1 00:00:01,440 --> 00:00:12,321 Welcome to Top Traders Unplugged. In markets success doesn’t 2 00:00:12,321 --> 00:00:24,411 come from predicting what happens next, it comes from being 3 00:00:24,411 --> 00:00:31,665 prepared for what you can’t predict. In each episode we go deep 4 00:00:04,620 --> 00:00:10,450 with some of the world’s most thoughtful minds in investing, economics, 5 00:00:10,450 --> 00:00:16,280 and beyond to understand how they think, how they prepare, and 6 00:00:16,280 --> 00:00:21,580 how they decide, and the experiences that shaped how they 7 00:00:21,580 --> 00:00:26,880 see the world. No noise, no short-cuts, just real conversations 8 00:00:26,880 --> 00:00:31,650 to help you think better and invest with confidence. 9 00:00:42,860 --> 00:00:46,556 Welcome and welcome back to this week's edition of the Systematic 10 00:00:46,556 --> 00:00:49,916 Investor series with Andrew Beer, Eric Crittenden and me, Niels 11 00:00:49,916 --> 00:00:53,612 Karstrup-Larsen, where each week we take the pulse of the global 12 00:00:53,612 --> 00:00:56,972 market through the lens of a rules-based investor. Andrew and 13 00:00:56,972 --> 00:01:01,004 Eric, it's really great to have you both here this week and 14 00:01:01,004 --> 00:01:06,044 it's been a little while since I had you on Eric, so that's a real 15 00:01:06,044 --> 00:01:06,433 pleasure. So let me start with you, Eric. How are you doing? 16 00:01:07,560 --> 00:01:11,967 Life is good. It's hot down here in the desert in Arizona. Business 17 00:01:11,967 --> 00:01:16,374 is good. Yeah, I have nothing to complain about. Is a fertile soil 18 00:01:16,374 --> 00:01:19,764 environment for finding trends and there's a lot of dislocation, 19 00:01:19,764 --> 00:01:24,510 a lot of uncertainty, and I think a lot of risk premiums to collect 20 00:01:24,510 --> 00:01:26,883 going forward. So, looking forward to it. 21 00:01:29,000 --> 00:01:31,695 Exciting. Good stuff. And Andrew, not that long since we last 22 00:01:31,695 --> 00:01:32,920 spoke. How are you doing? 23 00:01:33,350 --> 00:01:36,221 I'm doing very well, thank you. Looking forward to the summer. 24 00:01:36,870 --> 00:01:51,858 Yeah, absolutely. Things are heating up in the US, with the invasion 25 00:01:51,858 --> 00:02:06,846 of football fans or soccer fans I should say. But we'll hear 26 00:02:06,846 --> 00:02:19,336 about that, I'm sure, as we head into the season. Now, we’ve 27 00:01:37,792 --> 00:01:43,324 got a few things that we wanted to cover today, but still 28 00:01:43,324 --> 00:01:49,317 I would like to just go a little bit outside the topics, as 29 00:01:49,317 --> 00:01:54,849 we normally do in the beginning, and just kind of get a 30 00:01:54,849 --> 00:01:59,920 feel for what you find interesting at the moment that doesn't 31 00:01:59,920 --> 00:02:04,530 necessarily relate to trend or anything finance for that matter. 32 00:02:04,530 --> 00:02:09,601 But Eric, since it's been a little while, is there anything, 33 00:02:09,601 --> 00:02:15,594 in particular, that I wouldn't say has kept you up at night, but 34 00:02:15,594 --> 00:02:19,282 something that you find interesting at the moment? 35 00:02:19,920 --> 00:02:29,150 It has been a while. I would say that the drawdown we experienced 36 00:02:29,150 --> 00:02:37,670 last year, maybe, what was that, 14 months ago? There were a 37 00:02:37,670 --> 00:02:46,190 couple of nights where it was more difficult than usual to fall 38 00:02:46,190 --> 00:02:52,580 asleep. That was a very challenging environment. The tariff 39 00:02:52,580 --> 00:03:01,810 tantrums that were going on in April of last year. Since then, it's 40 00:03:01,810 --> 00:03:04,650 basically been smooth sailing. Can't count on that forever, but 41 00:02:24,252 --> 00:02:33,638 it's been a very profitable period of time. It's been a lot of 42 00:02:33,638 --> 00:02:43,024 trends, a lot of risk premiums to collect, but there was a challenging 43 00:02:43,024 --> 00:02:52,410 period of time for pretty much everyone I know that was trend related 44 00:02:52,410 --> 00:03:01,074 in April of last year. But this year and the subsequent 12, 45 00:03:01,074 --> 00:03:04,684 14 months have been pleasant. 46 00:03:05,820 --> 00:03:10,660 That's good to hear. Andrew, since we last spoke, anything exciting 47 00:03:10,660 --> 00:03:14,620 that you've come across that you've been interested in? 48 00:03:15,260 --> 00:03:31,172 Well, I mean this was I'm sort of a, like a curmudgeonly battle 49 00:03:31,172 --> 00:03:47,084 hardened investor in a lot of ways and I'm very skeptical of a 50 00:03:47,084 --> 00:04:02,996 lot of things that are going on the markets. And you know, when 51 00:04:02,996 --> 00:04:17,684 I see the valuations of AI companies and the kind of circular 52 00:04:17,684 --> 00:04:29,924 financing and everything that's going on in it my natural 53 00:04:29,924 --> 00:04:44,612 instinct is just to, is to feel like… it feels “dot comish” 54 00:04:44,612 --> 00:04:47,060 to me. On the other hand, I was talking to the guys here at the 55 00:03:30,769 --> 00:03:40,313 office yesterday. And there's something so wonderfully optimistic 56 00:03:40,313 --> 00:03:54,629 and exciting about it. I mean, SpaceX, a private company like shoots 57 00:03:54,629 --> 00:04:07,752 these rockets into the sky and catches them with chopsticks. They're 58 00:04:07,752 --> 00:04:19,682 talking about colonizing… And like the private sector… We have 59 00:04:19,682 --> 00:04:31,612 companies coming back into the public markets after two decades 60 00:04:31,612 --> 00:04:43,542 of basically public companies going private and the wealth creation 61 00:04:43,542 --> 00:04:47,121 involved in it. So, there's something… I just took a step back 62 00:03:30,290 --> 00:03:55,340 and I thought this is… I mean, yes, maybe AI will kill us all in 63 00:03:55,340 --> 00:04:15,380 a few years and this will be… But there's something just wonderfully 64 00:04:15,380 --> 00:04:33,750 optimistic and exciting about what humanity can do at this very, 65 00:04:33,750 --> 00:04:47,110 very moment in time. And I don't know. So, in the midst of all 66 00:03:24,146 --> 00:03:43,399 the macro chaos, and waking up every night at three in the morning, 67 00:03:43,399 --> 00:03:59,690 and checking where the hell oil is, and everything else like 68 00:03:59,690 --> 00:04:18,943 that, I just had this kind of burst of optimism. And maybe it's 69 00:04:18,943 --> 00:04:35,234 just the fact that it's finally warm here after a brutally 70 00:04:35,234 --> 00:04:47,082 long winter. So, that's been on my mind. 71 00:04:47,450 --> 00:04:52,934 Yeah, absolutely. It's funny, speaking of AI, I think you and I, 72 00:04:52,934 --> 00:04:57,504 actually, Andrew, last time we spoke I mentioned something about 73 00:04:57,504 --> 00:05:03,902 AI and there was a single guy who had created quite a large company, 74 00:05:03,902 --> 00:05:09,386 in terms of revenues, just by using AI. Anyways, so, the other 75 00:05:09,386 --> 00:05:15,784 day I was sending a song on Spotify to my son saying, yeah, take 76 00:05:15,784 --> 00:05:21,725 a listen to this is pretty good. And he comes back, like half 77 00:05:21,725 --> 00:05:27,666 an hour later and said, dad, you do realize this was AI generated. 78 00:05:27,666 --> 00:05:34,064 I thought, wow! I mean this is crazy. If it can make music like 79 00:05:34,064 --> 00:05:37,263 that, we're in for a good time. But you're right I guess, is 80 00:04:55,526 --> 00:05:10,332 it an hour ago SpaceX launched? I don't even know what 81 00:05:10,332 --> 00:05:30,522 the price of the stock is, but I guess it IPOed at US$135. So, we'll 82 00:05:30,522 --> 00:05:37,252 see how it all goes. 83 00:05:38,230 --> 00:06:00,966 I don't know to share, but you know, but I think Musk just made 84 00:06:00,966 --> 00:06:22,078 another US$400 billion in the last hour. So, it just is… it's just 85 00:06:22,078 --> 00:06:25,326 incredible. Right? I mean, if you like hear the thing, the number 86 00:05:48,470 --> 00:05:59,734 of times it almost went bankrupt, and the way they're talking 87 00:05:59,734 --> 00:06:10,998 about the people who stood behind him through good and bad, 88 00:06:10,998 --> 00:06:22,262 the fact that this is an industry that had basically been 89 00:06:22,262 --> 00:06:25,334 nationalized for decades. And I don't know there's so much that's 90 00:05:45,206 --> 00:05:53,054 problematic, that I find problematic, about social media and 91 00:05:53,054 --> 00:06:02,646 technology and other things like that, but there is just something 92 00:06:02,646 --> 00:06:10,494 boyishly exciting about sending people into orbit and putting 93 00:06:10,494 --> 00:06:20,086 data centers in space. It's just… I don't know, I'm feeling... 94 00:06:20,086 --> 00:06:25,318 There's something wonderful about it all. 95 00:06:25,990 --> 00:06:44,814 It actually reminds me also about, we had a guest on many years 96 00:06:44,814 --> 00:07:02,190 ago, I would say five, six, seven years ago, a financial astrologer. 97 00:07:02,190 --> 00:07:18,118 So, even by definition that title, you get pushback when you 98 00:07:18,118 --> 00:07:35,494 put someone on the podcast like that, and he was making his 99 00:07:35,494 --> 00:07:54,318 forecast, and so on, and so forth. But actually, one of the things 100 00:07:54,318 --> 00:08:14,590 that stood out to me (and this was kind of the beginning of Tesla 101 00:08:14,590 --> 00:08:31,966 and all of that stuff), basically, I don't know if this was 102 00:08:31,966 --> 00:08:49,342 on the record or off the record, but he was basically saying, 103 00:08:49,342 --> 00:09:09,614 Elon Musk is going to be the richest man on the planet. And I 104 00:09:09,614 --> 00:09:19,750 think he just solidified that position today. So anyways, enough 105 00:06:31,594 --> 00:06:54,010 about that. Let's jump into the program, so to speak. Trend following, 106 00:06:54,010 --> 00:07:12,690 my trend, barometer finished yesterday at 43. That indicates a 107 00:07:12,690 --> 00:07:29,502 slightly weaker environment, the last couple of weeks. Probably 108 00:07:29,502 --> 00:07:46,314 that aligns with the performance we'll hear about, in 109 00:07:46,314 --> 00:08:10,598 a second. And I think mostly, at least from my vantage point, what 110 00:08:10,598 --> 00:08:34,882 I see is that equities and metals have been a little bit challenging. 111 00:08:34,882 --> 00:08:57,298 And that's probably where most of the difficulty has come, but this 112 00:08:57,298 --> 00:09:19,714 Friday, today, it might change a little bit going into the weekend. 113 00:06:25,990 --> 00:07:08,662 BTOP 50 down 69 basis points for the month of June, up 8.93% for 114 00:07:08,662 --> 00:07:45,238 the year. SocGen CTA Index down 58 basis points, but still up 115 00:07:45,238 --> 00:08:21,814 9.83% for the year. SocGen trend down 84 basis points, up 9.49% 116 00:08:21,814 --> 00:08:52,294 for the year. And the Short-Term Traders Index down about 117 00:08:52,294 --> 00:09:19,726 0.50%, but still up 4.84% so far this year. And in the traditional 118 00:06:37,386 --> 00:07:11,574 world, MSCI world, as of last night, down 2.39% for the month, 119 00:07:11,574 --> 00:07:48,611 and up 8 and change for the year. The S&P 500 Aggregate Bond 120 00:07:48,611 --> 00:08:25,648 index up 6 basis points for the month, up 64 basis points for 121 00:08:25,648 --> 00:09:08,383 the year. And the S&P 500 down 2.4% so far in June, and up 8.6% 122 00:09:08,383 --> 00:09:19,779 so far this year. Now, before we jump into the topics, because 123 00:06:58,318 --> 00:07:50,851 people heard that both you and, well, both of you were on the 124 00:07:50,851 --> 00:08:35,302 show this week, we did actually get a couple of questions, 125 00:08:35,302 --> 00:09:19,753 three in total, that I wanted to just briefly run through. And 126 00:06:27,781 --> 00:06:47,482 the first one, Eric, is probably to you because I think, 127 00:06:47,482 --> 00:07:10,765 in a sense, from your vantage point, you've been around for a long 128 00:07:10,765 --> 00:07:32,257 time, as people well know who are listening to the podcast. And 129 00:07:32,257 --> 00:07:51,958 of course, you launched your product, your fund, in 2020, January 130 00:07:51,958 --> 00:08:15,241 2020, if I'm not mistaken. And the question is really how you see 131 00:08:15,241 --> 00:08:36,733 the current state of the kind of US ETF/40 ACT managed futures 132 00:08:36,733 --> 00:08:56,434 industry. You fall in one category, Andrew, in the other. But 133 00:08:56,434 --> 00:09:16,135 how do you see maybe the evolution since you launched into 134 00:09:16,135 --> 00:09:19,717 that world? 