1 00:00:06,800 --> 00:00:12,120 Markets are non linear creatures. We deal with imprecision 2 00:00:12,120 --> 00:00:17,280 and probabilities only. And there's one thing that you know, 3 00:00:17,280 --> 00:00:21,640 the market psychologists generally say that you've got to 4 00:00:21,640 --> 00:00:25,920 expect that anything can happen. Anything can happen in the 5 00:00:25,920 --> 00:00:34,050 market. Today's a great example, for God's sake. And it's 6 00:00:34,050 --> 00:00:38,130 a humbling thing. It really is. It's humbling for a systematic 7 00:00:38,130 --> 00:00:41,090 trader, it's humbling for a discretionary trader. Anybody that's 8 00:00:41,330 --> 00:00:42,690 watching what's going on, 9 00:00:44,850 --> 00:00:49,050 imagine spending an hour with the world's greatest traders. Imagine 10 00:00:49,050 --> 00:00:51,770 learning from their experiences, their successes and 11 00:00:51,770 --> 00:00:57,330 their failures. Imagine no more. Welcome to Top Traders Unplugged, 12 00:00:57,330 --> 00:01:00,310 the place where you can learn from the best, best hedge fund managers 13 00:01:00,310 --> 00:01:03,710 in the world. So you can take your manager, due diligence or investment 14 00:01:03,790 --> 00:01:07,630 career to the next level. Before we begin today's conversation, 15 00:01:07,630 --> 00:01:10,950 remember to keep two things in mind. All the discussion we'll have 16 00:01:10,950 --> 00:01:14,270 about investment performance is about the past. And past performance 17 00:01:14,430 --> 00:01:17,870 does not guarantee or even infer anything about future performance. 18 00:01:18,350 --> 00:01:21,310 Also, understand that there's a significant risk of financial loss 19 00:01:21,310 --> 00:01:24,070 with all investment strategies. And you need to request 20 00:01:24,070 --> 00:01:27,430 and understand the specific risks from the investment manager 21 00:01:27,430 --> 00:01:30,830 about their product before you make investment decisions. Here's 22 00:01:30,830 --> 00:01:34,810 your your host, veteran hedge fund manager, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen. 23 00:01:40,650 --> 00:01:43,770 Hey everyone, and welcome to another edition of Top Traders Unplugged, 24 00:01:43,770 --> 00:01:46,810 where today Alan Dunne and I are delighted to be joined by no 25 00:01:46,810 --> 00:01:49,690 other than Toby Crabel, the founder of Crabel Capital Management, 26 00:01:50,010 --> 00:01:54,010 as part of our series focusing on CTA and managed futures strategies 27 00:01:54,170 --> 00:01:58,250 and the legends that make up this wonderful industry. Toby, it's 28 00:01:58,250 --> 00:02:02,130 a real pleasure to have you on the podcast. You've had a front row 29 00:02:02,130 --> 00:02:05,400 seat to how markets have evolved over several decades and 30 00:02:05,400 --> 00:02:09,400 how edges that once worked incredibly well eventually get competed 31 00:02:09,400 --> 00:02:13,880 away. And I think understanding this process is more 32 00:02:13,880 --> 00:02:17,320 important today than ever. So Al and I have really been looking 33 00:02:17,320 --> 00:02:22,000 forward to this conversation and a warm welcome to the podcast. 34 00:02:22,000 --> 00:02:24,080 How are you doing? How are things in California? 35 00:02:24,080 --> 00:02:27,560 Good, thank you. Good. Weather's 90 degrees in the spring. 36 00:02:27,560 --> 00:02:30,650 I think global warming is destroying everything, but that's 37 00:02:30,650 --> 00:02:31,130 all good. 38 00:02:31,530 --> 00:02:32,730 That's all good. Okay. 39 00:02:32,730 --> 00:02:33,370 Good weather. 40 00:02:33,770 --> 00:02:37,290 Good weather. Okay, cool. Now, before we dive into all the topics 41 00:02:37,290 --> 00:02:41,650 that we have planned to discuss today, as we normally do, 42 00:02:41,650 --> 00:02:44,930 we do want to set the stage a little bit for our conversation so 43 00:02:44,930 --> 00:02:47,450 that the audience knows a little bit about your background. 44 00:02:47,850 --> 00:02:53,050 So perhaps we could start with perhaps the transition from professional 45 00:02:53,050 --> 00:02:56,870 tennis player to futures trader, as that in itself is quite 46 00:02:56,870 --> 00:03:00,510 unique and how, and perhaps why did that happen? 47 00:03:01,630 --> 00:03:06,950 Well, in my later teens, my father was trading his own account 48 00:03:06,950 --> 00:03:11,390 and the stock, the stock market. And he took me into the brokerage 49 00:03:11,390 --> 00:03:16,630 firm and between tennis workouts in the morning and in the 50 00:03:16,630 --> 00:03:20,510 afternoon we'd watch the market on the ticker, which Trans 51 00:03:20,510 --> 00:03:24,270 Lux I believe it was. Would scroll across from left to right 52 00:03:24,270 --> 00:03:27,990 and. And make it dizzy if you watch it long enough. But it was 53 00:03:27,990 --> 00:03:31,350 fascinating. That's, that's where I sort of got the bug. And 54 00:03:32,310 --> 00:03:37,110 from there I looked and study markets through college and gravitated 55 00:03:37,110 --> 00:03:42,350 towards technical analysis. And while I was playing tennis, I 56 00:03:42,350 --> 00:03:46,550 mean it was the era of the gold market making its move up to 57 00:03:46,550 --> 00:03:53,640 $800 and an ounce. And so that was interesting. And I would, I would 58 00:03:53,640 --> 00:03:58,840 watch that over, over time and actually trade a bit generally options 59 00:03:58,840 --> 00:04:07,040 on gold stocks. And then when I was 25, having had played tennis 60 00:04:07,040 --> 00:04:13,770 through college and made a decent. Okay living it at it. I was 61 00:04:13,770 --> 00:04:20,850 playing professional tennis in Europe. And then I. I had a. A friend 62 00:04:20,850 --> 00:04:26,530 that I had given tennis lessons to in Chicago during the 63 00:04:26,530 --> 00:04:31,250 summer sometime. And he was on the exchange floor and he invited 64 00:04:31,250 --> 00:04:34,770 me to come down and take a look at it. And eventually I ended 65 00:04:34,770 --> 00:04:38,530 up started starting as a runner at 25 years old on the Mercantile 66 00:04:38,530 --> 00:04:43,860 Exchange, working for him. Two months after I started there he, 67 00:04:44,180 --> 00:04:49,860 I. I was continually doing technical work and he wanted me to 68 00:04:49,860 --> 00:04:57,540 be his chartist and give him ideas in the cattle market and other 69 00:04:57,540 --> 00:05:01,820 markets. And then we started trading account together. And that 70 00:05:01,820 --> 00:05:04,660 was at RBH Commodity. He was one of the principals there. Tim 71 00:05:04,660 --> 00:05:12,790 Brennan is his name. And that's how it started. From there 72 00:05:12,790 --> 00:05:17,390 I was generally a trend follower. Early on he had no commissions 73 00:05:17,390 --> 00:05:22,310 in his account because he was an owner of a brokerage firm. So 74 00:05:22,310 --> 00:05:28,990 I then started gradually going towards shorter term trading. And 75 00:05:28,990 --> 00:05:33,720 around the exchanges. Most of the traders were day traders. They 76 00:05:33,720 --> 00:05:36,920 didn't generally hold positions for very long. So that 77 00:05:36,920 --> 00:05:43,040 mentality sort of overwhelmed me and had a big influence on what 78 00:05:43,040 --> 00:05:48,360 I was developing then for clients later on. That's kind of 79 00:05:48,360 --> 00:05:53,240 the beginning. There's a little twist in there. In the mid-80s 80 00:05:54,120 --> 00:05:58,520 I started hearing about this idea of opening range breakout. Some 81 00:05:58,520 --> 00:06:02,610 people had already talked about it. John Hill, Larry Williams. 82 00:06:04,690 --> 00:06:07,730 There's a fellow named Mark Fisher in New York that wrote a great 83 00:06:07,730 --> 00:06:13,170 book. The Logical Trader and his group were keying in on the open. 84 00:06:13,410 --> 00:06:18,490 And the floor traders in Chicago had a. Had a concept in the 85 00:06:18,490 --> 00:06:22,170 bond market in particular. If the market moved eight ticks above 86 00:06:22,170 --> 00:06:24,690 or below the open, they would actually fade that. And if it went 87 00:06:24,690 --> 00:06:27,440 beyond that, they would start to, to go with it. They would think 88 00:06:27,440 --> 00:06:31,480 that that would be a breakout and just that that concept as it 89 00:06:31,480 --> 00:06:36,480 in itself was sort of a foundational principle that I started 90 00:06:36,480 --> 00:06:42,520 to work on and then wrote a book about in the late 80s, a famous 91 00:06:42,520 --> 00:06:45,520 book that became very difficult to buy for most people, 92 00:06:45,520 --> 00:06:46,040 I think. 93 00:06:47,000 --> 00:06:50,800 Well, we didn't publish much. It was through Ed Dobson at Traders 94 00:06:50,800 --> 00:06:57,150 press. He published 3,000 copies. And then there was a paperback 95 00:06:57,310 --> 00:07:00,990 later on through Dan Rayfeld, who's not in business anymore. And 96 00:07:01,230 --> 00:07:07,110 I don't know how Ed's doing, but I see some of his books now and 97 00:07:07,110 --> 00:07:14,510 again. But look, I was surprised and it really helped me. 98 00:07:14,510 --> 00:07:19,070 I met some wonderful, very successful people in the business. 99 00:07:19,950 --> 00:07:26,030 It was a great calling card for me, including, you know, the 100 00:07:26,030 --> 00:07:32,510 introduction to Victor Niederhofer in 1991 and ending up 101 00:07:32,510 --> 00:07:38,230 going to work for him, which I would consider to be a, a really 102 00:07:40,230 --> 00:07:43,590 foundational moment for me in, in my career. 