Speaker:

In those ten qualities of good companies, you will not find love. Sacrificial love. I'm talking

Speaker:

about suffering love. Sacrificial love. Yes, you have to sacrifice, but for the sake of,,

Speaker:

not in the sense of bringing for. For bringing humans to a Übermensch.

Speaker:

To the Superman. They said, our goal is one day for people to have such a

Speaker:

conscience that they will go to work and will not be paid, but they will go to the shops, will

Speaker:

take things as much as they need, not more than that, and everything will be perfect.

Speaker:

Well, Saimir, welcome to the podcast. We're going to be talking a little bit about the Communist ideology

Speaker:

ideology.. But before we do that, I want to get some of your background so people know how this ties

Speaker:

into your story, which we have a separate episode where you tell your story that will already be

Speaker:

released. We'll link that and so forth. Uh, but you grew up in essentially the strictest

Speaker:

country in Europe, the strictest communist country in Europe. Uh, give us a little bit of context

Speaker:

there, a little bit of groundwork before we plow into the main topic. Let me tell you, uh, a

Speaker:

story. Uh, when our dictator, Enver Hoxha,

Speaker:

communist dictator, died. Uh, everybody was supposed to cry. And anyone in

Speaker:

Albania, you know, the line was, you know, 1 or 2km

Speaker:

to go and weep to his around his casket and all

Speaker:

this in Albania. But, um, we were in a I remember that

Speaker:

day we were in a, uh, in our class that the news came. It was a

Speaker:

we were ten years old. It was a fourth grade elementary.

Speaker:

And, uh, everyone I mean, most of the children started to cry.

Speaker:

Me too, you know. Oh, our not dictator, but our leader. Not our leader, but our God

Speaker:

has died. So, um, one child in the back of the

Speaker:

room, he was not crying. Some of them observed that, but, you

Speaker:

know, continued. There was one guy, he stood up. He

Speaker:

pointed him in that day. Terrible day. He pointed him as a why are you not crying?

Speaker:

The other friend was saying, I don't know, why are you not crying?

Speaker:

And then he said he started to cry because this other

Speaker:

child pointed the finger to him. And, uh, I thought I told this story

Speaker:

because even in that day, you could see the terror that had brought

Speaker:

this type of I mean, it was not an ideology. It was a system of a

Speaker:

state police state that was as entered even in the

Speaker:

blood of the in the veins of the children. So, you know,

Speaker:

children, they act, they imitate adults. So we were at that

Speaker:

moment, we were imitating, you know, our parents, the generation of our parents, what was happening with

Speaker:

the adults even in that day. So the terror, the fear. Uh

Speaker:

uh, spying was everywhere. Every day a danger, a risk. So can you

Speaker:

imagine, uh, living and in in that kind of life.

Speaker:

So, of course, you, um, you have to adapt by acting

Speaker:

all the time. So this friend was acting like he was a

Speaker:

communist follower. Mhm. Even he was ten years old and the other was acting

Speaker:

like he was not doing anything. And he, he was, uh, he wanted to cry, but

Speaker:

he couldn't. And, and in the end he cried. So it was, uh,

Speaker:

a painful reality. Everywhere I said, even in The previous

Speaker:

interview. Interview that it amazed me how human beings have the ability

Speaker:

to adapt and to find a way to live even in those

Speaker:

circumstances. Yeah. And it reminds me that when you give them, you know, when when you

Speaker:

give them the opportunity to have life like Jesus gave to everyone, they

Speaker:

just refuse that. That's I don't know. I mean, I did

Speaker:

this myself for 27 years, but even now, I don't know, how can I,

Speaker:

how can I, how can we be combined in a, in a, in a person this this thing. So yeah.

Speaker:

So let's let's drill into that a little. So you're describing Albania right. Which is where you live.

Speaker:

Where you still live. Very strict communist regime. I guess you could say or dictatorship, [indistinct]

Speaker:

etc.. Can you first of all tell me a little bit about like what is the communist ideal like, what

Speaker:

were they even trying to do? And then what have you said you believed in that. Did you believe the

Speaker:

communist ideology? Were you? Yes. This is the right thing or did you not really think about it? Yeah.

Speaker:

Tell me about those two things. Communist ideology. I mean, uh, yes. Even ideology. And even in

Speaker:

how it is applied because it is applied differently in different countries. Um,

Speaker:

had a high value, highly the moral standard

Speaker:

of the character of the communist, of the people who are

Speaker:

or the people who are under the system. So justice, truth, they are

Speaker:

preached. They were preached, you know, strongly in the in the schools and everywhere. Mhm. Um

Speaker:

in, in the, in the, in the working place, you know they would, they would read

Speaker:

newspapers talking about these characteristics before starting to work you know.

