring up later, so I apologize if I skip the queue here a little 424 00:33:51,485 --> 00:34:04,827 bit), we're now talking a lot about AI and all of that. But leave 425 00:34:04,827 --> 00:34:16,263 that aside for a second. Clearly, one of the things that has 426 00:34:16,263 --> 00:34:27,699 changed in our careers, let's put it that way, is the introduction 427 00:34:27,699 --> 00:34:38,182 of the Internet. And with the Internet, and what followed, was 428 00:34:38,182 --> 00:34:47,712 this information flow that became instant. We all knew what 429 00:34:47,712 --> 00:34:54,383 was going on at the same time. AndI certainly remember, from decades 430 00:33:21,217 --> 00:33:33,109 ago, talking to people about it, where they were kind of questioning, 431 00:33:33,109 --> 00:33:45,001 well, how is trend following going to cope with the fact that 432 00:33:45,001 --> 00:33:55,902 now we all have the information at the same time. And 433 00:33:55,902 --> 00:34:05,812 so, what's interesting about what you're mentioning is that information, 434 00:34:05,812 --> 00:34:19,686 even though there is a limit to how quick it can become in terms 435 00:34:19,686 --> 00:34:29,596 of distribution, let's just say that it's pretty much instantly 436 00:34:29,596 --> 00:34:40,497 distributed now. You would kind of think, well, that must mean 437 00:34:40,497 --> 00:34:48,425 that shorter-term timeframes, shorter-term models should be doing 438 00:34:48,425 --> 00:34:54,371 better, they can navigate this quicker. Butas you rightly mentioned, 439 00:33:24,986 --> 00:33:50,245 what has been clear, not just this year, but generally in the last 440 00:33:50,245 --> 00:34:11,618 many years, is that it's the opposite. It's actually the slower 441 00:34:11,618 --> 00:34:31,048 systems, the slower models that are better at navigating the 442 00:34:31,048 --> 00:34:48,535 environment. That's kind of interesting and a bit counterintuitive 443 00:34:48,535 --> 00:34:54,364 in my opinion. 444 00:34:55,670 --> 00:35:09,794 Well, I think you're touching on one of the fundamental issues 445 00:35:09,794 --> 00:35:25,202 of how markets behave over the last few decades is that there's 446 00:35:25,202 --> 00:35:36,758 information reaction. So, information is now more readily available 447 00:35:36,758 --> 00:35:50,882 than before, which means that the markets should become more efficient 448 00:35:50,882 --> 00:36:03,722 because you get the information right away and you can 449 00:36:03,722 --> 00:36:22,982 act on it. But the real issue in where you make money is what is 450 00:36:22,982 --> 00:36:30,686 your ability to process that information? Ourability to gain 451 00:35:03,426 --> 00:35:24,755 information is better than ever in the past, but our ability 452 00:35:24,755 --> 00:35:46,084 to process that information may not have improved. And so, consequently 453 00:35:46,084 --> 00:36:03,535 there could be more uncertainty that leads to behavior, 454 00:36:03,535 --> 00:36:26,803 or that leads to behavior that leads to trends, that last longer 455 00:36:26,803 --> 00:36:30,681 than expected. Now,can I form a direct hypothesis about this? Can 456 00:35:07,400 --> 00:35:22,649 I be able to find a testable… Yeah, that's a little bit harder. 457 00:35:22,649 --> 00:35:39,071 But we will sort of say that the people who are very high frequency 458 00:35:39,071 --> 00:35:50,801 traders, or those who react immediately to new information, they 459 00:35:50,801 --> 00:36:06,050 have an edge. But those that actually sort of allow for the human 460 00:36:06,050 --> 00:36:18,953 behavior and that processing is still difficult also have an edge. 461 00:36:18,953 --> 00:36:30,683 And those are for trends that are longer, not shorter. 462 00:36:31,841 --> 00:36:36,339 Yeah. By the way, the whole supply shock and where you said it's 463 00:36:36,339 --> 00:36:40,145 actually harder for the economy to deal with that, is that 464 00:36:40,145 --> 00:36:43,605 part of this “newer inelastic” market hypothesis that people are 465 00:36:43,605 --> 00:36:46,719 talking about? Is that part of the same argument? 466 00:36:46,741 --> 00:36:57,011 Well, inelastic is not so much to do with the behavior and flow 467 00:36:57,011 --> 00:37:06,491 of markets. I think that the supply shock problem means that governments 468 00:37:06,491 --> 00:37:14,391 who can actually arrest trends, you know, don't know how 469 00:37:14,391 --> 00:37:24,661 to deal with it. When you think about it, the worst fear of 470 00:37:24,661 --> 00:37:34,931 a trend follower is that the trends start to occur and then government 471 00:37:34,931 --> 00:37:44,411 policy comes in and arrests the trends or tries to reverse it. 472 00:37:44,411 --> 00:37:53,891 So, let's say that you have a market is moving into recession. 473 00:37:53,891 --> 00:38:01,791 If we move into recession, you'll see equity markets decline. 474 00:38:01,791 --> 00:38:09,691 You're going to have a reaction in commodity prices. You're 475 00:38:09,691 --> 00:38:19,171 going to have a reaction to fixed income market. So, you start 476 00:38:19,171 --> 00:38:28,651 to see that market behavior is sending signals that'll tell us what 477 00:38:28,651 --> 00:38:34,971 our trends are that are associated with recession. Well,what 478 00:36:50,681 --> 00:37:16,291 is the worst thing that could see happen if you're a trend follower? 