103 00:07:45,030 --> 00:07:49,960 I wanted to maybe stay a little bit with your book Open range 104 00:07:49,960 --> 00:07:55,520 breakout from 1989. Maybe you can take us back those 40ish years 105 00:07:55,520 --> 00:08:02,080 and describe the edge that you found and maybe also how that edge 106 00:08:02,320 --> 00:08:03,680 evolved over time. 107 00:08:04,080 --> 00:08:07,680 Well, it's an interesting story. In fact, it's going to be 108 00:08:07,680 --> 00:08:12,440 a subject that I'm going to take up here in the next several 109 00:08:12,440 --> 00:08:17,220 years. I'll start with you guys. You know, this is, we're, we're 110 00:08:17,220 --> 00:08:17,540 on it. 111 00:08:17,540 --> 00:08:18,340 Thank you, Toby. 112 00:08:18,340 --> 00:08:22,340 Well, I'm writing a little bit about it, but look, the subject is 113 00:08:22,500 --> 00:08:26,860 fascinating to me. What, what orb is, is, is a momentum strategy, 114 00:08:26,860 --> 00:08:31,700 of course. And, and when I went to Victor's, I, I was, I was 115 00:08:31,700 --> 00:08:36,340 steeped in the idea of trading with momentum. But then I saw him 116 00:08:36,340 --> 00:08:41,220 trading against momentum in, in fact, our trades were probably 117 00:08:41,220 --> 00:08:48,530 opposite each other, which was, was interesting. And so I, I 118 00:08:48,530 --> 00:08:52,570 came to appreciate the other side of the equation. But opening 119 00:08:52,570 --> 00:08:56,690 range breakout is a great measure of momentum in markets, which 120 00:08:56,690 --> 00:09:01,930 is a huge factor. And you can, you can see it even now in, in the 121 00:09:01,930 --> 00:09:05,890 markets how powerful momentum can be. And so you have to really 122 00:09:05,890 --> 00:09:12,550 be aware of the moments that, that you're going to run into. Trend 123 00:09:12,550 --> 00:09:16,630 days generally they're not as frequent, it doesn't look like, as 124 00:09:16,630 --> 00:09:21,150 they used to be. There seem, there seem to be, there seems to 125 00:09:21,150 --> 00:09:27,310 be a lot of liquidity against momentum that, that's used strategically 126 00:09:27,310 --> 00:09:33,910 and it's, I think it's a, and that's again, that sort of moves 127 00:09:33,910 --> 00:09:37,870 you towards the mean reversion side. But over the years it's it 128 00:09:37,870 --> 00:09:41,670 had done. In fact when I published the book the next 10 years 129 00:09:41,670 --> 00:09:46,270 was one of the best periods in history for open opening range breakout. 130 00:09:46,990 --> 00:09:51,310 And in, in effect that, that was a good part of the strategies 131 00:09:51,310 --> 00:09:56,990 that we had in the firm in my trading and it was, it was sort of 132 00:09:56,990 --> 00:10:00,710 a launching point for the, for the track record. There have been 133 00:10:00,710 --> 00:10:05,110 in an incredible amount of money, new and different ways of 134 00:10:05,110 --> 00:10:09,430 trading that we've developed at our firm. But there still is a 135 00:10:09,430 --> 00:10:17,270 momentum feature other than 1960-1962, which one of the worst 136 00:10:17,270 --> 00:10:23,430 periods for what we would have done. What we do the last two or 137 00:10:23,430 --> 00:10:30,430 three years have been equally as bad. The basic concept of opening 138 00:10:30,430 --> 00:10:35,200 range breakout and in a nutshell I think the reason why that's 139 00:10:35,680 --> 00:10:41,960 deteriorating like it is is because where is the open? I for 140 00:10:41,960 --> 00:10:46,080 God's sake. I mean there's so much volume in the 24 hour sessions 141 00:10:46,080 --> 00:10:50,040 it's impossible to determine what the open is. So you're, you 142 00:10:50,040 --> 00:10:52,640 know the one, the wonderful thing about open range breakout is 143 00:10:52,640 --> 00:10:56,080 back in the day when there were just primary session domestic 144 00:10:56,080 --> 00:11:01,420 session trading was it was the most vital piece of information reference 145 00:11:01,420 --> 00:11:06,740 point that you could have. And I started to see deterioration even 146 00:11:06,740 --> 00:11:12,100 in the 80s when they started the night session in the US treasury 147 00:11:12,100 --> 00:11:17,780 markets at the Board of Trade you could see a dissipation of follow 148 00:11:17,780 --> 00:11:22,220 through from close of the prior day to the open of the next 149 00:11:22,220 --> 00:11:27,190 day and you would also see some dissipation of the sort of vitality 150 00:11:27,190 --> 00:11:33,190 of momentum off of the open. So that was sort of a warning. And 151 00:11:34,470 --> 00:11:39,670 the one thing that I did in the 90s also with my portfolio after 152 00:11:39,670 --> 00:11:43,030 working with Victor was to add mean reversion to sort of offset 153 00:11:43,430 --> 00:11:47,790 what I thought may and because when I went to Victor's there was 154 00:11:47,790 --> 00:11:52,000 a, a wonderful trader that worked for Victor named Monroe Trout 155 00:11:52,480 --> 00:11:57,880 who's you know, legendary in the business. And I had a, I met 156 00:11:57,880 --> 00:12:04,319 him before I, I went to work for Victor and when I went got to 157 00:12:04,319 --> 00:12:10,280 Victor shop they would just disparage poor Monroe who is one 158 00:12:10,280 --> 00:12:15,640 of the best sharp traders in history and talk about opening range 159 00:12:15,640 --> 00:12:20,800 breakout just falling apart and you know, going to find its demise 160 00:12:21,040 --> 00:12:25,960 sometime soon. And but at the same time I was, I was developing 161 00:12:25,960 --> 00:12:30,280 the strategies, you know, to, to trade it and it worked and it 162 00:12:30,280 --> 00:12:33,760 worked for another eight to 10 years. These, these changes are glacial. 163 00:12:34,640 --> 00:12:38,720 You know, they, it has changed, yes. But you know Monroe 164 00:12:38,720 --> 00:12:43,280 made a fine living with it and so did my firm develop around it 165 00:12:43,280 --> 00:12:48,840 and but there are adjustments that have to be made I'm going to 166 00:12:48,840 --> 00:12:54,440 just throw one thing out. So the real problem is where is the 167 00:12:54,440 --> 00:12:57,680 reference point where the open was a great reference point, but 168 00:12:57,680 --> 00:13:00,960 now what, what other reference points are there in the, in the markets? 169 00:13:01,760 --> 00:13:05,320 One is the close of the previous day and the movement off 170 00:13:05,320 --> 00:13:08,240 of that, that that will then cover. When you come into the day 171 00:13:08,240 --> 00:13:12,070 session of the U.S. for instance, you've got all the overnight 172 00:13:12,070 --> 00:13:16,070 information that's been acquired in the movement and does 173 00:13:16,070 --> 00:13:22,270 that have an effect on the upcoming price behavior? And what 174 00:13:22,270 --> 00:13:26,390 we have found is it does. It's not as strong as the old opening 175 00:13:26,390 --> 00:13:30,310 range breakout was in the 80s, but it's a factor. It's one of the 176 00:13:30,310 --> 00:13:36,800 factors that you can look at highs and lows of the session in 177 00:13:36,800 --> 00:13:40,640 the 24 hour session, highs and lows of the previous day, you know, 178 00:13:40,640 --> 00:13:44,800 where. What's the market doing when it makes a new low? Like for 179 00:13:44,800 --> 00:13:50,280 instance today we happen to have made a new low overnight and 180 00:13:50,440 --> 00:13:54,600 rallied significantly. Now that's something that we see a lot 181 00:13:54,600 --> 00:13:59,440 more of right now. Probably won't impress someone who's been 182 00:13:59,440 --> 00:14:02,520 in the markets for five or 10 years. It would probably. It impresses 183 00:14:02,520 --> 00:14:06,760 somebody who's been in the markets for 50 years and that's me. 184 00:14:06,760 --> 00:14:12,280 And I think that what's going on is there is many more reversals 185 00:14:13,880 --> 00:14:18,560 instead of follow through days now than there have been in quite 186 00:14:18,560 --> 00:14:19,000 a while. 187 00:14:21,880 --> 00:14:25,600 Maybe just to follow up on two things mentioned. One is more like 188 00:14:25,600 --> 00:14:31,600 a fun fact, I think and I don't know this for sure but over 189 00:14:31,600 --> 00:14:34,520 the years when I heard the name Monroe child being mentioned, 190 00:14:35,110 --> 00:14:39,630 it was always associated with him only hiring like professional 191 00:14:39,630 --> 00:14:45,190 college basketball players, super tall guys. So you can probably 192 00:14:45,190 --> 00:14:47,190 confirm that it 193 00:14:47,190 --> 00:14:52,070 was a tall firm that was. That's for sure. Not all. But his 194 00:14:52,070 --> 00:14:56,630 brother was about the same height as he was. Yeah, yeah. I mean 195 00:14:56,630 --> 00:15:00,750 Monroe was Monroe and it affected his trading. You know, he 196 00:15:00,750 --> 00:15:07,170 was the. Apparently he was the highest percentage of scoring basketball 197 00:15:07,170 --> 00:15:12,850 player in Harvard's history. It's like 73% field goal. 198 00:15:13,810 --> 00:15:14,450 Exactly. 199 00:15:14,530 --> 00:15:16,930 Which tells you a little bit about his personality. Apparently 200 00:15:16,930 --> 00:15:22,890 he only shot layups as a center at Harvard, I guess and that, 201 00:15:22,890 --> 00:15:28,050 you know, the trades that he did were only layups. I think. 202 00:15:29,040 --> 00:15:32,560 Yeah, that makes sense. But I wanted to just touch before we move 203 00:15:32,560 --> 00:15:38,400 on on this thing about where is the open. I don't follow trading 204 00:15:38,560 --> 00:15:41,880 that closely. That's obviously done by other people in the firm 205 00:15:41,880 --> 00:15:46,800 I work for. But is it true that actually liquidity has also 206 00:15:46,800 --> 00:15:50,720 changed? So the liquidity was in the old days around the Open for 207 00:15:50,720 --> 00:15:53,600 the most part, but nowadays it's actually around the close. 208 00:15:54,570 --> 00:15:57,810 Yeah, which may suggest like if you look at the stock indexes, 209 00:15:57,810 --> 00:16:01,490 I believe that the closing volume is higher, especially like 210 00:16:01,490 --> 00:16:05,290 S and P. There's a lot of action right around the close, so 211 00:16:05,290 --> 00:16:11,770 that, that marks it as a reference point of significance. 