1 00:00:01,440 --> 00:00:12,321 Welcome to Top Traders Unplugged. In markets success doesn’t 2 00:00:12,321 --> 00:00:24,411 come from predicting what happens next, it comes from being 3 00:00:24,411 --> 00:00:31,665 prepared for what you can’t predict. In each episode we go deep 4 00:00:04,620 --> 00:00:10,450 with some of the world’s most thoughtful minds in investing, economics, 5 00:00:10,450 --> 00:00:16,280 and beyond to understand how they think, how they prepare, and 6 00:00:16,280 --> 00:00:21,580 how they decide, and the experiences that shaped how they 7 00:00:21,580 --> 00:00:26,880 see the world. No noise, no short-cuts, just real conversations 8 00:00:26,880 --> 00:00:31,650 to help you think better and invest with confidence. 9 00:00:35,820 --> 00:00:38,845 Welcome and welcome back to this week's edition of the Systematic 10 00:00:38,845 --> 00:00:41,595 Investor series, with Yoav Git and I, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, where 11 00:00:41,595 --> 00:00:45,170 each week we take the pulse of the global market through the lens 12 00:00:45,170 --> 00:00:48,470 of a rules-based investor. Yoav, it is great to be back with 13 00:00:48,470 --> 00:00:52,045 you this week. Hope you're doing well. How is life in the UK? 14 00:00:52,460 --> 00:00:57,010 Oh, Cambridge is sunny, but we are getting a little bit of water, 15 00:00:57,010 --> 00:01:00,860 a little bit of rain hopefully. And I'm sitting here sipping 16 00:01:00,860 --> 00:01:04,360 my Indonesian avocado coffee that my daughter, who's back from 17 00:01:04,360 --> 00:01:07,160 Indonesia, made for me. So, life is good. 18 00:01:07,480 --> 00:01:10,312 Yeah, certainly sounds like it. I'm not sure I would pick the 19 00:01:10,312 --> 00:01:12,908 same coffee but I haven't tasted it. So, you never know. 20 00:01:12,920 --> 00:01:14,040 We have to try new things. 21 00:01:14,040 --> 00:01:20,178 Yes, try new things, that's absolutely true. So, now we've got 22 00:01:20,178 --> 00:01:26,874 a few new things on the agenda, some great topics that we're 23 00:01:26,874 --> 00:01:33,012 going to be talking about. We're going to announce the winner 24 00:01:33,012 --> 00:01:38,592 of the very important TTU merch competition that was running 25 00:01:38,592 --> 00:01:44,730 in August. So, I'm sure there'll be some exciting news there. 26 00:01:44,730 --> 00:01:52,542 And yeah, and then we got some papers to review as well, so all 27 00:01:52,542 --> 00:01:53,658 is good. However, before we get into any of that, as usual, I'm 28 00:01:26,866 --> 00:01:40,858 always interested in finding out what kind of has hit your radar, 29 00:01:40,858 --> 00:01:53,684 your desk in the last few weeks that you found interesting. 30 00:01:54,100 --> 00:02:25,054 Oh, hi Niels, it's always nice to be here. So actually, I want to 31 00:02:25,054 --> 00:02:47,164 talk a little bit about clients, not about current events 32 00:02:47,164 --> 00:03:09,274 or anything outside. Actually, we've had a few interactions with 33 00:03:09,274 --> 00:03:33,595 investors in the last month, and it really brought home about 34 00:03:33,595 --> 00:03:55,705 the nature of the relationship we have with different investors. 35 00:01:54,100 --> 00:02:21,829 So, we had two very distinct meetings. The first one was in Zurich, 36 00:02:21,829 --> 00:02:43,159 and we were discussing allocation to trend, and the guy 37 00:02:43,159 --> 00:03:06,622 said, oh, you shouldn't worry about it because Claude wants us 38 00:03:06,622 --> 00:03:32,218 to have more trend in our portfolio. So, you know, we've been 39 00:03:32,218 --> 00:03:55,681 advocating TPA. It makes sense to be part of a portfolio. And so, 40 00:01:57,960 --> 00:02:19,190 there's a little bit of like total portfolio approach which is 41 00:02:19,190 --> 00:02:44,280 coming along. And I think AI, when you give the data of allocators, 42 00:02:44,280 --> 00:03:07,440 they kind of realize Claude really wants trend. So, I think actually 43 00:03:07,440 --> 00:03:28,670 this is really exciting for the industry. I think that's being 44 00:03:28,670 --> 00:03:49,900 dispassionate about, you know, what is actually best for the portfolio. 45 00:03:49,900 --> 00:03:55,690 It's really interesting. So, that was like the first interaction, 46 00:02:00,799 --> 00:02:11,326 you know, a very technical discussion. And then the second one 47 00:02:11,326 --> 00:02:22,810 was much more personal. So, we had a very long-term supporter of 48 00:02:22,810 --> 00:02:31,423 the ACoS strategy, the commodity strategy, and he’s retiring. 49 00:02:31,423 --> 00:02:43,864 He’s moving off to spend more time with his family, and I thought 50 00:02:43,864 --> 00:02:55,348 it was a really emotional meeting. And I wished him all the 51 00:02:55,348 --> 00:03:07,789 best, him and his family. And it really brought home to me how 52 00:03:07,789 --> 00:03:17,359 much the nature of the investor relations is really about 53 00:03:17,359 --> 00:03:25,972 trust and about the relationship. It's not just, you 54 00:03:25,972 --> 00:03:36,499 know… People allocate to you not just because you are running 55 00:03:36,499 --> 00:03:49,897 a CTA, but also because they trust you. So that was very… I didn't 56 00:03:49,897 --> 00:03:55,639 realize how emotional I would get. 57 00:03:56,600 --> 00:04:05,264 I mean, it's interesting you say you bring that up because obviously 58 00:04:05,264 --> 00:04:13,206 that's the side of the business that I've been working in 59 00:04:13,206 --> 00:04:21,870 for more than three decades. And so, I completely agree. Of course, 60 00:04:21,870 --> 00:04:30,534 I think it's a very personal business or side of the business, 61 00:04:30,534 --> 00:04:38,476 very important. Often, of course, as you say, people tend to 62 00:04:38,476 --> 00:04:47,140 start by screening just for numbers. But I think once you get 63 00:04:47,140 --> 00:04:54,360 into the conversations, the due diligence, and ideally once you 64 00:04:54,360 --> 00:05:01,580 start having a business relationship, I think that it changes 65 00:05:01,580 --> 00:05:03,024 a lot. And I also find that, I mean a lot of it is also about the 66 00:04:08,060 --> 00:04:15,700 journey, right? When you've been through a few difficult times 67 00:04:15,700 --> 00:04:24,868 with a client and they have felt supported along the way. You've 68 00:04:24,868 --> 00:04:33,272 given them the tools and the information they needed to essentially, 69 00:04:33,272 --> 00:04:40,148 you know, justify the investment to their investment committee 70 00:04:40,148 --> 00:04:47,788 or their colleagues. Once you build up that relationship, that 71 00:04:47,788 --> 00:04:57,720 trust, as you mentioned, and of course, as long as you don't screw 72 00:04:57,720 --> 00:05:03,068 it up completely on the performance side. 73 00:05:03,230 --> 00:05:04,430 Yeah, absolutely. 74 00:05:04,430 --> 00:05:08,346 I think it really solidifies the relationship. And it is often, 75 00:05:08,346 --> 00:05:12,974 I think, maybe part of a business that may not be as appreciated 76 00:05:12,974 --> 00:05:17,602 as it probably should be. Of course I'm biased when I say that 77 00:05:17,602 --> 00:05:22,586 because I think a lot of maybe (and this is a little bit unfair), 78 00:05:22,586 --> 00:05:27,570 I think a lot of people who are on the, say, the strategy side 79 00:05:27,570 --> 00:05:31,130 feels, oh, they're the most important because without the strategy 80 00:05:31,130 --> 00:05:35,758 there's no clients. But on the other hand, I think we could argue 81 00:05:35,758 --> 00:05:40,030 whether if there's no clients, there's no strategy. So, it’s a really… 82 00:05:40,840 --> 00:05:45,790 It's a two-way process. It's really about conjoined response. 83 00:05:45,790 --> 00:05:52,390 I think the important thing is that you are actually working in 84 00:05:52,390 --> 00:05:57,340 partnership with business development in the investors in order 85 00:05:57,340 --> 00:06:04,490 to, as you say, they need to justify to themselves, and they need 86 00:06:04,490 --> 00:06:11,090 to justify to their IC. And you will go through periods where 87 00:06:11,090 --> 00:06:17,140 you are in a drawdown or performance isn't what is expected 88 00:06:17,140 --> 00:06:25,390 and they will come to you and you need to be able to actually explain 89 00:06:25,390 --> 00:06:32,540 to them what's going on and your thinking about when is the strategy 90 00:06:32,540 --> 00:06:35,290 working, when it's not working. So, that responsiveness 91 00:05:43,984 --> 00:05:54,464 and that sort of direct relationship with clients is something 92 00:05:54,464 --> 00:06:08,088 that I haven't done until I came to Gresham and I really, really 93 00:06:08,088 --> 00:06:20,664 appreciate it. I have to say, it's really wonderful. It's an eye-opener 94 00:06:20,664 --> 00:06:32,192 about how the business is actually, as you say, running. It's 95 00:06:32,192 --> 00:06:35,336 not just strategy. 96 00:06:36,060 --> 00:06:54,060 Well, somewhat related to this, and I have to be careful. I 97 00:06:54,060 --> 00:07:15,060 don't want to be… I don't want to say things that, you know, are 98 00:07:15,060 --> 00:07:33,060 not fair or reasonable. But I did notice over the weekend that 99 00:07:33,060 --> 00:07:54,060 suddenly there was a lot of chatter on X about one of the CTA 100 00:07:54,060 --> 00:08:12,060 ETFs out there. Actually, quite a big one - the Simplify ETF 101 00:08:12,060 --> 00:08:33,060 called CTA. I mean, it's got a great ticker. And I saw some people 102 00:08:33,060 --> 00:08:49,560 talking about it saying, what's going on here? All the positions 103 00:08:49,560 --> 00:09:07,560 are being wound down, there are only a few big positions now 104 00:09:07,560 --> 00:09:21,060 left in oil, but there was no real news. Then when you looked around 105 00:06:46,770 --> 00:07:10,332 a little bit further, you know, some of the portfolio managers 106 00:07:10,332 --> 00:07:33,894 had left Simplify recently, Mike Green one of them, and some 107 00:07:33,894 --> 00:07:57,456 of the people who worked on the business development side. But 108 00:07:57,456 --> 00:08:21,018 again, no real news, no real announcement. But then someone shared 109 00:08:21,018 --> 00:08:42,438 with me, you know, the official announcement that then came 110 00:08:42,438 --> 00:09:08,142 out a few days later saying, oh, great news, we're changing the 111 00:09:08,142 --> 00:09:20,994 strategy. We found something that's better. I bring it up because, 112 00:06:41,950 --> 00:06:54,908 partly because we just had the sub-advisor on the podcast, Altis. 113 00:06:54,908 --> 00:07:06,688 They're no longer the sub-advisors, as far as I understand. 114 00:07:06,688 --> 00:07:20,824 And as I said, they may well have found something that's much 115 00:07:20,824 --> 00:07:33,782 better. And you know, that's great for the investors, of course. 116 00:07:33,782 --> 00:07:46,740 However, two things, one, as you kind of suggested, yeah, communication 117 00:07:46,740 --> 00:07:59,698 with your investors is pretty important. So, that's one thing I 118 00:07:59,698 --> 00:08:15,012 would just mention. But the other thing is in the ETF land, we, 119 00:08:15,012 --> 00:08:27,970 I mean, obviously we have people who are great supporters of 120 00:08:27,970 --> 00:08:43,284 ETFs on the podcast. I have my biases, of course, as everybody knows. 121 00:08:43,284 --> 00:08:59,776 But one of the things that maybe one should be aware of in investing 122 00:08:59,776 --> 00:09:12,734 in these ETFs is that suddenly big changes can happen underneath 123 00:09:12,734 --> 00:09:20,980 the hood without the investors really knowing. And even if you get 124 00:06:45,650 --> 00:07:08,666 a letter a few days late saying, oh, we're changing, you know, 125 00:07:08,666 --> 00:07:27,846 that's… do you really know, then, what exactly you've invested 126 00:07:27,846 --> 00:07:54,698 in, and so on, and so forth. And I do highlight that a little 127 00:07:54,698 --> 00:08:17,714 bit, even though I may get some angry emails, because I think 128 00:08:17,714 --> 00:08:40,730 that's one difference when you go and you invest with an actual 129 00:08:40,730 --> 00:08:57,992 underlying manager where they're not suddenly going to completely 130 00:08:57,992 --> 00:09:15,254 change the strategy and certainly not without giving notice 131 00:09:15,254 --> 00:09:21,008 to the investors. 