Hey, hi everyone.
Speaker:Welcome to our monday gossip session.
Speaker:We gather here every other monday So not every monday every other monday at
Speaker:12 noon eastern time we talk about all the things happening in the british
Speaker:world and The bookish community.
Speaker:Normally it's the trio, but we have all friends.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:Group text friends.
Speaker:They're out of the group text and they're on the live with us.
Speaker:And I'm really excited to have them here, but just in case you're
Speaker:joining us for the first time, I'm Victoria from Biblio lifestyle.
Speaker:I'm Laura from what to read next podcast.
Speaker:I'm Francesca from Under the Covers.
Speaker:Do I go, I'm Becky from Too Stupid to Live, as you I'm Kelly from Boobies
Speaker:and Newbies Podcast, and I'm an author.
Speaker:Yes, and guess what, fun fact, we are all on Substack.
Speaker:So, link in the video's description to join us on Substack.
Speaker:We're writing amazing things and doing lovely things over there.
Speaker:So if you find one of us, you'll find us all because we recommend each
Speaker:other because that's what friends do.
Speaker:Okay, so friends in a group chat and friends in content creation, but anyway.
Speaker:Today we're talking all things bookish gossip live news and just
Speaker:all the happenings and we have a lot going on today I have my notes.
Speaker:Okay cue card ready to go and One of the topics we want to kind of cover before
Speaker:we get you know Pictures up on screen is the fact that there's a growing
Speaker:trend of historical Romance authors so historical romance authors who seem to be
Speaker:losing their contracts coming to an end.
Speaker:There's no renewal We even have a situation in With author Nora Roberts.
Speaker:So Nora Roberts is a very popular author.
Speaker:I just put up on screen.
Speaker:If you're listening, a screen grab from an interview she did with the AP.
Speaker:So AP news.
Speaker:com.
Speaker:I'll have the source.
Speaker:In the video's description the link to the article but essentially, after
Speaker:250 books in of historical romance She's been releasing four books a year.
Speaker:She's a fast writer She actually feels like she does not see herself
Speaker:as part of the romance genre anymore Laura, what is your take on laura
Speaker:roberts, but just also historical?
Speaker:historical romance authors not getting contract renewals and all the happenings
Speaker:So I guess there are two separate things.
Speaker:Nora writes romance, romantic suspense, fantasy, and all deserving daughters.
Speaker:She does, she may have written some historical, I don't think so, but
Speaker:she has written two, mainly romance.
Speaker:But we have historical romance being a trend that's been, it's been not
Speaker:selling, I guess, to critical publishers and it's not selling so well, so
Speaker:they're not renewing contracts.
Speaker:They're moving toward paranormal fantasy, or paranormal romanticity,
Speaker:or paranormal rom coms, or rom coms.
Speaker:And so a lot of our historical authors are being asked to go and switch
Speaker:genres or trying to sell contracts.
Speaker:So we've seen Sam McLean selling women's fiction.
Speaker:We see Eva Eva Lee and Sophie Jordan selling romanticy.
Speaker:We saw some authors who are like, okay, I'm going to move indie.
Speaker:I'm going to just going to start.
Speaker:continue to publish historical moments because I'm passionate about it, but
Speaker:I'm going to move to Indie route.
Speaker:So historical moments are not getting also that one of the things
Speaker:is the move away from mass market.
Speaker:A lot of these historical moments come in mass market paperbacks and many
Speaker:stores are not filling those slots.
Speaker:And so they're moving to trade paperbacks and those are more expensive.
Speaker:And maybe the market is just like, not, doesn't understand, but it's
Speaker:a, it's market trends is a lot of conversations about like, do.
Speaker:It's a book talk.
Speaker:They want to read historical moments to define the actual, like,
Speaker:part of it, even though they're a great genre there's a lot of like,
Speaker:discrimination for historical moments.
Speaker:What do you think, Fran, because we do have historical romance, but then
Speaker:we also have OGs in the romance genre, like Nora Roberts, who's also saying she
Speaker:doesn't feel like she belongs anymore.
Speaker:So clearly a lot is changing.
Speaker:What are you thinking?
Speaker:So on the historical romance aspect, I, Actually, what I think is we're
Speaker:seeing a change in publishing that also happened with paranormal romance in the
Speaker:2000s, so I don't think it's as much of a trend of people don't want to buy it.
Speaker:It's just that what the traditional publishers are putting out.
Speaker:It's not what the people that read that genre want to read.
Speaker:So I don't think that they're publishing the right historical romances that
Speaker:The readers actually want to read.
Speaker:I think the fact that they moved away from mass market and the pricing
Speaker:changes also makes a difference.
Speaker:But I think in general, they're going in.
Speaker:a particular direction with the ones that they do publish.
Speaker:And I think that does have an impact on the ones that they sell.
Speaker:But you do see some Indies historical romance authors doing
Speaker:quite well on Indie publishing.
Speaker:So I think that we're probably going to see more of that in my opinion.
