Speaker:

Become A Human Behavior Scientist:

Speaker:

Observe,

Speaker:

Read,

Speaker:

Understand,

Speaker:

and Decode People With Minimal Information (How to be More Likable and Charismatic Book 18)

Speaker:

Written by

Speaker:

Patrick King, narrated by russell newton.

Speaker:

Chapter 1.

Speaker:

All About Emotions.

Speaker:

Understanding Primary Versus Secondary Emotions.

Speaker:

On our mission to become expert people-readers,

Speaker:

we need to start at the very beginning - emotions.

Speaker:

People think,

Speaker:

speak,

Speaker:

and act,

Speaker:

and these expressions can all be analyzed and interpreted to gain insight into

Speaker:

who they are as people.

Speaker:

But deeper than these expressions is what people feel—understand people’s

Speaker:

emotions and you unlock a more genuine,

Speaker:

more authentic picture of who they are.

Speaker:

Not only do you “get” them in a more profound way,

Speaker:

but you are then able to respond to them with understanding,

Speaker:

compassion,

Speaker:

and real empathy.

Speaker:

Paul Ekman’s notable emotion research identifies seven basic emotions -

Speaker:

disgust,

Speaker:

surprise,

Speaker:

anger,

Speaker:

enjoyment,

Speaker:

fear,

Speaker:

contempt,

Speaker:

and sadness.

Speaker:

Other researchers have more or fewer categories and organize them differently,

Speaker:

but the idea is that as human beings we all share a few “primary colors”

Speaker:

when it comes to emotions.

Speaker:

The subtler feelings emerge when we consider mixes of these foundational

Speaker:

emotions at different intensities.

Speaker:

These so-called primary emotions have evolved from our earliest ancestors and

Speaker:

are innate—we don’t learn how to feel them.

Speaker:

They were and are essential for our survival and functioning in the world,

Speaker:

and are a natural reaction to events or situations,

Speaker:

i.e.,

Speaker:

you win the lottery and feel elated and joyful.

Speaker:

Primary emotions are automatic and universal,

Speaker:

but they can be either more or less adaptive (here,

Speaker:

adaptive simply means healthy or useful in context).

Speaker:

Anger,

Speaker:

for example,

Speaker:

is adaptive if it empowers us to protect the innocent or assert a boundary.

Speaker:

It’s less adaptive if it inspires destruction or overriding other people’s

Speaker:

boundaries.

Speaker:

Similarly,

Speaker:

fear is a functional and healthy emotion if it serves our needs for safety or

Speaker:

alerts us to when we need to escape danger;

Speaker:

it’s less adaptive when it immobilizes us in the face of things that are

Speaker:

genuinely not a threat,

Speaker:

such as with a panic disorder.

Speaker:

So,

Speaker:

emotions are simply what they are—there are no “good” emotions or

Speaker:

“bad” ones.

Speaker:

Rather,

Speaker:

it’s about what works—emotions that undermine your wellbeing (or the

Speaker:

wellbeing of others)

Speaker:

are maladaptive,

Speaker:

while those that support the life we want to live are generally adaptive.

Speaker:

Emotions all have one thing in common - they move.

Speaker:

They change and flow,

Speaker:

come and go.

Speaker:

Remember that primary emotions are physiological functions that evolved to

Speaker:

increase our chances of survival.

Speaker:

Primary emotions emerge in a situation to serve a function,

Speaker:

like a temporary tool,

Speaker:

and then they disappear once that function is served.

Speaker:

What,

Speaker:

then,

Speaker:

are secondary emotions?

Speaker:

While primary emotions follow events in the environment,

Speaker:

secondary emotions follow primary emotions - they are our reactions and

Speaker:

emotions about our reactions and emotions.

Speaker:

If the primary emotion is,

Speaker:

for whatever reason,

Speaker:

unable to flow and move or to serve its purpose and dissipate,

Speaker:

then we may respond with secondary emotions.

Speaker:

These are not innate,

Speaker:

automatic,

Speaker:

or universal—in fact,

Speaker:

they follow cultural and familial patterns and are socialized and learned.

Speaker:

For example,

Speaker:

a primary emotion can be joy at winning the lottery.

Speaker:

But then,

Speaker:

someone might feel guilty about feeling so happy,

Speaker:

since they know that others aren’t so lucky,

Speaker:

and they’ve always been taught to not be boastful.

Speaker:

Maybe they come from a culture that emphasizes merit and earning money fair and

Speaker:

square,

Speaker:

so they construct a narrative around how unearned their success is,

Speaker:

and this fuels feelings of embarrassment and shame.

Speaker:

The primary emotion is joy;

Speaker:

the secondary one is shame and guilt.

Speaker:

Importantly,

Speaker:

the secondary one is more malleable,

Speaker:

voluntary,

Speaker:

and actually unconnected to the event of winning the lottery.

Speaker:

Remember that emotions are neither good nor bad.

Speaker:

However,

Speaker:

if we have a primary emotion in the context of a family or society that tells

Speaker:

us that,

Speaker:

for example,

Speaker:

it’s bad to be afraid,

Speaker:

we might then develop secondary emotions such as anger,

Speaker:

sadness or,

Speaker:

ironically,

Speaker:

more fear.

Speaker:

If you grew up in a family where sadness was not acceptable but anger was more

Speaker:

tolerated,

Speaker:

you might never realize that beneath your anger was a more fundamental primary

Speaker:

emotion of sadness.

Speaker:

Whenever there is a judgment or resistance against a naturally emerging primary

Speaker:

emotion,

Speaker:

we generate secondary emotions.

Speaker:

We can feel disgusted at our fear.

Speaker:

We can feel overwhelmed by our happiness.

Speaker:

We can feel sad about our anxiety.

Speaker:

We can feel angry at our anger!

Speaker:

Messages about what emotions mean and how to respond to them come from our

Speaker:

immediate family,

Speaker:

from our culture and general environment,

Speaker:

and from our experiences going through life.

Speaker:

It’s these beliefs that cause the secondary emotions,

Speaker:

rather than any objective external event.

Speaker:

A man might lash out at his wife when he is feeling vulnerable and insecure.

Speaker:

In his culture,

Speaker:

lashing out in anger is more socially accepted for a man than crying or asking

Speaker:

for help.

Speaker:

Yet,

Speaker:

his feelings of fear and vulnerability are natural,

Speaker:

automatic,

Speaker:

and normal ...and they serve a purpose.

