1 00:00:01,440 --> 00:00:06,560 It's the usual tragedy of managed money to watch people watch 2 00:00:06,560 --> 00:00:11,280 performance, wait for there to be enough confirmation and confidence, 3 00:00:11,920 --> 00:00:16,319 get in a little bit too late and put themselves on a right shift 4 00:00:16,319 --> 00:00:17,600 of time off cycle. 5 00:00:20,400 --> 00:00:22,800 Welcome to Top Traders Unplugged. 6 00:00:22,960 --> 00:00:26,480 In markets, success doesn't come from predicting what happens 7 00:00:26,480 --> 00:00:26,800 next. 8 00:00:27,040 --> 00:00:30,000 It comes from being prepared for what you can't predict. 9 00:00:30,960 --> 00:00:34,340 In each episode, we go deep with some of the world's most thoughtful 10 00:00:34,340 --> 00:00:38,300 minds in investing, economics and beyond to understand how they 11 00:00:38,300 --> 00:00:42,380 think, how they prepare and how they decide, and the experiences 12 00:00:42,380 --> 00:00:44,060 that shaped how they see the world. 13 00:00:44,540 --> 00:00:48,980 No noise, no shortcuts, just real conversations to help you think 14 00:00:48,980 --> 00:00:51,020 better and invest with confidence. 15 00:00:53,420 --> 00:00:57,500 Hey, everyone, and welcome to another edition of Top Traders Unplugged, 16 00:00:57,500 --> 00:01:00,700 where today Alan Dunn and I are delighted to be joined by Pat 17 00:01:00,700 --> 00:01:04,690 Weldon and founder and CEO of Welton Investment Corporation as 18 00:01:04,690 --> 00:01:08,250 part of our series focusing on the one investment strategy that 19 00:01:08,250 --> 00:01:11,770 we have dedicated pretty much all of our careers to, namely trend 20 00:01:11,770 --> 00:01:13,890 following and managed futures more broadly. 21 00:01:14,210 --> 00:01:17,370 First off, Pat, it's really great to have you on the podcast. 22 00:01:17,370 --> 00:01:19,090 Thanks so much for joining us today. 23 00:01:19,330 --> 00:01:21,970 We really have been looking forward to our conversation. 24 00:01:21,970 --> 00:01:23,090 I hope you're doing well. 25 00:01:23,730 --> 00:01:25,890 I am doing well and thanks for inviting me. 26 00:01:26,450 --> 00:01:26,930 Absolutely. 27 00:01:26,930 --> 00:01:29,910 I'm actually, maybe more importantly, as I told you the other 28 00:01:29,910 --> 00:01:33,270 day, thank you for all you do for the trading community. 29 00:01:33,830 --> 00:01:37,750 You've probably built the single largest and best resource 30 00:01:37,910 --> 00:01:41,510 to help traders and investors that they could find anywhere. 31 00:01:41,910 --> 00:01:43,350 That's very kind of you to say. 32 00:01:43,350 --> 00:01:44,190 Thank you so much. 33 00:01:44,190 --> 00:01:46,750 And of course, we do it because we have contributors like 34 00:01:46,750 --> 00:01:49,030 yourself, so that's how we can do it. 35 00:01:49,190 --> 00:01:51,230 Alan, it's also great to see you. 36 00:01:51,230 --> 00:01:52,190 How are you doing? 37 00:01:52,190 --> 00:01:53,590 How is Dublin treating you? 38 00:01:53,850 --> 00:01:54,250 Dublin? 39 00:01:54,250 --> 00:01:55,170 Very good, yeah. 40 00:01:55,170 --> 00:01:58,290 Great to be on and looking forward to speaking with yourself 41 00:01:58,290 --> 00:01:58,730 and Pat. 42 00:01:58,730 --> 00:02:00,890 I'm sure we'll have a lot to delve into. 43 00:02:01,690 --> 00:02:03,130 Yes, absolutely. 44 00:02:03,450 --> 00:02:06,370 Now, before we get into all of the different topics we're going 45 00:02:06,370 --> 00:02:09,490 to be discussing, I would like to set the stage a little bit for 46 00:02:09,490 --> 00:02:12,770 our conversation so that the audience knows a little bit about 47 00:02:12,770 --> 00:02:13,370 your background. 48 00:02:13,370 --> 00:02:13,650 Pat. 49 00:02:13,650 --> 00:02:17,930 But instead of doing the usual list of places you worked and all 50 00:02:17,930 --> 00:02:20,890 of that stuff, I was hoping that maybe you could tell us about 51 00:02:21,390 --> 00:02:25,670 maybe 2, 3 pivotal points in your career where you experienced 52 00:02:25,670 --> 00:02:31,310 something profound that shaped how you think about investing and 53 00:02:31,310 --> 00:02:35,790 maybe also kind of led to where you are specifically today. 54 00:02:36,830 --> 00:02:37,229 Wow. 55 00:02:37,229 --> 00:02:39,910 Well, you know, when you're 65 years old, there's definitely been 56 00:02:39,910 --> 00:02:42,350 a few pivots, especially in this industry. 57 00:02:42,830 --> 00:02:43,870 Tell me about it. 58 00:02:44,510 --> 00:02:50,300 You Know, I think for those who know me and know that I'm a physician 59 00:02:50,300 --> 00:02:55,060 and know that I started a hedge fund years ago and the, the 60 00:02:55,060 --> 00:03:00,340 usual three pivots that I get asked about are something like why 61 00:03:00,340 --> 00:03:02,300 medicine, why trading? 62 00:03:02,300 --> 00:03:02,660 And. 63 00:03:03,060 --> 00:03:05,980 And then when they hear those, then the most perplexing one is they 64 00:03:05,980 --> 00:03:06,740 say why both. 65 00:03:07,700 --> 00:03:11,060 So the we could delve into those. 66 00:03:12,340 --> 00:03:15,920 Why medicine's a pretty short story and mostly about working in 67 00:03:15,920 --> 00:03:22,240 a cancer laboratory and why trading really is a, a life pivot. 68 00:03:22,240 --> 00:03:26,920 Because that really is also how fortunate I was to meet my wife 69 00:03:26,920 --> 00:03:28,320 and co founder Annette. 70 00:03:29,120 --> 00:03:31,360 And why both is. 71 00:03:32,320 --> 00:03:36,200 It's a, it's a multi legged story but the capstone of it was 72 00:03:36,200 --> 00:03:41,960 probably a very kind Paul Tudor Jones that Annette and I went 73 00:03:41,960 --> 00:03:46,960 to visit many, many, many years ago that gave us some resolve 74 00:03:46,960 --> 00:03:47,520 afterwards. 75 00:03:47,840 --> 00:03:50,800 So like to delve into any of those? 76 00:03:51,520 --> 00:03:54,720 Yeah, actually, you know, because you have a very interesting 77 00:03:54,720 --> 00:03:58,720 background and obviously it dates back to the commodities Corp. 78 00:03:58,720 --> 00:04:04,640 Days and many people don't really know how important I think 79 00:04:04,640 --> 00:04:06,880 that that company was. 80 00:04:06,960 --> 00:04:10,570 Not that I want to spend too much time on it, but I mean of course 81 00:04:10,570 --> 00:04:14,890 it could be fun and interesting maybe just to hear one 82 00:04:14,890 --> 00:04:17,450 or two short stories. 83 00:04:18,410 --> 00:04:19,290 You had mentors. 84 00:04:19,290 --> 00:04:20,650 You mentioned Paul Tudor Jones. 85 00:04:21,370 --> 00:04:22,810 I think you know, John Henry. 86 00:04:22,970 --> 00:04:27,370 There are others that are well, very well known people from 87 00:04:27,370 --> 00:04:27,850 our industry. 88 00:04:28,250 --> 00:04:32,610 If you have a few things you can share that would of course make 89 00:04:32,610 --> 00:04:33,690 it very, very interesting. 90 00:04:33,850 --> 00:04:37,530 That will probably help condense 40 years into a smaller 91 00:04:37,530 --> 00:04:37,810 number. 92 00:04:37,810 --> 00:04:40,100 But so sort of spinning my way up. 93 00:04:40,740 --> 00:04:47,740 I ended up changing initials college studies into medicine, received 94 00:04:47,740 --> 00:04:50,980 a grant for a medical scientist training program which 95 00:04:50,980 --> 00:04:55,660 led me to ucla, which is also where I met Annette, the very first 96 00:04:55,660 --> 00:04:57,780 person I met at ucla. 97 00:04:58,260 --> 00:05:02,540 So I've warned young people for years, be very careful who you 98 00:05:02,540 --> 00:05:03,860 get into an elevator with. 99 00:05:04,220 --> 00:05:05,740 You might be there for a long time. 100 00:05:06,540 --> 00:05:13,420 And that subsequently led to really I think to some degree US 101 00:05:13,660 --> 00:05:16,140 trading personally to make some ends meet. 102 00:05:16,140 --> 00:05:20,540 But with Annette's entrepreneurialism and sort of striving, 103 00:05:21,340 --> 00:05:24,500 we ended up getting discovered, if you will, when we 104 00:05:24,500 --> 00:05:29,420 were up in the Palo Alto area when we since moved to Stanford and 105 00:05:29,500 --> 00:05:32,020 one thing led to another and we were introduced to commodities 106 00:05:32,020 --> 00:05:32,700 corporations. 107 00:05:32,780 --> 00:05:36,990 So we learned about them much like somebody today might. 108 00:05:38,350 --> 00:05:43,390 If you roll back into the late 1980s commodities corporation I think 109 00:05:43,390 --> 00:05:46,990 could, could reasonably be thought of as the very first multi 110 00:05:46,990 --> 00:05:49,470 strategy pod shop of traders. 111 00:05:50,750 --> 00:05:54,270 I think of them as much more dimensional than that though because 112 00:05:54,270 --> 00:05:58,430 they also were very explicitly in the business of developing trading 113 00:05:58,430 --> 00:05:58,830 talent. 114 00:05:59,490 --> 00:06:04,770 They had senior traders, they had that Oftentimes mentored juniors. 115 00:06:04,770 --> 00:06:09,330 They had facilities that, you know, helped junior traders work. 116 00:06:09,330 --> 00:06:12,810 And one thing led to another and we were offered a contract to 117 00:06:12,810 --> 00:06:13,570 trade for them. 118 00:06:14,130 --> 00:06:17,650 So while we were trading for ourselves initially and thinking 119 00:06:17,650 --> 00:06:22,370 we might be saving up some money for some kind of opportunity 120 00:06:23,090 --> 00:06:26,090 to explore later in life, it turned out the trading itself became 121 00:06:26,090 --> 00:06:29,640 the opportunity when we turned professional and started trading 122 00:06:29,640 --> 00:06:30,080 for them. 123 00:06:32,240 --> 00:06:37,440 And that really sort of leads to the mentorship that we learned 124 00:06:37,440 --> 00:06:38,520 from many other traders. 125 00:06:38,520 --> 00:06:41,240 And there are many others that we met. 126 00:06:41,240 --> 00:06:45,320 And we learned a lot from some of the very biggest names in the 127 00:06:45,320 --> 00:06:49,360 industry that you and I might know, some of which aren't even in 128 00:06:49,360 --> 00:06:50,240 the industry today. 129 00:06:50,240 --> 00:06:51,840 For instance, like John Henry. 130 00:06:52,000 --> 00:06:52,480 True. 131 00:06:53,130 --> 00:06:54,330 But there was one episode. 132 00:06:55,130 --> 00:06:58,650 We were still thinking about medicine as a primary career, and 133 00:06:58,650 --> 00:07:00,570 trading was just on the side. 134 00:07:01,530 --> 00:07:03,770 It was just simply a profession for us. 135 00:07:05,130 --> 00:07:08,250 And we hadn't really thought about developing a separate company. 136 00:07:08,250 --> 00:07:12,370 But I do remember when we in 89, we had sort of had a really good 137 00:07:12,370 --> 00:07:13,290 start with cc. 138 00:07:14,570 --> 00:07:16,930 We were allocated more money every quarter. 139 00:07:16,930 --> 00:07:18,490 As we hit return targets. 140 00:07:19,870 --> 00:07:23,910 By 1990 or so, we, you know, were trading sort of more and more 141 00:07:23,910 --> 00:07:26,830 money and met more traders along the way. 142 00:07:27,310 --> 00:07:30,190 And it was about that time that Elaine Crocker, who was the 143 00:07:30,190 --> 00:07:34,589 head of Commodities Corp's trading at the time, called ahead 144 00:07:34,589 --> 00:07:38,470 for us and said we should really meet Paul Tudor Jones. 145 00:07:38,470 --> 00:07:40,790 And so she brokered that. 146 00:07:40,790 --> 00:07:45,710 And though it was long ago, Paul was already very famous as a 147 00:07:45,710 --> 00:07:46,110 trader. 148 00:07:46,110 --> 00:07:50,130 Even that many years ago, he is just a standout natural talent. 149 00:07:50,530 --> 00:07:52,290 So we really looked forward to meeting him. 150 00:07:53,090 --> 00:07:57,250 And I still remember that day because we arrived and one of his 151 00:07:57,490 --> 00:08:00,530 colleagues, I think his name was Sean, met us and he guided us 152 00:08:00,530 --> 00:08:03,490 in and showed us about the office. 