The human brain evolved to deal with scarcity, not abundance.
Speaker AYou know, and for much of human history, there were no guarantees to when our next meal would arrive.
Speaker ASo our biological systems, our brains will seek out that sweetest, most energy dense food.
Speaker ASo we're wired to focus on the most salient stimuli in our environment.
Speaker AIt's not that our brains are not working well.
Speaker AIt's not that our brains are broken.
Speaker AIf anything, they're working too well.
Speaker BWelcome to the Metabolic Mind Podcast.
Speaker BI'm your host, Dr. Brett Scher.
Speaker BMetabolic Mind is a nonprofit initiative of Bouzouki Group where we're providing information about the intersection of metabolic health and mental health and metabolic therapies, such as nutritional ketosis as therapies for mental illness.
Speaker BThank you for joining us.
Speaker BAlthough our podcast is for informational purposes only and we aren't giving medical advice, we hope you will learn from our content and it will help facilitate discussions with your healthcare providers to see if you could benefit from exploring the connection between metabolic and mental health.
Speaker CWhat's the biggest medical and public health failing of our lifetime?
Speaker CWell, I'm joined by Dr. David Kessler, who's pretty clear that it is visceral fat, visceral adiposity, and the metabolic dysfunction and obesity that goes along with it and the just myriad of health complications related to it.
Speaker CBut what can we do about it and why are we here in the first place?
Speaker CWell, Dr. Kessler has an extensive pedigree to help us answer this question.
Speaker CHe is a MD pediatrician, but also a lawyer.
Speaker CHe was the former commissioner of the Food and Drug Administration.
Speaker CHe's been the dean of two different medical schools and he's a well respected author.
Speaker CThe end of Overeating, Question of intent he helps, which was about the tobacco industry and he helped sort of take on the tobacco industry and now diet, drugs and dopamine where he explores this connection between diet, visceral adiposity, insulin resistance, GLP1s and the food that we're eating.
Speaker CSo there's a lot to unpack here, but I think it's going to help you better understand the predicament we're in and how to get out of it.
Speaker CSo enjoy this interview with Dr. David Kessler.
Speaker CMany of the interventions we discuss can have potentially dangerous effects if done without proper supervision.
Speaker CConsult your healthcare provider before changing your lifestyle or medications.
Speaker CIn addition, it's important to note that people may respond differently to ketosis and there isn't one recognized universal response.
Speaker CDr. David Kessler, thank you so much for joining me today at Metabolic mind.
Speaker AMy pleasure.
Speaker CWell, as we've heard in the intro, you've got quite the pedigree with a lot in your background, in your history as a doctor, as a lawyer, as former head of the fda, and of course as an author.
Speaker CDiet, Drugs and dopamine being your new book.
Speaker CBut what I found really interesting in your book is really started with a personal journey.
Speaker CIt started with your personal journey since you were a kid, of weight gain, weight loss.
Speaker CSo give us a little bit about that background, about your background.
Speaker CWhat got you interested in this really this world of metabolic health and diet and how it all came to be for you.
Speaker AThe mystery of weight.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AI've gained and lost my body weight repeatedly over my lifetime.
Speaker AI have suits in every size.
Speaker AYou know, I had the privilege of co leading operation Warp Speed during COVID you know, an intense period of time for all of us.
Speaker AYou know, I found myself at the end of that, you know, 16, 18 hour days, you know, seven days a week, 676 million vaccines later, I found myself some 40 pounds heavier.
Speaker AAnd I just really wanted to dig in to this mystery of weight.
Speaker AHere I was, you know, I ran fda, took on tobacco, did Covid dean at two med schools.
Speaker AI usually can get things done.
Speaker ANo one ever accused me of not having discipline or willpower, but I just couldn't understand what was going on with weight and wanted to tackle that.
Speaker CAnd what makes your personal journey, I think so interesting is you talk about how during COVID you gained all this weight, but you weren't new to the concept of weight management.
Speaker CI mean, you had already written the end of overeating years before that.
Speaker CSo you'd already researched it and looked into it and.
Speaker CAnd yet it still kind of snuck up on you.
Speaker CDid that, did that kind of surprise you?
Speaker AAbsolutely.
Speaker AI was, you know, I did, you know, with a team, we did the food label back in the 1990s, you know, that nutrition facts panel on, you know, all packaged foods in the United States.