212 00:16:12,410 --> 00:16:16,490 You know, if you see. To really get an idea of how this has 213 00:16:16,570 --> 00:16:21,180 panned out, there are markets that do trade primary sessions like 214 00:16:21,180 --> 00:16:26,020 the, like the old 80s, I think, I don't know, palm oil or 215 00:16:29,700 --> 00:16:35,380 well, the Brazilian markets to some extent. So when that is happening, 216 00:16:35,380 --> 00:16:38,980 those markets have much better results for the open, the opening 217 00:16:38,980 --> 00:16:43,980 range breakout concept. And so that tells you something. Whereas 218 00:16:43,980 --> 00:16:48,060 in the stock indexes, actually the markets have been pretty dynamic 219 00:16:48,060 --> 00:16:53,140 there and that's probably a place where momentum works very well. 220 00:16:53,140 --> 00:16:58,020 But the open is obscured enough so that there's a lot of crossover 221 00:16:59,300 --> 00:17:03,420 around the open intraday. It doesn't mean that the market's not 222 00:17:03,420 --> 00:17:06,940 going to move directionally from the open, but it, there's a 223 00:17:06,940 --> 00:17:09,300 wider path, let's put it that way. 224 00:17:11,411 --> 00:17:15,851 I wanted to shift gear a little bit, Toby, just because, I 225 00:17:15,851 --> 00:17:19,021 mean we could continue talking about just that little area for a 226 00:17:19,021 --> 00:17:22,821 while, but I'm trying to. Or we're trying to cover quite a few 227 00:17:23,541 --> 00:17:29,061 topics but staying with this in some ways anyways is that when 228 00:17:29,061 --> 00:17:34,181 you see markets as closely have you done. Have done for so long, 229 00:17:34,821 --> 00:17:39,141 do you feel that the markets themselves, other than the fact that 230 00:17:39,141 --> 00:17:43,381 they don't open, so to speak, at a specific time, do you think 231 00:17:43,381 --> 00:17:47,451 that they are different today than they were back then, or is it 232 00:17:47,451 --> 00:17:50,971 more about the participants in the markets, do you think? 233 00:17:54,491 --> 00:17:57,931 Well, I think that we have to assume the markets are evolving. 234 00:17:58,091 --> 00:18:03,091 Right. I think that's the. We look at our past portfolios in the 235 00:18:03,091 --> 00:18:07,611 firm and if we're not making progress and making changes that 236 00:18:07,611 --> 00:18:12,121 we think and making good assumptions there, which we have 237 00:18:12,121 --> 00:18:17,761 been able to do pretty well, is that those old portfolios just 238 00:18:17,761 --> 00:18:21,641 don't work nearly as well as they as the present, present day. 239 00:18:22,441 --> 00:18:24,881 And that's because of the changes we make. I mean, I think 240 00:18:24,881 --> 00:18:28,521 there's probably a 10% or more shift in our portfolios every year 241 00:18:29,401 --> 00:18:34,561 because of the, the amount of work we're doing on it. Are the participants 242 00:18:34,561 --> 00:18:41,611 different? I think this, you know, in, in a way you can say that 243 00:18:41,611 --> 00:18:45,091 markets are really the same and they're also much. There are 244 00:18:45,091 --> 00:18:53,131 much different. The patterns do exist, I think. But look, it's 245 00:18:53,131 --> 00:18:57,651 the thing about markets, it's a probabilistic gain and if you, 246 00:18:58,451 --> 00:19:01,811 if you don't look at it that way, there's nothing certain about 247 00:19:01,891 --> 00:19:04,611 what's going on. And the uncertainty, I think, is greater, 248 00:19:06,271 --> 00:19:10,791 maybe especially in the last few years. But so that means that 249 00:19:10,791 --> 00:19:15,751 sort of outlier movements can catch you, I think, a little bit 250 00:19:15,751 --> 00:19:20,751 easier than they used to be, a little bit more damaging to the portfolio. 251 00:19:21,871 --> 00:19:27,671 But the basic concepts, I think are still valid. Certainly 252 00:19:27,671 --> 00:19:31,351 there's room for new concepts. The players themselves, I mean, if 253 00:19:31,351 --> 00:19:37,181 you think about the market makers now, they're all, you know, 254 00:19:37,181 --> 00:19:44,541 algorithmic and they're huge and most of them are very profitable. 255 00:19:45,661 --> 00:19:51,021 We work against them, we work against large, larger interest above 256 00:19:51,021 --> 00:19:57,181 and below previous day's highs and lows. There's, there's a lot 257 00:19:57,181 --> 00:20:01,881 of, if you think of yourself, if you imagine yourself as one of 258 00:20:01,881 --> 00:20:05,401 the largest traders in the world and you'd ask the question, 259 00:20:05,401 --> 00:20:10,441 where would you get in and out of a market you want to get out when 260 00:20:10,441 --> 00:20:14,921 there's tremendous amounts of activity? Today is a great example. 261 00:20:14,921 --> 00:20:16,601 I mean, I don't know if you're going to date this. 262 00:20:19,161 --> 00:20:23,041 We can date it now. We are recording on March 23rd and we're 263 00:20:23,041 --> 00:20:27,161 recording in the afternoon, European time, almost dinner time. 264 00:20:27,161 --> 00:20:31,841 So people will notice that markets have reversed direction quite 265 00:20:31,841 --> 00:20:35,481 sharply a few hours ago, given the news coming out of Iran. 266 00:20:36,041 --> 00:20:40,441 I mean, it's, it's, you know, maybe I haven't watched markets enough, 267 00:20:40,841 --> 00:20:45,641 but to see a move like silver and gold like, like they had today 268 00:20:47,001 --> 00:20:50,521 going through the Asian session, having a bounce in the Asian 269 00:20:50,521 --> 00:20:54,681 session, going all the way into an hour or so of the European 270 00:20:54,681 --> 00:20:59,481 session and then having another significant rally. I mean, 271 00:20:59,481 --> 00:21:04,761 and the percentage changes are just something I haven't, I don't 272 00:21:04,761 --> 00:21:09,321 recall percentage. Maybe I'm just, you know, mentally recording 273 00:21:09,321 --> 00:21:13,161 the percentage changes. But damn it, they seem much larger than 274 00:21:13,161 --> 00:21:17,281 they've ever been. And I think we could probably verify that. And 275 00:21:17,281 --> 00:21:22,661 what does that do? I mean, who asks? I think the question is who 276 00:21:22,661 --> 00:21:27,861 bought it today? Gold, silver on the lows at plenty of time and 277 00:21:28,101 --> 00:21:31,501 higher volume than they've had. I mean, five, ten times more 278 00:21:31,501 --> 00:21:37,661 volume than typically at the lows over a half hour period or hour 279 00:21:37,661 --> 00:21:42,061 period. Tremendous liquidity and a tremendous move in the opposite 280 00:21:42,061 --> 00:21:46,661 direction. Somebody's buying it. And why not? I mean, because 281 00:21:46,661 --> 00:21:50,101 that's what's happening a lot in the markets. But a big trader 282 00:21:51,821 --> 00:21:55,621 must welcome the kind of liquidity liquidation that took place 283 00:21:55,621 --> 00:22:01,741 there today. And also, you know, there's also suspicions about 284 00:22:01,741 --> 00:22:04,901 people entering. Before announcements today, there was quite 285 00:22:04,901 --> 00:22:09,181 a, quite a few number of contracts traded 10 minutes before 286 00:22:09,261 --> 00:22:13,821 the announcements of the Iran talks, which I haven't heard any 287 00:22:13,821 --> 00:22:18,701 sort of confirmation that they actually exist, but so be it. But 288 00:22:18,941 --> 00:22:21,621 somebody came in with tremendous volume 10 minutes before 289 00:22:21,621 --> 00:22:26,001 that announcement. I've got the number right here which worth 290 00:22:26,001 --> 00:22:32,201 talking about. Let's see, on the five minute basis it was five 291 00:22:32,201 --> 00:22:38,361 to ten times greater than normal. So okay, big traders need 292 00:22:38,361 --> 00:22:42,881 liquidity, they need to get fed, so to speak. And the markets 293 00:22:42,881 --> 00:22:47,121 by trading through highs and lows provide that liquidity. And 294 00:22:47,121 --> 00:22:52,901 it unfortunately it's the fodder of that liquidity is the poor 295 00:22:53,381 --> 00:22:58,621 scared, fearful trader who's liquidating their longs. And silver 296 00:22:58,621 --> 00:23:03,701 and gold have been just great up markets by the way, just a point 297 00:23:03,701 --> 00:23:06,621 here that if the market actually holds here in silver and 298 00:23:06,621 --> 00:23:10,981 gold and start, let's say this is a pullback, which by the way there's 299 00:23:10,981 --> 00:23:14,261 some precedent to suggest that it's just a pullback in a bull market, 300 00:23:15,651 --> 00:23:18,971 then I hate to see what the next three to six months are to the 301 00:23:18,971 --> 00:23:21,091 upside anyway. 302 00:23:21,491 --> 00:23:24,091 Interesting. Well, time, you'll have to come back in six months 303 00:23:24,091 --> 00:23:25,891 and tell us if it's lovely. 304 00:23:25,971 --> 00:23:30,291 Yeah, I know I can't hold a position that long personally. 305 00:23:30,931 --> 00:23:35,651 Oh yeah, yeah, that is true Alan. You've been waiting patiently 306 00:23:35,731 --> 00:23:37,731 so dig a little bit deeper here. 307 00:23:38,851 --> 00:23:42,531 Yeah, I mean you touched on how you were attracted to technical 308 00:23:42,531 --> 00:23:46,781 analysis straight away. So, and I mean as your token, you know, 309 00:23:46,781 --> 00:23:50,221 it's all about price, volume, volatility. So these are still are 310 00:23:50,221 --> 00:23:54,141 the key variables. And you know, technical analysis is much 311 00:23:54,141 --> 00:23:57,941 maligned. A lot of the time people can be quite dismissive but 312 00:23:57,941 --> 00:24:01,461 at the same time, you know, a lot of technicals is around observing 313 00:24:01,461 --> 00:24:04,541 the patterns. It's because of the behavior of insiders like you're 314 00:24:04,541 --> 00:24:09,511 talking about today. So you think it's as valid today technical 315 00:24:09,511 --> 00:24:13,831 analysis as it was. And what's the attraction for you? Why, why, 316 00:24:13,831 --> 00:24:15,031 why does it have such merit? 317 00:24:15,191 --> 00:24:20,791 Well, I, I don't like momentum much personally but it makes money. 