Speaker:But I feel like people that write historical romance are not as I don't
Speaker:see them as open as going indie.
Speaker:I think this is probably going to push them in that direction.
Speaker:And there's going to be a lag in time for that to happen, like
Speaker:there was with Paranormal Romance.
Speaker:So when publishing pretty much cut releasing any Paranormal
Speaker:Romance, there was still a demand and there were no books.
Speaker:And then slowly you could see those authors going indie.
Speaker:I think that probably that will be faster now than it was before.
Speaker:But I think that definitely there is a disconnect.
Speaker:And I think that disconnect is probably what Laura was saying
Speaker:because they are really chasing the book talk trend and they really
Speaker:want to like mark it to whatever the book talk girlies are reading.
Speaker:And you don't really see that as much with historical romance.
Speaker:So I think that if they find one big booktalker that starts
Speaker:pushing historical romance, they'll probably change their tune.
Speaker:But I'm actually more excited to see historical romance go indie
Speaker:and get a variety of stories versus just like the, they can pretty much
Speaker:all fit in a box when it comes to the traditionally published ones.
Speaker:Now, on the Nora Roberts ask.
Speaker:I am a little I am shocked but also not shocked like Nora Roberts is kind
Speaker:of like the OG romance author and at the same time I'm not shocked to see
Speaker:that she's not identifying with the genre in a way because of All of the
Speaker:tropey things like everything has to be marketable to a trope in romance
Speaker:right now And that's not how she writes.
Speaker:I think she writes It's very much a romance, but not picking it apart
Speaker:for what tropes does this fit into?
Speaker:So I think that's probably harder to sell to the audience
Speaker:that they're trying to appeal.
Speaker:Again, in my opinion, this is, both of these is because of the book talk trend.
Speaker:Right.
Speaker:Is that a good thing?
Speaker:I don't know.
Speaker:I mean, I think we'll have to wait, we'll have to wait to see.
Speaker:But Becky, what are your thoughts on historical romance, but also Nora Roberts?
Speaker:Yeah, I have a few thoughts.
Speaker:One is, it seems like.
Speaker:With book talk and how fast book talk goes, it feels like publishers are making
Speaker:very quick decisions before, like, kind of reflecting on like, oh, is this true?
Speaker:Because like book talk moves so fast, trends move so fast.
Speaker:And when you have something like Bridgertons, like when that comes back
Speaker:in, Five years or however long it takes.
Speaker:They're going to be kind of, regretting that choice because people will probably
Speaker:be into historical fiction again.
Speaker:And I just think like I think there's like there's TikTok and like
Speaker:there's the rest of society who is just like, what do we do with this?
Speaker:You know what I mean?
Speaker:And I feel like publishers are kind of like that.
Speaker:And to an extent, maybe even Nora Roberts, too.
Speaker:It's so interesting because like I have so much respect for Nora Roberts.
Speaker:I love Nora Roberts books because sometimes they, it is
Speaker:just like after, I don't know.
Speaker:I feel like we're all reading the writers who have read Nora Roberts, who were
Speaker:inspired by Nora Roberts and have kind of changed some of the conventions.
Speaker:So when you read Nora Roberts, you kind of see like, Oh, it's going
Speaker:a different route or it's bringing in this or it's bringing in that.
Speaker:And yeah, I can understand cause I don't want to say it's.
Speaker:I don't want to blame it on like age, you know what I mean?
Speaker:But like, yeah, I know a lot of people say my mom reads Nora Roberts and like.
Speaker:And not, and it's like, it's interesting because it's generational, but there
Speaker:is also kind of format wise too.
Speaker:So yeah, I was, I feel kind of rude saying that because I love Nora
Speaker:Roberts and like age doesn't matter.
Speaker:It really doesn't matter.
Speaker:But like, Here's the thing, right?
Speaker:We have our family members who've been reading classics for generations
Speaker:and our grandparents and everyone, and then we came and now we're
Speaker:reading it and I'm like, come.
Speaker:But I hear you though, but I had to throw in the classics because
Speaker:I mean, we're still fighting over Jane Austen 250 years later.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:You're still reading Jane Austen?
Speaker:But anyway, Kelly, what are your thoughts on all the happenings with historical
Speaker:romance and of course Laura Roberts?
Speaker:Well, first of all, I cut my teeth on reading Nora Roberts library
Speaker:books when I was like 18, 19.
Speaker:Those were some of the first romances I read.
Speaker:And it's always interesting to me.
Speaker:to, between I know between Becky and I we've interviewed so many authors
Speaker:and talked to them and asked them like, well, who were your influences
Speaker:and what romance did you read?
Speaker:What was your first introduction to romance and Nora Roberts?
Speaker:And along with like Dan Hellsteel and Julia Quinn and Diana Quincy,
Speaker:like you're very up high on the list.
Speaker:of answers we hear and it's because we didn't have a book talk.
Speaker:I hate to be that person that's like back in my day.