Speaker:

Yeah. Okay. It was almost like how we would have a morning devotions or something. They would have a

Speaker:

reading of like communist ideals or something. It's amazing how close whoa. They are. You know,

Speaker:

ideologically the ideology, the characteristics of the of

Speaker:

and for, uh, the qualities of a communist, uh, our dictator, he,

Speaker:

uh, wrote down ten commandments of a good communist. Really? Yes.

Speaker:

That's also quite ironic because, like, we talked about this a little bit in the other interview,

Speaker:

but how Albania was one of, as far as I know, maybe there's been other examples, but one of the or the

Speaker:

only country where they officially as state policy, we will have no religion. We will be

Speaker:

atheist. It's in our Constitution. This is who we're going to be. That seems kind of ironic. Yeah.

Speaker:

What you're describing here. He he said, um, you have the the first quality is I

Speaker:

mean, you have to be you have to worship. I'm talking now

Speaker:

in Christian terms. You have to be obedient and venerate only the

Speaker:

party exclusively. You have to worship only one god. You have to,,

Speaker:

uh, continue. And, um, only you have to be obedient only to the,

Speaker:

uh, to the ideology and the teachings of the party, which is like the obedient to the Word of

Speaker:

God. You have to, um, to be a good communist. You have

Speaker:

to, uh, share. You have to be. You have to have a good fellowship with the

Speaker:

others. You have to be a, uh, the ones who promote fellowship with the others. You have

Speaker:

to, uh, um, be, um, a doer of the world of the word. Not

Speaker:

just only someone who speaks that, but you have to act out to live out that word.

Speaker:

You have to, uh, um, fight the enemies by trying to

Speaker:

convince them. Whoa. Okay. Was this were these commandments for just your country, or would

Speaker:

it this been fairly standard in the other communist like? Do you know? I don't know, but I'm

Speaker:

not sure even my our. This guy has ever done anything

Speaker:

originally, you know, authentically. Well, somewhere he has to. You know. That's so interesting. This is

Speaker:

it's it's almost like a copy paste for religion. Yes, but they don't copy and paste the concept of

Speaker:

God. Yeah. Which is kind of weird when you. See replaced God, you know. The dictator kind of. Yeah

Speaker:

he was God. You know. The Communist party replaces God. Yes. When? When he was talking about party, he

Speaker:

was party, you know. No one can could say anything against the one. The one thing that he was coming

Speaker:

to his mind, that was party. So it's you're describing what sounds to me like

Speaker:

an atheistic religion, which is an oxymoron. I mean, that doesn't even seem possible, but yet it. Yes,

Speaker:

yes, but it is then. Yeah. Kind of. Did you did you believe all this back, back then or did you

Speaker:

not? Was it the kind of thing where it wasn't even considered? Whether you believe or disbelieve, it's

Speaker:

just what was. I liked the moral part. I liked the quality of

Speaker:

a high, you know, uh, value of the Morality for good things and bad things and

Speaker:

and to be true. But there were these qualities.

Speaker:

But especially like the ones. The philosophers. The philosophers. The

Speaker:

philosophers that had the new idea of communism. It was a little thing there

Speaker:

when he was saying, we will try to win our enemies by convince them.

Speaker:

And then he continued. And that's made the whole difference of that. So

Speaker:

if they will not be convinced, then we have to crush them. Oh,

Speaker:

yes. Eliminate them. So, so there's like this utopian ideal that

Speaker:

they have. And so as long as you fit within the ideal, you're fine. But if you don't, we eliminate

Speaker:

you. Yeah. Which hardly seems to describe Utopia, but I guess they they had this idea that it was

Speaker:

important enough. Let me see if I can get this right. That the concept and the

Speaker:

party as a whole were so important that the the loss of an individual who's not convinced is a

Speaker:

signal is not significant enough to matter. It's totally a humanistic ideology. It comes from

Speaker:

humanistic, uh, philosophy. So, um, remember when the philosopher Friedrich

Speaker:

Nietzsche, he said, God is dead? Yep. Now God is dead and we have killed him. We have killed him. Yeah..

Speaker:

He's sad. Now, what should we do? That was his idea. What should we do? What is. How is that quote? We of

Speaker:

all men are most to be pitied, I think he says. Or something like that. Like this is. Whoa! Oh, no. You

Speaker:

know, God's gone. But now we should be a rise at the level of gods. We should be gods now.

Speaker:

In other words, he was saying, yeah, we should find a way Now that the Christian morals and

Speaker:

values in Europe, which that is another another story and I think is the, the cause of the

Speaker:

problem, I don't think it's the cause of a problem. Uh, philosophers like Karl

Speaker:

Marx or Nietzsche or dictators. I probably will elaborate later

Speaker:

that, but in my conviction. But I think that's what he said. He said, now we have to find a way. We have

Speaker:

to find some. That was his idea. Some Übermensch. What he said. Oh, this. Superman. This.