479 00:37:16,291 --> 00:37:39,931 That the government comes in and then says well, if the market 480 00:37:39,931 --> 00:38:05,541 is declined, I'm going to try to reverse that flow. So, if the 481 00:38:05,541 --> 00:38:25,241 equity markets are declining, I'm going to do something that's 482 00:38:25,241 --> 00:38:35,091 going to reverse that flow. So,then the trends are going to 483 00:36:58,592 --> 00:37:17,215 reverse. You're going to actually sort of be hit with losses. 484 00:37:17,215 --> 00:37:35,838 You might then see a drawdown, a supply shock environment. What 485 00:37:35,838 --> 00:37:54,461 is the proper response by government? It's not clear. So, that 486 00:37:54,461 --> 00:38:14,777 means that prices are going to be primal, prices are still going 487 00:38:14,777 --> 00:38:33,400 to be driven by market behavior, not by the behavior of 488 00:38:33,400 --> 00:38:35,093 governments. 489 00:38:36,061 --> 00:38:40,897 Yeah, although, and this is a sample of one, so, people should 490 00:38:40,897 --> 00:38:45,733 be incredibly skeptical about it. But I do remember when they last 491 00:38:45,733 --> 00:38:50,166 time really intervened was in March of 2020, not the government, 492 00:38:50,166 --> 00:38:54,599 but certainly, you know, the Fed did, probably by the invitation 493 00:38:54,599 --> 00:38:59,032 of the government. And you're right, that certainly led to some 494 00:38:59,032 --> 00:39:03,465 reversals and some trends that changed direction. But it also led 495 00:39:03,465 --> 00:39:07,495 to one of the strongest periods for trend following subsequently 496 00:39:07,495 --> 00:39:11,122 because it turned out to be incredibly inflationary afterwards. 497 00:39:11,122 --> 00:39:15,958 So yeah, you're right. I mean, we don't want people to influence 498 00:39:15,958 --> 00:39:20,794 markets or trends for sure. But I mean, sometimes it can actually, 499 00:39:20,794 --> 00:39:25,227 because they're reflexive, I guess, it can lead to some opportunity. 500 00:39:25,451 --> 00:39:33,403 Well, we’ll sort of say that a corollary to what I'm saying is that, 501 00:39:33,403 --> 00:39:39,651 okay, let's go back to the pandemic, which was a government 502 00:39:39,651 --> 00:39:46,467 induced supply shock and we'll sort of say, not the pandemic itself, 503 00:39:46,467 --> 00:39:52,715 but the response. Okay, well then the government said well, now 504 00:39:52,715 --> 00:40:00,667 we induce the supply shock. But now what we've got to do is we've 505 00:40:00,667 --> 00:40:07,483 got to do something to offset the supply shock that we generated. 506 00:40:07,483 --> 00:40:14,299 So, what we're going to do is increase fiscal spending. We're going 507 00:40:14,299 --> 00:40:19,979 to keep interest rates extremely low. We're going to flood 508 00:40:19,979 --> 00:40:26,795 the market with liquidity. And then, lo and behold, what do you 509 00:40:26,795 --> 00:40:30,771 think happened? You actually got inflation. Okay. So,their response 510 00:39:30,008 --> 00:39:51,274 to this supply shock was to say, how do I offset the supply shock? 511 00:39:51,274 --> 00:40:06,464 But by offsetting the supply shock, then they actually created 512 00:40:06,464 --> 00:40:20,135 a bigger problem which actually led to inflation, which 513 00:40:20,135 --> 00:40:30,768 then led to advantages for trend followers. 514 00:40:31,961 --> 00:40:35,201 Indeed. Indeed. Well, talking about trend followers, I noticed 515 00:40:35,201 --> 00:40:39,521 in your notes that you have a point called my current research 516 00:40:39,521 --> 00:40:43,121 on a different hedge fund strategy sensitive to risk volatility 517 00:40:43,121 --> 00:40:46,721 shocks, but there are exceptions. So, is that where we're 518 00:40:46,721 --> 00:40:48,161 going to head now? 519 00:40:48,441 --> 00:41:12,335 Let's talk about this, and I think that it's always good to put 520 00:41:12,335 --> 00:41:36,229 this in a discussion of trend following or in the context of how 521 00:41:36,229 --> 00:41:58,285 it fits within all other hedge fund strategies. I think that, when 522 00:41:58,285 --> 00:42:18,503 we look at the institutional investor, he doesn't think in terms 523 00:42:18,503 --> 00:42:40,559 of, am I going to choose trend following? They're going to say, 524 00:42:40,559 --> 00:43:02,615 how do I choose trend following vis a vis all the other 525 00:43:02,615 --> 00:43:19,157 types of hedge fund strategies that might offer diversification? 526 00:43:19,157 --> 00:43:37,537 Which one is better? So, you're not competing against other 527 00:43:37,537 --> 00:43:52,241 trend followers, you're competing against all other hedge 528 00:43:52,241 --> 00:43:55,917 fund strategies. So,one of the things I wanted to look at is 529 00:41:03,071 --> 00:41:19,031 that when you think about it we've looked at hedge fund strategies 530 00:41:19,031 --> 00:41:37,651 beta and how we can be able to classify them. And the standard argument 531 00:41:37,651 --> 00:41:54,941 is that the beta for trend following is close to zero. So, it's 532 00:41:54,941 --> 00:42:09,571 a very low number. Other hedge fund strategies still have positive 533 00:42:09,571 --> 00:42:26,861 beta. So, okay, if you really want to have, you know, strong diversifier, 534 00:42:26,861 --> 00:42:44,151 by managed features, what you find out is that some of the other 535 00:42:44,151 --> 00:43:00,111 strategies have higher alpha. And this is by just looking at a 536 00:43:00,111 --> 00:43:12,081 simple regression of looking at systematic risk and measuring 537 00:43:12,081 --> 00:43:24,051 alpha over time. They might have significant positive alpha. 