Speaker:

Welcome to the Transit Unplugged Live, CEO Round table at the Vontas booth 2025.

Speaker:

I'm Paul Comfort, the host of Transit Unplugged, and we're excited

Speaker:

to be today at the APTA TRANSform Conference with a panel of five

Speaker:

of America's leading transit CEOs.

Speaker:

Let's give them all a round of applause.

Speaker:

All right.

Speaker:

Bring it in from the sides if you'd like to.

Speaker:

Let's go right down and talk.

Speaker:

Actually, let me start with Ken McDonald, who is the APTA CEO of the year in 2025.

Speaker:

And, next to him, Ben Stupka, the Executive Director of the

Speaker:

RTA in Detroit, and a graduate of Leadership APTA this year.

Speaker:

Congratulations.

Speaker:

Alright.

Speaker:

All right.

Speaker:

And Amanda Wanke she's CEO of Dart, Des Moines Transit.

Speaker:

And then my good friend, Ben Limmer, who we were just up filming an episode

Speaker:

of our TV show there in Connecticut.

Speaker:

He's head of CT Transit.

Speaker:

And, Jessica Mefford Miller, CEO of Valley Metro in Phoenix, where

Speaker:

we filmed an episode last year.

Speaker:

Thank you so much for being here.

Speaker:

The goal of the show and the goal of this live panel is to elicit great

Speaker:

responses from CEOs and executives about what they're working on, what

Speaker:

it's like to live a day in their life, and also what they see the future as.

Speaker:

So let's start.

Speaker:

With Jessica.

Speaker:

So Jessica heads up the transit system.

Speaker:

She came from Bi-State in St. Louis, where I got to know her some there.

Speaker:

And, now she's the CEO in Phoenix, Arizona.

Speaker:

So give us a little about your agency.

Speaker:

Tell us about the size and scope of your responsibilities.

Speaker:

Let's start with you.

Speaker:

Thanks.

Speaker:

Paul Valley Metro is the regional public transportation authority for the Phoenix

Speaker:

Metropolitan Region, and we operate bus, light rail, paratransit, demand responsive

Speaker:

service, as well as streetcar across the vast Maricopa County metropolitan region.

Speaker:

We have a number of operators across Valley Metro.

Speaker:

The Valley Metro team itself, including our contract workforce, is about 2000.

Speaker:

2000 people.

Speaker:

And, you just recently opened a whole new line.

Speaker:

Tell us about that.

Speaker:

That's right.

Speaker:

We opened the South Central Light Rail extension in June of this year.

Speaker:

Five and a half miles, eight stations connecting downtown

Speaker:

Phoenix with South Central Phoenix.

Speaker:

So we celebrated that with 5,000 of our friends and neighbors on a hot

Speaker:

and sunny day in Phoenix in June.

Speaker:

5,000 people out for a transit event.

Speaker:

That's saying something that's exciting.

Speaker:

Alright.

Speaker:

Ben Limmer has been a good friend of mine for a long time.

Speaker:

He heads up Connecticut transit authority, kind of similar to what

Speaker:

Maryland is, a statewide agency.

Speaker:

He heads up transit.

Speaker:

There's very unique responsibility.

Speaker:

Tell us about what you've got going there, Ben.

Speaker:

Yeah, I mean, you're spot on.

Speaker:

We are one of the few states where the statewide organization actually

Speaker:

operates the transit system.

Speaker:

So we have about 700 buses.

Speaker:

We have 420 rail cars.

Speaker:

We have three commuter rail lines, of course bus routes all over the state.

Speaker:

And we, similar to Jessica use a lot of contracted operators.

Speaker:

All in all, it's about 6,500 employees providing transit

Speaker:

services throughout our state.

Speaker:

And I'm very happy to be up here 'cause I was born in Michigan, went

Speaker:

to college in Iowa, and my first big transit job was in Phoenix.

Speaker:

So happy to be up here with these folks.

Speaker:

That's great.

Speaker:

And, in Connecticut, Ben, tell us about the place of, you may not

Speaker:

have known this, but Connecticut is the birthplace of an American icon.

Speaker:

The hamburger.

Speaker:

And you get nothing but the bread and the burgers.

Speaker:

That's right.

Speaker:

So don't ask for like jalapenos or something, 'cause

Speaker:

you are not gonna get it.

Speaker:

Literally the hamburger was invented and first sold there in Connecticut.

Speaker:

Anyway, just interesting little fact.

Speaker:

Alright, Amanda, tell us about Des Moines, Iowa and your transit agency there.

Speaker:

Good afternoon.

Speaker:

I'm Amanda and the Des Moines area Regional Transit Authority is

Speaker:

made up of 11 member governments, including a county and 10 cities.

Speaker:

We have approximately 130 vehicles and about 300 employees operating fixed route,

Speaker:

microtransit, and paratransit as well.

Speaker:

Ken, tell us about Long Beach Transit.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

I'm Ken McDonald, I'm the President and the CEO at Long Beach Transit,

Speaker:

which is south of LA County in well southern part of LA County.

Speaker:

We have about 250 buses.

Speaker:

We carry about 19 million people a year.

Speaker:

So we are in a dense urban area.

Speaker:

We have four water taxis that we also operate in paratransit.

Speaker:

Important thing about us we had paratransit operation in 1978, so

Speaker:

long before paratransit was something in the industry, Long Beach Transit

Speaker:

was providing that service to people with the necessity to get around

Speaker:

on outside of our regular buses.

Speaker:

That's great, man.

Speaker:

Thanks.

Speaker:

Ben.

Speaker:

All right.

Speaker:

tell us about what's happening in Detroit.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And explain the structure.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

It's kind of similar to Chicago, but your RTA actually operates service.