Speaker:

What’s more,

Speaker:

the cause of his anger is not his wife or anything in his immediate

Speaker:

environment,

Speaker:

but his own reaction to his primary emotion of fear.

Speaker:

He can wrestle endlessly with his anger,

Speaker:

but the “real” problem is that he is feeling vulnerable,

Speaker:

yet unable to allow that vulnerability to be what it is.

Speaker:

Many people have no idea about the extent to which their internalized messages,

Speaker:

assumptions,

Speaker:

beliefs,

Speaker:

and biases affect their emotional state.

Speaker:

They simply lump everything in as “how I feel."

Speaker:

And so,

Speaker:

depression might actually be at its root anger or resentment,

Speaker:

or anxiety can be more about deep sadness that we feel compelled to hide,

Speaker:

downplay,

Speaker:

or ignore.

Speaker:

How can we use this information to deepen our understanding of other people?

Speaker:

Emotional awareness is typically something we cultivate within ourselves,

Speaker:

but when we can grow an awareness of other people’s emotions,

Speaker:

we are in the realm of empathy and deep understanding.

Speaker:

Awareness of other people’s emotions is about being able to clearly identify

Speaker:

what is primary and what is secondary.

Speaker:

A great way to practice this is to become adept at noticing your own emotional

Speaker:

patterns!

Speaker:

One important way to distinguish between primary and secondary is to locate the

Speaker:

emotion - primary emotions are felt in the body,

Speaker:

while secondary emotions are cerebral and abstract and may not match the

Speaker:

expression or sensation of the physical body.

Speaker:

Imagine someone is suddenly responding to you with what seems like anger.

Speaker:

They might be yelling and hurling insults.

Speaker:

But you also notice what their body is doing.

Speaker:

They’re cowering almost in a defensive posture.

Speaker:

They’re shaking.

Speaker:

They look to be on the verge of tears and their voice is cracking up.

Speaker:

Here is your clue of the primary emotion - sadness,

Speaker:

vulnerability,

Speaker:

or terror.

Speaker:

Because you have become aware of the primary emotion,

Speaker:

you can respond to that and find far more compassion,

Speaker:

understanding and resolution for the situation than if you had merely responded

Speaker:

to the superficial display of anger.

Speaker:

If you had simply heard the words they said rather than reading the body

Speaker:

language,

Speaker:

you will not have truly understood their full state of mind in that moment.

Speaker:

While it would be great if everyone was ultra-aware of their own emotions and

Speaker:

knew how to self-regulate and communicate clearly,

Speaker:

the fact is that most people are messy and pretty complex.

Speaker:

To become good at reading people,

Speaker:

you need to learn the language of emotions—and there’s usually information

Speaker:

being communicated on several levels!

Speaker:

Here’s a tip to keep in mind as you start to delve into the people-reading

Speaker:

arts - learn to listen to the deeper emotional content of what people are

Speaker:

saying or doing.

Speaker:

Notice what is a cascade of secondary emotions,

Speaker:

what is conscious rationalization and socialization,

Speaker:

what is performance ...and what is simply a pure,

Speaker:

raw emotional reaction at the root of all that.

Speaker:

People can react according to what they’ve been taught,

Speaker:

or expectations,

Speaker:

or what they think they should be doing.

Speaker:

Ask,

Speaker:

“What’s underneath this reaction?"

Speaker:

Often,

Speaker:

what is causing a person’s response is not the situation,

Speaker:

but their perception and interpretation of their initial response to that

Speaker:

situation.

Speaker:

Understand this and some people will think you can read their minds!

Speaker:

Step 1 .- Pause and become aware.

Speaker:

Look at all the information being communicated—body language is usually more

Speaker:

honest.

Speaker:

Step 2 .- Try to identify the primary emotion.

Speaker:

It may be a few layers deep.

Speaker:

Step 3 .- Bypass the secondary emotion and validate the primary emotion.

Speaker:

There’s no need to dissect,

Speaker:

argue,

Speaker:

judge,

Speaker:

or interpret.

Speaker:

Just remember that emotions are there to serve a function.

Speaker:

Figure out what function they are trying to serve,

Speaker:

allow them to do so,

Speaker:

then acknowledge them so they can be released.

Speaker:

Example .- You become aware that the person you’re on a date with is laughing

Speaker:

loudly and being extroverted,

Speaker:

but you notice signs of tension in their body.

Speaker:

You recognize that they probably feel nervous (primary)

Speaker:

and are trying to conceal it out of embarrassment (secondary).

Speaker:

You recognize that fear and apprehension and ask yourself what purpose it might

Speaker:

serve.

Speaker:

Fear is there to protect us against danger.

Speaker:

So,

Speaker:

you allow that fear to dissipate when you act to put them at ease and reduce

Speaker:

the threat in the situation.

Speaker:

Perhaps you playfully acknowledge that it’s normal to get nervous on first

Speaker:

dates and that you’re nervous too.

Speaker:

By making a light-hearted joke,

Speaker:

you create an atmosphere of trust and relaxation.

Speaker:

Congratulations—you’ve not only “read” the situation but used what you

Speaker:

learned to connect more deeply with another human being.

Speaker:

Understanding Allows Us To Predict.

Speaker:

The classical Newtonian model of the physical universe saw the various

Speaker:

elementary particles like billiard balls on a table.

Speaker:

One idea was that if you understood the starting position of the billiard balls

Speaker:

and the rules that governed how they rolled around on the table,

Speaker:

then you could predict exactly where they would be at any point in the future.

Speaker:

Of course,

Speaker:

while human beings are far more complex than billiard balls on a table,

Speaker:

and while there is always chance and the effect of the unknown,

Speaker:

the basic principle applies.

Speaker:

If you understand how people are in the present,

Speaker:

and you understand the laws that govern their behavior,

Speaker:

then you can extrapolate that present moment into the future.

Speaker:

In other words,

Speaker:

you can predict what they’ll do.

Speaker:

A big part of wanting to understand people is precisely this power to

Speaker:

anticipate how they’ll act.

Speaker:

Understanding why people act as they do is a question of motivation.

Speaker:

We can assess other people’s behavior not according to our own emotions,

Speaker:

expectations,

Speaker:

and interpretations (i.e.,

Speaker:

the “laws”),

Speaker:

but according to theirs.