132 00:09:24,890 --> 00:09:27,326 So, yeah, I'm just putting it out there. Not necessarily… I don't 133 00:09:27,326 --> 00:09:30,574 know if you want to comment on it or not, but I just feel it's an 134 00:09:30,574 --> 00:09:32,401 important difference to highlight that when you have these 135 00:09:32,401 --> 00:09:34,228 structures that are so convenient for everyone. Well, they're 136 00:09:34,228 --> 00:09:36,461 also very convenient if you want to change the strategy completely. 137 00:09:36,461 --> 00:09:38,288 So, you know, that's my biased comment, of course. 138 00:09:38,450 --> 00:09:43,574 So, I think it is important that you know, if you are doing a 139 00:09:43,574 --> 00:09:48,332 CTA, you are actually a CTA. But I think your point about communication, 140 00:09:48,332 --> 00:09:53,090 I think my COO's favorite word is “sequencing”. If you want to implement 141 00:09:53,090 --> 00:09:57,482 a change, you speak to your clients first, you make sure that 142 00:09:57,482 --> 00:10:02,240 they're on board with it, you explain to them what you are doing, 143 00:10:02,240 --> 00:10:05,900 because changes happen. Right? You know, you raise volatility targets, 144 00:10:05,900 --> 00:10:09,560 you reduce volatility targets, you change, you start trading another 145 00:10:09,560 --> 00:10:12,854 strategy. All of these changes, you just basically need 146 00:10:12,854 --> 00:10:17,246 to keep them abreast of what you're doing, why you're doing them, 147 00:10:17,246 --> 00:10:19,442 and they will be on board. 148 00:10:19,540 --> 00:10:22,366 But listen, let's be transparent about this or whatever 149 00:10:22,366 --> 00:10:27,076 the word is. I don't think, if I went to my clients and said, oh, 150 00:10:27,076 --> 00:10:30,530 listen, we're going to go and completely change the strategy, that 151 00:10:30,530 --> 00:10:34,612 they would be on board with that. I just don't think that's going 152 00:10:34,612 --> 00:10:38,694 to happen. So, I think there are nuances here where you need to 153 00:10:38,694 --> 00:10:42,776 be careful in terms of what you mean by changes - small tweaks, 154 00:10:42,776 --> 00:10:44,032 small improvement, for sure. 155 00:10:44,520 --> 00:10:47,650 Actually, I don't know what's happening. It completely went under 156 00:10:47,650 --> 00:10:52,032 my radar. So. Yeah, I haven't heard of this so, I have no good 157 00:10:52,032 --> 00:10:55,475 comment about that. But yes, a CTA is normally a CTA. 158 00:10:55,580 --> 00:11:05,768 Yeah, well, and anyways. All right, let's leave it at that. The 159 00:11:05,768 --> 00:11:14,258 other thing I noticed, and this was something someone mentioned, 160 00:11:14,258 --> 00:11:25,295 you know, just a comment, but I did find the source story, which 161 00:11:25,295 --> 00:11:37,181 was in Hedge Week. This Bobby Jain had been in the news about him 162 00:11:37,181 --> 00:11:48,218 setting up his own fund, etc., etc. And then later on, I think, 163 00:11:48,218 --> 00:11:57,557 he moved into the Millennium stable and is managing money for 164 00:11:57,557 --> 00:11:58,406 them. But there was this little notice out in Hedge Week saying 165 00:11:04,325 --> 00:11:13,070 that the firm's gross gains since launch equate to roughly 34% 166 00:11:13,070 --> 00:11:21,020 of the capital raised, while investors received about 8.4% in 167 00:11:21,020 --> 00:11:29,765 net gains over that period. And I thought, hmmm, that's kind 168 00:11:29,765 --> 00:11:39,305 of interesting. And I know there's a lot of caveats. I'm sure 169 00:11:39,305 --> 00:11:48,845 there's a lot of information in detail, but still, those are the 170 00:11:48,845 --> 00:11:57,590 kind of headlines that don't make some of these strategies look 171 00:11:57,590 --> 00:11:58,385 great. 172 00:11:59,969 --> 00:12:04,688 I think that was part of the rationale for the merger with Millennium. 173 00:12:04,688 --> 00:12:09,407 Right? So, the idea is, these days, setting up a multi strat is 174 00:12:09,407 --> 00:12:14,126 an expensive business, both in terms of data and in terms of infrastructure, 175 00:12:14,126 --> 00:12:18,845 let alone expenses of what you pay as a passthrough to your underlying 176 00:12:18,845 --> 00:12:23,201 pods. So, there's a lot of friction, let's put it this way. 177 00:12:23,201 --> 00:12:28,283 And I think it makes sense for him to have merged with the Millennium 178 00:12:28,283 --> 00:12:28,646 operation. 179 00:12:28,710 --> 00:12:30,588 No, it certainly sounds like it. 180 00:12:30,590 --> 00:12:34,298 And hopefully they will get a higher share of the gross profits 181 00:12:34,298 --> 00:12:35,225 as a result. 182 00:12:36,030 --> 00:12:41,622 Yeah, let's hope for that. Anyways, it is time to announce the 183 00:12:41,622 --> 00:12:46,282 winner of the review competition, and who gets the TTU 184 00:12:46,282 --> 00:12:46,748 merch. 185 00:12:46,750 --> 00:12:47,870 Should I do the drum roll? 186 00:12:47,870 --> 00:13:18,515 I did not see any reviews from you, Yoav. But the good news is you 187 00:13:18,515 --> 00:13:36,902 already have a very prestigious TTU vest already. But 188 00:13:36,902 --> 00:14:03,461 before we get into the usual trend update and topics, let me just… 189 00:14:03,461 --> 00:14:32,063 Allow me a few minutes just to talk a little bit about that. So, 190 00:14:32,063 --> 00:14:54,536 for people who know nothing about what I'm talking about, it 191 00:14:54,536 --> 00:15:19,052 is because we had, in my opinion, one of the best conversations 192 00:15:19,052 --> 00:15:41,525 about kind of trend and why these strategies make sense, between 193 00:15:41,525 --> 00:16:06,041 Dave Dredge and Rich Brennan, towards the end of July, I think 194 00:16:06,041 --> 00:16:14,213 the episode came out. It really is a must listen in my completely 195 00:13:15,599 --> 00:13:52,571 biased opinion, but we said, you know, this is great. For those 196 00:13:52,571 --> 00:14:23,381 who leave a really good review, which of course supports 197 00:14:23,381 --> 00:15:00,353 the podcast, let's give out one of these vests which, you know, 198 00:15:00,353 --> 00:15:34,244 right now is really only something that I created for the 199 00:15:34,244 --> 00:16:11,216 wonderful people who work with the podcasts and of course all the 200 00:16:11,216 --> 00:16:14,297 co-hosts. But of course, once I start looking at these submissions 201 00:13:11,060 --> 00:13:38,888 and the reviews, it becomes very hard just to pick one because 202 00:13:38,888 --> 00:14:06,716 there were some really kind ones in between. So, I decided to 203 00:14:06,716 --> 00:14:36,863 pick a handful. So, the good news is that the winners are (and 204 00:14:36,863 --> 00:15:07,010 I will email you if you are among them and we'll figure things 205 00:15:07,010 --> 00:15:32,519 out), but the winners are Todd, Adam, Anton, Tim and Nikolai. 206 00:15:32,519 --> 00:15:58,028 So, those are the five winners. And yeah, first of all, 207 00:15:58,028 --> 00:16:14,261 thanks for submitting some really wonderful reviews. I don't 208 00:12:51,146 --> 00:13:15,716 think I'm going to read them. I mean it would be, you know, a little 209 00:13:15,716 --> 00:13:33,734 bit too embarrassing for myself. But they are quite nice and 210 00:13:33,734 --> 00:13:58,304 positive so, no need for that. But I also want to say a huge thank 211 00:13:58,304 --> 00:14:21,236 you to all of those who left reviews and who did not win this 212 00:14:21,236 --> 00:14:42,530 time around because it really does mean a lot. And it's also a 213 00:14:42,530 --> 00:15:05,462 way to show (as I always end up episode saying), it's a way for 214 00:15:05,462 --> 00:15:23,480 you to show the appreciation for all the wonderful co-hosts that 215 00:15:23,480 --> 00:15:39,860 spend a lot of time in preparing for these conversations. 216 00:15:39,860 --> 00:16:02,792 So, there we are, some great news and we will have five more people 217 00:16:02,792 --> 00:16:14,258 around the world wearing the TTU vests. Anyways, back to the regular 218 00:12:55,745 --> 00:13:11,495 programming as they say. So, performance was pretty broad based 219 00:13:11,495 --> 00:13:27,245 in August, which is important. Of course, contributions from equities 220 00:13:27,245 --> 00:13:44,570 and metals did the heavy lifting but actually there were quite 221 00:13:44,570 --> 00:13:58,745 a few sectors that participated which is pretty good. 222 00:13:58,745 --> 00:14:14,495 And I was actually curious from your perspective. You obviously 223 00:14:14,495 --> 00:14:28,670 trade some alternative fixed income markets, for example, that 224 00:14:28,670 --> 00:14:47,570 I have no exposure to and don't really follow. But you know, 225 00:14:47,570 --> 00:15:04,895 interest rates are certainly part of the conversation at the moment. 226 00:15:04,895 --> 00:15:28,520 And I was just curious, Yoav, if you could give us a sense of where 227 00:15:28,520 --> 00:15:45,845 are yields around the world, sort of broadly speaking, where are 228 00:15:45,845 --> 00:16:04,745 they? Because we always only really talk about the US but that's 229 00:16:04,745 --> 00:16:14,195 just one out of many countries. 230 00:16:14,630 --> 00:16:19,206 I'm not going to do a full review, I think, but the stories 231 00:16:19,206 --> 00:16:23,078 the markets in our portfolio that we are watching… So, Japanese 232 00:16:23,078 --> 00:16:27,654 rates are the gift that keeps on giving, if you're sort short JGBs… 233 00:16:28,110 --> 00:16:36,146 Where are 10-year JGB yields now, roughly? 234 00:16:36,230 --> 00:16:41,664 Roughly 2.8% if you're in the swap book, the bond book is slightly 235 00:16:41,664 --> 00:16:46,262 different. But you know, it's the long dated which is actually 236 00:16:46,262 --> 00:16:50,442 at an all-time high. So, really quite impressive. Canada got 237 00:16:50,442 --> 00:16:55,458 affected by the tariffs so, we are seeing changes there as well, 238 00:16:55,458 --> 00:17:00,474 actually on the long side. And then Malaysia, there's a little bit 239 00:17:00,474 --> 00:17:05,908 of a story, and China. But really, I think Japan is the sort 240 00:17:05,908 --> 00:17:10,088 of the main worry at the moment because they're financing 241 00:17:10,088 --> 00:17:15,522 the debt. They've always been easy to finance the debt at 0% but 242 00:17:15,522 --> 00:17:21,374 now that the GDP… the debt to GDP ratio has always been high, it’s 243 00:17:21,374 --> 00:17:26,390 at 250% or thereabouts. Now that yields, the long end is sort 244 00:17:26,390 --> 00:17:30,570 of approaching the 4% level, that's really kind of painful. 245 00:17:31,550 --> 00:17:35,590 Yeah, it certainly changes the appetite for foreign bonds, like 246 00:17:35,590 --> 00:17:40,842 US bonds, I would imagine, in that sense. And the other thing I 247 00:17:40,842 --> 00:17:45,286 noticed, for the month of August, is that I think, relatively 248 00:17:45,286 --> 00:17:50,134 speaking, even though there was a little bit of, how should I 249 00:17:50,134 --> 00:17:54,982 say, news that affected the fixed income markets in the US with 250 00:17:54,982 --> 00:17:59,022 Scott Bessent's announcements. I mean, generally I think fixed income 251 00:17:59,022 --> 00:18:03,466 exposure in the CTA land was really relatively stable. Maybe equities 252 00:18:03,466 --> 00:18:08,314 exposure reduced a little bit because of you know, a slightly weaker 253 00:18:08,314 --> 00:18:13,566 momentum, if I can call it that. But, on the other hand, given 254 00:18:13,566 --> 00:18:18,414 the new conflicts, you know, coming back again in the Middle East 255 00:18:18,414 --> 00:18:23,262 we have seen some firmer, I think, exposures in the energy sector. 