Speaker:

Yeah, we're, so we're a pretty unique and young agency, so we're about 10 years old.

Speaker:

The Regional Transit Authority of Southeast Michigan covers a four county

Speaker:

region, so about 4 million people.

Speaker:

There's three large transit providers that we work with.

Speaker:

We're the funding agency and the regional planning agency, and we

Speaker:

run regional programs for them.

Speaker:

So if you take the full scope of the entire region, we're talking about three

Speaker:

major agencies, two rail operations, about several dozen, over 50 small

Speaker:

community operations, 600 buses.

Speaker:

Tons of- 10,000 bus stops.

Speaker:

It's a pretty big scope.

Speaker:

We just recently started operating some express bus services under a contract.

Speaker:

Those are our first major express bus services we've ever had in the region.

Speaker:

And then just last year, about a year ago in October, we took

Speaker:

over the streetcar operation.

Speaker:

So my day to day is things at a very, very high level and things at a

Speaker:

very, very close to the street level.

Speaker:

So it can be very varied.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Alright, let's go to you Ken.

Speaker:

Tell us about the biggest transformation that your agency

Speaker:

has had in the last couple years.

Speaker:

So, I think our biggest in 2016 we started switching over to a hundred

Speaker:

percent zero emission vehicles.

Speaker:

That was a big transition for our agency.

Speaker:

We are now going through halfway through this project, and our biggest challenge

Speaker:

right now is I tell folks that we found out that is it the chicken or the egg?

Speaker:

And I found out it is the chicken.

Speaker:

You need to have the infrastructure before you can buy electric buses.

Speaker:

So we are going through a lot of infrastructure upgrade at

Speaker:

Long Beach Transit right now.

Speaker:

Is your goal to go all electric or are you gonna add hydrogen

Speaker:

or what's your game plan?

Speaker:

Half, half electric, half hydrogen is our plan.

Speaker:

So we are-

Speaker:

That's good, man.

Speaker:

-close to 75% completed on electric and about to begin hydrogen.

Speaker:

Excellent.

Speaker:

Wow, that's good.

Speaker:

I'm a big advocate of looking into hydrogen.

Speaker:

I think that's a sustainable fuel for the future.

Speaker:

That's great.

Speaker:

Amanda, how about you?

Speaker:

What's some of the biggest transformations you've had there?

Speaker:

Sure.

Speaker:

So we are right in the middle of our biggest transformation in

Speaker:

more than a decade, and we are re-imagining our transit network.

Speaker:

But then even going beyond that, we're looking at everything from our fare

Speaker:

policy to an economic impact study to new partnerships and programs.

Speaker:

But we're starting first with the network and focusing that service

Speaker:

because I think for all of us we need to deliver the best possible service

Speaker:

in the best, in the most important corridors, and the region's changed a lot.

Speaker:

Travel patterns have changed a lot, and it's time to change that service.

Speaker:

How big is Des Moines?

Speaker:

The greater Des Moines region is about 750,000 as a region.

Speaker:

Des Moines itself is around 250.

Speaker:

Okay, very good.

Speaker:

If you're just coming up, this is a live Transit Unplugged Roundtable with

Speaker:

five of America's number one CEOs.

Speaker:

Next up is my good buddy, Ben Limmer from Connecticut.

Speaker:

Ben, you've got so much going on up there.

Speaker:

I was so impressed with your operations when I was there just last month.

Speaker:

While we were there, Ben and I got the experience of being able to go to

Speaker:

an REO Speed Wagon Styx concert and interview the lead singers for our show.

Speaker:

And so that was kind of fun.

Speaker:

The lead singer of Styx, which was my band back in the eighties,

Speaker:

you know, so that was pretty cool.

Speaker:

But, tell us about some new transformations you've got going on.

Speaker:

You got so much happening.

Speaker:

Yeah, for sure.

Speaker:

And thank you for coming up.

Speaker:

We really did ride buses and trains when Paul came up.

Speaker:

We didn't have fun the entire time, but we tried to.

Speaker:

Transformations, I mean, similar to my partners up here , I'd say one of the

Speaker:

biggest ones is we invested, noticed during COVID and actually even before

Speaker:

that, that our bus system was really the workhorse of our transit network.

Speaker:

Everyone loves the rail system to take you to New York or wherever

Speaker:

that might be throughout the state.

Speaker:

But the bus system was really the workhorse.

Speaker:

The governor recognized that.

Speaker:

So we invested about 15% more of our operating budget towards beefing up

Speaker:

our bus system and the returns on the ridership and the support we got from

Speaker:

the public was really off the chart.

Speaker:

So as we look forward, we too are going to do a re-imagining a bus system.

Speaker:

I think you're not cool in 2025 if you don't do one.

Speaker:

So looking forward to that.

Speaker:

Alright, so you've got so much going on too.

Speaker:

You just had a brand new line open up.

Speaker:

Also, Ben's system just celebrated 50 years.

Speaker:

That was great.

Speaker:

We got to see that we were there.

Speaker:

Alright, tell us what's happening there in the last two years.

Speaker:

What's the coolest thing?

Speaker:

The most biggest transformation.

Speaker:

So for us the biggest transformation that we've implemented has been rail expansion.

Speaker:

And in the last three years we have opened three rail expansion projects,

Speaker:

two light rail, one streetcar, all ahead of schedule, all under budget.

Speaker:

So building out this system and continuing the economic development and

Speaker:

the communities around us I think has been our biggest transformation so far.

Speaker:

But we wanna keep up with the cool kids, of course.

Speaker:

And we remember that 70% of our customers every day are actually

Speaker:

riding the bus portion of our system.