Speaker AYou know, I had written in this area, but I still had just, you know, very hard time controlling weight.
Speaker AYou know, I would always be able to lose it.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AGet it off.
Speaker ABut then, you know, I would go on with life and I would gain it back.
Speaker AAnd I really didn't understand why.
Speaker AI didn't understand what was driving that.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CAnd here you are within the medical system, struggling with the things that so many Americans and worldwide are struggling with.
Speaker CBut yet you had the inside track.
Speaker CSo what do you think?
Speaker CI mean, it's such a broad question, but what are we doing wrong?
Speaker CWhy aren't we succeeding as doctors, as a government, as you know, the fda, the dietary guidelines?
Speaker CWhy aren't we succeeding in helping people maintain a healthy weight and sort of by association, healthy metabolism, metabolic health?
Speaker AI think the.
Speaker AYou tell me, but I think our colleagues, the medical profession has been relatively clueless on what is going on.
Speaker AI think we've turned, we can turn around and see that the American body in general, overwhelmingly, I mean, is ill. Only 12.2% of us are metabolically healthy when it comes to basic parameters of blood pressure, blood glucose, lipids, waist circumference.
Speaker AAnd I think we, more importantly, I think we are all waking up to the fact that the problem is not weight.
Speaker AOkay?
Speaker AI mean, it really isn't how big or how small you are, but it is this toxic fat, this visceral adiposity, the abdominal adiposity that is metabolically active.
Speaker AYou know, we always knew, I certainly knew that weight wasn't good for us.
Speaker AWe always knew it was a risk factor.
Speaker ABut what we didn't understand was that it was causative.
Speaker AIt was in the causal chain of many cardiac, renal, metabolic diseases, diabetes, certain forms of cancer, potentially dementia, that this visceral adiposity really was at the center of many of those diseases.
Speaker AWhy did we get here?
Speaker AWhat happened?
Speaker AI think that the way I look at it, these ultra formulated foods that consume much of our diet, these ultra formulated foods trigger the addictive circuits.
Speaker AThese new anti obesity drugs can help tame down that addiction.
Speaker ABut the ultimate solution is obviously to deal with these ultra formulated foods.
Speaker AThe problem is this visceral adiposity.
Speaker AThe only way you get into trouble is, you know, that accumulation of that visceral adiposity that is a result, I think, I mean, it's complex.
Speaker AThere's no doubt.
Speaker AYou have to be in an energy positive state to accumulate that visceral adiposity.
Speaker ABut the composition of food also adds fuel to the fire.
Speaker AWe're just waking up to this and I think, you know, medicine has really not distinguished itself, you know, greatly on this issue.
Speaker CYeah, it is interesting as we start to realize something, I don't know, being so obvious, we always ask the question, well, why didn't we know this earlier and it wasn't so obvious, this connection that you're drawing, you know, a decade ago, 20 years ago, maybe wasn't so obvious and really is taking sort of a new focus.
Speaker CFellow mental health clinicians and healthcare providers, you now have access to a suite of free CME lectures on metabolic psychiatry and Metabolic Health.
Speaker CEach of these CME sessions provide insight on incorporating, incorporating metabolic therapies for mental illnesses into your practice.
Speaker CThese CME sessions are approved for AMA Category 1 credits, CNE nursing credit hours, and continuing education credit for psychologists.
Speaker CAnd they're completely free of charge on mycme.com now back to the video.
Speaker CNow, in your prior answer, though, you use the term addiction, which I think is really interesting because in your, in your prior books and your prior works, you didn't use the term addiction so much.
Speaker CAnd I heard you recently on Food Junkies Podcast, which is sort of, you know, all about food addiction.
Speaker CSo I'm curious to learn a little bit more about your sort of evolution of coming to the word addiction.
Speaker CBecause it's a, you know, from a legal standpoint, from a regulatory standpoint, it's kind of a loaded word.
Speaker CIf we're just talking amongst ourselves, yeah, it makes sense to call it addiction.
Speaker CBut for you, someone you know from the FDA with a law background, for you to call it addiction, to me, sort of comes with a little higher bar.
Speaker CSo tell me about that.
Speaker ASo let's just see if we can agree that the effect of these foods are both on these reward or addiction circuits.
