This is Transit Unplugged.
Paul Comfort:I'm Paul Comfort.
Paul Comfort:On today's episode of the Transit Unplugged podcast, we
Paul Comfort:talk about some of the hottest topics in public transportation.
Paul Comfort:And.
Paul Comfort:They are written in a book called The New Future of Public Transportation,
Paul Comfort:which I put together with 30 of my friends and leaders of top transit
Paul Comfort:agencies, consultants, and experts in the technology field from around the world.
Paul Comfort:The book is out now.
Paul Comfort:It is The New Future of Public Transportation, basically the next
Paul Comfort:phase of my The book I wrote a few years ago, before the pandemic, called
Paul Comfort:The Future of Public Transportation, and Society of Automotive Engineers
Paul Comfort:reached out to me about nine months to a year ago and asked me if I would
Paul Comfort:be interested in writing an updated version, kind of a post pandemic version.
Paul Comfort:What are the hot topics now?
Paul Comfort:You know, new things that we weren't really talking a lot about before.
Paul Comfort:Back then, cybersecurity, AI driven advancements, hydrogen fuel buses,
Paul Comfort:infrastructure challenges, workforce shortages, all of those things.
Paul Comfort:And so I accepted and invited these 30 top leaders from around the world
Paul Comfort:to write on five topics, people, modal futures, zero emission vehicles,
Paul Comfort:data, funding and faring, and for one extra bonus, geographic futures.
Paul Comfort:later on in the podcast at the end, I'll go through each of them and what
Paul Comfort:their chapters are about, but this, as an intro, is an exciting time to
Paul Comfort:talk about these important issues.
Paul Comfort:On today's episode of the podcast, I, spent some time talking to two
Paul Comfort:of the guests who wrote in the book.
Paul Comfort:first is Dr.
Paul Comfort:Karen Philbrick, a friend of mine, and executive director
Paul Comfort:Mineta Transportation Institute.
Paul Comfort:She wrote about cybersecurity, workforce shortages, operator mental health,
Paul Comfort:rebuilding ridership, safety in transit.
Paul Comfort:She talks about that on an interview right after this opening.
Paul Comfort:Then after that, we hear from Paige Malott, who is a high speed rail
Paul Comfort:researcher with the International Union of Railways and a consultant
Paul Comfort:with her own company P7 Strategies.
Paul Comfort:this is one of the hottest topics.
Paul Comfort:You know, we just had Brightline Trains, break ground on the
Paul Comfort:Southern California, kind of L.
Paul Comfort:A.
Paul Comfort:to Las Vegas route they're going to have
Paul Comfort:so, it's on the minds of people here in the U.
Paul Comfort:S., and of course, they really know how to do this well in Europe and Asia, and
Paul Comfort:she's seen half the rail systems in the world, and talks about them on today's
Paul Comfort:podcast on the second part of the show.
Paul Comfort:And then on the third part, as I mentioned, we'll dive a little bit
Paul Comfort:into all the other, contributors to the book and what their topics are.
Paul Comfort:It's a great day to celebrate the new future of public transportation.
Paul Comfort:Now let's join my conversation with Dr.
Paul Comfort:Philbrick.
Paul Comfort:Great to have Dr.
Paul Comfort:Karen Philbrick with us as our first guest on today's podcast.
Paul Comfort:Karen's a good friend of mine and Executive Director of the Minetta
Paul Comfort:Transportation Institute, one of the top think tanks and study groups
Paul Comfort:in the country and the world when it comes to public transportation.
Paul Comfort:Dr.
Paul Comfort:Philbrick, thank you so much for being with us tonight.
Karen Philbrick:Thank you for having me and thank you for your leadership
Karen Philbrick:in putting together this book.
Karen Philbrick:It's an indispensable resource for transportation professionals and
Karen Philbrick:people just interested in our sector.
Karen Philbrick:You are phenomenal.
Karen Philbrick:Thank you, Paul.
Paul Comfort:Oh, thanks, Karen.
Paul Comfort:That's great.
Paul Comfort:I really appreciate that.
Paul Comfort:Yeah, the book is exciting.
Paul Comfort:And as we record this today on May Day, May 1st, the book has rocketed to number
Paul Comfort:one, Even before, today was supposed to be the launch day, which is why we're
Paul Comfort:recording today, but Amazon put it out a little early, and it already went
Paul Comfort:to number one in multiple categories.
Paul Comfort:So very exciting, and I'm sure your chapter is one of the big reasons why I
Paul Comfort:care, which is why I wanted you on the show today, because you cover probably
Paul Comfort:more topics than anybody else in the book.
Paul Comfort:there are 30 chapters written by 30 different individuals, mine is on people,
Paul Comfort:leadership and stuff, but your chapter really digs into five hot topics, which
Paul Comfort:I know people are going to want to know the latest about, because you all have
Paul Comfort:done a lot of studies on these, and you have some personal, knowledge about some
Paul Comfort:of these topics I think that'll be very interesting, and they are cyber security,
Paul Comfort:workforce shortages, operator mental health, assaults on transit, overall
Paul Comfort:safety, and then rebuilding ridership.
Paul Comfort:You think we can dig into some of them today?
Karen Philbrick:I think we can, and I think we should.
Paul Comfort:Yeah, good.
Paul Comfort:You know, I was just out in the Midwest part of the country with a
Paul Comfort:CEO, and he told me they just had a ransomware attack, and they had
Paul Comfort:just worked their way through it.
Paul Comfort:They didn't pay the ransom, but it was very difficult, very challenging.
Paul Comfort:I actually did a presentation with him, and his laptop was shut down.
Paul Comfort:He couldn't do anything.
Paul Comfort:He lost the presentation.
Paul Comfort:It was, you know, it's, that's small potatoes compared to what really
Paul Comfort:happens, but it has a big effect, doesn't it, on a transit agency.
