Ladies and gentlemen, Jesse Hirsch.
Speaker AAll farmers are futurists, because if you don't think of the future as a farmer, you're not going to be a very successful farmer, whether anticipating your crops, your livestock.
Speaker ABut to Renee's tease, I also quickly realized that every single farmer is a hacker.
Speaker ABecause when that tractor breaks down, when any system breaks down, you're not going to wait for a clean fix.
Speaker AYou're going to fix it by any means necessary.
Speaker ASo my remarks today are not just those of a futurist, it's those of a hacker who believes that technology needs to be understood, needs to be taken apart, put together, so that we can best understand how that technology can serve us instead of us serving the technology.
Speaker ANow, part of the reason we have gathered here today is we acknowledge that the future is almost certainly going to be radically different than the present.
Speaker AHistorically, this is actually novel phenomenon.
Speaker AMost human institutions have existed to make sure that the future was exactly identical to the present.
Speaker AThat was ultimately the power of the Catholic Church for centuries, right?
Speaker ATo make sure that nothing changes, that it remains the same, that it is predictable, versus I can tell you right now, the only constant that we will deal with in our life is change.
Speaker AEverything is now variable.
Speaker AIf you don't recognize that everything is a variable, you're gonna have a very difficult life.
Speaker AI just had a very heated argument with my 25 year old when I tried to explain to him he was variable.
Speaker AEverything he wanted was variable.
Speaker AIf he didn't embrace the idea that life was about change, he was not going to enjoy it very much.
Speaker ASo, thankfully, that's why we're all here today, because we want to make the change.
Speaker AWe don't want the change to happen to us.
Speaker AWe want to be the ones making that change.
Speaker AThat's partly why I became a farmer as a futurist.
Speaker AI kept showing up at all these different conferences and credit the Farm, Credit Canada, that it was a bunch of their young farmer events that connected me with a lot of young farmers, that made me realize this is where I ought to be, this is where I should be, applying my expertise, my principles, but most importantly, because I love to disrupt and I love disruption, and I perversely enough, am kind of excited by growing climate change.
Speaker AThe idea that the heat, the water, the wind, the earth is all going to become volatile and unpredictable.
Speaker AThat sounds like an interesting challenge.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker AI want to harvest the sun, I want to harvest water, I want to harvest wind.
Speaker AI want to grow the most microbial, diverse soil imaginable and then have my crops and animals flow from that too.
Speaker ASo this is why I think it's an exciting time to be here.
Speaker ABecause not only can we make change, we can make futures.
Speaker ABecause anyone can be a futurist, right?
Speaker AFuturists have about the same predictability rate as weather people.
Speaker AAt best maybe 20%.
Speaker AI personally like to argue that there is no such thing as the future.
Speaker AWe only ever experience a series of todays.
Speaker AYou know, it's today time to do the chores again.
Speaker AOh, it's today I gotta do the chores again.
Speaker ABut at the same time, we like to imagine futures.
Speaker APart of what I'm gonna do today is fantasize and offer you some crazy visions of a future that I'd like to see.
Speaker ABut of course, the power is when we align those futures, when we collaborate on those futures, when we iterate on those futures in a way that actually not only gives us the confidence and leadership and optimism to tackle the unknown, but actually gives us a responsiveness, a resilience, if not a capacity to make our dreams come true.
Speaker ABecause that is kind of what the future is.
Speaker AAnd thankfully our friends at AAC recognize that imagining the future is not a one off exercise.
Speaker AIt's something you have to keep coming back to repeatedly and repeatedly.
Speaker AAnd here's the irony, that's what church used to be.
Speaker APeople used to come together every Sunday and imagine the future heaven as a way to alleviate the toils of the everyday here on earth.
Speaker AGranted, I am a secular individual, we live in a secular society.
Speaker ABut guess what?
Speaker AWe're engaged in a similar philosophical, spiritual exercise.
Speaker AAnd when done right, it is transcendent.
Speaker AIt feels great, it connects us to our fellow human beings, it enlightens our soul and brings the spirit around us.
Speaker ASo again, that's kind of why I'm excited about today and why I think there's an incredible opportunity to not just face uncertainty, but thrive.
Speaker ARight?
Speaker ACreate systems that are based on variables, not constants.
Speaker ATo create systems that are dynamic and resilient, that can handle any change that comes at us.
Speaker ABecause lo and behold, our society is enraptured by a story that I happen to actually find kind of religious, unfortunately.
Speaker ABut it suggests that great change is upon us.
Speaker AThat AI will transform every profession, every role at work.
Speaker AAnd here's where I'm going to take the liberties throughout this presentation to not only talk about the agri food sector, but give us some glimpse as to actually what's going on in our society so we can make sense of it.
Speaker ABecause I personally think that artificial intelligence is a whole bunch of nonsense.
Speaker ADon't get me wrong, there is very real, profound, even, dare I say it, magical technology that is transforming every industry as we know it.
Speaker ABut the stories we are telling about these tools are misguided at best, if not delusional.