Speaker:

So,

Speaker:

when done right,

Speaker:

empathy confers the power of prediction.

Speaker:

Psychologists Emily Balcetis and David Dunning have found that human beings are

Speaker:

actually poor at predicting our own behavior but are far better at predicting

Speaker:

what others will do.

Speaker:

There may be a personal blind spot when it comes to considering the effect of

Speaker:

the environment—we typically see ourselves in a vacuum,

Speaker:

whereas we (more correctly)

Speaker:

consider the effect of the environment on other people’s decision-making.

Speaker:

This bias again may have evolutionary roots.

Speaker:

Many of us overestimate how generous and kind we are,

Speaker:

or indulge more flattering visions of who we are—visions that objective

Speaker:

observers may be able to see more clearly!

Speaker:

The key to seeing others clearly?

Speaker:

It may lie in awareness not just of the person in themselves,

Speaker:

but of the person in context,

Speaker:

i.e.,

Speaker:

how that person interacts with their situation.

Speaker:

It’s a little like knowing that a billiard ball is round and usually rolls,

Speaker:

but also that it won’t roll unless it’s on a smooth flat surface.

Speaker:

One of the biggest errors in predicting behavior—our own or others’—is

Speaker:

that we fail to factor in the context/environment.

Speaker:

We assume that people act only according to their own inner drives and

Speaker:

personalities,

Speaker:

when it’s more realistic to see people’s behavior as resulting from an

Speaker:

interaction between them and their environment.

Speaker:

Let’s look at two basic “rules” or laws we have uncovered when it comes

Speaker:

to human emotion -

Speaker:

•People experience primary emotions in response to events,

Speaker:

and secondary emotions in response to primary emotions,

Speaker:

and

Speaker:

•The secondary emotions are formed when we make a judgment about the primary

Speaker:

ones,

Speaker:

i.e.,

Speaker:

we welcome them or avoid/resist them Using these two laws,

Speaker:

we can begin to understand people’s behavior and predict their future

Speaker:

behavior.

Speaker:

We’ll use the A. B. C. model,

Speaker:

which helps us understand what comes before behavior and what comes after.

Speaker:

People’s behavior becomes understandable when you know how they’re making

Speaker:

their own independent choices,

Speaker:

how they’re interpreting events,

Speaker:

what they value,

Speaker:

and what they’re trying to achieve.

Speaker:

Every person acts for a range of reasons;

Speaker:

understand the reasons and you can guess the act.

Speaker:

People aren’t machines,

Speaker:

and so any predictions are going to be mere guesses—but they can be pretty

Speaker:

good guesses!

Speaker:

The A. B. C. model is built on cause and effect - A – Antecedents.

Speaker:

B – Behavior.

Speaker:

C – Consequences.

Speaker:

A stimulus in the environment is an antecedent that triggers a behavioral

Speaker:

response,

Speaker:

and that is followed by consequences.

Speaker:

If the consequences are “good,” the behavior is more likely to continue,

Speaker:

and vice versa—this is feedback (or learning,

Speaker:

depending on the context).

Speaker:

Consequences can in turn act as antecedents for other behaviors,

Speaker:

and people’s actions and reactions are constantly overlapping with other

Speaker:

people’s.

Speaker:

When you’re trying to understand people,

Speaker:

your goal is to make the invisible visible—you want to see what is happening

Speaker:

before it manifests in outward behavior.

Speaker:

Using the A. B. C. model gives us a frame to break down and analyze human

Speaker:

behavior.

Speaker:

We can examine the consequences to see what they say about the behavior (more

Speaker:

of a problem-solving or trouble-shooting approach),

Speaker:

or we can start with the antecedents and try to see what they can tell us about

Speaker:

possible behaviors and outcomes (making predictions).

Speaker:

Again,

Speaker:

this is a model of human behavior—actual human behavior will be more complex.

Speaker:

Let’s look at an example.

Speaker:

Maybe you work with someone who has started to deliver projects late or miss

Speaker:

deadlines,

Speaker:

claiming mental health issues.

Speaker:

You also notice the response to them doing so - everyone else in the team picks

Speaker:

up their slack while expressing kindness and understanding.

Speaker:

Your manager,

Speaker:

noticing the increasing number of “mental health days,” decides to do

Speaker:

something.

Speaker:

She tries to solve the problem with a compromise - your colleague is allowed to

Speaker:

take some time working from home,

Speaker:

and the company will pay for regular sessions with a therapist ...but they’re

Speaker:

still required to meet their deadlines.

Speaker:

Now,

Speaker:

what do you predict will happen here?

Speaker:

You can gain a deeper insight when you break the initial situation down using

Speaker:

the A. B. C. model - Antecedents .- Your colleague is asked to meet a deadline

Speaker:

Behavior .- They miss the deadline,

Speaker:

blaming poor mental health Consequences .- No serious consequences (and

Speaker:

possible support and encouragement)

Speaker:

Using an operative conditioning model here allows us to think of the

Speaker:

consequences in terms of reward - the colleague will continue to shirk their

Speaker:

duties because,

Speaker:

frankly,

Speaker:

it’s working for them.

Speaker:

The response they get reinforces their initial behavior.

Speaker:

Now,

Speaker:

if your manager comes in and thinks,

Speaker:

“Mental health problems?

Speaker:

Okay,

Speaker:

I’ll take some steps to improve mental health,” what will happen?

Speaker:

You might predict some sort of friction.

Speaker:

When the manager removes the reward/consequence (not having to meet the

Speaker:

deadline),

Speaker:

the cause-and-effect chain breaks down.

Speaker:

Your colleague’s behavior no longer gets them the result it used to,

Speaker:

so we can predict their behavior will change.

Speaker:

What do you predict will happen?

Speaker:

Most likely,

Speaker:

the colleague will not accept this compromise as a solution at all and may

Speaker:

continue trying to negotiate,

Speaker:

miss further deadlines,

Speaker:

or try to get what they want (i.e.,

Speaker:

the freedom to miss deadlines)

Speaker:

some other way (for example,

Speaker:

seeking a doctor’s note exempting them from having to work at all).

Speaker:

This may be frustrating for the manager,

Speaker:

who was dealing simply with the surface-level problem;

Speaker:

that is,

Speaker:

that the employee was struggling with their mental health.

Speaker:

But if you become aware of the other,

Speaker:

hidden dynamics,

Speaker:

you can see something the manager can’t - why the behavior is really there.