Karen Philbrick:Absolutely, it affects every level of the transit agency
Karen Philbrick:and potentially the riding public.
Karen Philbrick:I mean, Paul, when we talk about our systems, cybersecurity has
Karen Philbrick:to be a part of the conversation.
Karen Philbrick:I mean, you've read the news yourself that multiple transit agencies over
Karen Philbrick:the last 5 or 6 years have been impacted, not only here in California,
Karen Philbrick:but even the systems in New York City and everywhere in between.
Karen Philbrick:Not only does it disrupt service, It can actually have a negative impact
Karen Philbrick:on people's safety and viability if there is some sort of breach.
Karen Philbrick:And I think the main takeaway, particularly that I'd like to emphasize is
Karen Philbrick:the fact that 80 to 90% of cybersecurity breaches are the result of staff members
Karen Philbrick:who unknowingly open up malware or ransomware within their own emails.
Karen Philbrick:So having that IT security tips, training on such issues is absolutely
Karen Philbrick:important to the well being and seamless connection of all of our systems.
Paul Comfort:That's great.
Paul Comfort:That's good advice.
Paul Comfort:I know a lot of agencies are working on that.
Paul Comfort:You know, I've talked to some senior IT people in big companies and transit
Paul Comfort:agencies recently, and they told me they're literally getting thousands
Paul Comfort:of attacks every day against their, you know, they're just being hit
Paul Comfort:from, sometimes, you know, foreign countries, it's coming from them, etc.
Paul Comfort:And so it's so important to keep those security measures up.
Karen Philbrick:And to make sure that you are downloading
Karen Philbrick:any of the different patches and other things that are happening.
Karen Philbrick:But really, Paul, we need to train people that when they get an email that
Karen Philbrick:has a really cute dog or a cute cat or something else they're interested in,
Karen Philbrick:good God, don't open it, move right along.
Karen Philbrick:And, and, you know, that's talking about more of the software, if
Karen Philbrick:you will, and the people focus.
Karen Philbrick:I want to give one example, and this was in 2018 with the
Karen Philbrick:Bay Area Rapid Transit, BART.
Karen Philbrick:Prior to the pandemic, it was the fifth busiest passenger
Karen Philbrick:rail system in the nation.
Karen Philbrick:It's here in the Bay Area specifically, but in 2018, they found that 86%
Karen Philbrick:of 1000 hardware devices, 86%.
Karen Philbrick:That Cisco had supplied to them, contained hidden back doors on the devices that
Karen Philbrick:sent information to foreign nationals that are hostile to American interests.
Karen Philbrick:BART did everything right, as soon as they found this, everything
Karen Philbrick:was replaced within 72 hours.
Karen Philbrick:But that's the level of granular detail that we need.
Karen Philbrick:We can't just trust what comes from suppliers and vendors.
Karen Philbrick:We have to have RFPs and other paperwork that are very specific about
Karen Philbrick:some of the technology safeguards that are being put into place.
Paul Comfort:Wow, that's amazing.
Paul Comfort:And you guys at the Minetta Transportation Institute, didn't you just have a
Paul Comfort:study or something on this topic?
Karen Philbrick:Yeah, we've done quite a few studies on this topic with our
Karen Philbrick:MTI Research Associate, Scott Belcher.
Karen Philbrick:In fact, some of that work has resulted in congressional testimony.
Karen Philbrick:And really, we tried to identify what was the issue within public transportation,
Karen Philbrick:and we worked hand in glove with the American Public Transportation
Karen Philbrick:Association, commonly known as APTA, to help survey the different transit
Karen Philbrick:agencies to determine where those hotspots were and what best practices
Karen Philbrick:could be introduced into our sector to help with any of these issues.
Karen Philbrick:So we continue that line of work.
Karen Philbrick:We are paying very close attention to it.
Paul Comfort:That's wonderful.
Paul Comfort:Let's move on to the next topic then, which I know is near and
Paul Comfort:dear to both of our hearts, and that is workforce shortages.
Paul Comfort:Post pandemic, a lot of transit agencies have had trouble.
Paul Comfort:What do you have to say about that?
Karen Philbrick:I have more than you can imagine to say about This is one
Karen Philbrick:of the areas that I am particularly passionate about, and I want to
Karen Philbrick:just step back for a minute, Paul.
Karen Philbrick:When you gave me the honor and the privilege of asking me to contribute,
Karen Philbrick:I sat and I thought, what, what do I get most passionate about?
Karen Philbrick:What do I think are the big issues?
Karen Philbrick:And workforce shortage was right up there, because what I always like to
Karen Philbrick:say is transportation touches us all, whether it's how we get from point A to
Karen Philbrick:point B, or whether it's the food we eat.
Karen Philbrick:For The devices we use and in fact some of the latest scientific literature
Karen Philbrick:shows that people who are socially isolated have physical health that
Karen Philbrick:can be the equivalent of people who smoke up to 15 cigarettes a day.
Karen Philbrick:So when you talk about how vital connection is, you're obviously
Karen Philbrick:talking about public transportation.
Karen Philbrick:Oh, I have goosebumps.
Karen Philbrick:I just love this.
Karen Philbrick:But we are suffering.
Karen Philbrick:This started before the pandemic.
Karen Philbrick:In fact, in 2019, we at the Institute did some research.
Karen Philbrick:That documented that shortage, but also reflected the percent
Karen Philbrick:of the workforce that were women.
Karen Philbrick:At that time, it was fewer than 15%.
Karen Philbrick:We have seen some growth in that area, but we are still woefully underrepresented.
Karen Philbrick:APTA did a recent study that looked at workforce shortage.
Karen Philbrick:They found that 96 percent of agencies reported experiencing
Karen Philbrick:such a shortage and that in many cases, it's impacted operations.
Karen Philbrick:Furthermore, when you look at our transit operators, the frontline, the
Karen Philbrick:people are making it happen every day.