153 00:08:03,810 --> 00:08:08,170 We waited for a little while and sort of in the distance we could 154 00:08:08,170 --> 00:08:13,290 see, at one point we could see Paul very sort of engaged, intensely 155 00:08:13,290 --> 00:08:17,480 engaged on a phone screen, you know, looking at something walking 156 00:08:17,480 --> 00:08:17,760 about. 157 00:08:18,640 --> 00:08:20,480 And we were delayed and delayed and delayed. 158 00:08:20,480 --> 00:08:24,360 And we were thinking we might be meeting him for a five minute 159 00:08:24,360 --> 00:08:25,360 handshake or something. 160 00:08:25,520 --> 00:08:29,480 But after about 15 minutes, just this remarkable thing happened. 161 00:08:29,480 --> 00:08:32,800 He sort of came out of his office, all intensity was gone. 162 00:08:33,360 --> 00:08:37,760 He was fully gracious and welcoming and kind and, you know, 163 00:08:37,760 --> 00:08:42,080 apologizing us to us as sort of trading nobodies from Commodities 164 00:08:42,080 --> 00:08:43,760 Corporation for his being late. 165 00:08:45,609 --> 00:08:48,929 And then almost instantaneously, he offered us one 166 00:08:48,929 --> 00:08:51,689 of, I think, the greatest trading lessons we ever learned. 167 00:08:52,249 --> 00:08:56,289 He said in this sort of marvelous Southern Memphis accent 168 00:08:56,289 --> 00:09:00,089 that he had at the time, which was much stronger then than I'VE 169 00:09:00,089 --> 00:09:03,169 heard him recently on interviews, but I still remember 170 00:09:03,169 --> 00:09:04,009 him saying no. 171 00:09:04,089 --> 00:09:09,009 He says, Pat Nanette, he starts going on one thing is that 172 00:09:09,009 --> 00:09:12,500 when you start trading size, you can't only think about getting 173 00:09:12,500 --> 00:09:13,500 out when you want. 174 00:09:13,820 --> 00:09:15,980 You have to get out when the market lets you. 175 00:09:17,500 --> 00:09:23,420 And from there forward, I could never sort of unsee the obvious, 176 00:09:23,660 --> 00:09:26,060 that markets weren't math, that there's somebody on the other 177 00:09:26,060 --> 00:09:30,420 side of every single trade who at that moment believes they also 178 00:09:30,420 --> 00:09:31,180 have an edge. 179 00:09:32,060 --> 00:09:36,540 And I'm sure as we wander on other topics, that theme is going 180 00:09:36,540 --> 00:09:37,580 to come up again and again. 181 00:09:38,570 --> 00:09:40,330 Market structure matters. 182 00:09:41,690 --> 00:09:45,490 The second thing we did was we walked around his office, had this 183 00:09:45,490 --> 00:09:50,010 marvelous tour, his graciousness, humor, all everywhere, 184 00:09:50,890 --> 00:09:53,170 telling us one short story after another. 185 00:09:53,170 --> 00:09:57,210 And he's pointing out the desks and pointing out the facilities. 186 00:09:57,210 --> 00:09:59,050 And then he said something like. 187 00:09:59,610 --> 00:10:03,090 Which just from memory was something like, when you grow, you 188 00:10:03,090 --> 00:10:07,150 need more things, you need more people, you need more capital. 189 00:10:07,710 --> 00:10:10,190 He said, and then it starts getting funny. 190 00:10:10,190 --> 00:10:14,150 And so now we have manuals for this, we have manuals for that, and 191 00:10:14,150 --> 00:10:16,110 now we have manuals for all the manuals. 192 00:10:16,670 --> 00:10:18,790 And of course, we're all laughing at this point. 193 00:10:18,790 --> 00:10:24,550 But we left that meeting and the lesson was really clear for us, 194 00:10:24,550 --> 00:10:27,230 was that trading was only one. 195 00:10:27,390 --> 00:10:30,830 One component of building a professional trading firm. 196 00:10:31,860 --> 00:10:33,780 And we digested those lessons for years. 197 00:10:33,780 --> 00:10:36,980 And ultimately that's after sort of processing them. 198 00:10:37,140 --> 00:10:41,820 We decided that if we built a small firm, even if one that was 199 00:10:41,820 --> 00:10:46,300 a tenth or the twentieth the size of Tudor, that we might be able 200 00:10:46,300 --> 00:10:52,060 to fully separate the missions of medicine, whether they were practicing 201 00:10:52,060 --> 00:10:56,340 or teaching or research or any combination from money. 202 00:10:57,170 --> 00:10:58,930 You know, we could solve for them separately. 203 00:10:59,970 --> 00:11:03,610 And so afterwards, we decided to build a small firm and we began 204 00:11:03,610 --> 00:11:04,810 taking in outside money. 205 00:11:04,810 --> 00:11:08,450 And that's what Welton is today. 206 00:11:08,610 --> 00:11:13,250 And even in retrospect, it seems naive, but it's exactly what 207 00:11:13,250 --> 00:11:13,930 became true. 208 00:11:13,930 --> 00:11:16,610 And it's been a guiding principle for us since the start. 209 00:11:17,170 --> 00:11:19,290 Yeah, wonderful, wonderful story. 210 00:11:19,290 --> 00:11:21,170 Thank you so much for sharing that. 211 00:11:21,810 --> 00:11:25,770 I have to say, I think these stories from around the time when 212 00:11:25,770 --> 00:11:27,650 I began as well, I think they're so important. 213 00:11:27,810 --> 00:11:32,050 And there are some people in this industry that have, yeah, really 214 00:11:32,050 --> 00:11:35,450 got some amazing lessons that they have shared along the way. 215 00:11:35,450 --> 00:11:36,450 So I appreciate that. 216 00:11:37,010 --> 00:11:42,450 Now, Alan and I, and you, we spoke a few days ago because you 217 00:11:42,450 --> 00:11:48,010 brought along a lot of great ideas in terms of what we could be 218 00:11:48,010 --> 00:11:48,610 talking about. 219 00:11:50,030 --> 00:11:55,550 And what we have done since then is we've kind of tried to divide 220 00:11:55,710 --> 00:11:59,710 topics up into the usual headlines, if you like. 221 00:11:59,950 --> 00:12:02,670 That we normally talk about when we do this particular series. 222 00:12:04,030 --> 00:12:07,910 And so what I will do in, in the usual tradition is I'm going 223 00:12:07,910 --> 00:12:11,630 to kick it over to you, Alan, to, to start off. 224 00:12:12,270 --> 00:12:12,670 Great. 225 00:12:12,670 --> 00:12:14,430 Well, maybe to pick up on that. 226 00:12:14,900 --> 00:12:18,460 And I suppose evolution that you talked about, Pat, in terms of 227 00:12:18,460 --> 00:12:20,140 medicine to trading. 228 00:12:20,140 --> 00:12:23,780 And then I suppose what came next was an asset management business. 229 00:12:23,860 --> 00:12:28,140 And obviously it was one of the themes you kind of touched on 230 00:12:28,140 --> 00:12:31,460 in your own notes, the transition from being a prop trader 231 00:12:31,940 --> 00:12:34,820 to running an asset management business, which you've mentioned 232 00:12:34,820 --> 00:12:35,460 again there. 233 00:12:35,700 --> 00:12:38,820 So just curious, maybe if you could delve into that a bit more. 234 00:12:38,820 --> 00:12:41,140 Obviously, when you run an asset management business, there's 235 00:12:41,140 --> 00:12:44,830 the old business side that comes with that in terms of compliance 236 00:12:44,830 --> 00:12:46,910 and sales, business development, et cetera. 237 00:12:47,070 --> 00:12:51,470 But I'm more interested in kind of the risk management and the 238 00:12:51,470 --> 00:12:51,950 trading. 239 00:12:52,350 --> 00:12:55,950 Does that differ when you're just trading as a prop trader for 240 00:12:55,950 --> 00:13:00,510 yourself, but purely just yourself accountable to then thinking 241 00:13:00,510 --> 00:13:03,470 about, okay, we're going to get into the business of managing 242 00:13:03,470 --> 00:13:08,190 risk and generating returns for outside investors and how that 243 00:13:08,190 --> 00:13:10,750 evolved and how you've thought about that over the years. 244 00:13:11,990 --> 00:13:15,790 You know, I think that's a question that doesn't receive enough 245 00:13:15,790 --> 00:13:16,310 attention. 246 00:13:16,630 --> 00:13:19,270 And we sort of. 247 00:13:19,430 --> 00:13:22,590 Or if it does receive attention, it's the mechanisms of 248 00:13:22,590 --> 00:13:26,870 building the firm kind of the lessons we introduced, the compliance, 249 00:13:26,949 --> 00:13:29,510 the operations, the regulations, et cetera. 250 00:13:30,870 --> 00:13:32,470 That's not really the big difference. 251 00:13:33,590 --> 00:13:35,990 I think the real big difference is a moral difference. 252 00:13:37,760 --> 00:13:42,160 When you're a proprietary trader and to make it easy for yourself, 253 00:13:43,840 --> 00:13:46,400 you would have one set of goals and hopefully they've been 254 00:13:46,400 --> 00:13:50,480 sharply defined because if they're not, that's going to be a 255 00:13:50,480 --> 00:13:51,320 principal weakness. 256 00:13:51,320 --> 00:13:53,600 And we could talk about that separately. 257 00:13:54,240 --> 00:13:57,840 But I think the minute you take in outside money, you really 258 00:13:57,840 --> 00:14:02,160 take in the moral obligation that it's their goals that are most 259 00:14:02,160 --> 00:14:06,540 important for what you do with that money, which shapes everything. 260 00:14:07,740 --> 00:14:11,420 It shapes the very heart of the question you just asked. 261 00:14:12,380 --> 00:14:16,900 How is risk managed in their particular world? 262 00:14:16,900 --> 00:14:20,380 If they're more like an allocator than an investor, they 263 00:14:20,380 --> 00:14:23,500 might want something that is more consistently exposed and more 264 00:14:23,500 --> 00:14:26,620 constant and targeted volatility, as it would be known 265 00:14:26,620 --> 00:14:26,940 today. 266 00:14:28,770 --> 00:14:32,250 If they were more of an investor, they might want more exposure 267 00:14:32,250 --> 00:14:34,930 when there's a better value or when there's a better forward return 268 00:14:34,930 --> 00:14:38,490 profile and less exposure when it's weaker, because there is a sense 269 00:14:38,490 --> 00:14:43,610 of wanting to have your investment size proportionate to 270 00:14:43,610 --> 00:14:43,890 return. 271 00:14:45,490 --> 00:14:49,650 But I think it all stems from really that moral difference that 272 00:14:49,810 --> 00:14:53,090 the day you take somebody's Outside money is the day you make 273 00:14:53,090 --> 00:14:53,810 their goals. 274 00:14:53,810 --> 00:14:55,140 The number one goal. 275 00:14:55,700 --> 00:14:59,260 If you were turning it into any kind of a formula, the formula 276 00:14:59,260 --> 00:15:03,260 is probably different because most prop traders for themselves 277 00:15:03,260 --> 00:15:06,340 are probably thinking something on the order of a ray rock, 278 00:15:06,420 --> 00:15:06,740 right? 279 00:15:06,740 --> 00:15:08,500 A risk adjusted rate of return on capital. 280 00:15:09,780 --> 00:15:13,380 So they think in dollars more than they think in percents. 281 00:15:15,411 --> 00:15:19,331 I mean with that in mind then obviously does that presumably it 282 00:15:19,331 --> 00:15:23,371 informs you of the kinds of programs you offer and the blends 283 00:15:23,371 --> 00:15:26,891 and the levels of volatility and, and, and everything that that 284 00:15:26,891 --> 00:15:27,691 that goes with that. 285 00:15:27,691 --> 00:15:30,411 Presumably absolutely. 286 00:15:30,411 --> 00:15:32,171 And, and, and it has over the years. 287 00:15:33,051 --> 00:15:37,571 You know, when we first began trading outside money we, we traded 288 00:15:37,571 --> 00:15:42,811 a what would be classified today as more or less a diversified 289 00:15:44,331 --> 00:15:49,811 medium term trend following program with a few shorter term elements. 290 00:15:49,811 --> 00:15:50,251 In it. 291 00:15:52,181 --> 00:15:54,421 That was not traded at a fixed volatility. 292 00:15:55,301 --> 00:15:58,501 The volatility would ebb and flow within a range though its average 293 00:15:58,501 --> 00:16:02,781 volatility would be in, in Approximately probably about a 15 294 00:16:02,781 --> 00:16:06,541 volume in the 90s, but that might be 10 volume when there's less 295 00:16:06,541 --> 00:16:09,461 opportunity and 20 when there's more something, something 296 00:16:09,461 --> 00:16:10,821 like that amplitude range. 