318 00:24:21,751 --> 00:24:27,871 But you, you can't. I don't, it's very hard to do it on a discretionary 319 00:24:27,871 --> 00:24:32,151 basis because the market moves much slower in that process. I think 320 00:24:32,231 --> 00:24:37,841 it's, but I think that there's huge interests that are taking advantage 321 00:24:37,841 --> 00:24:43,281 of liquidity pockets wherever that, wherever that volume comes 322 00:24:43,281 --> 00:24:48,441 in, they, that's, you know, their eyes open wide. It's a, it's 323 00:24:48,441 --> 00:24:52,441 a great opportunity for I, I think that's when you see volume, 324 00:24:52,441 --> 00:24:55,801 that's opportunity, you know, especially when you're outside of 325 00:24:55,801 --> 00:25:01,101 ranges. I think it's much more important than I, I recall ever seen. 326 00:25:01,821 --> 00:25:06,181 Now I may be wrong. I mean there, there are times when years 327 00:25:06,181 --> 00:25:10,341 and years ago, I mean we just, it's hard to get data to really nail 328 00:25:10,341 --> 00:25:15,541 it down. But you can look at a graphic display of, of data and you 329 00:25:15,541 --> 00:25:20,661 can get some feel for it. There's a great study that Woff did 330 00:25:20,661 --> 00:25:26,731 back on the New York Times index in the 30s, 2000-30s and 30, 331 00:25:26,871 --> 00:25:32,231 1931. And it's a great, it does reflect a lot of the stuff that's 332 00:25:32,231 --> 00:25:35,391 going on now. It was very, it's really incredibly volatile time 333 00:25:35,391 --> 00:25:39,871 in a bear market. I think that there's, there's a concentration 334 00:25:39,871 --> 00:25:44,911 of really big players out there that are able to come in and 335 00:25:44,911 --> 00:25:50,031 hold the market and reverse much more effectively than I say 336 00:25:50,031 --> 00:25:54,031 much more. It doesn't take much. I mean, let's say that it used 337 00:25:54,031 --> 00:25:59,511 to be, you know, 63% of the time the market would follow through 338 00:25:59,511 --> 00:26:04,751 after it took out a higher low. Well now it's only 58% of the 339 00:26:04,751 --> 00:26:09,671 time. But if that were a climate change, we would be melting 340 00:26:09,671 --> 00:26:16,551 the, you know, the Arctic, the polar caps and we would probably 341 00:26:16,551 --> 00:26:22,521 be flooded here in Beverly Hills. And, and so if you can think 342 00:26:22,521 --> 00:26:29,241 of markets sort of as an environmental or ecological analogy, 343 00:26:29,241 --> 00:26:33,601 it just, a few percentage points can change us so much in the 344 00:26:33,601 --> 00:26:37,201 way the markets behave. And you can see that in the charts, the 345 00:26:37,201 --> 00:26:40,161 charts aren't really. Look, it's not like you, there's a, there's 346 00:26:40,161 --> 00:26:44,081 a, a premise that we, we have to hold to all the time. The charts 347 00:26:44,081 --> 00:26:47,731 are there just to tell us what's going on in the market. And 348 00:26:47,811 --> 00:26:51,211 if you're, you're constantly watching this, you can get us, you 349 00:26:51,211 --> 00:26:54,571 can get a sense, you can get a feel for it. Now the next step for 350 00:26:54,571 --> 00:26:59,171 us is to always quantify that. And we, we have, we've done some 351 00:26:59,171 --> 00:27:03,051 very, very good work on detecting some of the changes that 352 00:27:03,051 --> 00:27:06,931 have, have taken place. And by the way, if we didn't do that, our 353 00:27:07,411 --> 00:27:11,331 five or ten year ago portfolio would have put us out of business 354 00:27:11,331 --> 00:27:11,971 probably. 355 00:27:11,971 --> 00:27:16,141 But just talking about some of the changes. So if you think about 356 00:27:16,141 --> 00:27:20,581 it, obviously, I mean you mentioned changes in exchange, trading 357 00:27:20,581 --> 00:27:23,981 hours, et cetera. But beyond that, obviously we've got new products, 358 00:27:24,461 --> 00:27:29,021 new participants, you've got maybe increased retail participation, 359 00:27:29,021 --> 00:27:34,941 you've got pod shops, you've got new options activities, 0 DTES 360 00:27:34,941 --> 00:27:37,621 got a lot of structured products. So the whole landscape 361 00:27:37,621 --> 00:27:41,211 has changed over the course of three, four decades. So when you're 362 00:27:41,211 --> 00:27:45,571 looking at all of that, can you say this is the most significant 363 00:27:45,811 --> 00:27:48,891 bit and this is causing this reaction or how do you think about 364 00:27:48,891 --> 00:27:50,371 all of those changes coming together? 365 00:27:50,451 --> 00:27:54,371 The wonderful thing about visual displays of data is that you 366 00:27:54,371 --> 00:28:01,731 can grasp a good deal about a subject, a market very quickly and 367 00:28:02,451 --> 00:28:06,981 easily. You know, you can see what's happening and you know, if 368 00:28:06,981 --> 00:28:13,181 you use some decent tools, I think it's, it augments that analysis. 369 00:28:13,421 --> 00:28:17,741 I don't know, I mean you could let the computer run all day. I'm, 370 00:28:18,781 --> 00:28:24,941 I, I really, you know, I enjoy the, the, the move towards AI and 371 00:28:26,301 --> 00:28:31,901 neural network, genetic algorithm, but I don't, it's so hard 372 00:28:31,901 --> 00:28:39,181 to capture I think even still what's going on. Seeing what's going 373 00:28:39,181 --> 00:28:45,741 on I think is invaluable. I couldn't imagine being in a market 374 00:28:45,741 --> 00:28:49,661 without a graphic display in front of me. And there's good reasons 375 00:28:49,661 --> 00:28:53,581 for that. I think the human mind can gather information from 376 00:28:53,581 --> 00:29:01,061 that picture still I think much better than a computer. We're 377 00:29:01,061 --> 00:29:03,541 still in the phase of having to tell the computer what to do. 378 00:29:04,421 --> 00:29:05,221 Unfortunately 379 00:29:06,981 --> 00:29:12,021 for short term traders. One of the feedback you'd sometimes hear 380 00:29:12,101 --> 00:29:14,661 from my own perspective, speaking with investors and talking 381 00:29:14,661 --> 00:29:17,341 about managed futures strategies, particularly when managed 382 00:29:17,341 --> 00:29:21,501 futures went into a drawdown in the last decade, there was a common 383 00:29:21,501 --> 00:29:25,101 view that we've had this growth of high frequency and those 384 00:29:25,101 --> 00:29:27,901 guys are making a lot of money. So they're basically, that's 385 00:29:27,901 --> 00:29:32,141 a lot of alpha they're taking out of the market which maybe previously 386 00:29:32,141 --> 00:29:35,021 was owned by short term traders. Is, is that valid or would 387 00:29:35,021 --> 00:29:35,941 you push back on that? 388 00:29:35,941 --> 00:29:39,021 Well, I think, I think that what, when you think of the, the 389 00:29:39,021 --> 00:29:42,741 high frequency groups, you know, they really are the liquidity 390 00:29:43,381 --> 00:29:49,341 backbone of the markets. There are some nuances there that are a 391 00:29:49,341 --> 00:29:54,861 little frustrating but they're like the floor traders of, of old 392 00:29:55,341 --> 00:30:00,101 I think. Right. And they're going to make money. The one thing 393 00:30:00,101 --> 00:30:03,421 I remember about being around the exchanges is that the same guys 394 00:30:03,421 --> 00:30:07,101 were there all the time and they were on top of the pits and 395 00:30:07,181 --> 00:30:11,781 the, the guys that were trading in the pits that were, were 396 00:30:11,781 --> 00:30:15,781 usually there wasn't a lot of turnover and there's some people 397 00:30:15,781 --> 00:30:19,931 came in and they were new but generally speaking there was a very 398 00:30:21,451 --> 00:30:26,771 solid crowd that they were profitable and they did well. They 399 00:30:26,771 --> 00:30:30,451 didn't do very well when things went more electronic but I 400 00:30:30,451 --> 00:30:34,771 think that these high frequency groups ended up picking 401 00:30:34,771 --> 00:30:40,051 that up obviously when it went electronic. And I don't begrudge 402 00:30:40,051 --> 00:30:44,141 them their money. They have to spend a lot to, to get that edge, 403 00:30:44,621 --> 00:30:48,021 you know. Just millions and millions of dollars just to, just 404 00:30:48,021 --> 00:30:53,421 to get a, a damn few microseconds which I'd rather have 405 00:30:53,421 --> 00:31:00,461 edge. That's not so expensive. At least that's, that's what our 406 00:31:00,461 --> 00:31:05,341 firm. We get better at execution. One of the things that's 407 00:31:05,341 --> 00:31:09,301 going on if you look at the book, I remember days when the S 408 00:31:09,301 --> 00:31:16,351 And P had 500 up, you know, on the bid ask. Well you're lucky to 409 00:31:16,351 --> 00:31:22,591 get 20 now showing in the book. But there's still much, much 410 00:31:22,591 --> 00:31:27,111 more volume being traded which is interesting because so it's, you 411 00:31:27,111 --> 00:31:35,191 know, they're much more cagey in the methods of execution and you 412 00:31:35,191 --> 00:31:39,681 have to do that in a firm that's relatively short term, I think 413 00:31:39,681 --> 00:31:44,081 and that's part of what we concentrate a lot on. I think that's 414 00:31:44,081 --> 00:31:48,361 okay. It's just not that much different than even 30, 40 years 415 00:31:48,361 --> 00:31:53,161 ago. We're still compete, we have to compete with other traders. 416 00:31:58,441 --> 00:32:03,881 Just staying on the models. And we've had only really a few short 417 00:32:03,881 --> 00:32:07,731 term managers on, on this series because there aren't that 418 00:32:07,731 --> 00:32:12,611 many of them. You are one. And as I mentioned in the beginning, 419 00:32:13,011 --> 00:32:15,571 one of the firms have been around the longest in this space. 420 00:32:16,051 --> 00:32:20,731 But one question we get, but also actually we get for a trend 421 00:32:20,731 --> 00:32:23,211 following strategy. But I would imagine that it's even more 422 00:32:23,211 --> 00:32:26,651 pronounced in your space and here I'm thinking more of the purely 423 00:32:26,651 --> 00:32:30,251 systematic part of your business. Toby, my understanding 424 00:32:30,251 --> 00:32:34,001 is that you probably see more model decay in short term models 425 00:32:34,001 --> 00:32:37,761 relative to longer term trend models. How do you deal with that? 426 00:32:38,721 --> 00:32:42,201 How do you evolve models? But also maybe the hardest question that 427 00:32:42,201 --> 00:32:44,321 is how do you know when to retire model? 