Speaker AFor example, the idea that we are about to launch some super intelligence that will be smarter than humans and take away all our jobs, that is 100% bullshit.
Speaker AI'm sorry to say.
Speaker AIf you actually look at the science, whether computer science, cognitive science, neuroscience, psychology, sociology, it will all tell you no, these machines do not think.
Speaker AThey will never think.
Speaker AThey're phenomenal at pattern recognition.
Speaker AOh my God, can they find the needle in the haystack?
Speaker ABut here's Jesse's number one tip for how to use a large language model with prowess and precision.
Speaker AYou have to do the thinking.
Speaker AIt does not think for you.
Speaker ABut if you come to it with lots of thoughts and you use it as a kind of mirror to work on those thoughts, wow.
Speaker AJust about anything is possible because it's your brain, it's your thinking, it's your capacity as an intellectual, a professional, a laborer, a leader.
Speaker AThat is the true power of AI.
Speaker ANot for control, but for collaboration.
Speaker ARight?
Speaker ANot for mindless automation, but hyper intelligent responsive systems.
Speaker ANow, the paradox of course is we have this magical marketing AI bubble.
Speaker AI just heard a quick podcast recommendation decoder by the publication The Verge interviews CEOs from the tech sector in the AI sector.
Speaker AIt is excellent.
Speaker AIt's some of the best investigative journalism out there.
Speaker ATheir most recent episode, or second most recent episode, is an interview with the chairman of OpenAI, not Sam Altman, but a friend of Sam Altman, and he details why he believes that AI is a bubble, why that AI bubble is going to burst.
Speaker AAnd I found this to be a very insightful conversation.
Speaker AAnd I'm going to use that as an opportunity because I'm old enough to remind you a little bit about Internet history, because I remember in 1993 when the web HTTP port 80 came about and everyone declared that governments would.
Speaker AThat the web all of a sudden would break the information monopolies.
Speaker AJohn Perry Barlow wrote the Declaration of Independence of Cyberspace.
Speaker AAnd at the time everyone believed it.
Speaker AYeah, governments would fall.
Speaker AOf course, that didn't happen.
Speaker AThen there was social media, what they call Web 2.0, right?
Speaker AFacebook and Twitter.
Speaker AAnd then they said it would be democracy all around the world.
Speaker AYeah, that didn't happen.
Speaker AAnd so now here we are at the age of AI and they're making equally ludicrous predictions.
Speaker AAnd I can guarantee none of them are going to happen.
Speaker AIn particular, massive unemployment.
Speaker ABut nonetheless, a lot of things will happen, things we weren't expecting, because that's what happened with the web.
Speaker AThe web did transform business as we know it.
Speaker AThat's what happened with social media.
Speaker ASocial media transformed marketing, transformed politics, transformed news completely, just not as anyone had predicted.
Speaker AAnd that is why collaborative futures, collaborative storytelling, collaborative sense making is so crucial.
Speaker ABecause whatever we think is going to happen is probably not going to happen.
Speaker ABut if we prepare for what we think is going to happen, then no matter what happens, we're good.
Speaker ABecause we're thinking about it, we're preparing about it, we're mobilizing towards it.
Speaker AAnd that's where AI is a paradox.
Speaker AOn the one hand, legitimately, a lot of people are going, that's nonsense.
Speaker AAnd they're right.
Speaker AAnd on the other hand, a lot of people are going, this is the most powerful tool humanity has ever invented.
Speaker AAnd they're right.
Speaker AThe question comes down to when, where and why.
Speaker AAnd that is context.
Speaker AAnd that's why agriculture is one of the leading areas when it comes to AI application and adultery.
Speaker APartly because agricultural environments are highly controlled, as is the case in greenhouses, but in many agricultural operations, but also because the needs of agricultural operations are generally pretty narrow.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AYou're not having to deal with the chaos of traffic, of kids and pets and balls.
Speaker ANo.
Speaker AYou're going to assume that no one likely is going to run in front of your colony or it's going to run in front of a tractor.
Speaker ASo the potential for AI in agriculture and food production is profound.
Speaker AIt has tremendous opportunity.
Speaker AThat's why in 2014, when I finished my master's degree at Toronto Metropolitan University with a major in algorithmic media and a minor in open source robotics, I said agriculture, that's where I want to go.
Speaker ABecause that is the most obvious application of this stuff.
Speaker ABut I've been alluding to the idea that I think mass unemployment as a result of AI is a myth, that it ain't gonna happen.
Speaker AUnfortunately, the nature of collaborative futures is if everyone believes it's gonna happen, they're gonna start laying people off before they realize maybe that wasn't such a good idea.
Speaker AWe might be in the midst of that little self fulfilling prophecy.
Speaker ABut what if I told you that work generally sucks and it doesn't have to?
Speaker AWhat if I told you that with my degree in AI I could go and make a lot of money just about anywhere in the world?
Speaker AIn fact, as an aside, in 2013 I hosted the first Toronto Bitcoin Summit and I charged people one bitcoin to come to my event and teach me about bitcoin.
Speaker AI ended that event with 50 Bitcoin that I spent in the next six to 12 months.