Speaker AThey also are on metabolic circuits.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker ASo the reason for the complexity, in part because of the damage and because this is so hard, is because they're working on multiple biological systems.
Speaker ANo doubt in my mind though, they are working on these reward circuits.
Speaker CAnd by they, you're specifically talking about ultra processed foods and the ultra formulated food.
Speaker AYeah, I mean, I, you know, I call them ultra formulated.
Speaker AI call it the, you know, that perfect trifecta of fat, sugar and salt, fat and sugar, fat and salt, fat, sugar and salt.
Speaker AI mean, there's no doubt that they trigger the reward circuits and those are the addictive circuits.
Speaker ALook, I think the, the issue is that the word addiction is generally, you know, when we hear that, we think about the people who are weak, the downtrodden, right?
Speaker AAnd the fact is that maybe we just have to, you know, just tweak that paradigm of addiction, Right?
Speaker ABecause it's not about the weak, it's not about the downtrodden, it's about those circuits.
Speaker AIn all of us, the human brain evolved, I mean, to deal with scarcity, not abundance.
Speaker AYou know, and from much of human history, there were no guarantees to when our next meal would arrive.
Speaker ASo our biological systems, our brains, you know, will seek out that sweetest, most energy dense food.
Speaker ASo we're wired to focus on the most salient stimuli in our Environment.
Speaker AIt's not that our brains are not working well.
Speaker AIt's not that our brains are broken.
Speaker AIf anything, they're working too well for the current environment.
Speaker AI think there's no doubt that sweetness or these complex mixtures, I call it ultra formulated, not ultra process, just a nuance of addiction.
Speaker AYou know, those ultra formulated foods, you know, what we did was we, you know, we put them on every corner, we made them available 24 7, we made it socially acceptable to eat anytime.
Speaker AYou know, we're living in a food circus.
Speaker AYou know, what did we expect to happen?
Speaker ABut you know, the fact that they are reinforcing, and I think this is key, is that, what do we mean by that?
Speaker AI mean they are, they are psychoactive, they can change how we feel.
Speaker AI can certainly tell you how I use food.
Speaker AYou know, it's 10 o' clock at night, I'm tired, you know, I'm fatigued.
Speaker AI need to, I need to, you know, focus for the next several hours to get work, you know, give me something to eat, you know, and it's not broccoli, I can tell you at 10:00 clock at night.
Speaker AAnd I mean I would condition myself to use that food to change how I feel.
Speaker AAnd I think that's, you know, just food is very powerful.
Speaker CYeah, yeah, well, and the food that we recommend as a country, as a government, as a, as a medical society is supposedly geared towards the healthy person.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CSomeone without metabolic dysfunction and presumably someone without a food addiction background.
Speaker CBut it's not really in practice that way, is it?
Speaker CSo you wrote a recent op ed for the Wall Street Journal talking about how you were recommending a separate recommendation for people with metabolic dysfunction, including a low carb diet.
Speaker CSo I'm curious if this concept of, you know, one healthy diet for everyone is just now outdated and completely unhelpful.
Speaker CSo what do you think there So.
Speaker AA lot to unpack in what you just said.
Speaker AWhat, you know, became apparent to me.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AAnd I think increasingly when we, you know, our understanding of, of metabolism is this visceral adiposity is the culprit.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AWhat do we mean by this visceral adiposity?
Speaker AI mean, it's basically this fat accumulated in the liver, in the pancreas, I mean in the heart.
Speaker AIt's ectopic fat, it's pro inflammatory, it's releasing all these cytokines and chemokines that are causing organ dysfunction.
Speaker AYou know, interestingly, it's, it's, it, it's not all the fat.
Speaker ANot that I'm giving, you know, subcutaneous fat a clean bill of health.
Speaker ABut there seems to be this sick fat that accumulates in the abdomen that is worse.
Speaker AThe thing that once you've are in, once that there's visceral adaptate, right.
Speaker AThe, the one thing that I am absolutely convinced the science shows is that if you are hyperinsulinemic, right.
Speaker AIf you're insulin resistant, right.
Speaker AThat is going to add fuel to the visceral adiposity and make it worse.
Speaker ANow I think the sort of silent epidemic that's happened in the last 20 years, I mean there has been a doubling in insulin levels throughout, in the United States.