428 00:32:45,361 --> 00:32:49,641 Well, I think there's an allocation process that needs to 429 00:32:49,641 --> 00:32:57,041 take place and it's recognizing individual strategy deterioration 430 00:32:57,281 --> 00:33:01,451 and it's also recognizing, looking at the environments that 431 00:33:01,451 --> 00:33:07,371 exist that we, that we're dealing with. And you know, there 432 00:33:07,371 --> 00:33:11,891 has been, there has been a move in our firm. Fortunately we 433 00:33:11,891 --> 00:33:15,491 have a good, a really solid research group, you know, led by 434 00:33:15,491 --> 00:33:19,131 the, the CEO who I think you've interviewed. Mike. 435 00:33:19,131 --> 00:33:20,811 Mike, Mike, yeah. 436 00:33:20,811 --> 00:33:26,251 And he, what they, what they have done and there's conversation 437 00:33:26,251 --> 00:33:31,671 around this is that we, we notice these incremental changes 438 00:33:31,671 --> 00:33:41,311 in the sort of the structure of the market. One is that let's 439 00:33:41,311 --> 00:33:44,311 say there's been a deterioration in the momentum, basic 440 00:33:44,630 --> 00:33:52,471 momentum strategies of 4 or 5%, they're still successful above 441 00:33:52,471 --> 00:33:58,911 50% or something like that or, but they've dropped. So what does 442 00:33:58,911 --> 00:34:03,271 that mean? That's the question that has to kind of be looked at 443 00:34:03,271 --> 00:34:06,231 Is what does that mean? Well, that means that there's more people 444 00:34:06,231 --> 00:34:12,831 that are, are quashing the volatility, they're compressing the 445 00:34:12,831 --> 00:34:17,431 market. That could be option traders, that could be the large 446 00:34:17,991 --> 00:34:24,201 pod. I think groups that have all these traders that are trading 447 00:34:24,201 --> 00:34:30,961 a particular way that maybe work against us and we can adjust 448 00:34:30,961 --> 00:34:37,521 to that. There's ways to do that and that's right. There's been 449 00:34:37,521 --> 00:34:44,921 a shift in our portfolios to try to accommodate and adjust to 450 00:34:44,921 --> 00:34:48,001 the new sort of newer environments that are taking place. 451 00:34:48,641 --> 00:34:53,331 We try to front load that and that's I think important. You know, 452 00:34:53,331 --> 00:34:57,571 we, we look at it, we look at, we have different sections of the 453 00:34:57,571 --> 00:35:00,771 portfolio and we look at those sections and we, we see how they're 454 00:35:00,771 --> 00:35:05,531 doing and we look at it from different markets standpoints. How, 455 00:35:05,531 --> 00:35:08,851 how is, how is it doing in particular markets? Which then we 456 00:35:08,851 --> 00:35:13,051 ask what, what's the environment that's doing that? Changing, 457 00:35:13,211 --> 00:35:17,901 changing the way that that is trading? And, and then we can, we 458 00:35:17,901 --> 00:35:21,781 can make adjustments around that. But you have to be, it's a 459 00:35:21,781 --> 00:35:24,701 vigilant process. It's, it's, you really have to be on, you really 460 00:35:24,701 --> 00:35:29,021 have to be on top of it. And especially lately I, today's a great 461 00:35:29,021 --> 00:35:38,981 example and I think that the markets are news prone, jumpy, maybe 462 00:35:38,981 --> 00:35:45,051 shorter term in their movements. Our portfolio has gone 463 00:35:45,051 --> 00:35:51,051 from probably an average of a 36 hour hold to something less than 464 00:35:51,051 --> 00:35:59,331 that. I think over time our basic core portfolio cravel and that 465 00:35:59,331 --> 00:36:04,531 reflects our observations about what's going on. 466 00:36:05,331 --> 00:36:09,801 We talked a lot about kind of itch and I was just thinking whether 467 00:36:09,801 --> 00:36:16,401 there is a difference between edges that try to be very precise 468 00:36:17,361 --> 00:36:21,761 and maybe those that try to be more robust, if I can put it that 469 00:36:21,761 --> 00:36:24,081 way. How do you think about that? 470 00:36:24,160 --> 00:36:28,841 Well, you know, I would lean towards generalization of strategies 471 00:36:28,841 --> 00:36:34,161 and in the, in the 90s, you know, the markets were a little easier 472 00:36:34,161 --> 00:36:38,681 and you could have more optimized strategies and still do 473 00:36:38,681 --> 00:36:44,241 pretty well. But late in the late 90s, I decided to generalize 474 00:36:44,961 --> 00:36:49,481 the strategies into a portfolio of six primary mean reversion 475 00:36:49,481 --> 00:36:54,361 strategies and six primary momentum strategies and tried to 476 00:36:54,361 --> 00:36:58,281 get an even balance of the two strategies because they're totally 477 00:36:58,281 --> 00:37:02,331 uncorrelated with each other and tried to get each one of the 478 00:37:02,331 --> 00:37:07,611 six also uncorrelated say with the momentum batch. And so they weren't 479 00:37:07,611 --> 00:37:14,371 all, you know, executing at the same time surprisingly. And we 480 00:37:14,371 --> 00:37:17,651 still had the other optimized strategies in there. Surprisingly. 481 00:37:17,651 --> 00:37:21,291 The four of the top five strategies that year were all the 482 00:37:21,291 --> 00:37:27,771 generalized strategies you know, the results on paper weren't, 483 00:37:28,491 --> 00:37:32,731 weren't better. The optimized were always looking better. But there's, 484 00:37:32,731 --> 00:37:36,051 you know, there's a fallacy in that, that you're fooling yourself 485 00:37:36,051 --> 00:37:39,051 if you think if you optimize too much, you're fooling yourself 486 00:37:39,051 --> 00:37:45,051 in this, in this systematic area. And we've kind of leaned in 487 00:37:45,051 --> 00:37:50,851 that direction since the, since the late 90s and try to find 488 00:37:50,851 --> 00:37:53,171 exactly what you're. I think you're talking about is there very 489 00:37:53,171 --> 00:37:57,861 robust strategies that will stand? You know, I always thought 490 00:37:57,861 --> 00:38:00,701 50 years would be, you know, something. If something could last 491 00:38:00,701 --> 00:38:04,381 for 50 years, I'd be very happy about it. And we still have 492 00:38:04,381 --> 00:38:07,741 strategies that I developed back in the 90s that are in the portfolio 493 00:38:07,741 --> 00:38:13,341 that were, were very general. So happy about that. But look, these 494 00:38:13,341 --> 00:38:17,501 markets are as tough as they've been and, and I don't know 495 00:38:17,501 --> 00:38:22,591 how like, like maybe 40 or 50 years and you would think, I think 496 00:38:22,591 --> 00:38:25,991 they're going to get better. I think we're kind of in a 70s environment, 497 00:38:27,991 --> 00:38:33,951 maybe. But there's something else in there, and I haven't quite 498 00:38:33,951 --> 00:38:37,591 put my finger on it, that's causing some challenges. 499 00:38:38,151 --> 00:38:43,871 Yeah. So maybe before I hand it back to Alan. So maybe I missed 500 00:38:43,871 --> 00:38:48,431 this, or maybe we haven't kind of fully explored it. I'd love to, 501 00:38:48,431 --> 00:38:53,501 if we could. Again, going back to this word edge. Where's your edge? 502 00:38:53,741 --> 00:38:59,061 And it sounds to me like actually, and I could be completely 503 00:38:59,061 --> 00:39:01,741 wrong here, Toby, but it sounds to me that a lot of the edge 504 00:39:01,741 --> 00:39:06,301 might be found in the way you execute in a sense. I mean, that 505 00:39:06,701 --> 00:39:11,381 execution is really, it's not just a little bit of friction here 506 00:39:11,381 --> 00:39:16,801 and there. It's really, if you get that right, that's how you unleash 507 00:39:16,801 --> 00:39:18,401 the edge, let's put it that way. 508 00:39:18,481 --> 00:39:20,081 And you keep it for sure. 509 00:39:20,321 --> 00:39:21,401 Yeah, yeah. 510 00:39:21,401 --> 00:39:25,721 You, you, you have to get better at execution. Find ways of 511 00:39:25,721 --> 00:39:30,521 doing something that don't cost you. And I would say that the 512 00:39:30,521 --> 00:39:37,961 execution in our firm has improved by multiples and compared 513 00:39:37,961 --> 00:39:42,171 to where we were 20 or 25 years ago, for sure. In fact, we've 514 00:39:42,171 --> 00:39:50,011 been getting. Mike sends out a report on slippage, and it's at the 515 00:39:50,011 --> 00:39:52,891 best levels that we've ever had in the history of the firm right 516 00:39:52,891 --> 00:39:58,611 now, which is gratifying. And by the way, we need that. It would 517 00:39:58,611 --> 00:40:03,611 appear you're right. You're absolutely right. We need to execute 518 00:40:03,691 --> 00:40:08,181 as effectively as possible. There's strategies, there's patience, 519 00:40:08,261 --> 00:40:11,701 there's speed. There's all kinds of things that Go into that. 520 00:40:12,261 --> 00:40:13,941 Alan, where do you want to go next? 521 00:40:14,341 --> 00:40:20,061 Well, I mean obviously AI is a hot topic at the moment and you're 522 00:40:20,061 --> 00:40:24,461 talking about selecting strategies, selecting speeds, execution 523 00:40:24,461 --> 00:40:27,181 and these are the kind of areas that a lot of people talk about 524 00:40:27,181 --> 00:40:32,421 AI as being very useful in. What's your experience? What do you 525 00:40:32,421 --> 00:40:38,101 expect going forward? How important is it going to be for you 526 00:40:38,101 --> 00:40:41,581 as a firm and for the industry in general right now? 527 00:40:41,581 --> 00:40:47,341 I mean, we've gone through a bit of a transition and pretty much 528 00:40:47,341 --> 00:40:52,381 everybody in the firm is coding. But now coding is different 529 00:40:52,381 --> 00:40:57,661 than it's ever been and that is that with these, the languages 530 00:40:57,821 --> 00:41:08,301 Codex and others is that you can build and program verbally basically. 