Speaker ASo there's lots of reasons that I kind of followed the technology path.
Speaker ABut I chose agriculture because if I'm going to experience a tyranny of today's, I want that to be a learning curve that not only improves my health, not only supplies me with food, but allows my brain to be constantly growing.
Speaker ASo I actually think when we talk about the role of technology in agriculture, we can also talk about reversing the quote, unquote brain drain that went from rural communities to urban.
Speaker AAnd I will self servingly present myself as exactly the kind of person you want to be attracting to the agricultural sector.
Speaker AAlthough if my partner would hear, she would be a far better example because she is way smarter than me, right?
Speaker AA far greater learner.
Speaker AThis is a woman with a PhD in the history of technology who is a certified teacher.
Speaker AAnd she said, you know what?
Speaker AEducation is just not the industry I want to be in.
Speaker AI want to be a farmer, right?
Speaker ASo there are a lot of people who might have been white collar workers who have post secondary education, who are workaholics who would love to enter the agricultural industry.
Speaker AThey just don't know how to.
Speaker AOnly reason I was able to do it, farm Credit Canada notwithstanding, because they brought me to lots of cool events was my early childhood was spent in the bush in northern Ontario.
Speaker ASo I already had connections to rural communities.
Speaker AThere wasn't a gap.
Speaker AI realized how much fun it is.
Speaker AI am now a preacher to urban communities as to why the future is rural and why agriculture is the place to be.
Speaker AUnfortunately, I am a weirdo in a chorus of people trying to say the future is urban.
Speaker AI wish I had more people adding to this, but this is something I would love to see y' all explore when you talk about the future of labor, that you recognize that these AI driven smart farms, they're gonna require people with a combination of skills.
Speaker AA combination of skills that includes things like data literacy, includes things like basic software skills, right?
Speaker AIncludes things like being able to assess which infrastructure, which technology, which platforms work with their operations, or if we are to imagine a heavily concentrated agricultural sector, they're able to confer with their higher ups in a way that allow these systems to be adopted.
Speaker ASo I don't actually think that the current projections of labor in agriculture are accurate or reflect our needs.
Speaker AAnd because I Don't think we have enough people participating in that conversation who recognize there's a lot of people living in the city who want out.
Speaker AThey don't know how to get out.
Speaker AThey don't have the capital to get out.
Speaker ABut oh boy, would they love to be engaged in farming, whether traditional or some of the emerging forms.
Speaker ABut let's take a moment to talk about open source because I am the kind of weirdo who loves to learn.
Speaker AThat's why I'm a farmer.
Speaker AI've been studying agricultural robotics now for about three, four years.
Speaker ABut I've also been a proponent of open source software for 25 years.
Speaker AAnyone who remembers dot.org I had authorship credit and code, the software that ran.
Speaker ANow, I'm not actually that good a programmer.
Speaker AI haven't done much over the last 10 years, but that's something that large language models do really well.
Speaker ASo I decided last winter I wanted to build my own farm robot.
Speaker AI wanted this robot to have AI capabilities.
Speaker AI wanted it to be a learning project for me, not only because I'm never going to be able to afford the kind of farm robotics that are out in the marketplace, but also because I feel that if I build it open source, I can cater to the needs of my agricultural operation and from that learn some really valuable skills.
Speaker AOf course, first I had to teach myself electricity, which because my 1970 John Deere tractor had a nest of rats in it, I had to learn that wiring to get the tractor back online.
Speaker AThen of course, I had to learn welding because I needed to learn how to deal with metal in terms of building the robot.
Speaker AAnd guess who helped me with both of those subjects?
Speaker AOh yeah, my friend ChatGPT or Claude or Gemini.
Speaker AAnd granted, it doesn't understand what it's telling me, so it gave me a lot of bad advice.
Speaker ABut mistakes are part of the learning process and it was a great way to be able to ask dumb questions about welding without someone calling me an idiot or, you know, telling me I was messing it up.
Speaker AAnd I did think, as an aside, that there's no way I would have been able to learn welding in the city because there would have been someone looking at me going, you're about to blow this place up.
Speaker ABut because I'm doing it on my own, I can make those mistakes.
Speaker AI'm actually a pretty decent welder here.
Speaker AThen of course, I get the raspberry PI, I get the camera, I order the motors off of Amazon.
Speaker AThere's already an open source kit for different types of agricultural robots.
Speaker AThere's open source software for mowing robots.
Speaker ASo I now have a reasonably functional farm robot.
Speaker AIt's my first.
Speaker AThis is the AI generated image.
Speaker AMy welding is so ugly, there's no way I'm going to show a photo of it here in front of people who probably know how to weld.
Speaker ABut it functions, it works.
Speaker AIt currently operates via remote control because I'm in the data collection phase where I'm teaching it about my pastures, I'm teaching it about my land, I'm learning how to recognize the goats or horses that it's moving amongst.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AI'm then going to start adding AI capability.
Speaker AI'm then going to start adding attachments.
Speaker AAnd so far the overall cost of this is about 2000 bucks, most of which went to Princess Auto.