Speaker:

So next month we kick off the public engagement portion of our bus network

Speaker:

redesign called Your Voice Your Ride, where for the first time in 20

Speaker:

years, if you can believe that we are re-imagining mobility across the streets

Speaker:

in the Phoenix metropolitan region.

Speaker:

I love the artwork you had installed in your stations.

Speaker:

Talk about that for just a minute.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

We have a wonderful arts in transit program at Valley Metro.

Speaker:

By board policy, 1% of our capital program budgets are devoted to art.

Speaker:

Many of those art installations include artists from our local

Speaker:

and regional communities.

Speaker:

And on our South Central extension, we were very focused on evoking the

Speaker:

culture and the history of those communities throughout our eight stations.

Speaker:

So it's a wonderful program.

Speaker:

We have a program called Arts Line.

Speaker:

You can find us online where you can see a beautiful photos and

Speaker:

descriptions of those pieces of artwork.

Speaker:

Or better yet, come visit us take a ride, enjoy some art, some culture, some great

Speaker:

food, as Paul and I did when he visited.

Speaker:

Oh, yeah, man, that was good.

Speaker:

Yeah, you gotta see her episode.

Speaker:

It's fun.

Speaker:

Alright, so we are at the Vontas booth today and I want

Speaker:

to introduce Simon Ferguson, who helps lead up the group here.

Speaker:

Thank you so much for your sponsorship today.

Speaker:

And Peter Aczel.

Speaker:

Thank you.

Speaker:

So Peter had a question for me.

Speaker:

He wanted me to ask you all the, today when we met this morning, and that was,

Speaker:

how about you, Jessica, tell us about a day in the life of Jessica Mefford

Speaker:

Miller as CEO of the transit agency.

Speaker:

What did you do on a, I know every day is different, but what's

Speaker:

an average day for you like?

Speaker:

Yeah, so one of the things I love about this role is that every day is different.

Speaker:

It is diverse.

Speaker:

So each day includes communicating with at least some of my 19 member,

Speaker:

elected official board members.

Speaker:

So that's a lot.

Speaker:

Our 11 executive team members who are responsible for running the organization.

Speaker:

And on any given day, I'm probably touching six or so different

Speaker:

projects and programs that we're doing deep, deep dives into.

Speaker:

And then at some point in each day, I'm consulting our dashboard so I

Speaker:

know where we stand with respect to our performance, our operations, as

Speaker:

well as our customer sentiment data.

Speaker:

And then ideally, I make it home at a good time to see my children and

Speaker:

have a workout, which is the one thing I do for myself to de-stress from

Speaker:

the intensity of those busy days.

Speaker:

Let me ask you a question on capital projects.

Speaker:

So you have a lot of them.

Speaker:

How do you hold your engineering department and all the A&E

Speaker:

vendors that are there, how do you hold them accountable?

Speaker:

Do you do like regular quarterly meetings where they have to come in

Speaker:

and justify, or what do you do there?

Speaker:

Yeah, yeah.

Speaker:

We have layers of meetings.

Speaker:

It culminates actually in a quarterly meeting with the Federal Transit

Speaker:

Administration, our state safety oversight and our project management oversight.

Speaker:

But these detailed meetings review all of our progress

Speaker:

against schedule, against budget.

Speaker:

We identify those critical path issues, and then within our teams

Speaker:

we have very well-defined touch points and escalation points.

Speaker:

So if we're not solving something at that field supervisor or resident

Speaker:

engineer level, we have a clear process for quickly escalating that

Speaker:

so that we can resolve any issues with schedule, budget, contract, challenge,

Speaker:

so we can keep our projects moving.

Speaker:

And that is one way we've been able to finish ahead of schedule and under budget.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

One of the things people don't understand about CEOs is the agencies they oversee,

Speaker:

all these are larger size agencies, are almost, they're almost like

Speaker:

little mini mayors is what I call it.

Speaker:

You're like a mayor of a city.

Speaker:

You've got so many operations spread Out.

Speaker:

All kinds of construction projects.

Speaker:

You're interacting with the city council and state legislature.

Speaker:

Ben has to go up there and do that as a state agency.

Speaker:

And you become almost like a politician.

Speaker:

You have to lead from the front.

Speaker:

You're making speeches and all like that.

Speaker:

So the average day of a CEO oftentimes doesn't just happen

Speaker:

during the working hours.

Speaker:

I remember, and I'm sure you guys do the same, I remember laying in bed 11

Speaker:

o'clock at night like this, texting on my phone, and my wife's like,

Speaker:

"Paul, put your phone down. You need to go to sleep." I gotta do this.

Speaker:

You know, somebody needs a response to, right?

Speaker:

Ben, let's send it down to you.

Speaker:

What's a day in your life like, man, being an RTA where you kind

Speaker:

of oversee three agencies, plus you have your own operation?

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So I wish I could say we were as organized and buttoned up as your operation.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So we're still, we're still kind of a small operation.

Speaker:

So, the one thing I wanted to touch on, we do spend a lot of time with the

Speaker:

state legislature and our partners.

Speaker:

So particularly over the last couple of weeks as a state budget is hopefully gonna

Speaker:

be passed by the end of September so we can, you know, can keep paying bills.

Speaker:

So we, just last week, I went up with the CEOs from the other major agencies

Speaker:

and did a whole tour of the state capital with all the key legislators.

Speaker:

So that was really important piece of advocacy that we're

Speaker:

doing at a state level.

Speaker:

So I do spend a lot of time doing that.

Speaker:

I answered a text from my board chair at 5:30 on a Saturday morning, just like,

Speaker:

I'm sure all the rest of you guys do.