256 00:18:23,262 --> 00:18:29,322 At least that's kind of how I see it at the moment. But as you 257 00:18:29,322 --> 00:18:32,958 say, there probably were a few single markets that… 258 00:18:34,740 --> 00:18:39,010 Well actually, in commodities we're seeing, across the board, very 259 00:18:39,010 --> 00:18:42,853 strong performance. The book is relatively long elsewhere, everywhere, 260 00:18:42,853 --> 00:18:47,123 and we're seeing things in anything from agriculturals, we are 261 00:18:47,123 --> 00:18:50,966 seeing it in electricity, we're seeing good performance in 262 00:18:50,966 --> 00:18:55,663 freight. It's been a very strong month. And the nice thing 263 00:18:55,663 --> 00:19:00,787 is about the cross sectional, the fact that pretty much every sector 264 00:19:00,787 --> 00:19:06,765 seems to be sort of earning its keep so to speak. So yeah, very 265 00:19:06,765 --> 00:19:07,192 good. 266 00:19:08,991 --> 00:19:31,351 Fantastic, good stuff. So anyways, as of yesterday my trend 267 00:19:31,351 --> 00:19:53,711 barometer finished at 52. That's a pretty strong reading and 268 00:19:53,711 --> 00:20:25,015 that is very much in line with what we see in terms of performance. 269 00:20:25,015 --> 00:20:54,083 I'm not going to talk about the first couple of days of September, 270 00:20:54,083 --> 00:21:09,735 but the August numbers were as follows. BTOP 50 up 2.95% for the 271 00:19:22,167 --> 00:19:50,715 month, up 11.14% for the year. SocGen CT Index up 2.49% for the 272 00:19:50,715 --> 00:20:19,263 month, up 10.79% for the year. SocGen Trend up 2.77% for the month 273 00:20:19,263 --> 00:20:45,615 and up 10.9% for the year. And even the Short-Term Traders Index, 274 00:20:45,615 --> 00:21:09,771 very strong month 2.44%, and up 5.7% so far this year. Now in 275 00:19:12,825 --> 00:19:31,995 the traditional world, MSCI World up 2.48% (that is actually 276 00:19:31,995 --> 00:19:54,999 as of last night), and up 12.13% year to date. The… (where 277 00:19:54,999 --> 00:20:18,003 are we?)… the US Aggregate Bond index is down 20 basis points 278 00:20:18,003 --> 00:20:44,841 and down 40 basis points for the year. And the S&P 500 so far 279 00:20:44,841 --> 00:21:07,845 in September down 25 basis points, and up 11.99% so far this 280 00:21:07,845 --> 00:21:09,762 year. Now, we actually had three questions come in for you, 281 00:19:26,241 --> 00:19:50,391 Yoav, so let me try and do that. The first one is from Jose 282 00:19:50,391 --> 00:20:09,366 and a good supporter of the podcast, so appreciate that. Now 283 00:20:09,366 --> 00:20:33,516 he did boil the question down to just a few lines. So, I'm only 284 00:20:33,516 --> 00:20:54,216 going to read out the few lines because there was a longer 285 00:20:54,216 --> 00:21:09,741 explanation to it. Anyways, the question is as follows. Does 286 00:19:12,169 --> 00:19:43,949 trend following pay too much attention to correlation and not 287 00:19:43,949 --> 00:20:12,551 enough to variance and covariance at the instrument level? 288 00:20:12,551 --> 00:20:44,331 Given that correlation tells us how stocks spread, while variance 289 00:20:44,331 --> 00:21:09,755 might show where stress is becoming most acute? 290 00:21:10,731 --> 00:21:48,600 Oh, that's a great question. I've got to tell you, as a mathematician, 291 00:21:48,600 --> 00:22:20,643 I love variance. I love correlation. We love them both. You 292 00:22:20,643 --> 00:22:58,512 know, we have no privileged children in our book, so I just want 293 00:22:58,512 --> 00:23:39,294 to highlight where each one of them is fitted. At the end of the 294 00:23:39,294 --> 00:24:14,250 day, correlation is important in terms of how it feeds into the 295 00:24:14,250 --> 00:24:20,076 covariance, actually. So, a lot of the CTAs, most of our trading 296 00:21:59,291 --> 00:22:52,707 strategies are univariate, i.e. You look at the price of the 297 00:22:52,707 --> 00:23:46,123 asset to predict that asset. Right? So, it's not necessarily cross 298 00:23:46,123 --> 00:24:20,115 sectionally. So, correlation features in several places. Let's 299 00:21:11,858 --> 00:21:26,509 take the easy one which is volatility. So, we look at a single 300 00:21:26,509 --> 00:21:40,033 market, we would basically like to trade in units of risk. We 301 00:21:40,033 --> 00:21:53,557 obstruct the asset and we say okay, given our position, what is 302 00:21:53,557 --> 00:22:10,462 the number of units of risk? And we like to work in sort of units 303 00:22:10,462 --> 00:22:22,859 of risk. So, we would generally both scale the signal in 304 00:22:22,859 --> 00:22:38,637 terms of Z scoring the trend. So, we will take the trend but then 305 00:22:38,637 --> 00:22:56,669 divide it by the volatility of the asset to get a sort of a Z score. 306 00:22:56,669 --> 00:23:07,939 But we would also, more importantly, we would actually divide 307 00:23:07,939 --> 00:23:19,209 our position by volatility. Not just volatility, by the way, 308 00:23:19,209 --> 00:23:32,733 FX, or the size of each contract, just to make sure that 309 00:23:32,733 --> 00:23:47,384 we get a constant unit of risk. So, if you're holding a bond, 310 00:23:47,384 --> 00:24:02,035 in my case, it's the duration of the bond, which is important and 311 00:24:02,035 --> 00:24:15,559 it's just sort of the measure of risk. So, that's what volatility 312 00:24:15,559 --> 00:24:20,067 is usually used for. Correlation in your portfolio is 313 00:21:30,056 --> 00:22:16,436 used in multiple places. I mean, the first place is really about 314 00:22:16,436 --> 00:23:02,816 the overall portfolio risk. Right? So, if I've got all the individual 315 00:23:02,816 --> 00:23:53,061 assets and I've normalized them so that each of them is a unit 316 00:23:53,061 --> 00:24:20,116 risk, what is the overall portfolio volatility? And that's 317 00:21:16,939 --> 00:21:47,979 really an important question because most CTAs would manage their 318 00:21:47,979 --> 00:22:28,331 book to have a certain level of volatility per day or per annum. 319 00:22:28,331 --> 00:23:11,787 So, say, 15% per annum, maybe 1% per day. And you have to look 320 00:23:11,787 --> 00:23:45,931 at the correlation right now between the markets to size that 321 00:23:45,931 --> 00:24:16,971 position appropriately. So, that's why we kind of care about 322 00:24:16,971 --> 00:24:20,075 correlation. But the other aspect of it is that also gives us 323 00:21:33,875 --> 00:21:59,123 the diversification. So, if we think of the portfolio, and we have 324 00:21:59,123 --> 00:22:15,955 100 assets, and the correlation takes the volatility 325 00:22:15,955 --> 00:22:43,307 down from, you know, instead of being 100 units of risk to 10 326 00:22:43,307 --> 00:23:12,763 units of risk, then what we have done is we have reduced by 10x 327 00:23:12,763 --> 00:23:31,699 our volatility, but our expectation has changed, has stayed 328 00:23:31,699 --> 00:23:54,843 the same. So, the square root of the variance, the volatility, 329 00:23:54,843 --> 00:24:15,883 that portfolio diversification is what actually gives us the performance 330 00:24:15,883 --> 00:24:20,091 of CTAs. So that's why we kind of care about it. It's not so much 331 00:21:55,490 --> 00:22:40,249 that we use it as a predictor between two assets, it's really thinking 332 00:22:40,249 --> 00:23:28,451 about where the risk is of the overall portfolio and how do we manage 333 00:23:28,451 --> 00:24:09,767 that to give the investor the return that he wants, the volatility 334 00:24:09,767 --> 00:24:20,096 that he wants. 335 00:24:20,921 --> 00:24:26,441 All right, the next question is from Vladimir. Vladimir writes, 336 00:24:26,441 --> 00:24:32,513 when a systematic process permits a human risk veto, what evidence 337 00:24:32,513 --> 00:24:38,033 should be preserved so the override can be judged separately 338 00:24:38,033 --> 00:24:43,553 from the original signal? For example, would you keep distinct 339 00:24:43,553 --> 00:24:49,625 records for a model forecast that authorized a position, the order 340 00:24:49,625 --> 00:24:55,145 that reached the broker, and the later outcome? Combining them 341 00:24:55,145 --> 00:25:01,217 may hide whether the model failed, the control level layer intervened, 342 00:25:01,217 --> 00:25:06,185 or execution changed the result. Separating them may also 343 00:25:06,185 --> 00:25:09,497 invite too much post trade interpretation. I would value your 344 00:24:29,753 --> 00:24:49,625 view on where the record keeping becomes useful governance 345 00:24:49,625 --> 00:25:09,497 rather than an unnecessary complexity. That's a good question. 346 00:25:10,311 --> 00:25:13,379 So, one thing is that we don't really intervene that much. So, it 347 00:25:13,379 --> 00:25:15,739 really is important to understand that we're not being paid 348 00:25:15,739 --> 00:25:19,043 to be risk managers… not to be risk managers, to make a macro call, 349 00:25:19,043 --> 00:25:22,111 to make judgment. That's not what we are paid for. We are paid 350 00:25:22,111 --> 00:25:24,943 to monitor the risk and make sure that the risk is correct. 351 00:25:25,751 --> 00:26:25,759 And most of risk intervention that we do is to avoid left tail 352 00:26:25,759 --> 00:27:25,767 and actually cost money to the investor. So, we do it very rarely. 353 00:27:25,767 --> 00:28:07,311 But actually, for your question, it's important to understand 354 00:28:07,311 --> 00:28:39,623 that even the risk intervention is systemized. And what 355 00:25:31,537 --> 00:26:09,146 I mean by that is we would never then tell the traders, oh, 356 00:26:09,146 --> 00:26:43,862 don't trade this. What we would do is, there are levels that 357 00:26:43,862 --> 00:27:15,685 we already set within the simulation that will tell the system, 358 00:27:15,685 --> 00:27:47,508 don't increase this position, right. So, the system can load from 359 00:27:47,508 --> 00:28:22,224 a database an intervention, and then it will trade the way it 360 00:28:22,224 --> 00:28:39,582 trades, it's incorporated into the code. So, it's never a case that 361 00:25:34,559 --> 00:25:47,771 we manually override something. We program into the system, 362 00:25:47,771 --> 00:25:56,579 into the simulation interventions, the interventions 363 00:25:56,579 --> 00:26:14,195 that we are likely to do: reduce the risk of the portfolio, 364 00:26:14,195 --> 00:26:30,343 reduce the risk of a certain asset, stop trading, stop increasing, 365 00:26:30,343 --> 00:26:47,959 all of these. You pre-program it, so, you're always able to play 366 00:26:47,959 --> 00:27:05,575 back because the process is, I think there is the Hormuz crisis 367 00:27:05,575 --> 00:27:21,723 in Iran, so I think maybe we shouldn't increase the positions 368 00:27:21,723 --> 00:27:42,275 in oil. It will go through the CRO, we will get an approval, and 369 00:27:42,275 --> 00:27:59,891 then we would basically add a new line into the database which 370 00:27:59,891 --> 00:28:14,571 is this intervention. That would be loaded by the simulation, 371 00:28:14,571 --> 00:28:30,719 and the simulation would know not to increase positions in oil. 372 00:28:30,719 --> 00:28:39,527 That's kind of how it works. It is really important, as you say, 373 00:25:44,336 --> 00:26:08,231 in terms of governance and later auditing what's happening. 374 00:26:08,231 --> 00:26:37,436 We definitely also monitor, by the way, the execution. So, sometimes 375 00:26:37,436 --> 00:27:14,606 if you get a partial fill, we need to know about it. Any drift 376 00:27:14,606 --> 00:27:43,811 between the simulation and the actual position we have to monitor. 377 00:27:43,811 --> 00:28:18,326 And we need to understand how much risk that amount is, and what 378 00:28:18,326 --> 00:28:39,566 happened to that, and why that is happening. So, all of these are 379 00:25:38,021 --> 00:26:02,561 really important. But I think it's important to understand that 380 00:26:02,561 --> 00:26:32,009 the simulation is a tool that does many things and it's important 381 00:26:32,009 --> 00:27:03,911 to separate what they do. And for each question that you ask, it 382 00:27:03,911 --> 00:27:38,267 will be a different answer. So, like we ask, we look at the simulation 383 00:27:38,267 --> 00:28:10,169 as one way to look at the simulation is to generate what should 384 00:28:10,169 --> 00:28:37,163 be my position today? Okay, that's really important part of the 385 00:28:37,163 --> 00:28:39,617 simulation. But we also use a statistical question which is, you 386 00:25:50,291 --> 00:26:17,285 know, does this code change actually makes sense? And there you 387 00:26:17,285 --> 00:26:39,371 have to answer separate questions. There is a difference 388 00:26:39,371 --> 00:27:08,819 between, is there gross alpha in this signal? And, is there difference 389 00:27:08,819 --> 00:27:25,997 between is correlation calculation correct? And there's 390 00:27:25,997 --> 00:27:52,991 a difference between what is the trading cost? Can we actually 391 00:27:52,991 --> 00:28:17,531 bear the costs of a particular, say, fast trend predictor 392 00:28:17,531 --> 00:28:39,617 with this market? All of these questions are separate. The simulation 393 00:25:34,767 --> 00:26:37,879 is not just one tool. It is designed so that you can tweak it 394 00:26:37,879 --> 00:27:36,483 and you set up the parameters of the simulation to answer the specific 395 00:27:36,483 --> 00:28:21,563 question that you want to answer. And that's something that 396 00:28:21,563 --> 00:28:39,595 people don't really appreciate. 