Karen Philbrick:Oh, this is, this is scary now.
Karen Philbrick:43 percent of the operators are 55 or older.
Karen Philbrick:We're talking retirement folks, and we are competing with every other
Karen Philbrick:sector for that qualified workforce.
Karen Philbrick:So when I think about that, I think how are we going to get people excited?
Karen Philbrick:How interested in joining our ranks?
Karen Philbrick:So at the Institute, we've developed workforce programs All the way into
Karen Philbrick:preschool, so kids can start learning about the industry and what exists for
Karen Philbrick:their future, and we need to start young.
Karen Philbrick:If we're starting when people are in their 20s, we've missed that boat, and
Karen Philbrick:we need to talk about jobs in transit in a different way that really reflects the
Karen Philbrick:power of these positions and the impact that they have on people's lives, as well
Karen Philbrick:as their communities, and that shortage, last comment that we face, is that It's
Karen Philbrick:from the front line to the C suite.
Karen Philbrick:So we have opportunities across that pipeline, regardless of
Karen Philbrick:what people are interested in.
Paul Comfort:I just heard, from Frank White, in Kansas City recently that, from
Paul Comfort:the APTA CEO summit that he went to, in Savannah somewhere he got this number
Paul Comfort:that was announced there that the average age of a CEO of a transit system is 58.
Paul Comfort:we're all getting toward that retirement age.
Paul Comfort:It's something.
Paul Comfort:Well, this is good stuff.
Paul Comfort:That's right.
Paul Comfort:You've got great information in the book about it as well.
Paul Comfort:and you are chapter four, by the way, in the book, right after mine.
Paul Comfort:I'm three, you're four, we're right next to each other.
Paul Comfort:So, we're in the people section, you know, so it's, Aaron Weinstein talks
Paul Comfort:about customer experience and I talk about transportation leadership.
Paul Comfort:You talk about these workforce shortages, mental health, and then
Paul Comfort:Daphne LeBlanc talks about the future of succession planning and labor shortages.
Paul Comfort:It's a great grouping of chapters there together.
Paul Comfort:And let's switch into that topic then for a minute if we could, Dr.
Paul Comfort:Philbrick, which is operator mental health.
Paul Comfort:what are your thoughts on that?
Karen Philbrick:I think that we are not paying close enough
Karen Philbrick:attention to mental health.
Karen Philbrick:I think when we take ourselves out of the transport sector and think of humanity,
Karen Philbrick:we can never even try to understand what another person is experiencing.
Karen Philbrick:And even though we may all present with happy faces, we might have some serious
Karen Philbrick:trauma that's happening underneath and particularly in the transportation sector.
Karen Philbrick:which tends to be relatively male dominated that can in times have
Karen Philbrick:more of a machismo sort of culture.
Karen Philbrick:People are not feeling comfortable, safe, or transparent enough to be
Karen Philbrick:able to talk about some of the issues that they're really experiencing.
Karen Philbrick:And for me, I'm a psychologist by training, double master's,
Karen Philbrick:PhD, different disciplines.
Karen Philbrick:My entire career has been in transportation.
Karen Philbrick:And so when something happens in our industry, it.
Karen Philbrick:It affects me deeply, not only intellectually and cognitively, but
Karen Philbrick:emotionally, and as you might recall, we lost a great person in our industry
Karen Philbrick:in 2022 when CEO Jeff Parker of MARTA in Atlanta committed suicide by
Karen Philbrick:laying down in front of his own train.
Karen Philbrick:This was a wonderful man.
Karen Philbrick:You've heard me tell this story before.
Karen Philbrick:And nobody knew, including his wife and his children, how bad he was suffering.
Karen Philbrick:And I can't help but to wonder if we just allowed people a little bit more space.
Karen Philbrick:To be that human and to really talk with each other to provide that social
Karen Philbrick:support that we would excel all together that everybody would be raised up.
Karen Philbrick:But unfortunately, I don't know that transit agencies are spending
Karen Philbrick:the time, the money, or the or the resources to take intentional steps
Karen Philbrick:to address this issue at present.
Karen Philbrick:I do think there's movement in the air.
Karen Philbrick:I do think that people are becoming more comfortable talking about this,
Karen Philbrick:but we need to get over that hump so that collectively we can be better.
Paul Comfort:That's good.
Paul Comfort:And then, you know, there's been a lot of talk about, crime on transit, assaults
Paul Comfort:on transit, you know, in New York City, it seems like every week there's a
Paul Comfort:story that comes out about something terrible that's happened on a platform.
Paul Comfort:where are we on that, do you think, in the country?
Karen Philbrick:Well, we are improving, but we have a long
Karen Philbrick:runway to really address this issue.
Karen Philbrick:And I think about what you just said in terms of assault.
Karen Philbrick:Whether it's assault on the operator or assault on the rider, this is happening.
Karen Philbrick:People being put into experiences that may not be comfortable.
Karen Philbrick:And yes, we have training on de escalation.
Karen Philbrick:We have some transit agencies not having operators do fare
Karen Philbrick:enforcement, for example, which can reduce some of that tension.
Karen Philbrick:But still, think about you going to your job every day and
Karen Philbrick:wondering if you'll get spit on.
Karen Philbrick:Hit,
Karen Philbrick:kicked, punched, or verbally yelled at.
Karen Philbrick:It's not a comfortable situation.
Karen Philbrick:And if I may just go back.
Karen Philbrick:Many, many years now, I started my career looking at operator response to
Karen Philbrick:trauma, particularly person under the train incidents, whether that was a
Karen Philbrick:grade crossing accident or a trespasser incident, and in thousands, literally
Karen Philbrick:thousands of interviews I conducted, what emerged Was the profile of being
Karen Philbrick:spat upon being more emotionally damaging and difficult psychologically
Karen Philbrick:than perhaps having an incident where someone lost their life under the train?