Speaker:It's true, like ever since I turned 30, I swear there's a lot of back in my day.
Speaker:Wait till you get to 40, 40, 40 o'clock.
Speaker:We're like, I'm
Speaker:coming to the 40 club.
Speaker:It's happening soon.
Speaker:But I just feel like So, depending on when you kind of started reading
Speaker:romance you see this big shift change of like, what was going on then?
Speaker:And so what romance books were coming out then.
Speaker:So for example, like when I started reading romance circa
Speaker:like 2008, 2009 there were a lot of historical mass paperbacks.
Speaker:However, a lot of them were also from, 10 years ago at that point.
Speaker:And a lot of the ones that I was reading were contemporary romance.
Speaker:Versus, say, my mom, who, when romance she first started reading
Speaker:romance, really all she had to go off of was historical romance.
Speaker:So it really is interesting just kind of like seeing the different generational
Speaker:changes between like what was publishing then, what was very popular then, to see
Speaker:now that you hear they're losing contracts for something that was the thing to write.
Speaker:10, 15, 20 years ago.
Speaker:So I don't know.
Speaker:I feel like every trend is, it's always changing.
Speaker:And I understand, I guess, to some degree where publishers are coming from, in
Speaker:that I think there's always this push to stay ahead of like what's coming next.
Speaker:And it's hard when you have something like a book talk that's changed things so
Speaker:exponentially, where one year, I remember, in 2023, hockey romance was popping off
Speaker:to the point where I thought about writing a hockey romance and then realized I
Speaker:know absolutely nothing about hockey.
Speaker:So I decided to write a baseball romance and then lo and behold, 2024 became
Speaker:like the year of baseball romance, but not because of me, just because there
Speaker:were so many people who at the same time decided that they were going to write.
Speaker:baseball romance.
Speaker:And now I see Cowboys coming back.
Speaker:So I mean, it really is one of those things where people
Speaker:are trying to, I think, write.
Speaker:to trend and write to trope.
Speaker:And Nora Roberts is not one of those people.
Speaker:Like, Nora Roberts was never one of those people.
Speaker:She was a, she was and is a storyteller.
Speaker:Through and through.
Speaker:I, to this day, reread her Bride Quartet series every year.
Speaker:So I'm really interested to see.
Speaker:Kind of what Francesca was saying, where we go next with
Speaker:historical romance, because I don't think it's going to go away.
Speaker:But I do think you're going to see people still wanting to read it, especially
Speaker:with something like Bridgerton.
Speaker:Every four years they want a new season.
Speaker:But it is interesting to know, too, that Bridgerton didn't Boost
Speaker:the sales of historical romance.
Speaker:Like I think people hoped it would and thought it would, it
Speaker:boosted the sales of Bridgerton.
Speaker:So you saw like a lot more people reading Julia Quinn's books and
Speaker:specifically Bridgerton, but it didn't, and I've talked about this
Speaker:with historical romance authors.
Speaker:It didn't have the wide effect that I think a lot of people were wanting,
Speaker:which is disappointing to say the least.
Speaker:Sure.
Speaker:You would hope you know that what I say the high tide raises all boats kind of
Speaker:vibes It just didn't work out in this instance Anyways, if you are just joining
Speaker:us welcome, we're doing or bookish gossip live show We're just talking about all
Speaker:things happening in the bookish world.
Speaker:We're talking about Historical romance authors not getting contract renewals
Speaker:not getting new contracts, but also simultaneously a heavy hitter in romance.
Speaker:Nora roberts also saying she doesn't feel like she belongs to the genre anymore
Speaker:again I'll include Links to all the sources in the video's description Now
Speaker:this one is just going to be a quick fire.
Speaker:So just Spit your feelings and thoughts on this one, and I
Speaker:wanna talk about Colleen Hoover.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:Colleen Hoover, according to People magazine has returned to Instagram
Speaker:after deactivating her account, so she deactivated on January 22nd.
Speaker:And she returned on February 12th.
Speaker:This is by a people magazine.
Speaker:Again links will be in the video's description cause
Speaker:we cite all sources here.
Speaker:And on her return, all images that had to do with Blake Lively
Speaker:and Justin Baldoni and just the film in general have been MIA.
Speaker:So, okay.
Speaker:Quick, fine, one sentence.
Speaker:What are your thoughts?
Speaker:Thoughts on Colleen Hoover reactivating her Instagram profile.
Speaker:I will start by saying, sis, you don't have to be here.
Speaker:You are rich.
Speaker:I just want to remind you, you are legit rich.
Speaker:Be here.
Speaker:Just take the break.
Speaker:Just disappear.
Speaker:Real life is fun.
Speaker:You can afford to do real life.
Speaker:I can't afford to do real life.
Speaker:So join me live at 12.
Speaker:Laura, what are your thoughts on Colleen Hoover again?
Speaker:Retire.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Fran.
