1 00:00:42,860 --> 00:00:46,180 All right, folks, this is Steve with Macro and Cheese. Today's 2 00:00:46,180 --> 00:00:51,020 guest is none other than the original OG L. Randall Ray, as you'll 3 00:00:51,020 --> 00:00:53,820 see him in his writings. That'd be Randy Ray, for those of 4 00:00:53,820 --> 00:00:58,420 you that get to know him and a prolific writer. He is a professor 5 00:00:58,420 --> 00:01:03,790 at Bard College at Levy. He is also one of the original developers 6 00:01:03,870 --> 00:01:07,590 of the economic school of thought known as modern monetary 7 00:01:07,590 --> 00:01:12,590 theory. Randy has been on the show many times, and for those of 8 00:01:12,590 --> 00:01:15,710 you who don't know him, please go look up more of his work. For 9 00:01:15,710 --> 00:01:19,310 those of you who heard my story, Randy's primer that he put 10 00:01:19,310 --> 00:01:23,870 in New Economic Perspectives, and his original book, which basically 11 00:01:23,870 --> 00:01:28,610 was the primer put into book form, was a core part of my learning 12 00:01:28,610 --> 00:01:33,210 mmt. It was way before the deficit myth, way before a lot of 13 00:01:33,210 --> 00:01:36,090 the stuff we get to see on the Internet that we've grown to know 14 00:01:36,090 --> 00:01:41,370 and love. And so Randy's work has been very, very, very instrumental 15 00:01:41,370 --> 00:01:44,810 in really what a lot of the work we've put out there represents. 16 00:01:44,810 --> 00:01:48,410 So I appreciate him taking the time to be with us. Today we're going 17 00:01:48,410 --> 00:01:52,690 to go over the Federal Reserve and we're going to talk about a policy 18 00:01:52,850 --> 00:01:57,450 paper or position paper that they put out at Levy Institute called 19 00:01:57,450 --> 00:02:01,250 no, the Fed is Not Independent. It is a Creature of 20 00:02:01,250 --> 00:02:05,290 Congress. You all have heard me talk about it. You've had multiple 21 00:02:05,290 --> 00:02:09,490 guests come on, such as Ron Gray. We've had Christopher Shaw 22 00:02:09,490 --> 00:02:13,010 come on. We've had a number of people come on to discuss the Fed. 23 00:02:13,250 --> 00:02:16,250 But it's really important today because as we're watching these 24 00:02:16,250 --> 00:02:19,890 no Kings rallies, for whatever they're worth, and we're watching 25 00:02:19,890 --> 00:02:23,640 the Trump administration rattle its sabers and talk about 26 00:02:23,720 --> 00:02:28,080 getting rid of Powell and so forth, the mere notion that the Fed 27 00:02:28,080 --> 00:02:31,840 is somehow or another truly an independent thing, that it's not 28 00:02:31,840 --> 00:02:36,200 part of the government, is ludicrous. And we will cover that 29 00:02:36,200 --> 00:02:40,240 today. We'll also cover the primary purpose that the Fed was 30 00:02:40,240 --> 00:02:44,120 originally supposed to serve for the government and what it's 31 00:02:44,120 --> 00:02:48,530 been reduced to over the last 30 years or so. I'm well on the record 32 00:02:48,690 --> 00:02:52,530 for saying I believe a lot of this stuff is a manufacturing of 33 00:02:52,530 --> 00:02:56,210 consent. These narrative forms that go out there are meant to keep 34 00:02:56,210 --> 00:03:00,130 us in a chaos mode, et cetera, and not really ever knowing what 35 00:03:00,130 --> 00:03:04,010 truth is. Kind of like a post truth society at this point meant 36 00:03:04,010 --> 00:03:06,890 to keep us all, you know, if there is no truth, then we can't 37 00:03:06,890 --> 00:03:10,330 ever know anything. Right. And so we can't make decisions. But let's 38 00:03:10,330 --> 00:03:15,020 be honest, MMT is a real source of truth. At least it's a 39 00:03:15,020 --> 00:03:19,260 mooring and anchoring that we can have in understanding the world 40 00:03:19,260 --> 00:03:23,620 around us as money is a primary mover of all things, quite 41 00:03:23,620 --> 00:03:26,740 frankly. And this is no different. So with that, I bring 42 00:03:26,740 --> 00:03:29,260 on my guest, Randy Ray. Welcome to the show, sir. 43 00:03:29,660 --> 00:03:31,420 Oh, yes, good to be back. 44 00:03:31,580 --> 00:03:34,820 I appreciate it so much. This paper that you and Yeva put out, 45 00:03:34,820 --> 00:03:38,620 I guess this is what, September 19th of 2025. Very timely. 46 00:03:39,020 --> 00:03:41,980 Can you talk a little bit about what prompted you guys to write 47 00:03:41,980 --> 00:03:43,860 this policy position paper? 48 00:03:44,340 --> 00:03:48,980 Well, actually, it was a statement by Senator Elizabeth Warren. 49 00:03:49,460 --> 00:03:56,020 She is normally very good on financial markets, and she said that 50 00:03:56,580 --> 00:04:01,460 she completely disagreed with the appointment of Chair Powell, 51 00:04:01,700 --> 00:04:07,100 but now wants to protect him from President Trump. She wants to 52 00:04:07,100 --> 00:04:10,840 protect the Fed's independence. And I was very shocked 53 00:04:10,840 --> 00:04:16,840 by this because the Fed is not independent, has never been independent, 54 00:04:17,080 --> 00:04:21,040 should never be independent of Congress. And what she should be 55 00:04:21,040 --> 00:04:26,480 doing instead is getting Congress to take back control over 56 00:04:26,480 --> 00:04:30,040 the Fed, take it away from Trump, take it away from Powell. 57 00:04:30,520 --> 00:04:34,880 The Fed is a creature of Congress from the very beginning 58 00:04:34,880 --> 00:04:37,790 when it was founded, and she should take control. 59 00:04:38,270 --> 00:04:41,150 You know, it's funny because you would think as a lot of these 60 00:04:41,150 --> 00:04:44,630 folks are lawyers that have been through a lot of legal review 61 00:04:44,630 --> 00:04:48,470 and have probably heard about this stuff in their schooling and 62 00:04:48,470 --> 00:04:51,750 their work, and yet they act like they're rubes, they're noobs. 63 00:04:51,750 --> 00:04:54,870 They have never heard of these things. It's almost oddly weird. 64 00:04:54,870 --> 00:04:59,030 It's weird how off they are, how just absolutely ignorant of the 65 00:04:59,030 --> 00:05:03,970 very system they control or have access to, etc. It's appallingly 66 00:05:03,970 --> 00:05:05,090 shocking, isn't it? 67 00:05:05,970 --> 00:05:11,290 Yes, it's shocking. Even if this was just a political angle, 68 00:05:11,290 --> 00:05:16,130 a way to get a ding against President Trump, which I'm all for 69 00:05:16,370 --> 00:05:21,490 doing. But if it really is a misunderstanding of this, it is very 70 00:05:21,650 --> 00:05:26,410 difficult to understand that Congress does not understand that 71 00:05:26,410 --> 00:05:30,620 the Fed is a creature of Congress. Now, the Fed has worked 72 00:05:30,620 --> 00:05:36,420 extremely hard over the past 30 years to become the wizard of 73 00:05:36,420 --> 00:05:40,940 odds, completely controlling the economy, getting people to believe 74 00:05:41,180 --> 00:05:45,300 that it's got all the right levers so that we don't really need 75 00:05:45,300 --> 00:05:49,500 fiscal policy, we don't really need regulation, that the Fed can 76 00:05:49,500 --> 00:05:53,660 do everything. The Fed can keep the economy on course. GreenSpan 77 00:05:54,240 --> 00:06:00,080 came in 1987, and the Fed worked very hard to build this belief 78 00:06:00,320 --> 00:06:04,880 that the Fed absolutely can control the economy. When all of 79 00:06:04,880 --> 00:06:09,840 the evidence for the past 30 years demonstrates that is completely 80 00:06:09,920 --> 00:06:15,120 false. There is no evidence to support the belief that the Fed is 81 00:06:15,120 --> 00:06:15,680 in control. 82 00:06:16,480 --> 00:06:20,000 You know, when I look at all the happenings, if you will, the 83 00:06:20,000 --> 00:06:24,360 market crashes and the recurring bailouts, and realizing 84 00:06:24,360 --> 00:06:29,410 that only once have we seen even a slight bailout of the American 85 00:06:29,570 --> 00:06:32,850 people. And that was during COVID and it was very temporary. 86 00:06:32,850 --> 00:06:38,130 Unfortunately, it doesn't seem like the Fed mandates, even in writing, 87 00:06:38,370 --> 00:06:41,249 even though they talk about full employment and price stability. 88 00:06:41,330 --> 00:06:44,450 And I know the Hubert Humphrey act, which we'll talk about here 89 00:06:44,930 --> 00:06:50,130 shortly, you know, is a legal end to that. It doesn't seem like 90 00:06:50,130 --> 00:06:54,220 the Fed really, not just the Fed, but our government as a whole, 91 00:06:54,220 --> 00:06:58,780 but the Fed in particular. It doesn't seem like its primary purpose 92 00:06:58,780 --> 00:07:02,740 is to make the American public whole. It seems like it's there to 93 00:07:02,740 --> 00:07:07,340 protect American enterprise. And whether it be shadow banks or 94 00:07:07,340 --> 00:07:12,020 whatever, it never really seems to work out for the little 95 00:07:12,020 --> 00:07:17,260 guy. How do we square up the Fed's mandate and the outcomes that 96 00:07:17,260 --> 00:07:18,140 it produces? 97 00:07:19,550 --> 00:07:24,590 First, let me just remind everyone the COVID bailout actually 98 00:07:24,670 --> 00:07:25,950 was fiscal policy. 