Speaker:

Yes. Oh, it is over, man. Which is not is not a superman. It is a human being, which is

Speaker:

a rise beyond the humanity that we see. Like risen to another, another level. So that was

Speaker:

Nietzsche who came up with. Yeah, yeah yeah, yeah. Okay. Because I've heard the term, I don't I guess

Speaker:

that's German. I didn't, I wasn't quite confident on what it meant, but I've read about that and it

Speaker:

always struck me as odd, but I guess it's a natural outworking of, well, God's dead. So we had

Speaker:

to figure out how to raise humans to another level, essentially. And his idea was also to, um, to

Speaker:

to the level of not having at all morality, get rid of morality. And I find our own path.

Speaker:

That's what was he saying? He didn't know it was. But we need some people like this. And then with

Speaker:

this ideology, because of this ideology, I strongly believe some Übermensch were revealed in

Speaker:

the Europe, you know, Mussolini, Adolf Hitler, Stalin, Joseph Stalin, they were, you know, they

Speaker:

came out from this kind of ideology, this kind of philosophy, you know, and they build in an

Speaker:

ideology like fascism or communism. They were progressive in their in their mind, you

Speaker:

know, that's moved the humanity to another level. So that's so interesting. You mentioned that

Speaker:

because. Because it's an underlying philosophy, it seems to me beyond just communism. You see it in a

Speaker:

lot of our workings, right? I actually I was in, um, Denmark and I found this old book

Speaker:

from pre-World War two since 1930s Germany. And it was a series that they had been publishing. And

Speaker:

this is again before Hitler and all of that, where it's outlining the great men of history that we

Speaker:

should be like is like we need to be striving for this ideal. And so and it listed them out, and it

Speaker:

was people like Alexander the Great and Mussolini and, you know, Julius Caesar and Adolf Hitler was

Speaker:

one of them in this book. And I remember reading that. And the guy who was he like, knew a lot of

Speaker:

local history and stuff like this was an important part for them in thinking, oh, we're

Speaker:

gonna lift ourselves up to another level, fix all these problems because we strive to be like this.

Speaker:

And and yet you look at the list of those people and you're like, I don't think I want to be like

Speaker:

those people. Like, Alexander the Great was really, really nasty. I mean, he killed a lot of people. You

Speaker:

know, really evil person. But they were saying, this is who you should be like. Yes, yes. And the idea is

Speaker:

to, you know, to have this new man, you know, to now has come as rising new man. We have

Speaker:

to to build this new man. I mean, the motto in for communists was, at

Speaker:

least in Albania, one for all, all for one. So these ideals were really. Yeah, sure. They

Speaker:

took took it from somewhere, but they were guess well, you know, Bible, but they, um,

Speaker:

they had to erase God and and they had a reason for that, I think. Oh, really? Why? Okay. Why

Speaker:

do you say that? Because the church at shown that God is dead. Mhm.

Speaker:

The in history the church has

Speaker:

shown sometimes the God is alive and that sometimes have proclaimed that God is dead..

Speaker:

So the first century, for example, and second century of the third century, they

Speaker:

shown they displayed the glory of God and the presence of God to the world.

Speaker:

People could see. You know why? Well, what is this power in these human

Speaker:

beings that they can pray for their persecuted tormentors while they are torn apart

Speaker:

from the beasts where they are crucified? What is this? And the people were drawn, and the people

Speaker:

were very curious, you know, and that's why they joined them to,

Speaker:

uh, to start to have to start this relationship, because it was this power was displayed

Speaker:

and they started, um, they wanted that this religion. They wanted this power. The one is this

Speaker:

kind of life. And then they fell in love with the source of this kind of power, which is God. And

Speaker:

then they continued, like the others, for 2 or 3 centuries, until the

Speaker:

church, uh, married with the power of human power in the mid of fourth

Speaker:

century. And then so interesting, you know, the description of

Speaker:

historian Flavius Eusebius when the bishops of different uh,

Speaker:

regions enter in the emperors palace. Constantine. And he says they are. Oh,

Speaker:

ah, it was wonderful, you know, they were walking. He invited them, I wonder, I wonder what what would

Speaker:

happen if they would say, oh, Constantine, you are now Christian. You converted. Yeah. Leave the

Speaker:

throne. Come to the catacombs. Come to the underground church. What would happen? Yeah, but I

Speaker:

don't know what would happen, but what we know is that it. The church was invited by

Speaker:

Constantine and they in during the Council of Nicaea. It was his festivals

Speaker:

of his 20th year of being an emperor. And then he invited them, and

Speaker:

he says he was very he was a fan of Constantine, the historian. They said, oh,

Speaker:

bishops were entering in the palace, and there were guards, bodyguards around with the swords

Speaker:

out, you know, and honoring them. And they stayed with them with the in the table, with

Speaker:

Constantine and on the couches around the table. It was a picture of Christ

Speaker:

and the disciples and the church. So guess who was Christ there?