297 00:16:11,781 --> 00:16:16,821 Later on in the early 2000s there were I still remember actually 298 00:16:16,821 --> 00:16:18,701 of a very pivotal meeting. 299 00:16:18,701 --> 00:16:22,501 I was speaking for one of the French bank circuits that were popular 300 00:16:22,501 --> 00:16:23,061 at the time. 301 00:16:23,061 --> 00:16:28,021 And after my speech we were gathered in one of the restaurants 302 00:16:30,821 --> 00:16:35,381 in the hotel outside of Florence and three pretty well known 303 00:16:35,381 --> 00:16:38,581 people in the industry, maybe even people who've been on the podcast. 304 00:16:38,581 --> 00:16:41,541 At one point in time I remember us all being at the table 305 00:16:41,541 --> 00:16:44,301 and them asking a really serious question. 306 00:16:44,301 --> 00:16:45,381 There's like why? 307 00:16:46,211 --> 00:16:49,211 Why when I have an account with some professional traders do 308 00:16:49,211 --> 00:16:54,131 I seem to lose money three or four times faster than I make money? 309 00:16:55,251 --> 00:16:59,771 And I of course thought it was an observation, a feeling, maybe 310 00:16:59,771 --> 00:17:00,531 some griping. 311 00:17:00,931 --> 00:17:05,051 But when I left, went back and looked at track records other than 312 00:17:05,051 --> 00:17:08,051 ours and looked at what would be likely in different products, 313 00:17:08,211 --> 00:17:09,571 it was exceptionally true. 314 00:17:10,611 --> 00:17:17,381 And the early industry at the time I don't think was as sensitive 315 00:17:17,381 --> 00:17:21,341 to some professional allocators needs for the fact that 316 00:17:21,341 --> 00:17:25,261 when there was when once they took positions, when there was rising 317 00:17:25,261 --> 00:17:28,781 volatility, which oftentimes was accompanied by rising correlation 318 00:17:29,981 --> 00:17:35,061 that the overall net exposure was rising and that it wasn't poor 319 00:17:35,061 --> 00:17:40,561 timing, but that a reversal in some cases was approximately three 320 00:17:40,561 --> 00:17:42,641 or four times faster in equity. 321 00:17:42,641 --> 00:17:47,321 P and L. I don't think you see that in track records today because 322 00:17:47,321 --> 00:17:51,601 in the early 2000s many people, including ourselves, began 323 00:17:52,241 --> 00:17:55,521 volatility targeting the portfolio or volatility targeting 324 00:17:55,921 --> 00:18:02,681 segments of the portfolio to Mute those kinds of responses to 325 00:18:02,681 --> 00:18:06,981 make it more compatible with professional allocators dedicating 326 00:18:06,981 --> 00:18:07,781 exposure. 327 00:18:09,141 --> 00:18:09,781 Interesting. 328 00:18:09,781 --> 00:18:13,941 I mean it is a topic that we've had on in different guises 329 00:18:13,941 --> 00:18:20,581 over the years fall targeting or not or should even the kind of 330 00:18:20,581 --> 00:18:23,701 the idea of pure trend versus more diversified systems. 331 00:18:23,941 --> 00:18:26,941 It sounds like from your perspective that you do really have 332 00:18:26,941 --> 00:18:28,741 to solve for investor needs. 333 00:18:29,301 --> 00:18:33,261 More so than shooting for the Maxon Rayrock. 334 00:18:35,181 --> 00:18:36,781 I think it's the only way you can go. 335 00:18:36,781 --> 00:18:41,701 I mean, I've had investors, savvy investors who I remember, I 336 00:18:41,701 --> 00:18:44,181 remember getting a call when they, when they would call and double 337 00:18:44,181 --> 00:18:45,101 the size of their account. 338 00:18:45,981 --> 00:18:49,101 I was almost certain that that was the end of any industry drawdown. 339 00:18:49,101 --> 00:18:51,741 They were so good at it or when they took half off the table 340 00:18:52,701 --> 00:18:56,741 that, you know, essentially it was time that the current party of 341 00:18:56,741 --> 00:18:57,501 the day was over. 342 00:18:58,781 --> 00:19:04,021 There were others that could never find that sense of value in 343 00:19:04,021 --> 00:19:04,621 investing. 344 00:19:06,381 --> 00:19:11,661 It's the usual tragedy of managed money to watch people watch 345 00:19:11,661 --> 00:19:16,381 performance, wait for there to be enough confirmation and confidence, 346 00:19:17,021 --> 00:19:21,341 get in a little bit too late and put themselves on a right shift 347 00:19:21,341 --> 00:19:22,701 of time off cycle. 348 00:19:23,351 --> 00:19:25,511 It doesn't really matter if you're taking outside money. 349 00:19:25,511 --> 00:19:30,071 I still think you just have to do the best job for every single 350 00:19:30,791 --> 00:19:32,311 allocation that you have. 351 00:19:33,111 --> 00:19:37,111 But by no means, I think, can you group them all in the same bucket. 352 00:19:37,111 --> 00:19:41,111 They really, I think, have idiosyncratic and important differences 353 00:19:41,111 --> 00:19:45,391 in their organizations for how they've designed their portfolio, 354 00:19:45,391 --> 00:19:48,951 how they consider your contribution, how they even capitalize 355 00:19:48,951 --> 00:19:49,831 that contribution. 356 00:19:50,371 --> 00:19:54,211 Things that I know you both are very expert at. 357 00:19:54,771 --> 00:19:57,731 Can I, can I jump in here in this particular topic? 358 00:19:57,731 --> 00:20:02,051 Sorry to do that, Alan, but, but here's something interesting 359 00:20:03,411 --> 00:20:09,011 I think we've heard from many industries, and I certainly remember 360 00:20:09,091 --> 00:20:13,171 from conversations that I've had with our colleagues in the industry 361 00:20:14,131 --> 00:20:18,331 that I think people would question that customers or clients 362 00:20:18,331 --> 00:20:24,571 actually know what product is best, if I can define it like that. 363 00:20:25,051 --> 00:20:28,491 And so I think I know what, what, what you're referring to, Pat. 364 00:20:28,491 --> 00:20:31,851 And I think from a purely business perspective, clearly if 365 00:20:31,851 --> 00:20:35,531 you only have products nobody wants to buy, there's no use in that. 366 00:20:36,251 --> 00:20:41,171 On the other hand, I think our industry as trend followers, it's 367 00:20:41,171 --> 00:20:48,111 probably not the most liked investment strategy out there, but 368 00:20:48,111 --> 00:20:49,951 it offers tremendous value. 369 00:20:50,751 --> 00:20:55,871 But I think part of that value actually comes from us doing it the 370 00:20:55,871 --> 00:20:59,391 way we think is the right way to do it. 371 00:20:59,951 --> 00:21:06,351 And then the data will support investors making allocation to it. 372 00:21:07,791 --> 00:21:10,351 So I don't know if I misunderstood what you were saying 373 00:21:10,991 --> 00:21:15,961 on or whether you agree that Certainly if we're just talking about 374 00:21:15,961 --> 00:21:19,121 pure trend, we can get to how you can diversify away from trend 375 00:21:19,121 --> 00:21:19,721 in a second. 376 00:21:19,721 --> 00:21:24,961 But certainly if you think about pure trend, it's probably not 377 00:21:24,961 --> 00:21:28,161 going to have the profile that most investors says, yeah, I love 378 00:21:28,161 --> 00:21:32,481 that shape of the return stream. 379 00:21:33,281 --> 00:21:37,041 But on the other hand, it's an incredibly useful property to have 380 00:21:37,041 --> 00:21:39,551 in, in a traditional portfolio. 381 00:21:39,631 --> 00:21:40,591 Do you know what I mean? 382 00:21:41,231 --> 00:21:45,511 I not only know what you mean, but let me take it a little further 383 00:21:45,511 --> 00:21:46,991 and see if you agree. 384 00:21:48,431 --> 00:21:51,431 When I say there's a moral difference of understanding the client's 385 00:21:51,431 --> 00:21:56,631 goals, I use those words on purpose because what the client exactly 386 00:21:56,631 --> 00:22:00,431 wants isn't necessarily always what their goals are. 387 00:22:01,391 --> 00:22:03,471 And I think there's a listening phase there. 388 00:22:03,951 --> 00:22:07,511 And one of the most pernicious and damaging things I think traders 389 00:22:07,511 --> 00:22:15,111 have done to themselves is to respond to marketing feedback in 390 00:22:15,111 --> 00:22:16,151 the hopes of growing their business. 391 00:22:16,151 --> 00:22:17,711 They end up changing what they do. 392 00:22:18,431 --> 00:22:23,911 And if we rolled back the clock 30 or 40 years, there would 393 00:22:23,911 --> 00:22:26,111 not be 20 page pitch decks. 394 00:22:26,351 --> 00:22:31,241 If you were interviewing a trader, the four seminal questions 395 00:22:31,241 --> 00:22:34,681 were always what's your edge in the marketplace? 396 00:22:35,881 --> 00:22:38,121 How and where are you going to exploit that edge? 397 00:22:39,481 --> 00:22:42,201 What is your risk management or position sizing? 398 00:22:43,001 --> 00:22:46,161 And just when you thought you were done with the interview, the 399 00:22:46,161 --> 00:22:48,921 last question was and how do you protect your tails? 400 00:22:50,121 --> 00:22:51,081 And the minute. 401 00:22:51,801 --> 00:22:53,401 And trend followers have done it. 402 00:22:53,401 --> 00:22:54,521 Hedge funds have done it. 403 00:22:54,601 --> 00:22:56,301 It's, it's pervasive. 404 00:22:56,301 --> 00:22:57,861 Private equity groups have done it. 405 00:22:58,341 --> 00:23:01,421 They get into the marketplace, they hear some feedback and they 406 00:23:01,421 --> 00:23:03,061 start to try to change what they do. 407 00:23:03,621 --> 00:23:06,941 And a trend follower has a very, a pure, I think the way you 408 00:23:06,941 --> 00:23:10,261 use the term, a pure trend follower has a very specific edge 409 00:23:11,141 --> 00:23:12,421 from agnosticism. 410 00:23:13,861 --> 00:23:20,101 And there are nuances along the way, but for the most part the 411 00:23:20,101 --> 00:23:25,611 setup, the signal, the position sizing, the asymmetry of 412 00:23:25,611 --> 00:23:31,811 positions, all of those things rely upon multi asset class, multidirectional 413 00:23:31,811 --> 00:23:32,611 participation. 414 00:23:32,691 --> 00:23:38,491 You get, you offer the client the ability for them as they're invested 415 00:23:38,491 --> 00:23:43,011 in singular asset classes long, you offer them the possibility 416 00:23:43,011 --> 00:23:46,691 as capital moves from one asset class to another, from one 417 00:23:46,691 --> 00:23:49,771 sub asset group to another, from another, from long to short, 418 00:23:49,771 --> 00:23:53,451 from long to flat, from selling one to buying another, which 419 00:23:53,451 --> 00:23:56,851 inherently of course is obviously a synthetic short and long. 420 00:23:56,931 --> 00:24:00,691 You are picking up return as that capital moves over months and 421 00:24:00,851 --> 00:24:01,571 quarters. 422 00:24:02,691 --> 00:24:06,051 It brings the convexity that is so valuable, it brings the skew 423 00:24:06,051 --> 00:24:09,851 that's so valuable, at least on the timeframe of quarterly and 424 00:24:09,851 --> 00:24:13,931 semiannually, which is another discussion of how those terms are 425 00:24:13,931 --> 00:24:18,941 sometimes confused and you know, if there's a reflexivity in 426 00:24:18,941 --> 00:24:24,101 the marketplace in pricing, which is strong, and there is, there's 427 00:24:24,101 --> 00:24:29,861 still a reflexivity in the managed money business of, of managers 428 00:24:29,861 --> 00:24:33,581 conforming to what they think clients need and then clients changing 429 00:24:33,581 --> 00:24:37,301 what they want based on what they think they heard managers evolving 430 00:24:37,301 --> 00:24:37,661 to. 431 00:24:38,701 --> 00:24:42,101 And I think the true north compass needs to always come back. 432 00:24:42,101 --> 00:24:43,141 Is there a market edge? 433 00:24:43,141 --> 00:24:46,941 Because if it starts to drift from that edge, results are just 434 00:24:46,941 --> 00:24:47,621 going to get worse. 