Hi and welcome back to another episode of the ADHD Women's Wellbeing Wisdom where I bring back to you conversations I've had previously because I find them so important and more poignant than ever.
Speaker AAnd today's episode is no different.
Speaker AI've got Professor Sandra Coy here and Sandra is fascinating because she is dissecting and understanding the most up to date research and evidence on of women's health, hormones and neurodiversity.
Speaker AShe works understanding about heart health and neurodiversity and she's spearheading so much more research in this area, desperately needed research.
Speaker AShe is the professor of Adult ADHD in Department of Psychiatry in Amsterdam and she started in 1995 with the research and the development of diagnostic assessment and treatment of adult ADHD in the Netherlands.
Speaker AAnd since 2002 she's been the head of the Dutch Expertise center of Adult adhd.
Speaker AShe has been dedicated and involved in research, treating patients, educating professionals, informing the public, publishing books, scientific papers, websites, webinars and podcasts, and now has a new ADHD app as well.
Speaker ASo what we're understanding here is that Professor Sandra Koi is someone who understands ADHD from a time perspective.
Speaker AShe's been there, she's been understanding, researching for such a long period of time.
Speaker AAnd what she knows are the nuances and the interplays and the many layers and fabrics of how neurodiversity, especially in adults, adult women, can show up.
Speaker AShe focuses on this overlooked interplay between estrogen and dopamine and its impact on women with adhd.
Speaker AWe're going to talk about this in today's episode, the historical research in this area and how ADHD symptoms can work worse and during times of lower estrogen.
Speaker ASo we're talking about, you know, before a period after childbirth and during menopause.
Speaker AAnd she's going to explain to us a little bit about the real world clinical observations and the emerging treatment areas, from adjusting stimulant medication to considering more hormonal support.
Speaker AI really hope you find this episode as fascinating as I did back when I recorded it.
Speaker AI can't wait to share this more condensed snippet here because I know that this is very much needed in our community here.
Speaker AHere is my conversation with Professor Sandra Coy.
Speaker BIf you dive into the literature, there's nothing about ADHD women at the time.
Speaker BThere was nothing about interaction of hormones and neurotransmitters.
Speaker BWhat I suspected, there was very few studies about dopamine and estrogen interaction.
Speaker BThat was the most interesting part that I found because estrogen proved to be like a neurotransmitter.
Speaker BIt's a hormone doing things for our female organs and so on.
Speaker BAnd we all know that.
Speaker BBut it's also a compound that works into the brain directly with dopamine.
Speaker BAnd dopamine is the compound.
Speaker BWe need to pay attention, to be organized, to be able to plan, to make decisions, to be quiet and having control over our emotions.
Speaker BEstrogen basically does similar things for us.
Speaker BSo we have two hormones or two neurosensmitters, if you like, that do the same.
Speaker BIf you have adhd, we assume that the brain is suffering from a low dopamine level.
Speaker BAnd when your estrogen drops in the last week of the cycle, or after giving birth or in menopause, you have twice nothing to control your behavior, your feelings, your cognition, your memory.
Speaker BYou are not able to fulfill any task that you intended to do in that week and maybe a bit longer.
Speaker BSo it's really understandable.
Speaker BAnd people, women were so enthusiastic when we wrote this down and gave webinars about it because they said, there's an explanation for us, we are not stupid, we are not crazy, it's not our fault.
Speaker BThere's a biology behind it.
Speaker BWell, of course I cannot measure it, but I hypothesize that this can be good explanation.
Speaker BAnd if that would be true, we cannot measure estrogen in the brain or dopamine in the brain.
Speaker BWe cannot.
Speaker BIt's not possible.
Speaker BWe cannot even use hormone levels in the blood because it's not reliable, it doesn't say anything about symptoms.
Speaker BSo there's no correlation between the level of estrogen, high or low, and your symptomatology.
Speaker BSo that's not a way to go.
Speaker BBut we can confirm this hypothesis by using medications that increase estrogen levels and or dopamine levels.
Speaker BAnd if that's true, women should improve with one or the other or both.
Speaker BAnd actually they do so, although RCTs are lacking.
Speaker BStill, I can tell you what I learned from clinical practice so far and from a case series that Maxime de Jong recently published.
Speaker BWhat she did was monitoring what women with ADHD are doing already themselves, because they find out it's helpful.
Speaker BAnd this is a little increase of the dosage of stimulant medication in the premensal week.
Speaker BAnd this is very helpful and it's easy, but you need to discuss it with your doctor because your prescription will be finished earlier and she needs to understand what you do with it.
Speaker BHe or she.
Speaker BBut we measured blood pressure and pulse and mood and Sleep and everything in those nine women only.