397 00:28:40,191 --> 00:28:46,197 Yeah. And of course, all firms do it differently. I think for a 398 00:28:46,197 --> 00:28:51,741 long time, I think generally there was a school of thought among 399 00:28:51,741 --> 00:28:56,823 established CTAs that it was very rare that you would intervene, 400 00:28:56,823 --> 00:29:00,519 however, and I mean discretionarily change things. I 401 00:29:00,519 --> 00:29:06,987 know for sure we certainly don't do it over at DUNN. But I do 402 00:29:06,987 --> 00:29:12,531 know that some managers came out after, say, COVID and were very 403 00:29:12,531 --> 00:29:18,537 open about it, said that yeah, we did intervene, and we did reduce 404 00:29:18,537 --> 00:29:25,467 the risk, and so on, and so forth. But I think as long as people 405 00:29:25,467 --> 00:29:31,011 are transparent about it and, as you say, probably a good idea 406 00:29:31,011 --> 00:29:37,941 to, you know, pay attention to it, and log it, and all of that stuff, 407 00:29:37,941 --> 00:29:39,327 it makes sense. All right, final question from Bandassian. You 408 00:28:52,378 --> 00:29:06,306 talked about different market participants leaving different footprints 409 00:29:06,306 --> 00:29:25,457 along the curve. Where today can you most clearly see hedges, 410 00:29:25,457 --> 00:29:39,385 CTAs and discretionary macro players fighting each other? 411 00:29:41,161 --> 00:29:55,058 Oh, I love this question. And the reason is because this is follow 412 00:29:55,058 --> 00:30:11,093 up for the question last time that I was on TTU. And I think it 413 00:30:11,093 --> 00:30:21,783 was Marcus who asked exactly this question about different points 414 00:30:21,783 --> 00:30:35,680 on the curve. And I think we also have a paper exactly addressing 415 00:30:35,680 --> 00:30:47,439 this question. But I'll just answer it generally. It really depends 416 00:30:47,439 --> 00:30:58,129 on the commodity market and the liquidity in the market. In general, 417 00:29:42,465 --> 00:29:50,941 where you will find most of the macros, and the CTAs, and what 418 00:29:50,941 --> 00:29:58,765 I would call the financial players, you will find them in the 419 00:29:58,765 --> 00:30:06,589 front contract. This is the one which is most liquid. You will 420 00:30:06,589 --> 00:30:13,109 see physical players playing in the spot market. So actually, 421 00:30:13,109 --> 00:30:20,281 cash, cotton, or cash wheat, or cash whatever. And then there 422 00:30:20,281 --> 00:30:26,801 will be producers and consumers that will be hedging out 423 00:30:26,801 --> 00:30:34,625 or further out the opposition, further out on the curve. So, if 424 00:30:34,625 --> 00:30:42,449 I'm an oil producer, I'm likely to sort of forward sell my 425 00:30:42,449 --> 00:30:49,621 oil sort of towards three years, five year points. So, that's 426 00:30:49,621 --> 00:30:57,445 kind of the broad, a broad brush stroke picture of who's playing 427 00:30:57,445 --> 00:30:58,097 what. 428 00:30:58,551 --> 00:31:04,115 Okay, very good. All right, now we are back into the topics that 429 00:31:04,115 --> 00:31:10,107 we usually bring up and there are a couple of main papers I think 430 00:31:10,107 --> 00:31:16,527 we want to talk about. And I, as I mentioned to you, to be completely 431 00:31:16,527 --> 00:31:21,235 transparent about it, it has month end, we're recording very early 432 00:31:21,235 --> 00:31:26,799 in September, so it's been pretty busy on my side. So, I'm going 433 00:31:26,799 --> 00:31:31,935 to let you lead the way through both papers here. But the 434 00:31:31,935 --> 00:31:37,499 first one is of course a classic, if you have come from the 435 00:31:37,499 --> 00:31:42,635 trend following world, and let me just point out there was another 436 00:31:42,635 --> 00:31:43,491 Dane involved. 437 00:31:43,571 --> 00:31:44,771 Absolutely. I love him. 438 00:31:45,331 --> 00:31:50,059 So that makes it even more special. Maybe we should ask him 439 00:31:50,059 --> 00:31:54,787 to join the podcast one day if he's interested. Anyways, we are 440 00:31:54,787 --> 00:31:59,121 of course talking about a century of evidence on trend following 441 00:31:59,121 --> 00:32:03,061 investing, a very famous paper. I know Lasse Pedersen was 442 00:32:03,061 --> 00:32:06,607 involved. Who are the other authors? Do you remember? 443 00:32:06,711 --> 00:32:10,068 Oh, I can't remember. You know, people from AQR. 444 00:32:10,711 --> 00:32:11,191 Yes. 445 00:32:11,991 --> 00:32:14,671 Which is really embarrassing because I really should know who 446 00:32:14,671 --> 00:32:16,547 the people are, but I don't remember. 447 00:32:16,551 --> 00:32:17,907 I think Hurst was another one. 448 00:32:18,071 --> 00:32:20,861 There's Brian Hurst and there's a Yao Hua Ooi. 449 00:32:21,331 --> 00:32:26,059 Yes, I think those are the three. Yes. Anyways, over to you 450 00:32:26,059 --> 00:32:26,847 my friend. 451 00:32:26,851 --> 00:33:30,299 Oh yes. So, this is a classic paper, and it came out, and it's 452 00:33:30,299 --> 00:34:24,683 really like one of those papers that come out and you think, 453 00:34:24,683 --> 00:35:23,599 damn, I really wish I wrote it myself because they've done a great 454 00:35:23,599 --> 00:36:04,387 amount of work. They've basically taken, created a 137-year 455 00:36:04,387 --> 00:36:13,451 data set. They've looked at monthly returns across like 67 global 456 00:32:44,743 --> 00:33:00,647 markets, major asset classes, commodities, equities, bonds, and 457 00:33:00,647 --> 00:33:20,527 FX later on. And they've literally hand collected from CBOT. 458 00:33:20,527 --> 00:33:40,407 They've hand collected a lot of historical commodity data with 459 00:33:40,407 --> 00:34:00,287 the explicit aim to check whether trend following works. Right? 460 00:34:00,287 --> 00:34:24,143 So, I think in 2012 Lasse Pedersen came up with his paper, 461 00:34:24,143 --> 00:34:47,999 the famous one. And this one is like, basically, let's go back 462 00:34:47,999 --> 00:35:11,855 and see, is it a recent phenomenon or is it something which 463 00:35:11,855 --> 00:35:35,711 goes back throughout history? And it’s not going to be a surprise 464 00:35:35,711 --> 00:35:59,567 to you that trend following is one of the most consistent across 465 00:35:59,567 --> 00:36:13,483 all asset classes and across all decades. They've gone back to 466 00:32:35,483 --> 00:32:59,221 1880 and guess what? Every decade was a positive return from 467 00:32:59,221 --> 00:33:27,275 1880 to 2016. But they've also looked at other things that are important 468 00:33:27,275 --> 00:33:48,855 for trend followers. They've looked at basically the smile, the 469 00:33:48,855 --> 00:34:08,277 crisis alpha, they've looked at stock bond diversification. And 470 00:34:08,277 --> 00:34:34,173 what they found is that pretty much in any environment, any micro 471 00:34:34,173 --> 00:34:57,911 regime, whether it is in high inflation, low inflation, or whether 472 00:34:57,911 --> 00:35:25,965 it's a boom or a bust, whether even through major wars, trend following 473 00:35:25,965 --> 00:35:51,861 just seems to work. Obviously in any given year, any given asset, 474 00:35:51,861 --> 00:36:13,441 there will be losses, but overall, it's an amazing result. 475 00:32:26,851 --> 00:33:08,932 And the reason I'm putting out this paper is because it's been essentially 476 00:33:08,932 --> 00:33:44,539 10 years since they've done it. So, we've got another decade 477 00:33:44,539 --> 00:34:33,094 in the mix. And I thought, oh, let's have a look. By the way, there 478 00:34:33,094 --> 00:35:05,464 have been papers afterwards that have criticized it, which we 479 00:35:05,464 --> 00:35:44,308 can address as well. But I think one of the important aspects 480 00:35:44,308 --> 00:36:13,441 is the sheer body of evidence supporting trend. Right? So, I think 481 00:32:35,914 --> 00:33:12,166 my colleague Tom Babbage, he wrote a blog recently (he's an astronomer), 482 00:33:12,166 --> 00:33:45,397 and he's looking at the way that you examine distant galaxies, 483 00:33:45,397 --> 00:34:24,670 and you have an image which is very noisy and it's very difficult 484 00:34:24,670 --> 00:35:06,964 to detect the actual star. But what you do is you take many, many, 485 00:35:06,964 --> 00:35:34,153 many photos from different places and over different times. 486 00:35:34,153 --> 00:36:07,384 And over time the noise disappears and cancels out and the 487 00:36:07,384 --> 00:36:13,426 phenomenon appears. And that's exactly how trend works. We've got 488 00:32:44,979 --> 00:33:07,639 an individual asset any individual year. The Sharpe is not 489 00:33:07,639 --> 00:33:32,565 great. In fact, the noise level, the signal to noise ratio 490 00:33:32,565 --> 00:33:59,757 is very similar for distant star and trend following is a signal. 491 00:33:59,757 --> 00:34:29,215 But as you diversify, in terms of the asset classes and in terms 492 00:34:29,215 --> 00:34:58,673 of the years, a clear picture emerges. And I think that's a really 493 00:34:58,673 --> 00:35:25,865 beautiful analogy that Tom uses. And it held up the good news, 494 00:35:25,865 --> 00:35:48,525 it held up another positive performance this decade. So, we've 495 00:35:48,525 --> 00:36:13,451 seen another 10 years have passed and trend has held up. 2017 496 00:32:30,506 --> 00:33:14,366 was an outstanding year. But there have been good years also during 497 00:33:14,366 --> 00:33:54,571 the COVID time. There have been good years during the Ukraine 498 00:33:54,571 --> 00:34:27,466 crisis, during inflation crisis, pretty much in all regimes. 499 00:34:27,466 --> 00:35:00,361 Trend has actually done decently, and it's really delivered 500 00:35:00,361 --> 00:35:55,186 on what it was supposed to do. But I think it's, we can go deeper, 501 00:35:55,186 --> 00:36:13,461 not just in terms of… 502 00:36:13,581 --> 00:36:33,853 Yeah, I'd love to go deeper. Let me try and interject just a few 503 00:36:33,853 --> 00:36:49,781 things and thoughts that spring to mind. I mean, now, it's 504 00:36:49,781 --> 00:37:07,157 good to know that since 2016, when the paper data series ended, 505 00:37:07,157 --> 00:37:25,981 that the next 10 years have been fine. But we have also been, 506 00:37:25,981 --> 00:37:41,909 you know, “criticized” as an industry for lower returns in the 507 00:37:41,909 --> 00:38:00,733 last 20, 25 years compared to the ‘70s, the ‘80s. We've been, obviously, 508 00:38:00,733 --> 00:38:18,109 the 2010s, people kind of picked that and said, oh, that it 509 00:38:18,109 --> 00:38:31,141 doesn't work anymore, and so on, and so forth. Now, I know that 510 00:36:21,121 --> 00:36:41,856 we interchange trend following with CTA and of course that's not 511 00:36:41,856 --> 00:37:00,706 exactly the same. The paper obviously talks about trend following, 512 00:37:00,706 --> 00:37:23,326 so that is different from “the CTA indices” that some people follow. 