99 00:07:26,110 --> 00:07:26,990 Yes, it was. 100 00:07:27,150 --> 00:07:32,070 Both Biden and Trump spent trillions of dollars to help bail 101 00:07:32,070 --> 00:07:38,070 out the economy. And Yev and I wrote a piece laying out what the 102 00:07:38,070 --> 00:07:41,230 response should be. And we were focused on the fiscal policy. 103 00:07:41,390 --> 00:07:46,930 And we believed, and still believe that Biden's relief package 104 00:07:47,090 --> 00:07:53,570 was very good, did a lot of good. We had our doubts about Trump's 105 00:07:53,650 --> 00:07:57,970 bailout package, but anyway, the bailout was not monetary policy. 106 00:07:58,210 --> 00:08:01,330 Now, it's true that the Fed lowered interest rates, but interest 107 00:08:01,330 --> 00:08:06,090 rates had been low for a very long time. The Fed has engaged in 108 00:08:06,090 --> 00:08:10,630 some bailouts. Everyone remembers Silicon Valley Bank. Yes, 109 00:08:11,030 --> 00:08:15,110 the Fed did step in, but that did not help the economy. It didn't 110 00:08:15,110 --> 00:08:18,510 help people. We can argue about whether it was a good idea 111 00:08:18,510 --> 00:08:22,550 to do that or not, but that is not what helped get us out of the 112 00:08:22,550 --> 00:08:28,870 deep Covid recession. Now, the Fed's mandates have always been interpreted 113 00:08:29,030 --> 00:08:33,150 as a dual mandate, but really it's a triple mandate. It's always 114 00:08:33,150 --> 00:08:39,270 been reasonable growth, reasonably low inflation, and reasonably 115 00:08:39,270 --> 00:08:44,630 high employment. So those are supposed to be the three things that 116 00:08:44,630 --> 00:08:49,550 the Fed focuses on. And this mandate was strengthened in the Humphrey 117 00:08:49,550 --> 00:08:54,470 Hawkins Act. Jamie Galbraith actually played a big role in writing, 118 00:08:55,030 --> 00:09:01,190 and even he thinks now that it was probably misguided. And the reason 119 00:09:01,190 --> 00:09:05,820 it's misguided is if you look at that triple mandate, the Fed has 120 00:09:06,140 --> 00:09:11,740 no levers, no tools to achieve any of them. In other words, even 121 00:09:11,740 --> 00:09:16,260 if we believed that all of these are good mandates, the Fed 122 00:09:16,260 --> 00:09:21,260 is not capable of pursuing any of them. All of these actually are 123 00:09:21,260 --> 00:09:26,300 better pursued by fiscal policy, not by monetary policy. Back 124 00:09:26,300 --> 00:09:30,660 in those days of the Humphrey Hawkins act, the Fed and many economists 125 00:09:30,660 --> 00:09:37,020 still believed that the Fed could control the money supply. And 126 00:09:37,180 --> 00:09:42,060 Milton Friedman had convinced many economists and politicians that 127 00:09:42,060 --> 00:09:46,540 the key to controlling the economy is to control the money supply. 128 00:09:47,180 --> 00:09:50,740 We now know, and the Fed actually began to discover this almost 129 00:09:50,740 --> 00:09:55,820 immediately after the Humphrey Hawkins act was passed. By the late 130 00:09:55,820 --> 00:10:01,140 80s, the Fed gave up on money targets. The Fed can't control the 131 00:10:01,140 --> 00:10:06,300 money supply and so they switch to interest rates, the Fed 132 00:10:06,300 --> 00:10:09,860 funds rate, the overnight interest rate. And the problem for 133 00:10:10,260 --> 00:10:15,419 pursuit of the mandates is the Fed funds rate is not a tool that 134 00:10:15,419 --> 00:10:19,380 can be used to hit any of the mandates. Just plain and simple. 135 00:10:19,540 --> 00:10:24,060 And all of the evidence since the late 80s, it demonstrates that 136 00:10:24,060 --> 00:10:27,580 what I'm saying is absolutely correct. And even some people within 137 00:10:27,580 --> 00:10:31,950 the Fed have now written research reports and stated publicly 138 00:10:32,190 --> 00:10:36,670 that the Fed cannot do this. And it is delusional for the Fed 139 00:10:36,750 --> 00:10:39,990 or for Congress or for the President to think that the Fed is 140 00:10:39,990 --> 00:10:41,150 able to do any of this. 141 00:10:42,270 --> 00:10:47,110 There's conspiracies galore. The Fed is probably the most propaganda 142 00:10:47,110 --> 00:10:52,070 driven institution that the United States government has. It's 143 00:10:52,070 --> 00:10:56,720 got more stories, more conspiracies, more insane, and some 144 00:10:56,720 --> 00:11:00,560 sane, some starting to feel more sane narratives behind the scenes 145 00:11:00,560 --> 00:11:06,200 as to its role and purpose. Most of us on the MMT side, whether 146 00:11:06,200 --> 00:11:10,440 it be Warren basically saying the Fed could be reduced to a spreadsheet, 147 00:11:11,000 --> 00:11:15,120 or some of the other folks that have said basically that, you 148 00:11:15,120 --> 00:11:18,400 know what you just said, which is that overnight interest rate isn't 149 00:11:18,400 --> 00:11:21,080 really much of anything. I mean, there was a meme going around 150 00:11:21,320 --> 00:11:25,850 where there was a child's pretend car steering wheel and the 151 00:11:25,850 --> 00:11:28,850 kid was in the passenger seat playing. They're saying this is the 152 00:11:28,850 --> 00:11:34,370 Fed and the reality driving it is fiscal policy. Fiscal policy belongs 153 00:11:34,370 --> 00:11:37,810 in the driver's seat, not the Fed. But we make a really big deal 154 00:11:37,810 --> 00:11:42,010 about this. There's obviously something very negative that the 155 00:11:42,010 --> 00:11:46,090 Fed is capable of doing aside from just choosing to bail out rich 156 00:11:46,090 --> 00:11:49,650 people and leave the working class to suffer. What are some of 157 00:11:49,650 --> 00:11:53,190 the things that the Fed's misguided approach to things has 158 00:11:53,190 --> 00:11:57,430 done negatively to not only the economy, but really the broader 159 00:11:57,430 --> 00:11:57,990 society. 160 00:11:59,190 --> 00:12:05,430 Yeah, back in, I think it was 2004 when the Fed had started raising 161 00:12:05,430 --> 00:12:09,630 interest rates sharply and that is what triggered the global 162 00:12:09,630 --> 00:12:15,510 financial crisis. I mean, we had severe financial problems, massive 163 00:12:15,590 --> 00:12:21,000 fraud by Wall Street. So a crisis was pretty much inevitable. 164 00:12:21,000 --> 00:12:24,520 But the Fed made it a lot worse by jacking up interest rates. 165 00:12:24,680 --> 00:12:28,160 And I was trying to think through why the Fed was doing this 166 00:12:28,160 --> 00:12:35,800 in 2004 and I noticed how much 2004 looked like 1994. And fortunately 167 00:12:36,120 --> 00:12:40,360 the Fed actually Greenspan, had been caught lying to Congress. 168 00:12:41,080 --> 00:12:46,640 And Congress induced the Fed to start releasing transcripts of 169 00:12:46,640 --> 00:12:51,050 the FOMC meetings, which is where the decisions are made with 170 00:12:51,050 --> 00:12:57,850 a five year lag. So by 2004 we had the transcripts from 1994 and 171 00:12:57,850 --> 00:13:04,050 I read through those to see why did the Fed raise rates in 1994 172 00:13:04,210 --> 00:13:08,570 when we were in a jobless recovery? It was our first jobless 173 00:13:08,570 --> 00:13:12,850 recovery. Normally when you recover from a recession, you create 174 00:13:12,850 --> 00:13:16,440 lots of jobs and people go back to work. That was not occurring 175 00:13:16,440 --> 00:13:22,760 in 1994. And so why was the Fed raising rates when, yes, okay, 176 00:13:22,760 --> 00:13:26,560 the economy was recovering, but labor markets were not. People 177 00:13:26,560 --> 00:13:30,160 weren't getting jobs. And so I read through the transcripts, which 178 00:13:30,160 --> 00:13:33,680 are almost word for word. The only thing that they take out is 179 00:13:33,680 --> 00:13:37,040 if they start discussing a bank that's in big trouble, they 180 00:13:37,040 --> 00:13:41,080 take out the bank's name, but otherwise it's word for word. And 181 00:13:41,320 --> 00:13:45,410 they were worried that some jobs were being created. Literally 182 00:13:45,410 --> 00:13:50,450 that was the reason they liked the high unemployment. And they were 183 00:13:50,450 --> 00:13:54,090 worried that if more jobs were being created and more people went 184 00:13:54,090 --> 00:13:58,490 back to work, then there could be inflation pressure. I think that 185 00:13:58,730 --> 00:14:04,650 indicates that you're right. The Fed acts against the interests 186 00:14:04,650 --> 00:14:10,210 of the working class. That I think is true. If you just plot the 187 00:14:10,210 --> 00:14:15,490 unemployment rate over time and you plot the Fed's interest rate 188 00:14:15,570 --> 00:14:19,330 movements, it becomes very clear that as soon as the economy 189 00:14:19,490 --> 00:14:24,210 starts creating jobs, they raise interest rates. So it's very 190 00:14:24,210 --> 00:14:27,770 clear that is what they're doing now. Should the Fed be doing 191 00:14:27,770 --> 00:14:32,210 that? Of course not, because high employment is one of those mandates. 