Speaker:

And then from there the the, the display of God's glory

Speaker:

to the earth. And most importantly, according to Ephesians chapter three verse ten. Most

Speaker:

importantly for me is the reason why we exist is to display God's glory to the heavenly

Speaker:

powers. That's what he's saying there the wisdom, the manifold wisdom of God. So, uh,

Speaker:

this this display started to diminish. And that's why I was amazed in the 16th century about the

Speaker:

Anabaptist, because that showed that power, that kind of character of

Speaker:

God, of Jesus. They show that. But then after that, the

Speaker:

Anabaptist left the Europe. They went to the New World. And the marriage

Speaker:

between church and state continue with the reformers. And then after a while,

Speaker:

you know, we have this philosophers of 17th century, like René Descartes, who

Speaker:

said, oh, I can, we can even. We're so good in reasoning with human beings that without

Speaker:

revelation, without a need of revelation, we can understand. We can conclude logically that God

Speaker:

exists for the first time in history. Yeah. And the church. What did they do? You know, they just

Speaker:

debated. And Descartes was famous for that, for his work on. See, we can we can show God as real just

Speaker:

using our brains and nothing else. And then future generations of philosophers were like, you're not

Speaker:

right, that you got it wrong. You got it wrong. You can't. Therefore, maybe God isn't real and you

Speaker:

start going down this whole thing and they kind of miss the whole point. Yeah. But you know. Yes, but

Speaker:

where was the church? Right. Because every time the church rise up at the level of the

Speaker:

name it carries, you know, it's, um, only there's only

Speaker:

one weapon left to the devil. Persecution. But if there is

Speaker:

not that, the is not the horizon at this level. Oh, there are other things. Like, for example,

Speaker:

in the 18th century French Revolution. Oh, these guys said, oh,

Speaker:

we will put out religion not only from universities, not only from, you know, we can think

Speaker:

alone now, but even from the state. It was not the church who disconnected from the state. It was

Speaker:

the, you know, the Europeans that disconnected the church from the

Speaker:

state. They said, you don't have to do anything. We said. And later the in a century

Speaker:

later, during the 19th century, they said the church must

Speaker:

not put its nose even in everyday life. So with the industrial revolution,

Speaker:

with scientific revolution. They said, oh no, no, you don't have a say on this in medical science. Oh

Speaker:

no, the church had to disclaim or had to shame. Shamefully,

Speaker:

to accept that it was wrong and wrong and wrong all the time. All the time, all the time, you know.

Speaker:

And then it creates this idea that, oh, God is dead. The church is not anymore. It's a

Speaker:

ancient thing. But wasn't that a lot of the the push of communism is saying we're the wave

Speaker:

of the future and religions, this dusty thing from the past. It's totally irrelevant to the future.

Speaker:

Well, since we're the ones bringing in the future, you've got to leave religion behind. Yes, because.

Speaker:

Religion wanted to dance with the world, went to dance with state and then and

Speaker:

it it it led the dance for a thousand years during the medieval ages.

Speaker:

But then the leader of the dance started to be. You know the humanism.

Speaker:

From the 17th century and on for five centuries, you know, we have. We

Speaker:

see this. You know, the church going after the world and trying to convince people today. You

Speaker:

know, it's you see. Yeah. It's like it's always struck me as the grasping for the wrong kind of

Speaker:

power, because you look at your earlier church and there was power there, but it was a very different

Speaker:

kind of power. It was being thrown to the lion's kind of power, you know, um, that kind of it was

Speaker:

suffering, love, you know, patience, um, persistence in faithfulness, you know. Oh, Lord. The same

Speaker:

thing. Yeah. And then you see so many cases where it's like, well, okay, now the church is trying to

Speaker:

grasp power by by actual, like, worldly power. You know, or. The. Sword. Or things like. That. And maybe

Speaker:

there is a lot of witness that was totally lost there over the years. Yeah. And in fact, what's left.

Speaker:

In effect of instead of shining the light. Of the. Glory of God, it diminishes it, you know, it

Speaker:

fades it out. You see the stadiums? Uh, they there are, you know, football teams playing

Speaker:

there. People go there, they fans cry and beat drums and they the the

Speaker:

the match, uh, ends and then they go out and then come the, the Christians there and

Speaker:

look, turn on the light, put a concert, shout, beat the drums the same thing.

Speaker:

And trying to convert for Christ and trying to display God's law and call it God's glory. No,,

Speaker:

it's it... You're trying to use that power. Yeah. I

Speaker:

see what you're getting at here because. Because when we were talking on the phone. And maybe we'll

Speaker:

dig into this a bit later. But one of the points we kept coming back to is this probably comes out

Speaker:

of the enlightenment and, you know, the age of reason and science. You know that we saw hit

Speaker:

Europe a couple hundred years ago and so forth. Um, where we humans can fix everything. That kind of

Speaker:

idea. You know, you mentioned a French Revolution that was kind of that concept and etc.. You read

Speaker:

that all through Karl Marx, right? He's like, we support every revolution ever, because that means

Speaker:

the people are going to, you know, take care of all these problems and they'll rise up and fix it.