Speaker AI mean just blood insulin levels.
Speaker AAnd we know that if you are in a weight gaining state, in an energy positive state, if you have this visceral adiposity, that hyperinsulinemia is, I mean, is just doing you no good.
Speaker ABring down that hyperinsulinemia and we can see much of the metabolic disease disappear.
Speaker AAnd I think one of the great debates is what's the effect of this ultra processed food on insulin levels?
Speaker ARight?
Speaker AAnd you know, I think that certainly when you see in an environment of excess calories, of energy dense foods, I mean this ultra processed, ultra formulated foods, not talking about the addictive circuits now, I'm talking about the metabolic circuits.
Speaker ASo I mean I take food, I remove anything that has any structure, I mean to the food.
Speaker ASo the food I mean is just, you know, fat, sugar and salt and the glucose and the fructose get so rapidly absorbed, right?
Speaker AThey flush through the stomach, they get absorbed rapidly into that, the, through the duodenum, through the early part of the small intestine and they give rise to these rapid glucose spikes.
Speaker AAnd we've always been focused on glucose, but in some ways what we don't measure, I mean because it's complex, the assays aren't as reliable, is we don't measure insulin levels.
Speaker ABut when you look carefully, the reason why glucose isn't even more off the charts from this processed food is because that we're becoming hyperinsulinemic and that insulin is trying to bring down that glucose.
Speaker ASo imagine, right.
Speaker CI mean, so by the time the glucose is elevated, the process has been going on for so long already, but we missed it because we didn't measure the insulin levels.
Speaker AI mean, I think that that is fair.
Speaker AAnd then the question is, if you just have this wrap, if I'm just pouring in rapidly absorbable glucose and fructose, right.
Speaker AWhat does that do to your insulin levels?
Speaker CYeah, I think there's no question that the ultra formulated foods are playing a central role in all this.
Speaker CI guess one of the questions I have though is is it going to be enough to try to limit it?
Speaker CAnd one, how do we limit it?
Speaker ARight.
Speaker CThere are all these different, different permutations on that.
Speaker CBut the question of is it going to be enough?
Speaker CAnd so that's what really, really got my attention with the Wall Street Journal editorial you wrote about dietary guidelines, including a low carb diet, and you've been in the fda, you know, the inner workings of government and health and how they interact.
Speaker CAnd do you think there's any viable way to get a low carb diet in the dietary guidelines directed towards people who are metabolically unhealthy with visceral fat, with hyperinsulinemia?
Speaker AYou know, one, couple, couple of distinctions, couple of nuances, right?
Speaker AYou're using the word low carb.
Speaker AGive me a little room here.
Speaker AIn the editorial, in the op ed piece, I use the word lower carb.
Speaker CLower carb.
Speaker AOkay, lower carb.
Speaker AI mean, I mean, the reason why, look, nutrition is probably the least studied field for the amount of, you know, effect on health that we could imagine.
Speaker ASo there's a lot we, we don't know about nutrition.
Speaker ABut I think it is, I mean, it's humbling that we all respond.
Speaker AThere's just such great variability.
Speaker AI'm not sure low carb or ketogenic, you know, we can choose our terms is necessary for everybody.
Speaker AI think there's great variability and I think we have to sort that out.
Speaker ABut if you're hyperinsulinemic, I mean, and you have visceral adiposity, I mean, then I'm with you.
Speaker AI mean, then, then low carb, I mean, is, you know, I, you know, I, I think can be, have enormous health benefits.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker ACutting, cutting that out for somebody who's not in that state.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AI think that, you know, certain, I mean, you know, the same parameters don't apply someone who has a seizure disorder.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AI mean, you know, I mean, if I want to achieve a ketogenic diet because I want to quiet down certain neural oscillations, right?
Speaker ASo I think, tell me what we need to treat and what we need to get.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker ABut I think we're at a point where half the country is hyperinsulinemic.
Speaker AAnd I think that we have to recognize that these ultra formulated, ultra processed, energy dense, highly rapidly absorbed, you know, high glycemic foods are just adding real toxicity, real poison to the system.
Speaker AAnd we just got to Wake up to that.
Speaker CAbsolutely right.