192 00:14:32,690 --> 00:14:37,010 What else is the Fed supposed to do in addition to the mandates? 193 00:14:37,170 --> 00:14:41,240 The Fed was founded be a lender of last resort. The US was 194 00:14:41,240 --> 00:14:45,600 very unusual. We didn't have a lender of last resort. What a lender 195 00:14:45,600 --> 00:14:49,960 of last resort is supposed to do is stop bank runs. And the idea 196 00:14:49,960 --> 00:14:55,400 is that if people start running on a bank, obviously it does 197 00:14:55,400 --> 00:15:00,160 not have the cash on hand so that people can take cash out of 198 00:15:00,160 --> 00:15:03,400 their demand deposits. If everyone's coming in at once. And 199 00:15:03,400 --> 00:15:07,750 if one bank has a run and the depositors find out they can't get 200 00:15:07,750 --> 00:15:10,910 their deposits out, then there'll be run on another bank. 201 00:15:10,990 --> 00:15:14,950 And this used to happen back in the 19th century and it happened 202 00:15:14,950 --> 00:15:21,150 in 1907. So Congress created the Fed. Finally, we would have a 203 00:15:21,150 --> 00:15:25,390 central bank that would act as lender of last resort. And the Fed 204 00:15:25,630 --> 00:15:30,190 does act as a lender of last resort. And that is a proper function 205 00:15:30,190 --> 00:15:35,000 of a central bank. You say, well, they're saving the banks, this 206 00:15:35,000 --> 00:15:42,040 is true. But if the banks are solvent but illiquid, which is when 207 00:15:42,040 --> 00:15:45,440 you're supposed to do lender of last resort interventions, you 208 00:15:45,440 --> 00:15:49,720 really don't want those banks to fail just because they're holding 209 00:15:49,720 --> 00:15:54,480 assets which are basically loans to households and firms that 210 00:15:54,480 --> 00:15:58,730 they can't sell immediately. So anyway, that function has been 211 00:15:58,730 --> 00:16:02,690 performed by all central banks. And it's been known since 212 00:16:03,090 --> 00:16:07,570 around the middle of the 19th century that you need a central bank 213 00:16:07,570 --> 00:16:11,490 to do this. So that's a proper one. Messing around with interest 214 00:16:11,490 --> 00:16:16,850 rates is how the Fed is trying to achieve those other mandates. 215 00:16:17,970 --> 00:16:22,010 And that is something that central banks were not set up to 216 00:16:22,010 --> 00:16:22,290 do. 217 00:16:23,040 --> 00:16:26,200 You know, I want to touch on something. I'm just an activist, 218 00:16:26,200 --> 00:16:29,520 I'm not an economist before anybody accuses me of saying otherwise, 219 00:16:29,760 --> 00:16:34,480 but I do want to ask this question. If the Fed's role is to 220 00:16:34,880 --> 00:16:38,879 manage interest rates or the overnight window, if you will, and 221 00:16:38,960 --> 00:16:43,560 the mandates are for shorthand, full employment and price 222 00:16:43,560 --> 00:16:48,320 stability. When you say that the Fed seemingly always raises interest 223 00:16:48,480 --> 00:16:52,650 rates when they start creating jobs, tells me a couple things, right? 224 00:16:52,650 --> 00:16:57,330 So number one, the more jobs there are, the more opportunity it 225 00:16:57,330 --> 00:17:01,490 is for labor to withhold itself for a better wage that they 226 00:17:01,490 --> 00:17:04,610 can bargain. They're in a position to bargain. That's not the 227 00:17:04,610 --> 00:17:08,890 case when it's the other way around. And interest rate hikes are, 228 00:17:09,050 --> 00:17:13,650 and I'll reduce this to a meme level, interest rates are cash to 229 00:17:13,650 --> 00:17:16,890 rich people, cash to people who already have money, cash to countries 230 00:17:16,890 --> 00:17:22,420 that. Whatever. And so as labor is trying to achieve some sort 231 00:17:22,420 --> 00:17:27,300 of stability of its own, trying to gain some strength, some 232 00:17:27,300 --> 00:17:31,340 bargaining power, the Fed swoops in to sweep the legs of the 233 00:17:31,340 --> 00:17:36,260 labor movement and knock away its bargaining power while simultaneously 234 00:17:36,260 --> 00:17:39,700 giving the rich, presumably the people that own those businesses, 235 00:17:40,100 --> 00:17:44,000 more money through interest income channel. What's not to like 236 00:17:44,000 --> 00:17:47,120 if you're an oligarch or a rich person? And the Fed's approach 237 00:17:47,200 --> 00:17:50,640 to this, it seems like they're working hand in glove. 238 00:17:51,200 --> 00:17:56,200 Yes. Reading the 1994 transcripts Chairman Greenspan put 239 00:17:56,200 --> 00:17:59,600 it this way. Now I'm summarizing, if unemployment is getting 240 00:17:59,600 --> 00:18:06,920 low enough that labor is able to demand higher wages, that will 241 00:18:06,920 --> 00:18:11,280 be inflationary because firms will pass the higher labor costs 242 00:18:11,280 --> 00:18:16,200 on in the form of prices. And the problem is that paying workers 243 00:18:16,440 --> 00:18:20,520 more doesn't increase their productivity. So it's just inflationary, 244 00:18:20,520 --> 00:18:26,520 okay? On the other hand, if firms are just raising prices to 245 00:18:26,520 --> 00:18:30,200 increase their profits, that would be inflationary too. However, 246 00:18:30,600 --> 00:18:35,240 firms then have more profits that they will invest that will increase 247 00:18:35,400 --> 00:18:41,030 productivity. So profits inflation is self limiting and in 248 00:18:41,030 --> 00:18:45,390 a way it's sort of desirable because it's going to increase productive 249 00:18:45,390 --> 00:18:52,510 capacity for the country. But wage inflation is undesirable because 250 00:18:52,590 --> 00:18:56,670 workers don't become more productive just because they have 251 00:18:56,670 --> 00:19:00,910 higher pay. And so think about that. That's the way the Fed thinks 252 00:19:01,150 --> 00:19:05,330 and I would say that's the way many economists think too. Now there 253 00:19:05,330 --> 00:19:09,130 actually is quite a bit of work that shows that if workers are 254 00:19:09,130 --> 00:19:13,170 paid more, actually they are more productive, they're happier, 255 00:19:13,250 --> 00:19:17,570 they work harder, they're more devoted to their jobs. And there's 256 00:19:17,570 --> 00:19:20,809 a whole literature on this that's been created by what is called 257 00:19:20,809 --> 00:19:25,610 New Keynesians, like Janet Yellen, who was at the Fed and also 258 00:19:25,610 --> 00:19:29,890 at the Treasury. There's sort of a whole literature on this that 259 00:19:29,890 --> 00:19:34,620 emphasizes that actually raising wages is good for productivity. 260 00:19:35,980 --> 00:19:39,420 It's interesting because like personal anecdote went to the hospital 261 00:19:39,580 --> 00:19:44,620 the other day, I had a weird reaction between a over the counter 262 00:19:44,620 --> 00:19:48,460 supplement and one of the other medications that I take and 263 00:19:48,620 --> 00:19:52,940 went to the ER and so forth. They kept finding nothing wrong because 264 00:19:52,940 --> 00:19:55,380 there was nothing wrong. I mean, I took a pill that didn't work 265 00:19:55,380 --> 00:19:58,380 well with another pill. The answer is stop taking the pill. But 266 00:19:58,380 --> 00:20:01,740 each time they were like, you know, I'm a doctor and I don't see 267 00:20:01,740 --> 00:20:05,710 any of the symptoms. However, my, my job is to recommend that we 268 00:20:05,710 --> 00:20:08,830 admit you. My job is to recommend that you stay, that my 269 00:20:08,830 --> 00:20:12,350 job is recommended, we do more tests and so forth. And that sounds 270 00:20:12,350 --> 00:20:15,470 great and all that stuff, but I said to him, I said, what would 271 00:20:15,470 --> 00:20:19,750 be my estimated out of pocket if I say yes to any of the above, 272 00:20:20,070 --> 00:20:24,710 including with not even thinking about, you know, my insurance 273 00:20:24,710 --> 00:20:27,910 payment, it was ridiculous what it didn't cover and how many 274 00:20:27,910 --> 00:20:33,040 different hands had to be fed in this process. And to me, my ability 275 00:20:33,440 --> 00:20:38,120 to pay that and be safe. And like hypothetically my doctor said 276 00:20:38,120 --> 00:20:41,720 I should do this thing. So technically, if you're just allowing 277 00:20:41,720 --> 00:20:45,400 yourself to follow a doctor's instructions, I should have done 278 00:20:45,400 --> 00:20:48,800 this thing. But I don't have the thousands and thousands of dollars 279 00:20:49,120 --> 00:20:52,480 that would have come from that simple stay just for diagnostics. 