Speaker:

Yeah. It's like it strikes me as really naive, actually. Um, okay. So to back up a

Speaker:

little bit. One of the critiques that worldviews like communism say, will make against religion is

Speaker:

saying, oh, this is irrational, illogical, easily disproven Christianity. It just

Speaker:

doesn't know there's no way. Whereas we, the communists or whatever, we have reason on our

Speaker:

side. This is the logical way we can easily prove we're right. Um, does that make sense? I'd

Speaker:

love to hear your response and critique to that. And like, and you were raised in that system, so

Speaker:

did it come across as like, oh yeah, this is the reasonable, rational thing. Of course they're right.

Speaker:

Of course Christianity is wrong. Talk to me about that. Does that make sense? I think if you don't

Speaker:

see. Um. The logic. Uh.

Speaker:

In the end of the road of something and you say, oh, um,

Speaker:

this doesn't make logic now, but we'll make later. You know, uh, and we are, um,

Speaker:

we're having this philosophy because the others aren't working. That's why we are experimenting

Speaker:

this. Of course, it doesn't make sense. I mean, they never had ultimately

Speaker:

ultimate answers for their ideologies. No

Speaker:

Evolution in in the core of this, you know, or of this, uh, of this ideology,

Speaker:

it doesn't have answer, you know, and it is also proven itself, you know, Communist has proven

Speaker:

itself that we have also communists. Now they're still saying, you know, uh oh, no, it was a

Speaker:

it was a Stalinist or type of communism. It was the wrong thing. But he didn't they didn't follow

Speaker:

the right ideology. But it is proven. And if you don't, that you don't have that and you say,

Speaker:

oh, we'll see on the road. But for now you have to be quiet because we will,

Speaker:

uh, crush you. Uh, that, of course, doesn't make sense. Of course,

Speaker:

doesn't make sense. But let me say this, this, uh, it it will make

Speaker:

or people will fake and people will act like it meant it. Uh, it it means something, or

Speaker:

it makes sense if they don't have another option. I, I remember

Speaker:

there was this, um, I read about this, uh, missionary, English missionary. Uh, he

Speaker:

was spreading Bibles during the, um, the early

Speaker:

90s, uh, not 90s, maybe first of the 20th century.

Speaker:

And he was going to Turkey, and he passed through Albania, and he said, his name is Alexander

Speaker:

Thompson. And he said, I was in the street in the in the middle of the city in Albania. And there

Speaker:

here comes the and trying to sell Bibles, and here comes the priest, the priest of the, of the of the

Speaker:

city. And he was barefoot and he was, uh, you know, uh, he

Speaker:

didn't even know what he was talking about in the church because he was speaking in Greek, but he

Speaker:

didn't even know Greek language. He was. Just. You know, repeating what he knew

Speaker:

that that how was Albania at that time? You know, the clerics, the, the, the people of, you know, the

Speaker:

leaders of faith. They didn't know what they were saying. And then comes this ideology, of course. Mm.

Speaker:

People what what can they do? And now they follow that because they are oppressed and they don't

Speaker:

have enough strength to resist that. So again, I don't I come again there, you know, to the same

Speaker:

place. So if it was the first century church present, they would

Speaker:

have, you know, a choice and they would, uh, I would have an example

Speaker:

and see, oh no, no, no, no, this doesn't make sense. This makes sense. Not intellectually,

Speaker:

but, uh, also, As a meaning of life. So is it kind of come

Speaker:

back to the fruits of the system, so to speak? Right. If Christianity is showing that

Speaker:

transformative power that we see in the early church or, you know, different points throughout

Speaker:

church history, it's like, oh, whoa, you know, that makes sense. Like you just said. And if that's not

Speaker:

there, maybe it's pretty easy to lose it. You know, I mean. All the history of humanity is

Speaker:

focused on church. Hmm. So everything is it's happening because of the church.

Speaker:

Everything. So if the church, uh, fades its light,

Speaker:

these ideas will come up, okay? And people will follow this. Many people will follow

Speaker:

this, and they will, you know, they will be a nightmare every time. For example, even now,

Speaker:

American Americans think they, um, they have, uh, escaped communism.

Speaker:

But you know what? Antonio Gramsci, this communist philosopher, um,

Speaker:

said in the when he was imprisoned by the fascists in 1930. Some

Speaker:

he said, oh, um, we've, we've seen we've watched the nightmare in Union, Soviet

Speaker:

Union. So we made some mistakes, uh, in this, um, ideology.

Speaker:

So we have to rearrange something. This, uh, these classes, these were of classes that

Speaker:

Marx talks about. Yeah. This class were of classes. Um,

Speaker:

now we understand that the upper class is the ones that are the oppressors. They, um, they use

Speaker:

these institutes, social institutions like education and media, and they build a system

Speaker:

that people don't know, but they are part of that, which in some it's true.