Karen Philbrick:Because, of course, the operators can't swerve.
Karen Philbrick:They have no control over what happens, but they are left.
Karen Philbrick:Hostage to watch what happens in front of them and that has a serious
Karen Philbrick:negative emotional impact in some cases.
Karen Philbrick:So, when I think about assault, I think about we can't presume
Karen Philbrick:to know what the impact is on someone who's had that experience.
Karen Philbrick:We need to put in more safety measures, more safeguards.
Karen Philbrick:And when it comes to ridership itself, you yourself have likely
Karen Philbrick:read some of the most horrifying stories of rape and other attacks
Karen Philbrick:that happened on the actual train car.
Karen Philbrick:It's just, it's absolutely devastating, but we are working
Karen Philbrick:as an industry to overcome that.
Karen Philbrick:We have many, many examples of how assault is being addressed,
Karen Philbrick:not only with the operators, but helping to support the riding public.
Karen Philbrick:In fact, the Institute was codified into law through California Senate Bill 1161.
Karen Philbrick:To develop a survey to quantify the issue, because right now you can't
Karen Philbrick:compare apples and oranges, and a small agency might be recording data in a
Karen Philbrick:different way than a larger agency.
Karen Philbrick:So, get an accurate picture.
Karen Philbrick:We're developing a template for a survey to document the existence of this,
Karen Philbrick:and then to look at best practices for mitigating that experience.
Paul Comfort:That's great.
Paul Comfort:Lastly, let's jump into rebuilding ridership.
Paul Comfort:The transit world is coming back, and I think we're coming back strong, but a lot
Paul Comfort:of agencies are tapping out at around 70 80 percent of their pre pandemic ridership
Paul Comfort:because we are in a new world now with hybrid work schedules, the three day city.
Paul Comfort:What are you seeing?
Karen Philbrick:Well, I'm seeing it depends on the area that you live.
Karen Philbrick:So, I'm going to go back to what I know best, and that's
Karen Philbrick:Silicon Valley and the Bay Area.
Karen Philbrick:We have one of the lowest return to work rates in the nation, in large part
Karen Philbrick:because we're in the Silicon Valley and it's a tech driven economy where
Karen Philbrick:people can do their jobs remotely.
Karen Philbrick:So, what we're seeing is agencies looking at ridership trends
Karen Philbrick:and changing their service.
Karen Philbrick:Maybe they no longer provide bimodal service at the peak distribution hours.
Karen Philbrick:Maybe they offer more evening service or more weekend service because they're
Karen Philbrick:seeing riders using the system for reasons other than commuting to work.
Karen Philbrick:And I think we need to really pay close attention to that.
Karen Philbrick:Certainly, we've seen ridership rebound very strongly on the East
Karen Philbrick:Coast, particularly in Washington, D.
Karen Philbrick:C.
Karen Philbrick:and New York City.
Karen Philbrick:We do see some of our other agencies struggling because people are still
Karen Philbrick:working through the cognitive mindset of the pandemic and feeling like exposure
Karen Philbrick:might be strong, or they got used to being in their own vehicle and have
Karen Philbrick:forgotten the ease, the convenience, the sustainability of using transit instead.
Karen Philbrick:So I think we need to be nimble, we need to be able to pivot, we
Karen Philbrick:need to look at the ridership numbers, and we need to adjust to
Karen Philbrick:provide the best service possible.
Karen Philbrick:And in doing so, we'll rebuild that ridership.
Paul Comfort:That's good.
Paul Comfort:I always think about what Jeremy Yap told me.
Paul Comfort:He runs Singapore's LTA transit system.
Paul Comfort:And after the pandemic, he said, you know, the silver lining is I don't have the peak
Paul Comfort:of the peak of the peak anymore, where I have to put all my resources out there.
Paul Comfort:Now I can spread them out.
Paul Comfort:And serve more people throughout the day.
Paul Comfort:And I think, well, like you said, that's what a lot of transit agencies have done.
Paul Comfort:Dr.
Paul Comfort:Philbrick, thank you so much for being not only a part of our podcast today, but
Paul Comfort:an integral part of our new book, The New Future of Public Transportation, talking
Paul Comfort:even more in depth on all these topics.
Karen Philbrick:Thank you for having me.
Karen Philbrick:It was just delightful.
Paul Comfort:Thank you so much.
Paul Comfort:You bet.
Paul Comfort:What a great interview with Dr.
Paul Comfort:Karen Philbrick, Executive Director of the Minetta Transportation Institute,
Paul Comfort:where she covered some of the hottest topics affecting our industry that
Paul Comfort:she wrote about in my book, The New Future of Public Transportation.
Paul Comfort:Now we interview Paige Malott, who is a high speed rail consultant and
Paul Comfort:researcher with the International Union of Railways, and she talks about what's
Paul Comfort:happening with high speed rail around the world and here in the United States.
Paul Comfort:Thanks Let's listen in.
Paul Comfort:Great to have Paige Malott with us today.
Paul Comfort:She is a high speed rail consultant, a researcher, has her own consulting
Paul Comfort:firm, P7 Strategies, and has written an amazing chapter in my book, and it
Paul Comfort:is on the future of high speed rail.
Paul Comfort:Paige, thanks so much for being with us today on the podcast to talk about it.
Paige Malott:Thanks for having me, Paul.
Paige Malott:Glad to be here.
Paul Comfort:Yeah, I, you know, this is one of the hottest
Paul Comfort:topics, clearly in America right now, but also around the world.
Paul Comfort:In America, people are, know, all about Brightline trains right now, right?
Paul Comfort:Brightline trains in Southern California over to Vegas is the latest.
Paul Comfort:Hot thing, they just did a groundbreaking, I actually got invited to it, uh,
Paul Comfort:it was just a couple weeks ago, wasn't able to make it, but, so,
Paul Comfort:higher speed rail, I know that's not real traditional high speed rail,
Paul Comfort:is on people's minds here in the U.