Speaker:

In this case,

Speaker:

your colleague may have been using mental health issues as an excuse,

Speaker:

which is why it’s a problem that can never actually be solved.

Speaker:

This is a very simplistic example.

Speaker:

You might have thought,

Speaker:

“Maybe the employee had many reasons for missing their deadlines ...maybe

Speaker:

there was some truth in their excuse."

Speaker:

Remember that -

Speaker:

•People experience primary emotions in response to events,

Speaker:

and secondary emotions in response to primary emotions,

Speaker:

and

Speaker:

•The secondary emotions are formed when we make a judgment about the primary

Speaker:

ones,

Speaker:

i.e.,

Speaker:

we welcome them or avoid/resist them If you know a little bit about your

Speaker:

colleague,

Speaker:

you may have been able to observe their behavior more generally.

Speaker:

Perhaps you’ve noticed that - They are young,

Speaker:

in a junior position,

Speaker:

and rather timid They often complain about other colleagues,

Speaker:

but always behind their backs They frequently express their work in terms of

Speaker:

what they begrudgingly “should” do On occasion when they’ve been

Speaker:

criticized by other team members,

Speaker:

they completely collapse and take it personally You notice they never say no,

Speaker:

even though they often claim afterward that they didn’t want to do something

Speaker:

Are you beginning to get an idea of who this colleague is?

Speaker:

Now,

Speaker:

you’ve seen the external events and environmental conditions (the deadlines

Speaker:

problem,

Speaker:

the manager’s “compromise,” etc.)

Speaker:

and you’ve seen some of the “rules” that your colleague uses to navigate

Speaker:

this context.

Speaker:

Let’s put in the final piece of the puzzle - emotions.

Speaker:

Seeing all the data you’ve gathered,

Speaker:

you might start to understand that their primary emotion is perhaps a feeling

Speaker:

of being overwhelmed,

Speaker:

uninterested,

Speaker:

or resentful of the work assigned.

Speaker:

In any case,

Speaker:

there is resistance or unhappiness associated with the project.

Speaker:

However,

Speaker:

your colleague doesn’t feel able to say so.

Speaker:

Instead,

Speaker:

they do something else - claim they have a mental health issue which gets them

Speaker:

off the hook.

Speaker:

In this person’s world,

Speaker:

it is not acceptable to say,

Speaker:

“No,

Speaker:

I don’t want to do that,” or,

Speaker:

“I can’t do this,

Speaker:

please help me."

Speaker:

Instead,

Speaker:

it’s easier for them to take on the passive,

Speaker:

blameless position of someone who needs mental health support.

Speaker:

In a way,

Speaker:

maybe this is an indirect path to receiving the help and support they feel

Speaker:

unable to ask for directly.

Speaker:

Unconsciously,

Speaker:

your colleague may have gotten into the habit of saying I can’t because they

Speaker:

feel unable to say I won’t.

Speaker:

The primary emotion may be anger or disagreement.

Speaker:

But if they’ve been socialized to never show dissent or go against

Speaker:

higher-ups,

Speaker:

then they try to get what they want some other way.

Speaker:

Primary emotion .- I hate this job and I don’t want to do this stupid project.

Speaker:

Secondary emotion .- Woah,

Speaker:

you can’t think that!

Speaker:

You have to be accommodating and capable and obedient.

Speaker:

Behavior .- Claim a mental health issue.

Speaker:

This gets you out of the stupid project without rocking the boat.

Speaker:

Of course,

Speaker:

all of this could be entirely unconscious.

Speaker:

But if you’re watching closely,

Speaker:

you can see it all.

Speaker:

You can predict not only what they’ll do with some accuracy,

Speaker:

but why.

Speaker:

You could guess that the employee will continue to evade doing the projects,

Speaker:

perhaps coming up with increasingly strained excuses and justifications.

Speaker:

Whatever happens,

Speaker:

you know that they’re going to act to avoid a primary emotion that they see

Speaker:

as unacceptable.

Speaker:

And you know that they’ll act according to their culture,

Speaker:

their personal biases,

Speaker:

their values,

Speaker:

their upbringing,

Speaker:

their family past,

Speaker:

and so on.

Speaker:

You won’t become a mind-reader,

Speaker:

but you’ll be able to see that the manager’s approach is unlikely to

Speaker:

succeed!

Speaker:

If you wanted to support your colleague?

Speaker:

You could skip over the part where they’re claiming mental health issues and

Speaker:

instead recognize and validate the primary emotion.

Speaker:

You could talk to them and find out the cause of their resistance to the work,

Speaker:

and encourage them to explore this and communicate it clearly.

Speaker:

Granted,

Speaker:

it’s not your job to help this person learn to accept and acknowledge their

Speaker:

primary emotions,

Speaker:

but you can go a long way to connecting and harmonizing with others when you

Speaker:

speak to what is really bothering them.

Speaker:

Let’s return to our original process for understanding other people’s

Speaker:

emotions - Step 1 .- Pause and become aware.

Speaker:

Look at all the information that is being communicated—body language is

Speaker:

usually more honest.

Speaker:

Step 2 .- Try to identify the primary emotion.

Speaker:

Step 3 .- Bypass the secondary emotion and validate the primary emotion.

Speaker:

Remember that emotions are there to serve a function.

Speaker:

Figure out what function they are trying to serve,

Speaker:

allow them to do so,

Speaker:

then acknowledge them so they can be released.

Speaker:

We can add to this process by considering the role that antecedents and

Speaker:

consequences play,

Speaker:

according to the A. B. C. framework.

Speaker:

When you’re analyzing a situation and what’s going in,

Speaker:

ask yourself - What came before this behavior that I’m observing?

Speaker:

What has come/will come/typically comes after the behavior I’m observing?

Speaker:

When you observe people in the moment,

Speaker:

you put them in context,

Speaker:

but when you ask the above questions,

Speaker:

you put the behavior into a chronological sequence and get insight into cause

Speaker:

and effect.

Speaker:

So,

Speaker:

for example,

Speaker:

you see that your friend is suddenly in a rotten mood.

Speaker:

You don’t understand it,

Speaker:

but then you recall what happened immediately before their mood plummeted and

Speaker:

put two and two together.

Speaker:

Or maybe you see your partner growing anxious.

Speaker:

Why?