538 00:43:24,051 --> 00:43:41,341 If you look at trend following it’s not so much the case. You're 539 00:43:41,341 --> 00:43:55,971 going to find out that the alpha is close to zero. So,you get 540 00:40:59,259 --> 00:41:35,319 this diversification benefit on your beta side, but you're not 541 00:41:35,319 --> 00:42:22,197 getting a lot of alpha. So, you have a trade-off. I said, well, 542 00:42:22,197 --> 00:43:05,469 let's take a look at different hedge fund strategies, how they behave 543 00:43:05,469 --> 00:43:48,741 with respect to risk. And we'll call it risk regimes and then 544 00:43:48,741 --> 00:43:55,953 risk shocks. So,what do we mean by risk? We can look at the 545 00:41:23,601 --> 00:42:01,691 VIX index which is a perfect example of risk. And the VIX index 546 00:42:01,691 --> 00:42:30,991 is different than the systematic risk that we see versus 547 00:42:30,991 --> 00:43:06,151 the stock market. So, we ran, and found out, and looked across 548 00:43:06,151 --> 00:43:38,381 all hedge fund strategies, and said well, how sensitive are you 549 00:43:38,381 --> 00:43:55,961 to sort of the risk regime? Andwhat we find out is, actually, 550 00:41:09,273 --> 00:41:44,985 we standardize what the VIX index is. If there's a low-risk regime, 551 00:41:44,985 --> 00:42:14,745 hedge funds generally do better. Okay, so low-risk, they do 552 00:42:14,745 --> 00:42:47,481 well. So, when we see high-risk and… sorry, Niels, I have 553 00:42:47,481 --> 00:43:23,193 got to ask you, as my ‘everyman’, what do you think hedge 554 00:43:23,193 --> 00:43:49,977 fund strategies, how their excess returns behave during high 555 00:43:49,977 --> 00:43:55,929 risk environments? 556 00:43:56,861 --> 00:44:00,381 Oh, I'm sure they're not as great as trend following. 557 00:44:01,731 --> 00:44:33,267 Exactly. So, what you find out is that in high-risk regimes well, 558 00:44:33,267 --> 00:45:02,175 the coefficient is negative which tells you is that high volatility, 559 00:45:02,175 --> 00:45:36,339 a lot of hedge fund strategies don't really do that well. So, even 560 00:45:36,339 --> 00:46:02,619 though they may market themselves that we have manager skill, 561 00:46:02,619 --> 00:46:39,411 and our skill is that we can be able to risk manage better than 562 00:46:39,411 --> 00:47:03,063 other types of managers, surprisingly they have a negative 563 00:47:03,063 --> 00:47:16,203 coefficient to the risk regime. Now,when you look at managed 564 00:44:24,615 --> 00:44:58,941 futures, they're actually insensitive to the risk regime. So, 565 00:44:58,941 --> 00:45:44,709 whether it's high risk, or low risk, that coefficient is not significant. 566 00:45:44,709 --> 00:46:34,291 So, it tells us is that a trend follower is not dependent or 567 00:46:34,291 --> 00:47:16,245 is not affected by the risk regime, which is very interesting. 568 00:44:01,731 --> 00:44:43,685 So,if you're really worried about risk in your portfolio, meaning 569 00:44:43,685 --> 00:45:25,639 the volatility as measured by the VIX, managed futures will be 570 00:45:25,639 --> 00:46:11,407 a better choice than many of these other strategies that may generate 571 00:46:11,407 --> 00:46:49,547 alpha, but that alpha is actually dissipated once you take 572 00:46:49,547 --> 00:47:16,245 into account the risk regime you have. So,in particular, then 573 00:44:16,411 --> 00:45:00,451 we looked at what is the alpha for these different hedge strategies 574 00:45:00,451 --> 00:45:40,821 in different risk regimes by partitioning, you know, the VIX into 575 00:45:40,821 --> 00:46:24,861 low, medium and high? And we'll sort of say that if you're 576 00:46:24,861 --> 00:47:08,901 looking at what happens to alpha in a high-risk regime, it actually 577 00:47:08,901 --> 00:47:16,241 turns negative. So,if you have alpha and you sort of say like, 578 00:44:45,401 --> 00:45:40,981 hey, I'm a good manager and I show skill in a low volatility environment, 579 00:45:40,981 --> 00:46:20,681 in a high volatility environment, I don't show it. On 580 00:46:20,681 --> 00:46:56,411 the other hand, managed futures, again, it's invariant or 581 00:46:56,411 --> 00:47:16,261 independent of the risk regime. Andthen finally what we 582 00:44:15,426 --> 00:44:53,772 did is that we said, let's look at this in terms of risk shocks, 583 00:44:53,772 --> 00:45:29,379 okay? And in particular you'd say what is a risk shock? Which would 584 00:45:29,379 --> 00:46:04,986 be the change in the VIX index. So, it's maybe not the risk 585 00:46:04,986 --> 00:46:40,593 regime, but we'll say it's not the regime, it's the fact of whether 586 00:46:40,593 --> 00:47:10,722 I have a big shock to volatility, either positive or negative, 587 00:47:10,722 --> 00:47:16,200 that matters. Andagain, most hedge fund strategies don't really 588 00:44:21,427 --> 00:44:48,509 do well with positive risk shocks. On the other hand, managed 589 00:44:48,509 --> 00:45:15,591 futures, again, seems to be invariant to risk shocks. So, in 590 00:45:15,591 --> 00:45:45,135 some sense, you’ve got the advantage of a low beta. But more 591 00:45:45,135 --> 00:46:09,755 importantly, you're not sensitive to the type of risk environment, 592 00:46:09,755 --> 00:46:36,837 in terms of regime or shock, where other hedge fund strategies 593 00:46:36,837 --> 00:46:54,071 that might purport that they're offering diversification 594 00:46:54,071 --> 00:47:16,229 just don't do it or don't offer that advantage. 