Speaker:

But he said, look what we have to do. We don't have to do now. We don't have to, um, take the power and

Speaker:

then crush the enemy. The crush the. It was wrong. The proletariat crushing the the the the

Speaker:

the the bourgeoisie class. It was wrong. He said no, we we understand now they are

Speaker:

doing their job through this social institution. So we have to have the power in these social

Speaker:

institutions, education and media and look what what is happening today

Speaker:

in the West. Everyone is fighting for education, our children and

Speaker:

media. Mm. Yes. So the question is, is still is communism that.

Speaker:

Yeah, that kind of communism is dead, but it's still alive, and,

Speaker:

uh. And it will come up. Humanity will, I think, with other different ideas.

Speaker:

If the church will. Not. Shine its light. It's like there's a vacuum or a void there. And so some

Speaker:

idea is going to come in and fill it. Something will write. You know that that okay. So. So when we

Speaker:

look at something like communism, which we're kind of using it as an example, right. Or you know,

Speaker:

humanism, fascism, whatever. But you could look at it at its core. Would you say it shares a lot of

Speaker:

the same foundations as a religious belief system? Well, I think the,

Speaker:

the, the, the, the enemy, the devil never created anything, just

Speaker:

copied everything, you know, just copy it. So he always

Speaker:

copied. And The aim was just to do the same thing,

Speaker:

but without God. Just put away. God. Yeah. And God and the the

Speaker:

very core of the nature of God. Love. You know, God is a person and love is an

Speaker:

action. Everything else. Yeah. Let's stay there. Let's do it like a religion. So

Speaker:

yes, I think, uh, they share all the time, uh,

Speaker:

things that people need. People love to see. Uh, but without

Speaker:

God and without love. Mm. These two components, you will not find it in every

Speaker:

ideology. These two, uh, human ideology, God. Biblical, you

Speaker:

know, uh, description of God and and love. Mm. Biblical love. Ooh, that's such a good

Speaker:

point, though, because I'm just thinking of when we did the other episode, you know, on your story and

Speaker:

hearing what life was like, you know, in Albania. Yeah. Love isn't really the the thing that. Came

Speaker:

then. Came to mind. Which is so ironic, though, because you were saying how the Communist Party

Speaker:

was saying things like, you know, we value truth and, you know, laying out all these things that are

Speaker:

really important. And yet at the same time, you mentioned how families would report each other to

Speaker:

the police, and the secret police are watching everything. And it's like, wait, if we value truth

Speaker:

that way, that seems really weird and really like upside down. It's like what you call truth isn't

Speaker:

even truth. It's very Orwellian. You know, it's like where you flip the what the words even mean. You

Speaker:

just flip them around almost or something. It's it's terribly ironic, and it would be funny if it

Speaker:

wasn't real. Like it would be a joke. It's so laughable, you know? But it's. But it's funny. It's

Speaker:

not a joke. You know, it happened. And you, in those ten qualities of good communists, you will not find

Speaker:

love there. Sacrificial love. I'm talking about suffering love. Sacrificial love. Yes, you have to

Speaker:

sacrifice. But for the sake of humanity, it's not in the sense of bringing for.

Speaker:

For bringing humans to a Übermensch. To the superman. Everyone. So they said

Speaker:

they. They said our goal is one day. For people to have such a conscience that they

Speaker:

will go to work and will not be paid, but they will go to the shops, will take things

Speaker:

as much as they need, not more than that. And everything will be perfect, but without

Speaker:

sacrificial love. Which means you give all in this life for

Speaker:

another person, not for an ideology in order to bring that person.

Speaker:

That's the condition in good relationship with God That's I think

Speaker:

the definition of. Wow. Of love. So. Uh

Speaker:

yeah. That's what. That's what happened. And it's still there. Still people are still searching you

Speaker:

know. Yeah. I was going to say like where you're describing that underlying philosophy is very

Speaker:

much there. It manifests in many different ways. Yeah. But the communism being one of them, perhaps

Speaker:

you know which. Okay. So which which is something I want to drill into a little because okay, so we

Speaker:

see communism like a system like communism. And there's this deep sense that if we can get it

Speaker:

just right, we can fix all of humanity's problems essentially. Yeah, we'll become the. The. Superman or

Speaker:

the we'll fix all of society's ills. Because if we because we're humans and we can do this. It's

Speaker:

interesting, though, because I hear a similar ideology sometimes in America, too. America has

Speaker:

this sense of like, you can pull yourself up by your bootstraps, you can become anything you want,

Speaker:

you can fix anything. We can do this because we're amazing or whatever, and it's like a very

Speaker:

different system than communism, obviously. But there seems like there's an underlying script

Speaker:

that's still there. Yeah, that's the same. There's some kind of foundational, some kind of

Speaker:

foundational philosophy that thinks humanity can fix everything. Yes. So talk to. Me about that. Yeah.