Speaker:

, And then for us, it's really learning how to also deal with things at that

Speaker:

level, but then also the day-to-day operations of a streetcar system.

Speaker:

So last week right before I came here, we just buttoned up our triennial

Speaker:

safety audit, which was so much fun.

Speaker:

So that's the first time I'd been through something like that.

Speaker:

So it's kind of ping ponging back and forth between things at the ground

Speaker:

level and things at a very high level.

Speaker:

I gotta tell you-

Speaker:

It's not boring.

Speaker:

Detroit is my new favorite American city.

Speaker:

The one from this year.

Speaker:

I'm not kidding, man.

Speaker:

And shout out to your new leaders there, right?

Speaker:

Absolutely.

Speaker:

Tiffany Gunter, the new head of SMART.

Speaker:

That's right.

Speaker:

It is phenomenal.

Speaker:

Great, there.

Speaker:

And Robert Cramer there.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

Running the city DDOT.

Speaker:

You guys have an amazing team.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Speaking of team, lemme call out my new buddy, Demetrius here from New York City.

Speaker:

Let's give the CEO of New York City Transit a round of

Speaker:

applause for being here today.

Speaker:

Great to see you, Demetrius.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

We just had him on the podcast to kick off super September.

Speaker:

Thanks for coming by, brother.

Speaker:

Let me just ask you, how are things going in New York?

Speaker:

Gimme a, gimme a quick shout out.

Speaker:

It's New York baby.

Speaker:

It's always great.

Speaker:

You gotta listen to his podcast.

Speaker:

How many jobs have you had?

Speaker:

Man in the agency?

Speaker:

22 jobs.

Speaker:

He's worked his way up in the agency to the president of New York City Transit.

Speaker:

40% of all the rides that happen in any given day in America on

Speaker:

transit happened with that man.

Speaker:

He had 40% of all the rides in America happen in New York City.

Speaker:

So a great ambassador for our industry.

Speaker:

Thank you.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Let's give him a round of applause, man.

Speaker:

It's good.

Speaker:

He's a superstar.

Speaker:

All right.

Speaker:

Let's talk about leadership under pressure.

Speaker:

Speaking of another superstar, CEO of the year.

Speaker:

Come on, Ken, share with us a moment when your leadership team this year

Speaker:

had to pivot to meet a challenge.

Speaker:

There's so many things that happen any given day.

Speaker:

You can't plan your day.

Speaker:

When's the last time your team had to pivot?

Speaker:

I think we do that every day.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

You get up in the morning and you decide, I'm gonna go to work, and you

Speaker:

pivot as soon as you hit the office.

Speaker:

So I think the, as a CEO, I find I spend about 75% of my time

Speaker:

outside of the organization.

Speaker:

I used to think it was-

Speaker:

Oh wow.

Speaker:

I used to think it was 60, but I have a deputy who runs mostly of

Speaker:

the inside, but I find I spend a lot of time with customers,

Speaker:

with the board, with politicians.

Speaker:

You get all these questions and now in Long Beach with the Olympics and

Speaker:

FIFA coming up, we are planning, we have 11 events of the Olympics

Speaker:

that will be held in Long Beach.

Speaker:

So we have to think about tha transportation.

Speaker:

So being, planning for the Olympics and for FIFA is a big

Speaker:

part of our daily life right now.

Speaker:

That's good.

Speaker:

How about you, Amanda?

Speaker:

Tell us about a time recently where you've had to pivot.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Well, like you said, pivoting is a part every day.

Speaker:

Adaptability is one of our core values as an organization, and it is, you

Speaker:

have to adapt out on the street.

Speaker:

You have to adapt to the politics.

Speaker:

One of ours within the last year was when some of our member governments, we

Speaker:

were made up of 11 member governments, had a disagreement that went quite

Speaker:

public and gained a lot of attention.

Speaker:

We pivoted and took that opportunity and we always say, take lemons

Speaker:

and make 'em into lemonade.

Speaker:

And so we took that opportunity to talk about the importance of working together

Speaker:

regionally and to do some education on what state and federal government

Speaker:

says about the importance of doing transit regionally and all that goes

Speaker:

into running a transit agency because you all, we all make it look so easy.

Speaker:

So sometimes taking that step back.

Speaker:

To help people understand how complicated it is and why we all need to be a part

Speaker:

of it together is really important.

Speaker:

Ben, other than eating the best pizza in America that you and I

Speaker:

had in New Haven, tell us about a time when you've had to pivot.

Speaker:

Well, the big secret about that is I'm actually from Detroit and I think

Speaker:

that pizza is much better, but please don't tell the people back home.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Um, so yeah

Speaker:

And by the way, all the ingredients are flown in from Italy.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

At that place, man

Speaker:

This is true.

Speaker:

Check out the episode we've got coming up where they show us how

Speaker:

they make the pizza and all there.

Speaker:

It's considered, it's ranked number one.

Speaker:

Sorry, go ahead.

Speaker:

Yeah, no problem.

Speaker:

I mean, certainly, you know, you do, definitely your day can change

Speaker:

very quickly, as everyone has said.

Speaker:

The one example that sticks out is unfortunately we're seeing a lot more

Speaker:

of the extreme weather in the northeast.

Speaker:

So late last year, we had a significant rainfall and we had a large washout on

Speaker:

one of our rail lines, the Waterbury line.

Speaker:

So we had to quickly work with our partners in New York to quickly

Speaker:

mobilize and get the situation fixed.

Speaker:

But it involved, you know, dozens of local towns, the state legislature, obviously.

Speaker:

And since we are A DOT, we had pretty quick access to some

Speaker:

significant engineering and rebuild resources that, you know, that's

Speaker:

just a small one that sticks out.