Speaker:Same, I feel like she doesn't need to be involved in the mess, just
Speaker:leave it alone, cause this just looks worse, like just stay out of it.
Speaker:That's what I say.
Speaker:Becky?
Speaker:At the very least, take a vacation and or please stop using a reputation
Speaker:management company to tell you what to do.
Speaker:It's clear that's what's going on.
Speaker:Kelly, what are your thoughts?
Speaker:I could not care less.
Speaker:But I will say I am like both thoroughly enjoying the drama surrounding everything,
Speaker:but also kind of like over it at the same time, like we're still talking about this.
Speaker:I don't know.
Speaker:I'm just like.
Speaker:It's I'm over it.
Speaker:We are talking about it.
Speaker:So if you're just joining us live, how do you feel about Colleen
Speaker:Hoover returning to Instagram?
Speaker:Do you believe like us she can retire now?
Speaker:I'm saying she's rich.
Speaker:Go do your pray love fire the reputation people They're saying it because she
Speaker:returned A little under a month after scrubbing her account of all photos
Speaker:and all references of Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni Let us know your thoughts
Speaker:in the comments But also if you had thoughts on the laura roberts of it all
Speaker:we'd love to hear your thoughts as well So please share them in the comments.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:Next up is another fandom kind of thing I'm guessing folks won't
Speaker:probably y'all won't probably have a lot of opinions on this.
Speaker:But anyways Again, people magazine announces twilight is
Speaker:celebrating its 20th anniversary With three collectible editions.
Speaker:Okay Let me know.
Speaker:How do you feel?
Speaker:Let me get a big picture.
Speaker:This is what the publisher little brown had released This is the vibe
Speaker:they're going For these new 20th editions, gorgeously designed slip
Speaker:cases, gorgeously designed books.
Speaker:Of course, you're going to get the bookmark.
Speaker:You're probably going to get foil on the, what do you call it?
Speaker:The design.
Speaker:Let me know, how do you all feel about this collectible edition?
Speaker:I know the last time we all gathered, We also talked about the collectible
Speaker:edition market and is this a money grab and what are our thoughts on it?
Speaker:But yeah, another rapid fire.
Speaker:How do you feel about twilight?
Speaker:I'm like, look, it's a money grab.
Speaker:I'm always here for a money grab.
Speaker:It looks beautiful.
Speaker:Will I buy it?
Speaker:I don't know.
Speaker:I mean, I really didn't pick teams during this time.
Speaker:I was too old.
Speaker:I felt like this was past my time.
Speaker:Did I read the books?
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:Are they okay?
Speaker:They're okay.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:Did I watch the movies?
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:Is it okay?
Speaker:Watch it with your teenagers, maybe.
Speaker:Laura, what do you think?
Speaker:I have not read, watched anything.
Speaker:It passed my, I was in rehab at that time when they came out.
Speaker:So if that tells you something.
Speaker:So do not, it just passed it.
Speaker:I still have not watched them 20 years later and maybe
Speaker:I'll watch them for Substack.
Speaker:So maybe I'll create play content for this.
Speaker:There we go.
Speaker:Fran, what do you think?
Speaker:A couple of thoughts.
Speaker:I'm actually, like, I actually enjoyed the whole fandom of it.
Speaker:When the I started reading them when the first movie came out.
Speaker:I was actually on vacation in Italy and I happened to pick up the book
Speaker:because it was at every like rest area on the highway that you would stop.
Speaker:And I'm like, this book is everywhere.
Speaker:Okay, I'm going to read it.
Speaker:So I did read it.
Speaker:I did enjoy them.
Speaker:Like you said, like they were good books.
Speaker:They were fine.
Speaker:The movies were fine.
Speaker:They were enjoyable.
Speaker:But I have thoughts on the design because if there is anything that
Speaker:twilight is not Pink and flowery.
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:I am.
Speaker:Sorry.
Speaker:What the hell is that?
Speaker:Like make it black background with some red flowers I can go for that.
Speaker:What is that?
Speaker:That is the most anti twilight vibe.
Speaker:Okay, hold on.
Speaker:Anyone watching this live, I see you all, but it's okay.
Speaker:If you're at work, if you're in the cubicle, if you're watching from
Speaker:the bushes, it's fine, but if you have a little free second, just
Speaker:look at the screen and drop in the chat, let us know your thoughts on.
Speaker:The cover design.
Speaker:So Fran, I have to jump in.
Speaker:I agree with you.
Speaker:I love a money grab.
Speaker:I wouldn't want it to be black just because the original
Speaker:book club was, were black.
Speaker:I am team, make it more wintry themed because I'm looking at this and I'm
Speaker:getting spring, summer, fall, spring, summer, groundbreaking where are the hoa
Speaker:hoa vibes, where are the trees and the fog, trying to make it classic, I think.
Speaker:They're trying to make it classic.
Speaker:You chose the wrong season!
Speaker:You chose the wrong season!
Speaker:It's not spring.
Speaker:Florals for spring?
Speaker:Groundbreaking.