Paul Comfort:S., and you told me, you just came back from an amazing trip
Paul Comfort:to Korea, tell me about that.
Paige Malott:That's right, yeah, so I was able to visit Korea, visit
Paige Malott:Seoul for their 20th anniversary of their high speed rail system.
Paige Malott:So Korea has the 4th high speed rail system that opened in the world with their
Paige Malott:line running from Seoul to Busan, and they had an amazing exhibit with historical
Paige Malott:artifacts, with representations of future trains, with art projects, and we even
Paige Malott:did a tour of the maintenance facility.
Paige Malott:I was able to go there with the International Union of Railways
Paige Malott:and talk about a little bit of research that I'm doing.
Paige Malott:On high speed rail stations at airports, so it was a really good time.
Paige Malott:great to check it out and have that firsthand experience
Paige Malott:to bring back to the States.
Paul Comfort:Yeah.
Paul Comfort:A long time ago, it might have been, I don't know, 15 years ago when I was a
Paul Comfort:county administrator, I did a trip to China and I got to ride on the real high
Paul Comfort:speed rail, Maglev, outside of Shanghai.
Paul Comfort:And I was just so impressed with that.
Paul Comfort:And then when I was in Baltimore at the MTA, my boss, the Secretary of
Paul Comfort:Transportation and the governor went to Japan to ride their high speed railway.
Paul Comfort:And we had a study going on that was federally funded to
Paul Comfort:potentially build in the future.
Paul Comfort:A high speed rail line between Washington, D.
Paul Comfort:C.
Paul Comfort:and Baltimore, which would be like a 15 minute ride, and there's still
Paul Comfort:a group that's doing the study.
Paul Comfort:but you've been all over the world.
Paul Comfort:Tell us what's happening with high speed rail around the world, and then we'll
Paul Comfort:segue to the United States, and you can tell us, why is it taking us so long?
Paige Malott:Sure, so I've had the opportunity to ride and
Paige Malott:witness 10 of the 21 high speed rail systems around the world.
Paige Malott:That's in Africa, in Asia, and in Europe.
Paige Malott:And most recently, just in this past October, Indonesia opened their 1st
Paige Malott:high speed rail system, connecting Jakarta to Bandung, and that operates
Paige Malott:at, it was 320 kilometers per hour, so roughly 200 miles per hour.
Paige Malott:miles per hour and true high speed.
Paige Malott:So, this line has been wildly popular, similar to what we saw in Morocco,
Paige Malott:with the results there, operating at 200 miles per hour and greater.
Paige Malott:That reduced travel times between Jakarta and Bandung in your from roughly 6 hours
Paige Malott:by driving down to 40 minutes by train.
Paige Malott:So it was, it was a huge success and they're already looking at expansions.
Paige Malott:also looking at Morocco, the line from Tangier to Casablanca, that takes
Paige Malott:roughly 90 minutes and it was a similar journey time on conventional rail and
Paige Malott:on a car about 5 to 6 hours there.
Paige Malott:So it was really game changing transportation for citizens that has
Paige Malott:reduced the need to drive or take an airplane between these destinations.
Paul Comfort:is 200 miles per hour considered the cutoff if you're above
Paul Comfort:that, your high speed, I mean, what tradition, you know, real high speed?
Paige Malott:So, 186 miles per hour is what the high speed classification is.
Paige Malott:And it's also the speed that trains can compete with air travel.
Paige Malott:So what we're looking at is anything greater than 106 miles, 186 miles
Paige Malott:per hour is high speed rail.
Paige Malott:The next step down is 125 to 186 is inner city rail, or what we call
Paige Malott:in the states higher speed rail,
Paul Comfort:and then
Paige Malott:anything below 125 is conventional rail.
Paul Comfort:Okay, so the Brightline train in Florida is the higher
Paul Comfort:speed, but the one they're proposing out west is going to be 200 miles
Paul Comfort:per hour, so that one would be classified as a true high speed rail.
Paul Comfort:So, what are some of the fastest trains in the world?
Paul Comfort:Do you know?
Paul Comfort:I mean, how fast are they going?
Paul Comfort:It seems like the one in Shanghai I was in was really fast.
Paige Malott:Yeah, so China has the fastest high speed trains in the world.
Paige Malott:They also have the most high speed lines in the world as well.
Paige Malott:And these have really changed where people can go in the country.
Paige Malott:It's serving rural areas, as well as connecting the bigger cities.
Paige Malott:And what we've heard is, uh, the essentially the mayors and the towns are
Paige Malott:getting demand from the folks in town saying, when is the station coming here?
Paige Malott:It doesn't matter what the size of the town is.
Paige Malott:People are excited for it, so it's really seeing those game changing
Paige Malott:outcomes and connecting places that are looking for more opportunities.
Paul Comfort:Yeah, I like the phrase here that I've heard used, which is,
Paul Comfort:high speed rail is great for places where it is too long to drive, but too
Paul Comfort:close to fly, really, to get out to go, yeah, take any, you know, spend an
Paul Comfort:hour and a half to get on your airplane to park, but do your bags and fly.
Paul Comfort:So, uh, if it's a niche.
Paul Comfort:Uh, evidently right in that spot.
Paul Comfort:Why is it, why is it so hard here in America?
Paul Comfort:I mean, we've got, like I mentioned, in Baltimore, they were studying
Paul Comfort:this before I got there, which was like eight, nine years ago, and
Paul Comfort:they're still studying it today.
Paul Comfort:Then you've got the California High Speed Rail Project, which everyone
Paul Comfort:still has very high hopes for, but it just seems to be taking a long time.
Paul Comfort:In your opinion, Paige, what's going on?
Paige Malott:All right, so, you know, we have the the too short to
Paige Malott:fly too long to drive radius, which is about 500 miles from a city center.