Speaker CAnd like you made reference to, if you're treating a seizure disorder, if you're trying to treat bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, you know, we're seeing the effects of a ketogenic diet, but that's very different than saying we have a countrywide, a global population crisis of metabolic health, and how do we best intervene to.
Speaker CTo reverse that?
Speaker CAnd, you know, it seems like the medical answer is GOP1 medications, but from a dietary, lifestyle, nutrition perspective, I'd like to think we can still have significant impact and.
Speaker CSorry, go ahead.
Speaker CLooks like.
Speaker CGo ahead.
Speaker CYou want to say something?
Speaker ANo, no, I interrupted you.
Speaker AI apologize.
Speaker AI just bristled when you said GLP1s is the medical answer.
Speaker AI mean, I think that the right medical answer.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AIs to.
Speaker ATo bring to bear those tools that are effective, of which GLP1s can be one tool.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker ABut I think the medical answer, I mean, has to include that full toolbox of, you know, nutrition therapy, physical activity, behavioral therapy, and pharmacology.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CAnd like you said, you said, a medicine alone is not good medical care, and it's critical to also provide nutrition guidance.
Speaker CBut the question is absolutely, I mean.
Speaker ALook, you know, we're in a, you know, what's the great public health success min of our lifetime?
Speaker CI guess there could be a bunch, but are you talking about tobacco?
Speaker AI mean, to back.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AWhat's the great public health failure of our life?
Speaker CMetabolic health and food.
Speaker AI mean, and.
Speaker AAnd obesity.
Speaker AI mean, visceral adiposity.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AI mean, I mean, I mean, all these diseases.
Speaker AI mean that.
Speaker AAll these chronic diseases.
Speaker AI mean, you know, no doubt if you were a, you know, if you came down from another planet and you see one industry making billions of dollars making us sick, and another industry making billions of dollars similar profits to reverse what the former industry does, you would say, you know, something's wrong with that picture.
Speaker AFix the underlying problem.
Speaker ABut, you know, I mean, this is at the core.
Speaker AI mean, I think.
Speaker AI mean, this is at the core of medicine.
Speaker AYou know, my.
Speaker AMy hat's off.
Speaker AYou know, there are a lot of people deserve a lot of credit.
Speaker AThey've been, you know, I mean, you know, on the periphery.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker CYou know, steering back to the Dietary Guidelines, there was another part of the book that, that really stuck out to me where, where you said the dietary Guidelines sort of declare certain foods as healthy.
Speaker CAnd it doesn't explicitly say it, but it provides sort of the aura of you can eat as much of these quote unquote, healthy foods as you want.
Speaker CAnd since those by definition are high carb foods, the way the Dietary Guidelines is set up, it's provided an environment for us to eat lots of carbohydrates.
Speaker ADo me a favor.
Speaker ADefine.
Speaker AI mean, one of the problems is, you know, I mean, we can bring our friends, you know, and have this conversation.
Speaker AWhat do we even mean by a car bottle?
Speaker CRight, so, right.
Speaker ASo, so, so am I talking about a blueberry or am I talking about a blueberry muffin?
Speaker CWell, it's not really defined so much, is it?
Speaker CI mean, when you look at kids, schools, like when my kid goes to school, he's given a blueberry muffin as part of his healthy breakfast according to the, the Dietary Guidelines.
Speaker CBut I would argue anything but, right?
Speaker A40 to 65% carbs.
Speaker AI mean, I mean, there is a line in there.
Speaker AEat, you know, eat, you know, fewer, you know, refined carbs in there.
Speaker ABut, you know, there's, look, there's every bit of difference between that carbohydrate that has structure, that has food integrity, that has fiber, for which that glucose is not rapidly absorbed.
Speaker AAnd I think that's the problem.
Speaker AAnd there are other, quote, complex carbohydrates.
Speaker AI mean, the, the, the, the starches, and I mean, that are every bit as damning as that sugar and, and, and fructose, it is as rapidly absorbed.
Speaker AAnd look, we did, we did the food label back in the 1990s, right?
Speaker AAnd you know, it was a big fight.
Speaker AYou know, we were very proud of it.
Speaker ABut we, but we didn't ask the question of what is the biology of those, you know, ingredients they were putting on that label.
Speaker AIt's fine if, you know, we can talk about, you know, what's the fat, what's the cholesterol, what's the protein, what's the carbohydrate, what's the added sugar in the food?