Speaker:

One of the other fun things we got to do in Connecticut last month was Ben runs

Speaker:

ferries that take cars across this river.

Speaker:

And they have the oldest ferry in America that's still

Speaker:

operating from the 1600s there.

Speaker:

This wasn't that one, this was the other one.

Speaker:

But I got to sit in the driver's seat, the captain's seat, and drive

Speaker:

the ferry over with cars on it.

Speaker:

That was pretty fun.

Speaker:

I know I wasn't supposed to say that out loud, but I was, was a good sign.

Speaker:

I would much rather Jessica drive the ferry, but my nobody fell overboard.

Speaker:

My car was on the ferry.

Speaker:

And seeing you drive made me very nervous, but hey.

Speaker:

Rightfully so, brother.

Speaker:

All right, Jessica, tell us about a time you've had to pivot.

Speaker:

You've had so many interesting... she's got America's car-free city

Speaker:

or town there in your area too.

Speaker:

Talk about that for a second.

Speaker:

That's kind of fun.

Speaker:

And then any pivoting.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

So we have Culdesac, which is a development located in Tempe.

Speaker:

It is a car-free community.

Speaker:

There is no parking within Culdesac.

Speaker:

When you lease an apartment in that development you'll get a transit pass.

Speaker:

You'll also get a membership with a discount to Lyft for rides and

Speaker:

you'll get an e-bicycle, which super handy in the Phoenix Summer.

Speaker:

So yeah, check it out, Culdesac.

Speaker:

We pivot a lot.

Speaker:

So transit is 24/7/365.

Speaker:

So in the interest of keeping it real, , the last time our team

Speaker:

pivoted is about the time my head hit the pillow last night.

Speaker:

Things happen.

Speaker:

We are a big system.

Speaker:

We have 38.5 miles of street running light rail, and three

Speaker:

miles of street running streetcar.

Speaker:

And last night we did have a situation where a motor vehicle impacted one

Speaker:

of our trains in revenue service and everybody walked away thankfully, but I

Speaker:

had teams on the ground who are working at this moment to rerail that train.

Speaker:

And to support our revenue service.

Speaker:

And so that means everyone steps into not only their role, but also stretch roles.

Speaker:

So I'm up through the night getting information from my team, communicating

Speaker:

with our board and elected officials.

Speaker:

I have staff who are communicating with the public.

Speaker:

We were able to single track for revenue operations and the 4:00 AM hour today.

Speaker:

And now we'll work to recover that service and rebuild our overhead catenary

Speaker:

system today, moving into tomorrow.

Speaker:

So that takes everyone working together.

Speaker:

We're working in shifts.

Speaker:

I've got team who are flying back from Boston to Phoenix right now to

Speaker:

support that effort, but this is just, doesn't happen every day, thankfully.

Speaker:

But things happen and we have to work to respond, and I'd like to think the

Speaker:

success of our team and our collaboration and teamwork are never more apparent

Speaker:

than when things don't go as planned.

Speaker:

Let's talk about ridership.

Speaker:

It's not the number one most important end all, be all, do all,

Speaker:

but it is something that we're measured by, by those who fund us.

Speaker:

And so we have to know the room and the room for people that are

Speaker:

politicians and the funding agencies often ask us about ridership.

Speaker:

So, let's start with you Jessica.

Speaker:

What are you doing to rebuild ridership?

Speaker:

Where are you at in ridership?

Speaker:

Yeah, so our rail ridership, not surprisingly, because our rail system

Speaker:

is so young and it is growing, so rail ridership has returned in Phoenix faster

Speaker:

than rail ridership at a national scale.

Speaker:

Our bus ridership has been more sluggish though, and what we're doing about

Speaker:

that is investing in network redesign.

Speaker:

We've also doubled down on the fundamentals.

Speaker:

We're improving on time performance.

Speaker:

We've improved connections between roots and our customer responsiveness,

Speaker:

and now we'll redesign those route to reflect where people are traveling more.

Speaker:

We're also doing a lot of marketing and campaigning, messaging around safety and

Speaker:

security in the system where we've had a lot of big wins and messaging about

Speaker:

the availability of transit and some of the tools that we have to make buying

Speaker:

your fare and planning your trip easier.

Speaker:

Who else wants to tackle that one?

Speaker:

Anybody else wanna say anything about ridership?

Speaker:

Yeah, so at DART in Des Moines we're at almost 4 million rides a year.

Speaker:

One of the biggest trends we're seeing with other agencies and their designs

Speaker:

and we are looking at is really the hours of service and the span of service.

Speaker:

You know, we used to be very commute heavy, peak oriented service, and now

Speaker:

spreading that service out through the days, through the nights, through

Speaker:

the weekends, um, is really important, especially as we look at getting

Speaker:

people to retail and service jobs.

Speaker:

And that change in providing the service when people need it and

Speaker:

meeting those changes is critical.

Speaker:

Anybody else, Ben?

Speaker:

Yes and, to everything that we just said.

Speaker:

I'd say the two other things that we're seeing in Metro Detroit, SMART,

Speaker:

which is a suburban bus system, has had a lot of success with the flexible

Speaker:

on demand type zone service, I'm sure other folks have experimented with.

Speaker:

We've seen a lot of ridership gains in that service.

Speaker:

And then we, about three years ago, put out our first full express bus line

Speaker:

connecting Ann Arbor to downtown Detroit.

Speaker:

It's just a simple 16 hour round, 16 round trips a day.

Speaker:

Very simple service.

Speaker:

In three years, I've not seen anything less than a 15% ridership increase every

Speaker:

single month, which just goes to show if you put just basic good, solid service

Speaker:

where people are gonna use it, even in the Motor City, people will absolutely use it.