531 00:41:09,021 --> 00:41:16,181 And this is a huge development that's taking place. So Mike is all 532 00:41:16,181 --> 00:41:24,141 about this. He's pushing this mandate. Pretty soon I'll be programming, 533 00:41:24,941 --> 00:41:29,421 which I always, I've always hired for that. But now basically 534 00:41:29,421 --> 00:41:34,541 all I have to do is tell it what to do, more or less. But he's 535 00:41:34,541 --> 00:41:38,461 even, he's even got, we got, we've even got the back office, you 536 00:41:38,461 --> 00:41:42,821 know, the people that are talking to clients and doing statements 537 00:41:42,821 --> 00:41:46,741 and things like that and accounting that are using these, 538 00:41:47,461 --> 00:41:56,351 these AI innovations to, you know, simplify processes and do things 539 00:41:56,751 --> 00:42:01,631 less expensively. It's an amazing time. I think it is the next 540 00:42:01,631 --> 00:42:06,911 major change. I think that's a great advancement for our firm and 541 00:42:06,911 --> 00:42:09,991 any firm who's going to use that, which they will, they'll have 542 00:42:09,991 --> 00:42:13,871 to. But what about the markets and what's that going to do? What's 543 00:42:13,871 --> 00:42:17,921 that going to do to trading? Does that mean that, you know, a 544 00:42:17,921 --> 00:42:21,801 20 year old can ask a question and, and get it, you know, about 545 00:42:21,801 --> 00:42:24,521 the markets and what direction it's going in the next five minutes 546 00:42:24,521 --> 00:42:30,321 and get a good answer? Probably not. Markets are non linear 547 00:42:30,321 --> 00:42:36,921 creatures. We deal with imprecision and probabilities only. 548 00:42:37,801 --> 00:42:40,521 And there's one thing that, you know, the market psychologists 549 00:42:40,601 --> 00:42:46,011 generally say to, says you've got to expect that anything can happen, 550 00:42:46,731 --> 00:42:50,731 anything can happen in the market. Today's a great example. 551 00:42:50,731 --> 00:42:56,491 So for God's sake. And, and you. It's a humbling, it's a humbling 552 00:42:56,491 --> 00:43:01,451 thing. It really is. It's humbling for a systematic trader, 553 00:43:01,451 --> 00:43:04,011 it's humbling for a discretionary trade or anybody that's 554 00:43:04,251 --> 00:43:08,851 watching what's going on. Now, I don't know if I were one of the 555 00:43:08,851 --> 00:43:13,781 people that was buying 10 minutes before various announcements 556 00:43:13,781 --> 00:43:17,221 were made today, I probably, maybe I wouldn't be humble, I don't 557 00:43:17,221 --> 00:43:21,501 know. But that's not my, that's not my approach. My approach 558 00:43:21,501 --> 00:43:24,821 is to see is there extraordinary volume prior here. 559 00:43:24,981 --> 00:43:31,141 Now watch out for that, Watch out for extraordinary volume at any 560 00:43:31,141 --> 00:43:34,261 point of the day. How about at the beginning of a daily session, 561 00:43:34,901 --> 00:43:40,141 something like that? How about at the, at the beginning of a region? 562 00:43:40,781 --> 00:43:45,581 Because that's, everybody's awake. If you're trying to get the 563 00:43:45,581 --> 00:43:52,701 US Stock market to rally, you'd probably do it sometime closer 564 00:43:52,701 --> 00:43:54,501 to the O in 565 00:43:54,501 --> 00:43:57,901 the trend following space. In the last few years there's been a 566 00:43:57,901 --> 00:44:02,101 lot of talk and some great success by people doing it in terms 567 00:44:02,101 --> 00:44:06,641 of replicating these strategies. Right now I have my own 568 00:44:06,641 --> 00:44:11,041 observations and views about that. But if someone tried to replicate 569 00:44:11,281 --> 00:44:15,681 what you do, what do you think they're going to get completely wrong 570 00:44:15,681 --> 00:44:20,001 about that? When it's a short term strategy, it's really, really 571 00:44:20,001 --> 00:44:20,481 difficult. 572 00:44:20,961 --> 00:44:25,441 First of all, it would be very complimentary if someone really did 573 00:44:25,441 --> 00:44:30,971 want to replicate strategy. Replicate. I can't even say it but. 574 00:44:32,331 --> 00:44:39,851 So thank you but no, it's not possible and may not want to, but 575 00:44:39,851 --> 00:44:45,091 this is what we do and this is what we know and this is what we're 576 00:44:45,091 --> 00:44:51,131 developing. And we have a time frame that hearkens back to the days 577 00:44:52,011 --> 00:44:56,011 of zero commission trading at the Chicago Mercantile Exchange. 578 00:44:56,011 --> 00:45:00,171 And now we do have other products that hold for longer periods. 579 00:45:00,171 --> 00:45:03,251 We have a couple that including a trend following product. 580 00:45:03,251 --> 00:45:08,291 And we have done a good job of not only replicating but lately we've 581 00:45:08,291 --> 00:45:12,931 done a little bit better and our clients are happy with that in 582 00:45:12,931 --> 00:45:21,371 our trend following area. But the short term stuff is I don't fear 583 00:45:22,101 --> 00:45:29,741 that and there's enough nuance and interesting elements about it 584 00:45:29,741 --> 00:45:32,021 that it's going to be very, it's going to be hard to replicate. 585 00:45:33,541 --> 00:45:36,701 That's why it's a higher cost product. It's, it's, it's more, more 586 00:45:36,701 --> 00:45:41,501 difficult to develop and, and also to execute the execution. You 587 00:45:41,501 --> 00:45:44,581 know, the amount of capital that we've put into execution development 588 00:45:44,661 --> 00:45:47,381 is, has been substantial. 589 00:45:49,021 --> 00:45:51,941 Speaking of that, speaking of execution, the importance of that, 590 00:45:51,941 --> 00:45:55,021 et cetera, et cetera, how do you actually think about capacity 591 00:45:55,021 --> 00:45:57,581 in our industry? Because that's obviously something that comes 592 00:45:57,581 --> 00:46:02,621 up from time to time. How do you think about capacity and is it 593 00:46:02,621 --> 00:46:06,461 harder to estimate in your space compared to say the trend following 594 00:46:06,541 --> 00:46:09,901 space? How do you view that? 595 00:46:11,932 --> 00:46:15,682 Well, we look at our dollars per contract net and we look, look 596 00:46:15,682 --> 00:46:19,402 at what it's costing us to actually execute. And if there's 597 00:46:19,402 --> 00:46:23,562 not a fair margin there, then you know, we certainly have stressors 598 00:46:23,642 --> 00:46:31,802 and problems it's much more of a factor than say, you know, five 599 00:46:31,802 --> 00:46:35,842 to ten day holds versus what we're doing in the really short term 600 00:46:35,842 --> 00:46:42,452 strategies and trend following is. But we still, that said, we still 601 00:46:42,692 --> 00:46:46,212 are very conscious of it in every product, in every time frame 602 00:46:46,372 --> 00:46:51,412 we're trading. But it's been absolutely necessary to take a look 603 00:46:51,892 --> 00:47:00,092 and keep eye on that and research on the ways to get more 604 00:47:00,092 --> 00:47:05,812 out of our actual execution of these strategies. That helps us a 605 00:47:05,812 --> 00:47:08,612 great deal when things aren't working very well and helps us a 606 00:47:08,612 --> 00:47:12,402 lot when things are working well too. So it's just a huge, it's 607 00:47:12,402 --> 00:47:12,482 a 608 00:47:12,482 --> 00:47:16,882 huge proponent just going back to AI. And I mean you talked about 609 00:47:16,962 --> 00:47:20,962 everybody using coding and the ease of developing new strategies. 610 00:47:22,002 --> 00:47:26,562 I mean the simple observation is AI is all about pattern recognition. 611 00:47:26,882 --> 00:47:30,562 It's like LLMs, that's what they do. I mean, can AI being used 612 00:47:30,722 --> 00:47:33,882 to identify the recurring patterns in the market and then if 613 00:47:33,882 --> 00:47:36,542 everybody is using it for that, how does that impact the patterns 614 00:47:36,542 --> 00:47:39,502 themselves as it becomes a bit circular? 615 00:47:40,542 --> 00:47:41,382 Yeah, I think. 616 00:47:41,382 --> 00:47:42,222 What are your thoughts? 617 00:47:42,862 --> 00:47:46,062 It may make them better. Who the hell knows if they can actually 618 00:47:46,222 --> 00:47:52,582 reproduce, you know, and get it right? Well, let's, this, let's 619 00:47:52,582 --> 00:47:55,542 assume this. What? For whatever reason, markets have become 620 00:47:55,542 --> 00:47:58,862 more competitive and the short term arena has become incredibly 621 00:47:58,862 --> 00:48:04,312 competitive, too competitive. We can just assume that people are 622 00:48:04,312 --> 00:48:09,432 using things that. Well, I know we are. So we're using every 623 00:48:09,432 --> 00:48:13,352 tool we possibly can to get an edge. So I don't know why anybody 624 00:48:13,352 --> 00:48:19,752 else wouldn't be doing it too. If it's AI, if it's genetic algorithms, 625 00:48:19,912 --> 00:48:26,882 whatever the key word is to describe the process, speed and ability 626 00:48:26,882 --> 00:48:32,642 to quantify data is really what, what, what it's all about. 627 00:48:33,762 --> 00:48:39,322 And we assume that the assumption right now is that that's 628 00:48:39,322 --> 00:48:43,122 accelerating that process and it's going to be, it's going to be 629 00:48:43,122 --> 00:48:45,202 a more and more competitive landscape. 630 00:48:45,762 --> 00:48:50,402 And in terms of new ideas, are you looking at different sources 631 00:48:50,722 --> 00:48:57,452 of material for new strategies or is this still primarily price, 632 00:48:57,772 --> 00:49:02,612 volume, volatility, et cetera? Or do you look beyond those kind 633 00:49:02,612 --> 00:49:06,012 of, I suppose, traditional metrics? 