280 00:20:52,640 --> 00:20:56,880 But if that was taken care of, I might have been willing to stick 281 00:20:56,880 --> 00:21:00,360 around. However, I race back because I don't have any paid time 282 00:21:00,360 --> 00:21:04,500 off. I'm a contractor, I'm a consult, and we don't get paid if 283 00:21:04,500 --> 00:21:09,340 we don't work. So if you think about the circular nature of pay, 284 00:21:09,340 --> 00:21:13,700 benefits, whatever, and, you know, my health and my ability to 285 00:21:13,700 --> 00:21:18,300 do my job and on and on and on, like I went back to work without 286 00:21:18,300 --> 00:21:23,420 any sleep, still in the throes of what had happened, knowing full 287 00:21:23,420 --> 00:21:27,580 well it wasn't deadly, but still scary, that couldn't be good 288 00:21:27,660 --> 00:21:30,860 for productivity if you think about it like that. And ultimately, 289 00:21:31,320 --> 00:21:34,640 if I would have had the peace of mind that it would have been covered 290 00:21:34,640 --> 00:21:38,080 and that I could have taken a day or two off from work just to 291 00:21:38,080 --> 00:21:41,800 get right, I would have come back to work healthier, better, ready 292 00:21:41,800 --> 00:21:46,080 to take on my role even more. But instead, because of these kind 293 00:21:46,080 --> 00:21:50,160 of austerity driven narratives that are real life narratives that 294 00:21:50,160 --> 00:21:53,920 are real life situations we find ourselves in anecdotally, I 295 00:21:53,920 --> 00:21:57,120 mean, it's my story. I think that kind of proves the point right 296 00:21:57,120 --> 00:22:00,320 there in and of itself. I'm a terrified guy, couldn't afford the 297 00:22:00,320 --> 00:22:03,700 bills, didn't do the thing that would ensure that I'm a. Okay. 298 00:22:04,020 --> 00:22:06,940 And simultaneously came to work without any sleep the night 299 00:22:06,940 --> 00:22:09,980 before. I mean, it doesn't sound like a winning proposition 300 00:22:09,980 --> 00:22:14,580 if your goal is to maximize your resources and not having them 301 00:22:14,580 --> 00:22:16,580 live in precarity, am I correct? 302 00:22:17,060 --> 00:22:21,500 Yeah, precarity is a big problem. You know, people have to 303 00:22:21,500 --> 00:22:26,740 string together two jobs, three jobs, and that's gonna hurt 304 00:22:26,740 --> 00:22:31,670 their productivity. Sure. And just the worry of being able to support 305 00:22:31,670 --> 00:22:36,630 your family is not going to be good. Low pay is a problem. It reduces 306 00:22:36,630 --> 00:22:40,710 productivity. I don't think there's any doubt about that. So 307 00:22:40,710 --> 00:22:44,870 the Fed has this one tool. It's the overnight interest rate 308 00:22:44,870 --> 00:22:50,190 target. And that's an interest rate that banks pay each other. Okay. 309 00:22:50,190 --> 00:22:56,510 For borrowing reserves. That's linked to interest rates for treasury 310 00:22:56,510 --> 00:23:02,070 bonds and bills. And as you said, when the Fed raises its interest 311 00:23:02,070 --> 00:23:06,870 rate target, the interest rates on bonds, both private and 312 00:23:06,870 --> 00:23:10,670 government bonds, are going to go up. Who are those held by? Well, 313 00:23:10,670 --> 00:23:14,550 they're held by people who already have money. Wealthy people 314 00:23:14,550 --> 00:23:18,630 hold those things. Your pension fund, if you have one, if 315 00:23:18,630 --> 00:23:22,310 you're lucky enough to have one, holds those things too. So sort 316 00:23:22,310 --> 00:23:26,410 of indirectly it can help working class People who someday 317 00:23:26,410 --> 00:23:31,170 hope to be retired and have a pension. But for the most part you're 318 00:23:31,170 --> 00:23:35,130 going to be shifting income towards the top. When you raise interest 319 00:23:35,130 --> 00:23:40,930 rates, it's going to increase mortgage rates. If bond rates go 320 00:23:40,930 --> 00:23:44,410 up, mortgage rates are going to go up. They're pretty closely 321 00:23:44,410 --> 00:23:48,170 linked to 10 year bonds. And that's going to make housing more 322 00:23:48,330 --> 00:23:54,170 unaffordable. It's going to make housing construction more expensive. 323 00:23:55,100 --> 00:23:59,740 Because of course, while developer is building a housing development, 324 00:24:00,060 --> 00:24:03,980 they've got to pay wages, they've got to buy the materials, 325 00:24:04,220 --> 00:24:09,580 they're not going to see revenue for months, maybe a year. 326 00:24:10,060 --> 00:24:14,980 They've got to carry loans at higher interest rates. When the Fed 327 00:24:14,980 --> 00:24:21,740 is raising rates, so it's going to most likely reduce construction. 328 00:24:22,730 --> 00:24:27,090 Contractors will wait until the interest rates go down in order 329 00:24:27,090 --> 00:24:32,650 to avoid the high costs of construction. The US built hardly 330 00:24:32,650 --> 00:24:37,770 any housing after the global financial collapse. So we already 331 00:24:37,930 --> 00:24:42,970 had a severe housing shortage before the Fed started raising rates. 332 00:24:43,370 --> 00:24:48,570 And they only compound the problem by making housing more unaffordable 333 00:24:49,290 --> 00:24:54,010 and by reducing the incentive to construct more. So there's many 334 00:24:54,010 --> 00:24:58,650 ways in which raising rates is going to hurt working class people 335 00:24:59,130 --> 00:25:04,570 while increasing the interest income to the already well off people. 336 00:25:05,290 --> 00:25:10,330 So there's that very negative distribution impact on the population. 337 00:25:10,730 --> 00:25:17,680 There also can be a link to the value of the US dollar. All things 338 00:25:17,680 --> 00:25:21,720 equal, if our interest rate goes up relative to the rest of the 339 00:25:21,720 --> 00:25:25,760 world, the dollar will increase in value. And that's going 340 00:25:25,760 --> 00:25:30,880 to have some negative impacts on production in the US Those costs 341 00:25:30,960 --> 00:25:35,520 relative to the cost of imports are going to be higher because 342 00:25:35,520 --> 00:25:38,800 imports become cheaper if the dollar is stronger. So there's another 343 00:25:38,880 --> 00:25:43,430 way that it can impact the working class. And then finally, 344 00:25:43,430 --> 00:25:48,110 the most important impact, and I would say the main avenue through 345 00:25:48,110 --> 00:25:53,830 which the Fed affects the economy is by tanking financial markets 346 00:25:54,070 --> 00:26:00,270 by causing a financial crisis. This is what the Fed did. When Chairman 347 00:26:00,270 --> 00:26:04,270 Volcker was brought in the high inflation period in the early 348 00:26:04,270 --> 00:26:09,530 80s, he actually increased the target rate to 20%. Half of all the 349 00:26:09,530 --> 00:26:13,610 savings and loans failed in a tremendous financial crisis. We've 350 00:26:13,610 --> 00:26:17,290 had several other financial crises, but then again we had the 351 00:26:17,610 --> 00:26:21,250 global financial crisis that was triggered by the Fed again raising 352 00:26:21,250 --> 00:26:25,570 interest rates. Today you don't cause bank runs for the most 353 00:26:25,570 --> 00:26:32,970 part. Silicon Valley was a bank run. But high rates cause insolvency 354 00:26:32,970 --> 00:26:38,140 of banks. And that is what the Fed did in the global financial crisis. 355 00:26:38,140 --> 00:26:43,220 The insolvency was so great among the US banks and global banks 356 00:26:43,540 --> 00:26:49,260 that the Fed had to spend and land $29 trillion to bail out the 357 00:26:49,260 --> 00:26:53,460 global financial system after it had caused the global financial 358 00:26:53,460 --> 00:26:58,100 crisis by raising interest rates sharply beginning in 2004. 359 00:26:58,580 --> 00:27:03,910 I think this really is how Fed policy works. It's by devastating 360 00:27:03,990 --> 00:27:09,030 the financial sector and then that will tend to depress the economy 361 00:27:09,190 --> 00:27:13,230 too. If your financial sector tanks, the economy is also going 362 00:27:13,230 --> 00:27:17,230 to go down. Unemployment is going to skyrocket. You're going 363 00:27:17,230 --> 00:27:22,190 to have stagnation. And that stagnation is going to bring down 364 00:27:22,190 --> 00:27:28,150 inflation. And so we did have a 20 year period of very low inflation 365 00:27:28,700 --> 00:27:32,780 where the inflation was running consistently below 2%, which 366 00:27:33,020 --> 00:27:36,380 central bankers have just decided on their own. 2% is the right 367 00:27:36,380 --> 00:27:40,740 number for inflation. There's no justification for this. Greenspan 368 00:27:40,740 --> 00:27:44,180 and Volcker have basically admitted this. They just say, oh 369 00:27:44,180 --> 00:27:47,460 well, central bank has decided this is the right number. We could 370 00:27:47,460 --> 00:27:49,820 not get the inflation rate up to 2%. 371 00:27:51,580 --> 00:27:55,660 You are listening to Macro N Cheese, a podcast by Real Progressives. 372 00:27:56,280 --> 00:28:01,280 We are a 501c3 nonprofit organization. All donations are tax 373 00:28:01,280 --> 00:28:05,400 deductible. Please consider becoming a monthly donor on Patreon 374 00:28:05,720 --> 00:28:10,880 Substack or our website realprogressives.org now back to 375 00:28:10,880 --> 00:28:11,560 the podcast. 376 00:28:14,440 --> 00:28:18,480 Europe could not get the inflation rate up to 2%. Japan has 377 00:28:18,480 --> 00:28:23,810 been suffering with near zero interest rates for 40 years. Central 378 00:28:23,810 --> 00:28:27,610 banks, no matter what they tried to do, couldn't get the inflation 379 00:28:27,610 --> 00:28:31,930 rate up to 2%. And we're supposed to believe the central bank 380 00:28:32,090 --> 00:28:35,050 manages inflation by using interest rates? 