Speaker:

Well, well. The experiment of trying to,

Speaker:

um, resolve the problem, the problem of humanity without God are

Speaker:

continually happening. Going back a little bit to communism, they were they were saying,

Speaker:

uh, we will we will have a conscience like this, that so high, the

Speaker:

moral will be so high that we will, um, we will understand, we will arrive at this point, that we

Speaker:

will understand that, um, we will take as much as we need. I mean, and it.

Speaker:

It didn't happen. It never happened. You know, the next day that the people were

Speaker:

allowed, you know, to to be individuals. They just started to, you

Speaker:

know, when there was no lo started to to kill each other in Albania or in other places. And all the

Speaker:

bad things came in Albania. But even in states, when the law somehow it happens sometimes, you

Speaker:

know, when, uh, it was a disorder, a little bit disorder, and the law was slow, you know, started

Speaker:

people immediately started to, to, to fight with each other. So, so they tried to imitate

Speaker:

the ideology. At least they tried to imitate Acts four,

Speaker:

when it says for the first church that they sold everything and they put in the

Speaker:

feet of the apostles to fulfill every need. And then we see the story

Speaker:

there, how it continues. They did it willfully because they believed

Speaker:

in resurrection of their Lord, in the power of the resurrection of the Lord.

Speaker:

If that is not there, any other experiment will end up. The same

Speaker:

will fail. So, uh, communism said, um, hey, we'll

Speaker:

do it by force. Like when I read the book of, uh, uh, Leonardo Verduin.

Speaker:

Ah, I was amazed. There was a chapter there. Communism. He was talking about the Münster

Speaker:

rebellion when they decided to to share everything with each

Speaker:

other. I mean, they were crazy Anabaptist, so they decided to share anything

Speaker:

with each other by imposing a rule, a law to do that. Totally.

Speaker:

Misled and totally opposed to what is the, what is saying. What did the

Speaker:

first church. But, um, the communists did the same and that experiment failed.

Speaker:

Now say, oh, let's do another, you know, experiment. So we are free. We

Speaker:

will resolve the problem of the people by being free. From what?

Speaker:

From God or from, uh, oppressors like

Speaker:

communists. But you are still in chains. That's my point, that we're you are still in chain. That and

Speaker:

you don't have power to do that. What? It will never have a power to do what the First church

Speaker:

did in Acts four, because, uh, individualism will never bring you

Speaker:

into there, into the level of conscious which is full of love for

Speaker:

other people. And it's it's for me. It's still this, the same, uh,

Speaker:

attempt from a different direction. Like I. We were talking before and I said to you, you

Speaker:

know, you, you want to go up to the mountain and you can go from different to the same point.

Speaker:

You can go to the different from the different directions. I mean, the good illustration would not

Speaker:

be a mountain, but, uh, a ditch, a big ditch, but yeah, yeah, you go from,

Speaker:

from other directions. So the same I see that. Yeah. The same attempt. Because at the, at the end of the

Speaker:

day, at its core, it's still trying to say we humans can do this on our own and we don't need

Speaker:

God. That's what you're getting us. Yeah. Yes. That's that's. Yeah. It just makes me think

Speaker:

of Paul writing in Corinthians, you know, that the love chapter, you have all these things, but you

Speaker:

don't have love. It's nothing. It's just nothing. And it makes me think, like, let's just pretend.

Speaker:

Which never would have happened, but let's pretend, you know, communism would have created its perfect

Speaker:

ideal. It's utopia. But if it would have done it without love, you know, Christianity would look at

Speaker:

that and say, it's nothing. It doesn't matter. You did this all wrong. You. Know, and which I think

Speaker:

we'd all say, you know, it wouldn't have been possible for them to do that because their

Speaker:

foundation was wrong. Yes. You know, they started at the they were going to the wrong spot, so to speak.

Speaker:

Well, let me let me say let me quote something from a Richard Wurmbrand. He was a

Speaker:

pastor. He was persecuted, tortured in Romania, in Communist Romania. And then

Speaker:

Western brothers gave money and brought him to the West. And when he went to the West, He wrote

Speaker:

this. He said, in the homes of many Western Christians hours are sometimes

Speaker:

spent listening to worldly music. In our homes loud music can also be heard,,

Speaker:

but it's only to cover the talk about the gospel and the underground work so that the neighbors

Speaker:

may not overhear it and inform the secret police. We're talking about, not about Albania. We're

Speaker:

talking about Romania. In Albania, I don't think there was an underground church, but in Romania it

Speaker:

was. And it displayed the the glory of God. How underground Christians

Speaker:

rejoice. And on those rare occasions when they meet a serious Christian

Speaker:

from the West. Persecution has always produced a better Christian

Speaker:

witnessing Christian, a soul winning Christian. Communist persecution has backfired and produced

Speaker:

serious, dedicated Christians such as, are rarely seen in free lands.