Speaker AThe other side basically has gone to Amazon.
Speaker ABut it really wasn't that difficult for me to do.
Speaker AAnd you don't need every farmer doing this.
Speaker AYou just need a Jesse in every community who helps people figure out they already know how to.
Speaker AWell, they probably know basic electrical.
Speaker AThe software is actually pretty easy.
Speaker AAnd if it's open source, the whole community can be adding and modifying.
Speaker AWhat if we scale this up across the province?
Speaker AWhat if we had a warehouse where we connected with factories in China, got those electric motors, got those controllers, got a whole bunch of Raspberry PI, some Arduino boards, had it, so it was available, maybe even subsidized.
Speaker ASo it was really cheap for people to get hands on this technology.
Speaker AThen there's a video of Jesse showing how he did it.
Speaker AOr maybe even better, our friends at the University of Guelph do their own prototype, make it available open source.
Speaker ABoom.
Speaker AAll of a sudden, the cost of robotics goes low.
Speaker AAnd because I built the robot, I understand how it works, I understand how the software interacts.
Speaker ASo I mostly built this first robot for pasture management, for harrowing, for dealing mowing with certain weeds.
Speaker ABut my partner, she's already starting to expand our crops and we've kind of got custom rows.
Speaker ASo next year I'm going to build her a robot custom made for her.
Speaker ARose and I will use an imaging application and start trying attempting to do weed detection, maybe put a little blade on it so it cuts the weeds.
Speaker AThis isn't rocket science.
Speaker AThis is really straightforward.
Speaker AThis is a whole lot easier than fixing your tractor.
Speaker AIt's a whole lot easier than keeping an old hay baler operation.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AIt just fundamentally requires literacy, right?
Speaker ABecause I understand how open source software works.
Speaker AIt's because I understand how to go on GitHub and compare different products.
Speaker AI can't understand the code, but I understand the culture the same way that I have been studying food culture.
Speaker ABecause before I got into farming, I had a rather foolish idea of opening a restaurant.
Speaker AThank God I didn't do that.
Speaker ABut fundamentally, this notion of literacy is what makes a successful agricultural operation a successful food operation from an unsuccessful one.
Speaker ABut literacy is also what changes the sector, and literacy is what impacts the consumer, right?
Speaker ADisinformation is a huge factor when it comes to agri food.
Speaker AI was invited actually to invite only event at Massey College in the summer on disinformation.
Speaker AAnd they invited me because of my political work and my hacking stuff.
Speaker ABut I was there talking about food and I was going over and over, we have to be looking at what disinformation is happening to food.
Speaker ABecause you better believe that if you were a hostile foreign country who had a specialized expertise in social media manipulation, the first thing you're going to do is go after your adversary's food supply.
Speaker AAnd the best way to do that is to attack trust, right?
Speaker AIs to attack perception, is to pit people eating the food against the people producing the food.
Speaker ASo I think literacy is at the heart of what we're doing today as futurists, right?
Speaker AAs people who want to create a resilient, vibrant, growing system.
Speaker AAnd literacy is something we kind of take for granted, because if you have a high level of literacy, you often make the mistake of thinking that people see what you see.
Speaker AI think most of us here in the room can recognize that we have a level of agricultural literacy, of maybe food literacy, of even rural literacy that the vast majority of Canadians do not at our peril, right?
Speaker AThe less they understand us, the less we are our priority in policy circles.
Speaker AThe less they understand us, the more they resent whatever funding, whatever supports, whatever programs.
Speaker ASo literacy is fundamentally the difference between the optimistic future, the status quo future, and the pessimistic future.
Speaker AAnd literacy is the kind of each one teach, one education we all have to be doing as organizations, as professionals, as family members, because RFK Jr. Is in a position of power.
Speaker AAnd my God, that guy's a monster, right?
Speaker AAn absolute monster when it comes to human health and disinformation.
Speaker AAnd he is in a position as state power.
Speaker ASo the time is upon us.
Speaker AAnd I think literacy is a huge, huge opportunity.
Speaker AAnd TikTok cruising, quick show of hands here.
Speaker AHow many people like myself are addicted to TikTok?
Speaker AAll right, some of you, I'm glad you are honest.
Speaker AIf you are serious, as a professional in the agri food industry.
Speaker AAnd you are not using TikTok as a research platform.
Speaker AYou're sleeping, you're behind.
Speaker ADon't get me wrong.
Speaker AIf you don't want to use it as a personal platform, more power to you.
Speaker AI get it.
Speaker AIt is dangerous.
Speaker AIt is 100% a vehicle for propaganda from the Chinese state for sure.
Speaker ABut their AI, their algorithm, in terms of its ability to organize information and connect audiences, is the best in the world by far.
Speaker AThe United States delayed and delayed and delayed a law banning it because they're happy to put military in the streets, they're happy to lock people up, but they're not gonna take away People's TikTok because that is how emotional and connecting it is.
Speaker AAnd TikTok is revolutionizing the food industry.
Speaker AThe individual here on the left, his name is Logan.
Speaker AIt's based in Vancouver.