Speaker:

You think about what’s coming up in the future.

Speaker:

Or,

Speaker:

you ask yourself what the result or outcome of their behavior is.

Speaker:

It might not make sense to you or anyone else,

Speaker:

but what does it mean to them?

Speaker:

Are they behaving in expectation of a certain outcome?

Speaker:

So many of our secondary emotions are there because we have learned in the past

Speaker:

that certain emotional expressions are acceptable and certain ones aren’t.

Speaker:

So,

Speaker:

ask yourself about the processes that are leading to a person’s secondary

Speaker:

emotions.

Speaker:

Imagine you meet a person who constantly brags about the Ph.D. they earned

Speaker:

from an Ivy League university.

Speaker:

They’re a published author and wearing a T-shirt printed with a quirky

Speaker:

mathematical joke.

Speaker:

One day you politely correct their pronunciation of a common word,

Speaker:

in public.

Speaker:

Now,

Speaker:

what is going on in the head of this person?

Speaker:

What are they going to do and why?

Speaker:

Primary emotion - embarrassment at not knowing something,

Speaker:

or perhaps even strong humiliation at being stupid or uneducated.

Speaker:

Denial and rejection of this primary emotion leading to ... Secondary emotion -

Speaker:

pride,

Speaker:

superiority,

Speaker:

mild irritation (more compatible with self-identity)

Speaker:

Antecedent - you say something that challenges this person’s identity as a

Speaker:

smarty pants know-it-all Behavior - the person laughs and scoffs,

Speaker:

saying,

Speaker:

“I know how it’s pronounced.

Speaker:

I was just making a joke.

Speaker:

Obviously."

Speaker:

Consequence .- People laugh and the person’s identity as intelligent is still

Speaker:

intact.

Speaker:

You can gather incredible amounts of high-quality data in just a few minutes or

Speaker:

seconds.

Speaker:

By merely paying attention to people’s emotions,

Speaker:

to their behavior and what follows and precedes it,

Speaker:

and to the little clues that tell you about their context,

Speaker:

you can gain astonishing insight into what makes people tick.

Speaker:

You’d now know that the way to this person’s heart would be to affirm their

Speaker:

value as a human being outside of their perceived intelligence.

Speaker:

If you wanted to make an enemy of them,

Speaker:

do the reverse (i.e.,

Speaker:

correct them!).

Speaker:

You now know what threatens them and where they get their sense of purpose and

Speaker:

direction from.

Speaker:

You know how to flatter them (ask their advice),

Speaker:

how to speak so they’ll hear you (frame your arguments as rational and

Speaker:

logical),

Speaker:

and how to motivate them (use status,

Speaker:

praise,

Speaker:

and recognition for their intellectual superiority).

Speaker:

You can predict the triggers that will have certain effects on them,

Speaker:

and this way be able to predict (and possibly,

Speaker:

if you liked,

Speaker:

control)

Speaker:

their responses.

Speaker:

And all this comes from simply learning to read the undercurrent of emotional

Speaker:

information flowing in every interaction or situation.

Speaker:

Understanding people is not magic—it just requires that we pay attention.

Speaker:

Learning To Perceive Emotion.

Speaker:

So far,

Speaker:

we’ve spoken about what to do with the undercurrent of emotional information

Speaker:

that people are constantly transmitting.

Speaker:

But you may have read the previous examples and wondered,

Speaker:

“That sounds great,

Speaker:

but how do you know your date is feeling nervous?

Speaker:

How exactly can you tell that someone is feeling embarrassed or sad or angry?"

Speaker:

The fact is that human beings are primarily built for non-verbal communication.

Speaker:

It’s what we do.

Speaker:

Think of it this way - we evolved to communicate without words thousands of

Speaker:

years before we developed symbols and syntax.

Speaker:

It may seem weird and abstract to read people beyond the words they’re

Speaker:

saying,

Speaker:

but the non-verbal mode is in fact more ancient,

Speaker:

more well-developed,

Speaker:

and more natural for human beings.

Speaker:

It’s just a matter of tuning back into that radio station,

Speaker:

so to speak!

Speaker:

Let’s recall that there are two kinds of emotions—primary and secondary.

Speaker:

We know that primary emotions are innate,

Speaker:

universal,

Speaker:

and automatic.

Speaker:

We express them automatically too—just think of how unconscious and

Speaker:

spontaneous your expression of surprise is.

Speaker:

People’s ability to read the basic primary emotions are also hard-wired into

Speaker:

the brain.

Speaker:

In fact,

Speaker:

scientists have discovered areas of the brain that appear to be specially

Speaker:

devoted to the perception and processing of other people’s facial

Speaker:

expressions,

Speaker:

body language,

Speaker:

and tone of voice.

Speaker:

But what about secondary emotions?

Speaker:

Since these are all about the narratives and interpretations we have in

Speaker:

reaction to primary emotions,

Speaker:

they’re more culture-bound and dependent on context.

Speaker:

Depending on the culture or historical period,

Speaker:

our families and our education,

Speaker:

we are all taught slightly different “rules” for the expression of

Speaker:

emotions,

Speaker:

which emotions are good and bad,

Speaker:

and what certain emotions mean.

Speaker:

So,

Speaker:

when we see cultural variation in how people experience emotions,

Speaker:

it’s usually the secondary emotions they’re talking about.

Speaker:

When it comes to raw,

Speaker:

fundamental feeling states like fear or happiness,

Speaker:

all human beings seem to agree on what the rules are!

Speaker:

As an example,

Speaker:

consider the simple act of smiling.

Speaker:

Even a tiny infant understands that someone who is smiling is friendly and

Speaker:

approachable.

Speaker:

Every human being,

Speaker:

regardless of language or background,

Speaker:

knows broadly that smiling = happy.

Speaker:

We spontaneously smile when we see something we like or that makes us glad.

Speaker:

However,

Speaker:

there are cultural differences in how smiling is used as a secondary emotion,

Speaker:

or a conscious and deliberate display.

Speaker:

In certain Asian countries,

Speaker:

it’s a cultural norm to smile during disagreements or tense moments,

Speaker:

in order to diffuse tension and increase harmony.

Speaker:

However,

Speaker:

if an Asian person tried smiling during a heated argument in,

Speaker:

say,

Speaker:

America,

Speaker:

he might find that people read him as mocking,

Speaker:

or assume he’s not taking them seriously ...which would lead to more friction.