135 00:09:22,020 --> 00:09:30,732 The developments have been positive, from my perspective. When 136 00:09:30,732 --> 00:09:44,284 we launched at the end of 2019, we took a long, hard look at 137 00:09:44,284 --> 00:09:55,900 all the different vehicles for launching. I would love to have an 138 00:09:55,900 --> 00:10:08,484 ETF vehicle someday. I would have loved it back then. But at the 139 00:10:08,484 --> 00:10:20,100 time, given the scope of our portfolio and what we were doing, 140 00:10:20,100 --> 00:10:30,748 it would not have worked very well because we have international 141 00:10:30,748 --> 00:10:42,364 markets and we have certain markets that the APs and the market 142 00:10:42,364 --> 00:10:53,012 makers in the ETF space, they weren't giving us positive feedback 143 00:10:53,012 --> 00:11:02,692 on being able to provide efficient liquidity in the secondary 144 00:11:02,692 --> 00:11:12,372 market given the scope of our portfolio, at the time. I was hopeful 145 00:09:27,543 --> 00:09:49,635 that would change over time. And the evidence I've seen thus far 146 00:09:49,635 --> 00:10:09,886 is that has been changing. Market makers are starting to build 147 00:10:09,886 --> 00:10:30,137 the infrastructure such that a portfolio like ours would run smoothly 148 00:10:30,137 --> 00:10:52,229 and efficiently in an ETF structure. So, it is on the horizon 149 00:10:52,229 --> 00:11:12,480 for us to look at offering it through an ETF structure. I think 150 00:09:25,828 --> 00:09:46,772 the things that Andrew has done were very intelligent; to take 151 00:09:46,772 --> 00:10:05,812 managed futures and reduce some of the dimensionality in order 152 00:10:05,812 --> 00:10:30,564 to fit it into an ETF structure. I think he's done a great 153 00:10:30,564 --> 00:10:51,508 job. Some of the other providers have also done a great 154 00:10:51,508 --> 00:11:12,452 job. And we've looked at doing something like that as well. So, 155 00:09:23,335 --> 00:09:39,115 some balance in the middle because you don't need all of these 156 00:09:39,115 --> 00:09:54,895 markets. We don't need to be trading platinum in Japan, and Malaysian 157 00:09:54,895 --> 00:10:10,675 palm oil, and whatnot. They're kind of nice to haves but they’re 158 00:10:10,675 --> 00:10:25,140 not needs in the portfolio. At least from a performance attribution 159 00:10:25,140 --> 00:10:40,920 perspective, you can kind of see that they just don't make that 160 00:10:40,920 --> 00:10:56,700 big of a difference. So, I'm happy with the direction that the 161 00:10:56,700 --> 00:11:12,480 ETF industry is going and it's something I have my eye on. 162 00:11:13,990 --> 00:11:18,111 So, maybe a follow up question for you, Eric, on that, and that 163 00:11:18,111 --> 00:11:22,232 is, what do you think it would make in terms of difference? What 164 00:11:22,232 --> 00:11:26,670 would you be able to do if you converted your product to an ETF 165 00:11:26,670 --> 00:11:30,474 or launched a version of it? But let's just say it's essentially 166 00:11:30,474 --> 00:11:34,278 trying to do the same thing, but within an ETF structure. What 167 00:11:34,278 --> 00:11:36,180 does that actually do for you? 168 00:11:37,270 --> 00:11:48,454 Well, given what we do, there would be some tax efficiency. Generally, 169 00:11:48,454 --> 00:12:00,570 the futures guys will tell you that there's not a benefit from stuffing 170 00:12:00,570 --> 00:12:11,754 1256 futures contracts into an ETF. As you know, we are combining 171 00:12:11,754 --> 00:12:21,074 global equity beta and managed futures together into one product 172 00:12:21,074 --> 00:12:33,190 and thinking of it more of a multi asset kind of all-weather approach. 173 00:11:37,270 --> 00:11:45,256 So, on the equity side, because we're using ETFs rather than 174 00:11:45,256 --> 00:11:51,790 futures for that dedicated long equity exposure, there would 175 00:11:51,790 --> 00:12:01,228 be some tax benefit and that would be great. But the main thing, 176 00:12:01,228 --> 00:12:07,036 selfishly, is simply to increase your distribution opportunity 177 00:12:07,036 --> 00:12:16,474 set. The newest generations of advisors, a lot of them are ETF only. 178 00:12:16,474 --> 00:12:25,912 A lot of individual investors, ETF only. So, it would be to increase 179 00:12:25,912 --> 00:12:33,172 our ability, our footprint to do business with more people. 180 00:12:35,231 --> 00:12:39,335 Maybe I could follow up with you, Andrew, on this because there's 181 00:12:39,335 --> 00:12:43,097 another question that kind of relates to what Eric was mentioning 182 00:12:43,097 --> 00:12:46,859 about market makers. There's a question from Johan who says he'd 183 00:12:46,859 --> 00:12:50,963 love to know more about how are these ETFs are actually priced 184 00:12:50,963 --> 00:12:55,409 intraday? And also, are you able always to buy or sell an ETF 185 00:12:55,409 --> 00:13:00,197 at some kind of official NAV once a day? Like if you were doing 186 00:13:00,197 --> 00:13:04,985 it with a mutual fund where I think you always can trade at an 187 00:13:04,985 --> 00:13:05,327 NAV. 188 00:13:05,851 --> 00:13:43,385 Yeah, so ETFs are different at least the way… And by the way, there 189 00:13:43,385 --> 00:14:15,557 are some mutual funds that will have ETF share of classes now 190 00:14:15,557 --> 00:14:47,729 and some ETFs that will mutual fund share classes now. I really 191 00:14:47,729 --> 00:15:17,220 don't understand all the mechanics of all that, so I'm going 192 00:15:17,220 --> 00:15:38,668 to talk specifically about just a straight ETF. So, a straight 193 00:13:15,403 --> 00:13:56,795 ETF is different from a mutual fund. In a mutual fund you don't 194 00:13:56,795 --> 00:14:38,187 do anything during the day and then you subscribe or redeem at the 195 00:14:38,187 --> 00:15:25,947 end of the day. They calculate the NAV at the end of the day, and 196 00:15:25,947 --> 00:15:38,683 you subscribe or redeem. But with an ETF you have an NAV that 197 00:13:28,774 --> 00:13:54,244 fluctuates during the day because you know what the underlying 198 00:13:54,244 --> 00:14:22,261 portfolio looks like and that changes your pricing. But the pricing, 199 00:14:22,261 --> 00:14:55,372 when you buy and sell, is the market. It's that there are people 200 00:14:55,372 --> 00:15:23,389 who are offering to sell at certain prices. There are people 201 00:15:23,389 --> 00:15:38,671 offering to buy at certain prices. And you know, all the things 202 00:13:25,363 --> 00:14:04,387 you would think about if you're buying a stock in terms of 203 00:14:04,387 --> 00:14:43,411 what's the mid, where's the bid, where's the ask, how deep it 204 00:14:43,411 --> 00:15:22,435 is on either side of it? There are different exchanges, there are 205 00:15:22,435 --> 00:15:38,695 off-market trades that get done. So, you know, back to Eric's 206 00:13:14,035 --> 00:13:30,403 point, I mean Eric makes, I think a very interesting point is 207 00:13:30,403 --> 00:13:46,771 that there is a structural question in the ETF space, the liquidity… 208 00:13:46,771 --> 00:14:04,503 but it’s a debt… One other things, as well, is there are people 209 00:14:04,503 --> 00:14:22,235 called market makers whose job it is, and who make money if that 210 00:14:22,235 --> 00:14:38,603 order book is imbalanced and somebody has too many buys or too 211 00:14:38,603 --> 00:14:54,971 many… They are supposed to step in and keep things close to 212 00:14:54,971 --> 00:15:11,339 NAV during the course of the day. Sometimes they do better, sometimes 213 00:15:11,339 --> 00:15:29,071 they do worse. But this is how firms like Virtu and Jane Street 214 00:15:29,071 --> 00:15:38,619 and others and Citadel have become monsters. But the efficiency 215 00:13:08,968 --> 00:13:20,397 of that process is also tied to the underlying portfolio. Because 216 00:13:20,397 --> 00:13:31,826 when people are buying and selling, when market makers are transacting 217 00:13:31,826 --> 00:13:43,255 in the market, they may often be hedging themselves, not necessarily 218 00:13:43,255 --> 00:13:55,723 with the ETFs themselves, but also just by hedging or looking through 219 00:13:55,723 --> 00:14:07,152 and looking at the underlying. So, the more complicated the underlying 220 00:14:07,152 --> 00:14:18,581 is, the more illiquid the underlying is, the more risk they 221 00:14:18,581 --> 00:14:31,049 have of moving the price of the underlying. They will take less 222 00:14:31,049 --> 00:14:46,634 risk to try to keep the price close to NAV. So, when we built the 223 00:14:46,634 --> 00:15:00,141 ETF that we launched, back then the idea was if we stick in 224 00:15:00,141 --> 00:15:11,570 the deepest and most liquid markets, they've got no excuse. If 225 00:15:11,570 --> 00:15:21,960 you guys need to hedge yourself with these 10 instruments, 226 00:15:21,960 --> 00:15:37,545 you should be within a penny or two of where the NAV is at that 227 00:15:37,545 --> 00:15:38,584 time. 228 00:15:39,581 --> 00:15:43,904 And given the massive success you've had in growing your product, 229 00:15:43,904 --> 00:15:49,013 Andrew, have you seen the kind of spread that I guess you refer 230 00:15:49,013 --> 00:15:54,122 to during the day between the bids and the offers that people can 231 00:15:54,122 --> 00:15:59,231 trade at? Have you seen that change a lot then? Meaning I imagine 232 00:15:59,231 --> 00:15:59,624 narrowing? 233 00:15:59,981 --> 00:16:17,243 Yeah, I think so. There's what you see if you look at the screen 234 00:16:17,243 --> 00:16:32,039 and clearly the spreads have come in. If you wanted to blindly 235 00:16:32,039 --> 00:16:48,068 put 25 or 50 million dollars into a managed futures ETF, and you 236 00:16:48,068 --> 00:17:01,631 looked, you said like where can we actually transact at that 237 00:17:01,631 --> 00:17:18,893 level and not have to think hard about it? I think what we do 238 00:17:18,893 --> 00:17:25,058 would be the obvious choice. But when you get into bigger dollar 239 00:16:05,301 --> 00:16:13,661 amounts, if you're a model allocator and you've decided on Tuesday 240 00:16:13,661 --> 00:16:24,301 we're going to put $75 million in, then that you have an ETF desk, 241 00:16:24,301 --> 00:16:32,661 and the ETF desk will basically do block trades or trade 242 00:16:32,661 --> 00:16:43,301 in dark pools or things like that. And so, one of the things that 243 00:16:43,301 --> 00:16:52,421 we found, and one of the selling points, is the ability to 244 00:16:52,421 --> 00:17:01,541 move large dollars in and out of this (hopefully just in, thank 245 00:17:01,541 --> 00:17:10,661 you), and to be able to do that efficiently because there is 246 00:17:10,661 --> 00:17:21,301 a fear, for people who grew up in a mutual fund world, you never 247 00:17:21,301 --> 00:17:25,101 had to think about this. And I think, as Eric can attest to, when 248 00:16:07,955 --> 00:16:15,929 you get into the advisor community, they're often incredibly 249 00:16:15,929 --> 00:16:27,447 focused on the one, or two, three things that can go wrong and 250 00:16:27,447 --> 00:16:38,965 make them look bad. And if they spend months looking at a fund 251 00:16:38,965 --> 00:16:49,597 or an ETF deciding they love it and then they accidentally put 252 00:16:49,597 --> 00:17:02,001 in a market order at 350 and are not paying attention to it. And 253 00:17:02,001 --> 00:17:12,633 their little trade moves the price 50 basis points and they look 254 00:17:12,633 --> 00:17:23,265 bad because of that. You've got to make sure that doesn't happen 255 00:17:23,265 --> 00:17:25,037 for them. 256 00:17:26,061 --> 00:17:32,217 While you were writing about, in your LinkedIn the other day, about 257 00:17:32,217 --> 00:17:38,373 another ETF that got a 4 billion dollar ticket one day. So, 258 00:17:38,373 --> 00:17:39,399 I guess… 259 00:17:39,401 --> 00:17:55,851 Eric, yeah… you got in against the ETF space. I mean this is the 260 00:17:55,851 --> 00:18:07,601 multi strat ETF space just tripled overnight. You know BlackRock… 261 00:18:07,601 --> 00:18:21,701 So, BlackRock launched this… It's kind of… I mean we can talk 262 00:18:21,701 --> 00:18:36,976 about it but like there are some allocators who want a one stop 263 00:18:36,976 --> 00:18:51,076 solution that kind of helps them to fill the alts bucket, gives 264 00:18:51,076 --> 00:19:04,001 them kind of an absolute return profile. There are other allocators 265 00:19:04,001 --> 00:19:13,401 who want to build those building blocks themselves. And so, 266 00:17:40,793 --> 00:17:48,449 there's a strategy called the multi strat space which is designed 267 00:17:48,449 --> 00:17:56,105 to be the one-stop solution. And there are really two, roughly, 268 00:17:56,105 --> 00:18:04,457 billion dollar funds in that space; one by New York Life called 269 00:18:04,457 --> 00:18:12,809 QII or IndexIQ (I wrote kind of a fairly obnoxious LinkedIn post 270 00:18:12,809 --> 00:18:21,161 about it a few minutes ago) that's now above US$1 billion, and 271 00:18:21,161 --> 00:18:28,817 then Franklin Templeton has a fund that's done very well. It's 272 00:18:28,817 --> 00:18:37,169 a long/short quant ETF called FLSP that's getting close to a billion. 