Speaker:

I keep waiting.

Speaker:

Every month I get my report.

Speaker:

I'm like, this is the month it's gonna be flat, and it keeps going up and up and up.

Speaker:

Something we're gonna probably have to deal with when I get back is

Speaker:

Oh yeah.

Speaker:

Talk about that.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So, the city of Windsor actually had what we call the tunnel bus that

Speaker:

would deliver workers over to Detroit mostly nurses and hospital workers.

Speaker:

And that service was just eliminated about a couple of weeks ago.

Speaker:

There was some Canadian political reasons for that, funding reasons.

Speaker:

There's other reasons that I think we all understand in terms

Speaker:

of relationships with Canada.

Speaker:

So, we're gonna be having a conversation on the Detroit side of

Speaker:

that equation to see, you know, is there something we can, we can solve

Speaker:

from a regional transit perspective.

Speaker:

And talk about the new bridge you got coming in between Canada and-

Speaker:

Gordie Howe, Gordie Howe Bridge, should be open next year.

Speaker:

So that'll have a bike ped path.

Speaker:

That project's been under construction and under planning for as long as I've been

Speaker:

in planning, which is gosh 20 or 30 years.

Speaker:

I actually started as an environmental advocate on the other side of that bridge.

Speaker:

I'll just leave it at that.

Speaker:

And now you're building it.

Speaker:

And now I'm excited it's being built.

Speaker:

But yeah, so next year that's gonna open.

Speaker:

And so again, having that connection, that transit connection, figuring

Speaker:

out how we can do that with our partners in Windsor, 'cause they're

Speaker:

essentially a suburb of Detroit.

Speaker:

And our hospital systems rely on those workers.

Speaker:

So we're gonna have to get, when I get back, we'll have to figure

Speaker:

out how we're gonna rebuild that relationship and that service.

Speaker:

Ken, I wanted to ask you about culture.

Speaker:

You've done a great job there, building culture and

Speaker:

retaining staff and attracting.

Speaker:

Tell us how you've done it.

Speaker:

Yeah, I think the most important part is we have five strategic priorities

Speaker:

that we rely on to plan it and design everything for the organization.

Speaker:

One of those is serving the customers first.

Speaker:

That whatever decision that you make in the organization,

Speaker:

think of the customers first.

Speaker:

So that customer first identity have gone through our organization.

Speaker:

All our employees believe that that's where we begin.

Speaker:

'cause that's the purpose that we are here for.

Speaker:

We are here to serve our customers.

Speaker:

So having a customer-centric environment has been really, really powerful to

Speaker:

changing the culture in the organization.

Speaker:

Ben, how about you down here?

Speaker:

This Ben.

Speaker:

Yeah, go ahead, Ben Limmer.

Speaker:

So yeah, I mean, definitely focus on the customer.

Speaker:

We like to say the, you know, the customer experience is our North Star.

Speaker:

But as far as building a culture internally is getting out, riding

Speaker:

the system, engaging with customers directly, engaging with, you

Speaker:

know, bus drivers, mechanics directly, hear directly from them.

Speaker:

And go to where they work, you know, go to their office and, you

Speaker:

know, most importantly, listen.

Speaker:

And follow up on what you are hearing from your frontline staff.

Speaker:

They are the face of the service and they absolutely need to be taken care of.

Speaker:

It goes a long way.

Speaker:

Alright, we're gonna pivot now to AI technology.

Speaker:

What are we doing right now with the latest technologies?

Speaker:

I recently did a podcast with Harry Wilson, who's the head of

Speaker:

MV Transportation, a great guy.

Speaker:

He actually was in Detroit helping lead the turnaround for General Motors for

Speaker:

the federal government a few years ago.

Speaker:

And he told me something that's resonated with me.

Speaker:

He said, "Paul, AI is gonna be bigger than cell phones and the internet.

Speaker:

That's the impact it's gonna have on our world." Are any of you all

Speaker:

seeing the impact in your agency?

Speaker:

How are you using it?

Speaker:

Is there any other new technologies?

Speaker:

You wanna start, Jessica?

Speaker:

Sure.

Speaker:

So, customer experience is our North Star and our strategic plan, and so we do a

Speaker:

lot of interaction with our customers.

Speaker:

We use traditional channels like surveys and follow up focus groups, but to

Speaker:

really keep our thumb on the pulse of our customers, we're using a tool, made

Speaker:

by AlphaVu that allows us to upload all of our customer contact data.

Speaker:

And then they also pull in social media data as well as

Speaker:

information from the news media.

Speaker:

And they have a tool called Ask Your Data.

Speaker:

And it really is an AI query so I can ask my data, what are customers saying

Speaker:

today about security on the system?

Speaker:

Which is a question I ask of my data several times a week.

Speaker:

These days, and I was actually just sharing this with administrator Molinaro

Speaker:

in a conversation earlier, here's how I know how we're doing in security.

Speaker:

It bears out in the monthly data in the stats.

Speaker:

But to really see what the customers are saying, it'll give you kind of temperature

Speaker:

information and then pull out illustrative comments that actual customers have made

Speaker:

or the public have made in social media channels and tell you what they're saying.

Speaker:

So that is a great quick way to really keep your thumb on

Speaker:

the pulse of the riding public.

Speaker:

Do you have anybody like monitoring social media at your agency or responding to

Speaker:

Twitter X and all that kind of stuff?

Speaker:

Yeah, we do.

Speaker:

Of course, we've got a communications team who is responding to that

Speaker:

and really mining that data and using AI helps us give more pointed

Speaker:

responses and it helps us be relevant.