381 00:28:37,530 --> 00:28:42,210 It's ridiculous. I want to touch on your policy paper. We've 382 00:28:42,210 --> 00:28:44,370 kind of touched a little bit of this, but I think there's something 383 00:28:44,370 --> 00:28:47,450 very specific here. It was like, can the Fed actually manage 384 00:28:47,450 --> 00:28:50,310 the economy, which we're determining quite clear. Clearly 385 00:28:50,310 --> 00:28:55,030 they cannot. They can do some very negative things, however. But 386 00:28:55,110 --> 00:29:00,910 you know, during the pandemic, obviously we had saw what Isabella 387 00:29:00,910 --> 00:29:05,590 Weber dubbed sellers inflation, which is the profiteering. 388 00:29:05,590 --> 00:29:10,110 They found an opportunity to use a crisis to raise rates. And 389 00:29:10,110 --> 00:29:13,430 those rates never, ever come back down. They just stay kind of 390 00:29:13,430 --> 00:29:17,880 where they were. But, but here we are now, we've got a new animal 391 00:29:17,880 --> 00:29:21,680 in town and that's Trump trying to play tariff fairy. And 392 00:29:21,680 --> 00:29:27,120 Trump has been willy nilly shooting favors out for lower tariffs. 393 00:29:27,120 --> 00:29:30,520 And you don't kiss the ring, you get higher tariffs. And one of 394 00:29:30,520 --> 00:29:34,040 the things that has occurred over the last several months is this 395 00:29:34,040 --> 00:29:39,840 tariff on lumber and wood built products in particular with 396 00:29:39,840 --> 00:29:44,560 Canada. And we're watching the tariffs on those really, really cause 397 00:29:44,720 --> 00:29:50,040 a tremendous impact on lumber in general, which is what we build 398 00:29:50,040 --> 00:29:55,080 houses with and a whole host of other things. What exactly is 399 00:29:55,080 --> 00:29:58,280 the Fed's role within the tariff space? It seems like there 400 00:29:58,280 --> 00:30:03,120 is no greater economic issue going on right now than Trump's willy 401 00:30:03,120 --> 00:30:07,960 nilly kind of gangster style tariff flinging. And there's nobody 402 00:30:07,960 --> 00:30:10,960 in Congress is doing a damn thing about this. Let's be fair. 403 00:30:11,040 --> 00:30:14,800 If they were ever a legitimate agency or organization or element 404 00:30:14,800 --> 00:30:17,990 of our government, they're doing nothing. They're just sit, 405 00:30:18,060 --> 00:30:21,900 sitting back and letting it happen. What exactly is the relationship 406 00:30:21,980 --> 00:30:27,380 between Trump's tariffs and the Fed? And Quite frankly, this 407 00:30:27,380 --> 00:30:33,100 2% target rate and how is the Fed managing that and is it effective 408 00:30:33,100 --> 00:30:36,060 and what will be done or what is being done about it? 409 00:30:36,460 --> 00:30:41,820 I agree that the tariffs are going to add some inflation pressure 410 00:30:42,300 --> 00:30:47,630 and especially lumber. It'd be hard to think of a worse strategy 411 00:30:47,790 --> 00:30:51,870 than to raise the price of lumber when we have a severe housing 412 00:30:51,870 --> 00:30:56,430 shortage. If you, you know, get down into the details of what 413 00:30:56,430 --> 00:31:02,750 is it that is causing our measure of inflation to be consistently 414 00:31:03,070 --> 00:31:09,430 around 3% instead of the 2% that the Fed wants. Housing is the 415 00:31:09,430 --> 00:31:13,970 biggest part of our inflation pressures. And the way to relieve 416 00:31:13,970 --> 00:31:18,770 that is fairly obvious. Build more houses and raising the price 417 00:31:18,770 --> 00:31:23,970 of lumber is not going to do that. But also because of Fed thinking, 418 00:31:24,290 --> 00:31:30,210 the Fed is afraid to lower interest rates because Trump is causing 419 00:31:30,210 --> 00:31:35,050 inflation with tariffs. And so we have this standoff between the 420 00:31:35,050 --> 00:31:39,650 President and the head of the Fed. If Trump would stop all the 421 00:31:39,650 --> 00:31:44,580 nonsense about the tariffs, the Fed maybe would lower interest 422 00:31:44,660 --> 00:31:49,380 rates as Trump wants him to do. But as long as he keeps threatening 423 00:31:49,460 --> 00:31:53,900 these ridiculous tariff rates, the Fed is scared to lower him. And 424 00:31:53,900 --> 00:31:57,100 Powell was warning. He says, okay, we're lowering now, but don't 425 00:31:57,100 --> 00:32:00,940 think that we're going to lower again. It's not baked in. The 426 00:32:00,940 --> 00:32:05,980 Fed is going to wait and see how much more damage is Trump going 427 00:32:05,980 --> 00:32:09,650 to do. So they're kind of a loggerhead now. I don't agree with 428 00:32:09,650 --> 00:32:14,490 either side. The Fed should be lowering interest rates to compensate 429 00:32:14,570 --> 00:32:19,450 for the problems that Trump is creating. We want to reduce the cost 430 00:32:19,610 --> 00:32:24,489 of building houses. We want to reduce the mortgage rates to help 431 00:32:24,489 --> 00:32:29,370 the market for homes. So keeping rates high is not the right 432 00:32:29,370 --> 00:32:31,130 response to tariffs. 433 00:32:31,610 --> 00:32:34,970 You know, obviously you went on to talk about some of the things 434 00:32:34,970 --> 00:32:39,520 you agree with Elizabeth Warren about regarding Fed policy 435 00:32:39,760 --> 00:32:43,840 and so forth. I guess we can let you. I mean, I'll boil it down. 436 00:32:44,000 --> 00:32:47,120 You agree that the President shouldn't be meddling, but you do 437 00:32:47,120 --> 00:32:50,600 believe Congress, which has created the Fed, this is important. 438 00:32:50,600 --> 00:32:53,960 This is kind of bringing a full circle. The Fed is a creature 439 00:32:53,960 --> 00:32:57,920 of Congress. Congress, however, doesn't show any. In my 440 00:32:57,920 --> 00:33:01,880 lifetime, I have not seen Congress actually do anything with 441 00:33:01,880 --> 00:33:06,860 the Fed. I'm 56, and maybe I just wasn't aware of activities that 442 00:33:06,860 --> 00:33:10,900 they did to do this. And this is why people go, the only thing 443 00:33:10,900 --> 00:33:14,260 federal about the Federal Reserve is the name. It's as federal 444 00:33:14,260 --> 00:33:19,020 as FedEx. You know, all the little tropes, but in reality it 445 00:33:19,020 --> 00:33:21,460 is a creature of Congress. And I want to take it a step further. 446 00:33:21,700 --> 00:33:24,740 I have my fair share of disagreements with Warren Mosler 447 00:33:24,740 --> 00:33:29,740 outside of mmt, but within the MMT space, he will frequently say 448 00:33:29,740 --> 00:33:32,900 banks are public purpose entities already. They're already 449 00:33:32,980 --> 00:33:36,720 national. The issue is they've been deregulated, regulated. And 450 00:33:36,720 --> 00:33:40,800 as a result of that, when we talk about reigning in the banks 451 00:33:40,800 --> 00:33:43,800 and we talk about all these various things, I mean, what we're 452 00:33:43,800 --> 00:33:47,640 really talking about is predatory lending practices and things 453 00:33:47,640 --> 00:33:52,160 like that. They are still intended to be for the public purpose, 454 00:33:52,160 --> 00:33:55,240 but they really don't serve the public purpose, not in a way 455 00:33:55,240 --> 00:33:59,360 that I think the public would deem in their best interest. Can 456 00:33:59,360 --> 00:34:03,310 you talk momentarily about the. The banking system, the relationship 457 00:34:03,310 --> 00:34:07,430 between the Fed and banks and their subordinate role to Congress 458 00:34:07,430 --> 00:34:10,030 in general and the charters that they're given from the federal 459 00:34:10,030 --> 00:34:10,430 government? 460 00:34:11,150 --> 00:34:16,110 Yeah, sure. So, as I said, the Fed was created in 1913 to be lender 461 00:34:16,110 --> 00:34:21,630 of last resort. We go into the Great Depression, we have a severe 462 00:34:21,630 --> 00:34:26,430 banking crisis. Half of the banks failed. In the 1930s, the first 463 00:34:26,510 --> 00:34:32,570 act of FDR was a banking holiday. Holiday sounded nice. What 464 00:34:32,570 --> 00:34:37,850 it really was, every bank was shut down. FDR sent his people in 465 00:34:37,930 --> 00:34:41,690 to decide which ones to reopen. So that's a long story, very 466 00:34:41,690 --> 00:34:45,610 interesting story. I won't go any more into that. But as a result, 467 00:34:46,010 --> 00:34:49,970 they said, well, hold up. What was the Fed doing to help prevent 468 00:34:49,970 --> 00:34:55,850 this crisis? The Fed was only willing to lend to solvent banks 469 00:34:55,930 --> 00:34:59,470 that had a liquidity problem. And that was the way the Fed was 470 00:34:59,470 --> 00:35:03,390 set up. And Congress said, well, oh, okay, that's not enough. 471 00:35:03,790 --> 00:35:08,510 What we need is for the Fed to also get involved in regulating the 472 00:35:08,510 --> 00:35:13,310 banks. Okay, so the second function was regulating the banks. 