273 00:18:37,169 --> 00:18:44,825 And then BlackRock came in (and in the interest of disclosure 274 00:18:44,825 --> 00:18:54,569 we sub advise a similar kind of product for SEI which is now an 275 00:18:54,569 --> 00:19:02,921 ETF)... And then BlackRock launched a new fund at the end of 276 00:19:02,921 --> 00:19:11,273 December. And it kind of got up to like US$100 million, US$200 277 00:19:11,273 --> 00:19:13,361 million, US$300 million. You're like, okay, they're putting 278 00:17:45,351 --> 00:17:57,251 into their models, it's growing and then boom, like US$4 279 00:17:57,251 --> 00:18:13,911 billion came in one day. So, to me this was the starter gun, back 280 00:18:13,911 --> 00:18:29,381 to Eric's point. It's going to eclipse the money that was ever in 281 00:18:29,381 --> 00:18:41,281 the mutual fund space once these trillions and trillions of 282 00:18:41,281 --> 00:18:54,371 dollars of model portfolio start to basically say we need something, 283 00:18:54,371 --> 00:19:09,841 we need a third leg of the asset allocation stool and how do 284 00:19:09,841 --> 00:19:13,411 we build that? 285 00:19:13,701 --> 00:19:19,335 Yeah, all right, well, speaking of products that people 286 00:19:19,335 --> 00:19:26,847 need, the magic combo was one of the headlines you brought along, 287 00:19:26,847 --> 00:19:33,733 Andrew. And of course we are referring to trend plus equities, 288 00:19:33,733 --> 00:19:41,245 or equities plus trend, or it has many names nowadays, this combination. 289 00:19:13,701 --> 00:19:23,659 And so, I'm going to pass it over to you, Andrew, because you 290 00:19:23,659 --> 00:19:34,383 know where you want to go with this. And I'm sure Eric has lots 291 00:19:34,383 --> 00:19:41,277 of good things to say about that as well. 292 00:19:42,081 --> 00:19:55,773 Well, so, I think this has probably been covered in, I don't 293 00:19:55,773 --> 00:20:07,183 know, 50 podcasts, 100 TTU podcasts with different people. And 294 00:20:07,183 --> 00:20:22,016 Eric has done great research on this and you know, Rob Croce wrote 295 00:20:22,016 --> 00:20:34,567 that paper recently for Fidelity and Man AHL has done this. 296 00:20:34,567 --> 00:20:45,977 I mean, it is about as statistically obvious as anything 297 00:20:45,977 --> 00:20:58,528 that managed futures, as a strategy, plus equities is, 1 plus 298 00:20:58,528 --> 00:21:14,502 1 equals 3, or 4, or something like that. It's a very, very valuable 299 00:21:14,502 --> 00:21:15,643 combination. When I first spoke to Eric, several years ago 300 00:19:48,930 --> 00:19:58,062 he had talked about (and he could talk about this himself), this 301 00:19:58,062 --> 00:20:07,955 idea of do you combine in the same package basically to bring those 302 00:20:07,955 --> 00:20:17,848 benefits together for somebody and do the work for them, or do you 303 00:20:17,848 --> 00:20:28,502 want to let them pick and choose in how to build it? And then 304 00:20:28,502 --> 00:20:36,112 it goes into a further direction with what Corey Hoffstein 305 00:20:36,112 --> 00:20:45,244 has done. And now JP Morgan is coming with managed futures plus 306 00:20:45,244 --> 00:20:55,137 equities and Winton is doing it. And I think Aspect has a product. 307 00:20:55,137 --> 00:21:02,747 So, we know this combination is incredibly powerful. And then 308 00:21:02,747 --> 00:21:12,640 just the question is, how do you deliver it to people based upon 309 00:21:12,640 --> 00:21:15,684 their different preference functions? And so, I will tell you 310 00:19:52,113 --> 00:20:12,177 that I spent some time with ChatGPT this morning and they love 311 00:20:12,177 --> 00:20:30,569 what Eric is doing in part because of this, because ChatGPT 312 00:20:30,569 --> 00:20:47,289 cares about results, it cares about the statistical outcome. You 313 00:20:47,289 --> 00:21:04,009 don't have to convince it that diversification, that improves your 314 00:21:04,009 --> 00:21:15,713 risk adjusted returns, is a good idea. 315 00:21:16,441 --> 00:21:20,926 Eric, why don't you take us back a little bit to the thought 316 00:21:20,926 --> 00:21:25,411 process and just tell us how you thought about it, why you chose 317 00:21:25,411 --> 00:21:29,206 the combination you did? And actually, also, in a sense, that 318 00:21:29,206 --> 00:21:33,691 allows you to be different from some of the new ones that have 319 00:21:33,691 --> 00:21:36,796 come out. And so, we'd love to hear that. 320 00:21:38,481 --> 00:23:17,034 Yeah. So early in my career I was a long/short equity guy, mostly 321 00:23:17,034 --> 00:24:48,006 in the hedge fund space. So, I had that experience before adopting 322 00:24:48,006 --> 00:26:18,978 more of a managed futures lifestyle, which I did kind of in 323 00:26:18,978 --> 00:26:41,721 the mid 2000s. So, I've experience dealing with the realities 324 00:22:19,298 --> 00:23:11,777 of getting allocations into long/short equity on a standalone 325 00:23:11,777 --> 00:24:21,749 basis, and managed futures on a standalone basis. And it took me, 326 00:24:21,749 --> 00:25:37,552 I don't know, a couple decades to be fatigued by the bizarre behavior 327 00:25:37,552 --> 00:26:41,693 that you see from people that allocate to these two spaces. They 328 00:21:41,008 --> 00:22:21,440 tend to buy things that are up a lot and sell them as soon as they 329 00:22:21,440 --> 00:22:49,237 stall out. I mean, you guys are familiar with prospect theory 330 00:22:49,237 --> 00:23:24,615 where a $10 gain gives you one unit of pleasure, but a $10 loss 331 00:23:24,615 --> 00:23:59,993 gives you two units of pain. If you take that, and I found that 332 00:23:59,993 --> 00:24:27,790 to be generally true of most human beings across cultures, across 333 00:24:27,790 --> 00:24:50,533 generations it's just a reoccurring thing. But when everyone 334 00:24:50,533 --> 00:25:18,330 is ranking investments against some benchmark like the S&P 500 or 335 00:25:18,330 --> 00:25:43,600 60/40 portfolio, the prospect theory gets even weirder, where it's 336 00:25:43,600 --> 00:26:18,978 not only are you up or down, it's are you up or down relative 337 00:26:18,978 --> 00:26:41,721 to what I and everyone else is staring at? So, it got to the point 338 00:21:58,257 --> 00:22:37,809 where it was almost impossible to get anyone to hold managed futures 339 00:22:37,809 --> 00:23:20,657 for more than a few quarters, let alone years or a full market 340 00:23:20,657 --> 00:24:00,209 cycle. So, no one ever disputed the math. I mean, it's such 341 00:24:00,209 --> 00:24:33,169 simple algebra. If you integrate in a decent managed futures 342 00:24:33,169 --> 00:25:12,721 program into any portfolio, it does the thing where returns go up, 343 00:25:12,721 --> 00:25:42,385 vol goes down, drawdowns get smaller, everything gets better. 344 00:25:42,385 --> 00:26:21,937 So, no one ever disputed that. And most people can be convinced 345 00:26:21,937 --> 00:26:41,713 that's a wise thing to do. Then they do it. And then every quarter 346 00:22:10,825 --> 00:22:55,298 of every month after that, they're staring at it. They're staring 347 00:22:55,298 --> 00:23:31,685 at that line-item risk, they're staring at the statement 348 00:23:31,685 --> 00:24:16,158 risk. And it just creates this psychotrophic cascade. It's a new 349 00:24:16,158 --> 00:25:04,674 problem that goes into their life that has them talking to their 350 00:25:04,674 --> 00:25:37,018 clients, and talking to regulators, and their compliance 351 00:25:37,018 --> 00:26:05,319 department. Everyone's micromanaging everything. And I just 352 00:26:05,319 --> 00:26:41,706 got fatigued by it after a couple of decades. So, in 2018 I 353 00:21:55,809 --> 00:23:00,789 left a firm, and I had a two year non-compete. So, I had to basically 354 00:23:00,789 --> 00:24:05,769 sit on my hands. And I was going to use that time to build kind 355 00:24:05,769 --> 00:25:06,417 of a product or a company for the final chapter for me. I'm in 356 00:25:06,417 --> 00:26:07,065 my early 50s and I want to do something for the next 25 years. 357 00:26:07,065 --> 00:26:41,721 And I had two thoughts enter my head. One was what would I do 358 00:22:10,401 --> 00:23:30,201 with my own money if I had to leave my money in something for 25, 359 00:23:30,201 --> 00:24:39,361 30 years and just set it and forget it, what would that something 360 00:24:39,361 --> 00:25:43,201 look like? And the other was product market fit. What does the 361 00:25:43,201 --> 00:26:36,401 marketplace need that it doesn't already have, at least at 362 00:26:36,401 --> 00:26:41,721 scale? And it didn't take long for me to realize that if I can build 363 00:22:15,077 --> 00:22:43,831 a good managed futures program and don't charge hedge fund fees, 364 00:22:43,831 --> 00:23:15,199 don't charge the 2 and 20, and have something that's scalable, and 365 00:23:15,199 --> 00:23:46,567 I combine it with low fee, tax efficient equity exposure, that would 366 00:23:46,567 --> 00:24:20,549 satisfy both my needs. I'm not afraid to own equities as long as 367 00:24:20,549 --> 00:24:49,303 I've got the long convexity trend component that can fill those 368 00:24:49,303 --> 00:25:15,443 potholes during the hard times, or at least the expectation 369 00:25:15,443 --> 00:25:46,811 of that. And going forward, I'm happy to own equities with a 370 00:25:46,811 --> 00:26:23,407 big chunk of my money. As long as I have that balance between convexity 371 00:26:23,407 --> 00:26:41,705 and equities. So, it solves that problem. And then the theory 372 00:21:59,037 --> 00:23:00,705 was that we think that there's a marketplace for products like this 373 00:23:00,705 --> 00:24:12,651 and we decided to put it in a mutual fund wrapper at the time. 374 00:24:12,651 --> 00:25:19,458 I think that was a wise decision. It remains to be seen if 375 00:25:19,458 --> 00:26:15,987 that's the best wrapper going forward. So, we're very open minded 376 00:26:15,987 --> 00:26:41,682 to other types of wrappers. But you know when you're embarking 377 00:21:58,473 --> 00:22:41,789 on the final chapter of your career, and you want to do something 378 00:22:41,789 --> 00:23:15,109 satisfying, kill two birds with one stone, it's the product 379 00:23:15,109 --> 00:24:05,089 that I would like to invest my money into. And I do think that the 380 00:24:05,089 --> 00:24:51,737 marketplace, once they see it for a while, will find a way to put 381 00:24:51,737 --> 00:25:21,725 it into their portfolio. Andrew mentioned that things like 382 00:25:21,725 --> 00:25:58,377 this sometimes are a one-stop solution for the alts bucket, at 383 00:25:58,377 --> 00:26:31,697 least for smaller advisors or smaller portfolios. And we found 384 00:26:31,697 --> 00:26:41,693 some of that. We’re still trying to find our exact place. The 385 00:22:36,540 --> 00:23:53,952 way that the industry works is they've got these boxes. Are