Speaker:

It’s not just culture that affects how we read one another.

Speaker:

Let’s say you’ve grown up in a family where it was taboo to raise your

Speaker:

voice,

Speaker:

and the unspoken rule was that people solved their disagreements by talking

Speaker:

quietly (or,

Speaker:

let’s be honest,

Speaker:

by sulking or silent treatment).

Speaker:

You might one day marry someone who frequently gets “excited” in lively

Speaker:

disagreements,

Speaker:

and you may read this as terrifying and something to avoid at all costs.

Speaker:

For you,

Speaker:

talking loudly and forcefully reads as anger,

Speaker:

whereas your spouse is confused by this and might say,

Speaker:

“What’s the problem?

Speaker:

I’m not angry!

Speaker:

I’m just making my point."

Speaker:

Of course,

Speaker:

the personal,

Speaker:

the cultural and the familial all bounce off one another.

Speaker:

The culture we live in influences the rules we teach our children,

Speaker:

and those children in turn shape how the culture at large expresses itself.

Speaker:

The way to read primary emotions is through the body.

Speaker:

The facial features and muscles (including the muscles in the voice box)

Speaker:

are part of the physical body and respond to changes in the environment like

Speaker:

any other organ.

Speaker:

The expression your face wears is a direct and literal expression of,

Speaker:

for example,

Speaker:

different hormone levels in your body (like cortisol or oxytocin).

Speaker:

In fact,

Speaker:

your entire body has its “expressions”—think about what it means when

Speaker:

your heart beats ultra-fast or your palms sweat or your mouth waters.

Speaker:

Your face,

Speaker:

then,

Speaker:

is just one outwardly visible expression of your body’s internal state.

Speaker:

The fusiform face area is a part of the brain’s visual processing machinery

Speaker:

that is exclusively in charge of reading and interpreting people’s facial

Speaker:

expressions.

Speaker:

These perceptions are then processed in part via the amygdala,

Speaker:

which is strongly connected to our memories and emotions.

Speaker:

For our ancient ancestors,

Speaker:

this skill was not a question of mere socializing but one of urgent

Speaker:

survival—being able to tell friend from foe and being able to bond and

Speaker:

connect with your tribe could literally spell the difference between life and

Speaker:

death.

Speaker:

Have you ever had a strong gut feeling about someone yet couldn’t quite put

Speaker:

your finger on why?

Speaker:

It’s probably because this part of your brain was working unconsciously and

Speaker:

automatically,

Speaker:

alerting you to who you could trust.

Speaker:

While our primary emotions are innate and universal,

Speaker:

we nevertheless have to be aware of cultural rules which shape secondary

Speaker:

emotions.

Speaker:

Some of these cultural norms include “display rules” about how to express

Speaker:

emotion and when and to whom.

Speaker:

In some countries,

Speaker:

excessive emotion is distrusted,

Speaker:

while in others being shy and withdrawn is seen as rude.

Speaker:

There are rules about eye contact,

Speaker:

smiling,

Speaker:

the volume of the voice,

Speaker:

who speaks first,

Speaker:

and laughing.

Speaker:

As human beings,

Speaker:

we all experience the same primary emotions,

Speaker:

but our culture shapes and determines how we express that.

Speaker:

We need to factor this into any reading we make.

Speaker:

A famous 1971 experiment by psychologist Paul Ekman had Japanese and American

Speaker:

participants watch various films.

Speaker:

All participants had the same facial expressions as they watched,

Speaker:

however,

Speaker:

the Japanese participants tended to show fewer “negative” emotions when

Speaker:

someone else was in the room with them.

Speaker:

In fact,

Speaker:

they were more likely to smile!

Speaker:

The primary emotion was the same for all participants—what differed was the

Speaker:

“rules” they’d internalized from their cultures,

Speaker:

and hence their secondary emotional expressions.

Speaker:

Culture affects not only the way we express our emotions,

Speaker:

but also the way we read and interpret the emotions of others.

Speaker:

Experiments have been done where the movement of the eyes can be accurately

Speaker:

tracked,

Speaker:

to see where people focus when they read a facial expression.

Speaker:

There are some cultural differences here,

Speaker:

too .- East Asians tend to read the eyes primarily,

Speaker:

while Westerners read the whole face more generally,

Speaker:

and in particular the mouth.

Speaker:

Have you ever noticed that Asian emojis are quite different from American ones?

Speaker:

The Western emojis vary widely in the mouth,

Speaker:

whereas the Asian emojis are all about the eyes.

Speaker:

Now you know why!

Speaker:

So,

Speaker:

how can we become better at reading emotion?

Speaker:

If it’s secondary emotions,

Speaker:

the answer is - be aware of the role that social and cultural contexts play,

Speaker:

to learn the “rules."

Speaker:

If it’s primary emotions,

Speaker:

however,

Speaker:

it’s all about reading the body,

Speaker:

and the good news is that you are already an expert at this—even if it

Speaker:

doesn’t feel like it!

Speaker:

The “Reading the Mind in the Eyes” test devised by Simon Baron-Cohen (no,

Speaker:

no relation)

Speaker:

asks you to guess people’s emotions from their eyes alone.

Speaker:

You can Google the test and try it free online.

Speaker:

You may be surprised at your result!

Speaker:

The superpower of expression-reading is really one that just needs a little

Speaker:

practice.

Speaker:

Encourage yourself often to really look at people and see what you see.

Speaker:

Sometimes we fail to read people not because we’re unskilled but simply

Speaker:

because we’ve become used to discounting what we already know.

Speaker:

Ignore their words for a moment and just let your fusiform gyrus do the work

Speaker:

for you!

Speaker:

Yes,

Speaker:

culture and upbringing affect both the expression and interpretation of facial

Speaker:

expressions,

Speaker:

but remember,

Speaker:

too,

Speaker:

that we have had finely tuned emotional recognition software in our brains for

Speaker:

a long,

Speaker:

long time—longer than we’ve had cultures!

Speaker:

Listening To What The Body Is Saying.

Speaker:

Let’s cut to the chase - if you’re reading this book,

Speaker:

chances are you’d really like some tips for how to make accurate guesses

Speaker:

about a person’s mental state beyond their verbal expression.

Speaker:

If empathy,

Speaker:

understanding,

Speaker:

and connection are your destination,

Speaker:

then there is one sure-fire path - communication.