595 00:47:18,852 --> 00:47:27,014 It's interesting, Mark. The reason, I guess, I got your surprise 596 00:47:27,014 --> 00:47:35,918 question right is because we looked at this in a slightly different 597 00:47:35,918 --> 00:47:45,564 way, about six months ago, and we published (and when I say we, 598 00:47:45,564 --> 00:47:55,210 I mean Dunn). And we published a couple of reports about these studies. 599 00:47:55,210 --> 00:48:05,598 I think it was for the first time as I haven't seen anything published 600 00:48:05,598 --> 00:48:13,760 like this before, where we looked at all the alternative investment 601 00:48:13,760 --> 00:48:22,664 strategies we could get our data on. I think there's like 14 602 00:48:22,664 --> 00:48:33,794 or 16 of them. And then we went back to the same time as when 603 00:48:33,794 --> 00:48:43,440 the Trend index started, in the year 2000, and we looked at all 604 00:48:43,440 --> 00:48:50,860 this, but not necessarily in specific VIX environments. So, I'd 605 00:48:50,860 --> 00:48:56,796 certainly love to see your study on that. ButI just wanted 606 00:47:22,088 --> 00:47:31,796 to mention that we, just last week, updated this study with more 607 00:47:31,796 --> 00:47:40,695 data. And for those who want to receive, not necessarily specifically 608 00:47:40,695 --> 00:47:49,594 about Dunn, but about trend and, and high volatility trend in 609 00:47:49,594 --> 00:47:57,684 particular, I'm going to publish that, on a regular basis, 610 00:47:57,684 --> 00:48:06,583 as part of my Sunday email updates. And people can subscribe 611 00:48:06,583 --> 00:48:10,628 to that on toptradersunplugged.com/ Sunday. 612 00:48:10,628 --> 00:48:20,336 So, just if people want to see this, there is definitely something 613 00:48:20,336 --> 00:48:30,044 that I can share publicly on that. But it's a slightly different 614 00:48:30,044 --> 00:48:39,752 way of attacking the same kind of question: How do these strategies 615 00:48:39,752 --> 00:48:47,842 actually perform and which are the most valuable alternative investment 616 00:48:47,842 --> 00:48:55,932 strategies, because I think there's a lot of confusion about 617 00:48:55,932 --> 00:48:56,741 that. 618 00:48:56,852 --> 00:49:01,212 And this doesn't dissipate, you know, the conversations and all 619 00:49:01,212 --> 00:49:06,008 of the research and work about, you know, crisis alphas. But 620 00:49:06,008 --> 00:49:12,112 we want to try to… and I think, as a group, you're going to 621 00:49:12,112 --> 00:49:17,344 talk about trend following and managed futures. We want to get beyond 622 00:49:17,344 --> 00:49:19,524 just the crisis alpha story. 623 00:49:19,552 --> 00:49:20,032 Yeah. 624 00:49:20,192 --> 00:49:39,587 We want to try to sort of say, are there other ways that we can 625 00:49:39,587 --> 00:49:58,982 be able to look at data, in a very systematic way, to be able to 626 00:49:58,982 --> 00:50:11,912 sort of say, is there something unique about managed futures 627 00:50:11,912 --> 00:50:24,842 versus other hedge fund strategies? And so, you say like, 628 00:50:24,842 --> 00:50:41,651 well, what are people most focused in on and where do they really 629 00:50:41,651 --> 00:50:55,874 worry about? You sort of say, yeah, they're worried about what's 630 00:50:55,874 --> 00:51:03,632 my overall portfolio beta or not. ButI think in reality, if volatility 631 00:49:26,275 --> 00:49:35,834 is high, or volatility is increasing, I want to find strategies 632 00:49:35,834 --> 00:49:44,524 that actually will protect me against a high volatility regime 633 00:49:44,524 --> 00:49:55,821 or do better in a perfect world. Reality is it's hard to find 634 00:49:55,821 --> 00:50:04,511 strategies, and that doesn't mean that you won't find individual 635 00:50:04,511 --> 00:50:14,939 managers who do well. But it's hard to find hedge fund strategies 636 00:50:14,939 --> 00:50:26,236 that do well in a positive risk shock or a high volatility regime. 637 00:50:26,236 --> 00:50:34,926 But you do have some exceptions and that's managed futures. 638 00:50:34,926 --> 00:50:44,485 You also have global macro does similar. But then you could 639 00:50:44,485 --> 00:50:53,175 say global macro and trend following are also similar strategies. 640 00:50:53,175 --> 00:51:00,127 One’s systematic, one’s a discretionary representation of a 641 00:51:00,127 --> 00:51:03,603 large set of markets. Butyou could sort of say there are unique 642 00:49:46,058 --> 00:50:09,050 characteristics that are associated with managed futures that 643 00:50:09,050 --> 00:50:37,790 you don't find with other strategies that offers benefits beyond 644 00:50:37,790 --> 00:51:03,656 just the fact that it's a low beta strategy. 645 00:51:04,632 --> 00:51:10,488 Yeah. Is this part of your kind of putting context to different 646 00:51:10,488 --> 00:51:13,416 types of analysis, storytelling versus narrative? 