Speaker:Like, what are you doing?
Speaker:Where are your florals?
Speaker:Yeah, I know.
Speaker:Becky, what are your thoughts?
Speaker:Yeah, I'm kind of just like, whoever designed that book,
Speaker:like, did they read Twilight?
Speaker:Like, do they know Twilight?
Speaker:Like, I feel like it was, I mean, that feels like it's more for Jane Austen
Speaker:historical romance than Twilight.
Speaker:That is all to say, a part of me is like, I kind of agree with you guys about
Speaker:how, like, the okayness of Twilight, like, I read it, I, and I enjoyed it,
Speaker:saw the movies, but I think it's like impossible to deny the impact it's made
Speaker:on culture, on reading romance, and getting, I mean, it ignited so many
Speaker:people, like, every time I have an author or a romance reader on my show.
Speaker:Like their first foray is Twilight.
Speaker:And I think it's like hard to not deny its impact.
Speaker:So when I see that, it just looks so like, I don't know, like.
Speaker:You picked the first design off of Canva.
Speaker:Do you know what I mean?
Speaker:Sorry, that's so rude.
Speaker:No, it's not!
Speaker:It's not him, huh?
Speaker:I am dead.
Speaker:Kelly, what are your thoughts?
Speaker:So, I, this was like my intro into reading romance.
Speaker:Like, I, for whatever thoughts I have about Twilight, or anybody has
Speaker:about Twilight, whether it's you know, great literature or whatever.
Speaker:This was definitely like my first introduction into the world of romance.
Speaker:And the following year was when I started reading adult romance.
Speaker:I agree this color design, I mean the colors, the design, it just, it is
Speaker:not fit for this particular series.
Speaker:And I, but I feel like it kind of taps into We see them doing all of
Speaker:the the classics and Jane Austen and putting this beautiful binding on them.
Speaker:And look I am, it gets me, like, it gets me.
Speaker:I all want to pick up a copy of Frankenstein because I see
Speaker:this beautiful cover on it.
Speaker:And it's also a little bit romanticy because we do see a lot of that design
Speaker:with romanticy, which is hot right now.
Speaker:So I do get I need to crack the code.
Speaker:You crack the code.
Speaker:Romanticy is the vibe they are going for.
Speaker:They want to get this new romanticy audience and not to bring it back to
Speaker:Jane Austen because y'all have listened to me rant about it on Substack.
Speaker:I have a dedicated video on YouTube about it.
Speaker:I did it in another live, but I think.
Speaker:Actually, they're trying to attract the new Romanticy crowd.
Speaker:Maybe Gen D folks who might have missed it.
Speaker:Cause obviously they weren't around.
Speaker:And then now Gen Alpha maybe get some of them.
Speaker:Twilight twilight!
Speaker:Even when they're little, they're saying twilight.
Speaker:But I love how That's Romanticy font.
Speaker:Like, I feel like I know that font.
Speaker:It's swirly, all caps.
Speaker:No, I get that.
Speaker:I get that.
Speaker:It's very interesting.
Speaker:That we can all agree on one thing and it's profound impact on
Speaker:reading So not for nothing because like I said twilight was okay.
Speaker:I'm not here dishing out five stars or whatever, but I, we would be remiss not
Speaker:to mention just how it really ignited reading and it got folks to read.
Speaker:It's one of those books.
Speaker:So yeah, Twilight is 20 years old.
Speaker:This is how I know I'm really getting old because I felt like I was really old.
Speaker:Back in my age, we read.
Speaker:I remember back in my day, I remember going to the midnight screening
Speaker:of the first movie at our recently opened movie theater in town.
Speaker:It was my senior year of high school was when the first movie came out.
Speaker:So, and there was nobody there because nobody really knew it.
Speaker:Yet, by the time I went to the midnight premiere of the second
Speaker:movie, though, that was really packed.
Speaker:Listen, when that book came out, I was a whole adult with a
Speaker:whole bunch of responsibilities.
Speaker:And I was just like, huh?
Speaker:And then to Fran's point, it was the same thing.
Speaker:The movie came out and I was like, okay, you know what?
Speaker:Let me just give it a read.
Speaker:And it was a good binge again.
Speaker:It was a week.
Speaker:It was a great binge.
Speaker:It was a weekend.
Speaker:I actually think the weather was bad too, cause I was indoors all weekend.
Speaker:It was great.
Speaker:So again, Twilight really made folks read.
Speaker:Y'all let us know in the comments, your thoughts on the cover design.
Speaker:But we're just going to move on next to the next headline real quick.
Speaker:It really doesn't need much discussion sunrise on the reaping.
Speaker:The audio book is to be narrated by Yellowstone star, Jefferson white,
Speaker:just in case you're not familiar.
Speaker:This is a highly anticipated latest book in the hunger game series, which
Speaker:will be available March 18th, 2025.
Speaker:It will also be told from the point of view of Hamish.
Speaker:So we're going to get Hamish's.