you 386 00:23:53,952 --> 00:25:11,364 large cap growth? Are you small cap value? Are you fixed income 387 00:25:11,364 --> 00:26:28,776 active? They've got these kind of discrete boxes they want to stuff 388 00:26:28,776 --> 00:26:41,678 you in. But to get that benefit that we're talking about, 389 00:22:15,354 --> 00:22:52,227 a diversifier that actually increases returns and lowers risk 390 00:22:52,227 --> 00:23:49,585 at the same time, you're not going to fit into any one of those 391 00:23:49,585 --> 00:24:38,749 boxes nicely. So, we're trying to figure out how to navigate that 392 00:24:38,749 --> 00:25:32,010 going forward. But I mean, I don't know. That's my answer is that 393 00:25:32,010 --> 00:26:29,368 it solved two problems for me and that's why we did it. And so 394 00:26:29,368 --> 00:26:41,659 far, so good. 395 00:26:44,361 --> 00:26:51,561 I'd love to hear, obviously, from you Andrew on this, but I’d 396 00:26:51,561 --> 00:26:58,761 also love to hear, before we move away from that product idea… 397 00:26:58,761 --> 00:27:05,961 There have been a lot of iterations, let's call it that, I 398 00:27:05,961 --> 00:27:14,361 mean the idea was obviously not new per se, but I think you should 399 00:27:14,361 --> 00:27:20,961 have the credit, Eric, for being really the first that kind 400 00:27:20,961 --> 00:27:28,161 of brought it out. Lots of people or some people were talking 401 00:27:28,161 --> 00:27:35,361 about it but never really brought it out as a product. So, 402 00:27:35,361 --> 00:27:41,961 kudos for that. But since then, there have been new versions 403 00:27:41,961 --> 00:27:47,361 of this idea; portable alpha, return stacking, etc. etc. Maybe 404 00:26:45,315 --> 00:26:56,763 you can talk a little bit about how you thought about balancing 405 00:26:56,763 --> 00:27:08,211 the risks between the trend part (and I know you don't necessarily 406 00:27:08,211 --> 00:27:19,659 talk about it as trend but global macro maybe), and the underlying 407 00:27:19,659 --> 00:27:30,153 equities, and also maybe how you maybe see the different directions 408 00:27:30,153 --> 00:27:39,693 other people have taken, rightly or wrongly, so to speak. 409 00:27:39,693 --> 00:27:47,325 And yeah, any thoughts you have on that? 410 00:27:48,481 --> 00:27:52,061 I strive for equal risk contribution from the equities and 411 00:27:52,061 --> 00:27:55,641 from the trend side. Call it trend, systematic macro, managed 412 00:27:55,641 --> 00:27:59,579 futures, those things are such close cousins that, you know, it's 413 00:27:59,579 --> 00:28:03,875 hard to tell them apart, in my opinion. That's from my definitions. 414 00:28:03,875 --> 00:28:07,813 So, I strive for equal risk contribution from both because I 415 00:28:07,813 --> 00:28:11,751 don't know which one's going to do better in the future. 416 00:28:13,091 --> 00:28:19,357 And when you say that, Eric, sorry to interrupt. I just want to 417 00:28:19,357 --> 00:28:24,177 make sure people out there listening, saying, well, what does 418 00:28:24,177 --> 00:28:26,587 he really mean by that? Do you mean you just want to have the same 419 00:28:18,091 --> 00:28:23,591 level of volatility for both or how should people think about 420 00:28:23,591 --> 00:28:26,591 when you say equal risk contribution? 421 00:28:26,751 --> 00:28:47,569 It's pretty close to that. You could think of it as equal vol contribution. 422 00:28:47,569 --> 00:29:00,952 Contribution mathematics are complicated and we're not doing super 423 00:29:00,952 --> 00:29:18,796 complicated stuff. But you could think of it as, I've got a 424 00:29:18,796 --> 00:29:39,614 managed futures program that has 8 vol, and if I put half my money 425 00:29:39,614 --> 00:30:00,432 in stocks, that gives me about 8 vol from stocks. So, 100% in my 426 00:30:00,432 --> 00:30:19,763 managed futures program at 8 vol, 50% in stocks that are at 16 427 00:30:19,763 --> 00:30:37,607 vol, mathematically gives me 8. You could think of it like that 428 00:30:37,607 --> 00:30:45,042 it's pretty close to that. I'm a firm believer that whatever it 429 00:28:39,008 --> 00:29:03,522 is that you're going to bat for, and you have to stick with for 430 00:29:03,522 --> 00:29:22,783 decades, it better be a decent fit for your personality. Because 431 00:29:22,783 --> 00:29:40,293 the accountability and the responsibility land on me. I need 432 00:29:40,293 --> 00:30:08,309 to be able to sleep at night and I need to be able to stand up, 433 00:30:08,309 --> 00:30:31,072 and deliver, and defend what it is I'm doing. So, it needs to 434 00:30:31,072 --> 00:30:45,080 be congruent with what I think is right. So, I picked the numbers. 435 00:28:35,731 --> 00:28:57,283 I'm not trying to get rich fast. This isn't an aggressive program. 436 00:28:57,283 --> 00:29:18,835 And I'm glad that the new entrants, many of which I'm friends 437 00:29:18,835 --> 00:29:38,591 with, so, I'm glad they're not exactly copying us. They're coming 438 00:29:38,591 --> 00:29:54,755 with much higher volatility products. They're doing what they 439 00:29:54,755 --> 00:30:14,511 need to do. They're also trying to balance what works for 440 00:30:14,511 --> 00:30:30,675 them psychologically and also their own interpretation of product 441 00:30:30,675 --> 00:30:45,043 market fit. Like what does the marketplace want? I took my shot. 442 00:28:36,291 --> 00:29:02,526 I built the program that I am comfortable with, something that 443 00:29:02,526 --> 00:29:35,916 I'm happy to invest my money or even my mom's money, and for a 444 00:29:35,916 --> 00:30:02,151 long period of time. I'm happy with the volatility, the drawdowns, 445 00:30:02,151 --> 00:30:33,156 the returns. It's just right there. And I wake up every day with 446 00:30:33,156 --> 00:30:45,081 a smile on my face. So, if I was running it two times the vol, 447 00:28:39,921 --> 00:28:53,091 I'd be worried about compliance and, you know, the VAR 448 00:28:53,091 --> 00:29:10,212 risk, and, you know, I might be losing sleep. If I was running 449 00:29:10,212 --> 00:29:26,016 at 1/2 vol, I'd be worried about being left behind, not keeping 450 00:29:26,016 --> 00:29:40,503 up with inflation, not making any money, not justifying the fees 451 00:29:40,503 --> 00:29:57,624 that one charges. So, it was just a place where that's what made 452 00:29:57,624 --> 00:30:08,160 me and my co-workers comfortable. It's aggressive enough 453 00:30:08,160 --> 00:30:22,647 to be competitive, but not so aggressive that, you know, we're 454 00:30:22,647 --> 00:30:37,134 going to be scrambling in risk-off events or, you know, when 455 00:30:37,134 --> 00:30:45,036 trend is way out of favor. 456 00:30:46,211 --> 00:30:49,984 Yeah, I guess Andrew, from all our conversations over the years, 457 00:30:49,984 --> 00:30:54,100 to me there's a lot of similarities. I mean you also, I 458 00:30:54,100 --> 00:30:57,873 guess, built a product that really was something that you wanted 459 00:30:57,873 --> 00:31:02,332 to be in for yourself and a few billion other people as well, 460 00:31:02,332 --> 00:31:06,791 so to speak. Tell me a little bit about… Because you had this, 461 00:31:06,791 --> 00:31:10,564 in the notes we shared together, you had a headline called 462 00:31:10,564 --> 00:31:15,366 the Good, Bad, and the Ugly of Zero. So, take us into that, and 463 00:31:15,366 --> 00:31:16,052 your thoughts? 464 00:31:16,081 --> 00:31:56,461 Sure. Well, I mean I just want to highlight and compliment something 465 00:31:56,461 --> 00:32:33,476 that Eric has been saying. To anybody who's listening to this, 466 00:32:33,476 --> 00:33:10,491 I want you to understand how different the way Eric described 467 00:33:10,491 --> 00:33:44,141 this is from normal product development in this business. Normal 468 00:33:44,141 --> 00:34:17,791 product development, in the mutual fund and ETF business, is 469 00:34:17,791 --> 00:34:51,441 marketing and distribution people who are saying, look at how 470 00:34:51,441 --> 00:35:25,091 much money they're raising over there with that product. How 471 00:35:25,091 --> 00:36:02,106 can we build something and stuff it in people's portfolios as 472 00:36:02,106 --> 00:36:32,391 fast as we can and all make money? Right? Whether it's going 473 00:31:26,284 --> 00:32:10,497 to work over five years is not a critical part of their thinking. 474 00:32:10,497 --> 00:32:54,710 They don't own it five years from now. They will have moved on 475 00:32:54,710 --> 00:33:28,720 to multiple different products. And I think what I have 476 00:33:28,720 --> 00:34:12,933 talked about a lot, and I think one of the great problems with 477 00:34:12,933 --> 00:34:46,943 the alternative products… I mean, the average… Look, I mean, 478 00:34:46,943 --> 00:35:24,354 I've said this a million times, the average hedge fund, mutual 479 00:35:24,354 --> 00:36:05,166 fund has been a catastrophe for investors. Like 2% to 3% per 480 00:36:05,166 --> 00:36:32,374 annum returns after 200 basis points in fees. I say stuff like 481 00:31:32,301 --> 00:32:16,906 if this was a football team, you'd be investigating people for 482 00:32:16,906 --> 00:33:05,566 throwing the game. I mean, it's worse than random. And I think 483 00:33:05,566 --> 00:33:54,226 that's the industry structure issue. So, I would just say to anybody 484 00:33:54,226 --> 00:34:42,886 who's listening to this, like you want to hear from somebody building 485 00:34:42,886 --> 00:35:23,436 a product that they're thinking about it from an investment 486 00:35:23,436 --> 00:36:03,986 perspective. They're thinking about how they're going to be judged 487 00:36:03,986 --> 00:36:32,371 on this 5 or 10 years now. And look, Eric has made a career bet 488 00:31:42,169 --> 00:32:27,823 that this will work over 5 or 10 years. And that is similar to 489 00:32:27,823 --> 00:33:10,216 the way that I had it. We don't have a zillion different products 490 00:33:10,216 --> 00:34:02,392 out there. I'm a very big fan of it. And I think what I would also 491 00:34:02,392 --> 00:34:44,785 say is that, when we talk about kind of addressing or the addressable 492 00:34:44,785 --> 00:35:14,134 market, there is no addressable market. There are hundreds 493 00:35:14,134 --> 00:35:53,266 of submarkets out there. And the challenge is how do you build 494 00:35:53,266 --> 00:36:25,876 products? How do you identify which of those submarkets you're 495 00:36:25,876 --> 00:36:32,398 going after? So, my submarket, my long-term end game, was to build 496 00:32:19,351 --> 00:33:41,602 something for an ETF model allocator who has 8 to 12 ETFs in 497 00:33:41,602 --> 00:34:51,199 their portfolios that are all stocks and bonds. Stock and bond 498 00:34:51,199 --> 00:35:41,815 correlations breakdown, bonds breakdown as a diversifier, that 499 00:35:41,815 --> 00:36:32,431 started in 2022, and they need other things. They then start doing 500 00:31:37,897 --> 00:32:37,891 screens and they look for managed futures, they look it up, 501 00:32:37,891 --> 00:33:37,885 they find hedge fund indices. They can't invest in hedge funds. 502 00:33:37,885 --> 00:34:37,879 They find mutual funds, they can't invest in hedge funds. Can 503 00:34:37,879 --> 00:35:43,327 I give them something that will make their lives better by making 504 00:35:43,327 --> 00:36:32,413 it easy for them to allocate 3% to 5%? If I did nothing but have 505 00:31:33,817 --> 00:32:15,201 allocators like that, and if I could find all of them and talk to 506 00:32:15,201 --> 00:32:56,585 them over the next 10 years, I'd be very happy. And I think what 507 00:32:56,585 --> 00:33:37,969 Eric identified, and I think I even said this on TTU, that I thought 508 00:33:37,969 --> 00:34:10,485 it was brilliant when he described it, was that what advisors 509 00:34:10,485 --> 00:34:43,001 say they want, when they say they want diversification, they say 510 00:34:43,001 --> 00:35:18,473 they want these benefits, they say they want tail risk or whatever 511 00:35:18,473 --> 00:35:53,945 it is, like tail protection or whatever it is they're talking about 512 00:35:53,945 --> 00:36:20,549 doing, there's often a narrative because their actions often 513 00:36:20,549 --> 00:36:32,373 don't follow their words. You can show up with them and say we 514 00:32:03,529 --> 00:32:40,433 have something that's providing diversification the way 515 00:32:40,433 --> 00:33:48,969 you just defined it to me, and they still don't pull the trigger. 