513 00:37:23,326 --> 00:37:49,716 And I don't know if this is true or not, but even within “trend 514 00:37:49,716 --> 00:38:06,681 following programs”, maybe there's a little bit of non-trend 515 00:38:06,681 --> 00:38:29,301 that has snuck in during the periods where trend didn't work so 516 00:38:29,301 --> 00:38:31,186 well. But you know, now that we sit in 2026, 10 years later from 517 00:36:27,439 --> 00:36:38,099 the paper, some of that criticism about returns being lower, 518 00:36:38,099 --> 00:36:51,957 and so on, and so forth, is that in your opinion (without it 519 00:36:51,957 --> 00:37:04,749 being too much of a leading question), is that because… and I 520 00:37:04,749 --> 00:37:16,475 brought this up in my last conversation with Tom and Andrew, 521 00:37:16,475 --> 00:37:29,267 that maybe the indices we're tracking are not really a great indication 522 00:37:29,267 --> 00:37:39,927 of the true performance because all the bad strategies that 523 00:37:39,927 --> 00:37:50,587 eventually disappear from the index are simply dragging the returns 524 00:37:50,587 --> 00:38:03,379 down. Which is why I would say, you know, investors should really 525 00:38:03,379 --> 00:38:17,237 try and find managers that are able to outperform the index. I mean 526 00:38:17,237 --> 00:38:28,963 we should be able to outperform the index in my opinion, 527 00:38:28,963 --> 00:38:31,095 over time. But anyways, I mean, I'm rambling a little bit here, 528 00:36:59,451 --> 00:37:59,082 but are there any thoughts, now that we sit 10 years later, towards 529 00:37:59,082 --> 00:38:31,191 some of that “criticism” that we've received? 530 00:38:31,911 --> 00:38:40,227 So, I have to say for what you're receiving, you would normally 531 00:38:40,227 --> 00:38:47,850 pay for. So, you think about trend as actually buying protection. 532 00:38:47,850 --> 00:38:55,473 It is a defensive strategy. There are very few strategies out 533 00:38:55,473 --> 00:39:02,403 there which have both a defensive nature… They have positive 534 00:39:02,403 --> 00:39:11,412 convexity, in fact, if I plot all the HFR hedge fund indices, so 535 00:39:11,412 --> 00:39:20,421 normally you would kind of pay for that. You would expect to pay. 536 00:39:20,421 --> 00:39:28,737 And in CTA land we have very strong evidence that you've made 537 00:39:28,737 --> 00:39:31,509 money over the years. So, in weird way I think CTAs are pretty 538 00:38:42,432 --> 00:38:57,629 much the only… not the only, but one of the very few phenomena 539 00:38:57,629 --> 00:39:08,150 that have been super consistent over many years. It's 540 00:39:08,150 --> 00:39:17,502 very understandable what's happening and actually provides you 541 00:39:17,502 --> 00:39:30,361 positive convexity versus sort of just tapping into sort of liquidity 542 00:39:30,361 --> 00:39:31,530 premia. 543 00:39:31,731 --> 00:39:35,595 The funny thing is here, Yoav (sorry to interrupt), the funny thing 544 00:39:35,595 --> 00:39:39,459 is that I agree with you. Normally you should pay for this. 545 00:39:39,459 --> 00:39:43,001 Right? But in our industry it's almost become like, oh, you 546 00:39:43,001 --> 00:39:47,509 don't have to pay for trend. It's so easy to do. You don't have 547 00:39:47,509 --> 00:39:51,695 to pay for it. That's kind of the funny thing because it's actually… 548 00:39:52,431 --> 00:40:14,355 No, absolutely. I think when I joined the CTA industry, the trend 549 00:40:14,355 --> 00:40:32,625 industry, then it was considered like an alpha. And of 550 00:40:32,625 --> 00:40:54,549 course, as the secret sauce has been, well, people know it and 551 00:40:54,549 --> 00:41:12,819 we are actually educating investors about it, then yeah, there 552 00:41:12,819 --> 00:41:34,743 are more entrants to the field. But I think, what really begs 553 00:41:34,743 --> 00:41:56,667 the question is that the AUM of the industry hasn't really gone 554 00:41:56,667 --> 00:41:58,494 up. So, you know, it might be that it's gone over to the pods inside 555 00:40:13,697 --> 00:40:33,444 the multi strat, and so forth, but you know, QIS products that have 556 00:40:33,444 --> 00:40:50,153 been ETFs. Absolutely, and it shows you that it's about supply 557 00:40:50,153 --> 00:41:08,381 and demand. The reason why people are not willing to pay for 558 00:41:08,381 --> 00:41:26,609 it is not because they don't think it doesn't work. It's because 559 00:41:26,609 --> 00:41:46,356 they think, oh, I can, you know, I can get it cheaper. Okay, 560 00:41:46,356 --> 00:41:58,508 which is fair. Which is a fair point. So, it's not just how good 561 00:40:01,227 --> 00:40:21,751 your product is. It's also the fact that there is a lot of competition 562 00:40:21,751 --> 00:40:40,809 for it. Right? So that's why, you know, the price of consumer electronics 563 00:40:40,809 --> 00:40:54,003 has been dropping. It's not because consumer electronics have 564 00:40:54,003 --> 00:41:11,595 been getting worse, it's just that. But you know, we're just becoming 565 00:41:11,595 --> 00:41:27,721 very good at, you know, competition. You can buy a Samsung, 566 00:41:27,721 --> 00:41:46,779 you can buy an Apple, you can buy… There are plenty of providers 567 00:41:46,779 --> 00:41:58,507 of, you know, a TV, a consumer TV. There is a genuine phenomenon 568 00:40:00,616 --> 00:40:21,897 that we've seen in the last 10 years which actually the paper sort 569 00:40:21,897 --> 00:40:43,178 of hints at. So, if you look at, historically, a decay of performance, 570 00:40:43,178 --> 00:41:02,822 there has been a decay of performance. The markets were a lot 571 00:41:02,822 --> 00:41:20,829 more liquid, the markets were a lot less efficient as mentioned 572 00:41:20,829 --> 00:41:43,747 in the good old days. So, one would expect to see, you know, one 573 00:41:43,747 --> 00:41:58,480 would expect to see some deterioration over the years. By 574 00:39:55,004 --> 00:40:33,599 the way, I'm pretty sure that if you were to run, if you were able 575 00:40:33,599 --> 00:41:01,902 to run, you know, relative value equity, some sort of long/short 576 00:41:01,902 --> 00:41:27,632 equity fund historically, which is very difficult to do, you 577 00:41:27,632 --> 00:41:53,362 would still see the same phenomenon exactly with any hedge 578 00:41:53,362 --> 00:41:58,508 fund strategy. 579 00:41:58,591 --> 00:42:01,761 But actually (sorry to interrupt again), but I just want 580 00:42:01,761 --> 00:42:05,882 to challenge that a little bit because I think that's what a lot 581 00:42:05,882 --> 00:42:09,686 of people will say. Oh yeah, just look at the returns. They're 582 00:42:09,686 --> 00:42:13,490 much lower today. Yeah, but so is the volatility. Right? I mean 583 00:42:13,490 --> 00:42:17,294 I wonder, if you vol adjust returns for the drop in volatilities… 584 00:42:17,294 --> 00:42:21,732 I mean, when I started in this industry, I mean back in the ‘80s 585 00:42:21,732 --> 00:42:26,170 we had the CTA. Even the Barclay CTA index had a vol of more 586 00:42:26,170 --> 00:42:29,340 than 20%. Right? Now it's down less than 5%. So… 587 00:42:29,751 --> 00:42:38,401 Well, personally, I mean, I measure things in Sharpe because 588 00:42:38,401 --> 00:42:47,916 we can provide pretty much any volatility that the client would 589 00:42:47,916 --> 00:43:00,026 want. Right? That's the whole point of what we do in terms of leverage. 590 00:43:00,026 --> 00:43:12,136 But what I would say is that 10 years is actually a very short 591 00:43:12,136 --> 00:43:21,651 time in terms of making a statistical decision, in a weird 592 00:43:21,651 --> 00:43:33,761 way. So, you will find if you're a new quant, if you're a young 593 00:43:33,761 --> 00:43:43,276 quant just going into the industry, they don't believe in trend 594 00:43:43,276 --> 00:43:51,926 because they haven't… The attention span is like two years. 595 00:43:51,926 --> 00:43:52,791 Okay. But the point being is that actually in order to see data 596 00:42:48,567 --> 00:43:05,815 clearly, in order to see a certain phenomenon clearly, you first 597 00:43:05,815 --> 00:43:23,063 of all need to understand the fundamentals, secondly why this is 598 00:43:23,063 --> 00:43:38,743 happening. But also, the amount of data involved is substantial, 599 00:43:38,743 --> 00:43:52,855 which I think is why this paper came about. So, I would say 600 00:42:35,479 --> 00:42:51,231 variation in performance in the last 10 years versus the historical 601 00:42:51,231 --> 00:43:06,983 (you can put it over the historical performance) is a little 602 00:43:06,983 --> 00:43:21,303 bit lower. Yeah, that's fine. Still positive, definitely. You know, 603 00:43:21,303 --> 00:43:38,487 faster… faster seems to have degraded in the last 10 years more 604 00:43:38,487 --> 00:43:52,807 than slower. Yeah, but you know, what can I say? I think the 605 00:42:42,216 --> 00:43:36,231 one thing I actually do want to go back to is the correlation 606 00:43:36,231 --> 00:43:52,851 story and the diversification. 607 00:43:53,101 --> 00:43:53,661 Okay. 608 00:43:53,741 --> 00:43:57,041 Which is the question from Jose. 609 00:43:57,201 --> 00:43:57,681 Yeah. 610 00:43:59,841 --> 00:44:12,801 One of the findings of the paper is that the system performs 611 00:44:12,801 --> 00:44:23,601 well, trend following performs well when the assets are uncorrelated. 612 00:44:23,601 --> 00:44:34,401 And that's exactly what we're talking about. The more diversified 613 00:44:34,401 --> 00:44:45,201 your portfolio is, you can lower the volatility while keeping 614 00:44:45,201 --> 00:44:57,081 the expectations and then you basically level things up to get 615 00:44:57,081 --> 00:45:08,961 a higher return. And over 130 years, the more uncorrelated your 616 00:45:08,961 --> 00:45:15,441 assets, the better your performance is. And that's something 617 00:44:02,748 --> 00:44:12,438 that people don't normally think about in CTAs. People think 618 00:44:12,438 --> 00:44:26,004 about us as crisis alpha. And in fact, we do things, we do well 619 00:44:26,004 --> 00:44:38,601 when there is a crisis alpha. And I think it's important to understand 620 00:44:38,601 --> 00:44:50,229 that the correlation of the trend P&Ls and the assets are not 621 00:44:50,229 --> 00:45:03,795 exactly the same thing. Right? So, we do like it, just like we had 622 00:45:03,795 --> 00:45:13,485 in August, when all sectors are firing for different reasons 623 00:45:13,485 --> 00:45:15,423 potentially. Right? That sort of correlation we actually like in 624 00:44:14,241 --> 00:44:32,241 terms of the performance P&L. Market correlation we don't like, 625 00:44:32,241 --> 00:44:50,241 we like low correlation because then we are actually are 626 00:44:50,241 --> 00:45:10,041 able to leverage up the portfolio and get a higher return 627 00:45:10,041 --> 00:45:15,441 for the investor. 628 00:45:15,591 --> 00:45:30,826 You know, you brought up something that, I don't think it 629 00:45:30,826 --> 00:45:46,061 was intentional as such, but actually it's a really, really important 630 00:45:46,061 --> 00:46:04,066 point and that is your entry point to this industry makes a big 631 00:46:04,066 --> 00:46:20,686 difference of whether you're a believer in trend or not, I actually 632 00:46:20,686 --> 00:46:33,151 think that. I believe that people who probably experienced, 633 00:46:33,151 --> 00:46:47,001 say, the first eight years, well, anything before 2008 probably 634 00:46:47,001 --> 00:47:02,236 say, yeah, we're a believer, we've seen it work many times. If 635 00:45:16,831 --> 00:45:34,191 you came in kind of in 2009 and you went through “the quiet period” 636 00:45:34,191 --> 00:45:50,311 with not too many years being kind of super years, I think… well, 637 00:45:50,311 --> 00:46:06,431 it's just a fact that a lot of the decision makers nowadays are 638 00:46:06,431 --> 00:46:22,551 people who've only been around for 10 or 15 years. And so, they 639 00:46:22,551 --> 00:46:37,431 are likely, I think in my opinion, to believe less in this 640 00:46:37,431 --> 00:46:52,311 strategy. Vice versa, they may be strong believers in a long equity 641 00:46:52,311 --> 00:47:02,231 type strategy because equities have been on fire. And I think also, 642 00:45:20,227 --> 00:45:34,135 even in my own case, sort of getting into the financial world 643 00:45:34,135 --> 00:45:48,043 in the mid-‘80s, you know, the whole 2000, sorry, 1987 crash certainly 644 00:45:48,043 --> 00:45:59,633 probably made me much more cautious overall. Even though people 645 00:45:59,633 --> 00:46:11,223 might think, well that's crazy, he's involved in trend following, 646 00:46:11,223 --> 00:46:23,972 how can he be cautious? Well, actually I think trend following 647 00:46:23,972 --> 00:46:37,880 is a very well risk managed strategy. We are risk managers first 648 00:46:37,880 --> 00:46:51,788 and foremost. So, I feel much safer in a long/short, fully diversified 649 00:46:51,788 --> 00:47:02,219 strategy than I do in a long only strategy. 