Speaker:Point of view and yes, this yellowstone star will narrate the audio book.
Speaker:So yeah I don't know this person.
Speaker:I don't watch yellowstone I don't know this name, but I am looking forward to
Speaker:sunrise on the reaping So just so you know newsworthy that's what's next But what we
Speaker:need to talk about that is conversation worthy is our next headline this time
Speaker:I got the news from vulture again.
Speaker:I'll include links to all the sources in the video's description So the headline
Speaker:reads a court of thorns and roses tv series Doesn't survive valentine's day.
Speaker:I'm going to read it cause it's really short, but I also have it
Speaker:up on screen just because I'm like, yes, look, I'm quoting the people.
Speaker:So this is from vulture.
Speaker:Oops.
Speaker:Nevermind.
Speaker:After a year's long situation ship, Hulu decided not to seal the deal
Speaker:and is no longer developing Sarah J masses, a quarter of thorns
Speaker:and roses into a scripted series.
Speaker:Vulture has confirmed news broke on Valentine's weekend.
Speaker:A. K. A. It was the worst news for a time all about roses and romance reps for 20th
Speaker:television and Hulu declined to comment.
Speaker:The show has been in development since 2021 with outlanders Ronald anymore
Speaker:originally hired as the show runner.
Speaker:Just last year there was a rumor that the series was canceled.
Speaker:However, the streamer confirmed our Qatar was still in
Speaker:development in February, 2024.
Speaker:Variety reports that Mass hopes to shop the series elsewhere
Speaker:as Disney has the rights to the series through to summer 2025.
Speaker:The ball is now in another studio's court and they have all
Speaker:summer to prepare for a battle.
Speaker:Y'all let me know what you think about Sarah J Mass
Speaker:series at Qatar being canceled.
Speaker:I find it interesting.
Speaker:She wants to go around immediately to shop it once the holding period has ended.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:I'm just like what is going on?
Speaker:Why is this being canceled?
Speaker:Why does she have to shop it elsewhere?
Speaker:Is it a creative thing?
Speaker:Is it, we're not aligning on the vision.
Speaker:Why is it taking so long?
Speaker:I'm sure fans of ACOTAR aren't pleased.
Speaker:Laura, what do you think?
Speaker:So same thing happened to Jennifer Armitra.
Speaker:I think she had a similar issue with Hulu.
Speaker:They canceled the show.
Speaker:The From Blood and Ash was picked up by Amazon.
Speaker:So there's probably something to be said.
Speaker:Hulu, Disney might have vision.
Speaker:They might have some They might not agree on the vision of the book
Speaker:and what their brand looks like.
Speaker:Just, I read Disney High and it's a really good book to hear about
Speaker:the Disney, how the brand is doing.
Speaker:So it might be something to be said, but I think there's creative difference
Speaker:between Sarah J Maas and The vision, and then there's also the expectation
Speaker:of the audience of how this needs to go.
Speaker:And you're going to disappoint the audience chances are.
Speaker:So yeah.
Speaker:What do you think, Fran?
Speaker:So I am probably the one that's going to say this time that I could care less.
Speaker:I read the first book, didn't like it, didn't continue.
Speaker:So I am like not the Sarah J Maas person here at all.
Speaker:And I'm kind of over hearing about it all the time, whether it's her books
Speaker:or even like all the chatter that's been going on about this going into
Speaker:a production for being a TV series.
Speaker:So in a way, I'm like, okay, finally, there's some resolution,
Speaker:but I'm also not surprised that she's gonna shop around immediately.
Speaker:Like that's very on brand.
Speaker:Okay, what do you think?
Speaker:I mean, I have a lot of thoughts on this.
Speaker:And especially because like, whatever, I'm out in LA and trying to Pursue, whatever.
Speaker:I feel like it all comes down to people and I can, I'll take, I could explain
Speaker:this in an entirety of like 45 minutes.
Speaker:I just think people don't know what to do with female characters
Speaker:enjoying sex and female characters having sex and portraying sex from a
Speaker:feminine female gaze point of view.
Speaker:So the reason why I think that Maybe it didn't do as well as
Speaker:because you see like kind of pitch.
Speaker:I imagine this is just pitch decks are landing on the CEO of Disney and all of
Speaker:these like executives and they're all like dudes who have like all their only job
Speaker:is to just save money and not Spend money and to appease, board members and they
Speaker:just see it and they just laugh it off.
Speaker:And like, I think that like, I know that I'm sure that things are trickling
Speaker:down from other levels, but I just think that it all, maybe I could be wrong.
Speaker:It all boils down to no one takes the genre seriously.
Speaker:And, like, I feel like if this were George r. Martin's Court of Thorns and
Speaker:Roses, it absolutely would be greenlit.
Speaker:And I think that's the issue.
Speaker:Wow.
Speaker:Kelly, what are your thoughts?
Speaker:Yeah, I can speak to this a few different ways.