Speaker:

We’re always communicating.

Speaker:

Consciously or unconsciously,

Speaker:

verbally or non-verbally,

Speaker:

people are continually broadcasting their state of mind,

Speaker:

their intentions,

Speaker:

and their emotions.

Speaker:

They do this on many different channels,

Speaker:

not just that of spoken language.

Speaker:

Gesture.

Speaker:

Posture.

Speaker:

Tone,

Speaker:

volume,

Speaker:

pace,

Speaker:

pitch,

Speaker:

and modulation of voice.

Speaker:

Facial expression.

Speaker:

Bodily movements.

Speaker:

Reactions to things in the environment.

Speaker:

This is all important data!

Speaker:

Even silence and stillness communicate plenty.

Speaker:

The first rule in reading body language is that it is primary—our bodies

Speaker:

respond immediately,

Speaker:

naturally,

Speaker:

and truthfully.

Speaker:

If the verbal and non-verbal expression don’t match,

Speaker:

the non-verbal is typically the “truth."

Speaker:

Now,

Speaker:

if you ever see a definitive collection of fixed body language behaviors and a

Speaker:

list of what they “mean,” then ignore it.

Speaker:

The second rule is that when you read someone,

Speaker:

you’re never interpreting a single expression in isolation.

Speaker:

Rather,

Speaker:

you’re looking for a)

Speaker:

patterns,

Speaker:

b)

Speaker:

context,

Speaker:

and c)

Speaker:

variation from baseline For example,

Speaker:

it’s often claimed that a woman twiddling her hair is being flirtatious.

Speaker:

If you see this behavior precisely once,

Speaker:

and it occurs on a windy day that causes her hair to blow around,

Speaker:

then it would be silly to conclude you’re being flirted with.

Speaker:

Instead,

Speaker:

look at the bigger picture - repeatedly touching the hair,

Speaker:

constant giggling and smiling,

Speaker:

joking,

Speaker:

playful touches on the arm,

Speaker:

and raised voice pitch all create a pattern that is strongly suggestive of (not

Speaker:

a guarantee of)

Speaker:

flirting.

Speaker:

Now,

Speaker:

if you also happen to be on a date with such a woman,

Speaker:

well,

Speaker:

that’s a big context clue that lends weight to the conclusion that she might

Speaker:

be flirting.

Speaker:

However,

Speaker:

you need to consider the behavior you’re seeing relative to that person

Speaker:

themselves.

Speaker:

How does what you’re seeing compare to how they normally are?

Speaker:

Despite all the laughing and giggling,

Speaker:

and despite being on a date,

Speaker:

if you later learn that this woman laughs and giggles this way with everyone

Speaker:

all the time,

Speaker:

your conclusion that she’s flirting suddenly seems a lot shakier!

Speaker:

Those caveats in mind,

Speaker:

consider the fundamentals of reading body language and the fact that it

Speaker:

typically serves a few main purposes.

Speaker:

Our body language can strengthen and confirm what we’re saying verbally,

Speaker:

it can contradict it (i.e.,

Speaker:

when you’re lying or concealing something),

Speaker:

it can replace it (when you show rather than tell),

Speaker:

or it can complement,

Speaker:

accent,

Speaker:

and diversify the message.

Speaker:

Your job as a body language reader is to see the big,

Speaker:

interconnected picture that the body language forms a part of.

Speaker:

Notice the verbal expression,

Speaker:

then notice the nonverbal expression—then notice the relationship between

Speaker:

them.

Speaker:

Do they contradict?

Speaker:

The person may be lying or else trying to hide something.

Speaker:

Maybe they themselves are unaware of a deeper truth.

Speaker:

Notice the overall feeling you get.

Speaker:

Do you get a sense of openness or closedness?

Speaker:

In general,

Speaker:

is there tension or relaxation?

Speaker:

Bigness in the body or smallness?

Speaker:

Is the body language defensive or exploratory (i.e.,

Speaker:

advancing or retreating)?

Speaker:

Remember the primary emotions and imagine that the body has its own primary

Speaker:

emotions,

Speaker:

too.

Speaker:

“Bigness” connects to confidence,

Speaker:

joy,

Speaker:

creativity,

Speaker:

or on the far end could signal dominance and aggression.

Speaker:

Think about a loud voice,

Speaker:

a sprawling posture,

Speaker:

and big,

Speaker:

open hands.

Speaker:

“Smallness” can mean fear,

Speaker:

submissiveness,

Speaker:

exhaustion.

Speaker:

A small voice,

Speaker:

breathlessness,

Speaker:

slouching,

Speaker:

hunching,

Speaker:

folding arms,

Speaker:

downcast eyes,

Speaker:

stillness ...or look for a feeling of tightness and restriction in the voice.

Speaker:

Are the hands and feet clenched,

Speaker:

held close,

Speaker:

fidgety,

Speaker:

quick,

Speaker:

unrelaxed?

Speaker:

What does this tell you in context?

Speaker:

Remember that no single data point is conclusive.

Speaker:

Instead,

Speaker:

look for patterns,

Speaker:

variation from baseline,

Speaker:

and context.

Speaker:

For example -

Speaker:

•Saying “I’m fine” and tightening the lips,

Speaker:

folding the arms,

Speaker:

and looking away (they’re not fine but want to conceal their irritation

Speaker:

...can you see primary and secondary emotions at play?).

Speaker:

•Taking a step back in a confrontational conversation and touching the hand

Speaker:

to the neck (a retreating,

Speaker:

defensive posture,

Speaker:

suggesting feeling threatened or attacked).

Speaker:

•A person who never,

Speaker:

ever praises others widens his eyes,

Speaker:

gives a slight nod,

Speaker:

and says,

Speaker:

“nice” when reviewing your work (a high compliment—for him!).

Speaker:

•A person quickly flutters a sideways glance at a friend and their eyes meet.

Speaker:

Both say nothing but both silently lift a single corner of their mouths before

Speaker:

breaking eye contact and continuing with the group meeting they’re both in (a

Speaker:

moment of camaraderie,

Speaker:

shared humor,

Speaker:

a secret in-joke;

Speaker:

without saying a word they say,

Speaker:

“You’re with me,

Speaker:

right?"

Speaker:

“Yup.”)

Speaker:

Judgments Of Others Reveal Attitudes To The Self.