650 00:47:03,571 --> 00:47:18,465 Absolutely. I think if you look at the variability in volatility 651 00:47:18,465 --> 00:47:32,005 in equity markets, it's enormous. Right? You can go through 652 00:47:32,005 --> 00:47:46,899 very quiet periods and then volatility spikes up. We get paid 653 00:47:46,899 --> 00:48:04,501 for that. And I think it's quite funny because one of the biggest 654 00:48:04,501 --> 00:48:16,687 criticisms… there have been papers criticizing this work and 655 00:48:16,687 --> 00:48:28,873 there's a famous paper which basically criticizes trend following. 656 00:48:28,873 --> 00:48:42,413 It says it's all about volatility scaling. Okay, the risk 657 00:48:42,413 --> 00:48:55,953 management is what the performance is coming from. And to 658 00:48:55,953 --> 00:49:05,431 me it's like precisely what we do. The reason why we're able to 659 00:47:11,107 --> 00:47:23,667 essentially obstruct each of the markets and actually put them 660 00:47:23,667 --> 00:47:38,739 together in a coherent fashion is because we manage the risk and 661 00:47:38,739 --> 00:47:52,555 because we volatility scale to get a proper diversification of the 662 00:47:52,555 --> 00:48:06,371 portfolio. And it feels odd that people criticize, oh, you know, 663 00:48:06,371 --> 00:48:22,699 it's like saying the cake was only good because you put eggs in 664 00:48:22,699 --> 00:48:39,027 it, of course, but that's part of the recipe. Right? You can't criticize 665 00:48:39,027 --> 00:48:54,099 that. It's completely integral to what we do. So, you know, that 666 00:48:54,099 --> 00:49:05,403 harks back to the first question that we asked. You know, 667 00:47:08,085 --> 00:47:30,655 other people criticize trend following because of costs. You know, 668 00:47:30,655 --> 00:47:57,739 they look at the simulation that they did and they said, oh, 669 00:47:57,739 --> 00:48:24,823 you know, the costs were higher that day. That may be the 670 00:48:24,823 --> 00:48:45,136 case. But again, simulation is about answering specific questions. 671 00:48:45,136 --> 00:49:05,449 And the question is, is the gross alpha there? Okay, we can discuss 672 00:47:16,403 --> 00:47:54,899 later whether it's relevant today in terms of being able to extract 673 00:47:54,899 --> 00:48:30,187 at today's costs level, whether I'll be able to extract it. 674 00:48:30,187 --> 00:49:05,475 So, it's a different question. It's a different question to ask. 675 00:47:03,571 --> 00:47:33,471 I think this paper has been a wonderful paper and I think investors, 676 00:47:33,471 --> 00:47:56,471 you're right, investors who actually care for long-term and they 677 00:47:56,471 --> 00:48:19,471 care about allocation for the long-term growth of capital, that 678 00:48:19,471 --> 00:48:51,671 CTA and maybe TPA and Claude will help it to do, it will actually 679 00:48:51,671 --> 00:49:05,471 allocate quite significantly to trend following. 680 00:49:05,731 --> 00:49:13,267 I'm excited about Claude, I have to say, because I think Claude 681 00:49:13,267 --> 00:49:21,431 has some friends in the OpenAI world and any other AI because, as 682 00:49:21,431 --> 00:49:29,595 you say, when you take an unbiased look at these types of things 683 00:49:29,595 --> 00:49:35,875 and you want to build the “best portfolio”, you definitely 684 00:49:35,875 --> 00:49:42,155 need, as probably everyone realizes on this podcast, that you 685 00:49:42,155 --> 00:49:47,807 definitely need a meaningful allocation to this wonderful strategy. 686 00:49:05,731 --> 00:49:19,387 Okay, anything else you want to mention here before we move on? 687 00:49:19,387 --> 00:49:35,319 By the way, I think our friends over at CFM, they did a 200-year 688 00:49:35,319 --> 00:49:47,837 paper. Maybe that's the one you need to bring next time. 689 00:49:48,901 --> 00:49:52,971 Yeah, it's absolutely right. There was a period when people stretched 690 00:49:52,971 --> 00:49:54,821 back as long as possible. 691 00:49:55,221 --> 00:49:59,466 I mean, I think did Katy and Alex in their book do 800 years or 692 00:49:59,466 --> 00:50:02,013 something like that? I can't remember. Maybe they did. 693 00:50:02,421 --> 00:50:09,493 I think that what is really interesting is that I did it for 694 00:50:09,493 --> 00:50:15,477 other asset classes like, you know, option trading and stuff like 695 00:50:15,477 --> 00:50:22,005 that. Yeah, I mean you don't necessarily publish it, but it works. 696 00:50:22,005 --> 00:50:28,533 And the reason it works is because we understand why it works. 697 00:50:28,533 --> 00:50:35,605 It is the two reasons, the two effects that drive trend. The first 698 00:50:35,605 --> 00:50:42,133 one is behavioral in terms of people buy winners. And we understand 699 00:50:42,133 --> 00:50:48,117 that. It's exactly why people don't believe in trend because it 700 00:50:48,117 --> 00:50:54,645 has had a few sort of weak years. That's fine, they're literally 701 00:50:54,645 --> 00:50:58,453 trend following and demonstrating why trend following 702 00:50:58,453 --> 00:50:58,997 works. The other reason, of course, is supply and demand, which 703 00:50:14,211 --> 00:50:27,180 is the mismatch between supply and demand is actually what drives 704 00:50:27,180 --> 00:50:38,970 prices. And the fact that price adjustment takes time, that 705 00:50:38,970 --> 00:50:51,939 sort of auto correlation in the price really drives why trend 706 00:50:51,939 --> 00:50:59,013 following works. It just makes sense. 707 00:51:04,711 --> 00:51:07,942 Let's move to something different, but also about supply 708 00:51:07,942 --> 00:51:12,968 and demand as far as I can tell. Again, I'm going to leave you 709 00:51:12,968 --> 00:51:15,481 to lead our way through this one. 710 00:51:17,401 --> 00:51:28,561 Okay, so this one is about Ilia Bouchouev. I hope I pronounced 711 00:51:28,561 --> 00:51:38,791 the name correctly. It's a stylized model of the oil squeeze. 712 00:51:38,791 --> 00:51:50,881 So, for those of you who don't remember, COVID happened a few years 713 00:51:50,881 --> 00:52:01,111 back, and in April 2020 crude was essentially long squeezed. The 714 00:52:01,111 --> 00:52:13,201 holders of the WTI contract had to pay for people to take the 715 00:52:13,201 --> 00:52:23,431 contract off their hands. And oil printed at a negative print. 716 00:52:23,431 --> 00:52:33,661 Okay, so the front contract traded negatively, which was a shock 717 00:52:33,661 --> 00:52:36,451 to the system. And Ilia Bouchouev is very illustrious, both 718 00:51:25,787 --> 00:51:40,163 a quant and a manager of sort of energy portfolios. He's published 719 00:51:40,163 --> 00:51:53,341 a really good book called Virtual Barrels, about the oil industry. 720 00:51:53,341 --> 00:52:08,915 And this paper is a short paper that he wrote which is amazing. 721 00:52:08,915 --> 00:52:23,291 I mean, if you're an oil trader or anything like that, an 722 00:52:23,291 --> 00:52:36,469 oil quant, you really want to read that paper and absolutely… 723 00:52:36,511 --> 00:52:37,711 What was the name of the paper? 724 00:52:38,111 --> 00:53:02,275 So, the name of the paper is A Stylized Model of The Oil Squeeze. 725 00:53:02,275 --> 00:53:24,713 And what is this paper about? So, it has like three distinct parts 726 00:53:24,713 --> 00:53:47,151 and is getting to the COVID crisis. So, the first one is reviewing 727 00:53:47,151 --> 00:54:00,959 the theory of storage. That's the first section. So normally we 728 00:52:41,255 --> 00:52:52,783 have supply and demand in economic theory and what you have 729 00:52:52,783 --> 00:53:05,359 is inventories which make up for imbalances, and they can do that 730 00:53:05,359 --> 00:53:20,031 until you run out of storage. And at that point you switch to a 731 00:53:20,031 --> 00:53:32,607 regime where supply and demand really have to do all the lifting 732 00:53:32,607 --> 00:53:44,135 themselves. And then instead of price stops being sort of relatively 733 00:53:44,135 --> 00:53:56,711 small, movement tends to be very volatile, and that kind of predicts 734 00:53:56,711 --> 00:54:00,903 very strong positive skew. Because the point where you run out 735 00:52:46,637 --> 00:53:01,253 of storage is the point where the commodity is in high demand, 736 00:53:01,253 --> 00:53:15,869 and basically the price spikes up because people run out of things. 737 00:53:15,869 --> 00:53:30,485 And we can see that in oil, for example, recently, when, you 738 00:53:30,485 --> 00:53:45,101 know, in Asia, people would pay US$200 to just have a barrel 739 00:53:45,101 --> 00:53:59,717 of oil because demand and supply in the oil industry is very 740 00:53:59,717 --> 00:54:00,935 inelastic. 741 00:54:01,601 --> 00:54:05,397 Can I just, sorry, I want to make sure I heard this correctly. 742 00:54:05,397 --> 00:54:09,485 You say the time when things run out of storage is when it's in 743 00:54:09,485 --> 00:54:12,697 high demand, but actually with COVID it was the opposite, right? 744 00:54:12,721 --> 00:54:17,791 Exactly, so, in traditional storage theory, when you run out 745 00:54:17,791 --> 00:54:23,368 of any inventories, stocks are going down. What happened in oil 746 00:54:23,368 --> 00:54:29,452 is potentially, it's not quite a story, but potentially on the other 747 00:54:29,452 --> 00:54:35,029 side, which is what happens when there's too much supply and 748 00:54:35,029 --> 00:54:37,564 you cannot store it anymore. 749 00:54:37,581 --> 00:54:38,221 Yeah, okay. 750 00:54:38,221 --> 00:55:18,701 That's actually one of the things he points out. That's actually 751 00:55:18,701 --> 00:55:59,181 not what happened, but it's the common story, people were saying. 752 00:55:59,181 --> 00:56:39,661 Okay, so that's interesting. But what he's pointing out is that, 753 00:56:39,661 --> 00:57:23,821 in this model, there is a right skew for the commodity. And 754 00:57:23,821 --> 00:57:42,221 we see that in agriculturals. So, for example, we saw coffee spiking 755 00:55:00,047 --> 00:55:37,463 up, cocoa spiking up when there is actually a shortage of the 756 00:55:37,463 --> 00:56:14,879 commodity. But he says, well, actually, if you look at oil, it's 757 00:56:14,879 --> 00:56:49,177 the other way around. Oil is essentially, the volatility of oil 758 00:56:49,177 --> 00:57:26,593 is constant, whether it's 20%. If it's trading at US$20, the volatility 759 00:57:26,593 --> 00:57:42,183 will be around US$20 annually. And if it's trading at UUS$100, the 760 00:54:57,730 --> 00:55:25,600 volatility will be around US$20 annually. In a percentage term, 761 00:55:25,600 --> 00:55:56,257 it's actually inverted. So, it's got a strong negative skew in 762 00:55:56,257 --> 00:56:29,701 many ways. And he's saying this doesn't make sense to us. What 763 00:56:29,701 --> 00:57:03,145 we really want to do is to skip the demand function altogether 764 00:57:03,145 --> 00:57:36,589 and we're going to model spreads as a direct function of the 765 00:57:36,589 --> 00:57:42,163 capacity utilization. Exactly this point about storage, we look 766 00:54:58,661 --> 00:55:39,541 at how much of the storage is available. And on the one side, when 767 00:55:39,541 --> 00:56:17,501 it goes to zero, when capacity is not utilized, we have the spike 768 00:56:17,501 --> 00:56:52,541 going off to infinity. But on the other side, when capacity is 769 00:56:52,541 --> 00:57:24,661 fully utilized, then we should go to minus infinity. Right? The 770 00:57:24,661 --> 00:57:42,181 price should go to minus infinity. And then we kind of use 771 00:54:49,837 --> 00:55:13,069 a bit of a hokey pokey magic sort of expectation, forward expectation, 772 00:55:13,069 --> 00:55:32,429 by saying actually we can think of the capacity utilization 773 00:55:32,429 --> 00:55:53,725 as a random variable which mean reverts. Okay. Which it does. 774 00:55:53,725 --> 00:56:13,085 Which is correct, and we basically think of integrating that, 775 00:56:13,085 --> 00:56:36,317 plus infinity at zero, and minus infinity at one, to the current 776 00:56:36,317 --> 00:57:01,485 levels. And you get a nice shape which is, you know, a nice 777 00:57:01,485 --> 00:57:22,781 spike near zero, to the upside, and the negative spike where 778 00:57:22,781 --> 00:57:42,141 capacity nears one. Okay. So, it's a really nice model. It's a 779 00:54:42,135 --> 00:55:03,662 heuristic model and you can calibrate it, and it calibrates the 780 00:55:03,662 --> 00:55:29,103 model to actually fit the oil spreads that we see in the market. 