Speaker AFor a while, he was individually responsible for a shortage of cucumbers.
Speaker ACucumbers across North America just wouldn't stay on shelves.
Speaker APeople were getting angry at grocery stores because they couldn't get their cucumbers because Logan was teaching them how to make cucumber salad.
Speaker AAnd he was doing so with such scale.
Speaker ALike each of his videos was get what, 10 million and like, more.
Speaker AAnd I certainly tried his recipe.
Speaker AIt's great.
Speaker ABut if I was a cucumber grower, if I was in the cucumber industry, I'd be like, oh, my God, what is happening?
Speaker AI hope someone knows who Logan is.
Speaker AI hope they're reaching out to him.
Speaker AI mean, these kind of sins move on.
Speaker AThe nature of, you know, these viral moments, they come and they go.
Speaker ASo you kind of have to be there prepared.
Speaker ABut quite frankly, the cucumber industry didn't have to do anything.
Speaker AThey were just lucky that Logan liked cucumbers, and he happened to be a very charismatic individual.
Speaker AAgain, if you have no idea what I'm talking about, I highly recommend you look it up.
Speaker ALogan cucumber phenomenal case example in food trends and the way in which these food trends are volatile, Right.
Speaker AThey move and go with the broader psychology.
Speaker ANow, quick show of hands, because it's not just TikTok.
Speaker AHow many people here know who Keith Lee is or have heard of the Keith Lee effect?
Speaker AA few hands.
Speaker AKeith Lee is this individual on the right.
Speaker AHe started off as just some guy in Las Vegas who wanted to support local restaurants.
Speaker ABut now when Keith Lee shows up somewhere like Toronto, the buzz is right through the restaurant industry.
Speaker AAnd any place he mentions will be sold out for months.
Speaker AWe'll have Lineups around the block.
Speaker ANow he happens to specialize in family owned, usually either African American or Caribbean communities.
Speaker ABut his track record is top notch, right?
Speaker AHe is one of these authorities online who his sense of taste, his following is so powerful he just has to mention a brand, mention a dish, mention a restaurant and they are overwhelmed.
Speaker AAnother more popular example of this is Dave Portnoy in his one bite pizza reviews.
Speaker ABasically he takes a bite of a pizza and if he gives it a 7.8 or later, that pizza place is overwhelmed again with business for months.
Speaker ASo this is why if you're in the agri food sector and you're not paying attention to TikTok as a source of data and intelligence, I implore you to do so.
Speaker AI'm mentioning the food side partly because my presentation today is heavily agricultural, because that's where I'm largely coming from.
Speaker ABut farm talk, the extent to which farmers and people in the ag tac are all throughout the agricultural rainbow, they are on TikTok.
Speaker AAnd it is far more valuable than any other social media platform because it connects people, it connects ideas, it connects interests.
Speaker AIt literally is the most powerful example of artificial intelligence that I can offer you today.
Speaker AAnd the impact that it is having on agricultural and food is profound.
Speaker AAnd I would use that as an argument to say we are missing a certain segment here in our collaborative future exercise.
Speaker AAnd that's the consumer, that's the person eating.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AWe're still kind of assuming that they're at the end of the loop and they're not at the table with us mostly because I don't think they see themselves at the table as us.
Speaker ABut there are some tiktokers who would.
Speaker AThere are some tiktokers who are consumers, are eaters who if we invited them to this process, not only would they love it and feel honored, but they might bring us some attention as well.
Speaker AThey might help get more buy in and participation, certainly on a diversity and inclusive level.
Speaker ASo I offer that as a wild thought moving forward.
Speaker ABut I do think we have to think about the on ramps to our quote unquote value chain, the way in which we make this sector as accessible as possible.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker ABecause I personally believe that agriculture and food kind of immune to competition.
Speaker AYes, there is competition, yes, there's a role for competition, but fundamentally people will always eat.
Speaker AAnd so I think that our ecosystem, our marketplace should not resist competition, not resist new entrants, but embrace radical openness, even radical transparency.
Speaker ABut I'll get that in a bit.
Speaker ABut why do we not have the kind of incubators, the kind of startups, the kind of accelerators that say the tech industry has, right?
Speaker AI mean, if you look at the tech industry, this is perhaps one of the more profitable.
Speaker ASo during the last couple of decades, the largest growing.
Speaker AAnd yet they go out of their way to make it possible for new entrants to get in the market, right?
Speaker AEven the largest, most dominant players allocate a significant amount of their resources to fuel potential new competitors.
Speaker AGranted, it's because they think they'll just buy them out and they become a threat, but nonetheless, we need to be thinking about how to make it easier for someone to get into agriculture, for someone to get into the food business, for someone to get into the consulting aspect of these sectors.
Speaker AThat would require new regulations, that would require intra industry support.
Speaker ABut I raise it as a value, I raise it as an ethic.
Speaker AAnd maybe it starts just by inviting consumers into the process, because the consumer today is the producer of tomorrow.
Speaker AAnd it's a matter of helping people who are food curious helping people who are farm curious get access to the literacy that in spite of social media, we still gatekeep, right?