647 00:51:13,432 --> 00:51:57,434 The context issue is something that I spent a lot of time with because 648 00:51:57,434 --> 00:52:38,293 when you think about what we do when we sell strategies or actually 649 00:52:38,293 --> 00:53:06,580 develop strategies, we always talk about context or narrative. 650 00:53:06,580 --> 00:53:47,439 And in some sense, I'll talk about two quotes to set this up. 651 00:53:47,439 --> 00:54:22,012 And this is from Daniel Kahneman. So, you know, Daniel Kahneman, 652 00:54:22,012 --> 00:54:59,728 the Nobel prize winner or finance guy. But he said, “no one 653 00:54:59,728 --> 00:55:37,444 ever made a decision because of a number. They need a story.” 654 00:51:13,432 --> 00:52:33,452 Andthen he also said, “the confidence that individuals have 655 00:52:33,452 --> 00:54:01,474 in their beliefs depends mostly on the quality of the story 656 00:54:01,474 --> 00:55:37,498 they can tell about what they see, even if they see little.” So,in 657 00:51:18,366 --> 00:51:45,503 some sense, that’s one of the constant challenges for managed futures, 658 00:51:45,503 --> 00:52:20,041 if you say, okay, what do you do? (And I'm making this overly simple.) 659 00:52:20,041 --> 00:52:49,645 I follow trends. Well, what does that mean? Prices go up, I'm 660 00:52:49,645 --> 00:53:24,183 a buyer. Prices go down, I'm a seller. So, that's it. What do you 661 00:53:24,183 --> 00:53:53,787 think about the market? Tell me what you think about what's going 662 00:53:53,787 --> 00:54:25,858 in the Middle East. I really don't have an opinion. If oil prices 663 00:54:25,858 --> 00:54:57,929 are going up, I'm a buyer. If they're going down, I'm a seller. 664 00:54:57,929 --> 00:55:27,533 And I think that is a classic conversation that you would have 665 00:55:27,533 --> 00:55:37,401 with a trend follower. Yet,in reality, the investor is saying, 666 00:51:35,433 --> 00:52:19,435 like, gee, you know, I want to hear the story, give me the story. 667 00:52:19,435 --> 00:52:54,008 Then the next global macro manager or some other manager comes 668 00:52:54,008 --> 00:53:38,010 in and he says, well let me tell you about what's going on in 669 00:53:38,010 --> 00:54:15,726 Iran. Let me tell you about the pipeline that's going from the 670 00:54:15,726 --> 00:55:02,871 UAE. Let me tell you about the number of ships and how we look at 671 00:55:02,871 --> 00:55:34,301 geopositioning to find out what the ship traffic would look 672 00:55:34,301 --> 00:55:37,444 like. AndI said like wow, that's a very smart manager. And 673 00:51:42,472 --> 00:52:14,152 it's because he gives context or gives a story or narrative. Now 674 00:52:14,152 --> 00:52:40,552 I'm giving one example of story and narrative as persuasion. 675 00:52:40,552 --> 00:53:09,592 But I think that context matters for our trend following behavior. 676 00:53:09,592 --> 00:53:43,912 The question is how do we add context in our modeling? And we'll 677 00:53:43,912 --> 00:54:10,312 start out with what started our conversation. We talked about 678 00:54:10,312 --> 00:54:41,992 geopolitical risk and then we said about how this plays out in 679 00:54:41,992 --> 00:55:05,752 and price shocks, and if markets dislocations extended for 680 00:55:05,752 --> 00:55:34,792 a longer time then it's better for trend following. That provides 681 00:55:34,792 --> 00:55:37,432 context. Canwe be able to use different tools to provide context 682 00:51:41,625 --> 00:52:14,944 to add value to our models? And that's an ongoing issue of how 683 00:52:14,944 --> 00:52:48,263 do you best use AI? And this is where we're actually seeing more 684 00:52:48,263 --> 00:53:19,019 AI being used in two areas. One is in natural language processing 685 00:53:19,019 --> 00:53:47,212 to come up with sentiment measures. I think that that's becoming 686 00:53:47,212 --> 00:54:10,279 a very interesting area of research for quantitative analysts. 687 00:54:10,279 --> 00:54:41,035 And then for large language models, LLMs, because how do we process 688 00:54:41,035 --> 00:55:14,354 a lot of Information, some of which is non-numerical in a way that 689 00:55:14,354 --> 00:55:37,421 we can then be able to convert into signals. Nowperfect example 690 00:51:21,598 --> 00:51:48,818 is that for natural language processing we could take earnings 691 00:51:48,818 --> 00:52:29,648 calls and we could be able to use what is called a bag of words 692 00:52:29,648 --> 00:53:05,034 and then be able to try to figure out the sentiment that's occurring 693 00:53:05,034 --> 00:53:34,976 in the marketplace. This is proving to be very profitable and 694 00:53:34,976 --> 00:54:15,806 being used by a lot of firms. The question is how do we use that 695 00:54:15,806 --> 00:54:51,192 for a trend following model? And I'll sort of say that the jury 696 00:54:51,192 --> 00:55:26,578 is still out. Not that there has been negative work, but the work 697 00:55:26,578 --> 00:55:37,466 hasn't been done yet. 698 00:55:38,622 --> 00:55:56,202 Yeah, it is interesting. I mean, it always in my mind comes 699 00:55:56,202 --> 00:56:16,712 back to this thing that a lot of this sentiment, and so on, and 700 00:56:16,712 --> 00:56:34,292 so forth, should all be reflected in the price. And the price 701 00:56:34,292 --> 00:56:44,547 is the only truth that we have. AndI'm not suggesting