Speaker ABut no one asked what's the effect of taking all that structure out, processing that food, having those rapid risers and having that effect that hyperinsulinemia?
Speaker CWell, and I think it's a, it's clear that we have to find a way to encourage people to eat less.
Speaker CAnd just telling them to eat less doesn't work.
Speaker CAnd that's why I was referring to sort of this halo of you can eat as much of these healthy foods as you want.
Speaker CAnd again, that's where GLP1s can come in to help people eat less.
Speaker CSo I think we also have to steer the discussion of what type of dietary makeup helps people naturally eat less.
Speaker CAnd I think forcing them to eat less is counterproductive.
Speaker CAnd that's where, you know, low carb keto diets certainly can come in.
Speaker CBut not the only way to do it.
Speaker ALook, I think you're absolutely right.
Speaker AGotta eat less, exercise more.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AI mean, just, I mean, it was, we told people and no one could do it.
Speaker AAnd why can't they do it?
Speaker AThey can't do it, you know, in part because of those addictive circuits.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AAnd now you have, you know, these GLP1 drugs, right?
Speaker AThey give people a way to do it.
Speaker ANow, I think we have to be clear that there's really no magic.
Speaker AI mean, the pharmaceutical industry would like us to believe, you know, there's something magical about these drugs.
Speaker ARight?
Speaker AAnd when I tell my, talk to my colleagues and I say they are appetite suppressants, they bristle, Right.
Speaker ABecause they're more than appetite suppressants, they say.
Speaker ABut I mean, I think the reality is least in significant part, probably not in all, you know, you know, entirely.
Speaker AI mean, I think we're coming to understand that they work by delayed gastric empty.
Speaker ASo food stays in your stomach longer.
Speaker AAnd when food stays in your stomach longer, you know, we've all experienced that, whether it's we have the flu with this decreased, you know, our GI motility or we have food poisoning, food just builds up, I mean, in our stomach.
Speaker ALast thing you want to do is put more food in your stomach.
Speaker AThe problem is, I don't know what you're seeing, you know, in your patients, but the average patient is what on these, you know, eight, nine months is the data that I'm seeing.
Speaker AAnd the one thing we know, if you go off them, you know, that conditioning, that, that, that feeling, that visceral malaise that the late gastric emptying is going to go away over time, it's going to fade and then people are going to gain back the weight.
Speaker ASo three, four years, you know, we're going to look at this.
Speaker APeople are going to spend thousands of dollars, the average person's on this for eight, nine months and they're going to gain back, we're going to get back all that weight and want to say, this is one big national failure unless we figure out how to use these drugs.
Speaker AAnd so I think, you know, my old agency needs to do a better job of getting, certainly requiring the manufacturers.
Speaker AI mean, how are we going to use these drugs in the real world?
Speaker AI mean, can I go back on, can I go off them?
Speaker AI can go back on them.
Speaker CIs that so once the FDA approves The drug.
Speaker CI mean do they have any role in insane how they're used or they're just approved?
Speaker ANow there's post marketing.
Speaker AWell, I mean they certainly have requirements to get the data.
Speaker AThese drugs were proved under the, the premise, I mean the people will stay.
Speaker COn them for life, which they're not doing.
Speaker AWell, I mean maybe if some people will do that.
Speaker ABut I, but I, you know, and I'm not sure, you know, what percentage we'll see but that's not been the case.
Speaker AAnd you know, I think we're all, you know, people are experimenting with microdosing and intermittent use and I mean that's the wild west.
Speaker AThat's no way to do pharmacology.
Speaker ASo fda, certainly you want to make billions of dollars selling this drug in the United States.
Speaker AYou can, FDA can require them to do studies, the post marketing studies of how this drug can be safely used.
Speaker AIt certainly has the authority to do that.
Speaker CWell, and I like your analogy.
Speaker CIf someone came from outer space and saw one industry making billions of dollars sort of making us unhealthy and another spending billions of dollars trying to undo that, it seems like the logical place is not to focus on building up the, the after effect, but to try and cut off the pre effect to try and cut off the industry making us unhealthy.
Speaker CBut in the world of regulation, in the world of free markets and companies, is there any hope at all of that happening?
Speaker AWhen you're taking care of one of your patients, you're going to tell them wait for the day where the environment and we fix the environment.