Paige Malott:So we're looking at city pairs within those those radiuses that
Paige Malott:could be served by high speed rail.
Paige Malott:And we currently have a gap of that in America where there may be
Paige Malott:existing inner city trains, but.
Paige Malott:But they have been underserved and under invested in.
Paige Malott:So they're not being utilized by people.
Paige Malott:I think a great example of this is from Chicago to Cincinnati.
Paige Malott:We've got a corridor that takes roughly 90 minutes to fly, five hours to drive.
Paige Malott:And there is an intercity train between these cities, except it takes
Paige Malott:nine and a half hours to get there.
Paige Malott:The train comes three times.
Paige Malott:Wait, wait, it gets better.
Paige Malott:Nine and a half hours to get there.
Paige Malott:The train comes three times a week.
Paige Malott:And it leaves Cincinnati at 1 in the morning.
Paige Malott:Now, these are cities, you know, that have a population area of, close to
Paige Malott:like 1 to 2 million people, right?
Paige Malott:And so they're sizable cities, goes through Indianapolis as well.
Paige Malott:So, these folks have been historically underserved by inner city rail.
Paige Malott:And I think we are looking at how we can have these game changing
Paige Malott:solutions from under investment in existing passenger rail.
Paige Malott:The Brightline West is going to be a great leading project for that because,
Paige Malott:well, everyone, everyone in the States.
Paige Malott:It ends up in Las Vegas at some time.
Paige Malott:It's a city that attracts people from everywhere.
Paige Malott:You know, it's not necessarily, being somewhere on the coast.
Paige Malott:Everyone comes there to have fun.
Paige Malott:And I think having a rail line there connecting into LA, particularly with the
Paige Malott:Olympics coming up, is going to be a great opportunity for people to see firsthand
Paige Malott:what actual high speed rail is in this country and how that can deliver results.
Paul Comfort:I know there's a lot of environmental regulations.
Paul Comfort:There's people that sue to stop things from coming through their neighborhood.
Paul Comfort:These are some of the issues that I've experienced
Paul Comfort:personally in my previous jobs.
Paul Comfort:Oh, and, and of course, nowadays everything is going up in costs and, but
Paul Comfort:what is taking so long here in the U.
Paul Comfort:S.?
Paul Comfort:Why can't we get, you know, a real high speed above 180 mile per hour train?
Paige Malott:I think part of the, the issue is kind of looking at what we
Paige Malott:need to do to implement fast trains.
Paige Malott:1 of the rules that we have is that if we have a grade level crossing, so where cars
Paige Malott:intersect with intersect with trains that we can't have speeds that that go over.
Paige Malott:125 miles an hour.
Paige Malott:That's basically the regulation there.
Paige Malott:So, so when we're looking to have trains that are competing
Paige Malott:with speeds airplanes, right?
Paige Malott:Like, 186 miles an hour trains and having those competitive travel times.
Paige Malott:We're needing to build grade separation for that, and that's
Paige Malott:going to cost more money.
Paige Malott:So it's going to take a little bit longer to do, it's going to have
Paige Malott:higher infrastructure costs, and that all takes political will and
Paige Malott:business partners and money to do.
Paige Malott:And getting all of that lined up takes time, particularly when we haven't had
Paige Malott:the generational investments in rail like other countries in Europe have.
Paige Malott:But I think we're getting to a point now where we're seeing other countries,
Paige Malott:such as Morocco, such as Indonesia, That have had these projects that were able
Paige Malott:to get them off the ground quickly and have seen the results and it's showing
Paige Malott:that as a well resourced country, we should be able to do the same.
Paul Comfort:Yeah, I think it requires sustained political support and that
Paul Comfort:sometimes is hard to get because we're turning people over in office every two
Paul Comfort:to four years sometimes and, the pendulum, political pendulum sometimes swings.
Paul Comfort:So, what do you see as the future?
Paul Comfort:of high speed rail.
Paul Comfort:I mean, that is the subject of your chapter and people
Paul Comfort:can read about it in the book.
Paul Comfort:It's available now.
Paul Comfort:But, uh, what do you think the future is in just a few sentences?
Paige Malott:The future of high speed rail, I see, is being incorporated into
Paige Malott:other mega projects that we have in the United States, incorporating high speed
Paige Malott:rail stations at airports, planning high speed rail alongside interstate
Paige Malott:expansions, and being able to see all of these projects and transportation systems
Paige Malott:working together instead of in silos.
Paige Malott:I believe we're going to have game changing opportunities for cities that
Paige Malott:have been historically underserved by rail, and it's really going to
Paige Malott:bring about a good opportunity for Growth and traffic congestion and
Paige Malott:sustainability in the United States.
Paul Comfort:That's great.
Paul Comfort:I hope your prediction and your future comes true.
Paul Comfort:That's great.
Paul Comfort:Paige Malott thank you so much for being not only a part of our podcast today,
Paul Comfort:but also a contributor to our book, The New Future of Public Transportation.
Paul Comfort:The title of your chapter, which is Chapter 8, is The
Paul Comfort:Future of High Speed Rail.
Paul Comfort:Thanks again.
Paul Comfort:Thanks so much, Paul.
Paul Comfort:What great interviews today with, , two of the contributors to the book.
Paul Comfort:Now I'd like to take a few minutes and share with you the rest of the
Paul Comfort:contributors to the book and all the topics that are included in it.
Paul Comfort:As you know, I've written about a book a year since I left the MTA as
Paul Comfort:CEO in Baltimore six years ago, and they've covered all kinds of topics.
Paul Comfort:My first book was Full Throttle.
Paul Comfort:Lessons On Leadership.
Paul Comfort:The next was The Future of Public Transportation, which was
Paul Comfort:the predecessor to this book.