Speaker:Becky and I have both worked in film and television.
Speaker:And so I really, I do agree with that in that it all comes down to money.
Speaker:Like a lot, all of the time in television, like always, whether
Speaker:you want to acknowledge it or not.
Speaker:That is always, if you ask any question of like, well, why did they make this choice?
Speaker:Or why did this happen?
Speaker:Or why was this person cast?
Speaker:It's always about money, right?
Speaker:And we're speaking from experience on that.
Speaker:Like it is always about the money.
Speaker:And I do think that if it was a male driven lead in this show or hypothetical
Speaker:adaptation that they were going to make about this, if it was not.
Speaker:sold as romance, but rather fantasy or science fiction,
Speaker:that would make a difference.
Speaker:I think if the author was male, that would make a difference.
Speaker:There, we see a lot of like high fantasy do well with like
Speaker:stuff like game of thrones.
Speaker:But I also think that's kind of an anomaly, like I don't think that
Speaker:romance not romance specifically, but I don't think romanticy is having
Speaker:the same drive in film and television that it is in book form, and it's
Speaker:because it's expensive, right?
Speaker:I, that's exactly it.
Speaker:I think it's too expensive, and that's why they turned it down.
Speaker:I think that's what it comes down to.
Speaker:So for Becky and Kelly, who have this experience, So my question is because my
Speaker:first gut reaction because i'm listening to y'all i'm like, well, I trust y'all
Speaker:this makes sense But folks would argue this would be a big money maker, and
Speaker:I know it's within the fandom and the romance romanticy community, but you
Speaker:think there's a disconnect between how the book community perceives it and what they
Speaker:see as big and what they love and she's a beloved author versus what translates
Speaker:to like, general population being like, I think it would still do well.
Speaker:Like if they made it, I think it would still do well, but a lot
Speaker:of people who are in film and television that have the money.
Speaker:To produce things who have the money to buy the intellectual property to
Speaker:then make it are usually a very similar demographic across the board, and that
Speaker:is older white men, and I don't think.
Speaker:that it's, I mean, it's selfish of them, but it's like, I don't
Speaker:think it speaks to like them.
Speaker:And because of that, they don't necessarily connect with
Speaker:like the popularity aspect.
Speaker:Like just see how long it took for something like Bridgerton to come around.
Speaker:Like we, we didn't have.
Speaker:A lot of, and that was at the helm of women, like, so I mean it really wasn't
Speaker:being pushed for, and when they made it people were like, huh, wow, I guess a lot
Speaker:of people like this, even though romance readers have been screaming it from the
Speaker:rooftops for years, so I don't know why there's this massive disconnect but I kind
Speaker:of wish the reason it wasn't being made was more of the fact that there are a lot
Speaker:of Readers, writers, bookish people out there who of their own accord canceled
Speaker:Sarah J Maas, like, several years ago.
Speaker:Definitely.
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:Myself being one of them.
Speaker:But I don't, I, that's not the reason.
Speaker:And that's kind of like Sort of the disappointing thing to
Speaker:me is like, Oh, I wish this was cancelled for the right reasons.
Speaker:Like, I wish that was the reason it was cancelled, and not just, Oh,
Speaker:we don't think romance will sell.
Speaker:Again.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:What about you, Becky?
Speaker:I mean, in my mind I'm like, Old white rich men, they love money.
Speaker:It's not just like how are we letting the money grab go?
Speaker:But Becky, I feel like to your point, old, rich white men love money.
Speaker:And I think that comes with a fear of spending money.
Speaker:And I think that is what is dictating Hollywood right now.
Speaker:We just had a pandemic.
Speaker:We just had two strikes.
Speaker:People are scared to spend money.
Speaker:And I think that like they're only looking at like intellectual
Speaker:property that they know.
Speaker:will sell.
Speaker:And I just think like right now, like even like, I don't know,
Speaker:like there, there are a lot less productions happening in LA right now.
Speaker:A lot of people don't have jobs.
Speaker:And like, it kind of correlates when you see an actor who's the
Speaker:star of a TV show, doing an audio book, it kind of correlates.
Speaker:Like, I feel like you see big star, if you see big stars doing commercials
Speaker:or big stars doing, taking jobs.
Speaker:Podcasts, like I feel like there's a, there is so much less
Speaker:content being made right now.
Speaker:And there's a lot of people are out of work.
Speaker:It's an interesting time to say the least.
Speaker:And it's so, it just, I don't know, it just doesn't surprise me that people
Speaker:are going to be stingy with their money, especially when it comes to.
Speaker:new ideas.
Speaker:Even if it is already been, even if those ideas have already been
Speaker:published in a popular book series Hollywood tends to be the opposite
Speaker:of what book publishing tries to be.
Speaker:Book publishing tries to stay ahead.
Speaker:Hollywood likes to recycle what's already worked.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And they've seen, Oh, I mean, that's why we see so many remakes.
Speaker:We're seeing Yeah.