781 00:55:29,103 --> 00:55:52,587 And then we can think about, he talks about COVID because COVID, 782 00:55:52,587 --> 00:56:10,200 what's actually happening there, we didn't actually run out 783 00:56:10,200 --> 00:56:31,727 of capacity. And he's talking about a specific incident about the 784 00:56:31,727 --> 00:56:51,297 Chinese retail investors and about the way they've been unable 785 00:56:51,297 --> 00:57:14,781 to essentially hold the roll during the roll. So, it gets complicated. 786 00:57:14,781 --> 00:57:40,222 If you want to read about TAS, you know, trade at settlement prices, 787 00:57:40,222 --> 00:57:42,179 that's… But I think it's one of those papers where you know that 788 00:55:12,721 --> 00:55:55,846 this person is both a quant. So, he's able to come up with a model 789 00:55:55,846 --> 00:56:30,346 and he really understands the dynamics of the oil market. And it's 790 00:56:30,346 --> 00:57:10,596 a beauty to read. And I really love this paper and I'm going to 791 00:57:10,596 --> 00:57:42,221 qualify it because I've got a disagreement with it as well. 792 00:57:42,221 --> 00:57:43,381 Okay, let's hear it. 793 00:57:43,381 --> 00:57:47,125 So, let’s do the good things. So, he really understands the market. 794 00:57:47,125 --> 00:57:49,309 He understands the participants, the physical players. 795 00:57:49,309 --> 00:57:53,053 He really explains the carry trades. One of the things that I 796 00:57:53,053 --> 00:57:56,797 really have a bugbear with lots of quants in the industry is, 797 00:57:56,797 --> 00:58:01,165 and by the way, with his last paper in which he wrote about carry. 798 00:58:01,281 --> 00:58:01,841 Okay. 799 00:58:02,001 --> 00:58:33,230 It's, I think carry in commodities and carry in fixed income 800 00:58:33,230 --> 00:58:58,781 are very different beasts. Okay. Because money is fungible, 801 00:58:58,781 --> 00:59:32,849 you can move it easily from side to side. In commodities, the 802 00:59:32,849 --> 01:00:04,078 way that carry interacts with the inventories and with the capacity 803 01:00:04,078 --> 01:00:32,468 with the storage mechanism is really important. Like, if there 804 01:00:32,468 --> 01:01:06,536 is no oil, you cannot borrow it. Right? It's a fixed commodity. 805 01:01:06,536 --> 01:01:37,765 And really most quants really simply fail to recognize how carry 806 01:01:37,765 --> 01:01:51,960 trade is tied to inventories. And in fact, you know, if you plot 807 00:58:26,529 --> 00:58:51,057 capacity utilization against the spread, against the contango 808 00:58:51,057 --> 00:59:21,717 versus backwardation, it's a very clear line. It's a complete 809 00:59:21,717 --> 00:59:58,509 sort of spread, it is a very good function of inventories. And 810 00:59:58,509 --> 01:00:26,103 he really understands the dynamics of inventories about the 811 01:00:26,103 --> 01:00:59,829 way the traders actually look at inventories now. But also look 812 01:00:59,829 --> 01:01:36,621 at what it's likely to be because supply and demand in the 813 01:01:36,621 --> 01:01:51,951 oil market is very inelastic. So, if we have an imbalance this 814 00:58:40,326 --> 00:59:51,501 week, we are likely to have an imbalance next week. So, the fact 815 00:59:51,501 --> 01:00:40,776 that you recognize that, that's a really beautiful paper. 816 01:00:40,776 --> 01:01:51,951 And I think we'll come back to the COVID explanation is 100% correct. 817 00:58:02,001 --> 00:58:41,799 I just want to run a back-of-the-envelope analysis with 818 00:58:41,799 --> 00:59:30,441 everybody, which I think will be a good explanation. So, there's 819 00:59:30,441 --> 01:00:32,349 a great IMF paper, by the way, a 2024 paper that talks about price 820 01:00:32,349 --> 01:01:16,569 elasticity in commodities. Again, it's called The Power of Prices: 821 01:01:16,569 --> 01:01:51,945 How Fast Do Commodity Markets Adjust to Shocks? We talked about 822 00:58:16,677 --> 00:59:05,597 GIV, about calibration of supply and demand when we talked 823 00:59:05,597 --> 00:59:49,625 about equity markets, actually, a few months back. And 824 00:59:49,625 --> 01:00:43,437 they've done this exercise and they've done it for commodities on 825 01:00:43,437 --> 01:01:27,465 an annual basis. They've looked at anything from bananas, 826 01:01:27,465 --> 01:01:51,925 to oil markets, to copper. And what comes up is that oil is indeed 827 00:58:34,338 --> 00:59:10,268 quite inelastic. It has about a multiplication factor of 0.15. 828 00:59:10,268 --> 01:00:07,756 And what it means is that if we see a 10% rise in price, we will 829 01:00:07,756 --> 01:00:43,686 see production increasing about 1.5% and we will see demand, 830 01:00:43,686 --> 01:01:16,023 the number for demand, actually it's quite symmetric. We 831 01:01:16,023 --> 01:01:51,953 will see demand following by about 1.5% for a 10%. And so now 832 00:58:06,792 --> 00:58:29,150 let's look at the oil industry as a whole. We started a run crisis 833 00:58:29,150 --> 00:58:46,717 with about somewhere between, depending on how you quote it, somewhere 834 00:58:46,717 --> 00:59:05,881 between 86 and 100 million of oil being produced every day. Okay. 835 00:59:05,881 --> 00:59:26,642 And we started the crisis with WTI roughly at US$60, a little bit 836 00:59:26,642 --> 00:59:47,403 above it. And what we know is that there are 20 million barrels 837 00:59:47,403 --> 01:00:06,567 of oil going every daily through Hormuz. And if you lose 10 838 01:00:06,567 --> 01:00:22,537 million barrels, which actually is what we got, then what 839 01:00:22,537 --> 01:00:46,492 we see is, in order to balance that, we would need to see a 33% 840 01:00:46,492 --> 01:01:08,850 rise, which will give us a 5% decrease in demand and a 5% increase 841 01:01:08,850 --> 01:01:29,611 in supply. And that will make up roughly for the 10 million barrels 842 01:01:29,611 --> 01:01:50,372 of oil we lost. So, like the new stable equilibrium would be at 843 01:01:50,372 --> 01:01:51,969 US$80. If you lose the whole 20 million barrels per day, the price 844 00:58:31,353 --> 00:59:03,151 would have to go to US$100 precisely to get the supply and demand 845 00:59:03,151 --> 00:59:30,057 sort of balanced. And I think what's really interesting is that 846 00:59:30,057 --> 01:00:01,855 this study, which was done by a bunch of academics from the IMF, 847 01:00:01,855 --> 01:00:31,207 based on annual data and you might think it's not accurate, actually 848 01:00:31,207 --> 01:00:58,113 came out pretty spot on. Because we've seen WTI trading in 849 01:00:58,113 --> 01:01:32,357 the US$80 to US$100 range. And I think it really shows you how understanding 850 01:01:32,357 --> 01:01:51,925 price elasticity is really important for our purposes. 851 01:01:53,922 --> 01:02:00,096 Can I just, before I forget. I mean, yes, but… I mean, keeping oil… 852 01:02:00,096 --> 01:02:06,270 and I guess that is a little bit of a surprise that we haven't 853 01:02:06,270 --> 01:02:12,003 seen more than US$100ish, you know, in oil. I mean it did require 854 01:02:12,003 --> 01:02:15,090 a lot of reserves to being released. 855 01:02:15,352 --> 01:02:16,152 Absolutely. 856 01:02:16,632 --> 01:02:21,120 And you know, there are still, I remember our conversation a few 857 01:02:21,120 --> 01:02:25,234 weeks ago with Adam Rozencwajg. I mean it's like a billion 858 01:02:25,234 --> 01:02:30,096 dollars that's gone out of the market. And in his opinion, you know, 859 01:02:30,096 --> 01:02:35,332 it takes a few months before it shows up as missing. I know the 860 01:02:35,332 --> 01:02:38,698 Chinese stopped doing exporting of products, so that obviously 861 01:02:38,698 --> 01:02:40,568 helped a lot, but still… 862 01:02:43,452 --> 01:02:58,676 So, what you're describing is exactly the events that bring… so, 863 01:02:58,676 --> 01:03:11,132 that price change is precisely… So, the Chinese stopped 864 01:03:11,132 --> 01:03:23,588 consuming oil precisely because it was becoming more expensive 865 01:03:23,588 --> 01:03:38,812 to them. So, the economic theory is actually being played out 866 01:03:38,812 --> 01:03:54,036 in the market, but reserves are actually a great point because 867 01:03:54,036 --> 01:04:09,260 what the US has done is essentially bringing more oil to 868 01:04:09,260 --> 01:04:20,332 the market, increasing the supply. They reduced inventories 869 01:04:20,332 --> 01:04:35,556 by about 120 million barrels, which is not insubstantial but also 870 01:04:35,556 --> 01:04:36,940 elsewhere. So, I think that the discussion about inventories 871 01:02:56,420 --> 01:03:12,630 and about how these are managing that process, because what 872 01:03:12,630 --> 01:03:35,324 we are seeing is that the front of the curve has gone up. But 873 01:03:35,324 --> 01:03:54,776 if you go five years out, you remember we're discussing five years, 874 01:03:54,776 --> 01:04:15,849 the price is still at US$60. Okay. It hasn't budged. So, you know, 875 01:04:15,849 --> 01:04:36,922 I think it was pretty much spot on from what it was then. If 876 01:02:45,554 --> 01:03:10,778 you look at the shape of the curve, inventories are allowing us 877 01:03:10,778 --> 01:03:36,002 to essentially to delay that shock. And that plays out in the 878 01:03:36,002 --> 01:04:03,328 shape of the curve, which used to be, you know, the front spread 879 01:04:03,328 --> 01:04:24,348 when the crisis started was something like US$0.40. It's now 880 01:04:24,348 --> 01:04:36,960 sitting at sort of US$3.00, US$3.50. So, it's exactly that, the 881 01:02:52,457 --> 01:03:14,069 way that the crisis has played is through a much steeper backwardation 882 01:03:14,069 --> 01:03:39,283 of the curve in the front. So, we are seeing front sitting at sort 883 01:03:39,283 --> 01:04:04,497 of US$90 and the back sitting at the back of the curve five years 884 01:04:04,497 --> 01:04:22,507 out, still hasn't budged, still at around US$60. So, inventories 885 01:04:22,507 --> 01:04:36,915 are a very strong part of that story. 886 01:04:37,522 --> 01:04:38,002 Yeah. 887 01:04:38,242 --> 01:05:29,345 But there's one issue which I have with this paper which is there's 888 01:05:29,345 --> 01:06:20,448 a little bit of a magical switch in the paper because it starts 889 01:06:20,448 --> 01:06:51,896 talking about the oil inelasticity, which I completely 890 01:06:51,896 --> 01:07:42,999 agree with. If we just looked at it, it's a very small number, 891 01:07:42,999 --> 01:08:38,033 0.15. But then the second part of the model, where he fits it, he 892 01:08:38,033 --> 01:09:25,205 fits the spread. It looks at capacity utilization and it is fitting 893 01:09:25,205 --> 01:09:33,067 the spread. And the spread is a different beast. And in fact, the 894 01:05:09,130 --> 01:05:42,826 spread is actually a lot more elastic because then you have different 895 01:05:42,826 --> 01:06:16,522 players in the market. And I think it's really important to understand 896 01:06:16,522 --> 01:06:53,026 supply and demand not in oil, but in oil spreads. And that's actually 897 01:06:53,026 --> 01:07:29,530 where the action is because the players out there are a lot more 898 01:07:29,530 --> 01:07:57,610 elastic but they still obey economic theory. Because what you 899 01:07:57,610 --> 01:08:31,306 have is you have the tank storage, tank farms in WTI. There 900 01:08:31,306 --> 01:09:05,002 are, I think, about 70 million barrels of capacity there. They are 901 01:09:05,002 --> 01:09:33,082 a lot more dynamic to the shape of the curve. For them, the 902 01:04:46,666 --> 01:05:14,746 price is exactly the roll yield, the difference between the 903 01:05:14,746 --> 01:05:48,442 front curve, the front price, the front contract and the next contract. 