435 00:24:48,901 --> 00:24:52,101 Yeah, you mentioned a few S's there. 436 00:24:54,021 --> 00:24:57,461 I think we probably should dive down maybe a little bit further 437 00:24:58,421 --> 00:25:02,901 into those S's, because I think one of the things that I hope 438 00:25:03,941 --> 00:25:09,301 we're going to do today is also to kind of get your take on 439 00:25:09,381 --> 00:25:10,661 the narrative side. 440 00:25:10,661 --> 00:25:14,101 I think this is something we've talked about for years, how 441 00:25:14,741 --> 00:25:20,661 difficult it has been for our industry to really maybe explain 442 00:25:20,661 --> 00:25:24,381 well enough the benefits and so on and so forth. 443 00:25:24,381 --> 00:25:27,581 We know narrative is incredibly important, but maybe we 444 00:25:27,581 --> 00:25:31,501 could just start with the kind of the four S's that you referred 445 00:25:31,501 --> 00:25:33,461 to and take it from there. 446 00:25:34,991 --> 00:25:38,591 Well, you know, the four S's is a helpful. 447 00:25:38,591 --> 00:25:42,831 It's not a complete framework, but it's a helpful starting framework 448 00:25:43,471 --> 00:25:47,311 for anyone who wishes to trade in that. 449 00:25:48,111 --> 00:25:49,471 It's part of the mechanism. 450 00:25:49,951 --> 00:25:52,431 It's not really part of, I think, of a grander narrative. 451 00:25:52,431 --> 00:25:54,991 We probably should park that for a separate question. 452 00:25:56,271 --> 00:26:00,921 But if somebody's trying to set up a successful trading approach, 453 00:26:01,241 --> 00:26:05,081 and it probably works for discretionary, systematic or both, 454 00:26:05,081 --> 00:26:07,881 but let's just confine it to systematic for now. 455 00:26:09,161 --> 00:26:12,041 Normally the four S's would need to be satisfied. 456 00:26:12,041 --> 00:26:14,721 You simply have to ask yourself, what is the setup for your 457 00:26:14,721 --> 00:26:15,241 trades? 458 00:26:15,641 --> 00:26:17,121 Are you trading continuously? 459 00:26:17,121 --> 00:26:20,081 Or is there some form of a setup you're looking for that raises 460 00:26:20,081 --> 00:26:23,601 your probability in a, in a Bayesian sense for when you wish 461 00:26:23,601 --> 00:26:25,001 to, to exploit your edge. 462 00:26:26,181 --> 00:26:28,821 2 2nds, what's your signal? 463 00:26:29,221 --> 00:26:30,301 What makes you get in? 464 00:26:30,301 --> 00:26:31,301 What makes you get out? 465 00:26:32,341 --> 00:26:33,941 Three, what's your sizing? 466 00:26:35,061 --> 00:26:39,341 This is sort of synonymous with risk management, but I'm sizing 467 00:26:39,341 --> 00:26:42,101 now includes forward opportunity and risk. 468 00:26:43,221 --> 00:26:45,221 And then two, what's your symmetry? 469 00:26:46,101 --> 00:26:50,261 Have you entered a trade with an equal window loss, balance, or 470 00:26:50,501 --> 00:26:53,581 have you entered a trade either directly or synthetically, 471 00:26:53,581 --> 00:26:55,421 where you have an asymmetric advantage? 472 00:26:57,341 --> 00:26:59,461 And that's what I really meant by the four S's. 473 00:26:59,461 --> 00:27:03,821 I think those are more of a practice, a discipline of understanding 474 00:27:03,821 --> 00:27:11,061 how to put together a trading system that has well defined steps 475 00:27:11,061 --> 00:27:14,461 and, and there's an infinite number of those solutions perhaps, 476 00:27:15,261 --> 00:27:17,021 but the better defined they are. 477 00:27:17,021 --> 00:27:22,801 And I think if a trader or an investor soul searches their answer 478 00:27:22,801 --> 00:27:26,601 to each one and understands why they're doing it, they will also 479 00:27:27,561 --> 00:27:28,441 stick with it. 480 00:27:29,161 --> 00:27:34,441 Which maybe gets back to another one of the early trading 481 00:27:34,441 --> 00:27:35,321 meetings I had. 482 00:27:35,321 --> 00:27:38,601 I remember when Annette and I drove down the coast. 483 00:27:38,601 --> 00:27:40,641 We lived up in Palo Alto at the time. 484 00:27:40,641 --> 00:27:44,481 We drove down and met John Henry in his early office back then, 485 00:27:44,481 --> 00:27:47,561 back in those days, he was in Newport beach right next to Pimco. 486 00:27:48,781 --> 00:27:51,821 And we had met him once. 487 00:27:51,821 --> 00:27:52,981 Then we met him a second time. 488 00:27:52,981 --> 00:27:56,301 And I still remember him saying something to the effect of 489 00:27:57,341 --> 00:28:01,541 Pat, the difference between our success and other people's is 490 00:28:01,541 --> 00:28:03,021 that we actually follow our system. 491 00:28:04,781 --> 00:28:10,101 And then the other thing I remember him saying was that we could 492 00:28:10,101 --> 00:28:14,191 print our system on a billboard on Highway 101 and not 493 00:28:14,191 --> 00:28:16,751 have to worry about anything because no one will ever follow it 494 00:28:16,751 --> 00:28:19,351 because it's not theirs and they'll have no confidence in it. 495 00:28:21,271 --> 00:28:24,831 Which really means you have to, you know, the trader or the investor 496 00:28:24,831 --> 00:28:28,231 and the methodology, they have to pair themselves with a degree 497 00:28:28,231 --> 00:28:31,391 of confidence or there's really no way to exploit that edge 498 00:28:31,391 --> 00:28:31,911 through time. 499 00:28:32,071 --> 00:28:35,991 They can't navigate the seas when they're rough or even when they're 500 00:28:35,991 --> 00:28:36,391 calm. 501 00:28:37,831 --> 00:28:39,351 But the four S's help there. 502 00:28:39,741 --> 00:28:40,661 I don't think it sells. 503 00:28:40,661 --> 00:28:41,501 The narrative, though. 504 00:28:42,701 --> 00:28:44,941 There is a. I think there's a little hook in the narrative part 505 00:28:44,941 --> 00:28:49,021 because there are a lot of managers and a lot of analysts for 506 00:28:49,021 --> 00:28:53,821 allocators who dive into the mechanism almost right away. 507 00:28:54,781 --> 00:28:57,421 But because it's, I think, a relatively. 508 00:29:00,941 --> 00:29:05,021 It's both unemotional and unattached to any rationale for success. 509 00:29:05,101 --> 00:29:07,181 It's more just facts and not reasonable. 510 00:29:07,491 --> 00:29:12,051 I don't think over time, there's been very many compelling 511 00:29:12,371 --> 00:29:18,771 matches between an investor and a manager based strictly on what 512 00:29:18,771 --> 00:29:24,411 do I do every single day, what math do I invoke, what formulas do 513 00:29:24,411 --> 00:29:24,931 I use. 514 00:29:26,611 --> 00:29:30,851 I think for the most part, they're either unappreciated, unmoved, 515 00:29:30,851 --> 00:29:31,891 or quickly forgotten. 516 00:29:37,441 --> 00:29:41,161 I want to bring Alan in in a second here because I also think 517 00:29:41,161 --> 00:29:43,961 it's relevant to talk maybe about regime shift and so on and 518 00:29:43,961 --> 00:29:44,401 so forth. 519 00:29:44,401 --> 00:29:47,601 But just staying on this topic for a little bit longer. 520 00:29:49,361 --> 00:29:51,400 You describe the four S's. 521 00:29:51,400 --> 00:29:52,001 There are a lot. 522 00:29:52,001 --> 00:29:52,361 There's. 523 00:29:52,361 --> 00:29:53,521 There's more to it. 524 00:29:54,721 --> 00:29:59,321 And then you also talked about, well, if it's not kind of 525 00:29:59,321 --> 00:30:02,121 your system, people probably wouldn't do it if you. 526 00:30:02,121 --> 00:30:03,601 Even if you told them the rules. 527 00:30:03,921 --> 00:30:08,821 Now, this is a bit of a stretch and I might get into trouble 528 00:30:08,821 --> 00:30:11,421 with some People that we know. 529 00:30:11,421 --> 00:30:20,061 Well, when I say replication comes to mind in a sense that, well, 530 00:30:20,300 --> 00:30:22,861 they probably solved the narrative, let's start there. 531 00:30:22,941 --> 00:30:27,341 But it's not really their system because they are not using 532 00:30:27,341 --> 00:30:29,421 the underlying rules. 533 00:30:30,631 --> 00:30:35,831 However, some of them at least have been pretty good at mimicking 534 00:30:36,951 --> 00:30:42,311 the returns, depending on how you define that, of course, or at 535 00:30:42,311 --> 00:30:44,791 least the correlation maybe they've been able to mimic. 536 00:30:46,871 --> 00:30:52,071 So I'm curious about your thoughts on replication. 537 00:30:54,471 --> 00:30:59,211 Well, I think I would separate replication from the mechanism of 538 00:30:59,211 --> 00:31:03,251 replicating and versus the productizing of replication. 539 00:31:05,571 --> 00:31:12,571 I think one of those is a, is a valid mathematical way of formulating 540 00:31:12,571 --> 00:31:15,771 a systematic approach and it's something that almost every trader 541 00:31:15,771 --> 00:31:17,171 does one way or another. 542 00:31:19,091 --> 00:31:24,621 Even a trend follower, for instance, does not trade primary 543 00:31:24,621 --> 00:31:29,541 cash bonds or primary cash commodities mano a mano with other 544 00:31:29,541 --> 00:31:33,381 counterparties when they're really waiting for price, smoothing 545 00:31:33,381 --> 00:31:37,981 price and deciding some formulaic way of deciding whether 546 00:31:37,981 --> 00:31:42,501 to say there's an uptrend or a downtrend that's really replicating 547 00:31:42,501 --> 00:31:45,021 the actions of others through the reflection of the information 548 00:31:45,181 --> 00:31:48,181 of the price signal, which is then typically smoothed and brought 549 00:31:48,181 --> 00:31:48,461 in. 550 00:31:48,951 --> 00:31:51,791 There's not much of a different step to then say the P 551 00:31:51,791 --> 00:31:56,511 and L of another trader is now just a price signal that then is 552 00:31:56,511 --> 00:32:01,431 used to replicate, usually by some form of regression technique 553 00:32:02,551 --> 00:32:05,791 where it's done and it's been done in many, many areas. 554 00:32:05,791 --> 00:32:09,431 I mean I, I don't think any of your sophisticated audience would, 555 00:32:10,471 --> 00:32:14,551 would be surprised to learn that AN S&P 500 Index Fund doesn't 556 00:32:14,551 --> 00:32:19,421 have to own all 500 stocks at any given point in time to replicate 557 00:32:19,421 --> 00:32:20,701 the S&P 500. 558 00:32:21,741 --> 00:32:24,741 So I just separate that because we've actually done some 559 00:32:24,741 --> 00:32:28,861 very specific work to replicate some of the replicators, 560 00:32:29,581 --> 00:32:31,021 mainly to ask our own questions. 561 00:32:31,021 --> 00:32:35,861 We wanted to see what are some of the reduced minimal market set 562 00:32:35,861 --> 00:32:39,021 sizes that replicate say the trend following industry. 563 00:32:40,061 --> 00:32:43,661 Is it similar, for instance, in some of the popular ETFs that 564 00:32:43,661 --> 00:32:44,101 are used? 565 00:32:45,061 --> 00:32:47,661 Some of those ETFs have changed their market set over times. 566 00:32:47,661 --> 00:32:50,661 If they hadn't, would there have been much of a change? 567 00:32:51,461 --> 00:32:52,661 There would not have been. 568 00:32:52,661 --> 00:32:56,941 By the way, if we do replicate the replicators, we actually end 569 00:32:56,941 --> 00:32:57,861 up with better performance. 570 00:32:58,341 --> 00:33:01,501 But that's probably not too surprising because we end up with 571 00:33:01,501 --> 00:33:05,181 a little better smoothing coefficient and we have probably 572 00:33:05,181 --> 00:33:08,981 end up with less churn for rebalances at the end of the day. 573 00:33:08,981 --> 00:33:13,521 And, and if it were fully funded, you'd have probably lower 574 00:33:13,521 --> 00:33:14,761 fees and better cash management. 575 00:33:15,321 --> 00:33:19,241 So if an institution wants to do $500 million. 576 00:33:19,241 --> 00:33:22,001 They don't necessarily have to go into a retail product and they 577 00:33:22,001 --> 00:33:23,481 could get the same idea. 578 00:33:24,441 --> 00:33:28,081 The other part of replication, of course, is sort of the less savory 579 00:33:28,081 --> 00:33:28,441 part. 580 00:33:29,161 --> 00:33:30,681 It's the narrative story. 