473 00:35:13,630 --> 00:35:18,990 And then skip forward to World War II. We know that the federal 474 00:35:18,990 --> 00:35:23,310 government is going to spend far more than it's going to raise 475 00:35:23,310 --> 00:35:28,130 in tax revenue. And I can tell you that everyone in the administration 476 00:35:28,610 --> 00:35:31,890 understood the government cannot run out of its own money. 477 00:35:31,890 --> 00:35:35,930 They understood that. Then they knew that finding the money 478 00:35:35,930 --> 00:35:39,890 was not the problem. But they were going to issue a lot of government 479 00:35:39,970 --> 00:35:45,850 bonds and they wanted to make sure that the government didn't waste 480 00:35:45,850 --> 00:35:50,010 a lot of its spending on interest, which we already said goes 481 00:35:50,010 --> 00:35:54,130 to rich people. So they wanted to keep the interest rate low. So 482 00:35:54,130 --> 00:35:59,930 Congress told the Fed, you will keep the interest rate. The 483 00:35:59,930 --> 00:36:04,490 short term interest rate. If I remember I was 3, 8 of 1%, way below 484 00:36:04,490 --> 00:36:08,330 1%. You're going to keep it there. And the longer rate was longer. 485 00:36:08,330 --> 00:36:13,810 I think maybe it was 2%. So Congress did tell the Fed exactly 486 00:36:13,810 --> 00:36:20,930 what the interest rate targets would be. In 1951 there was a, it's 487 00:36:20,930 --> 00:36:24,810 called the Fed Treasury Accord. Supposedly they got together 488 00:36:24,810 --> 00:36:28,050 and agreed on this. Now the treasury actually did not want to 489 00:36:28,050 --> 00:36:33,009 do it, but was forced to do it. They freed the Fed so that the 490 00:36:33,009 --> 00:36:37,290 Fed did not have to keep the interest rates at that range. The 491 00:36:37,290 --> 00:36:42,900 third thing was the Fed is supposed to do what Congress once 492 00:36:43,060 --> 00:36:45,820 with regard to the interest rate, although Congress decided we're 493 00:36:45,820 --> 00:36:49,260 not going to do that anymore. Okay. So those are the things that 494 00:36:49,260 --> 00:36:54,660 the Fed is supposed to do. The problem is the Fed is not good at 495 00:36:54,660 --> 00:36:59,660 regulating. The Fed has become a very free market oriented. Let 496 00:36:59,660 --> 00:37:02,540 the biggest banks do whatever they want to do. Don't worry, the 497 00:37:02,540 --> 00:37:06,940 market will discipline them. We know how well that works with 498 00:37:06,940 --> 00:37:11,790 failure after failure and then the Fed doing something it is not 499 00:37:11,790 --> 00:37:16,990 supposed to do, which is bailing out an insolvent institution. 500 00:37:17,310 --> 00:37:20,510 That's what it did in the global financial crisis. That is 501 00:37:20,510 --> 00:37:25,030 actually illegal by US law, but the Fed did it and it does it 502 00:37:25,030 --> 00:37:29,870 over and over and over again. It should not do that. And it is 503 00:37:29,870 --> 00:37:34,110 demonstrated it's not capable of regulation. So I actually would 504 00:37:34,110 --> 00:37:38,820 take that away from the Fed. It already is in the fdic. But you 505 00:37:38,820 --> 00:37:42,340 need good people working in the FDIC in order to get them to 506 00:37:42,340 --> 00:37:47,300 do that. Okay. It's also a responsibility of the Office of the 507 00:37:47,300 --> 00:37:51,300 Comptroller of the Currency. Now both of these are actually under 508 00:37:51,300 --> 00:37:58,020 the Treasury. So you need a good Treasury Secretary and you say, 509 00:37:58,020 --> 00:38:01,630 okay, you guys are going to regulate the banks. And then of course 510 00:38:01,630 --> 00:38:06,630 Elizabeth Warren got through a very good idea. Good legislation. 511 00:38:07,110 --> 00:38:11,990 You also need to protect the consumers from the financial institutions. 512 00:38:12,630 --> 00:38:17,870 So we created the Consumer Protection Bureau. Those are a better 513 00:38:17,870 --> 00:38:21,750 way to regulate the financial institutions. States also regulate 514 00:38:21,750 --> 00:38:26,670 banks, which also is another layer of regulation, which is a good 515 00:38:26,670 --> 00:38:31,030 idea. Congress can pass laws that regulate banks, tell them what 516 00:38:31,030 --> 00:38:34,630 they can do and what they cannot do. I think that's the right 517 00:38:34,630 --> 00:38:38,390 way to regulate. So I would take that away from the Fed. I would 518 00:38:38,390 --> 00:38:41,990 take interest rate setting away from the Fed. Just do what we 519 00:38:41,990 --> 00:38:46,790 did in World War II say hey, we're tired of you jacking around 520 00:38:46,790 --> 00:38:52,790 the interest rates, causing financial crises, sending money off 521 00:38:52,790 --> 00:38:58,520 to the already rich. We're going to mandate from now on the 522 00:38:58,520 --> 00:39:02,720 Fed funds rate will be some target set by Congress. I recommend 523 00:39:03,440 --> 00:39:08,880 1 or 2%. A lot of MMT people say zero. I'm okay with that too. 524 00:39:09,040 --> 00:39:13,640 Okay, let's just choose one. It's movements of the rate that cause 525 00:39:13,640 --> 00:39:21,220 the financial problems. So let's choose 1 0, 1 2%. Okay, any 526 00:39:21,220 --> 00:39:26,980 of those, fine. And the Fed must hit those. And that's it. That's 527 00:39:26,980 --> 00:39:30,420 what I would use the Fed for as well as lender of last resort. 528 00:39:30,500 --> 00:39:34,620 You must have a lender of last resort and they are only supposed 529 00:39:34,620 --> 00:39:38,060 to lend to solvent institutions. Then you have to have 530 00:39:38,060 --> 00:39:43,180 a good way to unwind the insolvent institutions. You don't 531 00:39:43,180 --> 00:39:47,910 prop them up, you shut them down. And we have laws that govern 532 00:39:47,910 --> 00:39:51,830 this. But the Fed has been breaking the law. So that's the short 533 00:39:51,830 --> 00:39:53,150 of an answer as I can give. 534 00:39:54,030 --> 00:39:57,390 Well, with the kind of like I don't even know what you want to 535 00:39:57,390 --> 00:40:01,230 call it banana republic type judiciary that we have now, the Supreme 536 00:40:01,230 --> 00:40:06,590 Court is laughably partisan. I have almost no faith in our judicial 537 00:40:06,590 --> 00:40:12,390 system whatsoever to net out any kind of fair equitable hearings. 538 00:40:12,550 --> 00:40:16,670 I don't see deliberation, not in a meaningful way. I don't see 539 00:40:16,670 --> 00:40:21,510 anything that I was trained in school to believe happening in real 540 00:40:21,510 --> 00:40:26,190 life, like everything that I thought I knew. When I watch it, 541 00:40:26,190 --> 00:40:29,990 it doesn't look like what I was told it was. It could have been 542 00:40:30,390 --> 00:40:34,190 error of understanding on my part, which certainly wouldn't be 543 00:40:34,190 --> 00:40:39,390 the first time. But my lying eyes are struggling to see a functioning 544 00:40:39,390 --> 00:40:45,470 government that actually provides justice, provides oversight. 545 00:40:45,870 --> 00:40:49,830 This nefarious idea that it's we the people. I mean, you almost 546 00:40:49,830 --> 00:40:52,870 have to be asleep to believe it. It's got to be like a dream or 547 00:40:52,870 --> 00:40:58,390 a nightmare. And reality is, is that I'm not seeing any pathway 548 00:40:58,390 --> 00:41:02,390 for regular people to have a say so here. I mean, obviously the 549 00:41:02,390 --> 00:41:05,830 more you dig into these things, you realize that the elites 550 00:41:05,830 --> 00:41:09,710 were always the ones that it was targeted for. I mean, our Constitution 551 00:41:09,790 --> 00:41:12,670 protects private property right up front. I mean we're talk 552 00:41:13,210 --> 00:41:16,890 the ultimate in elite capture here, if you ever want to call it 553 00:41:16,890 --> 00:41:19,570 capture. I mean, it was set up for the elite. It's always been for 554 00:41:19,570 --> 00:41:23,690 them. We were a slave nation. What, if anything, gives you hope 555 00:41:23,690 --> 00:41:26,970 that this will change? This is not even thinking politically, it's 556 00:41:26,970 --> 00:41:31,290 thinking structurally. I mean, these institutions that we have are 557 00:41:31,290 --> 00:41:35,730 being defunded they're being destroyed, maybe in some cases for 558 00:41:35,730 --> 00:41:39,210 better, but it would be accidental if it was for better. 559 00:41:40,210 --> 00:41:45,010 It just seems like a complete unraveling of any kind of meaningful 560 00:41:45,090 --> 00:41:49,210 structure. I don't know whether this is a transition or whether 561 00:41:49,210 --> 00:41:53,330 this is a ending or a beginning or where we are in a process, 562 00:41:53,570 --> 00:41:58,490 some sort of change. But what appears to be obvious anyway, to 563 00:41:58,490 --> 00:42:03,330 me is that none of this has anything to do with voters or public 564 00:42:03,490 --> 00:42:09,190 interest or public desire at all. Where is this coming from? What 565 00:42:09,190 --> 00:42:11,910 is driving these things that we're seeing today? 