904 01:05:48,442 --> 01:06:22,138 And they are the suppliers of inventories. And then on the other 905 01:06:22,138 --> 01:06:47,410 side, you have the misbalance between producers and consumers, 906 01:06:47,410 --> 01:07:18,298 like refineries on the demand side. And the dynamic between them 907 01:07:18,298 --> 01:07:49,186 we can actually model very much like economic theory with supply 908 01:07:49,186 --> 01:08:20,074 and demand. And it makes perfect sense because they are very 909 01:08:20,074 --> 01:08:45,346 sensitive. The physical players are very sensitive to the 910 01:08:45,346 --> 01:09:19,042 level of inventories. Because I can only offer storage if I have 911 01:09:19,042 --> 01:09:33,082 storage left in my tank. So, if the amount of storage I have in 912 01:05:06,772 --> 01:05:51,152 my tank sort of goes down, so, say in this crisis, I become more 913 01:05:51,152 --> 01:06:22,852 price inelastic. I will require a higher spread to release 914 01:06:22,852 --> 01:07:00,892 oil from my tanks. And similarly, on the other side of the 915 01:07:00,892 --> 01:07:32,592 equation, when we reach capacity, like in the COVID sample, 916 01:07:32,592 --> 01:08:07,462 I will require much, much, much stronger contango in order to 917 01:08:07,462 --> 01:08:45,502 store it in my tank. So, the supply and demand works perfectly 918 01:08:45,502 --> 01:09:33,052 if you think about it not as an oil market, but as a spread market. 919 01:04:38,242 --> 01:05:28,019 But I think the spread market is really also very exciting in its 920 01:05:28,019 --> 01:06:10,138 own right. Because there's a bunch of people that trade spreads 921 01:06:10,138 --> 01:06:48,428 that don't even know they're trading spreads. And I'm talking 922 01:06:48,428 --> 01:07:42,034 about the CTA markets, the CTA people. So, I mean, if I ask you 923 01:07:42,034 --> 01:08:24,153 does DUNN trade spreads, and if the company clients would come 924 01:08:24,153 --> 01:09:17,759 to you, do you trade spreads, you will say no, of course not, we 925 01:09:17,759 --> 01:09:33,075 just trade outright, whatever. I mean there are CTAs that specialize 926 01:05:04,037 --> 01:05:48,257 in this. There's Moritz and Mauritz who are very much into spreads. 927 01:05:48,257 --> 01:06:39,847 But broadly we just trade the outright oil. If I ask you if I'm 928 01:06:39,847 --> 01:07:31,437 a long only investor in oil funds in the USO, okay, are you a 929 01:07:31,437 --> 01:08:19,342 trader in spreads? You would say of course not. This is just long 930 01:08:19,342 --> 01:09:03,562 only oil. But actually you do trade spreads. And you trade the 931 01:09:03,562 --> 01:09:33,042 spreads, but only when you roll your position. So, what you 932 01:04:46,828 --> 01:05:18,310 have is you have physical players who play the spread market, 933 01:05:18,310 --> 01:05:52,654 and they do it during the month, and everything is fine. And 934 01:05:52,654 --> 01:06:29,860 then we're getting to the point where we need to roll the contract 935 01:06:29,860 --> 01:07:01,342 and suddenly you have an influx of financial players and they 936 01:07:01,342 --> 01:07:29,962 are truly price insensitive. They don't even realize how price 937 01:07:29,962 --> 01:08:01,444 insensitive they are because they just don't want to get delivered 938 01:08:01,444 --> 01:08:35,788 the oil. The CTA will never hold their position, a long only 939 01:08:35,788 --> 01:09:12,994 position. And at that point what you have is you have a bunch 940 01:09:12,994 --> 01:09:33,028 of financial players coming in with excess. If you think of it as 941 01:04:53,626 --> 01:05:24,394 a demand shock into the spread market and the physical players have 942 01:05:24,394 --> 01:05:55,162 to make up for it. And in normal operation, this is great. 943 01:05:55,162 --> 01:06:28,494 But when they are not, like in COVID, you have the financial players 944 01:06:28,494 --> 01:06:56,698 who are 100% must roll the position, okay? And that's exactly 945 01:06:56,698 --> 01:07:30,030 the incident that we saw in COVID. So, it wasn't the case that 946 01:07:30,030 --> 01:07:58,234 the physical traders were running out of space to store, but 947 01:07:58,234 --> 01:08:31,566 it was the case that the amount of demand shock that we saw 948 01:08:31,566 --> 01:08:59,770 in the roll wasn't matched by the physical player. And suddenly 949 01:08:59,770 --> 01:09:33,102 you saw the big spike in the contango and the price went negative. 950 01:04:38,242 --> 01:06:25,462 So, I think you can really explain this as supply and demand, 951 01:06:25,462 --> 01:08:39,487 but you just have to be aware of this is not the oil market per 952 01:08:39,487 --> 01:09:33,097 se, this is the spread market. 953 01:09:33,102 --> 01:09:38,100 Good stuff. I think we have to wrap it up, Yoav, because we are 954 01:09:38,100 --> 01:09:40,242 past the hour by some margin. 955 01:09:42,242 --> 01:09:49,430 Can I just say something about trend following just for this because 956 01:09:49,430 --> 01:09:56,618 you know, we talk about the physical markets and like if you're 957 01:09:56,618 --> 01:10:03,806 a CTA, you're thinking, okay, this is a really nice story, but 958 01:10:03,806 --> 01:10:11,593 it's not relevant. But I think it is important for people to realize 959 01:10:11,593 --> 01:10:19,380 that, which is the first one, the first lesson is that for CTAs 960 01:10:19,380 --> 01:10:26,568 and for any investors, the roll is an issue. In most liquid 961 01:10:26,568 --> 01:10:31,959 commodities it’s not. But if you're trading alternative commodities 962 01:10:31,959 --> 01:10:37,949 or slightly less liquid markets, it's not just the daily 963 01:10:37,949 --> 01:10:43,340 volume, it's also the liquidity during the roll because 964 01:10:43,340 --> 01:10:50,528 you don't want to be short squeezed or long squeezed in the 965 01:10:50,528 --> 01:10:54,122 position. So, roll is really important. And the second question 966 01:09:45,030 --> 01:09:52,697 is really when you understand the dynamics of the market, trend 967 01:09:52,697 --> 01:09:58,970 following in commodities is not necessarily a symmetric process. 968 01:09:58,970 --> 01:10:06,637 Right? There are some assets that will have negative skew, some 969 01:10:06,637 --> 01:10:14,304 assets will have positive skew. And you really want to think 970 01:10:14,304 --> 01:10:23,365 about how you want to handle it. And good luck with that. And 971 01:10:23,365 --> 01:10:31,729 I think Moritz and Mauritz probably know all there is to know 972 01:10:31,729 --> 01:10:38,699 about trend following in spreads. But I think it's really 973 01:10:38,699 --> 01:10:44,972 interesting in terms of understanding the dynamics of who 974 01:10:44,972 --> 01:10:52,639 are playing there in terms of understanding how to harvest trend 975 01:10:52,639 --> 01:10:54,033 in spreads. 976 01:10:54,122 --> 01:10:57,994 Sure, sure, I think the most important thing, actually, my takeaway 977 01:10:57,994 --> 01:11:01,866 is that when people think about oh, trend following is easy 978 01:11:01,866 --> 01:11:07,146 because all you need to do is develop an algo. No, I mean I think 979 01:11:07,146 --> 01:11:11,370 we have to appreciate the fact that the experience of the people 980 01:11:11,370 --> 01:11:14,538 who implement the trades, especially in the commodities, is 981 01:11:14,538 --> 01:11:18,762 hugely important. And that is, as we talked about very early in 982 01:11:18,762 --> 01:11:22,986 our conversation today, there are so many parts of a CTA business 983 01:11:22,986 --> 01:11:26,858 that need to work together in order to make the whole… 984 01:11:26,922 --> 01:11:27,682 Absolutely. 985 01:11:28,242 --> 01:12:07,467 … the best it can be. And that also goes in this case. So great 986 01:12:07,467 --> 01:12:33,617 stuff, very interesting. I've certainly learned a few things here, 987 01:12:33,617 --> 01:12:49,307 Yoav, so very much appreciate that. And by the way, even though 988 01:11:35,964 --> 01:11:52,695 the competition for leaving a great review is over for now, I will 989 01:11:52,695 --> 01:12:10,713 encourage you to do it anyways because it's a way to show your appreciation 990 01:12:10,713 --> 01:12:27,444 for Yoav and all the other co-hosts for the work they do and 991 01:12:27,444 --> 01:12:40,314 all the preparation. So, please go to your favorite podcast 992 01:12:40,314 --> 01:12:49,323 platform and leave a rating and review. Now, I think that's pretty 993 01:11:33,307 --> 01:11:46,476 much it. You can, of course, always go and check out the website 994 01:11:46,476 --> 01:11:59,645 for the updates we do every week, blog post, and the trend barometer 995 01:11:59,645 --> 01:12:11,801 to follow along. In addition to tuning in each week. Next week 996 01:12:11,801 --> 01:12:24,970 I will be joined by Rob, who comes back from his very extended 997 01:12:24,970 --> 01:12:37,126 holiday that he always takes in the summer. No doubt he'll be 998 01:12:37,126 --> 01:12:48,269 full of energy and it'll be a very insightful conversation, I'm 999 01:12:48,269 --> 01:12:49,282 sure. If you have any questions for Rob, please send them 1000 01:11:40,712 --> 01:11:44,453 to info@toptradersunplugged.com and 1001 01:11:44,453 --> 01:12:04,405 I'll do my very best to get it in front of him. That's it for now 1002 01:12:04,405 --> 01:12:20,616 from Yoav and me. Thanks ever so much for listening. We look forward 1003 01:12:20,616 --> 01:12:36,827 to being back with you next week. And in the meantime, as always, 1004 01:12:36,827 --> 01:12:49,297 take care of yourself and take care of each other. 1005 01:12:51,812 --> 01:14:24,919 Thanks for listening to Top Traders Unplugged. If you feel you 1006 01:12:57,132 --> 01:13:10,432 learned something of value from today's episode, the best way 1007 01:13:10,432 --> 01:13:27,722 to stay updated is to go on over to your favorite podcast platform 1008 01:13:27,722 --> 01:13:46,342 and follow the show so that you'll be sure to get all the new 1009 01:13:46,342 --> 01:13:59,642 episodes as they're released. We have some amazing guests lined 1010 01:13:59,642 --> 01:14:16,932 up for you and to ensure our show continues to grow, please leave 1011 01:14:16,932 --> 01:14:24,912 us an honest rating and review. It only takes a minute and 1012 01:13:13,298 --> 01:14:03,432 it's the best way to show us you love the podcast. We'll see you 1013 01:14:03,432 --> 01:14:24,918 next time on Top Traders Unplugged. This podcast expresses 1014 01:12:57,755 --> 01:13:23,508 the views of its hosts and the guests appearing on the podcast as 1015 01:13:23,508 --> 01:13:49,261 of the date of its recording, and such views are subject to change 1016 01:13:49,261 --> 01:14:11,052 without notice. Top Traders Unplugged do not have any duty or 1017 01:14:11,052 --> 01:14:24,919 obligation to update the information contained herein. Furthermore, 1018 01:12:54,082 --> 01:13:16,782 Top Traders Unplugged make no representation to its accuracy and 1019 01:13:16,782 --> 01:13:41,752 it shall not be assumed that past investment performance is an 1020 01:13:41,752 --> 01:14:04,452 indication of future results. Moreover, wherever there is a potential 1021 01:14:04,452 --> 01:14:24,882 for profit, there is also the possibility of loss. This content 1022 01:13:02,156 --> 01:13:48,704 is made available for educational purposes only and should 1023 01:13:48,704 --> 01:14:24,908 not be used for any other purpose. The information contained 1024 01:12:59,570 --> 01:13:28,016 in this podcast does not constitute and should not be construed 1025 01:13:28,016 --> 01:13:59,048 as investment advice or an offer to sell or a solicitation to 1026 01:13:59,048 --> 01:14:24,908 buy any securities or related financial instruments in any jurisdiction. 1027 01:12:51,812 --> 01:13:09,424 Certain information contained herein concerning economic trends 1028 01:13:09,424 --> 01:13:34,584 and performance is based on or derived from information provided 1029 01:13:34,584 --> 01:13:54,712 by independent third-party sources. Top Traders Unplugged may 1030 01:13:54,712 --> 01:14:19,872 believe that the sources from which such information are obtained 1031 01:14:19,872 --> 01:14:24,904 are reliable. However, Top Traders Unplugged cannot guarantee 1032 01:13:00,536 --> 01:13:13,622 the accuracy of such information and has not independently 1033 01:13:13,622 --> 01:13:25,254 verified the accuracy or completeness of such information 1034 01:13:25,254 --> 01:13:41,248 or the assumptions on which such information is based. This podcast, 1035 01:13:41,248 --> 01:13:54,334 including the information contained herein, may not be reproduced, 1036 01:13:54,334 --> 01:14:11,782 copied, republished or posted in whole or in part in any form, 1037 01:14:11,782 --> 01:14:24,868 without the prior written consent of Top Traders Unplugged.