Speaker BAnd they all were happy and wanted to continue every month in the premenstrual week with the increased dosage.
Speaker BSo everybody whose interest can read it, it's on PubMed, so everybody can read what we did, how high the dosages were and what the women reported.
Speaker BSo that's good news.
Speaker BOf course, it's not rct, it's not randomized controlled trial.
Speaker BWhat we need to do to prove it.
Speaker BAnd then you give women a placebo versus this increased dosage.
Speaker BThe other way to go would be increasing estrogen.
Speaker BThis can be done with the pill continuously.
Speaker BSo no stop week, because in the stop week you drop your estrogen again to get this withdrawal bleeding that's normal.
Speaker BBut in this case you can continue to take the pill, which is not dangerous at all, in order to limit the chance of getting symptoms again due to drop of estrogen.
Speaker BAnd for some women this is also helpful.
Speaker BWe don't know yet for whom which one is best.
Speaker BIncreasing the dosage of the stimulants or the continuous taking of the pill.
Speaker BThis should be studied.
Speaker BThis is next.
Speaker BThe other way is our three options now is ssri, the antidepressants.
Speaker BThey have been studied in PMDD for a long time ago and they have been proven effective for improving the symptoms in the last week.
Speaker BSo you can even take it shorter than a whole month, you can take it two weeks because the effect of the antidepressants starts earlier than with normal depressions, maybe because the fluctuation of the hormones have impact on that.
Speaker BWe don't know exactly why, but it means that serotonergic medication, dopaminergic medication and hormones interact, which we said in the first place, but also that serotonin can have influence on this process.
Speaker BSo we have not one, but three options now potentially, which is good because not everybody can use every medication.
Speaker BAnd sleeping enough and having a healthy lifestyle and so on is very nice for people who can control themselves, but not in this week for women with adc.
Speaker BSo it's kind of cruel, it's kind of a cruel treatment option to tell them that they should behave better and take care of themselves.
Speaker BAnd of course you should do that, but it's not possible.
Speaker BSo it's not a way to go.
Speaker BAnd so I think medicine should think of better options and understand why this happens.
Speaker BAnd if you understand why this happens, how it happens, you can invent the right treatments.
Speaker AYeah, absolutely.
Speaker AAnd I think what you said then about just saying, right, or just sleep better or just have a Bath and, you know, you'll be fine.
Speaker AIt's.
Speaker AI've heard this as well.
Speaker AI've done some research in my community and about 300 women, and I asked some different questions, and I would say every single woman and the question of hormones and how have they impacted you and how's it shown up?
Speaker AEvery single woman had a story.
Speaker ASo that's 300 women all saying, I've either had postnatal depression, severe PMS or PMDD, suicidal ideation, anxiety, depression towards the end of my period.
Speaker ALike anything, it's it not one of them said, I've been absolutely fine.
Speaker AI'm sure you, you know, you understand this is that as women, we've all got off our hormones.
Speaker AIt all fluctuates in very different, unique ways.
Speaker AAnd then with adhd, we're also fluctuating, and it shows up in very unique ways as well.
Speaker ASo to be able to find something that works for both our hormones and both our ADHD is a very kind of very highly sensitized dance, isn't it?
Speaker AUntil.
Speaker AAnd then things change.
Speaker ASo something that could work for me at 40, at 50, it might be.
Speaker AI might need something totally different.
Speaker AAnd then we have to bring in all the medication and all of that.
Speaker AAnd so I'm just saying that to validate to anyone that's listening here, going, I've still not found that dance that works for me.
Speaker ABut at least now with your research and what you're bringing to the table, women have got more options.
Speaker AWe're able to say, if that doesn't work, let's try this.
Speaker AAnd if that doesn't, you know, but.
Speaker BWhat you say is true.
Speaker BAnd research recently showed that women with ADHD have earlier menopausal onset.
Speaker BAnd this is completely unknown in the rest of the world except among researchers now, because it's only one study showing that, and this is a genetic thing.
Speaker BSo there is something that's in your genes that tells that time has come to stop making eggs and lowering your hormones.
Speaker BIt's not in your advantage because your bones will lack estrogen for being dense, and the fractures that come when you are 60 are ahead.
Speaker BSo you must be protected from an early age, earlier than anybody else.
Speaker BAnd it's not known.
Speaker BSo that's dangerous for women with ADHD.
Speaker BAnd it means that when you're, for instance, you're 44 and you're having PMDD, severe PMDD in the week for before menstruation, your PMDD may increase by advancing during the cycle.
Speaker BSo first, it's only the Third week, then it starts in the third, and then the second, and then it's a whole month.