that 702 00:55:41,792 --> 00:55:48,766 things won't change in the future, but I'm also noticing that 703 00:55:48,766 --> 00:55:56,374 for so many decades, with so many different changes in the world, 704 00:55:56,374 --> 00:56:03,982 in the technology, and so on, and so forth, those managers who've 705 00:56:03,982 --> 00:56:10,956 just stuck with using price have actually done very well. Even 706 00:56:10,956 --> 00:56:18,564 though there is a difference, for sure. There is. You know, now 707 00:56:18,564 --> 00:56:24,270 we hear something about economic trend. Well, that's maybe 708 00:56:24,270 --> 00:56:32,512 giving context in another way. Right? But I just don't see it necessarily 709 00:56:32,512 --> 00:56:40,120 as being better. And I'm happy to see that classical trend following, 710 00:56:40,120 --> 00:56:44,558 using price is, is still very potent. 711 00:56:45,222 --> 00:57:18,362 This is, again, ongoing research, and I think it's important 712 00:57:18,362 --> 00:57:58,130 to try to test different hypotheses. You may come to the conclusion 713 00:57:58,130 --> 00:58:37,898 it doesn't add value, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't try to 714 00:58:37,898 --> 00:58:47,840 look at this. Nowwhat we found is that, in some of the research 715 00:56:57,828 --> 00:57:12,726 that I've been looking at, for example, for a lot of LLMs, they'll 716 00:57:12,726 --> 00:57:27,624 use multiple agents so that you come up with an agent and an 717 00:57:27,624 --> 00:57:42,522 agent has a very specific task in a process. So, what they find 718 00:57:42,522 --> 00:57:58,566 is that if you have a model that has an agent, one is following 719 00:57:58,566 --> 00:58:08,880 technical signals, another one that's looking at fundamentals, another 720 00:58:08,880 --> 00:58:22,632 one is looking at sentiment. And then you sort of ensemble all 721 00:58:22,632 --> 00:58:34,092 of those agent behaviors, you actually get better Sharpe ratios 722 00:58:34,092 --> 00:58:47,844 than if you use a coarse model which only uses one agent. So,what 723 00:56:50,228 --> 00:57:20,264 would be the analogy is that you could have a trend following 724 00:57:20,264 --> 00:57:52,803 agent in some type of AI model, but then you also have other 725 00:57:52,803 --> 00:58:22,839 agents, that do other things, that are coming up with other forecasts, 726 00:58:22,839 --> 00:58:47,869 and you blend them together, can you actually do better? Nowis 727 00:56:47,858 --> 00:57:06,310 there a real life analog for this? We do know that when you look 728 00:57:06,310 --> 00:57:19,490 within, we interchangeably use the word trend following versus managed 729 00:57:19,490 --> 00:57:33,988 futures. We do know that finding a pure trend following manager, 730 00:57:33,988 --> 00:57:52,440 there are fewer of those, and more of them try to mix and match 731 00:57:52,440 --> 00:58:05,620 sort of other types of strategies within, that that may 732 00:58:05,620 --> 00:58:20,118 be changing. Again, they may go back to pure trend following. 733 00:58:20,118 --> 00:58:37,252 But when you think about a manager that uses a number of different 734 00:58:37,252 --> 00:58:47,796 strategies, he's acting like a multi agent LLM. 735 00:58:48,672 --> 00:58:54,408 Yeah, I mean again it's, it's interesting and, and I hear this 736 00:58:54,408 --> 00:58:59,188 narrative that using more things is potentially better. I just 737 00:58:59,188 --> 00:59:01,578 think it's an easy narrative. 738 00:59:01,592 --> 00:59:01,912 Right? 739 00:59:01,912 --> 00:59:14,536 Because it could also be much more confusing. I mean you could 740 00:59:14,536 --> 00:59:27,160 have strong GDP data, but the markets could still be going down 741 00:59:27,160 --> 00:59:43,992 and so on and so forth. So, I get it and I know we're heading in 742 00:59:43,992 --> 00:59:55,564 a way where people will innovate, and they will use things, 743 00:59:55,564 --> 01:00:01,932 and combine things, and that's great. Ijustpersonally think that 744 00:59:04,852 --> 00:59:12,496 it's also great to see that just sticking with kind of a more 745 00:59:12,496 --> 00:59:19,552 narrow set of information, and in this case where it all started, 746 00:59:19,552 --> 00:59:26,608 namely price, seems to at least continue to work well for now. 747 00:59:26,608 --> 00:59:33,664 And we'll see. But I think your other point about, you know, 748 00:59:33,664 --> 00:59:40,132 there aren't that many pure trend followers left. And so that's 749 00:59:40,132 --> 00:59:47,188 also maybe just part of the evolution that maybe there will be 750 00:59:47,188 --> 00:59:54,832 even fewer of us left in five year’s time because people will have 751 00:59:54,832 --> 01:00:01,300 added more things to their strategies. I don't know, time will 752 01:00:01,300 --> 01:00:01,888 tell. 753 01:00:02,082 --> 01:00:12,508 And that gets down to one of the classic issues, when you pick 754 01:00:12,508 --> 01:00:19,726 strategies, hedge fund strategies, should you want to have 755 01:00:19,726 --> 01:00:29,350 a pure strategy, and then be able to find another pure strategy 756 01:00:29,350 --> 01:00:38,974 of someone who's doing someone else, and then you as the investor, 757 01:00:38,974 --> 01:00:48,598 you could blend whatever you want. So, for example, and I'm not 758 01:00:48,598 --> 01:00:58,222 saying that people would do this, I have a manager over here 759 01:00:58,222 --> 01:01:07,846 that is a, we'll call it, carry expert. You know, he's Mr. 760 01:01:07,846 --> 01:01:13,460 Carry in terms of all different forms. Andthen I have 761 01:00:05,366 --> 01:00:13,576 another manager that I'm looking at that's a trend follower. 