634 00:49:06,092 --> 00:49:11,652 You know, the feeling I get when I look at it is that it's an 635 00:49:11,652 --> 00:49:19,702 endless process with the databases being so deep that I mean, 636 00:49:19,782 --> 00:49:23,622 I just feel like we've just scratched the surface that there's 637 00:49:23,622 --> 00:49:30,062 so much more to take out of the analysis. I just wish, even with 638 00:49:30,062 --> 00:49:33,901 all of the tools that we've been talking about here, I just feel 639 00:49:33,901 --> 00:49:38,822 like it's so slow, the development and it's not because 640 00:49:38,822 --> 00:49:42,262 Our firm isn't working hard and they're not smart people doing 641 00:49:42,262 --> 00:49:46,302 a good job. You know that this, if there's one question that's 642 00:49:46,302 --> 00:49:49,782 being answered and some development around that, there's 643 00:49:49,782 --> 00:49:54,142 going to be another 50 to be asked right after that. Just on that 644 00:49:54,142 --> 00:49:59,142 note alone, it just doesn't, it doesn't end the quantification 645 00:49:59,142 --> 00:50:04,342 of the prices. That it's such a complex problem. It's daunting 646 00:50:04,342 --> 00:50:09,382 in a way. I don't want to. I think I'm impatient. But I think 647 00:50:09,622 --> 00:50:16,032 this is what everybody is running into, like one for one, just 648 00:50:16,032 --> 00:50:20,832 for an. As an example, I mean, volume itself and the relationships 649 00:50:20,832 --> 00:50:26,272 of volume to price is a subject that I think a lot of people 650 00:50:26,272 --> 00:50:31,992 have overlooked. And I think it's a very deep subject and there's 651 00:50:31,992 --> 00:50:35,072 a lot of ways to look at it. A lot of people have just stuck with 652 00:50:35,072 --> 00:50:41,492 price action alone, just price, which I think is, that misses 653 00:50:41,652 --> 00:50:46,572 the nuances, I think to some extent. So, you know, look, you know, 654 00:50:46,572 --> 00:50:51,812 I wish AI could do something very quickly into sort of keeping 655 00:50:51,812 --> 00:50:55,252 my mind active for the next 150 years because I think maybe I'd 656 00:50:55,252 --> 00:50:56,612 be able to solve the volume problem. 657 00:50:57,972 --> 00:51:01,812 You know, when we spoke last week briefly, you mentioned something 658 00:51:01,812 --> 00:51:05,752 and I don't know if we've covered that today. We haven't used 659 00:51:05,752 --> 00:51:08,872 the same words at least. So maybe just want to make sure that 660 00:51:08,872 --> 00:51:12,512 we do touch on it. Something. It seemed like important to you. 661 00:51:13,232 --> 00:51:16,832 I think you spoke about something called effort versus result 662 00:51:17,392 --> 00:51:20,752 in price movement. What's so interesting about that? 663 00:51:20,752 --> 00:51:26,192 Well, it was a hundred years ago. This fellow talked about markets, 664 00:51:26,192 --> 00:51:31,112 volume and price and price range and ease of movement and labored 665 00:51:31,112 --> 00:51:36,412 movement and churning. And you know, these are all things that he, 666 00:51:36,412 --> 00:51:40,372 he, he saw, apparently volume, it was the ticker. You could, you 667 00:51:40,372 --> 00:51:43,612 could actually at that time take the tape and the, the length 668 00:51:43,612 --> 00:51:46,612 of the tape would tell you how much activity there was right there 669 00:51:46,612 --> 00:51:49,532 just there wasn't that much being transacted. I remember sitting 670 00:51:49,532 --> 00:51:54,212 in the brokerage firm in 1970s and it was 15 million shares traded 671 00:51:54,212 --> 00:51:57,532 a day on the New York Stock Exchange. That was a huge day. I 672 00:51:57,532 --> 00:52:02,732 mean, now look at it. So tracking volume in individual markets 673 00:52:02,732 --> 00:52:06,292 is not an easy thing. But here's, here's the thing. You know, 674 00:52:07,012 --> 00:52:11,492 effort versus result is a con, a concept that was developed a hundred 675 00:52:11,492 --> 00:52:15,932 years ago. Is it still valid today? Yeah, I think, I think it 676 00:52:15,932 --> 00:52:20,572 probably is. I think, you know, there's big think about large 677 00:52:20,572 --> 00:52:25,262 traders coming in on a rally and just stopping it dead. And it's 678 00:52:25,262 --> 00:52:29,102 Tracks, but with a lot of volume taking place. Is that a place 679 00:52:29,102 --> 00:52:34,942 where you want to buy? I don't like that area and I don't like it 680 00:52:34,942 --> 00:52:38,742 on a low. Like by the way, today when the market goes down and 681 00:52:38,742 --> 00:52:43,222 it kind of dead stops and the range is narrow and volume is high, 682 00:52:43,702 --> 00:52:46,502 what's that telling me? Well, someone's standing in front of that 683 00:52:46,502 --> 00:52:52,902 move and you know that I think that's a key point in. And that's 684 00:52:52,902 --> 00:52:57,142 one of the concepts that's derived from the idea of effort versus 685 00:52:57,142 --> 00:53:02,742 result. Effort is volume and the result is the position of the 686 00:53:02,742 --> 00:53:08,422 price range, the size of the price range. One thing here, and 687 00:53:08,422 --> 00:53:11,342 this is an offshoot, it take 10 seconds to tell you about it. 688 00:53:11,742 --> 00:53:18,472 I don't think there's been a complete philosophical justification 689 00:53:18,472 --> 00:53:22,192 for technical analysis done anywhere. I see people talk about 690 00:53:22,192 --> 00:53:27,312 how charts are nice, we should use charts. They're easy, they tell 691 00:53:27,312 --> 00:53:30,112 you everything about the market, all of that. But really there's 692 00:53:30,112 --> 00:53:34,272 something cognitive. There's a cognitive element here that has to 693 00:53:34,272 --> 00:53:38,912 be considered. It seems to me to be really one of the best ways 694 00:53:38,912 --> 00:53:43,682 to pick up this information. And these vertical bars and, or candles 695 00:53:43,682 --> 00:53:50,002 or whatever have profound elements of information in them. 696 00:53:50,242 --> 00:53:52,322 Is that going to be part of your next book, Toby? 697 00:53:52,642 --> 00:53:59,602 Yeah, that's chapter one, Foundations and Philosophical Premises. 698 00:53:59,682 --> 00:54:05,282 Yeah. So somebody's got to do it. Yeah, an armchair philosopher 699 00:54:05,762 --> 00:54:08,162 like myself should probably give it a shot. 700 00:54:09,212 --> 00:54:15,492 Alan, as we begin to kind of wind down, what else do you think 701 00:54:15,492 --> 00:54:21,052 we need to extract from Toby now that we have him here? 702 00:54:21,932 --> 00:54:26,052 Yeah, I guess it's about, I think we've covered a lot of the 703 00:54:26,052 --> 00:54:31,492 big topics, but you know, when we talked about when things stop 704 00:54:31,492 --> 00:54:37,012 working, which is a big topic, I mean, you've also touched on maybe 705 00:54:37,012 --> 00:54:40,252 the 1970s. You made that reference. And I'm also curious. 706 00:54:40,492 --> 00:54:43,892 I mean, you've been in the markets a long time, but it's still 707 00:54:43,892 --> 00:54:47,532 been broadly a favorable period for financial assets, unlike 708 00:54:47,532 --> 00:54:51,212 the 70s, which was a tough period. I mean, how much does that 709 00:54:51,212 --> 00:54:54,932 kind of inform your thinking, these kind of big picture macro regimes, 710 00:54:54,932 --> 00:54:57,132 Is that something to think about or is that too big picture 711 00:54:57,132 --> 00:54:58,572 for a short term trader? 712 00:54:58,732 --> 00:55:05,332 Well, I'm not keen on selling my house right now and I like gold 713 00:55:05,332 --> 00:55:10,532 coins and silver coins, but. And I actually, I actually bought 714 00:55:10,532 --> 00:55:15,892 some, believe it or not, you know, how much 5,000 ounces of silver 715 00:55:15,892 --> 00:55:20,052 weigh? It's like 350 pounds. And you know, if you, if you want 716 00:55:20,052 --> 00:55:23,932 to store it somewhere, it's going to sink the floor in, you know, 717 00:55:23,932 --> 00:55:30,312 but Anyway, there's many, many ways to transact financially. Now 718 00:55:30,312 --> 00:55:34,312 it's not necessarily all gold and silver, but these markets, you 719 00:55:34,312 --> 00:55:37,152 know, one of the examples is I have a trust and I put a life insurance 720 00:55:37,152 --> 00:55:42,352 policy in there, you know, for I don't know, say it's a hundred 721 00:55:42,352 --> 00:55:48,272 dollars. It's lost 95% of its value value against gold for my kids. 722 00:55:48,592 --> 00:55:54,872 Right. And so what's happening? Well, it's that same old 723 00:55:54,872 --> 00:56:01,392 story and what that's doing is creating these tremendous price movements 724 00:56:01,392 --> 00:56:05,752 that we never maybe could have imagined including stocks going up 725 00:56:05,752 --> 00:56:09,912 for so long and if we can hold the gains today, we're probably going 726 00:56:09,912 --> 00:56:13,072 to get a rally to new all time highs, something like that. I mean, 727 00:56:13,072 --> 00:56:20,712 why not? What else to do under the circumstances? Is there any really 728 00:56:20,712 --> 00:56:24,632 significant change taking place? I mean this is a lot like 729 00:56:24,632 --> 00:56:28,072 the 70s now. Of course it's different. It's so much bigger it 730 00:56:28,072 --> 00:56:33,192 seems like and it permeates globally. I think it's a tremendously 731 00:56:33,192 --> 00:56:37,072 dynamic time. I'm actually surprised that profitability in markets, 732 00:56:37,072 --> 00:56:41,112 I mean our trend following products done very well and I think 733 00:56:41,112 --> 00:56:49,122 that, and trend following I think is up and I think that what 734 00:56:49,122 --> 00:56:52,562 it's doing is these large moves are giving tremendous some 735 00:56:52,562 --> 00:56:57,162 real opportunities and investments. The short term's a little 736 00:56:57,162 --> 00:57:03,162 interesting though I have to say. It's not quite as spectacular. 737 00:57:03,961 --> 00:57:09,042 But the movements are so abrupt. Are they with trend? Yeah, 738 00:57:09,042 --> 00:57:13,762 generally speaking they are. So the 200 day moving averages become 739 00:57:13,762 --> 00:57:18,672 much more important than ever. I guess that's, we're in really dynamic 740 00:57:18,672 --> 00:57:22,352 times. I mean let's, let's face it, it's, we can't, we can't 741 00:57:22,352 --> 00:57:27,352 complain about the, the volume and volatility, can we? I don't think 742 00:57:27,352 --> 00:57:27,552 so. 743 00:57:27,552 --> 00:57:31,751 No, no, no, it does as, as, as you said at some point it, it does 744 00:57:31,751 --> 00:57:37,272 feel a little bit like the 70s for sure. So let's, let's hope it 745 00:57:37,272 --> 00:57:40,032 continues for a little while longer at least from a trend following 746 00:57:40,112 --> 00:57:40,832 perspective. 