516 00:33:48,969 --> 00:34:46,961 And so, I think the really interesting thing about this business, 517 00:34:46,961 --> 00:36:00,769 and what I enjoy about talking to people about it is trying to understand 518 00:36:00,769 --> 00:36:32,401 really what's in their decision making. And I think when 519 00:31:36,489 --> 00:32:37,713 I think about Eric's product, what he identified was a very specific 520 00:32:37,713 --> 00:33:28,733 investment, or a very specific fear that allocators have, which 521 00:33:28,733 --> 00:34:40,161 is, I put money into this, I've taken it from stocks or a combination 522 00:34:40,161 --> 00:35:41,385 of stocks and bonds. Equity markets go up 100% over the next 523 00:35:41,385 --> 00:36:32,405 three years. And people are asking why I did that. And even if 524 00:31:30,679 --> 00:32:33,937 this is fantastic in year four, if equity is one of a hundred, 525 00:32:33,937 --> 00:33:22,597 and my managed futures portfolio had a fine three years 526 00:33:22,597 --> 00:34:20,989 and went up 20%, even though that's a success from a diversification 527 00:34:20,989 --> 00:35:24,247 perspective, I'm going to be blamed for it. But if I've got 50% 528 00:35:24,247 --> 00:36:32,371 equity in there as well. And I'm up 70%. No one's going to complain. 529 00:31:16,081 --> 00:32:35,161 And so, the way, when we first met and talked about it, is I thought 530 00:32:35,161 --> 00:33:27,881 it was such an insightful perspective on a particular segment 531 00:33:27,881 --> 00:34:25,873 of the allocator community who was looking for an absolute return 532 00:34:25,873 --> 00:35:23,865 product, who wants something they can put in their portfolio for 533 00:35:23,865 --> 00:36:32,401 a long period of time, and this happens to be an important criteria. 534 00:31:16,081 --> 00:31:54,746 When you shift over to the full portable alpha products with 535 00:31:54,746 --> 00:32:36,926 100% equities, the driver there is that there is a subset within 536 00:32:36,926 --> 00:33:12,076 the allocator community who is very worried about capital efficiency. 537 00:33:12,076 --> 00:33:54,256 They don't want to sell anything to get exposure to it. They 538 00:33:54,256 --> 00:34:43,466 don't want to sell a penny. Why would you sell a penny of stocks? 539 00:34:43,466 --> 00:35:32,676 They've gone up 15% a year for 15 years. Like, keep them all. But 540 00:35:32,676 --> 00:36:14,856 yet, we still need to diversify, so what can we add on 541 00:36:14,856 --> 00:36:32,431 top up to do that? And so, I think the great thing that's happening 542 00:32:11,899 --> 00:33:26,323 is, between the ETFs, and the mutual funds, and the different kind 543 00:33:26,323 --> 00:34:28,343 of shapes and sizes of different products, is trying to 544 00:34:28,343 --> 00:35:42,767 identify, within this broad landscape, as to how do we make the 545 00:35:42,767 --> 00:36:32,383 allocators lives better around their specific preference functions? 546 00:36:33,391 --> 00:36:44,523 I mean, you mentioned something that I just picked up on 547 00:36:44,523 --> 00:36:57,679 when I was listening to you and you said lots of products are 548 00:36:57,679 --> 00:37:06,787 being sold. It essentially starts with the marketing problem 549 00:37:06,787 --> 00:37:19,943 and then how do we do that? And you've mentioned this thing about, 550 00:37:19,943 --> 00:37:34,111 well, they don't own it, and all that. And I think, I mean, it 551 00:37:34,111 --> 00:37:48,279 does raise a little bit of a topic, I think, that is the industry, 552 00:37:48,279 --> 00:38:00,423 as a whole, including the firms that we represent, we are individual 553 00:38:00,423 --> 00:38:13,579 firms where we probably have a very large part over there, our net 554 00:38:13,579 --> 00:38:24,711 worth, liquid net worth tied in the products that we offer. And 555 00:36:34,575 --> 00:36:52,335 as you say, and that goes for the three of us here, and for most, 556 00:36:52,335 --> 00:37:08,911 I would say, of, at least from the CTA community that I know, to 557 00:37:08,911 --> 00:37:23,119 a large extent, they have one, maybe two big products that they 558 00:37:23,119 --> 00:37:34,959 offer, but they're very focused on making that the success. 559 00:37:34,959 --> 00:37:47,983 But the challenge is always… And we've seen this, we've talked 560 00:37:47,983 --> 00:38:03,375 about this, Andrew, in the last year or two, I mean we have 561 00:38:03,375 --> 00:38:16,399 the very, very biggest asset managers in the world coming this 562 00:38:16,399 --> 00:38:24,687 space now offering these types of products. But as you rightly mentioned, 563 00:36:38,316 --> 00:36:50,136 they're not doing it with the same background, so to speak, or 564 00:36:50,136 --> 00:37:00,971 whatever the word is, that the all the small individual managers 565 00:37:00,971 --> 00:37:15,746 are doing. So, I don't know. I mean, I don't know if this is good, 566 00:37:15,746 --> 00:37:27,566 this is bad. But I do think it's important maybe for investors 567 00:37:27,566 --> 00:37:39,386 to know the difference between what it means when you invest with 568 00:37:39,386 --> 00:37:49,236 a manager where they are really committed and invested in 569 00:37:49,236 --> 00:38:03,026 the product, and in a product that is just one of a hundred and 570 00:38:03,026 --> 00:38:14,846 where the people you talk to probably own very little or nothing 571 00:38:14,846 --> 00:38:24,696 of the product. So, I think that is an interesting… 572 00:38:26,601 --> 00:38:38,781 And I think that should be part of the due diligence process. 573 00:38:38,781 --> 00:38:52,991 Right? I mean, so, I spoke to Yaz Romahi who's the JP Morgan guy 574 00:38:52,991 --> 00:39:03,141 who's built their products (I've known Yaz for years), because 575 00:39:03,141 --> 00:39:17,351 they're coming with an ETF in the US. They had a series of ETFs 576 00:39:17,351 --> 00:39:28,516 years ago and they pulled them. Yaz is an all-star. Right? 577 00:39:28,516 --> 00:39:40,696 I mean, he is an absolute brilliant quant who runs a very, 578 00:39:40,696 --> 00:39:50,846 very large business who's been running trend products for years 579 00:39:50,846 --> 00:39:52,876 and years. So, to me, JP Morgan is doing something very serious. 580 00:38:41,221 --> 00:39:00,227 Incredible. They're going to a team who knows how to do this. They're 581 00:39:00,227 --> 00:39:16,309 not asking somebody, kind of, who happens to have an engineering 582 00:39:16,309 --> 00:39:33,853 degree to try to become a trend follower over time. I think 583 00:39:33,853 --> 00:39:49,935 Fidelity did something similar when they went out and they hired 584 00:39:49,935 --> 00:39:52,859 Rob Croce. I think my criticism of some of the other people 585 00:38:36,631 --> 00:38:48,667 out there is that they've kind of just gone and grabbed anybody 586 00:38:48,667 --> 00:39:00,703 who seem to meet the criteria because again, it's really, for them 587 00:39:00,703 --> 00:39:10,733 it's largely a one-sided option. If it works, they've got 588 00:39:10,733 --> 00:39:23,772 a product they can go out and market and throw a distribution team 589 00:39:23,772 --> 00:39:36,811 behind. And if it doesn't work then they'll just shut it down and 590 00:39:36,811 --> 00:39:51,856 move on to the next thing. But again, the burden of that is on the 591 00:39:51,856 --> 00:39:52,859 allocator. This is a… you guys have got to ask these questions. 592 00:38:42,958 --> 00:39:00,802 You should talk to people and see if you're comfortable that this 593 00:39:00,802 --> 00:39:14,185 person is making decisions on the product development, modeling, 594 00:39:14,185 --> 00:39:30,542 etc. side that is going to maximize the likelihood that you're 595 00:39:30,542 --> 00:39:46,899 going to achieve what you're looking to achieve over the next 596 00:39:46,899 --> 00:39:52,847 five or ten years. 597 00:39:53,601 --> 00:40:00,916 Yeah. Now, the other topic that we already touched a little 598 00:40:00,916 --> 00:40:10,891 bit on, but it was one of the topics you wanted to bring up, Andrew, 599 00:40:10,891 --> 00:40:19,536 comes back to… I think you've been writing about it, but it also 600 00:40:19,536 --> 00:40:27,516 touches a little bit on Eric's initial research in terms of how 601 00:40:27,516 --> 00:40:36,161 do I build the trend path, part of my product, how complex or 602 00:40:36,161 --> 00:40:42,811 how simple? It's an ongoing debate, ongoing discussion we have 603 00:40:42,811 --> 00:40:44,806 in this industry. So maybe I start with you, Eric, in terms of 604 00:40:05,241 --> 00:40:13,389 some thoughts about complexity, what's enough, what's 605 00:40:13,389 --> 00:40:26,193 too much, and then you can obviously chime in, Andrew, with 606 00:40:26,193 --> 00:40:41,325 some of the things you've been out saying. So why don't we start 607 00:40:41,325 --> 00:40:44,817 with you, Eric? 608 00:40:45,801 --> 00:41:20,355 Sure, well, let me admit up front that I have a lifelong complexity 609 00:41:20,355 --> 00:41:52,251 bias. I have kind of an engineering brain. I have a scarcity 610 00:41:52,251 --> 00:42:21,489 bias and a complexity bias. Which means that I'm inclined to 611 00:42:21,489 --> 00:42:53,385 believe that in order for something to be good or great it 612 00:42:53,385 --> 00:43:25,281 must be complex, and that in order for something to be valuable 613 00:43:25,281 --> 00:44:02,493 it must be scarce. I have found both of those to be false in 614 00:44:02,493 --> 00:44:15,783 this space, which was humbling. I think it's actually an 615 00:41:04,551 --> 00:41:49,551 area of strength. Right? Like, I'm also dyslexic, but I am very, 616 00:41:49,551 --> 00:42:34,551 very reliable when it comes to doing things that you normally wouldn't 617 00:42:34,551 --> 00:43:15,801 trust a dyslexic person with because I know my weaknesses and 618 00:43:15,801 --> 00:43:57,051 I do things necessary to accommodate them and make sure that 619 00:43:57,051 --> 00:44:15,801 they don't translate into failure. So, I have built many programs, 620 00:41:01,551 --> 00:41:25,176 from long/short equity, to tail risk hedging, to systematic 621 00:41:25,176 --> 00:41:51,426 trend. I've built really complicated ones and I built embarrassingly 622 00:41:51,426 --> 00:42:15,051 simple ones. The complicated ones oftentimes, almost always, will 623 00:42:15,051 --> 00:42:38,676 look better in hindsight, and their presentations are impressive, 624 00:42:38,676 --> 00:43:10,176 and they'll look a little bit better than the simple ones. However, 625 00:43:10,176 --> 00:43:44,301 the simple ones are the ones that hold up on data they haven't 626 00:43:44,301 --> 00:44:15,801 already seen a lot better. And that's what matters is real life. 627 00:40:45,801 --> 00:41:27,799 So, there's theoretical life like on the screen, and then there's 628 00:41:27,799 --> 00:42:09,797 real life: what happens when you take a hundred million dollars, 629 00:42:09,797 --> 00:42:59,431 and you push it into a program, and you track it for three 630 00:42:59,431 --> 00:43:41,429 years? Does it look similar to what your beautiful spreadsheet and 631 00:43:41,429 --> 00:44:15,791 your model is telling you, or is it dissimilar? I can tell you 632 00:40:57,629 --> 00:41:27,199 that the simple, durable, blunt tools, in my experience, do 633 00:41:27,199 --> 00:41:53,812 a lot better digesting changing markets, new stuff you've 634 00:41:53,812 --> 00:42:32,253 never seen before. I mean, go back to COVID, when crude oil went 635 00:42:32,253 --> 00:43:07,737 negative. We were short that market and our broker said, you can't 636 00:43:07,737 --> 00:43:40,264 stay short a market that's negative. I mean, those were simple 637 00:43:40,264 --> 00:44:15,748 blunt tools that put us on the right side of risk premium. But to 638 00:40:55,133 --> 00:41:41,793 answer your question or your point, I built really complicated 639 00:41:41,793 --> 00:42:37,785 systems, but I know from experience, I'm in my 29th year now, 640 00:42:37,785 --> 00:43:33,777 that simple blunt tools are much more reliable. So, I don't fall 641 00:43:33,777 --> 00:44:15,771 victim to the seduction of the more complicated stuff. The other 642 00:40:52,801 --> 00:41:38,301 thing I would point out is, and I think Andrew sent this over 643 00:41:38,301 --> 00:42:20,301 a couple papers, about beta and how the majority of the returns 644 00:42:20,301 --> 00:42:58,801 that trend followers collect can be mapped back to four, five, 645 00:42:58,801 --> 00:43:23,301 maybe six principal components. You've got energies, 646 00:43:23,301 --> 00:43:58,301 you've got fixed income, you've got grains, you've got the 647 00:43:58,301 --> 00:44:15,801 US dollar versus everything else. I didn't want to believe that 648 00:40:57,051 --> 00:41:21,426 was true 20 years ago, but pretty much all of the research I've 649 00:41:21,426 --> 00:41:43,926 done shows that the vast majority, it's kind of like the Pareto 650 00:41:43,926 --> 00:42:06,426 principle; 80% of the results come from 20% of the parts. It's 651 00:42:06,426 --> 00:42:27,051 more like 90/10 in my experience. So, I've had to check 652 00:42:27,051 --> 00:42:51,426 myself, and check my ego, and stay humble, and admit that all of 653 00:42:51,426 --> 00:43:06,426 the empirical data consistently over decades has told 654 00:43:06,426 --> 00:43:30,801 me that simple, blunt rules work or if you can find ones that 655 00:43:30,801 --> 00:43:45,801 work, and they're more reliable than complicated fragile 656 00:43:45,801 --> 00:44:08,301 things that look elegant in a spreadsheet but don't hold up in 657 00:44:08,301 --> 00:44:15,801 real life going forward. 