581 00:33:31,241 --> 00:33:32,921 It's the hero's journey, if you will. 582 00:33:33,561 --> 00:33:38,721 Somebody has to come along and you know, solve the problem. 583 00:33:38,961 --> 00:33:43,801 You know, the, the rapacious managers are charging too much money, 584 00:33:43,801 --> 00:33:46,721 they're too opaque and we're going to beat them at their own game 585 00:33:46,721 --> 00:33:50,561 and we're going to sell this much lower, et cetera, et cetera. 586 00:33:50,721 --> 00:33:53,921 And you know, it certainly worked for Jack Bogle. 587 00:33:54,161 --> 00:33:55,601 He wasn't in the hedge fund world. 588 00:33:55,601 --> 00:33:57,601 He was trying to give consumers a better deal. 589 00:33:58,961 --> 00:34:01,481 It starts to stretch though, as you get more and more into the 590 00:34:01,481 --> 00:34:03,201 very, very active ETFs. 591 00:34:04,411 --> 00:34:09,611 At some point that gets to be a fuzzy margin of extracting cost, 592 00:34:10,091 --> 00:34:13,771 which is clearly true when you have a three or five basis point 593 00:34:13,771 --> 00:34:18,651 product or whether or not you're simply trying to carve another 594 00:34:18,651 --> 00:34:24,411 narrative niche out and finding a sensitivity point. 595 00:34:24,971 --> 00:34:30,420 And some allocators, the overall cost or the manager selection 596 00:34:30,420 --> 00:34:34,260 risk, those are two failure points for some of the professional 597 00:34:34,260 --> 00:34:36,540 allocation stabs that exist in the world. 598 00:34:36,540 --> 00:34:39,420 So solving for those two would definitely appeal to a large number 599 00:34:39,420 --> 00:34:39,860 of people. 600 00:34:40,660 --> 00:34:44,660 Sure, Alan, sorry I hijacked the conversation there. 601 00:34:45,140 --> 00:34:50,140 Yeah, I'm just curious, you know, you've obviously been in the 602 00:34:50,140 --> 00:34:53,940 markets many years and you know, you've started off trading 603 00:34:53,940 --> 00:34:56,620 in college, I think you said, and you know, then had a big focus 604 00:34:56,620 --> 00:34:59,340 on trend following the Hunt Brothers silver. 605 00:34:59,340 --> 00:35:00,620 Trade, my first trade. 606 00:35:00,860 --> 00:35:02,540 Okay, so here you go. 607 00:35:03,580 --> 00:35:07,300 But you've, you've, you've had programs in kind of quant macro type 608 00:35:07,300 --> 00:35:10,220 program, short term equity. 609 00:35:10,620 --> 00:35:15,140 You know, I'm just curious where your philosophy around markets 610 00:35:15,140 --> 00:35:17,100 and investing came from. 611 00:35:17,100 --> 00:35:21,620 Was it an observation on behavior or just an observation on 612 00:35:21,620 --> 00:35:25,811 what works or something that has just evolved the markets and 613 00:35:26,131 --> 00:35:29,211 what underpins that to give you confidence that these types of 614 00:35:29,211 --> 00:35:31,811 strategies will continue to work going forward? 615 00:35:33,171 --> 00:35:38,411 Yeah, I think that goes back to Niall's question of if we were 616 00:35:38,411 --> 00:35:42,491 to want to improve our narrative, at least for some classes 617 00:35:42,491 --> 00:35:47,971 of investors, would we stay with the true statement that trends 618 00:35:47,971 --> 00:35:52,751 are behavioral, but then be willing to defend the fact that the 619 00:35:52,751 --> 00:35:56,751 non trending periods are also behavioral and the periods of high 620 00:35:56,751 --> 00:35:59,191 liquidity are behavioral and the periods of low liquidity are 621 00:35:59,191 --> 00:36:02,871 behavioral because the markets are the sum of the participant behaviors. 622 00:36:03,511 --> 00:36:04,231 All true. 623 00:36:05,671 --> 00:36:10,111 I think sometimes those kinds of explanations just simply aren't 624 00:36:10,111 --> 00:36:15,751 enough for the types of people who are listening who either if they've 625 00:36:15,751 --> 00:36:19,661 had sort of CFA and securities training, they're listening one way. 626 00:36:20,221 --> 00:36:24,541 If they've been entrepreneurs or it's family office wealth, they're 627 00:36:24,541 --> 00:36:26,141 listening from a different point of view. 628 00:36:27,741 --> 00:36:30,421 Perhaps if they've had technical or engineering type backgrounds, 629 00:36:30,421 --> 00:36:32,221 they're listening from yet another point of view. 630 00:36:33,101 --> 00:36:39,661 And I think that it took 10 or 20 years of a lot of disciplined 631 00:36:39,661 --> 00:36:44,781 work and especially as we began trading for individual clients, 632 00:36:44,861 --> 00:36:46,341 a volatility arb program. 633 00:36:46,341 --> 00:36:49,891 We traded a stat arb program, thousands of trades per day. 634 00:36:49,891 --> 00:36:52,211 For a while we've traded trend following. 635 00:36:53,411 --> 00:37:00,771 Really to come back and say, I think the best narrative after some 636 00:37:00,771 --> 00:37:04,691 form of a story, of a character overcoming a challenge, 637 00:37:05,971 --> 00:37:07,171 that's the thin layer. 638 00:37:07,251 --> 00:37:09,971 The next layer I think comes with, can you really tell me where 639 00:37:09,971 --> 00:37:11,411 the returns source from? 640 00:37:12,051 --> 00:37:13,491 I'm a student of the markets. 641 00:37:13,821 --> 00:37:15,141 Where do these returns come from? 642 00:37:15,141 --> 00:37:16,461 And I think from trend following. 643 00:37:17,821 --> 00:37:23,181 We've been quite successful decomposing trend returns into true 644 00:37:23,181 --> 00:37:23,781 counterparts. 645 00:37:23,781 --> 00:37:25,421 I think that there are four. 646 00:37:26,941 --> 00:37:30,501 If we stick truly with trend following, which I'm going to define 647 00:37:30,501 --> 00:37:35,261 now, says holding positions through time for a profit. 648 00:37:35,501 --> 00:37:37,661 I didn't say long or short, I didn't say one. 649 00:37:37,741 --> 00:37:41,761 I just said holding positions through time with one more feature, 650 00:37:42,481 --> 00:37:45,761 some form of buying strength and selling weakness. 651 00:37:45,761 --> 00:37:47,601 That's what the following part means. 652 00:37:48,001 --> 00:37:49,121 We're not predicting. 653 00:37:50,401 --> 00:37:54,801 I think one can decompose returns into the components of economic 654 00:37:54,961 --> 00:38:02,561 trend, into financial carry, into information diffusion and then 655 00:38:02,561 --> 00:38:07,581 into some form of reflexivity in a Sorosian term or in an academic 656 00:38:07,581 --> 00:38:09,261 term, or just a feedback loop. 657 00:38:09,261 --> 00:38:10,501 Buying begets buying. 658 00:38:12,261 --> 00:38:16,341 Each of those, it's different powers in different sectors. 659 00:38:16,981 --> 00:38:19,381 They have different time frames and clocks. 660 00:38:19,861 --> 00:38:24,101 And when I talk to investors and they need a natural metaphor, 661 00:38:24,421 --> 00:38:27,061 it's not a stretch for them to say, look, if you had a boat in the 662 00:38:27,061 --> 00:38:28,981 ocean, there isn't one source. 663 00:38:29,941 --> 00:38:32,021 The boat will move because it's in a current. 664 00:38:33,261 --> 00:38:35,421 The boat will also move because it's in a tide. 665 00:38:36,061 --> 00:38:38,541 The boat will move because a wind is applied to it. 666 00:38:38,941 --> 00:38:41,581 A boat may also move because someone starts an engine. 667 00:38:42,141 --> 00:38:44,061 Now all those could all be in the same direction. 668 00:38:44,061 --> 00:38:45,581 They could be in the opposite direction. 669 00:38:45,661 --> 00:38:48,541 You could have a positive economic carry, for instance, in 670 00:38:49,421 --> 00:38:54,341 equity indices, which is extremely strong, but have face for 671 00:38:54,341 --> 00:38:57,661 the most of the time a negative financial carry and still 672 00:38:57,661 --> 00:39:03,531 come out of head in something that has very little influence of 673 00:39:03,531 --> 00:39:06,571 a long term economic carry, but a strong financial carry. 674 00:39:06,571 --> 00:39:09,891 One could look at say roll premium and fixed income contracts. 675 00:39:11,171 --> 00:39:15,691 If one does a pretty careful decomposition of trend, one will 676 00:39:15,691 --> 00:39:19,771 find that the majority, and in some cases the vast majority of returns 677 00:39:19,771 --> 00:39:24,371 will be accumulated term structure, premium, not so true in 678 00:39:25,091 --> 00:39:25,811 other markets. 679 00:39:26,371 --> 00:39:31,931 But those four components, I think way beyond the scope of our 680 00:39:31,931 --> 00:39:32,931 one hour podcast. 681 00:39:33,491 --> 00:39:37,491 We could spend entire times decomposing returns and showing those 682 00:39:37,491 --> 00:39:41,131 return decompositions and why a trend follower picks them up and 683 00:39:41,131 --> 00:39:43,371 why a trend follower picks them up agnostically. 684 00:39:43,371 --> 00:39:47,411 Because they do flex, they do change, and they can have unexpected 685 00:39:47,491 --> 00:39:48,371 directionality. 686 00:39:50,301 --> 00:39:53,261 There's a great story of 2013. 687 00:39:53,421 --> 00:39:59,101 I remember 2013 is not unlike a little bit today in that everyone, 688 00:39:59,501 --> 00:40:05,141 everyone was writing how much bonds will go up and how much interest 689 00:40:05,141 --> 00:40:06,061 rates will go up. 690 00:40:06,781 --> 00:40:10,061 And to get ready and of course what happened in 2014? 691 00:40:11,181 --> 00:40:15,181 Interest rates went down the entire year and Trend followers made 692 00:40:15,181 --> 00:40:19,561 20 or 30% and almost everybody else missed on their predictions, 693 00:40:19,561 --> 00:40:22,561 but they were still happy because if they own bonds, they went 694 00:40:22,561 --> 00:40:22,841 up. 695 00:40:23,641 --> 00:40:29,321 So trend following has a very powerful meta cognition of all these 696 00:40:29,321 --> 00:40:29,841 returns. 697 00:40:29,841 --> 00:40:32,121 But I think if you're trying to explain it and the person has 698 00:40:32,121 --> 00:40:35,641 an economics or investment background, showing the return attributions 699 00:40:35,641 --> 00:40:38,841 plainly that they could even derive on their own, or they can 700 00:40:38,841 --> 00:40:42,201 see how they are derived independently from the opinion of 701 00:40:42,201 --> 00:40:42,841 the trader. 702 00:40:44,291 --> 00:40:48,491 I've seen light bulbs go off in people's head like why didn't 703 00:40:48,491 --> 00:40:50,291 somebody just show me this years ago? 704 00:40:51,171 --> 00:40:52,051 Now I get it. 705 00:40:53,251 --> 00:40:54,091 And they get everything. 706 00:40:54,091 --> 00:40:56,971 They get why the correlation is zero, they get why it's positively 707 00:40:56,971 --> 00:40:57,491 convex. 708 00:40:58,611 --> 00:41:01,491 All kinds of things happen positively. 709 00:41:03,091 --> 00:41:06,131 And that kind of high level justification, you think that's the 710 00:41:06,131 --> 00:41:07,891 same to different degrees. 711 00:41:07,891 --> 00:41:10,451 I mean, maybe you might weigh those four factors differently for 712 00:41:11,131 --> 00:41:14,811 say short term trend following or systematic macro signals. 713 00:41:16,091 --> 00:41:18,331 I think the answer is true in both cases. 714 00:41:18,571 --> 00:41:24,411 So almost by definition something that is some form of a 715 00:41:24,411 --> 00:41:30,211 carry, like an economic carry or a financial carry, I'm essentially 716 00:41:30,211 --> 00:41:33,131 saying something that those positions benefit by time. 717 00:41:33,451 --> 00:41:35,931 Your ownership through time is what accrues profits. 718 00:41:36,421 --> 00:41:39,301 So if I make something short term, I'm essentially taking those 719 00:41:39,301 --> 00:41:40,181 out of the equation. 720 00:41:41,461 --> 00:41:42,861 Back to a water analogy. 