762 01:00:13,576 --> 01:00:24,249 Now, would you prefer to have a single manager who does both together 763 01:00:24,249 --> 01:00:35,743 in the same fund or would you prefer that they say you purely follow 764 01:00:35,743 --> 01:00:45,595 trends, the next person follow carry, and then I as the investor 765 01:00:45,595 --> 01:00:56,268 will figure out what the weights are that I want to have for 766 01:00:56,268 --> 01:01:04,478 my portfolio. And that's an ongoing issue of finance, should 767 01:01:04,478 --> 01:01:13,509 you buy it bundled or should you buy the component parts? 768 01:01:14,232 --> 01:01:18,467 Yeah, yeah, we see that as well with portable alpha. Right? 769 01:01:18,467 --> 01:01:23,087 I mean, more or less everybody can create their own portable alpha 770 01:01:23,087 --> 01:01:27,707 product. But of course there's been a huge market where they success 771 01:01:27,707 --> 01:01:31,557 successfully have, you know, bundled it together. And maybe it's 772 01:01:31,557 --> 01:01:36,177 easier sometimes to give the investors what they need in a package 773 01:01:36,177 --> 01:01:39,257 that they want. And maybe that's the answer. 774 01:01:39,282 --> 01:01:47,334 In driving in very simple terms, the behavior of multi strats, 775 01:01:47,334 --> 01:01:55,386 they're saying we have, maybe, hundreds of pods. What they're saying 776 01:01:55,386 --> 01:02:03,438 is that all those pods are supposed to be orthogonal. They're 777 01:02:03,438 --> 01:02:10,758 all supposed to have slightly different strategies. They say, well 778 01:02:10,758 --> 01:02:21,006 you could go find managers who are like a given pod. But what we're 779 01:02:21,006 --> 01:02:31,254 going to do, our value added, is that we could bundle all of those 780 01:02:31,254 --> 01:02:39,306 pods together in a better portfolio than you could. We could 781 01:02:39,306 --> 01:02:45,894 then react, from a risk management perspective, faster than 782 01:02:45,894 --> 01:02:47,358 you could. So,say this is our value added statement. So we'll say 783 01:01:49,831 --> 01:02:00,380 Wall Street is constantly focused at trying to figure out how 784 01:02:00,380 --> 01:02:09,011 to bundle or de-bundle different risk premia, or different 785 01:02:09,011 --> 01:02:19,560 products, in an effort to serve clients. And the investor is 786 01:02:19,560 --> 01:02:32,027 constantly having to sort of say, do I do the bundling, or do 787 01:02:32,027 --> 01:02:44,494 I let someone else do the bundling? And this is going to be 788 01:02:44,494 --> 01:02:47,371 the age-old problem. 789 01:02:48,862 --> 01:02:52,525 Wall Street has always been good at bundling. Do you remember 790 01:02:52,525 --> 01:02:56,188 when they bundled together really bad loans and it became a 791 01:02:56,188 --> 01:02:58,519 not so great solution for the investor? 792 01:02:58,782 --> 01:03:03,105 Yes, there's good bundling and bad bundling and sometimes we may 793 01:03:03,105 --> 01:03:07,821 not know what is good or bad bundling until after the fact. 794 01:03:09,502 --> 01:03:14,143 That is very true. Anyways Mark, I know you have a hard stop 795 01:03:14,143 --> 01:03:18,427 today, so should we leave it here? Is there anything else you 796 01:03:18,427 --> 01:03:19,855 want to just mention? 797 01:03:20,282 --> 01:03:39,504 Well, the one that I'm going to come back to is that there's been 798 01:03:39,504 --> 01:03:53,234 some interesting research on, we'll call it, bimodality and deep 799 01:03:53,234 --> 01:04:09,710 momentum. And if you look at momentum you actually look at separating 800 01:04:09,710 --> 01:04:24,813 winners, look at winners, past winners or past losers. That also 801 01:04:24,813 --> 01:04:37,170 goes on for trend following and it's cross sectionally. Butwhat 802 01:03:22,722 --> 01:03:39,802 they find out is that, within the set of past winners or past losers, 803 01:03:39,802 --> 01:03:54,442 there's a lot of “noise,” but you'll have some past winners that 804 01:03:54,442 --> 01:04:09,082 continue to win, which is what you'd expect in momentum. But then 805 01:04:09,082 --> 01:04:23,722 you have some past winners that lose really bad. And they use 806 01:04:23,722 --> 01:04:37,142 that as an explanation for why there could be momentum crashes. 