Speaker AWe still do not make it easy for people to get involved in our sector, involved in our industry, because the issue here is data.
Speaker AOne of the things I suspect would be a dominant thread, certainly in the automation part of today, but maybe even in the other streams, is we have a sore, I don't want to use the word deficit, obstacle.
Speaker AI want to say handicap in the golf sense, not in the disability sense.
Speaker ABut we, Canada as a country are really in a difficult position when it comes to data.
Speaker AJust about every single other industrialized nation is generating, collecting, understanding, facilitating the literacy of data better than we are.
Speaker AFirst thing I did when I became a farmer six years ago was install cameras all across my operation so I could start collecting data in the form of video, knowing full well that I could analyze that video and use it for my own purposes, at the very least for pattern recognition.
Speaker AThe other point of building my robot is I want to collect more finite data about my soil, about my pastures are orchard.
Speaker AData literacy is something our sector sorely lacks.
Speaker AAnd where the food aspect of this, they totally understand data, they sure don't want to share it.
Speaker AAnd unfortunately, we as a society are operating under this dangerous myth that data is valuable.
Speaker AAnd I'm here to tell you that data is not valuable, not at all.
Speaker AIn fact, I think data is worthless.
Speaker AAttention is what's valuable.
Speaker AAttention is the scarce resource.
Speaker AThe whole purpose that people use Data is to get our attention.
Speaker AThe whole reason we want agricultural data is to allocate attention.
Speaker AWhether a robot's attention, whether a system's attention, whether a buyer's attention, whether a regulator's attention, we flipped it around.
Speaker AData is something we should be sharing.
Speaker AData is something that we should be making transparent.
Speaker AData is something we should be collecting at all times, not because it is valuable, but because it enables value, because it allows us to do other things.
Speaker AAnd unfortunately, in our risk averse culture, we are too obsessed with protecting data, with hoarding data when we need to be sharing that data.
Speaker AAnd I suspect our academic colleagues here today will be reinforcing that argument.
Speaker ABut I think those of us within industry need to be championing that argument.
Speaker AIt's the idea that it raises all boats, that we will all benefit if we can understand our system.
Speaker ABecause imagine this crazy fantasy.
Speaker AImagine there was a dashboard food ca, you go to that dashboard, anyone can go to that dashboard and you get a real live broadcast picture, a digital twin, as it were, of our entire value chain, of the entire agricultural food system.
Speaker AWho would benefit from such radical transparency, from such a living system?
Speaker AWell, the primary beneficiaries would be the largest players, the people with the most resources, the people with the ability to engage that market at scale.
Speaker ABut the other benefits would be the smallest players, right?
Speaker AThe people who are happy to scavenge, the people who are happy to look for opportunities.
Speaker AYou know, this is how I generally see the waste disposal business, including scrap metal recycling, and I'll get into that in a moment.
Speaker ABut the opportunity here, when it comes to data, when it comes to automation, when it comes to literacy, is profound.
Speaker AAnd we are penny wise, pound foolish because we are thinking of data as some kind of asset when it is an innate right.
Speaker AThe World Wide Web was revolutionary because it was wide across the world, because anybod, nobody could set a website, anyone could look at a website.
Speaker ASo imagine the entire system was transparent.
Speaker AI think we would have not only thriving, profitable, prosperous, diverse systems, but the rest of the world will be coming to learn from us and eat our food.
Speaker ANow granted, that's a pretty crazy concept and I can elaborate on that concept in a moment, but that is the requirement for integrated systems, right?
Speaker AIf we want to have greater efficiency, if we want to have greater resources, if we want to have greater cooperation and collaboration, we kind of have to be reading off the same page because that is the consequence of social media is it got us all on our own page.
Speaker ABefore social media, maybe it was the Globe and Mail Right.
Speaker AMaybe it was cbc, maybe it was the New York Times.
Speaker AWe literally all read the same page.
Speaker ABut I can tell you right now, for those of us who are on TikTok, we are on a completely different page than the rest of us.
Speaker AThose of you who are on Facebook, for example.
Speaker AAnd Facebook, of course, is where the Canadian agricultural ecosystem exists.
Speaker ALike if you want to buy used agricultural equipment, if you want to buy livestock, it's on Facebook.
Speaker ABoy, is that a problem with national sovereignty and national security.
Speaker ABut nonetheless, that's the page you're on.
Speaker ASo how do we get people on the same page?
Speaker AHow do we get people being able to collaborate and even speak the same language?
Speaker ANow, Rene, personally, I don't believe there's such a thing as pronunciation.
Speaker ALike language is a virus.
Speaker AAnd I think the more we speak en francais, the more we use colloquial, the more we mispronounce words, the more human we are.
Speaker AI mean, how many of you look at an email and ask yourself, did AI write this or did the person sending me write this?
Speaker AI like to let the sender know because I do deliberate misspellings, I do all sorts of weird words and they know they're really getting jested.
Speaker ABut one of the things you're going to talk about today are integrated systems.
Speaker AAnd I will challenge that.