721 00:41:42,861 --> 00:41:45,701 If I'm, if I'm, if I'm swimming downstream in a river, I 722 00:41:45,701 --> 00:41:48,981 can swim faster with the carry than I'm swimming upstream against 723 00:41:48,981 --> 00:41:49,621 the carry. 724 00:41:51,061 --> 00:41:53,781 That will matter if I'm swimming for 20 hours. 725 00:41:53,781 --> 00:41:56,421 If I'm swimming for three seconds, the carry doesn't matter 726 00:41:56,421 --> 00:41:56,981 very much. 727 00:41:58,181 --> 00:42:04,061 So short term definitely spends more time not only in the 728 00:42:04,061 --> 00:42:07,441 information diffusion and reflexivity, but it also begins to 729 00:42:07,441 --> 00:42:10,961 pick up other terms I didn't include in trend following because 730 00:42:11,601 --> 00:42:16,641 the impact of flows, accelerating flows, periodic flows, 731 00:42:16,881 --> 00:42:23,161 rebalancing flows, these Kinds of, these kinds of more market mechanistic 732 00:42:23,161 --> 00:42:28,321 I think are far more useful in the time frames of say less than 733 00:42:28,321 --> 00:42:29,601 10 day holding periods. 734 00:42:29,921 --> 00:42:33,081 As a matter of fact, there have been very few instances except 735 00:42:33,081 --> 00:42:38,851 for very large contracts, large dollar volatility of the contracts, 736 00:42:39,571 --> 00:42:43,411 oftentimes with large point values in those contracts where you 737 00:42:43,411 --> 00:42:48,651 can parameterize any type of a traditional trend following mechanistic 738 00:42:48,651 --> 00:42:53,371 approach and make money with very short term holding periods. 739 00:42:53,371 --> 00:42:55,091 Three days, four days, five days. 740 00:42:56,611 --> 00:43:00,661 Even in academic studies when they look at short term trend following, 741 00:43:00,661 --> 00:43:05,541 usually the holding periods are closer to a month on average. 742 00:43:06,741 --> 00:43:09,741 There's just a very narrow window where by the time you buy 743 00:43:09,741 --> 00:43:12,861 strength and sell weakness, what's left in the middle is your 744 00:43:12,861 --> 00:43:13,861 potential profit. 745 00:43:14,021 --> 00:43:18,501 And if you're only in the market for three days or six or five, 746 00:43:19,381 --> 00:43:20,901 other techniques work better. 747 00:43:21,621 --> 00:43:28,061 And, and we've learned that and experienced that, but we've also 748 00:43:28,141 --> 00:43:29,421 focused a lot on it. 749 00:43:29,741 --> 00:43:31,581 We love trend following, it works. 750 00:43:33,181 --> 00:43:37,341 We love macro systematic macro trading because it works. 751 00:43:37,581 --> 00:43:42,741 And what I mean by that in this case definitionally is a full 752 00:43:42,741 --> 00:43:44,621 separation trend uses price. 753 00:43:44,621 --> 00:43:49,581 The macro trading uses only cross asset signals, fundamental 754 00:43:49,581 --> 00:43:54,771 signals, government reports, alternative data, the short term 755 00:43:54,771 --> 00:43:59,011 data, the short term models are all principally focused on flows 756 00:43:59,011 --> 00:44:02,491 with holding periods far less than 10 days typically. 757 00:44:04,331 --> 00:44:08,091 And in our particular firm we also would include things like relative 758 00:44:08,091 --> 00:44:12,331 value trading where we are very specifically trying to create 759 00:44:12,731 --> 00:44:16,651 neutralized baskets that are really helpful to our main portfolio, 760 00:44:16,651 --> 00:44:20,491 a main portfolio and macro or in managed futures some will pick 761 00:44:20,491 --> 00:44:25,531 up large scale thematic risks, direction of U.S. interest rates, 762 00:44:25,531 --> 00:44:27,931 direction of U.S. equities, direction of energies. 763 00:44:28,731 --> 00:44:31,491 And there's a natural construction where you can build 764 00:44:31,491 --> 00:44:34,971 say a dollar neutral currency basket. 765 00:44:34,971 --> 00:44:37,171 Now you're not stacking on top of your dollar risk. 766 00:44:37,171 --> 00:44:41,891 You can pick a, a rate neutral interest rate basket and you're not 767 00:44:41,891 --> 00:44:45,331 stacking on your DVO1 or commodity neutral basket. 768 00:44:45,331 --> 00:44:48,541 And you're not just landing on top of broad based. 769 00:44:49,021 --> 00:44:54,061 So that adds diversification and I guess as long as I'm actually 770 00:44:54,141 --> 00:44:54,821 addressing it. 771 00:44:54,821 --> 00:44:58,301 The fifth thing that we do in our multi strategy is a dedicated 772 00:44:58,781 --> 00:45:02,981 risk off sleeve which is only designed to sell equities. 773 00:45:02,981 --> 00:45:07,741 When there's a rapid rise in flow data that shows us to have hedging 774 00:45:07,741 --> 00:45:09,101 and mispricing activities. 775 00:45:11,261 --> 00:45:16,551 When people are willing as an edge to give us money to neutralize 776 00:45:16,551 --> 00:45:20,151 the risk, our edge rises and it helps our clients. 777 00:45:23,782 --> 00:45:28,022 Now Pat, you mentioned yourself there the word multistrad. 778 00:45:28,742 --> 00:45:35,582 And of course we can see the rise of multi strategy funds in the 779 00:45:35,582 --> 00:45:41,752 past, call it 20 years, maybe even shorter than that and I was 780 00:45:41,752 --> 00:45:45,792 wondering because obviously my personal bias is trend following. 781 00:45:47,472 --> 00:45:49,632 Have you noticed? 782 00:45:49,872 --> 00:45:54,872 And I guess maybe it goes into some of the great work that Alan 783 00:45:54,872 --> 00:45:57,312 has been talking about in terms of regimes. 784 00:45:57,312 --> 00:46:04,792 But do you think that multi strat funds at large and how they 785 00:46:04,792 --> 00:46:08,842 trade, and I'm not an expert in that, but it's not trend following, 786 00:46:09,082 --> 00:46:10,362 at least not all of it. 787 00:46:11,322 --> 00:46:17,642 Do you think that that has had an impact on, let's call it microstructure 788 00:46:18,762 --> 00:46:26,402 in some ways that is reflected on trend following or does trend 789 00:46:26,402 --> 00:46:31,682 following actually by being adaptive in itself kind of find ways 790 00:46:31,682 --> 00:46:35,312 to compensate for it even though for short periods of time 791 00:46:36,192 --> 00:46:37,392 it may get affected? 792 00:46:37,952 --> 00:46:38,992 How do you see that? 793 00:46:39,872 --> 00:46:45,512 Yeah, this is the kind of subject matter that forms the basis 794 00:46:45,512 --> 00:46:46,872 of financial journalism. 795 00:46:46,872 --> 00:46:50,432 And then when one wants to really dive into it, it's harder 796 00:46:50,432 --> 00:46:53,392 to substantiate the information. 797 00:46:53,472 --> 00:46:53,912 I think. 798 00:46:53,912 --> 00:46:55,552 What do I think of multi strats? 799 00:46:56,032 --> 00:46:58,752 I think for the right clients they're a wonderful idea. 800 00:46:58,992 --> 00:47:03,792 I think many clients don't, don't have the skill or the time 801 00:47:03,792 --> 00:47:09,392 or the budget yet they have the desire to have a real alternative 802 00:47:09,392 --> 00:47:14,552 allocation and a vigorous sort of multi strategy product providers 803 00:47:14,552 --> 00:47:19,992 are there to provide it for good or for bad, expensive or cheap. 804 00:47:21,272 --> 00:47:25,392 We're not really in that realm because we now only focus on futures 805 00:47:25,392 --> 00:47:26,232 and foreign exchange. 806 00:47:26,232 --> 00:47:30,232 So in our multi strategy approach is still at the more macro 807 00:47:30,232 --> 00:47:31,872 and individual derivative level. 808 00:47:31,872 --> 00:47:38,112 But I would say that's bullish for investors overall because I think 809 00:47:38,112 --> 00:47:41,872 all investors, if we looked at $100 trillion in allocatable capital 810 00:47:41,872 --> 00:47:46,112 around the world are massively under allocated to alternatives, 811 00:47:46,112 --> 00:47:46,592 not over. 812 00:47:46,992 --> 00:47:49,712 So that's going on. 813 00:47:49,712 --> 00:47:50,752 Sorry to interrupt here, Pat. 814 00:47:50,752 --> 00:47:51,632 Sorry to interrupt. 815 00:47:51,632 --> 00:47:53,152 My question was a little bit different. 816 00:47:53,232 --> 00:47:58,522 I think I was looking for, with your experience, the way you 817 00:47:58,522 --> 00:48:02,602 look at say being a trend follower for part of what you do, 818 00:48:03,242 --> 00:48:08,202 whether you think the size of these funds and the way they trade 819 00:48:09,562 --> 00:48:14,082 has actually made it more difficult to be a trend follower. 820 00:48:14,082 --> 00:48:14,522 Meaning. 821 00:48:15,722 --> 00:48:16,122 No. 822 00:48:16,602 --> 00:48:17,162 Okay. 823 00:48:17,162 --> 00:48:18,042 No, not at all. 824 00:48:18,282 --> 00:48:23,502 I think the majority of hedge or of trend following returns are 825 00:48:23,582 --> 00:48:28,462 have been driven by accumulated economic and financial 826 00:48:28,542 --> 00:48:32,302 carries and information diffusion over months, if not semi 827 00:48:32,302 --> 00:48:34,062 annual to years. 828 00:48:35,742 --> 00:48:40,502 None of which is definitely affected when you go into a ZIRP 829 00:48:40,502 --> 00:48:40,782 environment. 830 00:48:40,862 --> 00:48:45,102 It's definitely affected when spreads from in G7 environments all 831 00:48:45,102 --> 00:48:47,422 become extremely narrow and there's virtually no difference. 832 00:48:47,822 --> 00:48:50,062 These are massive differences for trend following. 833 00:48:50,792 --> 00:48:52,552 Yeah, not the type of trading. 834 00:48:53,192 --> 00:48:57,272 I think a lot of the trading at the high leverage, shorter term, 835 00:48:57,272 --> 00:49:02,472 more arbitrage level is more in the concave surfaces of Markets 836 00:49:03,352 --> 00:49:07,112 that exist not just at the microstructure, which might be more 837 00:49:08,312 --> 00:49:12,552 market making, high frequency or the medium microstructure like 838 00:49:12,552 --> 00:49:13,672 say stat arb. 839 00:49:15,112 --> 00:49:19,022 If anything, for most trend followers it's either not seen or 840 00:49:19,022 --> 00:49:21,222 it may even be providing a liquidity pool. 841 00:49:22,902 --> 00:49:23,382 True. 842 00:49:23,862 --> 00:49:28,662 Now before Alan jumps in, just one other thing. 843 00:49:28,662 --> 00:49:35,142 And of course I know you sense my distinct bias for trend following 844 00:49:35,382 --> 00:49:40,102 here, but I'm curious again, is there something you have heard 845 00:49:41,062 --> 00:49:47,032 being said about trend following that you really, I mean, 846 00:49:47,032 --> 00:49:50,392 what's the thing you disagree with the most when people kind of 847 00:49:50,872 --> 00:49:53,352 describe trend following? 848 00:49:54,792 --> 00:49:55,432 Oh boy. 849 00:49:55,432 --> 00:49:58,232 I'd love to give a clean answer, but I think it'll, it's, 850 00:49:58,232 --> 00:50:03,312 I'll be a slightly nuanced answer because it depends who's providing 851 00:50:03,312 --> 00:50:04,232 the criticism. 852 00:50:04,792 --> 00:50:09,032 Okay, so for instance, you know, I served wonderful with this, 853 00:50:09,032 --> 00:50:09,872 a wonderful man. 854 00:50:09,872 --> 00:50:12,312 So I served on a board with Bill Sharp for many years. 855 00:50:13,362 --> 00:50:17,042 And someone like Bill Sharpe, he wouldn't necessarily have had 856 00:50:17,042 --> 00:50:18,722 a criticism of trend following. 857 00:50:19,522 --> 00:50:22,642 It would have been more like why bother? 858 00:50:23,682 --> 00:50:26,562 If you're going to invest for 20 years, you're going to invest 859 00:50:26,562 --> 00:50:30,642 in broad assets, own everything in the right proportion 860 00:50:30,642 --> 00:50:34,562 with the right growth because everything else at some point is 861 00:50:34,562 --> 00:50:35,042 noise. 862 00:50:36,802 --> 00:50:39,852 And that's simplified answer. 863 00:50:39,852 --> 00:50:41,052 That's not even a criticism. 864 00:50:43,292 --> 00:50:45,012 But that doesn't reflect the reality. 