566 00:42:13,110 --> 00:42:18,110 I agree that the original setup of the United States was to 567 00:42:18,110 --> 00:42:23,430 protect the wealthy and to protect the slave owners from democracy. 568 00:42:23,830 --> 00:42:27,630 That is, it wasn't set up as a democracy. It was to protect the 569 00:42:27,630 --> 00:42:33,350 elite from democracy. But over hundreds of years, we have remedied 570 00:42:33,590 --> 00:42:39,470 some of the problems with the original setup. And I agree we have 571 00:42:39,630 --> 00:42:45,870 some major setbacks taking many steps backward. Pavlina Chernova 572 00:42:45,870 --> 00:42:51,390 and I have a paper on the visions of the presidential candidates 573 00:42:51,870 --> 00:42:57,390 since Carter and on the movement of the electorate, both 574 00:42:57,390 --> 00:43:02,510 those that vote and those that are registered to vote but do not 575 00:43:02,510 --> 00:43:08,330 vote, which is the majority. None of the above always wins presidential 576 00:43:08,330 --> 00:43:12,530 elections because they don't vote for either one. And I think 577 00:43:12,530 --> 00:43:17,250 the problem is that the Democratic Party abandoned the working 578 00:43:17,330 --> 00:43:21,770 class. I mean, completely abandoned. It has paid no attention 579 00:43:21,770 --> 00:43:25,370 to it. Chuck Schumer said, yeah, don't worry about losing the 580 00:43:25,370 --> 00:43:28,930 working class. We're going to get some of those suburban white 581 00:43:29,170 --> 00:43:32,570 women who have been leaning Republican. We're going to get some 582 00:43:32,570 --> 00:43:37,640 of those. Well, this was a complete disaster. And you mentioned 583 00:43:37,640 --> 00:43:41,560 Bernie. You know, Bernie, I think, has been on the right path 584 00:43:41,560 --> 00:43:48,680 all along, but he was alone. I think that now more and more Democrats 585 00:43:48,680 --> 00:43:54,480 and others recognize that the hope really is with focusing on the 586 00:43:54,480 --> 00:43:59,360 working class, getting those who have refused to hold their nose 587 00:43:59,360 --> 00:44:03,050 and vote for people that they cannot possibly support, bring those 588 00:44:03,050 --> 00:44:05,930 back. The belief always has been, well, the people who don't 589 00:44:05,930 --> 00:44:10,130 vote, they're not engaged. They're not following the politics. 590 00:44:10,770 --> 00:44:15,410 They're probably uneducated, probably in a nice show. That's absolutely 591 00:44:15,410 --> 00:44:18,690 false. The ones who are sitting it out, they were probably 592 00:44:18,690 --> 00:44:23,330 the ones that are the best educated. Yes. The most involved, 593 00:44:23,570 --> 00:44:28,470 the most active. They're just disgusted with the candidates that 594 00:44:28,470 --> 00:44:33,350 are being put forward. And so I'm a lot more optimistic, I think, 595 00:44:33,510 --> 00:44:40,110 than you. Yes, yes, you are. That some people. I think we are 596 00:44:40,110 --> 00:44:42,950 seeing this in the mayor's race. I can't remember the number 597 00:44:42,950 --> 00:44:48,390 of volunteers that he has, but it was tens of thousands of people 598 00:44:48,710 --> 00:44:53,230 that are willing to go knock on doors that can defeat all the 599 00:44:53,230 --> 00:44:57,350 money that's coming in from billionaires to support Cuomo. Okay? 600 00:44:58,300 --> 00:45:03,180 So I think that there's some hope in both Bernie and that guy. 601 00:45:03,660 --> 00:45:08,940 That guy has shown that you can get people out, you can get people 602 00:45:09,420 --> 00:45:14,060 to support you who have not been supporting the Democratic candidates. 603 00:45:14,860 --> 00:45:19,580 I follow the Mamdani stuff marginally, but he doesn't represent 604 00:45:19,740 --> 00:45:22,860 my area. So, you know, I'm not going to larp, like, I have some 605 00:45:22,860 --> 00:45:28,280 sort of role in this, but the reality is that he's a mayor in a 606 00:45:28,360 --> 00:45:32,680 major city, no question about it. And so it's naturally interesting 607 00:45:32,680 --> 00:45:37,840 and so forth, but we've seen various people come in, they come 608 00:45:37,840 --> 00:45:40,520 in to bring the ruckus, and five minutes later they'd call him 609 00:45:40,520 --> 00:45:46,040 Pelosi Mama Bear. And losing the people's faith in them instantaneous. 610 00:45:46,040 --> 00:45:49,480 The minute that they sell out, and that is selling out, that right 611 00:45:49,480 --> 00:45:54,300 there is a. A tell to the people that are following very closely 612 00:45:54,300 --> 00:45:58,940 but unimpressed by the results. And I think to myself, what 613 00:45:58,940 --> 00:46:02,980 will it take? And now we can talk about an electoral side. I think 614 00:46:03,140 --> 00:46:07,500 that there needs to be another element here. You saw a lot of MMT 615 00:46:07,500 --> 00:46:11,860 activists bring a lot of attention, some of it unwanted, perhaps, 616 00:46:11,860 --> 00:46:16,860 but nonetheless got MMT in a lot of ways on the map for a lot 617 00:46:16,860 --> 00:46:19,860 of people that would have never otherwise heard of it. I think 618 00:46:19,860 --> 00:46:24,780 that was done outside of a political party, that was done outside 619 00:46:25,180 --> 00:46:30,900 of the electoral system. And I think that looking at folks like 620 00:46:30,900 --> 00:46:34,620 the Black Panthers and looking at the Rainbow Coalition and looking 621 00:46:34,780 --> 00:46:39,620 at Fred Hampton and others, I believe in order to make these kind 622 00:46:39,620 --> 00:46:44,060 of changes matter, it has to go beyond just this electoral process. 623 00:46:44,060 --> 00:46:47,580 And people scoff at that like somehow or another. That's irrational 624 00:46:47,580 --> 00:46:52,250 and crazy. But even MLK, outside of the electoral process, 625 00:46:52,250 --> 00:46:57,890 who famously said the greatest threat to the Negro was basically 626 00:46:57,890 --> 00:47:02,010 the liberal, the white liberal, who values their own convenience 627 00:47:02,010 --> 00:47:06,450 and everything over justice. They prefer law and order over justice 628 00:47:06,450 --> 00:47:09,970 and have sold out every step along the way. Kind of like a Bacon's 629 00:47:09,970 --> 00:47:14,730 rebellion, watching them sell out the working class if it was inconvenient 630 00:47:14,730 --> 00:47:18,740 for them. And if you remember the dnc, you. You saw people walking 631 00:47:18,740 --> 00:47:22,260 outside the DNC being asked about Gaza and they threw their head 632 00:47:22,260 --> 00:47:25,820 back laughing, or they plugged their ears and kept walking. I think 633 00:47:25,820 --> 00:47:29,660 this is a bigger stain on the Democrats than perhaps people are 634 00:47:29,660 --> 00:47:34,620 willing to acknowledge. There was a very elite, very, you know, 635 00:47:34,620 --> 00:47:39,420 the Hamptons kind of look to it, and I think it's going to take 636 00:47:39,420 --> 00:47:42,620 more than just political party kind of stuff. I think it's going 637 00:47:42,620 --> 00:47:48,470 to require an untainable, un corruptible kind of external influence 638 00:47:49,030 --> 00:47:52,550 to create some sort of dual power to force things to happen. 639 00:47:52,630 --> 00:47:56,150 Because I don't see it happening naturally. I mean, I don't 640 00:47:56,150 --> 00:48:00,030 think people have enough time to sit there and hound these representatives 641 00:48:00,030 --> 00:48:04,390 to do what they say they're going to do. And sometimes what they 642 00:48:04,390 --> 00:48:06,990 say they're going to do is so muddled that people have no idea 643 00:48:06,990 --> 00:48:09,390 what they actually said. And I don't know that they know what they 644 00:48:09,390 --> 00:48:13,190 said. I guess as we're going through this, monetary policy and 645 00:48:13,190 --> 00:48:17,990 MMT have taken in many ways a step back because the corruption 646 00:48:17,990 --> 00:48:23,110 and the insanity are at such a high level that it's really hard 647 00:48:23,190 --> 00:48:27,070 to bring things about the Fed into a conversation or bring things 648 00:48:27,070 --> 00:48:31,110 in about interest rates or monetary policy or fiscal policy 649 00:48:31,110 --> 00:48:34,750 or even modern monetary theory. Because they're like, show 650 00:48:34,750 --> 00:48:38,110 me the candidates that are doing any of this stuff, Steve. Show 651 00:48:38,110 --> 00:48:41,870 me anybody that gives a crap about this stuff. And be honest, 652 00:48:41,870 --> 00:48:45,070 Steve, you can't do it. Show me. And I struggle because they're 653 00:48:45,070 --> 00:48:50,110 not wrong. I can't do it. Help me see this. Do you see a dual approach? 654 00:48:50,110 --> 00:48:52,430 I mean, you've been around a minute, you've seen some movements 655 00:48:52,430 --> 00:48:55,390 in your day. What are your thoughts about the approaches people 656 00:48:55,390 --> 00:48:59,430 have been taking? Strictly leaning into the kind of electoral 657 00:48:59,430 --> 00:49:02,110 process? I hadn't really borne the fruit that they would like, but 658 00:49:02,350 --> 00:49:05,030 I don't know. What are your thoughts? I know you're an economist, 659 00:49:05,030 --> 00:49:06,030 by the way. I'm just asking. 