Speaker AOr you're going to try to help them today to reclaim their head.
Speaker AI mean, I think for the first time.
Speaker ATell me how you feel.
Speaker ARight, But I think finally, finally we have the tools so people can reclaim their metabolic health.
Speaker CWell, that's interesting.
Speaker CI mean it depends on what the tools are.
Speaker CSo for me personally, you're absolutely right.
Speaker CI'm not going to wait for that day.
Speaker CAnd that's why I use low carb and ketogenic diets in a lot of those people because I've seen it reduces the cravings, it addresses the addiction, it takes away the potential for those ultra processed foods.
Speaker CBut that certainly hasn't reached mainstream in that form in, in medicine.
Speaker CSo what, what tools are you referring to when you say we have the tools?
Speaker ANo, well I'm, I'm talking the same tool you and I have.
Speaker AWe have, we have the same tools, right?
Speaker ASo we, we have nutrition therapy, of which there can be, you know, diet, you Know, we, you know, the ketogenic diets, lower, low carb diets, right?
Speaker ASo that can, that can take away food noise for some people.
Speaker AFair.
Speaker AAnd we also have a, you know, some drugs, such as, not just the GLP1s, but the phentermine topiramate combinations.
Speaker AHow did those drugs work?
Speaker AWhat circuits do they work on?
Speaker AAnd then we have the GLP1 drugs.
Speaker ANow the one thing that's always fascinated me and I can't quite understand is there's no doubt that, I mean, how do those ketogenic diets decrease that food noise?
Speaker AWhat are they doing?
Speaker ARight?
Speaker AAnd, and you know, some of my colleagues, well, it's ketone bodies, you know, when I, I mean, I can simulate that decrease in that food noise by either these aversive circuits can counterbalance those addictive circuits, that GOP ones, or these drugs like, you know, topiramate can change, you know, the neural oscillations.
Speaker AI wonder whether the ketogenic diet in these GLP1s, I mean, in these other drugs, and I mean, this decrease in this food noise, whether the, whether the kind of neural changes that are happening that mean to me that that decrease in food noise is just a reduction of that addiction, right?
Speaker AIt's a reduction of that cue induced wanting, right?
Speaker AI mean, normally I'm highly responsive.
Speaker AI go in front of the refrigerator, it calls out.
Speaker AI go past, you know, my favorite place, you know, on the highway, and you know, all of a sudden I get cued, I get these thoughts of wanting and I can't get it out of my head.
Speaker AHow do I quiet that cue induced wanting, right?
Speaker ASo that is clearly, you know, neural.
Speaker AAnd you know, my sense is, I mean, there are neural circuits, not just one neuro, you know, neuro chemical.
Speaker AI mean, that is at play here.
Speaker AAnd, but my guess is if we understood ketogenic diets, these drugs like topiramate and these GLP1 reward mechanisms, I think we would find that, hey, maybe there's a common, common link to that food satiety.
Speaker ASo, you know, whether I can achieve that aversion through GLP1s or whether that aversion through ketogenic diets.
Speaker AYou know, I think that, I mean, my guess is, you know, we just don't understand ultimately what they're working.
Speaker CYeah, yeah, you know, it's a good point and it is fascinating.
Speaker CI've had a couple of interviews recently with people who are working with ketogenic diet specifically on addiction, whether it's alcohol or drug addiction.
Speaker CAnd certainly that also plays into food Addiction.
Speaker CAnd I, like in your book, you actually quoted Dr. Tro.
Speaker CTro Kalasian, who's been a vocal supporter of using ketogenic diets for food addiction.
Speaker CSo I think there's definitely a crossover, and I don't want to keep bringing it up to say ketogenic diets are the one and only answer, but I think they need to be embraced as a potential answer, especially when we're Talking about the GLP1s not being as successful in the real world as.
Speaker CAs, you know, the FDA had hoped.
Speaker AI think one of the reasons, one thing I do in the book is, you know, the reality that people are only going to be on these GLP1 drugs for eight, nine months.
Speaker AI mean, whatever it is, some people will be on it for years, some will be on it for a lifetime, some will be on it for months.
Speaker ABut what do you, what do you do when you want to go off these?
Speaker AHow are you going to control appetite?
Speaker ASo I then go on a lower carb diet.