658 00:44:17,331 --> 00:44:22,479 Can you give me an example, Eric? Because I think, again, I want 659 00:44:22,479 --> 00:44:26,439 to make sure everybody understands what, to you, would be 660 00:44:26,439 --> 00:44:30,795 examples of things that are too complicated, that look good but 661 00:44:30,795 --> 00:44:35,547 don't hold up, so to speak, just so we're sure that everybody 662 00:44:35,547 --> 00:44:37,923 understands what is meant by that. 663 00:44:38,341 --> 00:45:10,837 Yeah. The one that comes to mind immediately when I get that 664 00:45:10,837 --> 00:45:35,209 question is correlation. Like finding situations in your portfolio 665 00:45:35,209 --> 00:46:10,413 where a new trade comes in and it's one of those markets that's 666 00:46:10,413 --> 00:46:37,493 uncorrelated to the others. So, that's great, that's what you 667 00:46:37,493 --> 00:46:59,157 want, but what do you do with it? My initial instinct would be 668 00:44:48,256 --> 00:45:08,086 to overweight that position and dilute positions that tend to 669 00:45:08,086 --> 00:45:27,916 have high correlation with each other because, in an elegant 670 00:45:27,916 --> 00:45:45,763 spreadsheet, everything else held static. That is something you'd 671 00:45:45,763 --> 00:46:05,593 want to do. You want to maximize diversification. So, I've 672 00:46:05,593 --> 00:46:25,423 wasted two years of my life chasing the correlation, co-integration 673 00:46:25,423 --> 00:46:49,219 copulas, like all of these things, trying to come up with the 674 00:46:49,219 --> 00:46:59,134 magic formula to maximize diversification. But then when you 675 00:44:48,053 --> 00:45:17,189 build these things, and you push them into the real world, and 676 00:45:17,189 --> 00:45:46,325 you get this mess that is reality with crude oil doing this, 677 00:45:46,325 --> 00:46:15,461 gold doing that, and whatnot, what you'll find is that you make 678 00:46:15,461 --> 00:46:47,025 a lot less money and you fool yourself into thinking you have less 679 00:46:47,025 --> 00:46:59,165 risk than you really do. And you know this, Niels, being with 680 00:44:55,946 --> 00:45:28,641 Dunn for so long. And Andrew, I'm sure knows this, in trend following 681 00:45:28,641 --> 00:45:56,306 you make your money in market environments where the vol’s going 682 00:45:56,306 --> 00:46:18,941 up, the correlation's going up, you-know-what is hitting the 683 00:46:18,941 --> 00:46:51,636 fan, and that's when you to be pressing the gas on that portion 684 00:46:51,636 --> 00:46:59,181 of your portfolio. If you want to reward low vol environments with 685 00:44:51,823 --> 00:45:03,807 gentle correlations, that tends to correspond with whipsaws 686 00:45:03,807 --> 00:45:23,281 and the lack of profits in the trend space. So, it's just another 687 00:45:23,281 --> 00:45:41,257 example of, you have this elegant idea that the CFAs and the 688 00:45:41,257 --> 00:46:02,229 PhDs, that I've known over the years, will pat you on the back and 689 00:46:02,229 --> 00:46:15,711 say, that's great, that's exactly what we're teaching people. 690 00:46:15,711 --> 00:46:32,189 But if you're an actual practitioner in the space, and you're 691 00:46:32,189 --> 00:46:47,169 pushing real money into the real world, you're getting kicked 692 00:46:47,169 --> 00:46:59,153 in the face and getting completely different feedback. So, 693 00:44:40,688 --> 00:45:06,505 I want to respect reality, not the elegance of academia. That's 694 00:45:06,505 --> 00:45:37,016 my job. And that's what I've found is that these blunt tools that, 695 00:45:37,016 --> 00:45:53,445 from a behavioral and psychological perspective, aren't 696 00:45:53,445 --> 00:46:23,956 the most satisfying in the world, but they just work a lot better. 697 00:46:23,956 --> 00:46:56,814 If our job is to make money and control risk, they work a lot 698 00:46:56,814 --> 00:46:59,161 better. 699 00:46:59,901 --> 00:47:02,937 Andrew, I'm sure you have a few things to add to this. 700 00:47:04,141 --> 00:47:35,497 I think there's, again, I'm not a quant, right? So, I'm always 701 00:47:35,497 --> 00:48:09,466 coming at this from, like, the work that Eric's done, I rely on 702 00:48:09,466 --> 00:48:43,435 my partners to do stuff like that. And I have the privilege of 703 00:48:43,435 --> 00:49:12,178 basically being able to sit back and just ask questions when 704 00:49:12,178 --> 00:49:43,534 something doesn't feel right to me. So we talked a little bit 705 00:49:43,534 --> 00:50:17,503 about when Rob Croce was on, and he wrote this great paper about 706 00:50:17,503 --> 00:50:35,794 the trend following the managed futures space. And it starts 707 00:47:12,388 --> 00:47:45,376 with this great description of why you definitely want this in your 708 00:47:45,376 --> 00:48:18,364 portfolio. And then he tries to construct a model to say, basically, 709 00:48:18,364 --> 00:48:56,850 how much of it is coming from picking up, as I think Eric would 710 00:48:56,850 --> 00:49:35,336 say, when correlations go high and a lot of assets are kind of moving 711 00:49:35,336 --> 00:50:00,077 together versus these true idiosyncratic risks. And going back 712 00:50:00,077 --> 00:50:27,567 to the simple versus complicated, so he built a model 713 00:50:27,567 --> 00:50:35,814 that's very simple. And again, it's always very, very hard reading 714 00:47:36,709 --> 00:48:13,348 these papers because you're presented with the final results. 715 00:48:13,348 --> 00:48:54,058 You're not handed an Excel spreadsheet to go through. You're 716 00:48:54,058 --> 00:49:38,839 not given a list of parameter assumptions. You're not shown the 717 00:49:38,839 --> 00:50:31,762 37 models that were thrown out that didn't make it into the final 718 00:50:31,762 --> 00:50:35,833 paper. But sometimes when you're reading things and things 719 00:47:33,341 --> 00:48:24,441 pop out. And the thing that came up, that popped out in his paper, 720 00:48:24,441 --> 00:48:53,641 was that this simple, super-ultra simple trend following 721 00:48:53,641 --> 00:49:37,441 model that he built, which is basically looking back over a year 722 00:49:37,441 --> 00:50:17,591 and reflexively just buying it. As Eric would say, blunt instruments, 723 00:50:17,591 --> 00:50:35,841 like a super blunt model. And he says, and by the way, this had 724 00:47:27,658 --> 00:48:01,627 a Sharpe ratio of one. The thing had a 12.5 vol. That means 725 00:48:01,627 --> 00:48:32,983 you're doing 1250 basis points over cash. And he says okay, well 726 00:48:32,983 --> 00:48:56,500 that doesn't include transaction costs or fees. So, he 727 00:48:56,500 --> 00:49:30,469 basically says that, in order to make it look more like the more 728 00:49:30,469 --> 00:49:53,986 complicated trend following hedge fund universe, we've got to 729 00:49:53,986 --> 00:50:25,342 knock 800 basis points off of those returns, and then we're going 730 00:50:25,342 --> 00:50:35,794 to run an analysis. That, to me, is like hold on, I want to stop 731 00:47:18,254 --> 00:47:31,084 there. If the simple model generates those kinds of returns 732 00:47:31,084 --> 00:47:49,046 over time, then my question is why aren’t you doing that in a product? 733 00:47:49,046 --> 00:48:04,442 Okay, so let's throw in a couple hundred basis points of implementation 734 00:48:04,442 --> 00:48:21,121 costs or whatever requires to get there. But I think there is just 735 00:48:21,121 --> 00:48:33,951 mounting, mounting, mounting evidence that the CTA signal is this 736 00:48:33,951 --> 00:48:44,215 unique trend following thing, this unique extraordinary signal. 737 00:48:44,215 --> 00:48:57,045 But there's a big difference between capturing the signal through 738 00:48:57,045 --> 00:49:12,441 a complicated portfolio. And at the end of the day, when you're 739 00:49:12,441 --> 00:49:27,837 making money in the real world that Eric describes, are you making 740 00:49:27,837 --> 00:49:43,233 it from 70 instruments working in your favor or are there clusters 741 00:49:43,233 --> 00:49:57,346 of instruments because oil's going up and it's dragging the whole 742 00:49:57,346 --> 00:50:11,459 energy complex with it, or gold's going up and it's driving 743 00:50:11,459 --> 00:50:28,138 the whole metals complex up with it, and the S&P is going up 744 00:50:28,138 --> 00:50:35,836 and all equities are going up? So, you know, I think what I've been 745 00:47:27,341 --> 00:47:56,341 surprised at, I've been talking about this for two years, 746 00:47:56,341 --> 00:48:16,641 I haven't seen a well-articulated evidence-based counter 747 00:48:16,641 --> 00:48:45,641 response to that argument. Where is the trend follower that 748 00:48:45,641 --> 00:49:20,441 has a Sharpe ratio of 1.1, not 0.3? Because the short-term models 749 00:49:20,441 --> 00:49:55,241 are getting people out at you know, 9:31, before the markets move, 750 00:49:55,241 --> 00:50:35,841 not at the end of the day, or the risk controls are kicking in. 751 00:47:04,141 --> 00:47:53,746 And so, I think it's just an area where I think Eric and I have 752 00:47:53,746 --> 00:48:30,123 both, again, he coming in from inside the industry, running the 753 00:48:30,123 --> 00:49:06,500 numbers, thinking about what he does with his own money, which 754 00:49:06,500 --> 00:49:42,877 applies a certain discipline. And I'm coming at it completely as 755 00:49:42,877 --> 00:50:29,175 an outsider saying I love the signal, how do I get it as efficiently 756 00:50:29,175 --> 00:50:35,789 as possible? 757 00:50:36,971 --> 00:50:42,273 So, there's something that's interesting to me. I know when we 758 00:50:42,273 --> 00:50:48,057 quote the Sharpe ratio, or certainly if the media quotes a Sharpe 759 00:50:48,057 --> 00:50:53,359 ratio of trend followers, they probably take the SocGen Trend index 760 00:50:53,359 --> 00:50:59,625 and 0.3. 