Speaker AMost of you actually have never experienced truly integrated systems.
Speaker AAnd we as a collective still can't fully conceive them.
Speaker ABecause here's the other piece.
Speaker ANot only do I think consumers need to be at our table, but I think dissidents need to as well.
Speaker AAnd the reason I say this is the dissidents are empowered by very powerful technology.
Speaker AAnd as we recently saw with the arrest of the so called Queen of Canada in Richmond, Saskatchewan, they can do a lot of damage to our societies, our communities, if we let them go unchecked.
Speaker ASo if we really are going to be on the same page, we actually need to find ways to bring in the people who hate us, I believe because they're misguided by disinformation.
Speaker AAnd if, for example, they understood that without animals we wouldn't have crops, that soil is fundamentally the basis of human.
Speaker AI digress.
Speaker ABut there are conversations that need to happen that aren't happening because we're yelling at each other.
Speaker AAnd there needs to be a way to bring this in.
Speaker AAnd that's where integrated systems.
Speaker AYou know, maybe I did resilient, regenerative and revolutionary.
Speaker AMaybe I should have done resilient, regenerative and reconciliatory.
Speaker ARight?
Speaker ABecause the Point about reconciliation, I think is crucial when it comes to the way in which as a country, we have a lot of work to do.
Speaker ABut I wanted to give another case example because Loop Resource, quick show of hands.
Speaker AAnyone here knows what Loop Resource is or involved in.
Speaker ALoop Resource, one hand in the back, two hands, three.
Speaker ALoop Resource initially started out of British Columbia.
Speaker AThey are now actively growing in Ontario.
Speaker AThey match farmers with grocery stores to take away their food waste.
Speaker ASo my farm is gratefully a member of Loop Resource.
Speaker AThat's a picture of my truck as we were coming back from the Loblaws, picking up about 40 boxes of free food.
Speaker AFood that legally we are not allowed to eat, but that our livestock certainly are able to.
Speaker AAnd it's allowed our pigs to grow.
Speaker AIt's allowing our goats to grow.
Speaker AOur livestock, guardian dogs are living their best lives ever.
Speaker AAnd Loop Resource, on the one hand, is a great initiative where it's literal waste diversion.
Speaker AAnd of course, I should say it is rather shocking how much a grocery store throws out on a daily basis, how much of it, in my view, is still totally edible.
Speaker ABut to their defense, it's stuff that consumers aren't gonna buy, because consumers have a certain culture and literacy of the food that they get versus me as a farmer.
Speaker AI'm like, yeah, no problem.
Speaker AWe'll take that food.
Speaker ABut I wish I could be going even more often in terms of getting all this free food.
Speaker AWhen I tell my friends about it, their mind is blown.
Speaker ABut here's the flip side.
Speaker AI'm a researcher.
Speaker AI'm a food researcher.
Speaker AI'm a technology researcher.
Speaker AI was already scoping out all the Loblaw stores that I go to, memorizing the prices, memorizing the shelving, memorizing the marketing in store.
Speaker AI'm on the autism spectrum.
Speaker AI got nothing better to do.
Speaker ANow I get to see what they throw out.
Speaker ASo now I get to see how their pricing goes.
Speaker ANow I get to see how their marketing goes.
Speaker ANow I get to see how consumers react.
Speaker AAnd of course, Loop's angle in all this is data collection.
Speaker AThey have each of us farmers recording data about all the waste that's being diverted.
Speaker AI'm sure laws is also recording that data and getting that.
Speaker ASo here we are.
Speaker AWe're starting to close the Loop, right?
Speaker AThey've dramatically lowered my feed.
Speaker AThey're enabling the growth of my livestock, literally and in numbers.
Speaker AAnd we are diverting a trip, tremendous amount of waste from landfills.
Speaker AAnd we're reusing the cargo.
Speaker AWe're even reusing the plastic in terms of our greenhouse and our.
Speaker ASo these are the types of opportunities that happen when you have integrated systems.
Speaker AAnd I do believe the only reason that loop is able to be agreeable to some of these grocery providers is because they're providing data.
Speaker ABecause this is fundamentally a data collection exercise above and beyond the environmental stuff.
Speaker ANow I want to, as I close, use fermentation as a metaphor because a lot of the stuff I'm talking about today, like open source robotics, like fully transparent value chain, like complete and integrated systems, it is kind of science fiction.
Speaker AGranted, that's our job today.
Speaker AThere's some maybe speculative fiction to imagine these worlds we desire and try to cultivate them.
Speaker ABut this is where I think patience is an important midwife to force that.
Speaker AOn the one hand, we are asking you to collaborate, we are asking you to participate ideally in a long term process.
Speaker ABut at the same time it's easy to get like I am excited, right?
Speaker AImpatient, eager for these types of things we have.
Speaker ASo there's a value to fermenting, there's a value to waging, there's a value to taking some of the food that's not looking so great and put it in a salt water brine and then a few weeks later, oh my God, does it taste fantastic?
Speaker AI mean, when I think about my current agricultural operations, I definitely don't want to be in the commodity business.
Speaker AWe definitely want to process.