747 00:57:41,242 --> 00:57:41,482 Foreign. 748 00:57:46,202 --> 00:57:49,642 I've got two things I wanted to bring up before we, we wrap up. 749 00:57:49,802 --> 00:57:54,762 Toby, we started out kind of on, on a personal level with you 750 00:57:54,842 --> 00:57:59,082 a bit about your backstory. I'd like to throw in one more question 751 00:57:59,322 --> 00:58:04,282 about that and that is you have, you seem to be very comfortable 752 00:58:04,282 --> 00:58:09,012 doing things kind of your, your own way and I mentioned to you 753 00:58:09,332 --> 00:58:13,692 last time we spoke that one of the, my own personal experience is 754 00:58:13,692 --> 00:58:17,652 not that I knew you at the time but was attending a conference 755 00:58:17,652 --> 00:58:20,812 with you where everybody was wearing black suits and you came 756 00:58:20,812 --> 00:58:25,212 in a white suit. So being different seems to be. And maybe 757 00:58:25,212 --> 00:58:29,652 also choosing the short term space rather than what most of us 758 00:58:29,652 --> 00:58:34,182 do in terms of trend following it seems to be something that, you 759 00:58:34,182 --> 00:58:37,062 know, is part of your personality. But where does that, 760 00:58:37,302 --> 00:58:40,942 where does that come from actually wanting to maybe do things 761 00:58:40,942 --> 00:58:42,502 your own way or a different way? 762 00:58:43,142 --> 00:58:47,502 It's a good question. Well, I do know that diversification is something 763 00:58:47,502 --> 00:58:51,902 that's really sought after in the business. And since I was hanging 764 00:58:51,902 --> 00:58:57,062 around exchanges in the 80s and early 90s and then went to a 765 00:58:57,062 --> 00:59:03,632 short term trading shop, one of the only ones that I knew. I remember 766 00:59:03,632 --> 00:59:08,552 Monroe was trading relatively short term in futures, but Victor 767 00:59:08,552 --> 00:59:13,352 was his teacher in a way at least a mentor. I just thought there 768 00:59:13,352 --> 00:59:18,592 was a better risk adjusted return there and it saved me. Trend 769 00:59:18,592 --> 00:59:24,112 following I did in the early 80s and it was a great time to do 770 00:59:24,112 --> 00:59:29,252 it. The markets are still really trending significantly well, 771 00:59:30,852 --> 00:59:37,772 but as I went along and you know, I, I also had a seat an early, 772 00:59:37,772 --> 00:59:42,372 I was an IOM for the S P when it first started and I would be on 773 00:59:42,372 --> 00:59:46,412 the floor watching the movements and I, when I, as I watched 774 00:59:46,412 --> 00:59:49,852 it in the pit, I, I said, you know, I, I can, I can get this on 775 00:59:49,852 --> 00:59:55,042 a chart, you know, and essentially I found a strategy for 776 00:59:55,042 --> 01:00:01,042 two months that quadrupled my account. You know, trading five minute 777 01:00:01,202 --> 01:00:07,322 bars. Essentially the market at the beginning would go straight 778 01:00:07,322 --> 01:00:11,122 up and straight down for five, six, even ten bars in a row without 779 01:00:11,122 --> 01:00:16,642 taking out a low or taking out a high if it was going down. That 780 01:00:16,642 --> 01:00:19,842 worked for a couple months until the institutions came into 781 01:00:19,842 --> 01:00:26,032 the S and P. Then it was an example of market compressing, quashing 782 01:00:26,032 --> 01:00:29,472 and there was much more variability. Whereas before it would 783 01:00:29,472 --> 01:00:32,152 be straight up, straight down, straight up, it would do that ten 784 01:00:32,152 --> 01:00:35,832 times a day. And it was a tremendously easy thing to capture. 785 01:00:36,472 --> 01:00:42,952 But anyway, when I saw that and without having a commission to 786 01:00:42,952 --> 01:00:47,862 speak of on my training, it's just that was what I did. Trend following 787 01:00:47,942 --> 01:00:53,982 wasn't an outshoot, an offshoot of that. Although, you know, 788 01:00:53,982 --> 01:00:58,462 we have it in the firm now and saw a need for it. But it's, this 789 01:00:58,462 --> 01:01:04,542 is just my area. I'm a day trader primarily for, for my own 790 01:01:04,542 --> 01:01:09,662 account. I'm, I'm, I think we're primarily day trading in our 791 01:01:09,662 --> 01:01:15,662 short term program too. It's, it suits me. I used to be a rather 792 01:01:15,662 --> 01:01:19,182 aggressive tennis player. Maybe there's an aggressive feature 793 01:01:19,182 --> 01:01:22,982 in my personality. Also the French didn't really like the fact 794 01:01:22,982 --> 01:01:28,982 that I was at the net all the time and especially on faster Courts 795 01:01:28,982 --> 01:01:33,782 on clay courts. It was a different story. So, yeah, it could 796 01:01:33,782 --> 01:01:38,422 be a personality thing. It could be just the development that 797 01:01:38,422 --> 01:01:41,862 I had in my particular environment. It could also be a level 798 01:01:41,862 --> 01:01:45,992 of insanity that you just don't want to add, but there it is. 799 01:01:46,312 --> 01:01:50,672 You never know. Well, speaking of, you never know, obviously when 800 01:01:50,672 --> 01:01:52,912 Alan and I do these conversations, we never know if we 801 01:01:52,912 --> 01:01:56,512 bring up all the topics that, that you would like to bring for 802 01:01:56,512 --> 01:02:01,352 us to bring up. So before I close our conversation, I certainly 803 01:02:01,352 --> 01:02:03,512 wanted to give you the opportunity to bring up anything 804 01:02:03,512 --> 01:02:06,512 that you think we may have missed or that's important to you, 805 01:02:06,512 --> 01:02:12,322 that you think we should just make sure, get, get recorded as part 806 01:02:12,322 --> 01:02:15,562 of, of this conversation because you don't do many of these 807 01:02:15,562 --> 01:02:19,282 podcasts, so when we have you, we should definitely make the most 808 01:02:19,282 --> 01:02:19,642 of it. 809 01:02:19,962 --> 01:02:24,082 Well, look, I, I'd be happy to do this going forward anytime you 810 01:02:24,082 --> 01:02:26,682 want. I, I really enjoy it. I think you, you've asked some great 811 01:02:26,682 --> 01:02:30,602 questions and, you know, cordial fellows, and I, I enjoy it. 812 01:02:30,602 --> 01:02:35,722 So. But look at this stage, you know, in my early 70s, I'm, I'm 813 01:02:36,012 --> 01:02:38,892 ready to talk about markets. That's what I'd like to do for the 814 01:02:38,892 --> 01:02:44,052 next 10 or 15, 20, like I said, maybe 150 years if we get lucky. 815 01:02:44,052 --> 01:02:49,772 But, and write and study and research. It's, it's a fascinating 816 01:02:49,772 --> 01:02:53,892 subject. You know, sometimes I have to tell you, I ask myself, Jesus, 817 01:02:53,892 --> 01:02:58,052 this is, this is almost not fair, you know, I mean, I'm not, 818 01:02:58,052 --> 01:03:02,972 I haven't found, you know, a cure for cancer or, or something 819 01:03:02,972 --> 01:03:07,412 like that, but, you know, I'm here and I'm stuck in my profession 820 01:03:07,412 --> 01:03:12,092 and I want to help cancer. Anyway, I'm pretty good at this and 821 01:03:12,092 --> 01:03:15,132 I, I, you know, I think I have something to talk about. I, I don't 822 01:03:15,132 --> 01:03:18,012 know. I mean, so I'll, I'll get, I'll give it, I'm giving it 823 01:03:18,012 --> 01:03:21,812 a try and I'm available to you guys anytime you want. 824 01:03:22,052 --> 01:03:24,732 So that's very kind. We appreciate that. And I know you started 825 01:03:24,732 --> 01:03:27,812 a substack, so for people who are listening, definitely go and 826 01:03:27,812 --> 01:03:33,622 check out Toby's new substack and subscribe to it and start following 827 01:03:33,622 --> 01:03:37,782 Toby much closer because now there is definitely some thoughts 828 01:03:37,862 --> 01:03:41,622 and wisdom being shared. But Toby, this was really wonderful. 829 01:03:41,622 --> 01:03:46,062 It's an excellent point to kind of finish off our conversation 830 01:03:46,062 --> 01:03:49,262 today. We're really grateful for you being on the podcast and 831 01:03:49,262 --> 01:03:53,582 sharing your thoughts and insights with us, and I'm sure we're 832 01:03:53,582 --> 01:03:57,462 going to take you up on the offer to come back at a later stage. 833 01:03:57,882 --> 01:04:01,722 And for all of you listening today, I hope you were also able 834 01:04:01,722 --> 01:04:04,722 to take something away from today's conversation to your own 835 01:04:04,722 --> 01:04:07,242 investment journey. And if you did, please share these episodes 836 01:04:07,242 --> 01:04:11,762 with your friends and your colleagues from Alan, Toby and myself. 837 01:04:11,762 --> 01:04:14,122 Thanks so much for listening. We look forward to being back with 838 01:04:14,122 --> 01:04:18,042 you as we continue this series where we dive into the CTA industry. 839 01:04:18,522 --> 01:04:21,642 And in the meantime, go check out the show notes for this episode 840 01:04:21,642 --> 01:04:24,642 and all the other resources you can find on the website. And 841 01:04:24,642 --> 01:04:28,802 not least, as always, take care of yourself and take care of 842 01:04:28,802 --> 01:04:30,762 each other. And thank you so much, Toby. 843 01:04:31,642 --> 01:04:35,042 Thanks for listening to Top Traders Unplugged. If you feel you 844 01:04:35,042 --> 01:04:38,082 learnt something of value from today's episode, the best way to 845 01:04:38,082 --> 01:04:41,642 stay updated is to go on over to itunes and subscribe to the show 846 01:04:41,722 --> 01:04:45,162 so that you'll be sure to get all the new episodes as they're released. 847 01:04:45,242 --> 01:04:48,562 We have some amazing guests lined up for you and to ensure our 848 01:04:48,562 --> 01:04:51,502 show continues to grow, please leave us an honest rating and review 849 01:04:51,652 --> 01:04:54,652 view in itunes. It only takes a minute and it's the best way to 850 01:04:54,652 --> 01:04:58,292 show us you love the podcast. We'll see you next time on Top Traders 851 01:04:58,292 --> 01:04:58,932 Unplugged.