Speaker:Then make live action how to train your dragon because people
Speaker:liked how to train your dragon.
Speaker:Did anybody ask for live action how to train your dragon?
Speaker:Probably not.
Speaker:So, they know what's worked and they just say, that's what audience is like.
Speaker:So we're going to give it to them again.
Speaker:Yeah, that makes sense.
Speaker:And if you're just joining us, we are talking about a court of thorns and roses.
Speaker:The TV series does not survive Valentine's day.
Speaker:Essentially the deal with Hulu has been falling through.
Speaker:It just so happened.
Speaker:Vulture wrote this on Valentine's weekend and what a time to do that.
Speaker:Let us know your thoughts in the comments on this one.
Speaker:I will end on this topic by saying.
Speaker:Book to screen adaptations are having a heyday at the Oscars, okay?
Speaker:I did a separate video on that, so needless to say, Hollywood,
Speaker:people, publishing, I don't know.
Speaker:Y'all need to get with it, because publishing is doing the thing,
Speaker:even though we see them making changes that we're questioning too.
Speaker:But ACOTAR is proven, whether you love it or not, and whether
Speaker:we support the author or not.
Speaker:That is what it is.
Speaker:To your point, Victoria, I will say, just like having taken meetings, there are
Speaker:people working at all sorts of production companies who find these properties, who
Speaker:find these books, and will champion them.
Speaker:Like, I know them, my brother does it, and they just get shut
Speaker:down by one person at the top.
Speaker:So it's like, I don't think it's necessarily like everyone in Hollywood.
Speaker:I think it's just the decision makers who are just saying yes, no.
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:Whatever.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:So, yeah.
Speaker:So there, it's, so it isn't to say that like LA is full of
Speaker:people who are just like, No.
Speaker:No.
Speaker:And also, noteworthy, it's Disney Hulu and I've tried working with them and
Speaker:they're very particular about their brand.
Speaker:Let's just say that.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:They cast Lizzie McGuire!
Speaker:Like, I'm so mad about this Lizzie McGuire because it was not grown
Speaker:up, it was too grown up for Disney.
Speaker:I'm like, put her in Lulu!
Speaker:I was one of the college girls watching it at 11 o'clock at night, that series.
Speaker:Me too.
Speaker:Please, so if you do want to hear about the Disney High, it's an
Speaker:audiobook and non fiction about the rise and fame of the Disney Channel
Speaker:and it actually goes over the Disney brand and all the different things.
Speaker:It's really engaging.
Speaker:It talks about all the Disney stars.
Speaker:If you have not watched Disney, you definitely, you can learn all about Hannah
Speaker:Montana Suite Live with Zack and Cody and all the peoples and stuff like that.
Speaker:It's great.
Speaker:It's a great place to understand from the Disney, from the Mickey Mouse
Speaker:Club to actually to what it's now and how their brand actually looks.
Speaker:I wouldn't be surprised if this also got, like, developed somewhere else.
Speaker:Like, I don't know.
Speaker:It will.
Speaker:I think it will.
Speaker:It will.
Speaker:I don't know what they have in place in terms of, like, how long they
Speaker:can retain rights to that property, or if, like, they have to sell it.
Speaker:Number 25.
Speaker:It said it in the article.
Speaker:They have rights until they sell it.
Speaker:Oh.
Speaker:It's just going to go and sell it again.
Speaker:Oh.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:She's taking lunches right now.
Speaker:She's at lunch right now.
Speaker:For the expiration date, one past midnight.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:Let's do it.
Speaker:It's either going to go to Amazon, HBO, like let's think about, well, we'll see.
Speaker:We'll see.
Speaker:Anyways, everyone, we are going over to Substack.
Speaker:We're going to be continuing the party on Substack for the after show.
Speaker:So again, there is a link to Substack in the video's description.
Speaker:If you're watching on YouTube, I think it translates to Facebook and other places.
Speaker:But just click the sub stack link.
Speaker:We'll be going live in five.
Speaker:But before we hop off here I just want to remind you laura francesca and I
Speaker:will be going live this thursday at 12 noon eastern time We'll be sharing
Speaker:book recommendations About books about black joy next week thursday.
Speaker:We're going to be doing locked room mysteries and then We're going live
Speaker:again the week after that to do spring reading guide We're going to be sharing
Speaker:recommendations with you as well because again We go live 12 noon Eastern time.
Speaker:So, do the conversions join us then.
Speaker:And again, use the links in the videos descriptions to connect with us.
Speaker:And we are going over to Substack.
Speaker:Alrighty, everyone.
Speaker:Bye.
Speaker:Bye.
Speaker:Bye.
Speaker:Thanks for joining me on this episode of The Watcherinex Podcast.
Speaker:If you enjoy our bookish conversations and want more recommendations, don't forget
Speaker:to subscribe so you never miss an episode.
Speaker:Also, head on over to The Watcherinex blog for a list of
Speaker:books mentioned in today's show.
Speaker:Happy reading!