Speaker CYeah, yeah.
Speaker CSo how do we get to the point where we, as a medical society and nutrition society and a government can recommend multiple different ways of eating as long as it addresses someone's metabolic health, addresses someone's addictive tendencies, addresses someone overeating, rather than saying, here's the one way for people to eat?
Speaker AWell, first we've got to, you know, as they say, you got to understand the problem.
Speaker AYou got to understand you got a problem, and we got a problem.
Speaker AAnd the Dietary Guidelines have failed.
Speaker ARight?
Speaker AAnd they failed miserably.
Speaker AI mean, again, this is the biggest public health failure, I mean, I mean, in our lifetime before.
Speaker ASo we got to understand there's a problem.
Speaker AWe got to understand what the cause of that problem is.
Speaker AI think it the, you know, I mean, at the core of that is this accumulation of this, know, for lack of a better term, this toxic fat, this visceral adiposity, this, this chronic disease.
Speaker AWhat is feeding that chronic.
Speaker AThat visceral adiposity?
Speaker AI think it's hyperinsulinemia.
Speaker AWhat is triggering that hyperinsulinemia for, you know, what's making that worse?
Speaker AFor many people, I think it's rapidly absorbable carbohydrates.
Speaker AFirst we gotta understand, you know, we got a problem.
Speaker AAnd once we understand, you know, the, the.
Speaker AThe.
Speaker AThe cause, right, we can, you know, either take societal action or we can take individual action, but at least we can be armed with an understanding in a way that, you know, the, the fact that, I mean, how many books, diet books have been written, I mean, Right.
Speaker AI mean, so.
Speaker ASo the fact that, you know, I just wrote a book, you know, diet Drugs and Dopamine, on the mystery of weight after thousands of books have been written, you know, I mean.
Speaker AI mean, something's wrong with that picture.
Speaker AAnd I think there is a.
Speaker AYou know, as docs, I mean, there is, you know, much of this chronic disease, I mean.
Speaker AI mean, goes back, you know, to this core adiposity that is being fed by what.
Speaker ABy what we eat.
Speaker CAll right, very good.
Speaker CWell, I really want to thank you for taking the time to join me today to explore all these concepts and.
Speaker CAnd if people want to, you know, find more about you, where.
Speaker CWhere can we direct them to go?
Speaker AOh, well, I mean, so the book took everything I could, you know, I mean, took everything out of me.
Speaker ARight?
Speaker AI mean, it was an intense period.
Speaker AYou didn't tell me.
Speaker AWhat did I get wrong?
Speaker AI mean, in the book, what did you get wrong?
Speaker CWell, gosh, that's an impossible question to answer.
Speaker CI mean, I'm not sure there is a right or wrong.
Speaker CI mean, like you said, you're.
Speaker CYou're really trying to lay out the problem, and then the question.
Speaker CI think the question is, what is the solution?
Speaker CAnd.
Speaker CAnd how do we go about doing that?
Speaker CThere are so many different layers to that solution.
Speaker AAnd that's why I did the book that.
Speaker AI mean, that's what I try to do in the book.
Speaker AAnd it's not beyond our reach, right?
Speaker AI mean, you can.
Speaker AYou can make.
Speaker AI mean, if I come to you, right, I mean, you can.
Speaker AYou can help me become metabolically healthy.
Speaker AFair.
Speaker AI mean, that's a profound thing, and that's gonna.
Speaker AI mean, that has profound implications.
Speaker CVery good.
Speaker CI encourage everybody then to check out your book to learn all about you and your work and your prior books, too.
Speaker CSo we'll link to them in the description of this episode for sure.
Speaker CSo thank you again for joining me.
Speaker AThanks, Ramakhala.
Speaker BThanks for listening to the Metabolic Mind podcast.
Speaker CIf you found this episode helpful, please.
Speaker BLeave a rating and comment as we'd love to hear from you.
Speaker CAnd please click the subscribe button so.
Speaker BYou won't miss any of our future episodes.
Speaker BAnd you can see full video episodes on our YouTube page at Metabolic Mind.
Speaker BLastly, if you know someone who may benefit from this information, please share it as our goal is to spread this information to help as many people as possible.
Speaker CThanks again for listening, and we'll see.
Speaker BYou here next time at the Metabolic Mind Podcast.