0.4, whatever the number is. When I look at the peer 761 00:50:59,625 --> 00:51:03,481 group that I follow of certainly larger, well-established 762 00:51:03,481 --> 00:51:09,747 managers, I tend to go back 10, 15 years. It just coincides with 763 00:51:09,747 --> 00:51:16,013 when we made some upgrades to our systems. And most of them, I 764 00:51:16,013 --> 00:51:20,351 would say, have certainly somewhat higher Sharpe ratios, for 765 00:51:20,351 --> 00:51:27,099 sure. But it also led me to think about, I mean, is there something 766 00:51:27,099 --> 00:51:31,437 inherently bad, for example, by creating these indices? Because 767 00:51:31,437 --> 00:51:38,185 I kind of feel that the SocGen Trend index or the SocGen CTA index, 768 00:51:38,185 --> 00:51:43,969 are they really showing the industry at its best, if you know 769 00:51:43,969 --> 00:51:51,199 what I mean? I don't know how to phrase it, but it just seems like 770 00:51:51,199 --> 00:51:57,465 there's a little bit of the air that goes out of the balloon 771 00:51:57,465 --> 00:51:59,875 when you mix them together. The index returns are, in fairness, 772 00:50:51,599 --> 00:51:20,855 they're not super great when you look at them. Right? But then 773 00:51:20,855 --> 00:51:47,673 I look at some of the individual managers in the index 774 00:51:47,673 --> 00:51:59,863 and they've done pretty well. 775 00:52:00,761 --> 00:52:07,394 But you still look at FORT, right? I mean… 776 00:52:07,401 --> 00:52:14,481 Yeah, yeah, I mean, the problem is that you get, I mean, 777 00:52:14,481 --> 00:52:22,741 in a sense the problem… A little bit what I feel maybe is that 778 00:52:22,741 --> 00:52:30,411 you, on one hand, get all the blowups in the index because they're 779 00:52:30,411 --> 00:52:36,901 all usually the biggest managers and then they blow up. So, 780 00:52:36,901 --> 00:52:44,571 that drags the index down. And you may not get the smaller, and 781 00:52:44,571 --> 00:52:51,061 I say smaller but it’s still hundreds of millions, maybe even 782 00:52:51,061 --> 00:52:57,551 a couple of billion dollar managers who are doing really well, 783 00:52:57,551 --> 00:53:03,451 they're just not big enough to get into the index. So, I think it's 784 00:52:10,429 --> 00:52:20,270 great to have these indices. All I'm just throwing out as a question, 785 00:52:20,270 --> 00:52:29,354 I don't know the answer is, I mean, is the performance actually… 786 00:52:29,354 --> 00:52:38,438 does it really reflect… I know people say yeah, it reflects the 787 00:52:38,438 --> 00:52:45,251 industry, it reflects a certain portion of the industry, 788 00:52:45,251 --> 00:52:55,092 but does it reflect the larger industry as a whole when you limit 789 00:52:55,092 --> 00:53:03,419 it to 10 or 20 managers, including all the blow ups? 790 00:53:03,731 --> 00:53:15,803 Well, so clearly the indices, like the SocGen CTA index, do not 791 00:53:15,803 --> 00:53:25,863 pick up smaller managers, right? And actually, even in the 792 00:53:25,863 --> 00:53:35,923 trend sub-index, again, trend it's longer, like a backfilling issue. 793 00:53:35,923 --> 00:53:47,995 And Corey Hohfstein (by the way, go to his LinkedIn thing), he 794 00:53:47,995 --> 00:54:00,067 did a great post showing the trend managers who've been in overtime 795 00:54:00,067 --> 00:54:13,145 and drop out, etc. Look, I mean the real challenge is what is 796 00:54:13,145 --> 00:54:25,217 the underlying if you look at the industry? And another issue that 797 00:54:25,217 --> 00:54:36,283 you’ve got is, if you're a big institutional investor, you're not 798 00:54:36,283 --> 00:54:48,355 paying the fees that are built into the SocGen CTA index. You're 799 00:54:48,355 --> 00:55:02,439 Sharpe ratio will be higher. The Trend index has a bit of a higher 800 00:55:02,439 --> 00:55:11,493 Sharpe ratio than the non-trend index or slightly higher 801 00:55:11,493 --> 00:55:13,505 Sharpe ratio. So, we look at least the large managers, which is 802 00:53:17,391 --> 00:53:35,149 our thing, and you know, what I can say definitively is, from our 803 00:53:35,149 --> 00:53:51,541 start date, when the starting gun went off in mid-2016, we've outperformed 804 00:53:51,541 --> 00:54:06,567 every single one but one. Okay, iSAM. Okay. iSAM's doing something 805 00:54:06,567 --> 00:54:20,227 different. I've never had their numbers but they're the one. 806 00:54:20,227 --> 00:54:33,887 We've outperformed everybody else since 2016. And some of those 807 00:54:33,887 --> 00:54:54,377 firms have gone away and a lot of them have dropped out of the index 808 00:54:54,377 --> 00:55:08,037 over time. So, you're right, the index performance includes the 809 00:55:08,037 --> 00:55:13,501 ones who dropped out. Now, of the ones that have been added in 810 00:53:16,574 --> 00:53:35,125 since then, Winton dropped out for a while now they're back. I don't 811 00:53:35,125 --> 00:53:52,249 think CFM was in the beginning. Now if you look at it 812 00:53:52,249 --> 00:54:03,665 versus the current constituents and so, the current 813 00:54:03,665 --> 00:54:17,935 manager which has selection bias also because you know Graham 814 00:54:17,935 --> 00:54:36,486 will switch from this one to that one, and man will switch from 815 00:54:36,486 --> 00:54:53,610 this one to that one. So again, looking at the current constituents, 816 00:54:53,610 --> 00:55:12,161 as far as we can tell we're number three, so we're not number 817 00:55:12,161 --> 00:55:13,588 two. So, I think it is actually a representation, an accurate 818 00:53:25,741 --> 00:53:47,751 representation of the large funds including the pool of managers 819 00:53:47,751 --> 00:54:11,962 today versus it's not that different relative to where it was 820 00:54:11,962 --> 00:54:36,173 10 years ago, when you look at their backtested returns. Smaller 821 00:54:36,173 --> 00:54:58,183 managers, like Throne, or Mulvaney, or something, I have no 822 00:54:58,183 --> 00:55:13,590 idea what that does to the results. 823 00:55:13,591 --> 00:55:18,337 I mean, it's kind of funny. I mean Greg, our friends over at iSAM. 824 00:55:18,337 --> 00:55:23,083 I know them well. Great guys. But the funny part is, when you mention 825 00:55:23,083 --> 00:55:26,473 that is, I couldn't help thinking, well actually, iSAM, given 826 00:55:26,473 --> 00:55:29,863 the conversation we just had before about simpler being better 827 00:55:29,863 --> 00:55:33,592 in many ways, actually, they're not simple in any way, shape 828 00:55:33,592 --> 00:55:36,982 or form. And they trade hundreds of markets. They're kind 829 00:55:36,982 --> 00:55:41,050 of the complete opposite of that. So, in a sense, that's kind 830 00:55:41,050 --> 00:55:44,779 of funny that they're the ones that are hardest to beat. 831 00:55:46,291 --> 00:56:09,435 There's one consulting firm that I've talked to for years about 832 00:56:09,435 --> 00:56:38,891 what we do. And their answer is always, why would we do you when 833 00:56:38,891 --> 00:57:04,139 we can do iSAM? And I have no good answer to that. Look there's 834 00:55:48,213 --> 00:55:58,784 enormous talent in futures. CFM, I mean, we talked about Mr. 835 00:55:58,784 --> 00:56:11,277 Bouchaud. I mean, the guy is, he's building a D.E. Shaw like contraption 836 00:56:11,277 --> 00:56:22,809 over there. Anyway, I'm just saying, from my perch, I don't see 837 00:56:22,809 --> 00:56:32,419 some secret pool of large, high Sharpe ratio managers except 838 00:56:32,419 --> 00:56:42,029 in very limited circumstances over time. Which, to me, reinforces 839 00:56:42,029 --> 00:56:51,639 my argument that there's an inefficiency issue across the large 840 00:56:51,639 --> 00:57:02,210 managers that has actually played in our favor from a relative 841 00:57:02,210 --> 00:57:04,132 performance perspective. Gunn is one of the managers who's not 842 00:55:53,979 --> 00:56:05,511 in the SocGen CTA index, who does have a meaningfully higher Sharpe 843 00:56:05,511 --> 00:56:18,004 ratio. And I think, in a lot of ways, a more interesting return 844 00:56:18,004 --> 00:56:29,536 stream because your alpha was so punctuated in 2022. I mean, if 845 00:56:29,536 --> 00:56:41,068 you have your 60 or something in 2022, you carry those numbers 846 00:56:41,068 --> 00:56:53,561 for the next decade. I mean, we know alpha is lumpy, but your 847 00:56:53,561 --> 00:57:04,132 alpha was ultra super lumpy in a very, very compelling way. 848 00:57:04,311 --> 00:57:06,751 Sure. Eric, you were saying. 849 00:57:06,751 --> 00:57:21,077 Yeah. On the topic of Sharpe ratios, I can't remember when I did 850 00:57:21,077 --> 00:57:37,607 this. I think it was back in 2008, or ’09, or whatnot. But I started 851 00:57:37,607 --> 00:57:51,933 pulling data of every hedge fund that I could get access to from 852 00:57:51,933 --> 00:58:04,055 all the different databases. And I would plot the Sharpe ratio 853 00:58:04,055 --> 00:58:20,585 on the Y axis and the length of their track record on the X axis. 854 00:57:06,751 --> 00:57:33,595 So, for anything five years in, you would see Sharpe ratios of 855 00:57:33,595 --> 00:58:02,676 5, and Sharpe ratios of 2, and Sharpe ratios of negative 1. And 856 00:58:02,676 --> 00:58:20,572 you would have this kind of scatter plot. You get out to three 857 00:57:13,006 --> 00:57:29,269 years, it starts to come down. No Sharpe ratios over 2, you get 858 00:57:29,269 --> 00:57:49,285 out to 10, no one has a Sharpe ratio over 1. And if you get out 859 00:57:49,285 --> 00:58:04,297 to 15 or 20, it basically zeros in on elite managers. 0.65 860 00:58:04,297 --> 00:58:19,309 Is about the maximum Sharpe ratio you're going to see over a 861 00:58:19,309 --> 00:58:20,560 career. So, I started looking at that in terms of mutual funds, 862 00:57:16,420 --> 00:57:26,968 ETFs, CITs, managed accounts, all the data I could get all around 863 00:57:26,968 --> 00:57:38,395 the world, and a few things and I can't prove this, but what 864 00:57:38,395 --> 00:57:48,943 appeared to me is that single strategies, good ones, have a Sharpe 865 00:57:48,943 --> 00:57:56,854 ratio somewhere between 0.3 and 0.4 sustainably. That's just 866 00:57:56,854 --> 00:58:08,281 what I see. Just that the empirical data says no one has a 867 00:58:08,281 --> 00:58:18,829 Sharpe ratio over 0.4. If the horizon's long enough, it's 0:4 if 868 00:58:18,829 --> 00:58:20,587 they're good. 869 00:58:22,392 --> 00:58:28,032 However, if you combine strategies, you take a.04 from equities 870 00:58:28,032 --> 00:58:34,800 and you take a.04 from managed futures, you get something like 1.1. 871 00:58:34,800 --> 00:58:42,132 And if you can get a.03 from tail risk hedging and something else 872 00:58:42,132 --> 00:58:50,028 and the next thing you know you got a Sharpe ratio of 1.2. The 873 00:58:50,028 --> 00:58:53,976 question then becomes is that part sustainable? And the data so 874 00:58:24,776 --> 00:58:33,120 far says it may not be perfect. You may not be able to maintain 875 00:58:33,120 --> 00:58:42,656 a Sharpe ratio of 1.2, but you can get a lot closer to 1 than with 876 00:58:42,656 --> 00:58:49,212 a single strategy. So, I don't know, it's just, it's interesting 877 00:58:49,212 --> 00:58:53,980 to me. So, I bring it up now. 878 00:58:54,022 --> 00:59:01,762 I know we have a hard stop today and so I want to respect our 879 00:59:01,762 --> 00:59:07,954 time. There were a few other things that we could have talked 880 00:59:07,954 --> 00:59:14,146 about. There's one paper I just want to mention because I think 881 00:59:14,146 --> 00:59:20,338 I might include it in my Sunday email coming up and that's 882 00:59:20,338 --> 00:59:26,530 a paper from Man Group called Don't Look Down, by Henry Neville. 883 00:59:26,530 --> 00:59:31,690 I thought it was interesting. It talked about different assets 884 00:59:31,690 --> 00:59:37,366 and strategies in terms of their drawdown and what it really 885 00:59:37,366 --> 00:59:43,558 means and the fact that maybe it's not really the individual drawdown 886 00:59:43,558 --> 00:59:49,234 that's important, it is what else is drawing down when you're 887 00:59:49,234 --> 00:59:54,394 drawing down. And that also has a reference to trend. So, I obviously 888 00:58:57,094 --> 00:59:10,406 think that's always relevant, but I also want to give both of you 889 00:59:10,406 --> 00:59:22,694 an opportunity before we wrap up just to bring up anything that 890 00:59:22,694 --> 00:59:34,982 you want to bring up since we didn't have time necessarily full 891 00:59:34,982 --> 00:59:47,270 agenda as we're coming up to our hard stop today. Andrew, let 892 00:59:47,270 --> 00:59:54,438 me start with you. Anything we missed? 