Speaker:

So we're talking about what the people are talking about.

Speaker:

That's interesting.

Speaker:

Go ahead, Ben.

Speaker:

Or you wanted Amanda.

Speaker:

Yeah, so I think one thing that's really important is with AI is we

Speaker:

are all operating pretty leanly.

Speaker:

As a government funded, taxpayer funded, we really wanna return that investment.

Speaker:

And so AI is one of the biggest ways to help our staff be more

Speaker:

efficient, get things done quicker.

Speaker:

And that's one of the ways we're starting as an organization.

Speaker:

Again, I know there's a lot of fear out there about how it might

Speaker:

replace jobs, but for us it can be a multiplier where we don't have the

Speaker:

opportunity to hire more people, but we can make sure our people have tools

Speaker:

to do their job faster and better.

Speaker:

And then, as you're answering Ken, are you doing autonomous vehicles?

Speaker:

I'm interested in that if you've got any ideas on that.

Speaker:

No, on the autonomous vehicle, but I've been very fortunate that one of

Speaker:

my board members own an AI company.

Speaker:

So we meet once a month and talk about how we bring that into the organization,

Speaker:

and that has been tremendous in helping me to bring AI into our organization.

Speaker:

'cause I have an expert who is actually free that's helping me

Speaker:

to bring it into the organization.

Speaker:

And it's, and employees have embraced it.

Speaker:

I've been very surprised at how fast employees embrace this new technology

Speaker:

to help them to do a better job.

Speaker:

And one of the things I tell them is put on their computer, and

Speaker:

this was given to me on a book I read, how can AI help with this?

Speaker:

Put it on your computer, and every time you have a problem,

Speaker:

ask, how can AI help me here?

Speaker:

Write it on a sticky note, huh?

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

Old school for new school.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

All right.

Speaker:

Either the Bens wanna say anything on that?

Speaker:

We are partnering with the City of Detroit to do some AV shuttles as

Speaker:

well, but I'll let Ben talk about other Ben talk about the other AI stuff.

Speaker:

Alright, Ben, we'll bring it down to you.

Speaker:

Ben Limmer from Connecticut.

Speaker:

Yeah, I was gonna touch on the automated bus project we have going on.

Speaker:

Oh yeah, Ben.

Speaker:

Yeah, so we have a BRT line called the CTfastrak.

Speaker:

It runs between New Britain and downtown Hartford.

Speaker:

It's about 10 miles, been around about 10 years.

Speaker:

Also just had a birthday.

Speaker:

Ridership wise has been wildly successful, all of the TOD surrounding

Speaker:

these stations, but it is a formerly used to be a railroad corridor, so

Speaker:

it's free from automobile traffic.

Speaker:

So there's a ton of operational enhancements that you need to operate a

Speaker:

successful BRT line, but it's also the perfect place to test autonomous buses.

Speaker:

So we are working on a couple of pilot projects in that space.

Speaker:

Super excited.

Speaker:

Got one more question left for everybody, but I want you to

Speaker:

imagine a scenario like this.

Speaker:

Imagine you wanted to go from one city to the next.

Speaker:

And you were able to have a vehicle, autonomous vehicle pick

Speaker:

you up at your front door, take you to the high speed rail station.

Speaker:

The high speed rail station would take you at 300 kilometers per

Speaker:

hour, and take you to the next city.

Speaker:

And what would take you multiple hours, shorten it.

Speaker:

When you got to the station there was everything you needed there.

Speaker:

Coffee, your bags you brought with you, and then you're picked up by

Speaker:

an autonomous vehicle and taken to the location you want to be at.

Speaker:

Imagine the power of that seamless transportation experience that we

Speaker:

don't quite have yet here in America.

Speaker:

So with that is our background context, which I would love to see.

Speaker:

Maybe part of that could also be an, I wanna be the first in America to

Speaker:

ride the autonomous helicopter that lands on my front yard and takes

Speaker:

me to the top of the FTA building.

Speaker:

But, so let's look at the future, Jessica.

Speaker:

It may not be as fantastic as that.

Speaker:

But in your mind, talk to us about what the future of public

Speaker:

transportation looks like to you, say in five or 10 years in Phoenix.

Speaker:

So what we're working toward and what I see happening in Phoenix is that the

Speaker:

bulk of the miles for our customers trips are gonna take place on our mass modes.

Speaker:

Those are our big buses and our trains that are designed to carry large volumes

Speaker:

of people over longer, short distances.

Speaker:

But what we're experimenting with in the Valley where we have a lot

Speaker:

of lower density communities, that might be a reality on the beginning

Speaker:

or end or both of a customer's trip, is demand responsive service.

Speaker:

So right now we've got microtransit in place.

Speaker:

We also did a pilot program in the city of Chandler.

Speaker:

Got shortened a little bit because of the pandemic, but they used Waymo and

Speaker:

it, they were piloting that with senior citizens specifically to see the tolerance

Speaker:

of that type of service with this demographic, which is pretty important

Speaker:

if you're in the Sunbelt like I am.

Speaker:

And they loved it.

Speaker:

It was fantastic.

Speaker:

So I can see smaller autonomous vehicles operating on the ends of

Speaker:

trips, and then our high capacity vehicles operating and carrying most

Speaker:

of the people for the long trips.

Speaker:

And for those people who choose to live in our dense, vibrant communities across

Speaker:

the valley, maybe they're spending most of their time on those big buses.

Speaker:

Or those trains, but we're getting people to the other places that might

Speaker:

not be well served by a 40 or a 60 foot bus and certainly doesn't have

Speaker:

the density to support rail service.

Speaker:

That's beautiful.