865 00:50:45,012 --> 00:50:49,932 As you know, if you go meet the allocation staff of a pension 866 00:50:49,932 --> 00:50:53,732 fund, if you go to a family office, if you, if you're on the 867 00:50:53,732 --> 00:50:58,572 other side of an endowment and their consultant has them in a particular 868 00:50:58,652 --> 00:51:02,572 allocation and somebody does a Monte Carlo analysis say on their 869 00:51:03,132 --> 00:51:07,572 pension assets and they find out that a, that a two sigma move 870 00:51:07,572 --> 00:51:13,612 on their pension plan might throw a $400 million liability onto 871 00:51:13,612 --> 00:51:18,452 a company that's got 60 million in P and L and earnings and 872 00:51:19,092 --> 00:51:19,972 their head explodes. 873 00:51:19,972 --> 00:51:24,692 They need to have a better allocation strategically and one 874 00:51:24,692 --> 00:51:27,172 that can cover tail exposures better. 875 00:51:27,492 --> 00:51:32,832 And I think then when you get to people who are living in a world 876 00:51:32,912 --> 00:51:39,152 where very adverse moves that occur over quarters or years matter 877 00:51:39,152 --> 00:51:43,912 to them, trend following becomes this invaluable tool if they 878 00:51:43,912 --> 00:51:50,472 use it right again, how one allocates capital to it, what's the 879 00:51:50,472 --> 00:51:51,952 opportunity cost to that capital? 880 00:51:52,352 --> 00:51:54,632 Is it for instance, more like portable alpha? 881 00:51:54,632 --> 00:51:56,992 Is it fully allocated to at what volatility? 882 00:51:56,992 --> 00:52:00,512 These become all these mechanistic questions, but I don't 883 00:52:00,512 --> 00:52:02,112 think those criticisms are there. 884 00:52:02,832 --> 00:52:06,712 The one criticism that not criticism but the one I remember 885 00:52:06,712 --> 00:52:10,832 I faced, it was again one of the popular financial press narratives. 886 00:52:12,112 --> 00:52:14,672 I was giving a speech, I think at Pension Bridge. 887 00:52:15,152 --> 00:52:18,992 I'm not even sure if it was the same year I was on a panel with 888 00:52:19,072 --> 00:52:24,472 Katie Kaminsky, who is just such a wonderful joy and a bulient 889 00:52:24,472 --> 00:52:26,512 mind to be on a panel with. 890 00:52:26,512 --> 00:52:29,232 But it was one of those things where somebody in the audience asked 891 00:52:29,232 --> 00:52:34,152 me a question and they at the time it was are trend followers too 892 00:52:34,152 --> 00:52:34,392 big? 893 00:52:34,392 --> 00:52:35,792 Is there a capacity problem? 894 00:52:37,072 --> 00:52:39,832 And I said, well, I'd like to just. 895 00:52:39,832 --> 00:52:43,312 I do this a lot with my graduate students and postdocs. 896 00:52:43,312 --> 00:52:46,152 Let's try a thought experiment and then we'll all decide at the 897 00:52:46,152 --> 00:52:46,432 end. 898 00:52:47,232 --> 00:52:51,362 I said, what if before speaking here, I had gone to the 899 00:52:51,362 --> 00:52:54,922 private equity shops up in Embarcadero and others and I had 900 00:52:54,922 --> 00:53:00,002 arranged financing to do a roll up of all the Trend followers 901 00:53:00,002 --> 00:53:05,562 and CTAs that I could and I had billions of dollars to buy their 902 00:53:05,562 --> 00:53:09,922 businesses and I went around because I know them and called them 903 00:53:09,922 --> 00:53:14,362 and made them offers and the vast majority accepted and I now 904 00:53:14,362 --> 00:53:18,922 own 200 of the $250 billion worth of capacity. 905 00:53:18,922 --> 00:53:25,222 I bought them all and I specifically did so with no consolidation, 906 00:53:26,582 --> 00:53:27,902 no operational nothing. 907 00:53:27,902 --> 00:53:30,502 I said, please do what you're doing, you're good at it. 908 00:53:31,702 --> 00:53:35,302 I'd be a single Trend follower with $200 billion under management 909 00:53:35,861 --> 00:53:38,662 and my performance would be exactly the same than if I didn't. 910 00:53:40,662 --> 00:53:43,462 This whole narrative that a trend follower can get too big and 911 00:53:43,462 --> 00:53:44,902 somehow the returns will go away. 912 00:53:45,302 --> 00:53:49,822 No, not if they compensate for it by same thought experiment. 913 00:53:49,822 --> 00:53:53,822 What if you just diversify the number of approaches you have now? 914 00:53:53,822 --> 00:53:57,342 It wouldn't be a criticism, might even be a compliment for someone 915 00:53:57,342 --> 00:54:00,182 to say, but if you did that, you would no longer have an edge 916 00:54:00,182 --> 00:54:03,381 to the industry, you would be the industry and they would be right 917 00:54:03,381 --> 00:54:04,542 in this particular case. 918 00:54:05,262 --> 00:54:07,422 But that kind of gets back to. 919 00:54:07,902 --> 00:54:10,062 That's another way to replicate if you will. 920 00:54:10,302 --> 00:54:11,502 You don't just have to follow. 921 00:54:11,502 --> 00:54:15,102 You could end up running hundreds of different kinds of systematic 922 00:54:15,102 --> 00:54:17,262 approaches and at some point you will become average. 923 00:54:18,702 --> 00:54:22,222 Maybe as a little follow up question on that, if we then go to 924 00:54:22,222 --> 00:54:28,742 a company specific situation and I think this is where, and you 925 00:54:28,742 --> 00:54:35,542 may not agree with this, but I seem to feel that over the last three 926 00:54:35,542 --> 00:54:39,992 or four decades, from time to time we've seen companies that probably 927 00:54:40,392 --> 00:54:42,072 overstepped their capacity. 928 00:54:43,752 --> 00:54:51,072 And I was wondering from your perspective, how do you know as a 929 00:54:51,072 --> 00:54:55,112 manager that you've reached capacity in. 930 00:54:55,192 --> 00:54:57,912 And again, let's just keep it simple, let's just stay with trend 931 00:54:57,912 --> 00:54:58,152 that. 932 00:54:58,152 --> 00:55:01,632 You know, most people on this listen to the show, they know what, 933 00:55:01,632 --> 00:55:02,272 what it is. 934 00:55:02,272 --> 00:55:07,602 How, how do we as trend followers really know when it's time 935 00:55:07,602 --> 00:55:10,842 to stop trading more assets. 936 00:55:11,642 --> 00:55:15,442 Well, I think first of all, your premise is demonstrably true. 937 00:55:15,442 --> 00:55:20,562 There are managers that have overstepped their capacity less so 938 00:55:20,562 --> 00:55:23,962 I think in long term trend following than in other categories 939 00:55:23,962 --> 00:55:27,402 we could talk about that are more sensitive to capacity. 940 00:55:28,442 --> 00:55:35,972 So real problem confounding that problem is that reflexivity 941 00:55:35,972 --> 00:55:37,892 we talked about between manager and client. 942 00:55:37,892 --> 00:55:42,252 If a, if a manager wanted to add or diversify their methodologies 943 00:55:42,252 --> 00:55:47,052 to accommodate more size and to have less of a footprint in the 944 00:55:47,052 --> 00:55:51,972 market, they would be fighting the impression of style drift or 945 00:55:51,972 --> 00:55:54,812 of changing what they're doing in front of their clients. 946 00:55:54,812 --> 00:55:58,012 So that would require a very trusting dialogue, probably one that 947 00:55:58,422 --> 00:56:01,702 can't occur fast enough if they're raising assets too fast, 948 00:56:02,422 --> 00:56:07,142 because those kinds of changes practically need to take place over 949 00:56:07,142 --> 00:56:09,222 years for client acceptance. 950 00:56:09,702 --> 00:56:14,102 Not if you have a good run of asset raising. 951 00:56:14,822 --> 00:56:16,942 But I think the real question is how do you tell? 952 00:56:16,942 --> 00:56:22,542 And I think everyone who's a listener pretty much understands 953 00:56:22,542 --> 00:56:26,272 that liquidity in the marketplace is the key question for 954 00:56:26,272 --> 00:56:27,072 any given market. 955 00:56:28,192 --> 00:56:29,752 And liquidity is dynamic. 956 00:56:29,752 --> 00:56:33,952 It's not consistently present, depends on time of day market. 957 00:56:34,832 --> 00:56:38,152 And it really gets back again to there's a participant on the other 958 00:56:38,152 --> 00:56:39,232 side of each trade. 959 00:56:40,832 --> 00:56:46,552 In the generic terms, a large volume of dollars trying to go into 960 00:56:46,552 --> 00:56:53,642 a smaller market more rapidly is going to press a market and cause 961 00:56:53,642 --> 00:56:56,762 a capacity issue in this case, if we use that term, but just going 962 00:56:56,762 --> 00:56:59,802 to simply move the market, you're going to have slippage, very 963 00:56:59,802 --> 00:57:03,962 small amount of money in a large market slowly, and it won't. 964 00:57:04,922 --> 00:57:11,322 And so I think if people are very diligent about seeing the fingerprint 965 00:57:11,882 --> 00:57:17,392 of their execution costs and their execution alpha and they begin 966 00:57:17,392 --> 00:57:23,992 to see their execution costs rise, objectively measured and trend 967 00:57:23,992 --> 00:57:27,512 in a particular upward direction, they may have a capacity 968 00:57:27,512 --> 00:57:27,792 problem. 969 00:57:27,792 --> 00:57:29,752 And it very likely could occur. 970 00:57:30,232 --> 00:57:34,272 It very likely could be noticed in a few markets long before 971 00:57:34,272 --> 00:57:35,712 it's noticed in all markets. 972 00:57:35,712 --> 00:57:40,592 It might be noticed in a few markets and then there are questions 973 00:57:40,592 --> 00:57:44,842 of whether that's short term or whether that will, you know, that's 974 00:57:44,842 --> 00:57:48,882 just a phenomena that the particular country or the particular 975 00:57:48,962 --> 00:57:52,162 currency is less liquid and six months later it will return to 976 00:57:52,162 --> 00:57:55,362 its liquidity, or it could be because there's just too much money 977 00:57:56,802 --> 00:57:59,682 there and it's, you know, and it's too tough. 978 00:57:59,682 --> 00:58:03,642 If you're a metals trader, you know, you could trade that much in 979 00:58:03,642 --> 00:58:05,522 copper, but you can't trade that much in tin. 980 00:58:05,522 --> 00:58:08,322 And you're going to have to Decide how to accommodate for that. 981 00:58:08,872 --> 00:58:09,112 Sure. 982 00:58:09,752 --> 00:58:12,232 Alan, I know you have a heart cut off today. 983 00:58:12,232 --> 00:58:14,632 We've had a few technical issues along the way. 984 00:58:14,632 --> 00:58:18,792 So I'm going to give you the rest of our conversation. 985 00:58:18,872 --> 00:58:22,152 And you asked the last few questions that you want. 986 00:58:23,752 --> 00:58:25,552 You and I could talk anytime if you want. 987 00:58:25,552 --> 00:58:26,072 That's good. 988 00:58:26,232 --> 00:58:29,032 I think we will have to do a follow up anyways, that's for sure. 989 00:58:29,512 --> 00:58:30,592 Just one theme. 990 00:58:30,592 --> 00:58:34,792 I mean we have talked about this, we've talked about regime change, 991 00:58:34,792 --> 00:58:40,612 we've talked about new market participants, pod shops, microstructure 992 00:58:40,612 --> 00:58:43,692 changing from a macro perspective. 993 00:58:43,692 --> 00:58:46,052 Markets have changed since you started trading. 994 00:58:48,772 --> 00:58:51,052 2010S were very different, 2000s. 995 00:58:51,052 --> 00:58:52,291 Now we're into a new regime. 996 00:58:52,852 --> 00:58:57,692 So I guess the question is do you just try and design systems that 997 00:58:57,692 --> 00:59:02,212 are robust regardless of how microstructure and macro factors 998 00:59:02,212 --> 00:59:06,212 might change over time or do you take that into account and try 999 00:59:06,212 --> 00:59:09,052 and incorporate that into your research process? 1000 00:59:09,612 --> 00:59:14,852 What do you see as a more kind of effective, robust way of having 1001 00:59:14,852 --> 00:59:15,652 a research process? 1002 00:59:15,652 --> 00:59:19,052 I guess the answers I think are all yes. 1003 00:59:19,612 --> 00:59:24,492 I don't think you can avoid not looking in practice. 1004 00:59:24,492 --> 00:59:29,852 If we were thinking of a trend following sleeve and there's a big 1005 00:59:29,852 --> 00:59:32,732 question, why would you even want different strategies, for instance? 