Speaker:

These people cannot understand how anyone can be a Christian and not want to win every soul

Speaker:

they meet. Mm. So probably, um. And yeah. And I

Speaker:

think there's also one element that it's missing every time that

Speaker:

these ideologies, you know. Start to. To, to be, you know, present more and

Speaker:

more persecution. We. You know, it's lacking in the church. So,

Speaker:

uh, to the church. So, yeah. So in humanity's push to create the perfect ideal, at least in your case

Speaker:

in Albania, they're they're trying to build a utopia. And historians look back at that and have

Speaker:

made the case that they created probably one of the worst dystopias in history. And Albania has

Speaker:

been called the North Korea of Europe at the time. It was awful. Truly awful. It shows the

Speaker:

limitations of what happens to us when we don't live out of love, and in the power of the

Speaker:

resurrection. Like you were saying earlier about the church in Acts, so you no longer live in that

Speaker:

system, you know? Communism fell in Albania. As you reflect back on these things and other ideologies

Speaker:

that don't have the proper foundation. What are the things? What is something you're most grateful

Speaker:

for? Now that that's in the past. For me now, um,

Speaker:

the only thing that I'm grateful is that there was a possibility for the gospel to come to

Speaker:

Albania after communism fell. Um. I'm

Speaker:

not grateful at all about, you know, things that have changed. I mean, not having any more, you know,

Speaker:

secret police or that kind, that type of, uh, oppression.

Speaker:

Oppression? I don't think it has changed much in the

Speaker:

context of what we're talking just minutes before. It's still another way

Speaker:

for. Us. To, in our attempt to diminish the

Speaker:

display of God's glory on earth. But I am grateful that, um, God

Speaker:

gave me. Uh, life and. In the in communism time,

Speaker:

like, for example, this example in Romania, but in even in every experimental

Speaker:

that humans do um, God he, the Holy Spirit works,

Speaker:

uh, in the hearts of the people in. In, in every

Speaker:

creative way that humans want to put God out of the of the

Speaker:

picture, every way he finds, you know, uh, a channel to, uh,

Speaker:

communicate the truth. And, uh, I am grateful that he,

Speaker:

uh, came into my life. It could be during communist time. It could be, uh, during,

Speaker:

uh, I mean, democratic, so-called democratic, uh, type of system. But,

Speaker:

uh, I'm grateful that he came and he rescued me. That's the one thing that I'm grateful.

Speaker:

And I would be grateful for that. Yeah. So we've. We've. Covered a lot of different things in this

Speaker:

episode. Is there anything in particular you'd like to leave people with a lesson they can pull

Speaker:

from what we see in history, what you lived through as they go forward after they've heard

Speaker:

this. Is there anything you'd like to leave as a lesson? Yeah. I would like to say, uh, and to

Speaker:

encourage everyone that is a Christian and is a follower of

Speaker:

Christ, that things happen in history. Uh,

Speaker:

bad things happen in history unto humanity when

Speaker:

we don't light properly by imitating our Lord in

Speaker:

our life and following him as king. And, uh, the world will not be

Speaker:

better.We. We can see that better and better. It will not improve. But, um,,

Speaker:

when we shine our light, um, people, more and more people will not be deceived

Speaker:

by these type of experiments. Mhm. However, they will, you know,

Speaker:

be creative in during the different times, different ages in the human history.

Speaker:

Mhm. Yeah. Bring it back to the core of what makes what what sets Christianity apart

Speaker:

from the rest of these systems, the rest of the religion. And that's, you know, obviously Christ. But

Speaker:

then that it living out in love in the power of the resurrection. Those are something these

Speaker:

ideologies don't have. They don't have that at their core. Yeah. And we owe to our Lord and to

Speaker:

the people if we were all wanting to humanity. Is this just to

Speaker:

live as our Lord in our lifetime, that he, you know, decided for us to live.?

Speaker:

That's how that's what this experiment with humanity teaches us. I want to

Speaker:

I don't know how much I want to or how much how, How can I

Speaker:

emphasize more? You know this. It's a powerful point to leave us with. Thank you for sharing

Speaker:

today. Same here. Thank you, Reagan, for giving the opportunity.

Speaker:

Thanks for listening to this episode with Samir. If you found this interesting, we did a whole episode with him on his story of growing up

Speaker:

Albania and how he found Christ after the fall of communism. And you can find that linked down

Speaker:

below. He also talked about different points in church history that were relevant to the topic we

Speaker:

were discussing in today's episode, and we're doing a whole documentary series on the first 100

Speaker:

years of the Anabaptist story. We have a separate YouTube channel for that. You can find it linked

Speaker:

in the description here on the screen. Make sure to subscribe to that so you don't miss those

Speaker:

documentaries when they come out. And of course, you can subscribe to this podcast on your

Speaker:

favorite podcast app. Thanks again for listening and we'll see you in the next episode.