Speaker:

I love that vision.

Speaker:

All right, Ben, what's your vision for five or 10 years for Connecticut?

Speaker:

I do think that Jessica's answer is absolutely spot on for the whole country.

Speaker:

Y ou know, we do a lot of customer satisfaction, customer surveys.

Speaker:

So on top of everything Jessica outlined, it's just making the

Speaker:

system more accessible, whether it's a tap and ride to get on.

Speaker:

I mean, we gotta be the last industry on earth that you couldn't

Speaker:

just tap something to get on.

Speaker:

You know, real time information as far as when the next bus or train is coming.

Speaker:

You know, it's really all the little things to just modernize

Speaker:

the system to make it easier and more comfortable to use.

Speaker:

So, Amanda, how about you?

Speaker:

What's your vision?

Speaker:

Again, on top of what these folks said, one of the key words for us and within

Speaker:

the industry needs to be sustainability.

Speaker:

And that can mean a lot of things, but our riders and our employees and

Speaker:

our communities need us to provide sustainable transit for the long term.

Speaker:

And we have to work together at all levels, local, state, federal, and between

Speaker:

our communities, which those relationships and that work can be really difficult.

Speaker:

So I envision 10 years from now where some of those relationships are a

Speaker:

lot smoother and we're living in a world where I hope there is a lot

Speaker:

more respect and listening for each other and helping each other because

Speaker:

that's the only way we as an industry, and a region, are going to succeed.

Speaker:

Excellent.

Speaker:

APTA CEO of the year.

Speaker:

Come on, Ken.

Speaker:

For me, the most important part is easy access to our system.

Speaker:

We have to make the system wayfinding and access to get into our system.

Speaker:

A couple of months ago I had never ridden Waymo and I took a ride in

Speaker:

there, scared at first do I get in a car that no one is driving.

Speaker:

But when I got into the vehicle and at the end of my trip, I thought, we have

Speaker:

to look at how we use this in transit.

Speaker:

Because it is way ahead of where we are in terms of having a 40 foot bus.

Speaker:

How do we extend our service with vehicles that are with no, with

Speaker:

no one operating it, but getting you to where you need to go?

Speaker:

So to me, there's a vision about wayfinding accessibility and less

Speaker:

cost to operate the vehicles.

Speaker:

Excellent.

Speaker:

Love it.

Speaker:

All right.

Speaker:

Bring us home.

Speaker:

You put me at the end of an august panel after the CEO of the

Speaker:

year, so I can say ditto, ditto, ditto all the way down the line.

Speaker:

I think, and we all touched on this, you know, transit and the reason I love this

Speaker:

industry is an absolute reflection of our society in the very best of what we are

Speaker:

in this nation and in our communities.

Speaker:

Whether it be innovation, partnership, customer focus, safety focus.

Speaker:

So I just see nothing but good things in the road ahead.

Speaker:

Bigger roles for transit, making land use decisions, economic decisions,

Speaker:

being at that table when those decisions are made, I'm sure we've

Speaker:

all been impacted by those decisions.

Speaker:

So really I just see a bigger and bigger role for transit, the

Speaker:

technology and all those things that will help us play that role.

Speaker:

I think nothing but good things ahead.

Speaker:

Nothing but blue skies, huh?

Speaker:

That's right.

Speaker:

That's beautiful.

Speaker:

Well, thank you all for being here today.

Speaker:

Let's give our august panel a round of applause.

Speaker:

As I mentioned, this will be on Transit Unplugged the podcast.

Speaker:

I also just wanna make one final closing thought, kind of

Speaker:

a point of personal privilege.

Speaker:

I served as CEO of the MTA in Baltimore, and I can tell you the lives they

Speaker:

lead, and it's a life of sacrifice for the good of the community.

Speaker:

This is not an eight to five job.

Speaker:

This is a job that literally is 24/7.

Speaker:

Part of the purpose why I started the Transit Unplugged podcast

Speaker:

was I wanted to give CEOs a chance to tell their own story.

Speaker:

Most of the time when they're in the media, they're responding real time

Speaker:

to a crisis like Jessica had too.

Speaker:

And they don't get an opportunity to talk about all the good things that

Speaker:

are going on because there is so much good happening in the industry.

Speaker:

Let's all become transit evangelists in our own communities and speak to the 85%

Speaker:

of voters who say they support public transportation even though they don't

Speaker:

use it, and they support it because it provides access to jobs, number one.

Speaker:

Number two, because it provides service to the elderly and people with disabilities.

Speaker:

And number three, because it provides access to services

Speaker:

for lower income people.

Speaker:

And the 85% of Americans that don't ride transit still see value in their tax

Speaker:

dollars coming to us for those reasons.

Speaker:

Thank you for listening to this episode of Transit Unplugged, the world's

Speaker:

number one transit executive podcast.

Speaker:

I'm Julie Gates, executive producer of the podcast.

Speaker:

Many thanks to the team that makes this show happen.

Speaker:

Host and producer, Paul Comfort, producer Chris O'Keefe, editor

Speaker:

Patrick Emile, associate producer Cyndi Raskin, and consultants Dan

Speaker:

Meisner and Jonas Woos at Bumper.

Speaker:

Transit Unplugged is being brought to you by Modaxo.

Speaker:

Passionate about moving the world's people.

Speaker:

If you would enjoy behind the scenes insights and updates from the show,

Speaker:

sign up for our weekly newsletter, which has links to can't-miss conversations

Speaker:

with the biggest names in mobility.

Speaker:

Head to transitunplugged.com and scroll to the bottom of the page to sign up.

Speaker:

Thanks for listening, and we'll catch you on the next episode of Transit Unplugged.