Speaker AI kind of think about fermented hot sauce.
Speaker ABut if I were to be honest, my farm fundamentally is a knowledge farm, right?
Speaker AThe primary product of our agricultural operations is knowledge.
Speaker APartly because I'm a voracious learner, partly because my partner is even a more voracious learner, but also because I think my skill, my prosperity as a farmer depends upon my ability to learn.
Speaker AAnd that's where I'm patient, right?
Speaker AThis is our sixth year and we still have not generated sufficient revenue to be able to register with an agricultural organization here, Ontario.
Speaker ABut here's my wish.
Speaker AShouldn't what I'm doing right now count?
Speaker ARight?
Speaker ALike, am I not right now as a farmer, I've harvested knowledge.
Speaker AI'm sharing with you that bounty.
Speaker AMaybe a handful of you are going to find value in that bounty and put it to work.
Speaker ASo why should this knowledge application that I'm engaging in not count as agricultural activity?
Speaker AHow come the fee that I'm getting paid to present today cannot be reported so that I could join the Federation of Agriculture, for example, if we were to allow that, if we were to recognize the role of the intellectual, the role of the researcher, the role of the futurist within the framework of agriculture.
Speaker AThat's when you start to see the demographics, the archetypes, the ideas, the future collaboration start to change and we start to get different kinds of people engaged in the sector.
Speaker AAnd to me, that's the notion of both fermentation and microbial innovation is our concepts of diversity are still not diverse enough.
Speaker AAnd we need to be including and fostering even greater people in our ecosystem, because that'll make us all healthier, stronger and more capable.
Speaker ABecause here's kind of what I want to end with.
Speaker AI think most people do not understand trust.
Speaker AAnd I think if you would ask most people who use the word trust if you could say, well, define the word trust, they would struggle.
Speaker AI would argue that trust is a byproduct of vulnerability, that if you want to earn trust with someone, you must be vulnerable.
Speaker ANow, scholarly literature frames this as shared risk, that risk is the prerequisite to trust.
Speaker AAnd if we want to foster trust within the agri food system, if we want to trust each other and increase collaboration, we need to embrace risk, we need to entertain risk, we need to embrace risk, we need to share risk.
Speaker AThat's part of what's done in sharing data.
Speaker AThat's part of the value of transparency.
Speaker AThat's why, personally, I think agrotourism, which is already a booming aspect of Ontario's agri food sector, is an area we could be doing even more.
Speaker ABecause every time people come to my farm, we feed them fantastic food, give them a phenomenal experience with our animals, and we basically have a walk through our forest, allowed to see our technology.
Speaker AThey leave with a huge literacy boost and a jar of pickles and hot sauce that allows them to feel connected with our operations with our sector.
Speaker AMany farms are doing this very successfully.
Speaker AThe 360 video project is a great digital example of this.
Speaker ABut I think as a province, we could be radically upscaling this level of agritourism because it's where the literacy happens.
Speaker AAnd then finally, I'm a big believer in podcasts.
Speaker ASo part of what I'm going to be doing today is walking around with my little microphone and spying, recording, asking questions of some of you.
Speaker AFeel free to come up to me if you want to get something on the record.
Speaker ABut we don't always have the privilege to be in a room like this.
Speaker AWe don't always have the time, in my case, to leave a farm to go and have these conversations.
Speaker APodcasts are a great way to do that.
Speaker AAnd the podcasts in the agricultural sector are already diverse and strong.
Speaker AI would encourage those of you who have organizations, who have associations, who have a stake in the game, think of your own podcast, put your own voice out there.
Speaker ABecause I think there's a way to have a collaborative intelligence to the way in which we have these foresight, these futurist practices.
Speaker ABecause it is about feeding possibility.
Speaker AThat is the moral here.
Speaker AWe are not going to get the future we desire.
Speaker AWe're probably not even going to get the future we expect.
Speaker ABut if we're prepared, if we focus on possibility, if we spend time imagining futures we desire, no matter what happens, we'll be good.
Speaker AWe'll be eating good food, living a good life, smoking good cannabis, enjoying good maple syrup.
Speaker AThese fundamentally are the opportunities that we have together as a group.
Speaker AWe gotta make the most of it.
Speaker AAnd so the last thing I would end with, we can't expect the Agricultural Adaptation Council to do all this.
Speaker AThat's why we're here, for us to work today.
Speaker ABut what if every single association, union, college here, present, organized their own foresight activity for your members?
Speaker ABecause if we were to have collaborative foresight, it can't just be us the leaders, it has to be a grassroots phenomenon.
Speaker ASo I'm adding an extra task for you today.
Speaker AOn the one hand, give us your thoughts.
Speaker AOn the other hand, imagine how you would do this with your group.
Speaker AImagine how you would translate this with your organization so that you could go and talk to them and then come back to the 2050 process with a mandate, with greater legitimacy, with greater voices.
Speaker AThat's what will make this process not only more possible, not only more potential, but powerful when it comes to shifting the policy management.
Speaker ASo thank you very much.
Speaker ALet's have a great day.