807 01:03:20,282 --> 01:03:34,262 AndI think that this is another area of research that is 808 01:03:34,262 --> 01:03:49,407 very insightful. If we go into the details of what's going on in 809 01:03:49,407 --> 01:04:01,057 marketplaces is that we can uncover some new relationships and 810 01:04:01,057 --> 01:04:17,367 I think that this is going to be important work that we need to 811 01:04:17,367 --> 01:04:31,347 explore a little bit more from the trend following area. But we'll 812 01:04:31,347 --> 01:04:37,172 save that for another call. 813 01:04:37,662 --> 01:04:56,655 We'll save that for another day. I mean, it's always so fun to 814 01:04:56,655 --> 01:05:11,265 be having these conversations with you because you never quite 815 01:05:11,265 --> 01:05:28,797 know what going to be in the next conversation. So, really appreciate 816 01:05:28,797 --> 01:05:46,329 that. And of course, you write a lot about many different interesting 817 01:05:46,329 --> 01:06:03,861 topics on your own blog, so people should definitely go and check 818 01:06:03,861 --> 01:06:09,705 that out as well. Now,if those of you listening today want 819 01:04:47,230 --> 01:05:02,778 to just show some appreciation for Mark and all the work and preparation 820 01:05:02,778 --> 01:05:17,130 that he does, along with all the other co-hosts, head over to 821 01:05:17,130 --> 01:05:27,894 your favorite podcast platform, leave a rating and review 822 01:05:27,894 --> 01:05:39,854 because it really does help more people discover the podcast. 823 01:05:39,854 --> 01:05:57,794 And of course, if you want to share it you can use a link called 824 01:05:57,794 --> 01:06:07,362 toptradersunplugged.com/share and people should be able to sign 825 01:06:07,362 --> 01:06:09,754 up there. Nextweek I'll be joined by Allan. So, that's going 826 01:04:58,122 --> 01:05:24,720 to be super interesting. I know he's up to some new stuff so, 827 01:05:24,720 --> 01:05:49,272 I'm sure he'll going to mention some of that. If there are 828 01:05:49,272 --> 01:06:03,594 some questions for Alan, info@toptradersunplugged.com is the 829 01:06:03,594 --> 01:06:09,732 email to use. Now,of course there are lots of other things that 830 01:04:58,592 --> 01:05:25,801 we have on the Top Traders website so people should go and check 831 01:05:25,801 --> 01:05:42,545 that out. Weekly, monthly trend following reports, updates, 832 01:05:42,545 --> 01:06:05,568 blog posts, all sorts of interesting stuff, even if I say 833 01:06:05,568 --> 01:06:09,754 so myself. FromMark and me, thanks ever so much for listening 834 01:05:02,552 --> 01:05:34,909 and we look forward to being back with you next week. And until 835 01:05:34,909 --> 01:06:07,266 next time, as usual, take care of yourself and take care of each 836 01:06:07,266 --> 01:06:09,755 other. 837 01:06:11,762 --> 01:06:21,695 Thanks for listening to Top Traders Unplugged. If you feel you 838 01:06:21,695 --> 01:06:30,725 learned something of value from today's episode, the best way 839 01:06:30,725 --> 01:06:42,464 to stay updated is to go on over to your favorite podcast platform 840 01:06:42,464 --> 01:06:55,106 and follow the show so that you'll be sure to get all the new 841 01:06:55,106 --> 01:07:04,136 episodes as they're released. We have some amazing guests lined 842 01:07:04,136 --> 01:07:15,875 up for you and to ensure our show continues to grow, please leave 843 01:07:15,875 --> 01:07:26,711 us an honest rating and review. It only takes a minute and 844 01:07:26,711 --> 01:07:39,353 it's the best way to show us you love the podcast. We'll see you 845 01:07:39,353 --> 01:07:44,771 next time on Top Traders Unplugged. Thispodcast expresses 846 01:06:14,933 --> 01:06:28,674 the views of its hosts and the guests appearing on the podcast as 847 01:06:28,674 --> 01:06:42,415 of the date of its recording, and such views are subject to change 848 01:06:42,415 --> 01:06:54,042 without notice. Top Traders Unplugged do not have any duty or 849 01:06:54,042 --> 01:07:02,498 obligation to update the information contained herein. Furthermore, 850 01:07:02,498 --> 01:07:13,068 Top Traders Unplugged make no representation to its accuracy and 851 01:07:13,068 --> 01:07:24,695 it shall not be assumed that past investment performance is an 852 01:07:24,695 --> 01:07:35,265 indication of future results. Moreover, wherever there is a potential 853 01:07:35,265 --> 01:07:44,778 for profit, there is also the possibility of loss. Thiscontent 854 01:06:22,100 --> 01:07:08,621 is made available for educational purposes only and should 855 01:07:08,621 --> 01:07:44,804 not be used for any other purpose. Theinformation contained 856 01:06:19,514 --> 01:06:47,938 in this podcast does not constitute, and should not be construed 857 01:06:47,938 --> 01:07:16,362 as investment advice, or an offer to sell, or a solicitation 858 01:07:16,362 --> 01:07:39,618 to buy any securities or related financial instruments in 859 01:07:39,618 --> 01:07:44,786 any jurisdiction. Certaininformation contained herein 860 01:06:17,154 --> 01:06:30,634 concerning economic trends and performance is based on or derived 861 01:06:30,634 --> 01:06:40,070 from information provided by independent third-party sources. 862 01:06:40,070 --> 01:06:53,550 Top Traders Unplugged may believe that the sources from which 863 01:06:53,550 --> 01:07:05,682 such information are obtained are reliable. However, Top Traders 864 01:07:05,682 --> 01:07:17,814 Unplugged cannot guarantee the accuracy of such information and 865 01:07:17,814 --> 01:07:31,294 has not independently verified the accuracy or completeness of such 866 01:07:31,294 --> 01:07:44,774 information or the assumptions on which such information is based. 867 01:06:11,762 --> 01:06:35,018 Thispodcast, including the information contained herein, may 868 01:06:35,018 --> 01:07:04,088 not be reproduced, copied, republished or posted in whole or 869 01:07:04,088 --> 01:07:38,972 in part in any form, without the prior written consent of Top 870 01:07:38,972 --> 01:07:44,786 Traders Unplugged.