Speaker:

One final tip to add to your people-reading toolkit is one you might not have

Speaker:

thought about - analyzing how people speak about others.

Speaker:

The words that someone uses to talk about other people can give you enormous

Speaker:

insight into their own personalities and how they think of themselves,

Speaker:

both good and bad.

Speaker:

Doctor Dustin Wood at Wake Forest University conducted a study in the Journal

Speaker:

of Personality and Social Psychology which suggested a link between your

Speaker:

perceptions of others and your own character.

Speaker:

In the study,

Speaker:

the participants were requested to list out the positive and negative qualities

Speaker:

of the people they knew.

Speaker:

Analyzing the data,

Speaker:

the researchers found that if a person had a habit of describing others

Speaker:

positively,

Speaker:

this pointed to similar positive traits in themselves.

Speaker:

So,

Speaker:

if someone judged their acquaintances as broadly kind,

Speaker:

happy,

Speaker:

emotionally stable,

Speaker:

and polite,

Speaker:

for example,

Speaker:

they tended to describe themselves that way too,

Speaker:

as well as be more likely to be described by others in similar terms.

Speaker:

Generally,

Speaker:

favorable descriptions tended to come from people who were satisfied with their

Speaker:

lives and generally liked by others.

Speaker:

If people used plenty of negative descriptors,

Speaker:

however,

Speaker:

the researchers found an increased likelihood of personality traits such as

Speaker:

narcissism and antisocial tendencies,

Speaker:

depression,

Speaker:

and even personality disorders.

Speaker:

What can we make of the findings of this study,

Speaker:

especially when it comes to better understanding the people around us?

Speaker:

Firstly,

Speaker:

notice not only what people are saying about others but also how they’re

Speaker:

saying it and the words they use.

Speaker:

Ask a friend what they think about another person,

Speaker:

and they may inadvertently tell you more about themselves!

Speaker:

Being overly negative may give you a hint that the person is largely unhappy,

Speaker:

neurotic,

Speaker:

or somehow disagreeable.

Speaker:

This makes sense—the mental models,

Speaker:

language,

Speaker:

and value judgments that the person applies to others are also applied to them.

Speaker:

This language is a peak into their world.

Speaker:

There’s also the fact that many people tend to project their worldview and

Speaker:

self-concept onto others—especially aspects of their “shadow” or those

Speaker:

parts of their personalities they’re unwilling to fully acknowledge.

Speaker:

When you’re reading people and getting to know them,

Speaker:

you might like to ask them their opinion about someone else—use a celebrity

Speaker:

if you don’t feel comfortable discussing a mutual acquaintance.

Speaker:

As they answer,

Speaker:

listen for a consistently negative interpretation of the others person’s

Speaker:

traits.

Speaker:

Complaining about a person’s actions is one thing,

Speaker:

and people may have justified reasons to dislike someone;

Speaker:

however,

Speaker:

listen closely to how the person is being described for who they actually are.

Speaker:

If you can notice the same negative patterns across different people,

Speaker:

this is an even stronger indication that the person speaking is in fact quite

Speaker:

unhappy with themselves.

Speaker:

Is there any relationship between what we say about others and our own

Speaker:

attitudes?

Speaker:

The study looked at broadly “negative” appraisals and personality traits,

Speaker:

but there may be reason to think that a person who constantly accuses others of

Speaker:

being “jealous,” for example,

Speaker:

is in fact themselves jealous.

Speaker:

It’s not always easy to spot when people are projecting onto others,

Speaker:

but if you notice someone leveling the same criticisms at everyone in their

Speaker:

lives,

Speaker:

that criticism probably applies more accurately to them.

Speaker:

Professional gossips tend to have low self-esteem—imagine their gossip is

Speaker:

really an externalized representation of their own negative inner talk.

Speaker:

What they deem unacceptable in others is usually what they cannot accept in

Speaker:

themselves!

Speaker:

Likewise,

Speaker:

people who blame others or complain about them are telling you that they have a

Speaker:

predominantly external locus of control—i.e.,

Speaker:

they see external events as controlling their lives,

Speaker:

and don’t see themselves as responsible free agents.

Speaker:

Finally,

Speaker:

people who describe others as threatening,

Speaker:

mean,

Speaker:

hostile,

Speaker:

and judgmental may be telling you that they have trouble with low self-worth,

Speaker:

depression,

Speaker:

or anxiety.

Speaker:

Listen closely—they’re seldom telling you about others but about how others

Speaker:

seem to them from their perspective.

Speaker:

Takeaways.

Speaker:

•To understand who people are and why they behave as they do,

Speaker:

we need to understand how they feel.

Speaker:

•Primary emotions are those that are automatic,

Speaker:

universal,

Speaker:

and innate - fear,

Speaker:

happiness,

Speaker:

surprise,

Speaker:

disgust,

Speaker:

sadness,

Speaker:

and anger all manifest via the body and serve a survival purpose.

Speaker:

Secondary emotions encompass the way we react to primary emotions,

Speaker:

and depend on cultural,

Speaker:

personal,

Speaker:

and familial factors.

Speaker:

Both primary and secondary emotions can be adaptive or maladaptive.

Speaker:

•We can use the A. B. C. model to help us understand and predict people’s

Speaker:

behavior .- Antecedents instigated Behaviors which are followed by Consequences.

Speaker:

Understanding what comes before and after an action helps us predict what

Speaker:

people will do in future and why.

Speaker:

•To observe primary emotions,

Speaker:

we read the body (and have evolved to do so!);

Speaker:

to observe secondary emotions,

Speaker:

we observe behavior while being aware of social and cultural contexts.

Speaker:

Though cultures differ in their expressions of secondary emotions,

Speaker:

all humans have a common experience of primary emotions.

Speaker:

•To be good people-readers,

Speaker:

we need empathy and verbal and non-verbal communication skills.

Speaker:

When reading body language,

Speaker:

no single action is conclusive.

Speaker:

Rather,

Speaker:

we observe repetition and patterns over time,

Speaker:

and we consider the context in which they occur and how that action varies

Speaker:

against a “control” baseline for that individual.

Speaker:

This has been

Speaker:

Become A Human Behavior Scientist:

Speaker:

Observe,

Speaker:

Read,

Speaker:

Understand,

Speaker:

and Decode People With Minimal Information (How to be More Likable and Charismatic Book 18) Written by

Speaker:

Patrick King, narrated by russell newton.