Paul Comfort:Then it was a children's book and then a book on Conversations on Equity and
Paul Comfort:Inclusion in Public Transportation which was number one on Amazon for
Paul Comfort:six weeks and then, I did a cookbook last year featuring recipes and
Paul Comfort:stories from public transit executives around the world called ComfortFood.
Paul Comfort:In this post COVID world, there's enough changes happening in the transit
Paul Comfort:industry that it merits and warrants a new book with new subject matter.
Paul Comfort:I was able to get 30 top transit and technology leaders from
Paul Comfort:around the world to write chapters on their areas of expertise.
Paul Comfort:And man, they're very well written chapters from these leading figures from
Paul Comfort:topics such as hydrogen fueled buses to AI driven advancements to cyber security.
Paul Comfort:So much has changed in the last four or five years.
Paul Comfort:and so it's exciting to have all of this information compiled into a book.
Paul Comfort:It's great for people who are interested in public transportation, the future of
Paul Comfort:cities, sustainability, it's focused on those topics and I want to share with you
Paul Comfort:some of the people who are in the book.
Paul Comfort:Actually, I'm going to take a few minutes and actually walk you through
Paul Comfort:everyone who wrote in the book because I think each of them deserves some
Paul Comfort:recognition for what they've done.
Paul Comfort:First off, I was very honored that Mark Miller, wrote the forward to the book.
Paul Comfort:Mark was one of the people who brought me to Trapeze at the time, and now
Paul Comfort:Modaxo, and, he, was the founder of Trapeze, and now is the head of,
Paul Comfort:Volaris and, still very involved with Modaxo and all the work we're doing.
Paul Comfort:He wrote the forward, and it was a very nice, kind forward.
Paul Comfort:He's one of the smartest guys I know, and it was an honor to have him in the book.
Paul Comfort:And then, Mohammad Mezghani writes the first chapter.
Paul Comfort:He kinda kicks off the book.
Paul Comfort:Mohammad, as you know, is a CEO.
Paul Comfort:of the International Transportation Union, known as UITP, and he writes about the
Paul Comfort:future of public transportation globally.
Paul Comfort:It's a fantastically written chapter that, you need to read.
Paul Comfort:Then we break the book into sections.
Paul Comfort:There's a section on people, a section on modal futures,
Paul Comfort:the modes of transportation.
Paul Comfort:Then a whole section on zero emission vehicles.
Paul Comfort:There's so much talk about that.
Paul Comfort:I wanted to have it come from multiple perspectives.
Paul Comfort:Then we go into data and big data and how it's being used in public transportation
Paul Comfort:with several chapters there.
Paul Comfort:And then of course funding and faring with all the transit agencies ready to
Paul Comfort:hit the fiscal cliff this year in the U.
Paul Comfort:S.
Paul Comfort:and Canada and around the world as the COVID money runs out.
Paul Comfort:We talk to people about what are you doing about that and also faring.
Paul Comfort:Are we going to do this zero fare thing or not?
Paul Comfort:We talk both sides of that.
Paul Comfort:And then we look at some special cases, geographic
Paul Comfort:futures, for what it looks like.
Paul Comfort:And so, those, each of those areas has multiple authors who wrote it.
Paul Comfort:This book is hefty.
Paul Comfort:Not as hefty as my first one, Future of Public Transportation,
Paul Comfort:which was about 450 pages.
Paul Comfort:This one is 350 pages.
Paul Comfort:We kept it 100 pages lighter for you, but it's still rich
Paul Comfort:and dense of great information.
Paul Comfort:The chapters on people are written by Aaron Weinstein.
Paul Comfort:Customer Experience Extraordinaire writes a chapter on the future of
Paul Comfort:customer experience, and you know me, I'm a people person, so my chapter
Paul Comfort:is on the future of transportation leadership, and I'm speaking on that,
Paul Comfort:by the way, all over the country and the world at various conferences,
Paul Comfort:and have a new conference coming up.
Paul Comfort:I'm going to be the keynote speaker.
Paul Comfort:I'm announcing here today, coming up at a state conference in In the middle
Paul Comfort:of the United States, we'll tell you more about that coming soon, where
Paul Comfort:I'll be sharing there in September.
Paul Comfort:I spoke at CUTA and the Southwest Transit Association, on that topic
Paul Comfort:along with Frank White from Kansas City.
Paul Comfort:The third chapter, in this area of people is written by my good friend, Dr.
Paul Comfort:Karen Philbrick you may have heard of her before.
Paul Comfort:She's very famous in the industry.
Paul Comfort:She is the Executive Director of the Minetta Transportation
Paul Comfort:Institute in California.
Paul Comfort:And she writes an all encompassing chapter on the future of workforce
Paul Comfort:shortages, mental health, assault, and rebuilding ridership.
Paul Comfort:Then we hear from Daphne LeBlanc, who wrote a chapter on the future of labor
Paul Comfort:shortages and succession planning.
Paul Comfort:She's one of the most successful transit industry recruiters in America.
Paul Comfort:Then we switch into modal futures, and I asked Harold Humphrey, who was in charge
Paul Comfort:of bus transportation in the cities of Dallas and Atlanta, to write a chapter
Paul Comfort:on the future of bus transportation.
Paul Comfort:Nat Ford, former chair of APTA, industry leader, and now head of
Paul Comfort:Jacksonville Transit, writes on the future of autonomous vehicles.
Paul Comfort:He's been working in that area for years.
Paul Comfort:Paige Malott who is a high speed rail researcher with the International Union
Paul Comfort:of Railways, and the second guest on today's podcast, Then, Laura Hendricks,
Paul Comfort:who is the chairman of the North American Transit Alliance and the CEO of
Paul Comfort:Transdev the largest contractor in the country, writes a chapter on the future
Paul Comfort:of public transportation contracting.
Paul Comfort:My friend Roger Helmy with Modaxo writes about the future of integrated
Paul Comfort:mobility, as does my pal, Ron Brooks, write about the future of paratransit.