1006 00:59:32,732 --> 00:59:34,282 But let's just say you do. 1007 00:59:34,522 --> 00:59:39,442 If you look at a trend following sleeve and if holding periods 1008 00:59:39,442 --> 00:59:43,562 are relatively long and execution is extremely insensitive, 1009 00:59:43,962 --> 00:59:47,722 meaning like for your listeners, if you had a, a trading 1010 00:59:47,722 --> 00:59:52,162 approach that you could trade the next day or the next day and 1011 00:59:52,162 --> 00:59:54,842 it would have the same results, you have one that's relatively 1012 00:59:54,842 --> 00:59:56,362 insensitive to market timing. 1013 00:59:56,762 --> 01:00:00,722 If you have one that if you delay by 15 minutes you lose 20% 1014 01:00:00,722 --> 01:00:04,722 of your P and L, you have one that's pretty time sensitive and 1015 01:00:05,362 --> 01:00:07,722 the ones that are more time sensitive and the ones that are, 1016 01:00:07,722 --> 01:00:13,882 you know, their impact and microstructure obviously are a bigger 1017 01:00:13,882 --> 01:00:16,722 research topic and a bigger capacity concern. 1018 01:00:16,722 --> 01:00:23,962 To your earlier question and frankly have I think less margin 1019 01:00:23,962 --> 01:00:26,362 of error in forward application. 1020 01:00:26,362 --> 01:00:31,452 You have to be humble enough to, you know, recognize, you know, 1021 01:00:31,452 --> 01:00:34,492 which is sort of the key aspect I think of all trading is 1022 01:00:34,492 --> 01:00:36,812 objectivity and objectivity. 1023 01:00:36,812 --> 01:00:40,412 The mana, the emotional manifestation of that is humility. 1024 01:00:40,732 --> 01:00:43,692 You have to be looking and then that fuels research. 1025 01:00:44,332 --> 01:00:49,332 I don't know that that the way I usually think of regime is, it's 1026 01:00:49,332 --> 01:00:52,372 more a bias because I'm used to that term. 1027 01:00:52,372 --> 01:00:56,582 More from the macro perspective are rates rising, rates 1028 01:00:56,582 --> 01:00:58,542 falling, inflation up, inflation down. 1029 01:01:00,222 --> 01:01:03,902 I think investors are both benefit from those regime considerations, 1030 01:01:04,462 --> 01:01:08,222 but I think they also are One of the things that ends up fooling 1031 01:01:09,422 --> 01:01:11,822 early investors, especially early quants. 1032 01:01:13,342 --> 01:01:15,902 I think the first stage of somebody who comes to the market 1033 01:01:15,902 --> 01:01:19,902 is somebody who thinks that when data changes in the market that 1034 01:01:19,902 --> 01:01:21,182 somehow the market moves. 1035 01:01:22,602 --> 01:01:26,522 And they constantly trying to model this sort of two body problem 1036 01:01:27,642 --> 01:01:31,122 and then they do all kinds of sensitivity analysis and they can't 1037 01:01:31,122 --> 01:01:34,562 figure out why sometimes this amount of unemployment report change 1038 01:01:34,562 --> 01:01:37,162 had this big of a market move and other times they don't. 1039 01:01:37,722 --> 01:01:41,642 And relatively rapidly one realizes there aren't two bodies 1040 01:01:41,642 --> 01:01:43,562 in the market, the data doesn't. 1041 01:01:44,042 --> 01:01:47,562 And data changes and surprises don't buy or sell anything. 1042 01:01:48,442 --> 01:01:52,482 People see those signals, people see those surprises, people 1043 01:01:52,482 --> 01:01:54,442 see those changes and then people buy. 1044 01:01:54,922 --> 01:01:59,322 And there are entire regimes where some data is simply important 1045 01:01:59,322 --> 01:02:02,602 and then later on it's ignored because it's felt to be. 1046 01:02:03,642 --> 01:02:08,882 When I first started trading, the M1, M2 and M3 money supply used 1047 01:02:08,882 --> 01:02:10,642 to be on the front page of the Wall Street Journal. 1048 01:02:10,642 --> 01:02:15,982 And because everybody followed money Supply, I think if I hired 1049 01:02:15,982 --> 01:02:21,102 a new young person today and they hadn't necessarily had specific 1050 01:02:21,182 --> 01:02:25,502 training in macroeconomics specifically, but were brilliant, 1051 01:02:26,222 --> 01:02:28,742 they would never even, it would, the topic would never even 1052 01:02:28,742 --> 01:02:30,822 occur to them unless it was brought up. 1053 01:02:30,822 --> 01:02:32,622 Because today it's muted. 1054 01:02:33,342 --> 01:02:33,742 Right. 1055 01:02:34,942 --> 01:02:38,622 And so regimes are also what information is important, I think 1056 01:02:38,622 --> 01:02:42,272 to the trading community and the investing community at the time. 1057 01:02:42,272 --> 01:02:43,632 And that fluxes over time. 1058 01:02:44,592 --> 01:02:48,192 I think it's always will be an imperfect process. 1059 01:02:49,152 --> 01:02:54,112 And I know you've done some, I think great work in regime shifting 1060 01:02:54,512 --> 01:02:56,712 and I know I've read your opinion. 1061 01:02:56,712 --> 01:02:58,032 It is an imperfect process. 1062 01:02:58,352 --> 01:02:59,232 It's a shift. 1063 01:02:59,552 --> 01:03:03,632 It's not a precise prediction, but it falls into that category. 1064 01:03:03,632 --> 01:03:07,342 What I said earlier is the setup, you know, markets. 1065 01:03:07,582 --> 01:03:11,422 You might want to trade differently in a high inflation, 1066 01:03:12,142 --> 01:03:15,582 rising interest rate, supply constrained world than you might 1067 01:03:15,582 --> 01:03:19,542 want to do in a demand constrained, low interest rate, low 1068 01:03:19,542 --> 01:03:20,382 inflation world. 1069 01:03:21,582 --> 01:03:24,142 And in fact I would even assert that you should. 1070 01:03:24,382 --> 01:03:27,622 But other people will find their own answer and then they'll 1071 01:03:27,622 --> 01:03:29,102 have to get convicted by it. 1072 01:03:29,262 --> 01:03:32,872 And if they stay with it, steady handedness. 1073 01:03:33,272 --> 01:03:35,952 Somebody asked me what's the biggest input to compounding and 1074 01:03:35,952 --> 01:03:38,872 once I said, well, it's actually how much your hand shakes. 1075 01:03:39,032 --> 01:03:45,192 Steady handedness compounds well the return gap, the negative 1076 01:03:45,192 --> 01:03:47,912 investor alpha that occurs from people switching on performance 1077 01:03:49,592 --> 01:03:53,712 is usually the biggest cost that they face in putting their portfolios 1078 01:03:53,712 --> 01:03:53,992 together. 1079 01:03:55,752 --> 01:04:00,202 Probably a good, a good way to end our conversation today. 1080 01:04:00,602 --> 01:04:04,962 I feel there's definitely enough to talk about in a follow 1081 01:04:04,962 --> 01:04:05,842 up conversation. 1082 01:04:05,842 --> 01:04:09,362 Pat, this was really wonderful, you know We've done a 1083 01:04:09,362 --> 01:04:13,762 lot of these conversations and I think today again we learned something 1084 01:04:13,762 --> 01:04:14,122 new. 1085 01:04:14,202 --> 01:04:17,362 You spoke about things even though it's a well known topic but 1086 01:04:17,362 --> 01:04:20,482 in a different way and it really benefits everyone listening. 1087 01:04:20,482 --> 01:04:22,922 So I really, really appreciate your time and your insights. 1088 01:04:24,042 --> 01:04:29,242 And as I said, I hope we will be doing this again in the not too 1089 01:04:29,482 --> 01:04:30,362 distant future. 1090 01:04:30,762 --> 01:04:33,722 And to all of you listening today, I hope you were also able 1091 01:04:33,722 --> 01:04:36,722 to take something away from today's conversation onto your own 1092 01:04:36,722 --> 01:04:37,642 investment journey. 1093 01:04:37,802 --> 01:04:41,242 And if you did, please share this episode along with the others 1094 01:04:41,242 --> 01:04:45,042 with your friends and colleagues from Pat, Alan and me. 1095 01:04:45,042 --> 01:04:46,362 Thanks ever so much for listening. 1096 01:04:46,362 --> 01:04:50,282 Look forward to being back with you as we continue our conversations 1097 01:04:50,282 --> 01:04:54,752 on Top Traders Unplugged and we we continue deep dive into the 1098 01:04:54,752 --> 01:04:58,912 CTA industry and in the meantime of course check out the 1099 01:04:58,912 --> 01:05:02,032 show notes for all these episodes where you also find links 1100 01:05:02,032 --> 01:05:06,712 to Pat's firm and to Alan's resources as well. 1101 01:05:06,712 --> 01:05:11,672 So anyways, as usual, let me finish up by saying take care of 1102 01:05:11,672 --> 01:05:13,832 yourself and take care of each other. 1103 01:05:16,472 --> 01:05:19,032 Thanks for listening to Top Traders Unplugged. 1104 01:05:19,232 --> 01:05:21,872 If you feel you learned something of value from today's episode, 1105 01:05:21,952 --> 01:05:24,752 the best way to stay updated is to go on over to your favorite 1106 01:05:24,752 --> 01:05:27,992 podcast platform and follow the show so that you'll be sure to 1107 01:05:27,992 --> 01:05:30,192 get all the new episodes as they're released. 1108 01:05:30,192 --> 01:05:33,432 We have some amazing guests lined up for you and to ensure our 1109 01:05:33,432 --> 01:05:36,512 show continues to grow, please leave us an honest rating and review. 1110 01:05:36,752 --> 01:05:39,632 It only takes a minute and it's the best way to show us you 1111 01:05:39,632 --> 01:05:40,592 love the podcast. 1112 01:05:40,832 --> 01:05:43,872 We'll see you next time on Top Traders Unplugged. 1113 01:05:44,272 --> 01:05:46,962 This is this podcast expresses the views of its hosts and the guests 1114 01:05:46,962 --> 01:05:49,522 appearing on the podcast as of the date of its recording, and such 1115 01:05:49,522 --> 01:05:51,042 views are subject to change without notice. 1116 01:05:51,042 --> 01:05:53,842 Top Traders Unplugged do not have any duty or obligation to update 1117 01:05:53,842 --> 01:05:55,202 the information contained herein. 1118 01:05:55,202 --> 01:05:57,602 Furthermore, Top Traders Unplugged make no representation 1119 01:05:57,602 --> 01:06:00,442 to its accuracy and it shall not be assumed that past investment 1120 01:06:00,521 --> 01:06:02,362 performance is an indication of future results. 1121 01:06:02,522 --> 01:06:05,122 Moreover, wherever there is a potential for profit, there is also 1122 01:06:05,122 --> 01:06:06,202 the possibility of loss. 1123 01:06:06,202 --> 01:06:09,002 This content is made available for educational purposes only and 1124 01:06:09,002 --> 01:06:10,142 should not be used for any other purpose. 1125 01:06:10,212 --> 01:06:12,492 Purpose the information contained in this podcast does not 1126 01:06:12,492 --> 01:06:15,132 constitute and should not be construed as investment advice or 1127 01:06:15,132 --> 01:06:17,812 an offer to sell or a solicitation to buy any securities 1128 01:06:17,812 --> 01:06:20,212 or related financial instruments in any jurisdiction. 1129 01:06:20,212 --> 01:06:22,852 Certain information contained herein concerning economic trends 1130 01:06:22,852 --> 01:06:25,772 and performance is based on or derived from information provided 1131 01:06:25,772 --> 01:06:27,212 by independent third party sources. 1132 01:06:27,212 --> 01:06:29,572 Top Traders Unplugged may believe that the sources from which 1133 01:06:29,572 --> 01:06:31,252 such information are obtained are reliable. 1134 01:06:31,252 --> 01:06:33,692 However, Top Traders Unplugged cannot guarantee the accuracy of 1135 01:06:33,692 --> 01:06:36,502 such information and has not independently verified the accuracy 1136 01:06:36,502 --> 01:06:38,822 or completeness of such information or the assumptions on 1137 01:06:38,822 --> 01:06:40,182 which such information is based. 1138 01:06:40,182 --> 01:06:42,982 This podcast, including the information contained herein, may 1139 01:06:42,982 --> 01:06:45,862 not be reproduced, copied, republished, or posted in whole or 1140 01:06:45,862 --> 01:06:48,502 in part in any form, without the prior written consent of Top 1141 01:06:48,502 --> 01:06:49,502 Traders Unplugged.