Speaker BAnd then you think, I'm getting crazy.
Speaker BI can't cope.
Speaker BSo this could be an indication of early menopause in women with pmdd.
Speaker BAnd of course, there's no underpinning for this, but it's logical thinking because estrogen drops, and so you will earlier and earlier in the cycle get more depressive symptoms, cognitive complaints, anger, outbursts, whatsoever.
Speaker BSo this is a group I worry about because if you do not start early with hrt, you may get unresponsive to hormones.
Speaker BSo the ovaries and the brain are not forever open for hormonal influence.
Speaker BIt stops after a few years.
Speaker BSo it's necessary that we learn.
Speaker BIt's necessary that women know, but especially the GPs who prescribe the hormones.
Speaker BAnd this is a problem because they don't.
Speaker BThey don't know it.
Speaker BBut awareness often comes from patients.
Speaker BSo I trust you that you will help.
Speaker BOh, yeah, but doctors don't believe women who are on their doorsteps and, and claim things.
Speaker BSo we should publish for you and do more research.
Speaker BAnd we do that.
Speaker BWe will do that.
Speaker AI'm grateful.
Speaker AI mean, a hundred percent.
Speaker AI've heard this through so many women that I've spoken to that their perimenopausal symptoms have started and they've just questioned it and said, well, I'm too young.
Speaker AAnd everyone tells me that, you know, before 45 it should.
Speaker AShouldn't happen, and you get invalidated and the doctors say you're too young for hrt.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BWe continue to do research on premature ovarian insufficiency.
Speaker BSo failure of your ovarian.
Speaker BOvarian leading to perimenopause early.
Speaker BOf course, it must go with early onset of hrt.
Speaker BHRT is important for not only your cognition and mood, but also for the heart.
Speaker BAnd there we come to the story of the female heart during menopause.
Speaker BThat's.
Speaker BThat's at stake.
Speaker BBecause first, cardiac heart attack is cause of death in women, number one.
Speaker BAnd this is not known.
Speaker BPeople think it's breast cancer, but it's cardiovascular disease.
Speaker BAnd we found out in the outpatient clinic of cardiologists here in the Netherlands with whom I co parate and I was intrigued by how many ADHD women she saw in her outpatient cardiology clinic.
Speaker BAnd I said, if that's true, we have to screen now immediately, because lives are at stake.
Speaker BI'm a bit dramatic sometimes, but it helps to get things done.
Speaker BSo she did and she was very committed.
Speaker BAnd Janneke Wittkuk is her name, and she's a defender of the female heart.
Speaker BIt has other problems than male hearts.
Speaker BAnd for recognition of the female heart.
Speaker BAnd we found that in the 300 women that we screened for ADHD, that 35% screened positive.
Speaker BSo that's a high, high number.
Speaker BAnd it's only screening.
Speaker BIt's not assessment.
Speaker BAnd for assessment, we need more time.
Speaker BBut all the women she referred to me for cardiac complaints and ADHD treatment, they did have it.
Speaker BAnd it's not saying everything, and we have to do more research.
Speaker BBut this was the very reason we also started the H3 network in the Netherlands, Head Heart and Hormones, for the connection between psychiatry, cardiology and kinnaecology, because those women who had heart problems and ADHD were all in perimenopause, and those women with ADHD were younger than the others with these complaints, two years younger.
Speaker BSo that means that the risk comes earlier for women with adhd.
Speaker BAnd this could very well be explained by early menopause in women with adhd.
Speaker BThis has to be combined in another study, but I think we find some directions here.
Speaker BAnd what does this Head Heart Hormones Network do?
Speaker BWe educate the public, we educate our colleagues.
Speaker BWe want to form regional little cells of the H3 network so that psychiatry, cardiology and gynecology voluntarily come together and start working together for the sake of women with ADHD and potentially also for other women with psychiatric disorders, because we assume it's not unique for ADHD to have this combination of interactions in the brain because estrogen protects the heart.
Speaker BSo it's not a good idea to stop too early with estrogen and progesterone, because it protects the heart, it protects the bones, it protects mental health.
Speaker BAnd yeah, that's why women with psychiatric problems, including adhd, suffer more when estrogen drops.
Speaker ASo I hope you enjoyed listening to this shorter episode episode of the ADHD Women's Wellbeing podcast.
Speaker AI've called it the ADHD Women's Wellbeing Wisdom, because I believe there's so much wisdom in the guests that I have on and their insights.
Speaker ASo sometimes we just need that little bit of a reminder.
Speaker AAnd I hope that has helped you today and look forward to seeing you back on the brand new episode on Thursday.
Speaker AHave a good rest of your week.
Speaker BIt.