893 00:59:54,942 --> 01:00:24,158 So, back to the Man AHL paper for a second. So, I will say it until 894 01:00:24,158 --> 01:00:47,896 I am blue in the face. I believe we have a messaging issue 895 01:00:47,896 --> 01:01:11,634 with this space. I have tried, and my partners joke about the fact 896 01:01:11,634 --> 01:01:35,372 that every six months I think I'd have a narrative angle that I 897 01:01:35,372 --> 01:02:00,936 think is going to convince the world and be able to bridge the gap 898 01:02:00,936 --> 01:02:19,196 between, Eric would say, between the theory of the Sharpe 899 01:02:19,196 --> 01:02:39,282 ratio and the experience of owning the product. So, I actually 900 01:02:39,282 --> 01:02:52,064 refer to this space now as CTAs. But instead of getting bogged 901 01:00:02,852 --> 01:00:20,254 down in commodity trading advisors, I say, you know what CTA 902 01:00:20,254 --> 01:00:36,074 stands for is Contrarian Tactical Alpha. And the reason I 903 01:00:36,074 --> 01:00:56,640 say it is because CTA as a term that is familiar to people. 904 01:00:56,640 --> 01:01:18,788 They know it. I don't have to introduce a new term. But when the 905 01:01:18,788 --> 01:01:34,608 space makes money, it's not trend following, it's not getting 906 01:01:34,608 --> 01:01:50,428 into something late. Right? When people think about trend following, 907 01:01:50,428 --> 01:02:09,412 they think about, I often say this analogy, it's like you show 908 01:02:09,412 --> 01:02:34,724 up at a party at 1 and hope it goes till 5. Right? It's like everybody 909 01:02:34,724 --> 01:02:52,126 is already there and you're showing up because it's already popular. 910 00:59:54,942 --> 01:00:22,202 When I've seen the space make money, you're really contrarian. 911 01:00:22,202 --> 01:00:52,188 You're buying crude oil in January after it's been going down 912 01:00:52,188 --> 01:01:27,626 and just starting to come back a little bit. You are buying gold 913 01:01:27,626 --> 01:02:00,338 at US$2,200 after it's been dead money for a decade. Didn't do 914 01:02:00,338 --> 01:02:24,872 anything in 2022. You are shorting bonds, shorting treasuries 915 01:02:24,872 --> 01:02:52,132 in September 2020 when treasury yields are 70 basis points. 916 00:59:54,942 --> 01:00:16,138 And the idea of inflation is just some out of the… it's not even 917 01:00:16,138 --> 01:00:31,278 on people's radars yet. So, contrarian also gives the reason 918 01:00:31,278 --> 01:00:49,446 why this is in your portfolio, because the rest of your portfolio 919 01:00:49,446 --> 01:01:04,586 is strategic consensus beta. You're building a portfolio of lots 920 01:01:04,586 --> 01:01:22,754 of different betas that aren't going to change a lot over time. 921 01:01:22,754 --> 01:01:39,408 Tactical, because that's what we are. Every other asset class in 922 01:01:39,408 --> 01:01:57,576 the portfolio, and a guy who actually was talking to, who's an 923 01:01:57,576 --> 01:02:14,230 investor in BMF, who's not in this business, he basically said, 924 01:02:14,230 --> 01:02:30,884 look (and he builds his own asset allocation model), he said, 925 01:02:30,884 --> 01:02:49,052 every other asset class has a static exposure to whatever is out 926 01:02:49,052 --> 01:02:52,080 underlying it. This isn't a strategy, it's an asset class. It's 927 01:00:46,386 --> 01:01:49,262 an asset class that, by its nature, is dynamic and tactical. 928 01:01:49,262 --> 01:02:52,138 That's what makes it different and that's what makes it valuable. 929 00:59:54,942 --> 01:00:32,419 And then alpha, because alpha for any allocator has a universally 930 01:00:32,419 --> 01:01:03,082 positive connotation, and because of the low correlation of 931 01:01:03,082 --> 01:01:40,559 the space, every dollar of generated returns shows up as alpha. 932 01:01:40,559 --> 01:02:04,408 So total Portfolio Construction, ChatGPT, Claude, etc., 933 01:02:04,408 --> 01:02:38,478 they're all looking at the statistical value benefits of it. 934 01:02:38,478 --> 01:02:52,106 But we need language. So, I would please encourage you guys, 935 01:00:20,779 --> 01:01:05,071 if you guys think this makes sense, you just keep repeating it 936 01:01:05,071 --> 01:01:56,745 and hopefully we'll get people to just say, what I need in my portfolio 937 01:01:56,745 --> 01:02:33,655 is a little contrarian alpha, whether it's blended with equities 938 01:02:33,655 --> 01:02:52,110 or on a standalone basis. 939 01:02:53,672 --> 01:02:57,110 Eric, any parting words from you? 940 01:02:57,592 --> 01:03:12,321 Yeah, I was going to say something else, but I'd like to follow 941 01:03:12,321 --> 01:03:24,784 up on what Andrew just said. The algorithmic discipline to get 942 01:03:24,784 --> 01:03:34,981 into trends before they're socially and politically safe is 943 01:03:34,981 --> 01:03:46,311 crucially important. I've had managed futures for decades. I didn't 944 01:03:46,311 --> 01:04:02,173 want to short equities in June of 2002, but I did because the algorithmic 945 01:04:02,173 --> 01:04:14,636 discipline forced me to. I didn't naturally want to short equities 946 01:04:14,636 --> 01:04:27,099 in April of 2008, but I did. The algorithmic discipline forced 947 01:04:27,099 --> 01:04:41,828 me to. I didn't want to short every energy market on the planet 948 01:04:41,828 --> 01:04:55,424 in the middle of February, right before COVID, but I did. The 949 01:04:55,424 --> 01:05:07,887 algorithmic discipline forced me to. I didn't want to buy cocoa 950 01:05:07,887 --> 01:05:21,483 and have it go up 400% or whatever it did. The algorithmic 951 01:05:21,483 --> 01:05:26,015 discipline forced me to. So, if you want alpha, it's not comfortable. 952 01:03:13,640 --> 01:03:43,730 They don't write a report and hand it to you and all of a sudden 953 01:03:43,730 --> 01:04:07,802 you're on the right side of this lumpy alpha. It requires algorithmic 954 01:04:07,802 --> 01:04:29,868 discipline. And if you're going to pursue it, you better have 955 01:04:29,868 --> 01:04:55,946 some risk controls in place because it is lumpy and it is volatile. 956 01:04:55,946 --> 01:05:20,018 So, you need the algorithmic discipline to give up on trades that 957 01:05:20,018 --> 01:05:26,036 don't work out. And in the trend following world, 50%, 60%, 958 01:03:11,560 --> 01:03:30,766 sometimes 70% of your trades don't work out. So, those losses 959 01:03:30,766 --> 01:03:53,464 need to be kept small, versus your gains where you can just hold 960 01:03:53,464 --> 01:04:14,416 for one year, two year, three or sometimes five years. I mean, 961 01:04:14,416 --> 01:04:37,114 at one point I was short natural gas, I think for eight consecutive 962 01:04:37,114 --> 01:04:56,320 years. It was just algorithmic discipline. Just sit on your hands 963 01:04:56,320 --> 01:05:15,526 and stay short. This heavy contango market that just seems going 964 01:05:15,526 --> 01:05:26,002 down year, after year, after year. What Andrew was saying is that 965 01:04:06,112 --> 01:05:26,052 you call it the tactical contrarian alpha. I like that. That 966 01:03:07,828 --> 01:03:38,536 makes sense to you and me, but those words mean different things 967 01:03:38,536 --> 01:03:59,008 to different people because people have different glossaries 968 01:03:59,008 --> 01:04:24,598 or whatever, but just the blunt algorithmic discipline of getting 969 01:04:24,598 --> 01:04:55,306 on the right side of trends that people aren't paying attention 970 01:04:55,306 --> 01:05:26,014 to yet. It's not safe yet. It doesn't make any sense yet. Like 971 01:03:00,685 --> 01:03:40,894 gold, gold was dead money for two decades and then it broke out 972 01:03:40,894 --> 01:04:21,103 and it just… it's been on a tear for 25 years. Algorithmic discipline 973 01:04:21,103 --> 01:05:07,498 forced you to not waste your time on it for 20 years and to be 974 01:05:07,498 --> 01:05:26,056 long and strong ever since then. So, I love trend but on a day-to-day 975 01:03:29,688 --> 01:04:25,856 basis it tends to drive people crazy which is why I blend it with 976 01:04:25,856 --> 01:05:14,000 other assets and just you know, call it multi asset and take 977 01:05:14,000 --> 01:05:26,036 what I get. 978 01:05:28,622 --> 01:05:35,336 Well said. All right gentlemen, this was really, really 979 01:05:35,336 --> 01:05:42,050 great. I appreciate the conversation and your time. Next 980 01:05:42,050 --> 01:05:50,256 week I'll be joined by Rob Carver. So that's another chance 981 01:05:50,256 --> 01:05:58,462 for people to send in questions like we had today. That's 982 01:05:58,462 --> 01:06:02,192 always great at info@toptradersunplugged.com. That's 983 01:06:02,192 --> 01:06:12,636 where you can send them and I'll do my best to bring them up. 984 01:05:28,622 --> 01:05:41,063 And if you want to show some appreciation, which I really do hope 985 01:05:41,063 --> 01:05:52,547 you will, for Andrew and Eric, for all their hard work preparation, 986 01:05:52,547 --> 01:06:02,117 head over to your favorite podcast platform, leave a rating 987 01:06:02,117 --> 01:06:12,644 and review and then hopefully more people will join the show. From 988 01:05:29,880 --> 01:05:44,976 Andrew, Eric and me, thanks ever so much for listening. We look 989 01:05:44,976 --> 01:06:01,330 forward to being back with you next week and in the meantime, take 990 01:06:01,330 --> 01:06:12,652 care of yourself and take care of each other. 991 01:06:15,082 --> 01:07:48,168 Thanks for listening to Top Traders Unplugged. If you feel you 992 01:06:20,398 --> 01:06:33,688 learned something of value from today's episode, the best way 993 01:06:33,688 --> 01:06:50,965 to stay updated is to go on over to your favorite podcast platform 994 01:06:50,965 --> 01:07:09,571 and follow the show so that you'll be sure to get all the new 995 01:07:09,571 --> 01:07:22,861 episodes as they're released. We have some amazing guests lined 996 01:07:22,861 --> 01:07:40,138 up for you and to ensure our show continues to grow, please leave 997 01:07:40,138 --> 01:07:48,112 us an honest rating and review. It only takes a minute and 998 01:06:36,562 --> 01:07:26,682 it's the best way to show us you love the podcast. We'll see you 999 01:07:26,682 --> 01:07:48,162 next time on Top Traders Unplugged. This podcast expresses 1000 01:06:21,022 --> 01:06:46,762 the views of its hosts and the guests appearing on the podcast as 1001 01:06:46,762 --> 01:07:12,502 of the date of its recording, and such views are subject to change 1002 01:07:12,502 --> 01:07:34,282 without notice. Top Traders Unplugged do not have any duty or 1003 01:07:34,282 --> 01:07:48,142 obligation to update the information contained herein. Furthermore, 1004 01:06:17,352 --> 01:06:40,052 Top Traders Unplugged make no representation to its accuracy and 1005 01:06:40,052 --> 01:07:05,022 it shall not be assumed that past investment performance is an 1006 01:07:05,022 --> 01:07:27,722 indication of future results. Moreover, wherever there is a potential 1007 01:07:27,722 --> 01:07:48,152 for profit, there is also the possibility of loss. This content 1008 01:06:25,424 --> 01:07:11,963 is made available for educational purposes only and should 1009 01:07:11,963 --> 01:07:48,160 not be used for any other purpose. The information contained 1010 01:06:22,837 --> 01:06:51,272 in this podcast does not constitute and should not be construed 1011 01:06:51,272 --> 01:07:22,292 as investment advice or an offer to sell or a solicitation to 1012 01:07:22,292 --> 01:07:48,142 buy any securities or related financial instruments in any jurisdiction. 1013 01:06:15,082 --> 01:06:32,687 Certain information contained herein concerning economic trends 1014 01:06:32,687 --> 01:06:57,837 and performance is based on or derived from information provided 1015 01:06:57,837 --> 01:07:17,957 by independent third-party sources. Top Traders Unplugged may 1016 01:07:17,957 --> 01:07:43,107 believe that the sources from which such information are obtained 1017 01:07:43,107 --> 01:07:48,137 are reliable. However, Top Traders Unplugged cannot guarantee 1018 01:06:23,806 --> 01:06:36,892 the accuracy of such information and has not independently 1019 01:06:36,892 --> 01:06:48,524 verified the accuracy or completeness of such information 1020 01:06:48,524 --> 01:07:04,518 or the assumptions on which such information is based. This podcast, 1021 01:07:04,518 --> 01:07:17,604 including the information contained herein, may not be reproduced, 1022 01:07:17,604 --> 01:07:35,052 copied, republished or posted in whole or in part in any form, 1023 01:07:35,052 --> 01:07:48,138 without the prior written consent of Top Traders Unplugged.