660 00:49:06,760 --> 00:49:12,600 I think that I'll agree that politics alone is not enough. Yes. 661 00:49:12,600 --> 00:49:17,400 I'm an economist. So what I think needs to be offered to them 662 00:49:17,640 --> 00:49:21,160 are economic policies that are going to improve their lives. 663 00:49:22,120 --> 00:49:22,680 Yes. 664 00:49:22,760 --> 00:49:26,760 There's no doubt that the current young generations are facing 665 00:49:26,760 --> 00:49:31,800 an economy that is much worse for them than the economy I faced 666 00:49:31,880 --> 00:49:36,150 50 years ago when I was young. And we need to offer them something 667 00:49:36,150 --> 00:49:40,670 better. I think we need to focus on the economics and less on 668 00:49:40,670 --> 00:49:45,870 the politics and maybe less on some of the things the Democratic 669 00:49:45,870 --> 00:49:51,150 Party have been associated with that are very important to some 670 00:49:51,150 --> 00:49:55,350 groups. But they. And that's fine, but they've been neglecting 671 00:49:55,510 --> 00:50:00,120 things that would benefit the vast majority of Americans. So I 672 00:50:00,120 --> 00:50:04,560 think we need to get a list of those things that will appeal and 673 00:50:04,800 --> 00:50:09,920 make those at least part of the central platform of the whatever 674 00:50:09,920 --> 00:50:17,880 part. The Democratic Party for a long time has been the party that 675 00:50:17,880 --> 00:50:21,440 was offering progressive economics. It has not been doing 676 00:50:21,440 --> 00:50:25,560 that for quite a while. I'm doubtful that the Republican Party 677 00:50:25,560 --> 00:50:28,160 is going to switch gears and become that party. 678 00:50:28,160 --> 00:50:29,020 No, never. 679 00:50:29,020 --> 00:50:32,140 It's extremely difficult to do the third party. 680 00:50:32,380 --> 00:50:33,020 Oh, yes. 681 00:50:33,180 --> 00:50:37,260 But you can do what Bernie does. You can do what AOC does. Working 682 00:50:37,260 --> 00:50:42,820 on the fringes within a party, but really beyond helping to put 683 00:50:42,820 --> 00:50:48,340 together an economic package that would improve the lives of the 684 00:50:48,340 --> 00:50:52,420 vast majority of Americans is pretty much the only thing I can 685 00:50:52,420 --> 00:50:52,700 offer. 686 00:50:53,180 --> 00:50:53,900 Understood. 687 00:50:54,390 --> 00:50:58,910 I can't offer the politics. I don't really know how you can bring 688 00:50:58,910 --> 00:51:03,750 people back if actually both parties would stop repelling the 689 00:51:03,910 --> 00:51:08,590 huge block of potential voters and bring them in. Whichever party 690 00:51:08,590 --> 00:51:11,990 can do that is going to be winning, and I hope it will be the 691 00:51:11,990 --> 00:51:14,710 party that is pushing progressive economic policy. 692 00:51:15,110 --> 00:51:18,230 That's a fair way to go out there, sir. I appreciate your time 693 00:51:18,230 --> 00:51:21,270 here very much and look forward to seeing the stuff you and 694 00:51:21,270 --> 00:51:24,490 Pavlina put together. That would be very interesting thought 695 00:51:24,490 --> 00:51:27,810 experiment, looking backwards. Tell us, do you have anything new 696 00:51:27,810 --> 00:51:30,730 coming up? I mean, last couple times you've had a book, you've had 697 00:51:30,730 --> 00:51:33,250 this or that or the other. What's going on in Randy's world 698 00:51:33,250 --> 00:51:33,810 right now? 699 00:51:34,290 --> 00:51:38,730 I am finishing a book on Minsky. It's fairly advanced. I already 700 00:51:38,730 --> 00:51:42,650 wrote one in 2015 for a general audience. But this one will 701 00:51:42,650 --> 00:51:48,170 be advanced, going deeply into his contributions, beginning with 702 00:51:48,170 --> 00:51:51,890 his dissertation. So that's an academic thing. But let me just say 703 00:51:51,970 --> 00:51:57,090 November 19th, the Levy Institute is holding presentations 704 00:51:57,250 --> 00:52:01,690 in Congress on rethinking the Fed's independence. So exactly what 705 00:52:01,690 --> 00:52:06,210 we've been talking about, directly related to that, Jamie Galbraith 706 00:52:06,210 --> 00:52:12,170 will be there, Claudia Sahm, Pavlina me, William Bergman, I don't 707 00:52:12,170 --> 00:52:14,930 know, but I think he's representing the more conservative 708 00:52:15,090 --> 00:52:19,620 point of view. But I think he also agrees that the Fed independence 709 00:52:19,620 --> 00:52:23,580 thing is overstated. But anyway, we'll see. I don't know. 710 00:52:23,980 --> 00:52:27,340 So we'll be in Congress presenting that, and we'll see whether 711 00:52:27,340 --> 00:52:29,420 that has any influence on thinking. 712 00:52:30,620 --> 00:52:33,820 It's exciting to at least give it a shot. Right. If you don't give 713 00:52:33,820 --> 00:52:36,860 it a shot, you'll never know. So I appreciate the effort there 714 00:52:36,860 --> 00:52:39,900 and looking forward to seeing that. Hopefully there's some sort 715 00:52:39,900 --> 00:52:43,770 of video of it or at least a transcript of it that we can kind 716 00:52:43,770 --> 00:52:45,530 of catch up on. That would be wonderful. 717 00:52:45,930 --> 00:52:47,290 Watch the Levy website. 718 00:52:47,850 --> 00:52:50,970 Okay, we'll do. We'll make sure we get that out there as well. 719 00:52:51,210 --> 00:52:53,810 All right. Randy, listen, it was wonderful to be with you. It's 720 00:52:53,810 --> 00:52:57,250 been a while, so I really appreciate your time. As far as it 721 00:52:57,250 --> 00:53:00,330 goes. I'm going to take us out, folks. My name is Steve Grumbine. 722 00:53:00,330 --> 00:53:04,130 I am the founder of Real Progressives, the nonprofit that 723 00:53:04,130 --> 00:53:08,610 sponsors this podcast, Macro and cheese. We are a 501C3, not for 724 00:53:08,610 --> 00:53:12,300 profit, and hopefully you guys find value in the work that we do. 725 00:53:12,300 --> 00:53:16,020 If you do find value in the work that we do, your donations are 726 00:53:16,020 --> 00:53:19,020 welcome. They are tax deductible and it is going into the 727 00:53:19,020 --> 00:53:22,220 fourth quarter. So if you're looking for a tax write off, we're 728 00:53:22,220 --> 00:53:24,940 a good place to go ahead and throw some money at us because we 729 00:53:24,940 --> 00:53:28,780 could use it. You can go to our website, realprogressives.org 730 00:53:28,780 --> 00:53:32,620 There is a donate area there. You can go to our substack, which 731 00:53:32,620 --> 00:53:36,240 is realprogressives.substack.com you 732 00:53:36,240 --> 00:53:39,800 can become a donor there. Or you can go to patreon, which is patreon.com 733 00:53:40,440 --> 00:53:44,400 realprogressives. All your donations are tax deductible, as 734 00:53:44,400 --> 00:53:48,360 I said. And of course, one more final thing, Real Progressives 735 00:53:48,360 --> 00:53:53,480 puts on a Tuesday webinar every week representing the podcasts 736 00:53:53,720 --> 00:53:56,920 that you listen to that come out every Saturday morning at 8am 737 00:53:57,560 --> 00:54:00,480 and so if you'd like to join us, go to our website and at the 738 00:54:00,480 --> 00:54:02,960 top there's a banner and you can go ahead and click on there. 739 00:54:02,960 --> 00:54:06,950 Register for the macro and chill webinar on Tuesday nights, 740 00:54:06,950 --> 00:54:10,750 8:00pm Eastern Standard Time and join us. Help us build community. 741 00:54:10,750 --> 00:54:13,950 We've had lots of people, Bob Hocketts come through, Bill Black 742 00:54:13,950 --> 00:54:16,830 has come through, we have a number of our guests come through. 743 00:54:16,830 --> 00:54:19,390 Hopefully we can get Randy sometime to come through and be a 744 00:54:19,390 --> 00:54:24,190 part of that. And we also on Thursday nights have a book club 745 00:54:24,190 --> 00:54:27,870 and Thursday night, right now we are doing State and Revolution 746 00:54:28,190 --> 00:54:32,020 as Thursday nights, 8pm Eastern Standard Time. We listen 747 00:54:32,020 --> 00:54:36,020 to it, we talk about it, and we discuss what we agree with, what 748 00:54:36,020 --> 00:54:39,500 we disagree with and have a great opportunity to build some community 749 00:54:39,900 --> 00:54:42,940 and build some mental muscle. So I hope that you will enjoy this 750 00:54:42,940 --> 00:54:47,420 podcast and support our work. On behalf of my guest, Randy Ray, 751 00:54:47,580 --> 00:54:52,740 myself Steve Grumbine, the podcast Macaron Cheese, we are out 752 00:54:52,740 --> 00:54:53,180 of here. 753 00:55:00,030 --> 00:55:03,550 Production, transcripts, graphics, sound engineering, extras 754 00:55:03,550 --> 00:55:06,790 and show notes for macroencies are done by our volunteer team at 755 00:55:06,790 --> 00:55:10,310 Real Progressives, serving in solidarity with the working class 756 00:55:10,310 --> 00:55:16,510 since 2015. To become a donor, please go to patreon.com realprogressives 757 00:55:16,910 --> 00:55:21,150 realprogressives.substack.com or realprogressives.org.