Paul Comfort:He's very active in that field.
Paul Comfort:Jody Godfrey writes on the future of transit safety.
Paul Comfort:Brett Koenig writes on the future of smart infrastructure asset management.
Paul Comfort:Carl Atencio, who is in charge of maintenance for here in the U S for
Paul Comfort:one of the best train companies I know of, Rocky Mountaineer, writes on
Paul Comfort:the future of rail fleet maintenance.
Paul Comfort:And then my pal Magda Robertson from Australia writes on the
Paul Comfort:future of automation and heavy rail from Australia and New Zealand.
Paul Comfort:And then Juan Carbonell writes on the future of mobility as a service.
Paul Comfort:Who better than him to handle that topic?
Paul Comfort:Then we move into zero emission vehicles.
Paul Comfort:There's been so much talk this year about how battery electric buses didn't make
Paul Comfort:the grade in the cold weather states as and in Canada, and many of them are moving
Paul Comfort:to hydrogen, but we cover all the topics.
Paul Comfort:We talk to Craig Cipriano, who talks about the future of
Paul Comfort:zero emission transformation.
Paul Comfort:He heads up that topic for one of the nation's largest,
Paul Comfort:engineering consulting firms.
Paul Comfort:Then Doran Barnes, former chair of APTA and.
Paul Comfort:the CEO, longtime CEO of Foothills Transit, writes on the future of
Paul Comfort:ZEB and hydrogen fueled buses.
Paul Comfort:His chapter tells a story about how he ended up with the largest
Paul Comfort:hydrogen fleet in America right now.
Paul Comfort:Kurt Conrad, from the home of the Pro Football Hall of Fame, heads up
Paul Comfort:the transit system there in Ohio, writes on the future of how hydrogen
Paul Comfort:fueled buses work, and he's one of the smartest guys I know on the
Paul Comfort:topic, and also a great humorist.
Paul Comfort:Gary Waitz writes on the future of EVs and Monica Backman from Northern
Paul Comfort:Virginia writes on the future of equity, climate change, and EVs.
Paul Comfort:What's it sound like to you?
Paul Comfort:I mean, aren't these some of the biggest names in transit writing on,
Paul Comfort:really, their areas of expertise?
Paul Comfort:Let's plow through the last 10 chapters.
Paul Comfort:Simon Reid, who worked at Transport for London for such a long time and helped
Paul Comfort:them in this area, writes on the future of contactless payments and big data.
Paul Comfort:Dave Jackson writes on the future of data and AI.
Paul Comfort:And Jean Pierre Barakat from Canada writes on the future of cyber security
Paul Comfort:of vehicles and infrastructure.
Paul Comfort:Very hot topic since so many transit agencies are being hit by it.
Paul Comfort:with ransomware and cyberattacks.
Paul Comfort:Then we move into funding and faring.
Paul Comfort:What's happening with the fiscal cliff?
Paul Comfort:And are we going to do zero fares or not?
Paul Comfort:Well, we talk about it.
Paul Comfort:Davey Kim, who is the former Secretary of Transportation in California, writes
Paul Comfort:on what's going on with road charging and the future of transit funding.
Paul Comfort:Noah Berger, a big advocate of zero fares, writes on what's from outside of
Paul Comfort:Boston, and Miva writes about the future of zero fares, and Rich Sampson, who
Paul Comfort:debated him for me at an event we held last year at the ThinkTransit Conference,
Paul Comfort:writes about the future of faring.
Paul Comfort:Rich is the Executive Director of the Southwest Transit Association,
Paul Comfort:representing eight states.
Paul Comfort:And then we move into geographic futures.
Paul Comfort:Scott Bogren, the Executive Director of the Community Transportation Association
Paul Comfort:of America, my good friend for the last 30 years, writes on the future
Paul Comfort:of rural and tribal transportation.
Paul Comfort:Here in the U.
Paul Comfort:S.
Paul Comfort:And then we jump overseas, to Australia, and Samantha Abidero, who is head of
Paul Comfort:transport in Brisbane, Australia, writes on what they're doing to get ready for the
Paul Comfort:Olympics and zero emission and the future of transportation in that city and region.
Paul Comfort:And then my good friend, Peter Varga, anchors the book in Chapter
Paul Comfort:30, former chair of APTA and head of the Rapid, writes on the
Paul Comfort:past, present, and future of U.
Paul Comfort:S.
Paul Comfort:federal transportation funding.
Tris Hussey:Thanks Paul, for that great introduction to your book.
Tris Hussey:I know we're all anxious to start reading it.
Tris Hussey:This is Tris Hussey, editor of Transit Unplugged.
Tris Hussey:And thank you for listening to this week's special episode,
Tris Hussey:celebrating Paul's newest book.
Tris Hussey:The New Future of Public Transportation.
Tris Hussey:And thanks to our guests, Dr.
Tris Hussey:Karen Philbrick and Paige Milan talking about their contributions to Paul's book.
Tris Hussey:Coming up next week on the show, we have something very special for you.
Tris Hussey:We have Andy Lord head of transport for London, the world's largest
Tris Hussey:public transportation network.
Tris Hussey:In this great conversation with Paul Andy talks about what it's
Tris Hussey:like managing the world's largest public transportation network.
Tris Hussey:And his career that started off in aviation.
Tris Hussey:And how that applies to public transport..
Tris Hussey:Did you know that you could email Paul a question about public transit
Tris Hussey:or leadership or anything like that?
Tris Hussey:Just drop him a line at Paul Comfort at transit unplugged.com.
Tris Hussey:He'll read your question and Hey, he might even answer it on the podcast.
Tris Hussey:Transit Unplugged is brought to you by Modaxo.
Tris Hussey:At Modaxo we're passionate about moving the world's people and at
Tris Hussey:Transit Unplugged, we're passionate about telling those stories.
Tris Hussey:So until next week, ride safe and ride happy.